English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For September 12/2023
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2023/english.september12.23.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
15 ÂÐÇÑ/2023
Bible Quotations For
today
It is easier for a camel to go through the eye
of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God
Holy Gospel of Jesus Christ according to Saint Luke
18/18-30/:”A certain ruler asked him, ‘Good Teacher, what must I do to
inherit eternal life?’Jesus said to him, ‘Why do you call me good? No one is
good but God alone. You know the commandments: “You shall not commit
adultery; You shall not murder; You shall not steal; You shall not bear
false witness; Honour your father and mother.” ’ He replied, ‘I have kept
all these since my youth.’When Jesus heard this, he said to him, ‘There is
still one thing lacking. Sell all that you own and distribute the money to
the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven; then come, follow me.’But
when he heard this, he became sad; for he was very rich. Jesus looked at him
and said, ‘How hard it is for those who have wealth to enter the kingdom of
God! Indeed, it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than
for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God.’Those who heard it
said, ‘Then who can be saved?’He replied, ‘What is impossible for mortals is
possible for God.’Then Peter said, ‘Look, we have left our homes and
followed you.’And he said to them, ‘Truly I tell you, there is no one who
has left house or wife or brothers or parents or children, for the sake of
the kingdom of God, who will not get back very much more in this age, and in
the age to come eternal life.’
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published on September 11-12/2023
Director Youssef El-Khoury
apologizes for his inability to respond to all those who tried or are trying
to call him because his cell phone is still confiscated by the security
forces.
Director Youssef Al-Khoury was released after arbitrary and illegal
detention
Director Youssef Al-Khoury Is illegally Arrested
Israel Sees South Lebanon Airport as Iran-Backed Springboard for Attacks
6 dead, over 60 injured in 5 days of clashes in Ain el-Helweh
Ceasefire agreement reached in Ain Al-Hilweh camp: Will it hold?
UNRWA calls for immediate halt in Ain el-Hilweh clashes, opens shelters for
displaced
Islamist factions in Ain el-Hilweh say they will honor cease-fire
Uncertain mission: French Envoy Le Drian returns to Lebanon
UN rights chief urges int'l probe into Beirut port blast
Lebanon’s exclusion from transport route linking India and Europe
Lack of quorum turns cabinet session on refugees into ministerial meeting
Berri denies suspending his dialogue initiative
LF tells Le Drian it won't attend dialogue before president election
Financial transition: BDL prepares for dollar transactions via the Bloomberg
platform
Undercover in Lebanon: Unraveling the web of forgery gangs and illegal
migration
Titles For The
Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published
on September 11-12/2023
Moroccans with Shovels and Bulldozers
Dig through Rubble but Hope for Survivors Dwindles after Quake
Iran, US on verge of prisoner swap under Qatar-mediated deal
Iran hopes for funds transfer in 'coming days' under US deal
IAEA expresses regret for ‘disregard’ in dealing with Iran nuclear file
Explainer-What has changed in Iran one year since Mahsa Amini protests
erupted?
Russia expands military bases along Finland border
Ukraine collects Russian bodies on 'road of death' in retaken southeast
Moscow and Pyongyang confirm North Korean leader Kim Jong Un will visit
Russia to meet with Putin
Russians opened fire on a Ukrainian flag tied to balloons, revealing their
position for a counterattack, Ukraine says
Russia says ban on Russians bringing cars, some goods into EU is racist
Burhan Visits Eritrea to Discuss Sudan Conflict with the President
Storm and Floods Kill at Least 150 People in Libya
Israeli delegation attends UNESCO gathering in Saudi Arabia
Israel's contentious legal overhaul comes to a head as judges hear cases on
their own fate
Israel Includes Gaza Americans in US Visa-waiver Pilot as Deadline Nears
Protests kick off at Israeli justice minister's home
Yemeni Authorities Try to Contain Clashes Between Ethiopian Immigrants That
Killed 10
Drone attack on open market kills at least 43 in Sudan
Historic Cairo cemetery faces destruction from new highways as Egypt's
government reshapes the city
North Korean train presumably carrying Kim Jong Un departed for Russia
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
analysis & editorials from
miscellaneous sources published
on September 11-12/2023
Analysis of IAEA Iran Verification and Monitoring Report – September
2023/Institute for Science and International Security/September 11/2023
Twenty Years Later, Iran Remains In Non-Compliance With Its Nuclear
Nonproliferation Obligations/Olli Heinonen and Andrea Stricker/
19FortyFive/September 8, 2023
Why did Turkey’s foreign minister go to Iran?/Sinan Ciddi/Washington
Examiner/September 11/ 2023
When 9/11 Was a Day of Victory against Jihad/Raymond Ibrahim/September 11/
2023
Time to Declare a 'People's War' on the CCP: All of China Is One Military
Machine/Gordon G. Chang/Gatestone Institute./September 11, 2023
UNESCO Vote Highlights Continued UN Bias Against Israel....Congress Must
Block Funding, Biden Should Reconsider His Decision to Join/Pete Hoekstra/Gatestone
Institute/September 11, 2023
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on September 11-12/2023
Director Youssef El-Khoury apologizes
for his inability to respond to all those who tried or are trying to call him
because his cell phone is still confiscated by the security forces.
Director Youssef El Khoury Friends/September 11/2023
Director Youssef El Khoury extends his thanks and gratitude to everyone who
stood by him and condemned his illegal and arbitrary detention arrest today. He
genuinely apologizes for his inability to respond to all those who tried or are
trying to contact him because his cell phone is still confiscated by the
security forces.
Director Youssef Al-Khoury was released after arbitrary
and illegal detention
Friends of director Youssef El Khoury/September 11, 2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/122158/122158/
Activist-Director Youssef El Khoury was released late today, after an illegal
detention since 11 am (September 11, 2023) at the Mount Lebanon Information
Center. (Jisr El Basha - Sin El Fil).
The detention was bizarrely justified as being for the sake of gathering
information.!!!
During the detention hours, his lawyer was prohibited from attending the
investigation. Meanwhile, Mr. Al-Khoury was released without the involvement of
the Public Prosecution.
We are shocked by this method of harassment, which apparently aims to deprive
citizens the right of have a legal representation during investigation
procedures.
It is worth mentioning that our friend, Mr., Al-Khoury was released as a result
of widespread condemnation and pressure in both Lebanon and Diaspora all over
the social media- press facilities, and before a scheduled public demonstration
that was going to take place in front of Mount Lebanon Information Center. where
he was detained.
Director Youssef Al-Khoury Is illegally Arrested
Youssef Al Khoury Friends/September 11/2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/122151/122151/
Director Youssef Al-Khoury was summoned to this morning to the Mount Lebanon
Information Center in Jisr El-Basha-Sin El Fil for interrogating about a
matter that is still unknown, under the pretext of preventive security and
information gathering.
The investigation began with him after the expulsion of his legal lawyer because
an investigation report was not been opened. Since more than six consecutive
hours have passed on his arrest without being allowed to contact his lawyer or
members of his family.
His current detention is considered a deprivation of freedom and requires
opposition from all those fighting for freedom of opinion. Therefore, we call on
all friends, comrades in the struggle, and people of free opinion to gather in
front of The Mount Lebanon Information Command Center, located in Jisr El-Basha
- Sin El Fil, starting at six-thirty this evening, to call for the release of
our comrade, director Youssef El-Khoury.
Israel Sees South Lebanon Airport as Iran-Backed
Springboard for Attacks
11 September 2023
Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant accused Iran on Monday of setting up an
airport in southern Lebanon to enable attacks against Israel. Israel is troubled
by arch-foe Iran's nuclear program, missile build-up and support for regional
militias. The most powerful of the latter, Lebanese Hezbollah, fought a war with
Israel in 2006 and tensions across the border are rising anew. In televised
remarks to an international security conference hosted by Reichman University,
Gallant showed aerial images of what he described as an airport built by Iran
with a view to pursuing "terrorist objectives" against Israel.
He did not elaborate on these, but said the site could accommodate mid-sized
aircraft. The location he gave was near the Lebanese village of Birket Jabbour
and city of Jezzin, some 20 km (12.4 miles) north of the Israeli border town of
Metulla. A non-Israeli source with knowledge of the site said it could
accommodate large drones - some of them weaponized - built off of Iranian
blueprints. The source said drones launched from the site could be used for both
internal and external operational activities - but added that the nature and
direction of the runway suggested the former were more likely.
Hezbollah has been investing heavily in drone technology, the source said.
Neither Hezbollah nor Iranian officials offered an immediate response to
Gallant's remarks.
6 dead, over 60 injured in 5 days of clashes in Ain el-Helweh
Agence France Presse/September 11, 2023
At least six people have been killed and dozens wounded in five days of
continuous clashes in the Ain el-Helweh Palestinian refugee camp in southern
Lebanon, first responders said Monday. Violence broke out late Thursday in the
camp, just weeks after similar clashes pitted members of Palestinian President
Mahmoud Abbas' Fatah movement against Islamist militants. The toll has risen to
at least "six dead, one of them killed on Monday, and more than 60 wounded,"
said Imad Hallak from the Palestinian Red Crescent's Lebanon branch. The
casualties include both fighters and civilians, he added.
An AFP correspondent in Sidon reported ongoing clashes with automatic gunfire
and shelling, after fighting had subsided somewhat overnight. Lebanon's official
National News Agency (NNA) said the city's southern entrance was closed to
traffic. The NNA had reported Saturday that three fighters and one civilian had
been killed. Ain el-Helweh is home to more than 54,000 registered refugees and
thousands of Palestinians who joined them in recent years from neighboring
Syria, fleeing the civil war there. The camp, Lebanon's largest, was created for
Palestinians who were driven out or fled during the 1948 war at the time of
Israel's creation. The U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, said Sunday
that "hundreds of families have left the camp" since the clashes began. Some 400
families were sheltering in a mosque, while others were taking refuge with
relatives or in emergency shelters, it added in a report.
The Lebanese Army said Sunday that shells hit two military sites near the camp,
"leaving five soldiers wounded, one of them in critical condition."By
long-standing convention, the army stays out of the Palestinian camps and leaves
the factions to handle security there.
In a statement on X, formerly Twitter, the army warned "the relevant parties
inside the camp" against endangering military sites, adding that it would "take
appropriate measures." Five days of previous clashes that began in late July
left 13 people dead and dozens wounded, in the worst outbreak of violence in the
camp in years. That fighting erupted after the death of an Islamist militant,
followed by an ambush that killed five Fatah members including a military
leader. Lebanon hosts an estimated 250,000 Palestinian refugees, according to
the U.N. agency. Most live in Lebanon's 12 official camps, and face a variety of
legal restrictions including on employment.
Ceasefire agreement reached in Ain Al-Hilweh camp: Will it hold?
LBCI/September 11, 2023
A ceasefire decision has been made in Ain Al-Hilweh camp following a meeting
held between the Acting General Security Chief, General Elias El-Baissari, and
several representatives of Palestinian factions affiliated with the Joint
Palestinian Action Committee, which falls under the umbrella of the Palestinian
Liberation Organization/Factions of the National Alliance and Islamic Forces.
However, the Fatah Movement has expressed readiness to cooperate with this
decision, but what about the 'Muslim Youth' armed group who do not usually
participate in official meetings? Will they also commit to it?
Palestinian sources closely monitoring the meeting have confirmed that a
committee will be formed within the Joint Action Committee, comprising Islamic
forces such as the 'Asbat Al-Ansar faction' and the 'Jihadist Islamic Movement.'
Furthermore, this committee will coordinate the ceasefire mechanisms with the
Muslim Youth group. This will coincide with the initiation of the Joint Action
Committee's plan to surrender wanted people in Muslim Youth and settle the
status of some wanted individuals, which may encourage them to turn themselves
in voluntarily. Furthermore, there will be an appeal to cease armed
demonstrations in the camp and limit them to the areas where Muslim Youth is
present. However, suppose these negotiations do not succeed, which will not
provide Muslim Youth with more than two weeks' notice, according to Palestinian
sources. In that case, a new field phase may begin where they are encircled by
several Palestinian factions. The extended meeting at the General Directorate of
General Security coincided with the return of a member of the Executive
Committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization, Azzam Al-Ahmad, to Lebanon.
Moreover, discussions are ongoing regarding a potential round of talks that may
include meetings with Speaker Nabih Berri and Caretaker Prime Ministry Najib
Mikati. Thus, will all these combined efforts lead to a permanent cessation of
hostilities in the camp?
UNRWA calls for immediate halt in Ain el-Hilweh clashes, opens shelters for
displaced
Naharnet/September 11, 2023
The U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, has opened shelters in schools
and other facilities to accommodate over 750 displaced people as fighting and
heavy destruction of homes and facilities continued across southern Lebanon's
Ain el-Hilweh refugee camp. "UNRWA, with partners, is responding to the urgent
humanitarian needs," said Dorothée Klaus, the director of UNRWA affairs in
Lebanon. "Meanwhile, armed groups continue to take over eight UNRWA schools
which provide education for 5,900 Palestine Refugee children. We continue to
receive horrific reports of extensive damage to the schools and education
material meant for children. UNRWA is currently exploring alternatives to
accommodate children from Ain el-Hilweh camp so they start the school year with
their peers on 2 October and do not miss on their right to education," Klaus
said. She called on all parties and those with influence over them to stop the
violence. "Until then, those fighting should protect civilians, including
children, wherever they are in the camp. They should refrain from attacks on
civilian infrastructure including schools and medical facilities."
Islamist factions in Ain el-Hilweh say they will honor cease-fire
Associated Press/September 11, 2023
Islamist factions in Lebanon's largest Palestinian refugee camp have said they
will abide by a cease-fire after three days of clashes killed at least five
people and left hundreds of families displaced. Fighting between Palestinian
President Mahmoud Abbas' Fatah movement and Islamist groups has rocked southern
Lebanon's Ain el-Hilweh refugee camp since Friday. Fatah and other factions in
the camp had intended to crack down on suspects accused of killing one of their
military generals in late July.
Besides the five killed, 52 others were wounded, Dr. Riad Abu Al-Einen, who
heads the Al-Hamshari Hospital in Sidon that has received the casualties, told
The Associated Press. The U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, however
stated that four people were killed and 60 others wounded.
The Lebanese military said in a statement that five soldiers were wounded after
three shells landed in army checkpoints surrounding the camp. One of the
soldiers is in critical condition. "The army command repeats its warning to the
concerned parties in the camp about the consequences of exposing military
members and positions to danger, and affirms that the army will take appropriate
measures in response," the statement said. Ain el-Hilweh, home to some 55,000
people according to the United Nations, is notorious for its lawlessness and
violence is not uncommon in the camp. It was established in 1948 to house
Palestinians who were displaced when Israel was established. Lebanese officials,
security agencies and the U.N. have urged the warring factions to agree on a
cease-fire. The interim chief of Lebanon's General Security agency Elias al-Baysari
said that he will attend a Monday meeting between Palestinian factions and urge
the factions to reach a resolution. The clashing factions in the camp said in a
statement published Sunday by Lebanon's state-run National News Agency that they
planned to abide by a cease-fire. UNRWA said hundreds of families displaced from
the camp have taken shelter in nearby mosques, schools and the Sidon
municipality building. The U.N. agency and local organizations are setting up
additional shelters after Lebanon's prime minister and interior minister shut
down an initiative by the municipality, the Lebanese Red Cross, and local
community groups to set up a few dozen tents for families.
Palestinian Red Crescent paramedics set up stations at the camp's entrance to
treat the wounded and provided food packages to displaced families.
Among the wounded was Sabine Al-Ahmad, 16, who fled the camp with her family.
She was being treated for shrapnel wounds. "We were running away and a shell
exploded over us," she told the AP. Dorothee Klaus, Director of UNRWA in
Lebanon, said armed groups are still occupying the agency's schools in the camp.
"UNRWA calls on all parties and those with influence over them to stop the
violence," Klaus said in a statement. Several days of street battles in the Ain
el-Hilweh camp between Fatah and members of the extremist Jund al-Sham group
erupted earlier this summer that left 13 people dead and dozens wounded, and
ended after an uneasy truce was put in place on Aug. 3. Those street battles
forced hundreds to flee their homes. However, clashes were widely expected to
resume as the Islamist groups never handed over those accused of killing the
Fatah general to the Lebanese judiciary, as demanded by a committee of
Palestinian factions last month. Lebanon is home to tens of thousands of
Palestinian refugees and their descendants. Many live in the 12 refugee camps
that are scattered around the small Mediterranean country.
Uncertain mission: French Envoy Le Drian returns to Lebanon
LBCI/September 11, 2023
The French envoy, Jean-Yves Le Drian, returns to Lebanon after approximately two
months since his last visit without a clear vision of the direction his
initiative will take. Before heading to Beirut on Monday morning, Le Drian met
with the Adviser at the Royal Court in Riyadh, Nizar al-Alula, and the Saudi
Ambassador to Lebanon, Walid Bukhari, at the Elysée Palace. However, Le Drian
came to listen to the political parties in Lebanon, discuss their concerns, and,
based on this, decide whether to intensify his efforts or declare that his
mission was impossible. In this context, French sources told LBCI that Le Drian
will meet all parties, especially Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati, Speaker
Nabih Berri, the Army Commander, and the heads of parliamentary blocs and
parties. Moreover, some of them will visit him at the Pine Palace. So far, Le
Drian's conversations with the Lebanese parties will be bilateral, and it is
unlikely that he will be able to bring them together for a roundtable dialogue
at the Pine Palace. However, French sources mentioned that there is nothing
fixed about the format of the dialogue, and it is related to the results of his
meetings in Beirut and whether he can create a dialogue dynamic among the
Lebanese parties, which is the primary goal of his mission to Lebanon. So, will
this visit be Le Drian's last to Beirut if he cannot break the presidential
deadlock? Will the French role be replaced by the Qatari role, especially since
Doha is part of the Group of Five working on mediating the presidential file?
UN rights chief urges int'l probe into Beirut port blast
Agence France Presse/September 11, 2023
The U.N. human rights chief decried Monday the lack of accountability for the
2020 Beirut port blast, urging an international probe into the massive explosion
that killed that killed more than 220 people, wounded 7,500 and destroyed
swathes of the city.
"Three years after the Beirut explosion, ... there has been no accountability,"
Volker Turk told the United Nations Human Rights Council, adding "it may
therefore be time to consider an international fact-finding mission to look into
human rights violations related to this tragedy."
Lebanon’s exclusion from transport route linking India and Europe
LBCI/September 11, 2023
Lebanon is out of the deal, a deal in which we could have been a part of, as the
project connects India by sea to the United Arab Emirates and then by land via a
railway to Saudi Arabia. Jordan has chosen the Israeli port of Haifa as its
final stop in the Middle East before continuing its journey to Europe. The
project aims to facilitate the movement of goods between Asia and the Middle
East, extending to Europe, and the transmission of renewable energy and clean
hydrogen through cables and pipelines. Lebanon, however, was excluded. According
to some observers, this exclusion can be attributed to the political and
economic instability that deters investments in the country. Additionally, as
the sponsor and investor in this project, the United States seeks to support its
ally, Israel, in its economic growth. Consequently, Lebanon has lost billions of
dollars across various sectors, such as trade, energy, and the digital economy,
which could have contributed to economic growth and opened the door to numerous
job opportunities. While Lebanon failed to become a bridge between the East and
West in the 21st century, it was a key route for transporting Saudi oil to
Europe in the 1950s through the Trans-Arabian Pipeline (Tapline). This pipeline
transported billions of barrels of crude oil over 1,648 kilometers from Abqaiq
in Saudi Arabia to the Arabian Gulf, passing through Jordan, Syria, and then to
the port of Sidon. From there, it continued to Europe through oil tankers in the
sea. After World War II, the idea of establishing Tapline was developed by Saudi
Aramco and other international companies to pump more oil to European countries
that had become economically dependent on it, especially as maritime oil
transportation was lengthy and expensive at the time. However, with the
emergence of large oil tankers, now the optimal way to transport oil worldwide,
Tapline was utterly shut down and dismantled in 2001. In the end, Lebanon
continues to lose out on its geographic advantages and remains marginalized on
the world map.
Lack of quorum turns cabinet session on refugees into
ministerial meeting
Naharnet/September 11, 2023
Cabinet failed to convene Monday at the Grand serail to discuss the Syrian
refugee crisis amid a new wave of illegal crossings, due to a lack of quorum.
Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati called instead for a consultative
ministerial meeting at his office. Army chief General Joseph Aoun and Acting
General Security chief Brig. Gen. Elias Bayssari attended the meeting to discuss
the crossing points and ways to limit illegal entries. In addition to the Free
Patriotic Movement ministers, Economy Minister Amin Salam, Environment Minister
Nasser Yassin, Agriculture Minister Abbas Hajj Hassan, Tourism Minister Walid
Nassar and Health Minister Firas Abiad did not attend the session. Over the past
months, thousands of Syrian citizens made it to Lebanon through illegal crossing
points seeking a better life, as living conditions are worsening in Syria, where
inflation surged after President Bashar Assad’s decision in August to double
public sector wages and pensions.Mikati warned last week that over a thousand
Syrian refugees each week fleeing to Lebanon "could create harsh imbalances",
after the The Lebanese army said it had prevented 1,200 Syrians from crossing
into Lebanon last week and another 1,100 Syrians the previous week. Lebanon
hosts some 805,000 United Nations-registered Syrian refugees, but officials
estimate the actual number is far higher: between 1.5 million and 2 million.
Cabinet is set to convene in a second session today to discuss the 2024 state
budget.
Berri denies suspending his dialogue initiative
Naharnet/September 11, 2023
Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri has denied reports claiming that he had suspended
his presidential dialogue initiative. “I have not suspended my initiative. To
the contrary, it is ongoing, continuous and in harmony with the French
initiative. The two initiatives complement each other and their essence is the
same: dialogue and consensus for the election of a president,” Berri said in an
interview with al-Liwaa newspaper published Monday. “I’m waiting for the visit
of French envoy Jean-Yves Le Drian and I expect that my initiative will be
merged with Le Drian’s initiative to reach the aspired positive result through
dialogue and consensus,” the Speaker added. Berri had on August 31 called on the
Lebanese parties to engage in seven days of dialogue in parliament prior to
going to open-ended electoral sessions to choose a new president. His initiative
was rejected by most of the opposition MPs and was eventually criticized by Free
Patriotic Movement chief Jebran Bassil.
LF tells Le Drian it won't attend dialogue before president election
Naharnet/September 11, 2023
The Lebanese Forces has informed French envoy Jean-Yves Le Drian that it will
not attend any dialogue conference prior to the election of a new president, LF
lawmaker Ghada Ayoub said. “The Strong Republic bloc’s specifications for the
president and his missions are clear and in line with the Doha meeting’s closing
statement,” Ayoub said in an interview on Radio Free Lebanon. “Parliament should
perform its role and dialogue must take place in the (electoral) sessions,” the
MP added. Le Drian is expected to arrive today, Monday in Beirut to meet with
the Lebanese parties over the presidential file. He will start his meetings on
Tuesday according to media reports.
Financial transition: BDL prepares for dollar transactions via the Bloomberg
platform
LBCI/September 11, 2023
Sources within the Banque du Liban (BDL) have confirmed that the transition to
conducting transactions in dollars through the Bloomberg platform will be
seamless and straightforward. Acting BDL Governor Wassim Mansouri, who has thus
far managed to prevent the dollar's exchange rate from spiraling at this stage,
will maintain control as Bloomberg integration begins. Any reports of exorbitant
dollar prices are dismissed as baseless speculation. The sources revealed that
the BDL has initiated negotiations with Bloomberg, and upon finalizing the
agreement, registration will commence for banks and financial institutions
interested in utilizing this platform. Notably, the BDL will not incur any costs
related to Bloomberg integration. Existing agreements with Bloomberg will remain
in place, allowing banks to fulfill their financial obligations to the agency.
Financial institutions, particularly licensed currency exchange businesses and
those in the top tier will be required to establish dedicated departments
responsible for verifying the sources of funds used in transactions via the
Bloomberg platform. This move is part of the country's ongoing efforts to combat
money laundering. Firms failing to establish these departments will not be
permitted access until the BDL drafts a circular to address this requirement. In
preparation for this transition, a Bloomberg team is set to arrive in Lebanon to
train those interested in working with the platform, instructing them on how to
trade foreign currency rates. The full implementation of the platform is
expected to take over two months.
Undercover in Lebanon: Unraveling the web of forgery gangs and illegal migration
LBCI/September 11, 2023
Lebanon is not only a victim of random displacement but has also become a haven
for forgery gangs facilitating illegal migration, even through legal border
crossings. These gangs exploit people's desire to migrate, mainly Syrians and
Iraqis. They provide mostly forged European passports or fake European visas to
travel to European countries, often France or Germany. Imagine that some
individuals send the genuine documents of someone who had previously obtained a
legitimate European passport through the mail to Lebanon. Then, a relative who
resembles them might attempt to enter Europe using these documents. Believe it
or not, this happens, and the danger lies in the fact that all security features
of the passport are intact, and uncovering these tricks depends on the
professionalism of the security personnel. In the document security lab of the
General Security at Beirut Rafic Hariri International Airport, dozens of seized
documents belong to civilians or individuals wanted locally or internationally
for various crimes and from different nationalities. Among the confiscated items
was a forged stamp of the General Security carried by a Syrian to prove his
legal entry into Lebanon. The list of forgeries is extensive. In 2022, the
General Security at Beirut Rafic Hariri International Airport seized 769 fake
documents, including 304 passports and 151 fake visas, held mainly by Syrian
nationals. At the airport, trained personnel examine documents and analyze
facial features during entry and exit procedures. Outside the airport, proactive
work led the Lebanese General Security to apprehend a Lebanese and another
Syrian in the Bekaa region, coordinating with his brother in Syria. They were
caught with forged documents, including Syrian passports and Palestinian travel
documents with European visas. These offenses deserve strict penalties for those
who manipulate the destinies of entire populations.
Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published on September 11-12/2023
Moroccans with Shovels and Bulldozers
Dig through Rubble but Hope for Survivors Dwindles after Quake
Asharq Al Awsat/11 September 2023
Survivors with shovels worked alongside bulldozers Monday to dig through remote
Moroccan villages flattened by a monstrous earthquake, as hope dwindled of
finding people alive under wood-and-dirt homes that pancaked into rubble and
rescuers overseas waited for Morocco to let them help. More than 2,400 were
killed when the quake struck late Friday — the strongest in the North African
country in more than a century.
A French aid group that specializes in locating people trapped under debris said
it is withdrawing an offer to send a nine-person search-and-rescue team after
waiting without success for a green light from Morocco to deploy. Rescuers
Without Borders' founder, Arnaud Fraisse, told The Associated Press that "our
role is not to find bodies."Because homes in quake-hit areas were often made of
mud bricks with roofs of wood, stone and clay, he said, the hope of finding
survivors at this point is slim. "When all of that collapses, you don’t have
much chance of surviving, because there are no air pockets," Fraisse said — a
contrast to places where buildings are made of concrete or other strong
materials. "People are generally suffocated by the dust." Moroccan officials
have so far accepted government-offered aid from just four countries — Spain,
Qatar, Britain and the United Arab Emirates. Morocco’s Interior Ministry says
officials want to avoid a lack of coordination that "would be
counterproductive." The United Nations estimates that 300,000 people were
affected by Friday night’s magnitude 6.8 quake, made more dangerous by its
relatively shallow depth. Most of the destruction and deaths were in Al Haouz
province in the High Atlas Mountains, where homes folded in on themselves and
steep and winding roads became clogged with rubble. Residents sometimes cleared
away rocks themselves. In the remote impoverished settlement of Tafeghaghte,
villagers estimated that more than half of the 160 inhabitants were killed.
People worked quickly to clear dead bodies, but a foul stench filled the air
Monday from what residents said were dead cattle. Most buildings had
disintegrated. Ibrahim Wahdouch lost two young daughters and two other family
members and likened the village to a warzone.
"There’s not shooting but look around," he said. On Monday, a teen carried a
shovel through the rocks, bulldozers cleaned up debris and survivors steered
away from half-wrecked buildings that threatened to collapse. A day earlier,
people cheered when trucks full of soldiers arrived in the town of Amizmiz, down
the mountain from Tafeghaghte. But they pleaded for more help.
"It’s a catastrophe,’’ said survivor Salah Ancheu. "We don’t know what
the future is. The aid remains insufficient." Army units deployed Monday along a
paved road leading from Amizmiz to remoter mountain villages. State news agency
MAP reported that bulldozers and other equipment are being used to clear routes.
Tourists and residents lined up to give blood. In some villages, people wept as
boys and helmet-clad police carried the dead through streets. Khadija Fairouje’s
face was puffy from crying as she joined relatives and neighbors hauling
possessions down rock-strewn streets. Offers of help poured in from around the
world. But Moroccan authorities frustrated some overseas rescuers who didn't
want to deploy without official approval, which wasn't quickly forthcoming.
Fraisse of Rescuers Without Borders said about 100 teams — with roughly 3,000
rescuers in total — that are registered with the UN could have deployed quickly
to the city of Marrakech that was also hit by the quake. He surmised that
Moroccan authorities may be trying to avoid the logistical chaos seen when a
2004 quake killed more 600 people and aid flights overwhelmed an airport in the
disaster zone. "Logistically, it’s extremely complicated to manage, because the
rescuers then all need to be transported by truck on broken, unusable roads to
the zones," he told the AP. "So I think they didn’t want to experience again
what they encountered during the last big quake."
He said his group lodged its offer of assistance on Saturday afternoon with
Morocco's Embassy in France before deciding Monday that it would no longer be of
help.
"It’s their responsibility. They can do what they want," Fraisse said. "They
didn’t call. So today we think it’s no longer necessary for us to go there,
because we won’t do effective work." A Spanish search-and-rescue team arrived in
Marrakech and headed to the rural Talat N’Yaaqoub, according to Spain’s
Emergency Military Unit. Britain sent a 60-person search team with four dogs,
medical staff, listening devices and concrete-cutting gear.
But the Czech Republic was waiting for permission to send a team of 70
rescuers. And Germany sent home more than 50 rescuers who'd been waiting to fly
out, news agency dpa reported. France, which has many ties to Morocco and said
four of its citizens died in the quake, said Moroccan authorities are evaluating
proposals on a case-by-case basis.
French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna said Morocco is "the master of its
choices, which must be respected." She announced 5 million euros ($5.4 million)
in emergency funds for Moroccan and international non-governmental groups
rushing to help survivors. French towns and cities have offered more than 2
million euros ($2.1 million) in aid, and popular performers are also collecting
donations. Those left homeless — or fearing more aftershocks — have slept
outside in the streets of the ancient city of Marrakech or under makeshift
canopies in devastated Atlas Mountain towns like Moulay Brahim.
"I was asleep when the earthquake struck. I could not escape because the roof
fell on me. I was trapped. I was saved by my neighbors who cleared the rubble
with their bare hands," said Fatna Bechar. "Now, I am living with them in their
house because mine was completely destroyed."The quake had a preliminary
magnitude of 6.8 and hit at 11:11 p.m. Friday, the USGS said. A total of 2,497
people were confirmed dead and at least 2,476 others were injured, the Interior
Ministry reported. Aftershocks have since hit the zone, rattling nerves in areas
where damage has left buildings unstable. Morocco’s deadliest quake was a
magnitude 5.8 temblor in 1960 that struck near the city of Agadir, killing at
least 12,000. It prompted Morocco to change construction rules, but many
buildings, especially rural homes, are not built to withstand such tremors.
Flags were lowered across Morocco, as King Mohammed VI ordered three days of
national mourning starting Sunday. But there was little time for mourning as
survivors tried to salvage anything from damaged homes.
Khadija Fairouje's face was puffy from crying as she joined relatives and
neighbors hauling possessions down rock-strewn streets. She had lost her
daughter and three grandsons aged 4 to 11 when their home collapsed while they
were sleeping less than 48 hours earlier. "Nothing’s left. Everything fell,"
said her sister, Hafida Fairouje.
Iran, US on verge of prisoner swap under Qatar-mediated
deal
Parisa Hafezi and Andrew Mills/September 11, 20236
DUBAI/DOHA, Sept 11 (Reuters) - When $6 billion of unfrozen Iranian funds are
wired to banks in Qatar as early as next week, it will trigger a carefully
choreographed sequence that will see as many as five detained U.S. dual
nationals leave Iran and a similar number of Iranian prisoners held in the U.S.
fly home, according to eight Iranian and other sources familiar with the
negotiations who spoke to Reuters. As a first step, Iran on Aug. 10 released
four U.S. citizens from Tehran’s Evin prison into house arrest, where they
joined a fifth, who was already under house arrest. Later that day U.S.
Secretary of State Antony Blinken called the move the first step of a process
that would lead to their return home. They include businessmen Siamak Namazi,
51, and Emad Sharqi, 59, as well as environmentalist Morad Tahbaz, 67, who also
holds British nationality, the U.S. administration has said. The Tahbaz and
Shargi families did not respond to requests for comment. A lawyer for the Namazi
family declined to comment. The identities of the fourth and fifth Americans,
one of whom according to two sources is a woman, have not been disclosed.
Reuters couldn't establish which Iranian prisoners, in turn, would be swapped by
the U.S.
Iran hopes for funds transfer in 'coming days' under US
deal
Agence France Presse/September 11, 20236
Iran said that it hopes the transfer of frozen funds as part of a deal with the
United States to exchange prisoners would take place within days. Iran said
Monday that it hopes the transfer of frozen funds as part of a deal with the
United States to exchange prisoners would take place within days. "We hope that
this transfer will be completed in the coming days and that Iran will have full
access to its assets," said Iran's foreign ministry spokesman Nasser Kanani. He
said the funds will allow the Islamic republic to "purchase all non-sanctioned
goods" which are not limited to food and medicine.
IAEA expresses regret for ‘disregard’ in dealing with
Iran nuclear file
LBCI/September 11, 2023
The Director-General of the International Atomic Energy Agency expressed his
regret on Monday for what he considered "disregard" of Iran's nuclear
escalation, amid a limited reduction in tension between Tehran and Washington.
Explainer-What has changed in Iran one year since Mahsa
Amini protests erupted?
DUBAI (Reuters)/Parisa Hafezi/September 11, 2023
Iran's rulers have intensified a clampdown on dissent nearly one year since the
death in police custody of Mahsa Amini sparked protests which spiralled into
some of the worst political turmoil since the 1979 Islamic Revolution.
HOW DID THE PROTESTS START?
Protests began soon after the Sept. 16 death of Kurdish Iranian woman Mahsa
Amini, 22, who had been arrested by morality police three days earlier for
allegedly violating Iran's mandatory Islamic dress code. Amini, described as a
shy person who minded her own business and stayed clear of politics, was
detained as she stepped out of a train station in Tehran. News of her death
circulated on social media. Protests erupted at her funeral in her hometown
Saqez and then spread across the country with demonstrators chanting "Woman,
life, freedom" in a furious challenge to Iran's clerical rulers. While Amini's
family said she had been killed by blows to her head and limbs, the authorities
said she had died due to existing medical problems, further fuelling anger over
her death.
WHAT DID PROTESTERS WANT?
With women and young people often at the forefront, protesters targeted symbols
of the Islamic Republic, burning pictures of Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali
Khamenei and chanting "Death to the Dictator". Women, including schoolgirls,
took off and burned headscarves, revolting against laws obliging women to cover
their hair and wear loose-fitting clothes. The protests were particularly
intense in areas home to ethnic minorities that have long faced discrimination
by the state, including Kurds in the northwest and Baluchis in the southeast.
Meanwhile, a growing number of women were disregarding the dress code. After a
chess player and a climber competed without wearing headscarves other prominent
women defied the authorities by violating the hijab law and voicing support for
the protests. Authorities have imposed travel bans and jail terms on several
public figures from athletes to actresses.
QUELLING THE PROTESTS
Security forces restricted access to messaging apps and fiercely confronted the
leaderless protesters using tear gas, clubs and, in some cases, live ammunition
even as the protests rumbled on into the new year. A paramilitary volunteer
militia, the Basij, played a prominent part in the crackdown. Rights groups said
over 500 people - including 71 minors - were killed, hundreds wounded and
thousands arrested. Iran carried out seven executions linked to the unrest.
Authorities have not given any official estimated death toll, but said dozens of
the security forces were killed in the "riots".
DID ANYTHING CHANGE?
Buttressed by the Revolutionary Guards, the ruling elite appears to remain
deeply entrenched in power despite its initial difficulties in subduing the
protests.
Morality police largely vanished from the streets after Amini died in their
custody. But as the protests fizzled they returned to streets and surveillance
cameras were installed to identify and penalise unveiled women. Authorities
described the veil as "one of the principles of the Islamic Republic" and
ordered both private and public sectors to deny services to any women who had
discarded it, temporarily closing thousands of non-compliant businesses. But
with many Iranians saying the number of unveiled women continues to grow, the
parliament is considering longer prison terms for anyone who flouts the dress
code and harsher penalties for celebrities and businesses that violate the
rules. Outside Iran, Western countries imposed new sanctions on security forces
and on dozens of Iranian officials over the protests, further straining already
difficult ties.
HOW WILL IRAN'S LEADERS SHORE UP THEIR POSITION?
Recent actions by security forces suggest Iran's rulers intend to brook no
flicker of dissent as the anniversary of Amini's death approaches. Activists
have accused authorities of a campaign to intimidate and instil fear, arresting,
summoning for questioning, threatening or firing people connected to the
protests. Journalists, lawyers, activists, students, academics, artists, public
figures and family members of killed protesters, especially among ethnic
minorities, have been targeted in recent weeks. Iranian officials have blamed
the unrest on foreign foes, notably the U.S. and Israel, raising the stakes for
anybody facing arrest.
However, in cracking down they risk widening a rift between the clerical
leadership and ordinary Iranians increasingly dismayed by an economy hammered by
sanctions and mismanagement, a potential source of future unrest.
Russia expands military bases along Finland
border
Joe Barnes/The Telegraph/September 11, 2023
Russia has started expanding military bases along its border with Finland,
according to new satellite imagery, as it seeks to reinforce supply lines of
tanks and heavy artillery for its war in Ukraine. Three large buildings have
been constructed at the Alakurtti military base, around 31 miles from the
frontier, in the first signs of development at the site for years. Satellite
images, published by Finland’s national broadcaster, appeared to show the
construction of another military storage site at a tank and artillery depot in
Petrozavodsk, some 108 miles from the border. The developments come after Moscow
earlier this year threatened “countermeasures” against Nato when Finland became
the Western alliance’s 31st member country. Finland’s membership nearly doubled
Nato’s border with Russia, adding 833 miles of frontier, close to where Russian
military bases house the largest concentration of nuclear weapons in the world.
The satellite images appear to show three new storage warehouses at the base in
Alakurtti, which is normally home to Russia’s 80th Separate Arctic Motor Rifle
Brigade. Each of the buildings were erected from foundation to full height
within a single day, according to a comparison of images taken late last year
and just last month. Major Marko Eklund, a retired Finnish military operative,
said the halls, which are about 100 metres long and 25 metres wide, could be
used to house up to 40 armoured vehicles, to support a battalion. Russia has
stationed about 2,000 troops at the Alakurtti base, but the majority of its
forces in the area have been deployed to fight in Ukraine.
Significant losses
The forces, which are trained to fight in cold, dark Arctic conditions, are
believed to have suffered heavy losses during the invasion. In June, it was
reported that Ukrainian troops struck a command post manned by the brigade near
the front lines. It’s not known whether Russia will increase the number of
troops stationed in the region, but Nato officials believe it could take Moscow
years to create a force capable of a cross-border offensive. Separate images
revealed the construction of a new large warehouse amid the artillery cannons
and tanks stored at Petrozavodsk, the site of Russia’s largest concentration of
military hardware near the Finnish border. The kit stored at the site is enough
to equip at least one motorised brigade of 4,000 Russian soldiers. Maj Eklund
told Yle that the new building could store 50 armoured vehicles, but is most
likely going to be used to refurbish and deliver equipment to Moscow’s forces in
Ukraine. Most of the kit there has been gathering dust, having sat at the base
since units were disbanded in the 1990s after the collapse of the Soviet Union.
However, Russian losses have been so significant in Ukraine that its military
has been forced to turn to deep storage units, like Petrozavodsk, to re-equip
its forces. Satellite images taken in July showed 2S3 Akatsiya self-propelled
howitzers, which were first manufactured in 1967, being loaded onto trains.
Artillery units stationed at Petrozavodsk have steadily declined, according to
Maj Eklund, who said more than 100 howitzers had been sent to the front lines in
Ukraine since the beginning of the war. Broaden your horizons with award-winning
British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month, then enjoy 1 year for
just $9 with our US-exclusive offer.
Ukraine collects Russian bodies on 'road of death' in
retaken southeast
BLAHODATNE, Ukraine (Reuters)/Anna Voitenko/September 11, 2023
Wearing face masks, the Ukrainian soldiers poked sticks into the undergrowth
along a deserted country road, searching for the bodies of Russian soldiers they
hoped to exchange for their own comrades, living and dead.
They called it the "road of death" after the number of Russian soldiers killed
there when Ukrainian forces retook the southeastern village of Blahodatne at the
start of their counteroffensive in June. Three months on, the frontline had
shifted south and it was finally safe enough for the three-man team of Ukrainian
soldiers to start their operation in this liberated part of Donetsk region.
"We're going to search," said Volodymyr, a 50-year-old marine, as artillery fire
boomed in the distance. "Search with our eyes. And using smell."
The route was dotted with gutted vehicles and shattered buildings. At one point,
they used a rope to tug a body to make sure it had not been booby-trapped by
retreating Russian forces. "Here's what we do. We gather up their bodies. We
arrange exchanges for our prisoners who are alive. And for bodies. Our boys,"
Vasylii, a 53-year-old volunteer, said. "You know, so that a mother can go and
visit the cemetery."Russia and Ukraine have conducted regular exchanges of
prisoners of war, as well as the bodies of dead soldiers, since the Kremlin
launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022. The group recovered nine
bodies in their day-long search on Friday. Each was loaded onto the back of a
truck and taken for forensic examination. Volodymyr said Russian forces had been
forced to retreat rapidly from Blahodatne and that the only other route out had
been unusable because it was heavily mined. "There was probably an exchange of
fire. But they retreated very quickly," he said. "They left the wounded and
killed on the way and escaped to Urozhaine. But they didn't stay in Urozhaine
for long either. There was intense fighting for Urozhaine," he said, referring
to a nearby village that was later retaken.
Moscow and Pyongyang confirm North Korean leader Kim Jong
Un will visit Russia to meet with Putin
SEOUL, South Korea (AP)/September 11, 2023
Russia and North Korea confirmed Monday that North Korean leader Kim Jong Un
will visit Russia in a highly anticipated meeting with President Vladimir Putin
that has sparked Western concerns about a potential arms deal for Moscow’s war
in Ukraine.
A brief statement on the Kremlin’s website said Kim’s visit is at Putin's
invitation and would take place “in the coming days.” The visit also was
reported by North Korea’s official Korean Central News Agency, which said the
leaders would meet — without specifying when and where. Associated Press
journalists near the North Korea-Russia frontier saw a green train with yellow
trim — similar to the train used by Kim during previous foreign trips — at a
station on the North Korean side of a border river.
It was unclear whether Kim was on the train, which was seen moving back and
forth between the station and the approach to the bridge that connects the
countries. It had not crossed the bridge as of 7 p.m. (1000 GMT). Citing
unidentified South Korean government sources, the Chosun Ilbo newspaper reported
that the train likely left the North Korean capital of Pyongyang on Sunday
evening and that a Kim-Putin meeting is possible as early as Tuesday. The Yonhap
news agency and some other media published similar reports. Japan’s Kyodo news
agency cited Russian officials as saying Kim was possibly heading for Russia in
his personal train. South Korea’s Presidential Office, Defense Ministry and
National Intelligence Service didn’t immediately confirm those details. U.S.
officials released intelligence last week that North Korea and Russia were
arranging a meeting between their leaders that would take place within this
month as they expand their cooperation in the face of deepening confrontations
with the United States. A possible venue for the meeting is the eastern Russian
city of Vladivostok, where Putin arrived Monday to attend an international forum
that runs through Wednesday, according to Russia’s TASS news agency. The city
was also the site of Putin’s first meeting with Kim in 2019. According to U.S.
officials, Putin could focus on securing more supplies of North Korean artillery
and other ammunition to refill declining reserves as he seeks to defuse a
Ukrainian counteroffensive and show that he’s capable of grinding out a long war
of attrition. That could potentially put more pressure on the United States and
its partners to pursue negotiations as concerns over a protracted conflict grow
despite their huge shipments of advanced weaponry to Ukraine in the past 17
months.
North Korea has possibly tens of millions of artillery shells and rockets based
on Soviet designs that could potentially give a huge boost to the Russian army,
analysts say.
In exchange, Kim could seek badly needed energy and food aid and advanced
weapons technologies, including those related to intercontinental ballistic
missiles, nuclear-capable ballistic missile submarines and military
reconnaissance satellites, analysts say.
There are concerns that potential Russian technology transfers would increase
the threat posed by Kim’s growing arsenal of nuclear weapons and missiles that
are designed to target the U.S., South Korea, and Japan. After a complicated,
hot-and-cold relationship for decades, Russia and North Korea have been drawing
closer since Moscow’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. The bond has been
driven by Putin’s need for war help and Kim’s efforts to boost the visibility of
his partnerships with traditional allies Moscow and Beijing as he tries to break
out of diplomatic isolation and have North Korea be part of a united front
against Washington. While using the distraction caused by the Ukraine conflict
to ramp up its weapons development, North Korea has repeatedly blamed Washington
for the crisis in Ukraine, claiming the West’s “hegemonic policy” justified a
Russian offensive in Ukraine to protect itself.
North Korea is the only nation besides Russia and Syria to recognize the
independence of two Russian-backed separatist regions in eastern Ukraine —
Donetsk and Luhansk -– and it has also hinted at an interest in sending
construction workers to those areas to help with rebuilding efforts. Russia -–
along with China -– have blocked U.S.-led efforts at the U.N. Security Council
to strengthen sanctions on North Korea over its intensifying missile tests while
accusing Washington of worsening tensions with Pyongyang by expanding military
exercises with South Korea and Japan. The United States has been accusing North
Korea since last year of providing Russia with arms, including artillery shells
sold to the Russian mercenary group Wagner. Both Russian and North Korean
officials denied such claims. But speculation about the countries’ military
cooperation grew after Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu made a rare visit
to North Korea in July, when Kim invited him to an arms exhibition and a massive
military parade in the capital where he showcased ICBMs designed to target the
U.S. mainland.
Following that visit, Kim toured North Korea’s weapons factories, including a
facility producing artillery systems where he urged workers to speed up the
development and large-scale production of new kinds of ammunition. Experts say
Kim’s visits to the factories likely had a dual goal of encouraging the
modernization of North Korean weaponry and examining artillery and other
supplies that could possibly be exported to Russia.
Jon Finer, U.S. President Joe Biden’s chief deputy national security adviser,
told reporters Sunday that buying weapons from North Korea “may be the best and
may be the only option” open to Moscow as it tries to keep its war effort going.
“We have serious concerns about the prospect of North Korea potentially selling
weapons, additional weapons, to the Russian military. It is interesting to
reflect for a minute on what it says that when Russia goes around the world
looking for partners that can help it, it lands on North Korea,” Finer said
aboard a plane carrying Biden from India to Vietnam.
Some analysts say a potential meeting between Kim and Putin would be more about
symbolic gains than substantial military cooperation. Russia, which has always
closely guarded its most important weapons technologies, even from key allies
such as China, could be unwilling to make major technology transfers with North
Korea for what is likely to be limited war supplies transported over a small
rail link between the countries, they say.
Russians opened fire on a Ukrainian flag tied to balloons,
revealing their position for a counterattack, Ukraine says
Sophia Ankel/Business Insider/September 11, 2023
A Ukrainian flag attached to helium balloons flew into occupied territory,
Kyiv's military said. Russian soldiers tried to shoot it down but revealed their
firing positions, an official said. Ukraine was able to use this information to
launch an attack on the soldiers, the official added. Russian soldiers
accidentally revealed their positions after they tried to shoot down a Ukrainian
flag suspended from balloons flying over occupied territory, a Ukrainian
official said. The large flag, attached to dozens of helium balloons, was
released from the Ukrainian-controlled town of Avdiyivka on Sunday by the
military. The launch was to commemorate the 245th anniversary of the city's
founding, according to Vitalii Barabash, the head of the Avdiivka city military
administration. It eventually flew over Russian-occupied Donetsk City in eastern
Ukraine, where Russian soldiers attempted to shoot it down, Barabash told
national television, The Kyiv Independent reported. "When the Ukrainian flag
flew from Avdiyivka to Donetsk, the Russians tried to shoot it down with all the
means at their disposal and revealed all their firing positions," he said,
according to a translation by the Ukrainian NGO Euromaidan Press. Barabash said
that Ukraine's 110th brigade then "worked effectively to attack the Russian
soldiers." He didn't give specifics of the attack or how successful it was.
Ukraine's defense ministry did not immediately respond to Insider's request for
comment. "To be honest, it was probably the most successful flag launch [from
Avdiyivka to Donetsk ] ever," Barabash added. "For several hours, the Ukrainian
flag was flying over occupied Donetsk. I had a lot of messages from people
living in the occupied territory, who told me they are waiting for the
liberation of Donetsk." Footage of the flag flying over various parts of the
Russian-occupied city was published by the Telegram channel Typical Donetsk.
Donetsk City has been occupied by Russia since 2014 when fighting in eastern
Ukraine began. Barabash's comments come amid elections in other Moscow-occupied
territories, including Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson, and Zaporizhzhia. The Kremlin
is expected to claim a heavy victory in the elections, which have been dismissed
as "fake elections" and a "sham" by Kyiv and the West, The Guardian reported.
Russia says ban on Russians bringing cars, some goods into EU is racist
MOSCOW (Reuters)/September 11, 2023
Russia said on Monday a European Union ban on Russians bringing their cars and
some personal goods into the bloc was racist, and one ally of President Vladimir
Putin suggested that all diplomatic relations should be severed in response. In
an explanatory note to its rules on sanctions imposed over the Ukraine war, the
European Commission said Russians were temporarily barred from bringing some
personal goods or vehicles into the 27-nation EU. The annex referred to in the
advice also appears to ban the import of a host of items which could be dual use
alongside more mundane items such as make-up, toothpaste, deodorants, toilet
paper and mobile phones. "It's just racism," Russian foreign ministry
spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, said of the Commission's advice. "This is racism
pure and simple."Former Russian president Dmitry Medvedev said the EU had just
spat in the face of all Russians, saying they were being treated as
"half-animals with bad heredity". "What should we do? Certainly not introduce
retaliatory restrictions for EU citizens, we are not racists," Medvedev said.
"It would be better to simply suspend diplomatic relations with the EU for a
while."
SANCTIONS
The West imposed stringent sanctions on Russia after Putin ordered troops into
Ukraine in a full-scale invasion in 2022. Moscow says the sanctions and the
confiscation of Russian property amount to a declaration of economic war. The
Kremlin has vowed that Russia, whose economy is forecast to grow this year, will
never bow to the West over Ukraine. In a question and answer sheet, the European
Commission asked: "Can Russian nationals temporarily bring personal goods and
vehicles listed in Annex XXI and subject to the prohibition in Art. 3i of
Council Regulation 833/2014 into the Union, e.g. for touristic travels?""No.
Article 3i of Council Regulation 833/2014 prohibits the purchase, import, or
transfer, directly or indirectly, of goods as listed in Annex XXI to the
Regulation if they originate in Russia or are exported from Russia. This
includes motor vehicles (cars) falling under CN code 8703."Asked about the
implementation of the rules, a Commission spokesperson said clothes worn by
someone crossing a border were unlikely to be aimed at circumventing sanctions.
"That is a different situation to an expensive car," the spokesperson said. Some
Russians say the West has at times played into the hands of the Kremlin by
appearing to cast all Russian citizens as enemies who should be punished and
ostracised for a war over which they have no say. The Kremlin says Russians are
being illegally discriminated against in the West amid a wave of Russophobia.
Burhan Visits Eritrea to Discuss Sudan Conflict with the
President
Asharq Al Awsat/15:47-11 September 2023
Sudan’s military chief traveled to Eritrea on Monday for a meeting with
President Isaias Afwerki, the general's latest international trip since fighting
broke out between his army and a rival paramilitary force in mid-April, state
media said. Gen. Abdel Fattah Burhan has been looking for international support
since tensions with the paramilitary Rapid Support Forces, commanded by Gen.
Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo, burst into open fighting that has reduced Sudan’s
capital, Khartoum, and its neighboring cities of Omdurman and Bahri, to urban
battlefields. According to Sudan's state-run SUNA news agency, Monday's talks
between Burhan and Isaias will focus on bilateral relations and the conflict in
Sudan. No further details were given. For year, relations between Eritrea and
Sudan have been fraught. Sudan is host to some 126,000 Eritrean refugees,
according to figures published by the UN refugee agency. The visit is Burhan's
fourth high profile diplomatic meeting in the past two weeks. Last week, he met
with Qatari Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani in Doha. The previous week, he
met with Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi in the Egyptian coastal city of
el-Alamein. Fighting raged in Sudan. On Sunday, a drone attack in an open market
in Khartoum killed at least 43 people. The Associated Press has been unbale to
verify which force was behind the attack. In the western Darfur region — the
scene of a genocidal campaign in the early 2000s — the conflict has morphed into
ethnic violence, according to rights groups and the United Nations. The conflict
has killed more than 4,000 people, according to the United Nations. The real
toll is likely much higher, doctors and activists say.
Storm and Floods Kill at Least 150 People in Libya
Asharq Al Awsat/15:47-11 September 2023
A powerful storm and heavy floods have killed 150 people in the eastern Libyan
city of Derna over the last two days and the death toll is expected to rise to
250, the head of the Red Crescent in Benghazi said on Monday. Footage on social
media showed people stranded on the roofs of their vehicles as Storm Daniel hit
Benghazi, Sousse, Al Bayda, Al-Marj and Derna, a city on the Mediterranean some
250 km (150 miles) east of Benghazi. "We recorded at
least 150 deaths after the collapse of buildings. We expect death toll to rise
to 250. The situation is very catastrophic," the Red Crescent's Kais Fhakeri
told Reuters. The toll in other areas was not immediately clear. "We were
asleep, and when we woke up, we found water besieging the house. We are inside
and trying to get out," Derna resident Ahmed Mohamed told Reuters by phone on
Monday. The missing include seven members of the Libyan National Army (LNA), its
spokesman, Ahmad Mismari, said. The LNA is led by Khalifa Haftar which controls
the eastern part of the divided country. Heavy floods
washed away vehicles, footage broadcast by eastern Libya's Almostkbal TV showed.
The channel also posted pictures of a collapsed road between Sousse and Shahat,
home to the Greek-founded and UNESCO-listed archaeological site Cyrene.
Witnesses said the water level had reached three meters (10 feet) in
Derna. Libya's eastern-based parliament declared three days of mourning.
Abdulhamid al-Dbeibah, head of the Government of National Unity in Tripoli, also
declared three days of mourning in all the affected cities, calling them
"disaster areas". Four major oil ports in Libya, Ras Lanuf, Zueitina, Brega and
Es Sidra, were closed from Saturday evening for three days, two oil engineers
told Reuters. Search-and-rescue operations were ongoing, witnesses said.
Authorities declared a state of extreme emergency, closing schools and stores
and imposing a curfew. His administration holds little sway in eastern Libya,
but Dbeibah said on Sunday he had directed all state agencies to “immediately
deal” with the damage and floods in eastern cities. Dbeibah's government is
recognized by the Central Bank of Libya, which disburses funds to government
departments across the country. The United Nations in
Libya said it was following the storm closely and would "provide urgent relief
assistance in support of response efforts at local and national levels".
Israeli delegation attends UNESCO gathering in Saudi
Arabia
RIYADH (Reuters)/September 11, 2023
An Israeli delegation on Monday attended a meeting by the United Nations'
cultural agency in Riyadh, in another sign that Saudi Arabia is opening up to
Israel with Washington pressing for a full normalisation of ties. Three Israeli
officials were seen sitting at Israel's chairs of the 45th session of UNESCO's
World Heritage Committee, a Reuters witness said. The officials declined to
comment when approached by Reuters. Another Israeli official said the delegation
included the Foreign Ministry's deputy director-general for international
organisations and the ambassador to international organisations in Paris. A
delegate from Israel's Education Ministry and the chair of Israel's Antiquities
Authority also took part in the gathering, the official said. The Saudi
government did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Israel's
Foreign Ministry spokesperson and UNESCO declined to comment. Public appearances
of Israeli officials are rare in Saudi Arabia, a Muslim powerhouse and home to
Islam's holiest shrines, but both sides have had covert contacts which were
forged partly through shared fears of Iran. Washington has been pressing its
traditional ally Riyadh to sign a normalisation deal with Israel, which would be
its biggest diplomatic win in the region and following similar agreements with
United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Morocco, known as the Abraham Accords.
However, Riyadh has so far resisted U.S. pressure and linked the move to the
creation of a Palestinian state as part of a two-state solution to the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict, along with other demands.
Israel's contentious legal overhaul comes to a head as judges hear cases on
their own fate
JERUSALEM (AP)/September 11, 2023
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's judicial overhaul plan has plunged
the country into nine months of unrest and exposed bitter divisions within
Israeli society. On Tuesday, the country’s gaze shifts from the streets to the
courtroom, where a panel of Supreme Court judges will deliberate over the very
laws meant to curtail their power. Israel’s High Court is to hear the first of
three flashpoint cases in the coming weeks, all dealing with the legality of the
overhaul. Netanyahu unveiled the plan early this year, saying the country's
unelected judges hold too much power over parliament. He is backed by an
alliance of ultranationalist and religious parties, each motivated by different
grievances against the legal system. Opponents say the plan will push the
country toward authoritarian rule by concentrating power in the hands of
Netanyahu and his parliamentary allies. The court's rulings could set the stage
for a constitutional crisis, casting doubt on who holds ultimate legal authority
in the country — parliament or the courts.
HOW DID WE GET HERE?
The plan has triggered mass protests, shaken the economy, sparked mass refusals
by military reservists and drawn concern from the country's top ally, the U.S.
But Netanyahu's government has barreled forward. It passed the first major law
in July, barring the Supreme Court from striking down decisions by parliament it
deems “unreasonable.”Judges have used this legal standard in the past to prevent
government decisions viewed as unsound or corrupt. Earlier this year, the court
blocked the appointment of a politician with past convictions of bribery and tax
offenses as finance minister. Netanyahu's allies say parliament should have the
final say over appointments. A second case will look at a law passed early this
year that makes it harder for the country's attorney general to declare a prime
minister unfit and remove him from office. The new law allows this only in cases
of mental or physical incapacitation. Critics say the law was passed to protect
Netanyahu while he is on trial for corruption charges. The third case involves
Justice Minister Yariv Levin's refusal to convene the committee that chooses the
country's judges. Critics accuse Levin, a key architect of the overhaul, of
holding up the committee until he can appoint judges sympathetic to the
overhaul.
WHY DO THESE CASES MATTER?
Tuesday's case is a contest between fundamentally different interpretations of
democracy.
Netanyahu and his coalition say that as the people’s elected representatives,
they have a democratic mandate to govern without being hobbled by the court. “A
court that sets the laws for itself and decides for itself which laws it
operates under is not a court,” Simcha Rothman, another key architect of the
overhaul, told the Army Radio station Monday. Opponents say with Israel's weak
system of checks and balances, the court must retain the power to review and
override some government decisions. They say that if the court loses the
reasonability standard, Netanyahu's government could appoint convicted cronies
to Cabinet posts, roll back rights for women and minorities, and annex the
occupied West Bank. “This government has already expressed a desire to fire
officials like the attorney general and replace them with yes-men that will do
whatever the government wants. And the reasonability bill presumably takes away
our power to challenge that,” said Noa Sattath, executive director of the
Association for Civil Rights in Israel, a group challenging the law. On Sept.
19, the Supreme Court is set to hear arguments challenging the legality of
Levin’s refusal to convene the judicial appointments committee. The final case,
on the attorney general's powers to declare a prime minister incapacitated, is
set for Sept. 28.
WHAT ARE THE POSSIBLE OUTCOMES?
The laws on reasonability and removing the prime minister from office are what
are known as “Basic Laws" — major pieces of legislation that serve as a sort of
informal constitution, which Israel does not have. While parliament can easily
amend Basic Laws with a bare majority, the court itself has never struck down
that type of legislation and doing so would thrust Israel into uncharted
territory. Rulings are likely months way, but much is at stake. If the court
strikes down the new laws, senior officials, including Levin, have hinted they
won't respect the ruling. That would plunge Israel into a constitutional crisis,
where citizens and the country's security forces are left to decide which set of
orders to follow — the parliament’s or the court’s. If, on the other hand, the
court sides with the government, protesters have vowed to amp up civil
disobedience. They say future measures could include strikes, walkouts, and tax
evasion. Given the controversy surrounding the case, it’s possible that the
court will find a way to soften its decision by limiting the implementation of
the law without striking it down. It is also possible that a compromise between
the coalition and the opposition will be reached, said Amichai Cohen, a
constitutional law professor at Ono College and a senior fellow at the Israel
Democracy Institute.
“The court has never before faced such an extreme threat,” he said.
Israel Includes Gaza Americans in US Visa-waiver Pilot as
Deadline Nears
Asharq Al Awsat/11 September 2023
Israel eased travel for Palestinian Americans from the Gaza Strip on Monday as
part of final preparations for a deal enabling Israelis to enter the United
States without visas, an Israeli official said. As a condition for its accession
to the US Visa Waiver Program (VWP), Israel has since July 20 loosened access
through its borders, and in and out of the occupied West Bank, for Palestinian
Americans in what the allies deem a pilot period, Reuters said. The deadline for
Israel to show compliance with the US conditions is Sept 30. If successful, it
expects to be incorporated in the VWP by November - a respite for relations
strained by disputes over Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's judicial
reforms and policies on the Palestinians. Gaza, whose governing Islamist Hamas
is designated a terrorist group by Israel and the United States, was previously
excluded from the pilot. The enclave is under an Israeli and Egyptian blockade
and both maintain restrictions along their borders with it. The exclusion
stirred protests by Palestinian Americans and calls from Washington for a change
in practice. An Israeli official said that, as of
Monday, Palestinian Americans living in Gaza and who are not deemed security
threats will be able to enter Israel on a "B2" tourist visa, opening up the
possibility of them taking flights out of its airports. Israel previously said
it intended to include Palestinian Americans living in Gaza - whose number it
puts at between 100 and 130 - on Sept 15 but would try to bring the date
forward. The US Embassy in Jerusalem had no immediate comment. As part of the
pilot, Israel says it has already been letting Palestinian Americans leave Gaza
by special buses to Jordan, from which they could travel elsewhere. In another
new policy, Israel says it is allowing Palestinian Americans from abroad who
have first-degree relatives in Gaza to make once-yearly visits of up to 90 days.
Palestinian and US officials have assessed that the number of dual US nationals
in Gaza may be several hundred. Asked about the apparent discrepancy in the
figures, an Israeli official said most of those are not full-time Gaza
residents.
Protests kick off at Israeli justice minister's home
Associated Press/11 September 2023
Scores of Israeli protesters on Monday flooded the streets outside the home of
Israel's justice minister, the architect of the country's divisive judicial
overhaul, a day before a pivotal hearing in which the Supreme Court will decide
whether to accept the curbing of its powers. Israeli police said they arrested
six people in the central Israeli town of Modiin, home to Justice Minister Yair
Levin, on charges of disrupting public order and blocking roads as they
protested plans by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government to
weaken the Supreme Court. The judicial plan has triggered one of the biggest
domestic crises in Israeli history and exposed the country's bitter divides.
On Tuesday, all 15 of Israel's Supreme Court justices will appear on the bench
for the first time ever to hear an appeal against the first major part of the
overhaul, which the the government pushed through parliament in July. The rowdy
crowd of roughly 200 demonstrators outside Levin's home blew horns, chanted
through megaphones against the government and brandished signs, jostling with
police who pushed back the crowds. After a few hours, Levin left his besieged
home in a sleek black car surrounded by police officers and security guards who
tried to clear a path for him through the swarm of protesters. Further
demonstrations are expected this week as the Supreme Court hears petitions
Tuesday by rights groups and individuals calling it to strike down the law
passed by parliament that cancels the court's ability to block government
actions and appointments using the legal concept that they are "unreasonable."
The hearings put the country's top justices in the unprecedented position of
defending their own independence and ruling on their own fate. The court faces
massive public pressure to strike down the law and has an inherent interest in
preserving its powers and independence. But if it does so, Netanyahu's
government could ignore the ruling, setting the stage for a crisis over who has
ultimate authority. Levin, a Netanyahu ally who has spearheaded the overhaul,
argued in interviews with local media last week against proposals to seek a
compromise with the opposition and soften the current judicial changes. Critics
of the overhaul describe it as a blow to democracy, arguing that Israel's
judiciary represents the primary check on the powers of the prime minister and
his majority coalition in parliament. They also say the prime minister has a
conflict of interest trying to change the legal system at a time when he is on
trial for corruption charges. Supporters of
Netanyahu's far-right, ultra-Orthodox government say the law will prevent
liberal, unelected judges from interfering with the decisions of elected
lawmakers. They also say the court should not be able to rule on a law limiting
its own authority.
Yemeni Authorities Try to Contain Clashes Between Ethiopian
Immigrants That Killed 10
Asharq Al Awsat/15:47-11 September 2023
The Yemeni security authorities launched a campaign in Aden to contain the
bloody clash between Ethiopian immigrants, which killed ten and injured dozens
of others.
Yemeni sources reported that the authorities in Aden are transferring migrants
to temporary camps in Mansoura and Sheikh Othman. According to the sources,
although the security forces ended the clashes, the issue persists, and police
vehicles were seen in the streets transporting migrants to a gathering point
near the Basateen camp in Sheikh Othman District. The Yemeni police and the
International Organization for Migration (IOM) remained silent about the reasons
for the outbreak of confrontations.
The President of Oromo Human Rights, Arafat Jibril Barki, stated that the main
reason for the confrontations was the refusal of the Ethiopian authorities to
receive migrants from the Amhara and Tigray nationalities. Ethiopia denied their
entrance because of the security conditions in the regions and only accepted
nationals of the Oromo ethnicity. Speaking to Asharq
Al-Awsat, Jibril said the problem began last Thursday in front of the office of
the International Organization for Migration. The migrants were demanding to
return to their country, but the Ethiopian government asked the UN not to allow
the return of two ethnic groups. The individuals banned from traveling attacked
the international immigration representative and one of the guards. Arafat
Jibril reported that the protesters tore up a travel ticket given to an Oromo
national, and one of them stabbed an employee while the guard responded and shot
the attacker, killing him. Clashes began and expanded to other areas, killing
ten, six of whom were from Amhara, one from Tigray, and three from Oromo. The
official stated that the news of excluding the Amhara and Tigray ethnicities
spread quickly among migrants, which led to heated discussions that developed
into violent clashes before the security forces intervened.
- Yemeni tries to contain the situation
The Yemeni authorities proceeded with their campaigns against illegal immigrants
and are discussing the issue with international organizations. Government
sources confirmed that transferring them to the Kharaz camp in Lahj is the best
option, given the complexities associated with the internal situation in
Ethiopia. Yemeni officials told Asharq Al-Awsat that the largest Kharaz camp in
the country lacks many services. But it is the only place capable of
accommodating the thousands of migrants pouring in, exceeding 86,000 over the
past months. Officials confirmed that thousands of migrants wanted to return to
their country after discovering that smugglers deceived them, bringing them to a
nation at war rather than taking them to the Gulf. The International
Organization for Migration had suspended the voluntary return program for
thousands of migrants due to lack of funding, but it has recently reactivated
it. UN estimates indicate that the number of African immigrants in Yemen exceeds
200,000, including 43,000 stranded people. The
organization explains that thousands of migrants are unable to continue their
journey onward. They cannot return to their countries of origin and are
currently living in dire humanitarian conditions. According to the organization
that monitors and tracks the movement of migrants and internal displacement,
thousands of migrants from the Horn of Africa continued to flow to Yemen. About
11,000 immigrants have returned to their home countries as part of the voluntary
return program, as the organization works to support stranded migrants to ensure
a safer return.
Drone attack on open market kills at least 43 in Sudan
Associated Press/September 11, 2023
A drone attack Sunday on an open market south of Sudan's capital, Khartoum,
killed at least 43 people, activists and a medical group said, as the military
and a powerful rival paramilitary group battle for control of the country. More
than 55 others were wounded in the attack in Khartoum's May neighborhood, where
paramilitary forces battling the military were heavily deployed, the Sudan
Doctors' Union said in a statement. The casualties were taken to Bashair
University Hospital. The Resistance Committees, an activist group that helps
organize humanitarian assistance, posted footage on social media showing bodies
wrapped in white sheets in an open yard at the hospital. Sudan has been rocked
by violence since mid-April, when tensions between the country's military, led
by Gen. Abdel Fattah Burhan, and the paramilitary Rapid Support Forces,
commanded by Gen. Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo, burst into open fighting. The RSF
blamed the military's air force for Sunday's attack, though it was not
immediately possible to independently verify the claim. The military, meanwhile,
said Sunday afternoon that it didn't target civilians, describing the RSF
accusations as "false and misleading claims."Indiscriminate shelling and
airstrikes by both factions are not uncommon in Sudan's war, which has made the
Greater Khartoum area a battleground. The conflict has since spread to several
parts of the country. In the Greater Khartoum area, which includes the cities of
Khartoum, Omdurman and Bahri, RSF troops have commandeered civilian homes and
turned them into operational bases. The military responded by bombing these
residential areas, rights groups and activists say. In the western Darfur region
— the scene of a genocidal campaign in the early 2000s — the conflict has
morphed into ethnic violence, with the RSF and allied Arab militias attacking
ethnic African groups, according to rights groups and the United Nations. Fierce
clashes ensued over the weekend in al-Fasher, the provincial capital of North
Darfur province, following an attack on a military facility by the RSF, local
media reported. Clementine Nkweta-Salami, the U.N. humanitarian coordinator in
Sudan, expressed concerns Sunday about the clashes in al-Fasher. Writing on X,
formerly known as Twitter, the U.N. official called for warring factions to stop
fighting "so that humanitarians can bring in food, medicine and shelter items to
those who need them most."
The war has killed more than 4,000 people, according to August figures from the
United Nations. However, the real toll is almost certainly much higher, doctors
and activists say. The number of internally displaced persons has nearly doubled
since mid-April to reach at least 7.1 million people, according to the U.N.
refugee agency. Another 1.1 million are refugees in neighboring countries,
according to figures released last week by the International Organization for
Migration. Chad received about 465,000 refugees, mostly from West Darfur
province where the RSF and its Arab militias launched scorched-earth attacks on
non-Arab tribes in the provincial capital of Geneina and its surrounding areas,
according to the U.N. and rights groups.
Historic Cairo cemetery faces destruction from new highways
as Egypt's government reshapes the city
CAIRO (AP)/September 11, 2023
The cane chairs and umbrella still stand in the courtyard of Hussein Omar’s
family mausoleum, where his grandmother came every morning for 19 years after
her daughter — his mother — died. Near her grave, she would sit and pray under
the date palm and among the flowering plants, a few hours of peace in Cairo ’s
historic City of the Dead. Now the mausoleum, built in 1924 in a neo-Islamic
style and housing the graves of a number of prominent Egyptians from a century
ago, is threatened with demolition.
Authorities have already razed hundreds of tombs and mausoleums as they carry
out plans to build a network of multilane highways through the City of the Dead,
a vast cemetery that has been in use for more than a millennium. Stunned
preservationists say the construction is destroying a unique part of Egypt’s
heritage where major Islamic figures, prominent Egyptian politicians, artists
and scholars and the loved ones of many Egyptians are buried.
“It’s always felt like a very sacred space. We always thought that whatever
happens in the rest of Cairo, the City of the Dead would be safe,” said Omar, a
historian who is writing a 500-year history of Cairo as told through the
necropolis. "As we see now, that’s not the case.”The work is part of a
mega-building campaign by President Abdel Fattah el-Sissi that is reshaping the
city of some 20 million people. His government has put up massive freeways and
flyovers at a furious rate, torn down several older neighborhoods it considers
slums and built housing projects. It has encouraged the growth of gated suburban
compounds outside the city while building a giant new capital in the desert.
Though many support the roadwork to unclog congestion in the overcrowded city,
the construction has also brought complaints of uprooting green spaces and
trees.
But the cemetery destruction sparked an outcry that is unusual in an Egypt,
where dissent has been squelched for years under el-Sissi. Dozens of parties,
activists, public figures and non-governmental organizations signed a petition
in August condemning the destruction. Five members of a committee of experts
formed by the government to study the cemeteries resigned in protest, saying
authorities ignored its recommendations that demolitions be halted and
alternatives to the routes be found. The government’s project is destroying a
“unique, architectural, historic fabric,” Ayman Wanas, an official with the
government department that lists distinctive buildings, wrote in his resignation
letter posted online. “It’s a waste of Egypt’s historic, valuable heritage which
is irreplaceable.”Apparently in response, authorities last week temporarily
halted the demolition of tombs in the main part of the cemetery, a municipal
official who oversees the eastern Cairo area where the cemeteries are located,
told The Associated Press. He said no explanation was given to the municipality,
but he believes the government either wants to examine alternatives or wants to
quiet criticism ahead of a meeting of the United Nations cultural agency,
UNESCO, that started Sunday in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. He spoke on condition of
anonymity because he wasn't allowed to brief media.
Security agents told grave caretakers not to let anyone enter or photograph
sites, several caretakers said. The area is designated by UNESCO as a world
heritage zone. But many preservationists sharply criticize the agency for
remaining silent over the destruction. In a statement to the AP, UNESCO said it
has expressed concerns to the Egyptian government and asked for more information
on the work.
There was no official announcement of the temporary halt and no word that the
highway plans had been changed. The City of the Dead, covering nearly 2 square
miles (5 square kilometers), has been a unique space in Cairo for centuries.
Originally a desert plain outside the city, it first came into use soon after
the Muslim conquest of Egypt in the 700s. Imam Shafii, one of the top scholars
of early Islam, was buried there after his death in 819, and now the grey dome
of his mausoleum-shrine towers over the district.
Over the centuries, it was filled with the tombs of Mamluk and Ottoman nobles
and ordinary Egyptians. A rare large open space in Cairo, it has a stark beauty
— quiet dirt paths run through a landscape of grave-markers, ancient domes and
unexpected areas of greenery. Stately mausoleum compounds hold elaborately
carved and decorated cenotaphs inside. The area also abounds with life. Families
come weekly to visit loved ones’ graves, spending the day with picnics and food.
Generations of caretaker families live in the mausoleums. Kids fly kites on its
empty roads in the evening. Tens of thousand of people live in residential
neighborhoods within the cemetery, and on Fridays its main avenue is packed with
an outdoor market. The main demolitions so far have been in an area dotted with
mausoleums of some of Egypt’s most notable families of the late 1800s and early
1900s. The government said it has given families who had to exhume and move
their loved ones new burial plots, usually in the suburbs outside Cairo. Omar’s
extended family has five mausoleums in the cemetery, two of which are slated for
destruction. His mother, who died in 2001, is buried in the Barakat family
mausoleum. Among his forebearers there are Fathallah and Atef Barakat, two
nationalist figures who participated in the 1919 Revolution against British
colonial rule. For Omar and others, the necropolis isn't just a historic site,
but a center of personal memories and a place that joins life, death and peace.
Omar recalls visiting the mausoleum as a 6-year-old and asking his grandmother
what the sound was that he was hearing. Raised in densely urbanized Cairo, he
didn’t recognize the sound of birds singing. “It is about the cohesiveness of
the space, the peacefulness of the space. It has historically been a place of
serenity,” he said. “What does it mean to have some lone surviving mausolea in
the middle of a massive jumble of roads and traffic?” In 2020, a large highway
flyover was built across the southern end of the cemetery, razing hundreds of
graves. The more extensive plans now reportedly include making way for two new
highways, two large roundabouts, a giant cloverleaf and the widening of other
roads. Preservationists fear that will mean the City of the Dead's end: Carved
up between highways, its remaining pieces would be vulnerable to further
destruction.
The government has long argued the graves are not on a list of protected
official historic Islamic and Christian monuments, a list that has hardly been
updated in decades.
Two 700-year-old minarets on the list that are in the path of the roadwork are
being dismantled and moved to another location. The planned highways weave
within yards (meters) of several other registered monuments.
Prime Minister Moustafa Madbouly said in June that alternative burial sites are
being provided for families moving their dead ahead of the construction. He said
tomb markers of historic figures would be collected in a “Cemetery of the
Immortals.”
Mostafa el-Sadek, a university professor who leads a volunteer initiative to
document ancient graves and mausoleums, was frustrated by the government’s
insistence on razing the tombs. “The demolition must stop,” he said. “This area
has layers and layers of history. Any problems, including the groundwater, could
be resolved. It’s a matter of willingness.”
Lee Keath And Samy Magdy, The Associated Press
North Korean train presumably carrying Kim Jong Un
departed for Russia
Associated Press/September 11, 2023
A North Korean train presumably carrying leader Kim Jong Un has departed for
Russia for a possible meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin, South
Korean media said Monday.Citing unidentified South Korean government sources,
the Chosun Ilbo newspaper reported that the train likely left the North Korean
capital of Pyongyang on Sunday evening and that a Kim-Putin meeting is possible
as early as Tuesday. The Yonhap news agency and some other media published
similar reports. Japan's Kyodo news agency cited Russian officials as saying
that Kim was possibly heading for Russia in his personal train. South Korea's
Presidential Office, Defense Ministry and National Intelligence Service didn't
immediately confirm those details. U.S. officials released intelligence last
week that North Korea and Russia were arranging a meeting between their leaders
that would take place within this month as they expand their cooperation in the
face of deepening confrontations with the United States. A possible venue for
the meeting is the eastern Russian city of Vladivostok, where Putin arrived
Monday to attend an international forum that runs through Wednesday, according
to Russia's TASS news agency. The city was also the site of Putin's first
meeting with Kim in 2019. According to U.S. officials, Putin could focus on
securing more supplies of North Korean artillery and other ammunition to refill
declining reserves as he seeks to defuse a Ukrainian counteroffensive and show
that he's capable of grinding out a long war of attrition. That could
potentially put more pressure on the United States and its partners to pursue
negotiations as concerns about a protracted conflict grow despite their huge
shipments of advanced weaponry to Ukraine over the past 17 months. North Korea
has possibly tens of millions of artillery shells and rockets based on Soviet
designs that could potentially give a huge boost to the Russian army, analysts
say. In exchange, Kim could seek badly needed energy and food aid and advanced
weapons technologies, including those related to intercontinental ballistic
missiles, nuclear-capable ballistic missile submarines and military
reconnaissance satellites, analysts say. There are concerns that potential
Russian technology transfers would increase the threat posed by Kim's growing
arsenal of nuclear weapons and missiles that are designed to target the United
States, South Korea, and Japan.
After a complicated, hot-and-cold relationship for decades, Russia and North
Korea have been drawing closer to each other since Russia's invasion of Ukraine
in February 2022. The bond has been driven by Putin's need for war help and
Kim's efforts to boost the visibility of his partnerships with traditional
allies Moscow and Beijing as he tries to break out of diplomatic isolation and
have North Korea be part of a united front against Washington. While using the
distraction caused by the Ukraine conflict to ramp up its weapons development,
North Korea has repeatedly blamed the United States for the crisis in Ukraine,
claiming the West's "hegemonic policy" justified a Russian offensive in Ukraine
to protect itself.
North Korea is the only nation aside of Russia and Syria to recognize the
independence of two Russian-backed separatist regions in eastern Ukraine —
Donetsk and Luhansk -– and it has also hinted at an interest in sending
construction workers to those areas to help with rebuilding efforts. Russia -–
along with China -– have blocked U.S.-led efforts at the U.N. Security Council
to strengthen sanctions on North Korea over its intensifying missile tests while
accusing Washington of worsening tensions with Pyongyang by expanding military
exercises with South Korea and Japan. The United States has been accusing North
Korea since last year of providing Russia with arms, including artillery shells
sold to the Russian mercenary group Wagner. Both Russian and North Korean
officials denied such claims. But speculation about the countries' military
cooperation grew after Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu made a rare visit
to North Korea in July, when Kim invited him to an arms exhibition and a massive
military parade in the capital where he showcased ICBMs designed to target the
U.S. mainland. Following Shoigu's visit, Kim toured North Korea's weapons
factories, including a facility producing artillery systems where he urged
workers to speed up the development and large-scale production of new kinds of
ammunition. Experts say Kim's visits to the factories likely had a dual goal of
encouraging the modernization of North Korean weaponry and examining artillery
and other supplies that could possibly be exported to Russia. Jon Finer, U.S.
President Joe Biden's chief deputy national security adviser, told reporters on
Sunday that buying weapons from North Korea "may be the best and may be the only
option" open to Moscow as it tries to keep its war effort going. "We have
serious concerns about the prospect of North Korea potentially selling weapons,
additional weapons, to the Russian military. It is interesting to reflect for a
minute on what it says that when Russia goes around the world looking for
partners that can help it, it lands on North Korea," Finer said aboard a plane
carrying Biden from India to Vietnam. Some analysts say a potential meeting
between Kim and Putin would be more about symbolic gains than substantial
military cooperation. Russia — which has always closely guarded its most
important weapons technologies, even from key allies such as China — could be
unwilling to make major technology transfers with North Korea for what is likely
to be limited war supplies transported over a small rail link between the
countries, they say.
Latest English LCCC
analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on September 11-12/2023
Analysis of IAEA Iran Verification and Monitoring
Report – September 2023
Institute for Science and International Security/September 11/2023
David Albright
Institute for Science and International Security
Sarah Burkhard
Institute for Science and International Security
Spencer Faragasso
Institute for Science and International Security
Andrea Stricker
Nonproliferation and Biodefense Program Deputy Director and Research Fellow
Background
● This report summarizes and assesses information in the International Atomic
Energy Agency’s (IAEA’s) quarterly report, dated September 4, 2023, Verification
and monitoring in the Islamic Republic of Iran in light of United Nations
Security Council resolution 2231 (2015), including Iran’s compliance with the
Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA). It also covers findings from a
separate IAEA report, NPT Safeguards Agreement with the Islamic Republic of
Iran, issued also on September 4, 2023.
Findings
● Iran retains the ability, using 40 kilograms (kg) of 60 percent highly
enriched uranium (HEU) and three or four advanced centrifuge cascades, to break
out and produce enough weapon-grade enriched uranium for a nuclear weapon in 12
days. Currently, Iran would only need one-third of its existing stock of 60
percent enriched uranium. This breakout could be difficult for the IAEA to
detect promptly, if Iran delayed inspectors’ access.
● Using more of its remaining stock of 60 percent enriched uranium in the same
three or four cascades, and its stock of near 20 percent enriched uranium in the
vast bulk of its production-scale cascades, Iran could produce enough
weapon-grade uranium (WGU) for an additional five nuclear weapons within the
first month of a breakout, bringing the total to enough WGU for six nuclear
weapons, or an increase of one since May 2023. Thus, Iran has increased its
breakout capability, despite only a small increase in its 60 percent stock (see
below), because its near 20 percent and less than five percent LEU stocks
increased.
● In the second month, using its remaining stock of 60 percent material and part
of its stock of less than 5 percent low enriched uranium (LEU), Iran could
produce enough WGU for an additional two weapons. Using the rest of its stock of
less than 5 percent LEU) (but greater than 2 percent enriched uranium), Iran
could produce enough WGU for a ninth weapon by the end of the third month, and a
tenth by the end of the fourth month.
● In summary, Iran could produce enough WGU for six nuclear weapons in one
month, eight in two months, nine in three months, and ten in four months. Iran’s
stockpile of 60 percent HEU was 121.6 kg (Uranium mass, or U mass) or 179.9 kg
uranium hexafluoride mass (hex mass) as of August 19.
● The amount of 60 percent HEU produced during this most recent reporting period
was about half of the amount produced during the previous reporting period,
despite comparable timespans. The average production rate dropped from 9 kg (U
mass) per month to 4.3 kg.
● The IAEA reports that from mid-June onwards, Iran reduced the production rate
of near 60 percent HEU “by approximately two-thirds,” indicating that during
this reporting period, which spans mid-May to mid-August, one month at full
production was followed by two months of reduced production.
● Of note, Iran only recently doubled its production of near 60 percent HEU when
it started, in November 2022, to enrich to near 60 percent HEU in two advanced
centrifuge cascades at Fordow. Thus, for six months, from December 2022 to June
2023, it accumulated about double the monthly average amount compared to the
previous year and may still be able to hit an annual production target even if
it were to stop producing 60 percent altogether for the next six months.
● The IAEA also reports that Iran downblended 6.4 kg (Uranium mass) of its near
60 percent stock by mixing it with near 5 percent LEU to produce 22.2 kg of 20
percent enriched uranium. Because it was not downblended to natural uranium or
to at least near 5 percent LEU, the downblending had little impact on the
breakout timelines.
● Overall, neither the slow-down in 60 percent production nor the downblending
improved the breakout situation; in fact, the situation worsened.
● Iran continued to produce 60 percent HEU from 5 percent LEU feed in advanced
centrifuge cascades at the above-ground Pilot Fuel Enrichment Plant (PFEP) and
the below-ground Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant (FFEP); the latter includes an
IR-6 centrifuge cascade that is easily modifiable to change operations. This
cascade was at the center of an IAEA-detected undeclared mode of operation in
January 2023. It was interconnected with another IR-6 cascade to produce HEU,
and subsequently, the IAEA detected the presence of near-84 percent HEU
particles at the cascade’s product sampling point.
● The IAEA has “accepted Iran’s explanation for the origin of these particles”
and verified that no diversion of declared uranium and no accumulation of
uranium enriched to more than 60 percent took place. At the same time, the IAEA
sought increased access and intensification of verification activities at the
FFEP. In a May 2023 report on Iran’s compliance with the Nuclear
Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), the IAEA reported that it installed enrichment
monitoring devices (EMD) at both the FFEP and at the PFEP to “monitor the
enrichment level of the HEU being produced by Iran.” These monitors are not
JCPOA-related but are installed pursuant to Iran’s comprehensive safeguards
agreement (CSA) with the agency. IAEA Director General Rafael Grossi confirmed
in a press conference that the EMD data will notify the IAEA of “another
oscillation or otherwise” in the enrichment level in “real-time.” The IAEA
reports, “The evaluation of the data collected confirmed the general good
functioning of the systems.” However, “adjustments and changes to operational
procedures required to enable their commissioning […] are being discussed with
Iran.”
● Iran continues to keep the majority (83 percent) of its stock of 60 percent
HEU and nearly 85 percent of its stock of 20 percent enriched uranium at the
Esfahan Fuel Plate Fabrication Plant (FPFP), where Iran maintains a capability
to make enriched uranium metal. Iran’s storage of so much
proliferation-sensitive material at the FPFP, which may not be as thoroughly
monitored as Natanz and Fordow, requires enhanced IAEA safeguards to detect and
prevent diversion to a secret enrichment plant. For example, there should be
stepped up inspector presence and remote camera surveillance.
● As of August 19, 2023, Iran had an IAEA-estimated stock of 535.8 kg of 20
percent enriched uranium (U mass and in the form of UF6), equivalent to 792.6 kg
(hex mass), representing an increase of 64.9 kg from 470.9 kg (U mass). Iran
also had a stock of 33 kg (U mass) of 20 percent uranium in other chemical
forms.
● The average production rate of 20 percent enriched uranium at the FFEP
increased slightly to 13.2 kg (U mass) or 19.6 kg (hex mass) per month.
● Iran’s number of installed advanced centrifuges has remained fairly steady
since February 2023. It now has a total of about 6100 advanced centrifuges at
Natanz and Fordow, where most are deployed at the Natanz Fuel Enrichment Plant (FEP)
(see Figures 1 and 2).
● Including the installed IR-1 centrifuges at Natanz and Fordow brings the total
number of installed centrifuges to about 13,330 centrifuges. It should be noted
that many of the advanced centrifuges are deployed but not enriching uranium,
and the IR-1 centrifuges have far less ability to enrich uranium than the
advanced ones.
● During this reporting period, Iran installed one additional cascade of IR-4
centrifuges at the Natanz Fuel Enrichment Plant (FEP), where Iran now has a
total of 36 cascades of IR-1 centrifuges, 21 cascades of IR-2m centrifuges, five
cascades of IR-4 centrifuges, and three cascades of IR-6 centrifuges installed.
An additional seven IR-4 centrifuge cascades are planned, and the installation
of one IR-4 cascade was ongoing.
● Iran did not install any additional advanced centrifuge cascades at the FFEP,
where it is currently operating six IR-1 centrifuge cascades and two IR-6
centrifuge cascades, although it plans to install up to 14 additional IR-6
centrifuge cascades.
● This lull in deployment was preceded by a spike in advanced centrifuge
deployment from August 2022 to February 2023. A slowing of advanced centrifuge
deployments and enrichment using those machines may be one reported term of an
informal nuclear understanding with the United States, although this is
unverified. It is unclear whether this means Iran is produced fewer centrifuges
than expected, implying possible manufacturing difficulties, or is keeping newly
produced machines in unmonitored storage instead.
● Iran’s current, total operating enrichment capability is estimated to remain
at about 19,100 separative work units (SWU) per year, where only cascades
enriching uranium during this reporting period are included in this estimate. As
of this reporting period, Iran was not yet using its fully installed enrichment
capacity at the FEP.
● Iran’s overall reported stockpile of enriched uranium decreased by 949 kg (U
mass) from 4744.5 kg to 3795.5 kg (U mass) (see Table 1). This decrease largely
stems from a decrease in uranium enriched to less than 2 percent, while all
other stocks grew.
● Iran’s stockpile of near 5 percent LEU increased by 610.7 kg (U mass) to
1950.9 kg (U mass) or 2885.9 kg (hex mass). Average production of near 5 percent
LEU at the FEP increased, while the feed rate for 20 percent and 60 percent
enriched uranium production decreased.
● Despite the increase during this reporting period in the amount of uranium
enriched between two and five percent, Iran has not prioritized stockpiling this
material over the past two and a half years. In addition, it has not made
planned progress on the Enriched Uranium Powder Plant, a key civil facility to
convert less than five percent enriched uranium hexafluoride into a uranium
oxide powder for use in nuclear power reactor fuel. These two choices are at
odds with Iran’s contention that its primary goal is to accumulate 4-5 percent
enriched uranium for use in nuclear power reactor fuel. Instead, Iran has used
this stock extensively to produce near 20 percent and 60 percent enriched
uranium, far beyond Iran’s civilian needs.
● The IAEA reported no progress by Iran on resolving a discrepancy in Iran’s
natural uranium inventory at the Uranium Conversion Facility (UCF). The IAEA
previously reported a shortfall in Iran’s declaration, which may indicate that
Iran mixed into the UCF inventory undeclared uranium it used in the past at the
Lavisan-Shian site during its early-2000s nuclear weapons program. After
acknowledging a discrepancy, Iran insisted that the discrepancy is “inaccurate”
and “baseless,” and that “differences” are “predictable” and that “the matter is
considered as resolved.” The IAEA did not agree with Iran’s claim.
● The IAEA reports that Iran has not started commissioning the Arak reactor, now
called the Khondab Heavy Water Research Reactor (KHRR), or IR-20. Iran
previously informed the IAEA that it expected to commission the reactor in 2023
and start operations in 2024, but construction efforts on the reactor continue.
● The IAEA underscores that “for more than two and a half years Iran has not
provided updated declarations and the Agency has not been able to conduct any
complementary access under the Additional Protocol to any sites and locations in
Iran.”
● The IAEA reports no new progress on installing new surveillance cameras at
Iran’s nuclear-related facilities, including centrifuge manufacturing and
assembly sites. Iran also has not turned over data or footage associated with
monitoring devices and cameras, as it committed in an IAEA/Iran Joint Statement
from March 2023.
● The absence of monitoring and surveillance equipment, particularly since June
2022, has caused the IAEA to doubt its ability to ascertain whether Iran has
diverted or may divert advanced centrifuges. A risk is that Iran could
accumulate a secret stock of advanced centrifuges, deployable in the future at a
clandestine enrichment plant or during a breakout at declared sites. Another
risk is that Iran will establish additional centrifuge manufacturing sites
unknown to the IAEA. Iran has proven its ability to move manufacturing equipment
to new, undeclared sites, further complicating any future verification effort
and contributing to uncertainty about where Iran manufactures centrifuges.
● Iran’s refusal to implement the non-voluntary Modified Code 3.1 to its CSA
raises doubts about whether Iran will report the construction of a new
enrichment plant or provide design information to the IAEA as soon as it decides
to construct such a facility. Iran is building a new facility in the mountains
near Natanz that is deeply buried and could be a potential site for a new
enrichment plant.
● The IAEA concludes that “Iran’s decision to remove all of the Agency’s
equipment previously installed in Iran for JCPOA-related surveillance and
monitoring activities in relation to the JCPOA has [had] detrimental
implications for the Agency’s ability to provide assurance of the peaceful
nature of Iran’s nuclear programme.”
● Concern about Iran’s installation of advanced centrifuges at an undeclared
site increases as its 60 percent HEU stocks grow. Such a scenario is becoming
more worrisome and viable, since a relatively small number of advanced
centrifuge cascades would suffice for the rapid enrichment of the 60 percent HEU
to weapon-grade. This hybrid strategy involves the diversion of safeguarded HEU
and the secret manufacture and deployment of only three or four cascades of
advanced centrifuges. With greater uncertainty about the number of advanced
centrifuges Iran is making, there is a greater chance of Iran hiding away the
requisite number of advanced centrifuges to realize this scenario.
● According to a separate NPT report, Iran held discussions with the IAEA in
August but did not make progress in addressing the IAEA’s remaining questions
about undeclared nuclear weapons activities and undeclared nuclear material
found at two sites, Varamin and Turquz-Abad. Iran is stone-walling the IAEA.
● Combined with Iran’s refusal to resolve outstanding safeguards violations, the
IAEA has a significantly reduced ability to monitor Iran’s complex and growing
nuclear program, which notably has unresolved nuclear weapons dimensions. The
IAEA’s ability to detect diversion of nuclear materials, equipment, and other
capabilities to undeclared facilities remains greatly diminished.
Figure 1. The total number of advanced centrifuges installed at all three
enrichment facilities. One cascade of IR-4 centrifuges was reportedly added
during this quarterly report. As can be seen, centrifuge installation has been
relatively minimal since February 2023.
Figure 2. The total number of advanced centrifuges deployed at the Natanz Fuel
Enrichment Plant. The deployment rate remained flat between February and May
2023 quarterly reports, with only a single cascade of IR-4 centrifuges deployed
during the most recent reporting period. These numbers demonstrate that Iran has
made no tangible concession and, on the contrary, continued to deploy advanced
centrifuges, albeit at a much slower rate than in 2022.
Andrea Stricker is deputy director of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies’
(FDD) Nonproliferation and Biodefense Program and an FDD research fellow. Follow
her on X @StrickerNonpro. FDD is a Washington, DC-based, nonpartisan research
institute focused on national security and foreign policy.
Twenty Years Later, Iran Remains In Non-Compliance With Its Nuclear
Nonproliferation Obligations
Olli Heinonen and Andrea Stricker/ 19FortyFive/September 8, 2023
Nonproliferation and Biodefense Program Deputy Director and Research Fellow
Sept. 12 will mark the 20th anniversary of the first resolution criticizing Iran
by the International Atomic Energy Agency’s (IAEA’s) board of governors.
The board, a 35-nation body tasked with policymaking for the UN nuclear
watchdog, issues such resolutions to pressure countries to comply with their
nonproliferation safeguards obligations. In 2023, the Islamic Republic has still
not fulfilled the demands of the original resolution, and it appears poised to
make nuclear weapons at a time of its choosing. A new approach is needed that
refocuses Western attention on addressing Iran’s fundamental breaches of its
nonproliferation obligations — and soon.
The strictly worded resolution passed by the board in September 2003 demanded
that Tehran provide “a full declaration” under its safeguards agreement — the
fundamental legal accord that parties to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty
reach with the IAEA to ensure international oversight and the peacefulness of
their nuclear programs.
The resolution followed international discovery in mid-2002 of Iran’s vast,
secret nuclear program, including a uranium enrichment site at Natanz and Iran’s
acquisition and processing of uranium. Both breached Tehran’s safeguards
agreement, because Iran failed to report them.
To support the IAEA’s “verification of the correctness and completeness of
Iran’s declarations,” the first resolution also demanded unrestricted access to
Iranian sites and environmental sampling, which would enable the agency to
detect traces of nuclear materials. The board requested Tehran answer the
agency’s questions about the origins of its nuclear activities, give details
about experimentation, and provide any other information or explanations the
agency deemed necessary.
Twenty years later, Iran has not remedied “all failures identified by the
Agency” or cooperated “fully with the Agency to ensure verification of
compliance with Iran’s safeguards agreement,” as the original resolution
stipulated. The board has since passed 15 other Iran resolutions. In 2006, it
referred Iran’s case to the UN Security Council, which passed a series of
sanctions against Tehran.
The United States, Europe, and their partners have tried nuclear deals — most
systematically the 2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, which Washington
left in 2018 — but to little success. Iran pockets concessions without
meaningful reciprocation.
Since 2018, the IAEA remains embroiled in a fruitless investigation of
information the agency learned from an Israeli raid on a Tehran warehouse. The
raid’s findings indicated that Iran had a full-fledged nuclear weapons program
up until mid-2003 called the Amad Plan.
The pilfered materials suggested Iran likely retains some of its nuclear
weapons-related work, today overseen by the Organization of Defense Innovation
Research, known by its Persian acronym, SPND. Under SPND, Tehran advances
disparate activities at locations not inspected by the IAEA.
Tehran initially refused IAEA access to sites so that Iran could remove
evidence. Yet when the IAEA succeeded in detecting undeclared nuclear material
and disclosed facts about Iranian nuclear weapons activities, as it did in March
2022 and May 2023, the international community failed to put meaningful pressure
on the IAEA to probe deeper, or on Iran to cooperate more.
In its Iran safeguards report for September, the IAEA still could not verify the
correctness and completeness of Iran’s declarations. In short: The IAEA is
unable to provide credible assurances of the peaceful nature of Tehran’s nuclear
program.
Iran now has thousands of advanced centrifuges spinning at fortified enrichment
locations, and the capability to produce enough weapons-grade uranium for
several nuclear bombs in under three months. It may be building a new enrichment
site deep in the mountains near Natanz that would be immune to even the
strongest U.S. bunker-buster bombs. Tehran is limiting IAEA monitoring of its
nuclear sites and activities, withdrawing cameras, and restricting inspections.
Iran advances its nuclear program, waiting for an opportune time to cross the
nuclear threshold.
A reported new arrangement between Tehran and the Biden administration requires
just token reductions of Iran’s capabilities in return for significant sanctions
relief. Thus far, according to the IAEA’s latest reporting, these regime
concessions appear illusory. The West heralds this as a win, but the Islamic
Republic remains a nuclear threshold state.
The United States and its partners must act.
They must demand a new, comprehensive, and verifiable declaration by Tehran of
all nuclear activities, past and present, and direct the IAEA to undertake a
large-scale investigation backed by full Iranian cooperation. The investigation
must include access to sites and equipment, personnel interviews, and provision
of documentation. It is indispensable that the IAEA inspect all installations
and institutes involved in the pre-2003 Amad Plan — something it has not yet
done.
Moreover, absent a halt to Iran’s uranium enrichment program, Tehran’s full
cooperation with the IAEA, and a deep IAEA investigation into the regime’s
ongoing nuclear weapons activities, Washington and its partners should not
authorize further sanctions relief for Iran.
The 20th year of the Iran nuclear crisis is upon us. Unless the West pivots soon
and changes its lackadaisical approach, the result could be a regime that need
not rush. Under the world’s watch, it will simply stroll to possession of atomic
weapons.
**Olli Heinonen is a distinguished fellow at the Stimson Center and served for
27 years at the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), most recently as
deputy director-general. Andrea Stricker is deputy director of the
nonproliferation and biodefense program and a research fellow at the Foundation
for Defense of Democracies (FDD). Follow them on X @OlliHeinonen and @StrickerNonpro.
Why did Turkey’s foreign minister go to Iran?
Sinan Ciddi/Washington Examiner/September 11/ 2023
Hakan Fidan, Turkey’s foreign minister, paid a visit to Iran on Sunday. The
invitation, extended to him by his Iranian counterpart, Hossein Amir-Abdollahian,
was publicized as an “opportunity to discuss the possibilities for further
advancing our bilateral cooperation in all fields with Iran and to exchange
views on current regional and international developments.”
While Ankara maintains an interest in expanding its horizons with Tehran, the
actual focus of the high-level meeting between the foreign ministers was to
discuss Syria.
Since 2022, Russian President Vladimir Putin has been keen to facilitate the
normalization of ties between Ankara and Damascus. This is easier wished than
accomplished as Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey and Bashar Assad of Syria are
bitter enemies. Erdogan spent the better part of the last decade trying to
overthrow Assad. Given that Assad is likely to hold on to power, Erdogan has few
options other than to rekindle a functional relationship with Assad.
Damascus, however, is in a strong bargaining position: In return for even
beginning talks to normalize ties with Ankara, the Syrian government has
demanded that all Turkish troops, presently occupying large swaths of northern
Syria, leave its territory.
Erdogan needs the cooperation of Assad for a number of reasons: He would like to
return a symbolic number of Syrian refugees, which number close to four million
in Turkey. He would also like the Syrian government to work with Turkey to
contain, ideally dismember, the Syrian Kurdish military entity, the Syrian
Democratic Forces, which is considered a terrorist entity by Turkey and which is
a key U.S. partner in the fight against ISIS.
Since the May elections, Erdogan has been under immense pressure to make headway
on these two issues. Independent of the Turkish public, Erdogan is also under
pressure from Putin to mend fences with Assad. Turkey’s political and economic
exposure to Moscow is too high for Erdogan to ignore. Turkey depends on Russia
for its natural gas supply, tourism revenues, nuclear energy capability, and
bilateral trade.
In light of this, what is the relevance of Fidan’s visit to Tehran? It is likely
a diplomatic push by Fidan to get Assad to drop his precondition to remove
Turkish troops from Syria before Assad and Erdogan can meet. Assad has no
motivation to make Erdogan’s life easier, but he may listen to Moscow and
Tehran, his two big patrons. Fidan’s visit to Tehran was preceded by a visit to
Moscow, where he met with his Russian counterpart SergeyLavrov and Defense
Minister Sergei Shoigu.
Similarly, Fidan’s diplomatic efforts were mirrored by Erdogan, who met with
Putin on Monday. In all of these meetings Ankara is trying to achieve two major
goals: To solicit Moscow and Tehran’s help in getting Assad to the negotiating
table without preconditions and to highlight Turkey’s importance to the West by
exploring opportunities of getting Russia to reenter the grain deal.
All of this helps underscore what Erdogan would like to label as Turkey’s
strategic autonomy. In reality, playing diplomatic footsie with Russia and Iran
is a further demonstration of Turkey’s drift from the West. On the one hand, the
Turkish government has been in quiet negotiations to secure $35 billion worth of
stabilization funding, likely facilitated by the Biden administration. On the
other, we see little to no commitment on the part of Ankara to back
international sanctions against two of the greatest threats to the liberal
international order. It is likely that the $35 billion line of credit that may
come from Washington is a quid pro quo for Ankara to approve Sweden’s NATO
membership in October. It is worth noting that while leaning on the West for
bailout funding, Erdogan referred to Putin as his “valued friend” during their
meeting in Sochi.
The previous three U.S. administrations have struggled with how to handle an
increasingly anti-Western Erdogan. Professor Henri Barkey recently published a
refreshingly concise set of recommendations in a Foreign Affairs article, which
the Biden administration appears reluctant to read, let alone implement. There
is little sense in offering cash incentives to Erdogan while he continues to
further distance Turkey from the West and move into the orbit of Moscow and
Tehran.
*Sinan Ciddi (@SinanCiddi) is a nonresident senior fellow at the Foundation for
Defense of Democracies, where he contributes to FDD’s Turkey Program and Center
on Military and Political Power. Follow Sinan on X @SinanCiddi. FDD is a
Washington, DC-based, nonpartisan research institute focusing on national
security and foreign policy.
When 9/11 Was a Day of Victory against Jihad
Raymond Ibrahim/September 11/ 2023
Although 9/11 will forever be associated with the jihadist massacre of some
3,000 Americans, for centuries earlier, September 11 was celebrated as the day
when a small band of Christian knights defeated a massive Muslim horde. That
story is worth recounting. After the Ottoman Empire declared jihad on Malta in
the spring of 1565, 30,000 Turks, armed to the teeth and with all sorts of heavy
artillery, descended on the tiny Mediterranean island, which was defended by a
few thousand shabbily armed Maltese men, under the leadership of the Knights of
Saint John.
Enter Jean Parisot de Valette (1494–1568), the Grand Master of the Knights: “His
disposition is rather sad,” wrote a contemporary, but “for his age
[seventy-one], he is very robust” and “very devout.” As the Muslim sails
approached, he explained to his men what was at stake: “A formidable army
composed of audacious barbarians is descending on this island,” he warned;
“these persons, my brothers, are the enemies of Jesus Christ. Today it is a
question of the defense of our Faith as to whether the book of the Evangelist
[the Gospel] is to be superseded by that of the Koran? God on this occasion
demands of us our lives, already vowed to His service. Happy will those be who
first consummate this sacrifice.”Once the Turks arrived, they subjected the tiny
Mediterranean island to what was then the heaviest nonstop bombardment any
locale had been subjected to in history. “With the roar of the artillery and the
arquebuses, the hair-raising screams, the smoke and fire and flame,” a
chronicler wrote, “it seemed that the whole world was at the point of
exploding.”The vastly outnumbered and soon wearied defenders, who were ordered
to “fight bravely and sell their lives to the barbarians as dearly as possible,”
did just that; and for every Christian killed defending the fort, numerous
Muslim besiegers fell.
After reducing to rubble and storming the fort of St. Elmo, the Turks
sadistically slaughtered all 1,500 of its defenders: the Knights of Saint John
“were hung upside down from iron rings . . . and had their heads split, their
chests open, and their hearts torn out.” The Muslim commander, Mustafa, ordered
their mutilated corpses (along with one Maltese priest) nailed to wooden crosses
and set adrift to deride and demoralize the other onlooking defenders.
The terror tactic failed. The 71-year-old Valette delivered a thundering and
defiant speech before the huddled Christians, beheaded all Muslim prisoners, and
fired their heads from cannon at the Turkish besiegers.
The Ottomans continued to subject the rest of the island to a sustained
bombardment (some 130,000 cannonballs were fired in total). “I don’t know if the
image of hell can describe the appalling battle,” wrote a contemporary: “the
fire, the heat, the continuous flames from the flamethrowers and fire hoops; the
thick smoke, the stench, the disemboweled and mutilated corpses, the clash of
arms, the groans, shouts, and cries, the roar of the guns . . . men wounding,
killing, scrabbling, throwing one another back, falling and firing.”
Although the rest of the forts were reduced to rubble, much Muslim blood was
spilled for each inch gained; for “when they got within arms’ reach the scimitar
was no match for the long two-handed sword of the Christians.” Desperate
fighting spilled into the streets, where even Maltese women and children
participated. It was now late August and the island
was still not taken. That, and mass Muslim casualties, led to mass
demoralization in the Ottoman camp. Embarrassed talk of lifting the siege had
already begun when a Sicilian relief force finally arrived with nearly 10,000
soldiers at St. Paul’s Bay. There, where the apostle was once shipwrecked, the
final scene of this Armageddon played out as the fresh newcomers routed the
retreating Ottomans. The Muslims finally fled, and
Malta was liberated, on September 11, a day which for years thereafter was
celebrated.
Note: All quotations in the above account were excerpted from and documented in
the Raymond Ibrahim’s book, Sword and Scimitar: Fourteen Centuries of War
between Islam and the West.
Time to Declare a 'People's War' on the CCP: All of China
Is One Military Machine
Gordon G. Chang/Gatestone Institute./September 11, 2023
Washington should be trying to end the rule of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
It is time to declare a "people's war" against the CCP. We are in an us-or-them
fight.
The Party certainly thinks that way. In May 2019, People's Daily, the CCP's
self-described "mouthpiece"... declared a "people's war" against the United
States.
"A people's war is a total war, and its strategy and tactics require the overall
mobilization of political, economic, cultural, diplomatic, military, and other
power resources, the integrated use of multiple forms of struggle and combat
methods." — PLA Daily, an official news website of the Communist Party's
People's Liberation Army, April 1, 2023.
Although it denies doing so, China's regime is conducting "unrestricted warfare"
against America.
Unrestricted warfare means total war. The regime's deliberate spread of COVID-19
and support for the Chinese fentanyl gangs, for example, should be viewed in
that light.
Most Americans have chosen not to see the Chinese regime's hatred of America.
Why should Americans be concerned?
The Party, with strident anti-Americanism, is establishing a justification to
strike America. As James Lilley, the great American ambassador to Beijing, said,
the Chinese always telegraph their punches. They are now telegraphing punches.
[US National Security Adviser Jake] Sullivan and others are willing to impose,
for instance, technology sanctions on China, but they are largely ineffective.
Xi Jinping has a policy of "military-civilian fusion," which means that anything
a civilian organization possesses can be — and is — pipelined to the Chinese
military. In the Communist Party's top-down system, every individual and entity
in China must obey every Party order.
It's a warning to America....
The U.S. Commerce Department allowed transfers of American technology to SMIC on
the condition there would be no transfers to Huawei.
Why would Commerce ever think SMIC would keep that promise? The only realistic
solution is to treat all Chinese parties as one and to prevent tech transfers to
all of them.
Xi's regime is mobilizing all of the country's civilians for war. The Chinese
leader never misses an opportunity to talk about it. China's regime is clearly
planning to wage "kinetic" war — the type Americans are used to seeing in the
movies — on America.
Obviously, American parties, especially businesses, should not be enabling the
Chinese regime to kill Americans. This means they should not be engaging in any
transaction that can strengthen any part of China. We should think of all of
China as military.
"Don't say we didn't warn you!" — Chinese Communist Party's People's Daily, May
31 2019.
China's regime is conducting "unrestricted warfare" against America.
Unrestricted warfare means total war. The regime's deliberate spread of COVID-19
and support for the Chinese fentanyl gangs, for example, should be viewed in
that light. Washington should be trying to end the rule of the Chinese Communist
Party (CCP). It is time to declare a "people's war" against the CCP. We are in
an us-or-them fight. Pictured: China's President Xi Jinping (standing in
vehicle) inspects People's Liberation Army soldiers at a military base in Hong
Kong on June 30, 2017. (Photo by Dale de la Rey/AFP via Getty Images)
"I want to be clear that we do not seek to decouple or to hold China's economy
back," declared U.S. Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo during her August trip to
Beijing.
Well, why not, Madam Secretary? The U.S. should be holding the Chinese economy
back. In fact, we should be doing more than just that. Washington should be
trying to end the rule of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). It is time to
declare a "people's war" against the CCP. We are in an us-or-them fight.
The Party certainly thinks that way. In May 2019, People's Daily, the CCP's
self-described "mouthpiece" and therefore most authoritative publication in
China, declared a "people's war" against the United States.
That phrase carries great meaning. As PLA Daily, an official news website of the
Party's People's Liberation Army, stated in April, "A people's war is a total
war, and its strategy and tactics require the overall mobilization of political,
economic, cultural, diplomatic, military, and other power resources, the
integrated use of multiple forms of struggle and combat methods."
What exactly are "multiple forms of struggle and combat methods"? Although it
denies doing so, China's regime is conducting "unrestricted warfare" against
America.
Unrestricted warfare means total war. The regime's deliberate spread of COVID-19
and support for the Chinese fentanyl gangs, for example, should be viewed in
that light. We must remember: In China's tightly controlled public square, the
extermination of Americans is a permitted topic, as the explosive comments of
prominent academic Li Yi tell us.
Most Americans have chosen not to see the Chinese regime's hatred of America.
Those who have noticed are probably perplexed by its overheated rhetoric.
Why should Americans be concerned?
The Party, with strident anti-Americanism, is establishing a justification to
strike America. As James Lilley, the great American ambassador to Beijing, said,
the Chinese always telegraph their punches. They are now telegraphing punches.
They are telegraphing punches when their country is facing severe economic and
other problems. For ideological reasons — Xi Jinping is a Maoist at heart —
China's leader is unwilling to adopt those measures that would stabilize the
situation. Instead, he is pursuing strategies that are clearly making matters
worse.
It can be no coincidence that, as the country's economy deteriorates and markets
fall, China's external behavior has become even more belligerent. For instance,
Beijing, by interfering with Philippine vessels resupplying an outpost at Second
Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea, has been risking war.
As Xi's regime telegraphs punches, President Joe Biden appears oblivious. On
September 10 while in Vietnam, he echoed Raimondo saying, "I don't want to
contain China."
Going one step further, Biden wished his Chinese counterpart well. "I want to
see China succeed economically," the president said.
Biden's comments are at best perplexing in light of both China's malicious
actions against America and his awareness that the country, as he proclaimed in
August at a Democratic Party fundraiser in Utah, is a "ticking time bomb."
"That's not good, because when bad folks have problems, they do bad things," he
noted.
Biden's administration, however, is not adopting adequate measures to defend the
U.S. in the face of such an evident danger. For example, National Security
Adviser Jake Sullivan on September 5 said the United States "should continue on
a course of 'small yard, high fence' set of technology restrictions focused
narrowly on national security concerns."
Sullivan and others are willing to impose, for instance, technology sanctions on
China, but they are largely ineffective. The general approach of the Biden
administration is to prohibit transfers of technology to military-related
parties in China — that's the reference to "small yard" — but allow transfers to
nominally civilian parties.
America cannot enforce Sullivan's "high fence," unfortunately.
Xi Jinping has a policy of "military-civilian fusion," which means that anything
a civilian organization possesses can be — and is — pipelined to the Chinese
military. In the Communist Party's top-down system, every individual and entity
in China must obey every Party order.
It's a warning to America: The just-released Mate 60 Pro smartphone of Huawei
Technologies contains chips from SMIC, Semiconductor Manufacturing International
Corp., China's largest contract chip-maker. SMIC sold those chips to Huawei in
violation of U.S. sanctions, including the Commerce Department's Foreign Direct
Product Rule. U.S. sanctions applied because the chips in the new phone were
made with U.S. technology. The U.S. Commerce Department allowed transfers of
American technology to SMIC on the condition there would be no transfers to
Huawei.
Why would Commerce ever think SMIC would keep that promise? The only realistic
solution is to treat all Chinese parties as one and to prevent tech transfers to
all of them.
Xi's regime is mobilizing all of the country's civilians for war. The Chinese
leader never misses an opportunity to talk about it. China's regime is clearly
planning to wage "kinetic" war — the type Americans are used to seeing in the
movies — on America.
Obviously, American parties, especially businesses, should not be enabling the
Chinese regime to kill Americans. This means they should not be engaging in any
transaction that can strengthen any part of China. We should think of all of
China as military.
Americans should take their enemy as it is, not the way they would like it to
be. So Secretary Raimondo needs to say that, yes, the United States will take
all measures to defend itself from China. And Biden must start telling the world
that China is America's enemy.
People's Daily in May 2019 issued a commentary titled "United States, Don't
Underestimate China's Ability to Strike Back." The Communist Party in that
commentary stated this: "Don't say we didn't warn you!"
Yes, Americans have been warned. All of China is one military machine, so it is
time to declare an American "people's war" on the Chinese Communist Party.
Gordon G. Chang is the author of The Coming Collapse of China, a Gatestone
Institute distinguished senior fellow, and a member of its Advisory Board.
© 2023 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
UNESCO Vote Highlights Continued UN Bias Against
Israel....Congress Must Block Funding, Biden Should Reconsider His Decision to
Join
Pete Hoekstra/Gatestone Institute/September 11, 2023
In one of the latest examples [of anti-Israel bias], UNESCO recently announced
it will designate the city of Jericho as a "Palestinian" heritage site.
This is a clear attack on Christians and Jews, who also view the city as an
important part of their cultural and religious history. The Biden administration
should object to this designation and protest UNESCO's clear bias strongly.
[A]s former U.S. Ambassador to the UN and former National Security Advisor John
Bolton advised in his strong article, "Biden's foolish rush to rejoin UNESCO has
nothing to do with China": "Congress should firmly block any UNESCO funding, as
it has consistently done."
Rather than building a culture of peace, UNESCO is perpetuating a culture of
anger and division.
By exiting UNESCO again, the U.S. would send a clear message that it will not
tolerate the organization's anti-Israel bias and that it will stand up to other
racist and anti-Semitic actions at the UN.
In one of the latest examples of anti-Israel bias, UNESCO recently announced it
will designate the city of Jericho as a "Palestinian" heritage site. Pictured:
Delegates attend the UNESCO Extended 45th session of the World Heritage
Committee in Riyadh on September 11, 2023. (Photo by Fayez Nureldine/AFP via
Getty Images)
Most people know the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural
Organization (UNESCO) through its eponymous and popular designation of UNESCO
World Heritage Sites. By UNESCO's own definition, "World Heritage sites belong
to all the peoples of the world, irrespective of the territory on which they are
located." But an impending late-September vote by UNESCO again calls into
question whether the organization holds to its stated beliefs or fits into the
broader pattern of anti-Israel bias that permeates the United Nations.
The clear bias of the UN against the State of Israel was on full display in
2022. The UN General Assembly passed 28 resolutions criticizing countries. Of
these resolutions, 15 criticized Israel, while only 13 were critical of all the
other countries around the world combined. In a world beset by conflict, with a
war in Ukraine, genocide against the Uyghurs in China, violence in Myanmar, the
Taliban horrors in Afghanistan, instability in the Sahel, military infighting in
the Sudan, and gang violence in Haiti, among the many global hotspots, Israel
being the primary focus of UN criticism is totally inappropriate.
The Biden administration correctly highlighted this bias early on. In 2021, U.S.
Ambassador to the UN Linda Thomas-Greenfield, addressing the UN Security
Council, stated:
"Israelis also shared with me their concern that the United Nations is
intrinsically biased against Israel. They interpret the overwhelming focus on
Israel in this body as a denial of Israel's right to exist and an unfair focus
on this one country – and they are correct."
Given the bias evidenced in the UN General Assembly and at the UN Security
Council, it should not come as a surprise to find anti-Israel bias at other UN
organizations such as UNESCO. In one of the latest examples, UNESCO recently
announced it will designate the city of Jericho as a "Palestinian" heritage
site. This is a clear attack on Christians and Jews, who also view the city as
an important part of their cultural and religious history. The Biden
administration should object to this designation and protest UNESCO's clear bias
strongly.
In addition, as former U.S. Ambassador to the UN and former National Security
Advisor John Bolton advised in his strong article, "Biden's foolish rush to
rejoin UNESCO has nothing to do with China": "Congress should firmly block any
UNESCO funding, as it has consistently done."
In 2017, UNESCO designated the city of Hebron as a "Palestinian World Heritage
site." As part of the Hebron designation, UNESCO labeled the Ibrahimi Mosque,
also known as the Tomb of the Patriarchs, as a site being "at risk." Designating
a site as "at risk" is meant to highlight a concern that sites are in danger of
damage, and maybe even loss. The U.S. objected to the "at risk" designation,
noting it called into question the seriousness of such assessments.
The Tomb of the Patriarchs is the burial site of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and a
site that is holy to Muslims, Christians and Jews alike. Given that the location
is revered by all three religions, the specificity of the designation was a
clear affront to Christians and Jews who also hold the site as sacred.
UNESCO's actions only serve to further inflame tensions in the area. Whether it
is the 2017 Hebron designations or the more recent plan to designate Jericho,
the moves clearly go against UNESCO's own stated mission:
"UNESCO's mission is to contribute to the building of a culture of peace, the
eradication of poverty, sustainable development and intercultural dialogue
through education, the sciences, culture, communication and information."
Let us put emphasis on the first part of that mission, "to contribute to the
building of a culture of peace." Creating turmoil over sites like Jericho and
Hebron does exactly the opposite. It transforms these historical sites into
political footballs and even sites of violence. Rather than highlighting the
opportunity for these major faiths — Islam, Judaism, and Christianity — to work
together to honor and preserve these important locations, UNESCO has put these
sites into the crosshairs of today's political disagreements. Rather than
building a culture of peace, it is perpetuating a culture of anger and division.
The U.S. has responded in the past to the blatant politically divisive positions
of the UN and UNESCO and the Biden administration should consider doing the
same. In 1984, President Ronald Reagan withdrew the U.S. from UNESCO because of
its political bias and perceived mismanagement. The U.S. and Israel stopped
financing UNESCO after it voted to include "Palestine" as a member state in
2011. In 2017, President Donald Trump filed notice that the U.S. was quitting
UNESCO because of its anti-Israel bias, a move that became effective in 2019.
President Joe Biden made the poorly-timed decision to rejoin UNESCO in July
2023. Given the pending vote by UNESCO regarding Jericho becoming a "Palestinian
heritage site," the Biden administration should reconsider its decision to
rejoin the organization. This is an in-your-face decision by UNESCO to the U.S.
that will only increase tensions and undercut the very foundation of UNESCO's
mission. By exiting UNESCO again, the U.S. would send a clear message that it
will not tolerate the organization's anti-Israel bias and that it will stand up
to other racist and anti-Semitic actions at the UN.
*Peter Hoekstra is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at Gatestone Institute. He was
US Ambassador to the Netherlands during the Trump administration. He also served
18 years in the U.S. House of Representatives representing the Second District
of Michigan and served as Chairman and Ranking Member of the House Intelligence
Committee.
© 2023 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.