English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For October 23/2023
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2023/english.october23.23.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
15 ÂÐÇÑ/2023
Bible Quotations For
today
Do not be deceived! Fornicators, idolaters,
adulterers, male prostitutes, sodomites, thieves, the greedy, drunkards,
revilers, robbers none of these will inherit the kingdom of God. And this is
what some of you used to be
First Letter to the Corinthians 06/01-11/:”When any of you
has a grievance against another, do you dare to take it to court before the
unrighteous, instead of taking it before the saints? Do you not know that
the saints will judge the world? And if the world is to be judged by you,
are you incompetent to try trivial cases? Do you not know that we are to
judge angels to say nothing of ordinary matters? If you have ordinary cases,
then, do you appoint as judges those who have no standing in the church? I
say this to your shame. Can it be that there is no one among you wise enough
to decide between one believer and another, but a believer goes to court
against a believer and before unbelievers at that? In fact, to have lawsuits
at all with one another is already a defeat for you. Why not rather be
wronged? Why not rather be defrauded? But you yourselves wrong and defraud
and believers at that. Do you not know that wrongdoers will not inherit the
kingdom of God? Do not be deceived! Fornicators, idolaters, adulterers, male
prostitutes, sodomites, thieves, the greedy, drunkards, revilers, robbers
none of these will inherit the kingdom of God. And this is what some of you
used to be. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in
the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and in the Spirit of our God.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on October 22-23/2023
The Beatification of Maronite Patriarch Estephan Douaihy... A Testament
of Faith for Lebanon/Elias Bajani, October 22, 2023
Hezbollah official says his group already ‘is in the heart’ of Israel-Hamas war
Netanyahu says Hezbollah war against Israel would be 'mistake of its life'
Hezbollah 'dragging Lebanon into a war', Israeli army warns
Mikati says efforts ongoing to 'stop Israeli attacks on Lebanon'
Fleeing Israeli strikes, south Lebanon families move into schools
Blinken notes 'growing concern' over Lebanon-Israel tensions in call with Mikati
Israel evacuates 14 North settlements near Lebanon border
Middle East Airlines Adjusts Flight Schedule Starting October 22
Israeli military's shifting focus: From Gaza to Lebanon amid escalating tensions
Aboul Gheit calls Mikati to discuss regional developments
Mikati: I call on our people to trust that necessary efforts ongoing to keep any
harm away from Lebanon
Middle East Airlines Adjusts Flight Schedule Starting October 22
Qassem says Hezbollah already 'in the heart' of Israel-Hamas war
Hezbollah alone will decide whether Lebanon gets dragged into Israel-Hamas
war/Asher Kaufman/Associated Press/University of Notre Dame/October 22, 2023
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News published on October 22-23/2023
Israel strikes Gaza, Syria and West Bank as war against Hamas threatens to
ignite other fronts
Israel pounds Gaza amid fears of wider Middle East conflictScroll back up to
restore default view.
Second aid convoy enters Egyptian side of Rafah crossing en route to Gaza,
sources say
Israel strikes Gaza, Syria and West Bank as war against Hamas threatens to
ignite other fronts
Israel did not bomb that hospital, according to the latest intelligence. It's a
reminder that in war, all sides engage in propaganda.
Canada has 'high degree of confidence' Israel didn't strike hospital in Gaza:
Blair
Israel welcomes Canada's conclusion that Israel didn't strike hospital in Gaza
Civilians in Gaza are terrorist sympathisers, warns Israeli military
Death toll in Palestine rises to 4,651 with nearly 2,000 Palestinian children
dead
US to send more air defense systems to Mideast, ups troop preparedness
Qatar says mediation will lead to Hamas hostage releases 'very soon'
US-led troops in Iraq reportedly targeted by suicide drone
Israel is now fighting on 3 fronts as airstrikes and violence escalate across
the Palestinian territories, Lebanon, and Syria
Israel warns Gaza airstrikes will intensify and hits West Bank ahead of war’s
‘next stage’
US upping Mid East presence due to risk of attacks on American troops, Austin
says
Iran warns Mideast could 'go out of control' as Israel steps up attacks: Live
updates
US advises citizens not to travel to Iraq after recent attacks on US personnel
Egypt's border crossing opens to let a trickle of desperately needed aid into
besieged Gaza
Russian casualties soar by 90% as Putin's generals order furious attacks on
small city in east, UK intelligence says
Thousands protest in Paris, demand 'an end to the massacre in Gaza'
Cairo Peace Summit: Arab and Western clashing perspectives
UNRWA announces death of 29 of its employees in Gaza
Detroit synagogue president found stabbed to death outside home
Iran to host Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process talks amid Middle East tensions
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on October 22-23/2023
Palestine: A Cause or a State?/Amir Taheri/Asharq Al-Awsat /October 22,
2023
China's Proxy Wars Are 'Encircling' America/Gordon G. Chang/Gatestone
Institute./October 22, 2023
Regional upheaval offers Assad regime a window to recalibrate/Zaid M. Belbagi/Arab
News/October 22, 2023
How Jordan and Syria can cooperate to improve relations/Dr. Majid Rafizadeh/Arab
News/October 22, 2023
Brinkmanship Politics/Charles Elias Chartouni/Face Book/October 22/2023
Israel-Gaza conflict only serves to benefit Hamas, Iran, Israeli far-right/Nadim
Shehadi/Alarabiya/October 22/2023
A Message to Khaled Meshaal/Tariq Al-Homayed/ Asharq Al-Awsat/October 22/2023
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on October 22-23/2023
The Beatification of Maronite Patriarch
Estephan Douaihy... A Testament of Faith for Lebanon
Elias Bajani, October 22, 2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/123408/123408/
We thank the Lord for His spiritual gifts and blessings bestowed
upon the Maronite believers, represented by the clergy and monks. We joyfully
and reverently thank Him for the grace of beatifying Maronite Patriarch Douaihy
in the Vatican on the past Thursday, October 19, 2023, adding him to the ranks
of the saints in our Maronite Church. These saints include:
Saint Maron, the Father of the Maronite Church
Saint John Maron, the first Patriarch of the Maronite Church
Saint Jacob, a disciple of Saint Maron
Saint Simeon Stylites the Elder, a disciple of Saint Maron
Saints Cyra and Marana, disciples of Saint Maron
Saint Domnina, a disciple of Saint Maron
The 350 Maronite Saints
Saint Marina of Qannoubine
Saint Sharbel Makhlouf, the Lebanese Maronite monk
Saint Rafqa Al Rayess, the Lebanese Maronite nun
Saint Nimatullah Kassab, the Lebanese Maronite monk
Blessed Maronite Martyrs Francis, Abd El-Moati, and Raphael
Saint Charbel Makhlouf
Saint Thérèse
Saint Maroun
And many more.
The beatification of Patriarch Douaihy is a significant historical moment for
our Church, our people, and our faith values. It symbolically affirms the
sanctity of his life and his contribution to the Church and society, prompting
the Maronite people to return to the wellsprings of faith and emulate the lives
of the saints.
To understand the importance of beatification, one must recognize the role of
saints in Christian teachings and traditions. Saints are individuals who lived
exemplary Christian lives, and their sanctification is a recognition of their
virtuous deeds and the examples they set for Christians. Our Church believes
that saints act as intermediaries between people and God, responding to prayers
and requests made to them. We witness the wonders of Saint Charbel, which are
countless in Lebanon and most parts of the world.
As a brief historical reminder, the Maronites trace their origins back to the
5th century when they separated from the Eastern Church and became an
independent Church. The Maronite Patriarchate and the Maronites are integral to
the fabric of Lebanese identity and heritage.
While the Maronite Church is a part of the Western Catholic Church, it retains
its distinct traditions and rituals.
In conclusion, the beatification of Maronite Patriarch Douaihy is a tribute to
the Maronite Church, a reflection of the rich history of the Maronites deeply
rooted in the land of Lebanon, a testament to holiness and the saints.
Patriarch Douaihy's beatification elevates the status of the Maronite community
and underscores the deep devotion of its followers. It is a moment of admiration
and respect for every believer, emphasizing the importance of reevaluating
Maronite Christian history, identity, and faith.
The beatification of Maronite Patriarch Douaihy brings hope, renewal, and a
sense of purpose to the Maronites and all Lebanese, reminding them of the
significance of dedicated service to faith, Christian values, Lebanon's essence,
identity, history, and sanctity.
Hezbollah official says his group already ‘is in the
heart’ of Israel-Hamas war
AP/October 22, 2023
BEIRUT: A top official with Hezbollah vowed that Israel will pay a high price
whenever it starts a ground offensive in the Gaza Strip and said Saturday that
his militant group based in Lebanon already is “in the heart of the battle.”The
comments by Hezbollah’s deputy leader, Sheikh Naim Kassem, came as Israel
shelled and made drone strikes in southern Lebanon and Hezbollah fired rockets
and missiles toward Israel. Hezbollah said six of its fighters were killed
Saturday, the highest daily toll since the violence began two weeks ago. For
Hezbollah, heating up the Lebanon-Israel border has a clear purpose, Kassem
said: “We are trying to weaken the Israeli enemy and let them know that we are
ready.” Hamas officials have said that if Israel starts a ground offensive in
Gaza, Hezbollah will join the fighting. Exchanges of fire along the
Lebanon-Israel border have picked up in the two weeks since the attack by the
Palestinian militant group Hamas that killed over 1,400 civilians and soldiers
in southern Israel. Retaliatory Israeli airstrikes on Gaza have killed more than
4,000 Palestinians. There are concerns that Iran-backed Hezbollah, which has a
weapons arsenal consisting of tens of thousands of rockets and missiles as well
as different types of drones, might try to open a new front in the Israel-Hamas
war with a large-scale attack on northern Israel. Kassem said his group, which
is allied with Hamas, already was affecting the course of the conflict by
heating up the Lebanon-Israel border and keeping three Israeli army divisions
tied up in the north instead of preparing to fight in Gaza. “Do you believe that
if you try to crush the Palestinian resistance, other resistance fighters in the
region will not act?” Kassem said in a speech Saturday during the funeral of a
Hezbollah fighter. “We are in the heart of the battle today. We are making
achievements through this battle.” On Friday, the Israeli military announced the
evacuation of a border city where three residents were wounded in the crossfire
a day earlier. Lebanon’s state-run National News Agency reported that an Israeli
drone fired a missile on a valley in the Sejoud area, about 20 kilometers (12
miles) north of the Israeli border. Hezbollah did not immediately confirm the
attack, but if true it would mark a major escalation as it is deep inside
Lebanon and far from the border. An Associated Press journalist in south Lebanon
reported hearing loud explosions Saturday along the border, close to the
Mediterranean coast.
Hezbollah said its fighters attacked several Israeli positions and also targeted
an Israeli infantry force, “scoring direct hits.”Lebanon’s state-run National
News Agency reported Israeli shelling of several villages and said a car took a
direct hit in the village of Houla. On Saturday evening, shelling intensified
around an Israeli army post across from the Lebanese village of Yaroun.
Hezbollah said six of its fighters were killed Saturday, raising the total of
Lebanese militants killed to 19 since Oct. 7. Israeli army spokesman Avichay
Adraee said a group of gunmen fired a shell into Israel and an Israeli drone was
launched back toward them. A drone also was dispatched after another group of
gunmen fired toward the Israeli town of Margaliot, Adraee said. “Direct hits
were scored in both strikes,” Adraee posted on X, formerly known as Twitter.
Hezbollah’s Kassem spoke about foreign dignitaries who visited Lebanon over the
past two weeks asking Lebanese officials to convince the group not to take part
in the latest Hamas-Israel battle. He said Hezbollah’s response to Lebanese
officials was, “We are part of the battle.”“We tell those who are contacting us,
‘Stop the (Israeli) aggression so that its (conflict) repercussions and
possibility of expansion stops,’” Kassem said, referring to the officials who
recently visited Beirut, including the foreign ministers of France and Germany.
Speaking about an expected Israeli ground invasion of Gaza, Kassem, said: “Our
information are that the preparedness in Gaza by Hamas and resistance fighters
will make (the) Israeli ground invasion their graveyard.”
Netanyahu says Hezbollah war against Israel would be
'mistake of its life'
Agence France Presse/October 22, 2023
Hezbollah will make "the mistake of its life" if it starts a war with Israel,
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Sunday. Hezbollah "will make the
mistake of its life. We will strike it with a force it cannot even imagine, and
the significance for it and the state of Lebanon will be devastating," Netanyahu
said on a visit to troops in northern Israel near the Lebanese border.
Hezbollah 'dragging Lebanon into a war', Israeli army warns
Agence France Presse/October 22, 2023
Hezbollah's escalating attacks on Israel risk "dragging Lebanon into a war,"
Israel's military said Sunday, after renewed cross-border exchanges of fire that
have raised fears of a wider conflict. "Hezbollah... is dragging Lebanon into a
war that it will gain nothing from, but stands to lose a lot," Israeli army
spokesman Jonathan Conricus said. "Hezbollah is playing a very, very dangerous
game. They're escalating the situation. We see more and more attacks every day.
Is the Lebanese state really willing to jeopardize what is left of Lebanese
prosperity and Lebanese sovereignty for the sake of terrorists in Gaza?" he
added. So far this weekend, cross-border attacks have killed six Hezbollah
fighters and a member of Palestinian militant group Islamic Jihad in Lebanon,
while three Israeli troops were wounded, one seriously, in Hezbollah anti-tank
fire. Two Thai farm workers were also hurt in Israel. On Sunday, Lebanese Prime
Minister Najib Mikati said diplomatic efforts were ongoing to "stop Israeli
attacks on Lebanon" and prevent the Gaza conflict from spilling into his
country. Tit-for-tat attacks at the border have so far been relatively
contained, but analysts have warned that the chances of Hezbollah scaling up
involvement could hinge on any Israeli ground invasion of Gaza. Hezbollah number
two Sheikh Naim Qassem warned Saturday that the group could step up its
engagement, as the group announced a series of attacks against Israeli and
contested territory. On Sunday morning, the Israeli army said its forces
"identified a terrorist cell attempting to launch anti-tank missiles toward the
Avivim area along the border with Lebanon." "Soldiers struck the cell before it
was able to carry out the attack," it said. The Israeli army also said a cell
fired an anti-tank missile at an Israeli tank "in the area of Har Dov," a site
in the disputed Shebaa Farms border district. "In response, the tank fired
toward the cell," it added, reporting no damage or casualties on the Israeli
side.
- Evacuations -
Lebanon's official National News Agency said Israeli aircraft overflew south
Lebanon on Sunday morning, adding Israel was bombing various sites along both
the border areas. Since October 7, exchanges of fire across the frontier have
killed at least four people in Israel -- three soldiers and one civilian. In
southern Lebanon, at least 29 people have been killed, according to an AFP tally
-- mostly combatants but also including at least four civilians, one of them a
Reuters journalist. Israel has ordered dozens of northern communities to
evacuate, and several thousand Lebanese have fled border regions for the
southern city of Tyre. On Sunday, the Israeli defense ministry said they were
evacuating 14 additional communities from the area. The Iran-backed Hezbollah
fought a devastating war with Israel in 2006 that left more than 1,200 dead in
Lebanon, mostly civilians, and 160 dead in Israel, mostly soldiers.
Mikati says efforts ongoing to 'stop Israeli attacks on
Lebanon'
Agence France Presse/October 22, 2023
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati said Sunday that diplomatic efforts were
ongoing to "stop Israeli attacks on Lebanon" and prevent the Gaza conflict from
spilling into the country. "Lebanon's friends are with us in continuing to make
every effort to return the situation to normal," Mikati said in a statement.
However, Lebanon was developing an emergency response plan "as a precaution," he
added. Tit-for-tat attacks at the Lebanese-Israeli border have so far been
relatively contained, but analysts have warned that the chances of Hezbollah
scaling up involvement could hinge on any Israeli ground invasion of Gaza.
Fleeing Israeli strikes, south Lebanon families move into schools
Agence France Presse/October 22, 2023
Shocked by images of dead children in Gaza, Mustafa al-Sayyid quickly whisked
his family to the closest shelter when Israeli strikes began near his village in
southern Lebanon this week. "What we are seeing on television -- the massacres
happening in Gaza, the children -- it cuts your heart to pieces," said the
53-year-old from Beit Leef, barely six kilometers from the Israeli border. "If I
wasn't afraid this would happen to us, I wouldn't have left my home," said
Sayyid, who has two wives and 11 children, around half of whom are under 10. The
family is among nearly 4,000 people who have fled flashpoint areas near the
Israeli frontier and flocked to the southern city of Tyre, according to local
officials. Around half are staying in three public schools that have been
converted into makeshift shelters, while the rest hunker down with relatives or
friends. The scale of displacement has gradually swelled since the Palestinian
militant group Hamas launched a massive October 7 assault on southern Israel in
the deadliest attack in Israel's history. Since then, some 4,385 Palestinians,
mainly civilians, have been killed in relentless Israeli bombardments, according
to Gaza's Hamas-run health ministry.
The tensions have spread to the Lebanese-Israeli border, where near-daily
tit-for-tat attacks have emptied out entire villages. At least 22 people,
including four civilians, have been killed on the Lebanese side, according to an
AFP tally. And at least three soldiers and one civilian have died in Israel.
Sayyid, whose brother was killed in the 2006 war between Israel and Hezbollah,
said he wants to avoid any more family deaths. "All my children are young. If
the apocalypse comes, how will I get them all out in one go?" he wondered inside
a classroom stripped of desks and dotted with thin mattresses. "So I thought,
better to leave now."
'Shelters at full capacity' -
Fears of a spillover loom large in Lebanon's border villages, which were
occupied by Israeli forces for 22 years before their withdrawal in 2000. A
steady stream of families, mostly from the pummelled village of Aita al-Shaab,
queued at the Tyre municipality this week to secure a spot in one of the
classrooms. "We have reached full capacity in all of our shelters," said Tyre
mayor Hassan Dbouk. "Now we are looking for a place to open a fourth center." In
the border village of Dhayra, farms and olive groves have been abandoned at the
height of the harvest season. Farmers already crushed by a four-year-long
economic crisis in Lebanon are bracing for an uncertain fate -- even if the
fighting abruptly stops. "Everyone in Dhayra relies on farming. We have nothing
but God and agriculture," said Moussa Suwaid, 47, speaking outside the Tyre
shelter where he has been staying for a week. "I have five sheep, each worth
around $500. I left them without food and ran away," he added. He also was
forced to leave behind his 88-year-old father and his cow. "He told me he would
rather die than abandon the cow and his home," Suwaid said.
'Sadness underneath' -
Ravaged by an economic crisis that has been widely blamed on official corruption
and ineptitude, Lebanon has not implemented an evacuation plan. Instead, the
villagers have left under their own steam, strapping bags to motorcycles or
hitching rides with neighbors. Yulla Suwaid, unrelated to Moussa, said she
waited for two hours in a pool of her own blood before her brother came to save
her during an Israeli bombardment that destroyed their Dhayra home last
Wednesday. The 43-year-old school teacher was running down the stairs when the
strike sent part of the wall crashing down on her legs, leaving her badly
wounded. "If I had completely lost my legs, what would I have done? Who would
have taken care of me?" she asked at a shelter in Tyre, both legs fully bandaged
after surgery. In a nearby school, Ahmad from Beit Leef said he had planned to
get married this month. Instead, the 26-year-old buried his father, who died of
cancer, as the Israelis shelled nearby. He then fled to Tyre with his fiancee's
family. Declining to provide his surname due to security concerns, Ahmad fought
back tears as he recalled one of his father's last actions. "I made him go to my
fiancee's family to ask for her hand in marriage," he told AFP. "I smile, but
there is a lot of sadness underneath."
Blinken notes 'growing concern' over Lebanon-Israel
tensions in call with Mikati
Agence France Presse/October 22, 2023
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken has noted "growing concern over rising
tensions" on the Lebanese-Israeli border in a telephone call with caretaker
Prime Minister Najib Mikati, a statement said. Blinken, however, "underscored
continued U.S. support" for Lebanon's army, security forces and people,
spokesperson Matthew Miller said in the Saturday statement.
Israel evacuates 14 North settlements near Lebanon
border
LBCI/October 22, 2023
After Israel evacuated 28 settlements along the border with Lebanon earlier this
week, all of which were within a 2-kilometer range from the border, and after
also evacuating the Kiryat Shmona settlement on Friday, which had over 20,000
residents, a new decision has been issued to evacuate 14 other northern
settlements.
Some of these settlements fall within a 5-kilometer range.
However, the reason behind this decision is that they are situated in areas
facing the front lines where daily clashes are occurring.
The settlements include Snir, Dan, Beit Hillel, She’ra Yashuv, and Hagoshrim,
all close to Al-Ghajar town and the Shebaa Farms. This area is one of the axes
witnessing daily confrontations.
In addition to these, the following settlements are also being evacuated:
- Matzuva, behind Hanita barracks, facing Alma Al-Shsab
- Eylon, Goren, Gornot HaGalil, facing Dhayra
- Even Menachem, behind Zerit barracks, facing Marwahin
- The settlements of Sasa and Tziv’on, behind Dovev barracks, facing Yaroun town
- The settlement of Ramot Naftali, facing the town of Blida
All these areas are witnessing daily clashes.
Lastly, Liman on the coast because it is exposed to missile attacks from the
Qlaileh Valley.
Middle East Airlines Adjusts Flight Schedule Starting
October 22
LBCI/October 22, 2023
Middle East Airlines – the Lebanese Airlines announced on Sunday its flight
schedule for Tuesday, October 24, 2023, after the company decided to reduce the
number of its flights and reschedule them starting from the early morning of
Sunday, October 22, 2023.
Israeli military's shifting focus: From Gaza to Lebanon
amid escalating tensions
LBCI/October 22, 2023
The Israeli army continues to supply the southern region with more military
equipment and points the barrels of its armored vehicles toward Gaza, awaiting
Israeli orders to launch a ground operation there. But its military focus
remains on Lebanon amid escalating tensions that have put all towns and
settlements in the north under the threat of Hezbollah's missiles and drones.
Israel has continued to evacuate settlements near Lebanon, adding 14 new
settlements to the 28 evacuated last week, all within five kilometers of the
border. Like Gaza, the Israeli-Lebanese border has become a top priority for Tel
Aviv.
An important meeting took place with the Chief of the General Staff of the
Israeli Army, Herzi Halevi, who rarely appeared since October 7, with Israeli
soldiers at their bases on the Gaza and Lebanon fronts. Furthermore, he
threatened to dismantle Hezbollah's capabilities on the northern borders and
attempted to boost the army's morale in preparation for a ground operation in
Gaza. The ground operation has once again been postponed due to operational
reasons and US pressure, in addition to the anticipated risks for the army if it
enters the Gaza Strip, given the expected ambushes. However, the postponement of
the ground operation did not prevent the Israeli Defense Minister from revealing
three stages for it. The first stage aims to eliminate Hamas and its military
infrastructure, while the second stage will continue for a more extended period,
during which internal matters in Gaza will be organized, leading to establishing
a new security system. Between the fronts of Lebanon on the one hand and Gaza on
the other, a new warning has emerged about the danger of opening up a third
battlefield in the West Bank, following the shelling of the Jenin camp and
intensified military operations inside West Bank towns.
With three potential fronts opening against Israel, a security report talks
about the lack of readiness of the Israeli army to engage in a ground operation
on its own.
So, how will the army fare when faced with at least three fronts?
Aboul Gheit calls Mikati to discuss regional developments
LBCI/October 22, 2023
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati received on Sunday a call from
Secretary-General of the Arab League, Ahmed Aboul Gheit, who briefed him on the
atmosphere of the "Cairo Summit for Peace" held yesterday.They discussed the
current developments and the situation in Lebanon, in addition to ongoing
efforts to halt the Israeli aggression on Gaza.
Mikati: I call on our people to trust that necessary efforts ongoing to keep any
harm away from Lebanon
LBCI/October 22, 2023
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati said on Sunday that diplomatic
communications on an international and regional level, as well as local
meetings, are ongoing to halt Israeli attacks on Lebanon, particularly in the
south, and prevent the spread of the conflict in Gaza to Lebanon. 'I understand
the fear and concern that the Lebanese people are experiencing due to the
ongoing events, and the calls from several embassies for their citizens to leave
Lebanon. However, I will not hesitate to exert every effort to protect Lebanon,'
he stated addressing visitors today. He added that “the meetings and
preparations we are undertaking to develop an emergency plan to face potential
events are a fundamental precautionary step. We are facing a historic enemy with
a bloody history. Yet, at the same time, we are reassured that Lebanon's true
friends continue to make every effort to return the situation to normal and
prevent it from deteriorating further.'
Middle East Airlines Adjusts Flight Schedule Starting October 22
LBCI/October 22, 2023
Middle East Airlines – the Lebanese Airlines announced on Sunday its flight
schedule for Tuesday, October 24, 2023, after the company decided to reduce the
number of its flights and reschedule them starting from the early morning of
Sunday, October 22, 2023.
Qassem says Hezbollah already 'in the heart' of Israel-Hamas
war
Associated Press/October 22, 2023
Hezbollah deputy chief Sheikh Naim Qassem has vowed that Israel will pay a high
price whenever it starts a ground offensive in the Gaza Strip, saying that his
Lebanon-based group already is "in the heart of the battle."The comments by
Qassem came as Israel shelled and made drone strikes in southern Lebanon and
Hezbollah fired rockets and missiles toward Israel. Hezbollah said six of its
fighters were killed Saturday, the highest daily toll since the violence began
two weeks ago. For Hezbollah, heating up the Lebanon-Israel border has a clear
purpose, Qassem said: "We are trying to weaken the Israeli enemy and let them
know that we are ready." Hamas officials have said that if Israel starts a
ground offensive in Gaza, Hezbollah will join the fighting. Exchanges of fire
along the Lebanon-Israel border have picked up in the two weeks since the attack
by the Palestinian militant group Hamas that allegedly killed over 1,400
civilians and soldiers in southern Israel. Retaliatory Israeli airstrikes on
Gaza have killed more than 4,000 Palestinians. There are concerns that
Iran-backed Hezbollah, which has a weapons arsenal consisting of tens of
thousands of rockets and missiles as well as different types of drones, might
try to open a new front in the Israel-Hamas war with a large-scale attack on
northern Israel. Qassem said his group, which is allied with Hamas, already was
affecting the course of the conflict by heating up the Lebanon-Israel border and
keeping three Israeli army divisions tied up in the north instead of preparing
to fight in Gaza. "Do you believe that if you try to crush the Palestinian
resistance, other resistance fighters in the region will not act?" Qassem said
in a speech Saturday during the funeral of a Hezbollah fighter. "We are in the
heart of the battle today. We are making achievements through this battle."On
Friday, the Israeli military announced the evacuation of a border city where
three residents were wounded in the crossfire a day earlier.
Lebanon's state-run National News Agency reported that an Israeli drone fired a
missile on a valley in the Sejoud area, about 20 kilometers (12 miles) north of
the Israeli border. Hezbollah did not immediately confirm the attack, but if
true it would mark a major escalation as it is deep inside Lebanon and far from
the border. The Israeli army later announced that it bombed an area from which a
surface-to-air missile targeted one of its drones in an apparent reference to
the incident. Hezbollah said Saturday that its fighters attacked several Israeli
positions and also targeted an Israeli infantry force, "scoring direct
hits."Lebanon's state-run National News Agency reported Israeli shelling of
several villages and said a car took a direct hit in the village of Houla. On
Saturday evening, shelling intensified around an Israeli army post across from
the Lebanese village of Yaroun.
Hezbollah said six of its fighters were killed Saturday, raising the total of
Lebanese militants killed to 19 since Oct. 7. Israeli army spokesman Avichay
Adraee said a group of gunmen fired a shell into Israel and an Israeli drone was
launched back toward them. A drone also was dispatched after another group of
gunmen fired toward the Israeli town of Margaliot, Adraee said. "Direct hits
were scored in both strikes," Adraee posted on X, formerly known as Twitter.
Hezbollah's Qassem spoke about foreign dignitaries who visited Lebanon over the
past two weeks asking Lebanese officials to convince the group not to take part
in the latest Hamas-Israel battle. He said Hezbollah's response to Lebanese
officials was, "We are part of the battle." "We tell those who are contacting
us, 'Stop the (Israeli) aggression so that its (conflict) repercussions and
possibility of expansion stops,'" Qassem said, referring to the officials who
recently visited Beirut, including the foreign ministers of France and Germany.
Speaking about an expected Israeli ground invasion of Gaza, Qassem, said: "Our
information are that the preparedness in Gaza by Hamas and resistance fighters
will make (the) Israeli ground invasion their graveyard."
Analysis: Hezbollah alone will decide whether Lebanon
gets dragged into Israel-Hamas war
Asher Kaufman/Associated Press/University of Notre Dame/October 22, 2023
Lebanon, which is teetering on the edge of economic and political collapse,
risks becoming entangled in the escalating war between Israel and Hamas.
Hezbollah has been gearing up for the possibility of joining the fight ever
since Hamas’ surprise assault on Oct. 7, 2023, killed nearly 1,400 people,
leading to Israel’s declaration of war a day later. The Shiite militant group
has launched multiple attacks on Israeli targets from Lebanon, prompting return
fire from the Israel Defense Forces. Over a dozen people have died, mostly
Hezbollah fighters but also at least a few civilians on both sides of the
border, including a Reuters photojournalist. As a historian, I have focused my
research and teaching on the dynamics of conflict and cooperation involving
Israelis, Lebanese and Palestinians. If a war between Hezbollah and Israel does
erupt, the already significant violence and destruction in southern Israel and
Gaza will likely be greatly compounded by further massive loss of life in
Lebanon, Israel and perhaps in other parts of the Middle East. Hezbollah’s
decision whether to fully join the war may answer a question that has been
preoccupying analysts of the organization for decades: Is its priority the
well-being of Lebanon or acting as a proxy for Iran?
A decades-old conflict -
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been spilling into Lebanon since 1948, with
the establishment of Israel and displacement of Palestinians, or what the latter
call the Nakba, or catastrophe. In fact, no Arab country has been more affected
by this conflict. About 110,000 Palestinians took refuge in Lebanon in 1948.
Today, the number is about 210,000, and they are denied basic rights. In
surveys, many Lebanese have said they resent the Palestinian refugees in the
country and blame them for the eruption of the Lebanese civil war, which took
place from 1975 to 1990. An estimated 120,000 died during the fighting, the
scars of which can still be seen in the capital of Beirut. Israel was deeply
embroiled in the Lebanese civil war. It supported Christian militias and pursued
its own fight against Palestinian militias, who used Lebanon as a base to launch
attacks against the Jewish state. In 1982, Israel invaded Lebanon in order to
wipe out the Palestine Liberation Organization and establish a pro-Israeli
Christian government in Beirut. Neither objective was achieved.
Hezbollah becomes Lebanon’s strongest force -
Since its foundation in 1920, Lebanon and its politics have been dominated by a
sectarian system in which government and state positions are divided among the
18 officially recognized religious sects, most notably Sunnis, Maronite
Christians, Druze and Shiites. Each sect has mandated representation in
government. Today, the Shiite population is the largest sect in the country,
making up 30% to 40% of the general population -- but no exact figure is
available because the sensitivity of the matter has meant no official census has
been conducted since 1932. For decades, Lebanon’s sectarian system has resulted
in what scholars call “hybrid sovereignty.” Political elites who represent their
sects in the sectarian system are both part of the state apparatus and also
operate outside of it by providing their constituents services that are normally
the responsibility of government, from providing marriage licenses to armed
protection. Hezbollah formed in 1982 with Iranian and Syrian support to fight
Israel after its invasion. It is by far the country’s strongest political,
socioeconomic and military force. This is due to the support of Iran and a
strong and cohesive internal social structure among its Shiite followers in the
country. Not all Shiites identify with Hezbollah, but no doubt many of them
sympathize with its causes. Hezbollah also operates within the hybrid structure
of the sectarian system by playing an integral part in the government but also
by functioning as a state unto itself. For example, it boasts its own military
force, which is far stronger than the formal Lebanese army, and provides social,
educational and economic services to Shiites. In fact, no group has benefited
more from this sectarian hybrid system than Hezbollah.
Lebanon in free fall -
Despite the fractured political system and weak state, Lebanon has managed to
retain some stability and vitality, even under the duress of the Syrian civil
war, which began in 2011. Things took a severe turn in October 2019, when years
of Ponzi-like financial mismanagement, excessive borrowing and a sharp decline
in remittances from abroad led the Lebanese economy to melt down. The World Bank
has described it as one of the worst economic crises since the mid-19th century.
The crisis sparked large-scale protests across the country, known as the
“October 17 revolution,” in which the Lebanese demanded social and economic
justice, an end to corruption and the dismantling of the sectarian political
system. As a result, foreign donors were alarmed, foreign currency flowed out of
the country, banks shut their doors to depositors, the government defaulted on
its debt and the local currency collapsed. A massive blast at the Beirut port in
August 2020, which killed 225 people and caused billions of dollars in damage,
further exacerbated the socioeconomic and political conditions in the country.
And since October 2022, the Lebanese political system has been in complete
gridlock, given the inability of the political class to agree on a new president
and a new government. Hezbollah has been the least affected by the national
crisis among political forces in the country and has emerged as a staunch
defender of the political system that nurtured it.
Some already see Lebanon as a failed state, so the last thing the country needs
is to become part of another war.
‘Back to the Stone Age’? -
But whether Lebanon becomes a part of the war, ultimately, is not up to the
Lebanese government. The current caretaker prime minister, Najib Mikati, has
cautioned against a war with Israel, as did Druze and Maronite political
leaders, who have traditionally opposed Hezbollah’s military hegemony in
Lebanon. Mikati acknowledged, however, that he holds no power to decide whether
Lebanon will go to war, reflecting the paradoxes of the Lebanese political
system in which the most crucial decision any national leadership could make --
the decision to launch a war -- does not rest within the government but within
Hezbollah and by extension within Iran. Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah has
repeatedly stated that the group’s prime role is to defend Lebanon’s
sovereignty. Its commitment to Iran, on the other hand, has been openly
demonstrated through its direct involvement in the Syrian civil war, which saved
Bashar Assad’s government. But that war was fought mostly on Syrian soil. A war
with Israel would be very different. It would be another tragic page in the
history of Lebanon if Hezbollah were to join the war against Israel, in
purported support for Palestinians in Gaza. It could prompt Israel -- in the
words of Defense Minister Yoav Gallant -- to try to send Lebanon “back to the
Stone Age.” Nasrallah, Hezbollah’s secretary-general, already answered in kind.
It would also likely lead to the broader regional war that U.S. officials,
including President Joe Biden, have been trying so desperately to avoid. And
Lebanon itself would move closer to the brink of absolute and irreversible
collapse. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative
Commons license.
Read the original article here:
https://theconversation.com/hezbollah-alone-will-decide-whether-lebanon-already-on-the-brink-of-collapse-gets-dragged-into-israel-hamas-war-212078.
Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published on October 22-23/2023
Israel strikes Gaza, Syria and West Bank as
war against Hamas threatens to ignite other fronts
Israel pounds Gaza amid fears of wider Middle East conflictScroll back up to
restore default view.
RAFAH, Gaza Strip (AP)/October 22, 2023
Israeli warplanes struck targets across Gaza, two airports in Syria and a mosque
in the occupied West Bank allegedly used by militants, as the 2-week-old war
with Hamas threatened to spiral Sunday into a broader conflict. Israel has
traded fire with Lebanon's Hezbollah militant group since the war began, and
tensions are soaring in the occupied West Bank, where Israeli forces have
battled militants in refugee camps and carried out two airstrikes in recent
days. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told troops in northern Israel that if
Hezbollah launches a war, "it will make the mistake of its life. We will cripple
it with a force it cannot even imagine and the consequences for it and the
Lebanese state will be devastating.”For days, Israel has seemed to be on the
verge of launching a ground offensive in Gaza following Hamas' deadly Oct. 7
rampage, with tanks and troops massed at the border. Israel’s military
spokesman, Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, said the country had increased airstrikes
across Gaza to hit targets that would reduce the risk to troops in the next
stage of the war. Hamas said it fought with Israeli forces near Khan Younis in
southern Gaza and destroyed a tank and two bulldozers. The Israeli military said
it had no information about the claim. On Saturday, 20 trucks entered Gaza in
the first aid shipment into the territory since Israel imposed a complete siege
two weeks ago.
Egypt’s state-run media reported 17 more trucks crossing Sunday, but the United
Nations said none had crossed. “Until now, there is no convoy,” said Juliette
Touma, spokeswoman for the U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees.
Associated Press journalists saw seven fuel trucks head north from the border,
but Touma and the Israeli military said those trucks were taking fuel that had
been stored on the Gaza side of the crossing deeper into the territory, and that
no fuel had entered from Egypt.
In a sign of how precarious any movement of aid remains, the Egyptian military
said in a statement that Israeli shelling hit a watchtower on Egypt's side of
the border, causing light injuries. The Israeli military apologized, saying a
tank had accidentally fired and hit an Egyptian post, and the incident was being
investigated. Relief workers said far more aid was needed to address the
spiraling humanitarian crisis in Gaza, where half the territory's 2.3 million
people have fled their homes. The U.N. humanitarian agency, known as OCHA, said
Saturday's convoy carried about 4% of an average day’s imports before the war
and “a fraction of what is needed after 13 days of complete siege." The Israeli
military said the humanitarian situation was “under control,” even as OCHA
called for 100 trucks a day to enter. Israel repeated its calls for people to
leave northern Gaza, including by dropping leaflets from the air. It estimated
700,000 already fled. But hundreds of thousands remain. That would raise the
risk of mass civilian casualties in any ground offensive. Israeli military
officials say Hamas’ infrastructure and underground tunnel system are
concentrated in Gaza City, in the north, and that the next stage of the
offensive will include unprecedented force there. Israel says it wants to crush
Hamas. Officials have also spoken of carving out a buffer zone to keep
Palestinians from approaching the border.
Hospitals packed with patients and displaced people are running low on medical
supplies and fuel for generators, forcing doctors to perform surgeries with
sewing needles, using vinegar as disinfectant, and without anesthesia.
The World Health Organization says at least 130 premature babies are at “grave
risk” because of a shortage of generator fuel. It said seven hospitals in
northern Gaza have been forced to shut down due to damage from strikes, lack of
power and supplies, or Israeli evacuation orders. Shortages in critical
supplies, including ventilators, are forcing doctors to ration treatment, said
Dr. Mohammed Qandeel, who works in Khan Younis' Nasser Hospital. Dozens of
patients continue to arrive and are treated in crowded, darkened corridors, as
hospitals preserve electricity for intensive care units.
“It’s heartbreaking,” Qandeel said. “Every day, if we receive 10 severely
injured patients we have to manage with maybe three or five ICU beds available.”
Palestinians sheltering in U.N.-run schools and tent camps are running low on
food and drinking dirty water. A power blackout has crippled water and
sanitation systems. OCHA said cases of chickenpox, scabies and diarrhea are on
the rise because of the lack of clean water. Heavy airstrikes were reported
across Gaza, including in the southern part of the coastal strip, where Israel
has told civilians to seek refuge. At the Al-Aqsa hospital in Deir al-Balah,
south of the evacuation line, several bodies wrapped in white shrouds were lined
up outside on the ground.
Khalil al-Degran, a hospital official, said more than 90 bodies had been brought
in since early Sunday, as the sound of nearby bombing echoed behind him. He said
180 wounded people had arrived, mostly children, women and the elderly who had
been displaced from other areas. Airstrikes also smashed through the marketplace
in the Nuseirat refugee camp. Witnesses said at least a dozen people were
killed.
Israel’s military has said it is striking Hamas fighters and installations, but
does not target civilians. Palestinian militants have fired over 7,000 rockets
at Israel, according to the military, and Hamas says it targeted Tel Aviv early
Sunday. More than 1,400 people in Israel have been killed — mostly civilians
slain during the initial Hamas attack. At least 212 people were captured and
dragged back to Gaza. Two Americans were released on Friday. More than 4,600
people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry.
That includes the disputed toll from a hospital explosion.
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken told CBS’ “Face the Nation” that Hamas
was responsible, not just for its brutal rampage in southern Israel, but for the
deaths of civilians in Israel’s attacks on Gaza. “It knew that in Israel’s
necessary response, civilians would be caught in that crossfire,” he said. He
said the militants were operating among the civilian population and its tunnels
were buried under hospitals and schools. “What does anyone expect Israel to do?”
he said.
“This is on Hamas.”
Syrian state media, meanwhile reported that Israeli airstrikes hit the
international airports in the capital, Damascus, and the northern city of
Aleppo, killing one person and putting the runways out of service. Israel has
carried out several strikes in Syria since the war began. Israel rarely
acknowledges individual strikes, but says it acts to prevent Hezbollah and other
militants from bringing in arms from Iran, which also supports Hamas. In
Lebanon, Hezbollah said six fighters were killed Saturday, and the group’s
deputy leader, Sheikh Naim Kassem, warned that Israel would pay a high price if
it invades Gaza. Israel struck Hezbollah in response to rocket fire, the
military said. Israel also announced evacuation plans for another 14 communities
near the Lebanon border. In the Israeli-occupied West Bank, 93 Palestinians have
been killed — including eight Sunday — in clashes with Israeli troops, arrest
raids and attacks by Jewish settlers since the Hamas attacks, according to the
Palestinian Health Ministry. Israeli forces have closed crossings into the
territory and checkpoints between cities, measures they say are aimed at
preventing attacks. Israel says it has arrested more than 700 Palestinians since
Oct. 7, including 480 suspected Hamas members. Among the dead were two killed in
an airstrike on a mosque in the town of Jenin, which has seen heavy gun battles
over the past year. The Israeli military said the mosque compound belonged to
Hamas and Islamic Jihad militants who had carried out several attacks in recent
months and were planning another. The internationally recognized Palestinian
Authority administers parts of the West Bank and cooperates with Israel on
security, but it is deeply unpopular and has been the target of violent
Palestinian protests.
Second aid convoy enters Egyptian side of Rafah crossing
en route to Gaza, sources say
Reuters/October 22, 2023
UNRWA, the UN’s Palestinian refugee agency, the sources said. The first convoy
of 20 trucks of badly needed supplies entered Gaza on Saturday. Israel imposed a
total blockade and launched air strikes on Gaza in response to a deadly attack
on Israeli soil by Hamas on Oct. 7. The Rafah crossing had been out of operation
since shortly afterwards, and bombardments on the Gaza side had damaged roads
and buildings. UN officials say a higher continuous pace of at least 100 trucks
a day would be required in Gaza to cover urgent needs. Before the outbreak of
the most recent conflict, several hundred trucks had been arriving in the
enclave daily. UN humanitarian chief Martin Griffiths told Reuters on Saturday
that work was underway to develop a “light” inspection system, whereby Israel
could check the shipments but ensure a sustained flow.
Israel strikes Gaza, Syria and West Bank as war against Hamas threatens to
ignite other fronts
AP/October 22, 2023
Israeli warplanes struck targets across Gaza overnight and into Sunday, as well
as two airports in Syria and a mosque in the occupied West Bank, as the
two-week-old war with Hamas threatened to spiral into a broader conflict.
Israel has traded fire with Lebanon's Hezbollah militant group on a near-daily
basis since the war began, and tensions are soaring in the Israeli-occupied West
Bank, where Israeli forces have battled militants in refugee camps and carried
out two airstrikes in recent days.
For days, Israel has seemed to be on the verge of launching a ground offensive
in Gaza as part of its response to Hamas' deadly Oct. 7 rampage. Tanks and tens
of thousands of troops have massed at the border, and Israeli leaders have
spoken of an undefined next stage in operations.
But the military acknowledges there are still hundreds of thousands of
Palestinian civilians in northern Gaza despite a sweeping evacuation order,
which would complicate any ground attack. And the risk of triggering a broader
war with Hamas' allies in Lebanon and Syria might also give them pause.
Spiraling humanitarian crisis
On Sunday, Egyptian media report a convoy of 17 trucks bringing aid to
Palestinians crosses into Gaza. This followed the 20 aid trucks that were
allowed to enter on Saturday through the Rafah crossing, the first time anything
has gone into the territory since Israel imposed a complete siege two weeks ago.
Aid workers said it was far too little to address the spiraling humanitarian
crisis in Gaza, where half the territory's 2.3 million people have fled their
homes. Hospitals packed with patients and displaced people are running low on
medical supplies and fuel for generators, forcing doctors to perform surgeries
with sewing needles, using kitchen vinegar as disinfectant, and without
anesthesia. Palestinians sheltering in UN-run schools and tent camps are running
low on food and drinking dirty water. The territory's sole power plant shut down
over a week ago, causing a territory-wide blackout and crippling water and
sanitation systems. The UN humanitarian agency said cases of chicken pox,
scabies and diarrhea are on the rise because of the lack of clean water. Gaza’s
Hamas-run Interior Ministry reported heavy Israeli airstrikes across the
territory overnight into Sunday, including southern areas where Israel had told
Palestinians to seek refuge. Late Saturday, an airstrike hit a cafe in the
southern town of Khan Younis where displaced people had gathered to charge their
phones. The nearby Nasser Hospital said 12 people were killed and 75 wounded.
Israel’s military has said it is striking Hamas members and installations, but
does not target civilians. Palestinian militants have continued daily rocket
attacks, with Hamas saying it targeted Tel Aviv early Sunday. Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu convened his Cabinet late Saturday to discuss the
expected ground invasion, Israeli media reported. A military spokesman, Rear
Adm. Daniel Hagari, said Israel planned to step up airstrikes starting Saturday
as preparation for the “next stages of the war.”An Israeli ground assault would
likely lead to a dramatic escalation in casualties on both sides. More than
1,400 people in Israel have been killed in the war — mostly civilians slain
during the initial Hamas attack. At least 210 people were captured and dragged
back to Gaza, including men, women, children and older adults. Two Americans
were released on Friday in what Hamas said was a humanitarian gesture.
More than 4,300 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run
Health Ministry. That includes the disputed toll from a hospital explosion.
Syrian state media meanwhile reported that Israeli airstrikes have targeted the
international airports in the capital, Damascus, and the northern city of
Aleppo. It said the strikes killed one person and damaged the runways, putting
them out of service. Israel has carried out several strikes in Syria, including
on the airports, since the war began. Israel rarely acknowledges individual
strikes, but says it acts to prevent Hezbollah and other militant groups from
bringing in arms from their patron, Iran, which also supports Hamas. In Lebanon,
Hezbollah said six of its fighters were killed Saturday, and the group’s deputy
leader, Sheikh Naim Kassem, warned that Israel would pay a high price if it
starts a ground offensive in the Gaza Strip. Israel struck Hezbollah targets
early Sunday in response to rocket fire, the military said. Israel also
announced evacuation plans for another 14 communities near the border with
Lebanon. Kiryat Shmona, with a population of more than 20,000 people, was told
to evacuate last week. In the occupied West Bank, dozens of Palestinians have
been killed in clashes with Israeli troops, arrest raids and attacks by Jewish
settlers. Israeli forces have closed crossings into the territory and
checkpoints between cities, measures they say are aimed at preventing attacks.
Israel has arrested hundreds of Palestinians since Oct. 7, mainly suspected
Hamas members. The internationally recognized Palestinian Authority administers
parts of the West Bank and cooperates with Israel on security, but it is deeply
unpopular and has been the target of violent Palestinian protests. Israeli
forces killed at least five people early Sunday in the West Bank, according to
the Palestinian Health Ministry. Two were killed in an airstrike on a mosque in
the town of Jenin, which has seen heavy gunbattles between Palestinian militants
and Israeli troops over the past year. The Israeli military said the mosque
compound belonged to Hamas and Islamic Jihad militants who had carried out
several attacks in recent months and were planning another one. Sunday’s
fatalities brought the death toll in the West Bank to 90 Palestinians since the
war broke out on Oct. 7, according to the Health Ministry. Most appear have been
killed during fighting with Israeli forces or violent protests.
Thirteen Palestinians, including five minors, and a member of Israel's
paramilitary Border Police were killed last week in a battle in a refugee camp
in the West Bank town of Tulkarem, in which Israel also launched an airstrike.
Inside Gaza, shellshocked residents said they were unsure where to go or how to
protect their families. “Even in my worst nightmares, I never thought this
could be possible,” said Rami Abu Wazna, staring at the destruction in central
Gaza’s Al-Zahra neighborhood. The scale of the bombing has left basic systems
unable to function, with the UN reporting around 40 unidentified bodies were
buried in a mass grave in Gaza City on Saturday because cold storage ran out
before they could be identified.
Meanwhile, the Israeli military said the humanitarian situation was “under
control” as aid workers called for the opening of a round-the-clock aid
corridor.
The UN humanitarian agency, known as OCHA, said the convey that entered Saturday
carried about 4% of an average day's imports before the war and “a fraction of
what is needed after 13 days of complete siege.” It is calling for 100 trucks a
day to enter. Huge quantities of aid have been gathered near the Egyptian side
of the crossing, but there has been no word on when more might enter.
President Joe Biden said the US, which has worked with other mediators to reach
an agreement on Rafah, “remains committed to ensuring that civilians in Gaza
will continue to have access to food, water, medical care, and other assistance,
without diversion by Hamas.”In a statement, he said the US would work to keep
Rafah open and let US citizens leave Gaza. But hundreds of foreign passport
holders who had gathered at the crossing on Saturday were unable to depart after
the aid convoy entered. American citizen Dina al- Khatib said she and her family
were desperate to get out. “It’s not like previous wars,” she said. “There is no
electricity, no water, no internet, nothing.” AFP infographic based on data
released on Oct. 18. Recent figures show the damage to housing at 40 percent. At
a peace summit organized by Egypt, UN chief Antonio Guterres again pleaded for a
humanitarian cease-fire “to end this godawful nightmare.”In a sign of
international divisions however, the meeting was unable to agree any joint call,
with Western officials demanding a clear condemnation of Hamas, and Arab
attendees opting to issue their own statement criticizing world leaders.
Israel did not bomb that hospital, according to the latest
intelligence. It's a reminder that in war, all sides engage in propaganda.
Charles R. Davis/Business Insider/October 22, 2023
Blame game follows Gaza hospital disasterScroll back up to restore default view.
Israel was blamed for bombing a hospital in Gaza. The media treated its denial
with skepticism.
But it turned out it was not an Israeli airstrike as many assumed.
The incident serves as a reminder that, in war, all sides engage in propaganda.
If a tree falls in a forest, and no reporter is there to witness it, the first
task for the seeker of truth is to establish: Did the tree even fall down at
all?
On Tuesday, most international news outlets — and, by extension, most news
consumers — were reasonably convinced that a hospital in Gaza had just been
destroyed in an explosion, killing many of its patients.
Most were also reasonably convinced that Israel was responsible, its denials
duly reported but with the knowledge that only one party to the conflict had the
firepower and means to deliver such destruction, along with a record of
targeting such facilities in the past.
"Israel's bombing of the Ahli Arab Hospital in Gaza killed 500 civilians,"
declared an emergency alert from Genocide Watch, a group that tracks ethnic
cleansing and campaigns of mass murder (and which has accused Hamas and the
Israeli government of engaging in both, to varying degrees). "The hospital
bombing was a clear war crime."By Wednesday, what became clear was that, while
narrowly accurate, the most truthful part of Tuesday's reporting was the
attribution: that a hospital was destroyed and hundreds of people killed,
according to Hamas, a terrorist organization that controls the Gaza Strip and
its various ministries, including the one that reports the Palestinian death
toll. The photos that emerged in daylight, of a hospital intact and a parking
lot with a crater far too small to be from an Israeli airstrike, called into
question everything that most reporters and their readers had taken for granted
— and lent credence to the earlier, adamant denials from the Israel Defense
Forces. A senior European intelligence official also said the actual death toll
was likely between 10 and 50 people, while an initial US assessment placed the
number at the "low end of the 100-to-300 spectrum."
There is good reason not to trust the IDF. Last year, in just one example, the
Israeli military killed an American journalist, Shireen Abu Akleh, who was
reporting outside the Jenin refugee camp in the West Bank, initially claiming
she was surrounded by armed militants and potentially killed by Palestinian
gunmen. But video and eyewitness testimony contradicted both claims. Evidence
suggested that Israeli troops were the ones who opened fire and that they
deliberately targeted the journalists.
What also emerged on Thursday, however, was a possibility that some could not
process: One, that the IDF was telling the truth, this time, when it blamed the
explosion near the Ahli Arab Hospital on a misfired rocket from Islamic Jihad;
and two, that the international media had actually challenged the assertions of
Israel, a Western ally, and in this case deferred to the claims of Hamas
authorities in Gaza.
"Just imagine the headlines if Putin had bombed a hospital in Kharkiv, killing
500 people, many of them kids, and then blamed it on the Ukrainians," Yanis
Vaourfakis, a leftist economist and Greek politician, posted on social media.
"Nothing makes Vlad happier than watching the West's touching attempts to
overtake his callous cynicism."Russia has bombed hospitals in Ukraine, as well
as Syria, and its denials have been viewed as dubious for a simple reason: If
something falls from the sky and explodes, it is generally right to suspect the
party with air supremacy. And that is what happened Tuesday, Israeli claims
treated with a similar, earned skepticism — even before the bombing of a
hospital was an established fact.
The knee-jerk response also went the other way. Before the IDF issued a denial,
Hananya Naftali, a right-wing Israeli influencer, assumed Israel was responsible
— and immediately attempted to justify it: A "Hamas terrorist based inside a
hospital" had been attacked, he posted on social media, killing a "number of
terrorists." In this, he was indeed no different than commentators who have
excused Russia's atrocities: projecting absolute certainty that whatever
happened, despite the little we know, was for a damn good reason. Many, then,
were embarrassed by what is objectively good albeit startling news: that a
hospital in Gaza, reported as leveled, was still standing — and not bombed by
the IDF at all. That's a conclusion backed by US intelligence and supported by
independent analysts, including a former UN war crimes investigator and
researchers at Bellingcat, who noted that the damage seen in photographs shared
the next morning was not consistent with the area being struck in an Israeli
airstrike. A French intelligence assessment, made public Friday, also rejected
claims of "an Israeli strike," saying there was "nothing to indicate" the
hospital was hit by the IDF this week. "The most probable hypothesis is that a
Palestinian rocket exploded with a charge of about five kilos," it said. The
Associated Press, too, concluded — after an analysis of video and input from
"experts with specialties in open-source intelligence, geolocation and rocketry"
— that the most likely cause of the blast near the hospital was a misfired
rocket, not an Israeli strike.
Members of the media (and others) have lessons to learn here.
First, the fog of war, paired with social media, is a recipe for inaccuracy. We
should all slow down and be more inclined to let the fog lift before
broadcasting an unverified claim. While some may see this week's reporting as
the product of an anti-Israel bias, the truth is likely more mundane: No news
outlet wants to be the last one to cover the most important story of the day.
Second, while the IDF's statements should continue to be viewed with healthy
skepticism, the official sources in Gaza clearly warrant at least as much
scrutiny, controlled as they are by a designated terrorist organization. Hamas
has an incentive to blame anything bad that happens in Gaza on the Israeli state
and has shown itself willing to fabricate a war crime — claiming a hospital
found standing on Wednesday was destroyed the night before. If it wasn't
absolutely clear before, it is today: The local health ministry, which rushed
out a now seemingly implausible body count, answers to this extremist group.
Acknowledging this is not to deny that Palestinians are suffering under Israeli
bombardment. People on the ground, with no connection to Hamas, can attest to
this, and the IDF would only dispute who is ultimately to blame. That points to
the last lesson from all this for partisans of either side and other news
consumers: What happens in war will not always reaffirm our prior convictions.
Assumptions should always be questioned, and truths acknowledged — convenient or
not.
Canada has 'high degree of confidence'
Israel didn't strike hospital in Gaza: Blair
The Canadian Press/October 22/ 2023
OTTAWA — Defence Minister Bill Blair says that after an independent review by
the Canadian military, Ottawa has a "high degree of confidence" that Israel did
not strike the al-Ahli Hospital in Gaza City on Tuesday. A statement from Blair
says Canada believes the more likely scenario is that the strike was caused by
an errant rocket fired from Hamas-controlled Gaza. The pronouncement from Ottawa
comes days after the United States said its own review found that Israel was not
responsible, with President Joe Biden saying during a visit to Israel that he
was confident the "other team" bore responsibility.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said on Thursday that his government was taking
"all necessary steps" to form its own understanding of what happened. The
hospital blast on Oct. 17, which the Gaza Health Ministry said killed hundreds
of people, quickly became a flashpoint in the war. Hamas, which Canada
designates as a terrorist group, quickly blamed an Israeli military airstrike
for the explosion, but Israel subsequently released images that it said proved
it was caused by a misfire from Gaza.
Israel welcomes Canada's conclusion that Israel didn't
strike hospital in Gaza
The Canadian Press/Sunday, October 22, 2023
Israel is "pleased" that Canada has joined the United States and France in
believing that an explosion at a Gaza City hospital last week was fired by an
errant rocket from within the Gaza Strip, the Israeli ambassador in Ottawa said
Sunday. “The loss of life at the al-Ahli Arab hospital was a tragedy that should
horrify any human being and it is a reminder of the double war crimes against
Palestinians and Israelis that are committed by Hamas and other terrorist groups
in Gaza,” Iddo Moed said in a statement. The rocket fired at the hospital Oct.
17 became a new flashpoint in the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas as both
sides blamed each other for the tragedy. Canadian Defence Minister Bill Blair
issued a statement late Saturday night saying an independent analysis by the
Canadian Forces gives the government a "high degree of confidence" that the
rocket did not come from Israel. Canada was slower than some of its allies to
reach that conclusion. During a visit to Tel Aviv on Oct. 18, US. President Joe
Biden said American defence intelligence showed the rocket came from within
Gaza, and France said its military had reached the same conclusion on Oct. 20.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau asked Blair on Oct. 17 to have the Canadian
military conduct its own assessment. On Oct. 19 he said Canada had seen some
"preliminary evidence" but would take the "necessary time to look carefully" and
work with allies to reach a firm conclusion. The Canadian military assessment
delivered its first report Saturday, and Blair and Trudeau were both briefed on
the findings before Blair made the conclusion public just before 10 p.m. Canada
has not yet assigned specific blame for the source of the rocket. Moed said he
believes further analysis from Canada will also conclude the rocket was fired by
the Palestinian Islamic Jihad. The PIJ is the second-largest armed group in
Gaza, whose sole objective is a military victory over Israel to establish an
Islamic State across all of Israel, along with the West Bank and Gaza. Israel
blames the PIJ for the rocket, and American officials told the New York Times
their preliminary evidence also pointed to the PIJ. “As Canada provides further
updates, Israel is assured that other findings uncovered by the Israeli Defense
Forces, including the culpability of Palestinian Islamic Jihad, will be
identified by Canada as the source of this war crime," Moed said. The latest
escalation of violence between Israel and Gaza erupted on Oct. 7 when Hamas
militants, who control the Gaza Strip, launched a multi-pronged attack on Israel
from the air and the ground. At least 1,400 Israelis were killed and more than
200 people — including children — were taken hostage by Hamas, which Canada has
designated as a terrorist organization since 2002. Israel responded with force,
cutting off power and supplies to the two million people who live in the Gaza
Strip and launching its own rocket attacks into the area. The humanitarian
situation in Gaza deteriorated quickly and Canada was among the countries who
backed Israel's right to defend itself while calling for Israel and Egypt, which
controls access to Gaza from the south, to allow in aid.
Both Israel and Egypt have imposed a blockade on Gaza since Hamas took control
of the small strip of land in 2007. The Palestinian death toll is now estimated
to be over 4,600 people. Aid began moving slowly into Gaza from Egypt Saturday
including fuel, food and medical supplies. That same day, Foreign Affairs
Minister Mélanie Joly announced an additional $50 million in funding for
humanitarian assistance in the Gaza Strip and reiterated Canada's request for
aid to be allowed into the territory. Joly and International Development
Minister Ahmed Hussen are also in Cairo this weekend for what is being billed as
a peace summit. The ministers were expected to discuss efforts to help some 400
Canadians leave Gaza. The Canadian government has helped 33 people out of the
West Bank and nearly 1,600 people out of Israel since the conflict began, with a
final military evacuation flight expected out of Tel Aviv on Monday.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 22, 2023.
Civilians in Gaza are terrorist sympathisers, warns
Israeli military
Ben Farmer/The Telegraph/October 22, 2023
Israel warned civilians in Gaza they could be seen as terrorist sympathisers if
they do not move south ahead of an expected invasion. The Israel Defense Forces
(IDF) repeated orders to evacuate the northern part of the Hamas-controlled
coastal enclave, ahead of an expected ground offensive likely to bring heavy
urban fighting and casualties. The United Nations meanwhile warned that some 120
newborn babies were in danger in the blockaded Gaza Strip as the fuel needed to
power hospital incubators ran out. Leaflets dropped by air in the 25-mile long
territory repeated calls for residents to move south of the Wadi Gaza, but used
stronger language than earlier warnings. Those who did not move “could be
considered or identified as a partner in a terrorist organization,” the leaflets
said. It came as an Israeli soldier was killed by an anti-tank missile on Sunday
during a raid into the Hamas-controlled Gaza Strip, the country’s military said.
Israeli troops have been conducting raids across the border, which the military
says are meant to clear the area and gather intelligence about missing people
and captives being held by Hamas in the enclave. “An IDF (Israel Defense Forces)
soldier was killed, one was moderately injured, and two were lightly injured as
a result of an anti-tank missile launched toward an IDF tank and an engineering
vehicle,” the military said.
Israel has vowed to wipe out Hamas and create a “new security reality” in the
enclave, after gunmen stormed border communities a fortnight ago and killed
1,400 people.
Troops have been put on alert for a ground offensive soon, which is predicted to
see heavy casualties on both sides, and among remaining civilians. Israeli air
and artillery strikes since the Oct 7 attacks have already destroyed large
numbers of homes in the Strip and killed some 4,650 Palestinians, the local
health ministry said. The evacuation zone is thought to be home to around a
million people. Israel has estimated some 700,000 have left, meaning hundreds of
thousands still remain. Those still in the north of the Strip said the scale of
Israel’s heavy bombardment had made it difficult to leave for civilians and
those being treated in hospitals. Doctors inside the Strip and Unicef, the UN
agency for the welfare of children, warned that a dangerous shortage of fuel to
run hospital generators was endangering the lives of newly born and premature
babies. Jonathan Crick, Unicef spokesman, said: “We have currently 120 neonates
who are in incubators, out of which we have 70 neonates with mechanical
ventilation, and of course this is where we are extremely concerned.”He said:
“If they [babies] are put in mechanical ventilation incubators, by definition,
if you cut the electricity, we are worried about their lives.”Dr Medhat Abbas,
director general at the ministry of health in Gaza, told the Telegraph there
were 130 premature babies spread across different hospitals. He said: “Without
power, the babies will be the first to die, followed by 1,000 kidney patients
who need dialysis three times a week. “Fuel and power will keep these babies
healthy and we won’t need to evacuate them. They need to stay where they are.”
Around 160 women give birth each day in Gaza, according to the UN Population
Fund, which estimates there are 50,000 pregnant women across the territory of
2.4 million people. Gaza has six neonatal units, including one at the large Al-Shifa
hospital, which has been overwhelmed with casualties since the Israeli campaign
began.
The hospital’s wards and corridors have overflowed with the wounded in the past
fortnight according to doctors, leaving the territory’s main health centre at
breaking point. Staff have said they are, at times, receiving hundreds of
injured people each hour and corpses in body bags are lined up outside the
hospital’s mortuary. Thousands of people have sought shelter at the site, hoping
it will be protected from strikes. Israel has, for years, accused Hamas of using
the hospital as a base. Ehud Barak, former Israeli prime minister, last week
alleged to the BBC that Hamas had buried a command post under the hospital.
Hamas has in the past told residents to ignore Israeli evacuation orders and
“remain steadfast in your homes”. Israel has long accused the group of using
Gaza’s civilians as human shields, by forcing people to stay at home in the path
of IDF activity, operating and firing from houses, and by setting up bases in
public institutions like hospitals. After the latest evacuation warning, the IDF
said it had “no intention to consider those who have not evacuated... as a
member of the terrorist group”. The order by Israel for civilians to move south
has already triggered a mass exodus, but damage to infrastructure has also
heightened risks. The danger of being hit by an air strike in Gaza led drivers
to hike prices for the journey beyond many people’s reach. Drivers were now
charging between £165 ($200) and £250 to take a family south, one resident told
the New York Times. Before the war, the same trip cost about £2.50 per person.
“We can’t even afford to eat,” Amani Abu Odeh, who lives in the town of Jabalia
in Gaza’s north, told the newspaper. “We don’t have the money to leave.”
Israeli commanders are predicting heavy casualties when they storm Gaza, given
Hamas has had years to build defences and plan to resist an assault. More than
350,000 reservists have been mobilised in Israel and tanks and troops are
building up near the fenced border.
Lt Col Jonathan Conricus, an IDF spokesman, said Israeli strategy was “to have a
weakened, tired and dislocated Hamas in preparation for our next stage of
military operations”. He went on: “Our working assumption is that Hamas has
prepared the battlefield, that there are various dimensions of warfare ready for
us – specifically tunnels – and that Hamas, at least in the first and the
intermediate stages, will fight and will inflict heavy casualties on [Israeli
forces]”. The White House has been pressing Israel to delay a ground invasion to
give negotiators more time to win the release of more than 200 hostages seized
by Hamas during the attacks. The release late last week of an American mother
and her teenage daughter after mediation by Qatar has raised the prospect of
other releases. “The [administration] pressed Israeli leadership to delay
because of progress on the hostage front,” and the need to get trucks of aid
into Gaza, one person familiar with the discussions told CNN.
Meanwhile, a second convoy of aid lorries crossed into Gaza via the Rafah border
point with Egypt on Sunday. The 17 vehicles that crossed, following 20 the day
before, were only a tiny fraction of what is needed, aid agencies said. The UN’s
own aid agency for Palestinian refugees was due to run out of fuel within three
days unless the siege was eased, it said. Already, 29 of its staff have been
killed in the past fortnight. A statement said: “Without fuel, there will be no
water, no functioning hospitals and bakeries. Without fuel, aid will not reach
those in desperate need. Without fuel, there will be no humanitarian assistance.
“No fuel will further strangle the children, women and people of Gaza.” The UN
estimates Gaza needs around 100 fully-laden lorries of aid each day, given the
“catastrophic” humanitarian situation. Israel imposed a “total siege” on Gaza
after the Hamas attacks and said it would not allow the transfer of supplies
from its territory until hostages seized in the assault had been freed. Joe
Biden last week persuaded Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel’s prime minister, to
instead let some supplies in via Egypt, but warned they would be halted if Hamas
tried to seize the aid. The UN’s humanitarian office said the volume of aid
entering so far was just less than a twentieth of the daily average before the
hostilities. Deprived of electricity and water, those in the southern town of
Khan Younis said they were struggling to feed their children.
“We are suffering extremely, waiting since dawn to get bread. If this continues
for two more days it will be catastrophic,” said Saleh Skafi, a father of four
from north Gaza now sheltering in Khan Younis. On Sunday, Israel’s defence
minister said that the war against Hamas could take “months” but insisted it
would be the last against the terrorist group. “It will take one month, two
months, three months, and at the end there will be no more Hamas,” Yoav Gallant
said during a visit to an air force base. “Before Hamas makes contact with our
tanks and our infantry, they will know the shells from our air force.”
He added that Israeli forces “know how to make this precise, qualitative and
mortal”. “This should be the last war in Gaza, for the simple reason that there
will be no more Hamas,” Mr Gallant said.
Death toll in Palestine rises to 4,651 with nearly 2,000
Palestinian children dead
Adam Schrader/United Press International/October 22, 2023
Israeli Defense Forces have so far killed at least 4,651 Palestinians and
wounded more than 14,245 in retaliation for the attack by Hamas that killed
about 1,400 Israelis earlier this month. The Palestinian Health Ministry said in
a statement that the dead include 1,871 children, 1,023 women and 187 elderly
people. Most of the deaths are in Palestine's Gaza, home to Hamas, though dozens
have also been reported dead in Palestine's West Bank. In addition, data
provided by the United Nations shows that Israel forces killed 227 Palestinians
this year before Hamas offensive while just 29 Israelis had been slain by
Palestinian attackers before the attack. Hamas has said the attack was made in
retaliation for Israel's multiple raids on the Al-Aqsa Mosque earlier this year
as Israelis continue to make illegal settlements on Palestinian lands in
violation of international law. The Palestine Red Crescent Society, an aid group
based in Ramallah, said in a statement that seven hospitals and 21 other health
centers in the country are out of service after being targeted by the Israeli
military. Israel has denied that it is attacking hospitals in Palestine,
claiming they are the result of "failed rocket launches" by groups including
Hamas and Islamic Jihad. According to CNN, some Palestinians in Gaza are taking
to writing the names of their children on their legs to help identify them if
they are killed. Meanwhile, the IDF has admitted to attacking the Al-Ansar
Mosque in Jenin, claiming that the holy center was used a "execute terrorist
attacks against civilians." Photos from Gaza show entire communities demolished
by Israel's ongoing blitz.
US to send more air defense systems to Mideast, ups
troop preparedness
Associated Press/October 22, 2023
U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin announced late Saturday he was sending
additional air defense systems to the Middle East as well as putting more troops
on prepare-to-deploy orders. Austin said the U.S. would be delivering a Terminal
High Altitude Area Defense, or THAAD, battery along with additional Patriot
missile defense system batteries “to locations throughout the region to increase
force protection for U.S. troops.” Bases in Iraq and Syria have been repeatedly
targeted by drones in the days since hundreds were killed in a hospital blast in
Gaza, and the destroyer USS Carney intercepted land attack cruise missiles in
the Red Sea shot from Yemen on Thursday. Austin said he had also placed
additional forces on prepare-to-deploy orders, “part of prudent contingency
planning” as the U.S. and others brace for the potential of a wider regional
conflict and as Israel prepares to launch a ground assault into Gaza. He said he
gave the orders after detailed discussions with President Joe Biden on the
recent escalations by Iran and its proxy forces across the region.
Qatar says mediation will lead to Hamas hostage releases
'very soon'
Agence France Presse/October 22, 2023
Qatar, a key power in the efforts to release hostages seized by Hamas from
Israel, believes they can be released "very soon" thanks to ongoing discussions,
a Qatari Foreign Ministry spokesman told the German Welt am Sonntag newspaper.
Doha's mediation played a key role in the release on Friday evening of two
American hostages who had been held since the Palestinian militant group's
attack against Israel on October 7, with the Gulf state adding that it was in
talks with Israel and Hamas. "I can't promise you this will happen today or
tomorrow or after tomorrow. But we are taking a path that will very soon lead to
release of the hostages, especially civilians," Majed Al-Ansari said. "We are
currently working on an agreement under which all civilian hostages will be
initially released," he added. Israel says 203 people -- Israelis, dual
nationals and foreigners -- were abducted by Hamas gunmen when they launched the
deadliest attacks in Israel's 75-year history. At least 1,400 people were
allegedly killed, mostly civilians, according to the Israeli government. Israel
has responded with a relentless bombing campaign against the Gaza Strip that has
left at least 4,385 people dead, mostly civilians, according to the Hamas
administration. Al-Ansari said that the release of the two American nationals
"proved to us and our partners that the efforts made in the past days are
feasible and must continue."The two women had been kidnapped by Hamas while
visiting the Nahal Oz kibbutz in southern Israel and were the first hostage
releases confirmed by both parties.
US-led troops in Iraq reportedly targeted by suicide drone
Agence France Presse/October 22, 2023
A suicide drone hit an airbase in Iraq hosting US troops, Iraqi security sources
said, but the Pentagon said it could not confirm that such an attack took place.
Armed factions close to Iran have threatened to attack U.S. interests in Iraq
over Washington's support for Israel since Hamas militants allegedly killed more
than 1,400 Israelis in a shock cross-border attack from Gaza on October 7.
Israel's retaliatory bombardment of Gaza has killed more than 4,300 people,
according to its Hamas-controlled health ministry. "The drone came down inside
the (Ain al-Assad) base" in the western province of Anbar, without causing any
casualties or damage, a military source told AFP on condition of anonymity. A
statement issued on Telegram channels used by pro-Iranian armed groups said the
attack was carried out by a group calling itself the Islamic Resistance in Iraq.
A second Iraqi security source told AFP the attack had involved two suicide
drones. "The first was intercepted and the second crashed because of a technical
problem," the source said. The Pentagon, however, said it was unaware of any
such attack. "We have not seen any operational reporting confirming" that an
attack occurred Saturday, a U.S. Defense Department official said on condition
of anonymity. Since Wednesday, three Iraqi bases used by U.S.-led coalition
troops have been targeted in five separate attacks -- Ain al-Assad, the Al-Harir
base in northern Iraq and a military camp near Baghdad airport. The United
States currently has about 2,500 troops stationed at the three bases, alongside
around 1,000 soldiers from other countries in the coalition set up to fight the
Islamic State jihadist group. The attacks came after factions loyal to Iran
stepped up threats against the United States. One of them, the Hezbollah
Brigades, demanded that U.S. forces "leave" Iraq, "otherwise they will taste the
fires of hell."
Israel is now fighting on 3 fronts as airstrikes and
violence escalate across the Palestinian territories, Lebanon, and Syria
Rebecca Rommen/Business Insider/October 22, 2023
Israel bombards Lebanon and Gaza in retaliatory attackScroll back up to restore
default view. Israel is now waging war on three fronts — the Palestinian
territories, Lebanon, and Syria. As the conflict spreads, the US is beefing up
its military presence in the region. US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said it
was in response to "recent escalations by Iran and its proxy forces." Following
the Palestinian militant group Hamas' attacks on Israel on October 7, Israeli
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu declared war on the group. Now, that conflict
is spilling over into the neighboring countries of Lebanon and Syria as Israel
ramps up airstrikes on the two Arab states. The US has sent more military assets
to the region to bolster Israel's forces following what US Defense Secretary
Lloyd Austin called "recent escalations by Iran and its proxy forces."
Hezbollah, a militant group backed by Iran, has been fighting Israeli forces on
Lebanon's northern border with Israel. The day after Israel declared war,
Hezbollah launched dozens of rockets on Israeli positions to support
"Palestinian resistance."Israel also targeted Damascus and Aleppo international
airports in Syria, where Iran maintains a military presence. The strikes
reportedly killed two workers. Austin told ABC News' "This Week" program: "We're
concerned about potential escalation. In fact, what we're seeing ... is a
prospect of a significant escalation of attacks on our troops and our people
throughout the region. And because of that, we're going to do what's necessary
to make sure that our troops are ... in a good position, and they're protected,
and that we have the ability to respond." Washington will also send more troops
and a Terminal High Altitude Area Defense system and additional Patriot air
defense missile system battalions to Israel, Austin also said, per Reuters.
Israel has been amassing troops and equipment near the border with Gaza ahead of
its expected ground invasion of the territory. Chief of the Israeli General
Staff Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi told troops: "We are going to go into the Gaza Strip
... to destroy Hamas operatives and Hamas infrastructure." The Palestinian death
toll in Gaza has exceeded 4,300 after Israel laid a "total siege" on the strip,
the Hamas-run Health Ministry said, The Associated Press reported. Violence has
also escalated in the West Bank, with over 90 Palestinians reported to have been
killed in the area since the start of the war.
Israel warns Gaza airstrikes will intensify and hits West
Bank ahead of war’s ‘next stage’
CNN/October 22, 2023
Israel’s military said it would increase its aerial bombardment of Gaza, and
carried out a rare airstrike in the occupied West Bank, as it signaled it was
readying for a new phase of war against Hamas. As the Israel Defense Forces (IDF)
prepares for a potential ground operation, it has amassed huge numbers of troops
outside Gaza and pounded the densely populated enclave with near-constant
airstrikes since Hamas’ deadly October 7 attack on Israel. “We will increase our
strikes, minimize the risk to our troops in the next stages of the war, and we
will intensify the strikes, starting from today,” Daniel Hagari, an IDF
spokesman, said Saturday. “We continue to destroy terror targets ahead of the
next stage of the war, and are focusing on our readiness to the next stage.”The
Biden administration has pressed Israel to delay its imminent invasion of Gaza
to allow for the release of more Hamas hostages and aid into Gaza, according to
two sources briefed on the discussions. The Friday release of two Americans held
by Hamas signaled the possible freeing of more of the around 200 believed to be
kidnapped by the militant group after its deadly attacks two week ago. Violence
has also flared in the occupied West Bank. The IDF on Sunday launched an
airstrike on the Al-Ansar mosque in the West Bank refugee camp of Jenin, which
it said was being used by militant groups to plan for “an imminent terror
attack.” It would not say whether the strike came from a jet, in what would be
the first fighter jet strike in the West Bank in nearly two decades. Lt. Col.
Jonathan Conricus, and IDF spokesman, told CNN that the military had
intelligence that “suggested there was an imminent attack coming from a joint
Hamas and Islamic Jihad squad,” which was making preparations from an
underground command center beneath the mosque. Three people were killed in the
Israeli strike, the Palestinian Ministry of Health said in a statement on
Sunday. Two people were also killed following clashes in the West Bank cities of
Toubas and Nablus, it said. Since the war erupted, Israel authorities have
placed additional restrictions on movement of Palestinians living in the West
Bank, and attacks by Israeli forces and settlers have surged. At least 90 people
have been killed in the occupied Palestinian territory since October 7,
according to the Palestinian Ministry of Health.
Ground incursion looms
In Gaza City, the IDF dropped leaflets written in Arabic that warned residents
to evacuate to the south or face the possibility of being considered “a partner
for the terrorist organization,” according to a CNN translation. In a statement,
the IDF confirmed it had dropped the flyers, but said there was “no intention to
consider those who have not evacuated from the affected area of fighting as a
member of the terrorist group.” The IDF “treats civilians as such, and does not
target them,” the statement added. Israeli war planes have been pounding Gaza,
leveling entire neighborhoods, including schools and mosques. Israel says it
strikes Hamas targets and that the group has used civilians as human shields. As
of Sunday, Israeli airstrikes have killed 4,651 people in Gaza, including
hundreds of women and children, according to the Palestinian Ministry of Health
in Gaza. More than 14,245 people have been wounded, it added.
In northern Gaza, more than 1 million residents have been told by Israel to
leave their homes and move to the south. Israel has also ordered the evacuation
of more than 20 hospitals in northern Gaza where thousands of patients are being
treated, according to the United Nations and the Palestinian Red Crescent, which
say the order could be tantamount to a death sentence. “We do not have the means
to evacuate them safely. Most of the patients are with critical injuries,” Nebal
Farsakh, a Red Crescent spokesperson, told CNN Sunday, adding that the hospitals
are under the threat of “being bombed at any second due to Israeli evacuation
orders.” The organization said on Friday that the Israeli military issued three
evacuation orders for the Al-Quds Hospital. The IDF has said it does not target
hospitals, though the UN and Doctors Without Borders say Israeli airstrikes have
hit medical facilities, including hospitals and ambulances.
Israel has offered no timeline for the possible ground offensive on Gaza, but
military officials have repeatedly told troops an incursion is imminent. The
Israeli Military Chief of Staff, Herzl Halevi, told IDF commanders Saturday that
the military will initiate an operation to “destroy” Hamas. “We’ll enter the
Gaza Strip. We’ll embark on an operational and professional task to destroy
Hamas operatives and infrastructures,” the chief said in comments to the Golani
Brigade of the IDF. The United States and its allies have urged Israel to be
strategic and clear about its goals during any ground invasion of Gaza, warning
against a prolonged occupation and placing a particular emphasis on avoiding
civilian casualties. During his visit to Israel last week, US President Joe
Biden “asked some hard questions” about Israel’s ground invasion strategy, a
senior US official told CNN, adding: “we’re not directing the Israelis, the
timeline is theirs – their thinking, their planning.” Meanwhile, the US military
is sending more missile defense systems to the Middle East and placing
additional US troops on prepare-to-deploy orders in response to escalations
throughout the region in recent days. US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin said
Saturday he had “activated the deployment of a Terminal High Altitude Area
Defense (THAAD) battery as well as additional Patriot battalions to locations
throughout the region to increase force protection for US forces.” The order for
troops to prepare for deployment is meant “to increase their readiness and
ability to quickly respond as required,” he said. Both the THAAD and Patriots
systems are air defense systems designed to shoot down short, medium and
intermediate ballistic missiles.
‘Catastrophic’ humanitarian situation
Conditions in Gaza have become increasingly dire following two weeks of
bombardment and a complete siege by Israel, which was unleashed in response to a
rampage by Hamas that killed more than 1,400 people in Israel. Hamas fighters
have also abducted about 210 people into Gaza as hostages, according to an
estimate released Saturday by the IDF. Two American hostages, a mother and her
17-year-old daughter, were released Friday. CNN has seen 15 humanitarian aid
trucks enter the border from Egypt to Gaza through the Rafah crossing on Sunday,
a day after the first convoy of 20 trucks carrying food, water, medicine and
medical supplies was allowed through following intense diplomatic efforts. The
trucks will go through additional security checks before entry into the strip, a
security official told CNN. The Egyptian Red Crescent said 17 aid trucks were
preparing to enter the strip through the Rafah crossing on Sunday. “God willing,
I am now entering the crossing, or in a few minutes. God willing, to deliver
this aid and will go in and out safely, God willing,” Ali Shousha, one of the
drivers waiting to cross into Gaza, told CNN. But aid workers and international
leaders have warned that much more is needed to combat the “catastrophic”
humanitarian situation in the enclave that is home to more than 2 million
people. WHO director general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has stressed that “the
needs are far higher” than the aid people in Gaza have received. The Ministry of
Health in Gaza said the initial aid convoy constituted “only 3% of the daily
health and humanitarian needs that used to enter the Gaza Strip before the
aggression.” From Ramallah, in the occupied West Bank, head of the
Palestinian National Initiative Mustafa Barghouti said Gaza needs “7,000 trucks
of immediate aid,” adding, “20 trucks will not really change much.”None of those
20 trucks brought fuel to the enclave, raising concerns as it is needed to run
hospitals and to desalinate or treat water, according to aid agencies. One UN
official warned on Sunday that the UN’s fuel supply in Gaza will run out in
three days. “Without fuel, there will be no water, no functioning hospitals and
bakeries,” Philippe Lazzarini, commissioner general for the United Nations
Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), said.
“Without fuel, aid will not reach many civilians in desperate need.”Citing an
acute shortage of food, water, power, and medical supplies that is pushing
civilian lives in Gaza “to the edge of catastrophe,” the UN’s World Food
Programme (WFP) said it urgently requires $74 million to sustain its emergency
response in Gaza for the next 90 days. The appeal came in a Palestinian
Territories situation report Saturday that said the coastal enclave’s stores
have food reserves of less than a week and that the ability to replenish these
stocks is “compromised by damaged roads, safety concerns, and fuel shortages.”
Three WFP trucks were part of the convoy of that moved through the Rafah
crossing into Gaza on Saturday. Another 40 WFP trucks are waiting at Al-Arish,
Egypt, to enter Gaza, the report said.
Wider conflict
As it prepares for the next stage of war, the Israeli military has warned other
regional actors against getting involved in the conflict. Conricus, the IDF
spokesperson, said Sunday the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah is “playing a
very dangerous game” that could drag Lebanon “into a war that it will gain
nothing from.” Conricus said Hezbollah has been attacking Israeli positions near
the Lebanon border, which had led to both civilian and military casualties. In
response, the IDF has used tanks, drones, artillery, and infantry to strike
various Hezbollah infrastructure, as well as Hezbollah squads manning anti-tank
missiles, he added. On Sunday, Israel’s Ministry of Defense and the IDF
announced the expansion of a state-funded evacuation plan to 14 additional
communities in northern areas near the border with Lebanon. The evacuation,
which is voluntary, was initially rolled out on Monday for 28 communities.
Around 123,000 civilians had been evacuated from their homes in northern and
southern Israel as of Friday. Meanwhile, Syrian state news agency, citing an
unnamed military source, reported that Israel had targeted airports in the
capital Damascus and the northern city of Aleppo at around 5:25 a.m. on Sunday
morning, damaging runways and putting both out of service. The agency reported
that one worker at Damascus airport was killed and another injured, and all air
traffic was being diverted to the city of Latakia.
US upping Mid East presence due to risk of attacks on
American troops, Austin says
Lauren Sforza/The Hill/October 22, 2023
Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin said Sunday that the United States is upping
its presence in the Middle East because of the risk of escalated attacks on
American troops. “What we’re seeing is a prospect of a significant escalation of
attacks on our troops and our people throughout the region,” Austin said on
ABC’s “This Week.” “And because of that, we’re going to do what’s necessary to
make sure that our troops are in that position and they were protected and that
we have the ability to respond.”He also said that upping the military presence
in the region will “send another message to those who would who would seek to
widen this conflict.” In response to potential attacks from Hezbollah in Lebanon
and from Iran, the administration has told any other groups seeking to get
involved “don’t.”“If any group or any country is looking to widen this conflict
and take advantage of this very unfortunate situation that we see. Our advice is
don’t,” he said. “We maintain the right to defend ourselves and we won’t
hesitate to take the appropriate action.”The United States announced plans to
ramp up its military presence in the Middle East as an act of deterrence amid
the ongoing fighting between Israel and the militant group Hamas on Saturday.
Austin said in the announcement that he redirected the USS Dwight D. Eisenhower
Strike Group to join the USS Gerald R. Ford Carrier Strike Group, which is
currently stationed in the Eastern Mediterranean Sea. He said in the Saturday
announcement that the U.S. will deploy the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense
battery in addition to Patriot battalions that will “increase force protection
for U.S. forces.” He also said that he ordered more troops to prepare for
deployment orders. The U.S. has vowed to back Israel in its war against militant
group Hamas, which launched an unprecedented, deadly attack on Israel on Oct. 7
that prompted Israel to declare war on the group and launch a series of
airstrikes targeting the group’s hotspots. The U.S. has designated Hamas as a
terrorist organization.
Iran warns Mideast could 'go out of control' as Israel
steps up attacks: Live updates
John Bacon, USA TODAY/October 22, 2023
The Israeli military ramped up its reach Sunday, striking targets in Syria, the
West Bank and Gaza amid growing concerns the war will spread more widely across
the Middle East. Iranian Foreign Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian warned Israel
and the U.S on Sunday that "if they do not immediately stop the crime against
humanity and genocide in Gaza, anything is possible at any moment and the region
will go out of control." The intensified military actions came as a convoy of
humanitarian aid trucks that was scheduled to make its way into Gaza from Egypt
for a second day Sunday never arrived, a U.N. aid agency said. The U.N. warned
the aid that got through on Saturday was only about 4% of the daily average of
imports into previous conflicts and a fraction of what is needed. Israel has
been pounding Gaza relentlessly since Hamas' stunning, brutal attack Oct. 7 that
killed more than 1,000 Israelis and saw the seizure of more than 200 hostages.
"Bombardments continue almost unabated as hostilities enter the 15th day in
Gaza," the U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs said in its
latest situation report. First humanitarian aid reaches Gaza: Convoy arrives
after 2 weeks of Israel-Hamas war
Developments:
∎ Thousands of pregnant women in the Gaza Strip who could give birth within
weeks are in grave danger because they are not able to reach a medical facility
to deliver, Doctors Without Borders warned. ∎ Hezbollah’s deputy leader in
Lebanon, Sheikh Naim Kassem, warned that Israel would pay a high price going
forward if it commences a much-anticipated ground offensive in Gaza. Reports
that the Rafah crossing from Egypt, which opened Saturday with the passage of 20
aid trucks, saw 17 more trucks enter Gaza on Sunday are incorrect, the U.N.
humanitarian affairs agency said.
“Until now, there is no convoy,” said Juliette Touma, spokeswoman for U.N.
agency for Palestinian refugees. The agency also said it is "imperative" to
increase the number to at least 100 trucks carrying food, water and medical
supplies per day. An Israeli blockade of Gaza has cut off food, water, medicine
and electricity since the war began.
Hamas field manual gave instructions to 'shock troops'
A Hamas field manual and other documents found in the days following the Oct. 7
attack reveal military strength of the group and provided how-to instructions on
techniques such as close-in, bloody killing, the Washington Post says. The Post
said it obtained the field manual, which was found on the body of a Hamas
fighter and lists instructions on operating weapons and identifies weaknesses in
Israeli military equipment. It also provides instructions for “shock troops” on
the best places to stab victims. The “neck in the collarbone area,” “spine” and
“underarms” are on that list, the Post says.
Israeli strikes shut down Syrian airports
Syria said it was forced to shut down international airports in Damascus and
Aleppo because of the Israeli strike. The Syrian Transport Ministry said landing
strips at both airports were damaged by missiles and one civilian worker was
killed and another wounded at Damascus International Airport. Israel has carried
out several strikes in Syria since the war began, citing the need to prevent
Hezbollah and other militant groups from bringing in arms from Iran, which also
supports Hamas. In the Israeli-occupied West Bank, Israeli forces killed at
least five people there early Sunday, according to the local Health Ministry.
Two were killed in an airstrike on a mosque in the town of Jenin, which the
Israeli military said belonged to Hamas and Islamic Jihad militants who had
carried out several attacks and were planning another one. Palestinian militants
have fired over 7,000 rockets into Israel since the war began, the Israel
Defense Force says, and tens of thousands of Israeli's have been forced to flee
their homes. Hamas says it targeted Tel Aviv early Sunday.
Housing situation dire in Gaza
The Israeli death toll has surpassed 1,400, most of the civilians killed in the
first hours of Hamas' bloody attack on border villages. At least 212 people were
taken hostage; two Americans were released Friday in what Hamas described as a
humanitarian gesture. The Gaza Health Ministry put the Palestinian death toll at
4,385; almost two-thirds of the fatalities are children and women. More than
1,000 people have been reported missing and are feared trapped or dead under the
rubble. Israel repeated its calls Sunday for Palestinians to leave northern
Gaza. Israeli authorities say an estimated 700,000 have already fled, but
hundreds of thousands remain. Fleeing to southern Gaza has provided little
relief as Israeli airstrikes there have also battered cities and infrastructure.
Gaza's Housing Ministry says more than 160,000 homes and apartments − more than
40% of all dwellings − in Gaza have been damaged or destroyed since the war
began two weeks ago. The result is that about 1.4 million of Gaza's 2.3 million
people have been "internally displaced," and 566,000 of them are staying in U.N.
emergency shelters, the U.N. says.
What is Hamas?
Hamas – an acronym for Harakat al-Muqawama al-Islamiya, or the Islamic
resistance movement – was founded in 1987 by activists connected to the Muslim
Brotherhood during the first Palestinian uprising against Israeli occupation of
Gaza and the West Bank. The State Department designated Hamas a terrorist group
in 1997, and several other nations also consider Hamas a terrorist organization.
In 2006, Hamas won parliamentary elections, and in 2007 the group violently
seized control of Gaza from the Palestinian Authority, which was controlled by
the rival Fatah movement that still governs the West Bank. There have been no
elections since. The group calls for the establishment of an Islamic Palestinian
state that would replace the current state of Israel and believes in the use of
violence to carry out the destruction of Israel. Hamas receives financial,
material, and logistical support from Iran. So far, however, the U.S. and other
nations have said there is no evidence that Iran was directly involved in Hamas’
attack.
US advises citizens not to travel to Iraq after recent
attacks on US personnel
Kanishka Singh/WASHINGTON (Reuters)/October 22, 2023
The U.S. State Department said on Sunday U.S. citizens should not travel to Iraq
after recent attacks on American troops and personnel in the region. The travel
advisory says, "Do not travel to Iraq due to terrorism, kidnapping, armed
conflict, civil unrest, and Mission Iraq’s limited capacity to provide support
to U.S. citizens."There has been a spike in attacks against U.S. forces in Iraq
and Syria since the conflict between Israel and Hamas militants in Gaza broke
out. Last week, a U.S. warship shot down more than a dozen drones and four
cruise missiles fired by Iranian-backed Houthis from Yemen. The advisory
followed the ordered departure of eligible family members and non-emergency U.S.
government personnel from U.S. Embassy Baghdad and U.S. Consulate General Erbil
"due to increased security threats against U.S. personnel and interests," the
State Department said in a statement. The statement added that anti-U.S.
militias "threaten U.S. citizens and international companies" throughout Iraq.
Earlier on Sunday, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Defense Secretary
Lloyd Austin said they saw the prospect of a significant escalation in attacks
on American troops in the Middle East and of Iran seeking to widen the Israel-Hamas
war. Washington is on heightened alert for activity by Iran-backed groups as
regional tensions soar during the Israel-Hamas war, which began after
Palestinian Islamist group Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7, killing over 1,400
people. Israel has since retaliated with deadly air strikes on Gaza, a 45
km-long (25-mile) strip of land that is part of the Israeli-occupied Palestinian
territories and home to 2.3 million people that has been ruled politically since
2007 by Hamas. Israel's air strikes have killed over 4,700 people, Palestinian
officials say. "Because of security concerns, U.S. government personnel in
Baghdad are instructed not to use Baghdad International Airport," the State
Department said on Sunday. The United States has sent a significant amount of
naval power to the Middle East in recent weeks, including two aircraft carriers,
their support ships and about 2,000 Marines. The U.S. will send a Terminal High
Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) system and additional Patriot air defense missile
system battalions to the Middle East, the Pentagon said on Saturday.
Egypt's border crossing opens to let a trickle of
desperately needed aid into besieged Gaza
RAFAH, Gaza Strip (AP)/October 22, 2023
The border crossing between Egypt and Gaza opened Saturday to let a trickle of
desperately needed aid into the besieged Palestinian territory for the first
time since Israel sealed it off and began pounding it with airstrikes following
Hamas' bloody rampage two weeks ago. Just 20 trucks were allowed in, an amount
aid workers said was insufficient to address the unprecedented humanitarian
crisis. More than 200 trucks carrying 3,000 tons of aid have been waiting nearby
for days. Gaza's 2.3 million Palestinians, half of whom have fled their homes,
are rationing food and drinking dirty water. Hospitals say they are running low
on medical supplies and fuel for emergency generators amid a territory-wide
power blackout. Five hospitals have stopped functioning because of fuel
shortages and bombing damage, the Hamas-run Health Ministry said. Doctors
reported using sewing needles to stitch wounds, and using vinegar as a
disinfectant until the shops ran out. With anesthesia running low, the screams
of patients could be heard during surgery. Doctors Without Borders said Gaza’s
health care system is “facing collapse.” Meantime, Gaza’s Hamas-run Interior
Ministry reported heavy Israeli airstrikes across the territory overnight into
Sunday, including southern areas where Israel had told Palestinians to seek
refuge. The ministry said that among the sites hit were homes and a cafe in the
evacuation zone where dozens of displaced residents had sought shelter.
Israel’s military has said it is striking Hamas members and installations, but
does not target civilians. In a statement posted early Sunday on X, the site
formerly known as Twitter, the Israeli military said it had launched a strike on
the Al-Ansar mosque at the Jenin refugee camp in the occupied West Bank.
There are growing expectations of a ground offensive that Israel says would be
aimed at rooting out Hamas. Israel said Friday that it doesn't plan to take
long-term control over the small but densely populated Palestinian territory.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu convened his Cabinet late Saturday to
discuss the expected invasion, Israeli media reported.
Israel’s military spokesman, Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, said the country planned
to step up its airstrikes starting Saturday as preparation for the next stage of
the war.
“We will deepen our attacks to minimize the dangers to our forces in the next
stages of the war. We are going to increase the attacks, from today,” Hagari
said, repeating his call for Gaza City residents to head south for their safety.
Israel has vowed to crush Hamas but has given few details about what it
envisions for Gaza if it succeeds. Yifat Shasha-Biton, a Cabinet minister, said
there was broad consensus in the government that there will have to be a “buffer
zone” in Gaza to keep Palestinians away from the border. “We need to create a
distance between the border and our communities,” she told Channel 13 TV, adding
that no decisions had been made on its size or other specifics. Tensions have
risen in the West Bank, where dozens of Palestinians have been killed in clashes
with Israeli troops, arrest raids and attacks by Jewish settlers. Israeli forces
have held the West Bank under a tight grip, closing crossings into the territory
and checkpoints between cities, measures they say are aimed at preventing
attacks. The opening of Rafah came after more than a week of high-level
diplomacy, including visits to the region by U.S. President Joe Biden and U.N.
Secretary-General Antonio Guterres. Israel had insisted nothing would enter Gaza
until Hamas released all the captives from its Oct. 7 attack on towns in
southern Israel. Late Friday, Hamas freed its first captives — an American woman
and her teenage daughter. It was not immediately clear if there was a connection
between the release and the aid deliveries. Israel says Hamas is still holding
at least 210 hostages, though their conditions — and if they are even alive —
remains unknown. On Saturday morning, an Associated Press reporter saw the 20
trucks heading north from Rafah to Deir al-Balah, a quiet farming town where
many evacuees from the north have sought shelter. Hundreds of foreign passport
holders at Rafah hoping to escape the conflict were not allowed to leave.
American citizen Dina al- Khatib said she and her family were desperate to get
out. “It’s not like previous wars,” she said. “There is no electricity, no
water, no internet, nothing.” The trucks carried 44,000 bottles of drinking
water — enough for 22,000 people for a single day, according to UNICEF. “This
first, limited water will save lives, but the needs are immediate and immense,”
said UNICEF Executive Director Catherine Russell. The World Health Organization
said four of the trucks were carrying medical supplies, including trauma
medicine and portable trauma bags for first responders. “We need many, many,
many more trucks and a continual flow of aid," said, the head of the U.N.’s
World Food Program, Cindy McCain. Gaza's Hamas-run government called for a
secure corridor operating around the clock. Hagari, the Israeli military
spokesman, said “the humanitarian situation in Gaza is under control.” He said
the aid would be delivered only to southern Gaza, where the army has ordered
people to relocate, adding that no fuel would enter. Biden said the United
States “remains committed to ensuring that civilians in Gaza will continue to
have access to food, water, medical care, and other assistance, without
diversion by Hamas.”The U.S. government would work to keep Rafah open and let
U.S. citizens leave Gaza, he said in a statement. U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd
Austin said late Saturday he was sending additional air defense systems to the
Middle East and putting more troops on "prepare to deploy" orders. Guterres
emphasized international concern over civilians in Gaza, telling a summit in
Cairo that Hamas’ “reprehensible assault” on Israel “can never justify the
collective punishment of the Palestinian people.”Two Egyptian officials and a
European diplomat said extensive negotiations with Israel and the U.N. to allow
fuel deliveries for hospitals had yielded little progress. They spoke on
condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to release information
on the sensitive deliberations.
One Egyptian official said they were discussing the release of dual-national
hostages in return for fuel, but that Israel was insisting on the release of all
hostages.
The release of Judith Raanan and her 17-year-old daughter, Natalie, on Friday
brought some hope to the families of others believed held hostage.
Rachel Goldberg, whose son is thought to have been badly wounded before he was
taken hostage, said she was “very relieved” by the news but urged quick work to
save others, including her son. “I think he could be dying," she said. "So we
don’t have time.”
Hamas said it was working with Egypt, Qatar and other mediators “to close the
case” of hostages if security circumstances permit. Israel has also traded fire
along its northern border with Lebanon’s Hezbollah militants, raising concerns
about a second front opening up. The Israeli military said Saturday it struck
Hezbollah targets in Lebanon in response to recent rocket launches and attacks
with anti-tank missiles. “Hezbollah has decided to participate in the fighting,
and we are exacting a heavy price for this,” Israeli Defense Minister Yoav
Gallant said during a visit to the border. Hezbollah said six of its fighters
were killed Saturday, and the group’s deputy leader, Sheikh Naim Kassem, warned
that Israel would pay a high price if it starts a ground offensive in the Gaza
Strip. Israel ordered its citizens to leave Egypt and Jordan — which made peace
with it decades ago — and to avoid travel to a number of Arab and Muslim
countries, including the United Arab Emirates, Morocco and Bahrain, which forged
diplomalarge demonstrationstic ties with Israel in 2020. Protests against
Israel's actions in Gaza have erupted across the region, and large
demonstrations were held Saturday in several European and U.S. cities.
An Israeli ground assault would likely lead to a dramatic escalation in
casualties on both sides in urban fighting. More than 1,400 people in Israel
have been killed in the war — mostly civilians slain during the Hamas attack.
More than 4,300 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run
Health Ministry. That includes the disputed toll from a hospital explosion.
At the summit Saturday, Egypt President Abdel Fattah el-Sissi called for
ensuring aid to Gaza, negotiating a cease-fire and resuming Israeli-Palestinian
peace talks, which broke down more than a decade ago. He also said the conflict
would never be resolved “at the expense of Egypt,” referring to fears Israel may
try to push Gaza’s population into the Sinai Peninsula. King Abdullah II of
Jordan said Israel's attacks on Gaza were “a war crime” and slammed the
international community's response. “Anywhere else, attacking civilian
infrastructure and deliberately starving an entire population of food, water,
electricity, and basic necessities would be condemned,” he said. Over a million
people have been displaced in Gaza. Many heeded Israel’s orders to evacuate from
north to south within the sealed-off coastal enclave. But Israel has continued
to bomb areas in southern Gaza . A senior Israeli military official said the air
force will not hit the area where aid is being distributed unless rockets, which
militants are relentlessly launching at Israel, are fired from there. “It’s a
safe zone,” said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity in order to
reveal military information.
Russian casualties soar by 90% as Putin's generals order furious attacks on
small city in east, UK intelligence says
Alia Shoaib/ Business Insider/Sun, October 22, 2023
Anti-Putin Russian fighters claim latest attack in southern RussiaScroll back up
to restore default view. Russia has been carrying out offensive operations in
the area of Avdiivka in eastern Ukraine. The assaults have contributed to a 90%
increase in Russian casualties, the UK MoD said. Russia has gained marginal
ground but suffered high personnel and weaponry losses in the area. Russian
offensive military campaigns in eastern Ukraine have been partly behind a 90%
increase in Russian casualties recorded by Ukraine, according to an intelligence
update from the UK Ministry of Defence.
Russia has been carrying out offensive operations in the area of Avdiivka, a
small city just to the north of Donetsk. The moves have been largely
unsuccessful so far, with Russia gaining marginal ground but suffering high
losses to its personnel and weaponry.
Much of the fighting in Ukraine is now in the south and east of the country,
where Ukrainian forces are conducting counteroffensive operations to take back
territory occupied by Russia. The US think tank the Institute for the Study of
War previously said that "Russian forces likely intend attacks in the Avdiivka
area to fix Ukrainian forces and prevent them from redeploying to other areas of
the front."But "Ukrainian officials have already identified the Avdiivka push as
a Russian fixing operation, and they are unlikely to unduly commit Ukrainian
manpower to this axis," the think tank added.
Russia is able to commit to such costly attacks as it has ramped up recruitment
over the course of the war by utilizing "financial incentives" and its partial
mobilization last year, the UK MoD also said in its update. "This increase of
personnel is the major factor behind Russia's ability to both defend held
territory and conduct costly assaults," it said. It added that it was likely
Russian forces had taken around 150,000-190,000 "permanent casualties" — those
killed and permanently wounded — since Putin's full-scale invasion began in
February 2022. Those figures do not include the mercenary Wagner Group, which
was headed by Yevgeny Prigozhin until he reportedly died in a plane crash in
August, or their prisoner battalions who fought in Bakhmut.
US pushes UN to back Israel self-defense, demand Iran stop arms to Hamas
Michelle Nichols/UNITED NATIONS (Reuters)/October 22, 2023
The United States proposed on Saturday a draft U.N. Security Council resolution
that says Israel has a right to defend itself and demands Iran stop exporting
arms to "militias and terrorist groups threatening peace and security across the
region."
The draft text, seen by Reuters, calls for the protection of civilians -
including those who are trying to get to safety - notes that states must comply
with international law when responding to "terrorist attacks", and urges the
"continuous, sufficient and unhindered" delivery of aid to the Gaza Strip. It
was not immediately clear if or when the United States planned to put the draft
resolution to a vote. To pass, a resolution needs at least nine votes in favor
and no vetoes by Russia, China, the United States, France or Britain.
The move by the United States comes after it vetoed a Brazilian-drafted text on
Wednesday that would have called for humanitarian pauses in the conflict between
Israel and Palestinian Hamas militants, to allow aid access to Gaza. U.S.
Ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield justified Wednesday's veto by telling the
council more time was needed for diplomacy on the ground as President Joe Biden
and Secretary of State Antony Blinken visited the region, focused on brokering
aid access to Gaza and trying to free hostages held by Hamas. Hamas released two
American hostages on Friday and the first humanitarian aid convoy arrived in
Gaza from Egypt on Saturday.
Israel has vowed to wipe out the Hamas Islamist group that rules Gaza, after its
gunmen burst through the barrier fence surrounding the enclave on Oct. 7 and
rampaged through Israeli towns and kibbutzes, killing 1,400 people. Israel has
since pounded Gaza from the air, imposed a siege and is preparing for a ground
offensive. Palestinian authorities say more than 4,000 people have been killed
in the enclave. The U.N. says more than a million have been made homeless. The
U.S. draft text does not call for any pause or truce in the fighting. It calls
on all states to try and stop the "violence in Gaza from spilling over or
expanding to other areas in the region, including by demanding the immediate
cessation by Hezbollah and other armed-groups of all attacks."
Lebanon's Iran-backed, heavily armed Hezbollah group has clashed with Israel
across the Lebanese border multiple times since Oct. 7 in the deadliest
confrontations since they fought a month-long war in 2006.
SELF-DEFENSE
The U.S. draft resolution demands Iran stop exporting arms to groups threatening
peace and security across the region, including Hamas. Iran's mission to the
U.N. in New York did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Iran has
made no secret of its backing for Hamas, funding and arming the group and
another Palestinian militant organisation Islamic Jihad. Iran's mission to the
U.N. said on Oct. 8 that Tehran was not involved in the Hamas attack on Israel a
day earlier. Thomas-Greenfield said on Wednesday that the U.S. was disappointed
the Brazilian draft did not mention Israel's right to self defense. The U.S.
text states that Israel has such a right under Article 51 of the founding U.N.
Charter. Article 51 covers the individual or collective right of states to self-defense
against armed attack and states must immediately inform the 15-member Security
Council of any action that states take in self-defense against armed attack.
In a letter sent the same day as the Hamas attack, Israel told the council it
would "act in any way necessary to protect its citizens and sovereignty from the
ongoing terrorist attacks originating from the Gaza Strip." But it does not
appear to have formally invoked Article 51, diplomats said. Arab countries have
argued that Israel cannot justify its actions as self-defense. "The Gaza Strip
is an occupied territory," Jordan's U.N. Ambassador Mahmoud Daifallah Hmoud told
the council on Monday, citing a 2004 opinion by the International Court of
Justice on an Israeli separation barrier built around the West Bank.
"We recall the advisory opinion of the ICJ ... according to which Israel does
not have the right to defend itself within occupied Palestinian territory," he
said, speaking on behalf of the Arab group. Israel said in 2004 that the barrier
was meant to keep suicide bombers out of its cities. The ICJ said Israel
"states, the threat which it regards as justifying the construction of the wall
originates within, and not outside, that territory."
"Consequently, the Court concludes that Article 51 of the Charter has no
relevance in this case," it ruled. Israel rejected the ICJ ruling.
Thousands protest in Paris, demand 'an end to the
massacre in Gaza'
LBCI/October 22, 2023
Around 15,000 people marched in Paris on Sunday to demand an end to Israeli
military operations in Gaza, following a call from a coalition that includes
various left-wing organizations. Protesters chanted slogans such as "Israel is a
killer, President Emmanuel Macron is complicit" and "No peace without ending the
settlements."
Cairo Peace Summit: Arab and Western clashing perspectives
LBCI/October 22, 2023
A significant difference in perspective between the Arab and Western nations
became obvious during the Cairo Peace Summit. The Arab view of the scale of the
Israeli attack on Gaza and the resulting humanitarian tragedy due to the
blockade imposed on Gaza was met with a Western perspective focused on what
Hamas had done in the Gaza Strip settlements. The Arab nations were inclined
towards issuing a strong statement condemning Israel for its massacres. At the
same time, some Western countries leaned towards a statement condemning Hamas
while rejecting calls for an immediate ceasefire.
However, they were willing to accept conditions for aid delivery through the
Rafah crossing. Most Western nations participating were not initially willing to
issue any statement, regardless of its wording. Qatar, whose Emir left the
summit before its conclusion, attended it out of respect for the participants
and did not intend to deliver a speech. On the other hand, Egypt attempted to
find a relatively balanced formula but failed. This can be interpreted through
the Egyptian presidential statement issued after the summit, which spoke of a
defect in international values. Furthermore, it criticized the rush and
competition to kill innocents in one place and an incomprehensible hesitation to
condemn the same act in another place, according to the statement. The vague
title "Cairo Peace Summit" indicates that even discussing a ceasefire was
unacceptable to the West. It is more likely that Egypt and Jordan, concerned
about any international attempts to relocate part of the Palestinians to their
territories, wanted to host a summit, even if it resulted in no significant
outcomes. This was in the hope that their concerns would find some Western
understanding, dispelling some of their fears that a solution might come at
their expense.
UNRWA announces death of 29 of its employees in Gaza
LBCI/October 22, 2023
Since the beginning of the war between Israel and Hamas Movement, 29 employees
of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees (UNRWA)
in Gaza have been killed. The agency also expressed its shock and mourning
through its account on the X platform.
Detroit synagogue president found stabbed to death outside home
ABC News/Sat, October 22, 2023
The president of a Detroit synagogue was found stabbed to death outside her home
Saturday morning, police and the synagogue said. The Isaac Agree Downtown
Synagogue put out a statement later in the afternoon identifying the victim as
board president Samantha Woll. Detroit police responded to a 911 call of an
unresponsive person around 6:30 a.m. and found a body outside a home on Joliet
Place. The woman, who was not immediately identified by investigators had
suffered multiple stab wounds, police said.
"At this point, we do not have more information, but will share more when it
becomes available. May her memory be a blessing," the synagogue said in a
Facebook post.
The police did not have any information on a possible motive behind the killing,
which is being investigated as a homicide. "Police officers observed a trail of
blood leading officers to the victim’s residence, which is where the crime is
believed to have occurred," the police said in a statement.
The investigation is ongoing.
A law enforcement official briefed on the probe told ABC News that the
preliminary investigation has revealed there was likely no forced entry to
Woll’s home.
All possible motives are being investigated and nothing has been ruled out at
this point, according to the official. Woll's death comes as law enforcement
agencies across the country are warning of increased anti-Semitic threats in
light of the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict. Detroit Police Department Chief
James E. White urged the public not to draw any conclusions until more facts
were gathered. "Understandably, this crime leaves many unanswered questions.
This matter is under investigation, and I am asking that everyone remain patient
while investigators carefully examine every aspect of the available evidence,"
he said in a statement. Woll had a long career in local politics and worked with
several elected officials over the years, according to her LinkedIn page.
She recently served as the political director for Michigan Attorney General Dana
Nessel's re-election campaign. Nessel released a statement on X, formerly known
as Twitter, expressing shock at Woll's murder. "Sam was as kind a person as I’ve
ever known. She was driven by her sincere love of her community, state and
country. Sam truly used her faith and activism to create a better place for
everyone," Nessel said in her post which included a photo of Woll. MORE: Law
enforcement 'very concerned' about 'lone wolf' threat against Jewish communities
after Hamas attack: Mayorkas
Woll also worked as a deputy district director for U.S. Rep. Elissa Slotkin, D-Mich.,
who also released a statement on X following her death. "She did for our team as
Deputy District Director what came so naturally to her: helping others & serving
constituents. Separately, in politics & in the Jewish community, she dedicated
her short life to building understanding across faiths, bringing light in the
face of darkness," Slotkin said.
Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer said the state police will be assisting the
Detroit Police department in the investigation.
"My heart breaks for her family, her friends, her synagogue, and all those who
were lucky enough to know her. She was a source of light, a beacon in her
community who worked hard to make Michigan a better place," she said in a
statement. Other Michigan elected officials also expressed their condolences.
"Decades ago, I shared a day of joy with Sam at the dedication of the newly
renovated Downtown Synagogue. It was a project she successfully led with great
pride and enthusiasm. Sam’s loss has left a huge hole in the Detroit community,"
Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan said in a statement to ABC affiliate WXYZ. Anyone with
information is urged to call the Detroit Police's Homicide section at
313-596-2260.
Iran to host Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process talks amid
Middle East tensions
DUBAI/MOSCOW (Reuters)/October 22, 2023
Foreign ministers from Iran, Turkey and Russia will meet their counterparts from
Azerbaijan and Armenia in Tehran on Monday and discuss progress towards a peace
agreement between the two South Caucasus neighbours, Iranian and Russian state
media said. The first meeting of foreign ministers of Russia, Armenia and
Azerbaijan after the September lightning offensive by Azeri forces in
Nagorno-Karabakh will also take place amid rising tensions in the Middle East.
IRNA news agency quoted the foreign ministry as saying the countries wanted to
talk about regional issues "without the interference of non-regional and Western
countries". That was an implicit reference to the United States and the European
Union, whose involvement in the search for a peace agreement between Armenia and
Azerbaijan has particularly annoyed Moscow. Russia's Interfax news agency said
Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov would travel to Tehran for the meeting. Since
launching its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Moscow has sought
to firm up military and diplomatic ties with countries outside the traditional
West. Lavrov has met his Iranian counterpart several times since. Russia regards
itself as the security guarantor between Azerbaijan and Armenia, but the demands
and distractions of its war in Ukraine have led to a weakening of its influence.
Azerbaijan last month staged a lightning offensive to regain control of the
region of Nagorno-Karabakh where ethnic Armenians had enjoyed de facto
independence since breaking away in the 1990s.
More than 100,000 ethnic Armenians were forced to flee and Armenia has accused
Azerbaijan of carrying out ethnic cleansing - a claim Azerbaijan denies, saying
people were free to stay and be integrated into Azerbaijan. The two countries
have fought two wars in the past three decades and have so far failed to reach a
peace deal despite long-running efforts by the United States, EU and Russia. The
so-called 3+3 South Caucasus Platform, which first held talks in 2021, were to
include also Georgia, but Georgia has stated previously it did not plan to
participate in the initiative and said on Sunday it will not be coming to
Teheran.
Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from
miscellaneous sources published on October 22-23/2023
Palestine: A Cause or a State?
Amir Taheri/Asharq Al-Awsat /October 22, 2023
Why did Hamas trigger its attack out of the blue? Hamas apologists repeat the
usual shibboleths: occupation, colonial settlements, expulsions, Apartheid, the
two-state solution.
A closer look, however, shows that none of those "reasons" could explain, let
alone justify, why Hamas did what it did on October 7.
The [Palestinian Authority] and Hamas have preferred to pose as guardians of the
flame rather than builders of state structures.... For a brief period,
2007-2013, the PA under Prime Minister Salam Fayyad tried to promote the
state-building culture as opposed to the chest-beating posture of "the cause".
But both Hamas and the PA did all they could to derail Fayyad's project.
The "Gaza first" scheme exposed the concept of "security through evacuation" as
a dangerous myth that replaced another myth: land-for-peace, which has offered
what amounts to lukewarm and always reversible peace.
All along, Israeli leaders tried to jump through one hoop after another to avoid
seriously dealing with the "two-state" formula, which the United States and its
Western allies promoted regardless of its lack of support among Israelis and
Palestinians.
[T]he "Palestinian cause" [is] used, and abused, as a means of legitimizing
regimes as diverse as the Islamic Republic of Iran; the AKP in Turkey and,
believe it or not, the leftist outfit in Colombia. And that not to mention
"return ticket revolutionaries" in the West who draw voyeuristic pleasure from
watching others kill and die for "great causes."
Throughout the Cold War, ignoring the geopolitical dimension of the
Israel-Palestine issue encouraged wild-goose diplomatic chasings most
notoriously symbolized by the "two-state" formula. Today, the same error is
repeated by focusing almost exclusively on Hamas without asking who is funding,
training, arming and manipulating Hamas in the name of "clash of civilizations".
The current tragedy has shattered the status quo that took shape in the
aftermath of the Cold War. Attempts at reviving it in one form or another would
only provide a prelude to even bigger tragedies.
Pictured: Hamas terrorists who were killed on the way to murder Israelis, near
the city of Sderot, Israel on October 8, 2023. (Photo by Jack Guez/AFP via Getty
Images)
Why did Hamas trigger the current tragedy that has given the old
Israel-Palestine conflict an even deadlier dimension? And what are the chances
for shooing the two sides away from the edge of the abyss?
The tsunami of comments on the latest episode shows that the Israel-Palestine
conflict remains a template on which advocates of rival ideologies project their
fantasies and prejudices. Why did Hamas trigger its attack out of the blue?
Hamas apologists repeat the usual shibboleths: occupation, colonial settlements,
expulsions, Apartheid, the two-state solution. A closer look, however, shows
that none of those "reasons" could explain, let alone justify, why Hamas did
what it did on October 7.
The occupation claim is out because Israeli occupation of Gaza ended in 2005,
and since 2007 Hamas has been in full control of the enclave and what is
presented as its government. The colonial settlements claim is equally
inapplicable here because the last Israeli settlements in Gaza were dismantled
in 2005 prior to full withdrawal.
The expulsion claim is even more outlandish. Between 2005 and the latest Hamas
attack the only expulsions that happened in Gaza concerned Bedouin tribes kicked
out of their villages and grazing areas for their flocks by Hamas gunmen. An
estimated 20,000 Bedouins have been expelled to Egypt and Israel, the latest
being inhabitants of villages in the Om Nasser area.
The Apartheid claim is even less credible only if because there is not a single
Israeli living in Gaza to practice it against other inhabitants. The claim that
Hamas is fighting for a two-state solution is also untrue, as the militant
organization has consistently opposed it. Hamas has never hidden its hope of
imposing a one-state solution which means the elimination of Israel in any shape
or form. People like Josep Borrel, the European Union's foreign policy
spokesman, and Jean-Luc Mélenchon, the leader of the French leftist coalition,
try to drown the fish by implying that although none of those "reasons" concerns
Hamas, we must assume that it is fighting on behalf of all Palestinians
including those in the West Bank.
But that means bestowing on Hamas a mandate it has never received from the
Palestinians while casting doubt on the legitimacy of the Palestinian Authority
(PA) which is recognized by all Arab and Islamic states and the United Nations.
In the only more or less credible election held among Palestinians, Hamas won
44.2 percent of the votes to PA's 42.5 percent. Even then it was Hamas who
withdrew from the scheme and expelled Fatah and other pro-PA groups from Gaza.
In the past few days, the traditional media and the cyberspace have been
presenting the "two-state" scheme as the magic formula that could close this
100-year saga. That, however, is no more than an attempt to fig-leaf the
nakedness of pundits and policymakers. We don't know whether or not a majority
of Israelis and Palestinians think about that fig-leaf. But what is certain is
that the leadership elites on both sides have never seriously committed to a
roadmap in that direction.
The PA and Hamas have preferred to pose as guardians of the flame rather than
builders of state structures, Hamas in a straightforward and honest way and PA
with a forked tongue. For a brief period, 2007-2013, the PA under Prime Minister
Salam Fayyad tried to promote the state-building culture as opposed to the
chest-beating posture of "the cause". But both Hamas and the PA did all they
could to derail Fayyad's project.
The PA's latest position on the two-state formula includes the return to 1949
ceasefire lines, something that no Israeli leader could accept.
Israeli leaders have been equally evasive, if not downright deceptive, on the
"two-state" formula. Even before it became a diplomatic cliché, Israel tried to
give a nod to Palestinian self-rule with the Yigal Allon plan that offered
Palestinians a Bantustan-style administration. Ariel Sharon's "Gaza first"
scheme was presented as the first step towards a two-state solution. Sharon,
however; saw a semi-independent Gaza in military terms as a glacis, not
realizing that a glacis could also morph into a base for aggression.
The "Gaza first" scheme exposed the concept of "security through evacuation" as
a dangerous myth that replaced another myth: land-for-peace, which has offered
what amounts to lukewarm and always reversible peace.
Israeli leaders always tried to drive a wedge between Gaza and the West Bank.
They encouraged, not to say actually promoted, the creation of Hamas as the
Palestinian branch of the Muslim Brotherhood, to undermine not only Fatah but
also the grass-root Palestinian leadership represented by people like Haidar
Abdul-Shafi that emerged in the aftermath of the Madrid Peace Conference. But
when Hamas proved disappointing and the Madrid negotiators not easily
controllable, Israel put their chips on Yasser Arafat with the Oslo Accords. All
along, Israeli leaders tried to jump through one hoop after another to avoid
seriously dealing with the "two-state" formula which the United States and its
Western allies promoted regardless of its lack of support among Israelis and
Palestinians.
The Israel-Palestine conflict started as a clash of Arab nationalism and
Zionism, both modeled on 19th century European nationalistic movements. After
the Second World War the clash assumed a geo-political dimension that was
intensified in the Cold War.
With the end of the Cold War that geopolitical dimension has assumed an
ideological varnish with the "Palestinian cause" used, and abused, as a means of
legitimizing regimes as diverse as the Islamic Republic of Iran; the AKP in
Turkey and, believe it or not, the leftist outfit in Colombia. And that not to
mention "return ticket revolutionaries" in the West who draw voyeuristic
pleasure from watching others kill and die for "great causes."
Throughout the Cold War, ignoring the geopolitical dimension of the
Israel-Palestine issue encouraged wild-goose diplomatic chasings most
notoriously symbolized by the "two-state" formula. Today, the same error is
repeated by focusing almost exclusively on Hamas without asking who is funding,
training, arming and manipulating Hamas in the name of "clash of civilizations".
The current tragedy has shattered the status quo that took shape in the
aftermath of the Cold War. Attempts at reviving it in one form or another would
only provide a prelude to even bigger tragedies.
*Amir Taheri was the executive editor-in-chief of the daily Kayhan in Iran from
1972 to 1979. He has worked at or written for innumerable publications,
published eleven books, and has been a columnist for Asharq Al-Awsat since 1987.
He is the Chairman of Gatestone Europe.
China's Proxy Wars Are 'Encircling' America
Gordon G. Chang/Gatestone Institute./October 22, 2023
What is the Communist Party of China up to?
Xi Jinping, who reveres Mao Zedong, is taking a page from his hero's "peasant
revolution" playbook. Mao in 1949 prevailed over his enemy, Chiang Kai-shek's
Nationalist government, by "encircling the cities from the countryside."
Ukraine, North Africa, and Israel, as Beijing sees it, are parts of the
"countryside" today. So, what is the "city"?
The main enemy of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is the United States of
America.
[T]he Party believes it must destroy the U.S. because of what America stands
for. An insecure ruling organization in Beijing is worried about the
inspirational impact of America's form of governance and values on the oppressed
Chinese people. This means the United States will never have amicable relations
with China as long as the Communist Party rules it.
Today... the Communist Party is waging proxy wars against America, such as
Russia's campaign to annex Ukraine.... Splitting off Europe from America, in
turn, would be another step in starving the U.S. Similarly, China is buying
friends in, among other places, Latin America, the Caribbean and the Pacific
Ocean as a means of further isolating America.
President Joe Biden is either unwilling or unable to defend the world from
malicious Chinese communism. The catastrophic withdrawal from Afghanistan....
signaled that American policy was in collapse.
China's leader will continue to attack... especially as Biden pays what are
essentially ransoms and thereby provides incentives for further disorder. The
ransoms include the unfreezing of $6 billion in connection with a hostage swap
with Iran... and the October 18th announcement of "humanitarian assistance" to
Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank, apparently to free Americans held by
Hamas.
Allowing China, Russia and friends to take over areas is a critical — and
probably fatal — mistake. Victories, for one thing, create momentum and the
appearance of inevitability. Xi Jinping promotes the notion of the inevitability
of Chinese rule as he tries to intimidate others into submission. China's
successes just embolden the regime to press attacks.
How, then, does the United States confront China's proxy-war strategy?
Washington can turn the tables on Xi by taking down Chinese proxies, thereby
isolating Beijing and creating the appearance of Chinese failure.
Communist China is already overstretched. The primary driver of its four-decade
rise, the economy, is in distress. The property sector accounting for at least a
quarter of gross domestic product, is crumbling. Money is fleeing the country.
GDP is growing nowhere near the 5.2% claimed for the first three quarters of
this year—if it is growing at all. Imports, perhaps the best indicator of
domestic demand, have now fallen for 12 straight months on a year-to-year basis.
[A]fter three decades of particularly naïve, indulgent, feeble, and otherwise
misguided policy, Washington has no good options. The worst option of all is to
continue policies that have created this disastrous situation.
America and the free world are running out of time.
America... is about to lose everything.
The Chinese Communist Party believes it must destroy the U.S. because of what
America stands for. Today. the CCP is waging proxy wars against America.
Allowing China, Russia, and friends to take over areas is a critical—and
probably fatal—mistake. Pictured: Chinese President Xi Jinping speaks to the
Politburo Standing Committee at the 20th CCP Congress on October 23, 2022 in
Beijing, China. (Photo by Lintao Zhang/Getty Images)
China is setting fires.
Chinese President Xi Jinping green-lighted Russia's invasion of Ukraine and is
supporting that war with lethal and other assistance. In North Africa, Beijing,
in conjunction with Moscow, has been fueling insurgencies that resemble wars. In
the Middle East, China is backing Hamas's monstrous attacks on Israel.
Hamas fighters, for instance, appear to have Chinese-made weapons, presumably
supplied through Iran. Moreover, the U.S. Navy in 2021 and this year seized
Chinese weapons in transit to another proxy of the Islamic Republic, the Houthi
militia in Yemen.
"Tehran for some time has distributed Chinese weapons to its terrorist proxies
throughout the region," Jonathan Bass of energy consultant InfraGlobal tells
Gatestone. "The Middle East, thanks in no small measure to Beijing, is soaked
with blood."
What is the Communist Party of China up to?
Xi, who reveres Mao Zedong, is taking a page from his hero's "peasant
revolution" playbook. Mao in 1949 prevailed over his enemy, Chiang Kai-shek's
Nationalist government, by "encircling the cities from the countryside."
Ukraine, North Africa and Israel, as Beijing sees it, are parts of the
"countryside" today. So, what is the "city"?
The main enemy of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is the United States of
America.
The CCP declared a "people's war" on America in a May 2019 landmark editorial in
People's Daily, the self-described "mouthpiece" of the regime. The CCP views the
U.S. as an existential threat. As an initial matter, America stands in the way
of Beijing from ruling tianxia, or "all under Heaven."
Moreover, the Party believes it must destroy the U.S. because of what America
stands for. An insecure ruling organization is worried about the inspirational
impact of America's form of governance and values on the oppressed Chinese
people. This means the United States will never have amicable relations with
China as long as the Communist Party rules it.
Today, therefore, the CCP is waging proxy wars against America, such as Russia's
campaign to annex Ukraine, or backing Iran, which has for decades been calling
for "Death to Israel" and "Death to America." Beijing's takeover of North Africa
looks like an attempt to control the migration routes to Europe. Splitting off
Europe from America, in turn, would be another step in starving the U.S.
Similarly, China is buying friends in, among other places, Latin America, the
Caribbean and the Pacific Ocean as a means of further isolating America.
The Chinese regime is not bashful in revealing overall strategy. "While in the
countryside, the Communist Party mobilized the masses of peasants and
established base areas, thus opening up a road of encircling the cities from the
rural areas and seizing political power by armed force," states China.org.cn, a
Chinese propaganda site, in "An Illustrated History of the Communist Party of
China."
President Joe Biden is either unwilling or unable to defend the world from
malicious Chinese communism. The catastrophic withdrawal from Afghanistan,
completed in August 2021, signaled that American policy was in collapse. As a
result, in the "countryside" there are many soft spots for Xi to attack.
China's leader will continue to attack them, especially as Biden pays what are
essentially ransoms and thereby provides incentives for further disorder. The
ransoms include the unfreezing of $6 billion in connection with a hostage swap
with Iran — announced on the 22nd anniversary of 9/11 — and the October 18th
announcement of "humanitarian assistance" to Palestinians in Gaza and the West
Bank, apparently to free Americans held by Hamas.
Violence is already spreading. Hezbollah has attacked Israel from the north, and
the Houthis launched missile and drone attacks from Yemen on the 19th. On
October 18 and 19, militants hit American bases in Iraq and Syria.
Many, especially on the American right, believe the United States must conserve
resources. They recommend, for instance, withdrawing support from Ukraine to
ensure America can defend Taiwan. Similarly, the Biden administration did not
lift a finger in North Africa in the past several months, ceding this crucial
area to Beijing and Moscow.
Allowing China, Russia and friends to take over areas is a critical — and
probably fatal — mistake. Victories, for one thing, create momentum and the
appearance of inevitability. Xi promotes the notion of the inevitability of
Chinese rule as he tries to intimidate others into submission. China's successes
just embolden the regime to press attacks.
Momentum has been working against the United States for two years. Biden took
the oath of office in a peaceful world. He then presided over a rapid collapse
of the international system.
How, then, does the United States confront China's proxy-war strategy?
Washington can turn the tables on Xi by taking down Chinese proxies, thereby
isolating Beijing and creating the appearance of Chinese failure.
Communist China is already overstretched. The primary driver of its four-decade
rise, the economy, is in distress. The property sector, accounting for at least
a quarter of gross domestic product, is crumbling. Money is fleeing the country.
GDP is growing nowhere near the 5.2% claimed for the first three quarters of
this year — if it is growing at all. Imports, perhaps the best indicator of
domestic demand, have now fallen for 12 straight months on a year-to-year basis.
Is confronting China risky and dangerous? Will doing so result in harm to
America?
The answer to both questions is "yes," but after three decades of particularly
naïve, indulgent, feeble and otherwise misguided policy, Washington has no good
options. The worst option of all is to continue policies that have created this
disastrous situation. Every course of action will be exceedingly risky.
Something has to be done, however. China is bleeding the United States and its
friends.
America and the free world are running out of time. Mao in the late 1940s
thought it would take him a decade to dislodge Chiang. As it turned out, he only
needed about a year. Encircling the cities worked then. And it is working now.
America, therefore, is about to lose everything.
*Gordon G. Chang is the author of The Coming Collapse of China, a Gatestone
Institute distinguished senior fellow, and a member of its Advisory Board.
© 2023 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
Regional upheaval offers Assad regime a window to
recalibrate
Zaid M. Belbagi/Arab News/October 22, 2023
When Arab streets erupted in protest more than a decade ago, the most vulnerable
regime was that of Bashar Assad in Syria. Remarkably, as his more established
counterparts were overthrown and even publicly lynched, the unassuming
ophthalmologist has shown incredible grit, holding on to power at any cost. The
reignited crisis in the Middle East not only risks exposing the fragilities of
his regime, but it also provides an opportunity for Assad to reimpose his writ
upon Syria.
Twelve years have elapsed since Syria was overcome by nationwide protests and
rebellion. Following the displacement of 12 million Syrians, vicious internal
conflict, the establishment of a terrorist proto-state and, most recently, a
debilitating earthquake, the only enduring factor has been the regime that Assad
inherited from his father. Stepping out from the cold, he has carefully
choreographed his regional political rehabilitation, with the reopening of Arab
embassies and, significantly, Syria’s readmittance to the Arab League.
However, the worst protests since 2011 threatened to undo this work when, last
month, public outrage at the prevailing economic crisis and resentment with the
regime gripped the country. Having worked to curtail the role of Iran and Russia
in propping up his regime, the protests highlighted Assad’s vulnerabilities. But
concerns with the economic crisis and the fifth decade of Assad rule have
shifted as the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has reignited.
The deployment of a great power naval presence in the Eastern Mediterranean in
recent days was in response to the perceived threat of Iran. Iranian Foreign
Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian last week shuttled between Beirut, Damascus,
Baghdad and Doha, underscoring his country’s muscular influence across the
region. His visits have stoked concerns that the further involvement of Iran or
its proxies could tilt the conflict out of Israel’s favor. Simultaneous Israeli
airstrikes on Aleppo and Damascus airports were indicative of Tel Aviv’s concern
that Iran-backed militias could become involved in the conflict by way of
Lebanon or Syria. Shellfire from Syria landing in northeastern Israel has
increased these concerns.
Having propped up the Damascus regime through the deployment of economic and
military assistance, Iran’s continued support has allowed Assad to retain
control. It has, in turn, provided an important foothold for Iran to support its
proxies, Hezbollah and Hamas. Given that Hezbollah possesses an arsenal of some
150,000 rockets, it is little surprise that, with the conflict not going its
way, Israel is concerned about the opening of another front. Syria, therefore,
would seem to be teetering on the edge of becoming embroiled in the conflict,
but in this complex scenario the Assad regime eyes an opportunity amid the
chaos.
Assad will either have an opportunity to break free from Iran’s shackles or it
will remain bound by them and unable to engage more broadly.
The immediate crisis in the region serves the Assad regime on multiple fronts.
It has successfully diverted attention from the chronic internal issues in
Syria, while simultaneously concerning both the US and Israel with the Iranian
presence on Israel’s northern borders. Though Iran’s enduring presence weakens
the ability of the Syrian regime to operate independently, it does allow the
regime to portray itself as a supporter of both Hezbollah and Hamas, both of
which are perceived as a useful tool in containing Israel. The utility of this
stance for Damascus was evident during its support for Hamas during operations
like the Al-Aqsa Flood, allowing a regime that has aligned itself with Iran to
paradoxically claim to be the last bastion of Arabism.
But Assad is in a bind, relying on Iran to stay on the front foot in the
conflict, while also betting on the conflict to deliver a significant reduction
in Tehran’s appetite for hegemony. Though China, Russia and Iran have been
integral to his durability, the rebuilding of the country and his regime’s
ultimate survival relies on Syria’s wider international rehabilitation. Syria
stands to gain from new supply chains connecting India with Europe through
America’s Partnership for Global Infrastructure and Investment, which plans to
draw in Israel alongside Saudi Arabia, Jordan and the UAE. However, should the
Shiite axis emerge from this conflict emboldened, Assad will neither be able to
reinforce his regime nor rebuild Syria, increasing the prospect for further
unrest.
There is no doubt that the aftermath of the Israeli-Palestinian conflagration
will have a lasting impact on the region’s geopolitical layout. Assad will
either have an opportunity to break free from Iran’s shackles or it will remain
bound by them and unable to engage more broadly.
The Assad regime’s survival therefore hangs in the balance. Though his strategic
alliances and recent diplomatic forays are significant, they might not be
enough. Repairing Arab relations, avoiding isolation and pursuing economic
reforms are vital steps that, if not taken, could jeopardize his hold on power.
The intricate interplay of regional politics, economic stability and
international alliances will ultimately determine the fate of the Assad regime.
• Zaid M. Belbagi is a political commentator and an adviser to private clients
between London and the GCC.
X: @Moulay_Zaid
How Jordan and Syria can cooperate to improve relations
Dr. Majid Rafizadeh/Arab News/October 22, 2023
Several of the challenges that Jordan and Syria currently face could be
addressed if the two countries invested political capital in cooperating in
three critical areas.
While the bilateral relationship between Jordan and Syria became strained
following the outbreak of the Syrian civil war, Amman and Damascus have been
improving their ties in the last few years, particularly after Syrian President
Bashar Assad called King Abdullah of Jordan in October 2021 to “discuss ways to
enhance cooperation” between the two nations.
As a part of its broader plan for ensuring regional stability and security,
Jordan has pushed for a peace plan that will end the conflict in Syria and allow
Damascus’ readmittance to the Arab League. One of Amman’s plans, announced in
April, was the formation of a joint Arab group that “would directly engage the
Syrian government on a detailed plan to end the conflict. The detailed roadmap
deals with all the key issues … and solving the crisis so that Syria can restore
its role in the region and rejoin the Arab League,” an official told Reuters.
Ultimately, the Arab League readmitted Syria in May, ending its decade-long
suspension. Nevertheless, since the initial rapprochement between Jordan and
Syria, their bilateral relationship does not seem to have advanced. Instead, it
appears to have stagnated due to several obstacles that require close
cooperation between the two nations.
The first issue is the smuggling of drugs from Syria into Jordan, which has not
subsided since the rapprochement. Drug trafficking could destabilize trade
between Jordan and Syria. One of the other problems of drug trafficking is that
it undermines the social, economic and political stability of countries and
subsequently leads to a rise in other crimes. This issue can become particularly
threatening in a country such as Jordan, which has a large youth population.
From Jordan’s perspective, the reintegration of Syria into the regional scene
could help address this issue, as Damascus has, unfortunately, become a hub for
the production of illicit drugs. The civil war, lack of security, political
vacuum, economic crisis and isolation of the country by the international
community have created a ripe environment for criminal groups to engage in an
illicit economy and produce and smuggle illegal drugs into other countries. This
multibillion-dollar industry in Syria is reportedly worth nearly three times the
combined trade of the Mexican cartels.
Jordan-Syria ties appear to have stagnated due to several obstacles that require
close cooperation between the two nations.
Jordan has intensified its efforts to put an end to the flow of illicit drugs
from Syria. The Jordanian military has been successful in downing some drones
flying into Jordan while carrying crystal meth from Syria. Several meetings have
been held between Jordanian and Syrian officials in order to address the illicit
drug trade, but the issue remains unresolved. Assad and Jordanian Foreign
Minister Ayman Safadi met in Damascus in July and Safadi was said to have raised
“the dangers posed by drug smuggling across the Syrian border into the kingdom,
and the need for cooperation to confront it.”
To address this issue, several critical steps should be taken. First of all,
Syria and Jordan ought to create several coordinated joint committees, both
political and military, that focus on enhancing border security, combating drug
trafficking in the entire region and preventing drug smuggling across Syria’s
border with Jordan. Amman can also seek the assistance of other Arab countries
to persuade and pressure the Syrian government into cooperating with them in
order to track down and dismantle the groups that are involved in the production
and smuggling of illegal drugs. Incentives such as reinvigorating import and
export opportunities and stronger economic ties generally can be offered to the
Syrian government if it takes firmer action to put an end to this problem.
The second obstacle between the two nations is the refugee issue. In spite of
the reengagement between Amman and Damascus, many Syrian refugees in Jordan have
not yet returned to their homes, preferring instead to remain where they are.
This is putting significant socioeconomic pressure on a country that has the
second-largest number of refugees per capita in the world. According to the UN
High Commissioner for Refugees, Jordan hosts some “675,000 registered refugees
from Syria, who began fleeing in 2011 when the crisis in their country brought
unimaginable suffering on its citizens. Most Syrian refugees in Jordan live in
its towns and villages, among local communities. Only 17 percent live in the two
main refugee camps, Za’atari and Azraq.”
To address this issue, peace, stability, economic growth and security in Syria
are vital. These conditions are necessary to allow the sustainable return of
Syrian refugees from Jordan. This means that, to enhance its ties with Amman,
the Syrian government must adequately address the economic mismanagement of the
country, the predominantly state-controlled economy and concentrate on the
reconstruction of infrastructure. These could all play a key role in creating
jobs and improving the economy. Syria could also attempt to attract investment
from other countries.
In a nutshell, in order for Jordan and Syria to further improve their bilateral
ties, they must cooperate closely on three key platforms: border security,
refugees and trade.
*Dr. Majid Rafizadeh is a Harvard-educated Iranian-American political scientist.
X: @Dr_Rafizadeh
Brinkmanship Politics
Charles Elias Chartouni/Face Book/October 22/2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/123432/123432
The Iranian regime succeeded changing the overall regional dynamics which
derailed the US-Saudi negotiations and the meeting between President Biden and
Arab leaders. The whole dynamic unraveled and the region is under the sway of
unleashed populism where political regimes live off political reprieve.
Otherwise, President Biden’s bold move needs to be reciprocated by Israeli
readiness to coordinate systematically their retaliation strategy and tie it to
consensual political objectives. The military assault on Hamas should not
compromise the chances of future negotiations, regional stability, ability to
contain the Iranian destabilization strategy and safeguard Arab
counter-dynamics.
The looming challenges summarize likewise:
1/ the destruction of Hamas operational infrastructures should be strictly
regulated to prevent tragic humanitarian consequences that undermine the
political leverage of the Palestinian National Authority and Palestinian
moderates;
2/ the military objectives should pair with major political moves towards a
final political settlement based on mutual recognition and separate Statehood,
as stipulated throughout the 75 years of international resolutions, peace
agreements and normalization scenarios. The ongoing dynamic is likely to
compromise a whole legacy of constructive engagement which marked major stages
in the life of this long hauled conflict;
3/ The eradication of Hamas should dovetail with the the demise of Israeli
radicalism and its predatory politics, and the reactivation of peace dynamics
all along;
4/ the containment of Iranian politics of subversion require stalwart strategic
levees, solid regional alliances and financial retorsion politics;
5/ the checkmate of Iranian power politics ability to question the regional
order, extend the realm of political wastelands and fuel strategic counter
dynamics.
The Peace Summit in Cairo is an adequate move on the part of Arab States to
counter the Iranian strategy, set the record straight and make the necessary
adjustments. Israeli politics are bound to reckon with the Arab
counter-balancing dynamics to safeguard the peace accords legacy, restart the
US-Saudi negotiation and further its attending choruses. The rightful military
retribution should not obfuscate the political openings and ultimately kill
them: the exponential dynamics of the ongoing conflict are likely to disseminate
and broaden the conflict spectrum and its destructive fallouts.The strategic
umbrella provided by the US, the firm stand of the Western coalition, the
equanimity of moderate Arab states, and the imperative of a comprehensive
solution, should be carefully considered while tackling the dilemmatic and
tragic choices elicited by the ongoing maelstrom.
Israel-Gaza conflict only serves to benefit Hamas, Iran, Israeli far-right
Nadim Shehadi/Alarabiya/October 22/2023
The current war between Israel and Hamas is a victory for both Iran’s “Axis of
Resistance” and benefits Israel’s far-right. It cannot end well for Israel, and
comes at the expense of Palestinian lives, and regional peace processes.
Hamas has won this war even before it ends. It is a victory against Hamas’
Palestinian and Arab rivals, who sought peace through negotiations. Israel
gifted this to Hamas by giving it the opportunity to take the moral high ground,
Israel lost because it has no options itself for a good outcome.
As it stands Israel cannot stop bombing Gaza, that would be capitulation. It
also cannot continue bombing Gaza, there is a limit to how many people Israel
can kill with no clear objective. Killing for the sake of killing is not a
strategy. Israel’s friends in the region are humiliated, its enemies triumphant.
Someone needs to save Israel from itself.
Wars can result in moral and political victories even when accompanied by
military defeats. The 1956 Suez War is a prime example. Gamal Abdel Nasser
emerged much stronger after losing the war, and regimes dominated by colonels
emulating his model of Arab nationalism sprang up throughout the region.
This is also reminiscent of the summer of 2006, when a war in Gaza was provoked
by Hamas abducting an Israeli soldier and resembles the 2006 Lebanon war –
triggered by Hezbollah crossing the border and the associated killing of eight
Israeli soldiers and abduction of a further two. Both were accompanied by rocket
attacks that caused panic in Israel, shutting down the airport and sending
terrorized Israeli citizens to underground shelters amid the sound of sirens.
Israel fell into the trap on both occasions and reacted with what is
euphemistically described as disproportionate violence. Both Gaza and Lebanon
suffered huge destruction and civilian casualties. Hamas and Hezbollah, however,
proved that armed resistance can achieve what years of negotiations could not:
Israel was later forced to release hundreds of prisoners and the paralysis
caused by the rocket attacks was seen as a deterrent.
Today, the optics could not have been worse for Israel. Refugees are being
publicly evicted and replaced by Jewish settlers in East Jerusalem. At the
center of this conflict is the Arab neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah, where most of
the city’s foreign consulates are located.
It is also difficult to imagine worse timing. On one of the holiest evenings of
the month of Ramadan, the Israeli army stormed the al-Aqsa mosque and shot at
people during prayers. Palestinians had been protesting a ban against gathering
in public places, such as the Damascus Gate of the old city, during the festive
evenings. The backdrop also includes an annual hate march by Israelis chanting
anti-Arab slogans. This was Israel at its worse, resuscitating memories of the
1948 Nakba, a few days before its anniversary. It triggered an unprecedented
wave of protests by Palestinian citizens of Israel in major cities from Lydda to
Jaffa and Acre. This was too good an opportunity to miss. Hamas gave Israel an
ultimatum that Israel was obviously going to disregard and attacked with more
sophisticated missiles than ever before. For the Israelis it was like a
recurring nightmare, with sirens, shelters, and civilian casualties. Worst of
all, Israel reacted predictably with brute force, with air raids and bombings
causing heavy civilian casualties.
At the same time Hamas proceeded to declare itself the protector of the al-Aqsa
mosque, the savior of refugees, and called for their right of return, all while
riding the spreading wave of protests by Palestinian citizens across Israel.
This was all eloquently articulated by Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh, who
reiterated that armed resistance is the only path to protection, and shamed both
the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), and the Palestinian authority for
achieving nothing through years of negotiations. He also discredited the recent
Abraham Accords of normalization of relations between Arab countries and Israel,
and went on a fundraising tour of Qatar and Kuwait.
For Hamas this was a win-win scenario, using the same logic as that of
Iran-backed Hezbollah: That the arms of the resistance are the only protection
against Israeli aggression. Its message was further legitimized by a flood of
dramatic videos circulating all over the media. One showed a woman calmly
pleading with a settler to give her back her home in Sheikh Jarrah. Others had
apocalyptic scenes of trees catching fire around the al-Aqsa Mosque, and of
soldiers attacking protestors and overturning food carts.
While Hamas may have achieved all its objectives even while the battle is still
raging, it is difficult to imagine what Israel’s options are to end the war with
tangible results. Israel cannot stop its operations, nor can it continue without
defining achievable goals. This is the same situation if found itself in the
Lebanon war of 2006 with only lose-lose scenarios.
This is also a war that affects elections on both sides. It may benefit both
Hamas and Prime Minister Netanyahu. It is a perfect illustration of how radicals
feed on each other and their actions mutually validate and legitimize their
positions. For the far-right in Israel, it is in their interest to portray
Palestinians as all being Hamas terrorists with whom negotiations are
impossible. Similarly for Hamas, a figure like Netanyahu confirms that armed
struggle is the only option, and that the PLO’s agenda of peace is unachievable
and does not provide any protection against Israeli aggression. War ultimately
benefits the warmongers and gets them votes by discrediting their internal
opponents.
This could have broader regional repercussions, embarrassing the signatories of
the Abraham Accords. It is a setback to any possible peace in the region. Iran
and the Axis of Resistance win again, and it is a boost for Iran-backed militias
in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Yemen and of course Palestine. Israel with its actions
may have given them all a new lease of life. There is, however, a major
difference with the summer wars of 2006. Those with the highest stakes in this
game are now from a new generation, and their aspirations are for that of a
better future. They are protesting across the region against the establishment
that has kept them in a state of war for over 70 years. Palestinian protests are
part of that, they deserve better leadership.
A Message to Khaled Meshaal
Tariq Al-Homayed/ Asharq Al-Awsat/October 22/2023
To Mr. Khaled Meshaal, I will address you as Abu Al-Walid. In your interview
with Al Arabiya broadcaster, you touched on several issues, political,
historical, and religious. Your rhetoric was neither coherent nor consistent,
but like that of a messenger. I will not dwell on the political matters you
discussed, as they are well-established.
Abu Al-Walid, I will focus on your religious rhetoric and your citations of the
Holy Quran and the words of the Prophet - peace be upon him. I am not a preacher
or a sheikh, but a father who fears that religion could be manipulated to
misguide his children. I am worried that they might listen to you and believe
that you are being truthful when you are not.
I say this because I have witnessed the various stages of your misleading and
inciting discourse. Our experiences have taught us that these lies have misled
youth into the abyss of terrorism and extremism, becoming fodder for failed
battles. This happened from Afghanistan, which you take as a reference, to
Palestine, whose cause you have tarnished.
Abu Al-Walid, you speak about the Prophet striking with the spade in the Battle
of the Trench, forgetting that he stood spade in hand on the battlefield,
surrounded by his Companions; he was not living a comfortable life in another
country like you are in Doha.
You ask the "Ummah" to "play with fire" and march to the borders, while you are
far away. Why don't you march to the borders of Gaza, even just to hand water
out to those who have gone? Go and do it. If the Egyptian authorities prevent
you; I promise to write an article condemning them for doing so.
And you cite the verse: "Permission has been granted to those being fought, for
they have been wronged" - a Makkan-Medinan verse revealed to the Prophet in
Medinah after he had spent 13 years in Makkah without calling for the use of
force. The Prophet did not call for battle until after he had the support and
strength of the Ansar (Supporters) in Medinah, and he did not recklessly send
the Muslims to their demise. This verse was revealed in Medinah.
We are taught that the Prophet refused, when asked for permission to do so, to
allow the killing of those who had harmed the Muslims in Makkah before the
Hijrah (migration). The Almighty revealed the following verse to address this
question: God does not love any of the treacherous, ungrateful ones.
When the family of Yasir was tortured, and Ammar witnessed the killing of his
parents, the Prophet did not ask for revenge. Rather, he behaved like a great
leader who sees the greater good. To prevent bloodshed, saying: "Patience, O
family of Yasir! Your meeting place will be Paradise."
And you, Abu Al-Walid, did not fight the Israelis but the Palestinians
themselves. The first thing you did after the Gaza elections was to throw
members of Fatah and the Palestinian Authority off the rooftops; this is a
documented fact.
These are the facts, Abu Al-Walid. Nothing can be more dangerous and harmful
than taking matters out of their context in moments of passion, especially since
honest people sympathize with the innocent people of Gaza not with you or Hamas.
Nothing is more dangerous than citing the Quran and the Prophet to mislead,
especially through populist rhetoric that harms the reputation of Muslims and
Islam, as Al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden had done.
I am not a sheikh but a father who worries for his children. I always teach them
that the noble Prophet had set terms and ethics even for conflict. My advice,
Abu Al-Walid, is thus that you focus on your adventures. Engage in them however
you want, but do not throw the Quran, religion, and the Prophet into these
discussions.
In conclusion, Salam