English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For April 07/2024
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2024/english.april07.24.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
Bible
Quotations For today
Jesus Appears to The 12 When Thomas Was With Them: Put
your finger here; see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it into my side.
Stop doubting and believe.
John20/14-29/Now Thomas (also known as Didymus, one of the
Twelve, was not with the disciples when Jesus came. So the other disciples
told him, “We have seen the Lord!”But he said to them, “Unless I see the
nail marks in his hands and put my finger where the nails were, and put my
hand into his side, I will not believe.” A week later his disciples were in
the house again, and Thomas was with them. Though the doors were locked,
Jesus came and stood among them and said, “Peace be with you!” Then he said
to Thomas, “Put your finger here; see my hands. Reach out your hand and put
it into my side. Stop doubting and believe.”Thomas said to him, “My Lord and
my God!”Then Jesus told him, “Because you have seen me, you have believed;
blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese
Related News & Editorials published on April 06-07/2024
Israeli raids on the Bekaa Valley in Lebanon
An Israeli escalation claims 7 martyrs after Nasrallah’s speech...and a
“tactical discrepancy” between Biden and Netanyahu over Gaza!
The southern front is on fire... continuous targeting and missiles!
8 Hezbollah, Amal fighters killed in Israeli airstrikes on Lebanon
3 Amal fighters killed in Israeli strike on Marjeyoun
Is Hezbollah “Unable to Sustain” Its Southern Front Battle?
An Israeli Drone Shot Down in Southern Lebanon
Bassil says Hezbollah delusional if it thinks it can beat Israel while
'controlling' other citizens
Waste sorting plant: Beirut and Mount Lebanon set to revive Karantina plant
Security Forces: Seizing of a large quantity of cocaine worth millions of
dollars hidden in a banana shipment at Beirut Port
A Potential Full-Scale War, Aid Conditional on Resolution 1701/Bassam Abou Zeid/This
is Beirut/April 06/2024
Money Supply Breaks New Record in Lebanon/Christiane Tager/April 06/2024
Campaign Accuses Wajdi Mouawad of Normalization with Israel
Sexual Violence in Schools: Taboos and Protection Strategies/Sana Richa Choucair/This
is Beirut/April 06/2024
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous
Reports And News published on April 06-07/2024
Washington sends a warning to Tehran regarding its
expected response to the consulate attack in Damascus
Hamas says delegation to go to Cairo on April 7 for Gaza ceasefire talks
Negotiators expected in Cairo as Israel-Hamas war nears six-month mark
Gaza truce talks on, after aid worker death outcry
UN humanitarian chief calls Gaza war ‘betrayal of humanity’
Royal Navy ship deployed in Gaza aid effort amid £9.7m funding
Their schools ruined, Gaza’s children face long road to healing
Hamas says refuses to ‘back down’ on Gaza ceasefire demands
For families of hostages, it’s a race against time as Israel’s war reaches
six-month mark
‘Show must go on’ for Iranian journalist stabbed in London
Iran arrests three suspected IS group jihadists
New York rattled by small earthquake, aftershock
Blast kills 7 children in southern Syria: state media
Russian missile strikes on the Ukrainian city of Kharkiv kill 6 and wound 11
Kuwait’s prime minister submits Cabinet resignation to Kuwaiti Emir - KUNA
Titles For The Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from miscellaneous
sources on April 06-07/2024
Is Israel deterring Iran — or provoking it?/Yossi Mekelberg/Arab
News/April 06, 2024
The Obama and Biden Administrations' Betrayal of America's Closest Ally in the
Middle East: Israel/Dr. Majid Rafizadeh/Gatestone Institute/April 6, 2024
Iran and Israel: Is the Denial Game Over?/Amir Taheri/Asharq Al-Awsat/April
06/2024
The Word’s Conscience is in Crisis/Dr. Amal Moussa/Asharq Al-Awsat/April 06/2024
Mass Tech Layoffs? Just Another Day in the Corporate Blender./Ashley Goodall/The
New York Times/April 06/2024
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published
on April 06-07/2024
Israeli raids on the Bekaa Valley in
Lebanon
Sky News Arabia/April 7, 2024
Two Lebanese security sources told Reuters that Israel carried out raids on the
Lebanese Bekaa region late on Saturday, a few hours after an Israeli drone was
shot down over Lebanon. The two sources added that the
Israeli attack targeted a Hezbollah training camp in the village of Jinta, near
the border with Syria. The two sources explained that one of the strikes
targeted the town of Al-Safari, near the city of Baalbek in the east of the
country.
An Israeli escalation claims 7 martyrs after Nasrallah’s speech...and a
“tactical discrepancy” between Biden and Netanyahu over Gaza!
Janoubia/06 April 2024 (google translation from Arabic)
The Secretary-General of Hezbollah, Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, confirmed in his
speech on International Jerusalem Day yesterday that the strike on the Iranian
consulate in Damascus will not pass, but rather a response from Tehran, and that
the response is inevitably coming. This was met with a bloody Israeli escalation
last night, which affected 3 southern villages, causing To 7 martyrs, 4 for
“Hezbollah” and 3 for “Amal Movement.” Hezbollah mourned the four martyrs: Ali
Nasser Abd Ali from the town of Aytit, Bilal Haidar Halal from the town of Qana,
Ahmed Ali Hamad 1992 from the town of Toura, and Abbas Deeb Daibes from the town
of Mays al-Jabal. While the “Amal Movement” mourned the three martyrs: Musa
Abdel Karim al-Musawi from the town of Nabi Sheet in the Bekaa, Muhammad Daoud
Sheet from the town of Kafr Kila, and Muhammad Ali Wahbi from the town of Khiam.
Janoubiya field sources believe that the “studied” escalation is still a feature
of the stage while awaiting the Iranian response, which is supposed to be
qualitative and in proportion to the size of the loss suffered by the
Revolutionary Guard, which to date has lost 17 of its senior officers with the
rank of brigadier general and major general! She pointed out that the Iranian
response can only be major and earth-shattering, otherwise Tehran will no longer
preserve its face before its audience and its axis from Lebanon to Yemen.
Meanwhile, it seems that America and Israel are convinced that Iran does not
want war and that it is fighting with proxies far from its land, so it will not
risk a response. Currently changing equations. On the “Hezbollah” front, the
sources believe that despite Nasrallah’s loud tone, the latter will not risk
expanding the war with Israel unless Tehran wants to, and it does not seem that
Iran is ready for a wide and comprehensive war after the battle of Gaza, which
does not seem to end without heavy costs for Iran, Hamas, and The entire axis of
resistance!
American expectations of an Iranian strike!
CNN quoted a senior American official as saying, “Washington is on high alert
and is preparing for a major Iranian attack within the next week,” in response
to the Israeli bombing of the Iranian consulate in Damascus. In this context,
American officials indicated, according to what was reported by NBC, that “the
Biden administration is concerned that Iran is planning to strike targets inside
Israel,” explaining that “any Iranian retaliation inside Israel will target
military or intelligence sites.”
The southern front is on fire... continuous targeting and missiles!
Al kalima on line/April 06/2024 (google translation from Arabic)
The southern front is still burning between Hezbollah and Israel. 3 missiles
were fired from southern Lebanon towards an Israeli position in the Western
Galilee. In parallel, Israeli Army Radio reported that sirens sounded in Shlomi
in the Western Galilee. A representative of the National News Agency reported
that a house was hit by an Israeli drone missile in the town of Shebaa. He also
reported that a Merkava tank directly targeted a house in the town of Yarin al-Fawqa
in the western sector. The Israeli warplanes launched raids targeting Labouneh
in the outskirts of Naqoura, Tayr Harfa and Aita al-Shaab. The vicinity of the
town of Naqoura was also subjected to artillery shelling. The National News
Agency reported that the raid on Tayr Harfa targeted a house belonging to the
Youssef family, and the Civil Defense is in the process of removing the rubble
and no casualties have been reported so far. In the evening, intermittent
shelling was recorded on Jabal Al-Alam in the vicinity of the town of Alma Al-Shaab.
In turn, Hezbollah announced that it had bombed the Al-Malikiyah and Jal Al-Alam
sites, and the deployment of Israeli soldiers between the site and the Shlomi
settlement, with “Burkan” missiles, and the Zibdin barracks in Shebaa Farms and
the Zaoura farm in the Golan, and they were directly hit. In the evening, the
party announced that it had targeted the drone jamming system in the Al-Asi site
with a swooping attack march. In this context, MTV Information reported that the
"Amal Movement" targeted the Admit barracks and the Elon and Jurin settlements
with missile weapons, in response to the Israeli army's attacks on southern
villages and the killing of 3 of its members in a raid on Marjayoun. Earlier,
the National News Agency reported that the southern front with Israel flared up
yesterday evening after its attacks and raids on Marjayoun and Mays al-Jabal and
the fall of a number of members of the Amal movement and Hezbollah. The attacks
continued and artillery bombarded the outskirts of the towns of Al-Bustan, Al-Dhahira
and Alma Al-Shaab. Which led to the paralysis of the region in the western and
central sectors. An Israeli raid was reported on the outskirts of Yammar-Shaqif,
and ambulances headed to the site of the raid.
8 Hezbollah, Amal fighters killed in Israeli airstrikes
on Lebanon
NAJIA HOUSSARI/Arab News/April 06, 2024
BEIRUT: Israeli airstrikes on southern Lebanon killed eight members of Hezbollah
and the Amal Movement on Saturday. A civil defense paramedic also died of his
wounds after being shot in the head by Israeli forces several days ago. Burkan
rockets launched by Hezbollah hit an Israeli military site in the Western
Galilee region. Israeli military reconnaissance aircraft flew over the villages
of the western and central sectors throughout Friday night into Saturday,
reaching the outskirts of the city of Tyre. The Israeli army also fired flash
bombs over the border villages adjacent to the Blue Line in the western and
central sectors. At dawn, Israeli forces fired weapons toward the outskirts of
the towns of Ramyah and Aita Al-Shaab from their positions. Saturday was marked
by intensive Israeli airstrikes on targets in southern Lebanon. Jets raided a
courtyard near Beaufort Castle in the Nabatieh area, north of the Litani Line,
targeting an abandoned room.The town of Marjayoun was hit by Israeli airstrikes
on Friday night for the first time since the start of hostilities on Oct. 8,
targeting a center affiliated with the Amal Movement, a Hezbollah ally.
Hezbollah, a close ally of the Palestinian group Hamas, says its campaign aims
to pressure Israel to end its war in Gaza. The town of Khiam was hit by intense
artillery and phosphorus shelling in the early morning. Israeli jets also
attacked a house in the town of Tayr Harfa, without causing casualties. Another
airstrike targeted the town of Labbouneh on the outskirts of Naqoura. Lebanon’s
civil defense crews worked throughout Friday night to recover the bodies of two
victims from under the rubble of a destroyed home in Mays Al-Jabal, which was
targeted by Israeli airstikes. Israeli Army Radio said that warning sirens
sounded in the town of Shlomi in the Western Galilee. Hezbollah said that it
targeted a group of Israeli soldiers near the military site of Ramya with
artillery fire. It also announced the targeting of the Israeli military site of
Malikiya with “a precision missile strike.”Hezbollah also targeted the Israeli
site of Jal Al-Alam in the Western Galilee. According to the government
displacement crisis management committee in Lebanon, hostile operations have
resulted in 331 deaths and about 1,000 injuries. Additionally, 75 public and
private schools in border and background towns have been closed since the start
of the war. About 790 hectares of agricultural land has been damaged and 340,000
livestock killed. A recent government survey conducted in tandem with
international organizations found that about 140,000 people have been displaced
in Lebanese border towns. Of these, about 93,000 have registered with
municipalities while 60,000 remain in conflict areas.
3 Amal fighters killed in Israeli strike on Marjeyoun
Associated Press/April 06, 2024
An Israeli airstrike on a house in southern Lebanon has killed three Amal
Movement fighters, the Hezbollah-allied movement said. Israel said warplanes
bombed what it described as an Amal military compound and said the group was
planning an attack against Israel. The military statement said its jets also
struck several locations used by Hezbollah in southern Lebanon, and a jet
attacked a person doing "drone observation activity" near the border.Friday's
violence comes as Israel has been trading fire almost daily with Hezbollah and
other Lebanese militant groups for months. The attack on Amal was the first
Israeli attack on Marjeyoun, a large town in southeastern Lebanon, since the
latest round of cross-border clashes began on Oct. 8. Hezbollah, a close ally to
the Palestinian militant group Hamas, says the clashes aim to pressure Israel to
end its war in Gaza. Fears of the Israel-Hamas war spilling over into other
Mideast countries worsened this week after an Israeli airstrike hit the Iranian
Consulate building in Syria.
Is Hezbollah “Unable to Sustain” Its Southern Front
Battle?
This Is Beirut/April 06/2024
Hezbollah is reportedly “unable to sustain” its fight against Israel on the
southern front, as per information obtained by This is Beirut, leaked by
Hezbollah officials. According to these sources, the pro-Iranian party is also
leaning towards the American diplomatic initiative for a settlement on the
Lebanese-Israeli border, “in exchange for Israel’s commitment not to violate UN
Resolution 1701.”The American proposal, akin to the one presented by France, is
said to entail the withdrawal of Hezbollah beyond the Litani River, along with
other planned measures, including a significant deployment of the Lebanese army
in southern Lebanon. US special envoy Amos Hochstein conveyed these proposals to
Lebanese officials during his recent visits to Beirut. Several related sources
suggest that the concern about Hezbollah’s weapons stands apart from the
implementation of Resolution 1701, “contrary to the belief that it is part of
the overall settlement” on the Lebanese-Israeli border. Indeed, “foreign and
local parties oppose the withdrawal of Hezbollah weapons beyond the Litani
River, insisting on the implementation of UN Resolution 1559.” The latter calls
for the limitation of weapons to “legitimate” (state) hands. These remarks come
amidst ongoing military operations in Gaza and clashes on Lebanese territory,
despite the adoption of UN Security Council Resolution 2728 on March 25, which
called for an immediate ceasefire. Against this backdrop, negotiations between
mediators are underway in Doha and Cairo to implement a cessation of hostilities
and an exchange of Israeli hostages for Palestinian prisoners.
An Israeli Drone Shot Down in Southern Lebanon
This is Beirut/April 06/2024
Hezbollah announced in a statement on Saturday evening that it had shot down an
armed Israeli army Elbit Hermes 450 drone over Lebanese territory. This
information was confirmed later that evening by the Israeli army, which stated
that the pro-Iranian formation had used a surface-to-air missile.
Additionally, a civilian who was injured in a raid on Yarin on Tuesday has
passed away. Tensions remained high on the southern front from Friday through
Saturday evening. According to local channel MTV, the Amal Movement has
retaliated against the Israeli army’s attacks on southern villages and the
killing of three of its members in the Marjayoun raid by targeting, with
rockets, the Adamit barracks as well as the settlements of Eilon and Goren.
However, Amal did not officially claim any attack.During the day, a Merkava tank
directly targeted a house in Yarine al-Fawqa in the western sector. Around noon
on Saturday, Israeli warplanes conducted a raid near Qal’at al-Shaqif, hitting
it with two missiles and causing an explosion that echoed throughout Nabatieh.
Reports suggested that the raid targeted a house in Nabatieh, resulting in no
casualties. The outskirts of Yahmar al-Shaqif were also targeted. Israeli
warplanes also raided Tayr Harfa and fired two missiles, targeting a house in
al-Yousef, with no reported casualties. Additionally, an airstrike targeted the
Labbouneh area, while Wadi Hamoul-al-Naqoura and Rmeish faced artillery
shelling. At dawn, the town of Khiam faced heavy artillery and phosphorus
shelling, while the Hammames Hill and the Marjayoun plain were also targeted
with artillery shelling. Israeli forces opened heavy machine gun fire towards
the outskirts of the towns of Ramya and Aita al-Shaab from their positions
adjacent to Aita al-Shaab. In response, Hezbollah announced in a statement that
it had targeted a gathering of soldiers near the Shomera and Shtula barracks.
The pro-Iranian group also targeted the Malkiya position with a Burkan missile,
along with the Jal al-Alam post. Furthermore, soldiers positioned between the
site and the Shlomi settlement were hit with Burkan missiles.
Bassil says Hezbollah delusional if it thinks it can beat
Israel while 'controlling' other citizens
Naharnet/April 6, 2024
Free Patriotic Movement chief Jebran Bassil has hurled a new jab at Hezbollah in
connection with the ongoing conflict with Israel, saying “delusional are those
who think that they can control the rest of the citizens and still defeat
Israel.”“It should go without saying that we should preserve our national unity
and our state and its institutions, and that we should have a president so that
he be the first resistance fighter in the face of any attack, occupation or
violation, whether it comes from terrorism or from the Israeli enemy,” Bassil
said during an iftar banquet in Jbeil. “When a war erupts on our border, our
priority must be to elect a president and not to await the end of the Gaza war,”
Bassil added. “What we’re doing to our country is wrong and it is wrong to think
that Lebanon can triumph through the rifle alone, regardless of its important
and necessity whenever someone brandishes it against us. Before anything else,
Lebanon triumphs throught its diverse culture,” Bassil went on to say.
Reiteraing that all Lebanese “do not want a war in Lebanon,” the FPM chief noted
that the U.S. and Iran also do not want a war in Lebanon. “Only (Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin) Netanyahu wants it, so are we supposed to give it to him so
that he kills and destroys further? Or should we adopt a policy that separates
Lebanon from Gaza by calling for a ceasefire in Lebanon?” Bassil added. “We are
not obliged to remain entangled in a war in Gaza that we don’t know when it will
end nor its impact and consequences for Lebanon,” the FPM chief urged
Waste sorting plant: Beirut and Mount Lebanon set to
revive Karantina plant
LBCI/April 06/2024
Residents of Beirut and Mount Lebanon will soon witness a significant turnaround
in waste management. The waste sorting plant at the Karantina facility,
destroyed after the August 4 explosion, is slated to resume operations. The
revival of this facility brings hope to those grappling with daily waste
disposal dilemmas. It will alleviate the burden on landfills in Jdeideh, which
can no longer accommodate additional quantities of waste.The Karantina plant,
equipped to handle various types of waste, is expected to start operating within
12 months of preparation. It will process 1,000 tons daily, with 450 tons from
Beirut and 550 tons from Mount Lebanon. With three sorting lines initially
operational out of six, it does not only promise environmental benefits but also
economic gains, with both residents and municipalities poised to
profit.Furthermore, the plant will be purely Lebanese. The impending revival of
the waste sorting plant offers hope in Lebanon's waste crisis, emphasizing the
potential for substantial gains with concerted efforts and determination.
Security Forces: Seizing of a large quantity of cocaine
worth millions of dollars hidden in a banana shipment at Beirut Port
NNA/April 06/2024
The Internal Security Forces Directorate General’s Public Relations Division
issued a statement this afternoon, indicating that as part of its continuous
pursuit and arrest of drug smuggling networks in the country, orders were given
to the relevant units to intensify their investigative efforts to uncover drug
smuggling operations to and from Lebanese territory and to identify and arrest
all those involved in said operations. “As a result of
the investigations, the Information Division reached confirmed data that an
international network smuggled a large quantity of cocaine from Ecuador to
Lebanon, by hiding it inside a shipment of bananas...After diligent follow-up,
the Division was able to determine the location of the container upon its
arrival at the port of Beirut, where a patrol unit worked to seize it and upon
careful inspection, 25.6 kilograms of cocaine worth millions of dollars were
found professionally hidden inside the metal structure of the container,” the
statement added. “The legal requirements have been
carried out concerning the seized shipment, and efforts are still underway to
arrest the smuggling network members involved in the aforementioned operation,”
the ISF statement concluded.
A Potential Full-Scale War, Aid Conditional on
Resolution 1701
Bassam Abou Zeid/This is Beirut/April 06/2024
According to diplomatic sources, tension along the Lebanese-Israeli front has
markedly intensified, and the likelihood of further escalation in the war is now
unmistakably real and no longer considered improbable. This follows the recent
Israeli attack on the Iranian consulate in Damascus, which resulted in the
tragic loss of seven Iranian Revolutionary Guard officials. Moreover, the
subsequent Iranian threats, in which Hezbollah played a part, led the Israelis
to ramp up military pressure against the party and to escalate interference,
specifically targeting GPS systems, despite the collateral damage inflicted on
Israeli society as well. Furthermore, despite the escalating military tensions,
efforts exerted by certain countries persist unabated to prevent a full-scale
war in Lebanon. However, these efforts have yet to yield any notable progress
and continue to face obstacles from both the Israelis and Hezbollah. There are
currently no indications of envoys arriving in Lebanon to engage in the
follow-up of these efforts on the ground. As such, US envoy Amos Hochstein is
monitoring the situation from a distance and does not currently have plans to
travel to Beirut any time soon. Similarly, the French envoy, Jean-Yves Le Drian,
and the French presidency recognize the interconnection between the presidential
election and the situation of the war in the region. In Lebanon’s context, the
toll of losses stemming from the southern war on various fronts shall rise on
various levels. Moreover, if the war were to escalate, the resulting catastrophe
would be staggering. With current damages already totaling billions of dollars,
Lebanon would find it impossible to manage. Furthermore, this figure could soar
to tens of billions of dollars if attacks extended across all Lebanese
territories, and the widespread destruction and casualties resulting from these
attacks would leave Lebanon devastated and collapsed, with scant resources for
recovery. In addition, Hezbollah’s lack of awareness of this reality may be due
to potential assurances of financial aid from the Islamic Republic of Iran to
cover losses, or the party thinks it can pressure the state to compensate from
Lebanon’s dwindling reserves in the central bank (BDL), even if it means
accessing part of the gold reserves. According to the same diplomatic sources,
the responsibility of those in power, particularly within the government and
parliament, is underscored in preventing this destructive path from unfolding,
especially if it becomes imminent.
The diplomatic sources mocked the government’s attempt to solicit humanitarian
and non-humanitarian aid in connection with the southern war. They insisted that
any assistance should hinge on Hezbollah’s cessation of the war it initiated
against Israel and the genuine implementation of Resolution 1701. This, they
stressed, is vital for establishing sustainable calm in the region and averting
future threats.
Money Supply Breaks New Record in Lebanon
Christiane Tager/April 06/2024
The money supply experienced phenomenal growth in Lebanon within one month,
increasing by 439% between December 2023 and January 2024. What are the reasons
for this, and what does it signify? A recently published report revealed that
Lebanon has experienced a significant increase in the circulating money supply,
which multiplied by more than five times in just one month. Accordingly, the M4
measure of currency in circulation and bank accounts in the country increased by
439% in January 2024 compared to December 2023, where it had increased by 0.1%,
according to data from the Central Bank of Lebanon (BDL). The money supply
corresponds to the volume of currency (both physical and digital) circulating in
an economy at a given time. In Lebanon, this supply is evaluated and regulated
by the BDL. The money supply is assessed, among other factors, by consolidating
the balance sheets of the central bank, credit institutions, and financial
institutions. This data contributes to compiling a monetary balance sheet,
updated every month. According to Fouad Zmokhol, President of the International
Movement of Lebanese Enterprises (MIDEL) and Dean of the Faculty of Management
at USJ, this increase in the money supply is “very normal with the salary
increases granted to the public sector,” not to mention “the implementation of
the new budget, the officialization of the exchange rate of the dollar against
the Lebanese pound at 89,500, and the conversion rate of taxes and duties to
89,500 pounds.”
On the other hand, Nassib Ghobril, Chief Economist at Byblos Bank, believes that
“all this fuss about the money supply is not justified.” According to him, since
the BDL changed the exchange rate from 15,000 pounds to 89,500 pounds for a
dollar since the end of January 2024, all official balances have changed and
increased. The BDL’s balance sheet and the consolidated balance sheets of
commercial banks have increased proportionally to the exchange rate hike. “It’s
the same for the money supply,” he explains. The economist believes that none of
these considerations about the reasons for this increase are in line with
reality. He recalls that the BDL issued a circular stating that the balances of
all companies and institutions should be calculated at the exchange rate of
89,500 pounds from the figures of January 2024. “This also applies to the
figures that the BDL publishes regarding the currency in circulation,” he says.
The only reason for this increase, according to him, is the increase in the
exchange rate, emphasizing that “this will not affect the stability of the
exchange rate in the parallel market.” Will this lead to inflation? “No,” he
answers, “since inflation is already very high.” He assured us that this
increase in the money supply is purely technical. “These are figures that have
changed, not a modification of economic activity,” Ghobril concluded.
Campaign Accuses Wajdi Mouawad of Normalization with
Israel
This is Beirut/April 06/2024
https://thisisbeirut.com.lb/lebanon/242425
The Campaign to Boycott Supporters of Israel in Lebanon accused
Lebanese-Canadian playwright Wajdi Mouawad of “normalization with Israel,” in a
statement published on April 3 and picked up by the Hezbollah-affiliated daily
al-Akhbar.
According to information provided to This Is Beirut, the smear campaign against
Mouawad is also affecting the Lebanese production team, particularly the actors,
who are receiving threats, being targeted by defamatory language on social media
and being accused of treason.
A person close to the organization talked to This Is Beirut about the issue.
They wished to remain anonymous for security reasons and stressed that the
boycott call some made against him is “unfair and unjustified.” They pointed out
that the play Journée de Noces chez les Cromagnons (Wedding Day at the
Cro-Magnons), presented in Beirut in its world premiere, “has absolutely nothing
to do with Israel.”
“Wajdi Mouawad is the director and playwright, but the organizers are
collaborating with the Colline Theater which is a public theater subsidized by
the French Ministry of Culture,” they added.
Mouawad is mainly criticized for his collaboration with Israeli actors in his
play Tous des Oiseaux (All Birds), performed in France in 2017 and then in Tel
Aviv in 2018. A play supported by the Israeli Embassy in Paris as part of the
“Saison culturelle croisée France-Israël” (France-Israel Cross-Cultural Season),
organized by the French Ministry of Culture.
It should be noted that this work, the actions of which take place against the
backdrop of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, was banned in Germany for being
considered anti-Semitic.
The Boycott Campaign “has sent direct notification to the relevant authorities
to put an end” to the theatrical performance project in Beirut, calling on the
artists involved in the work “to withdraw from the production.”
“Lebanon will not allow normalization with Israel, nor will it accept becoming
the theater for the laundering of the enemy’s crimes,” the statement read.
The organization’s close associate called for “clarity and honesty, recognition
that Wajdi Mouawad, who is considered today as one of the most important
playwrights in the world, is in no way hostile to the Palestinian cause, and
that he practices his craft with conscience, professionalism and independence,
in collaboration with local artists and Lebanese playwrights.”
They added, “The Lebanese public, which is sufficiently mature and capable of
discernment, is looking forward to the premiere of this show, whose cast is made
up of Lebanese from all walks of life.” The play will take place in early May at
the Monnot Theater.
It’s worth noting that plays by Wajdi Mouawad have already been presented in
Lebanon, including Incendies (Scorched) at the Al-Madina Theater and Seuls (The
Lonely Ones) at the Monnot Theater.
Wajdi Mouawad’s play Journée de noces chez les Cromagnons (Wedding Day at the
Cro-Magnons) is scheduled to run at the Monnot Theater from April 30 to May 19.
This tragi-comic work tells the story of a family who, despite being bombarded,
prepares for the wedding of their eldest daughter to her fiancé… who doesn’t
exist.
Author, director, playwright, actor and filmmaker, Wajdi Mouawad, 55, is
recognized as one of the most unifying artists in contemporary theater.
He spent his childhood in Lebanon, his adolescence in France and his young adult
years in Quebec before settling in France. Trained at the National Theatre
School of Canada, he has directed several theater companies in Canada and
France.
He was Artistic Director of the National Arts Centre French Theatre in Ottawa
from 2007 to 2012. He has been the director of the Colline National Theatre in
Paris since 2016. His mandate was recently renewed until 2027.
Sexual Violence in Schools: Taboos and Protection
Strategies
Sana Richa Choucair/This is Beirut/April 06/2024
Sexual violence, especially in schools, remains a delicate and often concealed
issue. What initiatives have been implemented in Lebanon to promote awareness,
prevention, and intervention against this scourge? Who among us hasn’t heard
rumors about children falling victim to sexual abuse by adults in Lebanese
schools? If these cases of abuse, often proven, aren’t widely publicized, it’s
mainly to preserve the reputation of the educational institution and protect the
victims. Some instances have still been exposed by the media. We can mention the
case of the young teacher who, in 2012, committed acts of pedophilia in one of
the private schools in Mount Lebanon. At the time, his victims were aged 8 and
9. With the help of social media, a public school teacher in North Lebanon was
denounced in 2021 by some young girls for harassment and inappropriate behavior.
Other cases are constantly reported to the relevant authorities without much
media attention. However, it’s important to note that abuse isn’t only committed
in schools; children can also fall victim to sexual violence within their
families. While these cases are mostly handled discreetly, primarily to protect
the victims, they highlight the importance of proactive work to prevent them and
raise awareness among various stakeholders about the signs that should alert
them and the tools available for intervention. It’s crucial to teach children to
protect themselves from any form of violence they might face from adults,
particularly in the school environment where they spend most of their time. What
are the strategies for raising awareness, prevention, and intervention
implemented in Lebanon, where challenges abound and where acceptance of violence
isn’t necessarily the same for everyone, especially considering that sexual
abuse remains a taboo subject for many?
A National Policy
It’s worth mentioning that Lebanon started taking this issue seriously in 2010
through local NGOs before the authorities also got involved. The local strategy
operates at two levels: official, through the Ministry of Education and Higher
Education and the Internal Security Forces, and social, through NGOs focusing on
child protection. This concerted effort is beginning to yield results,
especially as approaches have become more standardized over the years. Society
is gradually aligning with the norms of behavior and common attitudes advocated
by various stakeholders, although there’s still much work to be done. “The
outcome is relatively positive, in the sense that taboos are gradually being
broken, giving victims more courage to speak up. Confidentiality rules reassure
them,” explains Amina Hamade, coordinator of the prevention program at Himaya,
an NGO fighting child abuse.
On May 11, 2018, the Ministry of Education launched the national policy for the
protection of students in schools with the support of UNICEF. “The methodology
implemented in schools relies on four steps: observation, characterization,
corresponding measures, and appropriate follow-up,” explains Hilda Khoury,
director of the department of pedagogical and school counseling at the ministry.
The official strategy was developed by the department operating under the
General Directorate of Education within the ministry. Also involved in the
project were the Center for Educational Research and Development (CRDP), the
Lebanese University, and the Lebanese School of Social Formation at Université
Saint-Joseph. The protocol for identifying and addressing cases of violence
includes standardized referral processes and branches into two types of
measures: internal within the Ministry of Education and external, involving the
intervention of other agencies outside the ministry.
In case of suspected harassment by an adult against a student at school,
administrative investigations are immediately conducted, followed, if necessary,
by referral to the judicial authorities. “Although these cases aren’t
publicized, they’re treated with strict confidentiality and the utmost
seriousness, not to preserve the institution’s reputation, but rather to protect
the integrity of those involved,” says Khoury. For example, a case of sexual
violence perpetrated by a family member against a student was identified in a
school. “Our department went to the school to meet with the affected student and
provide appropriate psychosocial support,” she says. “At the same time, the case
was reported to the Ministry of Justice to ensure the protection of the minor
and initiate a thorough investigation into the incident,” she explains. “The
educational counselor intensified visits to the school until the competent
external services took over.”The Ministry of Justice is a crucial partner in
this process, as Law 422, promulgated in June 2002, defines the legal framework
for the protection of minors at risk. It provides for judicial and social
procedural measures to protect children, up to the age of 18, from any type of
aggression.
A guide has been developed by the Ministry of Justice’s Department of Minors,
with technical assistance from the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC),
for any adult in contact with children, especially educational staff. The aim of
this document is to present intervention strategies for children who are victims
of criminal offenses and to familiarize the general public with judicial
protection procedures.
The Internal Security Forces, Always Vigilant
Another awareness-raising mission in Lebanese schools against abuse towards
students of all ages is also carried out by the ISF and is not a recent
initiative. “It started more than ten years ago, but over time, an increasing
number of schools have been requesting interventions from the Cybercrime
Bureau*,” explains an informed ISF source to This Is Beirut. “Our teams,
composed of specialized officers, conduct weekly interventions in schools,
focusing mainly on cybersecurity, as children are increasingly exposed to social
media at a younger age,” says the same source, explaining why a growing number
of schools are requesting the Cybercrime Bureau for interventions on this
phenomenon and the associated risks. A booklet on cyber threat awareness is also
available in three languages from the official ISF website. This guide aims “to
raise awareness among all members of society about the most important cyber
threats and crimes, and to strengthen the protection and privacy” of internet
users. This document includes “preventive measures and good practices to
follow.”
Individual and Organizational Initiatives
Long before the development of the national policy for the protection of
schoolchildren, some individuals had already been working in this field
alongside NGOs, starting in 2010. Roula Lebbos, a social worker by profession, a
consultant, and a juvenile protection trainer, carried out pioneering work in
this regard. Having developed a child protection policy, she worked on its
implementation in about ten Lebanese schools from 2010 to 2017. The overall goal
of any child protection policy, as explained by Lebbos, is to establish a common
language regarding violence, its nature, and its typology, in order to
disseminate a culture of non-violence. “Violence in adults can be
unintentional,” Lebbos continues; “it can stem from certain behaviors that
aren’t perceived as violent by society, especially in the presence of
stereotypes associated with the teaching profession or the educational system in
general.” For Lebbos, the foundation of this approach is familiarity with Law
422 on child protection in Lebanon, which allows the child, school personnel,
and parents to know their rights and duties. Therefore, she believes that any
successful child protection approach should combine psychosocial and legal
aspects. On the NGO side, This is Beirut spoke with Kafa and Himaya, which have
been working on this issue since 2009–2010.
The approach developed by Roula Lebbos and those practiced by these NGOs
converge in their holistic nature. Interventions in schools include the
development of a child protection charter, alongside training sessions for
learners, school staff (administrative and teaching), and parents.
Three main axes are addressed: types of violence (physical, psychological, and
sexual, in addition to neglect); attitudes and behaviors to adopt; and the legal
aspect. The institution should also commit to updating the adopted strategy,
which is of paramount importance to Lebbos. “The goal is to integrate new
factors that should be taken into consideration and to train new personnel
joining the institution,” she emphasizes. These interventions also aim to create
a child protection unit within the school or any other reference structure that
includes qualified specialized personnel, also referred to as “security agents.”
These individuals are authorized to detect, report, refer, and follow up on
cases of student victims of violence. “Each school decides on the executive
measures to adopt to ensure the implementation of the protection charter,”
explains Maria Semaan, head of the child protection unit at Kafa. “Some
institutions appoint protection agents, others establish a complaints office or
train specialized personnel already working, such as social workers or
psychologists.”As part of the prevention program, Himaya offers “a peer
education approach, which is particularly effective,” Hamade says. “Among the
children who attended the training sessions, groups are selected to organize, in
turn, awareness and education activities on protection against violence,
addressed to children of their age, such as skits, videos, or posters,” she
explains.
Impact on Society?
The efforts made over the years have fortunately made a difference in the lives
of thousands of children in Lebanon. In this regard, Hamade notes that “an
increasing number of cases, especially online harassment, are reported through
the ISF assistance hotline.”“The demand from private schools is also on the
rise, particularly in the areas of Beirut and Mount Lebanon, but also in
Baalbeck, where an increasing number of private sector establishments are
turning to Himaya to implement an awareness and prevention program,” she
continues. However, some institutions, where topics like harassment or sexual
assaults are taboo, remain resistant, Semaan deplores, while others, Hamade
notes, “go as far as denying cases reported to the NGO through other channels.”
Nevertheless, “the impact of education on a culture of non-violent communication
isn’t always visible or measurable by numbers,” as highlighted by Rebecca Wakim,
a graduate in social work specializing in social animation. “After three to five
awareness sessions in schools, a spectacular impact occurs when students’ voices
are heard. Cases of abuse come to light, and children feel safe to talk about
them and start the process of seeking help,” she says, emphasizing “the snowball
effect of this phenomenon: when one child breaks the barrier of fear, others are
encouraged.”
* The ISF’s Cybercrime Bureau registers complaints through its assistance
hotline (01/293293) and its online reporting service, which can be accessed on
the ISF’s official website.
Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published on April 06-07/2024
Washington sends a warning to Tehran regarding its
expected response to the consulate attack in Damascus
NNA/April 6, 2024
The United States warned Iran against using the Israeli strike on the Iranian
consulate in Damascus as a “pretext to target its interests,” according to CNN,
citing a US State Department spokesman. The spokesman said that the warning came
in response to a message from Iran, and did not provide details about its
content, nor about the American response or how it was conveyed to Iran.
The official added that the United States is on "high alert and is
actively preparing for a major attack by Iran that may occur as soon as next
week," targeting Israeli or American interests in the region in response to the
attack in which prominent leaders of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard were
killed. Israeli officials have confirmed that they have intelligence information
indicating that Iran may attack Israel from its territory using long-range
ballistic missiles or cruise missiles or drones, according to "Russia Today".
Hamas says delegation to go to Cairo on April 7 for Gaza ceasefire talks
CAIRO (Reuters)/April 6, 2024
A Hamas delegation headed by the group's deputy chief in Gaza, Khalil Al-Hayya,
will go to Cairo on April 7 for Gaza ceasefire talks, in response to an
invitation extended by Egyptian mediators, the group said in a statement on
Saturday.
U.S. CIA Director Bill Burns arrived in Cairo on Saturday evening to attend
Sunday's talks, sources at Cairo airport told Reuters. Qatari Foreign Minister
Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani and an Israeli delegation were expected
to take part in the talks as well, Egypt's Al Qahera news reported on Saturday.
Hamas reiterated its demands issued in a March 14 proposal prior to a U.N.
Security Council resolution calling for a ceasefire in the Gaza Strip that was
passed on March 25. The demands include a permanent ceasefire, the withdrawal of
Israeli forces from Gaza, a return of the displaced, and a "serious" exchange
deal of Palestinian prisoners for Israeli hostages being held in Gaza, the
statement said.
Negotiators expected in Cairo as Israel-Hamas war nears
six-month mark
Agence France Presse/April 6, 2024
American and Israeli negotiators were expected in Cairo over the weekend for a
renewed push to reach a ceasefire-hostage deal in a war that has raged for
nearly half a year. Ahead of the talks, U.S. President Joe Biden wrote to the
leaders of Egypt and Qatar urging them to dial up pressure on Hamas to "agree to
and abide by a deal," a senior administration official told AFP on Friday night.
The United States, Qatar and Egypt have engaged for months in behind-the-scenes
talks to broker a ceasefire and an exchange of hostages for Palestinian
prisoners, but have made no headway since a week-long truce in November.
The White House confirmed that negotiations would occur this weekend in Cairo,
but would not comment on U.Sm media reports that CIA Director Bill Burns would
be attending, along with Israel spy chief David Barnea, Qatari Prime Minister
Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al-Thani and Egypt's intelligence chief Abbas Kamel.
Israel and Hamas, which negotiate through intermediaries, have traded blame for
the lack of progress. "This basic fact remains true: There would be a ceasefire
in Gaza today had Hamas simply agreed to release this vulnerable category of
hostages -- the sick, wounded, elderly, and young women," the senior Biden
administration official said. Hamas officials and Qatari mediator Al-Thani have
previously accused Israel of stymying the truce with objections over the return
of displaced Gazan civilians and the ratio of prisoners to hostages. During a
phone call with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Thursday, Biden
pushed him to "fully empower" his negotiators to reach a deal. A staunch backer
of Israel, Biden's patience with the immense toll inflicted by the war on Gaza
appears to be waning, especially after the killing of seven aid workers. With
both international and domestic outrage mounting, Biden has warned of a
reassessment of U.S. support if more is not done to protect civilians. Allies
have been pressing Biden to leverage the billions of dollars in US military aid
to Israel. More than three dozen U.S. lawmakers on Friday signed a letter to
Biden urging him to reconsider the "recent decision to authorize the transfer of
a new arms package to Israel, and to withhold this and any future offensive arms
transfers until a full investigation into the airstrike is completed."
'Inhumane ferocity'
The Israeli army announced it was firing two officers after finding a series of
"grave mistakes" led to the drone strikes that killed seven World Central
Kitchen aid workers on Monday. It was a rare admission of wrongdoing by Israel
in its campaign to root the militant group Hamas out of the Gaza Strip, where
the health ministry says more than 33,091 people, mostly women and children,
have been killed. In response to the Israeli army's preliminary findings on the
strike, Australia's Foreign Minister Penny Wong said Saturday it was "not
sufficient."World Central Kitchen said Israel "cannot credibly investigate its
own failure in Gaza", noting that its staff was attacked despite having
"followed all proper communications procedures." WCK said its operations in Gaza
remain suspended after the attack, while top global aid groups said relief work
has become almost impossible. "In its speed, scale and inhumane ferocity, the
war in Gaza is the deadliest of conflicts -– for civilians, for aid workers, for
journalists, for health workers and for our own (U.N.) colleagues," U.N. chief
Antonio Guterres told a U.N. Security Council briefing on Friday. At the same
briefing, Israeli ambassador Gilad Erdan insisted the "only reason" aid fails to
reach Gazan civilians "is because Hamas loots it and the U.N. is incapable of
handling the capacity of supplies". Following the Biden-Netanyahu call, Israel
said it would allow "temporary" deliveries through additional aid routes,
without specifying when that would begin. For the 2.4 million Gazans, simply
procuring food and water in the relentlessly bombarded strip has become a
torturous struggle. Since January, Palestinians in famine-threatened northern
Gaza have eaten an average of just 245 calories per day -- less than a can of
beans -- since January, according to Oxfam. "Living in tents is difficult,
everything is hard. Securing water and food is difficult," said Gazan Siham
Ashour, who like more than a million others has been displaced to the sprawling
encampment in the strip's southernmost city Rafah.
Gaza truce talks on, after aid worker death outcry
AFP/April 06, 2024
GAZA: American, Israeli and Hamas negotiators are expected in Cairo over the
weekend in a renewed push for a ceasefire and hostage release deal in a war that
reaches the half-year mark on Sunday. Egypt’s Al-Qahera News said CIA Director
Bill Burns and Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim
Al-Thani would join Egyptian mediators for Sunday’s indirect talks between the
Israeli and Hamas delegations. Ahead of the talks Hamas, confirmed its core
demands — a complete ceasefire in Gaza and withdrawal of Israeli forces. The
ceasefire attempt comes after Israel’s military made a rare admission of
wrongdoing and said it was firing two officers over the killing of seven aid
workers in Gaza where humanitarians say famine is imminent. The admission did
not quell calls for an independent probe, however. The deaths of the workers
from US-based World Central Kitchen (WCK) on April 1 led to a tense call between
US President Joe Biden and Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Biden
urged an “immediate ceasefire” and for the first time hinted at conditioning US
support for Israel on curtailing the killing of civilians and improving
humanitarian conditions. The bloodiest-ever Gaza war began on October 7 with an
unprecedented attack from Gaza by Hamas militants resulting in the death of
1,170 people in southern Israel, mostly civilians, Israeli figures show.
Palestinian militants also took around 250 Israeli and foreign hostages, about
130 of whom remain in Gaza, including more than 30 the army says are dead.
Vowing to destroy Hamas, Israel has relentlessly bombarded the territory,
killing at least 33,137 people, mostly women and children, according to the
health ministry in the Hamas-run territory.
The UN humanitarian chief Martin Griffiths decried Israel’s war against Hamas
and called for a “collective determination that there be a reckoning for this
betrayal of humanity.”Fears that the war could spread intensified after Iran
vowed retaliation after seven Revolutionary Guards were killed in an air strike
Monday on the consular annex of its embassy in Damascus. Ahead of the weekend
talks, Biden wrote to the leaders of Egypt and Qatar urging them to secure
commitments from Hamas to “agree to and abide by a deal,” a senior
administration official told AFP. Stop-start talks have made no headway since a
week-long truce in November saw some hostages exchanged for Palestinian
prisoners detained by Israel. The White House confirmed negotiations would occur
this weekend in Cairo, and Hamas said its delegation would head there on Sunday.
But Hamas also restated its key demands.
“Hamas confirms its adherence to the position it presented on March 14 ... and
we will not back down from this position,” a statement said.
“The demands ... are complete ceasefire, withdrawal of the occupation forces
from Gaza, the return of the displaced to their residential areas, freedom of
movement of the people, offering them aid and shelter, and a serious hostage
exchange deal,” it said. Biden’s Thursday call with Netanyahu included
discussions on “empowering his negotiators” to reach a deal, National Security
Council spokesman John Kirby said. Washington blames the lack of a deal on
Hamas’s refusal to release sick and other vulnerable hostages. Qatar has said
Israeli objections to the return of displaced Gazans are the main holdup.
Biden is under pressure over massive US military aid to Israel which, so far,
Washington has not leveraged despite increasingly critical comments about
Israel’s conduct of the war. The Israeli military announced it was firing two
officers after finding a series of errors led to the drone strikes that killed
the WCK workers. WCK said its Gaza operations remain suspended after the attack,
while other global aid groups said relief work in the territory has become
almost impossible. The army said a commander “mistakenly assumed” Hamas had
seized the aid vehicles, which were moving at night.
Australia’s Foreign Minister Penny Wong said Saturday Canberra had “not yet
received sufficient information” from Israel about the death of Lalzawmi “Zomi”
Frankcom and the other aid workers. “It cannot be brushed aside and it cannot be
covered over,” Wong said.
WCK said Israel “cannot credibly investigate its own failure in Gaza.” Britain
called for a “wholly independent review,” while Poland sought a “criminal”
probe. Hours after Biden and Netanyahu spoke, Israel announced it would allow
“temporary” aid deliveries through Ashdod port and the Erez border crossing.
UN chief Antonio Guterres called for a “paradigm shift” rather than “scattered
measures.” Mahmud Bassal, spokesman for Gaza’s Civil Defense agency, told AFP on
Saturday that aid reaching Gaza is “absolutely not sufficient” for its 2.4
million people, with basic necessities “extremely scarce” particularly in the
north. “Children are dying from hunger” there, he said.
Around 1.5 million Gazans are sheltering in the territory’s far south, in Rafah.
“We are ordinary citizens and human beings,” Siham Achur, 50, said in the tent
that is now her family’s home. “Why did they bomb our house?“They had lived in
Khan Yunis for 30 years, Achur said, but those memories “have become dust.”On
Saturday, Israel’s military said warplanes had killed Akram Salamah, a “senior”
militant it said held several positions including Hamas’s deputy chief for Khan
Yunis. Troops also recovered from Khan Yunis the body of Elad Katzir, who was
abducted on October 7 and “murdered in captivity” by Islamic Jihad, a group
fighting alongside Hamas, the army said. The Israeli ambassador to Warsaw, Yacov
Livne, said on social media that Katzir had dual citizenship with Poland. The
Polish foreign ministry said it had received news of his death with “sadness.”
His sister Carmit Palty Katzir blamed the Israeli authorities for Elad’s death,
saying he would have returned alive had the authorities agreed to a new truce.
UN humanitarian chief calls Gaza war ‘betrayal of humanity’
AFP/April 06, 2024
UNITED NATIONS: Israel’s war against Hamas in Gaza has escalated into a
“betrayal of humanity,” the United Nations’ humanitarian chief said Saturday. In
a statement on the eve of the six-month anniversary of the war, Martin
Griffiths, the outgoing under-secretary-general for humanitarian affairs and
emergency relief, called for a “collective determination that there be a
reckoning for this betrayal of humanity.”“Each day, this war claims more
civilian victims,” said Griffiths, who will leave his post at the end of June
due to health reasons. “Every second that it continues sows the seeds of a
future so deeply obscured by this relentless conflict.”The war began on October
7 with an unprecedented attack by Hamas militants resulting in the death of
1,170 people in southern Israel, mostly civilians, Israeli figures show.
Palestinian militants also took around 250 Israeli and foreign hostages, about
130 of whom remain in Gaza, including more than 30 the army says are dead.
Vowing to destroy Hamas, Israel has relentlessly bombarded the territory by air,
land and sea, killing at least 33,137 people, mostly women and children,
according to the health ministry in the Hamas-run territory. Griffiths lamented
“the unconscionable prospect of further escalation in Gaza, where no one is safe
and there is nowhere safe to go.” He added that “an already fragile aid
operation continues to be undermined by bombardments, insecurity and denials of
access.”“On this day, my heart goes out to the families of those killed, injured
or taken hostage, and to those who face the particular suffering of not knowing
the plight of their loved ones,” he said in the statement.
Royal Navy ship deployed in Gaza aid effort amid £9.7m
funding
David Lynch, PA Political Staff/April 6, 2024
A Royal Navy ship will be deployed to help get more aid into Gaza, the UK has
announced. Alongside the vessel, which is not being named for security, the
Government announced a £9.7 million package for aid deliveries, logistical
expertise and equipment support for a humanitarian corridor in the eastern
Mediterranean between Cyprus and Gaza. Foreign Secretary Lord David Cameron said
the UK and its allies needed to “explore all options” including sea and air
deliveries to “ease the desperate plight of some of the world’s most vulnerable
people” in the territory. News of the UK’s support for the international aid
effort came as Israel marked six months since the October 7 attacks in which
Hamas killed more than 1,100 people and kidnapped about 250. It is also nearly a
week since an Israel Defence Forces air strike killed three British aid workers
in Gaza, in an attack the IDF later admitted was a “grave mistake”. The UK
Government continues to call for further safety measures to protect aid workers
on the ground in Gaza from being caught up in the fighting. Lord Cameron said:
“The situation in Gaza is dire and the prospect of famine is real. We remain
committed to getting aid to those who so desperately need it. “Along with the
US, Cyprus and other partners, we are setting up a new temporary pier off the
coast of Gaza to get aid in as quickly and securely as possible. “Land access
remains crucial to deliver aid at the scale now required. The opening of Erez
and the Port of Ashdod is hugely welcome and something the UK has long been
calling for. “Israel has also agreed to increase the number of aid trucks
entering Gaza to a minimum of 500 a day. “But we need to continue to explore all
options, including by sea and air, to ease the desperate plight of some of the
world’s most vulnerable people.” The British armed forces have dropped 40 tonnes
of aid into Gaza in recent weeks to tackle the bottleneck in supplies reaching
Palestinians. The five air drops have seen supplies including water, flour and
baby formula parachuted into the territory. Defence Secretary Grant Shapps said
the RAF had played a “central role” in delivering aid. He added: “We are now
going further, working with international partners to set up a humanitarian
maritime corridor from Cyprus to Gaza. “A new temporary pier on the coast of
Gaza will be critical to supporting these efforts, by hosting cargo ships to
deliver aid by sea.”
Their schools ruined, Gaza’s children face long road to
healing
AFP/April 07, 2024
UNICEF says, but it is the psychological damage the war has done to the
territory’s nearly 1.2 million children that has experts worried. “To be able to
learn, you need to be in a safe space. Most kids in Gaza at the moment have
brains that are functioning under trauma,” said child psychiatrist Audrey
McMahon of Doctors Without Borders. Younger children could develop lifelong
cognitive disabilities from malnutrition, while teenagers are likely to feel
anger at the injustice they have suffered, she said. “The challenges they will
face are immense and will take a long time to heal.” To be able to learn, you
need to be in a safe space. Most kids in Gaza at the moment have brains that are
functioning under trauma.
Audrey McMahon, Child psychiatrist
David Skinner of Save The Children said rebuilding the “schools is massively
complicated ... but it’s straightforward compared to the education loss.”“What’s
often lost about the coverage of Gaza is that this is a catastrophe for
children. “These are children who have been bereaved, who have lost people, who
are sick and malnourished,” he said. Small children whose brains are still
developing are particularly at risk from mental health and cognitive damage,
Skinner said. The UN child welfare agency estimates that 620,000 children in
Gaza are out of school. Skinner said getting them back into class and rebuilding
their schools were only the first steps. The true challenge will be healing
displaced and traumatized young Gazans so that they can learn to learn again.
Fighting has ravaged Gaza since Hamas’s unprecedented October 7 attack resulted
in 1,170 deaths in Israel, most of them civilians, according to an AFP tally of
Israeli official figures. Israel has responded with a relentless offensive
against Hamas that has killed at least 33,037 Palestinians. When the war broke
out, schools immediately stopped classes, and the majority were turned into
shelters for families fleeing air strikes. Nearly half of the Palestinian
territory’s population is under 18, and its education system was already
struggling after five wars in 20 years. So far in this war, at least 53 of
Gaza’s 563 school buildings have been destroyed, according to UNICEF. According
to a report by aid agencies, including UNICEF, based on satellite imagery and
on-the-ground reporting, more than eight out of 10 schools have been damaged,
and 67 percent took direct hits. “This is an unprecedented situation,” said
Juliette Touma of the UN Palestinian refugee agency, UNRWA, which helps educate
300,000 Gazan children. “Colleagues who have been here the longest remember
maybe one school being hit” in previous conflicts, she said. Majd Halawa didn’t
have to wait for the bombs to destroy his school in Gaza City to realize his
dreams of becoming a lawyer would have to be put on hold. Two weeks after the
war began, the Israeli army gave him and his family three minutes to leave their
apartment block in the north of Gaza. “I left all my books, thinking it wouldn’t
take long to return, but it didn’t happen,” the 16-year-old said. An airstrike
flattened their home. Makeshift schools have been set up in tents in the
southern city of Rafah, where half of the territory’s population has fled. In
one tent, Hiba Halaweh was teaching 30 children to learn to read their first
words. “The children are happy to get back into it,” said the teacher, who lacks
even “textbooks and pens.” The Hamas-run education ministry plans 25,000 such
temporary schools. Elsewhere in the world, many children who have lived through
wars never return to school. In Iraq, six years after the government declared
victory over the Daesh group, tens of thousands are still out of school.
According to the World Bank, thousands of destroyed school buildings have yet to
be rebuilt. But for Majd, whose family managed to get him out to Canada, it is
not just about having a school to go to again. “No one can get over all the
memories of what happened, not in 100 years.”
Hamas says refuses to ‘back down’ on Gaza ceasefire
demands
AFP/April 06, 2024
CAIRO: Palestinian movement Hamas refused to “back down” on Saturday from its
demands for a Gaza ceasefire, but agreed to send a delegation for renewed talks
in Cairo over the weekend. “Hamas confirms its adherence to the position it
presented on March 14 ... and we will not back down from this position,” a
statement said, referring to the group’s demands that include a complete
ceasefire in Gaza and the withdrawal of Israeli forces from the Palestinian
territory.
For families of hostages, it’s a race against time as
Israel’s war reaches six-month mark
AP/April 06, 2024
JERUSALEM: It’s the last wish of a dying mother, to be with her daughter once
more. But six months into Israel’s war against Hamas, time is running out for
Liora Argamani, who hopes to stay alive long enough to see her kidnapped
daughter come home. “I want to see her one more time. Talk to her one more
time,” said Argamani, 61, who has stage four brain cancer. “I don’t have a lot
of time left in this world.”Noa Argamani was abducted from a music festival Oct.
7 when Hamas-led militants stormed into southern Israel, killing some 1,200
people and taking around 250 hostage. The video of her abduction was among the
first to surface, images of her horrified face widely shared — Noa detained
between two men on a motorcycle, one arm outstretched and the other held down as
she screams “Don’t kill me!”There’s been little news about Noa, 26. But in
mid-January, Hamas released a video of her in captivity. She appears gaunt and
under duress, speaking about other hostages killed in airstrikes and frantically
calling on Israel to bring her and others home. Half a year into Israel’s war,
agonized families such as the Argamanis are in a race against time. In November,
a weeklong ceasefire deal saw the release of more than 100 hostages. But the war
is dragging on, with no end in sight and no serious hostage deal on the table.
Israel says more than 130 hostages remain, with about a quarter of those
believed dead, and divisions are deepening in the country over the best way to
bring them home. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has vowed to both
eliminate Hamas and bring all the hostages back, but he’s made little progress.
He faces pressure to resign, and the US has threatened to scale back its support
over the humanitarian situation in Gaza. Israelis are divided into two main
camps: those who want the government to put the war on hold and free the
hostages, and others who think the hostages are an unfortunate price to pay for
eradicating Hamas. “They have these two goals and the assessment of the type of
risk they’re willing to take to get the hostages back — this is where you see
divisions,” said Shmuel Rosner, a senior fellow at the Jewish People Policy
Institute and analyst for Israeli public television station Kan News. On-and-off
negotiations mediated by Qatar, the United States and Egypt have yielded little.
If a viable deal emerges, decisions will become harder and the divisions
sharper, Rosner said. But for most families and friends whose loved ones are in
captivity, there is no choice but to bring them home. Many are concerned in
particular about the women held in Gaza and say, based on testimonies from freed
hostages, they fear those remaining could be suffering from sexual abuse. Before
a recent parliamentary committee meeting, attendees held posters showing the
hostages. Yarden Gonen, whose 23-year-old sister, Romi, also was taken from the
Oct. 7 music festival, criticized what she said was the government’s inaction.
“What are we fighting for?” she said. “What is more important than this?”
Outside an art installation mimicking the Gaza tunnels where some hostages are
believed to be held, Romi’s mother said she can’t believe it’s been half a year,
with much of the world wanting to forget or ignore such a horrible situation.“We
are doing everything we can so the world will not forget,” Merav Leshem Gonen
said. “Every day we wake up and take a big breath, deep breath, and continue
walking, continue doing the things that will bring her back.” When Yonatan Levi
saw the video of his friend Noa Argamani in captivity, he said he could barely
recognize the smart, free spirit of the woman who loved parties and traveling
and was studying computer science. “When I saw that video, I thought maybe she’s
living physically but has died inside,” said Levi, who met Argamani during a
diving course in the southern Israeli city of Eilat.A few months before her
abduction, Argamani asked Levi to help navigate insurance issues for her mom, he
said. As an only child, she was a big part of her mother’s life and care, and
she seemed hopeful she would be OK, Levi said. But Liora Argamani’s cancer has
worsened, according to a video released by the Hostages and Missing Families
Forum.
In it, Liora and her husband tearfully thumb through childhood photos of Noa.
From her wheelchair, Liora addresses the camera — and US President Joe Biden
directly. Behind her rests an enlarged photo of Noa’s pained face as she’s
dragged into Gaza, on a posterboard with her words overtop: “DON’T KILL ME!”
“My heart really hurts,” Liora, a Chinese immigrant, says slowly in accented
Hebrew. “I am asking you, President Joe Biden. ... I am really begging you.”The
stress of missing a loved one like Noa is hard on the healthiest of people, and
it will only exacerbate a condition like cancer, said Ofrit Shapira Berman, a
psychoanalyst who heads a group of health professionals treating freed hostages,
families and survivors. “The fact that so much of her psychic energy is invested
in her daughter’s trauma leaves her lesser chance to survive,” Berman said. In
the video, Noa’s father, Yaakov Argamami, strokes the family photo albums and
chokes back tears. “I miss everything about her,” he says. “Her hug. The hug I
wanted to ...”Unable to finish, he simply nods and the camera cuts away.
‘Show must go on’ for Iranian journalist stabbed in London
AFP/April 06, 2024
LONDON: A journalist for an independent Iranian media outlet in London stabbed
outside his home last week has returned to work, saying “the show must go on.”
Pouria Zeraati, a presenter for Iran International, needed hospital treatment
for leg wounds suffered in the March 29 attack. The 36-year-old said the
stabbing was a “warning shot.” “The fact that they just stopped in my leg was
their choice,” he told ITV News. “They had the opportunity to kill me because
the way the second person was holding me and the first person took the knife
out, they had the opportunity to stop anywhere they wanted,” he added. Zeraati
said he had returned to work on Friday, adding: “Whatever the motive was, the
show must go on.”London’s Metropolitan Police say the two suspects went straight
from the scene in southwest London to Heathrow Airport and left the UK “within a
few hours.”
Detectives were considering whether “the victim’s occupation as a journalist at
a Persian-language media organization based in the UK” could have prompted the
assault. Iran’s charge d’affaires in the UK, Mehdi Hosseini Matin, however, said
Tehran denied “any link.”The Met has previously disrupted what it has called
plots in the UK to kidnap or even kill British or Britain-based individuals
perceived as enemies of Tehran. The Iranian government has declared Iran
International a terrorist organization. The UK government last year unveiled a
tougher sanctions regime against Iran over alleged human rights violations and
hostile actions against its opponents on UK soil.
Iran arrests three suspected IS group jihadists
Agence France Presse/April 06, 2024
Iranian police have arrested three suspected members of the Islamic State group
who were plotting attacks at the end of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan, state
media reported Saturday. Those arrested in the city of Karaj in the northwestern
province of Alborz included Mohammed Zaker who was identified as "a senior
member" of the group, according to the official IRNA news agency. "The police in
Alborz province arrested three members of the Islamic State group who were
planning a suicide attack during the end of Ramadan celebrations," IRNA said. It
was not immediately clear when the arrests took place or whether they included
foreign nationals. IRNA also reported the arrest of eight other "accomplices",
but without elaborating. Local media on Tuesday reported the arrest of two
alleged IS members in the holy city of Qom. In January, IS claimed
responsibility for twin bombings in the southern Iranian city of Kerman that
killed more than 90 people. The attacks took place at a ceremony commemorating
the anniversary of the death of Qasem Soleimani, a top Revolutionary Guards
general killed in a US drone strike in Iraq in 2020. Iran has been battling
jihadist and other militant groups for years. On Saturday, IRNA reported that
the number of "martyrs" killed in recent attacks by jihadists near the border
with Pakistan had risen to 15, without elaborating. State media had earlier
reported that 10 security personnel and 18 members of the Jaish al-Adl jihadist
group were killed in the clashes.
The Sunni Muslim rebel group Jaish al-Adl was formed in 2012 and is listed by
both Iran and the United States as a "terrorist" organisation.
New York rattled by small earthquake, aftershock
Agence France Presse/April 06, 2024
U.N. Security Council diplomats were shaken in their chairs, planes got briefly
grounded, and furniture rattled across New York Friday when an earthquake jolted
the city that never sleeps. No one was hurt, though, and New York's iconic
skyline remained intact. "I AM FINE," reported the Empire State Building on its
X account. The tremor had a 4.8 magnitude, according to the United States
Geological Survey (USGS). Near the epicenter in Lebanon, New Jersey, Dominika
Uniejewska, a 50-year-old retail worker, said "I'm still shaking" after being
woken up by the quake. "I've never experienced such a strong earthquake. I did
experience some before, but it was nothing compared to that. The whole house was
really shaking. The bed was shaking, the house was making rumbling noises," she
said. "I ran to check on my dog. The dog was okay." In Brooklyn, buildings
shook, rattling cupboard doors and fixtures, an AFP correspondent reported. "I'm
nervous, I'm shaking. Many people are scared right now," said Brooklyn resident
Ana Villagran, 62. Shortly before 6:00 pm (2200 GMT) the region was shaken by an
aftershock which the USGS said was 4.0 magnitude. "I AM STILL FINE," the Empire
State building wrote on X. At the United Nations, which has its headquarters in
New York, a Security Council meeting on the situation in Gaza was temporarily
paused after the initial tremor. "Is that an earthquake?" said Save the Children
representative Janti Soeripto who was speaking at the time. One diplomat joked:
"One for the memoirs."
'Under control'
A short time later many diplomats' cell phones blared with the sound of the
emergency alert system confirming the quake. "Residents are advised to remain
indoors and to call 911 if injured," the emergency alert said. Flight operations
were halted at several airports in the region including New York's La Guardia,
Newark in New Jersey and in Philadelphia. "Air traffic operations are resuming
as quickly as possible," the Federal Aviation Administration said in a
statement. Social media users reported feeling the earthquake from Philadelphia
up to New York and eastward along Long Island. Several users posted images of
knocked over garden furniture captioned, "we will rebuild." "Earthquakes are
uncommon but not unheard of along the Atlantic Coast, a zone one study called a
'passive-aggressive margin' because there's no active plate boundary between the
Atlantic and North American plates," the USGS wrote on X. Moderately damaging
earthquakes strike somewhere in the urban corridor roughly twice a century, and
smaller earthquakes are felt roughly every two to three years, USGS said. U.S.
President Joe Biden was briefed on the situation, spokeswoman Karine Jean-Pierre
said. Social media users jokingly questioned whether an earthquake coming days
before the April 8 solar eclipse, which will be visible across swaths of the
northeastern United States, heralded the end of the world. New York Governor
Kathy Hochul acknowledged New Yorkers were "not accustomed" to earthquakes and
–- at a hastily convened press briefing -- warned residents to be wary of any
possible aftershocks.
Blast kills 7 children in southern Syria: state media
AFP/April 06, 2024
DAMACUS: Seven children were killed in southern Syria’s Daraa province on
Saturday when an “explosive device” detonated, state media reported. “Seven
children” were killed “and two other people were injured, one of them a woman,
when an explosive device planted by terrorists” went off in the city of Sanamayn,
state news agency SANA reported, quoting a police source. The Syrian Observatory
for Human Rights war monitor gave a different toll, saying that “eight children
of different ages were killed and another was wounded” in the blast. The
Britain-based monitor said militias were accused of planting the device in order
to target an unidentified person in the area. Daraa was the cradle of the 2011
uprising against President Bashar Assad’s rule but it was returned to government
control in 2018 under a ceasefire deal backed by Russia. The province has since
been plagued by killings, clashes and dire living conditions. Syria’s war, which
escalated into a deadly conflict that pulled in jihadists and foreign armies,
has killed more than 507,000 people, displaced millions and battered the
country’s infrastructure and industry.
Russian missile strikes on the Ukrainian city of Kharkiv
kill 6 and wound 11
KYIV/06 April 2024
Russian forces overnight attacked Ukraine with drones and missiles, killing at
least six people and wounding 11 more in Kharkiv, Ukraine’s second largest city,
officials said Saturday. Governor of the Kharkiv region Oleh Syniehubov said
missile strikes on the city damaged residential buildings, a gas station, a
kindergarten, a cafe, a shop and cars. Overall, Russia fired 32 Iranian-made
Shahed drones and six missiles at Ukraine overnight, according to the air force
commander. Ukrainian air defense forces shot down three cruise missiles and 28
drones, Lt. Gen. Mykola Oleshchuk said in a statement. “Russian killers continue
to terrorize Ukrainians and attack Kharkiv and other peaceful cities,” he said.
The Russian military has not commented on the strikes, but said that Ukraine on
Saturday morning fired Vampire rockets at Russia. All 10 of them were shot down
over Russia’s border region of Belgorod by air defense systems, the Russian
Defense Ministry said.
Battles on the ground
On the ground in Ukraine, Russian forces were advancing, and pushing back
against them was “difficult,” said Oleksandr Syrskyi, commander of Ukraine’s
armed forces. Syrksyi said the situation in the Bakhmut area in the partially
occupied eastern Donetsk region was particularly challenging. He said Russian
forces are carrying out offensive operations day and night, using assault groups
with the support of armored vehicles, as well as assaults on foot. Fierce
battles are taking place east of the town of Chasiv Yar, which Ukraine still
controls, and which is located near the occupied city of Bakhmut. Russian forces
are trying to break through defensive lines there, Syrskyi said on the messaging
app Telegram, adding that “Chasiv Yar remains under our control, all enemy
attempts to break through to the settlement have failed.” Near Avdiivka, another
city in the Donetsk region held by the Russians, the fiercest battles were
occurring in Pervomaiskyi and Vodyanyi, according to the official. He also said
the situation is tense on the southern and northeastern parts of the front line.
Kuwait’s prime minister submits Cabinet resignation to
Kuwaiti Emir - KUNA
ARAB NEWS/April 06, 2024
DUBAI: The prime minister of Kuwait has submitted the Cabinet’s resignation to
Kuwait Emir Sheikh Meshal al-Ahmad al-Sabah, state news agency KUNA said
Saturday.
Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources
published
on April 06-07/2024
Is Israel deterring Iran — or provoking it?
Yossi Mekelberg/Arab News/April 06, 2024
As such, it is no surprise when Israel carries out airstrikes,
either in Lebanon or Syria, and even beyond, since it has been engaging in such
operations for years in what the Israeli military calls the “campaign between
wars,” aimed at containing what it sees as Iran’s aspirations to regional
hegemony.
In most cases, these airstrikes, or other clandestine operations, directly
target Iran or its proxies across the Middle East, mainly the Lebanese
Hezbollah. This campaign has now been conducted for over a decade, but the
assassination on Monday of Brig. Gen. Mohammed Reza Zahedi, commander of the
Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps’ Quds Force in Syria and Lebanon, and the
rather safe assumption that Israel is behind it, was a step-up in what is
already a volatile and fragile regional instability, much of it caused by the
war in Gaza.
Tehran’s immediate response of vowing retaliation at a time, place, and scope of
its choosing was not surprising, but it brings Israel and Iran closer to direct
confrontation, potentially embroiling the wider Middle East to an even greater
degree.
The concept of the “campaign between wars” is one of low-intensity, integrated,
and pre-emptive warfare aimed at keeping Iran and its proxies guessing and
unsettled, and permanently on the defensive. Yet, over the past six months the
circumstances have changed radically and, consequently, there is a real danger
of war by miscalculation, as every move by any of the actors involved is
perceived as part of a grand plan for eliminating the other side. It makes an
unintentional escalation, and even a full-blown confrontation a real
possibility, one that could drag the entire region into war and chaos.
Both its main target, Zahedi, and the location of the attack, Iran’s consulate
in Damascus, make this attack different from past incidents in its implications.
It suggests that at this point Israel is putting a premium on deterring Iran and
its Lebanese proxy Hezbollah, and is prepared to take the risk of edging closer
to escalating its current hostilities with Hezbollah along its border with
Lebanon and to a possible direct confrontation with Iran.
On the other hand, Israel might be deliberately provoking Tehran in the hope
that Hezbollah will retaliate and thereby give it a pretext to launch a massive
attack on the militia group, a scenario favored by quite a few of Israel’s
political leaders and military commanders, who see the militant organization as
a much greater existential threat to Israel than Hamas in Gaza. And judging by
how Israel is conducting its war in Gaza, one can only imagine how intense and
lethal a war in Lebanon would be. Washington is seeking to distance itself from
this Israeli military operation.
Israel’s attack on an Iranian diplomatic building in Damascus is legally a
direct strike on Iran’s sovereignty. Moreover, considering that Zahedi was the
highest-ranking Iranian military commander to be killed since Qassem Soleimani,
who led Iran’s IRGC operations in two of the most crucial countries for Iran in
the region, died in a 2020 US drone strike, the fear of the situation getting
out of hand is genuine.
In response to the attack, Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has
promised revenge and declared that “the evil Zionist regime will be punished at
the hands of our brave men. We will make them regret this crime and the other
ones.” For Iran the loss of Zahedi must be disruptive of its operations in
Lebanon and Syria, but equally also of its sense of pride. Whether Tehran is
capable of once more swallowing its pride and thus avoiding a possible direct
confrontation with Israel and then with the US as a result, remains to be seen,
but there are growing voices within the regime calling for immediate and
forceful retaliation. It has also become apparent that Washington is seeking to
distance itself from this Israeli military operation. According to the US-based
news website Axios, it has told Iran that “it had no involvement or advanced
knowledge of an Israeli strike on a diplomatic compound in Syria.” This is
clearly a US attempt to prevent the incident from escalating, by almost
suggesting that at least in this case Israel has gone rogue. Israel, by not
sharing its intentions before embarking on such a sensitive operation — one with
much wider implications for the US, too — is helping Washington by not
implicating the US.
On the other hand, its action can only further anger a Biden administration that
appears to be losing its ability to influence Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
By testing Tehran’s patience, but not coordinating such a significant operation
with the Americans, Israel tests theirs, too, especially as relations between
the two allies are more strained than ever as a result of the war in Gaza, and
Israel’s ignoring calls for a truce, and preventing further humanitarian aid
from reaching Gaza.
What is most baffling about the attack in Damascus is to decipher what Israel is
trying to achieve by blatantly exacerbating another front when it is already
deep in the quagmire of the war in Gaza and has lost most of the international
support it enjoyed only six months ago. Israel is increasingly falling into a
pattern of open-ended conflicts with no clear endgame, which rather than serving
its interests, or those of any of its allies, is only helping to unnecessarily
prolong its wars, which gives Netanyahu an excuse, albeit a flimsy one, to
remain in power.
Iran’s hegemonic aspirations are a source of instability in the region and are
hardly in question. Its support of Hamas and Hezbollah poses a threat to Israel,
to which the latter must respond. However, Israel has no means to militarily
eliminate this threat altogether, and as the war in Gaza has proven, even a
lesser military force such as Hamas cannot be eradicated. Military deterrence is
an important element of dealing with the Iranian threat, but more importantly
Israel needs astute political and diplomatic cooperation and coordination with
its regional and international allies who are equally concerned about Iran’s
adventurism, without provoking or humiliating Tehran. To humiliate Iran rather
than defeat it might give Israel some short-lived satisfaction, but it might
also open another front, and this time while the international community is less
sympathetic. And as past experience has made clear, whenever one senior Iranian
figure is assassinated, a replacement is quickly found, while the root causes of
the conflict remain and are further aggravated.
**Yossi Mekelberg is a professor of international relations and an associate
fellow of the Middle East and North Africa Program at international affairs
think tank Chatham House. X: @YMekelberg
The Obama and Biden Administrations' Betrayal of America's
Closest Ally in the Middle East: Israel
Dr. Majid Rafizadeh/Gatestone Institute/April 6, 2024
What onlookers see, including terrorists and America's enemies and adversaries –
when they also factor in the open US southern border across which millions of
illegal immigrants have recently poured, including 46,000 Chinese, many of whom
are military-aged men possibly "building an army from within" – is that the
Biden administration is perfectly content to welcome and support terrorists. The
White House actions have bolstered America's adversaries and pretty much
extinguished America's credibility as an ally. The universal "optics" are that
if America will throw its closest ally, Israel, under the bus, what chance has
anyone else got? Many people in Israel call to "Bring the Hostages Home." The
request is wrong, because it is addressed to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu, who has been doing his best to do free the hostages, while preventing
Hamas ever to be able to strike Israel again – and standing up to US pressure,
as he did during the fraudulent Iran nuclear deal. But the hostages are not his
to bring home. The cry should be: "Release the Hostages" -- addressed, as well
as calls for a ceasefire -- to the people who are holding them: Hamas, Qatar and
Iran.
The US administration would clearly like to replace Netanyahu with new
US-handpicked prime minister who would do whatever they tell him to, and appears
to have launched a plan to do just that, using Senate Majority Leader Chuck
Schumer as its mouthpiece. The Israelis must not fall for it. If they want to
preserve Israel, preserve Netanyahu.
The Palestinian state, even if it were officially "demilitarized," would, of
course, be free to enter into military alliances with any countries it wished --
perhaps Russia, China, Iran, North Korea? Israel's new US puppet prime minister
would presumably be happy to have Qatar – a country that has supported virtually
every Islamic terrorist group -- including Hamas, ISIS, Hizballah, the Taliban,
the al Nusra Front and Al Shabaab -- "operate" the Gaza pier now being built to
bring "humanitarian aid" and Heaven knows what else into Gaza. Above all, of
course, the new puppet would presumably agree to Iran being armed to the teeth
with nuclear bombs. The Biden administration would do far better, especially for
November 5, instead of aligning itself with the terrorist groups and the
countries that support them -- such as Hamas, Qatar and Iran -- to align itself
with those in the Free World, fighting for freedom, human rights and
civilization. The White House actions have bolstered America's adversaries and
pretty much extinguished America's credibility as an ally. The universal
"optics" are that if America will throw its closest ally, Israel, under the bus,
what chance has anyone else got?
The Biden administration persists in granting victories to Hamas and its primary
supporters, Qatar and Iran, and in a way that only strengthens their positions
in support of terrorism. On March 25, the Biden administration declined to
exercise its veto power at the United Nations Security Council, effectively
betraying Israel and aligning itself with Hamas. This decision was perceived by
Israel's enemies in Iran, Qatar, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria and Iraq as the United
States finally having abandoned Israel. The American abstention looked as if the
US had adopted Hamas's position at long last -- and during the height of the
conflict! The Biden administration, throughout its term, of course, has also
been providing, mostly in sanctions waivers, "closer $60 billion" to Iran,
topped off by another $10 billion that looked as if it were a reward to Iran and
its proxies for having killed three US service members, after attacking American
troops in the region more than 150 times just since October.
The Iranian regime has undoubtedly has used this windfall not only to strengthen
its own Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), which trained Hamas for its
atrocities on October 7, but also, to further enrich its uranium -- now,
admittedly at 84% purity, close to the 90% purity needed for nuclear
weapons-grade material -- to put the finishing touches on its eagerly
anticipated nuclear bombs. The Biden administration has therefore been funding
both sides of two major wars it effectively ignited. The first war, Russia's
invasion of Ukraine, was enabled by Biden's hobbling US energy production his
first days on the job, causing the price of oil on the world market to triple –
from $40 a barrel at the end of 2020, to $120 a barrel in 2022 -- making Russia
rich enough to launch a Ukraine. The US has also been funding Ukraine – which
must defeat Russia -- but the entire Russian expedition would not have been
possible without this catastrophic US policy. The second war, Iranian-backed
aggression in the Middle East, was enabled by the Biden administration's
sanctions waivers to Iran, which, as the world's leading state sponsor of
terrorism, had been in 2020, comfortably for everyone else, destitute. The Biden
administration's sanctions waivers gifted Iran the use of up to $100 billion, at
least some of which undoubtedly went into training at least 500 Hamas terrorists
to attack Israel.
Former US National Security Advisor John Bolton, mincing no words in his
condemnation of the Biden administration's stance, labeled it "confused" and
"dangerous." He pointed out the dangerous precedent the Biden administration had
set by allowing Hamas to wield a "terrorist veto" over Israel of the right to
defend itself — a move that not only undermines Israel's security but also
seriously weakens global counterterrorism efforts. Senator Bill Hagerty further
denounced the administration's actions as a betrayal of both Israel and the
American citizens still held hostage by Hamas terrorists.
The apparent willingness by the Biden administration to appease the sponsors of
Hamas — Qatar and Iran — at the expense of strategic alliances, underscores a
troubling shift in US foreign policy priorities, one that seems to value winning
votes in Michigan on November 5 over longstanding geostrategic alliances.
The Biden administration's actions at the UN Security Council additionally dealt
a severe blow to efforts aimed at securing the release of hostages held by Hamas.
By separating Hamas's demands from the release of hostages, Resolution 2728
significantly worsened the situation for those held captive -- including six
remaining Americans -- an outcome that Israel rightly saw as a breach of trust.
Former US Ambassador to Israel David Friedman drew parallels between the Biden
administration's actions and the infamous UNSC Resolution 2334 during the Obama
administration — a move that similarly undermined Israel's position on the
international stage and encouraged terrorists worldwide.
By failing to condemn Hamas and failing to condition a ceasefire on the release
of hostages, the Biden administration handed Hamas and other terrorist groups a
monumental diplomatic victory. What onlookers see, including terrorists and
America's enemies and adversaries – when they also factor in the open US
southern border across which millions of illegal immigrants have recently
poured, including 46,000 Chinese, many of whom are military-aged men possibly
"building an army from within" – is that the Biden administration is perfectly
content to welcome and support terrorists.
The White House actions have bolstered America's adversaries and pretty much
extinguished America's credibility as an ally. The universal "optics" are that
if America will throw its closest ally, Israel, under the bus, what chance has
anyone else got?
The Iranian regime last month celebrated what appeared a weakening of Israel's
position, as an opportunity to advance its own agenda in the region. Iran's
Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei held meetings with Hamas and Palestinian
Islamic Jihad leaders, reinforcing Iran's support for their "world war" in Gaza.
The elaborate reception aimed to intimidate adversaries and enhance Iran's image
as a steadfast supporter of Hamas, as if to say, "Want to see what loyalty looks
like? Watch this!"
Hamas leaders expressed gratitude for Iran's backing since the October 7 attack.
Ismail Haniyeh, chair of Hamas's political bureau, thanked Iran for its support,
positioning the country as a champion: "Iran stands at the forefront of
supporting the cause and people of Palestine," said Haniyeh, he extending his
appreciation to Iran's leadership and its people.
Sadly, the Biden administration's Middle East policy appears to have disastrous
from the start, beginning with President Barack Obama's illegitimate and lethal
Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) or "nuclear deal" in 2015, which
permitted Iran to have as many nuclear weapons as it liked presumably, according
to Obama, so long as "Iran will not get a nuclear weapon on my watch."
As the columnist Amir Taheri wrote in 2018:
"To start with the 'deal' isn't legally binding because it was negotiated by the
P5+1, an informal group with no legal existence, no mission statement and
answerable to no one. They produced a press release, titled 'Joint Comprehensive
Plan of Action' (JCPOA) in 176 pages, in three different versions, which was
neither signed by anyone nor approved by any legislative authority in any of the
countries concerned."
The previously year, Taheri wrote:
"A vague text was established, fudging the issue, and declaring victory for both
sides. The participants in the game agreed to keep the text away from their
respective legislatures so as not to risk scrutiny of the witches' brew they had
cooked...
"Legally speaking, the so-called deal doesn't exist and thus cannot be 'torn up'
by anybody...
It was not formally and legally appointed by anybody, had no written mission
statement, implied no legal commitment for members and was answerable to no
one."
To set the record straight, if someone were to brutally attack your family or
community, resulting in the deaths of several members, the rape of others, and
the abduction of hostages, would you decide to empower them to strike again? It
was Hamas that initiated the attack on October 7th, launching a barrage of
rockets at Israel while approximately 3,000 terrorists crossed the Gaza-Israel
barrier and assaulted Israeli military bases and civilian communities. This
onslaught resulted in the murder of approximately 1,200 people in Israel; Jews,
Muslims, Christians; Israelis, tourists and foreign workers. The horrific
atrocities included Hamas's sustained gang rape and torture of men, women and
children, and included babies beheaded and burned alive, and the seizure of 240
hostages who were abducted and taken to Hamas's tunnels in Gaza.
Now Israel finds itself embroiled in a multi-front conflict against Iran and its
proxies, fighting for its very survival.
Israel has the right to self-defense, to once and for all eradicate the threat
of 20 more years of attacks from Hamas terrorists. This defense entails
defeating the four Hamas battalions that remain in the southern Gaza city of
Rafah. There are rumors that Yahya Sinwar, the leader of Hamas in Gaza – not,
like the other Hamas leaders, living as billionaires in 5-star hotels in Qatar
-- has surrounded himself with many of the remaining hostages, being used as
human shields to protect him.
Many people in Israel call to "Bring the Hostages Home." The request is wrong,
because it is addressed to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has
been doing his best to do free the hostages, while preventing Hamas ever to be
able to strike Israel again – and standing up to US pressure, as he did during
the fraudulent Iran nuclear deal. But the hostages are not his to bring home.
The cry should be: "Release the Hostages" -- addressed, as well as calls for a
ceasefire -- to the people who are holding them: Hamas, Qatar and Iran.
The US has failed to put any pressure whatever on Hamas, Qatar or Iran to demand
that the hostages be immediately released. The Biden administrations seems to be
all about protecting Iran and Qatar, who are protecting Hamas. Instead of being
pressured, Iran is being paid billions of dollars – probably as a bribe not to
make trouble before the US presidential election November 5. When several
members of Iran's IRGC were killed in a pinpoint Israeli airstrike in Syria last
week, the Biden administration rushed to tell the Iranians that it wasn't the US
that did it, and please not to attack US assets.
Qatar was invited to operate the Gaza pier; how is that for pressure? The US
administration would clearly like to replace Netanyahu with new US-handpicked
prime minister who would do whatever they tell him to, and appears to have
launched a plan to do just that, using Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer as
its mouthpiece. The Israelis must not fall for it. If they want to preserve
Israel, preserve Netanyahu.
The US seems, for the moment at least to have selected a former defense
minister, Benny Gantz, who was invited on an unauthorized visit to Washington
last month and has now called for "September elections." The new US puppet, in
exchange for the job promotion and its concomitant limelight, would presumably
be happy to do whatever the US orders him to, allowing a terrorist Palestinian
state to be established next door to Israel, ruled by the people who have
already vowed to attack Israel time and again until it is annihilated. The
Palestinian state, even if it were officially "demilitarized," would, of course,
be free to enter into military alliances with any countries it wished -- perhaps
Russia, China, Iran, North Korea?
Israel's new US puppet prime minister would presumably be happy to have Qatar –
a country that has supported virtually every Islamic terrorist group --
including Hamas, ISIS, Hizballah, the Taliban, the al Nusra Front and Al Shabaab
-- "operate" the Gaza pier now being built to bring "humanitarian aid" and
Heaven knows what else into Gaza. Above all, of course, the new puppet would
presumably agree to Iran being armed to the teeth with nuclear bombs.
Netanyahu enjoys support from Israel's public, who realize that he has the brass
to stand up to the US administration, as he has before.
The Biden administration would do far better, especially for November 5, instead
of aligning itself with the terrorist groups and the countries that support them
-- such as Hamas, Qatar and Iran -- to align itself with those in the Free
World, fighting for freedom, human rights and civilization.
*Dr. Majid Rafizadeh is a business strategist and advisor, Harvard-educated
scholar, political scientist, board member of Harvard International Review, and
president of the International American Council on the Middle East. He has
authored several books on Islam and US Foreign Policy. He can be reached at
© 2024 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
Iran and Israel: Is the Denial Game Over?
Amir Taheri/Asharq Al-Awsat/April 06/2024
The body bags contain the mortal remains of 13 Iranian diplomatic and military
officers including two senior commanders of the Islamic Revolutionary Grad Corps
Gen. Muhammad-Reza Zahedi (alias Abu Mahdi) and Gen. Muhammad-Hadi Haj-Rahimi
killed in an Israeli air raid on what was presented as a consular building in
the Syrian capital. To be sure this is not the first time that Israelis take out
IRGC officers and Lebanese, Iraqi, Syrian, Pakistan, and Afghan mercenaries in
Syria. The take-out operation started in 2015 and reached a peak in 2020. The
last time an Islamic Republic official organ provided figures was in 2018 when
The Foundation for Martyrs and Self-Sacrificers put Iran’s losses at around
5,000. The figures didn’t show how many were Iranian officers or mercenaries. In
the first three years of this deadly cycle, Tehran used the transfer of body
bags from Damascus as a propaganda ploy and organized mass rallies on the burial
day of its “heroes of Islam.” Later, when Tehran’s losses grew the propaganda
aspect was forgotten, and “heroes of Islam” were quietly buried in their native
hometowns and villages. Over time, partly thanks to the influence of late Gen.
Qassem Soleimani Tehran decided to swallow the bitter pill and brag about
“taking revenge” but not retaliate. Soleimani would do everything to avoid a
direct clash with either Israel or the US forces in the region. In fact, he may
have established a channel of communication with the Israelis through his
correspondence with Gen. David Petraeus, then the top US commander in the
region. In line with that tacit agreement Israel never officially admitted its
more than 40 attacks spread over six years. Tehran reciprocated by not directly
blaming Israel, using the euphemism “enemies of Islamic Revolution” instead.
Even when Israelis killed Gen. Hussein Hamadani, one of “Supreme Guide”
Ayatollah Khamenei’s favorite commanders, Tehran decided not to implement its
threat of “taking hard revenge.” Similarly, the assassination of six top IRGC
scientists in Iran itself went unpunished. Soleimani’s strategy was to fight
Israel and the US through proxies while dangling the promise of reining them in
as a card in his deadly poker game with the “Great Satan” and the “Zionist
entity.”
Has that fragile balance of terror come to its end?
Vibes from Tehran suggest that it has.
One reason is that there is no personality with Soleimani’s charisma and access
to huge financial resources to continue marketing his idea of “kill the enemy
with a thousand cuts” and the use of mercenaries as human shields. Another
reason is that this time around Israel has bombastically admitted having carried
out a punitive attack against the Islamic Republic. More importantly, perhaps,
this is the first time that Israel has attacked a building flying the Islamic
Republic’s official flag. All previous attacks were on bases and buildings where
Iranian officers and mercenaries were located as “advisers” to the official
Syrian army. Tehran could pretend that those attacks were against the Syrian
Republic which had the responsibility to respond. This time the attack was
against the Iranian consulate and the adjacent residence of the ambassador, both
flying the Islamic Republic flag. In international law and diplomatic norms, an
attack on an embassy or consulate is a casus belli (a cause for war). Another
factor that might force Khamenei to respond differently this time is genuine
anger among his followers, already uneasy about his refusal to back Hamas in the
Gaza war. “How much longer should we wait for the promised hard revenge to
happen?” demands Ibrahim Azizi vice-chair of the National Security Committee in
the Islamic Consultative Assembly (Majlis). Announcing the sending of a special
mission to Damascus to “see what happened” Majlis spokesman Nizameddin Mussawi
says “taking revenge is a national demand that cannot be ignored.”
The official news agency IRNA echoed that sentiment with the headline” The Whole
Nation Demands Revenge”. In an editorial on Tuesday IRNA suggested that
“embassies and consulates of the Zionist enemy in several countries are ready
targets for revenge.” Ominously, it added: “the balance of terror must be
restored”. The official TV’s chief strategic analyst Mahdi Kharratian surprised
viewers by saying “If we do nothing this time, we ought to be prepared for the
assassination of the highest officials in Tehran.”The “enough is enough” message
is echoed in sermons by some of the most radical mullahs. Ayatollah Hashem
Husseini says “As the center of resistance, the Islamic Republic cannot show
weakness especially now that Palestinian resistance is rubbing the Zionist nose
in the dust.”Ayatollah Pour-Khaqani says Israel attacked the Islamic diplomatic
mission in Damascus to hide its humiliation by Palestinians.
IRNA echoes that theme by claiming that “Netanyahu has failed in his three
objectives: Freeing Israeli captives, killing Yahya Sinwar and Muhammad Dhif,
and destroying the Gaza tunnels.” Kamal Sajjadi, spokesman for The Followers of
the Imam Movement suggests that the forthcoming Quds (Jerusalem) Day could be a
proper time for revenge. Newly elected Majlis member Hojat al-Islam Ali-Reza
Panahyan says the Islamic Republic must maintain its military presence in Syria
and this requires assuring the safety of “our Islamic heroes”.
The fact that Ayatollah Khamenei ordered a full session of the High Council of
National Security, the first in more than two years, shows his concern about
dissent in his core constituency and the perception that his “strategic
patience” is a pretense for lack of resolve.
Seen from his angle there is a growing danger that the radical elements in his
camp will see him as an indecisive leader, and blame him for Israeli “audacity.”
Interior Minister Gen. Ahmad Wahidi says “Israel should expect a suitable
answer” but adds that “the decision must come from the Leader of the Revolution”
i.e. Khamenei.Islamic President Ayatollah Dr. Ibrahim Raisi, too, has promised
“crushing revenge” but insists that the decision must come from Khamenei. The
“Supreme Leader” is in a delicate situation. Israel has broken the tacit
agreement that allowed both sides to cite plausible deniability about attacks
against each other. If he does nothing he could anger his core supporters. If he
orders attacks on Israeli and/or Jewish targets he won’t be able to cite
plausible deniability. And that, as the Islamic TV analyst suggests, could give
Israel an excuse for attacks on big targets in Tehran itself.
The Word’s Conscience is in Crisis
Dr. Amal Moussa/Asharq Al-Awsat/April 06/2024
Today, April 5th, is the "International Day of Conscience," which was officially
declared as a global day of awareness in 2019, making it relatively new. The
United Nations General Assembly invited all Member States, organizations of the
United Nations system and other international and regional organizations, as
well as the private sector and civil society, including non-governmental
organizations and individuals, to build a culture of peace with love and
conscience that is in accordance with the culture and other appropriate
circumstances or customs of their local, national and regional communities,
including through quality education and public awareness-raising activities,
thereby fostering sustainable development. In reality, the occasion brings
several themes and subjects to mind. Firstly, the fact that this awareness day
exists suggests that the world is without conscience or that, at the very least,
there is something problematic about its conscience. It could also be inferred
or presumed that, in 2019, global elites became aware that this lack of
conscience is an obstacle to the realization of the United Nations’ Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs).
Indeed, its existence amounts to an explicit public acknowledgment that no goals
can be achieved without an active, honest, and vigilant conscience. The world
cannot eradicate hunger and poverty if its conscience is deep asleep. Quality
education and high standards of living cannot be secured if we do not act in
accordance with our conscience. It is clear to anyone who reads them that the
SDGs support the marginalized of the world and the victims of its new order,
since those who are lagging behind often fail to catch up for material reasons.
In other words, the promise to "Leave No One Behind" cannot be achieved or
advanced if the world has no conscience. Without it, the world will remain as it
is.
This conclusion linking sustainable development, stability, and a culture of
peace, elevates the conscience to a prerequisite. It renders having a global
conscience the foundation of global security. Here, we arrive at the heart of
the matter and the root of the problem. Indeed, the question is: how do we build
a culture of conscience, and how can we convince those who yield power around
the world of the importance of conscious and sustainable development?
Thus, we believe that today’s commemoration of the International Day of
Conscience will put many in an awkward position. It is an occasion that affirms
the weakness of their conscience. All the global actors who have no conscience
will be exposed: How can we claim to have a conscience after over 33,000
martyrs, half of whom are women and children, fell in Gaza? It is good to
commemorate the International Day of Conscience. It is an opportunity to note
and remember that humans have something no other living beings possess, a
conscience.
It is a day in which we can advocate for a more moral world. Those who believe
that this is an idealistic and pursuit discourse are mistaken. Nothing attests
to this more emphatically than terrorism. Do terrorist networks not feed on the
marginalized people of the world who have been pushed out of the economy, that
is, those suffering from poverty and unemployment? This clearly means that
global security, even that of those who have no conscience, is under threat. The
conscience, here, becomes a safeguard. It creates a bulwark against the approach
centered on profit and spoils, developing one that accounts for security,
without which money and property become worthless. One thing we can be certain
of is that bitterness can be seen on the faces of the words’ nations. It is the
result of an accumulation of developments precipitated by the absence of human
conscience. There has always been a struggle between good and evil, between
those who have a conscience and those who do not. What has changed is that those
who advocate acting on it are now without influence or power. That is
terrifying, as it allows for global ruin.
Mass Tech Layoffs? Just Another Day in the Corporate
Blender.
Ashley Goodall/The New York Times/April 06/2024
Silicon Valley, home of so many technological and workplace innovations, is
rolling out another one: the unnecessary layoff.
After shedding over 260,000 jobs last year, the greatest carnage since the
dot-com meltdown more than two decades ago, the major tech companies show little
sign of letting up in 2024 despite being mostly profitable, in some cases
handsomely so. In their words, the tech companies are letting people go to
further the continuing process of aligning their structure to their key
priorities, or “transformation” or becoming “future ready.” Behind these
generalities, however, some tech companies are using what has hitherto been an
extreme measure in order to engineer a short-term bump in market sentiment.
Investors are indeed thrilled. Meta’s shares are up over 170 percent amid its
downsizing talk. And where stock prices go, chief executives will generally
follow, which means it is not likely to be long before the unnecessary layoff
makes its appearance at another publicly traded company near you.
These layoffs are part of a tide of disruption that is continually churning the
work days in corporations everywhere. If you’ve spent any amount of time working
at a company of pretty much any size, you’ll be familiar with what I call the
resulting “life in the blender”: the unrelenting uncertainty and the upheaval
that have become constant features of business life today. A new leader comes
in, promptly begins a reorganization and upends the reporting relationships
you’re familiar with. Or a consultant suggests a new strategy, which takes up
everyone’s time and attention for months until it’s back to business as usual,
only with a new mission statement and slideware. Or, everyone’s favorite: A
merger is announced and leads to all of these and more.
Now, no business prospers by standing still, and there is no improvement without
change. Course corrections, re-orgs and strategic pivots are all necessary from
time to time. Technological changes continue to demand the restructuring of
major industries. But over the last quarter-century or so, the idea of
disruption has also metastasized into a sort of cult, the credo of which holds
that everything is to be disrupted, all the time, and that if you’re not
changing everything, you’re losing.
You can take courses in disruption at the business schools of Stanford, Cornell,
Columbia and Harvard. You can read, on the cover of a leading business magazine,
about how to “Build a Leadership Team for Transformation: Your Organization’s
Future Depends on It.” And if it is the catechism of chaos you’re after, you can
buy the inspirational posters and chant the slogans: Fail fast; disrupt or be
disrupted; move fast and break things. Part of this, of course, is a product of
the hubris of the Silicon Valley technologists. But part, too, is the belief
that the fundamental task of a leader is to instigate change. It is hard to
remember a time when there was any other idea about how to manage a company.
Moreover, because a majority of corporate executives — together with the
consultants and bankers who advise them, the activist investors who spur them on
and the financial analysts who evaluate their efforts — have been raised
according to this change credo, the constant churn becomes a sort of flywheel. A
leader instigates some change, because that’s what a leader does. The advisers
and investors and analysts respond positively, because they’ve been taught that
change is always good. There’s a quick uptick in reputation or stock price or
both, the executives — paid, remember, mostly in stock — feel they have been
appropriately rewarded for maximizing shareholder value, and then everyone moves
on to the next change.
But it’s hardly clear that this is having the desired result. Studies of merger
and acquisition activity have pegged the rate at which they destroy — rather
than increase — shareholder value at something between 60 and 90 percent; a
Stanford business school professor, Jeffrey Pfeffer, has argued that layoffs
seldom result in lower costs, increased productivity or a remedy for the
underlying problems in a business; and few of us who have lived through re-orgs
remember them as the occasion for a sudden blossoming of productivity and
creativity.
Seen through the eyes of the people on the front lines, the reason for this gap
between intent and outcome comes into tighter focus. After all, when the people
around you are being “transitioned out,” or when you find yourself suddenly
working for a new boss who has yet to be convinced of your competence, it’s a
stretch to persuade yourself that all this change and disruption is leading to
much improvement at all.
“It’s exhausting,” one person I spoke to about change at work told me. “It’s
soul-sucking,” said another. One person told me that after the combination of
two departments, his people were like deer in the headlights, unsure of what
they should be working on.
Of the dozens of people I spoke to, every single one had some sort of
change-gone-bad story to share. And these sorts of reactions are about more than
simple frustration or discontent. They are rooted in the psychological response
we humans experience when our sense of stability is shattered and our future
feels uncertain, and indeed the scientific literature has much light to shed on
exactly why life in the blender is so hard on us.
Experimenters have found, for example, that our stress is greatest when
uncertainty, not discomfort, is at its peak — and uncertainty is the calling
card of change at work.
But while the essential response of the human animal to uncertainty and
disruption is hard-wired, the degree of change we introduce into our workplaces
isn’t. It’s often a choice. We’ve reached this point because the business world
seems to have decided that change is an unalloyed good, and so there is no
amount of it that is too much, and no cost of it that is too great.
Were more leaders to be guided by the science of change, or by the stories that
people on the front lines share, they would quickly discover that it is
stability that is the foundation of improvement. Only once we begin to honor
people’s psychological needs at work, by thinking twice before launching into
the next shiny change initiative and by paying more heed to the rituals and
relationships that allow all of us to point our efforts in a useful direction,
can we begin to do justice to the idea that a company must be, first, a platform
for human contribution if it is to be anything else at all.