English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For November 08/2023
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2023/english.november08.23.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
15 ÂÐÇÑ/2023
Bible Quotations For
today
They do not belong to the world, just as I do not belong to the world.
Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth
Holy Gospel of Jesus Christ according to Saint John 17/14-19/:”I
have given them your word, and the world has hated them because they do not
belong to the world, just as I do not belong to the world. I am not asking
you to take them out of the world, but I ask you to protect them from the
evil one. They do not belong to the world, just as I do not belong to the
world. Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth. As you have sent me
into the world, so I have sent them into the world. And for their sakes I
sanctify myself, so that they also may be sanctified in truth.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published
on November 07-08/2023
There is no difference between who calls for throwing Israel into the sea
and chants death to Israel and America, and who advocates for dropping a nuclear
bomb on Gaza/Elias Bejjani/November 05/2023
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu: We won’t accept reality of Hezbollah
rocket attacks
Netanyahu: Hezbollah's choice of war would be a costly mistake
Gallant says Israel doesn't have any intention to fight a war against Hezbollah
Hochstein visits Beirut, calls for 'restoring calm' on southern border
US envoy Hochstein's visit to Lebanon: A message of stability
US envoy Hochstein calls for calm in South Lebanon
Army chief discusses with Hochstein developments olong southern border
Israel discusses 'mechanism' to avoid war on Lebanon front
Hezbollah fires rockets at Golan in response to Iqlim al-Tuffah strike
How Hezbollah became a critical player in the Israel-Hamas war
Contacts intensify with Lebanon in bid to contain border tensions
Report: US not opposed to appointment of army chief of staff
Three children and grandmother killed in Israeli strike laid to rest
Israel-Hezbollah border skirmishes: Latest developments
Middle East Airlines: Operating additional flights to Riyadh and Jeddah
Nabil Amr to LBCI: The liberation organization is the only legitimate place for
Palestinians
Kataeb Party calls for fortifying country, emphasizes urgent need to restore
institutions
Berri follows up on south Lebanon situation with Mikati, broaches developments
with US envoy Hochstein, meets former Vice Speaker Ferzli
Hezbollah MP: group will respond 'double' over Lebanese civilians hurt
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News published
on November 07-08/2023
One month on, what we know about the Israel-Hamas war
10 Things to Know About Hamas Tunnels
Israel fights Hamas deep in Gaza City and foresees control of enclave’s security
after war
Israeli military says its ground forces are battling Hamas 'in the depths' of
Gaza City
Israel open to 'little pauses' as it bombards Gaza
One month into Israel-Hamas war, more than 10,000 killed in Gaza, almost 1.5
million displaced
Israel advances rapidly in Gaza, but eliminating Hamas leaders to take time
New attacks hit US bases in Iraq, Syria as Iran ups threats over Gaza
Iran's Khamenei urges Iraq PM to pressure US over Gaza
The world is turning against Israel’s war in Gaza – and many Israelis don’t
understand why
An American nurse who was evacuated from Gaza describes the hospital staff who
stayed behind: 'We're going to die saving as many people as we can'
Cyprus has a plan for a humanitarian sea corridor to Gaza and will present it to
EU leaders
Jewish man dies after altercation at Israel-Palestine protest
Armed drones shot down over Iraq airport where US forces based
NATO announces formal suspension of Cold War-era security treaty after Russia's
pullout
Al-Mayadeen reporter files complaint against Israeli journalist who
'intimidated' her
Titles For The Latest English LCCC analysis &
editorials from miscellaneous sources published
on November 07-08/2023
Jewish Americans, motivated by 'duty to protect Israel,' head overseas to fight
Hamas/Phaedra Trethan, USA TODAY/November 7, 2023
I’m an expert in urban warfare. Israel is upholding the laws of war/ John
Spencer/CNN/November 07/2023
What I’ve learned since the attacks on Israel: people don’t deem Jews worthy of
solidarity and empathy/Danny Cohen/The Telegraph/November 7, 2023
Today's Nazis Are Hamas/Alan M. Dershowitz/Gatestone Institute/November 07/2023
Gaza: Are there any winners?/Faisal J. Abbas/Arab News/November 07, 2023
How will the Israel-Gaza war end?/Abdulrahman Al-Rashed/Arab News/November 07,
2023
America’s indifference on Gaza creates watershed moment in Arab-US ties/Osama
Al-Sharif/Arab News/November 07, 2023
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published
on November 07-08/2023
There is no difference between who calls for throwing Israel into the sea and
chants death to Israel and America, and who advocates for dropping a nuclear
bomb on Gaza.
Elias Bejjani/November 05/2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/123949/123949/
It is essential and a moral duty to condemn the bizarre statement of the Israeli
Minister of Heritage, Amihai Eliyahu, in which he called for dropping a nuclear
bomb on Gaza. This unethical and criminal statement raises significant and
serious concerns due to the dangerous ideas and kind of hostile culture it
represents and advocates for, as well as its negative impact on peace,
stability, and the acceptance of the different other in the Middle East region.
Meanwhile, we must focus on this provocative and blind hostile rhetoric from its
cultural and ethical aspects, and everything related to human dignity and the
right to a free and dignified life for each and every person all over the world
First, it must be pointed out that the use of nuclear weapons is an inhumane and
criminal option and is irresponsible, with potentially dire consequences for
civilians and the environment, and because it direly violates human values and
principles. This makes it imperative that security and defense strategies in all
countries of the world be cautious, moderate, and far from such an option, which
necessitates a continuous search for diplomatic and peaceful solutions in a bid
to resolve conflicts, especially the complex Arab-Israeli conflict.
Second, the elements of fanaticism, recklessness, hatred, and the desire to kill
the different other are qualities that do not foster the necessary constructive
components of dialogue and understanding required to resolve conflicts in the
Middle East countries. Therefore, it is necessary for leaders and officials in
Arab countries, Israel, and the rest of the free world to work on achieving
communication and opening channels of dialogue with all relevant parties to
avoid wars, violence, and to promote peace and stability.
Third, it is vital not to view any such atrocity with one eye, and focus solely
on criticizing the inhumane statement of the Israeli minister, which, in
practice and reality, is not significantly different from the barbarism,
hostility, and fundamentalism of those who adopt and promote slogans calling for
“death to America and Israel”, and openly call for the annihilating of Israel
and throwing it into the sea, as is evident in the discourse and culture of the
Iranian regime and its proxy armed-terrorist militias in Lebanon, Syria, Yemen,
Gaza, Iraq, and many other third-world countries. As well as the fundamentalist,
Jihadist, and political Islamic groups, such as the Muslim Brotherhood, Boko
Haram, and dozens of alike terrorist organizations that share the same Jihadist
Iranian-Mullahs’ culture and agenda.
In conclusion, there is no credibility in any criticism of the extremist and
fundamentalist statement of the Israeli minister, while ignoring the culture and
depravity of those who call for throwing Israel into the sea, view America and
Israel as demons, and openly expressing their hatred and hostility towards them.
It is worth mentioning, that the language of violence and killing the different
other does not serve the interests of any party, and does not help in resolving
conflicts, in a civilized, peaceful, and constructive manner, whether large or
small.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu: We won’t
accept reality of Hezbollah rocket attacks
Jerusalem Post/November 07/2023
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu warned Hezbollah against attacking Israel as
he touted the IDF’s success in Gaza, insisting that Israel won’t agree to a
ceasefire without the release of the hostages. “We will not accept a reality in
which Hezbollah or its henchmen Hamas-Lebanon will harm our communities and
citizens” on the northern border with Lebanon, Netanyahu stated in a video
address to the Israeli public.He spoke as the IDF struck at Hezbollah targets,
after the Iranian proxy group fired 20 rockets at Israel from Lebanon on Tuesday
afternoon. “We will continue to respond with strong fire to any attack against
us. We have attacked many Hezbollah targets. We eliminated many terrorists,”
Netanyahu said. The Biden administration on Tuesday continued with its efforts
to contain the Gaza war and to prevent a two-front war that would include
Hezbollah.
US special envoy Amos Hochstein visited Lebanon in an effort to underscore that
message as he met with Lebanese officials, including caretaker Prime Minister
Najib Mikati. In Washington, US National Security Council spokesperson John
Kirby told reporters, “We have been trying to send a strong signal of deterrence
to any other actor in the region, be it a nation-state or a terrorist group,
that now is not the time to think about widening and escalating and keeping this
conflict.”
Regarding the Hezbollah rocket launches in the North, “that does not necessarily
mean that the war is widening and that these other actors have decided to go all
in to help Hamas out,” Kirby said. “We do believe we have sent a strong signal
about how seriously we take our national security in the region,” he said,
adding that the US has beefed up its military in the region. In Israel,
Netanyahu said in his video address, “If Hezbollah chooses to enter the war – it
will make the mistake of its life.”
In addressing the situation in the South, “The war in Gaza is progressing with
an intensity that Hamas has never known,” Netanyahu said. PM: we are increasing
the pressure on Hamas every hour, every day. “Gaza City is surrounded. We are
operating within it,” Netanyahu said, emphasizing that “we are increasing the
pressure on Hamas every hour, every day.”He repeated statements he had said
since the start of the war, that Israel would not accept any ceasefire until
Hamas releases the hostages. On Monday night, he did acknowledge that Israel
could consider a small tactical pause to the war for an hour or so, in an
interview he gave to David Muir of ABC’s World News Tonight program. “As far as
tactical little pauses, an hour here, an hour there, we have had them before,”
Netanyahu said.
“We will check the circumstances in order to enable humanitarian goods to come
in or individual hostages to leave,” he stated on Tuesday. Earlier in the day,
he spoke with US President Joe Biden about the possibility of such a pause to
the war, which was sparked on October 7, when Hamas killed over 1,400 people in
southern Israel and kidnapped over 240 others. According to the White House,
“The two leaders discussed the possibility of tactical pauses to provide
civilians with opportunities to safely depart from areas of ongoing fighting.”
Such pauses, the White House said, would “ensure assistance is reaching
civilians in need, and... enable potential hostage releases.”
Israel: any ceasefire must include release of all hostages
Israel has insisted that any ceasefire must include the release of all the
hostages, and that even then it could happen only with the understanding that
the IDF still intends to pursue its military campaign to oust Hamas from Gaza.
The United States has backed Israel on that point, but the two sides have
differed on a mechanism for humanitarian pauses, with Israel fearing that such a
break in the fighting could become a de facto ceasefire. Kirby told reporters on
Tuesday that the US had not put any redlines on Israel’s military operation in
Gaza. He noted that if anything, it has used only a small tactical force to
enter Gaza City. Netanyahu, in defending the continuation of the military
campaign, told ABC, “A ceasefire would be a surrender to Hamas. It would be a
victory for Hamas and you would no more have it than you would have a ceasefire
after the al-Qaeda bombings of the World Trade Center” in New York in 2001.
“There will be no general ceasefire in Gaza without the release of our
hostages,” he stressed. A ceasefire would hamper the “war efforts” as well as
efforts to secure the release of the hostages, he said. “The only thing that
works on these criminals in Hamas is the military pressure we are exerting,”
Netanyahu said.
PM: ground op created pressure to release hostages
“Until we started the ground operation there was no pressure on them to release
hostages. What we see is that the minute we started the ground action there was
pressure,” he added. Netanyahu also appeared to indicate that Israel might have
some intelligence on the location of the hostages. He also addressed the
civilian cost of the campaign to Palestinians in Gaza, in light of the UN’s
reporting that some 1.5 million of the 2.7 million people living in the coastal
enclave have been displaced due to the war. Hamas has asserted that over 10,000
people have been killed. Netanyahu said the number included at least several
thousand Palestinian combatants. “Every civilian lost is a tragedy. We are
fighting an enemy that is particularly brutal. They are using their civilians as
human shields,” he said, referencing the fact that Hamas places its
infrastructure in civilian areas. “It’s important to understand that there is no
way to defeat terrorists” embedded in civilian areas without incurring civilian
casualties, he stated. Muir also asked Netanyahu if he took responsibility for
the Israeli security failure that led to the October 7 attack. “The
responsibility of the government is to protect the people and that clearly was
not met,” Netanyahu said, but he added that the issue was best addressed after
the war. Netanyahu agreed with Muir that he needed to take responsibility but
not while conducting a military campaign. When the war is over, he said, “tough
questions are going to be asked and I am going to be among the first to answer
them.”In Brussels on Tuesday, met with Jordan’s King Abdullah and accused Israel
of disproportionally attacking Gaza. “Bombing down a refugee camp because it
allegedly houses one Hamas leader is completely disproportionate. It is never
acceptable that so many civilian casualties are caused trying to eliminate one
person,” De Croo said.
“Civilians and civilian places must be protected, but of course Hamas cannot use
them as a shelter either because that only complicates matters.”He also said
both Israel and Hamas disregard international humanitarian law on a daily basis.
He added that Hamas should also release as soon as possible innocent hostages,
saying it could be an important part of halting the “spiral of violence.”
*Reuters and Jerusalem Post Staff contributed to this report.
Netanyahu: Hezbollah's choice of war would be a costly
mistake
LBCI/November 07, 2023
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated that if Hezbollah chooses to
engage in war, it would be a grave and irreversible mistake. He further
emphasized that there would be no ceasefire until all hostages are released.
Netanyahu addressed the international community saying that "Israel's war is
your war, and if we do not win, you could be the next target."
Gallant says Israel doesn't have any intention to fight a
war against Hezbollah
Naharnet/November 07, 2023
Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant announced Tuesday that Israel does not
have "any intention to fight a war against Hezbollah." He however warned that if
Hezbollah chief Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah "commits a mistake" he will be
"destroying Lebanon."Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for his part
reiterated that Hezbollah would be making the "mistake of its life" if it joined
the war.
Hochstein visits Beirut, calls for 'restoring calm' on
southern border
Naharnet/November 07, 2023
U.S. mediator Amos Hochstein on Tuesday said "restoring calm on the southern
border" of Lebanon with Israel is "of utmost importance to the United
States.""It should be the highest priority for both Lebanon and Israel,"
Hochstein urged after meeting Speaker Nabih Berri in Ain el-Tineh after he
arrived in Lebanon on a surprise visit. "The United States cares about Lebanon
and the Lebanese people, especially during these difficult times," he said. "The
United States does not want to see the conflict in Gaza escalating and expanding
to Lebanon," Hochstein stressed, while calling on all parties to "fully
implement" U.N. Security Council Resolution 1701, which ended the 2006 war
between Israel and Hezbollah. Hochstein later met with caretaker Prime Minister
Najib Mikati and said that he has sensed from his talks that both Lebanon and
Israel do not want to escalate the situation. "Hochstein's visit was decided
days ago, specifically after the speech that was delivered by Hezbollah chief
Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah," MTV reported, noting that the visit is aimed at
"avoiding war, especially after the Israeli enemy's latest escalation through
attacking civilians, as happened on Sunday, which changed the specified rules of
engagement."
US envoy Hochstein's visit to Lebanon: A message of
stability
LBCI/November 07, 2023
Lebanese officials were informed on Monday night about the visit of the US
Presidential Advisor Amos Hochstein to Lebanon. This visit carried a message to
Lebanon emphasizing the implementation of Resolution 1701 and the prevention of
the full-scale war that erupted in Gaza from spilling into Lebanon. Hochstein
also highlighted that the United States is working with Israel to prevent the
situation from deteriorating along the southern borders, expressing condolences
for the Lebanese civilian casualties resulting from the Israeli attacks.
However, the Speaker of the Parliament, Nabih Berri, stressed to Hochstein that
Israel is the one violating the rules of conflict, citing the example of its
actions against a civilian family that led to the death of four civilians. He
also mentioned Israeli shelling in the Bekaa and Nabatieh areas, far from the
confrontation lines, and emphasized that the ceasefire is in Israel's hands.
Hochstein discussed all these issues extending from Gaza to Lebanon during his
meeting with the Caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati and in the presence of
the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Abdallah Bou Habib.
Furthermore, some sources suggested that the Americans reiterated the necessity
of controlling the situation along the southern border and not expanding the
area of tension beyond 2 kilometers, as well as controlling those who attempt to
expand this area from the Lebanese side, especially Palestinian factions. The
discussion at the Grand Serail also touched on the first day in Gaza after the
end of the war, and the Americans emphasized their desire for a situation that
does not allow a repetition of what happened on October 7th.
US envoy Hochstein calls for calm in South Lebanon
LBCI/November 07, 2023
US envoy Amos Hochstein called on Tuesday for a return to calm in South Lebanon
after a month of escalation between Lebanon and Israel, coinciding with the
ongoing war in the besieged Gaza Strip. The border region has witnessed an
exchange of shelling, particularly between Hezbollah and Israel, following an
unprecedented attack on Israel by Hamas on October 7, to which Israel responded
by intense bombing of Gaza. Following his meeting with Lebanese Parliament
Speaker Nabih Berri in Beirut, Hochstein stated, "The United States does not
want to see the conflict in Gaza escalate and spread to Lebanon." In a brief
comment to reporters, he added, "The restoration of calm to the southern borders
is of paramount importance to the United States, and it should be a top priority
for both Lebanon and Israel alike."
Army chief discusses with Hochstein developments olong southern border
NNA/November 07, 2023
Lebanese Army Commander, General Joseph Aoun, received, at his Yarzeh office, US
envoy Amos Hochstein, in the presence of US Ambassador to Lebanon, Dorothy Shea.
Discussions reportedly touched on the general situation in the country and
developments alongthe southern border.
Israel discusses 'mechanism' to avoid war on Lebanon front
Naharnet/November 07, 2023
The Israeli war cabinet has discussed a mechanism for avoiding being dragged
into wars on other fronts, specifically with Lebanon, Al-Jazeera television
reported. Israeli troops and militants from Lebanon’s Hezbollah and their
Palestinian allies have been clashing for a month along the border following the
start of the Israel-Hamas war. The deadly clashes have intensified since Israel
launched a ground incursion into Gaza against Hamas, an ally of Hezbollah.
Hezbollah officials have warned that if Israel kills Lebanese civilians, it will
retaliate by attacking civilian targets. Israel considers the Iran-backed
Hezbollah its most serious immediate threat and estimates that Hezbollah has
around 150,000 rockets and missiles aimed at Israel. The group also has
different types of drones and surface-to-sea missiles.
Hezbollah fires rockets at Golan in response to Iqlim al-Tuffah strike
Naharnet/November 07, 2023
Hezbollah said Tuesday that it fired rockets at Israel's artillery positions in
the occupied Golan Heights in response to an overnight Israeli strike on a
Hezbollah post on the outskirts of the town of Aramta in the Iqlim al-Tuffah
region. Aramta lies about 20 kilometers north of the border and is a Hezbollah
stronghold. The strike was one of the deepest inside Lebanon since the fighting
along the border erupted on October 8. In retaliation to Tuesday's attack,
Israel carried out a drone strike near a Lebanese Army post in Naqoura and fired
artillery shells at the al-Labbouneh forests south of Naqoura, at the outskirts
of Deir Mimas and at an open area between al-Ahmadiyeh and al-Dallafeh.
How Hezbollah became a critical player in the Israel-Hamas war
Associated Press/November 07, 2023
When Hezbollah announced last week that its leader Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah would
deliver his first public speech since the outbreak of the Israel-Hamas war, much
of the region held its breath. Would Iranian-backed Hezbollah, the Arab world's
most powerful paramilitary force, continue its limited exchanges of fire with
Israel or throw itself wholeheartedly into the war? In Lebanon, streets emptied
as people sat glued to their screens to watch, ready to parse his words along
with decision-makers in Israel and across the Mideast. Hezbollah has traded fire
with Israeli troops along the border since the day after Hamas' Oct. 7 surprise
attack in southern Israel sparked war in the Gaza Strip. Both sides have
suffered casualties, but the fear is that the conflict will escalate and spiral
into a regional fight. Nasrallah nodded to those concerns in his speech Friday.
"Some say I'm going to announce that we have entered the battle," he said. "We
already entered the battle on Oct. 8."But he stopped short of saying Hezbollah
would more fully join the fight.Here's a look at why Hezbollah and its leader
are key players in the trajectory of the Israel-Hamas war. "Iran's support has
helped Hezbollah consolidate its position as Lebanon's most powerful political
actor as well as the most equipped military actor supported by Iran in the whole
of the Middle East," Lina Khatib, the director of the SOAS Middle East Institute
in London, told The Associated Press.After Hezbollah fighters ambushed an
Israeli patrol in 2006 and took two Israeli soldiers hostage, Hezbollah and
Israel fought a monthlong war that ended in a draw — but not before Israeli
bombardment wreaked widespread destruction in southern Lebanon and Beirut's
southern suburbs. At the time, Israel's objective was similar to its current war
with Hamas: eliminate Hezbollah. Instead, the group came out stronger — not only
an armed force but also a key political party in Lebanon. However, domestic
opponents criticized Hezbollah for maintaining its arsenal and dominating the
government. Its reputation also suffered when it briefly seized a section of
Beirut in May 2008 after the Lebanese government took measures against its
private telecommunications network. Khatib likened Hezbollah to a "big brother"
of fledgling Iranian-backed groups that "do not enjoy the same level of
infrastructure or discipline."While Hezbollah is bound to Iran by doctrine, its
relationship with Hamas is based on pragmatism. The Palestinian militant group
was founded in 1987 as an offshoot of the Sunni Muslim Brotherhood movement. Its
political and financial backing from Iran and Syria did not pick up until 2006.
A schism erupted between Hamas and the Iranian-backed axis over the Syrian civil
war, where Hamas for some time backed Syria's largely Sunni opposition fighters.
Despite differences over Syria, "over the past five years, relations improved at
a fast pace," said Qassim Qassir, a Lebanese analyst close to Hezbollah.
Although many top Hamas officials lived in Qatar and Turkey, which backed the
Syrian opposition, the group's return to the Iranian fold put them in a tricky
situation. Some Hamas officials, including its second-in-command, Saleh al-Arouri,
have since moved to Lebanon, where they have Hezbollah's protection and a
presence across Lebanon's multiple Palestinian refugee camps.
HOW FAR IS HEZBOLLAH WILLING TO GO TO PROTECT HAMAS? -
For Hezbollah, fully entering the Israel-Hamas war would risk dragging Lebanon —
beset by economic calamity and internal political tensions — into a conflict it
can ill afford, fueling domestic opposition to the group. But staying on the
sidelines as Israeli troops take control of the Gaza Strip could compromise
Hezbollah's credibility, and a Hamas defeat would be a blow to Iran. Hezbollah's
steady pressure on Israel's northern border shows support for Hamas and keeps
open the threat of a wider intervention. Qassir interpreted the message behind
Nasrallah's speech as: "If you don't want the regional war to expand, then the
war (in Gaza) has to stop."But it's unclear how long Hezbollah can maintain this
delicate balancing act, with Israel seemingly determined to crush Hamas and the
Palestinian death toll in Gaza passing 10,000. "If there is a full collapse in
Gaza and things reach a point where they have to be fully involved, then they're
ready," Qassir said.
Contacts intensify with Lebanon in bid to contain border tensions
Naharnet/November 07, 2023
Western and non-Arab nations intensified their contacts over the past hours with
Lebanese officials in a bid to contain the tensions on the southern front with
Israel and avoid descent into a bigger confrontation, media reports said.
“These contacts expressed desire to preserve security and stability in Lebanon,
especially on the southern front, and carried a renewed U.S. assurance that
Israel does not intend to engage in a confrontation with Hezbollah in Lebanon,”
al-Joumhouria newspaper reported. Lebanese officials said that “Lebanon has been
and is still in a position of self-defense in the face of the continuous Israeli
attacks,” the daily said. U.S. mediator Amos Hochstein meanwhile held phone
talks with several Lebanese officials in the wake of Hezbollah chief Sayyed
Hassan Nasrallah’s speech on Friday, the newspaper added.
Report: US not opposed to appointment of army chief of
staff
Naharnet/November 07, 2023
The appointment of a new army chief of staff has become the most likely choice
to avoid vacuum in the army command after the expiry of the term of Army
Commander General Joseph Aoun on December 10, a media report said.
U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon Dorothy Shea has not insisted on extending Aoun’s
term although she has considered his departure to be a great loss, al-Akhbar
newspaper reported on Tuesday. Quoting informed sources, the daily said “the
Americans will deal pragmatically with the army command, the same as they
previously dealt with the vacancy in the central bank governor post.”The sources
also quoted Shea as saying that Washington prefers extension for the current
commander or naming a new commander, although it considers the appointment of a
chief of staff to be better than vacuum.
Three children and grandmother killed in Israeli strike
laid to rest
Associated Press/November 07, 2023
A Lebanese woman and her three granddaughters were laid to rest in their
hometown in southern Lebanon on Tuesday, two days after they were killed in an
Israeli drone strike that hit the car they were traveling in near the
Lebanon-Israel border. Hundreds of men and women marched before the four
coffins, which were draped in black and white banners as they were carried
through the streets of the village of Ainata. The coffins were later taken for
burial in a cemetery in the nearby village of Blida. Israeli troops and
militants from Lebanon's Hezbollah group and their allies have been clashing for
a month along the border following the start of the Israel-Hamas war. The
clashes have intensified since Israel launched a ground incursion into Gaza
against Hamas, an ally of Hezbollah. Large posters of Samira Abdul-Hussein Ayoub
and her three granddaughters — Rimas Shor, 14; Talin Shor, 12; and Layan Shor,
10 — were displayed in the cemetery in the southeastern town of Blida. The three
girls' mother, Hoda Hijazi, was wounded in the attack and is still undergoing
treatment in a hospital. Following the drone strike that killed the four,
Hezbollah said its fighters fired rockets toward the northern Israeli town of
Kiryat Shmona, killing one person. Hezbollah officials have warned that if
Israel kills Lebanese civilians, it will retaliate by attacking civilian
targets. "Protecting civilians is a main pillar of the rules of engagement with
the enemy," Hezbollah legislator Ali Fayad said during the funeral.
Israel considers the Iran-backed Shiite militant group its most serious
immediate threat and estimates that Hezbollah has around 150,000 rockets and
missiles aimed at Israel. The group also has different types of drones and
surface-to-sea missiles.
Israel-Hezbollah border skirmishes: Latest developments
Associated Press/November 07, 2023
Israel bombed Tuesday al-Labbouneh, near the southern Lebanese town of Naqoura,
and the outskirts of the southern towns of Mhaibib and Aitaroun, as two Iron
Dome missiles landed in an open area in the outskirts of the town of al-Tiri in
south Lebanon after a failed interception attempt. Meanwhile, Israeli media said
that Israeli residents of the Galilee Panhandle near Lebanon's border had been
asked to stay near shelters over a suspected security incident. "An IDF tank
attacked a terrorist squad in Lebanese territory that tried to launch an
anti-tank missile towards Israeli territory near the Shatula area," Israeli army
spokesperson Daniel Hagari said. He added that earlier today, Israeli forces
attacked a position of Hezbollah, "in order to remove a threat."Israel also
bombed al-Bustan and Yarin, after Hezbollah targeted the Israeli Birket Risha
post facing the two towns. On Monday, Hezbollah fighters attacked at least three
Israeli military posts along the border around sunset, while the military wing
of Palestinian group Hamas, the Qassam Brigades, fired 16 rockets from Lebanon
into the town of Nahariya and the southern outskirts of the city of Haifa in
northern Israel. Haifa is the furthest city targeted by rockets from the
Lebanese side since the start of the Israel-Hamas war nearly a month ago. The
Israeli army responded by shelling the origin points of rocket launches and
carried out airstrikes on “Hezbollah targets” inside Lebanon, according to
Israeli military spokesman Avichay Adraee. The clashes between Hezbollah and
Israeli forces erupted on Oct. 8, a day after the war started. The fighting has
been largely contained along the border but in recent days, as Israeli troops
began moving ground troops into Gaza, military activities have increased. The
violence along the border has forced thousands of people along both the Lebanese
and Israeli sides to move to safer areas.
Middle East Airlines: Operating additional flights to
Riyadh and Jeddah
LBCI/November 07, 2023
Middle East Airlines - Lebanese Airlines announced on Tuesday its plans to
operate additional morning flights, in addition to its existing evening flights,
to Riyadh and Jeddah in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Nabil Amr to LBCI: The liberation organization is the only
legitimate place for Palestinians
LBCI/November 07, 2023
Former Palestinian Authority Minister of Information, Nabil Amr, considered the
Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) to be the "sole legitimate
representative organization of the Palestinian people."Speaking on LBCI’s
“Nharkom Said” TV show, he stated, "I do not deny the role of Palestinians in
the deteriorating Palestinian situation, and I do not deny that the PLO has been
mistreated by its people before others mistreated it, and I do not deny that
there is clear fragmentation in Palestinian camps."He added, “When the PLO,
which used to be a unifying entity for the Palestinian people, disappeared, we
did not witness scenes like these.”He emphasized that the solution lies in
"abandoning intermediaries and contractors who are trying to unite us and
inviting us to their capitals as an investment in what they want. It does not
prevent Fatah, Hamas, and other factions from meeting and announcing to the
world that the PLO is the only legitimate place for the Palestinian people,” He
continued, “It does not prevent Hamas, Islamic Jihad, or any other faction from
maintaining their positions within this framework, and this does not harm
liberation movements. The solution is to hold a comprehensive popular conference
for all factions, declaring an end to the division."Amr said: "No one has not
invested in the Palestinian division."
Kataeb Party calls for fortifying country, emphasizes urgent need to restore
institutions
NNA/November 07, 2023
During its weekly meeting, chaired by Kataeb Leader MP Samy Gemayel, the Kataeb
Party's Political Bureau discussed the latest developments regarding the
expansion of the war zone, the targeting of civilians in Lebanon, Hezbollah's
insistence on tying Lebanon to the axis of resistance and the danger of the
vacuum in the army leadership.
Accordingly, the following statement was issued:
1- The Kataeb Political Bureau considers that the country is heading towards
increased danger due to the ongoing war in Gaza, saying that Hezbollah's
insistence on determining the country's fate and linking it to Gaza’s fate,
without any regard for the Lebanese people's will, threatens the country.
The Kataeb Political Bureau emphasizes the necessity of making a historic and
exceptional decision to protect Lebanon by deploying the army along the entire
border densely, preventing the violation of the south, safeguarding the country
and implementing UN Resolution 1701 in cooperation with international forces to
de-legitimize the claim that Lebanon is protecting the axis of resistance.
The Kataeb Political Bureau condemns the targeting of Lebanese civilians,
extending its condolences to the families of the innocent martyrs including
children and women.
The Kataeb Political Bureau warns against any escalation that Lebanon might pay
dearly for, urging the international community to fulfill its responsibility by
pressuring Israel to halt the massacres and urging Iran to stop exploiting the
region's peoples to serve its interests.
2- The Kataeb Political Bureau rejects Lebanon's remaining in limbo waiting for
the results of regional wars.
The Kataeb Political Bureau calls for fortifying the country against the
upcoming regional developments, emphasizing the urgent need to restore
institutions and ensure their proper functioning, starting with the election a
sovereign and reformist President to restore the state's authority.
The Kataeb Political Bureau considers that the expected vacuum in the army
leadership will push Hezbollah to tighten its grip on the country under the
pretext of filling the void.
The Kataeb Political Bureau stresses the necessity of adopting a solution within
legal and constitutional frameworks, considering that the available option lies
in postponing the army commander's retirement based a decision taken by the
defence minister (in accordance with Article 55 of the National Defence Act) due
to the failure to elect a President and the parliament's inability to legislate
since it is an electoral body according to Article 75 of the Lebanese
constitution.
The Kataeb Political Bureau holds the government collectively responsible for
any security vacuum that Lebanon might experience, urging to take the initiative
if the minister fails to fulfill his duties, based on the concepts of
exceptional circumstances (circonstances exceptionnelles) and the supreme
interests of the state (raison d’état), which allow the government to take
extraordinary measures to deal with exceptional situations or threats to
national security. -- Kataeb.org
Berri follows up on south Lebanon situation with Mikati,
broaches developments with US envoy Hochstein, meets former Vice Speaker Ferzli
NNA/November 07, 2023
House Speaker, Nabih Berri, followed up on the development of the situation in
south Lebanon, in light of the escalating Israeli aggression, as well as the
latest political developments, during his meeting with Caretaker Prime Minister
Najib Mikati, at the former’s Ain El-Tineh residence. On emerging, in response
to a question regarding scheduling a government session to extend the term of
the army commander, Mikati said: “Speaker Berri and I are very keen on the
military institution.”Speaker Berri later met with former Vice Speaker, Elie
Ferzli, over the current situation.
This afternoon, Speaker Berri met with US envoy Amos Hochstein, and the
accompanying delegation, in the presence of US Ambassador to Lebanon Dorothy
Shea. Discussions reportedly touched on the general situation and political and
field developments, in light of the escalating Israeli aggression against
Lebanon and the Gaza Strip. Following the meeting, Hochstein said, "I came to
Lebanon today because the United States cares deeply about Lebanon and the
Lebanese people, especially during these difficult times," adding, “We extend
our deepest condolences to the civilian lives lost in Lebanon, and today I had a
good exchange with the Speaker. I heard his concerns and I briefed him on what
the United States is doing to address them.”"The United States does not want to
see the conflict in Gaza escalating and expanding into Lebanon," Hochstein said,
adding, "Restoring calm along the southern border is of utmost importance to the
United States, and it should be the highest priority for both Lebanon and
Israel. That is what U.N. Security Council Resolution 1701 is all about and what
it was designed for. Let’s all use it and fully implement it."On the other hand,
Speaker Berri contacted by phone the family of the martyr Samira Abdel Hussein
Ayoub, offering condolences for her martyrdom and her three granddaughters in
the Israeli airstrike that targeted their car on the Aitaroun -Ainatha -Blida
road.
Hezbollah MP: group will respond 'double' over Lebanese
civilians hurt
BEIRUT (Reuters)/November 7, 2023
A Hezbollah lawmaker said on Tuesday that the Lebanese militant group would
respond "double" to any Israeli attacks on civilians after a strike that killed
three children and their grandmother in south Lebanon.
The remarks reflect the volatile situation on the Israeli-Lebanese border, where
deadly clashes between Israeli troops and Iran-backed Hezbollah fighters are
fuelling fears of a wider regional war while Israel invades the Gaza Strip. "The
resistance will respond double to any aggression that targets civilians," Ali
Fayyad said at the funeral of the four Lebanese killed in the south on Sunday.
"It hasn't yet shown all its weight," he said, referring to the powerful
Iran-backed group. He did not elaborate.
Lebanese authorities said an Israeli strike hit the car the family was
travelling in on Sunday. Israel's military said its troops engaged a vehicle in
Lebanon which was "identified as a suspected transport for terrorists" and it
was looking into reports there were civilians inside. At the funeral, the family
cried over four coffins draped in the flags of Lebanon and of a local scouts
organisation. A banner of the three girls, who were aged between 10 and 14, said
they were martyrs and featured the emblem of Hezbollah. Violence at the
Lebanese-Israeli frontier is the deadliest there since 2006 as Israel bombards
Hezbollah's Palestinian ally Hamas in Gaza - a response to an Oct. 7 Hamas
attack on Israeli towns. Hamas killed 1,400 Israelis, according to Israeli
figures. Israel's bombardment of Gaza has killed 10,000 Palestinians, health
officials in the enclave say. Israel said on Monday it struck Hezbollah targets
in response to a large barrage of rockets fired at northern Israeli cities. The
violence along the Lebanese border has killed more than 60 Hezbollah fighters
and 10 civilians, Lebanese security officials say. At least seven Israeli
soldiers and one civilian have been killed.
Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published
on November 07-08/2023
One month on, what we know about the Israel-Hamas
war
Nadeen Ebrahim, CNN/November 7, 2023
Editor’s Note: A version of this story appears in CNN’s Meanwhile in the Middle
East newsletter, a three-times-a-week look inside the region’s biggest stories.
Sign up here.
Israel and the Palestinian militant group Hamas are fighting a war that has
killed thousands and resulted in a devastating humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
The Israeli military began an offensive on the Palestinian enclave after Hamas
militants launched a brutal assault on Israel on October 7 – the biggest
terrorist attack in the country’s history – with gunmen killing more than 1,400
people and taking more than 200 people hostage, according to Israeli
authorities.
Israel’s retaliation has been fierce, with an air, sea and ground campaign on
Gaza as well as a total siege on the territory to choke its Hamas rulers.
The conflict has led to a humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza, with more than
10,000 people killed there, according to the Palestinian health ministry in
Ramallah. Residents of the Strip, which is home to more than 2 million
Palestinians, are trapped, lacking basic supplies and with nowhere to escape
Israel’s bombs.
In response, aid groups, Arab states and the United Nations have repeatedly
called for a ceasefire to allow for the delivery of food, water, medical
supplies and other necessities.
Israel has so far shown no signs of scaling back its military operation, which
is only widening, as it vows to eliminate Hamas once and for all.
Here’s what we know about the war.
How did the conflict start?
In an operation it called “Al-Aqsa Storm,” Hamas fired thousands of rockets
towards Israeli towns on October 7, before breaking through the heavily
fortified border fence with Israel and sending militants deep into Israeli
territory.
There, gunmen killed civilians and soldiers, and took more than 200 hostages,
including dozens of foreign nationals. The attacks were unprecedented in tactics
and scale, as Israel hasn’t faced its adversaries on its own territory since the
1948 Arab-Israeli war. It has also never faced a terror attack of this magnitude
that took the lives of so many civilians.
How did Israel react?
Israel responded by launching “Operation Swords of Iron,” with the goal of
eliminating Hamas. It imposed a complete siege on Gaza, blocking food, water and
fuel from entering, and launched a ground offensive that saw its troops enter
deep into the enclave and effectively split it in two.
Amid the bombardment, Gaza residents were advised by Israel to evacuate their
homes in the north and move southwards as troops sought to encircle Gaza City,
which Israel described as “the fortress of Hamas’s terrorist activities.”
Human rights groups have said Israel’s evacuation order could breach
international law, and CNN has documented instances when Palestinian civilians
were killed by Israeli strikes around evacuation zones.
What is Hamas?
Hamas is an Islamist organization with a military wing that emerged in 1987 out
of the Muslim Brotherhood, a non-violent Sunni Islamist group that was founded
in the late 1920s in Egypt. Hamas, like most Palestinian factions and political
parties, says that Israel is an occupying power and that it is trying to
liberate the Palestinian territories. It has over the years claimed many attacks
on Israel and has been designated as a terrorist organization by the United
States, the European Union and Israel. Unlike some other Palestinian factions,
Hamas refuses to engage with Israel and does not recognize its right to exist.
In 1993, it opposed the Oslo Accords, a peace pact between Israel and the
Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) that saw the PLO give up armed
resistance against Israel in return for promises of an independent Palestinian
state alongside Israel. The Accords also established the Palestinian Authority
(PA) in the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
Hamas seized power in Gaza in 2007, and presents itself as an alternative to the
PA.
Israel occupied Gaza from 1967 to 2005, when it unilaterally withdrew its troops
and settlers, but continued to exert control over the territory’s sea, airspace
and land crossings. The vast majority of Gaza’s residents are descendants of
refugees whose ancestors either fled or were forced out of their homes in what
is now Israel. The enclave is one of the most densely populated places on earth.
What is the situation in Gaza?
Before the war, Israel and Egypt imposed a blockade of Gaza that strictly
controlled the movement of people and goods both into and out of the territory.
But Israel has now imposed an even tighter siege, banning the entry of food,
water and fuel, which the United Nations has said amounts to “collective
punishment.” Residents are grappling with severe shortages and power is running
out as fuel dwindles, with hospitals ill-equipped to treat the wounded as Israel
continues its bombardment. Doctors often operate on patients without anesthesia,
and maternity and postnatal services are close to non-existent. As the water
system collapses, some Gazans have been forced to drink dirty, salty water,
sparking concerns of a health crisis and fears that people could start dying
from dehydration. The UN’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
has said that more than 1.4 million people in Gaza are now internally displaced.
More than half a million are seeking refuge in facilities run by the UN’s Relief
and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA), which are accommodating numbers
three times their intended capacity. Thousands of people are sheltering in
hospitals and other civilian facilities, which health workers say have been
targeted by Israel. The World Health Organization (WHO) has said that it has
documented at least 102 attacks on health care facilities in Gaza since October
7. Israel has said it is targeting Hamas operatives in the strip, and accused
Hamas of embedding itself in civilian areas, as well as using civilians as human
shields. Out of those who have been killed in the enclave, more than 4,100 are
children, according to the Gazan health ministry.
The enclave has been described by the UN as “a graveyard for children.”
What is the Rafah crossing?
Israel has shut its two border crossings with Gaza. And with aid desperately
needed, the only route for its entry into the territory is through the Rafah
Crossing with Egypt. Rafah is the sole border crossing between Gaza and Egypt,
falling along an 8-mile (12.8-kilometer) fence that separates Gaza from the
Sinai Peninsula. The crossing has been essential for the delivery of aid and
evacuation of wounded Palestinians during previous wars with Israel. Following
intense negotiations, the crossing was finally opened more than three weeks into
the war, allowing a small number of wounded Palestinians and foreign nationals
to leave Gaza. Aid trucks have started entering the enclave in very small
numbers
How has the international community reacted to the war?
The US has largely supported Israel’s operation in Gaza throughout the war,
despite heavy criticism from some opponents at home and mass protests across the
world calling for a ceasefire. Arab leaders have delivered strong messages to
Israel, especially against what they perceive as plans to expel Palestinians
from Gaza into Egypt, and those in the West Bank to Jordan. US President Joe
Biden has said that it would be a “mistake” for Israel to occupy Gaza, but
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that Israel will have the
“overall security responsibility” in Gaza for an “indefinite period” after the
war ends.
Some of Hamas’ allies in the region, such as Iran and Lebanon’s powerful
Iran-backed Hezbollah movement, have also warned Israel and Washington against
continued bombing of Gaza. Amid rising death tolls and an international outcry
over the humanitarian situation in Gaza, however, the Biden administration has
been warning Israel that its support for the carnage in the enclave is running
out.
What will it take for de-escalation?
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said his government opposes any
temporary ceasefire in Gaza unless Hamas frees all the hostages it holds, adding
that it will continue to block fuel from entering the strip. Netanyahu has
however said he is open to short pauses taking place.
Israel has accused Hamas of hoarding and diverting fuel. CNN cannot
independently verify the amount of fuel in the enclave. Qatar, a US ally that
maintains ties with Hamas, has been trying to mediate deals to free hostages, as
well as evacuate foreign nationals from Gaza.
Four hostages held by Hamas – two Israelis and two American-Israelis – have so
far been freed through Qatari and Egyptian mediation.
How likely is this war to escalate into a regional conflict?
The Hamas attack raised concerns that the conflict could spread across the
region, with the potential entry of Hezbollah from Lebanon as well as Israel’s
arch enemy Iran. The US has warned regional players against getting pulled into
the war, calling on Iran and its proxies not to escalate.
The US military has said that a guided missile submarine has arrived in the
Middle East, a message of deterrence directed at regional adversaries. The
Pentagon last month ordered a second carrier strike group to the eastern
Mediterranean and sent Air Force fighter jets to the region.Iran, which backs
Hamas, has denied involvement in the October 7 attack but has said that it
morally supports the “anti-Israel resistance” – which includes Hamas, Hezbollah
and other Iran-backed militias. On Israel’s northern border, Iran-backed
Hezbollah has engaged in an exchange of fire since the Gaza war began. Those
altercations have however been confined to the border areas. There have also
been skirmishes in Syria and Iraq, from which Iran-backed militias have launched
multiple drone attacks on US forces. Yemen’s Iran-backed Houthis have attempted
an aerial attack on Israel, which Israel’s military said it thwarted.In a
November 3 speech, Hezbollah Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah said his
“primary goal” was to achieve a ceasefire in Gaza, and said it was incumbent on
the US to implement the cessation of hostilities. The speech appeared to show
that Nasrallah’s immediate plans do not include broadening the conflict.
**CNN’s Abbas Al Lawati, Mohammed Abdelbary, Kevin Liptak, MJ Lee, Natasha
Bertrand, Priscilla Alvarez, Jennifer Hansler, Xiaofei Xu, Tamara Qiblawi,
Mohammed Tawfeeq, Kareem Khadder, Abeer Salman, Ibrahim Dahman, Akanksha Sharma
and Mostafa Salem contributed to this report.
10 Things to Know About Hamas Tunnels
DOWNLOAD INSIGHT/FDD/Novermer 07/2023
The terrorist organization Hamas operates an extensive and sophisticated tunnel
system to transport weapons, store supplies, and train operatives. The network
zigzags for hundreds of miles under the Gaza Strip and across the Egyptian and
Israeli borders. Tunnels can run up to 230 feet deep, about the height of a
20-story building. Iran-backed Hamas used tunnels to infiltrate Israel during
previous conflicts in 2006 and 2014.
1. Hamas tunnels span hundreds of miles in Gaza
The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) reportedly destroyed over 60 miles of Hamas’s
tunnel network during the May 2021 Gaza war. After the war, Hamas leader Yahya
Sinwar said that Hamas possesses over 300 miles of tunnels and that Israel had
“only destroyed 20 percent.” Israel often refers to the network as the Gaza
“metro.”
2. Hostages are believed to be held in Gaza tunnels
Hamas spokesperson Abu Obeida claims that the group is holding hostages in “safe
places and the tunnels of resistance.” On October 24, a freed Israeli hostage
recounted her experience in captivity, explaining that she was taken through a
network of tunnels akin to a “spider web.” The terrorists led the hostages to a
“large hall” and then separated them into smaller groups.
3. Hamas tunnels played a central role in the 2014 Gaza war
Israel launched Operation Protective Edge on July 7, 2014, in response to
repeated rocket fire from Gaza into southern Israel. On July 17, thirteen Hamas
terrorists infiltrated Israel through the cross-border tunnels, violating a
humanitarian truce. The IDF launched a ground operation that night “to target
Hamas’ tunnels that cross under the Israel-Gaza border,” according to the IDF.
By the end of the operation, the IDF had destroyed 32 tunnels. Israel proceeded
to build a 40-mile above and below ground barrier, which it completed in 2021.
The barrier includes cameras, radars, and sensors, and was designed to cut off
Hamas’s ability to invade Israel using its underground network.
4. Hamas tunnels are equipped with advanced technologies
Hamas tunnels are outfitted with telephone lines, electricity, and railways.
Hamas terrorists reportedly planned the October 7, 2023, attack over two years,
using landlines installed in the tunnels to communicate. According to IDF
estimates, each tunnel costs $3 million to build.
5. Hamas builds tunnels underneath hospitals, violating international law
On October 27, 2023, Israeli military spokesman Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari
shared evidence of Hamas hiding tunnel entry points inside Gaza hospitals.
Notably, Hamas also operates a large military complex underneath Shifa hospital,
the largest hospital in Gaza. International law prohibits such use of hospitals
for military purposes. A 1977 protocol to the Geneva Conventions makes clear
that “under no circumstances shall medical units be used in an attempt to shield
military objectives from attack.”
6. Hamas operates cross-border tunnels into Egypt to smuggle weapons and
personnel
The IDF confirmed on October 26, 2023, that Hamas used tunnels under the
Egyptian border to smuggle weapons and ammunition into Gaza before invading
Israel on October 7. The terrorists could potentially flee to Egypt using the
same underground network. Historically, smugglers have leveraged the tunnels
between Egypt and Gaza to transport drugs, money, and other goods into the Gaza
Strip. Hamas profits from the illicit trade by taxing commercial activity
through the underground network.
7. The Egyptian government has shut down numerous tunnels into Gaza
Former Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi, an Islamist affiliated with the Muslim
Brotherhood, tacitly allowed Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad to transport
missiles and other weapons using the cross-border tunnel system. Cairo started
to crack down on the underground network after current President Abdel Fattah
al-Sisi took power in 2013. To date, the Egyptian military has destroyed
numerous tunnels using a variety of tactics, including flooding them with
sewage. Nevertheless, Cairo has yet to completely shut down cross-border tunnel
operations.
8. Hamas operates cross-border tunnels into Israel
The most well-known case of Hamas using the tunnel system to breach Israel’s
border took place during the 2006 kidnapping of Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit.
Israel exchanged 1,027 Palestinian security prisoners for Shalit in 2011. Hamas
does not appear to have used tunnels to enter Israel on October 7. However, they
remain a tactical option as evidenced by Hamas releasing footage on October 14
showing terrorists emerging from tunnels, simulating an attack on Israeli tanks,
and returning underground.
9. Hamas diverts resources to construct terror tunnels
Hamas diverts concrete and other materials meant for civilian projects to build
and reinforce its tunnel system. Former Israeli National Security Advisor Maj.
Gen. Yaakov Amidror explained in 2014 that “when you look at what Hamas did with
all the cement and the materials that went into Gaza for ‘building,’ and you see
that most went on the tunnels, you understand that from their point of view the
civilian side is not important.”
10. Hamas used child laborers to build its tunnel network
A report published in 2012 noted that as many as 160 children had died working
in Hamas’s tunnel network. In a documentary produced that year, a youth laborer
said, “It’s a really dangerous job. We call it ‘graveyard of the living.’”
Israel fights Hamas deep in Gaza City and foresees
control of enclave’s security after war
KHAN YOUNIS, Gaza Strip (AP)/November 7, 2023
Israel said Tuesday that its ground forces were battling Hamas fighters deep
inside Gaza’s largest city, signaling a major new stage in the month-old
conflict, and its leaders foresee controlling the enclave's security after the
war.The push into Gaza City guarantees that the already staggering death toll
will rise further, while comments from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu about
controlling Gaza’s security for “an indefinite period” pointed to the uncertain
endgame of a war that Israel says will be long and difficult. Israeli ground
troops have battled Palestinian militants inside Gaza for over a week, cutting
the territory in half and encircling Gaza City. The army's chief spokesman, Rear
Adm. Daniel Hagari, said that Israeli ground forces “are located right now in a
ground operation in the depths of Gaza City and putting great pressure on
Hamas.”Hamas spokesman Ghazi Hamad, speaking on Tuesday from Beirut, denied that
Israeli forces were making any significant military gains or that they had
advanced deep into Gaza City. “They never give the people the truth,” Hamad
said. He added that numerous Israeli soldiers were killed on Monday and “many
tanks were destroyed.”
“The Palestinians fight and fight and fight against Israel, until we end the
occupation,” said Hamad, who left Gaza days before Hamas' Oct. 7 rampage in
southern Israel, which sparked the war.The Associated Press could not
independently verify the claims of either side.
Israelis commemorated the 30th day — a milestone in Jewish mourning — since the
Hamas incursion, which killed 1,400 people. About 240 people Hamas abducted
during the attack remain in Gaza, and more than 250,000 Israelis have evacuated
homes near the borders of Gaza and Lebanon amid continuous rockets fired into
Israel. A month of relentless bombardment in Gaza has killed more than 10,300
Palestinians, two-thirds of them women and minors, according to the Health
Ministry of the Hamas-run territory. More than 2,300 are believed buried from
strikes that reduced entire city blocks to rubble.
Around 70% of Gaza’s 2.3 million people have fled their homes, and many of them
are crowded into U.N. schools-turned-shelters. Civilians in Gaza are relying on
a trickle of aid and their own daily foraging for food and water from supplies
that have dwindled after weeks of siege.
FLEEING SOUTH
Israel unleashed another wave of strikes across the Gaza Strip on Tuesday as
hundreds more Palestinians fled Gaza City to the south. Some arrived on donkey
carts, most on foot, some pushing elderly relatives in wheelchairs, all visibly
exhausted. Many had nothing but the clothes on their backs. “There is no food or
drink, people are fighting in the bakeries,” said one man who didn’t want to
give his name. Hundreds of thousands have heeded Israeli orders to head to the
southern part of Gaza, out of the ground assault’s path. Others are afraid to do
so since Israeli troops control part of the north-south route. Bombardment of
the south has also continued. An Israeli airstrike destroyed several homes early
Tuesday in Khan Younis. An Associated Press journalist at the scene saw first
responders pulling five bodies — including three dead children — from the
rubble. One man wept as he carried a bloodied young girl, until a rescue worker
pried her from his arms, saying, “Let her go, let her go,” to rush her to an
ambulance. AP video at a nearby hospital showed a woman desperately searching
for her son, then crying and kissing him when she found him, half-naked and
bloodied, but apparently without serious injuries. A girl sobbed next to a baby
on a stretcher, apparently dead. “We were sleeping, babies, children, elderly,”
said one survivor, Ahmad al-Najjar, who is the general director at the Education
Ministry in Gaza. In the town of Deir al-Balah, rescue workers brought out at
least four dead and a number of wounded children from the wreckage of a
flattened building, witnesses said. “My daughter,” screamed a woman as she ran
behind them. Israel says it targets Hamas fighters and infrastructure and
accuses the group of endangering civilians by operating among them. At a school
in Khan Younis, thousands of displaced were living in classrooms and the
playground. One of them, Suhaila al-Najjar, said the last month had been filled
with sleepless nights. “What’s to come? How will we live? Bakeries have closed,
there’s no gas. What will we eat?” she said.
ISRAEL TO MAINTAIN CONTROL
Israel has vowed to remove Hamas from power and crush its military capabilities
— but neither Israel nor its main ally, the United States, has said what would
come next. Netanyahu told ABC News that Gaza should be governed by “those who
don’t want to continue the way of Hamas,” without elaborating.
“I think Israel will, for an indefinite period, will have the overall security
responsibility because we’ve seen what happens when we don’t have it. When we
don’t have that security responsibility, what we have is the eruption of Hamas
terror on a scale that we couldn’t imagine,” he said.
Netanyahu did not make clear what shape that security control would take. The
White House on Tuesday reiterated that President Joe Biden does not support an
Israeli reoccupation of the Gaza Strip after the war. “We do think that there
needs to be a healthy set of conversations about what post-conflict Gaza looks
like and what governance looks like,” said White House National Security Council
spokesman John Kirby, adding that he would leave it to Netanyahu to clarify what
he means by “indefinite.”Israeli officials say the offensive against Hamas will
last for some time and acknowledge that they have not yet formulated a concrete
plan for what comes after the war. The defense minister has said Israel does not
seek a long-term reoccupation of Gaza but predicted a lengthy phase of
low-intensity fighting against “pockets of resistance.” Other officials have
spoken about establishing a buffer zone that would keep Palestinians away from
the Israeli border. “There are a number of options being discussed for The Day
After Hamas,” said Ophir Falk, a senior adviser to Netanyahu. “The common
denominator of all the plans is that 1) there is no Hamas 2) that Gaza is
demilitarized 3) Gaza is deradicalized.”Israel withdrew troops and settlers in
2005 but kept control over Gaza’s airspace, coastline, population registry and
border crossings, excepting one into Egypt. Hamas seized power from forces loyal
to President Mahmoud Abbas in 2007, confining his Palestinian Authority to parts
of the occupied West Bank. Since then, Israel and Egypt have imposed a blockade
on Gaza to varying degrees.In his ABC interview, Netanyahu also expressed
openness for the first time to “little pauses” in the fighting to facilitate
delivery of aid to Gaza or the release of hostages. But he ruled out any general
cease-fire without the release of all the hostages.
HEAVY FIGHTING IN THE NORTH
For now, Israel’s troops are focused on northern Gaza, including Gaza City,
which before the war was home to about 650,000 people. Israel says Hamas has
extensive militant infrastructure within residential areas, including a vast
tunnel network.
The military says it has killed thousands of Hamas fighters. The Gaza Health
Ministry’s death toll does not distinguish between civilians and combatants —
and slain fighters not brought to hospitals would not be in its count. Israel
also says 30 of its soldiers have been killed in Gaza since the ground offensive
began.
Several hundred thousand people are believed to remain in the north in the
assault’s path. Residents in northern Gaza reported heavy battles overnight into
Tuesday morning on the outskirts of Gaza City. The Shati refugee camp — a
built-up district housing refugees from the 1948 war surrounding Israel’s
creation and their descendants — has been heavily bombarded over the past two
days, residents said. The war has also stoked wider tensions, with Israel and
Lebanon’s Hezbollah militant group trading fire along the border. More than 160
Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank since the war began, mainly
during violent protests and gunbattles with Israeli forces during arrest raids.
Hundreds of trucks carrying aid have been allowed to enter Gaza from Egypt since
Oct. 21. But humanitarian workers say the aid is far short of mounting needs.
Egypt’s Rafah Crossing has also opened to allow hundreds of foreign passport
holders and medical patients to leave Gaza.
Israeli military says its ground forces are battling
Hamas 'in the depths' of Gaza City
KHAN YOUNIS, Gaza Strip (AP)/November 7, 2023
The Israeli military said Tuesday that its ground forces are now fighting in
“the depths” of Gaza City. The comments signaled a new stage by the Israeli
military as it moves in toward what it says is the headquarters and stronghold
of the Hamas militant group. Speaking to reporters, the chief military
spokesman, Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, said that Israeli ground forces “are located
right now in a ground operation in the depths of Gaza City and putting great
pressure on Hamas.” Earlier, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu claimed Israel
was making great progress in its war, saying that the army has killed thousands
of Hamas fighters.
THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. AP’s earlier story follows below. KHAN YOUNIS,
Gaza Strip (AP) — Israel will take “overall security responsibility” in Gaza
indefinitely after its war with Hamas, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said,
the clearest indication yet that Israel plans to maintain control there one
month into a conflict that has claimed thousands of lives and leveled swaths of
the territory. In an interview with ABC News that aired late Monday, Netanyahu
expressed openness to “little pauses” in the fighting to facilitate delivery of
aid to Gaza or the release of some of the more than 240 hostages seized by Hamas
in its Oct. 7 attack into Israel that triggered the war. But he ruled out any
general cease-fire without the release of all the hostages. The White House said
there was no agreement on U.S. President Joe Biden’s call for a broader
humanitarian pause after a phone call between the leaders. The war has already
come at a staggering cost, and Israel unleashed another wave of strikes across
the territory Tuesday. Entire city blocks have been reduced to rubble, and
around 70% of Gaza’s 2.3 million people have fled their homes, with many heeding
Israeli orders to head to the southern part of the besieged territory, which is
also being bombed.
MORE THAN 10,000 PALESTINIANS KILLED
Israeli troops have been battling Palestinian militants inside Gaza for over a
week, and have succeeded in cutting the territory in half and encircling Gaza
City. Food, medicine, fuel and water are running low, and United Nations-run
schools-turned-shelters are overflowing. The Palestinian death toll has
surpassed 10,300, two-thirds of them women and minors, according to the the
Health Ministry of the Hamas-run Gaza Strip. More than 2,300 people are missing
and believed to be buried under the rubble of destroyed buildings, the ministry
said. The ministry does not distinguish between civilians and combatants, and
Israel says it has killed thousands of fighters. About 1,400 people in Israel
have died, mostly civilians killed during the Oct. 7 incursion by Hamas.
Israelis observed a moment of silence Tuesday in memory of the victims. The 30th
day is a milestone in Jewish mourning, and memorial events are planned in Tel
Aviv and Jerusalem. The military says 30 Israeli troops have been killed in Gaza
since the ground offensive began. In southern Gaza, where Palestinians have been
told to seek refuge, an Israeli airstrike destroyed several homes early Tuesday
in the town of Khan Younis. An Associated Press journalist at the scene saw
first responders pulling out five bodies — including three dead children — from
the rubble. One man wept as he carried a bloodied young girl, until a rescue
worker pried her from his arms, saying, “Let her go, let her go,” to rush her to
an ambulance. AP video taken at a nearby hospital showed a woman desperately
searching for her son and then crying and kissing him when she found him,
half-naked and bloodied, but apparently without serious injuries. A girl sobbed
next to a baby on a stretcher, apparently dead. “We were sleeping, babies,
children, elderly people … I’m not sure about their fate,” said one survivor,
Ahmad al-Najjar, who is the general director at the Education Ministry in Gaza.
In the central town of Deir al-Balah, rescue workers ran carrying a number of
wounded, dust-covered children and young girls from the wreckage of a flattened
building. “My daughter,” screamed a woman as she ran behind them. The number of
casualties in the strike was not immediately known. An airstrike destroyed a
home in the southern city of Rafah, killing at least five people, including
three children, according to the municipality and a local hospital.
ISRAEL TO MAINTAIN CONTROL
Israel has vowed to remove Hamas from power and crush its military capabilities
— but neither Israel nor its main ally, the United States, has said what would
come next. Netanyahu told ABC News that Gaza should be governed by “those who
don’t want to continue the way of Hamas,” without elaborating. “I think Israel
will, for an indefinite period, will have the overall security responsibility
because we’ve seen what happens when we don’t have it. When we don’t have that
security responsibility, what we have is the eruption of Hamas terror on a scale
that we couldn’t imagine,” he said. Netanyahu dd not make clear what shape that
security control would take. U.S. officials have advised that Israel should not
re-occupy Gaza. Israel withdrew troops and settlers in 2005 but kept control
over Gaza's airspace, coastline, population registry and border crossings,
excepting one into Egypt. Hamas seized power from forces loyal to President
Mahmoud Abbas in 2007, confining his Palestinian Authority to parts of the
occupied West Bank. Since then, Israel and Egypt have imposed a blockade on Gaza
to varying degrees. Israel captured Gaza, the West Bank and east Jerusalem — the
three territories that Palestinians want for a future state — in the 1967
Mideast war. It annexed east Jerusalem in a move not recognized by most of the
international community.
HEAVY FIGHTING IN THE NORTH
For now, Israel’s troops are focused on northern Gaza, including Gaza City,
which before the war was home to some 650,000 people. Israel says Hamas has
extensive militant infrastructure within residential areas, including a vast
tunnel network, and accuses it of using civilians as human shields. Several
hundred thousand people are believed to remain in the north in the assault’s
path. Thousands have traveled south in recent days on a corridor Israel has told
residents to use to evacuate. But many are afraid to use the route, part of
which is held by Israeli troops. Residents in northern Gaza reported heavy
battles overnight into Tuesday morning on the outskirts of Gaza City. The Shati
refugee camp — a built-up district housing refugees from the 1948 war
surrounding Israel’s creation and their descendants — has been heavily bombarded
over the past two days, residents said. Marwan Abdullah, who is among thousands
of people sheltering at Gaza City’s Shifa Hospital, said they heard constant
explosions overnight as ambulances brought in dead and wounded from the Shati
camp, about a mile away (1.6 kilometers). “We couldn’t sleep. Things get worse
day by day,” he said. The war has also stoked wider tensions, with Israel and
Lebanon’s Hezbollah militant group trading fire along the border. More than 160
Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank since the war began, mainly
during violent protests and gunbattles with Israeli forces during arrest raids.
Hamas and other militants have continued firing rockets into Israel, disrupting
daily life even as most are intercepted or fall in open areas. Tens of thousands
of Israelis have evacuated from communities near the borders with Gaza and
Lebanon. Hundreds of trucks carrying aid have been allowed to enter Gaza from
Egypt since Oct. 21. But humanitarian workers say the aid is far short of
mounting needs. Egypt’s Rafah Crossing has also opened to allow hundreds of
foreign passport holders and medical patients to leave Gaza.
Israel open to 'little pauses' as it bombards Gaza
The Associated Press/November 7, 2023
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Israel will have “overall
security responsibility” in Gaza “for an indefinite period” after its war with
Hamas and expressed openness to “little pauses” in the current fighting to
facilitate the release of hostages. His comments, in an interview that aired
late Monday on ABC News, offered the clearest indication yet that Israel plans
to maintain control over the territory that is home to some 2.3 million
Palestinians. Netanyahu ruled out any general cease-fire without the release of
the more than 240 captives seized by Hamas in its Oct. 7 raid into Israel, but
said he was open to “tactical little pauses.” U.S. President Joe Biden had
raised the need for humanitarian pauses directly with Netanyahu on a call
earlier Monday, but no agreement was reached, the White House said. The
Palestinian death toll in the Israel-Hamas war surpassed 10,000, including more
than 4,100 children and 2,640 women, according to the Hamas-run Health Ministry
in Gaza. In the occupied West Bank, more than 140 Palestinians have been killed
in the violence and Israeli raids. More than 1,400 people in Israel have been
killed, most of them in the Oct. 7 Hamas attack that started the fighting, and
242 hostages were taken from Israel into Gaza by the militant group.Roughly
1,100 people have left the Gaza Strip through the Rafah crossing since Wednesday
under an apparent agreement among the United States, Egypt, Israel and Qatar,
which mediates with Hamas.
Currently:
— Israeli military says it has surrounded Gaza City and is preparing for
expected ground battles.
— South Africa recalls diplomatic mission to Israel and accuses it of genocide
in Gaza.
— Majority of Israelis are confident in justice of Gaza war, even as world
sentiment sours.
— U.S. secretary of state ends Mideast tour with tepid support for pauses in
fighting.
— A U.N. official says the average Palestinian in Gaza is living on two pieces
of bread a day.
— Find more of AP’s coverage at https://apnews.com/hub/israel-hamas-war.
Here’s what is happening in the latest Israel-Hamas war:
GERMANY RELEASES $97 MILLION FOR UN PALESTINIAN REFUGEE AGENCY
BERLIN -– The German government says it is releasing 91 million euros ($97
million) for the U.N. agency for Palestinian refugees following a review that it
launched after Hamas attacked Israel. Germany on Oct. 8 suspended development
aid for the Palestinian areas pending a review, though it has kept up
humanitarian aid. The Development Ministry said Tuesday that it hasn’t yet
completed the review, but focused initially on U.N. agency UNRWA. It said that
“as a first partial result” it has decided to release 71 million euros already
earmarked for UNRWA and to add 20 million euros in new funding. It said that
funding, announced by Development Minister Svenja Schulze after a meeting in
Jordan with the head of UNRWA, will be used to help continue providing basic
services -– particularly drinking water --- to displaced people in the Gaza
Strip and help Palestinian refugees in Jordan.
BLINKEN SEEKS G7 CONSENSUS ON ISRAEL-HAMAS WAR
TOKYO — U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken shifted his intense diplomacy on
the Israel-Hamas war to Asia on Tuesday with an appeal for the Group of Seven
leading industrial democracies to forge a consensus on how to deal with the
crisis.
As he and his G7 counterparts began two days of talks in Japan, Blinken said it
was critically important for the group to show unity as it has over Russia’s war
in Ukraine and other major issues and prevent existing differences on Gaza from
deepening.
“This is a very important moment as well for the G7 to come together in the face
of this crisis and to speak, as we do, with one clear voice,” Blinken told
Japanese Foreign Minister Yoko Kamikawa. The devastating monthlong conflict in
Gaza and efforts to ease the dire humanitarian impacts of Israel’s response to
the deadly Oct. 7 Hamas attack will be a major focus of the meeting. Yet with
the Russia-Ukraine war, fears North Korea may be readying a new nuclear test,
and concerns about China’s increasing global assertiveness, it is far from the
only crisis on the agenda.
ISRAELIS OBSERVE ONE-MONTH ANNIVERSARY OF HAMAS ASSAULT
JERUSALEM — Israelis observed a minute of silence on Tuesday morning in memory
of the victims of Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on southern Israel and the 348 soldiers
killed since the assault, on its one-month anniversary. Israelis are marking the
anniversary as a day of mourning over the attack, in which more than 1,400
people were killed and 242 were taken hostage. The one-month anniversary is a
milestone in the timeline of Jewish mourning. Memorial events are scheduled to
be held in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem later in the day.
UAE TO ESTABLISH 150-BED FIELD HOSPITAL IN GAZA
DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — The United Arab Emirates says it will establish a
field hospital in Gaza with 150 beds, a surgery department and intensive care
units for adults and children. The state-run WAM news agency reported the move
late Monday, saying five aircraft had flown to Egypt, where the equipment will
be unloaded and transferred to Gaza. It says the hospital will be set up in
multiple stages, without providing an exact timetable. The UAE was the driving
force behind the Abraham Accords in which four Arab countries normalized
relations with Israel in 2020. The wealthy Persian Gulf country has previously
said it would provide $20 million in aid to the Palestinian people and bring
about 1,000 Palestinian children, along with their families, to the UAE for
medical treatment.
PAKISTAN SENDS SECOND PLANELOAD OF RELIEF GOODS FOR GAZA
ISLAMABAD — Pakistan sent a second planeload of relief goods for people in Gaza
on Tuesday, the Foreign Ministry said. It said the humanitarian assistance
consisted of hygiene kits, medicines and food. Foreign Minister Jalil Abbas
Jilani expressed Pakistan’s full solidarity with the Palestinian people and
condemned Israel’s bombardment of Gaza. He said Israel was targeting civilians,
including women and children, and demanded an end to the strikes.
SINGAPORE WARNS AGAINST DISPLAYING EMBLEMS LINKED TO ISRAEL-HAMAS WAR
Singapore’s government has warned that anyone who displays or wears emblems
linked to the Israel-Hamas war could be jailed, saying the conflict was an
“emotive issue” that could disrupt national peace. The Ministry of Home Affairs
said in a statement late Monday that Singapore’s laws prohibited the display or
wearing of foreign national emblems, including flags and banners of any state.
It also warned that promoting or supporting terrorism by exhibiting apparel or
paraphernalia with logos of terrorist or militant groups such as Hamas or its
military wing, Al-Qassam Brigade, will not be condoned. Those convicted face up
to six months in prison or a fine of up to 500 Singapore dollars ($370) or both.
Travelers who wear such apparel can also be denied entry into Singapore, it
added.
NETANYAHU SAYS ISRAEL OPEN TO ‘LITTLE PAUSES’ IN FIGHTING
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Israel was open to “little
pauses” in its fight against Hamas — although it was not clear whether some kind
of small stoppage had been agreed to or whether the U.S. was satisfied with the
scope of the Israeli commitment. U.S. President Joe Biden had raised the need
for humanitarian pauses directly with Netanyahu on a call earlier Monday, but
there was no agreement reached, the White House said. Lulls in the fighting are
being sought to facilitate humanitarian aid deliveries and the release of some
of the estimated 240 hostages that Hamas seized during its Oct. 7 raid into
Israel. Netanyahu, in an interview Monday night with ABC News, also said there
would be no general cease-fire in Gaza without the release of the hostages.
UNITED NATIONS FAILS TO AGREE ON RESOLUTION TO HALT GAZA WAR
UNITED NATIONS – The U.N. Security Council has failed again to agree on a
resolution on the Israel-Hamas war. Despite more than two hours of closed-door
discussions Monday, differences remained. The U.S. is calling for “humanitarian
pauses” and many council members are demanding a “humanitarian cease-fire” to
deliver desperately needed aid and prevent more civilian deaths in Gaza. “We
talked about humanitarian pauses and we’re interested in pursuing language on
that score,” U.S. deputy ambassador Robert Wood told reporters after the
meeting. “But there are disagreements within the council about whether that’s
acceptable.”Secretary-General Antonio Guterres earlier Monday told reporters he
wanted an immediate humanitarian cease-fire in Gaza and a halt to the “spiral of
escalation” already taking place from the occupied West Bank, Lebanon and Syria
to Iraq and Yemen. Guterres said international humanitarian law, which demands
protection of civilians and infrastructure essential for their lives, is clearly
being violated and stressed that “no party to an armed conflict is above” these
laws. He called for the immediate unconditional release of the hostages Hamas
took from Israel to Gaza in its Oct. 7 attack. China, which holds the Security
Council presidency this month, and the United Arab Emirates, the Arab
representative on the council, called Monday’s meeting because of the “crisis of
humanity” in Gaza, where more than 10,000 people have been killed in less than a
month.
PROTESTERS BLOCK ROAD AT US PORT AS MILITARY CARGO SHIP DOCKS
TACOMA, Wash. — Hundreds of protesters calling for a cease-fire in Gaza blocked
traffic on Tuesday at the Port of Tacoma, where a military supply ship had
recently arrived. Organizers say they targeted the vessel based on confidential
information that it was to be loaded with weapons bound for Israel. Those claims
could not immediately be verified. Police said no arrests had been made. The
Defense Department confirmed that the ship is supporting the movement of U.S.
military cargo. The Cape Orlando drew similar protests in Oakland, California,
on Friday before it sailed to Tacoma.
One month into Israel-Hamas war, more than 10,000 killed
in Gaza, almost 1.5 million displaced
Beatrice Farhat/Al-Monitor/November 07/2023
The Israeli war in the Gaza Strip, sparked by Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on southern
Israel, has entered its second month. The death toll has reached 10,328,
including 4,237 children, the Hamas-run Ministry of Health said on Tuesday. More
than 25,000 others have been injured, the ministry says, as the humanitarian
situation continues to deteriorate. The prospects of a cease-fire remain dim
after the United Nations Security Council failed again on Monday to agree on a
resolution on the Israel-Hamas war. "We talked about humanitarian pauses and
we’re interested in pursuing language on that score,” Washington's deputy
ambassador to the United Nations, Robert Wood, told reporters after the meeting.
Other council members are calling for a complete cease-fire. Almost 1.5 million
people have been internally displaced in Gaza since the start of the war,
according to the UN. Israel urged citizens to move to the southern part of the
Gaza Strip ahead of its ground invasion. The Israel Defense Forces said on
Tuesday that a corridor had been established for Gazans to flee and shared
videos showing groups of civilians waving white flags as they headed south.
"The IDF has once again opened a corridor to evacuate civilians from the
northern part of Gaza to the southern part," the IDF account posted on X. The
Hamas Information Ministry responded, "The [Israeli] army rounded up dozens of
Palestinians who asked to evacuate to the south and photographed them in a
humiliating way to argue there is a flow of refugees to the south.”Rights groups
have criticized Israel for failing to protect hospitals, schools and houses of
worship amid its heavy airstrikes. The UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine
Refugees said on Monday that 88 of its staff members have been killed since the
war started and 48 of its facilities have been damaged. UNRWA warned of a public
health crisis in its overcrowded facilities, where roughly 717,000 Palestinians
are sheltering. Hospitals and medical centers across the Gaza Strip have also
been subject to heavy bombardment. The World Health Organization said in a Nov.
5 post on X that it had so far "documented 102 attacks on health care
[facilities] in the Gaza Strip." On Saturday, at least 15 people were killed in
an airstrike on an ambulance outside Al-Shifa hospital, the largest in Gaza
City, according to the Palestinian Red Crescent. The Israeli army claimed the
ambulance was being used by Hamas operatives.
"The deliberate targeting of medical teams constitutes a grave violation of the
Geneva Conventions, a war crime," the Palestinian Red Crescent said in a
statement on X.
The IDF said in a statement that “a number of Hamas terrorist operatives were
killed in the strike,” adding, “We have information which demonstrates that
Hamas’s method of operation is to transfer terror operatives and weapons in
ambulances.”
UN Secretary-General António Guterres condemned the attack while renewing calls
for an immediate cease-fire. “I am horrified by the reported attack in Gaza on
an ambulance convoy outside Al Shifa Hospital,” he said in a statement. “Now,
for nearly one month, civilians in Gaza, including children and women, have been
besieged, denied aid, killed, and bombed out of their homes, "he added. "This
must stop."Israel has tightened its blockade on the Gaza Strip in response to
Hamas' attack. Since then, no fuel has been allowed into the Strip. A total of
569 aid trucks carrying food, water and medication have entered the enclave
since the opening of the Rafah border crossing with Egypt on Oct. 21, according
to the United Nations. On Tuesday, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker
Turk headed to Egypt and Jordan as part of a five-day regional tour amid the
ongoing escalation.
“It has been one full month of carnage, of incessant suffering, bloodshed,
destruction, outrage and despair,” Turk said in a statement, adding, “Human
rights violations are at the root of this escalation and human rights play a
central role in finding a way out of this vortex of pain.”
Israel advances rapidly in Gaza, but eliminating Hamas
leaders to take time
Ben Caspit/Al-Monitor/November 07/2023
TEL AVIV — The Israeli army has been advancing quicker than its own commanders
anticipated in encircling Gaza City and reaching Hamas headquarters, but
accomplishing the goal of eliminating the group’s political and military
leadership would take time, a commodity Israel is currently short of.
Taking into account American pressure for a humanitarian pause, Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu told American broadcaster ABC News on Monday that Israel
might agree to "small cease-fires, an hour here and an hour there," for
delivering humanitarian aid, emphasizing that a full cease-fire "will delay the
war effort."Israel’s vision of a knockout victory over Hamas is simple:
assassinating or capturing the organization’s entire military and political
leadership, killing all the planners and perpetrators of the Oct. 7 massacre in
southern Israel, eliminating all Hamas arsenals and firepower, and denying the
organization any ability to run the Gaza Strip or maintain its sovereignty
there.
'Give us time'
No Israeli decision-maker is willing to bet on how long it will take to achieve
such ambitious goals. Politicians and generals have been preparing the Israeli
public for a long war. When pressed, they talk about a month or two of
high-intensity warfare, followed by a force drawdown and continued operations in
Gaza to complete the tasks. This second stage would allow time to build a
mechanism for transferring control of the enclave to a third party. Force
commanders on the ground, some of whom spoke to Al-Monitor in recent days,
believe these goals are achievable: Give us time and backup, and we will do the
rest, they say. They will have their work cut out for them in convincing
Israelis that the Hamas threat has been eliminated. The Oct. 7 carnage destroyed
the nation’s collective and personal sense of security. Restoring Israelis'
self-confidence and convincing residents of the Gaza border communities to
return to their homes at the site of the worst civilian disaster to strike
Israel in its 75-year history will be a residual uphill battle.
The top brass says the war plan is advancing faster than expected, with forces
exerting unprecedented pressure on Hamas. Three divisions are currently
operating in Gaza with artillery, helicopter gunships, drones and fighter jets
backing up their advance every step of the way. The forces have encircled Gaza
City from the north, south, west and east, hemming in the Hamas command and
control centers located inside and below the beleaguered town. The Israeli
Combat Engineering Corps has been exposing and bombing every Hamas shaft and
tunnel along the troops’ advance.
According to the military, Hamas has so far avoided for the most part
confronting the troops head on, opting to exploit its advantage in ambushing and
attacking them from tunnels, and booby-trapping their route.
The number of Israeli casualties, as of now, is at the low end of the
preliminary estimates provided by planners. Based on similar battles fought by
US and other troops over the past decade — against the Islamic State (ISIS) in
Mosul and Raqqa, for example — the projections indicated a daily death toll of
four to 20 fighters. At the moment, the numbers are lower. On the other hand,
Hamas is not showing any signs of breaking and has maintained much of its
military strength.
"This will not end until we reach the command bunker of Yahya Sinwar and
Mohammed Deif," a senior Israeli military source told Al-Monitor on condition of
anonymity, referring to the top Hamas leader in Gaza and the chief of its
military wing. "It will be expensive and ugly, but we will not leave Gaza before
that happens."Hamas knows that ultimately it does not stand a chance against
what Israel describes as an unprecedented "rolling curtain" of artillery and
aerial fire.
This week, I visited the 162nd Armor Division, aka the Steel Formation, which
directs all the firepower at Gaza. A representative of the military advocate’s
office embedded with the unit approves the targets in accordance with the
international laws of war and intelligence information. The UN and other rights
groups have accused Israel and Hamas of not following international laws of war.
"We enter a new area only after the population has left and we have taken all
measures to get them to leave. We only strike targets used for terrorist
activity and Hamas operatives," one of the senior officers explained. "We
accompany the forces with a screen of fire and destroy everything that threatens
them, using everything the division has to offer, including close air force
cover."
In a clear indication of things to come, the military’s top spokesperson, Rear
Adm. Daniel Hagari, has repeatedly mentioned in his recent daily briefings that
al-Shifa hospital, Gaza’s largest medical facility, shields the underground
Hamas nerve center and military command. Reporters have also been presented with
video and audio clips, photos and testimony to prove that Hamas was launching
rockets at Israel from tunnel shafts located dozens of meters from the hospital.
Hospital compound not off limits
Military and security officials admit that Israel will eventually have little
choice but to roll into the compound and purge it of the Hamas commanders. To
that end, advanced discussions are underway on equipping field hospitals inside
or near the Gaza Strip, on the Egyptian side, as an alternative to al-Shifa
hospital. Jordan and the United Arab Emirates have already begun setting up such
facilities. Preparing public opinion for a potential operation at the hospital
site as the pinnacle of its war against Hamas, Israel has repeatedly insisted
that it cannot guarantee wartime immunity to hospitals harboring assailants.
A senior Israeli source told Al-Monitor that the Hamas leadership was mistaken
in thinking Israel would avoid the hospital compound. “Wherever Hamas is
located, we are allowed to harm it. This is a murderous ISIS-style terrorist
organization that commits horrific war crimes on a daily basis. They will not
escape punishment this time," he said speaking on condition of anonymity.
Israel has met the goals set out in its updated planning for the first stage of
the ground offensive, launched 10 days ago. The military estimates that between
1,500 and 2,000 assailants have been killed, including some 15 officers at
tactical command levels (battalion and brigade). Commanders are satisfied with
what they describe as almost perfect coordination among air, ground, naval,
intelligence and other support units.
But this performance does not diminish from the magnitude of the intelligence
and tactical failure that allowed some 3,000 Hamas assailants to slaughter 1,400
Israelis, and take back to Gaza more than 200 hostages, according to Israel
Defense Forces (IDF) estimates. The Hamas-run Health Ministry has claimed that
over 10,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza since Oct. 7. Israeli
authorities have raised doubts about those claims, but the war — now in its
second month — is the deadliest since Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005.
The military’s wish for time and patience should be addressed mainly to
Washington, where patience with the disastrous civilian death toll in Gaza is
waning. The demand for a humanitarian pause, already presented to Israel by top
American officials, is expected to intensify as early as next week. IDF
commanders say that Israel must find a way to persuade the Biden administration
to allow it more time as a prerequisite for a real and effective victory over
Hamas.
New attacks hit US bases in Iraq, Syria as Iran ups threats over Gaza
Jared Szuba/Al-Monitor/November 07/2023
WASHINGTON — US troops in Iraq and Syria came under a spate of new rocket and
drone attacks over the weekend, as the Pentagon sent an Ohio-class
nuclear-powered submarine into the region to join two aircraft carrier strike
groups in a bid to deter Iran and its proxies from exploiting Israel’s war in
Gaza.US troops at the Ain al-Asad air base in Iraq’s Anbar province and at three
separate bases in Syria have shot down at least six separate one-way attack
drones directed at their positions since Friday, a defense official revealed to
Al-Monitor on Monday.
On Sunday alone, US troops shot down drones in three attacks targeting the Ain
al-Asad airbase in Iraq and one each targeting separate US bases at al-Tanf and
Tal Baydar in Syria. US forces at al-Asad airbase shot down two attempted
one-way drone attacks Sunday morning and afternoon before responding a third
barrage of multiple drones and rockets Sunday night, according to the official,
who spoke on the condition of anonymity. Pentagon officials did not say which
groups were behind the latest attacks but have blamed Iran-backed militias for
previous such incidents, many of which have been claimed by a media front
associated with such militias. White House and Pentagon officials have said they
will hold Iran accountable for attacks by its proxies and reserve the right to
respond in self-defense.
No US troops were reported injured and no damage incurred in the latest attacks,
Pentagon press secretary Air Force Brig. Gen. Pat Ryder told reporters on
Monday.
Nor have any US troops been injured in the attacks since President Joe Biden
authorized airstrikes targeting two facilities used by Iran’s Islamic
Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and associated groups in eastern Syria on Oct.
26, one US military official told Al-Monitor. But the number of American
personnel reporting traumatic brain injuries resulting from prior attacks,
including two that hit the Ain al-Asad air base and the Al-Tanf garrison on Oct.
17-18, have doubled, the Pentagon revealed on Monday. A total of 46 American
personnel have reported injuries from those attacks, Ryder said, marking a
significant uptick in reports of concussive injury symptoms which were first
reported by Al-Monitor. In all, US troops in Iraq and Syria have come under
attack 38 separate times since Oct. 17, he said.
Coalition troops successfully thwarted most of those attacks thanks to "robust
defenses," the US defense official told Al-Monitor. Why it matters: Iran-backed
groups are threatening to increase their attacks on American troops in the
region as Israel’s war against Palestinian militants in the Gaza Strip grinds on
into its second month. The continued attacks suggest the militias are signaling
they do not intend to stand down. Asaib Ahl al-Haqq on Sunday released a
statement threatening to target the US Embassy and bases in Iraq. The so-called
Islamic Resistance in Iraq, a suspected media front for IRGC-backed militias in
Iraq, claimed on social media on Monday to have unveiled a new missile
resembling previously known Iranian models. Iran’s Defense Minister
Mohammad-Reza Ashtiani on Sunday publicly warned that Americans “will be hit
hard” if Washington does not “immediately halt the war in Gaza and implement a
cease-fire,” Iran International reported. President Biden and other US officials
have repeatedly warned Iran and Iran-backed groups not to launch opportunistic
attacks on US troops or their allies.
"We will continue to adjust our force posture in the region to make sure we can
protect our troops and our facilities on the ground and continue to send a
strong deterrent message," White House National Security Council coordinator
John Kirby told reporters on Monday.
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken made a stop in Baghdad to meet with Prime
Minister Shia al-Sudani, as Washington seeks Iraqi security forces’ support in
cracking down on the attacks. Blinken’s stop in Iraq, which came amid a wider
diplomatic tour of the region, was not announced prior to his arrival,
underscoring Washington's concerns about security.
What’s next: The White House on Monday confirmed the Biden administration still
does not support the prospect of a cease-fire despite increasing international
calls and repeated pleas by top UN officials. US President Joe Biden discussed
with Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Monday the potential for
implementing “tactical pauses” in Israel’s campaign to allow civilians to flee
and to bring humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip, Kirby said. “We believe we’re
at the beginning of these conversations, not the end,” Kirby told reporters
Monday. “In the early goings here, Israel was very resistant to humanitarian
assistance getting in at all.”Some 30 truckloads of humanitarian aid have
entered the Gaza Strip from Egypt via the Rafah border crossing since Sunday,
marking a total of 476 truckloads since Oct. 21 — which Kirby described as "a
trickle" and "not enough."
“I repeatedly made clear to Israel’s leaders that protecting civilians in Gaza
is both a moral responsibility and a strategic imperative,” US Defense Secretary
Lloyd Austin told Senate lawmakers last week, in reference to conversations held
during his Oct. 13 visit to Israel. Kirby on Monday seemed to suggested that US
officials have seen signs of Israeli forces attempting to minimize civilian
casualties, but he did not cite any evidence for the assertion. “We have seen
some indications that there are efforts being applied in certain scenarios to
try to minimize, but I don’t want to overstate that," Kirby said. Health
authorities in Gaza have reported more than 10,000 Palestinians killed in
Israel’s campaign, which began in response to an Oct. 7 terrorist attack in
which Hamas fighters killed 1,400 people across southern Israel.
Israeli forces on Friday bombed the lead ambulance in a convoy of five near the
al-Shifa hospital, the largest in the Gaza Strip, killing 15 people and injuring
more than 60, the Palestine Red Crescent said. Israel’s Air Force alleged the
ambulance it targeted was being used by "a Hamas terrorist cell," but had not
released any evidence as of publictation time. Know more: Read Suadad al-Salhy's
inside reporting at Al-Monitor on the rift between Iran-backed groups in Iraq
over whether they should get involved in the Israel-Gaza war.
Iran's Khamenei urges Iraq PM to pressure US over Gaza
Al-Monitor/November 07/2023
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said pressure must build on the
United States to end Israel's attacks on the Gaza Strip, his official website
reported on Monday. "The Islamic Republic of Iran and Iraq can act in liaison
and play an effective part in this regard," Khamenei told Iraqi Prime Minister
Mohammed Shia al-Sudani, who was on a brief visit to Tehran that was focused on
coordinating diplomacy at the height of the deadly Israel-Hamas conflict. The
Iranian leader renewed his condemnation of Washington's support for Israel,
saying the US government was "truly an accomplice to the Zionist crimes in
Gaza." He claimed that there was more than enough evidence proving that "America
was directly leading the war," without which Israel would be unable to press
ahead. The hard-line cleric called for urgent humanitarian help for Gaza and "an
end to the crimes by the Zionist entity." The Iraqi premier's visit also
occurred only one day after US Secretary of State Antony Blinken was in Baghdad
on an unannounced trip. Iran-backed Shiite militia groups have claimed
responsibility for a chain of attacks targeting US bases in Iraq and Syria over
the past two weeks. Those proxies, which Iran refers to as "resistance groups,"
had pledged to hit US interests if Israel refused to halt its attacks on the
Gaza Strip, which were triggered by Hamas' bloody Oct. 7 operation in southern
Israel. Reporting by Iran's state-controlled media did not highlight a link
between Blinken's visit to Baghdad and that of Sudani to Tehran. But Iraq's
Shafaaq news said Sudani was carrying messages to the Iranian leadership,
including a US warning to restrain the armed proxies. In Baghdad, Blinken had
already announced that the threats coming from Iran-aligned militias were
unacceptable and that "we will take every necessary step to protect our people."
Since the outbreak of the Israel-Hamas war, the United States has relentlessly
pushed to stop other actors from being dragged in. Iran has held the same
position in its official statements as well but has also warned that proxies
could be activated at any moment. Tehran also insists that the United States "is
not being sincere" in its overall stance on the Israel-Hamas war. At a joint
press conference with Sudani in Tehran, President Ebrahim Raisi said US
statements about efforts for humanitarian pauses in Gaza were "absolute lies."
Proof of that, according to Raisi, was Washington's veto at the UN Security
Council of an Oct. 18 draft resolution proposing a cease-fire. Separately,
Foreign Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian told Iran's state TV on Monday that
Tehran had received messages from Washington indicating that the latter was
seeking a "cease-fire" in Gaza. He said, however, that the US support for the
Israeli "massacre" was not in line with those messages. Meanwhile, a
spokesperson for the US National Security Council dismissed Amir-Abdollahian's
claim about the content of the message as "categorically false." In an interview
with CNN, the unnamed official said the message was indeed a warning to Tehran
not to expand the ongoing conflict. The back and forth continued as
Amir-Abdollahian declared on his X account that Tehran had indeed received the
cease-fire message. He called on the United States to give up "hypocrisy" and
put an end to what he called "the Gaza genocide."
The world is turning against Israel’s war in Gaza – and many Israelis don’t
understand why
Ivana Kottasová and Adi Koplewitz, CNN/November 7, 2023
Editor’s Note: A version of this story appears in CNN’s Meanwhile in the Middle
East newsletter, a three-times-a-week look inside the region’s biggest stories.
Sign up here.
Yoav Peled says he has started wondering if the world has gone mad.
Sitting outside the Kirya, Israel’s equivalent of the Pentagon in Tel Aviv,
Peled was cutting pieces of yellow ribbon off a large wheel last Thursday,
handing them out to strangers passing by. The bands symbolize solidarity with
the roughly 240 hostages held by Hamas in Gaza. It is this solidarity – and
specifically whether it still extends beyond Israel’s borders – that Peled was
questioning.
“I used to consider myself part of the extreme liberals, whatever they call
themselves. But when I see demonstrations with cries in support of Hamas and
stuff like that, I doubt that the world understands complexity … and when they
can’t understand complexity, they see this as a one-sided thing and their sense
of justice is very simple. But it’s not simple,” he told CNN. “I think the
governments understand this, but the people… I don’t know.”
As global leaders continue to pile pressure on Israel over the mounting civilian
death toll from its bombardment of Gaza and huge crowds gather for
pro-Palestinian protests in cities like London, Washington DC, Berlin, Paris,
Amman and Cairo – almost all in support of civilians in Gaza, rather than Hamas
– many Israelis are getting frustrated with what they see as unequal treatment.
It’s a feeling that cuts across the deep divisions within Israeli society: the
world does not understand us.
“The world loves us as victims. I’m sorry to say that, but yes, they love
Israel, they sympathize with the Jews when we are victims, when they kill us.
But when we do things to protect ourselves? No,” Sigal Itzahak told CNN.
A teacher at a religious school for girls, Itzahak brought some of her students
to the little plaza outside the Kirya where Peled was handing out the ribbons.
The spot has become a gathering place for the victims’ families, their
supporters, and well-wishers after the October 7 terror attacks.
Missing people posters and photographs of the victims are displayed on the wall
of the government complex, a seemingly never-ending row of smiling faces of men,
women, children, babies, soldiers, and, at times, entire families.
The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said more than 1,400 people were murdered in the
attacks. About 240 people were kidnapped and are believed to be held by Hamas
and others in Gaza. Four women – two Americans and two Israelis – have been
released, while one soldier has been rescued by the IDF.
“I think any country in the world that would find itself in our situation would
probably do much, much more and no one would say anything. It’s just the Jews.
Because the Jews are not entitled to live in a country in peace. That’s what we
want. And I’m sorry, but no one understands it,” Itzahak said.
Anger against Netanyahu
There is a lot of love outside the Kirya complex. Some people come here to pray,
hug each other, and spend time together. The group of students brought by
Itzahak came with dozens of freshly baked loaves of bread, a powerful and deeply
meaningful gesture in Judaism. But there’s also a lot of anger and frustration.
Most of it is aimed squarely at Israel’s embattled Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu.
Benny Zweig, a retired professor of sociology and political science, told CNN he
has been coming to the square to protest against Netanyahu since day one of the
war.
“Two shifts a day. From 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. and from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m.,” he said,
holding a sign depicting Netanyahu and other members of his government in jail.
Like many in Israel, Zweig is placing some of the blame for the brutal October 7
Hamas attack on Netanyahu. “We should have taken down Hamas a long time ago, but
instead Netanyahu started allowing Qatari money in,” he said referencing
Netanyahu’s decision to allow Qatar to transfer millions of dollars to Hamas-run
Gaza in 2018. “You’re not going to change a terror organization’s agenda with
money. Now, the price of taking them down will be much higher,” Zweig said.
It’s been a month since the attack and Ruby Chen still has had no news about his
son, Itay. The second of three sons, a former Boy Scout, and a fierce basketball
player, Itay was kidnapped on October 7. Like many of the families with loved
ones held in Gaza, Chen is pushing for the Israeli government to do whatever it
can to bring the hostages home. “It should not be the second co-objective of the
war. It must be the first, the second, and the third objective to bring the
hostages back,” he told CNN.
On Saturday night, Chen and hundreds of other family members of the hostages
gathered outside the Kirya to demand “greater actions by the government.”
They pitched up tents in the plaza, vowing to stay until their children,
siblings, parents, grandparents, and other loved ones were released.
The organizers of the event said it was not “an anti-government protest,” but
their frustration was clear. In the early days after the Hamas terror attack,
many of the hostages’ families were reluctant to criticize the government of
Netanyahu. That has now changed.
A strongly worded statement issued by the Hostage and Missing Families Forum
last week spoke of the “enormous anger” that the government was not speaking to
them about the operation in Gaza.
A tense meeting between Netanyahu and some of the families, led to further
heated exchanges, including a demand that the government should consider an
“everyone for every one deal” floated by Hamas in a statement the terror group
issued last week.
Such a deal would involve exchanging the hostages for Palestinians currently
held in Israeli prisons – some 6,630 people, according to estimates by the
Palestinian Prisoner’s Society.
It would be highly controversial because many of the prisoners have been either
convicted or held on charges or suspicions related to acts of terrorism.
The IDF dismissed the Hamas offer as a tool of “psychological terror aimed to
manipulate Israeli civilians.”
In October 2011, Israel agreed to exchange Gilad Shalit, an IDF soldier
kidnapped by Hamas in 2006, for more than 1,000 Palestinian prisoners, including
convicted terrorists who went on to carry out further attacks. Yahya Sinwar, who
heads Hamas in Gaza and was identified by the IDF as one of the masterminds
behind the October 7 attacks, was one of those released in the deal.
Chen said he still believes the government should do everything it can to secure
the release of the hostages. “I’m not in a position to understand the dynamics.
At the end of the day, we look at the end results … I still don’t know if my kid
is dead or alive. That’s the bottom line,” he added.
The families have said that no ceasefire should be agreed until all the hostages
are released. And the country is behind them. Anger about the government’s
response to the crisis is mounting even among some of the people who have
previously supported Netanyahu and his government. “I voted for someone else,
but I think he has done wonderful things for Israel, he was a soldier, he was a
courageous soldier, but he has been the prime minister for 15 years, so he is to
blame. And he has to go. I think everybody knows this and he knows it as well,”
Itzahak said.
Support for Netanyahu and his government has collapsed, with the latest polling
conducted by Tel Aviv University for Israeli media showing the vast majority of
Israelis want Netanyahu to quit. But while the government’s approval ratings are
nose-diving, the decision to launch a war on Hamas has firm backing from most
Jewish Israelis – despite the strong international criticism. And while most of
Israel’s Arab and Palestinian citizens, and a small minority of Jews, don’t
approve of the war, a wide-ranging crackdown on freedom of speech means that any
form of dissent against the war is risky.
Dozens of Palestinian residents and citizens of Israel have been arrested in
Israel for expressing solidarity with Gaza and its civilian population. Israel
Police said that as of October 25, it had arrested 110 people since the start of
the war for allegedly inciting violence and terrorism, mostly on social media.
Of these arrests, 17 resulted in indictments. Public displays of solidarity with
Gaza or criticism of Israel’s military response are few and far between.
Demonstrations against the war have been banned and more than 100 people have
been arrested for posting messages of solidarity with Gaza on social media.
‘Very fine line’ in criticizing Israel
“I am 22 and I’ve been to four funerals in the past four weeks, and two more
funerals in the past year, when two of my friends were killed in terror
attacks,” Yonatan Rapaport told CNN at Zion Square in Jerusalem city center on
Thursday.
A musician who recently finished his compulsory military service with the
Israeli Navy – including stints patrolling around the Gaza Strip – Rapaport said
he, too, was getting frustrated with the world’s reaction to the events in Gaza.
“When people ask, ‘why are you taking Gaza?’ what I don’t understand is – do we
not have the right to protect our civilians and soldiers? What is a
proportionate response? We try not to kill civilians,” he said.
“This conflict (between Israel and the Palestinians) isn’t black and white, but
this war (with Hamas) is,” he added. “There’s very valid criticism of the
Israeli government and Israel, but there’s a very fine line that has been
crossed in a lot of these conversations between criticizing Israel and hating
Jews. You can criticize Israel occupying the West Bank or Gaza, but you can’t
say oh, so because of that it’s okay to kill 1,400 civilians.”Rapaport said he
had criticized Netanyahu’s government before the war, opposing his plans to
reform the judicial system – a major fault line that has split the country.
“After the war, I think the whole government should go. But now… we are at war.
I don’t trust Netanyahu as a person, but I have to trust him as a leader,” he
said.
Later that night, Rapaport joined a large circle of musicians and mostly young
people sitting at Zion Square. They were playing guitars and singing classic
Israeli hits.
The songs ranged from sad to hopeful. Among them, “Lu Yehi,” a song inspired by
the Beatles’ song “Let It Be.” The ballad was written by Naomi Shemer in 1973,
during the first days of the Yom Kippur War, and has since become synonymous
with that war and hope for Israel’s victory.
On Thursday night, the song’s words rang out in Zion Square, almost exactly 50
years since its debut and with Israel once more at war.
An American nurse who was evacuated from Gaza describes the hospital staff who
stayed behind: 'We're going to die saving as many people as we can'
Katherine Tangalakis-Lippert,Kwan Wei Kevin Tan/November 7, 2023
An American nurse working with Doctors Without Borders has returned home after
working in Gaza. Emily Callahan told CNN some of her colleagues chose to stay
behind, knowing they may die there. "We're going to die saving as many people as
we can," Callahan said her colleagues told her. An American nurse who returned
to the US last week after working in Gaza told CNN on Monday that some of her
colleagues chose to stay in the region despite knowing they could be killed.
Emily Callahan, a nurse activity manager for Doctors Without Borders, had been
in Gaza since August. She was evacuated on Wednesday.In an interview with CNN,
Callahan described thousands of Palestinians living in unsanitary conditions
while grappling with attacks from Israel as the country wages war with Hamas.
"There were children with just massive burns down their faces, down their necks,
all over their limbs, and because the hospitals are so overwhelmed, they are
being discharged immediately after," Callahan told CNN's Anderson Cooper. "And
they're being discharged to these camps with no access to running water. There's
50,000 people at that camp now and four toilets, and they're given two hours of
water every 12 hours," Callahan continued. Callahan told CNN that one of her
colleagues, a nurse, was killed in the first weekend of counter-strikes after
Hamas launched a series of brutal terrorist attacks against Israel on October 7.
"He was killed when the ambulance outside the hospital was blown up," Callahan
said. When the evacuation orders to leave Gaza came, Callahan said she
immediately texted members of her hospital staff to see if they'd come with her.
"I said, 'Did any of you move south? Did any of you get out like, are any of you
coming down this way?'" Callahan said. "And the only answer I got was, 'This is
our community. This is our family. These are our friends. If they're going to
kill us, we're going to die saving as many people as we can.'"
Now, she said she worries every day about the safety of her colleagues."I wake
up every morning and I send out a text message and I ask, 'Are you alive?'"
Callahan told CNN. "And every night before I go to sleep I send another message
that says, 'Are you alive?'"Israel has launched a devastating and ongoing series
of airstrikes on the densely populated Gaza Strip since it declared war on Hamas
on October 8. On Sunday, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu brushed aside
calls for a ceasefire, saying it would not be possible "without the return of
the hostages."
Hamas has taken at least 242 hostages since it attacked Israel in October,
according to the Israel Defense Forces. Four hostages have been released by
Hamas, while another was rescued by the Israeli military. "We say this to our
friends and to our enemies. We will simply continue until we defeat them. We
have no alternative," Netanyahu told Israeli troops at an air force base in
southern Israel on Sunday. The ongoing war has resulted in civilian deaths and
injuries on both sides. More than 1,400 Israelis have died, while Gaza officials
say that over 10,000 Palestinians have died, with thousands more injured.
Cyprus has a plan for a humanitarian sea corridor to
Gaza and will present it to EU leaders
NICOSIA, Cyprus (AP)/November 7, 2023
Cyprus will present its plan for a humanitarian sea corridor to Gaza when the
Cypriot president meets other EU heads of state in Paris at an international
donor conference for the besieged Palestinian enclave on Nov. 9, an official
said Tuesday. Government spokesman Constantinos Letymbiotis told reporters the
initiative to ship aid from the eastern Mediterranean island will be discussed
at length during the conference, which will also seek to address Gaza’s pressing
needs including water, electricity and fuel supply. Last week, senior U.N.
officials said the average Palestinian in Gaza was living on two pieces of bread
a day, while only one of three water supply lines from Israel was operational.
More than 1.5 million Palestinians have been displaced in Gaza by the Israeli
offensive launched in the wake of Oct. 7, when Hamas attacked Israel, killing
1,400 people. President Nikos Christodoulides said Tuesday the initiative aims
for a “sustained, secure high-volume flow of humanitarian assistance to Gaza in
the immediate, medium and long term." Ships would deliver the aid to Gaza from
Cyprus’ main port of Limassol, some 255 miles away (410 kilometers.)
Christodoulides said his government is working with neighboring countries
including Israel, Egypt, Jordan and the Palestinian Authority as well as the US,
France, the EU and the UN to set the initiative in motion. To address Israeli
security concerns, the aid would be inspected at its departure point to ensure
nothing is delivered that Hamas, which runs Gaza, could weaponize in its war
with Israel. Hamas is on the EU and US lists of terrorist organizations.
Christodoulides met briefly with U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken on
Sunday at Larnaca airport, on the south coast of Cyprus, where they discussed
the initiative. “What I can tell you is the (Christodoulides-Blinken) meeting in
and of itself shows how much importance the U.S. also attaches to the Cyprus
Republic’s initiative,” Letymbiotis said.
Jewish man dies after altercation at Israel-Palestine
protest
The Telegraph/November 7, 2023
A Jewish man has died after suffering a head injury during a confrontation
between pro-Israel and pro-Palestinian protesters in California, police and a
Jewish organisation said. Paul Kessler, 69, died of blunt force head trauma a
day after the altercation on Sunday, the Ventura County Sheriff’s Office said,
adding that witnesses described the incident as battery. As of Monday night, no
suspect was in custody in what the sheriff’s office said “appears to be isolated
and not part of a large effort,” though it had not ruled out a hate crime. The
Jewish Federation of Greater Los Angeles identified the victim as a Jewish man
and labelled the incident as the fourth act of anti-Semitic violence in the Los
Angeles area this year and the second since Oct 7. Separate pro-Israel and
pro-Palestinian demonstrations occurred simultaneously on Sunday in the city of
Thousand Oaks, about 40 miles west of Los Angeles, the sheriff’s office said.
Mr Kessler was involved in a physical altercation between counter-protesters,
the sheriff’s office said, citing witness accounts. It did not specify which
side instigated the altercation. “During the altercation, Mr Kessler fell
backwards and struck his head on the ground. Kessler was transported to an area
hospital for advanced medical treatment. On Nov 6 2023, Mr Kessler succumbed to
his injuries,” the statement said. Deputies asked the public for help in what it
called “an active and ongoing investigation”. The sheriff’s office said it would
hold a news conference on Tuesday about the incident. The leader of the Jewish
Federation of Greater Los Angeles, citing conversations with local government
officials, said a pro-Palestinian protester had struck the victim on the head
with a megaphone.
Culture of real terror
Rabbi Noah Farkas, president and chief executive of the group, said
investigators have identified the person but that they have not made an arrest
because the inquiry was ongoing. “This is what’s happening in America right now.
There is a culture of fear and a culture of real terror against the Jewish
community happening,” Mr Farkas said. Mr Kessler, who was carrying an Israeli
flag at the demonstration, came from a family of philanthropists who were
devastated by his death, Mr Farkas said. The Los Angeles chapter of the Council
on American-Islamic Relations, a civil rights group, also expressed grief over
what it called a “tragic and shocking loss”, while also asking people to
“refrain from jumping to conclusions” or “sensationalising such a tragedy for
political gains”.
Muslims stand with Jewish community
“CAIR-LA and the Muslim community stand with the Jewish community in rejecting
any and all violence, antisemitism, Islamophobia, or incitement of hatred,” the
statement said. Emotions have run high in the United States over the war between
Israel and Hamas, with US officials and civil rights groups warning of increased
threats against Jews, Muslims and Arab Americans since fighting broke out on Oct
7. In September, an Illinois man was charged with hate crimes for stabbing a
6-year-old Muslim boy to death and wounding his mother in an attack that
officials said targeted them for their religion in a response to the war.
Armed drones shot down over Iraq airport where US forces based
CAIRO (Reuters)/November 07, 2023
Three armed drones were shot down on Tuesday in two separate attacks over Erbil
airport in northern Iraq where U.S. forces and other international forces are
stationed, Iraqi Kurdistan's counter-terrorism service said in a statement.
The attacks are the latest in a series on U.S. troops in Iraq and Syria as
tensions soar in the Middle East over the Israel-Hamas war. A group called the
"Islamic Resistance in Iraq" said it targeted Al-Harir military base, which is
about 70 km northeast of Erbil airport. The defence system at a military base
near the airport successfully defended against the drones, the statement said.
There were no casualties or damage to infrastructure, a U.S. Defense Department
official said. Coalition forces have been attacked at least 38 times since Oct.
17, most of these attacks failed to reach their targets, thanks to our robust
defences, the U.S. official added. Iraqi Prime Minister Mohammed al-Sudani has
pledged to pursue those responsible for recent attacks on three military bases
in Iraq hosting international coalition advisers, including Ain al-Asad in
western Iraq, a military base near Baghdad's international airport and Harir in
Erbil.
NATO announces formal suspension of Cold War-era security
treaty after Russia's pullout
BRUSSELS (AP)/November 07, 2023
NATO on Tuesday announced the formal suspension of a key Cold War-era security
treaty in response to Russia’s pullout from the deal just hours earlier. The
alliance also said its members who signed the treaty are now freezing their
participation in the pact.
Most of NATO’s 31 allies have signed the Treaty of Conventional Armed Forces in
Europe, which was aimed at preventing Cold War rivals from massing forces at or
near mutual borders. It was signed in November 1990, but not fully ratified
until two years later. NATO said its action was required because “a situation
whereby Allied State Parties abide by the Treaty, while Russia does not, would
be unsustainable.”Earlier in the day, Moscow said it had finalized its
withdrawal from the treaty, also known as CFE. The long-expected move came after
both houses of the Russian parliament approved a bill proposed by President
Vladimir Putin denouncing the CFE. Putin signed that bill it into force in May
this year. The treaty was one of several major Cold War-era treaties involving
Russia and the United States that ceased to be in force in recent years. Russia
suspended its participation in 2007, and in 2015 announced its intention to
completely withdraw from the agreement. In February 2022, Moscow invaded
Ukraine, sending hundreds of thousands of Russian troops into the neighboring
country, which also shares a border with NATO members Poland, Slovakia, Romania
and Hungary.
Russia's Foreign Ministry said the process of the formal withdrawal from the
treaty has been completed, without elaborating what that entailed. It blamed the
U.S. and its allies for the withdrawal and the West’s allegedly “destructive
position” on the treaty.
“We left the door open for a dialogue on ways to restore the viability of
conventional arms control in Europe,” it said. “However, our opponents did not
take advantage of this opportunity.”The statement further said that “even the
formal preservation” of the treaty has become “unacceptable from the point of
view of Russia’s fundamental security interests,” citing developments in Ukraine
and NATO’s recent expansion. In Brussels, NATO said that its allies who had
signed on “intend to suspend the operation of the CFE Treaty for as long as
necessary, in accordance with their rights under international law.” The
alliance underlined that its members remain committed “to reduce military risk,
and prevent misperceptions and conflicts.” NATO said that its members will
continue to “consult on and assess the implications of the current security
environment and its impact on the security" of the alliance.
Al-Mayadeen reporter files complaint against Israeli
journalist who 'intimidated' her
gence France Presse/November 7, 2023
A journalist with Lebanese Al-Mayadeen television channel has filed a police
complaint against an Israeli journalist who she alleged had "intimidated" her.
Hana Mohamed said Israeli journalist Haim Etgar confronted her at a post office
after allegedly impersonating a postal employee and "threatening" her.
"This is not the first time that this journalist has chased Arab journalists and
intimidated them," she told AFP. "When a journalist gives himself the authority
to question another journalist like a policeman it legitimizes racist attacks on
anyone," Mohamed said. Etgar posted on his Instagram account a video of him
following Mohamed out of the post office to her car, asking about her take on
the war, Mayadeen's coverage and accusing her of broadcasting "fake news," such
as that the Israeli army is using chemical weapons. "We tried to ask questions,
as always politely and without physical contact," Etgar wrote, alleging that
Mayadeen was affiliated with Hezbollah. "We didn't get answers." There was no
indication from police as to whether they were launching an investigation
following the complaint.
Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from
miscellaneous sources published on November 07-08/2023
Jewish Americans, motivated by 'duty to protect
Israel,' head overseas to fight Hamas
Phaedra Trethan, USA TODAY/November 7, 2023
A columnist with The Jerusalem Post and former deputy communications director
for Benjamin Netanyahu, Freund, like a lot of other Jewish Americans, was
horrified by Hamas' Oct. 7 attacks on Israeli border communities that left 1,400
people dead.
But there's something, or someone, else keeping him up at night. Five someones,
actually.All of Michael Freund's sons are serving in the Israeli military, a
conscripted military service made up of more than 169,000 troops.
"It's been a very difficult time," Freund told USA TODAY. "But I am very proud
of them for doing their duty to protect Israel, the land and the country and the
people."
It's unclear how many dual citizens and Americans are serving in Israel. The
Israeli military, Israeli Foreign Ministry, Interior Ministry and Prime
Minister's Office each told USA TODAY they are not currently tracking that
information. But Freund said the attacks ignited a collective sense of urgency
to unite against an enemy bent on Israel's destruction.
"It's a stressful time for everyone," said Freund, a New York native who lived
in Israel for several years before returning to the U.S. temporarily. "Everyone
knows someone or is within a couple degrees of separation to someone who was
killed or injured or kidnapped (on Oct. 7)."
American identities but a 'strong sense of civic duty'
Freund's sons grew up mostly in Israel and hold dual citizenship there and in
the U.S., where they would spend weeks each summer at camp and visiting family.
His youngest was already in the midst of his mandatory military service, while
his other sons are reservists who were called up after the Hamas attacks.
His sons are "all good baseball fans," said Freund, whose own Jerusalem Post
webpage notes his Mets fandom, "and there's a strong American element to their
identities."Two of Freund's older sons are married and one has a young child. So
worry about the five Freunds is by no means limited to their dad.
But asked if he felt any ambivalence about his sons' service, Freund didn't
hesitate.
"Absolutely not," he said. Serving one's country is "a duty and a responsibility
and in times of national crisis every person has to step forward and contribute
as best they can. I did what I can to raise them with strong sense of civic duty
toward their country and their fellow Jews."He also sees their commitment as
emblematic of a generation that gives him hope even in the midst of a conflict
with no easy end in sight. Israeli youths understand the stakes of the fight
against Hamas and "rather than running away from the danger, they run toward
their responsibility," he said.
"As much as they say a son looks up to his father, in this case, the opposite is
no less true."
A sister's service makes brother proud
Yosef Lazar said his sister, one of 12 Lazar children, was always "a very girly
girl."
But when she enlisted in the Israeli military at 19, he said, Sara Lazar became
a soldier's soldier, proud to be one of the few women serving in a combat unit.
Growing up in Brooklyn, Sara talked for years about going to Israel and joining
its military, her brother remembered. "But being my sister, I thought she was
nuts. Then at 19, she was like, 'OK, I'm going for real.'"Her family worried she
might come back a different person − tougher, perhaps, or hardened by the
military's demands.
"When she's in our house in America, she's always wearing jewelry and wants to
look her best," Yosef said. "But then there's this opposite side to her that she
shows (in the military)." Sara served 18 months in the Israeli military and came
home "still herself, that girly girl," said her brother, who recently moved from
New Jersey to Florida.
When Hamas attacked Israel, though, Sara was determined to go back, two years
after her initial service ended. "The second after our holiday ended, she was
ready to hop on a plane," Yosef said. "She was like, 'I'm ready to go and they
need me.'" He wasn't sure she was serious, but when the siblings connected, she
was already en route. Their parents initially tried to talk Sara out of going
back, worried about her safety. "Obviously, they're protective like any
parents," Yosef said, but they are still supportive. He's concerned for his
sister, too, but also proud. "When you tell your friends, my sister happens to
be in the Army, and they think she’s doing intelligence or in the kitchen and
then, here’s a picture of her in a combat unit. ... That's pretty cool."
Going not to fight Hamas, but to help Israelis
Michael Balaban lives outside Philadelphia and is a volunteer and board member
with the Lower Merion Fire Department's Penn Wynne-Overbrook Hills Fire Company.
"People are talking a lot about the war aspect," he said. "But there's a people
aspect of this as well." Balaban went to Israel shortly after war broke out and
was preparing to return the day after he spoke with USA TODAY. Balaban, the CEO
of the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia, met with top-level politicians
and families of victims of the Oct. 7 attacks. He visited hospitals to talk to
wounded soldiers and met with federation members and staff who were already in
Israel.
As Israeli first responders were called up for military service, or were killed
or wounded in the Hamas attacks, first responders from the U.S. rushed to fill
the void left by their absence, Balaban said.
He's working with the Emergency Volunteer Project, a disaster relief and
response that deploys volunteer doctors, nurses, EMTs and firefighters to Israel
during crises. At least 55 firefighters have already gone to Israel, and another
deployment was preparing to go within the next several days. The Jewish
Federation of Greater Philadelphia is funding at least one deployment.
"What's interesting to me is, most of them aren't Jewish," he noted. "Some of
them are; I am. ... But I asked, 'Why are you doing this? I have a stake in this
land.'"
A volunteer from Texas told him the fight against Hamas was a battle between
good and evil. Balaban agrees, noting Israel's position as a rare U.S. ally in
the Middle East, a country that values democracy and freedom. He wants people in
the U.S., and everywhere else, to know the true source of the conflict. "I don’t
know anyone in Israel who believes residents of Gaza shouldn’t be able to live a
productive, prosperous and peaceful life, but they can’t do it as long as they
are under authority of Hamas," he said, calling civilian deaths and the
humanitarian crisis unfolding in the territory "tragic." He's taking a group of
15 clergy members to meet with and counsel victims of violence, and their
families, people who have been displaced or barely escaped the horrors Hamas
wrought at places like Kfar Aza and Be'eri, two of the kibbutzim brutally
attacked on Oct. 7. Family members, including their adult children, are worried
as Balaban and his wife go to Israel. But, he said, "they know the role we play
in our community."
I’m an expert in urban warfare. Israel is upholding the
laws of war
John Spencer/CNN/November 07/2023
Editor’s Note: John Spencer is chair of urban warfare studies at the Modern War
Institute (MWI) at West Point, codirector of MWI’s Urban Warfare Project and
host of the “Urban Warfare Project Podcast.” He served for 25 years as an
infantry soldier, which included two combat tours in Iraq. He is the author of
the book “Connected Soldiers: Life, Leadership, and Social Connection in Modern
War” and co-author of “Understanding Urban Warfare.” The views expressed in this
commentary are his own. View more opinion on CNN.
All war is hell. All war is killing and destruction, and historically civilians
are inordinately the innocent victims of wars. Urban warfare is a unique type of
hell not just for soldiers, who face assaults from a million windows or deep
tunnels below them, but especially for civilians. Noncombatants have accounted
for 90% of casualties per international humanitarian experts in the modern wars
that have occurred in populated urban areas such as Iraq’s Mosul and Syria’s
Raqqa, even when a Western power like the United States is leading or supporting
the campaign.
The destruction and suffering, as awful as they are, don’t automatically
constitute war crimes – otherwise, nearly any military action in a populated
area would violate the laws of armed conflict, rules distilled from a
complicated patchwork of international treaties, court rulings and historic
conventions. Scenes of devastation, like Israel’s strikes on the Jabalya refugee
camp in northern Gaza earlier this week, quickly spark accusations that Israel
is engaging in war crimes, such as indiscriminately killing civilians and
engaging in revenge attacks. But war crimes must be assessed on evidence and the
standards of armed conflict, not a quick glimpse at the harrowing aftermath of
an attack.
Hamas forces indisputably violated multiple laws of war on October 7 in taking
Israelis hostage and raping, torturing and directly targeting civilians, as well
continuing to attack Israeli population centers with rockets. Years of
intelligence assessments and media reports have shown that Hamas also commits
war crimes by using human shields for its weapons and command centers and by
purposely putting military capabilities in protected sites like hospitals,
mosques and schools.
On the other hand, nothing I have seen shows that the Israel Defense Forces are
not following the laws of wars in Gaza, particularly when the charges that the
IDF is committing war crimes so often come too quickly for there to have been an
examination of the factors that determine whether an attack, and the resulting
civilian casualties, are lawful. The factors that need to be assessed are the
major dimensions of the most commonly agreed to international humanitarian law
principles: military necessity, proportionality, distinction, humanity and honor.
President Joe Biden and multiple European countries, including the UK, Germany
and France, are supporting Israel’s self-defense even as they express concerns
over the humanitarian situation in Gaza. Though Gaza’s legal status is
unresolved under international law, Israel needs no permission to enter the
territory and resort to using force in order to wage defensive operations
because Israel’s right to immediate and unilateral self-defense in accordance
with Article 51 of the UN Charter is universally recognized.
Israel has pledged to obey international law, and one of its cornerstones is
proportionality. The concept is often misunderstood to allow only for equal
numbers of civilian casualties on both sides, with any lopsided numbers
considered disproportionate. But proportionality is actually a requirement to
take into account how much civilian harm is anticipated in comparison to the
expected concrete and direct military advantage, according to UN protocols. In
other words, a high civilian death count in Jabalya could potentially be
considered legal under international law so long as the military objective is of
high value. The Israel Defense Forces said the intended target in this case was
the senior Hamas commander who oversaw all military operations in the northern
Gaza; neutralizing him is an objective that most likely clears the proportional
bar. Furthermore, Israel pointed out that the loss of life was compounded
because Hamas had built tunnels that weakened the targeted structure that then
collapsed in the strike.
The attack also passes muster on the level of “military necessity,” the
principle that the action was necessary to pursue an allowed military goal
(killing enemy troops), rather than an illegal goal (causing civilians to
suffer). The IDF has said that its aim is to remove the rockets, ammunitions
depot, power and transportation systems Hamas has embedded within their civilian
population. So far, a number of military experts have assessed that Israel
appears to be trying to follow the law of armed conflict in its Gaza campaign.
Of the remaining principles of the law of war – distinction, humanity (which, as
the International Committee of the Red Cross phrases it, “forbids the infliction
of all suffering, injury or destruction not necessary for achieving the
legitimate purpose of a conflict”) and honor in conduct of waging war – the
principle of distinction is the most complex. Distinction requires Israel to
“distinguish between the civilian population and combatants” and between
civilian facilities and military targets, while taking all feasible precautions
to avoid civilian casualties. So far I have seen the IDF implementing – and in
some cases going beyond – many of the best practices developed to minimize the
harm of civilians in similar large-scale urban battles.
These IDF practices include calling everyone in a building to alert them of a
pending air strike and giving them time to evacuate – a tactic I’ve never seen
elsewhere in my decades of experience, as it also notifies the enemy of the
attack – and sometimes even dropping small munitions on top of a building to
provide additional warning. They have been conducting multiple weeks of requests
that civilians evacuate certain parts of Gaza using multi-media broadcasts,
texts and flyer drops. They’ve also provided routes that will not be targeted so
that civilians have paths to non-combat areas, though there have been some
tragic reports that Palestinians from northern Gaza who have relocated to the
south were subsequently killed as the war rages throughout the strip.
When Hamas uses a hospital, school or mosque for military purpose, it can lose
its protected status and become a legal military target. Israel must still make
all feasible attempts to get as many civilians out of the site as possible, but
the sites don’t need to be clear of civilians before being attacked.
Unfortunately, it’s essentially impossible to empty a city of all civilians
before conducting an urban battle. Some people always stay, and it can be
impossible for the elderly, infirm, hospitalized and similar to evacuate. In the
densely populated Gaza Strip, where most Palestinians have nowhere to fully
escape the dangers of the war, the proportion of those who remain is likely to
be higher, as border crossings remain closed to nearly all Gazans, many
Palestinians object to leaving and Hamas has warned others not to go.
Still, even if Hamas has no interest in meeting its obligation to take all
feasible precautions to minimize harm to civilians, Israel does and should. The
IDF should take steps like constraining its forces to smaller portions of larger
urban areas while continuing to provide safe areas and routes out of the combat
areas. It should continue its calls for civilian evacuations. It should restrict
the use of air strikes and artillery near certain safe areas or gatherings of
civilians. It should continue to cooperate with the US in facilitating the entry
of humanitarian supplies into Gaza (though it’s reasonable to block fuel, which
Hamas can use in its attacks and which the group is also stockpiling while
refusing to share it with its own people).
There is no escaping that pursuing a terrorist organization touches off a
nightmarish landscape of war. The visually repulsive imagery in Gaza essentially
recreates the same scenes that unfolded under American and allied campaigns
fighting Al Qaeda, ISIS and other terror groups, because that is what it looks
like when you are forced to uproot a sadistic terror organization embedded in an
urban area. Sadly, successful US-led or supported campaigns in places such as
Mosul and Raqqa caused billions of dollars in damage and killed and displaced
hundreds of thousands of civilians; that is the hellish reality of defeating
terrorism.
Like all similar conflicts in modern times, a battle in Gaza will look like the
entire city was purposely razed to the ground or indiscriminately carpet bombed
– but it wasn’t. Israel possesses the military capacity to do so, and the fact
that it doesn’t employ such means is further evidence that it is respecting the
rules of war. It is also a sign that this is not revenge – a gross
mischaracterization of Israeli aims – but instead a careful defensive campaign
to ensure Israel’s survival.
What I’ve learned since the attacks on Israel: people don’t
deem Jews worthy of solidarity and empathy
Danny Cohen/The Telegraph/November 7, 2023
A month ago today, the terrorist group Hamas launched a barbaric attack on the
people of Israel. I have learnt an awful lot since that murderous day. I have
learnt so much that it has changed the way I see the world and made me wonder
whether things will ever be the same again.
I learnt that massacres of Jews for no other reason than they are Jewish can
still happen. That pogroms did not end in the 20th century as I had come to
believe.
I learnt that Jews could experience a level of barbarism at the hands of their
enemies so extreme that it is hard to process. Families burned to death in their
houses. Children murdered in front of their parents. Women raped before being
killed. Kidnappings. Beheadings. Unspeakable cruelty. I realised that this
genocidal barbarism had not ended with the fall of the Nazis in 1945. It could
be repeated with a sinister contemporary twist, the kidnappings and butchery
streamed live on Facebook for the world to see.
I learnt that the Jewish pledge of ‘‘never again’’ after the Holocaust did not
come true. That it could happen again. That it had.
And I learnt that many people just didn’t care. That as it was Jews being
massacred it could be overlooked and ignored. That it was somehow different.
That silence and apathy could again feed the poison of Jew hatred as it had done
in the 1930s.
I watched as just days after the massacres in Israel a group of well-known
entertainers calling themselves Artists for Palestine spoke up for the people of
Gaza but had no empathy to extend to Jewish people. For some reason they forgot
to even mention the murder of 1,400 Jews and the kidnapping of hundreds more. I
discovered that the terrorist attacks of Oct 7 were somehow different from the
Black Lives Matter movement or the plight of Ukraine and were not worthy of
solidarity or remembrance, whether that be in student unions or at Wembley
Stadium.
Out on the streets of Britain, I learnt that anti-Semitism is alive and well. I
watched as tens of thousands marched in opposition to Israel, a country still
burying its dead and searching for its kidnapped children. Masked men called for
jihad against Jews. Genocidal chants rung out in central London. I wondered
where these people were during recent Middle East conflicts when lives were
being lost in the Syrian civil war or the battle to destroy Islamic State. We
did not see them on the streets en masse then. Their vitriolic anger seems
solely focused on the Jewish State, their protest a statement of anti-Semitism
as much as a call to support the innocent in Gaza.
Talking to friends, I heard racist horror story after racist horror story, right
here in Britain. The poster of kidnapped Israeli children defaced with Hitler
moustaches. Threats and intimidation on university campuses. The toxic waste of
social media overflowing with anti-Semitism. Jewish people in our country taking
unprecedented steps to protect their safety and that of their children.
British Jews must carry on
I should also say that amidst this rude awakening there have been sparks of
light, reasons for optimism and gratitude. I have seen the UK Government stand
up firmly against terrorism and support Israel’s right to self-defence. I have
watched President Biden stand by Israel and warn off its enemies. I have been
moved to tears by messages from many non-Jewish friends, expressing sympathy,
support and solidarity.
Now, the question that really matters is what should I and other Jews do with
all we have learnt? What can we take from this rude awakening other than pain,
sorrow and grief? Should we be fearful? Should we hide? Should we make plans to
travel, just in case? If we did, where would we go?
To these questions I have a very clear answer. What I have learnt in the month
since the Hamas attacks has left me very certain of how we must respond.
British Jews must proudly carry on our Jewish life. We must not be intimidated.
We should not live in fear. We must stand up to prejudice wherever we see it. We
must take the hands of our non-Jewish friends who support us and work with them
to ensure that anti-Semitism does not prevail.
The Jewish people have been here before - not once, not twice but countless
times.
The Jewish people have been here before and got through it. And we will get
through it again.
Today's Nazis Are Hamas
Alan M. Dershowitz/Gatestone Institute/November 07/2023
Gays for Gay-Killers, Jews for Jew-Killers, Feminists for Wife-Beating,
Progressives for Fascists
[B]igots hate Jews and their nation-state. This has nothing to do with support
for the Palestinian people, who are horribly oppressed by Hamas. If they really
wanted to support the Palestinian people, they would be demonstrating for
Palestinian freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom not to be used as a
human shield, due process, equal justice under law, and especially freedom from
the corrupt and repressive governance of their own leaders, some now safe from
the devastation they began from their five-star hotels in Qatar.
Nor does it reflect support for stateless, oppressed or occupied national groups
in general. These selective bigots are silent about the stateless Kurds , the
oppressed Uyghurs and other groups that deserve their support. They only focus
on the Palestinians because they are allegedly oppressed by Jews. It is hatred
of Jews, not love of the Palestinians or other groups that motivates these
bigots.
Let us remember that these shows of support for Hamas began before Israel even
responded to the Hamas barbarity. They were shows of support for what Hamas did
to innocent Jews: rapes, beheadings, torture, mass murder and kidnapping.
Many university students and faculty, not only in Germany but at Harvard, Yale,
Georgetown and other American universities, supported Nazi Germany in the 1930s.
Today's Nazis are Hamas. Today's enablers of Nazism are the students and others
who support Hamas. History will judge them the way history has judged Nazi
collaborators.
Many university students and faculty, not only in Germany but at Harvard, Yale,
Georgetown and other American universities, supported Nazi Germany in the 1930s.
Today's Nazis are Hamas. Today's enablers of Nazism are the students and others
who support Hamas. History will judge them the way history has judged Nazi
collaborators.
Among the groups that have supported the rapes, beheadings, burning alive, mass
murder and kidnappings of Jews by Hamas have been some that purport to speak for
gays, Jews, feminists and progressives. If any of these groups were actually to
travel to Gaza, they would be murdered by Hamas.
Hamas has no tolerance for gays, Jews, feminists or progressives. Indeed, among
the people beheaded, raped, murdered and kidnapped were gays, Jews who support
Palestinians, feminists, progressives and non-Jews. None of that matters to
Hamas. If you are a Jew or an Israeli or just happen to be in the way, you are a
target of their barbarity.
Why do so many people from groups that Hamas seeks to destroy support that
racist organization? The answer is clear: these bigots hate Jews and their
nation-state. This has nothing to do with support for the Palestinian people,
who are horribly oppressed by Hamas. If they really wanted to support the
Palestinian people, they would be demonstrating for Palestinian freedom of
speech, freedom of the press, freedom not to be used as a human shield, due
process, equal justice under law, and especially freedom from the corrupt and
repressive governance of their own leaders, some now safe from the devastation
they began from their five-star hotels in Qatar. Nor does it reflect support for
stateless, oppressed or occupied national groups in general. These selective
bigots are silent about the stateless Kurds , the oppressed Uyghurs and other
groups that deserve their support. They only focus on the Palestinians because
they are allegedly oppressed by Jews. It is hatred of Jews, not love of the
Palestinians or other groups that motivates these bigots.
Let us remember that these shows of support for the terrorist group Hamas began
before Israel had even responded to the Hamas barbarity. They were shows of
support for what Hamas did to innocent Jews: rapes, beheadings, mass murder,
kidnapping and torture too unspeakable to show. It was the victimization of Jews
that stimulated these displays of antisemitism. There were few criticisms of
Hamas for what it did. The most ferocious demonization was against Israel for
what it is: the nation-state of the Jewish people. Never mind that there are
many Arab and Muslim states. As is typical of bullies, victimizing Jews came
when Israel was at its weakest and most vulnerable, still grieving the loss of
so many innocent civilians.
Among the most hypocritical supporters of Hamas are "Gays for Gaza." Rainbow
flags and posters identifying the protesters as gay were rampant at anti-Israel
demonstrations calling for the end of that nation. In Gaza, such signs are
illegal. Anyone displaying them would be killed, as was Hamas commander Mahmoud
Ishtiwi, who was caught having sex with another man, and promptly tortured and
killed.
Gay men in Gaza seek asylum In Israel. The city of Tel Aviv is among the most
accepting of gays in the world. But none of this matters to the gay bigots: they
put their hatred of Jews above their concern for gay Palestinians.
Even worse is the misnamed group, Jewish Voice for Peace, which has long served
as a front for Hamas and other anti-Israel terrorist groups. It claims to be
anti-Zionist, opposing the existence of Israel, but many of its members and
supporters are overtly antisemitic.
If its Jewish members (many are not Jews, despite its name) sought to protest in
Gaza, they would be murdered or kidnapped. Hamas, like the Nazis, does not
distinguish among Jews based on their politics, as evidenced by the fact that
some of the Jews killed on October 7 were critical of the Israeli government and
perhaps even of Zionism. But that did not matter to the rapists and beheaders of
Hamas. To them a Jew is a Jew, regardless of whether they belong to Jewish Voice
for Peace or Likud.
Then there are the feminists, progressives and labor unions that support the
Hamas brutality and oppose the existence of Israel.
Hamas is the among the world's most anti-feminist group. It subjugates women to
the whims of their husbands and fathers, and tolerates, if not encourages,
wife-beating and "honor killing" women who supposedly dishonor their families.
Hamas imprisons progressive critics and does not permit independent labor
unions. Its members exploit workers, and use child laborers and child soldiers.
But not a word of criticism from the bigots who are willing to give Hamas a pass
on their fascism as long as they murder Jews. If this is not antisemitism, I
don't know what is.
Yes, Jews, too, can be antisemites. So can gays, feminists, progressives,
socialists and others on the hard left. Hitler was a vegetarian. Some leading
Nazis were gay. Gertrude Stein, a Nazi collaborator, was gay and a Jew. Many
university students and faculty, not only in Germany but at Harvard, Yale,
Georgetown and other American universities, supported Nazi Germany in the 1930s.
Today's Nazis are Hamas. Today's enablers of Nazism are the students and others
who support Hamas. History will judge them the way history has judged Nazi
collaborators.
*Alan M. Dershowitz is the Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law, Emeritus at
Harvard Law School, and the author most recently of Get Trump: The Threat to
Civil Liberties, Due Process, and Our Constitutional Rule of Law. He is the Jack
Roth Charitable Foundation Fellow at Gatestone Institute, and is also the host
of "The Dershow" podcast.
© 2023 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
Gaza: Are there any winners?
Faisal J. Abbas/Arab News/November 07, 2023
One thing is for sure: as Benjamin Netanyahu said after the Hamas attacks on
Oct. 7, Israel’s response “will change the Middle East”— perhaps the only words
of wisdom the Israeli prime minister has uttered since this crisis began.
Indeed, the first change may be in the occupant of his office. Polls show
Netanyahu’s personal approval rating having slumped to 27 percent, there are
protests outside his home over what Israelis overwhelmingly view as a security
lapse on his watch, and a raft of media opinion pieces hold him personally
responsible — as Haaretz put it: “The disaster that befell Israel … is the clear
responsibility of one person: Benjamin Netanyahu.”Second, as previously
predicted in this column, the Hamas leaders who declared victory on Oct. 7 and
thought that by holding hostages they could negotiate better terms have now put
the world in a situation where it needs to negotiate only limits to the Israeli
reaction — which, after long years of experience and five wars since 2006, Hamas
should have known was never going to be proportionate.
This is not to say that Israel’s ongoing occupation of Palestinian land and the
continuing undermining of Palestinian rights is not to blame for the escalation
to where we are today — but rather that whatever strategic gain Hamas wildly
imagined it would achieve is not materializing. In other words, no matter how
this ends, the current leaderships of both Hamas and Israel are finished — a
fitting end for a couple who have for so long been unlikely tag-team partners in
their unwavering commitment to killing any prospect of peace.
In fact, Netanyahu — who could be described as the Francis Underwood of Israeli
politics — has not only survived this far but has become his country’s
longest-serving prime minister by deploying one simple tactic: avoiding any
serious engagement with resolving the Palestinian issue, and doing anything
possible to undermine a solution for it.
This has unbelievably included going as low as empowering his sworn enemy Hamas
in Gaza, and undermining the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank, where Hamas
doesn’t exist.
But don’t just take my word for it. “For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now
it’s blown up in our faces,” read a headline in The Times of Israel. Worse, as
recently as 2019 Netanyahu reportedly said: “Those who want to thwart the
establishment of a Palestinian state should support the strengthening of Hamas.”However,
even a serial survivor like Francis Underwood eventually runs out of luck:
everything collapses like a house of cards when you upset 80 percent of your
voters, members of your own Cabinet, and the 121 countries who opposed Israel at
the UN last month, albeit in a non-binding vote — all that plus still
outstanding corruption charges that mean when Netanyahu leaves office his next
destination may well be a prison cell.
Hamas, on the other hand, has a different equation. Even if Israel succeeds in
its impossible mission of killing all the group’s estimated 40,000 fighters, or
expelling them and their leaders from Gaza (while completely disregarding legal,
humanitarian and political consequences) they will have “killed only the
combatants but not the cause” — as Queen Rania of Jordan told Becky Anderson in
her CNN interview. So, are there any winners? Well, apart from extremists
finding justification in the current events to attack mosques and synagogues;
there is a hopeful argument that the intensity, severe casualties and ugliness
of this war — and its already global ramifications — will now force the
international community to accept that no more patch-up solutions are possible.
The only way to ensure this doesn’t happen again is finally to have a just and
fair peace that gives Palestinians land, freedom and hope. As argued here
before, now is the time to double down on peacemaking efforts, and this starts
with ending the illegal occupation — a hard ask given that the only country with
genuine influence over Israel has vetoed even a ceasefire.
Indeed, as if we did not know this before, when the current US government
shamelessly supports an occupying power that has killed more than 10,000
Palestinians in Gaza, many of them children, it no longer holds the moral high
ground to preach to others about not doing enough to condemn Russia’s invasion
of Ukraine. In the end, no one put it better than UN Secretary-General Antonio
Guterres when he said: “The nightmare in Gaza is more than a humanitarian
crisis. It is a crisis of humanity.”
• Faisal J. Abbas is the editor-in-chief of Arab News.
X: @FaisalJAbbas
How will the Israel-Gaza war end?
Abdulrahman Al-Rashed/Arab News/November 07, 2023
Discussing the start and the developments of the deadly war taking place in Gaza
is inescapable, but so are the questions of how this war will end, who will
raise the white flag first and at what price.
The ongoing Israeli military assault, which has spared no civilian lives or
facilities, is more than a mere response to the attack by Hamas on Oct. 7.
Judging by the sheer size of the Israeli response, a change in the political
reality is about to unfold before us.
In the aftermath of the attack, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said
that the region would never be the same again. This claim was echoed loudly in
Western capitals, which were quick to announce their support and to back efforts
to expel Hamas from Gaza.
Today, we stand before a horrific humanitarian crisis, a bloody military battle
and the prospects of a different political project. Israel may achieve its
ambition and wipe out the armed group as we know it, yet the Palestinian cause
and rights are here to stay, with or without Hamas in the picture. Israel will
still be in danger, as evidenced by the scale of Hamas’ latest attack, despite
years of blockade and surveillance by Israel.
Judging by the sheer size of the Israeli response, a change in the political
reality is about to unfold before us. Three important observations must be made
here.
First, Netanyahu and Hamas may be enemies, but they are allies in the effort to
thwart the peace project in the region.
Second, neither will emerge victorious in this war: Hamas may lose Gaza, while
Netanyahu not only risks losing the leadership of the Israeli government
following the Oct. 7 failure, but he also may go to jail on the charges of
corruption leveled against him before the war. Finally, deadly as it may be,
this war will breathe new life into the peace project. The expulsion of Yasser
Arafat and his fighters from Lebanon was the end of Fatah as a military
organization, but Arafat knew how to play his political cards. He repositioned
and managed to return to Palestine as leader of the Palestinian Authority, no
less, following the Oslo Accords.
Today, history may repeat itself, even in light of the worst humanitarian crisis
in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict for 50 years.
In a few weeks, the war will end and the fronts will fall silent. Then, it will
be time for politics. While bombs rained down from the skies above Gaza, Hamas’
political leader Ismail Haniyeh dropped a metaphorical bombshell of his own when
he announced the group’s readiness to accept peace in the form of a two-state
solution. Haniyeh is well aware of what the war could be hiding next. Hamas is
not strong enough to repel the US-backed Israel, especially without any support
from its allies. Haniyeh wants Hamas to have a political front that could reap
the benefits of the Oct. 7 attack.
But he and former leader Khaled Mashal must first overcome a big hurdle: the
leaders of Hamas in Gaza do not recognize any role for their peers abroad. It
has even been leaked that the supporters of Haniyeh and Mashal were removed from
leadership roles as far back as 2017, when the military leadership headed by
Yahya Sinwar took control of the movement. Today, Hamas is cornered and
blockaded, which could mean a guaranteed seat at any future negotiating table
for its leadership abroad. However, the movement tried, through last month’s
attack, to nip any such negotiations in the bud.
But a challenge arises here. The US has listed Hamas on its terrorist blacklist,
so any American undertaking of a peace project would force Washington to
backtrack.
Even if Hamas agreed to disarm, no Arab state would be willing to take the
movement under its wing
Arafat was once banned from entering the US or meeting with American officials,
with alternatives like Haidar Abdel-Shafi and Hanan Ashrawi appearing in his
place during the 1991 Madrid Conference. Eventually, the Americans had to sit
down with Arafat because no peace or negotiations were possible without him.
Granted, the extremist movement of Hamas is not the same as Fatah, but it is
still impossible to ignore and its concession would strengthen the position of
the PA in potential negotiations.
Until then, the road is fraught with traps. Israel has vowed to annihilate the
35,000-strong movement, but such a goal is militarily impossible without both
sides incurring horrific civilian and other losses.
Will Hamas agree to step away from the scene in order to curb the loss of lives
among civilians and its own fighters?
Moreover, even if Hamas agreed to disarm, no Arab state would be willing to take
the movement under its wing and bear the potential dangers that would accompany
such a move. Caught between a rock and a hard place, the two sides of the
conflict may finally agree to a compromise, which no one is better positioned to
engage in than the PA. Thus, the lights will again shine at the end of Gaza’s
dark tunnels.
As for the prospects of peace and disarmament, that is a subject for another
time.
*Abdulrahman Al-Rashed is a veteran columnist. He is the former general manager
of Al Arabiya news channel, and former editor-in-chief of Asharq Al-Awsat, where
this article was originally published. X: @aalrashed
America’s indifference on Gaza creates watershed moment in
Arab-US ties
Osama Al-Sharif/Arab News/November 07, 2023
No one knows how Israel’s war on Gaza, which is now in its second month, will
end and what the final civilian death toll will be. But when the guns finally go
silent and the dust settles, the Middle East and indeed the rest of the world
will wake up to a new reality. Whatever happens to Hamas will mean little
compared to the human cost already endured: more than 10,000 deaths, almost half
being women and children, and more than 25,000 injured. The level of destruction
is beyond description, not seen anywhere since the Second World War.
Most of Gaza has been turned into a wasteland and no one knows if Gazans will
ever be allowed to return to their bombed-out homes to resume whatever is left
of their miserable and tragic lives.
But beyond the humanitarian fallout, which will linger for years, there will be
multiple political accounts that need to be settled. In the eye of the storm
will be the future of US-Arab ties and where the shaky alliance with the West
will go from here.
In Amman last week, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken met with the foreign
ministers of five key Arab countries, in addition to a Palestinian Authority
representative. They all called on the US to accept the need for an immediate
ceasefire and to allow the unfettered delivery of much-needed humanitarian
supplies to the besieged Gaza Strip, now a disaster zone. Instead, Blinken
rebuffed their calls and repeated the now overused statement that Israel has the
right to defend itself and that any truce would favor Hamas. He pretended to
sympathize with Palestinian civilian losses, urging Israel to abide by the rules
of war — whatever that means — and tossed the Arab world a bone: a commitment to
a two-state solution. In short, the US took Israel’s side completely and ignored
the pleas of its Arab allies.
Even though Blinken said he supported humanitarian pauses, none have come into
effect so far. Israel’s pummeling of the entire Gaza Strip has only picked up
pace, targeting fleeing civilians, hospitals, ambulances, civil defense and
medical workers, and journalists. The carnage went on as Blinken continued to
warn against expanding the conflict beyond Gaza.
This complete indifference to the Arab point of view, which has nothing to do
with defending Hamas but is centered on protecting civilians and ensuring
humanitarian assistance, has become a watershed moment in US-Arab ties.
Washington could not care less for the sentiments of millions of Arabs, or those
of millions of people all over the world. It has unabashedly taken the side of
Israel, even when the war violates all definitions of self-defense and all the
scopes of international laws and conventions.
Even though Blinken said he supported humanitarian pauses, none have come into
effect so far.
And when Arab diplomats pointed to the escalating situation in the West Bank,
where Israeli soldiers and radical settlers are shooting and terrorizing
Palestinians, all Blinken could do was to ask Israel to do something about the
spiraling violence and then say that he was assured that something would be
done.
The level of public rage against the US position on the war in the Arab world
must not be ignored. It is putting Arab governments under pressure. It is
shaking the foundations of the alliance between the US and its Arab partners.
The chasm between these allies and Washington could expand depending on the
outcome of Israel’s war on Gaza. A forced displacement of millions of
Palestinians into Egypt would bring that relationship to the brink, leaving
Cairo and Amman in a tough and precarious position. Jordan has already said that
such forced displacement would be considered a declaration of war. No one knows,
not even the US, how far Israel will go with its current military campaign. And
it is now clear that the Biden administration does not have the leverage to stop
Israel from going as far as pushing hundreds of thousands of Palestinians into
the Sinai desert.
The final outcome of the war on Gaza could push relations with Washington to a
breaking point. No Arab country can take the risk of abandoning the Palestinian
cause. In fact, the events following Oct. 7 have proven — for Israel, the Arabs
and the rest of the world — that ignoring the strife of Palestinians will keep
the region on edge and will not bring peace and security to Israel.
President Joe Biden and Blinken are yet to say what Arab leaders need to hear:
that, following this horrific round of violence, the US will make amends by
addressing the core of the region’s troubles — the Palestinian issue. The
problem is that, even if they do deliver such assurances, few will take them
seriously.
The level of public rage against the US position on the war in the Arab world
must not be ignored.
For more than 30 years, the US has taken hold of the so-called peace process,
whose aim was to deliver a two-state solution. But Washington has failed to play
the role of an honest broker. It has looked the other way while an extremist
Israel grabbed more Palestinian lands, demolished Palestinians’ homes, empowered
Jewish settlers, marginalized the Palestinian Authority and enforced an illegal
siege on Gaza’s 2.3 million inhabitants. The US ignored warnings by its Arab
allies that the region was at a boiling point and that, unless the Palestinian
issue was resolved in a just way, chaos would erupt. And that is exactly what is
happening now.
No more US assurances will suffice. The US monopoly of the so-called peace
process has to end. Israel’s impunity must also end. Israel’s war on Gaza and
its collective punishment of Palestinians ahead of possible ethnic cleansing
must be addressed and cannot be ignored. The fact that Israel has committed
multiple war crimes in Gaza cannot be swept under the carpet. The entire
rules-based world order is about to keel over as a result of Western complicity
and its application of double standards.
What is immediately needed following the war is to have an international peace
conference, in which Russia, China, the Arab region and the rest of the Global
South play a key role. The US cannot be trusted to chair, on its own, another
round of peace talks that ends up buying time for Israel to complete its
usurpation of whatever is left of Palestinian land. The two-state solution was
declared dead a long time ago thanks to Israel’s policy of colonizing the West
Bank while forcing millions of Palestinians in Gaza into another Nakba.
Israel’s right to exist has been enshrined in peace treaties and in the Arab
Peace Initiative. But this is not a blank check that can be cashed at the teller
at the expense of millions of Palestinians, who have the right to
self-determination and a state of their own. The war on Gaza has brought us to
the moment of truth: Israel wants to liquidate the Palestinian issue once and
for all and let the region pick up the tab. That will not happen and the US must
not allow it to happen. The US is not an honest broker and the Arab world cannot
allow it to continue to buy time for Israel as it embarks on a pernicious scheme
to normalize the occupation and dispose of millions of Palestinians.
America’s Arab allies need to send a stern message to the US that choosing
Israel, no matter what it does, over its allies and their genuine interests can
no longer continue.
• Osama Al-Sharif is a journalist and political commentator in Amman. X:
@plato010