English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For March 02/2024
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2024/english.march02.24.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
Bible Quotations For
today
When you are offering your gift at the altar,
if you remember that your brother or sister has something against you, leave
your gift there before the altar and go; first be reconciled to your brother
or sister, and then come and offer your gift
Matthew 05/21-26/:”‘You have heard that it was said to those
of ancient times, “You shall not murder”; and “whoever murders shall be
liable to judgement.”But I say to you that if you are angry with a brother
or sister, you will be liable to judgement; and if you insult a brother or
sister, you will be liable to the council; and if you say, “You fool”, you
will be liable to the hell of fire. So when you are offering your gift at
the altar, if you remember that your brother or sister has something against
you, leave your gift there before the altar and go; first be reconciled to
your brother or sister, and then come and offer your gift. Come to terms
quickly with your accuser while you are on the way to court with him, or
your accuser may hand you over to the judge, and the judge to the guard, and
you will be thrown into prison.Truly I tell you, you will never get out
until you have paid the last penny.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese
Related News & Editorials published on March 01-02/2024
An Israeli raid kills 5 Hezbollah members
Israeli strike in Syria kills Iran Guard, and Two Hezbollah Jihadists
A leader in the Iranian Revolutionary Guard, and 2 Hezbollah members were killed
in the Baniyas raid
Sadness and anxiety prevail in the south due to the impact of the convoy of
martyrs... and Hezbollah responds with a “Falak” and attack aircraft.
International Day of the Wheelchair: Highlighting mobility challenges and
accessibility issues in Lebanon
Hezbollah says downed Israeli drone overnight
Berri stresses support for Palestine amid regional struggles
Mikati: Hochstein to visit Lebanon soon, truce would trigger land border talks
Hezbollah's drone warfare: A challenge for Israel
International Day of the Wheelchair: Highlighting mobility challenges and
accessibility issues in Lebanon
Kanaan from Bkerke raises alarm on stamp mafia, pushes for swift government
action
UNIFIL troops briefly detained by 'locals' in Hay al-Sellom
Mikati meets Quintet ambassadors at the Grand Serail
Gen. Aoun heads to Italy to attend army support meeting
Bou Habib says Lebanon to respond to Paris' 'good ideas' next week
Al Jazeera: Bou Habib coordinates with Hezbollah amid rising tensions with
Israel
The Lebanese Hezbollah has become a criminal Entity in Kuwait..Joining the
organization and cooperating with it is a “crime punishable by law.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
Miscellaneous Reports And News published on March 01-02/2024
Hamas armed wing says seven hostages killed in Gaza
Deaths at aid delivery site in Gaza draw condemnation
EU clears 50-mn-euro payment to UNRWA
WHO says Gaza health system in Gaza 'more than on its knees'
The EU says it will send funds to Gaza's main aid provider after the UN agency
agrees to an audit
Calls for probe, ceasefire follow Israeli gunfire near aid convoy
Hamas, other Palestinian groups stress 'unity' at Moscow talks
Media leaders express support for journalists in Gaza
Humanitarian crisis: Why have most countries opted to deliver airlifted aid?
Biden announces US airdrops of humanitarian assistance into Gaza
Netanyahu says he will pave way to end exemption for ultra-Orthodox from
military service
Iran votes in its first parliament election since 2022 protests as questions
over turnout loom
Iran hard-liners set to tighten grip in election amid voter apathy
Grammy-winning Iranian singer, awarded over Mahsa Amini protest anthem,
sentenced to prison
Putin foe Alexei Navalny is buried in Moscow as thousands attend under heavy
police presence
Election in UK likely this year, here's what to know
European Commission will proceed to paying EUR 50 million to UNRWA and increase
emergency support to Palestinians by EUR 68 million in 2024
Islamic State attack kills one Iraqi soldier north of Baghdad
Palestinians' Musical Chairs: Replacing One Mohammed with Another Mohammed/Khaled
Abu Toameh/Gatestone Institute./March 01, 2024
Accelerating the region’s transformation of its agrifood systems/QU DONGYU/Arab
News/March 01, 2024
‘When Christendom Had Muscle’/Raymond Ibrahim/American Reformer:/March 01/2024
Gaza and the shameless vacuum of Western morality/Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib/Arab
News/March 01, 2024
Turkiye, Gulf states’ converging interests in Horn of Africa/Sinem Cengiz/Arab
News/March 01, 2024
Starvation: Israel’s criminal weapon of war/Daoud Kuttab/Arab News/March 01,
2024
Question: “Can a Christian lose salvation?”/GotQuestions.org/March 01/2024
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on March 01-02/2024
An Israeli raid kills 5 Hezbollah
members
Agencies/02 March 2024
The Israeli army announced the killing of a number of Hezbollah members, in a
bombing on the Ramia area in southern Lebanon, and also published the first
pictures of the strike. The Israeli army said: “We bombed, with aircraft and
artillery, infrastructure and two military buildings belonging to Hezbollah in
the town of Ramia.” A number of members were spotted leaving a military
building, and a plane attacked and killed them shortly after. Sky News Arabia,
citing Hezbollah sources, indicated that 5 party members were killed in the
Israeli strike. The Israeli strike came a day after a similar strike, carried
out on the home of an Iranian Revolutionary Guard advisor, in the Baniyas area
in Syria. On Friday, Iranian media reported that Reza Zarei, an advisor to the
Revolutionary Guard, was killed by Israeli bombing on Baniyas, western Syria.
The Syrian Observatory reported that three Iranian leaders were targeted in the
coastal area of Baniyas, northwestern Syria. According to the Observatory, the
Baniyas strike targeted a house used by Iranian militias, while local sources
indicated that three violent explosions were heard, causing a state of panic
among the population as a result of their violent sounds.
Israeli strike in Syria kills Iran Guard, and Two
Hezbollah Jihadists
Agence France Presse/March 01, 2024
An Israeli strike in Syria on Friday killed an Iranian Revolutionary Guard and
two other people, reports said, in the third consecutive day of Israeli attacks
on Syria. Three violent explosions shook the centre of Banias, on Syria's
Mediterranean coast, during the dawn strike on a villa that sheltered "a group
affiliated with Iran", said the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights war monitor.
A building was destroyed, killing the Iranian and two other non-Syrians who were
with him, said the Britain-based Observatory, which relies on a network of
sources inside Syria. Iran's official news agency IRNA later said Reza Zarei, a
member of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps' navy, had been "killed at dawn
today by the usurping Zionist regime". The government-controlled city of Banias
is home to an oil refinery with Iranian tankers docking at its port. On
Thursday, Israel killed a Hezbollah fighter in a strike on Syria, close to the
Lebanese border, the Observatory said, hours after similar attacks. Israel has
launched hundreds of air strikes on targets in Syria since civil war broke out
in 2011. The strikes have mainly targeted Iran-backed forces including militants
from Lebanon's Hezbollah movement as well as Syrian army positions. Iran is a
key political, military and financial backer of the Assad government, and has
sent military advisers and volunteers to bolster its forces.Tehran says it has
deployed forces in Syria at the invitation of Damascus, but only as advisers.
The strikes have increased since Israel's war with Palestinian militant group
Hamas began on October 7. Israel rarely comments on individual strikes but has
repeatedly said it will not allow Iran to expand its presence in Syria. Iran
backs Assad's government and Hezbollah, which supports Hamas. Syria's war has
claimed the lives of more than half a million people and displaced millions
since it broke out in March 2011 with Damascus's brutal repression of
anti-government protests.
A leader in the Iranian Revolutionary Guard, and 2
Hezbollah members were killed in the Baniyas raid
Nedda Al Watan/March 02, 2024
Yesterday, three people were killed, including a member of the Iranian
Revolutionary Guard, as a result of an Israeli raid targeting the city of
Baniyas on the Syrian coast, according to what the Syrian Observatory for Human
Rights reported. The Observatory said: “Three violent explosions sounded at
dawn, resulting from an Israeli airstrike targeting a villa” on the outskirts of
Baniyas on the Syrian coast. The Observatory added: “It was confirmed that a
leader of Iranian nationality and two other people who were with him of
non-Syrian nationality were killed.” Iranian media later reported that the two
people who were killed, along with the Iranian leader, belonged to Hezbollah.
This targeting “is the first of its kind in Baniyas in three years,” according
to the Observatory. The official Iranian News Agency (IRNA) in Tehran confirmed
later on Friday the killing of a member of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard, Reza
Zarei, “one of the guards of the 1st District of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard
Navy, who was martyred at dawn today at the hands of the usurping Zionist
regime.” From Baniyas to the south, the Israeli army announced last night that
it had attacked “infrastructure and two buildings belonging to Hezbollah” in
Ramia in the western sector, and the raid led to casualties among the party’s
ranks. He said: “A number of people were spotted leaving a military building,
and a plane attacked them and killed them shortly after.”
Sadness and anxiety prevail in the south due to the impact of the convoy of
martyrs... and Hezbollah responds with a “Falak” and attack aircraft.
Hussein Saad/Janoubia/March 02, 2024
New martyrs in the sad south, fell this evening in Ramia, homes were destroyed,
and the level of pessimism rose, in light of the blockage of the horizon of
prisoner exchange negotiations and agreement on a humanitarian truce, coinciding
with the massacres against civilians in Gaza, and the acts of destruction in the
Lebanese border towns and villages, which raise the level of The number of
displaced people increases their suffering. In a parallel context, a number of
southern towns bid farewell to their martyrs who fell yesterday and the day
before, in Kafra, where they mourned the spouses Hussein Ali Ibrahim Hamdan and
Manar Abadi, wrapped in the Lebanese flag, amid an atmosphere of sadness that
pervaded the town. In which the martyr Mahmoud Hammoud also fell, in an Israeli
raid, on the Lebanese-Syrian border yesterday morning, while Hezbollah and the
town of Dabal mourned the two martyrs who fell in a raid on Blida, namely
Abdullah Asal and Ali Jumaa. In the wake of these funerals, enemy warplanes
continued to launch devastating raids on a number of towns, including Ramia, in
the Bint Jbeil district, where Israeli planes raided a house in the town, close
to the border, and the raid resulted in the fall of a number of martyrs. Inside
this house, the operations to remove the rubble continued for many hours, during
which the civil defense teams, the Al-Resala Association, and the Health
Authority were able to recover the bodies of martyrs who fell as a result of the
raid, and the martyrs were known among them, Muhammad Ali Ghabris, from Tairdaba,
Mustafa Salman, from Majdal Zoun, Ali Shalhoub, From Qana, and Ali Qasim Wahbi
from Mahrouna. Within the framework of the work and support operations for Gaza,
Hezbollah carried out a series of attacks against Israeli occupation sites, and
according to statements issued by the party, it bombed with a missile, opening
positions at the Khirbet Maar base, and attacked the Ma’yan Baruch settlement,
with a attack aircraft, and bombed Al-Manara sites. , Ruwaisat Al-Alam,
Al-Baghdadi, Ramim, and the party previously announced that it shot down an
Israeli helicopter, over the Al-Azziyah area, south of the city of Tyre.
International Day of the Wheelchair: Highlighting mobility
challenges and accessibility issues in Lebanon
LBCI/March 01/2024
The wheelchair, a tool designed to assist people with mobility challenges, began
with the simple idea of a chair on wheels and evolved with technology to become
more accessible and flexible. This enables people using wheelchairs to integrate
more into society, and opening many paths. Can you imagine how difficult their
lives were before? We visited Sesobel, where they are celebrating this holiday
for the first time, to learn more about it and its purpose. The International
Day of the Wheelchair is a celebration that may be unfamiliar to some, so let's
delve into its significance and purpose. The concept of the International Day of
the Wheelchair was initiated by a British wheelchair user who aimed to highlight
its importance and positive impact on his life. However, here in Lebanon, we
encounter a challenge. The cost of these chairs can be prohibitive for some.
According to Salma Assi, the head of the Medical Equipment & Device Importers
Syndicate, prices range from $100 to $2000. Beyond the cost issue, Lebanon lacks
specific pathways that allow wheelchairs to access all locations. While many
institutions provide these pathways, numerous public places and institutions
must also be equipped with such facilities. Even if they exist, who is
responsible for enforcing the law? These pathways often become blocked rather
than serving as accessible routes.
Hezbollah says downed Israeli drone overnight
Naharnet/March 01/2024
Hezbollah said Friday it has downed an Israeli drone overnight in southern
Lebanon and targeted Friday a military post and a group of Israeli soldiers in
northern Israel. The group said it has downed the drone over the al-Azziyeh
valley in the Tyre district, in support of Gaza and its resistance, and targeted
the al-Baghdadi post and a group of soldiers in the Ramim barracks in northern
Israel. Israeli warplanes and drones meanwhile targeted Aita al-Shaab, Jabal
Blat and the outskirts of Ramia and Marwahin. Israeli warplanes had raided
overnight al-Labbouneh and a valley between Ramia, Beit Leef and Aita al-Shaab.
As the Gaza war raged, Hezbollah and the Israeli army have traded almost daily
fire. On the Lebanese side, at least 280 people have been killed, mostly
Hezbollah fighters and their allies, along with 44 civilians, according to an
AFP tally. On the Israeli side, the army says 10 soldiers and six civilians have
been killed, while tens of thousands of residents on both sides have been
displaced.
Berri stresses support for Palestine amid regional
struggles
LBCI/March 01/2024
Nabih Berri affirms Lebanon's support for Palestine amid regional challenges.
During a meeting with the Secretary-General of the General Union of Arab Writers
and the President of the General Union of Writers in Egypt, Dr. Alaa Abdelhadi,
along with a delegation, Nabih Berri, the Speaker of the Parliament, emphasized
that Lebanon pays a high price for its stance with Palestine, considering it as
"our destiny."Berri stated, "It must be emphasized that what is happening in the
Gaza Strip, the West Bank, and Jerusalem, and the potential fall of these Arab
territories, God forbid, will not only be a fall for Palestine, but it will also
be a fall for Arab national security, and it is a fall for humanity as a
whole."The delegation briefed the Speaker of the Parliament on the Union's work
programs and its role in preserving Arab identity, stressing the importance of
establishing an Arab cultural front to confront the risks and challenges facing
the nation, foremost among them the situation in the Gaza Strip.Abdelhadi
presented Berri with an honorary shield for his efforts, and several literary
publications by participating writers and poets in the delegation were also
presented to him. Additionally, Berri received the former Deputy Governor of the
Central Bank of Lebanon, Dr. Mohammad Baasiri.
Mikati: Hochstein to visit Lebanon soon, truce would
trigger land border talks
Naharnet/March 01/2024
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati has said that U.S. special envoy Amos
Hochstein will visit Lebanon soon, amid fears of an all-out war between Lebanon
and Israel as tensions escalated between the two archfoes in recent weeks.
Hochstein was last in Beirut in January in a diplomatic effort to prevent a
bigger conflict between Israel and Hezbollah. Mikati told Reuters, in comments
published Thursday, that he is certain that Hezbollah would cease fire if Israel
did the same, and that a truce in Gaza would trigger mediated land border
negotiations between Lebanon and Israel. As Israel and Hamas inch toward a new
deal, Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said there would be no let-up in
Israeli action against Hezbollah even if a Gaza ceasefire and hostage deal were
secured, while Hezbollah said it would abide by any Gaza truce.
Hezbollah's drone warfare: A challenge for Israel
LBCI/March 01/2024
In light of Israel's air force superiority, Hezbollah had to develop an
alternative weapon, and thus emerged what became known as the "drone war." In
this war, two prominent challenges stood out: the precision assassination of
Hamas leader Saleh al-Arouri in an apartment deep in the suburb and, in return,
Hezbollah's breach of the Meron base bypassing the Iron Dome system. For Israel,
facing Hamas' drones in the south and Hezbollah's drones in the north
necessitated a technological response. As it flies toward its target, each drone
uses a GPS system to determine its location. However, in a bid to disrupt Hamas'
signals for its drones internally and to hinder Hezbollah's drone signals from
the north, Israel has jammed the GPS system in its airspace. Concurrently,
Israel has developed its technology, known as GPS Dome 2, to guide its drones.
On the military front, Israel's focus also turns toward Hezbollah. Israel is
wary of Hezbollah's aerial capabilities, possessing 2,000 combat, surveillance,
and suicide drones used by the party for the first time, according to Israeli
reports. While Hezbollah manufactures some of these drones in Lebanon, the
majority are Iranian-made, capable of replacing warplanes, according to Israeli
website Alma. Despite their small size, their advantage lies in their ability to
carry 20 kilograms of explosives and reach speeds of up to 20 kilometers per
hour. What is most concerning for Israel is Hezbollah's ability to launch dozens
of drones simultaneously due to their small size and low cost, allowing the
party to produce large quantities, according to Tal Amber, an Israeli expert at
the American Institute "Fisher." At that point, it would be difficult for
Israeli defense systems to counter this attack, especially given the challenge
of detecting these drones. In response to this situation, Israel began
developing new defensive systems last month, testing the "Spider" system capable
of dealing with drones, ballistic missiles, and precision-guided munitions.
International Day of the Wheelchair: Highlighting mobility
challenges and accessibility issues in Lebanon
LBCI/March 01/2024
The wheelchair, a tool designed to assist people with mobility challenges, began
with the simple idea of a chair on wheels and evolved with technology to become
more accessible and flexible. This enables people using wheelchairs to integrate
more into society, and opening many paths.
Can you imagine how difficult their lives were before? We visited Sesobel, where
they are celebrating this holiday for the first time, to learn more about it and
its purpose.The International Day of the Wheelchair is a celebration that may be
unfamiliar to some, so let's delve into its significance and purpose. The
concept of the International Day of the Wheelchair was initiated by a British
wheelchair user who aimed to highlight its importance and positive impact on his
life. However, here in Lebanon, we encounter a challenge. The cost of these
chairs can be prohibitive for some. According to Salma Assi, the head of the
Medical Equipment & Device Importers Syndicate, prices range from $100 to $2000.
Beyond the cost issue, Lebanon lacks specific pathways that allow wheelchairs to
access all locations. While many institutions provide these pathways, numerous
public places and institutions must also be equipped with such facilities. Even
if they exist, who is responsible for enforcing the law? These pathways often
become blocked rather than serving as accessible routes.
Kanaan from Bkerke raises alarm on stamp mafia, pushes for
swift government action
NNA/March 01/2024
Maronite Patriarch, Cardinal Mar Bechara Boutros al-Rahi, on Friday met with MP
Ibrahim Kanaan at the Maronite Patriarchate in Bkerke for 40 minutes, followed
by a meeting at the patriarchal residence. In the wake of the meeting Kanaan
said that the focus of his session with the Patriarch was “responsibility”.
“Either we have a state that genuinely and seriously assumes responsibility, or
we merely have stances, displays, and folklore, starting with the primary file,
which is war. The Lebanese people unite in rejecting war, and there are
international atmospheres that help prevent war. What practical measures are
being taken? What is the actual path to implement Resolution 1701 to protect our
people in the south and Lebanon, in parallel with rejecting the massacres
occurring in Gaza, and in full solidarity with the Palestinian people suffering
from Israeli violations? However, there is also the interest of the nation and
the decision that the state must make, with everyone's solidarity, and here lies
the responsibility,” Kanaan said. "The second focus was the financial and
social file, and the outcry we hear from people about the black market. His
Beatitude asked me about this issue. Village mayors may resort to strikes within
days because the official stamp that the state is supposed to print and
distribute is missing, and official financial stamps are distributed in the
black market at exorbitant prices, right in front of government ministries and
centers, without any action being taken. Is this how responsibility should be?
Shouldn't providing stamps legally to alleviate people's suffering, or
suspending their use until they are legally provided, be considered? This outcry
from Lebanese village mayors and citizens is not the responsibility of the
legislator but of the government and the relevant ministers. We are ready to
collaborate with them to alleviate citizens' suffering, but the situation cannot
be left as it is, without initiatives or superficial initiatives and passing the
buck,” Kanaan explained. Regarding the presidential file, the lawmaker stated,
"It is known that procrastination extends and includes all ports, including
local authorities if a president is not elected. What are we waiting for?
Initiatives? While welcoming all initiatives, it is essential to get to the
heart of the matter, and any dialogue must start from the constitution, which
determines the method of electing a president. After a year and a half of
vacancy, it is our duty to determine and decide our options in Parliament. No
one should shut the door on any initiative, and Bkerke welcomes all initiatives,
but time should not be wasted, going from week to week amidst the erosion and
deterioration evident in all financial, social, economic, and political files
and at the level of state institutions.”Kanaan concluded by saying, "This is my
cry from Bkerke, which I share with many citizens, foremost among them His
Beatitude the Patriarch." Responding to a question about who protects the stamp
mafia, Kanaan said, "Allowing this mafia to continue is what sustains it. I have
filed complaints before the judiciary, and it is its duty to determine
responsibilities and hold people accountable. It is the government's duty to
provide official stamps, so why go to the mafia instead of the legitimate
market? This is where the investigation must begin."
UNIFIL troops briefly detained by 'locals' in Hay al-Sellom
Naharnet/March 01/2024
A UNIFIL vehicle lost its way and ended up in the Beirut southern suburb of Hay
al-Sellom on Thursday evening, which sparked an altercation with locals and a
brief detention of the peacekeepers, media reports said. The UNIFIL peacekeepers
were eventually handed over to the Lebanese Army according to al-Mayadeen
television. Other reports said the vehicle was intercepted by Hezbollah members,
who “seized devices and cameras” that were with the troops. “The UNIFIL members
were handed over to Hezbollah’s security committee, which interrogated them,
especially amid the presence of doubts that there were taking footage with the
cameras,” the unconfirmed reports said. Kandice Ardiel, UNIFIL's Deputy
Spokesperson, meanwhile confirmed to LBCI television that on Thursday night, "a
peacekeeping vehicle on a routine logistical movement to Beirut ended up on an
unplanned route."
Ardiel revealed that the vehicle was stopped, adding that the peacekeepers were
detained by local individuals. Fortunately, they were later released, she said.
"We emphasize that, in addition to freedom of movement inside UNIFIL's area of
operations, peacekeepers have the freedom and authorization from the Lebanese
Government to move throughout Lebanon for administrative and logistical
reasons," UNIFIL's Deputy Spokesperson affirmed. She also stressed that "this
freedom of movement is essential to the implementation of Resolution
1701."Similar incidents have frequently happened in south Lebanon in recent
years, but this is the first time such an incident takes place near the capital.
Mikati meets Quintet ambassadors at the Grand Serail
Naharnet/March 01/2024
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati met Friday with the ambassadors of the
five-nation group at the Grand Serail. Egyptian Ambassador Alaa Moussa, U.S.
ambassador Lisa Johnson, French Ambassador Herve Magro, Saudi Ambassador Walid
al-Bukhari, and Qatari Ambassador Sheikh Saud bin Abdul Rahman Al-Thani
discussed the Lebanese presidential impasse with Mikati. Egypt's Ambassador
Moussa said after the meeting that the Quintet's ambassadors are unified and
willing to help the Lebanese end their presidential crisis but that the group
does not discuss or suggest names. "The name of the president must come from
within Lebanon, not from the Quintet," Moussa said. He added that the
presidential election must be separated from the war on Gaza, as cross-border
clashes on the Lebanese-Israeli border escalated in recent days. Crisis-hit
Lebanon has been without a president since Michel Aoun's term ended in October
last year, with neither of the two main blocs -- Hezbollah and its opponents --
having the majority required to elect one. The international community and the
five-nation group have long urged Lebanese leaders to end months of political
wrangling and stem the financial meltdown.
Since October 8, the day after the Israeli war on Gaza erupted, Hezbollah, a
Hamas ally, has exchanged near-daily fire with the Israeli army, stoking fears
of an all-out war.
Gen. Aoun heads to Italy to attend army support meeting
Naharnet/March 01/2024
Army Commander General Joseph Aoun on Friday traveled to Italy at an invitation
from his Italian counterpart Admiral Giuseppe Cavo Dragone, the army said. Aoun
will take part in “a meeting organized by Italian authorities to discuss means
to support the military institution in the face of the current extraordinary
circumstances,” an army statement said. The commanders of the armies of Spain,
Germany, Britain and France will also take part in the meeting.
Bou Habib says Lebanon to respond to Paris' 'good ideas'
next week
Naharnet/March 01, 2024
Caretaker Foreign Minister Abdallah Bou Habib on Friday said that Lebanon wants
a “complete solution” for the border conflict with Israel. “Hezbollah and the
Houthis have announced that they will halt attacks if Israel stops the war on
Gaza,” Bou Habib noted in an interview with al-Jazeera television. “The French
have proposed good ideas that we are studying and will respond to next week,”
Bou Habib added.
“What Israel cares for is the return of residents to the areas from which they
fled in the north,” the minister pointed out. He added: “We want peace on the
border, but we are prepared for war should it be imposed on us.”“Any Israeli
attack on our territory will not be a walk in the park and will lead to a
regional war,” Bou Habib warned. “Foreign envoys conveyed to us Israel’s threat
and our response was that they should withdraw from our land,” he added.
Hezbollah and the Israeli army have traded almost daily fire since the eruption
of the Gaza war. On the Lebanese side, at least 280 people have been killed,
mostly Hezbollah fighters and their allies, along with 44 civilians. On the
Israeli side, the army says 10 soldiers and six civilians have been killed,
while tens of thousands of residents on both sides have been displaced.
Al Jazeera: Bou Habib coordinates with Hezbollah amid
rising tensions with Israel
LBCI/March 01, 2024
Abdallah Bou Habib, the Foreign Minister in the caretaker government, affirmed
that the government is consulting with Hezbollah regarding the prevailing
tensions in the south. Bou Habib told Al Jazeera, "Consultation is binding and
does not imply a final decision."He clarified that international delegates
conveyed Israel's threats, but Lebanon's response was the withdrawal from
Lebanese territories. He emphasized that any Israeli attack on Lebanese
territory would not be a picnic and would lead to a regional war. He called for
peace on the borders and indicated Lebanon's readiness for war if imposed. He
said, "What matters to Israel is the return of residents to the areas they
evacuated in the north."Bou Habib pointed out that the French presented good
ideas that were being studied by the Lebanese side, with a response expected
next week. He called for a comprehensive solution with Israel regarding the
border issue.
The Lebanese Hezbollah has become a criminal Entity
in Kuwait
Joining the organization and cooperating with it is a “crime punishable by law.”
Kuwait: Mirza Al-Khuwailidi / Asharq Al-Awsat / March 2, 2024
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/127535/127535/
The Kuwaiti Court of Cassation, the highest judicial authority in the country,
decided its position on the classification of the Lebanese “Hezbollah”,
considering that this group is “banned and criminal according to the law,” and
it is “an armed organization that plans to demolish the basic systems in Kuwait
to form the greater Iranian republic,” and that the party “An organization that
believes in the Iranian revolution and its principles and seeks to spread them
in Kuwait.” This position removes confusion regarding the legal status of this
Lebanese organization, since those accused of spying with it have repeatedly
defended Kuwait not classifying Hezbollah as a prohibited “terrorist entity.”
The position of the Court of Cassation came in the merits of the ruling
convicting 3 Kuwaiti citizens on charges of spying with the Lebanese Hezbollah,
where the court ruled to cancel their acquittal, but decided to refrain from
pronouncing punishment, while requiring them to “be of good conduct and
conduct,” which is a legal expression that indicates that it is conditional on
their not being involved. Again in a similar case.
However, the court explained that joining the Hezbollah group and cooperating
with it is considered a “crime punishable by law.” The case in which the three
Kuwaitis and a Lebanese woman are being tried goes back to accusations made by
the State Security Service regarding the defendants’ involvement in financing
parties affiliated with the Hezbollah organization and sending money and
donations to them. The case was heard in the Court of Appeal in late 2023, where
an acquittal was issued for 3 defendants, because the court I noticed that it is
not enough for a conviction to be merely supported or purely inclination and
sympathy. Rather, significant evidence is required to prove affiliation with the
party.
However, after the appeals submitted against the appeal ruling, the case was
presented again to the Court of Cassation, where yesterday (Thursday) it ruled
in a final ruling headed by Counselor Abdullah Al-Jassem, canceling the
acquittal of a Lebanese and two Kuwaiti citizens on the charge of collaborating
with “Hezbollah,” and again ruled to convict them, while refraining from
exonerating them. Declare punishment and force them to behave well. But what was
included in the cassation ruling is remarkable, and it established new
principles regarding the classification of the Lebanese “Hezbollah” in Kuwait,
where supporting and financing “Hezbollah” was criminalized, as the court
considered sending financial donations to Lebanon to support “Hezbollah” a crime
punishable by law.
The other matter is that the court classified “Hezbollah” as an armed
organization hostile to Kuwait. The court confirmed that “Hezbollah” “plans to
demolish the basic systems in Kuwait to form the greater Iranian republic, and
it is prohibited and criminalized by law.”
The court also considered that Hezbollah is an organization that seeks to spread
the principles related to the Iranian revolution, an arm of Iran in Islamic and
Arab countries, and an armed organization that relies on violence and force.
The court rejected the defendants’ defense that there is no law in Kuwait that
criminalizes joining Hezbollah, confirming the existence of laws criminalizing
support for terrorist organizations. The court explained in the merits of the
ruling: “The point is in banning any group established in contravention of
Article 30 of Law No. 31 of 1971 amending some The provisions of the Penal Code
No. 16 of 1960 and considering them as illegal groups are based on the purpose
they aim for and the means they take to achieve their goal.”
She also explained that “the organization called (Hezbollah) that the three
defendants joined is an armed organization that works in the interest of the
Republic of Iran, believes in the Iranian Revolution and its principles, and its
purpose is to spread it in the State of Kuwait and all Islamic countries, which
is based, in essence, on the idea of demolishing the basic systems in those
countries.” Through illegal means and by force attacking the existing social and
economic system in order to control it and form the Greater Iranian Republic.”
What applies to the Lebanese Hezbollah also applies to another organization
called “Saraya al-Ashtar,” which is an organization that announced itself in
Bahrain after the events of 2012. One of the three Kuwaiti defendants was
affiliated with this organization, and he also pleaded not to classify it as a
terrorist organization, and the court said. In the merits of the ruling, “it has
been proven from investigations that the group called (Saraya al-Ashtar), which
the first accused joined, follows the same approach.”
She said: “The two organizations’ means of achieving their goals is to call for
the use of force, violence, and illegal means of breaking the law to achieve
their goal, with the knowledge of the defendants who joined them.”
The court added: “What the incident officer testified to, in addition to the
other evidence mentioned above, confirms all the elements of the crime of the
three defendants joining a group prohibited by force of law, and using force and
violence as means to achieve their goals, and therefore the defendants are aware
that this crime does not exist against them.” The failure to issue a law
criminalizing joining the group called (Hezbollah) or the group called (Saraya
al-Ashtar) and not banning these two organizations is not valid for the court to
propose.”
Dealing with Lebanese Hezbollah is the government’s prerogative
Kuwaiti jurist Dr. Muhammad Al-Faily told Asharq Al-Awsat: “The court has the
right to exercise its diligence in deriving its conclusions from the facts,
given that the criminal ruling is based on conviction, and the Kuwaiti criminal
law criminalizes joining parties that call for the demolition of the social and
economic system in Kuwait by force.”He added: “The Lebanese Hezbollah is not a
party to this story, as it is a party licensed in a foreign country that
operates according to its laws and in its territory, but the court says that the
group operating in Kuwait under the name Hezbollah is a group/party calling for
the demolition of the social system in Kuwait by force.” Regarding the impact of
this ruling on dealing with the party in Lebanon, Al-Faili said: “Reading the
ruling in connection with the Lebanese Hezbollah is a political reading, and
deciding the method of dealing with the Lebanese Hezbollah is the government’s
prerogative. Because, according to the constitution, it is the one that manages
the state’s foreign relations file.”
on March 01-02/2024
Hamas armed wing says seven hostages killed in Gaza
CAIRO (Reuters)/March 1, 2024
Seven hostages who have been held in Gaza were killed as a result of the Israeli
military's bombardment of the enclave, Abu Ubaida, the spokesperson for Hamas'
armed wing al-Qassam brigades said on Friday. It was not immediately clear when
the seven died. The Al-Qassam brigades confirmed that the number of hostages
killed due to Israel's military operations in Gaza has now exceeded 70 captives,
Abu Ubaida added in a statement on Telegram. Israel's military campaign follows
Hamas militants' killing of 1,200 people in southern Israel and the abduction of
at least 250 on Oct. 7, according to Israeli tallies. Israel has responded with
a military assault on the Gaza Strip that has killed more than 30,000
Palestinians, according to the Hamas-run health ministry. During a week-long
truce in late November, Hamas freed more than 100 Israeli and foreign hostages
in exchange for Israel releasing about 240 Palestinian prisoners.
Deaths at aid delivery site in Gaza draw condemnation
Agence France Presse
Israeli troops in the northern Gaza Strip opened fire on Palestinians scrambling
for food aid on Thursday, in a chaotic incident that the health ministry in the
Hamas-run territory said killed more than 100 people. There were conflicting
reports about how the pre-dawn incident unfolded. The Israeli military said a
"stampede" occurred when thousands of Gazans surrounded a convoy of 38 aid
trucks, leading to dozens of deaths and injuries, including some people being
run over. An Israeli source said troops had opened fire on the crowd, believing
it "posed a threat". The Gaza health ministry condemned the "massacre" in Gaza
City, saying 112 people were killed and more than 750 wounded. Reactions to the
deaths have poured in from around the world.
U.S. 'pressing for answers' -
U.S. President Joe Biden said the incident would complicate delicate ceasefire
negotiations in the almost five-month-old war, with the White House calling the
deaths "tremendously alarming". State Department spokesman Matthew Miller said
the United States was "urgently seeking additional information on exactly what
took place". Washington will be monitoring an upcoming investigation closely and
"pressing for answers", he said.
France says fire 'unjustifiable' -
France's foreign ministry said "the fire by Israeli soldiers against civilians
trying to access food is unjustifiable". The "tragic event" came as an
"increasing and unbearable number of Palestinian civilians" were suffering from
hunger and disease, it added, saying Israel must abide by international law and
protect aid deliveries to civilians. Writing on the social media platform X that
Palestinian "civilians have been targeted by Israeli soldiers", French President
Emmanuel Macron expressed his "strongest condemnation" of the killings.
Turkey condemns 'crime against humanity' - Turkey accused Israel of committing
"another crime against humanity" and condemning Gazans to "famine" as civilians
scavenge for dwindling supplies of food.
"The fact that Israel... this time targets innocent civilians in a queue for
humanitarian aid, is evidence that (Israel) aims consciously and collectively to
destroy the Palestinian people", the Turkish foreign ministry said.
Colombia scraps Israel arms purchases -
Colombia's President Gustavo Petro denounced what he called a "genocide" of the
Palestinian people and suspended purchases of weapons from Israel, a key
supplier of his country's security forces. "Asking for food, more than 100
Palestinians were killed by (Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin) Netanyahu. This is
called genocide and recalls the Holocaust," Petro wrote on X.
"The world must block Netanyahu."
Spain condemns 'unacceptable' incident -
"The unacceptable nature of what happened in Gaza, with dozens of Palestinian
civilians dead as they were waiting for food, underlines the urgency of a
ceasefire," Spanish Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Albares wrote on X.
Italy demands 'immediate ceasefire' -
Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani called for an "immediate ceasefire" in
Gaza and urged Israel to protect the Palestinian population after the "tragic
deaths".
"We strongly urge Israel to protect the people in Gaza and to rigorously
ascertain facts and responsibilities," he said on X. Prime Minister Giorgia
Meloni expressed her "deep dismay and concern" over the violence.
U.N. condemnation
U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres condemned the incident and was "appalled
by the tragic human toll of the conflict", his spokesman Stephane Dujarric said.
"The desperate civilians in Gaza need urgent help, including those in the
besieged north where the United Nations has not been able to deliver aid in more
than a week," Dujarric said.
EU decries 'carnage' -
European Union foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell denounced the deaths as
"totally unacceptable". "I am horrified by news of yet another carnage among
civilians in Gaza desperate for humanitarian aid," he said on X.
Qatar denounces 'heinous massacre' -
Qatar's foreign ministry condemned "in the strongest terms the heinous massacre
committed by the Israeli occupation", calling for "urgent international action"
to halt the fighting in Gaza. It went on to warn that Israel's "disregard for
Palestinian lives... will ultimately undermine international efforts aimed at
implementing the two-state solution, and thus pave the way for the expansion of
the cycle of violence in the region".
Saudi calls for ceasefire -
Saudi Arabia's foreign ministry condemned the deaths and reiterated "the need to
reach an immediate ceasefire". It also renewed its "demands to the international
community to take a firm position to oblige Israel to respect international
humanitarian law, immediately open safe humanitarian corridors, allow the
evacuation of the injured, and enable the delivery of relief aid".
China shocked, condemns deaths -
Foreign ministry spokeswoman Chinese Mao Ning said China was shocked by the
incident and strongly condemned the killing of Palestinians during an aid
delivery.
"China urges the relevant parties, especially Israel, to cease fire and end the
fighting immediately, earnestly protect civilians' safety, ensure that
humanitarian aid can enter, and avoid an even more serious humanitarian
disaster," Mao said.
Australia 'horrified' -
Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong said her country was "horrified by
today's catastrophe in Gaza and the ongoing humanitarian crisis that has led to
it".
"These events underscore why for months Australia has been calling for an
immediate humanitarian ceasefire in Gaza," she said. "I have instructed my
department to express Australia's views directly to the Israeli ambassador."
EU clears 50-mn-euro payment to UNRWA
Agence France Presse/March 01/2024
The European Commission announced Friday it was clearing a 50-million-euro ($54
million) payment to the U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees UNRWA, which was
under review following Israeli claims its staff participated in Hamas's October
7 attack. Commission spokesman Eric Mamer told reporters the funds would be
released "early next week" after UNRWA agreed to a "series of conditions"
including an EU-led audit, with a further 32 million euros to follow later. The
Commission also decided Friday to allocate an additional 68-million-euro to
support the Palestinian population across the region to be implemented through
international partners like the Red Cross and the Red Crescent. "The Commission
will proceed to paying 50-million-euro of the UNRWA envelope next week," the
European Commission said, adding that UNRWA has indicated that it stands ready
to ensure that a review of its staff is carried out to confirm they did not
participate in the October 7 attacks and that further controls are put in place
to mitigate such risks in the future. "UNRWA has agreed to the launch of an
audit of the Agency to be conducted by EU appointed external experts. This audit
will review the control systems to prevent the possible involvement of its staff
and assets in terrorist activities," the Commission said in a statement. "On
this basis, and following the exchange of letters with UNRWA confirming its
commitments, the Commission will proceed disburse a first tranche of
50-million-euro out of the 82-million-euro foreseen for UNRWA for 2024," the
statement said. The Commission said that it will allocate an additional
68-million-euro for in 2024, as it "remains fully committed to addressing the
humanitarian plight of the Palestinian people, particularly in Gaza but also
more widely in the region.""We stand by the Palestinian people in Gaza and
elsewhere in the region. Innocent Palestinians should not have to pay the price
for the crimes of terrorist group Hamas. They face terrible conditions putting
their lives at risk because of lack of access to sufficient food and other basic
needs. That is why we are reinforcing our support to them this year by a further
68-million-euro,” the Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said.
WHO says Gaza health system in Gaza 'more than on its knees'
GENEVA (Reuters)/March 1, 2024
People in the Gaza Strip are risking their lives to find food, water and other
supplies such is the level of hunger and despair amid the unrelenting Israeli
assault, the World Health Organization (WHO) said on Friday. "The system in Gaza
is on its knees, it's more than on its knees," WHO spokesperson Christian
Lindmeier told reporters in Geneva. "All the lifelines in Gaza have more or less
been cut."Lindmeier said this had created a "desperate situation", as seen on
Thursday, when more than 100 people seeking humanitarian aid in Gaza were
killed. Gaza health authorities said Israeli forces shot dead the Palestinians
as they waited for an aid delivery. Israel blamed the deaths on crowds that
surrounded the aid trucks, saying victims had been trampled or run over. "People
are so desperate for food, for fresh water, for any supplies that they risk
their lives in getting any food, any supplies to support their children, to
support themselves," Lindmeier said. While aid is reaching southern parts of the
Gaza Strip, it is too slow to avert a hunger crisis even there. Aid barely makes
it to northern areas that are further from the main border crossing and only
accessible through more active battle fronts. "The food supplies have been cut
off deliberately. Let's not forget that," Lindmeier said. Israel has said the
failure to get enough aid into Gaza to meet humanitarian needs is due to U.N.
distribution failures. A senior U.N. aid official told the U.N. Security Council
on Tuesday that one quarter of the population of Gaza is one step away from
famine and widespread famine could be "almost inevitable" without action.
The EU says it will send funds to Gaza's main aid provider
after the UN agency agrees to an audit
BRUSSELS (AP/March 1, 2024
The European Union said Friday that it will pay 50 million euros ($54 million)
to the main provider of aid in Gaza next week after the cash-strapped U.N.
agency agreed to allow EU-appointed experts to audit the way it screens staff to
identify extremists. The UNRWA agency is reeling from allegations that 12 of its
13,000 Gaza staff members participated in the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks in southern
Israel. The agency fired the employees, but more than a dozen countries
suspended funding worth about $450 million, almost half its budget for 2024. The
Israel-Hamas war has driven 80% of Gaza’s population of 2.3 million Palestinians
from their homes, and U.N. officials say a quarter of the population is
starving. The agency is the main supplier of food, water and shelter, but it is
also on the brink of financial collapse. The European Commission had been due to
disburse 82 million euros ($89 million) to UNRWA on Feb. 29, but wanted the
agency to accept its terms for an audit. The EU's powerful executive branch is
the third biggest donor to UNRWA after the United States and Germany. The
commission said the agency has now “indicated that it stands ready to ensure
that a review of its staff is carried out to confirm they did not participate in
the attacks and that further controls are put in place to mitigate such risks in
the future.” The commission said the funds will be dispatched next week once
UNRWA has confirmed in writing that it accepts the EU's conditions. Two further
tranches worth 16 million euros ($17.3 million) each will be given to UNRWA as
it complies with their agreement. In a post on X, formerly Twitter, UNRWA
Commissioner-General Philippe Lazzarini welcomed the EU’s announcement and said
that the commitment to provide money next week “comes at a critical time.”
“The full disbursement of the EU contribution is key to the agency’s ability to
maintain its operations in a very volatile area,” he tweeted. Israel has long
accused UNRWA of tolerating or even collaborating with Hamas activities in or
around U.N. facilities, but no one — in Israel or abroad — has offered an
alternative for delivering aid to Gaza’s besieged population. UNRWA took the
unusual step of immediately firing its staffers based on Israel’s allegations
against them, but with no hard evidence being provided. Each year, UNRWA gives a
list of its staff to the Israeli authorities for vetting, and the agency said it
has received no complaints. Two U.N. investigations into Israel’s allegations
against the agency are already underway. Even as the commission was negotiating
the terms of its audit, Crisis Management Commissioner Janez Lenarčič told EU
lawmakers this week that “we have not received any evidence supporting the
allegations by Israel that UNWRA’s staff were involved in the terrible events on
7 October.”“To our knowledge, none of the donors — other donors — have received
any evidence,” he added. Belgian Development Minister Caroline Gennez, whose
country currently holds the EU's rotating presidency, tweeted on Friday that
UNRWA “is the only organization that can structurally get humanitarian aid to
Palestinians. Defunding would mean a death sentence for tens of thousands.”The
funding dispute comes a day after witnesses said that Israeli troops had fired
on a crowd of Palestinians racing to pull food off an aid convoy in Gaza City.
More than 100 people were killed in the chaos. The death toll since October
stands at more than 30,000, according to health officials. The Hamas attack into
Israel that ignited the war killed 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and the
militants seized around 250 hostages. Hamas and other militants are still
holding around 100 hostages and the remains of about 30 more, after releasing
most other captives during a November cease-fire.
Calls for probe, ceasefire follow Israeli gunfire near aid
convoy
AFP/March 01, 2024
GAZA STRIP, Palestinian Territories: World leaders on Friday called for an
investigation and a ceasefire nearly five months into the Gaza war, a day after
dozens of desperate Palestinians were killed rushing an aid convoy. Israeli
troops opened fire as Palestinian civilians scrambled for food aid during a
chaotic incident Thursday which the Hamas-run territory’s health ministry said
killed more than 100 people in Gaza City. The deaths came after a World Food
Programme official had warned: “If nothing changes, a famine is imminent in
northern Gaza.”The Israeli military said a “stampede” occurred when thousands of
Gazans surrounded the convoy of 38 aid trucks, leading to dozens of deaths and
injuries, including some who were run over. An Israeli source acknowledged
troops had opened fire on the crowd, believing it “posed a threat.”Gaza’s health
ministry called it a “massacre” and said 112 people were killed and more than
750 others wounded. The fatalities helped push the total number of Palestinian
war dead in Gaza to 30,228 mostly women and children, according to the
ministry’s latest toll. Overnight Thursday-Friday 83 people were killed in
strikes, the ministry said.
The war began on October 7 with an unprecedented Hamas attack on southern Israel
that resulted in the deaths of about 1,160 people, mostly civilians, Israeli
figures show. Israel’s military says 242 soldiers have died in Gaza since ground
operations began in late October. “The Israeli army must fully investigate how
the mass panic and shooting could have happened,” German Foreign Minister
Annalena Baerbock wrote on social media platform X. Her French counterpart
Stephane Sejourne said: “there will have to be an independent probe to determine
what happened,” and Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani urged Israel “to
protect the people in Gaza and to rigorously ascertain facts and
responsibilities.” European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen, also writing
on X, said “every effort must be made to investigate what happened and ensure
transparency.”
The head of Libya’s Presidential Council, Mohamed el-Manfi, appealed for “an
urgent investigation” by the United Nations Security Council into the
“unprecedented crime.” US President Joe Biden — whose country provides billions
of dollars in military aid to Israel — said Washington was checking “two
competing versions” of the incident. Aerial footage of the incident made clear
“just how desperate the situation on the ground is,” a US State Department
spokesman said. Washington was pushing Israel to allow in more aid, he said.
The Gaza City aid incident came with talks progressing toward a ceasefire, but
would now complicate those efforts, Biden said. The White House later said it
had asked Israel to probe the “tremendously alarming” deaths. Deputy press
secretary Olivia Dalton said the event “needs to be thoroughly investigated.”
Qatar’s foreign ministry condemned “in the strongest terms the heinous massacre
committed by the Israeli occupation” and called for “urgent international
action” to halt the fighting in Gaza. Further afield, in South America,
Colombian President Gustavo Petro announced the suspension of arms purchases
from Israel after the “genocide” in Gaza City. While the situation is
particularly acute in Gaza’s north, Gazans are struggling for food, water and
medical care throughout the territory including in far-south Rafah where around
1.4 million people have sought refuge from fighting elsewhere.
Israel is threatening to send in troops against Hamas fighters in Rafah.
Information conflicted on what exactly unfolded in Gaza City.
A witness, declining to be named for safety reasons, said the violence began
when thousands of people rushed toward aid trucks, leading soldiers to open fire
when “people came too close” to tanks.Israeli army spokesman Rear Admiral Daniel
Hagari said the military had fired “a few warning shots” to try to disperse a
“mob” that had “ambushed” the aid trucks. “Thousands of Gazans” swarmed the
trucks, “violently pushing and even trampling other Gazans to death, looting the
humanitarian supplies,” he said. When the crowd got too big, he said the convoy
tried to retreat and “the unfortunate incident resulted in dozens of Gazans
killed and injured.” Aerial images released by the Israeli army showed what it
said were scores of people surrounding aid trucks in the city. Ali Awad Ashqir,
who said he had gone to get some food for his starving family, told AFP he had
been waiting for two hours when trucks began to arrive.
“The moment they arrived, the occupation army fired artillery shells and guns,”
he said. Hagari denied Israeli forces carried out any shelling or strikes at the
time. Looting of aid trucks has previously occurred in northern Gaza, where
residents have taken to eating animal fodder and even leaves to stave off
starvation. The chief of the United Nations agency for Palestinian refugees,
UNRWA, said no UN agency had been involved in Thursday’s aid delivery, and
called the incident “another day from hell.”Among its war aims, Israel says it
is fighting to bring home 130 hostages captured by militants on October 7 who
remain in Gaza, including 31 presumed dead. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu has come under increasing pressure over the captives. On Friday
relatives and supporters of the hostages rallied outside the US embassy branch
in Tel Aviv in a call for help to secure their release. At another protest in
the city on Thursday night, Alon Lee Green, 36, said things were at a
crossroads. “It’s either we are going into an eternal war that will never stop,”
he said, “or we’re going to a diplomatic agreement, an Israeli-Palestinian
peace.”
Hamas, other Palestinian groups stress 'unity' at Moscow
talks
Agence France Presse/March 01/2024
Palestinian factions including rivals Hamas and Fatah said on Friday they would
pursue "unity of action" in confronting Israel after representatives met at
Russia-hosted talks. The meeting in Moscow on Thursday brought together Hamas,
Islamic Jihad, Fatah and other Palestinian groups for talks on the war in Gaza
and an eventual post-war period. It came on the heels of the resignation of the
Palestinian Authority government, which is led by Fatah and based in the
occupied West Bank. Outgoing prime minister Mohammad Shtayyeh called for
intra-Palestinian consensus as he announced the resignation, and some analysts
said the development could pave the way for a government of technocrats that
could operate in the West Bank and Hamas-run Gaza after the war. Arab and
Western leaders have been pushing for reforms to the Palestinian Authority as
they discuss possible reconstruction efforts. A statement on Friday by the
Palestinian factions represented in Moscow said there would be an "upcoming
dialogue" to bring them under the banner of the Palestine Liberation
Organization (PLO). Thursday's "constructive" talks saw agreement on points
including the need for the withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza and the
creation of a Palestinian state, the statement said. While Hamas and Islamic
Jihad are considered "terrorist" entities by Western powers, the PLO is
internationally recognised as representing Palestinians in the Palestinian
territories and diaspora. Discussions in recent years about integrating Hamas
into the PLO have ended in failure. In recent years, Moscow has strived to
maintain good relations with all actors in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict,
including Fatah and Hamas. Russia's relations with Israel have become strained
amid Moscow's criticism of Israeli actions in Gaza and rejection of a
Palestinian state. The war in Gaza was triggered by Hamas's October 7 attack on
Israel that resulted in the deaths of about 1,160 people, mostly civilians,
according to an AFP tally based on official Israeli figures. At least 30,228
people, mostly women and children, have been killed in Israel's retaliatory
military offensive in Gaza, according to the health ministry in the Hamas-run
territory.
Media leaders express support for journalists in Gaza
Associated Press/March 01/2024
Three dozen leaders at news organizations around the world have signed a letter
expressing solidarity with journalists in Gaza, calling for their safety and
freedom to report in the war zone. The letter, released Thursday, was
spearheaded by the Committee to Protect Journalists, which said at least 89
journalists and media workers have been killed in the Israel-Hamas war, the vast
majority of them Palestinians. Leaders at The Associated Press, The New York
Times, The Washington Post, Los Angeles Times, Reuters, New Yorker, CNN, NBC
News and ABC News have signed on. International signatories include the BBC, Der
Spiegel in Germany, Agence France-Presse, Daily Maverick in South Africa,
Nawaiwaqt Group in Pakistan and The Asahi Shimbun in Japan. More organizations
are welcome to participate, said Jodie Ginsberg, CEO of the Committee to Protect
Journalists. "We felt that it was important that we show that the international
journalism community stands in solidarity with our Palestinian colleagues,"
Ginsberg said. The letter says that journalists are civilians and that Israeli
authorities must protect them as noncombatants in accordance with international
law. Anyone violating this should be held accountable, it said. "Attacks on
journalists are also attacks on truth," the letter said. "We commit to
championing the safety of journalists in Gaza, which is fundamental for the
protection of press freedom everywhere."Israel is only mentioned once in the
letter. While CPJ has advocated for more access for journalists in Gaza, the
letter steered clear of that subject because it was important to focus on
solidarity, Ginsberg said. She would not comment on whether any news
organization contacted chose not to participate.
Humanitarian crisis: Why have most countries opted to
deliver airlifted aid?
LBCI/March 01/2024
After five months of Israeli aggression on Gaza, the situation in the territory
has reached a critical point. According to the United Nations, nearly a quarter
of Gaza's population is now on the brink of famine, with humanitarian aid
entering the region dropping by 50% in February compared to the previous month.
To alleviate the suffering of Gaza's residents, Jordan, along with other Arab
and foreign countries, resorted to conducting airlift operations to deliver aid
to Gaza. These aid packages include essential relief supplies and food items.
Will these airborne deliveries adequately meet the needs of Gaza's population?
While aid deliveries have primarily focused on the southern regions of Gaza,
where many Palestinians have sought refuge due to the destruction and Israeli
siege, recent operations have targeted the northern areas, which have also been
severely affected by the crisis. How are these operations conducted, especially
amid reports of potential US involvement in future aid drops? Critics have
raised concerns about the indiscriminate method of these aid deliveries, with
reports suggesting that much of the aid ends up in the sea and fails to reach
those most in need. Why have most countries opted to deliver airlifted aid?
Several countries have opted for airlift operations due to Israeli obstacles to
land-based aid deliveries, using this as leverage against Hamas. Israel also
favors this method as it ensures that aid deliveries do not contain weapons
intended for Hamas, further complicating the situation in the region.
Biden announces US airdrops of humanitarian assistance
into Gaza
Jennifer Hansler and Kevin Liptak, CNN/March 1, 2024
The United States will begin air dropping food aid to the people of Gaza,
President Joe Biden announced Friday, as the humanitarian crisis deepens and
Israel continues to resist opening additional land crossings to allow more
assistance into the war-torn strip. Speaking in the Oval Office, Biden said the
US would be “pulling out every stop” to get additional aid into Gaza, which has
been under heavy bombardment by Israel since the October 7 Hamas terror attacks.
“Aid flowing to Gaza is nowhere nearly enough,” the US president said, noting
that “hundreds of trucks” should be entering the enclave.
Biden said the US is “going to insist that Israel facilitate more trucks and
more routes to get more and more people the help they need, no excuses.”He also
noted the efforts to broker a deal to free the hostages and secure an “immediate
ceasefire” that would allow additional aid in. The US military is working to
carry out the airdrops in the coming days, a US official told CNN. The
announcement of the US airdrops is an acknowledgment of the dire situation in
Gaza, where more than a hundred people were killed Thursday where Israeli troops
opened fire as people waited for a food convoy in the north.
Aid trucks tried to escape the area, accidentally ramming others and causing
further deaths and injuries, the eyewitnesses added to CNN. The airdrops will
provide some relief to those on the ground. However, their use is highly
unlikely to bring about a sustainable solution for the humanitarian crisis in
Gaza, as each drop can only bring in a fraction of the amount of aid that could
be transported into the enclave by trucks. Instead, their use underscores the
devastating impact of the Israeli government’s ongoing refusal to open more land
crossings for the critically needed aid. The US’ calls for the Netanyahu
government to open more crossings in the north have thus far failed. In the
south, the number of trucks entering the war-torn strip trickled to just 85 per
day last week. Biden made the announcement as his administration faces sharp
domestic criticism for its handling of the conflict – criticism that has had
political consequences for the president during an election year.
National Security Council spokesman John Kirby described airdrops as “a
supplement to, not a replacement for, moving things in by ground.”State
Department spokesperson Matt Miller said Thursday that air drops “would help
immediately.”“But the real solution here to this is to try to get – or to get, I
should say – an agreement that would dramatically increase the flow of
assistance in and help with the distribution problems and help with the problem
that civilians face of being able to move safely to get to aid when it actually
does make it in,” Miller said at a department briefing. Earlier this week,
Jordan, Egypt, the UAE, Qatar and France airdropped relief aid on various areas
in the Gaza Strip in a sign of how desperate the situation has become.
Palestinians run along a street as humanitarian aid from Jordan is airdropped in
Gaza .There are discussions with Israel and other stakeholders about a potential
maritime corridor for humanitarian aid into Gaza, Kirby confirmed Friday.
However, numerous logistical challenges would need to be addressed for the
corridor to actually be operational, a US official told CNN. Senior US officials
have repeatedly pressed Israeli officials in face-to-face meetings on the urgent
need to open additional crossings. “This is a matter of life and death,” said
USAID Administrator Samantha Power, who met on Wednesday with Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu and Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant. Power announced
$53 million in additional humanitarian aid during her travels in the region this
week. US officials have also held ongoing conversations with Israeli officials
about the need to ensure the safety of humanitarian aid workers once they enter
Gaza. “The aid workers who on the ground in Gaza are risking their lives to get
food to people in desperate, desperate need, those aid workers have to be
protected. They have to know they can do their jobs without being shot at and
killed,” Power said on Tuesday. Convoys have come under attack within the
enclave, both “by desperate mobs” and “by criminal elements,” US envoy for
Middle East humanitarian issues David Satterfield said last month. Israeli
forces targeted members of the Hamas-run police force that travels with the UN
aid convoys in an effort to protect them from looting, which has led the police
to stop protecting the convoys, Satterfield said. “With the departure of police
escorts, it has been virtually impossible for the UN or anyone else – Jordan,
the UAE, any other implementer – to safely move assistance in Gaza because of
criminal gangs,” he said.
Netanyahu says he will pave way to end exemption for
ultra-Orthodox from military service
REUTERS/March 01, 2024
JERUSALEM: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Thursday his government
would find a way to end exemptions for ultra-Orthodox Jews from Israeli military
service in the face of political pressures that threaten his narrow coalition’s
future. “We will determine goals for conscripting ultra-Orthodox people to the
IDF and national civil service,” Netanyahu said at a press conference, referring
to the Israel Defense Forces. “We will also determine the ways to implement
those goals.”Israel’s Supreme Court in 2018 voided a law waiving the draft for
ultra-Orthodox men, citing a need for the burden of military service to be
shared across Israeli society. Parliament failed to come up with a new
arrangement, and a government-issued stay on mandatory conscription of
ultra-Orthodox expires in March. Ultra-Orthodox parties have helped Netanyahu
hold a narrow parliamentary majority alongside far-right nationalist parties but
in past governments have made draft exemption a condition for remaining in the
coalition. Netanyahu appeared to be responding to a pledge made by his defense
minister to veto a law that would allow the continuation of exemptions unless
the government reached an agreement paving a path for ultra-Orthodox enlistment.
“We recognize and support those who dedicate their life to studying Jewish holy
scripture but, with that, without physical existence there is no spiritual
existence,” Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said on Wednesday. The
exemptions granted to ultra-Orthodox Jews have been a longstanding source of
friction with more secular citizens now stoked by the country’s costly
mobilization for the Gaza war. The ultra-Orthodox claim the right to study in
seminaries instead of serving in uniform for the standard three years. Some say
their pious lifestyles would clash with military mores, while others voice
ideological opposition to the liberal state. Ultra-Orthodox Jews make up 13
percent of Israel’s population, a figure expected to reach 19 percent by 2035
due to their high birth rates. Economists argue that the draft exemption keeps
some of them unnecessarily in seminaries and out of the workforce.
Iran votes in its first parliament election since 2022
protests as questions over turnout loom
DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP)/March 01, 2024
Iran on Friday held the country's first parliamentary election since the mass
2022 protests over mandatory hijab laws after the death in police custody of
Mahsa Amini, with questions looming over just how many people will turn out at
the polls. Iranian officials and even Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei have
urged the public to cast ballots, but polling stations in the country's capital,
Tehran, appeared to see few voters. Authorities have largely barred politicians
calling for any change within the country's theocracy, known broadly as
reformists, from running in the election — leaving mostly only a broad slate of
conservative or hard-line figures. Iran's economy continues to stagnate under
Western sanctions over Tehran's rapidly advancing nuclear program and the
country's arming of militia proxies in the Middle East and Russia in its war on
Ukraine. Some of the voters acknowledged the challenges facing the Islamic
Republic. “There are many problems; too many problems," said one voter, who just
gave her last name, Sajjad. "We are sad, we are sorrowful and we voice our
criticism as much as we can. God willing, those responsible (will) start
thinking about us, and probably many of them do care.”Khamenei, 84, cast one of
the first votes in an election that also will see new members elected to the
country's Assembly of Experts. The panel of clerics, who serve an eight-year
term, is mandated to select a new supreme leader if Khamenei steps down or dies,
underscoring the panel's increased importance, given Khamenei's age.
Khamenei voted before a crowd of journalists in Tehran, his left hand slightly
shaking as he took his ballot from his right, paralyzed since a 1981 bombing.
State television showed one woman nearby weeping as she filmed Khamenei with her
mobile phone. He urged people to vote as soon as possible in the election,
saying that both Iran's friends and enemies were watching the turnout. “Pay
attention to this, make friends happy and disappoint the evil-wishers,” he said
in brief remarks by the ballot boxes. Khamenei's protégé, hard-line President
Ebrahim Raisi, repeated that call and urged the public to make "a glorious day
for the Iranian nation.”Some 15,000 candidates are vying for a seat in the
290-member parliament, formally known as the Islamic Consultative Assembly. Out
of them, only 116 are considered as relatively moderate or pro-reform
candidates. Those demanding radical changes are banned or didn't bother to
register given widespread disqualifications by authorities. Parliament terms run
for four years, and five seats are reserved for Iran’s religious minorities.
Under the law, the parliament has oversight over the executive branch, votes on
treaties and handles other issues. In practice, absolute power in Iran rests
with its supreme leader. Hard-liners have controlled the parliament for the past
two decades — with chants of “Death to America” often heard from the floor.
Under Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Qalibaf, a former Revolutionary Guard
general who supported a violent crackdown on Iranian university students in
1999, the legislature pushed forward a bill in 2020 that greatly curtailed
Tehran’s cooperation with the United Nations nuclear watchdog, the International
Atomic Energy Agency. That followed then-President Donald Trump’s unilateral
withdrawal of America from Iran’s nuclear deal with world powers in 2018 — an
act that sparked years of tensions in the Middle East and saw Iran enrich enough
uranium at record-breaking purity to have enough fuel for “several” nuclear
weapons if it chose. More recently, the parliament has focused on issues
surrounding Iran’s mandatory head covering, or hijab, for women after the 2022
death of 22-year-old Amini in police custody, which sparked nationwide protests.
The protests quickly escalated into calls to overthrow Iran’s clerical rulers. A
subsequent security crackdown killed over 500 people, with more than 22,000
detained. Calls for an election boycott have spread in recent weeks, including
from imprisoned Nobel Peace Prize laureate Narges Mohammadi, a women’s right
activist, who called them a “sham.”The boycott calls have put the government
under renewed pressure — since its 1979 Islamic Revolution, Iran’s theocracy has
based its legitimacy in part on turnout in elections.
The state-owned polling center ISPA hadn't put out election data prior to the
vote until Thursday, something highly unusual as their figures typically get
released much earlier. Its polling, based on a survey of 5,121 voting-age
people, predicted a turnout of 23.5% in the capital, Tehran, and 38.5%
nationally. It said the margin of error in the poll was 2%. Iranian state
television showed crowded polling stations but elsewhere, there appeared to be
few voters braving the freezing temperatures in Tehran. In one place, a young
woman without a hijab and her mother, wearing one, entered teh polling station
together. There was no comment from officials or police on hand. “I accompanied
my mother who wanted to vote just to remind authorities about last year’s
crackdown," said the daughter, who gave her first name, Zohreh. Her mother voted
for a relative moderate running in their district, while Zohreh declined to cast
a ballot, she said. Meanwhile, a heavy security presence could be seen across
the capital, with ordinary and anti-riot police officers visible in main squares
and junctions. Some 200,000 security forces have been deployed across the
country as over 59,000 polling stations opened. Another 1 million people
reportedly are running the election, home to some 85 million people. Estimates
put the voting-age population at 61 million. Polling places will be open until 6
p.m. local time (1430 GMT), though Iran typically extends voting at the last
minute. Initial election results are expected as early as Saturday.
Iran hard-liners set to tighten grip in election amid voter apathy
REUTERS/March 01, 2024
DUBAI: Iranians voted for a new parliament on Friday in an election seen as a
test of the clerical establishment’s legitimacy at a time of growing frustration
over economic woes and restrictions on political and social freedoms.
Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who has called voting a religious duty,
was the first to cast his vote in Iran. “Vote as soon as possible ... today the
eyes of Iran’s friends and ill-wishers are on the results. Make friends happy
and disappoint enemies,” Khamenei said on state television. The election is the
first formal measure of public opinion after anti-government protests in 2022-23
spiralled into some of the worst political turmoil since the 1979 Islamic
Revolution. Iran’s rulers need a high turnout to repair their legitimacy, badly
damaged by the unrest. But official surveys suggest only about 41 percent of
eligible Iranians will vote. Turnout hit a record low of 42.5 percent in the
2020 parliamentary election, while about 62 percent of voters participated in
2016. State TV, portraying a general enthusiastic mood with live coverage from
across Iran interspersed with patriotic songs, aired footage of people braving
snow to vote in some towns and villages. Several people told state TV that they
were voting “to make the supreme leader happy.” Over 15,000 candidates were
running for the 290-seat parliament. Partial results may appear on Saturday.
Activists and opposition groups were distributing the hashtags #VOTENoVote and #ElectionCircus
widely on the social media platform X, arguing that a high turnout would
legitimize the Islamic Republic. Officials said the participation was “good,”
state media reported, but witnesses said most polling centers in Tehran and
several other cities were lightly attended. A two-hour extension of voting
announced by state TV was followed shortly by another two-hour extension —
taking the close of voting to 18.30 GMT — to allow late-comers to cast ballots.
“I am not voting for a regime that has restricted my social freedoms. Voting is
meaningless,” said teacher Reza, 35, in the northern city of Sari. Imprisoned
Nobel Peace Prize laureate Narges Mohammadi, a women’s rights advocate, has
called the election a “sham.”
ECONOMIC CRISIS AND CRACKDOWN ON UNREST IN FOCUS
The parliament, dominated for over two decades by political hard-liners within
the religious Islamic Republic, has negligible impact on foreign policy or a
nuclear program that Iran says is peaceful but the West says is aimed at making
nuclear arms — issues determined by Khamenei. With heavyweight moderates and
conservatives staying out and reformists calling the election unfree and unfair,
the contest is essentially among hard-liners and low-key conservatives who
proclaim loyalty to Islamic revolutionary ideals. Pro-reform Iranians have
painful memories of the handling of nationwide unrest sparked by the death in
custody of a young Iranian-Kurdish woman in 2022, which was quelled by a violent
crackdown involving mass detentions and even executions.
Economic hardships pose another challenge.
Many analysts say large numbers of Iranians no longer think the ruling clerics
capable of solving an economic crisis caused by a mix of mismanagement,
corruption and US sanctions — reimposed since 2018 when Washington ditched
Tehran’s nuclear pact with six world powers. Efforts to revive the 2015 nuclear
pact have failed. The election comes at a time of huge tension in the Middle
East, as Israel fights the Iranian-backed Palestinian Islamist group Hamas in
Gaza, and other groups backed by Tehran attacking ships in the Red Sea and
Israeli and US targets in the region.
Khamenei has accused Iran’s “enemies” — a term he normally uses for the United
States and Israel — of trying to create despair among Iranian voters. The
parliamentary election is twinned with a vote for the 88-seat Assembly of
Experts, an influential body that has the task of choosing the 84-year-old
Khamenei’s successor.
Grammy-winning Iranian singer, awarded over Mahsa Amini protest anthem,
sentenced to prison
AP/March 01, 2024
DUBAI: An Iranian singer who won a Grammy presented by US first lady Jill Biden
has been sentenced to more than three years in prison over his anthem supporting
the 2022 protests over the death of Mahsa Amini. Shervin Hajjipour posted on
Instagram on Friday, the same day that Iran held its parliamentary election,
what appeared to be part of the judgment against him. It said Hajjipour received
a three-year, eight-month sentence on charges of “propaganda against the system”
and “encouraging people to protest.” The court issued its sentence in part
because it found he hadn’t properly expressed regret over publishing the song.
It also imposed a two-year travel ban and ordered him to create a song about “US
crimes,” as well as make posts about those crimes online. Hajjipour thanked his
lawyers and his agent for their support. “I will not mention the name of the
judge and the prosecutor so that they don’t get insulted and threatened, because
insults and threats are not in the religion of humanity,” he wrote. “Finally,
one day we will understand each other. Until then.” Hajjipour already had served
some prison time, but was out on bail pending the court’s decision. It was
unclear if he had already reported to serve his sentence.
Iranian state-run media, focused on the election Friday, didn’t note Hajjipour’s
sentence. Iran’s mission to the United Nations in New York didn’t respond to a
request for comment. Hajjipour’s song “Baraye,” or “For” in English, begins
with: “For dancing in the streets,” “for the fear we feel when we kiss.” The
lyrics list reasons that young Iranians posted online for why they had protested
against Iran’s ruling theocracy after Amini’s death in September 2022, allegedly
for not wearing her mandated headscarf to the liking of security forces. The
protests quickly escalated into calls to overthrow Iran’s clerical rulers. A
subsequent security crackdown killed more than 500 people, with more than 22,000
detained. Jill Biden awarded Hajjipour the Grammy’s new song for social change
special merit award during the ceremony last year. “This song became the anthem
of the Mahsa Amini protests, a powerful and poetic call for freedom and women’s
rights,” Biden said at the ceremony. “Shervin was arrested, but this song
continues to resonate around the world with its powerful theme: Women, life,
freedom.” Hajjipour’s sentencing comes as other activists, journalists and
artists have faced arrest, imprisonment and harassment since the demonstrations.
Among those imprisoned is Nobel Peace Prize laureate Narges Mohammadi. The New
York-based Center for Human Rights in Iran condemned Hajjipour’s sentencing
Friday, and demanded Iran immediately release him from the sentence. “This
blatant violation of Shervin’s rights to free speech and expression is a grave
injustice and a clear affront to human rights principles,” the center said. “His
imprisonment serves as a chilling reminder of the ongoing repression faced by
artists, activists and dissenting voices in Iran.”
Putin foe Alexei Navalny is buried in Moscow as thousands attend under heavy
police presence
News Agencies/March 01/2024
Under a heavy police presence, thousands of people bade farewell Friday to
opposition leader Alexei Navalny at his funeral in Moscow after his
still-unexplained death two weeks ago in an Arctic penal colony.
Navalny was buried at a cemetery in the snowy southeastern outskirts of the
capital after a short Russian Orthodox ceremony, with vast crowds waiting
outside the church and then streaming to the fresh grave of President Vladimir
Putin's fiercest critic with flowers and anti-government chants.
Although riot police set up barricades at both the church and cemetery, no
detentions were reported. Navalny's widow, Yulia, who was not seen at the
funeral, thanked him for “26 years of absolute happiness."
“I don't know how to live without you, but I will try to do it in a way that you
up there are proud of me and happy for me,” she wrote on Instagram.
The service followed a battle with authorities over the release of his body. His
team said several Moscow churches refused to hold the funeral for the man who
crusaded against official corruption and organized massive protests. Many
Western leaders blamed the death on the Russian leader, an accusation the
Kremlin angrily rejected. Navalny’s team eventually got permission from the
Church of the Icon of the Mother of God Soothe My Sorrows, which was surrounded
by crowd-control barriers.
As his coffin was removed from the hearse and taken inside the church, the crowd
waiting outside broke into respectful applause and then chanted: “Navalny!
Navalny!” Some also shouted, “You weren’t afraid, neither are we!” and later “No
to war!” “Russia without Putin!” and “Russia will be free!”
Western diplomats, including U.S. Ambassador Lynne Tracy, were among those who
attended, along with presidential hopefuls Boris Nadezhdin and Yekaterina
Duntsova. Both wanted to run against Putin in the upcoming presidential
elections and opposed his war in Ukraine; neither was allowed on the ballot.
Images from inside the church showed an open casket with Navalny’s body covered
with red and white flowers, and his parents, Lyudmila and Anatoly, sitting
beside it. Navalny's closest associates live outside Russia and made comments in
a livestream of the funeral on his YouTube channel, their voices occasionally
cracking with emotion. “Those people who follow what is happening, it is of
course obvious to them that this man is a hero of our country, whom we will not
forget," said Nadezhda Ivanova of Kaliningrad, who was outside the church with
other supporters. “What was done to him is incredibly difficult to accept and
get through it." Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov urged those gathering in Moscow
and other places not to break the law, saying any “unauthorized (mass)
gatherings” are violations. After the short church service, thousands marched to
the nearby Borisovskoye Cemetery, where the police were also out in force. With
the casket open, Navalny’s mother and father stroked and kissed his head. A
large crowd gathered at the cemetery's gates, chanting: “Let us in to say
goodbye!” The coffin was then lowered into the ground. In keeping with his
irreverent sense of humor, music from the “The Terminator 2" was played, a movie
his allies said he considered “the best in the world.” Mourners streamed by his
open grave, tossing handfuls of soil onto the coffin as a large crowd waited at
the cemetery's entrance. As dusk fell, workers shoveled dirt into the grave
while Lyudmila Navalnaya watched. A mound of flowers, funeral wreaths, candles
and a portrait of Navalny sat nearby. She had spent eight days trying to get
authorities to release her son's body following his Feb. 16 death at Penal
Colony No. 3 in the town of Kharp, in the Yamalo-Nenets region about 1,900
kilometers (1,200 miles) northeast of Moscow.
Even on Friday, the morgue where the body was being held delayed its release,
according to Ivan Zhdanov, Navalny's close ally and director of his
Anti-Corruption Foundation. Authorities originally said they couldn't turn over
the body because they needed to conduct post-mortem tests. Navalnaya made a
video appeal to Putin to release it so she could bury her son with dignity.
Russian authorities still haven’t announced the cause of death for Navalny, who
was 47. His team cited paperwork Lyudmila Navalnaya saw that listed “natural
causes.”At least one funeral director said he had been “forbidden” to work with
Navalny’s supporters, his spokeswoman Kira Yarmysh said on social media. They
also struggled to find a hearse. “Unknown people are calling up people and
threatening them not to take Alexei’s body anywhere,” Yarmysh said Thursday.
Navalny had been jailed since January 2021, when he returned to Moscow to face
certain arrest after recuperating in Germany from nerve agent poisoning he
blamed on the Kremlin. His Foundation for Fighting Corruption and his regional
offices were designated as “extremist organizations” by the Russian government
that same year. Yulia Navalnaya accused Putin and Moscow Mayor Sergei Sobyanin
of trying to block a public funeral. “We don’t want any special treatment — just
to give people the opportunity to say farewell to Alexei in a normal way,” she
wrote on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter. Moscow authorities refused
permission for a separate memorial event for Navalny and slain opposition leader
Boris Nemtsov on Friday, citing COVID-19 restrictions, according to former
presidential hopeful Duntsova. Nemtsov, a 55-year-old former deputy prime
minister, was shot to death as he walked on a bridge adjacent to the Kremlin on
the night of Feb. 27, 2015. Yarmysh also urged Navalny's supporters around the
world to lay flowers in his honor Friday.“Everyone who knew Alexei says what a
cheerful, courageous and honest person he was,” Yarmysh said Thursday. “But the
greater truth is that even if you never met Alexei, you knew what he was like,
too. You shared his investigations, you went to rallies with him, you read his
posts from prison. His example showed many people what to do when even when
things were scary and difficult.”
Election in UK likely this year, here's what to know
News Agencies/March 01/2024
The United Kingdom is poised to hold its first election in five years in a
country battered by a cost-of-living crisis, fallout from the Israel-Hamas
conflict and deep divisions over how to deal with migrants and asylum seekers
crossing the English Channel from Europe on small inflatable boats. Here is a
look at the upcoming election and the biggest issues at stake.
When is the election in the United Kingdom?
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak can call an election at any time up to Dec. 17, with
the election taking place 25 working days later. That means the last possible
date for the election is Jan. 28, 2025. The timing of the election will be
determined by Sunak's calculation of what date will be most advantageous for the
Conservatives. The most likely time for the election is in the autumn, according
to the Institute for Government, a London-based think tank. But one can't be
sure.
How does voting work in the United Kingdom?
People throughout the United Kingdom will choose all 650 members of the House of
Commons for a term of up to five years. The party that commands a majority in
the Commons, either alone or in coalition, will form the next government and its
leader will be prime minister. That means the results will determine the
political direction of the government, which has been led by the center-right
Conservatives for the past 14 years. Opinion polls suggest that Labour is
currently in the strongest position.
Who is running in the United Kingdom?
Sunak, a former Treasury chief who has been prime minister since October of
2022, is expected to lead his party into the election. His primary opponent will
be Keir Starmer, a former director of public prosecutions in England and leader
of the Labour Party since April 2020. But there are other parties, some of which
have strong regional support and could be crucial to forming a coalition
government if no one wins an overall majority. The Scottish National Party,
which campaigns for Scottish independence; Liberal Democrats; and Democratic
Unionist Party, which seeks to maintain ties between Britain and Northern
Ireland, are currently the three largest parties in Parliament after the
Conservatives and Labour. Some observers suggest the new Reform Party, formed by
Tory rebels, may siphon votes from the Conservatives.
What are the big issues at stake in the United Kingdom?
The economy: Britain has struggled with high inflation and slow economic growth,
which have combined to make most people feel poorer. The Conservatives succeeded
in meeting their goal of halving inflation, which peaked at 11.1% in October
2022, but the economy slipped into a technical recession in the last six months
of 2023, raising questions about the government's economic policies.
Immigration: Thousands of asylum seekers and economic migrants have crossed the
English Channel in flimsy inflatable boats in recent years, raising concerns the
government has lost control of Britain's borders. The Conservatives' signature
policy for stopping the boats is a plan t o deport some of these migrants to
Rwanda. Critics say the plan violates international law, is inhumane, and will
do nothing to stop people fleeing war, unrest and famine. Health care: Britain's
National Health Service, which provides free health care to everyone, is plagued
with long waiting lists for everything from dental care to cancer treatment.
Newspapers are filled with stories about seriously ill patients forced to wait
hours for an ambulance, then longer still for a hospital bed. The environment:
Sunak has backtracked on a series of environmental commitments, pushing back the
deadline for ending the sale of gasoline- and diesel-powered passenger vehicles
and authorizing new oil drilling in the North Sea. Critics say these are the
wrong policies at a time the world is trying to combat climate change.
European Commission will proceed to paying EUR 50 million
to UNRWA and increase emergency support to Palestinians by EUR 68 million in
2024
NNA/March 01/2024
Today, the Commission has decided to allocate an additional EUR 68 million to
support the Palestinian population across the region to be implemented through
international partners like the Red Cross and the Red Crescent. This comes in
addition to the foreseen EUR 82 million of aid to be implemented through UNRWA
in 2024, bringing the total to EUR 150 million. The Commission will proceed to
paying EUR 50 million of the UNRWA envelope next week. Furthermore, the
Commission has allocated EUR 125 million of humanitarian aid for Palestinians
for 2024. The Commission is contracting the first EUR 16 million today. As set
out on 29 January, the Commission has assessed its funding decision for UNRWA in
light of the very serious allegations made on 24 January that implicate several
UNRWA staff in the heinous 7 October attacks. It took account of the action
taken by the UN and the commitments the Commission required from UNRWA. The
Commission welcomes the UN's Office for Internal Oversight Services
investigation to shed light into the serious allegations against UNRWA staff.
Furthermore, it commends the UN for creating an independent Review Group led by
Catherine Colonna to assess whether the Agency is doing everything within its
power to ensure neutrality and respond to allegations of serious breaches.
Following exchanges with the Commission, UNRWA has also indicated that it stands
ready to ensure that a review of its staff is carried out to confirm they did
not participate in the attacks and that further controls are put in place to
mitigate such risks in the future. UNRWA has agreed to the launch of an audit of
the Agency to be conducted by EU appointed external experts. This audit will
review the control systems to prevent the possible involvement of its staff and
assets in terrorist activities. Finally, UNRWA agrees to the strengthening of
its department of internal investigations and the governance surrounding it.
UNRWA and the Commission have today confirmed their understanding on these
points. On this basis, and following the exchange of letters with UNRWA
confirming its commitments, the Commission will proceed disburse a first tranche
of EUR 50 million out of the EUR 82 million foreseen for UNRWA for 2024. The
second and third tranches of EUR 16 million will be released in line with the
implementation of this agreement. Beyond its support to UNRWA, the Commission
remains fully committed to addressing the humanitarian plight of the Palestinian
people, particularly in Gaza but also more widely in the region. For this
purpose, it will allocate an additional EUR 68 million for in 2024. President
von der Leyen said: "We stand by the Palestinian people in Gaza and elsewhere in
the region. Innocent Palestinians should not have to pay the price for the
crimes of terrorist group Hamas. They face terrible conditions putting their
lives at risk because of lack of access to sufficient food and other basic
needs. That is why we are reinforcing our support to them this year by a further
EUR 68 million.” -- European Commission
Islamic State attack kills one Iraqi soldier north of
Baghdad
BAGHDAD (Reuters)/Fri, March 1, 2024
A roadside bomb exploded near an Iraqi army patrol north of Baghdad on Friday,
killing one soldier and wounding four others, the defence ministry said in a
statement. The attack took place in the town of Tarmiya, 25 km (15 miles) north
of Baghdad, the ministry said. Islamic State formally claimed responsibility for
the attack, saying it killed one soldier and wounded nine others, the group said
in a statement. Iraq’s Defence Minister Thabit al-Abbasi reached the area where
the attack took place and ordered an investigation, the ministry's statement
said. Despite the defeat of the Islamic State militant group in 2017, remnants
of the group switched to hit-and-run attacks against government forces in
different parts of Iraq.
Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from
miscellaneous sources published on March 01-02/2024
Palestinians' Musical Chairs: Replacing One Mohammed with Another
Mohammed
Khaled Abu Toameh/Gatestone Institute./March 01, 2024
The assumption that a new Palestinian government headed by Mustafa (or any other
figure selected by Abbas) would be different than the one headed by Shtayyeh is
deadly mistaken. The cabinet shake-up is an insignificant cosmetic change.
If the Shtayyeh government was already working on a plan to revamp the
Palestinian Authority (as the US administration is demanding), why is he being
asked to be replaced with another Abbas loyalist? Is the new government headed
by Mustafa going to come up with a different plan for reforming the PA? This
just shows that Abbas's real objective is to play the Americans for fools by
creating the impression that the new prime minister will be different than his
predecessor.
Abbas is well aware that it is safer for him to live under Israeli security
control than under the rule of Hamas, whose members killed dozens of his
supporters during the 2007 Hamas coup against the Palestinian Authority.
Besides, Abbas knows that assuming control of the Gaza Strip in the post-war era
would mean taking upon himself the almost impossible task of rebuilding the Gaza
Strip and preventing Hamas and other terror groups from reasserting their power.
So, to appease the US administration, Abbas is once again playing the musical
chairs game of the prime ministers. Abbas wants the Americans to believe that he
is serious about revitalizing the Palestinian Authority and rebuilding the Gaza
Strip. Abbas is hoping that his latest musical chair ploy will incentivize the
international community to continue pouring millions of dollars into the coffers
of the PA leadership.
To appease the US administration, Palestinian Authority (PA) President Mahmoud
Abbas is once again playing the musical chairs game with PA prime ministers.
Abbas wants the Americans to believe that he is serious about revitalizing the
PA and rebuilding the Gaza Strip. Abbas is hoping that his latest ploy will
incentivize the international community to continue pouring millions of dollars
into the coffers of the PA leadership.
On February 26, Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Mohammed Shtayyeh announced
his resignation, paving the way for the formation of a new Palestinian
government. The resignation came in response to pressure from the US
administration on the Palestinian leadership to "revitalize" the Palestinian
Authority (PA) so that it could assume control over the Gaza Strip after Hamas
is removed from power.
Shtayyeh, who was appointed by PA President Mahmoud Abbas in 2019, is a veteran
member of the ruling Fatah faction. The government he headed consisted of
ministers affiliated with a number of political factions, as well as others
known as independent technocrats.
Abbas is reportedly considering replacing the outgoing prime minister with
Mohammed Mustafa, a senior PLO official who previously served as PA deputy prime
minister and minister of economy. Mustafa, in addition, also served for many
years as economic advisor to the PA president.
Both Shtayyeh and Mustafa have long been closely associated with the Palestinian
Authority president. They have both held senior jobs in various PA political and
economic institutions, as well as Fatah and the PLO.
As far as most Palestinians are concerned, there is no real difference between
the two Mohammeds: Shtayyeh and Mustafa. They both belong to the same PA
leadership that has been governing the Palestinians since the signing of the
Oslo Accords between Israel and the PLO more than three decades ago.
By replacing one loyalist with another, Abbas is again playing musical chairs in
an effort to appease the US administration and persuade it that he is serious
about revamping the Palestinian Authority.
The assumption that a new Palestinian government headed by Mustafa (or any other
figure selected by Abbas) would be different than the one headed by Shtayyeh is
deadly mistaken. The cabinet shake-up is an insignificant cosmetic change.
The Palestinians do not need cosmetic changes in governance. Instead, they need
new leaders who care about the interests of the people in addition to their own
interests. Such potential leaders do exist, but they have no role to play
because Abbas and his cronies in the West Bank have long been blocking the
emergence of such leaders, whom they see as a threat to their authority. The
same applies to the Iran-backed Hamas terror group that has for many years
cracked down on political activists, journalists, and human rights advocates in
the Gaza Strip.
Palestinians need a serious and comprehensive plan for political, economic, and
administrative reforms in all the institutions of the Palestinian Authority. At
the end of January, to that end, the Shtayyeh government unveiled a new plan for
"judicial, administrative, security and financial reforms." Just a month later,
he and his entire cabinet submitted their resignations to Abbas. This means that
the plan is unlikely to materialize.
If the Shtayyeh government was already working on a plan to revamp the
Palestinian Authority (as the US administration is demanding), why is he being
asked to be replaced with another Abbas loyalist? Is the new government headed
by Mustafa going to come up with a different plan for reforming the PA? This
just shows that Abbas's real objective is to play the Americans for fools by
creating the impression that the new prime minister will be different than his
predecessor.
Crucially, Palestinians need to get rid of all the incompetent and corrupt
leaders and officials – whether from Fatah or Hamas – who have failed to bring
them democracy, freedom of speech, the rule of law, good governance, or a decent
economy.
As long as Abbas is the one who has the power to appoint and fire the prime
minister and set the policy of the cabinet, it is unrealistic to expect real
change when a new government is formed. If appointed, Mustafa, like his
predecessors, will be a puppet in the hands of his master, Abbas.
The last three cabinets that served under Abbas were also described as
"technocratic" and independent. One was headed by Salam Fayyad, a former World
Bank official and minister of finance.
Fayyad was not affiliated with any Palestinian political faction. He headed an
electoral list called Third Way, which won only two seats in the Palestinian
Legislative Council election in 2006. Fayyad's "problem" was that he never spent
a day in an Israeli prison and did not carry out an attack against Israel. In
the world of the Palestinians, it is more important if one graduates from an
Israeli prison than from the University of Texas in Austin.
Fayyad may have been a reformist, but that is not how one gains popularity among
Palestinians. Instead, Palestinians prefer someone who was part of the
Palestinian "resistance" against Israel. That is why senior Fatah operative
Marwan Barghouti, who is serving five life sentences in Israeli prison for his
role in a number of deadly armed attacks against Israelis two decades ago, is
the Palestinians' favorite candidate to succeed Abbas, according to Palestinian
public opinion polls.
The two prime ministers who came after Fayyad – Rami Hamdallah and Shtayyeh –
were also selected by the Palestinian Authority president. Hamdallah and
Shtayyeh were known to be even more loyal to Abbas than Fayyad, who moved to the
US a few years ago after reportedly falling out with the PA president. Despite
their loyalty, Hamdallah and Shtayyeh were eventually forced by Abbas to step
down.
No Palestinian Authority prime minister can make comprehensive changes in the
political and economic structure of the PA without the backing of Abbas and his
inner circle. For now, it is clear that neither Abbas nor the handful of
officials in his close circle is interested in bringing about substantial
changes to the PA. That is because they are comfortable with the status quo,
whereby they are the sole rulers and decision-makers, while the prime minister
and the government are stooges in their hands.
The 88-year-old Abbas, who is in the 19th year of a four-year term in office,
has until now proven that he cares more about his own survival than good
governance. He will get rid of any prime minister or senior official who dares
to challenge him or speak out against his autocratic rule. That is why he turned
against Fayyad a decade ago and drove him away -- not only from the position of
prime minister, but into exile abroad. That is also why Abbas was quick to expel
senior and veteran Fatah officials Mohammed Dahlan and Nasser al-Qidwa for
criticizing him and the Palestinian leadership in public.
Abbas may be publicly stating that he is ready and wants to return to the Gaza
Strip, from where he and his Palestinian Authority were expelled by Hamas in
2007. Those who believe that Abbas really wants to go back to the Gaza Strip are
living under an illusion. Abbas had many chances to return to the Gaza Strip
over the past 15 years, but he preferred to stay in the comfort of his home and
office in Ramallah, the de facto capital of the Palestinians in the West Bank.
No one prevented Abbas from heading to the Gaza Strip.
Abbas is well aware that it is safer for him to live under Israeli security
control than under the rule of Hamas, whose members killed dozens of his
supporters during the 2007 Hamas coup against the Palestinian Authority.
Besides, Abbas knows that assuming control of the Gaza Strip in the post-war era
would mean taking upon himself the almost impossible task of rebuilding the Gaza
Strip and preventing Hamas and other terror groups from reasserting their power.
So, to appease the US administration, Abbas is once again playing the musical
chairs game of the prime ministers. Abbas wants the Americans to believe that he
is serious about revitalizing the Palestinian Authority and rebuilding the Gaza
Strip. Abbas is hoping that his latest musical chair ploy will incentivize the
international community to continue pouring millions of dollars into the coffers
of the PA leadership.
*Khaled Abu Toameh is an award-winning journalist based in Jerusalem.
© 2024 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
Accelerating the region’s transformation of its agrifood
systems
QU DONGYU/Arab News/March 01, 2024
The world is facing a major challenge in achieving the UN’s Sustainable
Development Goal 2, which seeks to eliminate hunger and all forms of
malnutrition by 2030. This is particularly true in the Near East and North
Africa region, which in recent years has experienced a worrisome surge in food
insecurity.
This dire development can be attributed to a multitude of factors, with the
impact of conflicts, the climate crisis and other calamities being the most
prominent. The recent crises in Gaza, Sudan and Yemen, coupled with prolonged
pressures in other countries such as Syria and Iraq, are of great concern and
immediate action is necessary to overcome these challenges and safeguard food
supply chains to ensure food security for all. For that, we need to accelerate
the transformation of agrifood systems to make them more efficient, more
inclusive, more resilient and more sustainable. This will be one of the main
issues under discussion at the 37th session of the Food and Agriculture
Organization’s Regional Ministerial Conference for the Near East in Amman,
Jordan, on March 4 and 5. During this biennial governing body meeting, ministers
will gather to assess the situation in the region’s agrifood systems and create
a plan of action going forward, as well as to identify key priorities for the
FAO’s program of work in the region. The challenges faced by agrifood systems
across the Near East and North Africa, and beyond, are enormous
At the FAO, we have realigned and refocused our efforts toward supporting
members in accelerating the transformation needed. We have adopted agile
operating strategies, offered tailored and timely data and analytical support,
enhanced our engagement with governments, the private sector, civil society,
academia and international financial institutions and have established
transformative partnerships with all key players. The reformed and restructured
FAO is now better equipped, fit for purpose and already working toward this
transformation.
Ownership and leadership by FAO members, and collective efforts by all
development partners and stakeholders, are crucial. Shared vision, foresight,
responsibilities and implementation arrangements are needed to achieve our
goals. I would like to emphasize the significance of collaborations and
partnerships, especially in the Near East and North Africa.
The challenges faced by agrifood systems across the region, and beyond, are
enormous and constantly increasing. With a growing population and dwindling
agricultural resources, we must strive to improve productivity and efficiency as
much as possible. We must produce more with less. To this end, we need to
leverage the potential of cooperation, trade, investment and the utilization of
innovation and technology within the region and with other regions. The priority
should be to establish food corridors, which ought to harness the potential of
production, regional value chains, intraregional trade, storage and reserve
systems. We need to safeguard supply chains and trade to ensure food
availability, accessibility and affordability for all. The region also faces
severe water scarcity and climate shocks. As a result, we must prioritize the
adaptation to climate change, as well as mitigating greenhouse gas emissions.
Agrifood systems are solutions based on science and data. We should recognize
and acknowledge the efforts made by Egypt and the UAE to encourage collective
action and pathways during the COP27 and COP28 climate summits and for advancing
the agenda of agrifood systems and food security, as well as the
food-water-energy nexus.
Currently, more than half of the region’s population cannot afford a healthy
diet, which is a serious concern
In support of this process, the FAO initiated a process at COP27 that culminated
at COP28 with the launch of a “Global Roadmap for Achieving SDG2 without
breaching the 1.5 C threshold.” This aims to make the case that accelerated
climate actions can transform agrifood systems and help to achieve good,
nutritious food for all for today and tomorrow. At the FAO, members have
endorsed a “Strategic Framework for 2022-2031” based on the aspiration of the
“Four Betters:” better production, better nutrition, a better environment and a
better life, leaving no one behind. This comprehensive framework provides us
with an opportunity to take a wide-ranging look at our agrifood systems,
identify areas that need improvement and take appropriate actions.
Members benefit from the FAO’s technical expertise, assistance and support
through its headquarters, as well as regional, subregional and country offices,
to ensure effective implementation in support of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development and the SDGs. My focus is on strengthening the FAO’s country offices
to maximize their impact on the ground and support the work of members at the
country level.
In support of our Strategic Framework, we have in place a number of flagship
initiatives to support transformation, including the FAO Hand-in-Hand Initiative
that supports the implementation of nationally led, ambitious programs to
accelerate agrifood systems’ transformations by eradicating poverty (SDG1),
ending hunger and malnutrition (SDG2) and reducing inequalities (SDG10). There
is also the One Country One Priority Product initiative that supports countries
in the development of more sustainable food value chains for special
agricultural products and improved rural livelihoods.
Proactive measures designed to tackle the challenges of agriculture and food
security play a crucial role here. This is not only important from a social and
economic point of view but also for maintaining peace and stability. In recent
times, this region has experienced social and political unrest caused by a lack
of food security. The consequences of such developments should be enough to
prioritize addressing this challenge and prevent potential future surges.
Currently, more than half of the region’s population cannot afford a healthy
diet, which is a serious concern. Governments should work toward improving
access to affordable, healthy diets for their population. The FAO will continue
to support these national efforts, including by acting as a professional
platform for dialogue and knowledge exchange.
I would like to emphasize the significance of transformation that is not only
efficient and effective, but also inclusive. We must tackle both structural and
societal gaps and inequalities. To achieve this, we must focus on rural
development, empowering women, mobilizing youth as key players in agrifood
systems, promoting agricultural entrepreneurs and local knowledge, and involving
communities and groups in marginalized situations. Farmers must be at the center
of our work.
It is time to mobilize all efforts to transform agrifood systems. Let us
prioritize resources to ensure food security and better nutrition for all, with
no one left behind. The FAO is committed to this noble pursuit.
**Qu Dongyu is Director-General of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations.
‘When Christendom Had Muscle’
Raymond Ibrahim/American Reformer:/March 01/2024
The following review, “When Christendom Had Muscle,” was written by Terry Grant
for American Reformer:
Western Christians have forgotten the meaning of the word persecution. They have
also forgotten that once upon a time Christians, when they had the power,
prestige and wealth to put a stop to persecution, resisted persecution with
violent, military force. Raymond Ibrahim is on a quest to remind us of both of
these forgotten truths.
In his book Defenders of the West, Ibrahim continues the work he started in his
previous book, Sword and Scimitar. In Sword and Scimitar, Ibrahim chose to focus
on events, specifically on battles that shaped the Crusades and the conflict
that he believes must be continuous between Muslims and Christians. In Defenders
of the West, he has chosen to go a different route by focusing on the men
themselves. Each chapter is a succinct biography of one of the heroes of the
Crusades.
After a very good forward by Victor Davis Hanson (whom Ibrahim studied under),
Ibrahim gets into his introduction to set the stage for his work. His
introduction takes a militant stance right away and sets out to right the wrong
of intentionally misrepresenting the Crusades, Crusaders and their Islamic
counterparts. Ibrahim has already established himself as a historical and
contemporary expert on Islam. In Defenders, he lays out the true historical
account of the misdeeds of the Muslims of the era in order to clarify the stakes
and motivations of the Crusaders. He also has a secondary goal of clarifying
actual Islamic beliefs about how non-Muslims are to be treated according to
their writings. The misunderstandings of the modern media regarding Islamic
doctrine are so ubiquitous that even some self-professing Muslims believe they
are a “religion of peace,” clearly in opposition to their history and teachings.
Ibrahim has a strong desire to get a complete picture of each man he is
highlighting in his book and so he considers sources both friendly to and
opposed to each subject. This pays dividends later on when seemingly outlandish
historical claims are made about the appearance, piety or fighting prowess of
one of the Crusaders, only to then have those hyperbolic claims be confirmed
begrudgingly by their enemies in private communiques or official records.
The Great Men
Ibrahim’s work is like a medieval, Christian version of Plutarch’s Lives. A book
in which Plutarch set out to strengthen the Roman ethos by linking the heroes of
Rome to a heroic Greek counterpart. Americans understand this in a way because
of the hackneyed trope in politics of appealing to the founders. Sometimes this
is warranted and accurate and sometimes it is absolutely false. A reversal of
this is to accuse enemies of being “nazis” or “literally hitlooor.” These things
are nearly universal in the way they are regarded. Most Americans give at least
lip service to agreeing with the Founders or regarding Hitler as a villain. To
connect a cause with them is to have instant ethos. This is the way many of the
Romans viewed their Greek predecessors. Plutarch set out to write the definitive
biographies of these men and show why Romans were equal to and surpassed their
exploits.
Ibrahim doesn’t seek to pair each Crusader to another or to a predecessor in
such a direct way. But many comparisons are easy to make within the book among
the men he has chosen to write about and in some cases their Islamic
adversaries. They are able to be grouped by region and temporal proximity for
the useful purpose of comparing and contrasting and offering a wide range of
personalities and physical types. If Ibrahim set out to present the men in the
book as figures worthy of imitation, he has succeeded brilliantly. If he did not
set out with that goal in mind, then these larger-than-life figures have
overshadowed whatever other goals he had. Unlike the Romans who appealed to the
greatness of their civilizational forebears the Hellenists, when the Crusaders
walked the Earth, they considered all the great men of their day to have already
bowed the knee to the Cross of Christ. They were of one Kingdom. They sought to
imitate biblical warrior kings, pious ancestors, and Christ Himself.
After telling my 5-year-old son a few anecdotes about Richard the Lionheart, he
laid siege to our sofa and started ordering his stuffed animals to convert to
Christianity. (Ongoing discussions of Soteriology are clearly necessary.) It is
very difficult for a man to read this book and not find himself inspired by the
men within. He wants to have a Crusader birthday party. He found a snapping
turtle shell near the creek and was hoping I could make him a shield out of it
with a lion on it.
Ibrahim knows that the study of the lives of great men is recalling a former way
of studying history that has been neglected. Classically trained and educated
people are generally more aware of the historiography of the individual because
of exposure to older historical works (like Plutarch) which are focused on
people’s lives, not merely a series of events. A dry history of mere events can
be interesting enough if you find the period compelling, but there is a reason
why our best stories have characters in them. To enter history, you must do so
through the life of a character who lived it. In that way, even boring periods
of history have proved quite captivating to readers.
Surveying the Field
Each chapter, except the introduction and the conclusion, covers a specific
Crusader. Ibrahim chooses to highlight Crusaders from each of the major fronts
of war with Islam in the Middle Ages and they are presented in chronological
order, some overlap each other. The Holy Land in the war with the Saracens and
Egyptians, Spain and the war with the Moroccan Moors, and the Balkans in the war
with the Ottoman Empire. The crusaders featured are Godfrey of Boullion
(French/Frankish), Rodrigo “El Cid” de Vivar (Spanish), Richard the Lionheart
(English), Ferdinand III (Spanish), Louis IX (French), John Hunyadi (Hungarian),
George “Skanderbeg” Castrioti (Albanian), and Vlad Dracula (Yes, that one.
Romanian).
The chapters have a formula that does not get old even though it is routine.
First, the situation is explained. In virtually all cases, Muslims have achieved
the upper hand politically and are using their power to extort Christians,
enslave them, steal their children and murder them. This is a dark part of each
chapter. The atrocities committed by the Muslims against their Christian
subjects are nearly too heinous to mention. Mass murder, enslavement,
brainwashing, forced conversion and forced circumcision, mass pedophilic rape,
routine covenant breaking, destruction of churches and holy sites, and forcing
captives to fight against their own people. This is an important chronology to
understand. The Christian Crusaders always set out to recapture Christian lands
and put a stop to the abuse and persecution of other Christians, or to actively
defend lands under threat of Muslim invasion. The Crusaders did not invade
Muslim lands unprovoked.
As an aside here, this realization is probably a revolution to some people on
its own. All of us, even friends of mine who were homeschooled by based parents
and myself (private Christian school educated), believe that, at best, the
Crusades were a conventional land war meant to expand the control of Islam or
the Roman Church. They believe that the Pope dispatched troops to the Holy Lands
to expand his personal influence and if the Christians didn’t go then they got
excommunicated or deposed. While there is no doubt some questionable doctrines
being bandied about at this time in history, such as indulgences for Crusaders,
that is not the reality. The Pope requested Christian kings to help in response
to outrages beyond count. In some situations the kings ignored him. The Pope’s
requests served as a way to explain the opinion of the Roman Church about the
rectitude of a military intervention. This gave the kings a clear warrant from
scripture to go on the offensive to save their brethren under bondage.
After setting the stage of the conflict by explaining the Muslim position, the
progress of the Crusaders is narrated with all the ups and downs attendant to
their respective campaigns. An explanation of the new status quo they achieved
as a result of their action and finally a recounting of their deaths and the
immediate aftermath. It is also important to note that, in many cases,
significant time is devoted to elaborating on the personal piety of each man.
Some more than others because, it would seem, some were more pious than others.
Some seemed to have fewer relevant sources expounding on their piety. It seems
certain that many Crusaders would have had beliefs outside what many American
Reformer readers would consider orthodox. They would have considered themselves
subject to the Pope and the church of Rome and thus a version of what we now
call “Catholic.” Though the Roman church has seen its dogma develop in the
intervening time. It is noteworthy that either Ibrahim has omitted references to
Mary or the veneration of other saints which modern Catholics emphasize so
strongly, or the Crusaders did not mention them as much as modern Roman
Catholics might be expected to (The Spaniards being the most noticeable
exception with their veneration of James). In contrast, they seem to heavily
emphasize Jesus Christ, alone, and consider themselves His subjects and warriors
for His glory mentioning Him often and appealing to Him as a victorious king.
Not every story has a happy ending and the book is a true emotional roller
coaster. From the fiery rage of reading about the abuses against our medieval
brothers, to the joyous highs of rescues and victorious charges against all
odds, to the dismal depression of a Crusader king failing in his quest to
liberate his captured subjects and friends. Ibrahim’s skill as a writer is
significant. It is not a common history tome that can elicit true emotion from
me. More than once in this read I teared up, but I never cried because crying is
for the weak and the Crusaders would make fun of me if they knew…unless it’s
from seeing Jerusalem for the first time after walking from France through blood
and ash-covered battlefields.
Gaza and the shameless vacuum of Western morality
Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib/Arab News/March 01, 2024
I rarely write angry pieces. However, as I see and read about the carnage on
Thursday, when Israeli troops turned their guns on starving Palestinians and 112
died, and I see the world’s hypocrisy, I have nothing to offer but my rage and
disgust at the shameless loss of Western morality.
Israel called these victims “a mob” — starving women and children, reduced to “a
mob.” Initially the Israelis did not even recognize the massacre. Then, as the
appalling truth became evident, they were forced to admit that they had indeed
opened fire — while simultaneously gaslighting the victims, as they usually do.
The victims were shot because they “posed a threat.” It was nearly 12 hours
before they admitted the obvious, while of course absolving themselves of any
responsibility.
If this did not sufficiently disgust you, what came next must surely have done —
the hypocritical reaction of the West, particularly the US. Joe Biden, president
of the land of the free and the shining beacon of Western civility, could not
even bring himself to issue a condemnation. All he said was that the “incident”
would complicate the Israel-Hamas ceasefire talks. Palestinians are now beyond
dehumanized — they are no more than a currency.
Actually, I did once hear an Israeli official calling Palestinians a “currency.”
We know Palestinians don’t matter to them, and we Arabs don’t matter to them.
But how can they face their own people? How can they convince them? What do they
tell them? No matter how they try to whitewash the facts, it is all obvious.
There is satellite imagery, testimonials by people present at the massacre. It
is very clear. Yet Biden does not even dare to call it a massacre. If Syria,
Iran or Russia did the same, what would have been the reaction? Would there be
the slightest hesitation in calling it a massacre, or carnage? But the barbaric
loss of 112 Palestinian lives is nothing but an “incident” that will complicate
or delay the hostage deal.
While the US is so concerned about those poor Israelis who have been trapped for
months in Gaza, no one talks about the Palestinian women and children festering
in Israeli prisons; or the thousands jailed without either charge or conviction;
or the women raped in Israeli prisons; or the children jailed for years for
throwing a stone. This is because when you are a Palestinian you are no longer a
woman or a child, not even a human being, just a currency — and in the eyes of
Israel, a cheap one at that.
Western politicians lie to the Palestinians, they lie to us Arabs, and they lie
to their own people
The West’s mainstream media reporting has been timid. CBS, for example, said
Israel was “accused of opening fire.” Seriously? Accused, as if this were not
established fact? The Reuters headline was: “More than 100 killed while seeking
aid.” Killed how? And by whom? Are we asked to believe they shot themselves?
The media does not even report the facts, always qualified by “according to the
Hamas-run Ministry of Health,” just to sow doubt in people’s minds. Even Biden
expressed doubt about the number of deaths on Thursday, although the Gaza
ministry has a track record that is far more credible than that of the Israeli
army. US media even reported as fact claims by the notoriously unreliable ZAKA
Jewish burial charity, which spread online lies about the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on
Israel. The BBC continues to attribute the figure of 30,000 Palestinian dead in
Gaza to Hamas. They appear not to have noticed that, according to US Defense
Secretary Lloyd Austin, Israel has killed 25,000 Palestinian women and children
in Gaza since the war began. Israel itself also claims to have killed more then
8,000 Hamas fighters. Do the math, guys.
Western politicians lie to the Palestinians, they lie to us Arabs, and they lie
to their own people, who no longer believe them. The anger is spreading. In the
UK, the maverick politician George Galloway beat all the major parties to win a
by-election in the north of England on Tuesday, with a campaign focused entirely
on Gaza. Americans are upset. Their tax money is going to fund genocide, and in
the name of civility: how ironic. Israel is the only democracy in the Middle
East trying to defend itself against those “barbaric terrorists.” Biden his and
ilk can dehumanize Palestinians, but can they convince their own people? We saw
the uncommitted vote in the Michigan presidential election primary. It tells you
that people have had enough hypocrisy.
Last week, the young US airman Aaron Bushnell self-immolated in front of the
Israeli Embassy in Washington. The shameless media tried to portray him as
unstable, a lost soul. The Washington Post said he had an anarchist past. Have
they no decency? His friend said Aaron was not contemplating suicide but wanted
to use his life as a message for justice. US media reporting, and its official
position, go beyond disrespecting Gazans and Palestinians; they are
disrespecting their own citizens, who stand with Palestinians, who stand with
justice —supposedly a concept engrained in Western principles. How cynical is
that? They preach to the world about great Western values, but they are the
first to trash them. They preach equality among humans but what we see is the
veneration of inequality.
As I said at the start, I rarely write angry pieces. But sometimes there is
simply no alternative.
• Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib is a specialist in US-Arab relations with a focus on
lobbying. She is co-founder of the Research Center for Cooperation and Peace
Building, a Lebanese nongovernmental organization focused on Track II.
Turkiye, Gulf states’ converging interests in Horn of
Africa
Sinem Cengiz/Arab News/March 01, 2024
Turkiye last week signed a 10-year defense and economic cooperation agreement
with Somalia, which aims to help defend the latter’s long coastline and also
rebuild the naval forces of the fragile Horn of Africa nation. The agreement
took a great deal of attention, as it came amid growing tensions in this region
due to Ethiopia’s controversial maritime deal with Somaliland, which is a
territory on the coast of the Gulf of Aden that declared its independence in
1991 but is still recognized internationally as part of Somalia.
Somalia received an outpouring of support for its stance against the
Ethiopia-Somaliland deal. Turkiye and the Gulf Cooperation Council states were
among several regional nations that backed Somalia, stressing the importance of
the country’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.
Over the past decade, GCC states have shown significant engagement and
investment in the Horn of Africa area, with the Red Sea regaining its prominence
as a geostrategic focal point, attracting competing global and regional actors
aiming to extend their influence.
In Somalia, the Gulf states are key players jockeying for influence. During the
Gulf diplomatic crisis that began in 2017, the Horn of Africa was an area of
rivalry for the GCC states and Turkiye. However, after the reconciliation that
kicked off in early 2021, they focused less on assertive policies that could
harm their reconciliation path and instead adopted policies aimed at preserving
the stability and security of the Horn of Africa and could contribute to
enhancing their interests.
Over the past decade, GCC states have shown significant engagement and
investment in the Horn of Africa area
Any tension that could pose a threat to the stability and security of this
region is now considered a collective threat by both Turkiye and the Gulf
states. The dynamics within and between African states are closely intertwined
with the Turkish-Gulf normalization trend and it is evident that both the GCC
states and Ankara will try to use their leverage to solve the disputes through
dialogue.
When mentioning the Gulf states, it is significant to underline that it is the
UAE, Qatar and Saudi Arabia that have played a pivotal role and have the
leverage in the region, particularly in Somalia. Following the
Ethiopia-Somaliland deal, Riyadh affirmed its stance on the unity of Somalia and
the country’s sovereignty over its entire territory.
Even before the Somaliland dispute erupted, Saudi Arabia was angling for a
closer relationship with Somalia, having appointed its first ambassador to the
country in three decades in 2021. Last year, the two countries inked a security
cooperation agreement. Somalia has also been participating in summits held in
Riyadh, such as the Saudi-African Summit and the joint Arab-Islamic
extraordinary summit, with Somali President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud aiming to
cultivate close personal ties with the Saudi leadership. Somalia has made it
clear several times that it hopes Saudi engagement will go much further,
including deeper into the security sphere.
The UAE is another actor in the Horn of Africa that has ties with all competing
parties. Prior to 2021, Turkiye and the UAE engaged in a bitter rivalry in the
wider Red Sea area that was driven by their different visions for the region’s
future. But when Turkish-Emirati relations started to improve, the two states
had common stances on some tensions, such as the war in Tigray, in which they
supported the Ethiopian government.
Without having a solution to the root cause of the insecurity in Somalia, it is
tough to achieve their goals
From a commercial and security perspective, the UAE gives special importance to
Somalia, where it manages two key ports — Berbera and Bosaso — and has close
ties with the presidency. The UAE and Somalia signed a security agreement in
early 2023 that improved bilateral ties.
Last month, a Mogadishu attack killed four Emirati soldiers and one Bahraini
officer tasked with training the Somali army. It was claimed by the
Al-Qaeda-linked Al-Shabab militant group, which had previously also attacked the
Turkish mission in Mogadishu. Al-Shabab described the UAE as an “enemy” for its
backing of the Somali government in battling the armed group. Notably, this was
not the first time Al-Shabab had targeted Emiratis. In 2015, it attempted to
kill Emirati diplomats in the Somali capital.
Amid the tensions in the region, the Somali president has visited the GCC
states. In the last few months, he has visited Qatar, the UAE and Kuwait. Qatar
is another Gulf state that has affirmed its commitment to supporting Somali
military officers in the fight against Al-Shabab.
Last month’s attack made it clear for the Gulf states and Turkiye that, without
having a solution to the root cause of the insecurity in Somalia, it is tough to
achieve their goals. Securing Somalia fits into the GCC and Turkiye’s wider
concerns about security in the Gulf of Aden and the Arabian Sea.
It is noteworthy that Somali piracy has recently resumed after a gap of several
years amid the attacks by Yemen’s Houthi rebels on shipping in the Red Sea.
Thus, the new Turkiye-Somalia deal affirms Ankara’s position as a major player
in Somalia, where it has a large military base that trains thousands of Somali
security personnel. This base is the backbone of Somali efforts to tackle Al-Shabab.
However, within this context, there remains considerable uncertainty regarding
the Ethiopia-Somaliland deal and the defense cooperation agreement between
Turkiye and Somalia. While Gulf states had serious concerns over the former,
they seem to be comfortable — although not publicly supportive — with the new
Turkish-Somali agreement, or at least Turkiye’s security provider role that
could also serve the GCC’s interests in the long term.
• Sinem Cengiz is a Turkish political analyst who specializes in Turkiye’s
relations with the Middle East. X: @SinemCngz
Starvation: Israel’s criminal weapon of war
Daoud Kuttab/Arab News/March 01, 2024
The international community has been calling on Israel for months now to end its
weaponization of starvation against the civilian population of Gaza. Israel’s
publicly stated hope is that by inflicting suffering on the Palestinian people
they can extract a better negotiated deal with Hamas.
But such Israeli action is a war crime — the full enormity of which became clear
on Thursday, when Israeli troops opened fire on starving Palestinians scrambling
for food from an aid truck convoy just outside Gaza City, and more than 100 of
them were killed.
International humanitarian law and the laws of war make it abundantly clear that
the starvation of civilians as a weapon of warfare is prohibited. The Rome
Statute of the International Criminal Court states clearly that intentionally
starving civilians by “depriving them of objects indispensable to their
survival, including willfully impeding relief supplies” is a war crime. Criminal
intent does not require the attacker’s admission, but can also be inferred from
the totality of the circumstances of the military campaign. In the case of Gaza,
both intent and action have been documented. From day one of the Israeli war,
its defense minister said publicly that no food, water, or electricity would be
allowed into the enclave.
“Israel’s continuing blockade of Gaza, as well as its more than 16-year closure,
amounts to collective punishment of the civilian population, a war crime. As the
occupying power in Gaza, under the Fourth Geneva Convention Israel must ensure
that the civilian population gets food and medical supplies,” Human Rights Watch
said in December. The situation by the end of February had become much worse.
Not only have the Israelis denied entry of food and other humanitarian aid into
the northern parts of Gaza, where there is a border with Israel, they have also
done so from the southern border with Egypt. Israel has bombed trucks from
Egypt, compelling the Egyptians to accept Israeli control of when and how
anything is allowed to cross into Gaza. As a result, every truck carrying food
supplies has to first go all the way to the Israeli border point, where it is
checked. After this time-consuming check, the trucks, accompanied by Israel, are
allowed into Gaza via the Rafah crossing.
Humanitarian aid workers speak of the need for hundreds of food trucks to enter
Gaza every day to meet the needs of the starving population. The absence of food
has become so extreme that a 3kg bag of wheat is being sold for $100, which
almost no family in Gaza can afford.
The Israeli effort to use starvation as a weapon has turned starving
Palestinians into dead Palestinians
The situation in the south of Gaza became even more dire as the Israeli military
moved from north, to center, to south. They occupied Gaza City, then Khan Younis,
while encouraging Palestinians to move south to Rafah, where up to 1.5 million
people are now trapped. They cannot return north without risking their lives,
and the Egyptians will not allow anyone to cross into Sinai for fear that Israel
would never allow them to go back —ethnic cleansing, yet another war crime. The
meager number of food trucks that finally make it to Rafah are naturally
overwhelmed by the starving population.
Instead of allowing the normal entry of sufficient food supplies into Gaza, the
Israeli effort to use starvation as a weapon has turned starving Palestinians
into dead Palestinians. While the situation in south Gaza is dire, the
starvation level in the north is even worse. Israel is refusing to allow wheat
trucks into the north because of a handful of radical Jewish Israeli protesters.
Had they been Palestinians they would of course have been instantly shot dead.
But since they are fellow Israelis, the army, happy to keep the humanitarian
pressure on, has done little to allow the trucks of wheat, which Israel promised
their US allies would be delivered to north Gaza, ever to arrive.
The dire situation in north Gaza has led the Royal Jordanian Air Force to
organize daily air drops, even though occupying armies are obliged by
international law to provide all the humanitarian needs of people under their
direct military control.
Israel’s belated response to Thursday’s massacre was to claim that they opened
fire only on people who “posed a threat,” and that most of the dead were
trampled in a chaotic stampede for food. But as enlightened Israelis such as the
journalist Gideon Levy have repeatedly observed, Israel is unique in claiming
victimhood while painting the real victims as responsible for their own deaths.
“I don’t remember one occupation where the occupier presented himself as the
victim,” he said.
The World Court, Israel’s strongest allies including the US, in fact the entire
world is calling on Israel to stop using starvation as a weapon of war. The time
has come for the world to begin imposing sanctions on Israel. Any country that
supplies weapons to Israel is complicit in its war crimes and the genocide of
the Palestinian people.
• Daoud Kuttab is an award-winning Palestinian journalist and a director of
Community Media Network. X: @daoudkuttab
Question: “Can a Christian lose salvation?”
GotQuestions.org/March 01/2024
Answer: First, the term Christian must be defined. A “Christian” is not a person
who has said a prayer or walked down an aisle or been raised in a Christian
family. While each of these things can be a part of the Christian experience,
they are not what makes a Christian. A Christian is a person who has fully
trusted in Jesus Christ as the only Savior and therefore possesses the Holy
Spirit (John 3:16; Acts 16:31; Ephesians 2:8–9).
So, with this definition in mind, can a Christian lose salvation? It’s a
crucially important question. Perhaps the best way to answer it is to examine
what the Bible says occurs at salvation and to study what losing salvation would
entail:
A Christian is a new creation. “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new
creation; the old has gone, the new has come!” (2 Corinthians 5:17, NKJV). A
Christian is not simply an “improved” version of a person; a Christian is an
entirely new creature. He is “in Christ.” For a Christian to lose salvation, the
new creation would have to be destroyed.
A Christian is redeemed. “For you know that it was not with perishable things
such as silver or gold that you were redeemed from the empty way of life handed
down to you from your forefathers, but with the precious blood of Christ, a lamb
without blemish or defect” (1 Peter 1:18–19). The word redeemed refers to a
purchase being made, a price being paid. We were purchased at the cost of
Christ’s death. For a Christian to lose salvation, God Himself would have to
revoke His purchase of the individual for whom He paid with the precious blood
of Christ.
A Christian is justified. “Therefore, since we have been justified through
faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 5:1). To
justify is to declare righteous. All those who receive Jesus as Savior are
“declared righteous” by God. For a Christian to lose salvation, God would have
to go back on His Word and “un-declare” what He had previously declared. Those
absolved of guilt would have to be tried again and found guilty. God would have
to reverse the sentence handed down from the divine bench.
A Christian is promised eternal life. “For God so loved the world that he gave
his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have
eternal life” (John 3:16). Eternal life is the promise of spending forever in
heaven with God. God promises that if you believe, you will have eternal life.
For a Christian to lose salvation, eternal life would have to be redefined. The
Christian is promised to live forever. Does eternal not mean “eternal”?
A Christian is marked by God and sealed by the Spirit. “You also were included
in Christ when you heard the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation.
When you believed, you were marked in him with a seal, the promised Holy Spirit,
who is a deposit guaranteeing our inheritance until the redemption of those who
are God’s possession—to the praise of his glory” (Ephesians 1:13–14). At the
moment of faith, the new Christian is marked and sealed with the Spirit, who was
promised to act as a deposit to guarantee the heavenly inheritance. The end
result is that God’s glory is praised. For a Christian to lose salvation, God
would have to erase the mark, withdraw the Spirit, cancel the deposit, break His
promise, revoke the guarantee, keep the inheritance, forego the praise, and
lessen His glory.
A Christian is guaranteed glorification. “Those he predestined, he also called;
those he called, he also justified; those he justified, he also glorified”
(Romans 8:30). According to Romans 5:1, justification is ours at the moment of
faith. According to Romans 8:30, glorification comes with justification. All
those whom God justifies are promised to be glorified. This promise will be
fulfilled when Christians receive their perfect resurrection bodies in heaven.
If a Christian can lose salvation, then Romans 8:30 is in error, because God
could not guarantee glorification for all those whom He predestines, calls, and
justifies.
A Christian cannot lose salvation. Most, if not all, of what the Bible says
happens to us when we receive Christ would be invalidated if salvation could be
lost. Salvation is the gift of God, and God’s gifts are “irrevocable” (Romans
11:29). A Christian cannot be un-newly created. The redeemed cannot be
unpurchased. Eternal life cannot be temporary. God cannot renege on His Word.
Scripture says that God cannot lie (Titus 1:2).
Two common objections to the belief that a Christian cannot lose salvation
concern these experiential issues: 1) What about Christians who live in a
sinful, unrepentant lifestyle? 2) What about Christians who reject the faith and
deny Christ? The problem with these objections is the assumption that everyone
who calls himself a “Christian” has actually been born again. The Bible declares
that a true Christian will not live a state of continual, unrepentant sin (1
John 3:6). The Bible also says that anyone who departs the faith is
demonstrating that he was never truly a Christian (1 John 2:19). He may have
been religious, he may have put on a good show, but he was never born again by
the power of God. “By their fruit you will recognize them” (Matthew 7:16). The
redeemed of God belong “to him who was raised from the dead, in order that we
might bear fruit for God” (Romans 7:4).
Nothing can separate a child of God from the Father’s love (Romans 8:38–39).
Nothing can remove a Christian from God’s hand (John 10:28–29). God guarantees
eternal life and maintains the salvation He has given us. The Good Shepherd
searches for the lost sheep, and, “when he finds it, he joyfully puts it on his
shoulders and goes home” (Luke 15:5–6). The lamb is found, and the Shepherd
gladly bears the burden; our Lord takes full responsibility for bringing the
lost one safely home.
Jude 1:24–25 further emphasizes the goodness and faithfulness of our Savior: To
him who is able to keep you from stumbling and to present you before his
glorious presence without fault and with great joy—to the only God our Savior be
glory, majesty, power and authority, through Jesus Christ our Lord, before all
ages, now and forevermore! Amen.”