English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For July 24/2023
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on
the lccc Site
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2023/english.july24.23.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since
2006
Click On The Below Link To Join Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group so you get
the LCCC Daily A/E Bulletins every day
https://chat.whatsapp.com/FPF0N7lE5S484LNaSm0MjW
ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÚáì ááÅäÖãÇã
áßÑæÈ
Eliasbejjaninews whatsapp group
æÐáß
áÅÓÊáÇã äÔÑÇÊí
ÇáÚÑÈíÉ æÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÇáíæãíÉ
ÈÇäÊÙÇã
Elias Bejjani/Click
on the below link to subscribe to my youtube channel
ÇáíÇÓ
ÈÌÇäí/ÇÖÛØ
Úáì ÇáÑÇÈØ Ýí
ÃÓÝá ááÅÔÊÑÇß
Ýí ãæÞÚí Ú
ÇáíæÊíæÈ
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAOOSioLh1GE3C1hp63Camw
15 ÂÐÇÑ/2023
Bible Quotations For
today
No one has greater love than this, to
lay down one’s life for one’s friends. You are my friends if you do what I
command you."
Saint John 15/09-14:"As the Father has loved me, so I have loved you;
abide in my love. If you keep my commandments, you will abide in my love,
just as I have kept my Father’s commandments and abide in his love. I have
said these things to you so that my joy may be in you, and that your joy may
be complete. ‘This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have
loved you. No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for
one’s friends. You are my friends if you do what I command you."
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
Lebanese & Lebanese Related News & Editorials published
on July 23-24/2023
Lebanon is an Iranian Occupied Country/Elias Bejjani/July 23/2023
Video Link of the Divine Liturgy presided over by Patriarch Al-Rahi today,
July 23/2023, in Al-Diman Church, with the text of his sermon.
Archbishop Aoudi: It is time to reintroduce concepts into the behavior of
politicians, such as respect for the constitution, transparency, honesty,
and accountability
Report: Le Drian won't propose dialogue, Iran may join 5-nation group
Bou Habib discusses with his Swedish counterpart additional steps to curb
Islamophobia in Sweden
Feasibility check: The motives and details of BDL Governor deputies'
recovery plan
Minister Bayram: We want a country representing all Lebanese citizens
Milano Street's drama: Lebanese authorities on high alert after shooting
Sheikh Daamoush: All the attempts made by the US to target the Resistance
have failed
Rome Conference on Mediterranean migration: Lebanese Prime Minister Najib
Mikati's speech
New Poll Shows Lebanese Frustrations with Government, Iran, and Other
Powers/Catherine Cleveland/Washington Institute/July 23/2023
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published on July 23-24/2023
Iran kicks off air force drill as US sends more fighter planes to the
region
Four police officers killed in south-eastern Iranian attack
Netanyahu gets pacemaker ahead of vote on judicial reforms
Jerusalem sees thousands of protesters as Netanyahu moves forward with
judicial reforms
New forum aims to tackle Syria-Jordan drug smuggling
Russia's Putin: Black Sea grain deal became meaningless
Putin claims Ukrainian counteroffensive has 'failed'
Russia and Iran's 'unprecedented' military ties worried the US, but it's
starting to look like Russia can't hold up its end of the deal/Paul Iddon/Business
Insider/Sun, July 23, 2023
Russia Using 'Disinformation' To Exaggerate Small Military Gains, Says UK
Russian strike on Ukraine's Odesa leaves 1 dead, many hurt and a cathedral
badly damaged
End of Russian-Chinese military exercises in the Sea of Japan
Right-wing preference in Spain and far-right elections hopes for a return to
power
Treaty that created modern Turkey still evokes pain for some, 100 years
after signing
Sudan war enters 100th day as mediation attempts fail
Plea for help as hunger stalks Khartoum
Pope’s plea over refugee plight as Saudi delegation attends Rome migration
talks
Titles For The Latest English LCCC analysis & editorials from
miscellaneous sources published
on July 23-24/2023
The Perfect Crime': Tech Companies Are Manipulating Our Elections and
Indoctrinating Our Children — How We Can Stop Them/Robert Epstein/Gatestone
Institute./July 23, 2023
Spotlight on Terrorism: Hezbollah, Lebanon and Syria/The Meir Amit
Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center/July 23/2023
Afghan Taliban Government's Persecution Of Musicians/Mantasha Ansari/MEMRI/July
23/2023
Shared American values crucial amid alarming political polarization/Dalia
Al-Aqidi /Arab News/July 23, 2023
How China became an ideal partner in the Middle East/Dr. Majid Rafizadeh/Arab
News/July 23, 2023
New mediator may be needed to rescue Black Sea grain deal/Dr. Diana Galeeva/Arab
News/July 23, 2023
Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on July 23-24/2023
Lebanon is an Iranian Occupied Country
Elias Bejjani/July 23/2023
Introduction/For the majorit y of the Lebanese people, the holistic patriotic
picture has become very clear. In general, they are now fully aware of the
precipitating factors and perpetuating elements underlying the ongoing flagrant
direct and indirect Iranian occupation of their country through armed
militias and a bunch of traitorous, Trojan horse politicians and officials
spearheaded by the terrorist – fundamentalist Hezbollah. Lebanese people both in
the homeland and Diaspora are very much aware of the numerous evil, vicious
Syrian-Iranian obstacles deliberately employed and imposed on them by force and
murder to hinder their beloved Lebanon from fully reclaiming its independence,
sovereignty, freedom, tranquility and peace. The free
and patriotic Lebanese strongly reject and ridicule the fake and camouflaging
slogans of hostility towards Israel, the USA and the Western Free world, as well
as those of resistance, liberation, the people, government, and army triad, one
people in two countries, and the many other deceitful tools of deception that
Hezbollah utilizes as a pretext to maintain its ministate and hegemony on
Lebanon and its people.
Video Link of the Divine Liturgy presided over by
Patriarch Al-Rahi today, July 23/2023, in Al-Diman Church, with the text of his
sermon.
Al-Rahi denounced the Iraqi president’s withdrawal of the republican decree from
Patriarch Raphael/ Warned that Lebanon’s identity and message are threatened
with distortion due to non-compliance with the constitution patriotism & renewed
Lebanon’s demand for the return of Syrian refugees to their country
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/120382/120382/
NNA/LCCC /July 23, 2023
Maronite Patriarch, Cardinal Mar Beshara Boutros Al-Rai,
considered that Lebanon and its message are threatened with distortion and
collapse due to non-compliance with the content of the constitution and
non-implementation of the Taif Agreement, in addition to obstructing the
election of a president and overthrowing the constitutional institutions for the
suspicious goals of the opponents. The Patriarch's words came in his homily this
morning as he presided over Sunday Mass service at the Patriarchal Summer Church
in Al-Diman, thanked the five-country committee for bearing Lebanon's concerns
and future more than the Lebanese authorities who continue to demolish it.
Finally, Al-Rahi renewed Lebanon's demand for the return of the displaced
Syrians to their homeland, in order to preserve their identity and mission in
their homeland on the one hand, and that they not be a cause for distorting
Lebanon's identity and mission on the other hand.
He added,We have been pained by the decision taken by the President of the
Republic of Iraq, Mr. Abd al-Latif Rashid, to withdraw the Republican Decree
from His Beatitude Patriarch Cardinal Mar Louis Raphael I Sako, unfairly and
accusingly. This is a violation of his dignity and the dignity of the Church and
Christians in Iraq. It is well known that it is the state's duty to respect the
Church's regulations and laws, which limit His Holiness the Pope to hearing any
criminal case involving patriarchs, cardinals, and bishops, if any.
We add our voice to all those who demand that His Excellency the President of
the Iraqi Republic reverse his decision, for the sake of a healthy coexistence
in the dear State of Iraq, where Christians are an integral part of its
historical components and have great historical merit in its culture and
civilization. The history of their patriarchs is the best witness to their
struggle for the sake of their homeland, its glory and dignity. The decision of
the President of the Iraqi Republic as a result does not serve his Iraqi nation.
Lebanon's identity and message are threatened with distortion and collapse due
to non-compliance with the content of the constitution, non-application of the
Taif Agreement (National Accord Document) in letter and spirit, and the
decisions of international legitimacy; And because of deliberately obstructing
the election of a president for the republic, and thus making the constitutional
institutions fall one after the other for the suspicious goals of the
obstructors. Thank you is the Committee of Five Countries for carrying the
concern of Lebanon and its future much more than the Lebanese authorities who
are devoted to destruction and sabotage.
Our demand is for the return of the displaced Syrians to their country, so that
they preserve their identity and message on the one hand, and so that they are
not another reason for distorting Lebanon's identity and message.
Let us pray to God that we, as Christians, may preserve our messianic
identity and message, and as Lebanese, our identity and mission, which are
necessary for our Arab environment and for the world. And together we raise
glory and thanks to the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, now and forever,
Amen.
Archbishop Aoudi: It is time to reintroduce concepts
into the behavior of politicians, such as respect for the constitution,
transparency, honesty, and accountability
NNA/LCCC/ July 23 / 2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/120386/120386/
The Greek Orthodox Metropolitan of Beirut and its Dependencies, Archbishop Elias
Aoudi, presided over the mass service at St. George's Cathedral in Beirut. After
the Gospel, he delivered a sermon in which he said: “The leaders of this country
are like the Pharisees. They do not want the salvation of the country and the
people, and they do not budge from the path of those who want to work for
reform, the end of crises, and access to a state of institutions with no
corruption, nepotism, or bullying. That is, in the absence of the head, and that
all centers are filled and the wheel of the state turns when a president is
elected and a government is formed that carries out the necessary reforms. The
time has come to re-introduce concepts into the behavior of politicians such as
respect for the constitution, application of laws, integrity, transparency,
honesty, duty and accountability, concepts that have been lost, but they are
necessary for the regularity of public life. He concluded, "Our call today is to
open our eyes to see the only truth, that is, Christ, and to release our tongues
with constant praise and recognition of the living God without shame, informing
the whole earth of His greatness and endless love."
Report: Le Drian won't propose dialogue, Iran may join 5-nation group
Naharnet/ July 23 / 2023
French presidential envoy for Lebanon Jean-Yves Le Drian will arrive in Beirut
on Tuesday and will amend the roadmap he had launched on his first visit, an
informed source said. "He will not raise the idea of holding a dialogue table
after the stance of the five-nation group, but he will stress Paris' readiness
to work for helping Lebanon and aiding the Lebanese exit the current crisis and
elect a president," the source told ad-Diyar newspaper in remarks published
Sunday. "Political circles believe that the crisis will likely protract, in the
absence of serious solution indications," the daily said.
A source close to a senior leader meanwhile told the newspaper that "the
five-nation group on the Lebanese presidential file might expand to resemble the
famous 5+1 format after Iran joins it in a certain manner.""There are contacts
aimed at achieving this goal," the source added.
Bou Habib discusses with his Swedish counterpart additional
steps to curb Islamophobia in Sweden
LBCI/ July 23 / 2023
Swedish Foreign Minister Tobias Billström expressed regret and condemnation from
his government for the disrespectful acts against the Holy Quran and the insult
to Islamic beliefs and symbols. This statement came during a phone call he held
with Lebanon's Foreign Affairs and Expatriates Minister, Abdallah Bou
Habib.Minister Bou Habib welcomed this position and encouraged Sweden to take
further practical steps to mitigate the growing manifestations of hatred and
Islamophobia. He also affirmed Lebanon's respect for international agreements,
particularly the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, and its commitment
to taking all possible measures to ensure the safety of Swedish interests and
citizens within its borders.
Feasibility check: The motives and details of BDL Governor
deputies' recovery plan
LBCI/ July 23 / 2023
The plan of the Banque du Liban (BDL) Governor's deputies to correct monetary
policy and initiate financial recovery has faced hurdles until now, especially
during the second meeting with the Administration and Justice Committee. What
are the motives behind this plan, its details, and is it feasible? Regarding the
motives, the plan does not differ from the reform laws demanded by the
International Monetary Fund (IMF). However, the BDL Governor's deputies refuse
to continue the current financial policy without reforms. They need laws that
hold them accountable, especially since many decisions made in the Council of
the BDL in the past were signed with reservations to protect themselves from
legal repercussions. As for the provisions, unlike the previous policy of
procrastination, the plan sets a specific timeline for implementation. The first
step of the plan is to adopt the 2023 budget in August, but with a review of the
current government's version, and correct the revenue numbers by raising it from
the current $2 billion per year to $3 billion. This is based on the World Bank's
request to increase tax revenues to 15% of the GDP to stimulate growth and
reduce poverty. The plan also grants an additional month to reconsider and
approve the Capital Control Law, pending between the government and parliament
for over three years. This law is crucial to protect the remaining bank deposits
and stop any discretion. Additionally, the plan obliges the government to submit
bills to parliament for approval within two months, including a financial
balance law that outlines the mechanism for depositors to reclaim their funds
instead of the current circulars.Another critical law to be addressed is the
bank restructuring law to determine which banks can survive and how to increase
their capital. The most sensitive point of the plan is to start implementing the
liberalization of the exchange rate by the end of September in a managed manner.
This involves stopping Sayrafa to stop the depletion of reserves and replacing
them with an international platform reflecting the market rate. The plan
requires the parliament to pass a law allowing the BDL to lend the government
from its mandatory reserves an amount not exceeding $200 million per month for
six months to protect vulnerable groups affected by the exchange rate hike and
to support the public sector. The government must commit to repaying these
funds. The four deputies' plan has quickly drawn criticism and rejection from
various parliamentary blocs, considering it unfeasible and arguing that the
government should bear primary responsibility instead of shifting it to the MPs.
In return, the BDL Governor's deputies call for cooperation between the BDL, the
government, and the parliament until they handle their responsibilities.
Otherwise, the option of resignation is on the table in the upcoming days unless
actions succeed in dissuading them due to the legal and financial risks
associated with such a move.
Minister Bayram: We want a country representing all
Lebanese citizens
LBCI/ July 23 / 2023
The caretaker Labor Minister, Moustafa Bayram, expressed his views on the
current difficult stage in Lebanon. He emphasized the importance of dialogue but
noted that when they call others for dialogue, they often refuse to respond
because his team has its stance and opinions. No one can dictate their views,
whether from external or international parties. Bayram pointed out that the
other parties lack decision-making power, which leads them to reject the
dialogue process. "The decision-making authority lies outside Lebanon,
particularly in the hands of the United States and other influential factors
within the country who prefer to maintain temporary stability in Lebanon," he
said. Despite the challenges, he mentioned that his team will not falter under
external pressures. They follow the culture of Imam Hussein, advocating for
solidarity and compassion and calling for a collective consciousness that
transcends sectarian issues and separates politics from administration. The
Minister delivered his speech amidst the presence of prominent figures and
participants at the Ashoura Council event in Yahmour. Bayram concluded, "we want
a country representing all Lebanese citizens." While he acknowledged some
regional breakthroughs, he emphasized that the international community has yet
to take the internal decision-making to relieve the situation in Lebanon. He
described the current stage as crucial and requires awareness and understanding.
Milano Street's drama: Lebanese authorities on high alert
after shooting
LBCI/ July 23 / 2023
In the heart of the Lebanese capital, Beirut, the streets remained calm after
the recent incident on Saturday evening near Hay El-Lija in Msaytbeh. Contrary
to speculations, the altercation did not involve Hezbollah and the Amal Movement
as widely rumored. A stroll through the vicinities reveals citizens going about
their everyday lives, participating in religious gatherings in mosques for
Ashoura. The gunfire in Milano Street originated from a personal dispute on
Friday evening. According to security sources, an individual from the Al-Hashem
family, known to be prominent in the area, was moving a motorcycle to get his
car out when he encountered another person who pointed a gun at the former,
accusing him of attempting to steal his motorcycle. The situation ended there
until Saturday evening when they met again with the victim's cousin, a media
official from the Amal Movement, and rebuked them verbally for their behavior.
In response, the latter opened fire at the media official from the Amal
Movement, but fortunately, no one was injured. Tensions escalated, resulting in
gunfire in the air for a few minutes, but no casualties were reported. Still, an
individual broke a leg after falling off his bike while attempting to flee from
the shooting area. The Lebanese Army promptly intervened, restoring order to the
area and conducting a series of raids to apprehend the main culprit responsible
for the gunfire involved in this incident and alleviate the apprehension and
fear among citizens and pedestrians in the region.
Sheikh Daamoush: All the attempts made by the US to target
the Resistance have failed
LBCI/ July 23 / 2023
In a statement, Sheikh Ali Daamoush, Deputy Head of the Executive Council of
Hezbollah, emphasized that all the attempts made by the United States to target
the Resistance have failed. He also asserted that efforts to steer the faithful
and religious youth away from the Resistance have been unsuccessful and will not
yield any results. Sheikh Daamoush stated that the generations of the
Resistance, which have overcome previous challenges, will not allow them to
divide the country, undermine its unity, destabilize its stability, or harm its
national unity. Regarding the United States' project in Lebanon, he affirmed
that it will not succeed because the people possess the required level of
awareness, consciousness, and national responsibility. He declared they would
not be affected by sieges, sanctions, or economic and financial pressures.
Sheikh Daamoush highlighted that despite their intense pressure in previous
years, they have not yielded to any outcome desired by their opponents, and they
will remain committed to their responsibilities.
Rome Conference on Mediterranean migration: Lebanese
Prime Minister Najib Mikati's speech
LBCI/ July 23 / 2023
Distinguished Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni,
Your Highnesses, Excellencies,
Ladies and gentlemen,
First and foremost, I would like to express my gratitude to Prime Minister
Giorgia Meloni and the Italian government for organizing this important meeting
on development and migration. I vividly recall our first meeting in March, where
we discussed how to address a common issue faced by both our countries: illegal
migration in Italy and the refugee crisis in Lebanon. During that meeting, we
emphasized the significance of convening a dialogue table or an international
conference involving all relevant countries and international stakeholders.
I also want to stress that the "Rome Process" meeting constitutes a first step
towards forging a strong strategic partnership and enhancing coordination
between the European Union, Mediterranean countries, and Lebanon. Our shared
goal is to effectively tackle the refugee crisis in a manner that aligns with
the expectations of the region's population, safeguards peace and security in
Lebanon, and assists Europe in addressing specific migration and
development-related challenges, with the priority being the preservation of
lives, internal stability, and security in our respective nations.
Today, I stand before you to shed light on some urgent issues that not only
impact the broader Mediterranean region but also have a profound effect on my
country, Lebanon. These include migration, the refugee crisis, security, peace,
stability, and prosperity.
Although Lebanon has not signed the United Nations High Commissioner for
Refugees (UNHCR) 1951 Refugee Convention, we must acknowledge the flexibility
and compassion shown by Lebanon in providing shelter and assistance to Syrians
during the Syrian war despite extremely limited resources and severe job
opportunities in the country. Lebanese people welcomed refugees with open arms
and shared all they had to support them during these challenging times.
Seventy-five years of distressing challenges, periodic conflicts and wars,
fleeting hopes, missed opportunities, and inadequate development strategies...
All these trials have tested the resilience of a single nation!
Distinguished Prime Minister,
Esteemed Guests,
As you are well aware, the conflict in Syria has forced millions of people to
flee their homes, seeking safety and refuge in neighboring countries like
Lebanon. However, the fundamental question arises: What do these refugees
envision for their future? Do they see Lebanon as their permanent home, or do
they aspire to reach Europe in search of better opportunities and stability?
The answer is complex and varies with individual aspirations. Therefore, we must
all understand these hopes and aspirations in order to formulate appropriate
policies to address this matter.
The Lebanese government's stance on this issue is as follows: Now that the
conflict in Syria has ended, we need to develop a plan for the safe and secure
return of all refugees to their homeland. International organizations and donor
countries should redirect the funds to host refugees in Lebanon to support
individuals and families who return to their home country.
Presently, the situation in Lebanon is critical, particularly considering its
hosting of one of the highest numbers of refugees relative to its population in
the world! This unsustainable situation grows more pressing each day. Lebanon, a
relatively small country with a population of five million, now accommodates
approximately two million Syrian refugees. To put this in perspective, it is as
if Italy were to host and accommodate 20 million refugees.
This disproportionate burden places immense strain on the country's
infrastructure, economy, and social fabric, which an unprecedented economic and
financial crisis has severely impacted.
Unfortunately, the recent resolution by the European Union Parliament
(RC-B9-0323-2023) appears to overlook the multifaceted complexities and
challenges that Lebanon faces. Rather than recognizing Lebanon's resilience and
supporting it and the Lebanese Armed Forces in addressing the refugee crisis, we
find ourselves blamed or, more accurately, penalized for our hospitality and
efforts.
Therefore, I must reiterate Lebanon's disappointment with the EU Parliament's
recent decision. This decision is a clear violation of Lebanese sovereignty and
fails to consider the concerns and aspirations of the Lebanese people. The
pressure imposed by this crisis and the dire consequences of the long-term
presence of Syrian refugees in Lebanon undermine the social fabric and directly
threaten its model of diversity. Lebanon has borne this tremendous burden of
hosting Syrian refugees for 12 years, experiencing the worst economic crisis in
its history. Our resources, if any, are minimal to contain the impact of this
refugee crisis on Lebanese society and overall infrastructure. Lebanon is ready
to engage in dialogue, cooperation, and collaboration with all international
partners to develop a joint roadmap for addressing this crisis. We are eager to
enhance our cooperation with the European Union in this endeavor.
Distinguished Prime Minister,
Esteemed Guests,
Undoubtedly, the interrelated challenges of migration, development, security,
and the Mediterranean refugee crisis necessitate our collective efforts to
resolve them.
Let us strive together to achieve a future that embodies security, stability,
cooperation, and prosperity for the peoples of the Mediterranean region.
New Poll Shows Lebanese Frustrations with Government, Iran, and Other Powers
Catherine Cleveland/Washington Institute/July 23/2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/120401/%d9%83%d8%a7%d8%ab%d8%b1%d9%8a%d9%86-%d9%83%d9%84%d9%8a%d9%81%d9%84%d8%a7%d9%86%d8%af-%d9%85%d8%b9%d9%87%d8%af-%d9%88%d8%a7%d8%b4%d9%86%d8%b7%d9%86-%d8%a7%d8%b3%d8%aa%d8%b7%d9%84%d8%a7%d8%b9-%d8%ac/
New polling results from Lebanon emphasize ways in which the country’s public is
frustrated domestically and at key Hezbollah ally Iran, while expressing mixed
views of other powers.
This poll, commissioned by the Washington Institute and conducted in March/April
2023, emphasizes the ways in which Lebanese are out of sync with other countries
polled in the region, as well as points where Lebanese views converge or diverge
by sect.
Ongoing Domestic Woes
With Lebanon in a state of collapse, and the still open question of who will
occupy the presidency after a months-long vacancy, Lebanese have little to be
optimistic about when it comes to domestic issues. Polling over the past several
years has repeatedly demonstrated that regardless of differences on other
issues, Lebanese are effectively unanimous in their frustrations with their
government on matters ranging from corruption to freedom of speech. And although
the protests of 2019 have subsided—in part due to brutal repression—92% of
respondents in this latest polling continue to reject the assertion that “it’s a
good thing we don’t have mass street protests against corruption.” Such views
mark the Lebanese public as an outlier in a region where many Arabs oppose large
demonstrations.
Open imageiconSpring 2023 Lebanon AA Chart
Deep Frustrations with Iran
Such frustrations appear to be spilling over into views of outside actors
involved in Lebanon. Of particular note is that there is by no means a unanimous
view of Iran, including among Lebanon’s Shia population. Among these Shia
respondents, only 58% classify Iran as primarily a friend of the country.
Meanwhile, a quarter see Iran as either an enemy or a competitor. In the case of
Sunni and Christian respondents, those who see Iran as an enemy jumps to 66% and
83% respectively. Notably, the proportion of Lebanese overall who see Iran as an
enemy is effectively the same proportion as in Saudi Arabia or the UAE—and a
larger proportion than in Egypt, Jordan, or Kuwait. Just 18% of Lebanese overall
characterize Iran as first and foremost a ‘friend.’
Open imageiconSpring 2023 Lebanon Iran Chart
Many Lebanese are also looking for movement on Iran’s position in the region. On
the one hand, Lebanese are by and large supportive of the restoration of
relations between Saudi Arabia and Iran. 83% say that this is a positive
development—compared to just 31% of Saudi citizens. On the other hand, over half
of Lebanese Sunni (53%) agree with the provocative statement “Since Iran is now
getting so close to having a nuclear bomb, it’s time for an Arab country to get
one too.” Moreover, when asked whether they agree that “a major American or
Israeli military strike on Iran would be too dangerous, and a bad idea for our
country,” a similar percentage of Lebanese Sunni (54%) disagree—standing out
from attitudes in other countries on the question.
Lebanese Sunni Muslims were likewise largely in favor of the anti-government
protests in Iran when asked back in November 2022, with 69% suggesting that they
would have a positive effect on the region. More in line with public opinion in
other states is the view on the regional impact of Arab states restoring
relations with Assad. In this case, views are split down the middle, with half
of respondents viewing this normalization in a positive light. This percentage
jumps to 71% among Shia respondents.
Significant Antipathy against US, Russia, China
Looking towards other outside actors would be one potential avenue for
addressing the country’s political and economic challenges. Nevertheless,
Lebanese of different confessions are divided on the roles of outside states.
Significant percentages of Lebanese see the major global powers of the United
States, Russia, and China as enemies of the country even as others describe them
as friends.
Lebanon is the only county polled, for instance, where almost half (47%) view
the United States as “an enemy of our country.” Such views are not limited to
Shia Lebanese, likely the most directly targeted with Hezbollah messaging about
Washington—about forty percent of Sunni and Christian Lebanese agree. In these
latter cases, however, roughly one-third (34% and 33%, respectively) instead
list the United States as “a friend of the country.” Relatively few see the
United States as primarily either a security or economic partner.
Neither is there a consensus over an alternative ‘friend’ of the country. In the
case of China, 30% of respondents are most likely to state that China is an
enemy of Lebanon. And when asked the same of Russia, this is all the more so the
case: 30% of Shia, 44% of Sunni, and 54% of Christians state that Russia is an
enemy.
Such attitudes towards Russia spill into respondents’ perception of the war in
Ukraine. Of the seven countries polled, Lebanese are the public most split as to
their views of a Russian military victory. Whereas about three fourths of Gulf,
Jordanian, and Egyptian respondents agree that “the best outcome would be a
Russian victory, including the annexation of significant Ukrainian territory to
Russia,” the Lebanese public is more ambivalent. Even among Shia respondents,
who are the most likely subgroup to agree with the statement, only 63% agree.
Moreover, just a third of Sunni and Christian Lebanese agree. About half instead
disagree strongly with this view—compared to just around 10% in other countries.
Staunch opposition to Israel—with Exception of Maritime Deal
The vast majority of Lebanese remain staunchly opposed to relations with Israel,
either in the case of humanitarian aid or economic ties. And in contrast to
those in the Gulf, a large proportion of Lebanese (62%) believe that Hamas
rocket attacks from Gaza on their southern neighbor are a positive development
for the region. Nevertheless, the Israeli-Lebanon maritime deal remains popular
among more than half of Lebanese respondents (58%), though the proportion of
Shia Lebanese who support the deal has dropped by about ten percentage points
since last November.
Methodological Note
This analysis is based on findings from a survey among a representative, random
national sample of 1,000 Lebanese citizens. Sample selection followed standard
geographic probability procedures, yielding a statistical margin of error of
approximately 3 percent. The survey was conducted by a highly qualified,
experienced, and completely apolitical regional commercial firm. Strict quality
controls and assurances of confidentiality were provided throughout. Additional
details, including full question wording and data set with demographic breaks,
are available on our interactive polling platform.
*Catherine Cleveland is The Washington Institute's Croft-Wagner Family Fellow
and managing editor of Fikra Forum. She recently received a master’s degree in
Middle East Studies from the University of Chicago.
Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published
on July 23-24/2023
Iran kicks off air force drill as US sends more fighter planes to the region
TEHRAN, Iran (AP)/Sun, July 23, 2023
Iran on Sunday began an annual air force drill in the central part of country,
state media reported, as the U.S. sends more fighter planes to the region to
deter the Islamic Republic from seizing commercial vessels in the Persian Gulf
area.
The official IRNA news agency said 11 Iranian air force bases participated in
the drill, dubbed Fadaeian Velyat-11, or Devotees of the Supreme Leader-11. It
said an air base at the southern port of Bandar Abbas at the mouth of the
strategic Strait of Hormuz is active in the drill. The Strait of Hormuz is the
narrow mouth of the Persian Gulf through which 20% of all crude oil passes. The
report said more than 90 fighter planes, bombers and drones would participate in
the drill. Air Force Chief Gen. Hamid Vahedi said the drill's message is one of
friendship, peace and security in the region. “Sustainable security, improving
and fostering regional ties, peaceful coexistence and defending air borders are
on the agenda,” he said. From time to time Iran holds such drills and says they
are designed to assess force's combat readiness and demonstrate the nation’s
military capabilities. The U.S. said last week it is sending additional fighter
jets and a warship to the Strait of Hormuz and Gulf of Oman to increase security
in the wake of Iranian attempts to seize commercial ships there. The Pentagon
said the USS Thomas Hudner, a destroyer, and a number of F-35 fighter jets will
be heading to the area. The Hudner had been in the Red Sea. The U.S. move comes
after Iran earlier in July tried to seize two oil tankers, the Marshall
Islands-flagged TRF Moss and the Bahamian-flagged Richmond Voyager, near the
strait last week, opening fire on one of them. The U.S. Navy said in both
instances the Iranian naval vessels backed off when the USS McFaul, a
guided-missile destroyer, arrived on the scene. The U.S. Navy says Iran has
seized at least five commercial vessels in the last two years and has harassed
more than a dozen others. Many of the confrontations have happened in and around
the Strait of Hormuz. The West accuses Iran of using seized commercial vessels
as bargaining chips. Iran denies the charge saying it seized the vessels after
they collided with local vessels and polluted the waterway. Tensions have
steadily risen since the administration of former U.S. President Donald Trump
unilaterally withdrew from Iran’s 2015 nuclear agreement with world powers and
restored crippling sanctions. Iran has responded by ramping up its nuclear
activities — which it says are purely peaceful — and also provided drones to
Russia for its war against Ukraine.
Four police officers killed in south-eastern Iranian
attack
AFP./July 23, 2023
Four traffic police officers were killed in a "terrorist attack" in the Sistan
and Baluchestan province in southeastern Iran, as reported by state media on
Sunday. According to the official news agency "IRNA," "Four traffic police
officers were martyred today (Sunday) as a result of a terrorist attack on a
patrol of traffic police on the Kash-Tafatan axis in Sistan and Baluchestan
province." Earlier, the agency had mentioned the death of three officers, but
the fourth officer succumbed to his injuries later. The province, bordering
Pakistan and Afghanistan, is one of the poorest regions in Iran and often
witnesses attacks on security forces and security incidents attributed to armed
militants belonging to extremist organizations, rebels from the Baloch minority,
or networks involved in drug and fuel smuggling. On July 8th, a police officer
was killed in an attack on a police station in the city of Zahedan, the
provincial capital. The attack involved a shootout that resulted in the killing
of four assailants, according to state media. The extremist Sunni group "Jaish
al-Adl," classified by Tehran as a "terrorist" organization, claimed
responsibility for the attack in the province, accusing them of launching their
attacks from neighboring Pakistan. In recent months, Zahedan has witnessed
tensions due to protests that erupted across the country since September
following the death of Mahsa Amini after she was arrested by the morality police
for not complying with dress code rules.
Netanyahu gets pacemaker ahead of vote on
judicial reforms
Agence France Presse./July 23, 2023
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu underwent surgery to implant a
pacemaker on Sunday, just hours before lawmakers began debate on a controversial
judicial overhaul bill that has brought tens of thousands of protesters to the
streets. Protests have intensified in the days leading up to the debate, which
began Sunday ahead of a parliamentary vote on Monday which could see a key part
of the proposals passed into law. Despite his operation, Netanyahu vowed to be
there for the vote. The judicial revamp proposed by his hard-right government
has split the nation and, since its unveiling in January, sparked one of the
biggest protest movements in Israel's history. Opponents see the proposed revamp
as a threat to Israel's democracy. "We want to continue to live in a Jewish and
a democratic state," opposition leader Yair Lapid said at the start of debate.
"We must stop this legislation," he said. Sheba Medical Center performed the
surgery on Netanyahu, a statement from his office said, while Deputy Prime
Minister Yariv Levin stood in for him. Days earlier Netanyahu, 73, had been
discharged from the same facility after a night of hospitalisation following
complaints of dizziness."A week ago I had a monitoring device implanted and this
device beeped this evening and announced that I needed to get a pacemaker. I
have to do this tonight, I feel great and I listen to my doctors," Netanyahu
said in a video posted on his Facebook page.
- Hours of debate -
The hospital confirmed after the surgery that Netanyahu's condition was good.
"He will remain under medical supervision in the cardiology department," it said
in a statement. "The doctors tell me that I will be free and I will be released
from the hospital tomorrow afternoon (Sunday) and will be able to go to the
Knesset to vote," Netanyahu said prior to the surgery. Debate is expected to
last hours, into Monday morning, and more than 20 lawmakers are scheduled to
speak against the bill, according to a list provided by parliament. The final
vote Monday will be on the "reasonability" clause through which judges can
strike down government decisions. Netanyahu's government, which includes
extreme-right and ultra-Orthodox Jewish allies, plans to curb the Supreme
Court's powers granted under this clause. They argue the changes are necessary
to ensure a better balance of power. Critics accuse Netanyahu, who is on trial
on corruption charges he denies, of trying to use the reforms to quash possible
judgements against him. He rejects the accusation. The "reasonability" clause
was most recently cited by Israel's top court to force Netanyahu to remove an
ultra-Orthodox cabinet member over a previous tax evasion conviction. If
approved on Monday, it would be the first major component of the proposed legal
overhaul to become law.Other proposed changes include giving the government a
greater say in the appointment of judges.
- Prayers at Western Wall -
Protests have drawn support from across political and social strata, from both
the left and the right, secular and religious groups, peace activists and
military reservists, as well as blue-collar and workers in the tech sector
crucial to the country's economy. Early on Sunday, hundreds of protesters prayed
at the Western Wall in Israeli-annexed east Jerusalem, the holiest place where
Jews can pray. Carrying Israeli flags, many also formed a human chain at
different locations in Jerusalem including in front of Jaffa Gate in the Old
City. "We have to keep the pressure, we have to guard our democracy," said
protester Amir Goldstein, who spent the night in a tent near parliament. Tens of
thousands like him rallied in Jerusalem on Saturday. Many had arrived from Tel
Aviv after a multi-day march. More protests were planned later on Sunday in Tel
Aviv, while right-wing supporters of the judicial overhaul were also scheduled
to rally there. Tens of thousands had protested in Tel Aviv on Saturday evening,
their 29th weekly rally since the proposals were unveiled. Many wore shirts with
"Democracy" printed on them. "The government is not listening to us, it means
it's the beginning of a new era, a bad era," protester Idit Dekel, 55, told AFP.
"For me it is catastrophic," added Dekel, a tech employee. Protesters also got
support from more than 1,100 air force reservists, including fighter pilots, who
have threatened to suspend their volunteer service if the reforms become law.
Late Thursday, Netanyahu said he was "still trying to reach an agreement with
the opposition", mainly on the "reasonability" clause.
Jerusalem sees thousands of protesters as Netanyahu
moves forward with judicial reforms
Ken Tran, USA TODAY/July 23, 2023
Thousands of protesters trekked into Jerusalem Saturday night as the right-wing
government moves to vote on the key piece of its controversial judicial reform
plans that would curb how the Supreme Court can overrule government decisions.
Demonstrators carrying Israeli flags marched for several days through scorching
heat on a roughly 45-mile trek starting in Tel Aviv in an attempt to block the
Israeli parliament from approving the legislation, which critics say could allow
for greater government overreach. Opponents were camped outside the country's
parliament and Israelis on both sides of the issue were praying outside the
Western Wall. But Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he would be back at
work Monday after being hospitalized for an emergency heart procedure. “This
extremist group has no mandate to turn Israel into a messianic and
non-democratic state,” opposition leader Yair Lapid said Thursday. “The
Netanyahu government is waging a war of attrition against the citizens of
Israel.” Demonstrators wave Israeli national flags as they march on the highway
near the town of Mevaseret Zion on Saturday, during a multiday march from Tel
Aviv to Jerusalem to protest the government's judicial overhaul bill ahead
of a vote in the parliament. Israel has been rocked by a months-long wave of
protests after the government unveiled in January plans to overhaul the judicial
system that opponents say threatens the country's democracy. Demonstrators
wave Israeli national flags as they march on the highway near the town of
Mevaseret Zion on Saturday, during a multiday march from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem
to protest the government's judicial overhaul bill ahead of a vote in the
parliament. Israel has been rocked by a months-long wave of protests after the
government unveiled in January plans to overhaul the judicial system that
opponents say threatens the country's democracy.
Why are Israelis protesting?
Netanyahu’s proposed reforms have incited constant intense protests across the
country for seven months since the plans were unveiled in January. Protests were
most intense at one point when Netanyahu fired his defense minister for publicly
opposing the reforms in March with demonstrators blocking highways and rallying
outside Netanyahu’s home in Jerusalem. Netanyahu later reversed his decision to
fire his defense minister in April. Israel could see even more intense protests
when the country’s parliament is expected to vote on a series of reforms on
Monday.
What are the judicial reforms in Israel?
The judicial reforms being voted on Monday will limit Israel’s Supreme Court to
block government decisions it deems “unreasonable.” Proponents of the judicial
reforms contend the standard of “reasonableness” gives the Supreme Court too
much broad authority over the government. The U.S., a longtime ally of Israel,
has also attempted to pressure Netanyahu and his allies to halt its plans to
overhaul the country’s judiciary. President Joe Biden called Netanyahu last
Monday and urged him to find a “consensus” on the issue. “President Biden
reiterated, in the context of the current debate in Israel about judicial
reform, the need for the broadest possible consensus, and that shared democratic
values have always been and must remain a hallmark of the U.S.-Israel
relationship,” the White House said in a statement about the call.
New forum aims to tackle Syria-Jordan drug smuggling
AFP/July 23, 2023
AMMAN: A new forum to combat drug smuggling from war-ravaged Syria through
Jordan to the wealthy Gulf states held its first meeting in Amman on Sunday, the
Jordanian foreign ministry said. The forum was agreed during talks between
Jordanian Foreign Minister Ayman Safadi and Syrian President Bashar Assad in
Damascus earlier this month as regional concern mounts over an influx of the
banned stimulant captagon from Syria. The Syrian delegation was headed by
Defense Minister General Ali Mahmud Abbas and General Intelligence Director,
Major General Husam Louka. Jordan’s was led by the chairman of Joint Chiefs of
Staff, Major General Yousef Huneiti, and General Intelligence director, Major
General Ahmed Husni, the Jordanian ministry said. The talks “went over the issue
of the parties that organize, run and carry out smuggling operations across
borders to Jordan, as well as necessary measures to... confront this escalating
danger to the entire region,” the ministry said. Jordanian security forces have
tightened border controls in recent years and occasionally announce thwarted
drugs and weapons smuggling attempts from Syria. There has been increasing
regional engagement with Assad’s government since its readmission to the Arab
League in May, ending more than a decade of isolation since civil war erupted in
Syria in 2011.
Russia's Putin: Black Sea grain deal became meaningless
July 24 (Reuters)/Sun, July 23, 2023
Russia withdrew from the Black Sea grain deal that ensured the safe export of
Ukrainian grains because the agreement lost its meaning, President Vladimir
Putin wrote in an article published early on Monday. "The continuation of the
'grain deal' - which did not justify its humanitarian purpose - has lost its
meaning," Putin said, according to the article on the Kremlin's website. Saying
that Russia's conditions for the extension had been ignored, Moscow last week
quit the deal which had allowed Ukraine a year ago to export grain from its
Black Sea ports, despite the war, to alleviate a global food crisis.
The key demands Putin presented last week for Moscow to return to the deal,
however, did not directly refer to humanitarian purposes. After quitting the
deal, Russia has been pounding Ukrainian food-exporting ports nearly on a daily
basis. An attack on Sunday on the southern port of Odesa killed one person and
injured scores more. Writing ahead of the second Russia-Africa summit that will
take place in St. Petersburg on Thursday and Friday, Putin said that Russia
expects a record harvest this year. "I want to assure that our country is able
to replace Ukrainian grain both commercially and free of charge, especially
since we again expect a record harvest this year," Putin said. Russia and the
West have been increasingly vying for influence in Africa. Although Moscow has
so far invested very little there, according to data from the United Nations,
Russia has been on a diplomatic push to win the continent's support. During a
U.N. vote in March 2022 to condemn Russia's invasion of Ukraine, 28 African
nations voted in favour of the resolution, but 25 either voted to abstain or did
not vote at all. "Russia will continue to vigorously work on organising the
supply of grain, food, fertilizers and more to Africa: we highly value and
continue to dynamically develop the entire range of economic ties with Africa,"
Putin wrote.
Putin claims Ukrainian counteroffensive has 'failed'
Agence France Presse./July 23, 2023
Russian President Vladimir Putin told his Belarus counterpart Alexander
Lukashenko Sunday that an ongoing Ukrainian counteroffensive to push back
Russian forces from Ukraine has "failed", according to Russian news agencies.
"There is no counteroffensive," Lukashenko said, according to the TASS news
agency before being interrupted by Putin: "There is one, but it has failed."
Russia and Iran's 'unprecedented' military ties worried
the US, but it's starting to look like Russia can't hold up its end of the deal
Paul Iddon/Business Insider/Sun, July 23, 2023
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/120404/120404/
Iran has supported Russia by providing it with arms to use in Ukraine.That has
worried the US, which sees it as part of a growing Russian-Iranian defense
partnership.But there are signs that Moscow may not deliver on the agreements it
has made with Tehran.
Less than a year ago, the White House was warning of "unprecedented" military
ties between Russia and Iran, but today, there are signs of increasing friction,
with Moscow proving to be an unreliable partner.
Late last year, as Russia risked depleting its missile stockpiles after months
of fighting in Ukraine, Iran agreed to supply Moscow with arms, mostly
Shahed-136 one-way attack drones, which Russia has used in attacks on Ukrainian
cities and infrastructure.
In December, National Security Council spokesman John Kirby said Iran and Russia
were forging "a full-scale defense partnership" that would threaten the Middle
East and the wider world. Kirby said "support is flowing both ways," with Moscow
providing Tehran "an unprecedented level of military and technical support."
As part of this burgeoning partnership, Iran expected to receive an unspecified
number of Russian Su-35 jets, along with helicopters and even advanced S-400
air-defense systems. Yet there is no indication Iran has received any equipment
or will receive any of it the foreseeable future.
Analysts expected Iran would receive at least 24 Su-35s — aircraft Russia built
for Egypt as part of an order that was later canceled — in the near future, but
in recent statements, Iranian officials have gone from expressing optimism that
the first jets would arrive in a matter of months, if not weeks, to making
comments that suggest they are unsure if the jets will arrive in the coming
years.
In a damning report published on July 13, Tehran-based journalist Saeed Azimi
cited one current and one former Iranian diplomat who, under condition of
anonymity, told him that Iran "fully paid" for 50 Su-35s during the second term
of former President Hassan Rouhani, who left office in August 2021.
While the figure of 50 Su-35s had not been disclosed prior to Azimi's article,
it fits with Iran's longstanding estimate that it needs 64 new fighters to
modernize its aging fleet, which is mostly composed of US-made jets acquired
before the 1979 revolution.
Moscow promised delivery of the Su-35s by 2023, which the diplomats quoted by
Azimi doubt will happen. "Iranian officials feel embarrassment over Russia's
failure to adhere to commitments," Azimi wrote.
As if to add insult to injury, in July, Moscow backed a joint statement by the
Gulf Cooperation Council that supported the United Arab Emirates' claim over Abu
Musa, Greater Tunb, and Lesser Tunb, three small but important islands in the
Persian Gulf near the Strait of Hormuz. Iran has controlled the islands since
1971, seizing them after the British left the region. The UAE, formed the same
year, has claimed them ever since.
Iran summoned Russia's ambassador and asked Moscow to "correct its position,"
which Tehran no doubt views as unacceptable interference in its internal
affairs.
By supporting the GCC statement, Russia is demonstrating how it still aims to
balance relations with Iran and the Arab Gulf states, despite its ostensible
strategic partnership with the former. Moscow has important economic ties with
those Arab states that have only grown since its attacked Ukraine last year.
Interestingly, in response to Russia's move, Iranian state-run media played down
their partnership, saying it was merely tactical and that Moscow is not a
strategic ally.
The head of Britain's Secret Intelligence Service, Richard Moore, said this week
that Iran was seeking cash by selling arms to Russia, which seems to bolster
earlier reports that Tehran sold Moscow drone technology for $900 million, paid
in US dollars, and suggests the Iranians seek a transactional relationship with
the Russians rather than a strategic defense partnership.
While Iran has never armed Russia to the extent it has in recent months, Moscow
has sold Tehran considerable military hardware in the past. After the Iran-Iraq
war ended in August 1988, the Soviet Union gave Tehran a "blank check" to buy
any conventional armaments it wanted.
At the time, the Soviets were offering 72 MiG-29 and 24 MiG-31 fighters and 36
Su-24MK tactical bomber. However, Tehran was strapped for cash after the
eight-year war with its neighbor and could only afford a smaller number of
MiG-29s and Su-24MKs, as well as S-200 air-defense systems. Moscow delivered the
aircraft in 1990 and 1991.
Those sales were recently described as "the most important acquisition of
military technology by the Islamic Republic until now and perhaps even as of
now."
Russian arms sales to Iran have continued but haven't reached the level of that
briefly amicable period, when Moscow and Tehran weren't even allies and had no
formal alliance or partnership like they purportedly do today.
Russia sold Iran only six relatively low-tech Su-25 attack planes in the 2000s.
In 2007, Iran signed an $800 million contract for Russian S-300 air-defense
systems, but Moscow refused to deliver them for almost a decade, only
transferring them in 2016.
The UN arms embargo on Iran officially expired in October 2020, leaving no
international restrictions that Russia could use as a pretext for refusing to
deliver weapons for which Iran has reportedly already paid.
With their partnership looking more and more one-sided, Iranians may ask what
they are getting militarily or politically from aiding Russia. Moore and his US
counterpart, CIA director William Burns, say there are already signs of that.
"Iran's decision to supply Russia with the suicide drones that mete out random
destruction to Ukraine's cities has provoked internal quarrels at the highest
level of the regime in Tehran," Moore said on Wednesday.
The US has also seen signs, Burns said Thursday, that "Iranian leadership has
hesitated about supplying ballistic missiles to the Russians, which was also on
their wish list as well, partly because they're concerned not just about our
reaction but about European reaction as well."
Paul Iddon is a freelance journalist and columnist who writes about Middle East
developments, military affairs, politics, and history. His articles have
appeared in a variety of publications focused on the region.
Russia Using 'Disinformation' To Exaggerate Small
Military Gains, Says UK
Kevin Schofield/HuffPost UK/July 23, 2023
Russia is using “disinformation” to exaggerate small military gains in Ukraine,
according to the UK. In their latest update on the progress of the war, the
Ministry of Defence (MoD) said there had been “an increase in artillery fire
along the north of the front line” in recent days. “This has likely been
accompanied by some increase in Russian small-unit assaults, but the situation
has been obfuscated by Russian disinformation,” the MoD said. “Russia has likely
only achieved marginal gains, but its renewed activity in the north highlights
its importance to the Kremlin.” The MoD said that Russian strategists are trying
“to create a buffer zone around Luhansk Oblast, the possession of which Russia
almost certainly considers one of its fundamental objectives of the war”. It is
the second time in recent days that the MoD has accused Russia of spreading
disinformation. UK officials said on Thursday that the Kremlin had concealed its
real reason for leaving the Black Sea Grain Initiative. Moscow chose not to
renew the pivotal agreement – brokered by the UN and Turkey in July 2022 – in
which it had promised to lift its wartime blockade so Ukrainian grain could
safely be exported. Publicly, Moscow has claimed that the UN has not kept to its
side of the bargain and helped Russia increase its own exports of grains and
fertilisers. But the MoD said: “Russia likely made the decision to leave some
time ago, because it decided that the deal was no longer serving its interests.”
Russian strike on Ukraine's Odesa leaves 1 dead, many hurt
and a cathedral badly damaged
Associated Press/July 23, 2023
Russia struck the Ukrainian Black Sea city of Odesa again on Sunday, local
officials said, keeping up a barrage of attacks that has damaged critical port
infrastructure in southern Ukraine in the past week. At least one person was
killed and 22 others wounded in the attack in the early hours.
Regional Gov. Oleh Kiper said that four children were among those wounded in the
blasts, which severely damaged the historic Transfiguration Cathedral, a
landmark Orthodox cathedral in the city. Russia has been launching persistent
attacks on Odesa, a key hub for exporting grain, since Moscow canceled a
landmark grain deal on Monday amid Kyiv's grinding efforts to retake its
occupied territories. Kiper noted that six residential buildings, including
apartment buildings, were destroyed by the strikes. In one such case in downtown
Odesa, some people became trapped in their apartments as a result of the damage
caused by the attack, which left rubble strewn in the street and partly blocking
the road, and damage to power lines. Svitlana Molcharova, 85, was rescued by
emergency service workers. But after she received first medical aid, she refused
to leave her destroyed apartment. "I will stay here," she said to the emergency
service worker who advised her to leave.
"I woke up when the ceiling started to fall on me. I rushed into the corridor,"
said Ivan Kovalenko, 19, another resident of the building. He came to Odesa
having fled the city of Mykolaiv in search of a safer place to live after his
house was destroyed. "That's how I lost my home in Mykolaiv, and here, I lost my
rented apartment. " In his home, the ceiling partially collapsed, the balcony
came off the side of the building, and all the windows were blown out. The
Transfiguration Cathedral, one of the most important and largest Orthodox
Cathedrals in Odesa, was severely damaged. Local officials said that the icon of
the patroness of the city had been retrieved from under the rubble. "The
destruction is enormous, half of the cathedral is now roofless," said Archdeacon
Andrii Palchuk, as cathedral workers brought documents and valuable items out of
the building, the floor of which was inundated with water used by firefighters
to extinguish the fire. Palchuk said the damage was caused by a direct hit from
a Russian missile that penetrated the building down to the basement and caused
significant damage. Two people who were inside at the time of the strike were
wounded. "But with God's help, we will restore it," he said, bursting into
tears.
The cathedral belongs to the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, which has been accused
of links to Russia. The church has insisted that it's loyal to Ukraine, has
denounced the Russian invasion from the start and has even declared its
independence from Moscow. But Ukrainian security agencies have claimed that some
in the Ukrainian church have maintained close ties with Moscow. They've raided
numerous holy sites of the church and later posted photos of rubles, Russian
passports and leaflets with messages from the Moscow patriarch as proof that
some church officials have been loyal to Russia. Odesa's historic center was
designated an endangered World Heritage Site by UNESCO earlier this year despite
Russian opposition. Russia's Defense Ministry said Sunday that Russian forces
had attacked sites in Odesa, "where terrorist acts against the Russian
Federation were being prepared."
The ministry said in a statement that the strikes were carried out with sea- and
air-based long-range high-precision weapons, and that there are "foreign
mercenaries" at the targeted sites. In a later statement, the ministry denied
that its attacks had struck the Transfiguration Cathedral, claiming that the
destruction of the cathedral was likely due to "the fall of a Ukrainian
anti-aircraft guided missile." Earlier Russian attacks this week crippled
significant parts of export facilities in Odesa and nearby Chornomorsk and
destroyed 60,000 tons of grain, according to Ukraine's Agriculture Ministry. The
attacks come days after President Vladimir Putin pulled Russia out of the Black
Sea Grain Initiative, a wartime deal that enabled Ukraine's exports to reach
many countries facing the threat of hunger. Putin vowed to retaliate against
Kyiv for an attack Monday on the crucial Kerch Bridge linking Russia with the
Crimean Peninsula, which the Kremlin illegally annexed in 2014.
End of Russian-Chinese military exercises in the Sea of
Japan
AFP/July 23, 2023
The Russian Defense Ministry announced on Sunday that Russia and China have
completed their joint military exercises in the Sea of Japan, amidst escalating
tensions with Western countries. The relationship between the two neighboring
nations, united in their desire to counter American dominance, has seen a
military convergence since Russia's invasion of Ukraine, which China refrained
from condemning. In recent months, China and Russia have conducted several
military exercises to enhance coordination between their armed forces. In March,
Chinese President Xi Jinping met with his Russian counterpart, Vladimir Putin,
in the Kremlin, and the two leaders expressed their determination to conduct
"regular joint patrols" to deepen mutual trust. The Russian army stated in a
press release that the "Russian-Chinese Naval Interaction 2023" exercises
concluded in the Sea of Japan. During the drills, which took place from Thursday
to Sunday, approximately twenty combat training sessions were conducted,
including joint artillery strikes on maritime, coastal, and aerial targets. In
June, China and Russia conducted a joint military air patrol over the East China
Sea and the Sea of Japan, prompting South Korea to deploy fighter jets as a
precautionary measure. This marks the sixth such joint exercise conducted by
Beijing and Moscow in the region since 2019. At the beginning of July, Chinese
Defense Minister Li Shangfu called for enhancing maritime military cooperation
with Russia during a meeting in Beijing with a senior Russian officer.
Right-wing preference in Spain and far-right elections
hopes for a return to power
AFP/July 23, 2023
Spanish citizens cast their votes on Sunday in early legislative elections, with
the right-wing appearing to have the advantage and the possibility of bringing
the far-right to power for the first time since the end of Franco's
dictatorship. After casting his vote in central Madrid, the leader of the
People's Party (right-wing), Alberto Núñez Feijóo, who could replace Socialist
Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez according to opinion polls, told the press that he
hopes Spain will "start a new era." Among the four main candidates, Sánchez was
the first to vote and stated to journalists that these elections are "very
important... for the world and for Europe."In an indication of the elections'
significance, voter turnout sharply increased to 40.48% at 14:00 (12:00 GMT),
compared to 37.92% in the last legislative elections in 2019. This number does
not include the 2.47 million voters out of 37.5 million who cast their ballots
by mail, setting a record due to the elections being held in mid-summer for the
first time. These elections have also garnered exceptional attention abroad due
to the possibility of a coalition between the conservative right-wing and the
far-right Vox party, whose support may be necessary for the People's Party to
form a government. Such a scenario could bring the far-right to power in Spain
for the first time since Franco's dictatorship ended nearly half a century ago
in 1975. After voting in Madrid, the leader of Vox party, Santiago Abascal,
stated that he is confident the elections "will allow for a change of course in
Spain."
Affirming the election's importance, the outgoing Minister of Labor Yolanda Díaz,
leader of the left-wing radical Sumar party and an ally of Sánchez, announced
that "these elections are the most important for my generation" and added that
their outcome "will shape the features of the coming decade."
Polling stations opened at 09:00 (07:00 GMT) for these elections, in which
voters are electing members of the Congress of Deputies (350 seats) and the
Senate (208 seats). Voting will close at 20:00 (18:00 GMT), and preliminary
results will be released approximately an hour later.
With the European elections scheduled for 2024, a right-wing victory, and
possibly the inclusion of the far-right in the government in the fourth largest
economy in the Eurozone, following its triumph in Italy last year, would deal a
severe blow to European left-wing parties. This would carry significant
symbolism, as Spain currently holds the rotating presidency of the European
Union.
Information technology expert Brian Sánchez (27 years old) who voted in
Barcelona told AFP that "forming a coalition government between the People's
Party and Vox would be beneficial because they would work to make Spain
better."All polls published until Monday predicted the victory of the People's
Party led by Alberto Núñez Feijóo (61 years old). However, the ban on publishing
polls five days before the elections has made the outcome uncertain. Feijóo
hopes to secure 176 seats, which would grant him an absolute majority in the
Congress of Deputies, which consists of 350 seats. However, no poll has
projected such a result, indicating that his party may need to form a coalition.
His only potential partner is the far-right Vox party, founded in 2013 after a
split from the People's Party, which currently governs three out of 17 regions
in Spain. Abascal warned the People's Party that the price of Vox's support
would be participation in the government. Feijóo did not disclose his intentions
regarding Vox, and in an interview with "El Mundo" on Friday, he said, "Two days
before the elections, the candidate should not say who he will form a coalition
with." However, he acknowledged that forming a coalition government with the
far-right nationalist party "is not ideal." Sánchez (51 years old), whose defeat
is indicated by opinion polls following the left's loss in local elections that
prompted him to call for these early elections, warned against the rise of the
far-right to power as the main theme of his election campaign. In a televised
debate on Wednesday, the outgoing Prime Minister argued that forming a coalition
government between the People's Party and Vox "is not just a setback for Spain
in terms of rights, but a serious setback for the European project."He believes
that the only alternative to such a coalition government is to maintain the
current left-wing coalition that was formed in 2020 between his Socialist Party
and the radical left. His words resonated with teacher Brauli Monyús (53 years
old) who told AFP in Barcelona that he hopes for the formation of a "progressive
government between the Socialists and Sumar."
Treaty that created modern Turkey still evokes pain for
some, 100 years after signing
Emma Farge and Brenna Hughes Neghaiwi/Sun, July 23, 2023
LAUSANNE, Switzerland (Reuters) /The Treaty of Lausanne that formed modern
Turkey is still cherished by some but remains a disappointment for others
including Kurds and Armenians who hoped for autonomous regions and justice for
Ottoman-era crimes. Some of those voices are included in an exhibit called
"Borders" - put on by the Swiss city's history museum to look at the
significance of the post-World War One deal 100 years after it was signed
between Turkey and allied powers like Britain and France on July 24, 1923.
Turkey's President Tayyip Erdogan commemorated the anniversary in a statement
last year, praising elements of it and saying that Turkey had meticulously
monitored its implementation. Sevgi Koyuncu, who was born in a Kurdish village
and now works in Lausanne, said her people had been "negated by a convention" in
an interview filmed in the palace where it was signed. Some 6,000 Kurdish
protesters joined a march through the city on Saturday, waving flags and forming
human chains. For Manuschak Karnusian, a Swiss resident whose Armenian
grandparents fled what is now Turkey in the early 20th century with the help of
missionaries and French war ships, the treaty is like a "second genocide". She
was referring to 1915 massacres and the forced deportation of Armenians in the
Ottoman Empire - an event now labelled genocide by dozens of countries but
denied by Turkey, which says thousands of both Turks and Armenians died in
inter-ethnic violence. "You cannot forget. You must show what this (treaty)
means," Karnusian told Reuters, saying that it stood for the "origin of the
denial of what happened" to the Armenians. While the agreement was hailed at the
time as a chance for lasting peace, some of its outcomes, like the exchange of
more than 1.5 million ethnic Greeks and Turks, are now seen as a "terrible
mistake", said Jonathan Conlin, a historian at a project that looks at the
legacy of the treaty. "I think it (the treaty) has endured because everyone's
equally unhappy about it," he said.
Sudan war enters 100th day as mediation attempts fail
Reuters)/Sun, July 23, 2023T
- Clashes flared in parts of Sudan on the 100th day of the war on Sunday as
mediation attempts by regional and international powers fail to find a path out
of an increasingly intractable conflict. The fighting broke out on April 15 as
the army and paramilitary Rapid Support Forces (RSF) vied for power, since when
more than 3 million people have been uprooted, including more than 700,000 who
have fled to neighbouring countries. Some 1,136 people have been killed,
according to the health ministry, though officials believe the number is higher.
Neither the army nor the RSF has been able to claim victory, with the RSF's
domination on the ground in the capital Khartoum up against the army's air and
artillery firepower. Infrastructure and government in the capital have fallen
apart while fighting has spread westwards, particularly to the fragile Darfur
region, as well as to the south, where the rebel SPLM-N group has tried to gain
territory. Over the weekend, the RSF moved into villages in Gezira State
directly south of Khartoum, where the army conducted air strikes against them,
according to witnesses. In Nyala, one of the country's largest cities and
capital of South Darfur, clashes have continued since Thursday in residential
areas, according to witnesses. At least 20 people have been killed, medical
sources say. The United Nations says 5,000 families have been displaced. Key
facilities have been looted, residents say. "Bullets are flying into homes. We
are terrified and no one is protecting us," said 35-year-old Salah Abdallah. The
fighting gave way to ethnically targeted attacks by Arab militias and the RSF in
West Darfur, from which hundreds of thousands of people have fled to Chad.
Residents have also accused RSF soldiers of looting and occupying wide swathes
of the capital. The RSF has said it would investigate.
While the two sides have shown openness towards mediation efforts led by
regional and international actors, none has resulted in a sustained ceasefire.
Both sides have sent delegations to attempt to re-start talks in Jeddah that
have yielded often-violated ceasefires. But the Sudanese foreign minister said
on Friday that indirect talks had not begun seriously. The leaders of the army
and RSF headed a joint council since the ouster of Omar al-Bashir in 2019, and
diverged over plans for a transition to democracy. Civilian political groups as
well as the RSF have accused the army of turning a blind eye to appearances by
wanted Bashir loyalists in recent days. The Forces of Freedom and Change, the
main civilian coalition, said on Sunday it was holding meeting in Egypt, which
has offered itself as a mediator in the conflict.
Plea for help as hunger stalks Khartoum
AFP/July 23, 2023
WAD MADANI, Sudan: In a war-devastated district of Sudan’s capital, Abbas
Mohammed Babiker says he and his family have only been able to eat once a day.
Now even that is in doubt, but on Sunday a citizens’ support group issued an
urgent appeal for donations to help people like him.
“We only have enough for two more days,” Babiker said from Khartoum North, where
residents said at least one person, a local musician, has already died from
hunger. Since April 15, battles between Sudan’s army led by Gen. Abdel Fattah
Al-Burhan and the paramilitary Rapid Support Forces or RSF, headed by Mohamed
Hamdan Dagalo, have killed more than 3,900 people, according to the latest toll
from the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project or ACLED. More than 2.6
million people have been internally displaced, mostly from Khartoum, the
International Organization for Migration said.
Thousands who remain in the capital, particularly in Khartoum North, are trapped
at home without water since the local water station was damaged at the start of
the war. Residents say there is only intermittent electricity and food has
nearly run out. Across the country, about one-third of the population already
faced hunger even before the war began, said the UN’s World Food Programme.
Despite the security challenges, the agency says it has reached more than 1.4
million people with emergency food aid as needs intensify. “With the fighting,
there is no market any more and anyway we have no money,” said another resident
of Khartoum North, Essam Abbas. To help them, the local “resistance committee,”
a pro-democracy neighborhood group, issued its emergency appeal. “We have to
support each other, give food and money and distribute to those around us,” the
committee wrote on Facebook.
In adjacent Omdurman, Khartoum’s other battle-scarred sister city, locally known
violinist Khaled Senhouri “died from hunger” last week, his friends wrote on
Facebook. In his own online posts, Senhouri had said he was unable to leave home
because of the fighting and had tried to hang on with the supplies that he had.
It wasn’t enough.
Lawyers and medics said on Saturday that at least 20 Sudanese civilians had been
killed by rocket fire on residential areas of one of Darfur’s main cities and by
shelling near hospitals in North Kordofan state. The doctors’ union said that
since Friday morning shells had struck near four hospitals in the North Kordofan
state capital El-Obeid, killing four civilians and wounding 45. In the South
Darfur state capital Nyala, the local lawyers’ union said that rocket fire had
killed 16 civilians. The Darfur region, already ravaged by brutal conflict in
the early 2000s, has seen some of the worst of the violence since fighting
erupted in mid-April between Sudanese rival generals vying for power. “During an
exchange of rocket fire between the army and the RSF, 16 civilians were killed
on Friday, according to a preliminary toll,” the lawyers’ union said. And at
least one man was killed by a sniper, it added. In the West Darfur capital of
El-Geneina, near Chad, snipers have reportedly been targeting residents from
rooftops since fighting began, and tens of thousands have fled across the
border. The war, which broke out in the capital Khartoum on April 15 and spread
to Darfur later that month, has left at least 3,000 dead across Sudan, according
to a conservative estimate. Fighting in Darfur, an RSF stronghold, has recently
concentrated around Nyala, after brutal clashes in El-Geneina where the UN had
reported atrocities. Battles have also continued in and around Khartoum.
Residents reported on Saturday the first army air strikes on villages in the Al-Jazirah
state, just south of the capital. The fertile land between the White Nile and
Blue Nile rivers now hosts several hundred thousands of the estimated 3.3
million people the war has displaced. If fighting expands into Al-Jazirah, they
may be forced to flee again. The humanitarian workers who support them would
have to move as well, but fear the many bureaucratic challenges in relocating
their operations. Analysts say both warring sides would like to see the
battlefield expand. “The RSF has held the upper hand in Khartoum since the early
days of the war, but that advantage is only growing more apparent,” the
International Crisis Group think tank said. The army on July 15 launched a major
offensive in North Khartoum, flattening entire suburban neighborhoods with air
raids, “but it failed spectacularly,” the ICG said.
The RSF, meanwhile, are trying to seize the main Darfur-Khartoum road to ensure
a constant supply of fighters and weapons.
Pope’s plea over refugee plight as Saudi delegation
attends Rome migration talks
Arab News/July 23, 2023
Italian PM seeks to build alliance to tackle illegal migration
Saudi delegation headed by interior minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Saud
ROME: Pope Francis has appealed to European and African leaders “for urgent
relief” for refugees, saying that help is needed for “these brothers and
sisters” suffering while trying to reach Europe.
“May the Mediterranean never again be a theater of death and inhumanity. May the
Lord enlighten the minds and hearts of all, arousing feelings of fraternity,
solidarity and welcome,” the pope told worshippers in St. Peter’s Square on
Sunday.
The pontiff’s comments come as top representatives of European, Mediterranean
and Middle Eastern countries gather in the Italian capital to discuss tackling
illegal migration, including extending an EU-backed deal with Tunisia to curb
the flow of asylum-seekers to European shores.
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni on Sunday inaugurated a “dialogue of
equals” forum on migration and development based on joint interests between
Europe and countries in the broader Mediterranean region.
The conference, which seeks to address irregular migration and promote growth in
North Africa, was announced by Meloni during one of her three trips to Tunisia
in the past month.
EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and Tunisian President Kais Saied
are among participants in the forum, which will be held at the Italian Ministry
of Foreign Affairs amid high security.
High-ranking representatives from North African and Middle Eastern countries
include the presidents of the UAE and Mauritania, and prime ministers from
Algeria, Libya, Egypt, Ethiopia, Jordan, Lebanon, Malta and Niger.
Top representatives of European, Mediterranean and Middle Eastern countries
gathered in the Italian capital to discuss tackling illegal migration. (SPA)
Prince Abdulaziz bin Saud, the Saudi interior minister, represented the Kingdom
at the conference.
Speaking on behalf of King Salman and Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Prince
Abdulaziz highlighted Saudi Arabia’s commitment to upholding human rights norms
and advancing sustainable development.
He spoke of the Kingdom’s “unwavering firm stance in favor of international
collaboration in addressing all common challenges.”
The prince also highlighted the Kingdom’s support for developing the regular and
institutional structure of the national human rights system, labor systems and
policies, and promoting labor rights and improving contractual relationships.
Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said that Italy wants the Mediterranean
to be a “sea of peace and progress” rather than a graveyard for those seeking
safety and a better life in Europe.
“What we are inaugurating today is, above all, a dialogue between equals, based
on mutual respect,” Meloni said in her opening address to the international
conference attended by Arab News.
The Italian leader said that between Europe and the larger Mediterranean “there
cannot be a competitive or conflictual relationship, because in reality the
interests are much more convergent than we ourselves recognize.”
She added: “Mass irregular migration harms everyone except criminal
organizations, which use their strength to play with the lives of the most
fragile people,” and called for “joint efforts and more cooperation to fight the
network of traffickers.”
Meloni said that the international “partnership in tackling illegal migration”
with countries of origin “must be equal, multidimensional and long-term,” and
“based on respect and not on a paternalistic approach, on solidarity, on respect
for each other’s sovereignty, on shared responsibility for upholding legality.”
This “is the only serious way to strengthen our bond, to trust each other, and
foster the development and prosperity of our peoples,” she said.
Sources in the prime minister’s office told Arab News that Tunisian leader Saied
described the Rome conference as “the beginning of a positive path.”
Tunisia and Italy have a common future, he added.
Libyan Prime Minister Abdul Hamid Dbeibah praised the Italian government for
organizing the talks. “This is the right approach to the problem,” he said in
his speech at the event. Last week, the EU signed an agreement with Tunisia that
will provide €105 million ($117 million) in direct European aid to prevent the
departure of migrant boats and combat people smugglers. The deal also provides
for more illegal Tunisian immigrants to be repatriated and for sub-Saharan
African migrants in Tunisia to be sent back to their countries of origin. The
Rome conference may open the door for the EU to sign a similar agreement with
Egypt and Morocco. “We want our agreement with Tunisia to be a model, a project
for the future that can open the way to more partnerships with other countries
in the region,” von der Leyen, the European Commission president, said. “We want
to adopt a pragmatic approach based on sharing common interests and values. We
want to find tailor-made solutions for local realities.”
According to the UN, more than 100,000 migrants arrived in Europe by sea from
the coasts of North Africa, Turkiye and Lebanon in the first six months of 2023.
There were more than 189,000 arrivals last year, with most landing in southern
Italy.
Latest LCCC English analysis & editorials from
miscellaneous sources published
on July 23-24/2023
The Perfect Crime': Tech Companies
Are Manipulating Our Elections and Indoctrinating Our Children — How We Can Stop
Them
Robert Epstein/Gatestone Institute./July 23, 2023
Big Tech companies are deliberately manipulating the outcomes of our elections
and the thinking and beliefs of our children. And they are having an enormous
impact.
Consider this: The GOP currently has a slim 10-seat majority in the House of
Representatives. Without Google's interference in 2022, it would likely now have
a majority of between 27 and 59 seats.
If Google had not interfered in the 2022 midterm elections, the GOP would likely
have ended up with a Senate majority of up to eight seats.
The Big Tech companies that exploded into existence over the past 20 years – as
some of their prominent insiders have stated – have undermined our democracy,
indoctrinated our children, and increasingly turned our freedom into an
illusion.
The techniques we have discovered – the Search Engine Manipulation Effect, the
Answer Bot Effect, the Targeted Messaging Effect, and others – can easily shift
the opinions and voting preferences of undecided voters by between 20% and 80%
after just one manipulation. Google can also repeat these manipulations many
times over a period of months prior to an election.
Assuming the effects of these techniques are additive, Google can likely produce
even larger shifts in opinions and voting preferences than the ones from a
single manipulation used just once.
Google also knows exactly who is vulnerable to these manipulations – who is
still undecided before Election Day, for example – so they can target and
bombard just the right people on a massive scale 24 hours a day.
Our research has shown repeatedly that the manipulations used can make them
invisible to people, and can often produce shifts of 40% or more in the voting
preferences of undecided voters without anyone having the slightest idea they
have been manipulated. They feel free, even while they are being strongly
controlled. As one journalist wrote, "It really is the perfect crime."
Finally, our research measures the influence of "ephemeral experiences" -- their
term -- meaning content that is seen briefly, affects the user, and then
disappears forever, leaving no paper trail for authorities to trace, Most online
content – search results, newsfeeds, video sequence, and so on – are ephemeral.
Can Google deliberately use ephemeral content to manipulate people? You bet. If
you doubt that, read this 2018 article from the Wall Street Journal about some
leaked emails from the company.
In the days leading up to the 2022 midterms, the American Institute for
Behavioral Research and Technology... preserved overwhelming evidence of
Google's manipulations on their search engine, on their video recommendations on
YouTube (owned by Google), and even on their homepage on Election Day. On that
day in Florida, for example, 100% of liberals received go-vote reminders on
their version of Google's homepage, but only 59% of conservatives did.
If, in 2024, 158 million people cast ballots, as they did in 2020, it means
Google could likely shift the votes of between 6.4 and 25.5 million people,
thereby easily controlling the outcome of any election in which the projected
win margin is less than 4%. No laws or regulations are in place to stop them,
but our monitoring can. We are monitoring their systems and doing to them what
they do to us. When the Big Tech companies know that their manipulations are
being watched, they back off. It has already worked to completely shut down
manipulations in one important election.
On November 5, 2020, three U.S. Senators sent a strong warning letter to the CEO
of Google expressing concern about the extreme political bias our monitoring
system had detected in the days leading up to the presidential election – bias
sufficient to have shifted at least 6 million votes to Joe Biden.
As a result, Google immediately shut down its election manipulations in the two
upcoming Senate runoff elections in Georgia.... Go-vote reminders ceased, and so
did bias in Google search results.
In other words, monitoring, combined with political pressure from our leaders
and our public, can and will force Google and other tech companies to stay clear
of our elections and our children. It will also give legislators, regulators,
and litigants the ammunition they need to challenge both the company and its
executives in court.
Yes, they do mess with us. As explained in "How Google Stopped the Red Wave,"
whenever you see online content screaming about Democrats who have perpetrated
widespread ballot harvesting or ballot box stuffing, you are being manipulated
by Google-and-the-Gang. It is their algorithms – controlled very precisely by
their employees – that decide what content goes viral and what content is
suppressed... because Google-and-the-Gang want them to. Why? So you will not
look at them – at the tech companies themselves.
The problem is: unless we can find additional major funding soon, we will have
to start scaling down our effort in August and may have to shut it down
completely soon after.
If this type of election interference continues unmonitored and unchallenged,
could the GOP itself – and ultimately all of American democracy – become
ephemeral experiences?
Big Tech companies are deliberately manipulating the outcomes of our elections.
In Florida, for example, on Election Day of the 2022 midterms, 100% of liberals
received go-vote reminders on their version of Google's homepage, but only 59%
of conservatives did. Figure 1. A go-vote reminder on Google's home page on
Election Day, 2022.
Big Tech companies are deliberately manipulating the outcomes of our elections
and the thinking and beliefs of our children. And they are having an enormous
impact.
If you doubt that, consider this latest snippet of data from my lab, the
American Institute for Behavioral Research and Technology (AIBRT).
Consider this: The GOP currently has a slim 10-seat majority in the House of
Representatives. Without Google's interference in 2022, it would likely now have
a majority of between 27 and 59 seats.
The 2022 midterm elections that gave the Democrats a two-vote majority in the
U.S. Senate had quite a bit of help from Google, and, to a lesser extent, from a
couple of other major tech companies.
If Google had not interfered in the 2022 midterm elections, the GOP would likely
have ended up with a Senate majority of up to eight seats.
The Big Tech companies that exploded into existence over the past 20 years -- as
some of their prominent insiders have stated – have undermined our democracy,
indoctrinated our children, and increasingly turned our freedom into an
illusion.
Tristan Harris, a former "design ethicist" at Google, says that he was a member
of a team at the company, whose job it was to influence "a billion people's
attention and thoughts every day." Jaron Lanier, a computer scientist and one of
the early investors in Google and Facebook, claims that Big Tech content has
"morphed into continuous behavior modification on a mass basis." Another early
investor in these companies, the prominent author and venture capitalist Roger
McNamee, has said that he now regrets having financed them, and asserts that
they constitute "a menace to public health and to democracy."
Rigorous Research
Such concerns are valid and the Senate numbers correct: we have been using
rigorous, scientific methods to study Google and other tech companies for more
than 10 years. During this time, we have discovered and quantified about a dozen
powerful new forms of influence that the internet has made possible. We have
also developed and deployed monitoring systems that track, record, and analyze
the personalized content that Google and other tech companies send to voters and
children 24 hours a day – in other words, we are monitoring their systems and
doing to them what they do to us.
Our basic scientific, peer-reviewed studies clearly show the power that Google
and other companies have to alter thinking and behavior. Our monitoring systems
confirm that these companies are actually using these techniques, as confirmed
by company whistleblowers, as well as by leaks of documents, emails, videos, and
other materials from Google, Facebook, and Twitter.
The techniques we have discovered – the Search Engine Manipulation Effect, the
Answer Bot Effect, the Targeted Messaging Effect, and others – can easily shift
the opinions and voting preferences of undecided voters by between 20% and 80%
after just one manipulation. Google can also repeat these manipulations many
times over a period of months prior to an election.
Assuming the effects of these techniques are additive, Google can likely produce
even larger shifts in opinions and voting preferences than the ones from a
single manipulation used just once.
Google also knows exactly who is vulnerable to these manipulations – who is
still undecided before Election Day, for example – so they can target and
bombard just the right people on a massive scale 24 hours a day.
Our research has shown repeatedly that the manipulations used can make them
invisible to people, and can often produce shifts of 40% or more in the voting
preferences of undecided voters without anyone having the slightest idea they
have been manipulated. They feel free, even while they are being strongly
controlled. As one journalist wrote, "It really is the perfect crime."
Finally, our research measures the influence of "ephemeral experiences" -- their
term -- meaning content that is seen briefly, affects the user, and then
disappears forever, leaving no paper trail for authorities to trace, Most online
content – search results, newsfeeds, video sequence, and so on – are ephemeral.
Can Google deliberately use ephemeral content to manipulate people? You bet. If
you doubt that, read this 2018 article from the Wall Street Journal about some
leaked emails from the company. In that email exchange, Googlers are discussing
how they might use "ephemeral experiences" to change people's views about
Trump's temporary 2017 travel ban on visitors from seven majority-Muslim
countries.
Rapidly Growing Monitoring Capabilities
In the days leading up to the 2022 midterms, the American Institute for
Behavioral Research and Technology monitored Big Tech content through the
computers of 2,742 registered voters in 10 swing states, and preserved more than
2.5 million ephemeral experiences – data that is normally lost forever – on
Google and other platforms.
We preserved overwhelming evidence of Google's manipulations on their search
engine, on their video recommendations on YouTube (owned by Google), and even on
their homepage on Election Day. On that day in Florida, for example, 100% of
liberals received go-vote reminders on their version of Google's homepage
(Figure 1), but only 59% of conservatives did (Figure 2).
Figure 2. Proportion of go-vote reminders on Google's home page, broken down by
the political leaning of the recipients.
The Tried and Tested Solution: a Permanent, Self-Sustaining Monitoring System
Google can, overall, easily shift the votes of between 20-80% of undecided
voters; right now, that is about 40% of the electorate. This could be enormously
consequential. By mid-2024, 20% of voters will likely still not have made up
their minds on who to support. At that point, Google will still be able to shift
up to 80% of the votes of those individuals -- or up to 16% percent of the
electorate.
If, in 2024, 158 million people cast ballots, as they did in 2020, it means
Google could likely shift the votes of between 6.4 and 25.5 million people,
thereby easily controlling the outcome of any election in which the projected
win margin is less than 4%. No laws or regulations are in place to stop them,
but our monitoring can. We are monitoring their systems and doing to them what
they do to us. When the Big Tech companies know that their manipulations are
being watched, they back off. It has already worked to completely shut down
manipulations in one important election.
On November 5, 2020, three U.S. Senators sent a strong warning letter to the CEO
of Google expressing concern about the extreme political bias our monitoring
system had detected in the days leading up to the presidential election – bias
sufficient to have shifted at least 6 million votes to Joe Biden.
As a result, Google immediately shut down its election manipulations in the two
upcoming Senate runoff elections in Georgia.
We were monitoring Google content through the computers of a
politically-balanced group of more than 1,000 registered voters in that state.
Go-vote reminders ceased, and so did bias in Google search results.
In other words, monitoring, combined with political pressure from our leaders
and our public, can and will force Google and other tech companies to stay clear
of our elections and our children. It will also give legislators, regulators,
and litigants the ammunition they need to challenge both the company and its
executives in court.
Since 2016, we set up six election monitoring systems, for only the weeks
leading up to each election. After the 2022 midterms – with the results being so
blatant and disturbing – we decided that the time had finally come to set up a
permanent monitoring system in all 50 states – a $50 million project that we
were able to launch with $3 million indentations from some patriotic Americans.
Without a permanent system like this in place, we will never know the extent to
which Google-and-the-Gang are messing with our elections, our kids, or even with
our own heads.
Yes, they do mess with us. As explained in "How Google Stopped the Red Wave,"
whenever you see online content screaming about Democrats who have perpetrated
widespread ballot harvesting or ballot box stuffing, you are being manipulated
by Google-and-the-Gang. It is their algorithms – controlled very precisely by
their employees – that decide what content goes viral and what content is
suppressed. If stories about other election irregularities are spreading like
wildfire online and then being echoed on the news, it is because
Google-and-the-Gang want them to. Why?
So you will not look at them – at the tech companies themselves.
As of this writing, we are preserving and analyzing Big Tech content through the
computers of a politically-balanced group of 9,838 registered voters in all 50
states, and we have met our minimum "representative sample" thresholds in 5
states. We are also now monitoring and preserving content – some of which is
quite alarming – through the phones and mobile devices of children and teens.
Best of all, we have now preserved more than 25 million ephemeral experiences on
Google and other platforms – content that is normally lost forever. Our goal is
to make our findings available to the public in real time, 24 hours a day,
through dashboards such as America's Digital Shield.
The problem is: unless we can find additional major funding soon, we will have
to start scaling down our effort in August and may have to shut it down
completely soon after.
If this type of election interference continues unmonitored and unchallenged,
could the GOP itself – and ultimately all of American democracy – become
ephemeral experiences?
Note from the author: If you are concerned about the dangers the Big Tech
companies pose to our democracy, our children, and our autonomy, please
contribute at https://MyGoogleResearch.com. All donations are fully
tax-deductible.
*Robert Epstein earned his Ph.D. at Harvard University in 1981. He is currently
Senior Research Psychologist at the American Institute for Behavioral Research
and Technology. He has published 15 books and more than 300 articles in both
mainstream media outlets and scientific journals, among them, Science, Nature,
and the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA. He is the former
editor-in-chief of Psychology Today magazine and was a longtime contributing
editor at Scientific American. His 2019 Congressional testimony about Google can
be viewed at https://EpsteinTestimony.com. To support or learn about his work,
visit https://MyGoogleResearch.com or https://TechWatchProject.org.
© 2023 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
ÏÑÇÓÇÉ ãØæáÉ ÈÇáÅäßáíÒíÉ ÊÊäÇæá ÇáÊØæÑÇÊ ÇáÃÎíÑÉ Úáì ÇáÍÏæÏ ÇááÈäÇäíÉ
æÇáÅÓÑÇÆíáíÉ ãä ãÑßÒ ãÇííÑ ÇãíÊ ááãÚáæãÇÊ ÇáÅÓÊÎÈÇÑÇíÉ æÇáÅÑåÇÈíÉ ÊÍÊ ÚäæÇä:
ÃÖæÇÁ Úáì ÇáÅÑåÇÈ¡ ÍÒÈ Çááå æáÈäÇä æÓæÑíÇ
Spotlight on Terrorism: Hezbollah, Lebanon and Syria
The Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center/July 23/2023
https://www.terrorism-info.org.il/app/uploads/2023/07/E_137_23.pdf
Overview
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/120390/120390/
This past week the tension along the Israeli-Lebanese border continued:
Hezbollah and its affiliates continued provocative actions along the border (the
Blue Line), including on the Israeli side. In an exceptional incident, IDF
surveillance cameras installed along the border fence were ripped out. A
correspondent for al-Manar TV issued a video showing three figures, apparently
Hezbollah operatives, climb a communications tower while waving the
organization’s flag and steal the cameras. The IDF acknowledged the malfunction
and installed new surveillance cameras. UNIFIL and the United States made
attempts to defuse the situation. A Hezbollah-affiliated correspondent published
a video allegedly showing the IDF Chief of Staff and other senior officers
visiting the northern border.
Hezbollah issued a video of its operatives simulating an attack on an Israeli
post.
Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah secretary general, gave a speech about Hezbollah’s
ideology, rife with anti-Semitic motifs and propaganda.
The Lebanese government demanded Israel withdraw to the 1923 borders (agreed
upon by the British and French mandates).
The Lebanese government withdrew its conditions for renewing UNIFIL’s mandate,
after seeking to reduce the agency’s powers in a way that would serve Hezbollah.
The about-face was most likely the result of international pressure.
Lebanon’s presidential crisis continues, and so far no candidate has a majority.
Lebanon harshly criticized the EU Parliament for its statement regarding the
Syrian refugees in Lebanon and their return to Syria.
Lebanon-Israel
Continued tension on the Israeli-Lebanese border
This past week tensions remained high along the Israeli-Lebanese border.
Hezbollah operatives and affiliates continued provocations along the border (the
Blue Line), including crossing over into Israeli territory. Some of the
provocations were carried out or accompanied by Lebanese media personnel, led by
correspondents from al-Manar TV, al-Mayadeen and al-Jadeed, all affiliated with
the organization and who may also have engaged in gathering intelligence on
Israel. The events were the following:
On July 14, 2023, IDF surveillance cameras along the border fence were ripped
out by three Hezbollah operatives or local residents acting for the
organization. Documented by Ali Shoeib, an al-Manar TV correspondent, the event
circulated on social media and was widely covered by the Lebanese media outlets.
The reporter, who took a photo holding one of the cameras, claimed the Israeli
cameras violated the privacy of Lebanese civilians and dismantling them solved
the problem (Twitter account @alishoeib1970, July 14, 2023).
The IDF spokesman called it a “mishap,” adding that the incident was under
investigation and changes would be made according to the results. Major General
Uri Gordin, commander of the Northern Command, admitted the fence had been
damaged and the cameras destroyed, and the amount of time that passed before the
incident was discovered was a technical fault (IDF spokesman and the Israeli
media, July 16, 2023). According to later reports, new cameras were installed at
the site (Lebanese TV, July 18, 2023) and the IDF continued fortifying the
border (photojournalist Ali Shoeib’s Twitter account, July 18, 2023)
On July 14 and 16, 2023, Lebanese residents went to the border near Metulla and
threw rocks at IDF soldiers. The soldiers used riot dispersal measures and fired
shots into the air to deter them (al-Manar, July 16, 2023). On July 16, 2023,
Qassem Hashem, a member of the Lebanese Parliament, was superficially injured by
IDF riot dispersal measures while being interviewed near the village of
Bustarah[1] in the Har Dov area, where he claimed the Shebaa Farms were “in
Lebanese territory” (al-Jadeed, July 16, 2023).
On July 18, 2023, Ali Shoeib reported that the IDF attacked local residents
[sic] with smoke grenades near Kafr Shuba (according to Shoeib, one Lebanese
farmer from the village). He claimed the incident occurred when UNIFIL forces
were examining the route of the IDF border security fence (@alishoeib1970
Twitter account, July 19, 2023).
On July 20, 2023, Ali Shoeib released a video he claimed showed the Chief of
Staff and other senior IDF officers on the northern border on July 18, 2023
(@alishoeib1970 Twitter account, July 20, 2023).
assem al-Qadri, mayor of Kafr Shuba, said that the municipality had begun paving
a road near the fence in front of the village. The objective was to facilitate
the movement of civilians and provide a response to Israeli excavations and
clearings which had changed the routes of local roads (al-Akhbar, July 20,
2023). He claimed the territory was Lebanese according to UN Security Council
Resolution 425 (al-Mayadeen, July 20, 2023). A correspondent for the Lebanese
daily newspaper al-Akhbar claimed that according to information he had received,
the Lebanese army was on standby and would respond with gunfire if Israel
attacked civilians or the bulldozers paving the road (Abdallah Kamah’s Twitter
account, July 20, 2023).
Attempts to defuse the tension
International actors mainly UNIFIL and the United States, tried to defuse the
situation. Candice Ardell, deputy director of UNIFIL’s information bureau,
called on both sides to exercise restraint (al-Nashra, July 16, 2023). UNIFIL
also tried to convene a meeting on July 17, 2023, chaired by the UNIFIL
commander and with the participation of representatives of the Lebanese army,
the IDF and UNIFIL, to discuss the issue of Israel’s activity along the border.
However, UNIFIL sources reported that Israel canceled its participation (Israeli
TV Kan 11, July 15, 2023).
Dorothy C. Shea, the US ambassador to Lebanon, informed Najib Mikati the prime
minister for the Lebanese interim government, that the American government did
not want tension in south Lebanon, and conveyed a message from Israeli stating
clearly that it had no interest whatsoever in escalation. She stressed that
UNIFIL had to coordinate with the Lebanese army regarding all points of tension
(Israeli media, July 14, 2023).
Dispute over the delineation of the Israel-Lebanon land border
Reporting on government action taken by the Lebanese foreign ministry to
delineate the border between Israel and Lebanon, the Hezbollah-affiliated al-Akhbar
wrote that Lebanese officials had informed American administration officials and
UN representatives that Lebanon had no interest in negotiating the country’s
southern border. Lebanon, according to al-Akhbar, demanded Israel vacate all the
points it had “invaded,” and Lebanon demanded a return to the international
borders established in 1923[2] (al-Akhbar, July 14, 2023)
Hezbollah propaganda video simulates an attack on an IDF post
To exacerbate the tension on the ground, Hezbollah’s combat propaganda unit
issued a video of Hezbollah’s al-Radwan force, the organization’s elite unit,
simulating the takeover of an Israeli post. According to the video, the
simulation began with “softening” the post by firing anti-tank missiles and
mortar shells. Then dozens of Hezbollah operatives on motorcycles and driving
ATVs launched the attack. After the takeover’s “successful completion,” a
Hezbollah flag was raised over the post. The operatives used UAVs, land mines
and IEDs to breach its fortifications, then entrenched their positions in the
area and searched the post’s “bunker” (al-Manar, July 17, 2023)
Renewing UNIFIL’s mandate
According to reports, in preparation for renewing UNIFIL’s mandate, the Lebanese
government withdrew its condition regarding the limitation of the force’s
activity (Nidaa al-Watan, July 15, 2023). In the meantime, the Lebanese foreign
ministry stated that it continued working to extend UNIFIL’s mandate, which
would ensure the agency’s freedom of action to coordinate with the Lebanese
government and the Lebanese army (Lebanese foreign ministry Twitter account,
July 15, 2023).
Hezbollah
Hassan Nasrallah’s speech for the Ashura[3]
On July 18, 2023, Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah secretary general, gave a speech
to mark the Ashura. He spoke about the meaning of the Battle of Karbala and the
religious importance of honoring the memory of the martyrs (the shuhadaa).
Nasrallah emphasized the importance of inculcating the Battle of Karbala, its
significance, values and instructions as a living memory, a model for fashioning
perception and a course for present and future action. He claimed the Islamic
Revolution in Iran in 1979 was “the greatest event of the last century” and that
Ayatollah Khomeini, who declared the Islamic Revolution, said that “everything
[the Shi’ites] have is from the Ashura.” According to Nasrallah, the Ashura
represented sacrifice, heroism, enthusiasm and determination, which was how the
“resistance” operated in Lebanon.
Nasrallah’s speech was rife with anti-Semitic and anti-Israeli motifs and
propaganda. For example, he said that in the Qur’an Allah warned the Muslims
about the “Children of Israel” [the Jews], and to this day they posed the
greatest challenge to the Muslims and “all humanity”. Allah, he claimed, taught
the Muslims about the “Children of Israel,” their psychology and their fears,
and from the Qur’an Hezbollah learned about them and about their “invincible
army.” He also claimed the Qur’an referred to the Jews as hedonists because they
loved life and as cowards who attacked when protected by fences. He pointed out
that Allah taught the Muslims not to be hedonists and Hezbollah benefited
greatly from [the system of sacrifice in this life for eternal life in
paradise]. He added that the Jews were not “the Chosen People” but rather
murdered the prophets and distorted Allah’s messages.
He concluded by claiming that this year the Ashura was celebrated with the
slogan, “Karbala, our way to the Mahdi” [the Muslim Messiah who is supposed to
appear before Judgment Day], and said the Battle of Karbala was a symbol which
taught many values, including, altruism, honesty, sacrifice, honesty, standing
firm and dealing with injustice, insult and humiliation. He said, “Karbala
teaches us not to collapse when faced with a multitude of enemies, despite their
strength, and paves the way for future generations until the end of time and for
the establishment of justice and the abolition of oppression and tyranny” (al-Manar,
July 18, 2023).
Hezbollah control of the border crossings
On July 12, 2023, a new scanner was installed on the Lebanese side of the al-Masnaa
Crossing, the main border crossing between Syria and Lebanon, and will be used
to scan trucks and other vehicles. Ali Hamia, Lebanon’s minister of
transportation and public works, and a member of Hezbollah, said it increased
border safety because it would now be possible to track incoming merchandise. He
said that in the near future similar scanners would be installed in Beirut’s
airport and seaports. Hezbollah also has considerable influence and control over
inspections conducted at the various border crossings, so that “merchandise”
marked for Hezbollah will continue to enter by land, air and sea without
inspection (The Alma Research and Education Center, July 16, 2023;
alraiionline.com, July 12, 2023).
Lebanon
The presidential crisis
The presidential crisis in Lebanon continues as no camp has been able to obtain
a majority for an agreed-on candidate. Hezbollah is still determined to support
the candidacy of Suleiman Frangieh, who is affiliated with organization and
close to the Syrian regime. An “unidentified political source” reported a Qatari
envoy would visit Lebanon in the near future to discuss the issue. The source
also claimed Qatar had been active behind the scenes for some time. According to
al-Diyar, four candidates will be discussed: Suleiman Frangieh, Lebanese army
Chief, Joseph Aoun, and two others whose names were not mentioned (naharnet.com,
July 16, 2023; al-Diyar, July 16, 2023).
The five-member committee for Lebanon, which includes representatives from the
United States, France, Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Egypt, met on July 17, 2023 in
Doha, the capital of Qatar. According to initial reports, they decided what
measures would be used against those who tried to prevent a successful
presidential election. Later, reports were published from Western sources
claiming the committee preferred to focus on the post-election phase. The French
envoy, Jean-Yves Le Drian, proposed Frangieh as a presidential candidate; his
was the only name mentioned. The sources added that electing the president from
one political party and appointing prime minister from another had not been
discussed. Furthermore, the sources said the committee would probably meet again
in France in September and discuss the possibility of instituting “harsh
measures” against anyone who tried to keep the electoral process from advancing
(al-Sharq al-Awsat, July 17 and 18, 2023).
Joint naval exercise held by the armies of Lebanon, the United States and other
countries
On July 9 and 18, 2023, the Lebanese Army held a naval exercise in the
Hannouch[4] area, (where the Lebanese army has training facilities), about 45
kilometers (about 28 miles) north of the Beirut. It was a joint exercise held in
cooperation with training teams from the United States, Great Britain and France
as well as units from Jordan, Iraq and Egypt. The exercise was conducted by the
command of the Lebanese navy in cooperation with the air force, military medical
unit, military engineering force and naval commando force. Joseph Aoun, Chief of
Staff of the Lebanese army, was present at the naval maneuver concluding the
exercise (Lebanon army website, July 18, 2023).
The American mediator visits Lebanon
Amos Hochstein, the senior advisor to the President of the United States who
mediated the issue of the Israel-Lebanon maritime border, will visit Lebanon
next month (August 2023). His visit will coincide with the beginning of offshore
drilling in Lebanon’s southern economic waters (Block 9). Hochstein is expected
to be present at the start of the drilling and may discuss additional issues
with Lebanese officials (agenzianova.com, July 14, 2023).
On July 15, 2023, the Transocean Barents drilling rig sailed from the coast of
Norway, en route to Lebanon to begin initial drillings for oil and gas
reservoirs. The rig is expected to anchor in the Straits of Gibraltar for
several days to refuel before resuming its journey to Lebanon, which will take
about a month. The first ship, which brought the pipes to be used by the rig,
has already arrived at the port of Beirut (This is Beirut, July 19, 2023).
Syrian refugees in Lebanon
On July 11, 2023, the European Parliament, the EU’s legislative body, passed a
resolution calling on Lebanon not to expel Syrian refugees from its territory.
The resolution called on Lebanon to refrain from deportations, discrimination
and encouraging hatred towards the Syrian refugees. Senior Lebanese officials
insist that Syrian refugees return to their homeland in light of Lebanon’s
economic hardships and shaky internal security (Xinhua, July 13, 2023). The
Lebanese government estimates there are about 1.5 million Syrian refugees in its
territory, but according to higher estimates there are 2 million or even 2.5
million people.
Abdullah Bou Habib, Lebanese foreign minister, sent a letter to Joseph Borrell,
the deputy chairman of the European Commission for Foreign Affairs, in which he
harshly criticized the European Parliament’s decision. Habib called for a
Lebanese-EU dialogue to discuss several issues, the Syrian refugees in
particular. He claimed the refugees had begun to pose a threat not only to
Lebanon’s social fabric and economic stability, but to the country’s very
existence. He promised that Lebanon would be responsible for facilitating the
refugees’ safe and dignified return to their homes in accordance with
international law and in a manner that did not conflict with the Lebanese
constitution, which states that Lebanon is not a country of refuge. He called on
the international community to address the reasons for the Syrian refugee
presence in Lebanon and to ensure the existence of infrastructure and social
services in Syria to facilitate their return (al-Nashra, July 19, 2023).
Other senior Lebanese officials also reacted to the EU resolution:
Issam Charafeddine, the minister of immigration, claimed the EU’s objective was
to put pressure on Lebanon not to advance a mechanism in conjunction with Syria
for the safe return of the displaced to their homes. He called for an urgent
cabinet meeting to condemn the “unfair” decision because Lebanon already
suffered from profound socio-economic and security challenges (Xinhua, July 13,
2023).
Amin Salam, the minister of economy and trade, also objected to the resolution
and pointed out that the European Parliament had neither the right nor the
authority to decide the issue because it was an internal Lebanese matter, and
the European countries themselves were reluctant to accept refugees (Xinhua,
July 13, 2023).
Nabil Qaouq, a senior Hezbollah official, called the resolution “crude,
provocative and tyrannical,” an attack on Lebanese sovereignty and Lebanese
honor, and a genuine threat to national stability and unity. He emphasized that
Lebanon was not obligated to follow European recommendations and had to act in
accordance with its own best interests by coordinating with the Syrian
government to resolve the refugee crisis (al-Manar, July 16, 2023).
Samir Geagea, the leader of the Lebanese Forces Party, said it was a sovereign
Lebanese decision and the EU Parliament resolution was merely a recommendation
which Lebanon was not in any way bound to follow (al-Nashra, July 16, 2023).
Syria
Aerial attack against Hezbollah targets south of Damascus attributed to Israel
On the night of July 18, 2023, an aerial attack attributed to Israel was carried
out against Hezbollah and pro-Iranian militia targets near the al-Dimas airport,
close to the Syria-Lebanon border. Reportedly, a Syrian army soldier or fighter
in its auxiliary forces and at least two foreign (non-Syrian) pro-Iranian
militia operatives were killed and four were wounded. The destruction of large
quantities of military and logistical equipment was also reported (Syrian
Observatory for Human Rights, July 19, 2023).
The Syrian opposition website, Syria TV, reported that one of the sites attacked
served as a training center for Hezbollah fighters, and had been recently
established within the nearby al-Ahrar training base. According to Syria TV,
also attacked was a site belonging to Hezbollah near the town of al-Sabourah,
about 8 kilometers (about 5 miles) west of Damascus (Syria TV, July 19, 2023).
[1] https://youtu.be/sMnU3ich0hM?t=2 ↑
[2] The 1923 border was delineated between the British Mandate in Eretz Israel
and the French Mandate in Lebanon and was also the ceasefire line of 1948 when
the State of Israel was established. ↑
[3] The Ashura marks the Battle of Karbala in 680 CE (the year 61 according to
the Muslim calendar) which ended with the defeat of the camp of Husayn ibn Ali.
He was killed, as well as many members of the family of Ali ibn Abu Taleb, who
according to Shi'a was supposed to inherit the leadership of the Muslim nation
from the Prophet Muhammad. For Shi'ites, the battle turned into a symbol of
sacrifice and martyrdom, and was a source of frustration and rage against the
Sunnis, who took the birthright from Ali and his descendants, and deprived and
persecuted them. ↑
[4]https://www.google.com/maps/place/Hannouch+beach/@34.3057969,35.7493561,13z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m6!3m5!1s0x1521e3b60488ed3b:0x85b77948060d63af!8m2!3d34.3058195!4d35.6755344!16s%2Fg%2F11gbm1shh1?hl=iw&entry=ttu
↑
https://www.terrorism-info.org.il/en/spotlight-on-terrorism-hezbollah-lebanon-and-syria-july-14-20-2023/
Afghan Taliban Government's Persecution Of Musicians
Mantasha Ansari/MEMRI/July 23/2023
Music is a powerful means of expression, allowing individuals to convey their
deepest emotions and life experiences. This art form goes beyond language,
culture, and politics, but it clashes with the interpretation of Islam by the
Afghan Taliban government. In Afghanistan, where things are chaotic, this
beautiful way of expressing one's soul is being violently crushed.
The Taliban, who took control in August 2021, regularly attack musicians and
destroy their instruments, often depriving them and their families of their
livelihoods. It is outrageous to see the Taliban rulers silencing the voices of
so many talented Afghan artists who simply want to share their music with the
world.
Jawid Shawqi, once a singer who performed on television and at weddings for a
living, has seen his life drastically change since August 2021. Due to the
Taliban's control of Afghanistan and their ban on music, Shawqi now spends his
days sitting on the side of the road, wearing a handkerchief around his head,
polishing boots from morning till evening.
the Taliban regime deems singing and musical instruments to be "un-Islamic," and
possessing such instruments is considered a crime according to shari'a. "The
Taliban are enemies of happiness and music, and life has become hell for the
people," Jawid Shawqi said.
Abdul Qadeer, a former professional folk singer in Afghanistan, was forced to
abandon his musical career and open a roadside electric motor repair shack in
Kabul after the Taliban took control and implemented shari'a. "I am a vocalist,
and I used to earn by singing at different functions," he said in an interview
with Anadolu Agency.
"Due To The Taliban Government's Persecution, Afghan Musicians Are Fleeing Kabul
To Remote Areas Or Abroad To Save Their Lives Or Simply Hide"
Ahmad Gholami, a skilled 25-year-old musician from Afghanistan, dedicated his
life to playing the tanbur, a musical instrument. Due to the Taliban's strict
implementation of Islamic law regarding music, Gholami and fellow musicians in
Bamiyan province have been silenced. "I feel like a dead fish out of the water.
If I do what the Taliban says, my life will be wasted," Ahmad Gholami stated. He
further said, "I do not think I can go on without music. I am really confused."
According to a report published by Afghan news website Tolo News, a disturbing
video has gone viral on social media platforms, depicting a distressing scene
involving musicians in Kunar province. The video shows two local musicians being
forced to walk while carrying their instruments, specifically tablas or drums,
around their necks by their straps, and with their hands restrained behind their
backs. The perpetrators behind this act are the Afghan Taliban.
Nasir Sakhi, a local singer, expressed his helplessness: "We are very
disappointed. We are weak now and get weakened by seeing such videos. Now we do
not know what to do. What should we do when we are being insulted? Where should
we go? Are we not from this country?" The distressing sentiments expressed by
Nasir Sakhi highlight a deep sense of disappointment, hopelessness, and
vulnerability. It is disturbing to see singers scared and questioning their
place in their own homeland.
Due to the Taliban government's persecution, Afghan musicians are fleeing Kabul
to remote areas or abroad to save their lives or simply hide. They are concerned
about the future of art under Taliban rule. As the Taliban gain more control in
Afghanistan, patrons of Afghan music in neighboring Pakistan are also closing
their offices and terminating licenses with Afghan musicians.
After the Taliban's takeover, the Afghanistan National Institute of Music (ANIM)
has been closed, and the students and staff face an uncertain future. Dr. Ahmad
Sarmast – the school's founder and director – expressed concerns for the
students' safety and explained that some had returned their instruments to the
school to prevent them from being discovered by the Taliban. Dr. Sarmast said:
"It is a time of devastation for our dreams and hope..."
The Taliban, based on shari'a, have also enforced a ban on playing music at
wedding halls. The Ministry for the Propagation of Virtue and the Prevention of
Vice issued instructions to the owners of wedding halls to prohibit music at
wedding parties because they consider music to be against Islamic teachings. A
manager of a wedding hall wondered: "If there is no music at a wedding, then
what is the difference between a wedding ceremony and a funeral ceremony?"
"Afghanistan's Only Women-Run Radio Station, Sadai Banowan, Which Means 'Women's
Voice,' Has Been Closed Down For Playing Music During Ramadan And For Violating
The Afghan Taliban's Laws"
Ahmad Fanoos, a renowned singer and former judge of "Afghan Star" – the
equivalent of American Idol – faced threats throughout his career in
Afghanistan. After receiving a note calling him an unbeliever, he decided to
leave the country after the Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan in August 2021.
Afghanistan's only women-run radio station, Sadai Banowan, which means "women's
voice," has been closed down for playing music during Ramadan and for violating
the Afghan Taliban's laws. The radio station had been broadcasting for ten years
and employed six female staff members, who are now jobless.
Music is forbidden and not broadcast on national radio and television in
Afghanistan, but the Taliban promote their own songs voiced only by men, which
honor their leaders and jihad. These songs serve as a source of entertainment
for the Taliban, who listen to them on their phones, in their cars, and
elsewhere.
Taliban members destroy musical instruments with an axe (image: Etilaat Roz)
Although the Taliban fighters use music for their own entertainment, the Taliban
government does not realize – or at least does not acknowledge – that music can
be a powerful source of healing for their wounded Afghan nation. Janan Mama, a
resident of Ghazni province in Afghanistan, has found peace in playing the flute
after the killing of his two sons on the same day, who were members of the
Afghan army under the former government.
Janan Mama said that playing the flute helps him reduce the sorrows in his
heart. He said, "When the pain crushes me, I start playing the flute. Not only
in tragic moments – I play in happy times as well," adding "I have no wish
except peace and calmness in the nation; I wish for a comfortable life for
Muslims (Afghan nation) to breathe comfortably."
The International Music Council (IMC) expressed "grave concern" that Afghan
people and musicians are "denied their music rights, just as Afghan girls and
women have been deprived of their basic human rights." The council said, "Today,
as during the first reign [1996-2001] of the Taliban, the group has once again
turned Afghanistan into a silent nation and denied the Afghan people, children,
and adults the right to enjoy access to music, to learn, experience, create,
perform, and express themselves through music freely."
* Mantasha Ansari is a Research Assistant at MEMRI's South Asia Studies Project.
This article was originally published by Afghan news website Hasht-e-Subh on
July 13, 2023.
Shared American values crucial amid alarming political
polarization
Dalia Al-Aqidi /Arab News/July 23, 2023
In this age of global interconnectedness, the polarization of US politics has
reached alarming heights, rendering genuine dialogue and cooperation seemingly
impossible. Political opponents are viewed as adversaries and the mere act of
finding common ground is considered treasonous. Such division poses a
significant threat to the very essence of US-led Western values of freedom and
democracy, particularly when confronting the rise of totalitarian regimes led by
erratic and authoritarian leaders.
As the standard-bearer of Western values, the US has long been admired for its
democratic principles, respect for human rights and commitment to individual
freedoms. However, the increasing animosity between political factions has
weakened the nation’s ability to uphold these cherished values in recent years.
A house divided cannot stand united against external threats, and that is where
the peril lies.
America has stood as a beacon of liberty and democracy, championing Western
values that have inspired nations across the globe. These values, courtesy of
the toils of generations past, are a testament to the power of unity, resilience
and open discourse.
History has repeatedly shown that united democracies possess a far greater
capacity to confront tyrannical regimes. Today, the threat of a totalitarian
state governed by a despot is a stark reminder of this historical reality. The
alarming polarization of US politics, where agreeing with one’s political
opponent is perceived as treason, poses a grave danger to the vital defense of
our Western values against the encroachments of totalitarianism.
At the core of the American experiment lies the belief that a diversity of
ideas, perspectives and visions are not only welcome but necessary for a
thriving democracy. Within this diverse tapestry of views, the US has woven a
fabric of resilience, capable of enduring the most turbulent times. Yet, today,
the threads of dialogue that should connect our society have frayed and the
resulting divisions have given birth to a toxic atmosphere, in which mutual
understanding is scarce and dissent is met with hostility.
We must not mistake principled disagreement for treachery. History has shown
that societies grow and evolve through constructive dialogue and the exchange of
diverse ideas. Embracing this ethos is crucial, especially when faced with
adversaries who seek to undermine the American values of freedom and democracy.
Shunning the very values that make the country strong inadvertently weakens the
collective defense against external threats.
The stark polarization of US politics has nurtured an “us versus them”
mentality, turning fellow citizens into ideological enemies. This paradigm
stifles progress and weakens the capacity to address shared challenges
effectively. In order to safeguard Western values against the encroachments of
totalitarianism, Americans must recognize that genuine strength lies in unity,
where the bonds of common purpose transcend political affiliations.
Shunning the very values that make the country strong inadvertently weakens the
collective defense against external threats.
It is essential to confront the underlying causes of this divisive climate. The
advent of social media and the information age has facilitated the spread of
echo chambers, where individuals are insulated from diverse perspectives and
presented with a skewed version of reality. Additionally, political actors have
increasingly exploited these divisions for short-term gains, prioritizing party
loyalty over the nation’s well-being.
A culture of active listening, empathy and humility must be cultivated to
overcome this polarization. The people of the free world must engage in debates
with an open mind, not to change the minds of others but to understand their
viewpoints better. Constructive discussions help identify common ground and
build bridges of cooperation, even with those who may strongly disagree on
certain issues. This is not an act of appeasement but rather a strategic move to
fortify the country’s defenses against those who seek to exploit the internal
discord. Moreover, fostering media literacy is paramount. Citizens must be
equipped with the tools to discern fact from fiction and sensationalism from
credible journalism. A well-informed populace is essential for a robust
democracy, enabling citizens to make decisions based on accurate information
rather than biased narratives.
Another pivotal factor in combating polarization is nurturing leaderships that
exemplify statesmanship over partisanship. Leaders who prioritize national
interests over party affiliations and who seek to bridge the gap between
opposing sides can set a precedent for constructive dialogue and compromise.
The challenge is immense, but it is not insurmountable. Society must reaffirm
its commitment to democratic principles, cherishing the inherent strength in our
diversity. Disagreement should be embraced not as a weakness but as a testament
to the vibrancy of the democratic culture. By uniting around shared values,
Americans can reaffirm the resilience of Western ideals and defend them against
the predations of any totalitarian state, regardless of its leadership.
Let us remember that the genius of the US-led Western values lies not in their
perfection but in their adaptability and capacity for improvement. The short
history of America is testament to the power of transformation, from abolishing
slavery to extending civil rights. In this journey, citizens discovered that
their strength lay in recognizing the humanity in one another, transcending
differences of race, creed and political persuasion.
The path forward is arduous, but it begins with acknowledging that agreeing with
political opponents does not equate to treason. To safeguard the principles of
freedom and democracy, Americans must embrace open dialogue, prioritize national
unity and foster leadership that transcends partisan interests.
In doing so, the power of Western values demonstrates that shared humanity will
always be more formidable than the darkest designs of any tyrant. Only then can
the US be a shining light to the world, inspiring future generations.
• Dalia Al-Aqidi is a senior fellow at the Center for Security Policy.
Twitter: @DaliaAlAqidi
How China became an ideal partner in the Middle East
Dr. Majid Rafizadeh/Arab News/July 23, 2023
It is important to examine China’s policy toward the Middle East, which has been
shown to be successful and productive for several key reasons.
First of all, China’s Middle East policy is multidimensional, with its first
facet composed of putting a significant emphasis on diplomacy. This policy is
strengthening Beijing’s soft power in the region and increasing its engagement
and footprints in the Middle East, specifically in the Gulf region, and first
and foremost toward Saudi Arabia and the UAE.
A core pillar of China’s diplomatic role in the Middle East is maintaining and
promoting peace and stability by preventing conflicts and tensions from
spiraling out of control and leading to full-fledged war.
China is also attempting to project itself as a global peacemaker, which will
definitely enhance its legitimacy, prestige and status on the international
level. Foreign Minister Qin Gang in April declared that China is prepared to
broker peace talks between Israel and Palestine with the aim of finding a
resolution to their long-standing conflict. “China is willing to strengthen
coordination and cooperation with Palestine to promote an early, comprehensive,
just and lasting solution to the Palestine issue,” Chinese President Xi Jinping
told Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas during the latter’s visit to China in
June.
Beijing has also become one of the first countries to be engaged in the
reconstruction of Syria. It hopes to bring peace and stability to the Arab state
after a memorandum of understanding was signed last year between the Chinese
ambassador and the head of the Syrian National Council. Syria is another Middle
Eastern nation that recently joined China’s Belt and Road Initiative.
China’s emphasis on soft power, rather than employing coercion and hard power,
is part of its broader Belt and Road Initiative, which is a global investment
strategy that is improving the infrastructure of more than 150 countries. This
critical project was incorporated into the Constitution of the Chinese Communist
Party in 2017.
The Belt and Road Initiative has two parts: the Silk Road Economic Belt and the
21st Century Maritime Silk Road. The key objective of the initiative is to
construct “a unified large market and make full use of both international and
domestic markets, through cultural exchange and integration, to enhance mutual
understanding and trust of member nations, ending up in an innovative pattern
with capital inflows, talent pool, and technology database.”
Any conflict between countries in the Middle East has the potential to ignite a
regional conflagration, which will not serve the interests of China or the
nations of the region.
China is attempting to project itself as a global peacemaker, which will
definitely enhance its legitimacy.
Another prominent recent example of Beijing employing diplomacy is the historic
deal it brokered between Saudi Arabia and Iran, which was announced in March and
was seen by some experts, scholars and policy analysts as a sign of China’s
increasing influence in the Middle East. The agreement was a key development not
only in terms of restoring ties between two Middle Eastern powers — Saudi Arabia
and Iran — but also in reducing tensions and enhancing peace and security in the
region. Improved ties between Riyadh and Tehran could have a significant impact
on the region’s geopolitical and economic landscapes as well.
The second pillar of China’s policy toward the Middle East is anchored in not
only the traditional oil and gas trade, but also in long-term investments in
other areas, including in some Middle Eastern nations’ infrastructure, clean
energy and information technology.
For instance, Beijing has committed itself to a significant investment in Iran
via various fields. In 2021, China and the Iranian government signed a 25-year
strategic partnership deal, which is now in the early stages of implementation.
According to the Tehran Times: “The Chinese foreign minister approved of his
Iranian counterpart’s views expounded in his op-ed published in China’s Global
Times. Wang (Yi) said the Iranian foreign minister’s views show the promising
horizon in relations between Tehran and Beijing. The top Chinese diplomat
underlined his country’s readiness to expand cooperation with Iran in financing,
energy, banking and cultural sectors.”
Positive partnerships between China and Middle Eastern nations can also be found
in other areas, including addressing climate change, renewable energy and the
solar industry. For example, during a state visit by Xi to Riyadh last December,
Saudi Arabia and China signed a memorandum of understanding on hydrogen energy.
Beyond gaining enhanced global legitimacy and status, it is worth noting that
Beijing has a vested financial interest in stressing diplomacy and promoting
peace and stability in the Middle East. China has strong trade and economic
relationships with Saudi Arabia and other regional countries beyond its oil
imports. According to Deutsche Welle, China “has cultivated strong economic and
political ties with both Riyadh and Tehran in recent years. Saudi Arabia is
China’s largest oil supplier, with trade between the two countries amounting to
$87 billion in 2021. Commerce between Iran and China, meanwhile, was worth more
than $16 billion in the same year, with Tehran depending on the Asian giant for
as much as 30 percent of its foreign trade.”
In a nutshell, China’s engagement with the Middle East has been efficient,
well-informed and successful due to the fact that it uses a multidimensional
policy focusing on employing soft power, playing the key role of peacemaker and
mediator, and carrying out long-term investments not only in the oil and gas
sectors, but also in clean energy, renewable energy, infrastructure and
technology.
• Dr. Majid Rafizadeh is a Harvard-educated Iranian-American political
scientist.
Twitter: @Dr_Rafizadeh
New mediator may be needed to rescue Black Sea grain deal
Dr. Diana Galeeva/Arab News/July 23, 2023
Russia last week suspended its participation in the deal that offered Ukraine
the ability to export its grain by sea. The Black Sea Grain Initiative,
originally mediated by the UN and Turkiye in July 2022 and extended by 60 days
in May, officially expired at 5 p.m. Eastern Time on Monday.
The agreement had meant that Ukrainian ships could deliver grain from the Black
Sea ports of Yuzhny, Odesa and Chornomorsk through the Bosphorus without being
attacked. However, Russia stated that it would not renew the deal, arguing that
it was being prohibited by Western sanctions from sufficiently exporting its own
products. The importance of the grain deal to global food security is obvious,
so this development is of great concern.
However, some parallels can be made with October last year, when Russia
similarly suspended its participation in the deal. It is worth considering how
the situation this time is different, the internal and external drivers of the
strategy, and how this decision fits into the broader picture of the Ukraine
war.
The most obvious outcome of this decision is a steep rise in grain prices. When
it began last July, the Black Sea Grain Initiative produced an immediate drop in
the price of wheat of up to 35 percent due to the restarting of supplies. Before
the deal came into effect, in March 2022, the price had reached a historic high
of $444 per ton. Within two days of Moscow announcing its decision to end the
deal, the market had seen a 9 percent rise in the price of wheat.
The situation is different in the local markets of Russia, understanding which
can help to see the domestic motivations for the decision. Russian farmers
reportedly saw record harvests in 2022. In March, however, the beginning of a
slow sowing campaign was accompanied by alarming signals — last year’s record
growth turned into low grain prices and a sharp increase in stocks, which put
pressure on the market.
According to Rosstat, the stocks of wheat in the agricultural organizations of
the Russian Federation in February amounted to 17.3 million tons, which is
almost 1.6 times more than the year before. A year ago, exporters bought wheat
of the fourth class from producers at 17,800 rubles ($195) per ton; in March, it
was 12,300 rubles.
For exporters, the problem is both the volatility of currencies and the
adjustment of export duties, which occurs on a weekly basis. Demand is
constrained by export quotas, as well as the disparity in export prices and the
grain sales price expected by agricultural producers. Exporters, due to the
prevailing conditions and the current situation, cannot offer purchase prices
for farmers that are even close to fair. Russia’s decision to withdraw from the
Black Sea Grain Initiative can plausibly be linked to efforts to predict and
control future pricing, making exports both more sustainable and more
competitive.
Another reason is external: Russia’s deteriorating relations with Turkiye. With
less incentive to consider relations with Ankara — for whom the Black Sea export
route is hugely important — Moscow may feel less constrained in conducting
policy based solely on its own vision and goals.
In his latest analysis for the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace,
Ruslan Suleymanov, of the Institute for Development and Diplomacy at ADA
University in Azerbaijan, argues that Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan
has, since May’s election victory, been gradually shifting the country’s
interests toward the West — and consequently to Kyiv. Erdogan’s interests are
linked with the West as potential investors and his tour of the Gulf last week
only confirmed this policy. Turkish support for Ukraine’s entry into NATO is
also part of this calculation.
Russia’s decision to withdraw can plausibly be linked to efforts to predict and
control future pricing.
Both Turkiye and Russia have raised the stakes in their relationship since the
grain deal lapsed. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov has warned that shipping
grain out of Ukrainian Black Sea ports could now be risky, given the lack of
Russian security assurances, while there have been suggestions that Turkiye
could step in to protect shipments.
The possible outcomes of Russia’s decision have worldwide implications. Among
the most-affected regions will be the Middle East, Africa and Asia, as they are
key importers of grain. Within the original period of the humanitarian
initiative known as Grain from Ukraine, from November 2022 to March 2023,
Ukraine delivered more than 140,000 tons of wheat to African nations. These
donations were funded by Norway, Italy, Belgium, the Czech Republic and the UK.
This helped to further develop relations with the recipient countries from many
sides — the donors, Ukraine, and even Russia for permitting the trade to
continue.
Ukraine and Russia are both among the biggest wheat suppliers to the Middle
East. In recent times, Ukraine has actively aimed to build strong links with the
Arab world, and President Volodymyr Zelensky’s presence at the Arab League
meeting in May only confirmed the strategic importance of the region, both as an
economic outlet and a policy influencer in multiple spheres.
Therefore, questions can be raised about the extent to which Ukraine will be
able to deal with the Middle East and North Africa region and specifically offer
it grain. The Arab League may have to weigh up the potential cost, in terms of
deteriorating relations with Moscow, of greater cooperation with Ukraine or,
alternatively, what policies Moscow might pursue to further strengthen its links
with the region, including as an exporter of grain.
Finally, the expiration of the deal happened on the same day that Ukraine
proclaimed an attack on the bridge linking the annexed Crimean Peninsula to the
Russian mainland, known as the Kerch Bridge, which has both strategic and
symbolic importance for Moscow. A previous attack on the bridge was conducted
last October, when a fuel tanker exploded. Peskov, while commenting on Russia’s
decision concerning the grain deal, stated: “These are absolutely unrelated
events.”
Whatever the truth of this, some parallels can be offered, as the grain deal was
also on the brink of breaking down in October and early November. It also
thereafter coincided with Moscow suspending its involvement in drone attacks on
the city of Sevastopol. Whether Russia will return to the negotiating table,
amid doubts over who could mediate the talks given the damaged Moscow-Ankara
relations, is another question. Perhaps this is an opening for the Gulf states
to show their neutrality and persuasiveness.
In the meantime, the only certainties are that there are many voices pressing
for the deal to be reinstated and that many ordinary people around the world
will feel the effects until a new agreement can be reached.
• Dr. Diana Galeeva is a former academic visitor to St. Antony’s College, Oxford
University (2019-2022).
Twitter: @Dr_GaleevaDiana