English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For March 06/2024
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2024/english.march06.24.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
Bible Quotations For
today
The Miracle Of Curing the Centurion Slave
Saint Luke 07/01-10/:”After Jesus had finished all his
sayings in the hearing of the people, he entered Capernaum. A centurion
there had a slave whom he valued highly, and who was ill and close to death.
When he heard about Jesus, he sent some Jewish elders to him, asking him to
come and heal his slave. When they came to Jesus, they appealed to him
earnestly, saying, ‘He is worthy of having you do this for him, for he loves
our people, and it is he who built our synagogue for us.’And Jesus went with
them, but when he was not far from the house, the centurion sent friends to
say to him, ‘Lord, do not trouble yourself, for I am not worthy to have you
come under my roof; therefore I did not presume to come to you. But only
speak the word, and let my servant be healed. For I also am a man set under
authority, with soldiers under me; and I say to one, “Go”, and he goes, and
to another, “Come”, and he comes, and to my slave, “Do this”, and the slave
does it.’ When Jesus heard this he was amazed at him, and turning to the
crowd that followed him, he said, ‘I tell you, not even in Israel have I
found such faith.’When those who had been sent returned to the house, they
found the slave in good health.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese
Related News & Editorials published on March 05-06/2024
Elias Bejjani/Video/ Let us be unequivocally clear,
Hezbollah is an Iranian jihadist terrorist organization//March 05, 2024
Video and Text/To All Owners of Tamed Political Parties, Politicians, Clergymen,
and Mouthpiece Figures such as Gebran Bassil and Melhem Riachi: Let us be
unequivocally clear, Hezbollah is an Iranian jihadist terrorist
organization./Elias Bejjani/March 05, 2024
Gallant tells Hochstein Israel committed to diplomacy but may resort to military
action
Hochstein holds 'positive' talks with Berri amid 'encouraging' signs
Three civilians killed in Israel strike on Lebanon
Hezbollah targets Kiryat Shmona in response to Bint Jbeil strike
Talks on ending Lebanon-Israel border hostilities to begin in Ramadan, Lebanese
PM says
Hezbollah buries the “Moderation” initiative with “There is no president but a
resistance man”
Mikati: Hockstein has entrusted us with a mechanism for 1701. Israel informs the
American envoy that it is close to a decision on war.
Unusual measures in the suburb... “Israeli aggression in its heart”?
Since the start of the battles 5 months ago, Hula has paid the price for its
steadfastness with 8 martyrs
Moderation Bloc's presidential initiative hinging on 'Hezbollah's answers'
Mikati says only way to peace is 'deterring Israel'
Raad: We have not used all our weapons yet
Berri lauds National Moderation bloc's presidential initiative
Lebanese state initiates roadmap to address Syrian refugee crisis: Mechanism
unveiled
Lebanese Forces criticize Berri's 'obstruction' of presidential elections
Hezbollah Deputy Secretary-General emphasizes support for Frangieh, asserts
readiness to respond to Israeli actions if Gaza ceasefire excludes southern
Lebanon
Relationship with the Free Patriotic Movement
Maronite Patriarch Cardinal Mar Bechara Boutros Al-Rai broaches local, regional
developments with MP Douaihy, meets Tripoli Bar Association delegation
United Nations and European Union improve the livelihoods and employment
prospects for youth in Tripoli and Al-Beddawi
Lebanese Army Chief broaches general situation with MP Abou El-Hessen, discusses
retired military personnel affairs with Armed Forces Retirees Association...
Fuel prices in Lebanon: Gasoline up, diesel down in recent adjustments
The American envoy punishes Bou Habib... by meeting with Maronite
representatives/Ghada Halawi/Nedal Al Watan/March 06, 2024
Hochstein, with his advice and warnings: “The reassuring and the frightening”/Munir
Al-Rabie/Al-Modon/March 06, 2024
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News published
on March 05-06/2024
Diplomatic push for Israel-Hamas ceasefire
intensifies
Gaza Strip: Ceasefire talks between Hamas and mediators broke up on Tuesday in
Cairo with no breakthrough
At least 17 killed in an Israeli airstrike in southern Gaza
Famine looms in Gaza — how will the world know it has arrived?
Sullivan, Qatar PM discussed potential ceasefire for hostage release
Saudi FM warns Israel against offensive in Rafah during OIC meeting
Netanyahu leaned on Gantz to help unify Israel, now Gantz is more popular
Israel to let same numbers into Al-Aqsa during first week of Ramadan as in
previous years, statement by Netanyahu's office says
Erdogan says Israeli settlers major obstacle to peace
Turkey detains 7 more people for selling information to Mossad
3 Red Sea data cables cut as Houthis launch more attacks in vital waterway
US forces down drones, missile fired from Yemen at warship
Pro-Palestinian group sues Canada over military exports to Israel
Israel and UN trade allegations of 'terrorism,' torture
on March
05-06/2024
In conclusion... Gaza died and Sinwar lived!/Muhammad Al-Saed/Okaz/March 05,
2024
The Illusion of a Palestinian 'Demilitarized' State/Bassam Tawil/Gatestone
Institute./March 05/2024
Gazans need international protection, not just a ceasefire/Osama Al-Sharif/Arab
News/March 05, 2024
Using smartphones in class smartly is better than a ban/Yossi Mekelberg/Arab
News/March 05, 2024
What will the US election mean for its foreign policy?/Dalia Al-Aqidi/Arab
News/March 05, 2024
What Democrats’ ‘uncommitted’ campaign means for US policy/Kerry Boyd
Anderson/Arab News/March 05, 2024
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on March 05-06/2024
Elias Bejjani/Video/ Let
us be unequivocally clear, Hezbollah is an Iranian
jihadist terrorist organization.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqN3v0jR7_4
March 05, 2024
Video and Text/To All Owners of Tamed Political
Parties, Politicians, Clergymen, and Mouthpiece
Figures such as Gebran Bassil and Melhem Riachi: Let
us be unequivocally clear, Hezbollah is an Iranian
jihadist terrorist organization.
Elias Bejjani/March 05, 2024
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/127620/127620/
It is imperative to uphold the truth and address national matters candidly,
devoid of falsehoods. It is our staunch belief that any Lebanese politician,
political party owner, journalist, activist, citizen, or religious figure who
propagates the false notion that Hezbollah is a legitimate Lebanese resistance
entity is not only deceiving the public, but also
inflicting harm upon Lebanon and its people. Such individuals must be
Judicially held accountable.
It is high time to debunk the fabricated myths, legends, and delusions
surrounding Hezbollah, the Iranian terrorist proxy. None of the
below following assertions hold any truth:
Hezbollah is a Lebanese entity representing the Shiite community in parliament.
Hezbollah is a legitimate armed resistance body in Lebanon.
Hezbollah liberated South Lebanon from Israeli occupation in 2000.
Hezbollah defeated Israel in the 2006 war.
Hezbollah's armed members killed in Lebanon or abroad while fighting in Iranian
battlefields are martyrs.
Hezbollah is defending Lebanon from Israel and jihadist groups such as ISIS,
Daesh, and Al Qaeda.
These claims, in addition to many other similar false
allegations are nothing but lies, illusions, and self-deception.
The undeniable reality about Hezbollah is as follows:
Hezbollah is solely an Iranian jihadist armed proxy and an enemy of Lebanon and
its people. This fact has been explicitly stated and proudly proclaimed by the
party's leaders, from the highest echelons to the ranks.
Contrary to claims, Hezbollah does not represent the Shiite communities in
Lebanon; instead, it holds them hostages through
coercion and terrorism. It sends their youth to senseless deaths in battles for
the Iranian regime across various countries, including Lebanon, Syria, Iraq,
Yemen, and Gaza. Furthermore, Hezbollah has imposed its 27 members of parliament
on the Shiites through force, intimidation, and assassinations, preventing any
opposition against its terrorist agenda.
The deaths of Hezbollah members in South Lebanon, and
i other Iranian battlefields are not martyrs but
victims. Legally, Hezbollah leaders who recruit individuals without any legal
Lebanese or international law standards must face
judicial accountability.
Hezbollah did not liberate South Lebanon in 2000, nor did it emerge
victorious in the 2006 war. Instead, it continues to occupy South Lebanon, as
well as exert control over the entire country following the withdrawal of
Israeli and Syrian forces. The 2006 war brought catastrophe upon Lebanon and its
people, while Israel's withdrawal from South Lebanon in 2000 was solely driven
by Israeli political and strategic agendas.
Contrary to popular belief, it was Hezbollah that declared war against Israel
and initiated aggression following the start of the Gaza war in October,
07/ 2023, not the other way around.
Therefore, anyone who promotes the fallacy of appeasing Hezbollah within the
Lebanese framework, altering the Lebanese system, or legitimizing its Iranian
weapons under the guise of a defensive strategy must face legal consequences.
In accordance with global standards of sovereignty and independence, leaders of
the terrorist Iranian proxy, Hezbollah, must be apprehended and brought to
justice.
Additionally, UN resolutions pertaining to Lebanon (such as the Armistice
Accord, Resolution 1559, Resolution 1701, and Resolution 1860), as well as the
"Taif Agreement", must be
enforced. These resolutions and agreements mandate the disarmament of all
Lebanese and non-Lebanese militias, and the establishment of state authority
through legitimate and sovereign forces across Lebanese territory.
In conclusion, Lebanon's current woes stem not from its system but from the
Iranian occupation masked by corrupt and deceitful politicians and rulers. That
is the undeniable truth.
Gallant tells Hochstein Israel committed to diplomacy
but may resort to military action
Naharnet/March 05, 2024
Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant on Tuesday held talks with U.S. mediator
Amos Hochstein, who had visited Lebanon on Monday as he seeks to mediate a
solution for the Israel-Hezbollah border conflict. “We are committed to the
political efforts to reach an agreement, but Hezbollah's aggression brings us
closer to a decision point regarding our military action in Lebanon," Gallant
told Hochstein. Hochstein had said Monday that a diplomatic solution was key to
ending nearly five months of intensifying hostilities between Hezbollah and
Israel. "A diplomatic solution is the only way to end the current hostilities"
and achieve "a lasting fair security arrangement between Lebanon and Israel,"
Hochstein told reporters in Beirut, adding that "a temporary ceasefire is not
enough.""A limited war is not containable," he warned after meeting with Speaker
Nabih Berri, a Hezbollah ally.
Security along the Blue Line, demarcated by the United Nations in 2000 after
Israeli troops pulled out of southern Lebanon, "has to change in order to
guarantee everyone's security," he added. The cross-border fighting has
displaced tens of thousands on both sides and has killed at least 299 people in
Lebanon, most of them Hezbollah fighters but also including 49 civilians. In
Israel, at least 10 soldiers and seven civilians have been killed and Israel has
repeatedly warned that it might launch an operation against Hezbollah to secure
the border area and return its residents to the north.
Hochstein holds 'positive' talks with Berri amid
'encouraging' signs
Naharnet/March 05, 2024
A “positive atmosphere” engulfed the meeting that Speaker Nabih Berri held
Monday with U.S. mediator Amos Hochstein, informed sources said. “The two men
agreed on a host of encouraging signs, which if respected and implemented on the
ground would lead to halting the war in the South between Israel and Hezbollah,”
the sources told Annahar newspaper in remarks published Tuesday. “Hochstein did
not carry a written paper containing his proposals, but rather raised old and
new ideas involving a halt of military operations, the return of displaced
residents to both sides of the border, and halting military activities south of
the Litani River, which would eventually lead to discussing a comprehensive
agreement over the situation on the border, from the B1 point all the way to the
Shebaa Farms,” the sources added. According to ad-Diyar newspaper, Hochstein
told Berri that once a truce is declared in Gaza, he would return to Lebanon to
“discuss a blueprint for the implementation of Resolution 1701.”Al-Akhbar
newspaper meanwhile said that the U.S. envoy’s proposals included ideas for
“creating an economic support program for the southern areas and pledges that
would guarantee the resumption of oil and gas exploration by the global
companies.” Quoting officials who met with Hochstein, the daily said the U.S.
mediator stated that Washington “wants, at any cost, to reach a mechanism that
would prevent a deterioration of things on the Lebanese front to a major
confrontation.”And as the Nidaa al-Watan newspaper said Hezbollah told Hochstein
through Berri that “there won’t be discussions before the Gaza truce,” al-Liwaa
daily said Hochstein called for consolidating calm in the South during the
expected Gaza truce and maintaining it even if war resumes in the Palestinian
enclave.
Three civilians killed in Israel strike on Lebanon
Agencies/March 05, 2024
BEIRUT: A Lebanese couple and their son were killed Tuesday in an Israeli strike
on a house in the southern border village of Hula, Lebanon’s official National
News Agency reported. Lebanon’s Iran-backed Hezbollah movement and Israel have
traded deadly cross-border fire on a near-daily basis since war broke out in
October between Israel and Gaza’s rulers Hamas, a Hezbollah ally. “The three
civilians, Hassan Hussein, his wife, Ruwaida Mustafa, and their 25-year-old son,
Ali Hussein, were killed in the enemy raid on a three-story house in Hula,” NNA
said. “Search operations and the removal of rubble are continuing,” it added.
Shortly before the strike, Hezbollah said it had targeted the Israeli city of
Kiryat Shmona in response to Israeli attacks on “civilian homes,” particularly
Bint Jbeil. The Lebanese Shiite movement also said it carried out several
attacks on Israeli military positions on the border on Tuesday. NNA had reported
on Monday evening that Israeli air raids targeted Bint Jbeil, but no casualties
were reported. Also on Monday, a missile fired from Lebanon killed a foreign
worker in Israel, according to the army, and three Hezbollah-affiliated
paramedics were killed in an Israeli raid on southern Lebanon, according to
Hezbollah. It came as US envoy Amos Hochstein said a diplomatic solution was key
to ending nearly five months of intensifying hostilities between Hezbollah and
Israel. “A diplomatic solution is the only way to end the current hostilities”
and achieve “a lasting fair security arrangement between Lebanon and Israel,” he
said, adding “a temporary ceasefire is not enough.”Israeli Defense Minister Yoav
Gallant has said there will be no let-up in Israeli action against Hezbollah
even if a Gaza ceasefire is secured. The fighting has killed at least 302 people
in Lebanon, most of them Hezbollah fighters but also including at least 51
civilians, according to an AFP tally. In Israel, at least 10 soldiers and seven
civilians have been killed.
Hezbollah targets Kiryat Shmona in response to Bint Jbeil
strike
Associated Press/March 05, 2024
Hezbollah targeted Tuesday Kiryat Shmona and carried out four other attacks on
northern Israel, while Israeli artillery shelled in response the Marjayoun plain
and al-Wazzani. Hezbollah said it targeted Kiryat Shmona "in response to the
Israeli attacks on southern villages and civilians, especially on Bint Jbeil."
The group had attacked at dawn an Israeli force near the al-Raheb post with
artillery shells and another armored force later in the day in the Berkat Risha
post. The group also targeted a group of soldiers on the Tayhat hill and a
Merkava tank in the Netu'a settlement "while it was shelling villages and
civilians." The attack on Netu'a inflicted casualties, according to Hezbollah's
statement. The attacks Tuesday came after a deadly and violent day during which
an Israeli airstrike killed three Hezbollah paramedics in Odaisseh and a missile
strike blamed on Hezbollah - although not claimed by the group - killed at least
one foreign worker in Margaliot in northern Israel. Later on Monday, Israeli
warplanes raided the southern towns of al-Sultaniyeh, Seddiqin and Bint Jbeil.
The deadly violence Monday came as a senior U.S. envoy visited Beirut and warned
that a Gaza truce wouldn't necessarily apply to conflict along the
Lebanon-Israel border. Amos Hochstein urged the parties to reach a lasting
cease-fire at the border following meetings Monday with Lebanese leaders. His
comments came hours after Hezbollah deputy leader Naim Qassem said the only way
to restore calm along the border is to end the war on Gaza.
Since the Israel-Hamas war started, Hezbollah has been exchanging fire with
Israel almost daily, displacing thousands of people and spiking fear that the
conflict may spread through the region. In northern Israel, 60,000 people have
evacuated, the Israeli government says. "People won't come back anytime soon,
they're scared, it's dangerous," Haim Menus, 70, said Monday while buying
hardware at one of the rare stores open in the nearly abandoned northern Israeli
town of Kiryat Shmona. He is one of the few who have remained, working curtailed
hours at a bakery.
"An anti-tank missile could come at any time," Menus said. Moments later, an
anti-tank missile struck a field in the nearby community of Margaliot as sirens
blared, killing one Indian worker and injuring seven other foreign workers from
India and Thailand, according the Israel Rescue Services and the Israeli army.
In Beirut, Hochstein began his talks by meeting Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri.
He later met with caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati and the army commander,
Gen. Joseph Aoun. Asked if a cease-fire in the Gaza Strip would include Lebanon,
he said it wouldn't necessarily be the case "that when you have a cease-fire in
Gaza, it automatically extends. That is why we are here today to be able to have
a conversation and discussions" on the situation in Lebanon. Since the Israel-Hamas
war began, more than 215 Hezbollah fighters and nearly 40 civilians were killed
on the Lebanese side while in Israel, nine soldiers and 10 civilians were left
dead in the attacks. Israeli officials have threatened a wider war in Lebanon if
Hezbollah does not withdraw its elite fighters north of the Litani River as
stipulated in a 2006 truce that ended a 34-day Israel-Hezbollah war. Western
diplomats have brought forward a series of proposals for a cessation of
hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah, most of which would hinge on Hezbollah
moving its forces 7-10 kilometers away from the border. Qassem, Hezbollah's
deputy leader, blasted the United States in a speech Monday during a conference
held in the group's stronghold south of Beirut attended by Muslim clerics from
several regional states. He blamed Washington for using its veto power three
times to prevent resolutions at the U.N. Security Council to end the war in
Gaza. "We have said it clearly that whoever wants to be a mediator should
mediate to stop the aggression," Qassem said in his speech. He added that those
who don't want the war to expand in the region should deal with the cause "which
is the brutal and criminal aggression by America and Israel against Gaza.""Stop
the aggression on Gaza and the war will stop in the region," he said.
Talks on ending Lebanon-Israel border hostilities to begin
in Ramadan, Lebanese PM says
REUTERS/March 06, 2024
BEIRUT: Indirect talks to end hostilities along the Lebanese-Israeli border will
begin during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan which starts next week, Lebanon’s
caretaker prime minister Najib Mikati said on Tuesday. Powerful Lebanese armed
group Hezbollah and Israel have been exchanging fire for nearly five months in
parallel with the Gaza war, prompting diplomatic efforts aimed at staving off an
escalation. In an interview on Tuesday night with local Lebanese broadcaster Al
Jadeed, Mikati said long-term stability on the southern border required Israel
to stop violating Lebanon’s territorial integrity and to return territories it
occupies all along the border. He said Lebanon’s parliament speaker Nabih Berri
— who is close to Hezbollah — was studying a proposal suggested verbally by US
envoy Amos Hochstein, who was in Beirut on Monday. Mikati said the proposal
centered on how to fully implement United Nations Security Council Resolution
1701, which ended the month-long war fought in 2006 between Hezbollah and
Israel. It calls for a withdrawal of non-state armed actors from southern
Lebanon and a deployment of up to 15,000 Lebanese army troops. Lebanon has
accused Israel of violating the resolution more than 30,000 times, and says it
would be ready to implement it fully. Mikati said Hochstein’s proposal also
included “a development plan for south Lebanon,” that would be backed by Arab
states and other countries outside the region. He said Lebanon still had
questions about the proposal and had some preliminary comments on it, and that
either he or Berri would speak to Hochstein within the next 48 hours,
particularly to learn Israel’s position as the US envoy traveled on to Tel Aviv
from Beirut. Mikati said the timeline for implementation was “elastic.”
Hezbollah is one of several Iran-aligned groups around the Middle East that have
entered the fray since Oct. 7, when Hamas militants stormed Israel from the Gaza
Strip, triggering a fierce Israeli land, air and sea offensive on Gaza.
Hezbollah, an ally of Hamas, has said its campaign aims to support the
Palestinians under Israeli bombardment. Mikati told Reuters in an exclusive
interview last week that a halt to fighting in the Gaza Strip would trigger
indirect talks to end hostilities along Lebanon’s southern border. But in Beirut
on Monday, Hochstein warned that a truce in Gaza would not necessarily
automatically bring calm to Lebanon’s southern border and he warned about the
risks of an escalation of the conflict.
Hezbollah buries the “Moderation” initiative with “There
is no president but a resistance man”
Mikati: Hockstein has entrusted us with a mechanism for 1701. Israel informs the
American envoy that it is close to a decision on war.
Neda Al Watan/March 06, 2024
What Israel said after its officials’ talks yesterday with US envoy Amos
Hockstein, and through Defense Minister Yoav Galant, indicates that the military
option to resolve the conflict on the front with Lebanon is still adjacent to
the diplomatic option. On the other hand, caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati
revealed yesterday evening that the American envoy “put a proposal on the table
and Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri is studying it and there will be a response
to it, and we have questions that we are waiting for answers from the American
envoy.” He said: “Hochstein presented oral ideas, but there is no written paper
on the Lebanon front.” Mikati expressed his belief that Berri “is consulting
with Hezbollah,” noting that “when we have a written paper on Hochstein’s
proposal, I will consult with the party.” He concluded that “the Hochstein
initiative will, over time, gain international coverage.” In this context,
diplomatic circles told “Nidaa al-Watan” that Hochstein informed Lebanese
officials that “Israel does not want to repeat the 2006 experience in terms of
implementing Resolution 1701, which remained practically unimplemented for
almost 18 years.” As for the conditions on the field on the southern border,
yesterday evening was marked by the announcement by the “Islamic Resistance,”
the military wing of the “Party,” in a statement that it had “bombed the Kfar
Blum colony with dozens of Katyusha rockets.” The statement said that this
bombing was in order to support Gaza and in response to “A civilian’s house was
targeted and a woman, her husband, and their son were martyred in the town of
Hula.” What about the Hockstein talks in Israel? He went to Tel Aviv immediately
after his visit to Lebanon and met with Israeli War Council member Benny Gantz.
Then he met Gallant, who told him the following: “We are committed to the
diplomatic process. However, Hezbollah’s aggression brings us closer to a
critical point in decision-making regarding our military activities in Lebanon.”
Gallant-Hochstein warned that Hezbollah was dragging the parties into a
“dangerous” escalation. According to a readout from the Israeli Defense
Minister's Office, Gallant and Hockstein spoke of "Hezbollah's daily attacks
with rockets, shells and drones, as well as efforts to reach an agreement that
would see the Iran-backed organization withdraw from the border and end
hostilities, to empower some 80,000 displaced people." Residents of northern
Israel are unable to return to their homes. In parallel, Israeli media reported
that “Gantz informed US National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan that Israel is
not seeking war with Lebanon.” At the same time, “Gantz told Sullivan that
Washington’s supply of weapons to Israel would make Hezbollah think twice before
any escalation.” From developments related to the south, to developments related
to the presidential file, “Call of the Nation” learned that what the mediators
on the line of this file heard was that “Hezbollah” is being tougher
presidentially, and it refuses to repeat the experience of President Michel
Suleiman. What is accepted is the election of the head of the Marada Movement,
Suleiman Franjieh, or the election of a president who resembles former president
Emile Lahoud, whom the “party” used to call and still calls the “resistance
president.” Therefore, there is no room for testing a centrist president or one
who submits to Western pressure.” This information concludes by saying that “the
parliamentary initiative of the Moderation Front was practically torpedoed, and
the “party” took charge of burying it.”
Unusual measures in the suburb... “Israeli aggression in
its heart”?
Janoubia/March 05, 2024
A website close to Hezbollah revealed that “unusual” security measures were
taken in the southern suburb of Beirut recently, indicating fears of “hostile
Israeli action” against it. Al-Ahed website said in information published on
Tuesday afternoon, citing security sources, that there were “severe and unusual
measures witnessed in the suburb by security forces and Hezbollah members.” The
party also “tightened the security of its centers after becoming concerned about
a number of violations that occurred recently in the suburb.” Reports indicated
strange arrests that took place last week in the suburb, of members of UNIFIL,
another of a Dutch group affiliated with the embassy, and a third of a Spanish
diplomat. The three parties said they lost their way before they were arrested
by the party and then handed over to the security and judicial services.
Security sources told Al-Ahed website that “the measures taken in the suburb are
for the purpose of prevention and precaution,” and that the main reason “is due
to fear of Israeli hostile action in the heart of the suburb.” Since October 8,
Israel has launched an aggression against Hezbollah members in a number of
southern border areas. It also carried out an assassination operation in the
heart of the southern suburbs on January 3, killing the deputy head of Hamas and
the movement’s leader in the West Bank, Saleh Al-Arouri, and two leaders of the
“Hamas” Brigades. Al-Qassam” in Lebanon. According to statistics from the
Janoubia website, 232 party members, including seven paramedics, have so far
been martyred in the ongoing bombing operations.
Since the start of the battles 5 months ago, Hula has paid
the price for its steadfastness with 8 martyrs
Hussein Saad/Janoubia/March 05, 2024
The continuous Israeli attacks on his town of Hula did not force the citizen,
Hassan Ali Hussein, to leave the town and its land, which he loves and tills. He
remained steadfast with his wife and children, in the northern neighborhood of
Hula, close to its cemetery. He was one of the few steadfast people, digging the
graves of the dead and martyrs. Until the day he was martyred, along with his
wife Ruwaida Mustafa and Falza Kabdeh Ali, by Israeli enemy missiles that
destroyed the house on their innocent and tender bodies. Hassan, his wife, and
their son, Ali, fell under the Israeli hatred, so they joined the convoy of
martyrs, who had no sin except to punish them for clinging to the town, which
from 1948 until today has provided hundreds of martyrs. After the martyrdom of
Nasifa Mazraani and her son Muhammad, at the beginning of the Israeli
aggression, as a result of a bombing on their house, after that, three martyrs
fell, in a bombing on the old neighborhoods of the town, namely Gendarmerie Ali
Mahdi, Hussein Musa Hussein and Noha Mazraani, so that the number of civilian
martyrs in this town rose to, Eight martyrs, along with the martyrs of today's
massacre, preceded by Ahmed Hassan Mustafa, a martyr on the road to Jerusalem.
As in the past, a number of southern towns experienced, directly and indirectly,
the terror caused by the enemy’s military raids on homes and the fake raids that
shook the homes of citizens throughout the south. After Houla, Israeli aircraft
raided a three-story house in the town of Dibin, near Marjayoun, destroying it,
while emergency sources reported four wounded civilians. This was preceded by
violent raids in which heavy missiles were used, including houses in Majdal Zoun,
the Butm Mountains, Kafra and Aita al-Shaab, in addition to throwing thermal
balloons, the Lebanese Army Command in Baban Laha warned against approaching or
touching these balloons. Meanwhile, Hezbollah responded to the targeting of
civilians in Houla, by bombing the Kfar Blum settlement with dozens of Katyusha
rockets, and also targeting a building in the Kiryat Shmona settlement and
directly hitting it. The party also launched, according to statements from its
military media, attacks on the occupation sites in Al-Tahat, Al-Baghdadi, and
Ruwaisat Al-Alam. Al-Raheb, Birkat Risha, and the Natua settlement. The Israeli
media described the missiles launched from Lebanon, towards the occupied
Palestinian north, as the largest in number since the beginning of the war, as
their number exceeded seventy missiles.
Moderation Bloc's presidential initiative hinging on 'Hezbollah's answers'
Naharnet/March 05, 2024
Monday’s meeting between the National Moderation Bloc and Hezbollah’s
parliamentary bloc did not lead to setting a date for a consultative
parliamentary meeting that would kickstart the Moderation Bloc’s initiative that
is aimed at securing the election of a new president, media reports said. The
bloc is “awaiting answers from Hezbollah regarding some related details,” Asharq
al-Awsat newspaper reported on Tuesday. The National Moderation Bloc had met
with the other parliamentary blocs prior to its meeting with Hezbollah in Haret
Hreik on Monday.
“Hezbollah’s MPs expressed certain concerns over the initiative, but we
presented answers,” Moderation Bloc sources told Asharq al-Awsat. “We’re
optimistic regarding the initiative, because it has pushed several parties
forward in the presidential election file,” the sources added. After they
receive the answers from Hezbollah’s bloc, the members of the Moderation Bloc
are supposed to brief Speaker Nabih Berri on the outcome of their meetings in
order to decide the next steps, specifically as to the consultative
parliamentary meeting, Asharq al-Awsat said.
Mikati says only way to peace is 'deterring Israel'
Naharnet/March 05, 2024
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati called Tuesday on the international
community to stop Israel's agressions and to work on peaceful solutions for the
region. "In order for this region to know peace and prosperity, Israeli
aggressions against southern Lebanon and Gaza must stop [...] and Israel must be
compelled to implement international resolutions, especially Resolution 1701,"
Mikati said, adding that "Israel must also withdraw from all the Lebanese
territories that are still occupied." The PM urged the Lebanese to unite and
unify their voices to demand the international community to deter Israel and
work to provide peaceful solutions to the region.
Raad: We have not used all our weapons yet
Naharnet /March 05, 2024
14 hours agoThe head of Hezbollah’s parliamentary bloc, MP Mohammad Raad, noted
Tuesday that Hezbollah is “still committed to accuracy in the deterrence
equations it has imposed on the Israeli enemy.”Israel is “trying to evade” the
aforementioned equations, “but will not be able to revoke them,” Raad stressed.
“Why is Israel threatening, warning and giving one deadline after another and
why is it not committing an act that would entangle it the same way it is
entangled in Gaza? Because it knows that a trouble with the Lebanese would have
dire consequences for its entity,” Raad said. “We do not wish for war and we are
not seeking it, but we are fully prepared to face it,” the lawmaker went on to
say. Noting that Hezbollah is trying to spare Lebanon and its people an all-out
war with Israel because it would involve “blood and losses,” Raad emphasized
that “the biggest and strategic loser in it would be the Zionist enemy.”“We have
not used all our weapons and we have not yet opened the arms depots of open war.
The enemy knows this,” Raad added.
Berri lauds National Moderation bloc's presidential
initiative
Naharnet/March 05, 2024
Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri is open to a presidential initiative by the
National Moderation bloc. "Their initiative is clear - there is no ambiguity,”
Berri told al-Joumhouria, in remarks published Tuesday, adding that he has
expressed "positivity" towards it. Berri said he has discussed with the bloc's
MPs the smallest details about the initiative. He expressed willingness to call
for an open session with successive rounds, but said that rounds cannot go on
indefinitely."If MPs fail to agree on a president's name through dialogue, I am
ready to call for an electoral session with successive rounds, but if we fail to
elect a president in that session, it is my duty to end it, and schedule another
one," Berri explained. "Otherwise, keeping the session open would disrupt the
legislative role of Parliament, the only constitutional institution still
functioning today."
Lebanese state initiates roadmap to address Syrian refugee
crisis: Mechanism unveiled
LBCI/March 05, 2024
The Lebanese state has consistently linked resolving the Syrian refugee crisis
to obtaining data from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)
to develop a plan for organizing their presence or facilitating their return to
their homeland. On December 5, 2023, the General Security received the data,
representing only the number of refugees in Lebanon, which is 1,486,000 refugees
without including additional details. Therefore, the state, particularly the
Ministry of Interior and the General Security, has initiated a roadmap to
directly regulate the legal status of refugees and a mechanism for their return.
The mechanism aims to categorize refugees between those who hold the status of
"refugee," that is, those who came to Lebanon before 2015 and are protected by
the international humanitarian law designated for displaced persons, and those
who arrived after 2015 after the Lebanese state closed its borders and issued a
decision to stop registering those coming from Syria under the status of
refugee, but under a separate category. The latter group falls under Lebanese
law, without international legal protection. They must obtain residency or work
permits and fulfill all their obligations, such as taxes and others. This
roadmap will be implemented in collaboration with municipalities and some
associations to gather information about all refugees. The initiative will start
in the northern Matn district as a pilot phase and will later extend to all
districts. Thus, the state is attempting to find a solution to this crisis, away
from politics, narrow interests, and, most importantly, far from the racism that
some apply to this issue.
Lebanese Forces criticize Berri's 'obstruction' of presidential elections
LBCI/March 05, 2024
The media office of the Lebanese Forces party stated in a press release that
Speaker of the Parliament Nabih Berri "has not only persisted in obstructing the
presidential elections for over a year and four months but has also taken it
upon himself to stifle any serious initiative for holding the presidential
elections."
It said that his latest attempt was to "place obstacles in the path of the
National Moderation bloc initiative, seeking to hinder it." It added: "After the
National Moderation bloc made strides in preparing for a natural and intuitive
consultative meeting among parliamentary blocs in preparation for electing a
president, Speaker Berri imposed conditions here and obstacles there. So, where
is the problem if parliamentary blocs convene for a mini-parliamentary session
in the Parliament? Isn't it customary, conventional, and logical to conduct this
type of consultation as preparation for the presidential elections?"The
statement continued, "The irony lies in obstructing the presidential elections
and distracting people every day with new 'news' far from reality and the
Constitution." "If Speaker Berri, you insist on your candidate, that is your
right, but it is by no means your right to continue obstructing the presidential
elections because you could not secure the parliamentary majority that
authorizes victory.""What is truly strange and perplexing is keeping Lebanon
without a president and without constitutional regularity in one of the most
critical phases the country is going through, only to achieve the equation of
'either our candidate or a vacuum, and let Lebanon deal with the consequences,"
it said. The press release concluded, "What is truly strange and perplexing is
the insistence on unconstitutional methods, as the presidential elections must
take precedence in an open session and successive daily rounds until the
election of a president."
Hezbollah Deputy Secretary-General emphasizes support for Frangieh, asserts
readiness to respond to Israeli actions if Gaza ceasefire excludes southern
Lebanon
LBCI/March 05, 2024
Sheikh Naim Qassem, the Deputy Secretary-General of Hezbollah, reaffirmed
Sleiman Frangieh's position as their primary presidential candidate, stating,
"At present, we are not considering another candidate. Others must adapt, not
us." Sheikh Naim Qassem also confirmed, "We have yet to provide a definitive
response to the National Moderation Bloc regarding the presidential initiative."
In an interview on LBCI's "Kalam Bel Siyasa," Qassem highlighted that Sleiman
Frangieh embodies the resistance axis's political ethos, "encompassing the Free
Patriotic Movement from our perspective."He further noted, "Frangieh has
reconciled with Geagea, maintains engagements with Arab nations, communicates
with the Americans, and is open to dialogue with all parties."He identified the
current presidential deadlock as internal, emphasizing the parties'
unwillingness to compromise. "Why should we be the ones to compromise? They
cannot assign blame to us; we do not impose our will on anyone, nor should
anyone impose theirs on us."Qassem questioned, "Who are they seeking? A
president who opposes Hezbollah? That is something we cannot accept. Only the
future will tell; perhaps we will support Frangieh as president." He refuted the
notion of a Christian coalition against the Hezbollah-Amal alliance. "The
convergence between the Free Patriotic Movement and the Lebanese Forces was
aimed at sidelining Sleiman Frangieh and nominating another candidate," he
stressed. He also emphasized that the constitution ensures sectarian balance by
requiring a quorum of 86 members of parliament (MPs), thereby validating the
right of Hezbollah and its allies to obstruct the quorum in successive sessions.
He stated, "We reserve the right to disagreement. When will they relinquish
their obstinacy?
Relationship with the Free Patriotic Movement
Regarding Hezbollah's relationship with the Free Patriotic Movement, he
expressed that both parties have come to different beliefs and visions. They
agreed that each would voice its perspective, acknowledging differences on
multiple topics. Qassem mentioned, "We have decided within the party to abstain
from engaging in debates about the relationship with the Free Patriotic
Movement." He noted, "While the Mar Mikhael understanding with the Free
Patriotic Movement is on pause, communication remains open."
War in the South
Qassem reflected on Hezbollah's pragmatism in the current conflict between the
party and Israel in southern Lebanon. He said that the party had made the
greatest sacrifices and suffered the most casualties to preserve Lebanese life.
"We separate the southern events from the domestic scenario," he said. He
declared, "The US leads the conflict, not Israel; we have borne the burden." He
asserted, "We have not embroiled Lebanon in conflict; the Israeli adversary
exists independently and does not need a justification to initiate conflict
against us. Our belief is in preemptive confrontation against the Israelis,
viewing it as a justified response following their assault on Gaza."The Deputy
Secretary-General remarked, "Israel will hesitate to escalate if it perceives
our readiness; should it proceed, we will respond more vigorously. We haven't
dragged Lebanon into conflict; a significant Israeli threat exists, capable of
initiating conflict at any moment without pretext. Early deterrence is crucial
to safeguard Lebanon, ensuring Israeli restraint benefits all Lebanese."He
further explained, "An undeterred enemy poses a constant threat of war. It's in
every Lebanese's interest for this adversary to remain deterred. The timing
demonstrates solidarity with Gaza and serves Lebanon's interests. We are
positioned defensively against an encroaching enemy." Sheikh Qassem stated, "We
have no intention of initiating war, but cannot remain passive if one is
imposed. Without effective deterrence, the Israelis will persist.""Amos
Hochstein's directives do not bind us; we do not interfere in state and
government-led negotiations. Upon the cessation of hostilities, these matters
will be deliberated," he announced. He noted, "In the ongoing conflict in Gaza,
no commitments or agreements are in place. Should a ceasefire emerge in Gaza,
and if the Israelis reject peace in southern Lebanon, we will resist them. They
cannot impose terms on us; they will face defeat."
Maronite Patriarch Cardinal Mar Bechara Boutros Al-Rai broaches local, regional
developments with MP Douaihy, meets Tripoli Bar Association delegation
NNA/March 05, 2024
Maronite Patriarch Cardinal Mar Bechara Boutros Al-Rai, on Monday received, in
Bkerke,, MP Michel Douaihy, with whom he discussed the current developments
locally and regionally.Patriarch Rahi then received in Bkerke the head of the
Tripoli Bar Association, Sami Al-Hassan, on top of a delegation from the
Association, who paid him a protocol visit. Discussions reportedly touched on
the current general situation. Following the visit, Al-Hassan stressed "the
necessity of speeding up the election of a President of the Republic in order to
regularize work in all institutions, and to preserve public liberties and
freedom of expression." Al-Hassan added, "We also touched on the existing
conflict and dispute in Qornet al-Sawda between the towns of Bsharri and Bekaa
Safrin and the necessity of cooperation to end this dispute in accordance with
the law and personal and tribal reconciliation in order to preserve
coexistence."
United Nations and European Union improve the livelihoods
and employment prospects for youth in Tripoli and Al-Beddawi
NNA/March 05, 2024
Committed to supporting local authorities improve livelihoods and youth services
in Lebanon, the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the United
Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-Habitat) with the generous support of
the European Union inaugurated the newly digitized public library system at
Nawfal Palace, Tripoli and business incubator and agricultural training center
at the rehabilitated Al-Beddawi Castle in Al-Beddawi municipality. The
protracted socioeconomic, financial, and political crises in Lebanon have
severely impacted municipalities, including those of Tripoli and Al-Beddawi.
This has affected the services municipalities can provide, as well as their
efforts to preserve historical buildings such as Nawfal Palace and Al-Beddawi
Castle.
Nawfal Palace
The rehabilitation of the Palace was made possible through the European Union's
funding of US$ 145,000. This contribution not only facilitated the restoration
work but also equipped the palace with CCTV cameras, a sound system, a
high-definition projector, and other essential equipment that supported the
library’s modernization. The work involved eliminating water leaks and restoring
the historical ceilings, building facades, windows, and walls. This initial
phase was completed in August 2023, and the Palace re-opened to the public in
September of the same year.
The second phase of the restoration, recently finalized, includes the renovation
of remaining parts of the Palace's ceiling and the establishment of a library
archiving system to monitor the usage of the library's books. This will
facilitate residents access to invaluable content at the palace library, home to
over 10,000 volumes spanning diverse disciplines and including century-old
documents. It will also contribute to revitalizing both the palace and its
library, and in creating an inclusive cultural space for all. Al-Beddawi Castle
Business Incubator and Agricultural Initiative
The business incubator and agricultural initiative at Al-Beddawi castle were
implemented by the UN in partnership with the municipality to complement its
socioeconomic development plan through the European Union's funding of US$
251,310. The main objective of this initiative is to improve the socioeconomic
situation of young people in Al-Beddawi municipality, through the provision of
vocational and business-related training opportunities. These trainings, which
the municipality will implement in partnership with different local civil
society organizations, come in response to the very high unemployment rate among
young people in the area. The first trainings are expected to start in April
2024 and will benefit at least 80 young people in the first training round.
To accommodate the trainings, several improvements were made to the castle – a
historically classified building – including upgrading its electrical network
and lighting, as well as the installation of a solar power system to provide the
castle with continuous and green electricity. Furthermore, the castle’s
facilities were renovated, and its roof was weatherproofed to prevent water
leaks.
The business incubator was equipped with electrical appliances and information
technology equipment. Furthermore, a studio sound system will be delivered in
the coming period to facilitate the delivery of trainings in partnership with
QUAD related to entrepreneurship, market analysis, and marketing among others.
As part of the agricultural initiative, two municipal lands were upgraded to
allow for agricultural related trainings. The lands were equipped with an
electrical generator, irrigation system, water tanks, and solar panels. A water
truck will also be provided in the ensuing months as well as all needed
gardening tools, seeds, and plants, to support the agricultural training
activities. Furthermore, additional funds will be allocated to support the
implementation of agricultural training for youth and women in the area,
expected to start in April 2024.
"UNDP is dedicated to enhancing livelihoods in Lebanon by supporting local
authorities. By rehabilitating Nawfal Palace and digitizing its library, we
offer the youth of Tripoli and the North access to invaluable resources and
training opportunities. Similarly, the refurbished Al-Beddawi Castle and
adjacent agricultural lands will facilitate vocational and business training for
Al-Beddawi's youth, boosting their employability. We emphasize the importance of
municipalities' ongoing maintenance and support for these projects to guarantee
their sustainability," said UNDP Lebanon Acting Resident Representative Mohammed
Salih. “Preserving historical places in cities is key to maintaining their
social fabric and identity for future generations. I am happy to see these
spaces transformed so that they are multipurpose and can be used by the public
as a place to come together, learn and exchange experiences. Not only are these
spaces now accessible, but they can also provide a wealth of opportunities for
people – especially youth – to gain knowledge and skills that can facilitate
their access to wider livelihood opportunities and income-generating
activities,” said Taina Christiansen, Head of UN-Habitat Lebanon.
Lebanese Army Chief broaches general situation with MP Abou
El-Hessen, discusses retired military personnel affairs with Armed Forces
Retirees Association...
NNA/March 05, 2024
Army Commander, General Joseph Aoun, on Tuesday received at his Yarzeh office,
MP Hadi Abou El-Hessen, with whom he discussed the country’s general situation.
The Army Chief also received a delegation from the Armed Forces Retirees
Association, headed by retired Major General Nicolas Mezher.
Discussions reportedly touched on affairs related to the retired military
personnel.
Fuel prices in Lebanon: Gasoline up, diesel down in recent
adjustments
NNA/March 05, 2024
The price of 95 and 98 octane gasoline increased by 6,000 LBP, while the price
of diesel decreased by 15,000 LBP and the gas cylinder by 2,000 LBP. The new
prices are as follows:
- 95 octane gasoline: LBP 1,663,000
- 98 octane gasoline: LBP 1,701,000
- Diesel: LBP 1,594,000
- Gas cylinder: LBP 946,000
The American envoy punishes Bou Habib... by meeting with
Maronite representatives
Ghada Halawi/Nedal Al Watan/March 06, 2024
During his previous visit to Lebanon, a difference in views emerged between US
Presidential Envoy Amos Hockstein and Foreign Minister Abdullah Bou Habib
against the backdrop of the implementation of Resolution 1701, as Bou Habib
demanded that Israel implement the international resolution in full while
withdrawing from the Shebaa Farms and the Kfar Shuba Hills. Hockstein urgently
asked him to stop discussing the issue. The issue of withdrawal is because it is
not subject to discussion by Israel. On that day, Bou Habib considered that
skipping the withdrawal meant that there was no solution for the southern front,
criticizing Netanyahu’s threats of war, destruction, and killing. The meeting
was not comfortable for Hockstein, who excluded Bou Habib from his tour, and
caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati did not ask him to join the meeting with
the guest in the government palace, contrary to custom. Was it intentional to
exclude the State Department politically? There are two American justifications
for Hochstein’s position: the excuse of lack of time, and that he is the envoy
of the White House and not the State Department, knowing that the two reasons do
not negate the passage of any discussion of the border issue and the return of
calm, outside the walls of the State Department. Contrary to his custom,
Hockstein did not include the visit on his program schedule. During his first
visit, Mikati requested that Bou Habib attend his meeting with Hockstein. When
he arrived at the Grand Serail, he found that the meeting had begun in his
absence, so he objected. A situation that was repeated in the previous visit,
where Mikati requested the presence of the Foreign Minister to meet with
Hockstein at the Grand Serail, pledging not to repeat what happened the last
time, but again the meeting was held before his arrival, and Bou Habib decided
to leave in protest had it not been for the intervention of the mediators.
During the meeting, Mikati asked the Foreign Minister to explain Lebanon’s
position. He spoke about the need for Israel to commit to implementing
Resolution 1701, including its withdrawal from the Shebaa Farms and the Kfar
Shuba Hills. Hockstein interrupted him, asking not to raise the issue of
withdrawal again, because Israel has no intention of implementing this clause.
The meeting was not friendly and witnessed tension between them due to the
withdrawal from the farms. Hockstein's visit was different from previous ones.
He did not include on his list of appointments to go to the State Department,
and the American ambassador to Lebanon, Lisa Johnson, justified the matter by
lack of time, then she added that Hochstein was visiting Lebanon as a
presidential envoy from the White House and not from the State Department. This
confirms the difference between the State Department and the White House
regarding the approach to the Lebanese file, which has become directly at the
core of the White House’s concerns. It implied that the Foreign Ministry had
nothing to do with his visit and no prior coordination with it.
Someone came to draw the ambassador's attention to the fact that Hochstein's
visit itinerary would be devoid of meeting with any Christian figure, and that
he excluded the only Maorite position in power. He later announced a meeting
with Maronite figures in the House of Representatives, which was not included in
the program of his meetings, which was limited to a visit to the heads of the
House of Representatives and the government, the army commander, and former MP
Walid Jumblatt. What strengthens the possibility is that Hockstein replaced the
meeting with Bou Habib, a Christian, with his meeting with the Maronite
representatives, excluding the representatives of the “Free Patriotic Movement”
and “Marada” from these meetings. If excluding “the Movement” and “Marada” has
political connotations due to their closeness to “Hezbollah,” and some of their
figures have been included on the US sanctions list, then it is unjustified,
according to diplomatic sources, to exclude the Foreign Ministry from a visit
whose goal is to research a file in which it is primarily concerned, i.e.
Implementing International Resolution 1701, which was the subject of
disagreement between the minister and Hochstein in previous visits. Did the
presidential envoy decide to punish him for his position, knowing that this is
the position that Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri emphasizes in his meetings with
Hochstein and is considered Lebanon’s official position? A position that did not
stop the government, and its president did not request Bouhabib’s presence, as
is his custom, and did not justify the reason for his absence, and he agreed to
exclude the Foreign Ministry from the discussions, knowing that Bouhabib did not
take the Lebanese proposal out of his own hands, but rather repeated Lebanon’s
official position, which Hockstein had previously objected to, adhering to a
partial solution based on Hezbollah withdrew kilometers from the border to
secure the return of settlers to the northern border.
Hochstein, with his advice and warnings: “The reassuring
and the frightening”
Munir Al-Rabie/Al-Modon/March 06, 2024
A new dress worn by the American envoy, Amos Hockstein, on his recent visit to
Lebanon. The man is keen to always appear within a broader framework than
limiting his tasks to the energy file and oil and gas exploration. Therefore, he
gave three dimensions to his visit. The first dimension, which constitutes a
priority, is calming the situation in the south and reaching an understanding
through which Lebanon will avoid war. The second dimension is to maintain his
interest in the energy, gas and oil file. This was reflected in his meeting with
the Minister of Energy and Water. The third dimension combines the military
situation, the border issue, and political entitlements. It is true that
Hockstein called Speaker of Parliament Nabih Berri “The Boss,” but he actually
wants this title to apply to him. The man visits Lebanon armed with a personal
achievement that he previously worked on in maritime demarcation. He wants to
repeat the experience on land.
High Commissioner?
The American envoy spoke with one meaning. At times, he used one language, and
at times he varied in his choice of expressions, between ensuring calm and
maintaining calm, and between warning and expressing fear, or talking about the
necessity of reaching a comprehensive solution, a permanent ceasefire, or
establishing peace and stability. All of these expressions were present in his
meetings, in addition to motivating the Lebanese to adopt a single language that
would put pressure on Hezbollah, about the necessity of stopping the war and not
adopting it, and pressing for the deployment of the army on the border, and for
it to be the only party concerned with protecting it. All of this pushes the
Lebanese to read the man’s personality and tasks from a different perspective.
Some considered him a High Commissioner, while others found in him that he was
seeking to encircle all other endeavors, whether French, British, or others, and
confine them to his person and his country, even though they extended from
establishing the truce to the Presidency of the Republic, which was touched upon
in passing, but with the potential for many indications.
Divisions game
Hockstein's visit came at a time when the level of Israeli divisions was rising,
especially in light of the visit of Israeli government member Benny Gantz to the
United States of America, despite the will of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu,
who tried to disrupt the visit. This also represents a major tension in the
relationship between Netanyahu and the US administration. It is as if someone
wants to show a vertical Lebanese political division on the other hand, by
focusing on showing the positions of political forces opposed to Hezbollah and
all of its orientations. Of course, this is understandable, and falls within the
framework of conflicting political trends. But what goes beyond that is that
some liken Hockstein's visit to Beirut to the visit of Condoleezza Rice in 2006,
which was considered at the time to be an attempt to form political forces that
objected to Hezbollah's choice in the war and its continuation.
Clear warning
It is clear that Hockstein did not raise the issue of implementing Resolution
1701 in its entirety, immediately and quickly, and he knows that its
implementation requires stages, and each stage requires time. But the basis for
him is to reach a ceasefire and return the displaced residents on both sides of
the border. After that, we can move on to discuss the application of all the
provisions of the international resolution. The Lebanese read the contents of
his positions with clear contradictions. Some of them expressed satisfaction
with the American path, and that negotiations are still on track to avoid
escalation. On the other hand, there are those who express serious fear about
the possibility of deteriorating conditions, especially when Hockstein said that
the Gaza truce does not necessarily extend to Lebanon. This must be linked to
changing the military and security reality in the south and on the Blue Line. In
one way or another, he means the issue of Hezbollah's withdrawal or withdrawal
of its weapons. But what the Lebanese agree on is that Hockstein’s message
includes a clear warning, which may amount to a threat, but in a clear language.
"Times have changed"
In some meetings, the proposed details of the solution formula were discussed,
including stopping Hezbollah’s military activities south of the Litani River,
dismantling heavy weapons and withdrawing them abroad. When asked how to be sure
of this, he replied that the Israelis know and are able to know. However, this
content contradicts Hezbollah’s basic demand regarding Israel’s implementation
of Resolution 1701, stopping violations of Lebanese airspace, and halting the
operation of drones or warplanes in the skies of Lebanon. Politically, there was
a keenness among the opposition forces to pass a position rejecting any attempt
to bargain between settling the situation in the south and the political
settlement at home. Therefore, opposition representatives stressed the issue of
rejecting any gifts or that Lebanon pay a political price to Hezbollah for any
arrangement of the southern situation. Here, the sources say that the opponents
heard from Hockstein that times have changed and such stages have passed.
5-06/2024
Diplomatic push for Israel-Hamas ceasefire intensifies
Agence France Presse/March 05, 2024
International mediators were with Hamas negotiators in Cairo Tuesday for talks
on a truce to pause nearly five months of fighting in Gaza before the Muslim
holy month of Ramadan, which begins early next week. Envoys from the Palestinian
militant group and the United States were expected to meet with Qatari and
Egyptian mediators for a third day of negotiations on a six-week truce, the
exchange of dozens of remaining hostages for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners
and increased aid to Gaza. Israeli negotiators have so far stayed away from the
talks, despite growing diplomatic pressure for a truce to take effect before
Ramadan. Israeli media reported that the country's negotiating team boycotted
the talks after Hamas did not provide a list of living hostages. Senior Hamas
leader Bassem Naim told AFP that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was
to blame for obstructing the talks and said it was for the United States to stop
the war before Ramadan, saying the "ball is in their court". Israel has said it
believes 130 of the 250 captives taken by Hamas in the October attack that
triggered the war remain in Gaza, but that 31 have been killed. As conditions in
the besieged Palestinian territory deteriorate and the spectre of famine looms,
Israel has faced increasingly sharp rebukes from its top ally the United States.
Vice President Kamala Harris expressed "deep concern about the humanitarian
conditions in Gaza" during talks in Washington on Monday with Israeli war
cabinet member Benny Gantz. The same day, the World Health Organization said an
aid mission to two hospitals in northern Gaza had found children dying of
starvation, amid dire shortages of food, fuel and medicines. "The lack of food
resulted in the deaths of 10 children," said WHO chief Tedros Adhanom
Ghebreyesus after the UN agency visited the Al-Awda and Kamal Adwan hospitals
over the weekend. Fighting in Gaza continued, with authorities reporting dozens
of Israeli air strikes near the European Hospital in Hamad, near Gaza's main
southern city of Khan Yunis. The Israeli army said it was conducting targeted
raids in Hamad and had captured dozens of Hamas and Islamic Jihad fighters who
were hiding among civilians. Its jets had struck 50 Hamas targets across the
Gaza Strip in the past day, the army said. The health ministry in the Hamas-run
territory said 97 people had been killed overnight, mostly women and children.
Khan Yunis residents described finding decomposing bodies lying in streets lined
with destroyed homes and shops. "We want to eat and live. Take a look at our
homes. How am I to blame, a single, unarmed person without any income in this
impoverished country?" asked Nader Abu Shanab, pointing to the rubble with
blackened hands.
- UN tensions -
The Hamas attack on southern Israel on October 7 resulted in about 1,160 deaths,
most of them civilians, according to an AFP tally based on Israeli official
figures. Israel's retaliatory offensive has killed 30,631 people, mostly women
and children, according to the health ministry. Tensions between Israel and the
United Nations erupted on Monday, with Israel recalling its ambassador over the
handling of allegations of sexual assault by Hamas militants during the October
attack. Israel accused the United Nations of taking too long to respond to the
claims, as the world body published a report on Monday that said there were
"reasonable grounds to believe" rapes were committed in the Hamas attack and
that hostages taken to Gaza had also been raped. "In most of these incidents,
victims first subjected to rape were then killed, and at least two incidents
relate to the rape of women's corpses," the report said. Shortly before the
report's release, Israel said it was recalling its ambassador Gilad Erdan over
what it said was an attempt by the UN to "silence" reports of sexual violence by
Hamas. UN chief Antonio Guterres's spokesman denied trying to suppress the
report. Israel previously accused 12 of the 13,000 Gaza staff of the UN agency
for Palestinian refugees (UNRWA) of involvement in the October 7 Hamas attack
that began the war. UNRWA is at the centre of efforts to provide humanitarian
relief in Gaza, where aid groups warn of looming famine. The agency said Monday
that members of its staff had reported "torture, severe ill-treatment, abuse and
sexual exploitation" in Israeli custody, while the Israeli army accused it of
employing more than 450 "terrorists". Phillipe Lazzarini, the head of UNRWA, has
said that Israel provided no evidence against his former employees.
Lebanon strikes -
The war has sparked violence across the region, including near-daily exchanges
of fire between Israeli forces and Lebanon's Hezbollah movement. "A diplomatic
solution is the only way to end the current hostilities," U.S. envoy Amos
Hochstein told reporters in Beirut on Monday, adding that "a temporary ceasefire
is not enough". "A limited war is not containable," he said after meeting with
parliament speaker Nabih Berri, a Hezbollah ally. On Monday, a foreign worker in
northern Israel was killed and seven Indian workers were wounded in a missile
strike near the Lebanese border, Israeli medics said. The Israeli army said it
had carried out strikes on Hezbollah targets in southern Lebanon in response.
Hezbollah said three paramedics affiliated with the group had been killed in an
Israeli strike.
Gaza Strip: Ceasefire talks between Hamas and mediators broke up on Tuesday in
Cairo with no breakthrough
REUTERS/March 05, 2024
CAIRO/RAFAH, Gaza Strip: Ceasefire talks between Hamas and mediators broke up on
Tuesday in Cairo with no breakthrough, with just days left to halt fighting in
time for the start of Ramadan. Senior Hamas official Bassem Naim told Reuters
the militant group had presented its proposal for a ceasefire agreement to the
mediators during two days of talks, and was now waiting for a response from the
Israelis, who stayed away from this round. “(Prime Minister Benjamin) Netanyahu
doesn’t want to reach an agreement and the ball now is in the Americans’ court”
to press him for a deal, Naim said.
Israel has declined to comment publicly on the talks in Cairo. A source told
Reuters earlier that Israel was staying away because Hamas had rejected its
demand to furnish a list of all hostages who are still alive. Naim said this was
impossible without a ceasefire first as hostages were scattered across the war
zone and held by separate groups. The Cairo talks had been billed as a final
hurdle to reach the war’s first extended ceasefire — a 40-day truce during which
dozens of hostages would be freed and aid would be pumped into Gaza to stave off
a manmade famine, ahead of Ramadan, which is due to begin at the start of next
week. Egyptian security sources said on Monday they were still in touch with the
Israelis to allow the negotiations to continue without an Israeli delegation
present. Washington, which is both Israel’s closest ally and a sponsor of the
ceasefire talks, has said an Israeli-approved deal is already on the table and
it is up to Hamas to accept it. Hamas disputes this account as an attempt to
deflect blame from Israel if the talks collapse with no deal. The United States
has also called on Israel to do more to alleviate the humanitarian catastrophe
in Gaza, where more than 30,000 people have been killed by Israel’s assault,
launched after Hamas attacks that killed 1,200 people in October.
Hunger stalks Gaza
Famine is now gripping the besieged Gaza Strip as aid supplies, already sharply
curtailed since the start of the war, have dwindled to barely a trickle over the
past month. Whole swathes of the territory are completely cut off from food.
Gaza’s few functioning hospitals, already overwhelmed by the wounded, are now
filling with children starving to death. Ahmed Cannan, a toddler with sunken
eyes and an emaciated face, lay on a bed at Al-Awda clinic in Rafah, wrapped in
a yellow cardigan. He had lost half his weight since the start of the war and
now weighs just 6 kg (13 pounds). “His situation worsens each day. God protect
us from what is coming,” his aunt, Israa Kalakh, told Reuters. Nurse Diaa Al-Shaer
said such emaciated children were now pouring into the clinic in unprecedented
numbers: “We will face a large number of patients who suffer from this, which is
malnutrition,” she said.The situation is worst in the north of Gaza,
beyond the reach of aid agencies or news cameras. Gaza health authorities say 15
children have died of malnutrition or dehydration at one hospital. Israel says
it is willing to allow in more aid to Gaza through the two checkpoints on the
southern edge of the territory it has permitted to open, and blames UN and other
aid agencies for failing to distribute it more widely. The aid agencies say this
has become impossible with a breakdown of law and order, and it is up to Israel,
whose troops have stormed Gaza’s towns and patrol them, to provide access and
security for food distribution. “The sense of helplessness and despair among
parents and doctors in realizing that lifesaving aid, just a few kilometers
away, is being kept out of reach, must be unbearable,” said Adele Khodr, UNICEF
regional director for the Middle East and North Africa.
At least 17 killed in an Israeli airstrike in southern
Gaza
Associated Press/March 06, 2024
An Israeli airstrike killed at least 17 people in the southern Gaza city of Khan
Younis on Tuesday, Palestinian officials said, adding that a total of 97 people
had died in the last 24 hours. First responders with the Civil Defense
circulated footage of rescuers pulling dead and wounded people from the rubble
of a house, including a child with blood on his face who was not moving. The
nearby European Hospital said Tuesday that it had received 17 bodies
overnight.The Israeli military said in a statement on Tuesday that it was
carrying out targeted raids on militant infrastructure in Khan Younis while
trying to evacuate civilians from the area. The latest fatalities brought the
overall Palestinian toll from the nearly five-month war to 30,631, according to
Gaza’s Health Ministry. It does not differentiate between civilians and
combatants in its figures but says women and children make up around two-thirds
of the total casualties. It says over 72,000 people have been wounded.
Famine looms in Gaza — how will the world know it has
arrived?
REUTERS/March 06, 2024
Israel captured the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem in a 1967 war
The United Nations said in February that more than a quarter of Gaza’s 2.3
million people were “estimated to be facing catastrophic levels of deprivation
and starvation” Israel has killed more than 30,000 Palestinians, most of them
women and children, according to the Hamas government's Ministry of Health
UNITED NATIONS: The United Nations has warned that widespread famine in the Gaza
Strip is “almost inevitable” without action. A formal conclusion that famine has
arrived in the coastal enclave of 2.3 million people could come next week.
WHAT IS FAMIME AND WHO DECLARES ONE?
A famine is assessed by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC).
It is an initiative made up of more than a dozen UN agencies, regional bodies
and aid groups. For famine to be declared, at least 20 percent of the population
must be suffering extreme food shortages, with one in three children acutely
malnourished and two people out of every 10,000 dying daily from starvation or
from malnutrition and disease. Famine has been declared twice in the past 13
years: in Somalia in 2011 and in parts of South Sudan in 2017.
WHAT IS THE CURRENT ASSESSMENT IN GAZA?
In late December, the IPC said the situation in Gaza had already been exceeded
the 20 percent threshold.It said the remaining two thresholds — the number of
children acutely malnourished and the number of people dying daily from
starvation or from malnutrition and disease — “may also be breached at some
point” in the coming months. “There is a risk of famine in the projection period
through May 2024 if the current situation persists or worsens,” it said. The
United Nations said in February that more than a quarter of Gaza’s 2.3 million
people were “estimated to be facing catastrophic levels of deprivation and
starvation.” It said without action widespread famine could be “almost
inevitable.”The IPC is due to release a new analysis of the situation in Gaza by
mid-March.
WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO DECLARE FAMINE?
While a declaration of famine does not trigger any formal response, it can help
focus global attention on how to help. But as UN Office for the Coordination of
Humanitarian Affairs has said: “Once a famine is declared, it is too late for
too many people.”
WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE WELFARE OF GAZA?
The United Nations views Israel as the occupying power in Gaza and says the
Israeli military has a responsibility to facilitate humanitarian operations
within the enclave. Under the 1949 Geneva Conventions on the laws of war: “To
the fullest extent of the means available to it, the occupying power has the
duty of ensuring the food and medical supplies of the population.”
WHAT DOES ISRAEL SAY?
Israel captured the West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem in a 1967 war. These are
areas of historic Palestine which the Palestinians want for a state. Israel
withdrew from Gaza in 2005 and Hamas won elections in 2006. But Israel, along
with neighboring Egypt, still controls the borders of the enclave.
Israeli leaders have long argued that Gaza and the West Bank are not formally
occupied on the basis that they were captured from Jordan and Egypt during the
1967 war rather than from a sovereign Palestine. Israel also stresses the Jewish
people’s historical and Biblical ties to the land.
WHY IS THE HUMANITARIAN SITUATION IN GAZA SO DIRE?
The war in Gaza began when Hamas fighters attacked Israel on Oct. 7, killing
around 1,200 people and seizing 253 hostages, according to Israeli tallies.
Israel retaliated by initially imposing a “total siege” on Gaza and launching an
air and ground assault has since killed around 30,000 Palestinians, health
authorities in the Hamas-run enclave say. Aid can currently be delivered into
southern Gaza via the Rafah crossing from Egypt and Kerem Shalom crossing from
Israel. The UN Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA has said that during February an
average of nearly 97 trucks were able to enter Gaza each day, compared with
about 150 trucks a day in January — well below a target of 500 trucks a day. The
United Nations has described aid access as “unpredictable and insufficient,”
blaming military operations, insecurity and extensive restrictions to delivery
of essential supplies. Specifically the UN cites: border crossing closures,
serious movement restrictions, access denials, onerous vetting procedures,
security risks, incidents by desperate civilians, a breakdown of law and order,
and restrictions on communications and protective equipment. Israel has said it
is committed to improving the humanitarian situation in Gaza and there is no
limit on the aid for civilians. It has blamed the United Nations for any
delivery issues, saying limitations on the quantity and pace of aid are
dependent on the capacity of the UN and other agencies.
Sullivan, Qatar PM discussed potential ceasefire for
hostage release
REUTERS/March 06, 2024
WASHINGTON: White House National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan and Qatari Prime
Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim Al Thani met Tuesday and
discussed a potential ceasefire in exchange for the release of hostages held in
Gaza, the US said in a statement. Sullivan and Al Thani agreed to stay in
regular contact, according to the statement from the White House.
Saudi FM warns Israel against offensive in Rafah during OIC
meeting
ARAB NEWS/March 06, 2024
JEDDAH: Saudi Arabia’s Foreign Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan on Tuesday said
any potential Israeli military actions in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip would
have dangerous repercussions, a foreign ministry statement said. Speaking during
an extraordinary session of the Organization of Islamic Countries (OIC) held in
Jeddah, Prince Faisal also reiterated the Kingdom’s opposition to the
displacement of Palestinians from the territory. The extraordinary session was
held to discuss the ongoing war in Gaza between Hamas and Israel which began in
October. More than 30,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israel’s assault,
launched after Hamas-led attacks that killed 1,200 people on Oct. 7. Citing
growing global outcry, the foreign minister said an increasing number of
countries were now pushing for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza, and support for
an independent Palestinian state was growing. “We have noticed a positive
development in the positions of some countries and an understanding of the
magnitude of the disaster. We have also seen an increase in the number of
countries calling for an immediate ceasefire. Additionally, we have heard from
several countries about their willingness in principle to recognize the State of
Palestine,” the minister said. The establishment of a Palestinian state has been
the long held position of many Arab and Muslim-majority states in line with the
Arab Peace Initiative. This state would be on the 1967 borders with East
Jerusalem as its capital. Prince Faisal said the creation of a state for
Palestinians would enable them to secure their rights, live in safety and
determine their destiny. The Saudi diplomat also stressed support for the UN
agency for Palestinian refugees, known as UNRWA, and warned against attempts to
dissolve the agency, adding that doing so would further exacerbate the suffering
of civilians in Gaza. “The Kingdom will continue its support for ... UNRWA and
urges all supporters to fulfill their supportive role in humanitarian missions
towards Palestinian refugees inside the besieged Gaza Strip,” the minister said.
He urged countries that had suspended funding to the agency to u-turn on their
decision. A number of countries pulled financial support for UNRWA after Israel
alleged that its employees had links to Hamas and had been involved in the Oct.
7 attacks on Israel.
Netanyahu leaned on Gantz to help unify Israel, now
Gantz is more popular
Associated Press/March 05, 2024
The top political rival of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is meeting
with U.S. leaders in Washington this week to discuss the war in Gaza. Benny
Gantz is a key member of Israel's War Cabinet whose popularity is on the rise —
and who has a pivotal role to play in the country's future. Gantz, 64, is a
centrist politician who joined Netanyahu's ultranationalist and religious
government soon after Hamas' Oct. 7 attack on Israel. The goal was to bring a
sense of national unity to the country as it wages war against Hamas in Gaza.
The former military chief of staff has seen his public support soar. Polls show
he would earn enough support to become prime minister if elections were held
today. In contrast, Netanyahu's backing has collapsed. Many Israelis blame the
prime minister for failing to prevent the Hamas attack, which killed 1,200
Israelis, most of them civilians. Amid the rivalry, Gantz' trip to Washington
earned him a rebuke from Netanyahu, a sign of the growing rift in the
government.Gantz is widely expected to leave the government once the heavy
fighting subsides, signaling the period of national unity has ended. The Israeli
public will likely see that as a cue to resume the mass anti-government
demonstrations that took place before Hamas' attack. While the government
wouldn't collapse if Gantz leaves, large demonstrations could ramp up the
pressure on Netanyahu's deeply unpopular coalition to hold early elections.
Gantz has been a top political rival of Netanyahu's for half a decade. He joined
Netanyahu's coalition in the disorienting days after Hamas' attack and at a time
when Israel was at its most divided after months of protests over planned
changes to Israel's legal system. He has served on the influential War Cabinet
and has acted as a moderating force in the far-right government. He has sought
to promote the cause of the roughly 250 hostages taken into Gaza, while others
in the Cabinet opposed dealing for their release because of the cost it could
exact from Israel. He has also sought to foster Israel's alliance with the U.S.,
which has provided key diplomatic and military support during the war. Gantz
heads the National Unity faction in parliament. After a nearly four decade
military career, Gantz entered politics in late 2018. That was the start of a
period of political instability that sent Israelis to the polls five times in
less than four years, each one a referendum on Netanyahu's fitness to serve
while facing corruption charges. After refusing to sit in a government under
Netanyahu, Gantz agreed to join a short-lived Netanyahu-led coalition in a bid
to stem the political turmoil as the COVID pandemic was taking root. After being
ousted in one of the elections, Netanyahu returned to power in late 2022,
forming a government of West Bank settlement supporters and opponents of
Palestinian statehood. Gantz has served as defense minister, overseeing brief
operations in Gaza. In 2021, he outlawed six prominent Palestinian rights
groups, citing alleged militant links, a step widely criticized by the
Palestinians. He has been vague on his views on Palestinian statehood but he has
taken steps to show he is open to the idea, including holding meetings with
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas while serving as defense minister.
Israel to let same numbers into Al-Aqsa during first
week of Ramadan as in previous years, statement by Netanyahu's office says
Reuters/March 05, 2024
Israel will allow a similar number of worshippers into Jerusalem's Al-Aqsa
Mosque compound in the first week of Ramadan as in previous years, a statement
by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office said on Tuesday. The decision was
agreed with top Israeli security officials during a meeting on preparations
ahead of the Muslim fasting month, without providing a specific number. "During
the first week of Ramadan a similar number of worshippers will be allowed on the
Temple Mount as in previous years," the statement said, using the Jewish name
for the site. "Every week a security assessment will be conducted and a decision
will be made accordingly."
Erdogan says Israeli settlers major obstacle to peace
AFP/March 05, 2024
ANKARA: Turkiye President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Tuesday that Israeli
settlers were one of the main obstacles to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict. “One of the biggest obstacles to a solution are the actions of the
usurpers, called settlers, who have invaded and stolen land that belonged to
Palestinians,” Erdogan said during a press conference with visiting Palestinian
president Mahmud Abbas. Erdogan, a vocal advocate of the Palestinian cause, also
called for unrestrained access to the Al-Aqsa mosque in Jerusalem during the
Islamic fasting month of Ramadan, due to start this year on March 10 or 11. “The
demands of radical Israeli politicians to restrict the entry of Muslims... are
totally absurd,” he said. “The consequences of such a move would undoubtedly be
serious.”“We’re about to start the month of Ramadan,” Abbas said. “It is well
known that extremist settlers go to Al-Aqsa and carry out attacks there.”Israel
said Tuesday that it would allow as many Muslim worshippers to access the Al-Aqsa
mosque during the first week of Ramadan as in previous years, and would assess
the situation every week. Every year, tens of thousands of Muslim worshippers
perform Ramadan prayers at the Al-Aqsa mosque compound. The site, known as
Temple Mount to Jews, is holy to both Jews and Muslims. Ramadan comes this year
as Israel wages a relentless military campaign in the Gaza Strip in response to
a deadly attack by Hamas in Israel on October 7. Israel’s far-right National
Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir had recently said that Palestinian residents
of the West Bank “should not be allowed” entry to Jerusalem to pray during
Ramadan. Ben Gvir leads a hard-right party advocating Jewish control of the
compound.Days later, the United States called on Israel to allow Muslims to
worship at Al-Aqsa. Abbas is in Turkiye for talks about the Gaza war and
reconciliation efforts between Palestinian factions.
Turkey detains 7 more people for selling information to
Mossad
Associated Press/March 05, 2024
Turkish police on Tuesday detained seven more people suspected of selling
information to the Israeli spy agency Mossad, authorities said, the latest in a
wave of such arrests in Turkey.The suspects were taken into custody during
simultaneous raids in Istanbul, Interior Minister Ali Yerlikaya said on the
social media platform X, formerly Twitter. The raids were a joint operation with
Turkey's National Intelligence Organization. The detained are suspected of
collecting data on individuals and companies in Turkey and selling it to the
Israeli intelligence agency, Yerlikaya said. "We will never allow espionage
activities to be carried out within the borders of our country." It was not
immediately known if any charges have been raised and authorities provided no
additional information. Last month, seven other people, including private
detectives, were arrested on similar suspicions. And in early January, 34 people
were also detained by Turkish police on suspicion of spying for Israel. The
suspects arrested in January have been accused of planning to carry out
activities that included reconnaissance and "pursuing, assaulting and
kidnapping" foreign nationals living in Turkey. At the time, Justice Minister
Yilmaz Tunc said most of the suspects were charged with committing "political or
military espionage" on behalf of Israeli intelligence. The state-run Anadolu
Agency, citing unnamed security officials, said those detained Tuesday included
a former civil servant currently working as a private detective who was
allegedly trained by Mossad in Belgrade, Serbia. He collected information on
Middle Eastern companies and individuals, and even placed tracking devices in
vehicles of people targeted by Israeli intelligence, Anadolu said. Turkey and
Israel had normalized ties in 2022 by reappointing ambassadors following years
of tensions. But those ties quickly deteriorated after the Israel-Hamas war,
with Ankara becoming one of the strongest critics of Israel's military actions
in Gaza. In December, the head of Israel's Shin Bet security agency said that
his organization was prepared to target the militant Hamas group anywhere,
including in Lebanon, Turkey and Qatar. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan
warned Israel of "serious consequences" if Israel pressed ahead with its threat
to attack Hamas officials on Turkish soil.
3 Red Sea data cables cut as Houthis launch more attacks
in vital waterway
Associated Press/March 06, 2024
Three cables under the Red Sea that provide global internet and
telecommunications have been cut as the waterway remains a target of Yemen's
Houthi rebels, officials said Monday. Meanwhile, a Houthi missile attack set a
ship ablaze in the Gulf of Aden, but caused no injuries. What cut the lines
remains unclear. There has been concern about the cables being targeted in the
Houthi campaign, which the rebels describe as an effort to pressure Israel to
end its war on Hamas in the Gaza Strip. The Houthis have denied attacking the
lines, however. While global shipping has already been disrupted through the Red
Sea, a crucial route for cargo and energy shipments from Asia and the Middle
East to Europe, the sabotage of telecommunication lines could further escalate
the monthslong crisis.
The cut lines include Asia-Africa-Europe 1, the Europe India Gateway, Seacom and
TGN-Gulf, Hong Kong-based HGC Global Communications said. It described the cuts
as affecting 25% of the traffic flowing through the Red Sea. It described the
Red Sea route as crucial for data moving from Asia to Europe and said it had
begun rerouting traffic. HGC Global Communications described the Seacom-TGN-Gulf
line as being two separate cables when it is actually one at the area of the
cut, according to Tim Stronge, a subsea cable expert with TeleGeography, a
Washington-based telecommunications market research company. Responding to
questions from The Associated Press, Seacom said that "initial testing indicates
the affected segment lies within Yemeni maritime jurisdictions in the Southern
Red Sea." It said it was rerouting the traffic that it was able to change,
though some services were down. Tata Communications, part of the Indian
conglomerate and behind the Seacom-TGN-Gulf line, told AP that it "initiated
immediate and appropriate remedial actions" after the line was cut. "We invest
in various cable consortiums to increase our diversity and hence in such
situations of a cable cut or snag, we are able to automatically reroute our
services," Tata said. Other firms behind those lines, which provide data to
Africa, Asia and the Middle East, didn't respond to AP's queries. In early
February, Yemen's internationally recognized government in exile alleged that
the Houthis planned to attack the cables. The lines appeared to have been cut on
Feb. 24, with the organization NetBlocks noticing internet access in the East
African nation of Djibouti suffering from interruptions two days later. Seacom
serves Djibouti. But for their part, the Houthis have denied targeting the
cables. The rebels blamed the disruptions on British and U.S. military
operations, but didn't offer evidence to support the allegation and have made
false claims in the past.
Since November, the rebels have repeatedly targeted ships in the Red Sea and
surrounding waters over the Israel-Hamas war. Those vessels have included at
least one with cargo bound for Iran, the Houthis' main benefactor, and an aid
ship later bound for Houthi-controlled territory.
Despite more than a month and a half of U.S.-led airstrikes, Houthi rebels have
remained capable of launching significant attacks. They include the attack last
month on a cargo ship carrying fertilizer, the Rubymar, which sank on Saturday
after drifting for several days, and the downing of an American drone worth tens
of millions of dollars. The Houthis insist their attacks will continue until
Israel stops its combat operations in the Gaza Strip, which have enraged the
wider Arab world and seen the Houthis gain international recognition. Meanwhile,
the British military's United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations center on Monday
separately warned of a new attack in the Gulf of Aden. The private security firm
Ambrey described the vessel targeted as a Liberia-flagged, Israel-affiliated
container ship that sustained damage and issued a distress call. "The container
ship reportedly encountered two explosions of which the first occurred at a
'distance' off its port quarter, while the second damaged the vessel's
accommodation block and a container leading," Ambrey said. "The explosion
further led to a fire onboard and the crew's firefighting efforts were
underway." Ambrey and the UKMTO said no crew member on the ship had been injured
in the blaze, which was extinguished several hours later.
Brig. Gen. Yahya Saree, a Houthi military spokesman, claimed the attack in a
prerecorded statement. He identified the ship as the MSC Sky II, sailing for the
Switzerland-based firm Mediterranean Shipping Co, but sought to link the vessel
to Israel. The ship's details and last-known location corresponded to details
about the attack. The Houthis "will continue to prevent Israeli navigation or
those heading to the ports of occupied Palestine until the aggression is stopped
and the siege on the Palestinian people in the Gaza Strip is lifted," Saree
said. The U.S. military's Central Command acknowledged the attack on the MSC Sky
II and said the vessel "did not request assistance and continued on its way."
The U.S. military separately conducted airstrikes on two anti-ship cruise
missiles in Yemen.
MSC didn't respond to questions about the attack.
It remains unclear how the Houthis could attack subsea cables themselves. The
rebels aren't known to have the diving or salvage capability to target the
lines, which sit hundreds of meters below the surface of the waterway. However,
subsea cables can be cut by anchors, including those dropped from some of the
ships that have been disabled in attacks. A drifting ship with its anchor
scraping the sea could be the culprit. "Our team thinks it is plausible that it
could have been affected by anchor dragging, due to the amount of marine traffic
the region deals with and the low seabed in many parts of the Red Sea," Seacom
said. "This can only be confirmed once the repair ship is on site."There are 14
cables now running through the Red Sea, with another six planned, said Stronge,
the subsea cable expert. "We estimate that over 90% of communications between
Europe and Asia traverse submarine cables in the Red Sea," he said.
"Fortunately, telecom operators have built a high degree of redundancy into the
system — there are many cables traversing the Red Sea." The Houthis later warned
any cable-laying ship entering Yemeni waters needed a permit from the rebels
"out of concern for its safety."
US forces down drones, missile fired from Yemen at warship
AFP/March 06, 2024
WASHINGTON: American forces shot down three drones and a missile fired toward a
destroyer in the Red Sea on Tuesday, the US military said, after Yemen’s Houthis
announced they had targeted two of Washington’s warships. The Iran-backed
Houthis have been attacking shipping in the Red Sea for months, and repeated
American and British strikes have so far failed to prevent them from threatening
the vital trade route. “US Central Command (CENTCOM) forces shot down one
anti-ship ballistic missile and three one-way attack unmanned aerial systems
launched from Iranian-backed Houthi controlled areas of Yemen toward USS Carney
(DDG 64) in the Red Sea,” the military command said in a statement. “There are
no injuries or damage to the ship,” CENTCOM said, adding that American forces
later destroyed three anti-ship missiles and three naval drones in Houthi-controlled
areas of Yemen. Houthi military spokesman Yahya Saree said earlier in the day
that their forces had targeted two US destroyers in the Red Sea “with a number
of naval missiles and drones.”The Houthis “will not stop until the aggression
stops and the siege imposed on the Palestinian people in the Gaza Strip is
lifted,” Saree said on social media. They began attacking Red Sea shipping in
November, saying they were hitting Israel-linked vessels in support of
Palestinians in Gaza, which has been ravaged by the Israel-Hamas war. US and UK
forces responded with strikes against the Houthis, who have since declared
American and British interests to be legitimate targets as well. Anger over
Israel’s devastating campaign in Gaza — which began after an unprecedented Hamas
attack on October 7 — has grown across the Middle East, stoking violence
involving Iran-backed groups in Lebanon, Iraq, Syria and Yemen.
Pro-Palestinian group sues Canada over military exports to
Israel
REUTERS/March 06, 2024
OTTAWA: Pro-Palestinian and human rights advocates in Canada on Tuesday filed a
lawsuit against the federal government to stop it from allowing companies to
export military goods and technology to Israel. The lawsuit, filed in a federal
court, argues that Canadian laws prevent military exports to Israel because
there is “substantial risk” they could be used to violate international law and
commit serious acts of violence against women and children, according to a
statement from the applicants. Israel launched a ground and air assault on the
Gaza strip nearly five months ago in response to a Hamas attack on Oct. 7 that
killed 1,200 people. More than 30,000 people have been killed by Israel’s
assault. Since then Ottawa has authorized at least C$28.5 million ($21.0
million) worth of new permits for military exports to Israel, more than the
value of such permits allowed in the previous year, the applicants said. The
applicants include the Canadian Lawyers for International Human Rights group,
the Palestinian organization Al-Haq and four individuals. Canada’s foreign
ministry did not have an immediate comment. Israel says it respects
international law and that it has a right to defend itself after the Hamas
attack.
NATO allies the United States and the Netherlands also face lawsuits over the
Gaza war. Last month, a Dutch court ordered the government to block all exports
of F-35 fighter jet parts to Israel over concerns they were being used to
violate international law. Israel’s military campaign has prompted regular
pro-Palestinian protests in major Canadian cities. Last week, demonstrators
gathered at gun maker Colt Canada’s facility in Kitchener, Ontario. Prime
Minister Justin Trudeau has consistently said Israel has the right to defend
itself after the Hamas assault in October. Senior officials though have called
for an immediate and sustained ceasefire in the conflict.
Israel and UN trade allegations of 'terrorism,' torture
Associated Press/March 06, 2024
Israel has ramped up its criticism of the embattled U.N. agency for Palestinian
refugees Monday, saying 450 of its employees were members of militant groups in
the Gaza Strip, though it provided no evidence to back up its accusation. Major
international funders have withheld hundreds of millions of dollars from the
agency, known as UNRWA, since Israel accused 12 of its employees of
participating in the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks on Israel that killed 1,200 people and
left about 250 others held hostage in Gaza, according to Israeli authorities.
Philippe Lazzarini, the head of the agency known as UNRWA, told a press
conference late Monday that he "has never been informed" or received any
evidence of Israel's claims, and this is not the first. Every year, he said,
UNRWA provides Israel and the Palestinian Authority with a list of its staff
"and I never have received the slightest concern about the staff that we have
been employing."The only allegation communicated to him verbally was about 12
UNRWA staffers alleged to have participated in the Oct. 7 attacks, he said, and
they appeared so serious that they were fired, and two U.N.-ordered
investigations are underway. The U.N. envoy focusing on sexual violence in
conflict, Pramila Patten, said Monday there were "reasonable grounds" to believe
Hamas committed rape, "sexualized torture," and other cruel and inhuman
treatment of women during the attack. The attack sparked an Israeli invasion of
the enclave of 2.3 million people that Gaza's Health Ministry says has killed
more than 30,000 Palestinians. Aid groups say the fighting has displaced most of
the territory's population and sparked a humanitarian catastrophe.
UNRWA, which employs roughly 13,000 people in Gaza, is the biggest aid provider
in the enclave. The allegations Monday were a significant escalation in the
accusations against the agency. Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, Israel's chief military
spokesperson, did not provide names or other evidence to back up the vastly
increased number of UNRWA employees it said were militants. "Over 450 UNRWA
employees are military operatives in terror groups in Gaza — 450. This is no
mere coincidence. This is systematic. There is no claiming, 'we did not know,'"
Hagari said. UNRWA in a statement accused Israel of detaining several of its
staffers and forcing them, using torture and ill treatment, into giving false
confessions about the links between the agency, Hamas and the Oct. 7 attack on
Israel. "These forced confessions as a result of torture are being used by the
Israeli Authorities to further spread misinformation about the agency as part of
attempts to dismantle UNRWA," the statement said. "This is putting our staff in
Gaza at risk and has serious implications on our operations in Gaza and around
the region.''
After Israel's initial accusation against UNRWA, the agency fired the accused
employees and more than a dozen countries suspended funding worth about $450
million, almost half its budget for the year. Juliette Touma, director of
communications for UNRWA, had no direct comment on the new Israeli allegations.
"UNRWA encourages any entity that has any information on the very serious
allegations against UNRWA staff to share it with the ongoing U.N.
investigation," she said. Two U.N. investigations into Israel's allegations were
already underway when the EU said Friday it will pay 50 million euros ($54
million) to UNRWA after the agency agreed to allow EU-appointed experts to audit
the way it screens staff to identify extremists. Hagari also released a
recording of a call he said was of an UNRWA teacher describing his role in the
Oct. 7 attack. "We have female captives. I caught one," the male voice is heard
saying in Arabic. A man on a second call, alleged to be an Islamic Jihad
militant who Israel also claimed was an UNRWA teacher, is heard saying "I'm
inside with the Jews."
The military named the men, though the man in the first call identified himself
in the recording by a different name. The military said that name may have been
a nickname. The military did not provide evidence as to their employment with
UNRWA. The accusations came as Benny Gantz, a top member of Israel's wartime
Cabinet, met with U.S. officials in Washington while talks were underway in
Egypt to broker a cease-fire in Gaza before the Muslim holy month of Ramadan
begins next week. Meanwhile, violence flared between Israel and Lebanon, amid
inflamed tensions across the region. An anti-tank missile fired into northern
Israel from Lebanon killed a foreign worker and wounded seven others Monday,
Israel's Magen David Adom rescue service said. The Hezbollah militant group in
Lebanon did not immediately claim responsibility for Monday's strike. Hours
later an Israeli airstrike in southern Lebanon killed three paramedics from
Hezbollah's health arm, Lebanon's state media said. U.S. envoy Amos Hochstein
arrived in Beirut on Monday to meet with Lebanese officials in an attempt to
tamp down tensions. The near-daily clashes between Hezbollah and Israeli forces
have killed more than 200 Hezbollah fighters and at least 37 civilians in
Lebanon. Around 20 people have been killed on the Israeli side, including
civilians and soldiers.
Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from
miscellaneous sources published on March 05-06/2024
In conclusion... Gaza died and Sinwar lived!
Muhammad Al-Saed/Okaz/March 05, 2024
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/127602/127602/
With the expected signing of the disengagement agreement between Israel and
Hamas in the coming days, cafe activists will return to playing backgammon,
drinking shisha, and exchanging advice on ways to immigrate to America and
Britain, which they have been cursing during the past weeks. As for the bearers
of Palestinian shawls that were used for five months and carried in stadiums and
concerts. The silent ones - which were not announced - will return to the
closet, waiting for another war, another bidding, and another imaginary victory.
The resonant slogans, false sentiments, enthusiastic songs, and mixed drumbeats
will take a step back, and instead the songs of Mustafa Ashour, Dana Salah, Saif
Sharrouf, Issam Al-Najjar, Fouad Gretli, Saif Al-Safadi, and the dance floors in
the suburbs and some Arab capitals will come forward.
The journalists who filled the screens screaming, analyzing, and lamenting will
return to their luxurious villas in the Arab diaspora capitals. They plan their
next vacations to Beirut, London, Paris, and Canada, where their children and
relatives are immigrants.
Hassan Nasrallah will disappear into his cozy basement with his four wives once
again, and his dull speech in which he threatened Israel will melt away “behind
and beyond Haifa.” All he did was send pictures of the coffins of his cadres one
after another to Al-Manar and Al-Mayadeen TV to cover up the shame of the
brokenness of the axis of resistance.
Khaled Mashal, Ismail Haniyeh, and Musa Abu Marzouk will emerge from their
hotels in the region declaring divine victory. They will race against Sinwar,
who they fear will steal their historical moment. As for Sinwar, he will emerge
from his basement, carried on the shoulders of his relatives who will protect
him from the wrath of the Gazans, who lost their loved ones, their homes, and
their safe lives because of the whim of the Seventh. October, his supporters
will carry him on their stocky shoulders, after the people of Gaza carried
30,000 bodies on their emaciated shoulders.
It is an illusory victory, but you must believe that defeat in the dictionary of
the Brotherhood and the absolutes of the resistance axis is victory, and that
disappointment is joy, and that the dismembered bodies on the roads of Gaza are
a bridge to the cause, and that donations are a right for the cadres, and life
is for them and death is for others.
Sinwar will return to the orange farm that he loves in the middle of Gaza, among
his children and grandchildren, and at the end of the week he will sit in his
seaside chalet, addressing the dead before the living, explaining to them how
Gaza was victorious because he was not killed or captured. Of course, he will
not say that Israel was keen on his life because - he knew. Or did he not know -
he served her as the most loyal to her did not serve her.
In the eyes of Haniyeh and Sinwar, all of Palestine, with its men, women and
children, living and dead, is not worth a toothpick, as their spiritual leader
Al-Zahar said in a previous conversation.
After that, Ismail Haniyeh will take his private plane heading to Tehran,
kissing the hand of the Supreme Leader, and visiting the grave of Qassem
Soleimani, praising them and offering the duties of loyalty and obedience.
As for the rest of the Hamas leaders who hid behind civilians, they will race to
operate their contracting companies for which they are famous. The market in
Gaza is huge and reconstruction is about to begin, and billions of Arabs are
standing at the gates and there is nothing better than to be won by “Abu Jamil,
Abu Jihad, Abu Youssef, Abu Bilal... etc.” » From the leaders of “Internal Hamas”
who are waiting for Israel to demolish homes so that they can build them again
at the expense of donors in order to get richer than they are.
As for the rest of the broken and grieving Gazans, they will return, and each of
them has a story of loss. Parts of it have been missing from their hearts, and
those who remain will return to the rubble of their homes. They will get lost in
the deserted streets of pain and alleys full of death, roads that have lost
their landmarks, homes that no longer exist, and neighborhoods that have
disappeared forever.
In conclusion... Gaza died; Sinwar lived weakly!
The Illusion of a Palestinian 'Demilitarized' State
Bassam Tawil/Gatestone Institute./March 05/2024
https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/20460/demilitarized-palestinian-state
[A]ny commitment to a demilitarized state by the Palestinian leadership would be
legally worthless.
"Any treaty is void if, at the time it was entered into, it conflicts with a
'peremptory' rule of general international law (jus cogens) – a rule accepted
and recognized by the international community of states as one from which 'no
derogation is permitted.' Because the right of sovereign States to maintain
military forces essential to 'self-defense' is such a peremptory rule,
Palestine, depending upon its particular form of authority, could be entirely
within its right to abrogate any pre-independence agreement that had compelled
its demilitarization." [Italics in original.] — Louis René Beres, professor
emeritus at Purdue University, and an expert in international law and political
science, jurist.org, December 23, 2023.
"Therein lies the jurisprudential core of the Palestinian demilitarization
problem: International law would not necessarily require Palestinian compliance
with any pre-state agreements concerning the use of armed force. From the
standpoint of such authoritative law, enforcing demilitarization upon a
sovereign state of Palestine would be sorely problematic." [Italics in
original.] — Louis René Beres, jurist.org, December 23, 2023
"Unhidden, both the Arab world and Iran still have only a 'One-State Solution'
for the 'Israel Problem.' It is a 'solution' that eliminates Israel altogether,
a physical solution, a 'Final Solution.' Even today, official Arab maps of
'Palestine' (PNA and Hamas) show the prospective Arab State comprising all of
the West Bank (Judea/Samaria), all of Gaza and all of Israel. They knowingly
exclude any references to a Jewish population and list 'holy sites' of
Christians and Muslims only." — Louis René Beres, jurist.org, December 23, 2023
No one can stop a future Palestinian state from becoming a lawless and
militarized state. Such a state on Israel's doorstep would pose a direct and
grave threat to Israel's existence and actually facilitate the mission of the
Iranian regime and its terror proxies to murder more Jews.
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken is reported to have asked the State
Department for a "review of what a demilitarized Palestinian state would look
like based on other models around the world." Pictured: US Secretary of State
Antony Blinken is welcomed by PLO Secretary General Hussein al-Sheikh, in
Ramallah on February 7, 2024. (Photo by Mark Schiefelbein/Pool/AFP via Getty
Images)
As part of its effort to promote the idea of a "two-state solution," the Biden
administration has been talking about the need to establish a "demilitarized"
Palestinian state next to Israel.
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken is reported to have asked the State
Department for a "review of what a demilitarized Palestinian state would look
like based on other models around the world."
The purpose of such a review is to look at options for how a "two-state
solution" can be implemented in a way that assures security for Israel, a US
official told the American media outlet Axios.
The Biden administration is homing in on a new doctrine involving an
unprecedented push to immediately advance the creation of a "demilitarized" but
viable Palestinian state, New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman reported in
early February:
"[The plan] would involve some form of U.S. recognition of a demilitarized
Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip that would come into being
only once Palestinians had developed a set of defined, credible institutions and
security capabilities to ensure that this state was viable and that it could
never threaten Israel.
Egyptian President Abdel Fattah Sisi has also voiced support for the
establishment of a "demilitarized" Palestinian state.
"There must be a Palestinian state on the June 4 borders with East Jerusalem as
its capital, side by side with Israel," the Egyptian president said in November
2023.
"We are ready for this state to be demilitarized, and for there to be guarantees
of the presence of forces, whether from NATO, the United Nations, or Arab or
American forces, so that we can achieve security for both states, the nascent
Palestinian state and the Israeli state."
The talk about a "demilitarized" Palestinian state comes in the aftermath of
Hamas's October 7, 2023 invasion of Israel and the murder, rape, torture,
mutilation and burning alive of 1,200 Israelis, including women, children, and
the elderly. Hamas also kidnapped more than 240 Israelis, more than half of whom
are still being held hostage in the Gaza Strip.
The Hamas terrorists who attacked Israel used various types of weapons,
including assault rifles, rocket-propelled grenades (RPGs), and motorized hang
gliders. Thousands of terrorists infiltrated Israel from the Gaza Strip, which
has been under the exclusive control of Hamas since 2007. The Iran-backed terror
group Hamas soon launched a coup, overthrowing the Palestinian Authority (PA)
and seizing control over the Gaza Strip.
The Hamas coup came two years after Israel withdrew from the entire Gaza Strip,
after evacuating more than 9,000 Jews who were living there in more than 25
communities. Since 2005, there have been no Jewish civilians or soldiers in the
Gaza Strip, which became a semi-independent Palestinian state.
After the Hamas takeover, Israel and Egypt tightened their respective border
crossings and placed restrictions on shipping to prevent smuggling and the
infiltration of terrorists and weapons. Since the Hamas takeover, Israel, a
state the size of New Jersey, has been bombarded by tens of thousands of rockets
and mortars -- more than 11,000 just since October 7: 9,000 from Gaza, 2,000
from Lebanon.
The Israeli and Egyptian arms blockade did not prevent Hamas and other terror
groups from smuggling large amounts of weapons into the Gaza Strip, mostly
through the border with Egypt. The blockade also did not prevent the Palestinian
terror groups from manufacturing and developing their own weapons, including
various types of rockets and missiles. The idea that the Gaza Strip would become
a "demilitarized" entity thanks to the Israeli and Egyptian security
restrictions proved to be a pipe-dream.
The October 7 massacre of Israelis demonstrated that Israel's enemies do not
need tanks and warplanes to invade Israel and murder 1,200 people and wound more
than 5,000 others. The Palestinians have proven over the past few decades that
when it comes to murdering Jews, they will use anything they can get their hands
on as a weapon, including knives, cars, swords, screwdrivers, clubs, daggers,
stones, Molotov cocktails, and explosive belts.
Four months after the start of the Israel-Hamas war, it has become clear how the
Palestinian terror groups were successful in transforming the Gaza Strip into
one of the most dangerous and militarized areas in the Middle East. The Israeli
army has discovered and destroyed dozens of Hamas tunnels, many of which were
equipped with electricity, ventilation, sewage systems, communication networks
and rails, as well as weapons and food. The Gaza Strip is so full of weapons
that, four months into the war, the Palestinian terrorists are still using
rocket-propelled grenades and explosive devices to attack Israeli troops.
The situation in the West Bank areas controlled by the Palestinian Authority is
equally worrying. In the past few years, Iran and its terror proxies had
accelerated efforts to smuggle weapons into the West Bank through Jordan.
"Iran wants to turn Jordan into a transit area for weapons going into Israel,"
said Amer Al-Sabaileh, founder of Security Languages, a counterterrorism think
tank in the Jordanian capital of Amman. The bulk of Iranian weapons to
Palestinians go into the West Bank, particularly to the Palestinian Islamic
Jihad, according to a senior Jordanian security official.
In November 2023, Israeli authorities foiled an attempt to smuggle 137 guns into
Israel from Jordan, in what they said was the largest-ever seizure of weapons on
the Jordanian border.
Four months earlier, Israeli authorities thwarted an unusual weapons smuggling
attempt into Israel from Jordan, the details of which have not been cleared for
publication. The smuggling was described as "irregular," and not similar to
previous, and frequent, smuggling attempts. Authorities investigating the
incident believe the weapons were being spirited in for use by Palestinian
terror groups in the West Bank.
In April 2023, a Jordanian parliament member was arrested by Israeli authorities
for attempting to smuggle more than 200 firearms into the West Bank using his
diplomatic passport.
The flow of weapons into the West Bank has facilitated the emergence of several
armed groups responsible for countless terrorist attacks against Israelis. Most
of these groups operate in areas controlled by the Palestinian Authority, which
has several security forces consisting of tens of thousands of officers who are
supposed to disarm the armed groups.
If the Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip managed over the past few
decades to accumulate so many weapons, one can only imagine what would happen if
they were handed an independent and sovereign state with full control over the
borders with Egypt and Jordan. The Palestinians would undoubtedly continue their
efforts to obtain more weapons to be used in the Jihad (holy war) to kill Jews
and eliminate Israel.
First, even if the Palestinians commit in advance to a "demilitarized" state,
experience shown that their promises are worthless.
More importantly, according to Louis René Beres, professor emeritus at Purdue
University and an expert in international law and political science, any
commitment to a demilitarized state by the Palestinian leadership would be
legally worthless:
"Any treaty is void if, at the time it was entered into, it conflicts with a
'peremptory' rule of general international law (jus cogens) – a rule accepted
and recognized by the international community of states as one from which 'no
derogation is permitted.' Because the right of sovereign States to maintain
military forces essential to 'self-defense' is such a peremptory rule,
Palestine, depending upon its particular form of authority, could be entirely
within its right to abrogate any pre-independence agreement that had compelled
its demilitarization." [Italics in original.]
The Palestinian Authority committed, under the terms of the peace agreements
signed with Israel, to combat terrorism and enforce law and order in the West
Bank and Gaza Strip. However, the PA essentially did nothing to confiscate
illegal weapons or crack down on the countless armed groups operating under its
nose.
Even today, the PA is virtually doing nothing to foil terrorist attacks against
Israelis from areas under its control in the West Bank. It is hard to find one
Palestinian family in the West Bank that does not possess an assault rifle,
pistol, or some other weapon.
After Israel's withdrawal from the Gaza Strip, the Palestinians had a chance to
turn the coastal enclave into the "Singapore of the Middle East." Instead, they
turned it into one massive base for Jihad and terrorism. They also used the Gaza
Strip as a launching pad to fire tens of thousands of rockets and mortars into
Israel.
According to Beres:
"There are several substantive and foreseeable problems with Palestinian
demilitarization. The first such problem has to do with conspicuously unchanging
Palestinian commitments to an Arab state that would replace Israel. The second
concerns certain critical expectations of international law-abiding expectations
that could conceivably allow any Palestinian state to abrogate its
pre-independence commitments to remain 'demilitarized'...
"Therein lies the jurisprudential core of the Palestinian demilitarization
problem: International law would not necessarily require Palestinian compliance
with any pre-state agreements concerning the use of armed force. From the
standpoint of such authoritative law, enforcing demilitarization upon a
sovereign state of Palestine would be sorely problematic." [Italics in
original.]
Beres noted that both the Palestinian Authority and Hamas continue to agree on
one central deal-breaking point: First, Israel's existence is intolerable on
purely religious grounds and, second, Israel, in its entirety, is nothing more
than "Occupied Palestine":
"Unhidden, both the Arab world and Iran still have only a 'One-State Solution'
for the 'Israel Problem.' It is a 'solution' that eliminates Israel altogether,
a physical solution, a 'Final Solution.' Even today, official Arab maps of
'Palestine' (PNA and Hamas) show the prospective Arab State comprising all of
the West Bank (Judea/Samaria), all of Gaza and all of Israel. They knowingly
exclude any references to a Jewish population and list 'holy sites' of
Christians and Muslims only."
Beres warned Israel not draw comfort from a purportedly legal promise of
Palestinian demilitarization:
"Should the government of a new state of Palestine choose to invite foreign
armies and/or terrorists onto its territory, it could do so without practical
difficulties and without violating international law."
As a fully sovereign state, Palestine might not be bound by pre-independence
agreements, even if the compacts were to include United Nations and/or United
States reassurances to the contrary.
Beres added:
"Because authentic treaties can be binding only upon states, any agreement
between a non-State Palestinian National Authority (presumably in tangible
concert with Hamas) and a sovereign state of Israel would garner little
respect...
"Following the Gaza war, any plan for accepting Palestinian demilitarization
would be built upon sand. Neither the United States nor Israel should ever base
its geostrategic assessments of Palestinian statehood upon such an illusory
foundation. Following any implemented form of post-Gaza war independence,
neither the Palestinian Authority nor Hamas would accept the idea of a 'limited'
form of Palestinian statehood. By any Arab world definition, such an idea would
be considered unreasonable and humiliating."
No one can stop a future Palestinian state from becoming a lawless and
militarized state. Such a state on Israel's doorstep would pose a direct and
grave threat to Israel's existence and actually facilitate the mission of the
Iranian regime and its terror proxies to murder more Jews.
*Bassam Tawil is a Muslim Arab based in the Middle East.
© 2024 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
Gazans need international protection, not just a ceasefire
Osama Al-Sharif/Arab News/March 05, 2024
Almost five months into Israel’s genocidal war on Gaza, the tide has turned.
Israel has lost the public relations campaign completely, its “self-defense”
operation to uproot Hamas has resulted in the worst humanitarian disaster in
decades and it now faces serious charges of committing genocide, as well as war
crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity.
Benjamin Netanyahu’s capricious and miscalculated misadventure in Gaza has
dragged his army more profoundly into a quagmire. There is no honor in what
Israel has done in the past five months: the mass killings of women and
children, the bombing of hospitals, the targeting of journalists, doctors,
medics and academics, and the displacement of more than 2 million people. Now,
Gazans face starvation and famine. In the process, Netanyahu’s dirty war has
also dragged Israel’s closest allies into the mud. The Gaza debacle has
triggered a global awakening of the hypocrisy of Western governments and their
complicity in the longest colonial occupation of modern times. Now, the Biden
administration is trying to salvage a hopeless situation and achieve two
impossible goals: save Israel’s face in any way it can and fix a dire
humanitarian crisis that is getting worse by the hour.
On Sunday, US Vice President Kamala Harris uttered what had for months been a
taboo statement for the Biden administration. She called for “an immediate
ceasefire” in Gaza. In the most forceful rebuke of Israel’s conduct by a US
official yet, she said that too many innocent Palestinians have been killed in
what has become “a humanitarian catastrophe.” She called on Israel to facilitate
the flow of aid and take measures to protect civilians.
The US hopes that a ceasefire, even if it lasts for only a few weeks, would give
it time to do several things
The proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back was last Thursday’s massacre,
when Israeli soldiers opened fire on thousands of Gazans as they tried to reach
UN aid trucks to receive sacks of flour. More than 100 people were killed and at
least 700 wounded. UN and aid observers visiting the nearby hospital where most
of the injured were taken confirmed that most of the casualties suffered from
bullet wounds.
This was not an isolated incident of Israeli soldiers, tanks, fighter jets or
naval ships firing at civilians in Gaza. But the number of those killed and
injured was staggering, while Israel also provided contradictory and
unconvincing accounts about what happened. But global denunciations of the
bloody incident did little to change Israel’s attitude. Three days later, an
Israeli strike hit an aid truck in Deir Al-Balah with civilians close by,
killing at least nine people. Israel has also continued to blow up entire
residential blocks and has done nothing to facilitate the flow of aid,
especially to northern Gaza, where about 700,000 people face famine, according
to the UN. By Monday, the number of Palestinian babies to have died from
starvation rose to at least 15. The harrowing image of a starving child, Yazan
Al-Kafarna, a 10-year-old with cerebral palsy, who died at Al-Najjar Hospital in
Rafah after suffering from malnutrition, was posted all over social media
platforms.
In a symbolic and desperate move to address the situation, the US, along with
the Jordanian air force, dropped more than 35,000 meals on northern Gaza on
Friday, in what President Joe Biden said would be one of many airdrops. The
irony of the US dropping food on tens of thousands of hungry civilians caught in
a war zone and denied access to aid by America’s ally, Israel, was not missed by
many commentators. This is the same US that has supplied Israel with 2,000-pound
bombs to drop on the most crowded enclave on the planet.
The US is now pushing for a six-week ceasefire to begin before the beginning of
the holy month of Ramadan. This deal would see the release of Israeli captives
by Hamas in exchange for letting some of the thousands of Palestinians in
Israeli jails go free. But the US hopes that a ceasefire, even if it lasts for
only a few weeks, would give it time to do several things.
First, it would work with Egypt and Qatar to facilitate the release of the
remaining captives, thus putting pressure on Netanyahu to end his Gaza
misadventure, which has harmed Israel and turned worldwide public opinion
against it in an unprecedented manner. Second, it would give Washington time to
influence internal Israeli politics and neutralize Netanyahu by encouraging
calls for a snap election that would remove him. Harris on Monday met with
Israeli war Cabinet member Benny Gantz, who traveled to Washington against
Netanyahu’s advice. Gantz, described as a right-of-center soldier turned
politician, is leading Netanyahu in the polls and would certainly defeat him if
elections were held today. Washington believes Gantz would realize the damage
that Netanyahu has inflicted on Israel’s ties with its Western partners and seek
a way to restore them.
Third, the White House hopes that a ceasefire would alleviate the pressure
coming from progressive Democratic voters, including Arab and Muslim Americans,
after more than 100,000 Democrats voted “uncommitted” in last week’s Michigan
primary as a protest against Biden’s Gaza position.
Fourth, the Biden administration hopes that a ceasefire deal would appease the
US’ Arab allies, who have expressed their frustration over Biden’s Gaza policy
and built up public pressure among their citizens.
We have to look at the glass as being half full and realize that there can no
longer be a return to the day before Oct. 7
But a ceasefire, vital as it is, is not enough to end the war on Gaza. More than
2 million Palestinians in Gaza and about 3 million in the West Bank are in dire
need of international protection. A ceasefire in Gaza could collapse at any
moment over many excuses and from both sides. The humanitarian catastrophe in
Gaza will take years to contain, but it must be tackled robustly and sustainably.
Any interruption to the truce will compound an already complicated situation
that has not been seen before in any part of the world.
While Israel and its allies will argue that no international peacekeeping force
is needed in the West Bank, it will be difficult to oppose such an idea in Gaza.
The US and the rest of the world have rejected any notion of Israel reoccupying
the Strip. The Palestinian Authority is too weak and unpopular to take over the
administration of a devastated Gaza. Only an international peacekeeping force
can maintain the peace, facilitate the flow of humanitarian aid and help in the
evacuation of thousands of injured and terminally ill people to foreign
hospitals. A sustainable truce is needed to rebuild much-needed facilities like
hospitals and schools.
UN and NATO peacekeeping forces have a checkered track record. They have been
successful in some conflicts and done poorly in others. But we have to look at
the glass as being half full and realize that there can no longer be a return to
the day before Oct. 7 — for both sides.
So, the US must lead despite its dismal record in pushing for the two-state
solution, which will take forever to materialize. While the Palestinians — and
Israelis — wait for a just and lasting solution, the people of Gaza do not have
that luxury. They need immediate help and they need protection. Tens of
thousands of orphaned children need immediate care and, every day, some newborn
babies will lack even the most basic medical care.
Gaza will need a massive and probably unprecedented aid bridge when a ceasefire
occurs. And once such an aid bridge is launched, it cannot stop. A tentative
truce is not the answer, but the permanent presence of a peacekeeping force is.
The world, having abandoned the Palestinians for so long, owes this much to the
children of Gaza.
*Osama Al-Sharif is a journalist and political commentator based in Amman. X:
@plato010
Using smartphones in class smartly is better than a ban
Yossi Mekelberg/Arab News/March 05, 2024
A debate about the use of technology in schools — and, in particular, students’
use of smartphones — has been raging in the education system for years. The
approaches range from the purists, who see them as the source of all evil in
education and reject their use outright, to those who have fallen under their
spell and see them as the be all and end all in providing all-embracing
education around the clock. Then there is the third, most commonsensical group,
which would like to mobilize the benefits and reduce the harmful byproducts that
come with the overuse of digital technology, especially in an unregulated
manner.
Tilting toward the view of the first school of thought, England’s Department for
Education last month issued a new “mobile phones in schools guidance,” which
encourages headteachers to prohibit the use of mobile phones throughout the
school day, including at break times. This is, in my view, a draconian decision
that relinquishes the responsibility of the education system to guide and
educate children from a very young age in the best practices for using their
mobile phone, from both the pedagogical and social behavioral aspects, instead
of banishing them.
It is not only England that bans smartphones in schools, but other countries
including France, Finland, the Netherlands and even China, which is the world’s
largest mobile phone manufacturer. In Italy, for instance, teachers collect
students’ smartphones at the beginning of the day to ensure that those itchy
fingers deprived of screen time do not cave into temptation.
Completely separating activities inside school from those outside it creates an
unnatural separation
Few would dispute that technology, and not only smartphones, has changed the
dynamic in the classroom, such as how learners acquire their knowledge, the
relationship between teachers and students and the seemingly inexorable
shortening of attention spans.
As with all other technologies, there are disadvantages to smartphones that can
affect children’s development and make it more difficult for them to become
lifelong learners. Their social skills can also be hindered, especially when
there is more interaction with technology than with humans, and there are also
genuine concerns about the ugly phenomenon of cyberbullying.
However, to ban smartphones outright is to apply the wrong remedy to a genuine
problem. The answer is to educate young people in how to use their phones
effectively and with due consideration for others, because we do not expect
smartphones to disappear from everyday life anytime soon.
For many years, education systems have either avoided social issues or barred
them at the school gates, instead of developing programs that help young people
from an early age to deal with these issues in a thoughtful and constructive
way. This could be about politics, personal relationships, controversial social
issues or more generally about growing up into a responsible adult who can make
informed judgments without falling into the black hole of excess.
Last year, UNESCO called for a global ban on smartphones in classrooms, even
though its own director-general, Audrey Azoulay, admitted that the potential of
the digital revolution is immeasurable and the challenge is to regulate its use
— and she is right on both accounts.
Do not get me wrong, in all my years of teaching, I have not found that the
introduction of technology was the answer to improving the quality of education.
At best, it is a partial one. Moreover, there is nothing more irritating in the
modern classroom than students obviously using their smartphones and looking at
apps or websites, including social media, unrelated to the topic being discussed
in class. With time, I have become able to tell when this was the case according
to students’ facial expressions and body language. Hence, it would be foolish to
argue that smartphones and other online devices are not a distraction.
The answer is to educate young people in how to use their phones effectively and
with due consideration for others
Yet there are ways to change the balance between the genuine concerns about
their use in class and the opportunities to enhance students’ school experience
by making them active and proactive learners while using technology. The days of
what, in education theory, was known as “chalk and talk” or “mug and jug”
learning, which saw the teacher as the jug standing in front of the class
pouring knowledge into students (the mugs), have long gone. This idea of a
one-way flow of knowledge and information from the teacher to the students is no
longer relevant, especially in a world where learners are exposed to infinite
sources of information, some of great value and others baseless and potentially
harmful.
It makes the task of the educator complex and more challenging, but a major
feature of the digital revolution is its ability to help students of all ages,
and according to their developmental level, to harness this vast world of
information in the palm of their hands in the best possible way and ensure they
take ownership of this process. Completely separating activities inside school
from those outside it creates an unnatural separation and distorts the
relationship between home and school, teachers and parents and the school and
the wider society.
The downside of young learners with their eyes constantly focused on their
phones is indisputable. Attention spans shorten, they are easily distracted by
notification pings and there is a real danger of them becoming accustomed to
abridged explanations and argumentations. In my experience, this does not make
them less critical thinkers but more disorganized in their critical thinking, as
they find it difficult to separate the wheat from the chaff — and there is
plenty of chaff in cyberspace — which is where good educational programs should
come to the rescue.
Understandably, cyberbullying is also a key concern and should not be tolerated,
but for that there are guidelines and policies, as with real-world bullying, and
those who are caught engaging in such behavior should be disciplined and, in
certain cases, prosecuted. As always, hard cases make a bad law and, in this
case, banning smartphones altogether from the school day is a hard case.
More research is needed to establish the short- and long-term impacts of using
smartphones in education. No educator would like to raise a generation that does
not interact in person with their peers and teachers and, hence, becomes devoid
of social skills and is increasingly solitary, instead of active and interactive
members of their societies. But smartphones are here to stay and, instead of
students waiting all day to see what they “missed” in their cyberspace life, it
would become an educational moment if they were to have limited time with their
smartphones and be guided in how to use them without becoming addicted to them
or indulging in antisocial behavior.
Banning smartphones completely from school is just another case of the education
system failing to fulfill its duty to deal with knotty issues in society instead
of helping young people to develop into mature, constructive and considerate
adults and citizens.
*Yossi Mekelberg is a professor of international relations and an associate
fellow of the Middle East and North Africa Program at international affairs
think tank Chatham House. X: @YMekelberg
What will the US election mean for its foreign policy?
Dalia Al-Aqidi/Arab News/March 05, 2024
Recent developments in the primary elections suggest a disquieting familiarity
for American citizens as they contemplate the impending clash between incumbent
Democratic President Joe Biden and former Republican President Donald Trump. The
prevailing sentiment among observers is one of deja vu, reminiscent of the
contentious showdown witnessed in the 2020 election. Notwithstanding any
unforeseen developments, the prevailing trajectory suggests a repeat of the
previous experience.
Discernible patterns have emerged throughout the primary elections, reinforcing
the likelihood of a Biden-Trump rematch. This anticipated repetition prompts
reflection on the electorate’s desire for novelty and fresh perspectives.
Despite aspirations for change, the political landscape appears entrenched in
familiar faces and established narratives.
An underlying sentiment among the populace is a craving for new, youthful
leadership — a sentiment not readily fulfilled by the prevailing contenders. As
citizens yearn for a departure from the status quo, the prospect of another
electoral showdown between Biden and Trump underscores the endurance of
entrenched political dynamics over aspirations for renewal.
While domestic concerns such as economic inflation, healthcare and immigration
understandably dominate the discourse among American citizens, the international
community eagerly awaits insights into the future direction of US foreign
policy. Eyes worldwide are fixed on the candidates vying for their parties’
nominations, eagerly anticipating their positions on global issues as
articulated in debates and campaign remarks.
Despite aspirations for change, the political landscape appears entrenched in
familiar faces. The significance of America’s foreign policy cannot be
overstated. Its decisions and actions reverberate across the globe, impacting
economies, security and diplomatic relations. As such, the world scrutinizes the
presidential contenders, seeking clues and assurances regarding the trajectory
of US engagement with the international community. Understanding the nuances of
US foreign policy is paramount for nations and leaders navigating an
increasingly complex geopolitical landscape. The rhetoric and policies espoused
by the presidential hopefuls have implications for diplomatic relations,
strategic alliances and shared global objectives. As the presidential race
unfolds, the international community remains attuned to the nuances of each
candidate’s foreign policy platform. The stakes are high and the world watches
with anticipation, knowing that the outcome of America’s presidential election
will reverberate far beyond its borders.
The divergent approaches to foreign policy of Biden and Trump underscore
significant disparities in how they address critical global issues. These
differences reflect nuanced perspectives on international relations and
strategic priorities, shaping the course of action taken by their
administrations.
Each candidate’s attitude to the Ukraine conflict and Washington’s military aid
to Kyiv reveals their differing foreign policy strategies. Biden prioritizes
robust support to counter Russian influence.
On multiple occasions on the campaign trail, meanwhile, Trump has expressed his
support for Russia intervening in NATO member states that fall short of their
defense spending requirements. He has disregarded the alliance’s collective
defense clause, suggesting that he would not automatically defend nations that
fail to contribute financially. Trump also attributed improvements in NATO’s
financial situation to his presidency.
If Trump secures victory, he is likely to escalate America’s involvement in the
Middle East. Biden promptly responded to this narrative by expressing his
concern over Trump’s assertion regarding Russia, characterizing it as alarming
and dangerous. He said that Trump’s statements could empower Russian President
Vladimir Putin to perpetuate further conflict and violence, mainly targeting
Ukraine, while also extending the threat to Poland and the Baltic states. Biden
denounced such prospects as deeply troubling.
At last month’s Conservative Political Action Conference gathering, Trump
conveyed a stance unsympathetic to Palestinians in the context of Israel’s war
on Gaza, given his recognition of the threat posed by radical Islamist groups
such as Hamas. Consequently, he would not be anticipated to advocate for
pressure on Israel to agree to a ceasefire.
Trump also underscored Israel’s perceived safety during his tenure in the White
House, attributing this to his administration’s policies. He specifically
highlighted Iran’s support of Hamas and asserted that his approach toward Tehran
had diminished its ability to support such proxies. “Iran was broke, and they
had no money for Hamas, and they had no money for Hezbollah. They had no money
for anything,” Trump told CPAC attendees.
If Trump secures victory in November, he is likely to escalate America’s
involvement in the Middle East significantly. His administration would likely
engage with numerous Arab countries, alongside Israel, to combat extremism and
counter Iranian influence in the region. Furthermore, Trump’s approach toward
Iraq suggests a willingness to target senior leaders within the Iranian Islamic
Revolutionary Guard Corps, particularly in response to threats against American
forces in the area. The possibility of a scenario akin to the targeted killing
of Maj. Gen. Qassem Soleimani cannot be discounted.
In regard to China, tensions with Washington escalated during Trump’s first
term, particularly concerning trade matters. His decision to impose tariffs on
Chinese goods in 2018 and 2019 exacerbated these tensions.
While the Biden administration has not rescinded these tariffs, it has
implemented additional restrictions. The former president has promised his
supporters further tariffs on Beijing, potentially surpassing 60 percent.
Regardless of the occupant of the White House, it appears improbable that the
relationship between the world’s two largest commercial centers will undergo
substantial change.
In the case of Biden, continuity is anticipated in his policy approach, with no
substantial deviations expected. Although there may be some alterations to his
Cabinet composition, these adjustments are projected to exert minimal influence
on the overarching policy trajectory.
*Dalia Al-Aqidi is executive director at the American Center for Counter
Extremism. X: @DaliaAlAqidi
What Democrats’ ‘uncommitted’ campaign means for US policy
Kerry Boyd Anderson/Arab News/March 05, 2024
Democratic voters in Michigan last week sent a message to President Joe Biden’s
reelection campaign, expressing their deep disapproval of his approach to the
war in Gaza. However, it remains unclear what impact their protest might have on
US policy. Michigan is a key swing state in US presidential elections and one of
the states that is crucial for Biden to win. The president is elected through
the Electoral College system, which is based on votes in states rather than a
nationwide popular vote, with electoral results often centered on the outcomes
in a few battleground states, such as Michigan. In 2020, Biden won in Michigan,
defeating then-President Donald Trump by about 154,000 votes. In 2016, Trump won
the state, defeating Hillary Clinton by fewer than 11,000 votes.
Michigan also has a relatively large Arab American community, though they remain
a small minority of the state’s population. The Arab American community played a
major role in organizing an effort to send a message to Biden that he risks
losing votes over his strong support for Israel in the face of the devastation
in Gaza. Importantly, Arab Americans were not alone and partnered with Muslim
Americans, young voters and others. Together, they launched a campaign to vote
“uncommitted” in Michigan’s Democratic primary.
In the US system, the Republican and Democratic parties choose their
presidential candidates through a series of state elections — primaries and
caucuses. As the incumbent president, Biden is nearly certain to be the
Democratic Party’s nominee, though he technically faces some opposition. In
Michigan, Marianne Williamson and Dean Phillips were running against him.
However, his major opponent was the “uncommitted” movement, which asked voters
to demonstrate their commitment by showing up to vote but choosing this option
rather than backing Biden or another candidate.
The campaign clearly demonstrated that Biden’s policy toward Israel is weakening
his chances in Michigan
The movement was successful. Some leaders of the campaign had set an initial
goal of 10,000 uncommitted votes, arguing that Clinton lost in Michigan by about
only 10,000 votes. Therefore, they said, if Biden lost that many due to his
Middle East policy, then he would risk losing the state — and thus, potentially,
the entire election. Some analysts noted that a goal of 10,000 votes was very
low because uncommitted vote totals in the past had sometimes been much larger.
However, on election day last week, more than 100,000 voters selected
“uncommitted” on the ballot, putting the campaign at 13 percent of the vote, far
more than Williamson or Phillips received.
Biden still received more than 80 percent of the vote, but the uncommitted
campaign received enough votes to send two delegates to the Democratic National
Convention in August, giving it a very small voice but at least some
representation.
More importantly, the campaign clearly demonstrated that Biden’s policy toward
Israel is weakening his chances in Michigan. If 100,000 voters actually choose
not to vote for Biden in the presidential election — even if they do not vote
for his opponent — that alone would risk a defeat in Michigan for the president.
Although it is likely that some of those voters would choose Biden when facing
Trump as the only viable alternative, the uncommitted campaign sent a clear
message that Biden risks losing badly needed votes.
However, it is unclear whether the Michigan primary outcome will have broader
electoral impacts or will help to change US foreign policy. The uncommitted
movement can place more pressure on Biden if it expands to other states, but
there are multiple obstacles. Many states do not have an “uncommitted” option on
the ballot, which could make similar campaigns difficult. Other states also lack
the type of concentrated numbers of Arab Americans that exist in Michigan. While
many other social justice groups and young voters increasingly share Arab
Americans’ outrage over the war in Gaza, they do not all have the same capacity
to organize around the war as a single issue in an election.
Without openly saying it, Biden’s campaign effectively suggested that he does
not intend to change his policy
The Biden campaign is well aware of many Democrats’ growing concerns about
Israel’s approach to the war and ongoing US support. But Biden’s personal
support for Israel remains strong. His administration has taken only a few,
small steps to try to demonstrate that it hears concerns, but sanctioning a few
Israeli settlers and acknowledging that Palestinian lives matter look incredibly
insufficient given the extreme suffering in Gaza.
Biden’s campaign officials have tried to express sympathy for the pain that
those worried about Gaza feel but, without openly saying it, effectively
suggested that Biden does not intend to change his policy. Rather, campaign
representatives said that voters should remember that Trump is their only other
choice and that Trump’s calls for a Muslim travel ban and positions on issues
like climate change and healthcare should be priority concerns for voters.
However, on Friday, Biden authorized the US military to start airdrops of
humanitarian aid into Gaza — the biggest policy change he has made since the
current war started in October. He also expressed his strongest criticism of
Israel so far, calling on it to allow more aid into the Strip.
It is unclear what role the uncommitted vote in Michigan played in pressuring
Biden to more actively ensure that aid reaches Palestinians. Biden
administration officials have clearly grown frustrated with the Israeli
government, which might matter as much or more than domestic political
pressures. Nonetheless, the uncommitted vote in Michigan is one factor battering
against the long-standing wall of the country’s unconditional support for
Israel, which is starting to show cracks.
*Kerry Boyd Anderson is a professional analyst of international security issues
and Middle East political and business risk. X: @KBAresearch