English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For October 12/2022
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on the lccc Site
http://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2021/english.october12.22.htm
News Bulletin Achieves
Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since 2006
Bible Quotations For today
You fool! This very night your life is being demanded of you. And the things you
have prepared, whose will they be?” So it is with those who store up treasures
for themselves but are not rich towards God
Saint Luke 12/16-21: ‘Then he told them a parable:
‘The land of a rich man produced abundantly. And he thought to himself, “What
should I do, for I have no place to store my crops?” Then he said, “I will do
this: I will pull down my barns and build larger ones, and there I will store
all my grain and my goods. And I will say to my soul, Soul, you have ample goods
laid up for many years; relax, eat, drink, be merry.” But God said to him, “You
fool! This very night your life is being demanded of you. And the things you
have prepared, whose will they be?” So it is with those who store up treasures
for themselves but are not rich towards God.’
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese &
Lebanese Related News & Editorials published
on October 11-12/2022
The US mediator Hochstein Is indirectly negotiates with Hezbollah, Which
means implicitly acknowledging the legitimacy of its occupation of Lebanon/Abu
Arz - Etienne Sakr/October 11/2022
Change org petition/Lebanese government and officials to stand trial for causing
Beirut Port Explosion.
President Aoun meets with PM-designate Mikati and Caretaker Minister Bou Habib
Israel satisfied with draft of maritime border deal with Lebanon: Israeli
official
Biden hails Israel-Lebanon deal as 'historic breakthrough'
Bou Saab hands demarcation draft to Aoun, says Lebanon secured 'full rights'
Report: Lebanon-Israel gas deal to be signed Oct. 20
Lapid says 'historic' sea border deal will strengthen Israel's security
Israel announces sea deal with Lebanon, but doubts remain
Mikati asks TotalEnergies to launch gas search 'immediately'
Report: Govt. formation not deadlocked as Ibrahim, Hezbollah continue mediation
Berri wonders if Oct. 13 is 'official holiday', LF says to attend session
Berri receives copy of modified official draft of border demarcation deal,
tackles overall situation with Ain El Tineh visitors
"Strong Lebanon" parliamentary bloc holds regular meeting, discusses FPM’s
“presidential priorities” paper
Bassil meets al Rahi over 'presidential priorities'
Nasrallah says Hezbollah to maintain readiness until deal with Israel is signed
Sayyed Nasrallah: Hezbollah Awaits Official Stance, to Maintain Readiness
Michel Mawad: Lebanon’s Education Sector to Witness Five Lean Years
Israel says historic agreement made with Lebanon on maritime borders/Steve
Hendrix and Sarah Dadouch/The Washington Post/October 11/2022
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
Miscellaneous Reports And News published
on October 11-12/2022
UAE president highlights need for dialogue during meeting with Russia’s
Putin
Iran Racing to Expand Enrichment at Underground Plant, IAEA Report Shows
Iran’s Crackdown on Protests Intensifies in Kurdish Region
France Says New Citizen Held in Iran, EU Sanctions to Come
Iran protests over woman's death persist despite crackdown
With winter fast approaching, Europe scrambles to prepare for energy shortages
Lavrov says Russia open to talks with West, awaiting serious proposal
Reports: Türkiye Exerting Efforts to Hold Talks Between Russia, West
G7 to Hold Crisis Talks on Russia's Bombing Blitz in Ukraine
Greece, Türkiye Set Tensions Aside for Direct Maritime Link
UN: 54 Poor Nations Urgently Need Debt Relief
Titles For The
Latest LCCC English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published
on October 11-12/2022
Egypt’s Institutionalized Discrimination against Its Coptic Christian
Citizens/Raymond Ibrahim/Coptic Solidarity/October 11/2022
China's Drug Attack on the US/Lawrence Kadish/Gatestone Institute/October
11/2022
What Does Washington Want from the Oil of OPEC+?/Nadim Koteich/Asharq Al-Awsat//October,11/2022
Elon Musk Taps His Inner Trump in Twitter Machinations/Timothy L.
O'Brien/Bloomberg/October,11/2022
The Latest English LCCC Lebanese &
Lebanese Related News & Editorials published
on October 11-12/2022
The US mediator Hochstein Is
indirectly negotiates with Hezbollah, Which means implicitly acknowledging the
legitimacy of its occupation of Lebanon
Abu Arz - Etienne Sakr/October 11/2022
https://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/112642/%d8%a3%d8%a8%d9%88-%d8%a3%d8%b1%d8%b2-%d8%a7%d8%aa%d9%8a%d8%a7%d9%86-%d8%b5%d9%82%d8%b1-%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%88%d8%b3%d9%8a%d8%b7-%d8%a7%d9%84%d8%a3%d9%85%d9%8a%d8%b1%d9%83%d9%8a-%d9%87%d9%88%d9%83%d8%b4/
The ongoing negotiations on demarcating the maritime borders between the state
of Israel and Lebanon, are in reality taking place between Israel and
"Hezbollah", as the latter confiscates the entire Lebanese decision making
process, even in the smallest details; Thus, the American mediator Mr. Hochstein
is practically negotiating with "Hezbollah" indirectly, and implicitly
recognizing the legitimacy of its occupation of Lebanon. This shameful human
rights atrocity, is unfolding despite the fact that Hezbollah tops the list of
the USA terrorist organizations, as well as the lists of numerous Western and
Arabic countries.
What a contradicting fake world-wide rhetoric?
This bizarre contradiction is taking place while the West continues to boast and
openly brag every day that they are the protectors of democracy and freedom for
all peoples in the world.
In conclusion: The demon of power and money controls the world, and the rest are
all false slogans that protect special interests.
اضغط على الرابط المرفق ووقع العريضة: الحكومة
اللبنانية والمسؤولون اللبنانيون سيحاكمون بتهمة التسبب في انفجار ميناء بيروت.
Lebanese government and officials to stand trial for causing Beirut Port
Explosion.
https://www.change.org/p/international-court-of-justice-lebanese-government-and-officials-to-stand-trial-for-causing-beirut-port-explosion?recruiter=177251429&utm_source=share_petition&utm_campaign=psf_combo_share_initial&utm_medium=whatsapp&utm_content=washarecopy_23910805_en-US%3A0&recruited_by_id=13948e40-66c9-11e4-8450-39aa5f745187&share_bandit_exp=initial-23910805-en-CA
Samer Bechara started this petition to INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE and 1
other
Following the massive destruction of Beirut city on 04-08-2020 which caused more
than 100 casualties 5000 injured and left Beirut surrounding area (20km radius)
from the blast heavily damaged.
The explosion is suspected to be caused by 2700 tons of ammonium nitrate which
are used for bomb making, these where left in the heart of a city since 2014 at
high risk of causing a devastating explosion similar to a nuke.
We want everyone involved or knew about this situation and did nothing to stand
trial and be given the death penalty, including high officials and politicians.
President Aoun meets with PM-designate Mikati and
Caretaker Minister Bou Habib
NNA/11 October ,2022
President of the Republic, General Michel Aoun, received at Baabda Palace this
afternoon, Prime Minister Najib Mikati and Minister of Foreign Affairs and
Emigrants Abdallah Bou Habib, in the presence of the Director General of the
Presidency of the Republic, Dr. Antoine Choucair, after the President of the
Republic received the final amended official version of the proposal submitted
by the American mediator, Amos Hochstein.
Following the meeting PM Mikati made the following statement:
"I met with His Excellency the President, the meeting was related to the recent
understanding that took place regarding the maritime borders. The meeting was
good and His Excellency and the working group conducted a final reading of the
memorandum of understanding, and in light of it, I believe that His Excellency
the President will address the Lebanese in this regard, marking a stage that
will be, God willing, a good one, a word of thanks must be addressed first to
the Lebanese working group that devoted themselves to studying this agreement,
starting with Deputy Speaker of Parliament, Elias Bou Saab, and Major General
Abbas Ibrahim, Professor Ali Hamdan and Professor Antoine Choucair.
Thank you also to the American administration, which made a great effort to
reach this agreement, and a thank you to the French government and the French
president in particular for what they have done in the last hours, with regard
to Total and the success of this agreement.
Prime Minister Mikati added: “This morning a meeting took place with Total
company in the Serail and we agreed to start the excavation process as soon as
the memorandum of understanding is completed. Currently, a final reading is
underway by the work team and there are some small details related to
translation into Arabic.
His Excellency the President will address at the Lebanese tonight or tomorrow.
Appreciation for the good news to the Lebanese about the beginning of a new
phase that we hope will bring good to Lebanon, after we have passed through a
difficult phase. We must also thank the army and the Hydrography Department,
which made a great effort with the Lebanese technical team to reach this
result.”
Question: What is the Lebanese position on the expected vote at the United
Nations regarding the Ukrainian crisis?
PM Mikati: The vote will be tomorrow, within the context that the Lebanese
government has taken since the beginning of the Ukrainian crisis. -- Presidency
Press Office
Israel satisfied with draft of maritime border deal with
Lebanon: Israeli official
Reuters/11 October ,2022
Lebanon and Israel have received a final draft of a US-mediated maritime border
deal that satisfies all of their requirements and could imminently lead to a
“historic deal,” negotiators from the two countries said on Tuesday. “If
everything goes well, Amos Hochstein's efforts could imminently lead to a
historic deal,” Lebanon's lead negotiator Bou Saab told Reuters minutes after
receiving the draft from Hochstein, the US official engaged in months of shuttle
diplomacy to try to end the dispute. Israeli National Security Advisor Eyal
Hulata who headed the Israeli negotiating team echoed Saab's remarks:
“All our demands were met, the changes that we asked for were corrected. We
protected Israel's security interests and are on our way to an historic
agreement,” he said in a statement. While limited in scope, an agreement would
ease security and economic concerns in both countries, whose shared history is
rife with conflict. The deal would resolve a territorial dispute in the eastern
tip of the Mediterranean sea in an area where Lebanon aims to explore for
natural gas, and near waters where Israel has already found commercially viable
quantities of hydrocarbons. Hezbollah, a Lebanese political party and militia
backed by Iran, has threatened to use force against Israel should Israel explore
for gas near the disputed area before Lebanon is allowed to do so in its own
maritime zone. “We received minutes ago the final draft... Lebanon felt that it
takes into consideration all of Lebanon's requirements and we believe that the
other side should feel the same,” Bou Saab said. Israel last week rejected
last-minute amendments to the deal by Lebanon that briefly appeared to
jeopardize long-standing efforts to reach an agreement. Officials from both
countries were in close contact via the U.S. mediator over the past few days in
an effort to resolve outstanding differences. Lebanon's president said that a
deal would not signify a “partnership” with Israel, a country Lebanon does not
recognise and officially regards as an enemy. “We are avoiding a sure-fire war
in the region,” Lebanon's caretaker Prime Minister Najib Mikati said last week.
Israeli Energy Minister Karine Elharrar told Army Radio a signing date has not
been set yet. Israel is holding an election on Nov. 1 and it is still unclear
whether the accord would require parliament's approval.
Biden hails Israel-Lebanon deal as 'historic
breakthrough'
Agence France Presse/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
U.S. President Joe Biden on Tuesday hailed a U.S.-brokered agreement between
Israel and Lebanon to settle their maritime border dispute as "a historic
breakthrough," and urged all parties to stick to the deal. Negotiations between
the neighboring countries, which are still technically at war, had suffered
repeated setbacks since their launch in 2020 but gained momentum in recent weeks
with both sides eyeing revenue from potentially rich Mediterranean gas fields.
"It is now critical that all parties uphold their commitments and work towards
implementation," Biden said in a statement. The agreement "will provide for the
development of energy fields for the benefit of both countries, setting the
stage for a more stable and prosperous region, and harnessing vital new energy
resources," he said. "This agreement also protects Israel's security and
economic interests critical to promoting its regional integration. It provides
Lebanon the space to begin its own exploitation of energy resources."
Bou Saab hands demarcation draft to Aoun, says Lebanon
secured 'full rights'
Agence France Presse/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Lebanon has secured its "full rights" in the latest text drafted by U.S.
mediators to demarcate the maritime border with Israel, its lead negotiator said
Tuesday, after Israel said it met its terms too. "Lebanon has obtained its full
rights, and all of its remarks have been taken into account," said lead
negotiator Elias Bou Saab, the deputy speaker of parliament, after handing the
draft to President Michel Aoun. "Today we have come to a solution that satisfies
both parties." Lebanon's presidency said the proposed final text submitted by
Hochstein was "satisfactory to Lebanon" and voiced hope that "the agreement on
the demarcation will be announced as soon as possible."Israel had said earlier
Tuesday that it was close to a "historic" deal with Lebanon and the U.S. draft
met its "demands". The welcome for the text on both sides of the border has
raised hopes that years of negotiations have finally borne fruit, allowing
cash-strapped Lebanon to develop potentially lucrative offshore gas reserves.
Bou Saab said he hoped an agreement could be signed before Aoun's term of office
ends on October 31. He added that Lebanon will "get its full rights from the
Qana field", and Israel might receive compensation through TotalEnergies. There
will be no direct partnership in gas exploration or exploitation between the two
enemy states, he said. Aoun’s office in a statement said the latest version of
the proposal “satisfies Lebanon, meets its demands, and preserves its rights to
its natural resources," and will hold consultations with officials before making
an announcement. Negotiations between Lebanon and Israel, which are still
technically at war, had suffered repeated setbacks since their launch in 2020
but gained momentum in recent weeks with both sides eying revenue from
potentially rich Mediterranean gas fields.
U.S. envoy Amos Hochstein floated a proposed final agreement earlier this month
that was accepted by Israel, but Lebanon sought some adjustments. Israel said
last week it intended to reject the changes sought by Lebanon, even if that made
a deal impossible, but negotiations continued, culminating in what both sides
described as acceptable final terms. "Israel and Lebanon have reached an
historic agreement settling the maritime dispute," said a statement from Israel
Prime Minister Yair Lapid's office, in which he hailed "an historic achievement
that will strengthen Israel's security."A major source of friction at the talks
was the Karish gas field, which Israel insisted fell entirely within its waters
and was not a subject of negotiation. Lebanon reportedly claimed part of the
field and Hezbollah, which holds huge sway in Lebanon, threatened attacks if
Israel began production at Karish. Israel has said production would begin at
Karish as soon as possible, regardless of Lebanon's demands.
Report: Lebanon-Israel gas deal to be signed Oct. 20
Naharnet/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Preparations are underway to officially sign the sea border demarcation
agreement between Lebanon and Israel, Qatar’s al-Arabi TV has reported. “The
agreement will be officially signed on October 20 in the border area of Ras al-Naqoura,”
the TV network added, quoting unnamed sources. Israeli Prime Minister Yair Lapid
said Tuesday that Israel has reached a "historic agreement" with Lebanon that
will allow both sides to benefit from offshore gas reservoirs.
Lapid says 'historic' sea border deal will strengthen
Israel's security
Associated Press/Agence France Presse/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Israel's prime minister said Tuesday that the country has reached an "historic
agreement" with neighboring Lebanon over their shared maritime border after
months of U.S.-brokered negotiations, potentially unlocking significant offshore
gas production.
Premier Yair Lapid called the deal a "historic achievement that will strengthen
Israel's security, inject billions into Israel's economy, and ensure the
stability of our northern border.""In the last few hours, Israel received a
draft agreement that meets all of its security, economic and legal demands," the
statement from Lapid's office said. The premier will "convene a security cabinet
meeting, followed by a special government meeting at which the agreement will
come before the government for approval before it is presented to the Knesset
(parliament)," it added. The agreement is expected to enable additional natural
gas production in the Mediterranean. Lebanon hopes gas exploration will help
lift its country out of its spiraling economic crisis. Lebanon and Israel have
been officially at war since Israel's creation in 1948 and both countries claim
some 860 square kilometers (330 square miles) of the Mediterranean Sea.
Israel announces sea deal with Lebanon, but doubts remain
Associated Press/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Israel's prime minister said Tuesday that Israel has reached a "historic
agreement" with neighboring Lebanon over their shared maritime border after
months of U.S.-brokered negotiations. The agreement would mark a major
breakthrough in relations with the two countries, which formally have been at
war since Israel's establishment in 1948. But the deal still faces some
obstacles, including key legal and political challenges in Israel. At stake are
rights over exploiting undersea natural gas reserves in areas of the eastern
Mediterranean that the two countries -- which do not have diplomatic relations
-- claim. Premier Yair Lapid called the deal a "historic achievement that will
strengthen Israel's security, inject billions into Israel's economy, and ensure
the stability of our northern border."The agreement is expected to enable
additional natural gas production in the Mediterranean. Lebanon hopes gas
exploration will help lift its country out of its spiraling economic crisis.
Lebanon and Israel both claim some 860 square kilometers of the Mediterranean
Sea. Under the agreement, those waters would be divided along a line straddling
a strategic natural gas field. According to a senior Israeli official, Lebanon
would be allowed to produce gas from that field, called "Qana," but pay
royalties to Israel for any gas produced from the Israeli side. Lebanon has been
working with the French energy giant Total on preparations for exploring the
field. The agreement would also leave in place an existing "buoy line" that
serves as a de facto border between the two countries, the official said. He
spoke on condition of anonymity because he was discussing behind-the-scenes
negotiations. Many leading Israeli security figures, both active and retired,
have hailed the deal because it could lower tensions with Lebanon's Iran-backed
Hezbollah, which has repeatedly threatened to strike Israeli natural gas assets
in the Mediterranean. With Lebanon now having a stake in the region's natural
gas industry, experts believe the sides will think twice before opening up
another war. The two sides fought a monthlong war in 2006, and Israel considers
the heavily armed Hezbollah to be its most immediate military threat. "It might
help create and strengthen the mutual deterrence between Israel and Hezbollah,"
said Yoel Guzansky, a senior fellow at Israel's Institute for National Security
Studies. "This is a very positive thing for Israel."An Israeli official said the
deal would go before Israel's Security Cabinet and then the full Cabinet on
Wednesday and be presented to Parliament for a 14-day review. After the review,
the Cabinet would reconvene to give final, formal approval, the official said,
speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss government policy.
The process will take place less than three weeks before Israel goes to the
polls Nov. 1 for the fifth time in under four years. Approval is not guaranteed.
Former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, has claimed Lapid does not have the
authority to sign an agreement and vowed to cancel what he calls a "disgraceful
deal" if re-elected. The Kohelet Policy Forum, an influential conservative think
tank, already has filed a challenge to the Supreme Court trying to block the
deal. Eugene Kontorovich, the forum's director of international law, claimed the
agreement requires parliamentary approval. He accused the government of trying
to rush through an agreement under pressure from Hezbollah. "This means
Hezbollah now overrides Israel's democracy," he said. Senior U.S. energy envoy
Amos Hochstein, whom Washington appointed a year ago to mediate talks, delivered
a modified proposal of the maritime border deal to lead Lebanese negotiator,
Deputy Speaker Elias Bou Saab late Monday night, according to local media and
officials. President Michel Aoun's office said the latest version of the
proposal "satisfies Lebanon, meets its demands, and preserves its rights to its
natural resources," and will hold consultations with officials before making an
announcement.
Mikati asks TotalEnergies to launch gas search
'immediately'
Naharnet/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Prime Minister-designate Najib Mikati on Tuesday asked French energy giant
TotalEnergies to kick start gas exploration off its shores, after Israel said
the two countries have reached a U.S.-mediated deal to settle their maritime
border. Lebanon's search for gas riches in the hydrocarbon-rich eastern
Mediterranean had stalled since 2020 over competing claims with Israel over
offshore gas fields. Following Israel's announcement on Tuesday, caretaker PM
Mikati met a visiting delegation from TotalEnergies -- which was awarded an
exploration license in 2018. "During the meeting, Mikati called on
representatives of TotalEnergies to immediately begin taking operational steps
to drill in Lebanese waters," his office said in a statement. Lebanon has yet to
officially agree to the deal, but Mikati said he hoped a "conclusion would be
reached soon" that could pave the way for "gas exploration in Lebanese waters".
Lebanon's energy minister, Walid Fayad, who also attended the meeting, said that
"logistical matters take time, but work will start immediately". TotalEnergies
is part of a consortium of energy giants awarded a license to explore for gas in
two of Lebanon's 10 blocks, numbers 4 and 9. One well drilled in Block 4 in 2020
by TotalEnergies, Eni and Novatek showed only traces but no commercially viable
gas deposits. Block 9, near the border with Israel, contains the so-called Qana
field or Sidon reservoir, and will be a major zone for offshore exploration
after a deal is finalized, according to Lebanese officials. Lebanon will "get
its full rights from the Qana field", and Israel could receive compensation
through Total, said Elias Bou Saab, Lebanon's lead negotiator in the maritime
border talks. Bou Saab had on Tuesday morning visited President Michel Aoun,
Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri and PM-designate Najib Mikati, to hand them a
copy of the latest text drafted by U.S. mediator Amos Hochstein. "The unified
Lebanese stance and Lebanon's adherence to its rights and demands have led to
this positive outcome," Mikati said, as he received the final draft of the
maritime border agreement from Bou Saab.
Report: Govt. formation not deadlocked as Ibrahim,
Hezbollah continue mediation
Naharnet/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
The government formation efforts are not deadlocked and mediators are seeking a
solution for the complications, al-Joumhouria newspaper quoted “credible
political sources” as saying. “General Security chief Maj. Gen. Abbas Ibrahim is
carrying out contacts with some sides, while Hezbollah is seeking to ease the
stance of Free Patriotic Movement chief Jebran Bassil. Accordingly, things are
not deadlocked until now and might lead to a breakthrough at any moment,” the
sources added. “The mediators do not rule out the possibility of the formation
of a government within a few days, but they have set a timeframe for the success
of their mission that ends on October 15 at the latest,” the sources said.
“What’s being worked on is a government format based on the format (initially)
presented by PM-designate Najib Mikati that changes a number of ministers and
not most of the Christian ministers as requested by MP Jebran Bassil,” the
sources added, noting that not more than five ministers will be changed. The
contacts with Mikati have convinced him to accept that Aoun name the Sunni
minister in agreement with Akkar’s MPs and the Druze minister in agreement with
Lebanese Democratic Party chief Talal Arslan as well as two Christian ministers,
the sources said. The sources added that such a format is the best possible one
and that the government might be formed before the end of this week should there
be good intentions and an end to political bickering.
Berri wonders if Oct. 13 is 'official holiday', LF says to
attend session
Naharnet/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri has said that he does not intend to change the
date of Thursday’s presidential election session, despite the Free Patriotic
Movement’s objection and declared boycott. Told that the October 13 anniversary
is a sensitive topic for the FPM, Berri asked: “Is October 13 an official
holiday? No, not as far as I know.” “I only abide by the official holidays and
nothing else,” Berri added, in remarks to al-Joumhouria newspaper. Asked about
the session’s quorum should other blocs decide to boycott it, the Speaker said:
“Those who fail to attend the session would bear the responsibility for their
stance, and should there be no quorum, I will set another date, no problem.”
Asked whether he intended to “target or provoke the FPM through setting a
session on the anniversary of General (Michel) Aoun’s ouster by force from the
Baabda Palace,” Berri smiled and said he wasn’t aware of the date. Lebanese
Forces bloc MP Ghayyath Yazbek meanwhile told Radio All of Lebanon that the LF
bloc will take part in the session. “With all due respect to the October 13
anniversary, this issue cannot be tackled in a political way,” Yazbek said.
Asked about the candidates of the Change bloc, Nassif Hitti, Ziad Baroud and
Salah Honein, Yazbek described them as respectable figures but added that the LF
does not believe that any of them can rescue Lebanon amid the current
circumstances. “The LF does not intend to nominate someone other than MP Michel
Mouawad, because it sees in him all the patriotic and political characteristics,
and he has all the professional capabilities and the sovereign expertise that
push the LF to stand by him until the end,” Yazbek added.
Berri receives copy of modified official draft of border
demarcation deal, tackles overall situation with Ain El Tineh visitors
NNA/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
House Speaker, Nabih Berri, on Tuesday received at the Second Presidency in Ain
El-Tineh, Deputy House Speaker, Elias Bou Saab, who handed him the final,
modified official version of the draft agreement submitted by the American
mediator, Amos Hochstein, over southern maritime border demarcation.
Speaking on emerging, Bou Saab said that the draft has taken into account all of
our observations, adding that the Lebanese unified national position has yielded
a very great result in these negotiations.
“Today we reached a final formula thanks to Lebanon's strength and the unity of
its position, and we obtained the observations we want, but these observations
are currently being studied by His Excellency the President, Speaker Berri and
the Prime Minister, and in light of which, there will be a unified position by
Lebanon,” Bou Saab said. On the other hand, Speaker Berri received “Kataeb
Party” parliamentary bloc MP Salim Sayegh, with whom he discussed the current
general situation, the latest developments and legislative affairs. Berri also
met with “Democratic Gathering” MP Hadi Abou Al-Hassan, over the general
situation, the latest political developments and legislative affairs. Among
Speaker Berri's itinerant visitors for today had been MP Michel Daher, with whom
he discussed the latest developments and an array of developmental and
legislative affairs.
"Strong Lebanon" parliamentary bloc holds regular meeting,
discusses FPM’s “presidential priorities” paper
NNA/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
The "Strong Lebanon" parliamentary bloc held its regular meeting presided over
by MP Gebran Bassil, during which the bloc's agenda was discussed and the
following statement was issued:
1- The bloc discussed the presidential priorities paper issued by the Free
Patriotic Movement. MP Hagop Pakradounian, representing the Tashnag party,
expressed his belief that the paper constitutes a future vision not only for the
presidency, but for the revival of the country and its progression from the
state of disintegration and collapse. Pakradounian considered that the paper
constitutes an entire roadmap to rebuild the state and seek public order as well
as restore Lebanon's role in the region and the world, on top of it being a
prelude for agreement on the person of the President of the Republic.
2- MP Bassil tackled the completion of the demarcation of the maritime borders,
considering it a victory for Lebanon and the culmination of a long path, thanks
to the continuous effort, steadfast position and diligent work of the Ministry
of Energy since 2009, with the Offshore Petroleum resources law and the
implementing decrees as well as the appointment of a management body for the
Petroleum sector and geophysical surveys of the entire marine waters in two and
three dimensions, launching the first licensing cycle in Lebanese marine waters,
signing contracts, starting exploratory drilling, promulgating a law to enhance
transparency in the petroleum sector and proposing a law for the Lebanese
Sovereign Fund.
The head of the bloc considered that what we have reached today could have been
achieved since 2013 if obstacles were not placed internally and pressures from
abroad were not exercised.
3- The bloc announces its abstention from participating in the parliament
session dedicated to electing a president of the republic, due to its
appointment on October 13 which constitutes a disregard for the feelings and the
historical meaning that bears national symbolism represented in the memory of
the martyrdom of the Lebanese army officers and soldiers as well as civilians in
a military operation carried out against legitimacy in violation of Lebanon's
freedom, sovereignty and independence, placing it under the tutelage for a
period of 15 years.
4- Emphasizing the need to form a government in accordance with the provisions
of the constitution, the bloc reiterates the warning against any attempt that
some might think of to consider the resigned government capable of assuming the
powers of the president of the republic in the event of a vacuum in the
presidency, which cannot be accepted, given that any attempt in this direction
will generate an uncontrollable constitutional chaos.
5- The bloc denounces the actions of the president of the Supreme Judicial
Council Souheil Abboud, in violation of laws and obstructing the course of
justice, and demands that he be referred to judicial inspection due to his
flagrant violation of legal texts, including Article 1 of the Corruption Law in
the Public Sector and Articles 371, 374 and 377 of the Penal Code, which punish
the use of influence and abuse of power, with confirmation of the right of the
minister of Justice to call on the Supreme Judicial Council to meet under
Article 6 of the Judicial Law.
Bassil meets al Rahi over 'presidential priorities'
Naharnet/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Free Patriotic Movement chief Jebran Bassil met Tuesday with Maronite Patriarch
Beshara al-Rahi and handed him a copy of a "presidential priorities" paper that
had been announced last week by the FPM leader. Bassil said that he will contact
the parliamentary blocs to discuss with them the presidential paper.
He urged the Patriarch and President Michel Aoun to call for a national dialogue
over the presidential election. According to the FPM's paper, the new president
must "preserve national sovereignty, protect the border and the full rights,
devise a defense strategy in which the state is the main authority, preserve and
develop Lebanon’s ties with the world, and achieve a swift and safe repatriation
of the displaced Syrians."
Nasrallah says Hezbollah to maintain readiness until deal
with Israel is signed
Naharnet/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Hezbollah chief Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah on Tuesday cautiously welcomed the
Lebanese, Israeli and American declarations about an imminent sea border
demarcation deal between Lebanon and Israel, noting that his group will maintain
its military readiness until the final agreement is signed by the two sides.
“We are awaiting the declaration of the official stance by the president… We are
awaiting the official stance of the enemy's government. What's important is what
will happen tomorrow in the meeting of Israel's cabinet,” Nasrallah said in a
televised address marking the Prophet’s Birthday.“We will await the official
stances and only after the agreement is signed we can say that we have a deal,”
Nasrallah added. “Until the Lebanese see the delegations going to Naqoura on TV,
we must remain cautious,” he urged. Dismissing accusations, Nasrallah added: “It
is strange that some in Israel and in the Arab media are claiming that Hezbollah
wants to sabotage the deal. We have no problem when the Lebanese officials say
that the agreement meets the Lebanese demands.”“We only care about the
extraction of oil and gas from Lebanese waters and our stance on demarcation is
known,” Hezbollah’s leader went on to say, noting that he does not recognize
Israel’s border. “Tonight we will not issue threats. Tonight there will only be
joy and clapping,” Nasrallah added. As for the funds that will be yielded by
Lebanon’s potential gas resources, Hezbollah’s leader called for benefiting from
“the experiences of the countries that have sovereign funds,” while noting that
Hezbollah is among those who have concerns over how the funds will be managed.
“We must all immunize the funds” that will come from the gas resources,
Nasrallah urged.
Sayyed Nasrallah: Hezbollah Awaits Official Stance, to
Maintain Readiness
Batoul Wehbe/Al-Manar English Website/October 11/2022
Hezbollah Secretary General Sayyed Hasan Nasrallah announced on Tuesday that
Lebanon is before decisive hours with regards to the maritime demarcation deal,
saying Hezbollah will await the official stances by the Lebanese President
General Michel Aoun.
“Only after the agreement is signed we can say that we have a deal,” Sayyed
Nasrallah said in a televised speech delivered during the celebration that was
held this evening on the occasion of Prophet Mohammad’s birthday (PBUH) along
with his grandson Imam Jaafar al-Sadiq (PBUH) and the Islamic Unity Week.Lebanon
received the updated proposal by US Energy Envoy Amos Hocshtein on an impending
deal on the maritime dispute with the Zionist entity. The Lebanese Presidency
Press Office announced on Tuesday that Deputy Speaker Elias Bou Saab handed over
President Michel Aoun the proposal finalized by Hochstein.“With regard to the
demarcation file, we are before decisive hours, and we, as Lebanese, are waiting
for the official stance to be announced by the President,” Hezbollah leader
announced, adding “We will await the official stances and only after the
agreement is signed we can say that we have a deal.”Sayyed Nasrallah said
‘Israel’ is sharply divided on the deal, even within the “same parties and
ministers in the government,” and that not all Israeli sides are satisfied with
the agreement. “We are waiting for the official position of the enemy’s
government and what’s important is what will happen tomorrow in the meeting of
the Israeli cabinet. We all witnessed the contradictory statements in the
Zionist entity over the past months and there is a rift there.”Israeli Prime
Minister Yair Lapid said on Tuesday that a “historic agreement” has been reached
on the maritime dispute. He called a Security Cabinet meeting, followed by a
general cabinet meeting for Wednesday to approve the deal, and that the deal is
expected to be submitted to the Knesset for review.
“The moment the Lebanese see the delegations going to Naqoura on TV, we must
remain cautious,” his eminence warned, “When the Lebanese side announces the
approval of the deal, then we consider that things are done and until then we
must remain vigilant.”
Sayyed Nasrallah called for attentiveness as there are those who can change
their minds at every moment. He described the negotiations as difficult,
“Reaching a deal was not an easy task.”Bou Saab, Lebanon’s lead negotiator in
the issue of maritime deal, said: “For Lebanon, the maritime deal has been
finalized,” noting that the US mediator is waiting for the official response by
Lebanon. He stressed, in remarks carried by Al-Manar, that Lebanon will have a
united stance towards Hochstein’s updated proposal, noting that “no
modifications have been made so far on the updated proposal.”
Hezbollah’s leader pointed that Hezbollah only cares about the extraction of oil
and gas from Lebanese waters and its stance on demarcation is known. “Since the
very beginning we said we stand behind the state on the issue of Lebanese
demands, and I always said we want to ‘eat grapes’ and extract oil,” Hezbollah’s
S.G. said.
“We have no problem when the Lebanese officials say that the agreement meets the
Lebanese demands. My call is that after publishing the final text, this
understanding should be approached in the spirit of national responsibility
required to judge it positively or negatively away from settling accounts,”
Sayyed Nasrallah indicated, hailing the cooperation spirit witnessed in Lebanon.
“We are before a new experience of cooperation between state officials that was
met with popular support. Lebanon will be able to achieve this great
accomplishment at time when no one is concerned about its rights.”“Where is our
sea? I tell you: To us, our sea extends to Gaza, and when Palestine is
liberated, we will not disagree with our Palestinian brothers on maritime
borders demarcation,” his eminence said.
Sayyed Nasrallah said Hezbollah had no need to send more drones than the ones
previously sent toward the Karish field on July 5, as “the objective was for the
enemy to understand that we are serious.”
In this context, the Hezbollah leader hailed the resistance fighters “whose
sacrifices and efforts exerted for years bore fruit within few months,”
stressing that the resistance will maintain its readiness until the agreement is
signed. “To resistance fighters I say: You’ll remain on your readiness,
vigilance and measures until we see with our very eyes that the deal is signed,
and after that is another day,” Sayyed Nasrallah said.
Sayyed Nasrallah stressed that “this is a national wealth that is not owned by a
particular sect, political party or region; it belongs to the entire Lebanese
people, so it must be approached with a spirit of responsibility,” and
continued, “I promise you to cooperate with all the pillars of the state.” “We
must benefit from the experiences of the countries that have sovereign funds,”
his eminence said, adding “we must all immunize the funds that will come from
the gas resources.”Hezbollah S.G. ended up the issue of maritime borders
demarcation deal by saying: Tonight, we will not issue threats. Tonight, there
will only be joy and clapping. On the internal Lebanese issue, Sayyed Nasrallah
said: “On the presidential file, I have nothing new to add regarding the issue
of the presidency and we call for the formation of a government.” He regretted
that officials are “blowing hot and cold”” in this regard, oscillating between
optimism and stagnation in the negotiations. As for Yemen, the Hezbollah leader
praised Yemenis for the huge celebrations held across the various provinces that
had been plagued by eight years of war. “This people, who suffered from an eight
years war and suffers from many life crises, is gathering in a scene like no
other, we bow in respect.”Turning to the Palestinian cause, Sayyed Nasrallah
hailed the latest resistance might in the West Bank, saying: “What’s going on in
the West Bank is percussive to the Zionist entity and all its political forces.
The resistance today in West Bank needs all ways of political, media and popular
solidarity. The resistance in West Bank is able to change equations, hopes are
pinned on it.”West Bank cities have witnessed a significant escalation of
resistance operations lately, especially in Jenin and Nablus, at the level of
shooting at the Occupation army’s checkpoints and settlers and throwing
explosive and incendiary devices, in response to the Israeli crimes in occupied
territories. Sayyed Nasrallah also lauded Hamas’ decision on strengthening the
relations with Syria as a courageous, wise and sound decision.
Michel Mawad: Lebanon’s Education Sector to Witness Five
Lean Years
Beirut - Thaer Abbas/Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
The president of the Lebanese American University in Beirut (LAU), Dr. Michel
Mawad, said that the education sector in the country would witness five lean
years, as a result of the financial and economic crisis and the lack of
resources. In an interview with Asharq Al-Awsat, Mawad pointed to the danger of
the human capital flight, which he said would take several years to compensate.
He stressed that brain drain and the loss of educational energy in the higher
education sector would have long-term repercussions and require many years to
address. “At the university, we face many difficulties, and we thank God that we
overcome them one by one,” Mawad said. “The great difficulty that people do not
notice is the brain drain from Lebanon and the university. Today, we have lost
between 20 to 25 percent of doctors who have specializations from abroad. This
affects the education of students in medicine, pharmacy or nursing…” he warned.
In addition to the loss of human and educational capacity in the higher
education sector, which Mawad deems “harmful to the sector,” he noted that many
of the students could no longer afford the tuition fees because the purchasing
power has decreased by about 15 times. “We are doing our best to bring in the
funds to retain the students. This priority stems from the fact that the
Lebanese University has become almost absent, forcing students to resort to
small businesses,” Mawad emphasized, pointing to the risk of the desperate youth
being dragged into extremist organizations due to the spread of poverty in the
country.
He stressed that based on LAU’s determination to promote the advancement and
support the youth, the university has provided last year $70 million in
scholarships and around $100 million for the current 2022-2023 academic year.
This has led to an increase in the number of students from 8,360 in 2021 to
8,500 students this year. Mawad underlined the need for funds in US dollars to
cover the university’s expenses. “We buy fuel in US dollars; we used to spend
$1.3 million annually, but now our budget is $8.7 million in expenses for
electricity, internet, water and heating,” he said, stressing that the LAU is a
private, non-profit organization, “but we are forced to secure the alternative
to what the state could not provide, and this puts pressure on us.”
The president of the LAU revealed that the university’s deficit in the past two
years amounted to $72 million, forcing it to withdraw the equivalent amount from
the endowment in the United States to cover its expenses and enable professors
to continue their mission. “We have reached the stage of turning off the lights
in some buildings, not only because of the high cost of diesel but also because
of its shortage,” he stated. Despite all the challenges, Mawad said that the
university has kept pace with modern scientific developments, and has taken the
lead in launching new specializations in artificial intelligence,
nanoengineering, and robotics, in addition to the opening of modern laboratories
in the faculties of medicine and engineering. Other important achievements
include the opening of the University Medical Center in Jounieh, known as Saint
John Hospital, in continuation of the university's mission to interact with its
community and promote its advancement.
According to Mawad, Lebanon’s exit from its crisis depended on time and
liquidity. “We are seeking in various ways to find foreign sources of funding,”
he noted. The LAU has launched an online educational plan, but Mawad said that
the Ministry of Education has not yet approved the granting of online degrees.”
“We are working with a company to market our online specializations for students
outside Lebanon, and we tell all students who study online that this certificate
is not recognized in Lebanon, but only abroad”, he continued. In addition, the
LAU has offices in New York since 2013 and now is starting to convert them into
a university campus due to the huge demand by non-American students, who wish to
pursue their education in the US, Mawad noted. “We are also seeking to repeat
this experience in Arab countries, and we have hired companies to study the
market in Saudi Arabia, and we have been informed that there are opportunities
in Riyadh, and an option in Baghdad,” he told Asharq Al-Awsat. LAU is seeking to
expand in the Arab region and build a university campus in Baghdad, during the
next three years. This will include campuses and colleges for medical sciences.
“The university is growing... We are not politicized or follow a specific
religion, and we do not differentiate between students. We use all our energies
to educate our students and allow them to have the best work opportunities in
Lebanon and abroad,” Mawad underlined. In light of the weak government
supervision that led to the spread of random universities and the issuance of
fake degrees, the LAU president insisted that well-established non-profit
universities such as AUB, LAU, USJ, and others, have put among their priority
maintaining high-quality education. All funds received “are used to cover
expenses, develop the university's premises, laboratories, scientific research
centers, and also help students,” he stated.
Israel says historic agreement made with Lebanon on
maritime borders
Steve Hendrix and Sarah Dadouch/The Washington Post/October 11/2022
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/10/11/israel-lebanon-maritime-border-deal/
JERUSALEM — Israeli and Lebanese leaders appear to have agreed to a
U.S.-brokered deal that will let both countries exploit gas fields in the
eastern Mediterranean, potentially ending a decades-long dispute over their
maritime border, easing growing military tensions and providing a desperately
needed source of income to Lebanon’s collapsing economy.
Are you on Telegram? Subscribe to our channel for the latest updates on Russia’s
war in Ukraine.
The agreement, which needs formal approval in both countries, was hailed by
leaders in Beirut and Jerusalem as a historic breakthrough. It is the first
agreement on border demarcation between the two nations.
“This is an historic achievement that will strengthen Israel’s security, inject
billions into Israel’s economy, and ensure the stability of our northern
border,” Israeli Prime Minister Yair Lapid said in a statement Tuesday.
Another bank heist in Beirut, another hero for Lebanon’s weary public
Lebanese leaders have yet to make an official announcement on the deal, but
President Michel Aoun said in a tweet Tuesday that “the final version of the
offer is satisfactory for Lebanon and answers its demands and preserves its
rights to its natural wealth.”
“If everything goes well, [Washington’s] efforts could imminently lead to a
historic deal,” Elias Bou Saab, Lebanon’s lead negotiator on the issue and
deputy parliament speaker, told Reuters after receiving the text of the deal
from American officials Tuesday.
Officials hope the agreement, if finalized, will cool intensifying tensions
along the frontier. Hezbollah, the Iran-allied militant group that controls
southern Lebanon, has threatened to attack a new offshore gas facility that
Israel is readying for production in what Lebanon claims are disputed waters.
The group has launched drones toward the gas field more than once, including
three unmanned aircraft that were shot down by Israel in early July.
In the face of Hezbollah’s threats to strike should Israel begin pumping natural
gas from the Karish Field, Defense Minister Benny Gantz put troops on high alert
after the maritime border talks ran into last-minute disputes last week.
Hezbollah, which along with its allies, holds the largest bloc in parliament,
had no immediate comment on the draft of the agreement. A media officer for the
group told The Washington Post that Hezbollah leader Hasan Nasrallah is likely
to talk about the deal in a speech scheduled for Tuesday. “Today we’ll find
out,” the official said.
The agreement would define only the offshore boundary between the sworn enemies,
not the 50-mile land border that remains in dispute after multiple wars and
continues to be patrolled by a United Nations monitoring force after more than
four-decades.
The maritime frontier has proved to be equally contentious in recent years,
particularly after gas deposits were discovered in the sea bed inside the
330-square mile region. Israel, which has already developed gas fields in nearby
waters, strung a line of buoys three miles out from a rocky cliff near the U.N.
headquarters. Beirut condemned the move as a unilateral provocation.
Resolving the dispute — which has gained urgency as the risk of conflict rose
and Lebanon’s economic free fall has grown more critical — has been a regional
priority for the Biden administration. The president’s special envoy, Amos
Hochstein, brokered talks over the past year with the goal of giving countries
fair access to the area.
The deal comes as gas discoveries are remaking the energy map of the
Mediterranean just as Europe is looking for alternate sources in the wake of
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Gas diplomacy may also be thawing Israel’s tense
relationship with Turkey, for example, as the two countries seek to revive
long-abandoned plans for a pipeline through Turkey to Europe.
Details of the agreement were not made public Tuesday. But reports of its broad
terms in recent week suggest that it clarifies the lines of Exclusive Economic
Zones for both countries. Lebanon would gain access to promising fields in
previously disputed waters; Israel would be free to begin operating the Karish
well with Lebanon’s agreement.
Lebanese officials have said the final deal would not have them in direct
partnership with Israel, and it was unclear how royalties would be split from
the one area, the Qana Field, which lies partially in Israeli waters.
Lebanon in 2017 issued licenses to move forward with offshore oil and gas
development for two of the 10 blocks in the Mediterranean, including Qana, and
officials were moving quickly to advance the process.
Lebanese Prime Minister Najib Mikati met Tuesday morning with Energy Minister
Walid Fayyad and a delegation from French oil giant Total. Fayyad expressed hope
that the deal will benefit Lebanon and grant it its “rights and full share in
Qana field without sharing it with anyone,” according to state media. He also
emphasized the need to begin exploration and development, which often take
years, as soon as possible.
“Logistical issues take time but work will begin immediately,” he said.
Lebanon’s leaders and public hope the deal will pave the way for gas exploration
and bring in much-needed revenue to the country, which has been hit by sharp
economic decline and a banking crisis that have ravaged the local currency and
left much of the country out of work.
In a place previously an oasis for opulence, people sifting through trash cans
for food is now a common sight in the capital Beirut. The World Food Program
said in a report last month that an estimated 33 percent of Lebanese now lack
minimum dietary provisions.
Access to gas fields could mean export revenue and energy sources for a country
where electricity is now an expensive luxury and some Lebanese have begun
joining Syrians and other migrants in perilous boat journeys to Europe.
Israel hopes access to the gas deposits will help pull Lebanon back from the
brink of collapse and reduce the risk of another out war.
“Such a field would weaken Lebanese dependency on Iran, restrain Hezbollah and
bring regional stability,” Lapid told his cabinet earlier this month.
In Israel, which does not have diplomatic relations with Lebanon, it was unclear
what steps the government needed to take to ratify the agreement. Legal experts
said the deal could be enacted simply on the approval of the current cabinet,
most of whom have signaled enthusiasm for a draft they said benefits both
countries. They pushed back on some right-wing lawmakers, including former prime
minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who blasted the government for “surrendering” to
Hezbollah.
But Israel is holding national elections in less than a month, and some
officials, including alternate Prime Minister Naftali Bennett, have said in the
past that such an important agreement should go before the Knesset, Israel’s
parliament.
Bennett, as Lapid’s partner in the government, still holds an effective veto in
the cabinet. His office said Tuesday that he will make a decision on the
agreement after reading the draft and consulting with security officials.
Dadouch reported from Beirut.
The Latest English LCCC
Miscellaneous Reports And News published
on October 11-12/2022
UAE president highlights need for
dialogue during meeting with Russia’s Putin
Arab News/October 11, 2022
DUBAI: The UAE’s President Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al-Nahyan highlighted the
need for dialogue between all parties to the Ukraine crisis during a visit to
St. Petersburg, Russia on Tuesday. During a meeting with Putin, Sheikh Mohamed
said his country seeks to contribute to strengthening the foundations of peace
and stability in the world, and is working to reduce tensions and find
diplomatic solutions to crises. He called for the continuation of serious
consultations to resolve the Ukraine crisis through dialogue, negotiation, and
diplomacy to reach a political settlement. The two presidents also reviewed a
number of regional and international issues and developments of common concern
during discussions, Emirates News Agency reported. The UAE’s foreign ministry
said on Monday that the president's visit to Russia aims to help reach
“effective political solutions” to the Ukrainian crisis. Russia's . The Gulf
country “seeks to achieve positive results to reduce military escalation, reduce
humanitarian repercussions, and reach a political settlement to achieve global
peace and security,” the ministry said. Meanwhile, Putin said Emirati-Russian
ties are an important factor of regional and global stability. “Despite all the
difficulties that exist in the international relations today, ties between
Russia and the United Arab Emirates are an important factor of stability in the
region and the entire world,” Russia’s president said at the start of his talks
with Sheikh Mohamed. Anwar Gargash, the diplomatic advisor to the UAE’s
president, said in a tweet that Sheikh Mohamed’s visit was pre-scheduled within
the framework of bilateral relations but that the war in Ukraine requires an
urgent solution.
Iran Racing to Expand Enrichment at Underground Plant,
IAEA Report Shows
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Iran is rapidly expanding its ability to enrich uranium with advanced
centrifuges at its underground plant at Natanz and now intends to go further
than previously planned, a confidential UN nuclear watchdog report seen by
Reuters showed on Monday. While indirect talks between Iran and the United
States on reviving the 2015 Iran nuclear deal have stalled, Tehran has brought
onstream an ever larger number of advanced centrifuges the deal bans it from
using to produce enriched uranium. These machines are far more efficient than
the first-generation IR-1, the only centrifuge that the deal lets Iran use to
grow its stock of enriched uranium. Iran has been adding them particularly at
two underground sites at Natanz and Fordow that may be designed to withstand
potential aerial bombardment. The third of three cascades, or clusters, of
advanced IR-6 centrifuges recently installed at the underground Fuel Enrichment
Plant (FEP) at Natanz has now come onstream, said the International Atomic
Energy Agency report to member states.
Diplomats say the IR-6 is Iran's most advanced centrifuge. Iran has also quickly
completed the installation of seven cascades that were either not finished or at
a very early stage of installation on Aug. 31, Monday's ad hoc report showed.
End-August marked the last visit by inspectors mentioned in the IAEA's most
recent quarterly report. Those seven cascades, one of IR-4 centrifuges and six
of IR-2m machines, were fully installed but not yet enriching, Monday's report
said. Iran has also informed the IAEA it plans to add an extra three cascades of
IR-2m machines at the FEP, on top of the 12 already announced and now installed,
the report showed. Of those three extra IR-2m cascades, installation has already
started on two of them, the report said. The report also showed that all the
centrifuges enriching at Natanz were still producing uranium hexafluoride (UF6)
gas enriched to up to 5% but now they were being fed with natural UF6. That
contrasted to the quarterly report issued in September that said on Aug. 31 the
centrifuges were being fed with UF6 enriched to up to 2%. It did not explain the
change. In 2018, then-President Donald Trump pulled the United States out of the
Iran deal and re-imposed sanctions against Iran that the deal had lifted. Iran
responded by breaching the restrictions on its nuclear activities imposed by the
deal. If the deal is revived Iran will have to put its advanced centrifuges into
storage, diplomats say.
Iran’s Crackdown on Protests Intensifies in Kurdish Region
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Iran intensified its crackdown Tuesday on Kurdish areas in the country's west as
protests sparked by the death of a 22-year-old woman detained by the morality
police rage on, activists said. Riot police fired into at least one neighborhood
in Sanandaj, the capital of Iran’s Kurdistan province, as Amnesty International
and the White House's national security adviser criticized the violence
targeting demonstrators angered by the death of Mahsa Amini. Meanwhile, some oil
workers Monday joined the protests at two key refinery complexes, for the first
time linking an industry key to Iran's theocracy to the unrest. Iran’s
government insists Amini was not mistreated, but her family says her body showed
bruises and other signs of beating. Subsequent videos have shown security forces
beating and shoving female protesters, including women who have torn off their
mandatory headscarf, or hijab.
From the capital, Tehran, and elsewhere, videos have emerged online despite
authorities disrupting the internet. Videos on Monday showed university and high
school students demonstrating and chanting, with some women and girls marching
through the streets without headscarves as the protests continue into a fourth
week. The demonstrations represent one of the biggest challenges to Iran’s
theocracy since the 2009 Green Movement protests. One video posted online by a
Kurdish group called the Hengaw Organization for Human Rights showed darkened
streets with apparent gunfire going off and a bonfire burning in Sanandaj, some
400 kilometers (250 miles) west of Tehran. Another showed riot police carrying
shotguns moving in formation with a vehicle, apparently firing at homes. The New
York-based Center for Human Rights in Iran posted another video showing what it
described as a phalanx of motorcycle-riding security forces moving through
Sanandaj. "They reportedly broke the windows of hundreds of cars in the Baharan
neighborhood," the center said. Amini was Kurdish and her death has been felt
particularly in Iran’s Kurdish region, where demonstrations began Sept. 17 at
her funeral there after her death the day before. Amnesty International
criticized Iranian security forces for "using firearms and firing tear gas
indiscriminately, including into people’s homes." It urged the world to pressure
Iran to end the crackdown as Tehran continues to disrupt internet and mobile
phone networks "to hide their crimes."Iran did not immediately acknowledge the
renewed crackdown in Sanandaj. However, Iran's Foreign Ministry summoned the
British ambassador over the United Kingdom sanctioning members of the country's
morality police and security officials due to the crackdown. Iran's Foreign
Ministry called the sanctions "arbitrary and baseless," even while threatening
to potentially take countermeasures against London. Jake Sullivan, US President
Joe Biden's national security adviser, similarly noted that "the world is
watching what is happening in Iran.""These protestors are Iranian citizens, led
by women and girls, demanding dignity and basic rights," Sullivan wrote on
Twitter. "We stand with them, and we will hold responsible those using violence
in a vain effort to silence their voices."
France Says New Citizen Held in Iran, EU Sanctions
to Come
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
France's foreign minister said on Tuesday five of its nationals were being held
in Iran and the European Union had agreed the technical aspects to impose
sanctions on Tehran, which would come into force next week. France lashed out at
Iran on Oct. 6 accusing it of "dictatorial practices" and taking its citizens
hostage after a video was aired in which a French couple appeared to confess to
spying, after weeks of unrest that Iran has linked to foreign foes. France
subsequently urged its nationals to leave Iran as soon as possible, saying they
were exposed to the risk of arbitrary detentions. "I hope to speak to the
Iranian foreign minister today to ask once again for the immediate release of
all our compatriots, who are held in Iran," Catherine Colonna told France Inter
radio. "There are currently five."Until now, Paris had not confirmed that a
fifth citizen had been detained during the nationwide protests. Iran said last
month that nine Europeans had been arrested in the unrest. Ties between France
and Iran have deteriorated in recent weeks as efforts to revive nuclear talks in
which France is one of the parties have stalled. Neither country has an
ambassador in place. The anti-government protests in Iran over the death of
22-year-old Mahsa Amini in police custody last month have pushed the EU to
follow the United States, Canada and Britain in imposing sanctions. "The EU
agreed yesterday the technical aspects of a sanctions package that will target
those behind the repression. "It will be validated on Monday," Colonna said,
referring to an upcoming meeting of EU foreign ministers.
Iran protests over woman's death persist despite crackdown
DUBAI (Reuters)/Tue, October 11, 2022
Clashes between protesters and security forces persisted across Iran on Tuesday,
with social media videos showing tanks being transported to Kurdish areas, which
have been a focal point of the crackdown on protests over Mahsa Amini's death in
custody. Protests calling for the fall of the clerical establishment have swept
Iran since Amini, a 22-year-old Iranian Kurdish woman, died on Sept. 16 while
being detained by the morality police in Tehran for "inappropriate attire".While
observers do not believe the unrest is close to toppling the government, the
protests mark one of the boldest challenges to the Islamic Republic since the
1979 revolution, with reports of strikes spreading to the vital energy sector.
The authorities are waging a deadly crackdown. Videos on social media showed
trucks moving dark green tanks to Kurdish areas, raising the stakes in the
revolt. Reuters could not verify the video footage.
At least 185 people, including 19 minors, have been killed, hundreds injured and
thousands have been arrested by the security forces, according to rights groups.
The government says more than 20 members of the security forces have been
killed.
Iranian authorities have said they will investigate civilian deaths. Tensions
have been especially high in Kurdish regions, given Amini's ethnic background.
Human rights groups say Iran's Kurdish minority of more than 10 million has long
been oppressed - a charge the Islamic Republic denies.
The Kurdistan Human Rights Network said the protests were continuing for a
fourth week in those regions "despite the tense security atmosphere and the
militarization of these cities".It said security forces had killed at least 30
protesters, injured another 825, and arrested more than 2,000 in the
predominantly Kurdish regions. Reuters could not independently verify the
report. The Hengaw human rights group said on Monday security forces had fired
towards residences in the Kurdish city of Sanandaj. The Iranian authorities have
blamed the violence on an array of enemies including armed Iranian Kurdish
dissidents, with the Revolutionary Guards attacking their bases in neighbouring
Iraq a number of times during the latest unrest. Interior Minister Ahmad Vahidi
reiterated accusations that Iranian Kurdish dissident groups were supporting the
protests and said security forces would "neutralize the desperate
anti-revolutionary effort".
ENERGY SECTOR
Unrest continued elsewhere overnight after demonstrations spread into Iran's
vital energy sector, according to videos on social media which Reuters could not
confirm. Energy installations in southwestern Iran were hit by strikes for a
second day on Tuesday, with workers protesting at the Abadan oil refinery,
Kangan and the Bushehr petrochemical plant, according to the widely followed
Tavsir1500 Twitter account. Videos posted on the account showed a few dozen
workers chanting "Death to the dictator", referring to Supreme Leader Ayatollah
Ali Khamenei. A regional official said on Tuesday the workers at the Assaluye
plant were angered by a dispute over wages and were not protesting over Amini's
death. Governor Ali Hashemi said some Iranians had tried to hijack the workers'
protests by chanting anti-government slogans, according to Iran’s Young
Journalists Club News (YJC) Telegram account.
It was a combination of mass protests and strikes by oil workers and bazaar
merchants that helped to propel the Shi'ite clergy to power in the Iranian
revolution four decades ago. Dozens of universities are also currently on
strike, with students playing a pivotal role in the protests. Meanwhile, in the
city of Fuladshahr in the central province of Isfahan protesters set fire to the
office of a prayer leader, according to a video posted by Tavsir1500. The
authorities' crackdown on protesters has prompted some Western states to draw up
more sanctions on Iran, stoking diplomatic tensions at a time when talks to
revive Tehran's 2015 nuclear deal with world powers are at a standstill.
France's foreign minister said on Tuesday five of its nationals were being held
in Iran and the European Union had agreed the technical aspects to impose
sanctions on Tehran, which would come into force next week. France lashed out at
Iran on Oct. 6 accusing it of "dictatorial practices" and taking its citizens
hostage after a video was aired in which a French couple appeared to confess to
spying.
With winter fast approaching, Europe scrambles to prepare
for energy shortages
Melissa Rossi/Yahoo News/Mon, October 10, 2022
Patrick Vranckx, a bakery owner in Temploux, Belgium — 50 miles southeast of
Brussels — is panicked. His Boulangerie Pâtisserie Vranckx, which sells hand-molded
bread and pastries to about 400 customers every day, is already struggling to
keep up with skyrocketing energy costs, and winter promises even greater
pain.“We won't be able to hold out many more months,” he told Yahoo News, noting
that electricity prices have quadrupled over the past year. With delivery of
Russian natural gas, which last year provided 40% of Europe’s supplies, now down
to a trickle, OPEC cutting oil production, hydropower crippled by this summer’s
drought, renewable electricity not fully in force, and temperatures already
falling as winter approaches, Europe is bracing for the worst energy crisis the
continent has ever known. Government officials and energy agencies are warning
of possible blackouts as the cold sets in. Energy may even be rationed as part
of “robust demand-reduction measures,” Thorfinn Stainforth, an analyst at the
Institute for European Environmental Policy, told Yahoo News, adding that
industrial customers are likely to be hit first.
Johan Lilliestam, who leads the Energy Transitions group at Germany’s Institute
for Advanced Sustainability Studies in Potsdam, Germany, has dubbed the dire
situation “Europe’s Energy Drama,” and says that each day seems to deliver a new
cliffhanger. Two weeks ago, it was the suspected sabotage of the underwater Nord
Stream pipelines, which closed them down for good and set off European panic
about the security of other gas pipelines amid an energy standoff with Russia.
Last Thursday, just as the 27-member European Union was finalizing its sanctions
on Russian oil, OPEC+ announced it had reached a deal with Moscow to slash
petroleum production, a move that some believe could accelerate inflation.
“I don’t think the announcement will strongly affect supply, but it may affect
prices,” Lilliestam told Yahoo News, while noting that the deal came “despite
strong calls from the West not to take measures that could further increase oil
prices.”
In France, normally an electricity exporter to its Western Europe neighbors,
thanks in part to its investments in nuclear power, the state electricity agency
is warning of possible cutoffs. Half of the country’s 56-reactor nuclear fleet
is down, due to corrosion and maintenance, Phuc-Vinh Nguyen, research fellow at
the Jacques Delors Energy Center, told Yahoo News. The reduced production of
electricity is particularly worrisome, he said, since the French rely on
electricity for heating. What’s more, wage strikes by oil workers have severely
reduced French gasoline supplies, as witnessed this weekend by long lines at
stations, a third of whose pumps are running dry. French labour union workers
march on a palm-lined street, waving crimson flags and matching banner.
Across the continent, everything from coal to wood is scarce. Tom Goethals, who
normally delivers cords of firewood grown in Belarus and Russia to 30 pizzerias
and 300 customers in Brussels, had to switch to a French supplier because of
shortages and high transportation costs. Demand, meanwhile, has gone through the
roof. “People are afraid they won’t have heat or it will be too expensive to
use,” Goethals said, adding that some Belgian suppliers are already out of wood
for the season and that most suppliers’ prices have doubled due to shipping
costs.
Despite expedited plans to transition to renewable sources of energy in the wake
of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the European Union remains dependent on natural
gas, which powers a large portion of industrial production, power generation and
heating needs, particularly in industrial countries like Germany. To bridge the
gap, the EU is being forced to import expensive liquefied natural gas from Qatar
and the U.S., a move that has sent electricity and heating prices to all-time
highs. Norway is now Europe’s main gas supplier through its pipelines, but is
cutting its neighbors no deals, leading to accusations of war profiteering.
French President Emmanuel Macron, who plans to confront gas suppliers about
their prices, told business leaders in Paris last week that “In a spirit of
great friendship, we will say to our American and Norwegian friends: ‘You’re
super, you supply us with energy and gas, but one thing that can’t go on for too
long is us paying four times more than the price you sell to your industry,'”
Bloomberg reported. He added, “That is not exactly the meaning of friendship.”
With no sign that the crisis will ease anytime soon, European governments are
trying to put in place measures to shield consumers and to save energy. Last
week, the EU’s executive branch, the European Commission, imposed a windfall tax
on fossil fuel producers, capped electricity prices for most utilities and
called for households to cut electricity demand during peak consumption periods
by at least 5%. In its quarterly report, the Paris-based International Energy
Agency, pointing out that Europe is facing “a winter of unprecedented
uncertainty of supply due to Russia’s behavior,” warned that “a complete
shutdown of Russian pipeline flows to the European Union cannot be ruled out,”
and urged consumers to slash natural gas consumption by 13%, by turning down
thermostats and water heaters.
Europe’s natural gas storage caverns are nearly 90% full, but those reserve
stocks are only enough to last three months, and future gas supplies appear
uncertain, all the more since caps on gas prices may come into effect. Across
much of the continent, heavily polluting coal plants that had been scheduled to
be decommissioned are operating again, nuclear plants that had been turned off
are powering back up, fracking is being discussed, new gas pipelines are being
proposed and Europeans are being asked to heat their homes to no more than 19°
Celsius, 66° Fahrenheit, although some stores and offices, won’t exceed 17°C
(62° F). “Most people have purchased additional blankets and [sweaters], and
they’re stalling turning on their heating until the cold really sets in,” said
Andy Hughes, an estate manager who lives in Cirencester, England, where
nighttime temperatures have fallen sharply in recent weeks.
Workers in white suits and helmets inside a vast power plant, seen from above.
The difference between energy prices in Europe and the United States is stark,
with the average Western European paying 41 cents per kilowatt hour while
American households pay around 15 cents. That disparity is hitting ordinary
citizens in Europe hard. “Vulnerable people are really squeezed now,” Stainforth
said.
Lilliestam also worries about how the manufacturing sector will deal with
unprecedented energy prices. “How much loss can industry take?” he asked. “How
long can they carry these prices? How long can you just shut down production and
then still come back?"
While the crisis has affirmed the need to transition from fossil fuels to
renewable sources of energy, it has also made clear that it won’t happen quickly
enough to meet Europe’s energy demands this winter. “It can't be stressed
enough, how much we really need — and there's so much that could be done with
renewable energy now, the prices are so advantageous,” Stainforth said, adding,
“There's no reason why just large amounts of renewables can’t be deployed across
the European Union now, to make sure we're in a good position in two, three,
five,10 years from now, both climate-wise but also energy security-wise.” Had
Europe moved more rapidly earlier, he noted, “We wouldn't be having these
problems with the wild fluctuations of consumer prices and industrial prices,
and problems with energy security.”
Lavrov says Russia open to talks with West, awaiting
serious proposal
LONDON (Reuters)/Tue, October 11, 2022
-Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said on Tuesday that Moscow was open to
talks with the West on the Ukraine war but had yet to receive any serious
proposal to negotiate. In an interview on state TV, Lavrov said Russia was
willing to engage with the United States or with Turkey on ways to end the war,
now in its eight month. His emphasis on Russia's receptiveness to talks came
after a series of stinging defeats since the start of September that have swung
the momentum of the conflict in favour of Ukraine. Lavrov said officials
including White House national security spokesman John Kirby had said the United
States was open to talks but that Russia had refused. "This is a lie," Lavrov
said. "We have not received any serious offers to make contact."He also said
Russia would not turn down a meeting between President Vladimir Putin and U.S.
President Joe Biden at a mid-November summit of the Group of 20 in Indonesia,
and would consider the proposal if it receives one. "We have repeatedly said
that we never refuse meetings. If there is a proposal, then we will consider
it," Lavrov said. Commenting on the possibility that Turkey could host talks
between Russia and the West, Lavrov said Moscow would be willing to listen to
any suggestions but could not say in advance whether this would lead to results.
He said Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan would have an opportunity to put
proposals to Russian President Vladimir Putin when both visit Kazakhstan this
week. Lavrov noted that direct talks between Russia and Ukraine had broken down
at the end of March. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has ruled out
talking to Putin after Russia claimed the annexation last month of four
Ukrainian regions that it partly occupies.
Deadly Russian Strikes May Have Violated International Law
Principles, Says UN
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Russia may have violated principles on the conduct of hostilities under
international humanitarian law with deadly strikes on Ukraine on Monday, a
spokesperson for the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR)
said. "We are gravely concerned that some of the attacks appear to have targeted
critical civilian infrastructure ... indicating that these strikes may have
violated the principles on the conduct of hostilities under international
humanitarian law," Ravina Shamdasani told a news conference on Tuesday. "We urge
the Russian Federation to refrain from further escalation, and to take all
feasible measures to prevent civilian casualties and damage to civilian
infrastructure," she added.
Reports: Türkiye Exerting Efforts to Hold Talks Between
Russia, West
Ankara - Saeed Abdulrazek/Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Türkiye plans to organize negotiations between Russia and four western countries
to discuss ending the war in Ukraine, according to reports from Ankara and
Moscow on Monday. Ismail Emrah Karayel, Chairman of the Joint Parliamentary
Committee of Türkiye and the European Union confirmed that Ankara is working to
hold negotiations between Russia and the US, France, Britain and Germany, to
help deescalate tensions. “We assume that Istanbul can become the venue for
negotiations, of course, if the parties agree,” RIA Novosti quoted Karayel as
saying. Turkish and Russian media outlets quoted Karayel as saying that Ankara
accepts the conditions to be a mediator between the countries. He cited
Türkiye’s previous role in the signing of the Agreement on the Safe Passage of
Grain in the Black Sea between Russia and Ukraine in Istanbul in July. The deal
was mediated by Ankara under the auspices of the United Nations. Meanwhile,
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Monday that Russian and Turkish
presidents, Vladimir Putin and Recep Tayyip Erdogan, may meet in the Kazakh
capital of Astana later this week. However, he responded negatively when asked
if Ankara passed to Russia any proposals on holding talks between Russia and the
West, but he said it might be raised at the Erdogan-Putin meeting. On Sunday,
the Turkish newspaper Milliyet said Ankara requested that the US, France,
Germany, and the UK to hold negotiations with Russia. It said influential
figures in Washington have already reacted positively to the plan. Earlier,
Ibrahim Kalin, adviser to the Turkish President, said that Putin wanted to reach
a "new big agreement" with the West, and this explained Moscow's desire to enter
negotiations.
G7 to Hold Crisis Talks on Russia's Bombing Blitz in
Ukraine
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
The United States and other G7 powers will hold crisis talks Tuesday on Russia's
recent bombing blitz across Ukraine, with Britain's Liz Truss expected to insist
they "must not waver one iota" in their support for Kyiv. The meeting comes a
day after Russian missiles rocked the Ukrainian capital for the first time in
months, with President Volodymyr Zelensky warning Moscow that his country
"cannot be intimidated", reported AFP. Russian forces rained more than 80
missiles on cities across Ukraine on Monday, according to Kyiv, in apparent
retaliation for an explosion that damaged a key bridge linking the Crimean
peninsula to Russia. Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba said the strikes
showed Moscow was "desperate" after a spate of embarrassing military setbacks,
as Russian President Vladimir Putin warned of "severe" responses to any further
attacks. At an urgent meeting of the United Nations General Assembly on Monday
-- called to debate Moscow's declared annexation of four partly occupied
Ukrainian regions -- Ukrainian ambassador Sergiy Kyslytsya branded Russia a
"terrorist state", noting his own immediate family had come under attack on
Monday. "Unfortunately, you can hardly call for a stable and sane peace as long
as an unstable and insane dictatorship exists in your vicinity," he said,
telling member states at least 14 civilians were killed and 97 wounded in the
strikes.
- 'Stay the course' -
Zelensky and G7 leaders are set to convene Tuesday to discuss the latest Russian
attacks. Truss's office said the British prime minister, who succeeded Boris
Johnson just over a month ago, would use the call "to urge fellow leaders to
stay the course". "The overwhelming international support for Ukraine's struggle
stands in stark opposition to the isolation of Russia on the international
stage," she is expected to say. "Nobody wants peace more than Ukraine. And for
our part, we must not waver one iota in our resolve to help them win it." German
government spokesman Steffen Hebestreit told reporters Monday that Chancellor
Olaf Scholz had spoken with Zelensky and assured him "of the solidarity of
Germany and the other G7 states". US President Joe Biden, meanwhile, condemned
Monday's strikes in stark terms, saying they "demonstrate the utter brutality"
of Putin's "illegal war". In a statement, the White House said Biden had spoken
to Zelensky and had pledged to furnish Ukraine with "advanced air defense
systems". Ahead of Monday's General Assembly session, UN Secretary-General
Antonio Guterres described the latest attacks as an "unacceptable escalation of
the war", his spokesman said. Though Russian representative Vasily Nebenzya did
not directly address the missile strikes at the session, he defended his
country's annexation of Ukrainian regions, saying the aim was "to protect our
brothers and sisters in eastern Ukraine".
- 'In an instant... it's death' -
Residents across Ukraine expressed shock and rage after Monday's barrage. Ivan
Poliakov, 22, was so angry he struggled for words as he tried to describe one of
the strikes on Kyiv. "I saw children and women cry," he told AFP. "I love Kyiv.
The people are good, they are courageous. But in an instant... it's death." In
Dnipro, soldier Maxim was on leave from the front lines for the first time in
six months to celebrate his wife's birthday when Russian missiles slammed into
the central Ukrainian city, damaging their home. "We are fighting on the front
exactly to protect these places" far from enemy lines, he said. "But they still
manage to hit them." The strike, he said, had made him more determined than ever
to push back the Russians in northeast Ukraine. Since Russia launched its
invasion on February 24, more than 7.6 million Ukrainian refugees have been
recorded across Europe, while another nearly seven million people have been
displaced within the country. Monday's missile strikes prompted a fresh warning
from the UN's refugee chief that more people could soon be forced to flee their
homes. "The bombing of civilians, of houses... of non-military infrastructure in
an indiscriminate manner in many cities across Ukraine, means the war is
becoming harder and more difficult for civilians," UN High Commissioner for
Refugees Filippo Grandi told journalists in Geneva. "I fear that the events of
these last hours will provoke more displacements."
Greece, Türkiye Set Tensions Aside for Direct Maritime Link
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Setting aside longstanding strategic rivalry, Greece and Türkiye on Monday
inaugurated a "friendship line" ferry link between Thessalonika in northern
Greece and the western Turkish port of Izmir. Greek-based shipping company
Levante Ferries announced the MV "Smyrna di Levante" vessel had started
passenger and freight services between the two countries, the first direct
maritime link between the regional rivals. The company said the vessel carrying
up to 948 passengers and as many as 300 vehicles would both promote the
neighbors' commercial interests and deepen ties, AFP said. The ship began its
maiden test voyage from Thessalonika at 5.15 pm (1414 GMT) on Monday with 35
people aboard -- mainly Levante employees -- bound for Izmir some 14 hours away.
The ferry firm has over the past three years invested a reported 16 million
euros in the three-times weekly route, the first direct major link between
continental Greece and Türkiye. Some eastern Greek islands off the Turkish coast
offer more ad hoc trips to nearby Turkish ports courtesy of small boats. "We
want to link Europe and Asia (and) benefit from market demand" to "promote
maritime and tourist transport," said Greek operator Yannis Dimitriadis.
Greece and Türkiye have endured long bouts of sometimes bitter rivalry with a
series of maritime border disputes raising tensions amid Turkish accusations its
fellow NATO member seeks to militarize more than a dozen of its islands in the
Aegean Sea. Athens has pushed back against Ankara's demands that it desist from
doing so. Last week saw a further spat at an informal EU gathering in Prague
when Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis left an official dinner during an
address by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.
Growing Trade Signals Deeper Ties Between Iran and Turkey
Sinan Ciddi/ Policy Brief/October 11, 2022
According to Turkish government sources, bilateral trade between Turkey and Iran
increased sharply over the last six months. Although formally a U.S. ally
through NATO, Turkey appears determined to deepen its economic ties with Tehran,
recalling its facilitation of Iranian sanctions evasion prior to 2016.
In September, the Turkish Institute of Statistics (TUIK) reported a 49 percent
increase in non-oil and gas imports from Iran in March through August 2022 as
compared to the same period during the previous year. (The data is available in
files posted for download on the TUIK website.) Additionally, Turkey reported a
20 percent increase in overall exports to Iran in the first six months of 2022
as compared to 2021. The rise in trade between the two neighbors is broadly
reflective of Turkey’s desire to increase bilateral trade with Iran. During the
July 2022 meeting of the Turkey-Iran High Level Cooperation Council, Turkish
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan declared, “we have reached $7.5 billion as of
now. I believe that we will achieve $30 billion” — an aspiration mirrored by his
Iranian counterpart. These aspirations may not be plausible, however, as the
level of trade between Ankara and Tehran has fallen dramatically over the past
several years, due in part to the reimposition of U.S. sanctions on Iran in 2018
and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. In the first six months of 2020, trade
declined by 73 percent, and overall Turkish imports from Iran are approximately
50 percent lower than they were in 2017. This year’s increase hints at a
post-pandemic recovery and/or an intention by both regimes to increase trade to
pre-pandemic levels and possibly surpass it. Independent of economic matters,
Tehran and Ankara remain suspicious of one another’s intentions. Although both
Erdogan and Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi have expressed interest in
combatting Kurdish separatist movements, they favor opposing policies in places
such as Syria and Iraq, where Turkey would like to see Iranian influence
diminished. The Biden administration should be wary of any increase in trade
between Iran and Turkey that points toward sanctions evasion, for which there is
ample precedent. In a six-count indictment in October 2019, federal prosecutors
in the Southern District of New York charged Halkbank, a major Turkish public
lender, with fraud, money laundering, and sanctions offenses related to the
bank’s alleged participation in “a multibillion-dollar scheme to evade U.S.
sanctions on Iran.” The prosecutors accused the bank of helping Tehran transfer
$20 billion worth of restricted funds, with at least $1 billion laundered
through the U.S. financial system. While Turkey has appealed to the U.S. Supreme
Court to invalidate the indictment on jurisdictional grounds, the administration
has good reason to be suspicious. In addition to monitoring Turkish trade with
Iran, the United States should be willing to help secure oil and natural gas
offsets for Turkey to reduce its dependency on Iranian energy sources.
Furthermore, the U.S. government should look for common ground with Ankara given
their shared concern about Iranian proxy networks, especially in Iraq and Syria.
High-level dialogue between Ankara and Washington on Iran could be a valuable
means to contain Iranian regional aspirations if Erdogan is prepared to respect
sanctions.
*Sinan Ciddi is a non-resident senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of
Democracies (FDD), where he contributes to FDD’s Turkey Program and Center on
Military and Political Power (CMPP). For more analysis from Sinan, the Turkey
Program, and CMPP, please subscribe HERE. Follow Sinan on Twitter @SinanCiddi.
Follow FDD on Twitter @FDD and @FDD_CMPP. FDD is a Washington, DC-based,
nonpartisan research institute focused on national security and foreign policy.
UN: 54 Poor Nations Urgently Need Debt Relief
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 11 October, 2022
Cascading global crises have left 54 countries -- home to more than half of the
world's poorest people -- in dire need of debt relief, the UN said Tuesday. In a
new report, the United Nations Development Program warned that dozens of
developing nations were facing a rapidly deepening debt crisis and that "the
risks of inaction are dire", AFP said. UNDP said without immediate relief, at
least 54 countries would see rising poverty levels, and "desperately needed
investments in climate adaptation and mitigation will not happen". That was
worrisome since the affected countries were "among the most climate-vulnerable
in the world". The agency's report, published ahead of meetings of the
International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, and also of G20 finance ministers
in Washington, highlighted the need for swift action. But despite repeated
warnings, "little has happened so far, and the risks have been growing," UNDP
chief Achim Steiner told reporters in Geneva. "That crisis is intensifying and
threatening to spill over into an entrenched development crisis across dozens of
countries across the world."
The poor, indebted countries are facing converging economic pressures and many
find it impossible to pay back their debt or access new financing.
- 'Volatility' -
"Market conditions are shifting rapidly as a synchronized fiscal and monetary
contraction and low growth are fueling volatility around the globe," UNDP said.
The UN agency said debt troubles had been brewing in many of the affected
countries long before the Covid-19 pandemic hit. "The rapid build-up in debt
over the past decade has been consistently underestimated," it said. The freeze
on debt repayment during the Covid crisis to lighten their burden has expired
and negotiations under the G20 Common Framework created during the pandemic to
help heavily-indebted countries find a path to restructure their obligations has
been moving at a snail's pace. According to available data, 46 of the 54
countries had amassed public debt totaling $782 billion in 2020, the report
said. Argentina, Ukraine and Venezuela alone account for more than a third of
that amount. The situation is deteriorating rapidly, with 19 of the developing
countries now effectively shut out of the lending market -- 10 more than at the
start of the year.
- 'Missing ingredient' -
A third of all the developing economies have meanwhile seen their debt labelled
as being "substantial risk, extremely speculative or default," UNDP's chief
economist George Gray Molina told reporters. The countries at the most immediate
risk are Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Tunisia, Chad and Zambia, he said. Gray Molina
said private creditors have so far been the biggest obstacle to moving forward
with needed restructuring. But he suggested that the current market conditions
could pave the way for a debt deal, as private creditors see the value of their
holdings plunge by as much as 60 percent. "When emerging market bonds trade at
40 cents on the dollar, private creditors suddenly become more open to
negotiation," he said. "The incentives are to now join a negotiation where you
might accept the haircut of 20 cents on the dollar, 15 cents on the dollar and
30 cents on the dollar."But willing creditors are not enough to actually nail
down a much-needed debt-relief agreement, Gray Molina acknowledged. "The missing
ingredients at this moment are financial assurances from major creditor
governments to clinch a deal."Steiner, who has repeatedly raised the alarm about
the crisis, voiced hope the international community might finally recognize that
action is in everyone's shared interest. "Prevention is better than treatment
and certainly... much, much cheaper than having to deal with a global
recession," he said.
The Latest LCCC English analysis &
editorials from miscellaneous sources published
on October 11-12/2022
Egypt’s Institutionalized Discrimination
against Its Coptic Christian Citizens
Raymond Ibrahim/Coptic Solidarity/October 11/2022
The president of Cairo University, Muhammad Uthman al-Khosht, recently assigned
31 new directors, deputy directors, managers, and researchers to head a number
of departments, including those of agriculture, medicine, engineering, nursing,
dentistry, statistical research, and African Studies.
Although the Copts—Egypt’s most indigenous, Christian, people—make up anywhere
from 10-20% of its population, notable among these new Cairo University hires is
that not a one of them is Christian. All are Muslim.
The significance of this news is not so much that discrimination against
Christians in Egypt exists—which should be beyond obvious by now—but rather that
it seems to permeate every single facet of Egyptian society.
As the Washington-based Coptic Solidarity (CS), an international human rights
organization focused on the plight of Egypt’s Copts, reported last June:
Egypt currently has some 135 ambassadors on-post abroad, and about 20
consul-generals (with an administrative rank of ambassador).
Over the past few weeks, we at Coptic Solidarity were able to survey the names
of 128 of these ambassadors and 16 consul-generals. The conclusions are
consistent with previous surveys we’ve done over the past twenty years and kept
in a database of Egyptian ambassadors and consul-generals created by Coptic
Solidarity. Although Copts, the indigenous Christian inhabitants of Egypt,
account for, at the very least, 10 percent of Egypt’s population—and should,
therefore, account for, at the very least, 10 percent of Egypt’s diplomatic
corps:
No Copts are appointed to any major Western capital (Washington, London, Paris,
Bonn, Rome, Ottawa, etc.).
No Copts are appointed to any major non-Western capitals (Tokyo, Beijing,
Moscow, Delhi, etc.)
No Copts are appointed to any international organization.
No Copts are appointed to any Arab or Muslim country.
No Copts are appointed as consul-general—anywhere…
Similarly, in an attempt to demonstrate Egypt’s advancement concerning women, on
March 3, 98 female judges took the legal oath in preparation for assuming
judicial roles in Egypt’s State Council. This was considered a major and
unprecedented development; since its inception 75 years earlier, not a single
woman had sat on the podium of the State Council court—and now 98 are. And yet,
not one of them is a Christian—again, despite the fact that the Copts account
for between 10-20% of the nation’s population, suggesting that at the very least
10 of the 98 should have, for proper representation, been Copts.
Or consider the recent presidential decree for new deputy prosecutors. Out of
516 hires, a paltry five—meaning less than 1%—are Copts. The decree was signed
by none other than President al-Sisi, whose lobbying agency in Washington D.C.
boasts his efforts to ensure “meritocracy in civil service.”
Such overt discrimination persists even in less “formal” settings. Take football
(American soccer), for example—a very popular national pastime in Egypt. As Aid
to the Church in Need noted in a February, 2022 report,
Christians make up around 15% of the population of Egypt and are as
football-crazy as their Muslim neighbours, but there is not a single Copt in the
national team….There are no official statistics on the number of Copts in Egypt,
but estimates vary between 10% and 20%. … The fact that no Copts, of any
denomination, are represented in top-level football, and therefore in the
national team, stings.
Or as Coptic Solidarity’s president, Ms. Caroline Doss Esq., observed:
Sports are to be participated in by all. It is inconceivable that not a single
Coptic athlete is skilled enough to represent Egypt in sports, particularly
considering that Egypt is the 14th most populous country in the world with at
least 15 million Copts. Your action is necessary to bring an end to this
religiously-motivated discrimination.
Nor is such widespread discrimination against the Copts limited to Egyptian
policies. Western elements, including those charged with combatting
discrimination, tend to ignore it; at the very least, they certainly do not
treat it the same way they would if the opposite was the case—if a Christian
nation was openly discriminating against Muslim minorities.
Regarding this last example, CS has sent various letters and reports (several
linked to here) to various responsible sporting committees, chief among them the
Zurich-based FIFA (the Fédération Internationale de Football Association), an
international governing body founded in 1904 to oversee international
competition. FIFI reportedly takes accusations of discrimination very seriously.
But as CS noted:
CS first reported widespread discrimination against Coptic athletes in Egypt to
the International Olympic Committee and to FIFA in August 2016. Neither entity
responded until European news outlets published stories on the topic in 2018
during the lead up to the World Cup. A FIFA employee finally contacted CS
requesting additional information—twenty months after the original complaint was
sent.
CS complied, but, to date, FIFA has done little if anything to reverse such
discrimination.
Similarly, in the latest summer games in Tokyo, Egypt’s delegation included 141
athletes: one of them—0.7% of them—was a Copt. CS’s complaints to the IOC went
on deaf ears.
Seemingly adding insult to injury, the IOC’s president recently visited Egypt,
where he applauded the country’s bid to host the summer Olympic Games in 2036.
There is no mention that he ever raised the issue of discrimination with the
authorities.
In short, whereas actual, violent and murderous persecution against Egypt’s
Christians is not uncommon, institutionalized and open discrimination against
them permeates every aspect of Egyptian society.
China's Drug Attack on the US
Lawrence Kadish/Gatestone Institute/October 11/2022
The Chinese have a very long memory. And a strong sense of history.
If only Americans possessed both, for we would be able far better to understand
the enormous consequences of the lethal drug abuse harming America from the
massive quantities of death-dealing fentanyl being smuggled into our country,
with its origins often a Chinese lab.
The Chinese know full well that a society's addiction to drugs can unravel a
proud nation, stripping away its very sovereignty. When opium was brought to
China in the 1700s, the British quickly used the drug as a means of gaining an
economic advantage over its new trading partner. The addiction to the drug was
so explosive that the Chinese emperor eventually sought to ban it. When his
military destroyed warehouses full of the drug, the British responded with a
crushing naval attack that became known as a series of Opium Wars.
Other Western nations followed Britain's lead, but it was England that forced a
humiliating treaty on the Chinese, and evidently that cause-and-effect has never
been forgotten by today's Chinese rulers.
So as a leading global manufacturer of fentanyl, China is unique in appreciating
just how destabilizing such a drug can be to a nation.
In fact, this very issue was explored during a recent interview with the
Communist Chinese Ambassador to the US, Qin Gang, who was quick to remind
Newsweek that China knows full well the devastating impact of illicit drugs. Not
surprisingly, he was quick to deny any suggestion their manufacturing of
fentanyl was their way of "returning the favor" to Western nations.
He told the reporter that during the 18th and 19th Centuries, "China decided to
ban the material to save its population and economy, the British launched the
Opium War, which started a century of humiliation for China, marked by a slate
of unequal treaties and waves of Western aggressions. The repercussions of
history are felt even today. With such searing pains in our national memory,
China holds an understandably stronger antipathy for narcotics than any other
country, as displayed in its zero-tolerance attitude towards all narcotic drugs,
as well as stringent control and tough punishment measures. Thanks to these
efforts, narcotics are not endemic in China."
One might suggest that the Ambassador has revealed more than he intended.
China said in word and deed that they intend to recapture what they view as
their historic role as a global superpower. Using military force might seem
appealing, but as Vladimir Putin's blunder in Ukraine has demonstrated, things
do not always go as planned. By introducing destabilizing addictive drugs,
coupled with alliances with mega-billionaires who know no allegiance to a nation
but, rather, to their own profits, China could simply wait for events to play
out.
As Qin observed in his interview, China's descent into nationwide addiction more
than two hundred years ago led to "a century of humiliation..." That experience
is apparently seared into their national consciousness: they know full well the
power of addiction as a national weapon. With that appreciation, the drug
dealers and criminal middlemen who peddle the fentanyl may very well be just
someone's useful soldiers in a far larger scheme of redefining who will be the
dominant global power for the rest of this century.
*Lawrence Kadish serves on the Board of Governors of Gatestone Institute.
© 2022 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
What Does Washington Want from the Oil of OPEC+?
Nadim Koteich/Asharq Al-Awsat//October,11/2022
The White House has gone too far in its reaction to the OPEC+ decision to cut
oil production by two million barrels a day. The decision was framed as a Saudi
attack on the US aimed at influencing the midterm elections by raising the price
American voters pay for oil and fueling resentment at the Democrats. Some have
even leaped to the conclusion that Riyadh has chosen to ally with Moscow in the
ongoing battle between the latter and Western capitals being waged against the
backdrop of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine.
Over the past few days, the major liberal newspapers have been brimming with
commentary and statements from members of Congress suggesting marvelously
creative punitive measures against Saudi Arabia, giving one the impression that
this was a sovereign decision Saudi Arabia had taken alone and that the US is
the sole target of this decision globally.
Since oil is a universally strategic commodity, an obvious question comes to
mind: why did neither India nor China consider the decision to cut production,
which aims to stop prices from dropping further, to have been taken to undermine
their interests? Indeed, these two countries are facing far more grave economic
challenges than the US and will thus take a bigger hit from the rise in oil
prices. Is it a secret to anyone that India and China are competing over every
drop of oil they can obtain at a discount, especially Iranian and Russian oil,
as they seek to cut costs and reduce the pressure their economies are under? Why
has Germany, the European country most dependent on Russian energy, decided to
seek agreements and develop solutions with the Gulf states instead of populist
rhetorical escalation against the Kingdom?
Moreover, what harms the global economy more, Iran’s direct role in prolonging
the Russian-Ukrainian conflict (or at least its criminal intention to do so, as
demonstrated by its decision to send Moscow drones to bomb Ukrainian cities
with), or the decision of OPEC+- the hostility to which wise, calm figures
within the administration, such as Amos Hochstein, have played down? Indeed, he
refrained from hastily and unfoundedly calling it an act of aggression, only
saying that, in his opinion, it was a wrong decision.
These questions do not need answers; they answered themselves as soon as the fog
of populist statements from Washington subsided.
The superficial and hasty conclusion that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has chosen
to align itself with Russia in the latter’s conflict with Ukraine is nothing
short of detached from reality. Does it imply that the United Arab Emirates, the
only Arab state currently in the Security Council, thus representing shared Arab
interests within it, went against Saudi Arabia by voting to condemn Russia’s
annexation of four Ukrainian regions?
Riyadh has not issued an opposing stance to that taken by the UAE at the
Security Council, meaning that the decision of the UAE does not express the
position of Abu Dhabi alone but reflects a solid joint understanding among the
Arabs that this position in their interests, even if the proposed resolution did
not pass because of a Russian veto. How, then, could Saudi Arabia be allied with
Russia and supportive of its war when it comes to oil but opposed to it
regarding the outcome of the war itself?
After calming down, Washington needs to ask itself, why have we seen prices drop
the way they have since August 30 despite the fact that Saudi Arabia had not
taken any serious technical or political measures to precipitate this decline?
The fact of the matter is that this drop in prices is a reflection of the
dynamics of the oil markets, which are affected by an array of shifting,
constantly effervescing factors. These factors include apprehensions created by
the war between Russia and Ukraine and the implications of the coronavirus
pandemic that we continue to feel, especially in China, where mass lockdowns are
still being imposed, reducing its demand for oil. Added to them are the facts
that central banks around the world are raising interest rates and that
recession is on the horizon in Europe and across the world.
Why are scientific and technical reasons accepted in explaining the decline of
the price of oil since August 30 but not in explaining the decision taken by
OPEC+?
Some of the reactions to the OPEC+ decision have gone as far as suggesting
support for a longstanding legislative proposal known as “NOPEC,” which
stipulates holding the OPEC+ cartel legally responsible in the event that it is
proven that its member states had colluded to manipulate prices!
Floating such proposals is enough to toxify the oil market, stir panic, and
raise prices far higher than any OPEC+ decision can.
To reiterate, oil is a strategic commodity, and decisions regarding this
commodity could have ramifications that go beyond the economy, affecting
politics and even questions tied to national security.
It seems that the truth of the matter, which has been articulated by American
officials and commentators, is that it is Washington that is demanding the
politicization of oil prices. The Biden administration wants OPEC+ to take
decisions aimed at punishing Russia by reducing the profits it makes from the
sale of oil and uses to fund its war on Ukraine. That is, it demands that
countries like Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, and others pay the bill
for punishing Vladimir Putin’s regime without the US accounting for the
interests and security concerns of these countries regarding the matters that
concern them.
Though it has political ramifications, the decision taken by OPEC+ is technical.
As for what Washington wants, it is the decision on the matter to be purely
political and aimed at weaponizing energy to confront the weaponization against
Europe by Putin’s regime through halting gas exports. Let us assume that this
was possible without implying significant economic, political, and security
ramifications on the countries concerned with the decision; why would they do
Washington this service?
Did the US administration act in accordance with the interests of Saudi Arabia
regarding the question of whether to designate the Houthi militia as a terrorist
organization? Have the concerns of Saudi Arabia and its Arab allies regarding
the nuclear deal with Iran, which the Biden administration still seeks to
conclude, been resolved? Has the US administration u-turned on its negative
position regarding arms deals?
Elon Musk Taps His Inner Trump in Twitter Machinations
Timothy L. O'Brien/Bloomberg/October,11/2022
Maybe Elon Musk will acquire Twitter Inc. before a court-appointed Oct. 28
deadline to complete the $44 billion acquisition rolls around. Maybe the price
of Tesla Inc.’s shares, currency that Musk may need to rely on to help pay for
the deal, will bounce back from a grinding downturn. Maybe the seven banks that
have arranged a $13 billion loan — and stand to lose as much as $500 million on
the transaction — will hang tough. Maybe the coalition of rich guys and venture
capitalists who promised to chip in $7 billion to support Musk’s bid will stick
around.
That’s a lot of maybes, however, even for an entrepreneur accustomed to vaulting
past expectations while also peddling ill-informed bunk about a wide range of
subjects, including Covid-19, reality TV, reproduction, Martian democracy and
the fates of Taiwan and Ukraine. And this time, for the first time, Musk has the
law closely corralling his shenanigans. (Previous tepid monitoring and slaps on
the wrist from the Securities and Exchange Commission don’t count.)
The lying, spin and misdirection Musk has attached to his Twitter bid might have
been fun when he first hatched the offer, but a judge is looking now. Yes, he’s
the world’s richest person, but his sagging Tesla shares, among his most liquid
holdings, lost 16% of their value last week after the company’s car sales didn’t
meet expectations. He may have to fork over more cash or sell assets such as
part of his stake in Space Exploration Technology Corp. to fully fund the
takeover. Reality is catching up to Musk, and it’s all very Trumpy.
There are distinct differences between Musk and former President Donald Trump,
of course. Musk hasn’t been running around fomenting coups, for example, so the
fallout from his brinksmanship is less consequential. But he has run roughshod
over business norms, securities regulations and the truth in his pursuit of
Twitter, wasting a lot of other people’s time and money and toying with the
fates of Twitter’s 7,500 employees. His penchant for doing as he pleases without
worrying about the damage is in sync with Trump’s own mojo.
Both men are thin-skinned and unpredictable; they both revel in lashing out at
their critics on social media; they both use social media to foster cults of
personality; and they both seem to think they possess a universal intelligence.
Musk and Trump have also both attracted flocks of courtiers and enablers who are
eager to further their own ambitions, bask in their access to power or make a
little money. Such sycophancy has produced rafts of tragicomic propaganda.
“Donald Trump is at his very best, at his very best, when he talks about the
issues,” the former president’s adviser, Kellyanne Conway once said of the man
who studiously avoided learning anything about most issues. Jack Dorsey, a
Twitter founder and former chief executive officer whose mismanagement of the
company helped make it a takeover target, waxed heroic about Musk’s attempted
buyout: “Elon is the singular solution I trust. I trust his mission to extend
the light of consciousness.”
Extending the light of consciousness doesn’t really seem to be the animating
force behind Musk’s Twitter bid. What is? Well, Musk will tell you that it’s “an
accelerant to creating X, the everything app.” Ah, yes, the everything app. As
my colleague Parmy Olson pointed out, an app that meets every consumer need has
enormous business appeal, and some already exist in places like China. But US
regulators are unlikely to sign off on a venture like that and, as Olson also
noted, “it’s probably not the best idea for someone as volatile as Musk to
oversee an app on which millions engage in social commentary, payments,
shopping, identification and more.”
But saying you have a mega-app called “X” in mind, without putting any clothing
on the idea, sends out just the right amount of guru-ness to the fanbase. When
one Musk follower told him on Twitter that it “would have been easier to just
start X from scratch,” Musk hit that softball out of the park with this reply:
“Twitter probably accelerates X by 3 to 5 years, but I could be wrong.”
Translation: “Twitter, which I don’t own yet and which is in a notoriously
fickle industry that I have never worked in, will speed up the development of an
unknown X I’ve never really elaborated upon, and by a metric I just invented.”
This sounds like, wait for it, wait for it … Trump.
The former president has been fumbling through the launch of a Twitter
competitor because managing media companies is hard, and money and celebrity
alone aren’t enough to make them successful. He entered the White House
promising to bring business-like efficiency to the Washington swamp but never
really elaborated on the concept. And then he bestowed chaos on everything
around him and filled the swamp with his own people. “I will give you
everything,” Trump promised when he campaigned for the presidency and didn’t
deliver on most of it.
A significant portion of Trump’s more concrete actions, many involving potential
election fraud and financial wrongdoing, have landed him in the lap of the law.
State and federal civil and criminal prosecutions of Trump and his minions are
afoot. Trump has circumnavigated the rule of law for decades, and he may prove
elusive again, but he’s facing some formidable challenges.
Musk — who has amazing, outsize accomplishments under his belt at Tesla and
SpaceX — isn’t anywhere close to the kinds of existential legal problems Trump
is enduring. Still, for someone who routinely thumbed his nose at the SEC, his
experience going against Twitter in the Delaware Chancery Court to try to
extricate himself from the buyout has to have been a sobering experience. The
case was an embarrassment for Musk. Cringeworthy text messages and other
communications were released. And Judge Kathaleen McCormick has presided over
the matter with an iron fist, refusing to let Musk or his lawyers get away with
any hijinks. When it became apparent that he wasn’t going to win in court and
would have to endure a grueling deposition, Musk pulled the plug on the case and
is now revisiting the Twitter takeover. The court caught up with him. Musk has
also ventured into dangerous legal territory. If he doesn’t have a deal in place
by Oct. 28, McCormick plans to proceed with a trial in November. He also told
the judge — not just investors and the media — that he intends to complete the
buyout. She might decide to force him to close the deal, or she might find
evidence of securities fraud in his court machinations. Some investors are also
probably waiting in the wings, ready to sue Musk if he doesn’t follow through.
That’s a lot of pressure. And Musk will most likely slip past most of it. Even
so, his Twitter foray has made him recognizable to anyone who has seen Trump
exposed on multiple occasions — as the emperor who has no clothes.