English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For April 30/2024
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2024/english.april30.24.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
Bible
Quotations For today
You know that among the Gentiles those whom they recognize as their rulers
lord it over them, and their great ones are tyrants over them. But it is not
so among you; but whoever wishes to become great among you must be your
servant
Holy Gospel of Jesus Christ according to Saint Mark
10/35-45./:"James and John, the sons of Zebedee, came forward to Jesus and
said to him, ‘Teacher, we want you to do for us whatever we ask of you.’And
he said to them, ‘What is it you want me to do for you?’And they said to
him, ‘Grant us to sit, one at your right hand and one at your left, in your
glory.’But Jesus said to them, ‘You do not know what you are asking. Are you
able to drink the cup that I drink, or be baptized with the baptism that I
am baptized with?’They replied, ‘We are able.’ Then Jesus said to them, ‘The
cup that I drink you will drink; and with the baptism with which I am
baptized, you will be baptized; but to sit at my right hand or at my left is
not mine to grant, but it is for those for whom it has been prepared. ’When
the ten heard this, they began to be angry with James and John. So Jesus
called them and said to them, ‘You know that among the Gentiles those whom
they recognize as their rulers lord it over them, and their great ones are
tyrants over them. But it is not so among you; but whoever wishes to become
great among you must be your servant, and whoever wishes to be first among
you must be slave of all. For the Son of Man came not to be served but to
serve, and to give his life a ransom for many.’
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese
Related News & Editorials published on April 29-30/2024
The student demonstrations in America are being orchestrated and funded
by nefarious groups including the Iranian lobby, the Muslim Brotherhood, and
elements of the leftist organizations
Elias Bejjani/April 27/2024
Libya demands improvements after leaked photos show tiny cell of Muammar
Qaddafi’s son in Beirut
French FM in Beirut submits new peace proposal
South Lebanon: Airstrikes on Khiam, Tayr Harfa
Southern Front: French Roadmap Handed over to Berry
Southern Lebanon: More Than 30 Rockets Fired Towards Galilee
South Lebanon: Airstrikes on Khiam, Tayr Harfa
Hamas claims rocket barrage from Lebanon into north Israel
Jamaa Islamiya armed parade and gunfire draw condemnations
Mikati Holds Two Meetings on the Illegal Syrian Presence
Syndicates of Banks’ Employees Reject Sector Restructuring Plan
Lebanon faces the imminent risk of being placed on the FATF grey list by late
May
Jordan and France coordinate efforts for Gaza and Lebanon peace
Fadlallah: Any external initiative aiming to relieve the enemy is doomed to fail
Arafat Tfayli to LBCI's Vision 2030: Cancer rates in Lebanon are higher than in
neighboring countries
Spring Storms: Hail, Flooding, Mudslides, Deadly Road Accidents
Berri: Lebanon yet to receive French paper, Hochstein hasn't requested meeting
Bassil reportedly refers Alain Aoun to FPM’s 'arbitration council'
EU's von der Leyen and Cypriot president to visit Lebanon together
Top French diplomat in Lebanon seeks Israel-Hezbollah de-escalation
War and Diplomacy: Who Will Win in Rafah?
Aoun Refrains From Appearing Before Disciplinary Commission
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
Miscellaneous Reports And News published
on
April 29-30/2024
Israeli officials fear international court is preparing arrest warrants over
Gaza war
Israeli Leaders Concerned About Possible ICC Arrest Warrants
Clear Encampment or Face Suspension, Columbia University Tells Israel-Hamas War
Protesters
US, Britain Urge Hamas to Accept Israeli Truce Proposal
Israel Kills at Least 22 Palestinians in Rafah
US appeals to UAE, others to stop support for Sudan's warring parties
Israel's strike showed Iran's air defenses were 'woefully unprepared.' Here's
what Tehran may do next.
‘My whole family has perished:’ 22 killed in Israeli airstrike on Rafah,
hospital staff say
Bernie Sanders Accuses Israel Of Ethnic Cleansing In Gaza's 'Humanitarian
Disaster'
McGill University calls pro-Palestinian encampment illegal, campers vow to stay
Paris Police Clear Gaza Protesters at Sorbonne University
Six-Party Ministerial Meeting Convenes in Riyadh to Discuss Israeli War in Gaza
Strip
No 'major issues': Hamas delegation to arrive in Egypt for Gaza truce talks
El-Sisi, Biden affirm the danger of a military escalation in Rafah
US says it 'does not support' ICC investigations of Israel
Italy reports downing a Houthi-launched drone in the Red Sea
Mali forces kill senior figure in Islamic State affiliate
Titles For The Latest English LCCC analysis &
editorials from miscellaneous sources on April 29-30/2024
U.S. Campuses: Grooming Terrorists/Bassam Tawil/Gatestone Institute./April 29,
2024
Kissinger’s Shadow Chases Blinken/Ghassan Charbel/Asharq Al-Awsat/April 29/2024
Why Are We Gambling With America’s Future?/David Brooks/The New York Times/April
29/2024
HomeUS policy toward the Israel-Palestine conflict needs rebalancing/Dr.
Mohammed Al-Sulami/Arab News/April 29, 2024
Will a new embassy mean a new approach for the US in Libya?/Hafed Al-Ghwell/Arab
News/April 29, 2024
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on April 29-30/2024
The student demonstrations in America are being orchestrated and funded by
nefarious groups including the Iranian lobby, the Muslim Brotherhood, and
elements of the leftist organizations
Elias Bejjani/April 27/2024
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/129236/129236/
The student demonstrations in America are being orchestrated and funded by
nefarious groups including the Iranian lobby, the Muslim Brotherhood, and
elements of the left. This revelation sheds light on the true nature of these
protests, which aim to undermine American values and sow discord.
A glaring example of this manipulation is evident in a widely circulated image
depicting a student protester brandishing a guitar while proudly displaying the
flag of Iranian Hezbollah—an organization designated as a terrorist group in the
United States. The irony is palpable; Iranian Hezbollah, known for its archaic
beliefs that reject music and advocate violence, stands in stark contrast to the
principles of freedom and tolerance cherished by American society.
These orchestrated demonstrations represent a clear affront to American culture
and values. They serve as a false veneer of dissent, incapable of altering the
realities of oppressive regimes like the criminal mullahs’ regime in Iran, the
jihadist activities of Hamas, the terrorist actions of Hezbollah in Lebanon, and
the pervasive influence of Iranian aggression across the Middle East.
It is imperative that Americans remain vigilant against the insidious influence
of these foreign actors and reject their attempts to subvert the democratic
principles. The true spirit of America cannot be swayed by the machinations of
those who seek to undermine it.
Libya demands improvements after leaked photos show tiny
cell of Muammar Qaddafi’s son in Beirut
AP/April 29, 2024
BEIRUT: Leaked photographs of the son of Libya’s late dictator Muammar Qaddafi
and the tiny underground cell where he has been held for years in Lebanon have
raised concerns in the north African nation as Libyan authorities demand
improvements. The photos showed a room without natural light packed with
Hannibal Qaddafi’s belongings, a bed and a tiny toilet. “I live in misery,”
local Al-Jadeed TV quoted the detainee as saying in a Saturday evening
broadcast, adding that he is a political prisoner in a case he has no
information about. Two Lebanese judicial officials confirmed to The Associated
Press on Monday that the photographs aired by Al-Jadeed are of Qaddafi and the
cell where he has been held for years at police headquarters in Beirut. Qaddafi
appeared healthy, with a light beard and glasses. A person who is usually in
contact with Qaddafi, a Libyan citizen, said the photos were taken in recent
days. All spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to
speak to media outlets. Qaddafi has been held in Lebanon since 2015 after he was
kidnapped from neighboring Syria, where he had been living as a political
refugee. He was abducted by Lebanese militants demanding information about the
fate of prominent Lebanese Shiite cleric Moussa Al-Sadr, who went missing during
a trip to Libya in 1978. The fate of Al-Sadr has been a sore point in Lebanon.
His family believes he may still be alive in a Libyan prison, though most
Lebanese presume Al-Sadr, who would be 95 now, is dead. A Libyan delegation
visited Beirut in January to reopen talks with Lebanese officials on the fate of
Al-Sadr and the release of Qaddafi. The talks were aimed at reactivating a
dormant agreement between Lebanon and Libya, struck in 2014, for cooperation in
the probe of Al-Sadr. The delegation did not return to Beirut as planned. The
leaks by Al-Jadeed came after reports that Qaddafi was receiving special
treatment at police headquarters and that he had cosmetic surgeries including
hair transplants and teeth improvements. Al-Jadeed quoted him as saying: “Let
them take my hair and teeth and give me my freedom.”Qaddafi went on a hunger
strike in June last year and was taken to a hospital after his health
deteriorated. Libya’s Justice Ministry in a statement Sunday said Qaddafi is
being deprived of his rights guaranteed by law. It called on Lebanese
authorities to improve his living conditions to one that “preserves his
dignity,” adding that Lebanese authorities should formally inform the ministry
of the improvements. It also said Qaddafi deserves to be released. After he was
kidnapped in 2015, Lebanese authorities freed him but then detained him,
accusing him of concealing information about Al-Sadr’s disappearance. Al-Sadr
was the founder of the Amal group, a Shiite militia that fought in Lebanon’s
1975-90 civil war and later became a political party that is currently led by
the country’s Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri. Many of Al-Sadr’s followers are
convinced that Muammar Qaddafi ordered Al-Sadr killed in a dispute over Libyan
payments to Lebanese militias. Libya has maintained that the cleric, along with
two traveling companions, left Tripoli in 1978 on a flight to Rome. Human Rights
Watch issued a statement in January calling for Qaddafi’s release. The rights
group noted that Qaddafi was only 2 years old at the time of Al-Sadr’s
disappearance and held no senior position in Libya as an adult.
French FM in Beirut submits new peace proposal
NAJIA HOUSSARI/Arab News/April 29, 2024
BEIRUT: The French foreign minister has submitted a new peace proposal in Beirut
aimed at ending months of violence between Hezbollah and Israel. Stephane
Sejourne met officials in Beirut on Sunday, calling on the warring parties to
abide by UN Resolution 1701. After the talks, he said: “War exists even if not
explicitly named. Civilians are paying the price, and no one is interested in
the continuing escalation. This is the message I conveyed here, and this is the
message I will convey on Tuesday to Israel.”The minister discussed an amendment
to a proposal Paris had presented to Lebanon for a diplomatic resolution to the
conflict. UN Resolution 1701, which brought an end to the brutal
Israel-Hezbollah war in 2006, is widely viewed as the most suitable framework
for ending the latest conflict. However, Hezbollah has persisted with linking
its strikes on Israel to events in the Gaza Strip, while the Lebanese state has
reminded Israel of its obligation to Resolution 1701 following repeated
violations. On Monday, reports said that a French technical team would bring the
revised French initiative to Lebanese authorities within 48 hours. Parliament
Speaker Nabih Berri was notified by Sejourne about the update. The proposal will
be delivered to Lebanon through diplomatic channels, said the French minister,
who left Lebanon on Sunday night following his visit. The revised version of the
French initiative contains several pillars, including the cessation of
hostilities between Hezbollah and the Israeli army under UN Resolution 1701. It
also calls for the safe return of Israelis to northern settlements and Lebanese
citizens to border towns in the south. Additionally, the initiative calls for
deploying more Lebanese military forces across border areas and strengthening
the UN peacekeeping mission in Lebanon, UNIFIL. The earlier version of the
French peace plan, sent to Lebanon in mid-March, called for Hezbollah and its
allies to retreat 10-12 km from the border. It also urged Israel to avoid “air
violations.”While in Beirut, Sejourne advised Berri to prioritize the election
of a president before finalizing negotiations on the situation in the south.
Establishing a governing authority and ensuring presidential involvement in
negotiations with Israel was “important,” he said. Berri presented Sejourne with
a map from the Scientific Research Institute that detailed the extensive damage
and losses caused by Israeli military operations in southern Lebanon. The map
said that Israeli phosphorus bombings had affected “an area of 10 million sq
meters.”In addition, since the low-level conflict began last October, 1,000
housing units have been destroyed and thousands partially damaged. Israeli
operations have caused “significant harm to the environment and agriculture,” an
infographic said. After his talks in Lebanon, the French foreign minister said:
“The crisis has lasted a long time. We are working to avoid Lebanon being
ravaged by a regional war. “We call on all parties to exercise restraint, and we
reject the worst scenario in Lebanon, which is war.”The UNIFIL operational
region in Lebanon saw no activity on Sunday morning, after months of hostilies
between Hezbollah and Israel in the area. It coincided with Sejourne’s visit to
UNIFIL headquarters in Naqoura, where he was briefed on the border situation by
commander Gen. Aroldo Lazaro. Sejourne also inspected the work of French
peacekeepers serving with UNIFIL. Meanwhile, Israeli military drones launched
two missiles toward Aita Al-Shaab on Monday. Other Israeli military drones
raided Khiam, following a night of heavy shelling on Lebanese border villages,
including Aita Al-Shaab, Kfarkila, Tayr Harfa, Naqoura and Jabal Blat. Hezbollah
said it targeted “a gathering of Israeli soldiers in the vicinity of the
Ruwaizat Al-Alam site with artillery shells.” Residents in southern Lebanon have
claimed that the Israeli army is deploying “a new type of heavy artillery.”One
resident told Arab News: “The whole region shakes and the ground trembles under
our feet from the border until Nabatieh as if they were using seismic,
thermobaric missiles.”The morning Israeli strikes were a response to the
interception of “over 30 missiles launched from southern Lebanon toward the
Galilee panhandle and the upper Galilee,” according to Israeli media. The Al-Qassam
Brigades — the military wing of Hamas — said in a statement that its Lebanon
branch had targeted the headquarters of Israel’s 769th Eastern Brigade. The
group launched a salvo of rockets from southern Lebanon, describing the attack
as a response to “Israel’s massacres in Gaza and the West Bank.”
South Lebanon: Airstrikes on Khiam, Tayr Harfa
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
In a recent escalation of tensions, Israeli airstrikes targeted multiple
locations in southern Lebanon, including Khiam and Tayr Harfa. Reports indicate
that no casualties were reported in Tayr Harfa, where a house was targeted.
Furthermore, Israeli drones were observed flying at unusually low altitudes over
the towns of Odaisseh, Taybeh and Deir Siriane, adding to the tensions in the
area. In a statement on Monday, Hezbollah said that they had targeted buildings
housing Israeli soldiers in the settlement of Metula, inflicting direct hits.
The airstrikes were not limited to specific areas, as Israeli warplanes also
raided a town between Aita al-Shaab and Ramia. One residential building in Aita
al-Shaab bore the brunt of the attack. In addition, an airstrike in Jebbayn on a
three-story building led to the closure of the main road at the Jebbayn-Tayr
Harfa junction, exacerbating tensions in the area.
Southern Front: French Roadmap Handed over to Berry
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
The roadmap proposed by Paris to end the armed conflict between Hezbollah and
Israel was reportedly handed over to the Lebanese authorities on Monday. The
move follows French Foreign Minister Stéphane Séjourné’s visit to Lebanon, on
Sunday. Beirut was the first leg of a regional tour that includes Saudi Arabia,
where the French minister is currently holding talks with Saudi officials, and
Israel. According to the daily An-Nahar, “At 7 PM (Monday), the French embassy
handed over to President Berry the French document aimed at finding a peaceful
and diplomatic solution (a ceasefire) to the war in southern Lebanon between
Israel and Hezbollah.”Earlier in the afternoon, caretaker Prime Minister Najib
Mikati received the French ambassador to Lebanon, Hervé Magro, at the Serail.
The diplomat discussed with Mr. Mikati “the results of yesterday’s (Sunday)
visit to Lebanon by the French Foreign Minister, Stéphane Séjourné, and new
French ideas regarding the situation in South Lebanon,” said a statement from
the Prime Minister’s office. Western diplomatic sources, contacted by This is
Beirut, would not confirm or deny the handover of the document to Mr. Berry,
saying it was up to the Lebanese authorities to “confirm and share this
information.”The same source indicated that the French ambassador’s visit to the
Serail was “protocolary” and that it was “normal for Mr. Magro to evaluate Mr.
Séjourné’s visit with the Prime Minister.” France, Lebanon’s long-standing
partner, has been engaged for months in a mission of good offices to prevent the
war between Hezbollah and Israel on the southern front from spreading to the
whole country, notably through a ceasefire and the application of Security
Council Resolution 1701.
Southern Lebanon: More Than 30 Rockets Fired Towards
Galilee
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
More than 30 rockets were launched on Monday morning from southern Lebanon
towards the Galilee panhandle and Upper Galilee. Additionally, the outskirts of
the towns of Alma al-Shaab and Naqoura were subjected to intermittent artillery
shelling at dawn, coinciding with the firing of flares above the villages of the
western and central sectors, reaching the outskirts of the towns of Zebqine,
Yatar and Kafra. Israeli warplanes raided the towns of Tayr Harfa, Marwahin,
Naqoura and Jabal Blat shortly before midnight, causing significant damage to
property, crops, infrastructure and homes. At midnight, a raid was launched on
the town of Aita al-Shaab in the central sector, which was more intense than
others, as its sound was heard throughout the South, resulting in significant
damage to property and crops. Israeli reconnaissance aircraft continued to fly
over villages adjacent to the Blue Line in the South. Israel also fired heavy
machine gun fire towards fishing boats in the port of Naqoura. Meanwhile, the
United Nations Interim Forces in South Lebanon (UNIFIL) expressed deep concern
on Sunday at the sharp increase in escalation on both sides of the Blue Line
between Israel and Hezbollah.
South Lebanon: Airstrikes on Khiam, Tayr Harfa
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
In a recent escalation of tensions, Israeli airstrikes targeted multiple
locations in southern Lebanon, including Khiam and Tayr Harfa. Reports indicate
that no casualties were reported in Tayr Harfa, where a house was targeted.
Furthermore, Israeli drones were observed flying at unusually low altitudes over
the towns of Odaisseh, Taybeh and Deir Siriane, adding to the tensions in the
area. In a statement on Monday, Hezbollah said that they had targeted buildings
housing Israeli soldiers in the settlement of Metula, inflicting direct hits.
The airstrikes were not limited to specific areas, as Israeli warplanes also
raided a town between Aita al-Shaab and Ramia. One residential building in Aita
al-Shaab bore the brunt of the attack. In addition, an airstrike in Jebbayn on a
three-story building led to the closure of the main road at the Jebbayn-Tayr
Harfa junction, exacerbating tensions in the area.
Hamas claims rocket barrage from Lebanon into north
Israel
Agence France Presse/April 29, 2024
Hamas' armed wing the Ezzedine al-Qassam Brigades fired Monday a barrage of
rockets from south Lebanon toward a command center in northern Israel. Hezbollah
has exchanged near-daily strikes with Israeli forces in the border region — and
sometimes beyond — for almost seven months against the backdrop of Israel’s war
on Gaza. Hamas has also claimed cross-border attacks. Hamas fighters "have fired
a concentrated rocket barrage from south Lebanon towards" an Israeli military
position, said the Ezzedine al-Qassam Brigades in a statement on Telegram. The
armed wing described the action as a "response to the massacres of the Zionist
enemy (Israel)" in Gaza and the occupied West Bank. The Israeli army told AFP
that "approximately 20 launches crossed from Lebanon into Israeli territory" but
it had intercepted most rockets and struck "the sources of fire"."No injuries or
damage were reported," the army said. An Israeli drone later struck the southern
border town of Aita al-Shaab. Hezbollah meanwhile targeted a group of soldiers
in the Ruweisat al-Alam post in the occupied Kfarshouba Hills. Hamas' rocket
barrage came as Hamas negotiators were expected to arrive in Egypt on Monday,
where they were due to respond to Israel's latest proposal for a long-sought
truce in Gaza and hostage release. On April 21, the Qassam Brigades claimed a
rocket barrage into northern Israel. A strike in January, which the U.S. said
was carried out by Israel, killed Hamas deputy leader Saleh al-Arouri and six
militants in Hezbollah's south Beirut stronghold. An Israeli strike later in
March killed a Hamas operative near the Palestinian refugee camp of Rashidiyeh
in the Tyre district. Also in March, a Hamas official escaped an Israeli drone
strike near the village of Souairi in the Bekaa Valley. In Lebanon, at least 385
people have been killed in months of cross-border violence, mostly militants but
also 73 civilians, according to an AFP tally. The tally includes at least 11
Hamas fighters. Israel says 11 soldiers and nine civilians have been killed on
its side of the border. Tens of thousands of people have been displaced on both
sides.
Jamaa Islamiya armed parade and gunfire draw condemnations
Naharnet/April 29, 2024
Gunmen in north Lebanon paraded with light- and medium-caliber arms and fired
heavily in the air during the funeral of two Jamaa Islamiya militants killed in
an Israeli drone strike, drawing condemnations from some Lebanese political
forces. The two militants, Mohammad Saeed Khalaf and Bilal Mohammad Khalaf, were
targeted by the Israeli strike in the West Bekaa town of Maydoun on Friday. The
funeral procession started at Tripoli’s al-Nour Square and made its way through
Minieh, al-Abdeh and al-Mhammara before reaching the militants’ hometown Bebnin
in the Akkar district, where stray bullets wounded three people including a
child. MP Waddah al-Sadek said “armed appearances inside the country only serve
Israel,” decrying that “the bullets and shells landed in Akkar, which lies
hundreds of kilometers away from Jerusalem, wounding Lebanese citizens and
highlighting anew the insistence on destroying the state.”“The main
responsibility falls on the Jamaa Islamiya, with its insistence on unjustified
armed appearances, previously on Beirut’s streets and yesterday in Akkar,” al-Sadek
added. The Tajaddod bloc, which comprises MPs Michel Mouawad, Ashraf Rifi, Fouad
Makhzoumi and Adib Abdel Massih, for its part said its rejects “the scenes of
armed parades and chaotic weapons,” stressing that “only the state with its
legitimate forces is responsible for defending Lebanon.”MP Mark Daou for his
part warned that such a parade “undermines the principle of the state,
legitimacy and sovereignty.”Jamaa Islamiya meanwhile issued a statement
regretting “the armed appearances and shooting that accompanied the transfer of
the coffins of the two martyrs from Tripoli to Bebnin.”Stressing that it is
“keen on the country’s stability and the citizen’s security,” the group said
that “any bullet fired at any side other than the Israeli enemy would be at the
wrong place” and that “any scene that sows fear and panic among the Lebanese is
unacceptable.”The Israeli military said Friday that it targeted an official with
Lebanon’s Jamaa Islamiya, or the Islamic Group, that is allied with Hezbollah
and Hamas. It has been active in predominantly Sunni Muslim villages along
Lebanon’s southern border with Israel. The Israeli military said the man killed
was Musab Khalaf. It says Khalaf was behind attacks on Israeli troops in the
disputed Shebaa Farms that Israel captured from Syria during the 1967 Mideast
war. The Lebanese government says the area belongs to Lebanon. Hezbollah and
Israel have traded fire on a near-daily basis along the border since the start
of the war in Gaza nearly seven months ago. Hezbollah says it is acting in
solidarity with the Palestinian militant group Hamas.
Mikati Holds Two Meetings on the Illegal Syrian Presence
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati held two meetings on Monday at the Grand
Serail, both focusing on the Syrian refugee crisis. The first meeting was
attended by Caretaker Minister of Interior and Municipalities Judge Bassam
Mawlawi, Acting Director of General Security Elias Baissari, UN Resident and
Humanitarian Coordinator for Lebanon Imran Riza, and the United Nations High
Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) Representative in Lebanon, Ivo Freijsen.
Discussions during this session primarily focused on Lebanon’s collaboration
with UNHCR, aiming to create collaborative strategies to tackle the multifaceted
challenges associated with the refugee crisis. Additionally, Lebanon is
considering potential repatriation of Syrian nationals who have served sentences
in Lebanese prisons. Subsequently, Prime Minister Mikati received a delegation
from the Lebanese Forces parliamentary bloc, led by MP Sethrida Geagea. The
delegation, alongside Mawlawi and General Baissari, engaged in discussions
concerning the issue of the illegal Syrian presence in Lebanon. A statement
issued by Geagea’s office emphasized that “Lebanon is a transit country and not
a refuge country at all.” It acknowledged the efforts of municipalities within
the bloc’s active areas in managing this presence. “However, this alone is not
sufficient, and it is the responsibility of the security forces and the General
Security to play their central and essential role in this matter,” the statement
read. The delegation urged Mikati to provide clear directives to the Ministers
of Interior and Defense, aimed at enforcing Lebanese laws concerning illegal
foreigners within the nation’s borders. These meetings precede the anticipated
arrival on Thursday of the Head of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen,
and Cypriot President Nikos Christodoulides. Cyprus is pressing Beirut for a
resolution to the persistent influx of Syrian migrants from Lebanon.
Christodoulides previously visited Beirut on April 16 to appeal to Lebanese
authorities for enhanced control over maritime borders. The latter sought
Nicosia’s intervention with the European Union for a comprehensive solution to
the Syrian presence issue, akin to agreements already established with certain
host countries.
Syndicates of Banks’ Employees Reject Sector Restructuring
Plan
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
The Federation of Syndicates of Banks’ Employees in Lebanon strongly rejected
the government’s proposed plan to restructure the banking sector. Discussion of
the proposed draft law aimed at addressing Lebanon’s banking crisis and the
government’s proposed restructuring measures took place on Monday in a meeting
organized by the Federation in collaboration with the Faculty of Management at
Saint-Joseph University. Participants unanimously concurred that “the proposed
project fails to offer a viable solution to the banking sector’s challenges;
rather, it exacerbates them.” They anticipate that its implementation will lead
to the liquidation of numerous banks, exacerbating the issue of deposit erosion.
Furthermore, Georges Antoine Al Hajj, the president of the Federation of
Syndicates of Banks’ Employees in Lebanon, stated that the outcomes of the
meeting would be documented in a memorandum to be presented to stakeholders
involved in the banking sector restructuring.
Lebanon faces the imminent risk of being placed on the FATF
grey list by late May
LBCI/April 29, 2024
Lebanon has been listed under the Grey List by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF),
signaling heightened oversight in combating money laundering and terrorist
financing. This development could potentially prompt correspondent banks to
cease dealings with Lebanese banks, leading to a halt in financial transfers to
and from the country. Last December, Lebanon narrowly avoided being placed on
the FATF grey list, being granted a six-month grace period following assurances
from Banque du Liban (BDL) and the government to implement measures enhancing
anti-corruption efforts and combating money laundering and terrorist financing.
In response, BDL imposed stricter reporting requirements on banks regarding the
source of funds and mandated that each bank establish departments dedicated to
combating money laundering and terrorist financing. However, these measures fell
short of FATF expectations. After six months, the Lebanese government had not
taken significant steps to address three key areas: Firstly, combating
corruption within state administrations remained stagnant. Secondly, the
judiciary's pursuit of money laundering cases was lacking, with the offense
considered a felony rather than a crime. Moreover, there were no instances of
assets or properties seized from prosecuted drug traffickers. Thirdly, the
government failed to confront financial activities associated with para-military
groups, including Hezbollah. Lebanon now faces the imminent risk of being placed
on the FATF grey list by late May. During his recent visit to Washington, the
acting BDL governor Wassim Mansouri, expressed hope that he was able to convey
Lebanon's unique circumstances and challenges to FATF officials. Mansouri
expressed optimism that Lebanon could once again avoid being listed but
cautioned that this might be the country's final opportunity to do so.
Jordan and France coordinate efforts for Gaza and Lebanon
peace
LBCI/April 29, 2024
Jordan's Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates,
Ayman Safadi, met with French Foreign Minister Stéphane Séjourné in Riyadh,
Saudi Arabia. The discussions ensued as a follow-up to meetings between King
Abdullah II and French President Emmanuel Macron, focusing on joint efforts to
secure a ceasefire in Gaza and foster a path towards a comprehensive peace
grounded in a two-state solution. The meeting, occurring on the fringes of the
World Economic Forum's special session hosted by Saudi Arabia, underscored
Safadi's emphasis on the critical need for a unified international stance to
prevent any attacks on Rafah, underscoring the potential for further tragedies.
Among the topics deliberated were the volatile circumstances in the West Bank,
where Safadi reiterated the importance of ceasing all unilateral and unlawful
actions by Israel exacerbating tensions, notably settlement expansions and land
seizures. Safadi lauded France's support of the two-state solution and its
condemnation of settlements as illegitimate endeavors. Additionally, discussions
extended to Lebanon, with Séjourné briefing Safadi on initiatives to avoid the
emergence of fresh hostilities.
Safadi stressed the necessity of preemptive measures to prevent the widening of
conflicts and ensure regional stability. Both Safadi and Séjourné reaffirmed
their commitment to collaborative efforts to halt hostilities in Gaza and
facilitate humanitarian aid distribution. Furthermore, they discussed ways for
enhancing bilateral ties, expressing mutual dedication to expanding cooperation
across diverse sectors to yield positive outcomes for both countries.
Fadlallah: Any external initiative aiming to relieve the enemy is doomed to fail
LBCI/April 29, 2024
Member of the Loyalty to the Resistance bloc, MP Hassan Fadlallah, stated that
any external initiative toward Lebanon aiming to relieve the Netanyahu
government so it can focus on Gaza is doomed to fail. He noted that seeking
solutions should not involve addressing the consequences but rather the causes
that led to the situation. During a memorial event held for the victims of the
Zionist aggression at the Imam Hussein (AS) complex in the city of Tyre,
Fadlallah emphasized that those seeking solutions should focus on pressuring the
Zionist entity to stop the massacre in Gaza. He stated, "Deciding how the south
will look after the cessation of aggression is up to the Lebanese people and
state, based on rules protecting the south, including the army, the people, and
the resistance, and preserving our national sovereignty." He added, "Our
achievements are far greater than what can be seen by those with limited vision,
weak minds, or those with prior records and no conscience. What matters to us is
the impact on the enemy, forcing it to stop its aggression."Fadlallah continued:
"This is evident in the pressure on Lebanon to stop the resistance and the
anxiety felt by the enemy, which causes anger and resentment in others."He
affirmed that any harm inflicted by the enemy on civilians will be met with an
immediate response. After targeting Hanin, the enemy suffered a severe blow for
two days. Any Israeli escalation will be met with an appropriate response from
the resistance. He pointed out that "the resistance is establishing a protection
model today that allows the people of the south to stand firm on their land,
preventing their displacement and keeping the enemy in check while the Zionists
continue building settlements."Fadlallah further emphasized, "Times have
changed: when we are displaced, so are they; when our villages are bombed, so
are their settlements. This is unlike the past when villages were invaded
without restraint, and the enemy could establish a foothold in our villages
using collaborators to execute its plans."
Arafat Tfayli to LBCI's Vision 2030: Cancer rates in
Lebanon are higher than in neighboring countries
LBCI/April 29, 2024
Doctor Arafat Tfayli confirmed that cancer rates in Lebanon are higher than in
neighboring countries. He explained that "these figures do not reflect what is
currently happening because a person exposed to pollution does not develop
cancer instantly." He pointed out that the number of cancer patients starts to
rise after five, 10, and 15 years from now. In an interview on LBCI's "Vision
2030" program, he said: "The numbers we have are trending upward, but not
significantly. Pollution has not shown its effects yet." He added: "We expect a
'cancer tsunami' in Lebanon in the next five to 10 years due to pollution,
smoking, and other reasons."He also pointed out that according to the latest
statistics, there are about 1200 people who have lung cancer out of about
10,000, which is a rate of 12 percent.
Spring Storms: Hail, Flooding, Mudslides, Deadly Road
Accidents
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
On Monday, many Lebanese lived to the rhythm of torrential rain, thunderstorms,
floods and even hail that affected several regions of the country, notably North
Lebanon, Hermel and the Beqaa, causing several road accidents. Due to the strong
atmospheric depression affecting Lebanon and the region, Dahr el-Baydar was
covered in a white coat for a few hours, following heavy hail. The bad weather
severely affected road traffic, to the point that the authorities had to issue
warnings to motorists, due to a series of other road accidents. On the Hazmieh
highway, a truck slid, hitting two vehicles, killing one man, D. B. (39 years
old) and injuring two others. On the Naameh highway, one person was injured when
his vehicle slid and fell on its side due to the rain. Monstrous traffic
jams were recorded everywhere, notably in the vicinity of Beirut’s National
Museum, due to a collision between two vehicles, and on the coastal highway.
Motorists were also stranded on the airport road, from Ouzai to Khaldeh, from
Downtown to Jal el-Dib. Torrential rains in the Hermel caza caused extensive
agricultural damage. They also caused flooding in Qaa and several other areas of
Hermel, leading to landslides, mudslides and flooding of the Orontes river. The
rising waters caused major damage to cafés on the banks of the Orontes. The bad
weather condition is causing dense fog in the mountains and a drop in
temperatures, with heavy rain sometimes accompanied by thunderstorms and active
winds. The weather will remain gloomy and unstable on Tuesday.
Berri: Lebanon yet to receive French paper, Hochstein
hasn't requested meeting
Naharnet/April 29, 2024
The Lebanese side is yet to receive a French paper proposing a solution for the
Israel-Hezbollah conflict, knowing that it was supposed to receive it two days
prior to French Foreign Minister Stéphane Séjourné’s weekend visit to Lebanon,
Speaker Nabih Berri said overnight. “When I asked Séjourné why the French paper
had not been sent, he said that we would receive it within hours and we agreed
that we would study it once it arrives,” Berri told al-Jadeed TV. “Séjourné did
not mention the separation of fronts and I reiterated to him that when the war
on Gaza stops, the front in Lebanon will be deactivated,” the Speaker added.
Informed French sources later told al-Jadeed that "the amended French paper will
be delivered to Lebanese officials today (Monday) or tomorrow." Separately,
Berri said that U.S. mediator Amos Hochstein, who was reportedly in Israel in
recent days, “has not requested an appointment and has not said that he would
visit Lebanon.”
Bassil reportedly refers Alain Aoun to FPM’s 'arbitration
council'
Naharnet/April 29, 2024
Free Patriotic Movement chief Jebran Bassil has informed MP Alain Aoun of the
FPM that he has been referred to the Movement’s so-called arbitration council,
days after Deputy Speaker Elias Bou Saab was reportedly expelled from the FPM, a
media report said. The developments prompted MP Ibrahim Kanaan to send a letter
to Bassil urging him to “reverse these decisions that threaten the FPM’s unity
and image, especially amid these circumstances,” the Nidaa al-Watan newspaper
reported on Monday. Kanaab also called on Bassil to “open the door of dialogue
to address these sensitive issues away from the current tensions,” the daily
added.
EU's von der Leyen and Cypriot president to visit Lebanon
together
Naharnet/April 29, 2024
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen will visit Beirut on May 2
together with President of Cyprus Nikos Christodoulides, the EU Delegation to
Lebanon said on Monday. “They will head to the Grand Serail for a meeting
chaired by caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati, then to Ain el Tineh for a
meeting with Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri,” the EU Delegation said in a
statement. The Cypriot president had visited Lebanon on April 8 alongside his
country's interior and foreign ministers and army chief, shortly after he urged
the EU to intercede with Lebanese authorities to help stop boatloads of Syrian
refugees from heading to Cyprus. Christodoulides and Mikati also called on the
European Union to provide financial support to help cash-strapped Lebanon stop
migrants from reaching European shores. Mikati said the Lebanese military and
security agencies have been doing their utmost to curb migration, but the
situation was so dire that it needed “a framework agreement” with the EU. He was
referring to already sanctioned migration-linked European financial packages
with cash-strapped Mediterranean countries Tunisia and Egypt. Christodoulides
agreed with Mikati on the importance of reaching a similar agreement with
Lebanon as Cyprus, along with other European countries, has been witnessing a
spike in migrant arrivals. According to the Cypriot Interior Ministry, some
2,140 people arrived by boat in Cyprus between Jan. 1 and Apr. 4 of this year,
compared to only 78 people during that same period in 2023. The vast majority
were Syrian nationals departing from Lebanon. Lebanon — which is coping with a
crippling economic crisis since 2019 — hosts some 805,000 U.N.-registered Syrian
refugees, of which 90% live in poverty, the U.N.’s refugee agency says. Lebanese
officials estimate the actual number is far higher, ranging between 1.5 and 2
million. Many have escaped the civil war in their country which entered its 14th
year. The U.N. refugee agency also noted the surge in migrant departures from
Lebanon and confirmed that most were Syrian refugees.
Lebanon and Cyprus already have a bilateral deal where Cypriot authorities would
return migrants attempting to reach the island from Lebanon. Mikati has said
that most of Syria has become safe as the conflict is now at a stalemate, urging
the EU to support the repatriation of Syrian refugees or help them resettle in
other countries. Christodoulides said earlier in April that most Syrian migrants
fled their home country mainly for economic reasons and called on the
international community to fund development projects in Syria that would help
incentivize or motivate their return, according to a statement issued by
Mikati's office. However, U.N. agencies, human rights groups, and Western
governments maintain that Syria is not yet safe for repatriation. In a separate
statement, Cyprus' government spokesman said Christodoulides told Lebanese
officials that EU help would depend on the results of Lebanon’s efforts to curb
increased migrant arrivals to the island nation. Cyprus has been pushing for the
EU to re-designate some areas within war-torn Syria into “safe zones” for such
repatriations. Cypriot Interior Minister Constantinos Ioannou said recently that
the proposal is gaining traction among the 27-nation bloc but it wouldn’t happen
in the near term. A Lebanese diplomatic official familiar with Lebanese-Cypriot
talks said that both delegations were discussing a joint proposal focused on
Syrian refugees returning home. Talks between Syrian parties to find a political
solution are currently frozen. While Damascus was reinstated in the Arab League
last year, the EU previously said conditions to restore ties were yet to be met.
Top French diplomat in Lebanon seeks Israel-Hezbollah de-escalation
Associated Press/April 29, 2024
French Foreign Minister Stéphane Séjourné visited Lebanon as part of diplomatic
attempts to broker a de-escalation in the conflict on the Lebanon-Israel border.
Séjourné met on Sunday with United Nations peacekeeping forces in south Lebanon
and with Lebanon's parliament speaker, army chief, foreign minister and
caretaker prime minister. France "is refusing to accept the worst-case scenario"
of a full-scale war in Lebanon, he told journalists after the meetings. "In
southern Lebanon, the war is already here, even if it's not called by that name,
and it's the civilian population who's paying the price," he said.Hezbollah has
exchanged near-daily strikes with Israeli forces in the border region — and
sometimes beyond — for almost seven months against the backdrop of Israel's war
against Hezbollah ally Hamas in Gaza. Israeli strikes have killed more than 350
people in Lebanon, most of them fighters with Hezbollah and allied groups but
also including more than 50 civilians. Strikes by Hezbollah have killed at least
10 civilians and 12 soldiers in Israel. Tens of thousands are displaced on each
side of the border. A French diplomatic official who spoke on condition of
anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to journalists said the
purpose of Séjourné's visit was to convey France's "fears of a war on Lebanon"
and to submit an amendment to a proposal Paris had previously presented to
Lebanon for a diplomatic resolution to the border conflict. Western diplomats
have brought forward a series of proposals for a cessation of hostilities
between Israel and Hezbollah. Most of those would hinge on Hezbollah moving its
forces several kilometers from the border, a beefed-up Lebanese army presence
and negotiations for Israeli forces to withdraw from disputed points along the
border where Lebanon says Israel has been occupying small patches of Lebanese
territory since it withdrew from the rest of south Lebanon in 2000. The eventual
goal is full implementation of a U.N. resolution that brought to an end a brutal
monthlong war between Israel and Hezbollah in 2006. The previous French proposal
would have involved Hezbollah withdrawing its forces 10 kilometers from the
border. Hezbollah has signaled willingness to entertain the proposals but has
said there will be no deal in Lebanon before there is a cease-fire in Gaza.
Israeli officials, meanwhile, have said that a Gaza cease-fire does not
automatically mean it will halt its strikes in Lebanon, even if Hezbollah does
so. Séjourné declined to provide more details about the latest version of
France's proposal ahead of his planned trip to Israel on Tuesday. He said he
will have "consultations" with Israeli authorities to move toward an agreement.
The French foreign minister also pushed for the Lebanese political factions to
come to an agreement on a candidate to fill a year-and-a-half-long presidential
vacuum. Séjourné said that Lebanon needs a president in place in order to be
"invited to the negotiating table" and to be able to implement any agreement
that might be reached on the border issue. During the talks, Lebanese officials
also raised the issue of the ongoing presence of more than 1 million Syrian
refugees in Lebanon, which has become an increasingly contentious issue.
Lebanese officials have increasingly called for Western countries to facilitate
their return to Syria. Séjourné acknowledged the burden placed on Lebanon by
hosting such a large number of refugees, and said that "all concerned parties
must work to make this return possible in a voluntary, dignified and safe manner
in accordance with international law."
War and Diplomacy: Who Will Win in Rafah?
Alissar Boulos/This Is Beirut/April 29/2024
In Saudi Arabia, Western diplomacy is discussing, on the sidelines of the World
Economic Forum (WEF), a ceasefire in Gaza, while in Israel, the debate continues
regarding an invasion of Rafah, in the southern part of the Palestinian enclave.
Time is of the essence, and it is still uncertain which option will prevail: a
ground invasion of Rafah, where more than a million displaced Palestinians from
the northern territories have sought refuge, or a diplomatic victory? Israel,
which has been insisting for months on this operation that is aimed, according
to its Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, at neutralizing Hamas, is under
increased international pressure not to proceed. But it is not yielding.
Diplomatic efforts, however, are intensifying to avert the military option.
According to British Foreign Secretary David Cameron, who is currently in
Riyadh, the latest ceasefire proposal for Gaza, presented to Hamas, calls for a
cessation of hostilities for 40 days. It is “a very generous offer of a 40-day
ceasefire, the release of thousands of Palestinian prisoners in exchange for the
release of (Israeli) hostages,” Cameron said during a meeting at the WEF. This
formula was developed by Egypt and amended by Israel. According to various
sources cited by pan-Arab and Israeli media, Hamas is expected to give its
response within the next 24 hours. To that end, a delegation from the group was
expected on Monday in Cairo, which has a vested interest in the negotiations’
success, given that Rafah is located on its border with Gaza, kept closed since
October 7, 2023. Two weeks ago, Hamas had called for a permanent ceasefire in
the Strip, which Tel Aviv had rejected. US Secretary of State Antony Blinken,
who is also in Riyadh for the WEF, expressed hope that Hamas would accept
Egypt’s proposal, while his Egyptian counterpart, Sameh Shoukry, stressed that
his country was optimistic about a breakthrough but was awaiting responses from
Israel and Hamas. However, the Israeli government remains divided on the issue:
right-wing Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich opposed any agreement that would
hinder a military operation in Rafah. He described the agreement proposed by
Egypt as “humiliating,” while the previous day, his colleague from the Foreign
Ministry, Benny Gantz, had stated that the government would lose its legitimacy
if ministers prevented a plan allowing for the release of the hostages.
Gantz had called for “a responsible plan for the return of the hostages,
supported by the entire defense establishment, which does not entail an end to
the war.”
Pressures on Israel
The diplomatic dynamics for a settlement are accompanied by strong pressures on
Israel, notably from its main funder, the United States, while Qatar threatened
to withdraw from the negotiations. This pressure has intensified since Sunday.
Some Israeli officials believe that the International Criminal Court is
preparing to issue arrest warrants against senior officials of the country,
including Benjamin Netanyahu, for charges related to the conflict in Gaza. An
attack on Rafah is likely to accelerate the process, something Tel Aviv, also
facing internal pressures, wishes to avoid. Sunday, just after Blinken’s
departure for Saudi Arabia, US President Joe Biden called Netanyahu to discuss
ceasefire talks and reaffirm his opposition to an invasion of Rafah. This phone
call comes three weeks after Biden warned Netanyahu that US military support was
contingent on reducing civilian casualties and increasing humanitarian aid to
Gaza. In addition to international pressures, there are also local pressures
exerted by Israelis on their government, whether from the parents of hostages
still held by Hamas or from residents of northern regions who have had to flee
due to ongoing exchanges of fire between Israel and Hezbollah. “An agreement,
now!” chanted thousands of people who gathered Saturday night in Tel Aviv to
demand the release of the hostages. They also called for Netanyahu’s government
to resign. The same call for an agreement with Hamas was made Monday by the
families of two hostages. This movement follows last week’s release by Hamas of
two videos showing three hostages.
The offensive
On the ground, Tel Aviv continues preparations for a military operation. The
Israeli army has begun recalling reservist soldiers and assembling dozens of
tanks and armored vehicles near the city. Some media outlets reported that
Israeli raids on Rafah had been launched since Saturday, with dozens of people
killed.
Still according to media sources, the Israeli army has completed preparations
for the evacuation of civilians from Rafah, after establishing a “tent city” in
Khan Younis, further north. Another indication of a pending attack is the
announcement by the Israeli army on Sunday that its chief of staff, Herzi Halevi,
had approved plans for further operations in the southern Gaza Strip. For
Israel, however, the calculations remain complicated: if the army does not enter
Rafah, it could be interpreted as a defeat, especially since the general
impression is that Hamas leadership is still operational. But if Israel carries
out a ground invasion, this could lead Hamas to suspend any agreement and
increase pressure on Netanyahu’s government, both domestically and
internationally.
Aoun Refrains From Appearing Before Disciplinary Commission
This Is Beirut/April 29, 2024
Mount Lebanon Public Prosecutor Judge Ghada Aoun failed to attend a hearing
session in front of the Supreme Disciplinary Authority (SDA) on Monday. Aoun had
submitted a written excuse through her attorney, Roland Awad, claiming that the
reason is SDA’s failure to resolve two requests which she had submitted to the
General Authority of the Cassation Court to dismiss the president of the Supreme
Disciplinary Authority, Judge Suhail Abboud. According to Aoun’s lawyer, both
requests to dismiss Abboud were supposed to be previously decided. According to
defense sources, the requests contend that there is a dispute between the
defendant and the head of the Supreme Disciplinary Authority, who had previously
threatened to dismiss Aoun from the judiciary without compensation when she was
summoned to appear before the Judicial Council.
Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published on April 29-30/2024
Israeli officials fear international court is preparing arrest warrants
over Gaza war
Joey Garrison and Michael Collins, USA TODAY/April 29, 2024
WASHINGTON ― Israeli officials are growing concerned the International Criminal
Court could issue criminal warrants against their top officials, including Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, opening up the possibility they could be arrested
if they travel to other countries. Israel's foreign minister, Israel Katz,
singled out "rumors" that the ICC will issue arrest warrants against
high-ranking government and Israel Defense Forces officials in a statement late
Sunday. In anticipation, Katz said he instructed all Israel embassies across the
world to "immediately prepare for the outbreak of a severe anti-Jewish and
anti-Israeli antisemitic wave in the world." The ICC is investigating Hamas'
Oct. 7 attack as well as Israel's brutal seven-month war in Gaza aimed at
defeating Hamas. The ICC, based in The Hague, can prosecute individuals for
genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression. Warrants for
Netanyahu or other Israeli officials would not result in their immediate
arrests. Neither the U.S. nor Israel are members of the court and do not
recognize its jurisdiction. But warrants could prevent Israeli officials from
traveling to the 124 countries that are ICC members, where they would be subject
to arrest. "As we have publicly said many times, the ICC has no jurisdiction in
this situation and we do not support its investigation," a spokesperson for
President Joe Biden's National Security Council told USA TODAY. Although it is
not clear what charges the ICC might bring, targets of criminal warrants by the
ICC could also include Defense Minister Yoav Gallant. "There is nothing more
twisted than trying to prevent Israel from defending itself against a murderous
enemy that openly calls for the destruction of the State of Israel," Katz said.
"If the orders are issued, they will harm the commanders and soldiers of the IDF
and give a boost to the terrorist organization Hamas and the radical Islamic
axis led by Iran against which we are fighting." "We will not bow our heads and
we will not be deterred," he added. Biden and Netanyahu spoke by phone Sunday.
The two leaders discussed efforts to deliver humanitarian aid into Gaza,
according to the White House, and Biden stressed "the need for this progress to
be sustained and enhanced." Netanyahu, in a statement Friday on X, formerly
Twitter, said Israel will "never accept any attempt by the Hague Criminal Court
to undermine its fundamental right to defend itself." He called the threat
against IDF soldiers and Israeli public officials "scandalous." "Israel will
continue until victory in our just war against the abominable terrorists who
seek to destroy us. We will never stop defending ourselves," Netanyahu said.
"While the Hague Tribunal's decisions will not affect Israel's actions, they
will set a dangerous precedent that threatens the soldiers and public figures of
any democracy fighting criminal terrorism and dangerous aggression. Separately,
the ICC is investigating actions by Israeli and Palestinian militants in
Palestinian territories that date back to the 2014 Israel-Hamas war. The
Palestinian territories were admitted to the court with the status of a member
state in 2015.
Will ICC warrants impact cease-fire deal?
Warrants would be a hurdle in the Biden administration's ongoing efforts to
secure a cease-fire deal between Israel and Hamas to allow the release of some
of the more than 130 hostages still held by Hamas, according to a report by
Bloomberg.Secretary of State Antony Blinken, while attending a special meeting
of the World Economic Forum in Saudi Arabia, urged Hamas on Monday to swiftly
accept Israel's latest proposal, which he called "extraordinarily generous.""The
only thing standing between the people of Gaza and a ceasefire is Hamas. They
have to decide, and they have to decide quickly," Blinken said.
Israeli Leaders Concerned About Possible ICC Arrest
Warrants
Anna Gordon/Reuters/April 29, 2024
Israeli leaders, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, appear
increasingly concerned that the International Criminal Court (ICC) may issue
arrest warrants against the country’s officials for actions taken in the war
between Israel and Hamas. On Monday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu posted on
X that “Israel will never accept any attempt by the ICC to undermine its
inherent right of self-defense… While the ICC will not affect Israel’s actions,
it would set a dangerous precedent that threatens the soldiers and officials of
all democracies fighting savage terrorism and wanton aggression.”Israel Katz,
the Foreign Minister of Israel, said that the potential warrants could provide a
“morale boost” to Hamas but would be unlikely to impact the most senior members
of Israeli leadership, according to the Associated Press. "We expect the court (ICC)
to refrain from issuing arrest warrants against senior Israeli political and
security officials," Katz said. "We will not bow our heads or be deterred and
will continue to fight." The ICC’s prosecutor Karim Khan has not confirmed the
possibility of imminent arrest warrants for Israeli leaders. In October after
the war broke out, Khan promised his office would scrutinize the actions of all
military parties engaged in the war. “The message is that any person with their
finger on the trigger of a gun or controls a missile, has certain
responsibilities. My Office will look closely to see whether those
responsibilities are being adhered to or not,” he said in a statement. Any
arrest warrants would need to be approved first by a panel of judges.
Approximately 60% of the world’s countries accept the ICC’s jurisdiction, but
the U.S. and Israel are not among them. While Israel has not accepted the
jurisdiction of the ICC, the state of Palestine has, which means the court still
claims jurisdiction over the West Bank and Gaza. Arrest warrants could
complicate Israeli officials’ abilities to travel to countries like the U.K.,
Canada, France, and Germany that accept ICC jurisdiction. More than 34,000
Palestinians in Gaza have died since the Israel Hamas war began, the majority of
them women and children, according to the Hamas-run Palestinian Ministry of
Health. 1,200 Israelis died in the Oct. 7 attack, and another 200 were taken
hostage by Hamas. The International Criminal Court was established in 2002 in
the aftermath of the genocides in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia. It differs
from the International Criminal Court of Justice (ICJ), which this year oversaw
a case about whether or Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, because it holds
specific individuals to account. The ICJ, on the other hand, deals with disputes
between state actors. In March 2023, the ICC issued an arrest warrant for
Russian President Vladimir Putin for the unlawful deportation of children during
the Russia-Ukraine war, though it has yet to be enforced. Other notable figures
that the ICC has issued arrest warrants for include Omar Al Bashir, the former
president of Sudan, for his role in the Darfur genocide, and former Libyan head
of state Muammar Gaddafi for crimes against humanity committed during the Libyan
civil war.
Clear Encampment or Face Suspension, Columbia University
Tells Israel-Hamas War Protesters
Asharq Al-Awsat/April 29/2024
Colleges around the country implored pro-Palestinian student protesters to clear
out tent encampments with rising levels of urgency Monday, including an
ultimatum from Columbia University for students to sign a form and leave the
encampment by the afternoon or face suspension. College classes nationwide are
wrapping up for the semester, and campuses are preparing for graduation
ceremonies. The notice sent by Columbia to protesters in the encampment Monday
said that if they leave by the designated time and sign a form committing to
abide by university policies through June 2025 or an earlier graduation, they
can finish the semester in good standing. If not, the letter said, they will be
suspended, pending further investigation. “We urge you to remove the encampment
so that we do not deprive your fellow students, their families and friends of
this momentous occasion,” the letter said, noting that exams are beginning and
graduation is upcoming at the Ivy League university in New York City. A
spokesperson for Columbia confirmed the letter had gone out to students but
declined to comment further. Mahmoud Khalil, the lead negotiator on behalf of
protesters, said university representatives began passing out the notices at the
encampment shortly after 10 a.m. Monday. He said discussions were ongoing about
how to proceed. Early protests at Columbia, where demonstrators set up tents in
the center of the campus, sparked pro-Palestinian demonstrations across the
country. Students and others have been sparring over the Israel-Hamas war and
its mounting death toll. Many students are demanding their universities cut
financial ties with Israel.
About 275 people were arrested Saturday at various campuses including Indiana
University at Bloomington, Arizona State University and Washington University in
St. Louis. The number of arrests nationwide has surpassed 900 since New York
police removed a pro-Palestinian protest encampment at Columbia and arrested
more than 100 demonstrators on April 18. The demonstrations at Columbia have led
it to hold remote classes and set a series of deadlines for protesters to leave
the encampment, which they have missed. The school said in an email to students
that bringing back police “at this time” would be counterproductive. The
students and administrators have negotiated to end the disruptions, but the
sides have not come to an agreement, university President Minouche Shafik said
in a statement Monday. Protests were still active at a number of campuses. Near
George Washington University, protesters at an encampment breached and
dismantled the barriers Monday morning used to secure University Yard, the
university said in a statement. The yard had been closed since last week.
Protesters at Yale University set up a new encampment with dozens of tents
Sunday afternoon, nearly a week after police arrested nearly 50 demonstrators
and cleared a similar camp. At least one school, the University of Southern
California, canceled its main graduation ceremony this spring. Others are asking
the protests to resolve peacefully so they can hold their ceremonies. Protesters
on both sides shouted and shoved each other during dueling demonstrations Sunday
at the University of California, Los Angeles. The university stepped up security
after “some physical altercations broke out among demonstrators,” Mary Osako,
vice chancellor for UCLA Strategic Communications, said in a statement. There
were no reports of arrests or injuries. The plight of students who have been
arrested has become a central part of protests, with the students and a growing
number of faculty demanding amnesty for protesters. At issue is whether the
suspensions and legal records will follow students through their adult lives.
US, Britain Urge Hamas to Accept Israeli Truce Proposal
Asharq Al-Awsat/April 29/2024
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Monday urged Hamas to swiftly accept an
Israeli proposal for a truce in the Gaza war and the release of Israeli hostages
held by the Palestinian group. Hamas negotiators were expected to meet Qatari
and Egyptian mediators in Cairo on Monday to deliver a response to the phased
truce proposal which Israel presented at the weekend. "Hamas has before it a
proposal that is extraordinarily, extraordinarily generous on the part of
Israel," Blinken said at a meeting of the World Economic Forum in the Saudi
capital Riyadh. "The only thing standing between the people of Gaza and a
ceasefire is Hamas. They have to decide and they have to decide quickly," he
said. "I'm hopeful that they will make the right decision." A source briefed on
the talks said Israel's proposal entailed a deal for the release of fewer than
40 of the roughly 130 hostages believed to be still held in Gaza in exchange for
freeing Palestinians jailed in Israel. A second phase of a truce would consist
of a "period of sustained calm" - Israel's compromise response to a Hamas demand
for a permanent ceasefire. A total of 253 hostages were seized in a Hamas attack
on southern Israel on Oct. 7 in which about 1,200 Israelis were also killed,
according to Israeli counts. Israel retaliated by imposing a total siege on Gaza
and mounting an air and ground assault that has killed about 34,500
Palestinians, according to Gaza health authorities. Palestinians are suffering
from severe shortages of food, fuel and medicine in a humanitarian crisis
brought on by the offensive that has demolished much of the territory. Britain's
Foreign Secretary David Cameron, who was also in Riyadh for the WEF meeting,
also described the Israeli proposal as "generous". It included a 40-day pause in
fighting and the release of potentially thousands of Palestinian prisoners as
well as Israeli hostages, he told a WEF audience. "I hope Hamas do take this
deal and frankly, all the pressure in the world and all the eyes in the world
should be on them today saying 'take that deal'," Cameron said. Cameron is among
several foreign ministers in Riyadh, including from the US, France, Jordan and
Egypt, as part of a diplomatic push to bring an end to the Gaza war. Blinken
reiterated that the United States - Israel's main diplomatic supporter and
weapons supplier - could not back an Israeli ground assault on Rafah if there
was no plan to ensure that civilians would not be harmed.
More than a million displaced Gaza residents are crammed into Rafah, the
enclave's southernmost city, having sought refuge there from Israeli
bombardments. Israel says the last Hamas fighters are holed up there and it will
open an offensive to root them out soon.
Israel Kills at Least 22 Palestinians in Rafah
Asharq Al Awsat/Mon, April 29, 2024
Israeli airstrikes on three houses in the southern Gaza city of Rafah killed at
least 22 Palestinians and wounded many others, medics said on Monday. Israel has
regularly carried out airstrikes on Rafah since the start of the war and has
threatened to send in ground troops, saying Rafah is the last major Hamas
stronghold in the coastal enclave. Over a million Palestinians have sought
refuge in the city on the Egyptian border. An assault on Rafah has been
anticipated for weeks but foreign governments and the United Nations have
expressed concern that such action could result in a humanitarian disaster given
the number of displaced people crammed into the area. The overnight strikes hit
three family homes. The first killed 11 people, including four siblings aged 9
to 27, according to records at the Abu Yousef al-Najjar Hospital, where the
bodies were taken. The second strike killed eight people, including a
33-year-old father and his 5-day-old boy, according to hospital records. The
third strike killed three siblings, aged 23, 19 and 12.
US appeals to UAE, others to stop support for Sudan's
warring parties
UNITED NATIONS (Reuters)/Michelle Nichols/Mon, April 29, 2024
The U.S. is appealing to all countries - including the United Arab Emirates - to
stop support for Sudan's warring parties, the U.S. envoy to the United Nations
said on Monday, warning that a "crisis of epic proportions is brewing."War
erupted in Sudan one year ago between the Sudanese army (SAF) and paramilitary
Rapid Support Forces (RSF), creating the world's largest displacement crisis.
The U.N. has voiced concern in recent days about a possible imminent RSF attack
on al-Fashir in Sudan's North Dafur region. The fight for al-Fashir, a historic
center of power, could grow more protracted, inflame ethnic tensions that
surfaced in the region 20 years ago and reach across Sudan's border with Chad,
say residents, aid agencies and analysts. "As I've said before, history is
repeating itself in Darfur in the worst possible way," U.S. Ambassador to the
U.N. Linda Thomas-Greenfield told reporters on Monday, adding that al-Fashir was
"on the precipice of a large-scale massacre." In the early 2000s the U.N.
estimates some 300,000 people were killed in Darfur when "Janjaweed" militias -
from which the RSF formed - helped the army crush a rebellion by mainly non-Arab
groups. Sudanese leaders are wanted by the International Criminal Court for
genocide and crimes against humanity. Top U.N. officials warned the Security
Council this month that some 800,000 people in al-Fashir were in "extreme and
immediate danger" as violence worsens and threatens to "unleash bloody
intercommunal strife throughout Darfur."
UAE REJECTS ACCUSATIONS
Al-Fashir is the last major city in the vast, western Darfur region not under
RSF control. The RSF and its allies swept through four other Darfur state
capitals last year, and were blamed for a campaign of ethnically driven killings
against non-Arab groups and other abuses in West Darfur. "We do know that both
sides are receiving support - both with weapons and other support - to fuel
their efforts to continue to destroy Sudan and yes, we have engaged with the
parties on that including with our colleagues from the UAE," Thomas-Greenfield
said. U.N. sanctions monitors have described as "credible" accusations that the
United Arab Emirates had provided military support to the RSF. The UAE has
denied involvement in military support to any of Sudan's rival parties."The
United Arab Emirates ... is not supplying any arms or ammunition to any faction
engaged in the ongoing conflict in Sudan," UAE Ambassador to the U.N. Mohamed
Abushahab wrote to the Security Council on April 25. He added the UAE
"categorically rejects any insinuation that it has extended financial,
logistical, military assistance, or diplomatic support to any armed group in
Sudan." The U.N. has said nearly 25 million people, half of Sudan's population,
need aid and some 8 million have fled their homes. A U.N.-backed global
authority on food security has called for immediate action to "prevent
widespread death and total collapse of livelihoods and avert a catastrophic
hunger crisis in Sudan."
Israel's strike showed Iran's air defenses were 'woefully
unprepared.' Here's what Tehran may do next.
Paul Iddon/Business Insider/April 29, 2024
Israel showed it can take out a key part of Iran's air defenses with a single
missile.
The S-300 damaged is the most advanced air defense system Iran has acquired from
Russia. Iran must field better air defenses like Russia's S-400 to stand a
chance against a barrage. In the early hours of April 19, Israel sent a message
to Iran with an air-launched ballistic missile that took out a critical part of
its air defense network: a radar belonging to one of its advanced Russian S-300
missiles. The Israeli missile scored a direct hit, and the next day Iran tried
to cover up the damage with an inferior replacement radar, according to images
obtained by the Economist. The incident in the city of Isfahan may force Tehran
to upgrade its air defenses, possibly from more advanced Russian systems, to
defend itself from the possibility of larger Israeli missile attacks. "I think
it's quite clear that Iran is woefully unprepared for such attacks unless it
receives significant help from Russia, which it has failed to do so far," Arash
Azizi, senior lecturer in history and political science at Clemson University
and author of "The Shadow Commander: Soleimani, the US, and Iran's Global
Ambitions," told Business Insider. "The attacks will also have given valuable
operational information to the Iranians in charge of missile defense in that
they'll have a better sense of their limits," Azizi said. Israel is known to
possess ballistic missiles it can launch from fighter jets. One example is its
15-foot-long Rampage missile. Weighing 1,200 pounds, the supersonic missile can
hit targets up to 186 miles away. Britain has shown interest in buying it.
Freddy Khoueiry, a global security analyst for the Middle East and North Africa
at the risk intelligence company RANE, believes it's possible Israel used the
Rampage on April 19. However, he noted that missile debris uncovered in
neighboring Iraq suggests it was more likely Israel used Blue Sparrow missiles,
which have a purported 1,250-mile range. "Either way, the debris in Iraq and
local reports of fighter jet activities over Iraqi airspace that same night
suggest Israeli fighter jets possibly fired the missiles from a distance closer
to the Iranian borders," Khoueiry told BI. While Iranian air defenses failed to
stop Israel's strike they have hugely improved in recent years. In the early
2000s, Iranian radars couldn't detect American and Israeli drones operating
inside Iranian airspace. Even bulky US tankers supporting missions in
Afghanistan and Iraq flew over parts of Iranian airspace undetected. That's all
changed. Iran shot down a sophisticated American RQ-4A Global Hawk surveillance
drone flying at high altitude in 2019, claiming it used its indigenous 3rd
Khordad system. "For the past few years, Iran has heavily invested in its air
defense capabilities but simultaneously knows that it might not be enough
against the technologically advanced Israeli or US weapons in a potential
conflict," Khoueiry said. That's one reason Iran has placed its most sensitive
installations in mountainous regions. "I believe the April 19 Isfahan strike
will likely make the Iranians think more in terms of countering Israel's
radar-evading systems by improving their radar capabilities while continuing to
improve their air defenses, especially because we did not see Iran's best air
defense equipment on display," Khoueiry said.
The S-300PMU-2 is the most advanced air defense system Iran has acquired from
Russia. Following the Isfahan strike, it's likely Tehran will conclude it needs
more advanced Russian systems, such as the S-400 they've by some accounts been
asking for. Khoueiry doesn't rule out the prospect of Iran seeking the S-400,
given its "more advanced stealth capabilities" and ability to track aircraft at
lower altitudes. These capabilities are "crucial" for defending vital Iranian
installations, especially given the S-300's failure to intercept Israeli weapons
on April 19.
Clemson University's Azizi believes an S-400 acquisition remains "crucial" for
Iran and one of its "best bets." Therefore, he anticipates Tehran will continue
pushing for it. "I think the April episode will certainly have convinced
Iranians that they need to be more serious about getting help from Russia,"
Azizi said. "But I think they ultimately have very little leverage unless Moscow
wants to play Israel and the West by giving help to Iran." Iran has a strong
card to play. It's become a major supplier of Russia's war against Ukraine via
thousands of Shahed loitering munitions and hundreds of short-range ballistic
missiles. But this may not be enough. "Moscow will be the key decision-maker
here, not Tehran," Azizi said. "The drone help is important for Moscow but not
indispensable."Iran could have a local solution in the form of indigenous
systems, such as the 3rd Khordad that felled a Global Hawk and the Bavar 373.
"Theoretically these Iranian systems should do better than the S-300 given that
the Iranians upgraded the Bavar 373 in 2022, claiming that it's now a competitor
of the S-400," Khoueiry said. "In practice, this could go either way, depending
on the amount of Israeli missiles that would be hypothetically launched and from
where."
Khoueiry anticipates that early detection by Iranian air defenses could give
these Iranian-made systems "more chances" against Israeli missiles. Conversely,
Azizi believes these systems are "quite unlikely" to fare any better than their
Russian counterparts. "These are impressive systems for Iran to have devised on
its own but they are ultimately no match for Israel's significant offensive
capabilities," Azizi said.
‘My whole family has perished:’ 22 killed in Israeli
airstrike on Rafah, hospital staff say
Tareq Elhelou, and CNN’s Kareem Khadder, Zeena Saifi and Abeer Salman/Mon, April
29, 2024
Twenty-two people, including at least one infant and a toddler, have been killed
in an Israeli airstrike over Rafah, Gaza, overnight into Monday, according to
hospital officials.The deceased were brought into Abu Youssef Al Najjar hospital
in Rafah following the attack, as their loved ones gathered for their final
farewells. A video filmed for CNN in the hospital courtyard shows several body
bags laid on the ground with dozens of anguished people including men, women and
children crowded around their late loved ones. People are seen crouching over
the body bags, with some caressing their loved one’s lifeless bodies. At least
one baby’s head can be seen sticking out of a bag, as the woman beside it
shouts: “My whole family has perished.” The baby’s uncle, Mahmoud Abu Taha, was
carrying the 1-year-old’s lifeless body while talking to the camera, saying his
parents had tried having children for 10 years before he was born.
“We were sitting in our homes, not doing anything. It was unexpected when they
struck the house. Everyone was asleep in their beds… most of the people that
were killed were displaced… they were women and children,” he said. Lifting the
baby boy’s body to the camera, Mahmoud Abu Taha cries out, “this is who they are
targeting. This is their objective. This is the generation they’re looking for.
This is the safe Rafah they talk about.”In response to a CNN request for comment
regarding the Rafah strike on Monday, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said in a
statement that its fighter jets “struck terror targets where terrorists were
operating within a civilian area in southern Gaza.”“The IDF will continue to
foil terrorist activity and protect Israeli civilians, in accordance with
international law,” it added.
CNN cannot independently verify those claims. Another member of the Abu Taha
family says in the video that 10 of his relatives were killed in the airstrike.
Some of his relatives were originally displaced from Khan Younis, where several
of them were killed in a previous Israeli airstrike. The remaining few who had
fled Khan Younis for the safety of Rafah have now been killed overnight in Rafah,
he says. “They were sleeping in their homes when the airstrike hit at around
12:20 am…nowhere is safe. The entire Gaza Strip is a target,” he told CNN. He
called on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to stop the war, saying “we
want to live. We want peace. Enough Arab bloodshed.”Another eyewitness says a
five-day-old boy named Ghaith Abu Rayya was killed in the airstrike. The footage
shows him opening a small body bag to reveal the infant’s head, saying his body
has been dismembered. “We are all alone. Nobody cares about us,” he cries. He is
seen opening another body bag next to Ghaith’s, sobbing, and saying, “my beloved
Ramy,” who he says is Ghaith’s 33-year-old father. Several men are seen bringing
in another body bag with the name “Ahmad Saleem Abu Taha” written across it, and
the crowded people start wailing in distress. One woman caresses the lifeless
face, which has been left exposed, saying: “Oh his smell. Oh God. Goodbye my
beloved.”The death toll in the Gaza Strip has risen to at least 34,454 following
205 days of war between Israel and Hamas, the Ministry of Health in Gaza
reported on Sunday. The ministry does not distinguish between casualties among
civilians and Hamas fighters. CNN cannot independently verify the ministry’s
casualty figures due to the lack of international media access to Gaza. Tareq
Elhelou reported for CNN from Rafah, CNN’s Kareem Khadder, Zeena Saifi and Abeer
Salman reported from Jerusalem.
Bernie Sanders Accuses Israel Of Ethnic Cleansing In Gaza's
'Humanitarian Disaster'
Sanjana Karanth/CNN/April 29, 2024
The Cost of Biden’s Israel SupportScroll back up to restore default view.
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) on Sunday accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu of ethnic cleansing against Palestinians in Gaza ― upping his rhetoric
against the U.S.-funded military offensive in the enclave that has been underway
for nearly seven months. CNN’s “State of the Union” show was Sanders’ first time
using the term “ethnic cleansing” to describe the Israeli military campaign in
Gaza, where soldiers have killed more than 34,000 Palestinians, wounded more
than 75,000, displaced most of the population, destroyed cultural, medical and
educational infrastructure, and created a famine by blocking most aid from
entering the territory. “I don’t think there’s any doubt that what Netanyahu is
doing now ― displacing 80% of the population in Gaza ― is ethnic cleansing,”
Sanders told CNN host Dana Bash. “That’s what it is, pushing out huge numbers of
people.”
He added: “I think I, and a majority of the American people, do not want to be
complicit in the humanitarian disaster that Netanyahu is causing in Gaza right
now.” The decision to use the term to describe the crisis in Gaza is an
escalation of Sanders’ criticism of the U.S. government’s role in supporting the
deadly military campaign, which began Oct. 7 after Hamas militants launched an
attack on Israel that killed about 1,200 people and resulted in about 250 people
being taken hostage. Half of the hostages were released during a temporary halt
in fighting, and about 30 of those remaining are presumed dead. Both Israel and
Hamas appear to be nowhere close to a deal that would allow a permanent
cease-fire, the return of hostages and the flow of humanitarian aid.
The Biden administration has continued to send billions in military aid to
Israel, despite growing opposition from various Democratic lawmakers and from
many everyday Americans ― including college students across the country who are
protesting Israel’s military campaign, Israeli soldiers’ use of U.S. weapons to
kill Palestinians, and universities’ financial ties to Israel. “Let’s take a
deep look beyond the protests: How do the American people feel about U.S.
military aid to the Netanyahu government?” Sanders asked, after having to
repeatedly redirect Bash’s questions about student demonstrations and refocus
the conversation on the humanitarian crisis itself. “What Netanyahu is trying to
do very clearly is to say, ‘Anybody who criticizes what Israel is doing, you are
antisemitic.’ Well, are there some antisemites? Well, you just saw one, yeah,”
the senator continued, referring to a clip Bash played of what she said was a
protester calling for the death of Zionists. “But what I’m saying is, if you
look at the polling, the vast majority of the American people are disgusted with
Netanyahu’s war machine in Gaza,” Sanders said. “And they do not want further
U.S. military aid to his government.”
Tensions between Sanders and Netanyahu have soared as the senator continues to
call out the prime minister for his military campaign. In response to what he
called “horrific” campus protests, Netanyahu described student protesters of all
races, ethnicities and religions as “antisemitic mobs.”
Viral clips have emerged of individuals making antisemitic comments, but protest
organizers have condemned such remarks and, in some cases, attributed them to
counterprotesters or outside agitators. Most photos and videos of the protests
show students peacefully demonstrating before law enforcement arrives.
“Mr. Netanyahu, antisemitism is a vile and disgusting form of bigotry that has
done unspeakable harm to many millions of people,” Sanders, who is Jewish and
whose father’s family was killed in the Holocaust, said last week in a video
addressed to the prime minister. “Do not insult the intelligence of the American
people by attempting to distract us from the immoral and illegal war policies of
your extremist and racist government.” Despite a growing number of U.S.
officials speaking out against Israel’s military campaign, most are still
hesitant to use terms like “apartheid,” “ethnic cleansing” and “genocide,”
language that is particularly freighted when discussing a state that was
established for Jewish survivors of the Holocaust. Sanders said he believes the
question of whether “genocide” is an applicable term should be determined by
international courts. South Africa has accused Israel of committing genocide
against Palestinians, a charge that Israel vehemently denies. That case is
currently sitting before the International Court of Justice. A bombshell United
Nations report also concluded that Israel’s actions in Gaza constitute genocide.
Multiple human rights groups have released reports that say Israel has long been
committing apartheid against Palestinians, not just in Gaza but also in the
occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem.
McGill University calls pro-Palestinian encampment illegal,
campers vow to stay
MONTREAL/The Canadian Press/Mon, April 29, 2024
Pro-Palestinian activists said on Monday they have no intention of dismantling
their camp at Montreal's McGill University, as the school said it was discussing
its next steps to deal with what it called an illegal encampment. Dozens of
tents were pitched on the lawn of McGill's downtown campus behind a metal fence
festooned with Palestinian flags and posters. Cases of bottled water and a small
generator could be seen behind the fence, as masked protesters at the gate
welcomed supporters dropping off donations including batteries, clothing and
medication. "Students have reiterated their intention to continue the encampment
indefinitely, until McGill and Concordia divest from all companies profiting
from genocide," read a joint statement published Monday by co-organizers
Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights McGill, Solidarity for Palestinian Human
Rights Concordia, Independent Jewish Voices McGill and Independent Jewish Voices
Concordia. McGill said Monday morning that the number of people who have set up
tents on campus has tripled since Saturday, and many of them, if not the
majority, are not members of the school community. It also said it had seen
video evidence of some people using "unequivocally antisemitic language and
intimidating behaviour" during the protest, but it did not provide further
details. "McGill has been steadfast in its support of the rights of our campus
community to freedom of expression and freedom of peaceful assembly, with the
understanding that these must be exercised within the bounds of McGill’s
policies as well as the law," the school said Monday in a statement.
"We have been clear that these encampments violate both."
The institution said its leaders were discussing next steps after lawyers
representing McGill students in the encampment informed them the protesters
refuse to discuss a timeline to remove the tents. The school has previously
asked one of the organizing groups — Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights
McGill — to stop using the university's name after it says the group made
"incendiary posts" following the Oct. 7 attack by Hamas militants on Israel that
killed about 1,200 people, mostly civilians. In a Facebook post soon after the
attack, SPHR McGill called the militants' actions "heroic" and asked Montrealers
to "celebrate the resistance’s success." Encampment members, meanwhile. are
demanding the school divest from Israeli companies it says are "complicit in the
occupation of Palestine." They also want the school to cut academic ties with
Israeli institutions and denounce Israel's offensive in Gaza, which has led to
more than 34,000 Palestinian deaths, according to the local health ministry. A
McGill student and encampment spokesperson who didn't want to give her full name
for fear of reprisals from the school or police confirmed Monday that the
campers refused to negotiate with the school to remove their tents. She said the
campers weren't leaving.
"We understand there may be police repression," she said. "We’ve seen it before,
we will see it again. We are ready, we are not moving, we are standing our
ground." While police cars could be seen on nearby streets, there was no visible
police presence on school grounds as the encampment members and dozens of
supporters gathered for a brief rally Monday morning. Marwah Mechti, a student
from Maisonneuve College, was among those who showed up to encourage the
campers. "It’s not an Arab cause, it’s not a religious cause anymore. It’s a
human cause," she said. "By being here in the tents, not eating, not bathing, it
shows the determination of students." The encampment in Montreal, which comes
just ahead of the end of final exams at McGill on Tuesday, follows a wave of
similar protests across campuses in the United States linked to the Israel-Hamas
war. Critics have argued the protests are antisemitic and leave Jewish students
feeling unsafe. Liberal MP Anthony Housefather, a McGill alumnus who represents
a Montreal riding, said the encampment is creating a climate of intimidation and
needs to be dismantled. "I've heard over the course of the weekend from
literally hundreds of Jewish students and their parents and grandparents that
are afraid of what's happening on campus," Housefather said Monday in Ottawa.
"And it's a terrible message to send to the Jewish community in Montreal that
has been in Montreal for over 250 years to see those type of remarks calling on
Jews to return to Poland that we heard in the videos yesterday. It is absolutely
antisemitic and it's unacceptable."But the McGill encampment spokesperson, who
said she was Jewish and a member of Independent Jewish Voices McGill, said the
protests are peaceful and aimed at Israel's actions, not Jewish people. "I want
to very clearly clarify: there is a difference between Judaism and Zionism," she
said. "And currently the McGill administration and many institutions across the
world right now are equating the two. We are here to say, as anti-Zionist Jews,
there is a difference."On Monday, there were signs the campus protest movement
within Canada could be spreading. A protest was beginning at the University of
British Columbia's Vancouver campus, with organizers writing on X to ask people
to bring tents and sandbags, as well as food, water and heating supplies. The
University of Ottawa, meanwhile, warned its students on Monday that the use of
university space is a privilege and not a right."While peaceful protest is
permitted in appropriate public spaces on campus according to our policies and
regulations, encampments and occupations will not be tolerated," read a message
signed by Éric Bercier, associate vice-president of student affairs.
Paris Police Clear Gaza Protesters at Sorbonne
University
Asharq Al-Awsat/April 29/2024
Police moved in to clear dozens of protesters who had set up tents in a
courtyard at the Sorbonne University in Paris on Monday to protest against the
war in Gaza, students there said. The demonstration took place three days after
protests at the capital's elite Sciences Po university and came in the wake of
rallies in campuses across the United States against the conflict. "We set up
tents ... like in several US universities," Sorbonne student Louis Maziere said.
"We're doing all we can to raise awareness about what is happening in Palestine,
about the ongoing genocide in Gaza." "Police then came running in, brought down
tents, grabbed students by the collar and dragged them on the ground, that's not
OK... We're quite shocked," he said. Fellow student Lou said: "What we're
pushing for is peace and they answer with force and violence." A police source
confirmed they had intervened to clear out the Sorbonne's courtyard. "This
operation, which lasted only a few minutes, was carried out peacefully without
incident," the source said, declining to respond to questions on how the
students had been removed. The university, one of the world's oldest, closed its
buildings for the day during the peaceful protests. Students chanted "Free
Palestine" and urged the institution to condemn Israel. Israel has imposed a
siege on Gaza and mounted an air and ground assault in which at least 34,488
Palestinians have been killed, according to Gaza health authorities. Israel's
actions came in response to an attack on southern Israel on Oct. 7 by militants
of the Palestinian group Hamas in which 253 people were taken hostage and about
1,200 people were killed, according to Israeli tallies. Several French
politicians, including Mathilde Panot who heads the hard-left LFI group of
lawmakers in the National Assembly, have urged supporters on social media to
join the Sorbonne protests.
Six-Party Ministerial Meeting Convenes in Riyadh to
Discuss Israeli War in Gaza Strip
Asharq Al-Awsat/April 29/2024
The Saudi Minister of Foreign Affairs, Prince Faisal bin Farhan bin Abdullah,
chaired the six-party Consultative Ministerial meeting with the United States in
Riyadh on Monday. The meeting focused on discussing the Israeli war on the Gaza
Strip and the latest developments. The attendees emphasized the urgency of
achieving an immediate and complete ceasefire to end the war while ensuring the
protection of civilians in accordance with international humanitarian law. They
also deliberated on strategies to eliminate all impediments restricting the
entry of humanitarian aid into all areas of the Strip to alleviate the
humanitarian crisis. Furthermore, the meeting addressed the efforts undertaken
by the Arab Six-Party countries to support the international recognition of the
Palestinian state, aiming to fulfill the aspirations of the Palestinian people
for an independent and sovereign state based on the borders of June 4, 1967. The
participants underscored the importance of taking irreversible measures to
implement the two-state solution, in alignment with relevant international
resolutions. Among the attendees were Saudi Ambassador to the United States
Princess Reema bint Bandar bin Sultan bin Abdulaziz, Undersecretary of the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs for Political Affairs Dr. Saud Al-Sati, Advisor to
the Ministry Dr. Manal Radwan, and Director of the Arab Levant Department
Mohammed Al-Harbi. Also, other attendees included Prime Minister and Minister of
Foreign Affairs of Qatar Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, Minister of
Foreign Affairs of the UAE Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Deputy Prime
Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates of Jordan Ayman Safadi,
Minister of Foreign Affairs of Egypt Sameh Shoukri, Secretary-General of the
Executive Committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization and Minister of
Civil Affairs Hussein Al-Sheikh; and Secretary of State of the United States
Antony Blinken.
No 'major issues': Hamas delegation to arrive in Egypt for
Gaza truce talks
Agence France Presse/April 29, 2024
A Hamas delegation is due Monday in Egypt, where it will respond to Israel's
latest proposal for a long-sought truce in Gaza and hostage release after almost
seven months of war. Egypt, Qatar and the United States have been trying to
mediate an agreement between Israel and Hamas for months, but a flurry of
diplomacy in recent days appeared to suggest a new push towards halting the
fighting. U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, on his seventh visit to the
region since the October 7 Hamas attack that sparked the war, arrived Monday in
Saudi Arabia and will also travel to Israel and neighbouring Jordan later this
week, a State Department official said. A senior Hamas official said Sunday that
the Palestinian group had no "major issues" with the most recent truce plan.
"The atmosphere is positive unless there are new Israeli obstacles," the
official told AFP, requesting anonymity to discuss the negotiations.
While Israel has pledged to go after Hamas battalions in Rafah despite mounting
global concern for Palestinian civilians sheltering in the southern Gaza Strip
city, Foreign Minister Israel Katz said the government may "suspend" the
invasion if an agreement is reached. The war has brought besieged Gaza to the
brink of famine, U.N. and humanitarian officials say, reduced much of the
territory to rubble and raised fears of broader conflict. An AFP correspondent,
witnesses and rescuers reported air strikes overnight on Rafah, where the
majority of Gaza's 2.4 million people have sought refuge near the border with
Egypt.
More strikes were reported in central Gaza. At least 22 people were killed in
Rafah, medics and the Civil Defence agency said Monday, with witnesses telling
AFP at least three houses had been hit.
A Hamas source close to the negotiations had told AFP the group "is open to
discussing the new proposal positively" and is keen for an agreement that
"guarantees a permanent ceasefire, the free return of displaced people, an
acceptable deal for (prisoner) exchange and ensuring an end to the siege" in
Gaza.
In Israel, protesters have taken to the streets to urge the government to secure
the freedom of the 129 hostages who remain in Gaza since being seized by
militants on October 7, including 34 the military says are dead.
'Irreversible path' to statehood
Hamas's October 7 attack resulted in the deaths of about 1,170 people in Israel,
mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally of Israeli official figures.
Israel's retaliatory offensive has killed at least 34,454 people in Gaza, mostly
women and children, according to the health ministry in the Hamas-run territory.
A one-week halt to the fighting in November saw 80 Israeli hostages exchanged
for 240 Palestinians held in Israeli prisons. Hamas has previously insisted on a
permanent ceasefire -- a condition Israel has rejected. However, the Axios news
website, citing two Israeli officials, reported that Israel's latest proposal
includes a willingness to discuss the "restoration of sustainable calm" after
hostages are released. It is the first time that Israeli leaders have suggested
they are open to discussing an end to the war, Axios said. As diplomatic efforts
intensified, Blinken arrived in Riyadh for talks with Arab and European foreign
ministers aimed at pushing an Israel-Hamas ceasefire and increasing humanitarian
aid into Gaza, a State Department official said. His Saudi counterpart, Foreign
Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan, said on Sunday that the international
community had failed Gazans. He reiterated that only "a credible, irreversible
path to a Palestinian state" will prevent the world from confronting "this same
situation" again in the future. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's
hard-right government has rejected calls for Palestinian statehood.
'Suspend' Rafah invasion
Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas, whose Palestinian Authority has partial
administrative control in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, appealed at the WEF
meeting for the United States to stop Israel from invading Rafah, which he said
would be "the biggest disaster in the history of the Palestinian people".
Katz, the Israeli foreign minister, signalled on Saturday that Israel would be
willing to call off an invasion of Rafah if Hamas accepted a deal to release
hostages. "If there is a deal, we will suspend the operation," he told Israel's
Channel 12.
In February, Netanyahu said any truce deal would only delay -- not prevent -- a
Rafah operation. Israeli war cabinet member Benny Gantz said in a statement that
"Rafah is important in the long struggle against Hamas" but that "the government
will not the right... to exist" if it prevents the return of the hostages.
U.N. humanitarian agency OCHA has warned that "famine thresholds in Gaza will be
breached within the next six weeks" if massive food aid does not arrive. The
White House said Sunday that a U.S.-made pier meant to boost aid to Gaza will
become operational in two to three weeks but cannot replace land routes.
National Security Council spokesman John Kirby said on ABC News that Israel is
letting in more trucks, in line with "commitments that President Biden asked
them to meet".U.S. President Joe Biden spoke with Netanyahu by phone Sunday and
"reviewed ongoing talks to secure the release of hostages together with an
immediate ceasefire in Gaza", the White House statement said. The two leaders
"also discussed increases in the delivery of humanitarian assistance into Gaza",
the statement said, including "preparations" to open new crossings to northern
Gaza, where condition have been particularly dire.
El-Sisi, Biden affirm the danger of a military escalation
in Rafah
Reuters/April 29, 2024
The Egyptian Presidency said that President Abdel Fattah El-Sisi received a
phone call today, Monday, from his American counterpart Joe Biden, during which
they discussed the latest developments regarding the ongoing negotiations to
achieve a ceasefire in Gaza and the risks of a military escalation in Rafah.
The presidency added in a statement, "The call addressed the latest developments
in the ongoing negotiations and Egyptian efforts to reach a ceasefire in the
Gaza Strip, halt firing, and exchange hostages." It also mentioned that during
the phone call, "emphasis was placed on the danger of military escalation in the
Palestinian city of Rafah, due to its potential catastrophic dimensions to the
worsening humanitarian crisis in the sector, as well as its impact on the
security and stability of the region." The statement stated, "President El-Sisi
emphasized the necessity of full and sufficient access to humanitarian aid,
highlighting Egypt's intensive efforts in this regard. The two presidents also
emphasized the importance of preventing the expansion of the conflict, and
reiterated the importance of the two-state solution as a means to achieve
security, peace, and stability in the region."
US says it 'does not support' ICC investigations of Israel
AFP/April 29, 2024
The United States has expressed its opposition to the International Criminal
Court's investigation into Israel's practices in Gaza, amid reports of Israeli
officials' concerns about the issuance of arrest warrants by the body, based in
The Hague.
White House spokeswoman Karine Jean-Pierre said in a press briefing: "We've been
really clear about the ICC investigation, that we don't support it, we don't
believe that they have the jurisdiction."
Italy reports downing a Houthi-launched drone in the Red
Sea
Reuters/April 29, 2024
The Italian Ministry of Defense said today, Monday, that a ship belonging to the
Italian navy shot down a drone launched by Houthi rebels in Yemen, targeting a
European cargo ship. The ministry added in a statement that interception of the
drone was possible "late in the morning" near the Bab el-Mandeb Strait at the
southern tip of the Red Sea. It added that the drone was flying towards the
cargo ship before being shot down five kilometers away. It said it was similar
to other drones used in previous Houthi attacks.
Mali forces kill senior figure in Islamic State
affiliate
BAMAKO (Reuters)/April 29, 2024
Malian forces killed Abu Huzeifa, a commander for a West African affiliate of
Islamic State, during a large-scale operation in the northern region of Menaka,
the Malian authorities said in a statement read on state television on
Monday.Huzeifa's death on Sunday had been confirmed after the operation in the
region's Indelimane sector, they said, but did not give further details. The
U.S. State Department's Rewards for Justice program offers a bounty of up to $5
million for information on Huzeifa for his alleged participation in a 2017
attack in neighbouring Niger that killed four U.S. and four Nigerien soldiers.
Over the past decade, attacks by groups linked to al Qaeda and Islamic State
have killed thousands of people in Mali, Niger, and neighbouring Burkina Faso,
destabilising West Africa's central Sahel region. As of March, the protracted
security and humanitarian crisis had displaced over 3 million people in the
region, according to the International Organization for Migration.
Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources
published on April 29-30/2024
U.S. Campuses: Grooming Terrorists
Bassam Tawil/Gatestone Institute./April 29, 2024
For these Arabs, including some Palestinians, there is nothing "pro-Palestinian"
about supporting the Iran-backed Hamas terrorist group....
Those who are chanting "we are all Hamas" on the streets of New York and U.S.
college campuses are not helping the Palestinians of the Gaza Strip even
slightly. They are being used as human shields by the terrorist group Hamas in
its genocidal war against Israel and Jews." — Loay Al-Shareef, social media
influencer from the United Arab Emirates, X, April 23, 2024.
"You would not survive a day in Gaza under Hamas, which demands that 'infidels'
live with dignity only if they are subordinate to Islamists.... You do not
understand Arabic, nor do you know Islam well enough to comprehend what awaits
you if Hamas prevails (God forbid)." — Loay Al-Shareef, X, April 23, 2024."[Y]ou
would also be the target of hatred because radical Islamists like Hamas believe
in eternal enmity towards Jews and Christians. They interpret the Quranic verse
("O you who believe, never take Jews and Christians as friends," as timeless,
applicable to all Jews and Christians forever." — Loay Al-Shareef, X, April 23,
2024.
"Hamas' approach, in other words, has been a disaster for Palestinians in
Gaza.... If universities cannot instil their students with peaceful, tolerant,
and coexistent attitudes, then they have failed as institutions of higher
learning." — John Aziz, a British-Palestinian writer, Jewish Chronicle, April
22, 2024.
"Violence has failed us for decades, and the only way to accomplish justice for
Palestinians is through peace." — Hamza Howidy, Palestinian from Gaza, X, April
25, 2024.
By blocking the three Palestinian social media influences, the SJP, which claims
to seek justice for the Palestinians, is proving that it does not care about
freedom of speech for the Palestinians and is as intolerant as Hamas and other
terrorist groups to criticism.
"The Muslim Brotherhood is a cancer on every university campus." – Amjad Taha,
Emirati researcher and journalist, X, April 23, 2024.
While protesters at Columbia University and Yale University celebrate Hamas and
its "resistance" (a euphemism for violence and terrorism), Arabs have been
ridiculing the "pro-Palestinian" demonstrators on American college campuses. For
these Arabs, including some Palestinians, there is nothing "pro-Palestinian"
about supporting the Iran-backed Hamas terrorist group.
While protesters at Columbia University and Yale University celebrate Hamas and
its "resistance" (a euphemism for violence and terrorism), Arabs have been
ridiculing the "pro-Palestinian" demonstrators on American college campuses. For
these Arabs, including some Palestinians, there is nothing "pro-Palestinian"
about supporting the Iran-backed Hamas terrorist group, whose members
slaughtered 1,200 Israelis and kidnapped more than 240 others on October 7,
2023.
It is also ironic that the current wave of protests on US college campuses comes
at a time when most Palestinian and Arab universities remain quiet. One would
have expected to see such protests at university campuses in the West Bank and
several Arab countries. True, there were some relatively small protests at a few
universities in Jordan and Egypt, but they did not come close to the wave of
antisemitism sweeping college campuses in the US.
Those who are chanting "we are all Hamas" on the streets of New York and U.S.
college campuses are not helping the Palestinians of the Gaza Strip even
slightly. They are being used as human shields by the terrorist group Hamas in
its genocidal war against Israel and Jews.
Behind Hamas, of course, is the puppeteer of the world's "leading state sponsor
of terrorism," Iran in its genocidal war against "the Little Satan," Israel --
"Death to Israel" -- and "the Great Satan," the United States --"Death to
America" (here, here, here and here).
When the Jew-haters on the college campuses proudly say "we are all Hamas," they
are supporting an Islamist terrorist group responsible for the murder, rape,
mutilation, and beheading of hundreds of Israelis, including burning infants
alive and baking one in an oven. In addition, by chanting slogans in favor of
Hamas, these individuals on campus are affiliating themselves with a group
officially designated by the US as a foreign terrorist organization.
The students and faculty members demonstrating in support of Hamas are actually
saying that they approve of the atrocities committed by Hamas over the past
three decades, including suicide bombings, stabbings, and the firing of
thousands of rockets and mortars into Israeli cities, villages and farms. These
anti-Israel protesters have openly demonstrated that they support the Islamists'
Jihad against Israel and the West.
"Death to America" and "Death to Israel" were shouted in Michigan, Illinois and
New York. Columbia University student Khaymani James went further. He said, "So,
yes, I feel very comfortable, very comfortable, calling for those people
[Zionists] to die." He added that people should "be grateful that I'm not just
going out and murdering Zionists."
Loay Al-Shareef, a social media influencer from the United Arab Emirates wrote:
"Dear White Americans and Gen Zs who support or tolerate Hamas supporters on US
campuses, a gentle reminder from a credible Arab Muslim voice from the Middle
East:
"You are supporting a terror group with the same Islamist/ Muslim brotherhood
pathological creed that brought down the twin towers in Manhattan in 2001.
"You would not survive a day in Gaza under Hamas, which demands that 'infidels'
live with dignity only if they are subordinate to Islamists.
"You would not endure a day under the rule of these radicals. You do not
understand Arabic, nor do you know Islam well enough to comprehend what awaits
you if Hamas prevails (God forbid).
"Furthermore, you would also be the target of hatred because radical Islamists
like Hamas believe in eternal enmity towards Jews and Christians. They interpret
the Quranic verse (O you who believe, never take Jews and Christians as friends)
as timeless, applicable to all Jews and Christians forever. In contrast,
mainstream Muslims believe this verse was context-specific.
"Living in a civil society under the rule of Islamists like Hamas is unfeasible.
Islamists unite against a common enemy but turn against each other when that
enemy withdraws—as evidenced by their actions in Afghanistan in the late 1980s.
Do you think you are safe?
"How can you trust an ideology that has failed its adherents so profoundly that
they fled to America, Canada, and Europe to seek asylum, only to exploit the
freedoms there to engage in activities that will ultimately endanger you as
well?
"Take it from someone who knows how much hate this ideology instills in your
heart, listen to those who overcome it.
"I am a credible voice who understands the region, the religions, and the
language. I implore you to wake up because you are next."
Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, a prominent Gaza-born Palestinian American humanitarian
activist and blogger, accused the "pro-Palestinian" protesters on the college
campuses of employing inflammatory rhetoric that actually harms the Palestinian
issue. It makes the Palestinians appear as extremists, and because such rhetoric
emboldens Hamas and other radical groups that have brought a catastrophe on the
Palestinians] Alkhatib revealed that the anti-Israel group Students for Justice
in Palestine (SJP), which is leading the protests, has blocked him on social
media because he dared to criticize their tactics, including support for the
"armed struggle" against Israel.
"I'm disappointed and frustrated with the statement by Columbia Students for
Justice in Palestine (who blocked me despite having never interacted with
them)," Alkhatib said.
"In it, they reaffirm the right of armed resistance, an explicit endorsement of
Hamas and October 7 and the 'all means necessary' narrative, reject the Two
State Solution, and attack 'normalizers' or anyone who's willing to talk to
Israelis and engage in promoting pragmatic solutions to achieve coexistence and
peace.
"This is what losing the plot looks like: at a time of rising empathy &
solidarity with the Palestinian cause, these students, heavily involved in the
Columbia protests, decided that the best thing to do is take an extremist,
maximalist, inflammatory, unreasonable, and totally illogical approach which is
harmful to the pro-Palestinian cause. They brag about their extremist rhetoric
and think it's bad to expect that they work on improving messaging. There is
nothing inspiring about their message or efforts, only rejections, calls for
'escalations,' and attacks against anyone who doesn't toe the party line. And
not a word about Hamas and the deadly impact that the Islamist group's program
and decisions have had on the Palestinian people in Gaza.
"What have 75 years of armed resistance achieved for the Palestinian people?...
"Without a doubt, there needs to be advocacy for Palestinians' right to
self-determination, independence, and sovereignty. But rejecting anything
pragmatic that will actually help the Palestinian people or thinking that
underinformed college students are going to dismantle Israel and eradicate it
from existence is the height of pompous and vain, 'feel-good' activism that's
never going to do a thing for the just and urgent Palestinian cause...
"Stop wasting your time, embarrassing the pro-Palestine movement, and alienating
desperately needed allies from supporting the cause."
John Aziz, a British-Palestinian writer and musician, also expressed disgust at
the anti-Israel messages of the protesters at the college campuses in the US,
including calls for a global intifada (uprising).
"This is the kind of message that as a Palestinian, I have heard a lot over the
years from a range of voices on my own side of the conflict," Aziz wrote.
"A message of unrestrained militancy, a threat to the world, a warning, an omen
of violence. The language of Hamas, the language of al-muqawama (the
resistance), the language of war.
"But this is not Gaza, nor Yemen, nor Tehran. These are not the militant words
of some radical imam amid the dust clouds of Arabia, or the war-torn
Mediterranean landscape of Gaza. These are signs posted and words spoken at
Columbia University's Gaza solidarity encampment, in New York, the city with the
largest Jewish population in the world - a city populated by 1.6 million Jews as
compared to second-place Jerusalem's 546,000 Jews. If these students wished to
emulate their heroes of the Al-Aqsa Flood and attack or kidnap Jews, they would
have plenty to choose from."
Aziz was referring to chants and slogans on some of the campuses in the US, such
as "Jews, Jews, go back to Poland" and "Paradise lies in the shadow of swords."
"How far have Hamas — the ideological heroes of these campus wannabe warriors —
been willing to go in losing all of the trappings and the material spoils of
their lives? They have gone all the way. Gaza today is shrouded in dust,
shrapnel and rubble, and the relative — albeit limited — economic and material
progress attained before the war is gone. In the region of 30,000 Palestinians,
many of them civilians including women and children are said to have died as a
consequence of the war Hamas instigated on October 7. Every university in Gaza
has been damaged, a majority of the hospitals are out of commission and have
been replaced by field hospitals. Gaza's productive economy has been replaced
with food packages dropped from planes and delivered by trucks.
"Hamas' approach, in other words, has been a disaster for Palestinians in Gaza,
not to mention the Israelis and people of other nationalities — including
Americans and Britons — murdered, raped, and kidnapped on October 7 itself.
Those who wish to style themselves as pro-Palestinian should recognise the
failure of Hamas as leaders for Palestinians.
"But this ongoing pattern of failure has not stopped American students from
falling into the arms of Hamas. While support for theocratic militants may for
many be a juvenile silliness that most will simply grow out of and cringe about
in future years, there is a risk of people following through on their words and
turning to violence and terror, very literally globalising the intifada. At the
very least, this is a fertile recruiting ground for radicals...
"The explosion of Hamasnik ideology on campuses in the United States and in
Britain, as such, is a major embarrassment for these institutions. If
universities cannot instil their students with peaceful, tolerant, and
coexistent attitudes, then they have failed as institutions of higher learning."
Like Alkhatib, Aziz was blocked on social media by the group Columbia Students
for Justice in Palestine.
Another Palestinian, Hamza Howidy, was also blocked by the same group for daring
to criticize their words and actions. Howidy commented:
"Before I realized I was being blocked by Columbia Students for Justice in
Palestine, along with two well-known Palestinian peace activists... I thought
the calls for violence, support for Hamas, and globalizing intifada that were
filmed during the Columbia SJP protests were strange and did not represent the
Columbia SJP's basic standards. Supporting Palestinians (according to the SJP)
appears to imply support for "armed resistance," which is entirely incorrect.
Violence has failed us for decades, and the only way to accomplish justice for
Palestinians is through peace."
By blocking the three Palestinian social media influences, SJP, which claims to
seek justice for the Palestinians, is proving that it does not care about
freedom of speech for the Palestinians and is as intolerant as Hamas and other
terrorist groups to criticism.
Emirati researcher and journalist Amjad Taha warned that the Muslim Brotherhood
(of which Hamas is an offshoot) is spreading on university campuses in the US.
"I'm leaving New York today, and I can confirm that antisemitism is spreading
here faster than COVID-19 ever did. The Muslim Brotherhood is a cancer on every
university campus. America needs #America before #Gaza and #Israel. Your next
generation is held hostage by extremist ideologies."
It is refreshing to see that there are Arabs who understand the dangers of
radical Islam infiltrating educational institutions in the US. It is also
refreshing to see that there are Arabs who understand that support for Hamas and
antisemitism are counterproductive to the Palestinian cause. If the US and other
Western countries do not wake up to the fact that Jihad has come to their
universities, they will wake up to October 7-style massacres on the streets of
New York, London, and Paris.
**Bassam Tawil is an Arab Muslim based in the Middle East.
© 2024 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/20606/us-campuses-grooming-terrorists
Kissinger’s Shadow Chases Blinken
Ghassan Charbel/Asharq Al-Awsat/April 29/2024
Antony Blinken went to Harvard. In the hallways, he met the shadow of a man who
preceded him there by decades. His name was Henry Kissinger. He will meet the
same ghost as he passes through the National Security Council as well as the
Council on Foreign Relations. The owner of the shadow also loved writing
articles and thinking at length about America’s future and its position in the
world. Blinken now sits in the Secretary of State’s office. Kissinger left this
office decades ago, but his shadow remained. How difficult it is to live with
the presence of a brilliant ancestor! It is as if he was always judging you and
testing you! People are tempted by comparisons. Emmanuel Macron understands what
it means to occupy the office of a man who left his aura hanging over him. He
knows the difficulty of living in Charles de Gaulle’s office.
Time is a judge that does not take into account mitigating factors. He pushes
position holders to their fate and monitors the results. There is no place for
ordinary employees who rush into oblivion like river water trickles into the
sea.
History only preserves the names of those with fingerprints, even if they are
sometimes stained by crimes. That is why history has not forgotten those who
left their mark at the turning points. Mazarin, Talleyrand, Metternich, and
Bismarck. It did not forget Molotov, Xuan-lai, Kissinger, Gromyko, Primakov, and
Lavrov, despite the latter’s image falling into the Ukrainian trap.
On the plane that took him to Beijing, he looked at his watch. Time runs out.
Biden is threatened with leaving the White House in the upcoming elections. The
courts are dealing with a loud man named Donald Trump, and his popularity is not
diminishing. If Biden leaves, he will leave with him. He will publish his
memoirs and give lectures. But retirement does not tempt him. Then the
fingerprint is more important than the details of the diary. It’s a permanent
stamp.
How difficult it is to meet with the Emperor of China, the man who holds the
keys to the “world factory” and who deigns to sit in the second place in the
ranking of the great powers. Vladimir Putin came to his mind. He will not lose
the war in Ukraine, but the West will make it long and costly.
The war in Ukraine increased Russia’s need for Mao’s country. It did not occur
to the master of the Kremlin that Russia’s real competitor is the human sea
residing on its borders, armed with technological progress and a will of steel.
Putin escaped from the American fate and fell into the Chinese destiny. The
appointment is really difficult. This man, with whom he will shake hands, is not
threatened by elections or means of communication, and no one dares to oppose
him since the party has established him as a counterpart to Mao Zedong and a bit
more.
Kissinger’s shadow haunted him. On July 9, 1971, Kissinger was supposed to be
resting in northern Pakistan. But comfort is something that tempts others. He
secretly took off for China, bringing with him his knowledge of the country he
was visiting and the drivers of its history and present. He also carried with
him a complete understanding of the brilliant man he would meet, in addition to
his intellectual arsenal, his precise knowledge of the details of complex files,
and the skill of gaining the trust of others and suggesting that he was capable
of granting and obstructing.
Marathon conversations took place between brilliant people, during which
Kissinger asked Chinese Prime Minister Xuanlai to extend an invitation to
President Richard Nixon to visit the Chinese continent, which was openly hostile
to imperialism and considered it a “paper tiger.” The result was Nixon’s visit
to China in February 1972, which constituted a coup in the international balance
of power. The Soviet Union had no choice but to take the path of détente with
the West, which Kissinger believed would lead to the decline of the Soviet
Empire.
In the talks, Blinken confirmed that Xi Jinping is not in a rush to confront
America, but he does not want to see Putin lose because his defeat deepens
Taiwan’s alienation. On the plane that took him to the Middle East, Blinken
turned to his watch. The current situation is difficult and dangerous. The
echoes of the massacres in Gaza reached the heart of American universities. The
Biden administration was quick to support Israel in the wake of the Al-Aqsa
Flood, but seven months of killing is beyond tolerance. The American machine
intercepted Iranian missiles and drones, but some of them reached Israeli
territory.
The Netanyahu government responded with a programmed strike also deep inside
Iran. Who guarantees the ability to continue pulling the strings? What if the
Middle East woke up to a total collapse? America does not hold back anything
from Netanyahu, but the man is behaving like a wounded warrior. If he carries
out his threat to invade Rafah, the fires are likely to expand.
Once again, Kissinger’s shadow haunts him. He seized the 1973 war. He supported
Israel, but practically imposed the option of negotiation as the only way out.
He launched his “shuttle diplomacy” and used the arsenal of realism, ingenuity,
and moving cards with Anwar Sadat and Hafez al-Assad, and the result was two
agreements to resolve the conflict. The Egyptian side’s agreement changed the
scene in the Arab-Israeli conflict and later opened the door to Camp David and
Egypt’s exit from the military aspect of the war.
Tragic situations require exceptional decisions and men who are skilled at
creating destinies at turning points. Can Blinken open the door to a path that
leads to an independent Palestinian state? Such a step would bring a major
change to the scene in the Middle East. America will thus compensate for the
historical mistake it committed when it allowed successive Israeli governments
to assassinate the Oslo Accords and ignore the importance of Yasser Arafat’s
involvement in it, as well as disregarding the Arab Peace Initiative.Half a
century after Kissinger’s tour in the Middle East, Blinken’s plane is on the
move. Removing the injustice done to the Palestinian people will constitute a
major coup that redraws the boundaries of roles, including the roles of Iran,
Türkiye, Russia, and China.
A comprehensive peace will give the terrible Middle East a chance to focus on
development, combat poverty and terrorism, and address the misery of living in
tents. Can Blinken leave his mark on history as Kissinger did in more than one
place, including the negotiations to withdraw from Vietnam?
Why Are We Gambling With America’s Future?
The New York Times/April 29/2024
Over the past few decades, in a surge of bipartisan national self-confidence,
the federal government has borrowed a lot of money, sometimes in response to
national emergencies and sometimes to do the things people thought were worth
doing. We gave ourselves permission to incur all this debt because interest
rates were low and many people assumed that things would stay that way, so the
costs of carrying that much debt wouldn’t be too onerous. Unfortunately, that
assumption turned out to be incorrect. Interest rates have risen. According to
The Wall Street Journal, America is expected to spend $870 billion, or 3.1
percent of gross domestic product, this year on interest payments on the federal
debt. According to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, the
government will spend more on interest payments than on the entire defense
budget. Within three years, if interest rates remain high, payments on the debt
could become the federal government’s second-largest expenditure, behind Social
Security. When money is tight, as it is now, government borrowing competes with
private borrowing, driving interest rates up for everybody. A 2019 Congressional
Budget Office study found that every 10 percent increase in the debt-to-G.D.P.
ratio results in an increase in interest rates of two-tenths to three-tenths of
a percentage point. That makes voters miserable, as they are now, because it’s
more expensive to, say, get a mortgage or some other kind of loan.
It makes government accountants miserable because the very act of borrowing
money to pay off debt can drive interest rates higher and make the prospect of
paying off debt even more expensive. You have to worry about the long-term
nightmare possibility of a debt spiral, in which you have to borrow and borrow
to service the debt while the act of borrowing itself makes paying off the debt
more unaffordable. Pretty soon, you’re staring at Ferguson’s Law. This is the
principle enunciated by the historian Niall Ferguson that any nation that spends
more on interest payments on the debt than on military spending will slip into
decline. It happened to Hapsburg Spain, the Ottoman Empire, the British Empire
and prerevolutionary France. Will it happen to us?
You don’t have to get to these nightmare scenarios to see all the problems that
can be caused by excessive federal debt. All that fiscal stimulus can cause
inflation, as it is doing now. Public sector borrowing can crowd out private
sector borrowing, thus slowing the economic growth you need to pay off the debt.
The debt burden also constrains future administrations, which have to worry so
much about paying off the debt they are less able to invest in programs that
might increase growth, reduce child poverty, educate children, house people or
respond to emergencies. Today’s high interest rate environment is already
hammering, say, the housing construction industry and making housing even more
unaffordable.
The United States continues to borrow all this money even though classical
Keynesian theory tells us to borrow in times of recession but commit to debt
reduction in times like these, when growth is good. We continue to go deeper
into debt even though the storm clouds are gathering around the world. The axis
of resentment — China, Russia and Iran — is on the march, making the world a
more dangerous place and possibly necessitating a surge in military spending and
a rapid need to beef up our military manufacturing infrastructure. We continue
to go further into debt even though the baby boom generation is aging, making
programs like Social Security and Medicare more and more costly. The federal
government already spends $6 on senior citizens for every $1 on children, which
is not exactly investing in the future. Personally, I’m not bothered that we
spent all that borrowed money during Covid. We clearly needed to, and we’ve
emerged from the pandemic with a dynamic economy. My concern is that deficit
reduction is not high on either party’s agenda right now. Donald Trump has
proposed whopping tax cuts. The Biden administration has an ambitious
second-term agenda that would involve everything from industrial policy to
student debt forgiveness to growth through fiscal stimulus. Even if a president
proposed debt reduction (as Biden has to some degree), a polarized Congress
probably couldn’t pass it. As the budget expert Maya MacGuineas has pointed out,
these days Congress favors giveaways over budget choices. It is infinitely more
difficult to get bipartisan majorities to cut spending or raise taxes on the
bulk of Americans than it is to get it to spend with borrowed money. Ultimately
responsibility lies with the voters. In the 1990s, Americans saw how high
government debt was raising their interest rates. Voters put tremendous pressure
on politicians to get the fiscal house in order. Along came Ross Perot and
deficit reduction plans under Presidents George H.W. Bush and Bill Clinton.
Voters today have not yet made that connection. When they do, I suspect the
political landscape will shift massively.
Maybe none of the problems I’m describing will get worse. Maybe interest rates
will fall (though they have remained stubbornly high). Maybe economic growth
will outpace interest rate increases, making the debt more affordable. Maybe the
government will be able to pour massive stimulus into the economy without
leading to continued inflation and high rates. But this is a gigantic gamble.
It’s a gamble that rosy scenarios about future inflation and interest rate
declines will come to pass. It’s a gamble that nothing unexpectedly bad will
happen in the world. It’s a gamble that our leadership class is so good at what
it does that we can continue to walk along the cliff’s edge without any danger
of falling over.
At some point all this self-confidence begins to look like hubris or a
rationalization for: We want to spend the future’s money on ourselves. Prudence
is a boring virtue, but the prudent course is to get the United States on a more
sustainable course. As the meme artists on the internet might say (in slightly
more colorful language), you mess around with debt, and sooner or later you’ll
find out.
HomeUS policy toward the Israel-Palestine conflict needs
rebalancing
Dr. Mohammed Al-Sulami/Arab News/April 29, 2024
Official support for a two-state solution has been the cornerstone of US
diplomatic engagement in the Middle East since the 1990s and the beginning of
the so-called peace process. Nevertheless, since Oct. 7, 2023, American
political influence on Israel has been limited.
There is an apparent contradiction between the US support of the Israeli
government’s military operation in Gaza, on the one hand, and the official
policy of supporting a two-state solution on the other. In other words, how can
one justify US political support to an Israeli government that opposes a
two-state solution? This political contradiction is also apparent in the
policies of other states, such as the UK, France, Australia, Canada and Egypt.
While Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has always been an opponent of a
two-state solution, he is still able to receive support from many countries that
officially back this political solution to the Palestinian question.
The Israeli prime minister’s display of strength to impose his own political
agenda on his Western allies can be best explained by the limited objective of
US and European policies toward the Middle East conflict. The first dimension of
Netanyahu’s strategy is to take advantage of Washington’s objective of pursuing
an Israeli-Arab normalization process without pursuing an agenda of a just peace
to end the suffering of the Palestinian people.
The second dimension is to use the US objective not to be involved in any Middle
Eastern conflict and to pivot to Asia. This US policy outlook dates back to the
emergence of the Obama administration in 2009. As President Joe Biden explained
in his State of the Union address last month, “no US boots will be on the
ground” to support Israeli war efforts in Gaza.
The US’ priority is the short-term management of the humanitarian consequences
of the Israeli military intervention
The focus of US-Israeli discussions has switched from a political solution to
the Palestinian issue to the management of the military escalation in the
context of the war in Gaza. Biden mentioned this imperative in his State of the
Union address, saying: “Israel must allow more aid into Gaza and ensure that
humanitarian workers aren’t caught in the crossfire.” In other words, today, the
US’ priority is no longer a comprehensive political solution to the Palestinian
issue, but rather the short-term management of the humanitarian consequences of
the Israeli military intervention. America’s objectives in Gaza have been
defined by a prioritization of the release of all hostages taken by Hamas on
Oct. 7.
The humanitarian catastrophe can only be addressed if the root cause of the
conflict is discussed. For now, humanitarian assistance to civilians in Gaza has
become a bargaining chip to release hostages. The inability of the US to
prioritize the end of famine, the risk of spreading diseases and the end of
death and destruction in Gaza is first and foremost the result of a
securitization of the US diplomatic approach toward the Palestinian issue. The
securitization of the US approach is still the main driver of Biden’s policy.
In this context, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken’s announcement that the
State Department will conduct a review and present policy options on possible US
and international recognition of a Palestinian state after the war in Gaza will
have limited effect. Indeed, there is no US political path to solving the
Palestinian issue. Since the 1980s, US policy has constantly been to oppose the
recognition of a Palestinian state both bilaterally and in UN institutions. On
the contrary, it has always underlined that Palestinian statehood can only be
realized through direct negotiations between Israel and the Palestinian
Authority.
The political proximity between Washington and Tel Aviv has always been a policy
question for the Palestinian leadership
This diplomatic approach of promoting direct negotiations between Israel and the
PA failed at the beginning of the 2000s with the end of the peace process. Many
factors explain this failure, such as the refusal of Israel to consider the
existence of a Palestinian partner and the weakening of US diplomatic
credibility because of an unbalanced policy between the two camps. Indeed, the
political proximity between Washington and Tel Aviv has always been a policy
question for the Palestinian leadership, which has struggled to see the US as an
honest broker in the negotiation process.
Today, the Biden administration is still facing the legacy of the failure of the
two-state solution. To overcome this US deficit of credibility, the Biden
administration is trying to link a possible normalization process between Israel
and Saudi Arabia to the creation of a pathway for the establishment of a
Palestinian state as part of its postwar strategy. Despite this US diplomatic
maneuver, a two-state solution is now further away than it has ever been, with
some even proclaiming it “dead.”
Beyond the US’ difficulty in recognizing the existence of a Palestinian state,
139 members of the UN have done so, even if the governing bodies in the West
Bank and Gaza (the PA and Hamas, respectively) do not have control over their
own security or borders.
The US president could recognize a Palestinian state with immediate legal
effect. To do so, he would not need permission from the US Congress or Israel,
even though Israeli troops remain in control of most Palestinian territory.
Netanyahu is against US calls for a path to a Palestinian state. The official
justification of the Israeli refusal to compromise on the question of
Palestinian statehood is the result of decades of securitization of this
question.
Netanyahu in January explained that he would not “compromise on full Israeli
security control over all territory west of the Jordan River.” This Israeli
security strategy will probably prevent the US from presenting a credible
diplomatic framework to advance military de-escalation in Gaza. Only a
rebalancing of US policy between Arab and Israeli interests could pave the way
for the end of the Gaza war and the relief of the suffering of the Palestinian
people.
**Dr. Mohammed Al-Sulami is the founder and president of the International
Institute for Iranian Studies (Rasanah). X: @mohalsulami
Will a new embassy mean a new approach for the US in Libya?
Hafed Al-Ghwell/Arab News/April 29, 2024
In Libya’s fractured political and security landscape, the evolution of hybrid
armed groups into near quasi-state actors has become a significant challenge
obstructing the nation’s progress toward stability, security and sovereignty.
A convoluted dynamic is now the norm, whereby nonstate actors are firmly welded
to what remains of Libya’s still functioning institutions, creating new
political economies that thrive on a predatory governance model that is
detrimental to the fabric of Libyan society. This strange mesh of political
leadership, financial systems, transnational organized crime and heavily armed
groups with foreign backing now ties any prospects of a promising Libyan future
to the almost impossible task of dismantling these groups and the political
economies that sustain them. Hybrid groups in Libya have morphed into complex
entities with vertically integrated operations that span from imposing tolls on
urban streets to divvying up national resources — embedding themselves deeper
within the country’s sociopolitical fabric. The political process in Libya,
marred by division and inertia, often appears as a facade, with the real power
dynamics being dictated by bargains between these groups and political elites.
Such arrangements not only disenfranchise the Libyan populace but also cement
the authority of these actors, making the transition toward a functioning state
increasingly unreachable.
The timid return of the US to Libya with a new ambassador, after many years of
failures, can be a positive step to at least a limited extent, given the major
mistakes Washington has made in Libya over the past few years, such as engaging
with and giving legitimacy to some of the worst characters that emerged after
the fall of Muammar Qaddafi.
The timid return of the US to Libya with a new ambassador, after many years of
failures, can be a positive step
The pending withdrawal of more than 1,000 US personnel from Niger, reports of a
series of shipments of advanced Russian hardware to Tobruk and even the
establishment of Russian military bases in the Eastern part of Libya might have
caused some panic and a few sleepless nights across the Atlantic. By returning
to Libya, the US will be able to put diplomatic boots on the ground, so to
speak, which may help it make some serious headway in countering the existing
and emerging threats, if only to safeguard American strategic interests in the
Southern Mediterranean.
So, how can Washington succeed in, for instance, countering Russia’s deepening
influence in eastern Libya and the likelihood of Western “over the horizon”
counterterrorism operations going “blind” in parts of the Sahel? The US must
take an active role in steering political and diplomatic activity toward
rebuilding the collapsed Libyan state, rather than its repeated policy failures
of trying to arrange a compromise between the thuggish forces that created this
ever-expanding mafia state. As such, a reengaged US policy toward Libya must
also prioritize the dismantling of Libya’s corrosive political economies, which
are central to the power and influence of its armed nonstate groups. This
endeavor is indispensable for slowing Libya’s fragmentation and energizing
efforts toward unified governance. Until then, however, Libya’s political
impasse will persist, driven by a mafia-like ruling elite that prioritizes power
and money over the populace and a financial system that is disproportionately
reliant on oil revenues, which creates an endless cycle of opaque wealth
distribution favoring the elites. The morass of semiofficial, mostly
state-funded, hybrid groups — benefiting from state privileges while exerting
mafia-like territorial control — remains the greatest barrier to any meaningful
progress, state rebuilding and security sector reform.
For more than a decade, these groups have enjoyed unchecked expansion. Not only
have their numbers grown exponentially, but US diplomats and military officials
have also injected them with credibility through public meetings and photo
opportunities showing America’s officials smiling while standing next to the
worst of Libya’s thuggish spoilers and mafia leaders.
Washington’s strategy must therefore prioritize the dismantling of these
economies through a multifaceted approach that includes encouraging transparent,
equitable financial systems to cut off the flow of oil revenues to armed groups.
There must also be robust support for nontraditional interventions that can
quickly offer viable alternatives to discredited militia membership and foster
inclusive political dialogue.
The inclusion of the Libyan populace in the political process — even through
holding referendums in the absence of an ability to hold elections — is not
merely a democratic ideal but a strategic necessity for degrading the influence
of hybrid actors. The widespread mistrust in state institutions and political
developments is a direct consequence of a system that allows criminal political
elites to escape punishment and that simply benefits these exclusionary elites,
leaving the broader population marginalized. Encouraging genuine
decentralization and local governance would empower communities and create a
bulwark against the resurgence of militia-based power.
A reengaged US policy toward Libya must prioritize the dismantling of Libya’s
corrosive political economies
Recognizing the pivotal role of security sector reform in paving the way for
effective governance in Libya, there has been an intensive discourse among
policymakers and analysts over the prospects for the successful implementation
of reforms specific to the Libyan context. Yet, despite extensive deliberation,
strategic missteps have plagued attempts at reform, such as an overreliance on
so-called train and equip programs, which have failed to address the need for
sustainable and holistic strategies. Such initiatives, undercut by a
shortsightedness that prioritizes quick fixes over the foundational
restructuring of Libya’s security apparatus, remain insufficient for long-term
stability.
Furthermore, within Libya, officials have engaged in superficial restructurings
of security-related ministries, driven by internal power dynamics rather than a
comprehensive vision — all a byproduct of those malignant militia-state
dynamics. Those decisions only deliver the facade of reform, yet systematically
undermine genuine progress while purporting to contribute to security sector
reform.
Libya’s security sector is still growing to this day — drawing recruits into a
mix of state-affiliated and nonstate militias — meaning the need for
interventions cannot be deferred until a nebulous “post-conflict” scenario
crystallizes. Instead, the US and its Western partners must draw inspiration
from the Democratic Republic of the Congo’s more proactive and comprehensive
“next-generation disarmament, demobilization and reintegration,” which is well
suited to the Libya scenario.
This model, unlike its predecessors, does not await peace agreements and instead
initiates action in anticipation of them. Its scope extends beyond piecemeal
efforts, integrating activities that align with broader national development
aims. Crucially, it functions in tandem with security sector reform,
transitional justice and state-rebuilding initiatives. This approach recognizes
the dismantling of Libya’s hybrid groups not as a static program but as a fluid
political process, one which is acutely attuned to localized contexts.
It is through these initiatives, continuously adapted to the Libyan
sociopolitical dynamics, that the US can reengage in a meaningful and credible
way. A renewed focus on underpinning long-term solutions over short-term
illusionary gains — and recognizing these efforts as inherently political and
intertwined with the overarching objectives of national unity and development —
would be groundbreaking. Strategic US participation, in concert with
international partners, would also help de-incentivize and disassemble the
hybrid groups entrenched within Libya’s political and economic sphere, thereby
advancing the country toward the dissolution of political gridlocks and the
restoration of its sovereignty.
Only by tackling these underlying issues can the US hope to contribute to a
stable and unified Libya, where governance and economic opportunities are not
held hostage by armed factions, some of them even headed by American citizens
without any fear of legal consequences in Libya or the US.
**Hafed Al-Ghwell is a senior fellow and executive director of the North Africa
Initiative at the Foreign Policy Institute of the Johns Hopkins University
School of Advanced International Studies in Washington, DC. X: @HafedAlGhwell