English LCCC Newsbulletin For
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For October 21/2020
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on the
lccc Site
http://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2021/english.october21.21.htm
News
Bulletin Achieves Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since 2006
Bible Quotations For today
Do you not know that you are God’s temple and that
God’s Spirit dwells in you? If anyone destroys God’s temple, God will destroy
that person
First Letter to the Corinthians
03/10-23/:”According to the grace of God given to me, like a skilled master
builder I laid a foundation, and someone else is building on it. Each builder
must choose with care how to build on it. For no one can lay any foundation
other than the one that has been laid; that foundation is Jesus Christ. Now if
anyone builds on the foundation with gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay,
straw the work of each builder will become visible, for the Day will disclose
it, because it will be revealed with fire, and the fire will test what sort of
work each has done. If what has been built on the foundation survives, the
builder will receive a reward. If the work is burned, the builder will suffer
loss; the builder will be saved, but only as through fire. Do you not know that
you are God’s temple and that God’s Spirit dwells in you? If anyone destroys
God’s temple, God will destroy that person. For God’s temple is holy, and you
are that temple. Do not deceive yourselves. If you think that you are wise in
this age, you should become fools so that you may become wise. For the wisdom of
this world is foolishness with God. For it is written, ‘He catches the wise in
their craftiness’, and again, ‘The Lord knows the thoughts of the wise, that
they are futile.’So let no one boast about human leaders. For all things are
yours, whether Paul or Apollos or Cephas or the world or life or death or the
present or the future all belong to you, and you belong to Christ, and Christ
belongs to God.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News & Editorials
published on
October 20-21/2021
U.S. Envoy Meets Lebanese Leaders over Israel Border Dispute
Ministry of Health: 778 new cases, 4 deaths
Aoun addresses maritime border negotiations with US envoy, tells Alvarez &
Marsal forensic audit will start tomorrow
Berri discusses maritime borders demarcation with Hochstein: We have a new
opportunity to resume negotiations in Naqoura
Berri signs electoral law amendment bill, refers it Council of Ministers
Mikati, US envoy tackle maritime border demarcation file
Mikati signs election law amendment
Army Chief, Hochstein tackle indirect negotiations to demarcate maritime borders
Bou Habib, Hochstein discuss demarcation dossier
Report: Higher Judicial Council Doesn't Intend to Discuss Bitar Removal
Bitar Renews Summonses of Zoaiter, Mashnouq
Hoteit-Led Delegation Meets Justice Minister over Port Case
Roads Blocked in Lebanon after Major Surge in Fuel Prices
Lebanon Central Bank Audit Demanded by Creditors to Resume
Nasrallah’s boast of commanding 100,000 fighters a message to Lebanese army,
political factions
Lebanon to hold elections amid economic meltdown, sectarian tensions
Nasrallah Brag of 100,000-Strong Force Seen Aimed at Foes at Home
Lebanon's Car Culture Questioned in Crisis
Tayyouneh Clash Fires Up Sectarian Anger in Echo of Civil War
Former Lebanese PM Fouad Siniora: Hizbullah Has Hijacked Lebanon; Iran's Fuel
Supply To Lebanon Is Only For Show – It Is Incapable Of Supplying Even Its Own
People With Fuel
Lebanese diaspora vote will not be enough to force change on a corrupt
establishment/Makram Rabah/Al Arabiya/October 20/2021
Oyez oyez oyez /Jean-Marie Kassab/Octobre 20/2021
The boomerang effect/Nicholas Frakes/Now Lebanon/October 20/2021
Titles For The Latest English LCCC
Miscellaneous Reports And News published on
October 20-21/2021
Blast at US outpost in Syria, no American injuries
— US officials
Six Loyalist Fighters Killed in Syria Arms Depot Blast
HRW Says 'Torture' Awaits Syrian Refugees Returning from Lebanon, Jordan
14 Killed in Rare Damascus Army Bus Bombing
In historic move, Egypt installs 98 women on main judicial body
Social unrest threatens ‘fragile’ recoveries in Middle East
Egypt: 19 killed in truck-microbus collision outside Cairo
UN Security Council condemns Houthi violations in Yemen, Saudi Arabia
Putin Orders Week-Long Paid Holiday to Curb Covid Infections
Second air strike this week hits capital of Ethiopia's Tigray TV
Titles For The Latest The Latest LCCC
English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on
October 20-21/2021
A Sword Of Damocles Over Free Thought In Egypt (And Elsewhere)/Alberto M.
Fernandez/MEMRI/October 202021
Why Turkey should swap military strikes for water diplomacy/Dr. Dania Koleilat
Khatib/Arab News/October 20, 2021
Biden’s Syria policy leaves US in no-win situation/Ray Hanania/Arab News/October
20/2021
The Latest English LCCC Lebanese &
Lebanese Related News & Editorials published
on October 20-21/2021
U.S. Envoy Meets Lebanese Leaders over
Israel Border Dispute
Agence France Presse/October 202021
U.S. envoy Amos Hochstein met Wednesday with President Michel Aoun, Speaker
Nabih Berri and PM Najib Miqati in a bid to rekindle moribund talks over a
maritime border dispute between Lebanon and Israel that is holding up oil and
gas explorations. The Presidency said Aoun and Hochstein discussed “the course
of the negotiations process regarding the sea border demarcation and the
prospects in this file.”The National News Agency meanwhile said Berri and
Hochstein reemphasized “the framework agreement that was announced in October
last year.”Berri for his part noted that “there is a new chance to resume the
negotiations in Naqoura with the new U.S. efforts that are being exerted in this
regard.” He also stressed to Hochstein “the importance of exempting Lebanon from
the restrictions of the Caesar Act in the issues of drawing Egyptian gas and
electricity from Jordan.”
NNA said the U.S. envoy expressed optimism to Berri about the two topics.
Hochstein has been recently appointed as the U.S. envoy to the
Washington-mediated talks. He has been a longtime close adviser to President Joe
Biden. Hochstein would "discuss sustainable solutions to Lebanon's energy
crisis," a U.S. State Department statement said. Lebanon is currently grappling
with its worst ever financial crisis, and fuel shortages have ground the country
to a halt in recent months. With a bankrupt state unable to deliver more than an
hour or two of mains electricity a day, individuals, businesses and institutions
have relied almost entirely on diesel-powered generators. Rivals Washington and
Tehran have in recent weeks appeared to jostle to bring the prime solution to
Lebanon's energy crisis. Iran, impeded by U.S. and other sanctions, sent an oil
tanker to Syria and then had its cargo trucked in through an illegal border
point to its Lebanese ally Hizbullah. The move was seen as a short-term fix with
a limited impact on the energy crisis but also as a successful media stunt that
goaded Washington into speeding up efforts to come up with alternative
solutions. The U.S. has since been publicly pushing for a regional initiative
involving Egypt, Jordan and the World Bank. "Mr. Hochstein will also underscore
the Biden administration's willingness to help Lebanon and Israel find a
mutually agreeable solution to their shared maritime boundary for the benefit of
both peoples," the U.S. statement said. Israel and Lebanon had resumed
negotiations over their disputed maritime border in 2020 but the process was
stalled by Lebanon's claim that the map used by the U.N. in the talks needed
modifying. Lebanese politicians hope that commercially viable hydrocarbon
resources off Lebanon's coast could help lift the debt-ridden country out of its
economic quagmire.
Ministry of Health: 778 new cases, 4 deaths
NNA/October 202021
The Ministry of Public Health announced 778 new coronavirus infection cases,
bringing the cumulative number of confirmed cases to 635,447.
Four deaths have been recorded.
Aoun addresses maritime border negotiations with US envoy,
tells Alvarez & Marsal forensic audit will start tomorrow
NNA/October 202021
President of the Republic, General Michel Aoun, met Chief Advisor to the US
State Department for energy security and the new mediator in the indirect
negotiations to demarcate southern maritime borders, Amos Hochstein, today at
the Presidential Palace.
US Ambassador to Lebanon, Dorothy Shea, also attended the meeting.
The course of negotiations to demarcate southern maritime borders and the future
directions of this issue were deliberated in the meeting.
Alvarez & Marsal General Manager:
The President then received the General Manager of Alvarez & Marsal, Mr. James
Daniel, Finance Minister, Youssef Khalil, Government Commissioner at the Central
Bank, Mrs. Christelle Wakim, and Mr. Paul Sharma.
The delegation informed the President that Alvarez & Marsal will start forensic
audit in BDL accounts from tomorrow morning, after completing all the related
arrangements. President Aoun wished the delegation to expedite work, due to the
accuracy of this task.
Head of the Antonine Institute:
President Aoun met head of the Saint Anthony Monastery and the Antonine
Institute, Father Nader Nader. Father Nader was heading a delegation of Antonine
monks who conveyed to the President congratulations on the formation of the new
government. The delegation also invited President Aoun to attend the divine
sacrifice on St. Michael’s Day, on November 8, and the feast of St. Anthony,
next January 17.
Father Nader:
In the meeting, Father Nader delivered the following speech:
“The harshness of the last days didn’t allow us to meet on St. Antony’s feast,
nor on other occasions. However, your kindness never disappeared from our
conscience and mind. You were always in the heart of our liturgy and prayers. We
thank the Lord for everything he gave you from blessings and virtues. The Lord
who helped you bear the cross of accusations, the arrows of evil which were
aimed at you, and all the slanders which you were stoned with. You endured all
this with patience, so victory was on your side and a new government was formed,
congratulations to you and to us.
As for now Mr. President, your adherence to the basic principles, role and
powers of the President of the Republic, in addition to the strong means which
help contribute to saving the country, land of holiness, remains the guarantee.
Your adherence also remains a space of hope and peace which we want for all the
Lebanese. We raise our prayers with you, if circumstances allow, to meet around
the feast of your patron St. Michael, and we will be more happy if you honor us
as usual next January 17 on the feast of our patron, St. Anthony”.
President Aoun:
For his part, the President thanked Father Nader for the passion he expressed,
and stressed the old relationship which binds him to the Antonine Order, noting
the role it had played in serving Lebanon at spiritual and national levels. The
President also explained the conditions which Lebanon is witnessing and the
difficulties which faced the reform process launched, as well as the crises
which have accumulated and brought the country to the current situation.
Finally, President Aoun asserted work to confront the current situation with
faith, firmness and hope, so that Lebanon would gradually recover.—Presidency
Press Office
Berri discusses maritime borders demarcation with
Hochstein: We have a new opportunity to resume negotiations in Naqoura
NNA/October 202021
Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri welcomed in Ain el-Tineh the Egyptian ambassador
to Lebanon, Yasser Al-Alawi, with whom he reviewed the general situation and
bilateral relations. The Speaker later met with Head of the US delegation for
indirect negotiations to demarcate the maritime borders between Lebanon and
occupied Palestine, Amos Hochstein, and the accompanying delegation, in the
presence of US ambassador Dorothy Shea. Speaker Berri indicated that "we have a
new opportunity to resume negotiations in Naqoura, with the new US efforts being
exerted in this context." He also tackled, during his meeting with Hochstein,
"the importance of excluding Lebanon from the controls of Caesar's Law on the
issues of importing Egyptian gas and electricity from Jordan."
Berri signs electoral law amendment bill, refers it Council
of Ministers
NNA/October 202021
House Speaker, Nabih Berri, on Wednesday signed the bill aiming to amend the
legislative law and referred it to the Presidency of the Council of Ministers
for urgent issuance in accordance with the first clause of Article 56 of the
Lebanese Constitution.
Mikati, US envoy tackle maritime border demarcation file
NNA/October 202021
Prime Minister Najib Mikati met with the US envoy in charge of following up on
the file of the demarcation of the southern Lebanese maritime border, and the US
State Department's senior adviser on energy security, Amos Hochstein, in the
presence of US Ambassador Dorothy Shea.
Later on, PM Mikati held two educational meetings in the presence of Minister of
Education Abbas Al-Halabi, to discuss the start of the academic year and the
difficulties faced by the sector.
Mikati signs election law amendment
NNA/October 202021
Prime Minister Najib Mikati signed the law issued by the House of
Representatives yesterday, which aims to amend some articles of Law No. 44
related to the election of members of the House, issued on June 17, 2017.The law
was transferred after signing the presidency of the republic.
Army Chief, Hochstein tackle indirect negotiations to demarcate maritime borders
NNA/October 202021
Armed Forces Commander, General Joseph Aoun, received in Yarzeh the Advisor to
the US Secretary of State for Energy Security Affairs, Amos Hochstein,
accompanied by US Ambassador Dorothy Shea.
Discussions touched on the indirect technical negotiations for the demarcation
of the maritime borders.
Bou Habib, Hochstein discuss demarcation dossier
NNA/October 202021
Minister of Foreign Affairs and Emigrants, Abdallah Bou Habib, welcomed the
Adviser to the US State Department for Energy Security, the new US mediator for
the indirect negotiation process on the demarcation of the southern Lebanese
maritime border, Amos Hochstein, accompanied by US Ambassador Dorothy Shea. A
statement issued in the wake of the meeting indicated that "the issue of
demarcating the maritime borders with occupied Palestine was discussed, and the
atmosphere was positive. It was also agreed to maintain communication and strive
to reach a positive result in this file, in what serves Lebanon's interest."
Report: Higher Judicial Council Doesn't Intend to Discuss Bitar Removal
Naharnet/October 202021
The Higher Judicial Council rejects "the intimidation and treason accusations
campaign against the judiciary," a Council source has said. The Council "also
rejects any attempt to undermine the judiciary's role as an independent
authority," the source told Kuwait's al-Anbaa newspaper in remarks published
Wednesday. "The Council does not intend, in any way whatsoever, to discuss any
format aimed at removing the investigative judge into the Beirut port blast
file, Judge Tarek Bitar," the source added.
Bitar Renews Summonses of Zoaiter, Mashnouq
Associated Press/October 202021
The judge leading Lebanon's probe into last year's massive port explosion has
renewed his summonses of two former ministers for questioning, a judicial
official said. The decision by Judge Tarek Bitar came despite intense criticism
from the country's powerful Hizbullah of the direction of the long-running
investigation. Hizbullah leader Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah has accused Bitar of
politicizing the probe and singling out some officials and not others. He has
called on the government to remove Bitar. Bitar has been in the post since
February, after his predecessor was removed by a court decision following legal
challenges from senior government officials who were also summoned. Nasrallah's
accusations marked a major escalation in rhetoric targeting Bitar and were
followed by protests in the capital Beirut last week by supporters of Hizbullah
and its ally Amal against the judge. The protests descended into violence unseen
in Lebanon in years: Seven people were killed during five hours of clashes
between supporters of the two Shiite groups and gunmen accused of being
supporters of the Lebanese Forces party.
Critics held Bitar responsible for the bloodshed.
But the judge went ahead with summoning two former government ministers, one of
them an ally of Hizbullah, for questioning regarding the port blast. Bitar had
issued arrest warrants for the two ex-ministers but with the resumption of
parliament sessions Tuesday following a recess, the ministers reclaimed
parliamentary immunity, which had shielded them from previous interrogation. The
two former ministers, Ghazi Zoaiter and Nouhad al-Mashnouq, are also lawmakers.
They were summoned to appear Oct. 29, the judicial official said, speaking on
condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the press. The
former ministers' legal teams argue that with parliamentary immunity in place,
the officials are exempt from appearing before the judge. But according to the
parliament's bylaws, Bitar can renew his summonses because he first called for
their questioning in a period when parliament was in recess -- at a time when
the two men had briefly lost their immunity. Legal experts have called it the
"battle of immunities" as the defendants and the lead judge have looked for
loopholes in the law to each get their way. The result has been interruptions of
the investigation, which is centered on what caused the explosion of ammonium
nitrate, a highly explosive fertilizer often used to make bombs, stored in the
port for years. Independent media and rights groups have revealed that senior
government officials knew of the material stored in the port but did nothing to
store it properly or warn the public of its presence and danger.
More than 215 people died and over 6,000 were injured in the blast that
devastated parts of the city Beirut.
Hoteit-Led Delegation Meets Justice Minister over Port Case
Naharnet/October 20/2021
A delegation from the families of the Beirut port blast victims on Wednesday
visited Justice Minister Henri Khoury and handed him a letter that was referred,
at their request, to the Higher Judicial Council. The delegation was led by
Ibrahim Hoteit, a former spokesman of the grouping of families who recently
appeared in a surprising video in which he made a U-turn in his stance on lead
investigator Judge Tarek Bitar. The majority of families distanced themselves
from Hoteit’s new stance and said the video was likely recorded under duress.
William Noun, an outspoken member of the families grouping, said Hoteit “only
represents himself and two other families.”In a statement on behalf of the
families, Noun added that Hoteit “has no right to act or speak on our
behalf.”“The families of the port martyrs and victims stress their insistence on
supporting the judiciary and Judge Tarek Bitar,” Noun said. Pro-Hizbullah
journalist Salem Zahran meanwhile said that the Hoteit-led delegation handed
Khoury a letter demanding “the removal of Judge Tarek Bitar from the case” and
that the letter was “referred to the Higher Judicial Council.”
Roads Blocked in Lebanon after Major Surge in Fuel
Prices
Agence France Presse/October 202021
Protesters took to the streets in several Lebanese regions on Wednesday after a
major surge in fuel prices, the latest in a series of recent increases. The
current hike is linked to a global rise in the prices of fuel and it marks a de
facto end to state subsidies, pushing the cost of filling a vehicle's tank to
more than the monthly minimum wage in the poverty-stricken nation. The prices of
fuel had already soared in Lebanon after the central bank gradually lifted and
eventually ended subsidization. A common unit of measurement -- 20 liters -- of
95-octane gasoline was hiked by LBP 59,900 on Wednesday to reach LBP 302,700, or
around $15 at the black market rate. This is around five times the price of
61,100 pounds set at the end of June, adding to the economic pain in a country
where power cuts are common and basic goods including medicine have become
scarce. Diesel will meanwhile sell at LBP 270,700 per 20 liters and a cylinder
of cooking gas will sell at LBP 229,600. The revised price "marks a complete
lifting of petroleum subsidies," Fadi Abou Shaqra of the country's fuel
distributors' association told AFP. "The fuel price hike will cause the cost of
services to also increase, especially transportation," he added.
An energy ministry official said that the "latest petroleum prices were
calculated on the basis of a currency exchange rate of 20,000 pounds to the
dollar as per a central bank request."The price increases have mostly erased
massive queues at gas pumps that clogged streets across the country during the
summer when importers and gas station owners severely rationed supply.In the
southern city of Sidon, taxi drivers blocked the vital al-Nejmeh Square with
their cars on Wednesday in protest at the new prices. “The issue has become
unbearable, especially that our livelihood mainly depends on this substance
(gasoline),” the National News Agency quoted the drivers as saying. The drivers
also blocked the city’s seaside corniche and the road outside the al-Zaatari
Mosque. In the capital, protesters blocked the Saifi road in central Beirut in
all directions. It was eventually reopened. The Corniche al-Mazraa and Sports
City roads were also briefly blocked by protesters. Outside the capital, retired
servicemen blocked the Beirut-Dora highway outside the Forum de Beyrouth.
Demonstrators in the North meanwhile blocked the Bireh-Qoubayat road in Akkar,
the Tripoli-Akkar highway in the Bab al-Tabbaneh area and the al-Nour Square in
central Tripoli.
Lebanon Central Bank Audit Demanded by Creditors to Resume
Agence France Presse/October 202021
A New York-based firm contracted by the Lebanese government is to resume its
audit of the central bank Thursday in line with creditors' demands, the Lebanese
presidency and a top official said. The International Monetary Fund and France
are among creditors demanding an audit of Banque du Liban as part of urgent
reforms to unlock financial support to deal with an economic crisis branded by
the World Bank as one of the planet's worst since the mid-19th century. The
Alvarez & Marsal (A&M) auditing firm had launched an audit in September last
year but was forced to pull out some two months later because the central bank
failed to hand over necessary data. On Wednesday, President Michel Aoun met with
A&M managing director James Daniell, who informed him that "the company will
begin tomorrow its forensic financial audit of Lebanon's central bank after all
arrangements were completed," the presidency said. Finance ministry official
Georges Maarawi told AFP that the auditing firm "will have 12 weeks to collect
information and draft a report," under the terms of its contract with the
Lebanese government. The contract with A&M was signed by Finance Minister
Youssef Khalil last month only days after he took up his post. Experts have
expressed doubts that the terms of the contract and the limited time given to
auditors will allow for a credible investigation. "As long as the auditors don't
have direct access to servers, IT and accounting systems and the work isn't
overseen by the competent authorities... then I don't expect anything out of
it," financial analyst Mike Azar said. "The way the work is structured now will
most likely not result in an honest and thorough forensic audit," he told AFP.
In December, parliament approved a bill that suspends banking secrecy laws for
one year to allow for the forensic audit -- which is widely seen as a necessary
prelude to any agreement with the IMF over financial assistance. Maarawi, the
finance ministry official, said that Lebanese authorities are currently holding
"technical meetings" with the IMF, without elaborating. Following a meeting with
IMF executive director Mahmoud Mohieldin on Tuesday, Prime Minister Najib Miqati
said that Lebanon was betting on an IMF plan to help it survive its
unprecedented financial crunch."We hope to clinch a cooperation agreement before
the end of the year," he said.
Nasrallah’s boast of commanding 100,000 fighters a
message to Lebanese army, political factions
The Arab Weekly/October 20/2021
Experts say the figure, which exceeds the size of Lebanon’s army by about 15,000
troops, is an exaggeration.
A boast by the leader of Hezbollah that he commands 100,000 fighters came as a
surprise to many Lebanese, not least because it was addressed to a domestic
audience rather than the militia’s archenemy Israel.
Analysts said that the Hezbollah’s chief’s message seemed to be directed at the
head of the Lebanese Forces Party, Samir Geagea, but was also to all those who
advocate bolstering the Lebanese army and making sure that in the long run it
becomes the only force in the country entitled to bear arms.
Nasrallah said Hezbollah has 100,000 armed fighters at its disposal. But
indicated these fighters are to defend Lebanon from external enemies, not to
fight in a civil war. Addressing Geagea, he said, “Who do you want to fight in
civil war, with whom do you want to engage in internal fighting, a hundred
thousand with their arms and equipment?”Nasrallah accused the leader of the
Lebanese Forces party of maintaining a militia under its command. Lebanese
sources said Hezbollah was following with concern US, French and Saudi talk
about supporting the Lebanese army in order to allow it to play an important
role in maintaining security in the country. Hezbollah seems wary that the goal
behind these talks is to prepare the army at a later stage in order to confront
the heavily-armed pro-Iranian party and seize control of its weapons. Experts
say the figure, which exceeds the size of Lebanon’s army by about 15,000 troops,
is an exaggeration. But Hassan Nasrallah’s brag is likely to further ratchet up
anxiety about a return to sectarian fighting in the small country roiled by a
series of devastating crises.
“This is more about flexing Hezbollah’s muscles to demonstrate its power against
other opposing political parties that want to undermine it,” said Dina Arakji, a
researcher at Control Risks, a Dubai-based global risk consultancy group.
Hezbollah’s clout exceeds that of the army not just in numbers but also in war
experience, considering the participation of its troops in military operations
in Syrian battlefields and its training on sophisticated weapons provided by
Iran. At the same time, the Lebanese army is shackled by lack of financial
resources to the point of being unable to feed its own soldiers. Army Commander,
General Joseph Aoun, said soldiers are “suffering and starving.”The army chief
stressed that military troops are part of Lebanese society and they “suffer and
starve like the rest of the people”. He asked politicians: “Where are we going?
What are your intentions? We have warned more than once that the situation is
serious and of the possibility of an explosion.”
Such statements led Hezbollah to believe that Joseph Aoun wanted to play an
internal role that competes with that of the party, buoyed by external
encouragement, although the army chief did not betray a desire to enter the
political fray. Hezbollah wants to keep its hold on the vital institutions in
Lebanon, starting with the military and including the security apparatus and the
judiciary. But developments are not going in the direction it wants, especially
after Judge Tarek Bitar, who is in charge of investigating the Beirut port
blast, has insisted on working in complete independence from Hezbollah and
directing accusations even at the party’s direct allies.
Nasrallah renewed Monday his objection to the port blast investigation, which he
said was “not objective”, adding that the way it was conducted would not lead to
truth or justice. Lebanese analysts said that Hassan Nasrallah’s speech tried to
placate the rising fears inside Lebanon over the growing influence of Hezbollah,
which threatens even the security of areas affiliated with its allies,
especially Christians. They note that the alliance of Hezbollah and Amal
Movement and the slogans raised in the march by their supporters last Thursday
brought back memories of the country’s bloody sectarian confrontations. This led
the Hezbollah chief to say that his party is not an enemy of Lebanon’s
Christians. “The biggest threat to the security of the Christian community is
the Lebanese Forces party and its leader,” he said. Seven Shia demonstrators
were killed last Thursday in Beirut violence as crowds were on their way to
protests called for by Shia duo Hezbollah and the Amal movement. The bloodshed
was reminiscent of the civil war that raged in the country between 1975 and
1990. The Lebanese Forces party condemned Thursday’s events and blamed the
violence on Hezbollah’s “incitement” against Judge Tarek Bitar, the lead
investigator into the Beirut port blast. Nasrallah admitted that some of the
Shia demonstrators may have chanted provocative slogans as they approached the
Christian area and that this was a mistake, but then shooting started and people
were killed. He added, “I advise the Forces Party and its leader to completely
abandon the idea of infighting and civil war … I tell you, you are
miscalculating … Hezbollah in the region has never been as strong as it is
now.”Despite his traditional hard-line stances, Nasrallah devoted an important
part of his speech to trying to assuage the fears of Lebanese Christians, saying
that Hezbollah protects their rights and is allied with the largest Christian
party, the Free Patriotic Movement.
Lebanon to hold elections amid economic meltdown, sectarian tensions
The Arab Weekly/October 20/2021
Bitar renews his summonses of two former ministers for questioning, a judicial
official said.
Lebanon’s parliament voted on Tuesday to hold legislative elections on March 27,
giving Prime Minister Najib Mikati’s government only a few months to try to
secure an IMF recovery plan amid rising sectarian tensions and a deepening
economic meltdown. Lebanon’s financial crisis, which the World Bank labelled one
of the deepest depressions of modern history, had been compounded by political
deadlock for over a year before Mikati put together a cabinet alongside
President Michel Aoun. The currency has lost 90% of its value and three-quarters
of the population have been propelled into poverty. Shortages of basic goods
such as fuel and medicines have made daily life a struggle.
Talks with IMF
Mikati, whose cabinet is focused on reviving talks with the International
Monetary Fund, had vowed to make sure elections are held with no delay and
Western governments urged the same. After a meeting an executive director at the
IMF on Tuesday, Mikati said his government had compiled the necessary financial
data for the fund. “We hope to complete a cooperation programme before the end
of this year,” Mikati was quoted in a statement by his office as saying after a
meeting with the IMF’s Mahmoud Mohieldin in Beirut. Meanwhile, a New York-based
firm contracted by the Lebanese government is to resume its audit of the central
bank Thursday in line with creditors’ demands, the Lebanese presidency and a top
official said. The IMF and France are among creditors demanding an audit of
Banque du Liban as part of urgent reforms to unlock financial support. The
Alvarez & Marsal (A&M) auditing firm had launched an audit in September last
year but was forced to pull out some two months later because the central bank
failed to hand over necessary data. On Wednesday, President Michel Aoun met A&M
managing director James Daniell, who informed him that “the company will begin
tomorrow its forensic financial audit of Lebanon’s central bank after all
arrangements were completed,” the presidency said. Finance ministry official
Georges Maarawi said that the auditing firm “will have 12 weeks to collect
information and draft a report,” under the terms of its contract with the
Lebanese government. The contract with A&M was signed by Finance Minister
Youssef Khalil last month only days after he took up his post. In December,
parliament approved a bill that suspends banking secrecy laws for one year to
allow for the forensic audit, which is widely seen as a necessary prelude to any
agreement with the IMF over financial assistance.Maarawi, the finance ministry
official, said that Lebanese authorities are currently holding “technical
meetings” with the IMF, without elaborating.
Probe into port blast
The efforts of Mikati government coincide with rising sectarian tensions,
following a row over the probe into last year’s Beirut port blast that killed
over 200 people and destroyed large swathes of the capital is threatening to
veer his cabinet off course. Some ministers, aligned with politicians that lead
investigator Judge Tarek Bitar is seeking to question over the explosion, last
week demanded that the judge be removed from the probe. Mikati has since said
the cabinet will not convene another meeting until an agreement is reached on
how to deal with the crisis. Bitar renewed on Tuesday his summonses of two
former ministers for questioning, a judicial official said. The decision by
Judge Bitar came despite intense criticism from the country’s powerful Hezbollah
group of the direction of the long-running investigation. Bitar had issued
arrest warrants for the two ex-ministers but with the resumption of parliament
sessions Tuesday following a recess, the ministers reclaimed parliamentary
immunity, which had shielded them from previous interrogation. The two former
ministers, Ghazi Zeitar and Nohad Machnouk, are also lawmakers. They were
summoned to appear October 29, the judicial official said, speaking on condition
of anonymity because he was not authorised to speak to the press. The former
ministers’ legal teams argue that with parliamentary immunity in place, the
officials are exempt from appearing before the judge. But according to the
parliament’s bylaws, Bitar can renew his summonses because he first called for
their questioning in a period when parliament was in recess, at a time when the
two men had briefly lost their immunity. Legal experts have called it the
“battle of immunities” as the defendants and the lead judge have looked for
loopholes in the law to each get their way. On Thursday, Beirut witnessed the
worst street violence in over a decade with seven people killed in gunfire when
protesters from the Hezbollah and Amal Shia movements made their way to
demonstrate against Bitar. The bloodshed, which stirred memories of the
1975-1990 civil war, added to fears for the stability of a country that is awash
with weapons. The early election date, elections were originally expected to be
held in May, was chosen to avoid clashing with the holy Islamic fasting month of
Ramadan. Once a new parliament is elected, the Mikati cabinet will only act in a
caretaker role until a new prime minister is given a vote of confidence and
tasked with forming a new government.
Nasrallah Brag of 100,000-Strong Force Seen Aimed at
Foes at Home
Associated Press/October 202021
A boast by Hizbullah chief Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah that he commands 100,000
fighters came as a surprise to many Lebanese, not least because it was addressed
to a domestic audience rather than the group's archenemy Israel. Experts say the
figure, which exceeds the size of Lebanon's army by about 15,000 troops, is an
exaggeration. But Nasrallah's brag is likely to further ratchet up anxiety about
a return to sectarian fighting in the small country roiled by a series of
devastating crises. "This is more about flexing Hizbullah's muscles to
demonstrate its power against other opposing political parties that want to
undermine it," said Dina Arakji, a researcher at Control Risks, a Dubai-based
global risk consultancy group.Nasrallah made the declaration Monday as part of
the growing confrontation over a judicial investigation into last year's massive
Beirut port explosion that killed more than 215 people and devastated parts of
the city. Hizbullah and its allies from the Amal Movement led by Parliament
Speaker Nabih Berri want the lead judge removed, accusing him of bias. Deadly
gunbattles broke out last week on Beirut's edge during a demonstration organized
by the two Shiite parties. Clashes with machine guns and rocket-propelled
grenades, reminiscent of the 1975-90 civil war, played out for several hours
along a former front line separating the Muslim and Christian sectors of the
city. Hizbullah accused the Lebanese Forces party of starting the fighting in
which seven were killed, mainly Hizbullah and Amal supporters. Lebanese Forces
leader Samir Geagea denied his group was the aggressor, but said residents of
Christian areas could not be blamed for defending themselves against hoards of
Hizbullah and Amal supporters marching violently through their neighborhoods. In
Monday's speech, Nasrallah accused Geagea of seeking to reignite a civil war and
said he was forced to announce the number of Hizbullah fighters "not to threaten
a civil war, but to prevent one." Hizbullah is a largely secretive organization
and it is difficult to independently verify Nasrallah's claim about the size of
the force. The group rarely comments on its military structure, weapons or
number of fighters. Most estimates for the number of fighters, however, range
between 25,000 and 50,000, including 10,000 elite troops known as the Radwan
Force and a separate reserve force. Hizbullah is known to have stepped up
recruitment in the years after the 2006 war with Israel. In the past decade,
however, it lost nearly 2,000 members while fighting in Syria alongside Syrian
President Bashar Assad's forces in that country's civil war.
Nasrallah said in his speech that those troops were armed and trained for
warfare against Israel, not for an internal armed conflict. Arakji, the analyst,
said it was significant that he chose a speech about the Lebanese Forces and
last week's Tayyouneh violence to reveal the figure.
Hizbullah's claim about a 100,000-strong fighting force was particularly jarring
because Lebanon's army only has about 85,000 troops. The country's financial
crisis and currency collapse have severely impacted the military as an
institution, and affected troop morale. Last week's fighting was a rare instance
of members of Hizbullah clashing with internal rivals, something the group has
repeatedly pledged to avoid. The group's reputation took a major hit in 2008,
after its fighters overran predominantly Sunni Muslim neighborhoods in Beirut.
It was considered the first time Hizbullah used its weapons internally since the
end of the civil war in 1990. It came in response to the then-government of
Prime Minister Fouad Saniora's decision to dismantle Hizbullah's crucial secret
telecommunication network. Some observers say Nasrallah's implicit threats
reveal a degree of vulnerability of Hizbullah, even though it is the most
dominant political and military force in Lebanon. Hizbullah's Shiite
constituency, like other Lebanese communities, has been thrown into poverty by
the country's severe financial crisis. More Lebanese regard the group, which
once had popular support across religious sects for its resistance to Israel, as
being part of a corrupt ruling class that drove the country to bankruptcy.
The group's recent campaign against Tarek Bitar, the judge leading the port
blast investigation, is further pitting the group against many Lebanese who
support him and seek justice and accountability. Civil strife pitting Hizbullah
fighters against rival Lebanese groups would be disastrous for the group, which
already lost popularity for its involvement in Syria's civil war. Hizbullah
officials have repeatedly said the group will not be pulled into an internal war
-- a weak point its opponents like the Lebanese Forces might be looking to
exploit as a way to gain popularity ahead of general elections expected next
spring. Hisham Jaber, a retired Lebanese general who heads the Middle East
Center for Studies and Political Research, said Hizbullah will avoid civil war
at all costs. Hizbullah could easily take control of most of Lebanon militarily
within a week, but this would hurt the group in the long term, Jaber said.
"Whenever they storm and control areas it will be the countdown for its (Hizbullah's)
existence, because their presence in Lebanon is a resistance movement and not a
force to fight in a civil war," he said. Sarit Zehavi, a former Israeli military
intelligence officer who runs the Alma research institute in northern Israel,
said Nasrallah greatly exaggerated his group's military capabilities with the
aim of intimidating his domestic rivals. "His message is 'I'm the strongest
player in Lebanon'," Zehavi said. She said it could backfire against Nasrallah
and draw further criticism in Lebanon. "What he's actually saying is 'I've built
up great power not only to fight Israel but to fight Lebanese'," she said.
Lebanon's Car Culture Questioned in Crisis
Agence France Presse/October 202021
By challenging Lebanon's national passion for automobile ownership, and driving
growing numbers towards greener or more collective transport, the economic
crisis is succeeding where everything else failed. In the absence of a
functioning public transport system, car culture has thrived and many
households, even modest ones, boast multiple vehicles. Since 2019, however, an
ever worsening financial crisis has made petrol unaffordable for many and long
queues at gas stations unbearable for the rest. One of the by-products of
Lebanon's historic shortages and currency crisis is the first meaningful dent in
decades in the reign of the private automobile. Tuk-tuks, bicycles, carpooling
and affordable buses -- which were once out of the question for many -- have
since become more popular amid changing public attitudes and skyrocketing
transport costs, including higher taxi fares.
"Before the crisis, I relied on my family's car or a taxi, but this has all
become unaffordable," said Grace Issa, a 23-year-old customer service
professional whose workplace is around 20 kilometers (12 miles) from home. Her
only option to get to the office now is a private coach operated by Hadeer, a
start-up without which she would not have accepted her new job in the first
place."I now spend about 30 percent of my salary on transportation instead of 70
percent," she told AFP as she boarded a bus to go back home.
'Unclean, unsafe'
There are more than two million cars for six million people in Lebanon. Car
imports have fallen by 70 percent over the past two years and many Lebanese can
no longer afford new vehicles with the local currency losing about 90 percent of
its value against the dollar on the black market.
Dwindling foreign currency reserves have forced authorities to scale back
subsidies on imports, including fuel, causing prices to skyrocket. Twenty liters
(4.4 gallons) of petrol are now worth around a third of the minimum wage, while
nearly 80 percent of the population lives below the poverty line. In response to
the crisis, Boutros Karam, 26, and three friends launched Hadeer, which provides
affordable bus transport along the country's northern coastal highway. Unlike
the dilapidated public transport system, buses operate along a fixed schedule,
are equipped with wi-fi and tracking services and are relatively safer for women
who often report harassment on public coaches and vans. Sixty percent of
Hadeer's customers are women. "The public transport problem is an old one but it
was compounded recently by the fuel crisis and the fact that many can no longer
afford to move around" using taxis or their own cars, Karam said.
The start-up, which has also developed a mobile app that allows customers to
book seats in advance, is breaking stereotypes Lebanese have harbored regarding
mass transit, Karam added. Many of our customers "were not accustomed to using
collective transportation," Karam said. "They used to refuse it because it was
seen as unclean... and unsafe."
'Way of life' -
Lebanon has had a railway network since the end of the 19th century but it has
been out of service since the start of the country's 1975-1990 civil war.
Several proposals over the decades to revamp public transport have been shelved.
In 2018, the World Bank approved a $295 million package to jumpstart the
country's first modern public transport system. The Greater Beirut Public
Transport Project, however, never took off and the Lebanese government is now
looking to use the funds to help support the country's poorest. "Discussions are
under way with the government of Lebanon regarding the feasibility of
restructuring and reprogramming the entire World Bank portfolio which also
includes the Greater Beirut Public Transport Project," World Bank spokesperson
Zeina El-Khalil told AFP. In the coastal city of Batroun, a popular tourist
hotspot during the summer, the tuk-tuk has gained traction among visitors and
residents alike, according to Toni Jerjes, who manages a service offering the
auto rickshaws. "The crisis has changed the Lebanese people's transportation
habits. Tuk-tuk is a less expensive and faster option," he said. In the city of
Tripoli further north, Natheer Halawani has relied on a bicycle for nearly two
decades to move around. He has lobbied for a bicycle boom in his car-clogged
city for years, but in the end, it was the economic calamity that finally put
the wheels in motion, and he says more people are now pedaling through the
city's streets. The private vehicle "is not just a means of transport, it is
also a way of life," he said. For the 35-year-old, the crisis provides "a
suitable opportunity to rethink" such old transportation models.
Tayyouneh Clash Fires Up Sectarian Anger in Echo of
Civil War
Associated Press/October 202021
He was only a year old when his panicked father picked him up and they fled with
his mother from the gunfire rattling their neighborhood. It was the day
Lebanon's civil war started 46 years ago. His family's apartment building in
Beirut was on the frontline. Now 47, Bahij Dana did the same thing last week. He
evacuated his wife and two of his kids as gun battles raged for hours outside
the same building. Civil defense rescuers came to help his father and mother,
stuck in the lower floors. "History is repeating itself," Dana said. The battle
Thursday went on for five hours between supporters of Lebanon's two powerful
Shiite factions -- Hizbullah and Amal -- and gunmen believed to be supporters of
a Christian party -- the Lebanese Forces. It took place on the line between the
Shiyyah and Ain al-Remmaneh neighborhoods on Beirut's southern edge, the same
notorious frontline that bisected the capital and its suburbs into warring
sections during the country's dark civil war era. It was not just memories of
the war that were triggered by the scenes of gunmen in streets and
schoolchildren ducking under desks. The battles, which left seven dead, also
fired up the sectarian passions from that violent past, which Lebanese had
learned to brush aside without ever dealing with the causes.
Add to that a bankrupt government, hyperinflation and mounting poverty, and the
country of six million is turning into a powder keg on the Mediterranean. The
clashes erupted over the probe into last year's massive port blast, as the
political elite closed ranks in their efforts to block it.
Despite calls for calm, leaders of Shiite Hizbullah and the rival Christian
Lebanese Forces kept up their heated rhetoric. They brought back civil war
jargon, talking about "frontlines" and "neighborhood defenses," deepening the
sense that the pact that kept the social peace since the war has come undone.
"We made up, and now they want to pit us against one another again," said
Camille Hobeika, a 51-year-old mechanic and Christian resident of Ain al-Remmaneh.
Since the war, the sectarian-based warlords who fought it have divvied up
political power, signing a pact in 1989 and issuing an amnesty for themselves.
Though rivals, they have had a common interest in maintaining the system, rife
with patronage and corruption, and so generally keep a shaky peace. The new
fighting highlighted a generational divide that stands at the heart of how
Lebanese deal with that legacy.
For those who lived through the atrocities of the communal fighting between 1975
and 1990, the country is fated to that system, even with occasional bouts of
violence whenever the entrenched political leadership looks to recalibrate the
balance of power. Dana sees the burst of violence as a tried tactic by the
leaders: When they face trouble, they stoke fear of civil war, so each sect's
followers rally around their chief, seeing him as their only protection. For
him, this is how things work, rooted in the "zaim," Arabic for leader, who
provides his community with jobs and services in return for his supporters'
unquestioning loyalty. "We are used to it. We were brought up in a war
environment," Dana said. "We are not accepting war. But I accept my country, my
cedar tree, my family and friends. Where else can I find that?"
But many in the younger generation say they refuse to be pawns of the political
elite. They tried protesting, with nationwide rallies in 2019, but hardly shook
the foundations of the ruling class. Dana's 22-year-old daughter, Vanda, a
university student, sees nothing to gain from the leadership and no point in
staying in Lebanon. In the last three years, Lebanon has lost its status as a
middle-income country, with over 70% of the population sinking into poverty, and
many skilled professionals leaving. Her father's 25-year-old printing business
has gone to ruins and the family money is locked in the bank, inaccessible
because of restrictions imposed during the financial meltdown. Now, her bedroom
windows are riddled with bullets. "We learned and attended the best
universities, only to experience this! Why? Why do I now have to be terrified
when a door slams? Why do I have to run to my father crying when there is any
sound? I don't have to live this life," she said, sobbing.
"My parents say they still have hope. But there is nothing left," the younger
Dana said. "Why should I plan a family here and make them go through this? In 10
or 20 years, the same thing will happen. It will always stay this way."
Some pin hopes on next spring's parliamentary elections as a way out of the
leadership's grip. But Lebanon's politics are mostly sectarian. Parties'
supporters are predominantly from the same sect, and election districts are
gerrymandered to fit sectarian lines. Days after the clashes, many residents of
the area have yet to return home. Apartment buildings freshly pockmarked by
bullets line the streets. Army vehicles and barbed wire separate predominantly
Christian Ain al-Remmaneh and mainly Shiite Muslim Shiyyah -- bringing back the
image of a West Beirut and an East Beirut, a split Lebanese have shunned since
the war.
In Shiyyah, the neighborhood is in mourning. All those killed were supporters of
the Shiite groups Hizbullah and Amal. Posters for a mother of five killed on her
balcony from flying bullets hang between buildings.
"Hizbullah has always been targeted," said Shiyyah resident Ali Haidar, 23.
With the sectarian violence, each sect brings out its stored-up resentments
against the other, imagined or real. Haidar said Hizbullah defended Lebanon
against Israel and terrorism only to be met with hostility from internal foes
like the Lebanese Forces. When Israel was bombing his neighborhood and other
Hizbullah areas in 2006, he said, "life was normal on the other side."On the
other side in Ain al-Remmaneh, electronics store owner Sami Nakad blamed the
Shiites for Thursday's violence. Bullets from Shiyyah landed in his apartment
above the store. He insisted Ain al-Remmaneh residents, defending their area,
carried only sticks. Asked how he explained the deaths on the other side, Nakad
said: "They killed themselves because they want to twist things around."During
Thursday's gunbattles, Nakad, who is in his 70s, hid with his wife and daughter
for hours in a stairwell. His employee, 45-year-old Shadi Nicola, left when the
bullets started flying, seeing no use in the fight. He called the clashes
"theatrics" by leaders losing popularity amid a crushing economic crisis.
"Elections will bring them back. Those people... came through blood. They will
only go with blood," he said.
Elie, a 28-year-old trainer, has slept at friends' homes away from the
neighborhood since the clashes. He has an upcoming interview for a job abroad
and is ready to leave Lebanon. "This (fighting) is not our decision," he said.
The country is slipping into trouble, and the leaders "are not even making a 1%
effort to fix things. They are taking us deeper."
Former Lebanese PM Fouad Siniora: Hizbullah Has Hijacked
Lebanon; Iran's Fuel Supply To Lebanon Is Only For Show – It Is Incapable Of
Supplying Even Its Own People With Fuel
MEMRI/October 21/2021
Asharq TV (Saudi Arabia)
Former Lebanese Prime Minister Fouad Siniora said in an October 15, 2021
interview on Asharq News TV (Saudi Arabia) that Lebanon has been "hijacked" by
Hizbullah and that Iran has been violating Lebanon's sovereignty. He explained
that Hizbullah wants to draw people's attention away from Lebanon's problems and
to make the world think that it is helping Lebanon and that it can breach the
international sanctions against Iran. Siniora also said that this help is only
"pretend" and that this is a way of showing off. He added that Iran has been
trying to provide oil products to Lebanon, even though it is incapable of
meeting its own market's oil demands. He also pointed out that Iran exports oil
to Lebanon without abiding by Lebanese law and without paying the necessary
taxes. Fouad Siniora: "When trucks loaded with Iranian mazut fuel entered
Lebanon, it was the epitome of undermining of the Lebanese state and its
sovereignty. Hizbullah wanted to portray a certain image to the people, and to
draw their attention away from Lebanon's basic problems. What I mean is that the
State of Lebanon has been hijacked by Hizbullah. Hizbullah wanted to portray an
image as if it wanted to help the Lebanese, and that it is showing them grace.
This is the message that Hizbullah wanted to deliver to Lebanon. "In addition,
Hizbullah wanted to deliver a message to the international community that it can
breach the siege laid by the international sanctions on Iran. However, this act
was nothing but Iran showing off in order to accomplish these two goals.
"However, Iran knows and everybody knows that it cannot meet Lebanon's demand
for oil products. Iran is incapable of supplying the oil products demanded by
its own market, so this was only for show. Iran pretended to be helping Lebanon,
but in fact, it breached our border, breached our sovereignty, refused to abide
by the law, and entered as a new trader in Lebanon that wants to sell Iranian
mazut fuel at a price lower than required for such imports. Why? Because it
entered Lebanon without paying customs, and without paying the tax for oil
products."
Lebanese diaspora vote will not be enough to force
change on a corrupt establishment
Makram Rabah/Al Arabiya/October 20/2021
The Lebanese diaspora has always been the pride and joy of this enterprising
nation of around six million residents, with over 14 million members of its
diaspora scattered around the world, most of which are well integrated and have
achieved success. For many in the diaspora, casting an absentee ballot in the
upcoming elections slated for Spring 2022 is their only chance to voice
disapproval of the ruling establishment which has destroyed their homeland.
However, millions of Lebanese across the world might find their chance to drive
through change through voting diluted by the efforts of the Lebanese political
establishment to gerrymander districts in a way to restrict the diaspora’s vote
to only six seats rather than the 128 which they are entitled to.
In 2018, the Lebanese diaspora voted for the first time for the 128 seats each
in their registered districts in Lebanon, with over 1.8 million votes cast.
However, this time around, the diaspora is likely to be much more enthusiastic
in casting a vote, and will not canvas for the traditional political
establishment which robbed them out of their lifesavings after convincing those
abroad to deposit their savings into the Lebanese banking system, funding the
banks and the Lebanese government before mismanagement brought the country, and
those deposits, to inevitable economic ruin.
The third wave of Lebanese immigration currently underway, triggered by the
political and economic crisis, is much more dire than the first wave of the
early 19th century or the second wave of the 1975-1990 civil war, as many of
Lebanon’s professional class – both in the healthcare and educational sectors –
have found themselves displaced from their homes and their jobs after the
collapse of the country’s currency and civilian infrastructure. Having been
forced to immigrate, these new members of the diaspora will join others who want
to do everything it takes to affect change by voting out the ruling
establishment and ushering in a new breed of policymakers, or so they hope. The
ruling establishment, on the other hand, has other plans in mind, as they wish
to implement article 122 of the electoral law which restricts the diaspora vote
to just six seats that will be added to the existing 128, with each representing
one of the world’s six continents, rather than allowing them to vote for their
home district.
Imposing article 122 not only clearly demonstrates the fear the ruling
establishment fosters for these enraged members of the diaspora, but also
underscores their ongoing commitment to ignoring the provisions of the Lebanese
constitution – Article 27 clearly states that “a member of the Chamber [of
deputies] shall represent the whole nation. No restriction or condition may be
imposed upon his mandate by his electors.”While it is true that many of the
members of the diaspora do not pay local taxes, their lifesavings and retirement
funds are stuck in Lebanese banks, a situation caused and prolonged by the
corrupt establishment, and thus they deserve the full right to practice their
constitutional right to vote. The Lebanese model has always been based on the
myth or the illusion that educated men and woman go abroad and their remittances
are enough to keep the Lebanese economy, or what turned out to be a glorified
Ponzi scheme, functioning. Yet, this Lebanese model which welcomes the
diaspora’s funds does not really welcome their voices or votes.
Regardless of how the situation regarding diaspora voting goes, the optimism
that surrounds the forces of change in Lebanon towards the upcoming elections is
both alarming and naïve. Elections are indeed tools of change, but within the
current Lebanese setup any elections conducted by the ruling elite, who are
allies of Iran’s proxy group Hezbollah, will only bring back the current line up
with minimal changes.
The international community’s call for Lebanese to face off with the ruling
elite is both unrealistic and insincere. Western powers who continue to endorse
elections should, at the same time, follow through on sanctions against these
so-called politicians and prevent them from claiming legitimacy through the
ballots.
The efforts of various opposition groups backed by the Lebanese diaspora to
challenge the ruling establishment in the upcoming elections is indeed a
commendable and noble endeavor, but these efforts are unlikely to secure
victory, and fail to ensure that their opponents, who are coincidently running
the election process, do not rig the ballots as they have time and again. As it
stands, elections are unlikely to change much, not simply because the final
results are already determined by ruling establishment, but rather because the
Lebanese, including the diaspora, have not yet reached political puberty, and
have yet to realize that democracy is not a simple matter of casting a vote
every four years, but rather a sustained effort to stand up to tyrants who usurp
power in the name of an imagined tribe or community. This notwithstanding, the
road to change is a long and arduous one. The liberation of Lebanon from Iran’s
malign occupation and their corrupt local allies cannot be achieved remotely nor
through proxies, but will require the Lebanese to continue to denounce
corruption and call for change.
Oyez oyez oyez !
Jean-Marie Kassab/Octobre 20/2021
Aux dirigeants du monde libre.
Écoutez bien, ouvrez vos yeux. Scrutez vos écrans télé. Lisez bien vôtre
courrier et les rapports de vos ambassades.
Regardez , voyez, comment les Libanais ont commencé à résister. Observez les
bouger , crier, hurler contre l'occupant Iranien, contre les usurpateurs, contre
l'intrus qui souille nôtre sol.
Et ce n'est qu'un petit début. Le reste est à suivre. Nous avons été appauvris
mais nôtre âme demeure libre. A genoux? JAMAIS.
Nous ne voulons pas de vos sous. Nous ne sommes pas des mendiants. Que Mikati
aille mendier tout seul. Que Aoun se mette à genoux en adoration. Ils ne nous
représente pas. Nous ne sommes pas eux et ils ne sont pas nous.Nous sommes la
première ligne de défense contre les mollahs . Faites de sorte que ce ne soit
pas la dernière.
Lisez vôtre histoire et la nôtre aussi. Occupés plusieurs fois , nous nous
sommes libérés, par la force et un courage sans égal.
Monsieur Macron vôtre pays et l'Europe ne se sont pas libérés tout seul: le
monde entier y a participé. Mister Biden, des centaines de milliers de vos boys
sont mort pour en finir avec le Nazisme.
Nos "boys and girls" sont prêts à tout pour leur pays. Tenez en compte en
faisant vos calculs et en jouant aux dieux.
Kissinger avait fait la même gaffe en mettant une croix sur le Liban en 75: sa
lecture était superficielle et son jugement faux. Il ne savait pas qu'une
poignée de jeunes étaient d'un avis contraire et enrayèrent ses desseins par la
force de leurs bras et leurs coeurs de lions.
A suivre et attentivement...
Vive la Résistance Libanaise
The boomerang effect
Nicholas Frakes/Now Lebanon/October 20/2021
Following the October 14 shootout in the streets of Beirut, Hezbollah’s
secretary-general took aim at the Christian Lebanese Forces in his speech,
something that analysts say could cause trouble for the Shiite party’s Christian
ally, the Free Patriotic Movement. Analysts say that Hezbollah leader Hassan
Nasrallah’s speech directed at Lebanese Forces Christina party and its leader
Samir Geagea may have affected its ally, the Free Patriotic Movement. Photo:
Anwar Amro, AFP. There was only a nondescript blue background and a collage of
the people who died in the shootout on October 14 displayed behind Hezbollah
leader Hassan Nasrallah when he spoke on Monday night on the occasion of the
Prophet’s Birthday. But the two-hour speech was not about the Prophet. It was
about the Lebanese Forces Christian Party, whom the Party of God and its
political ally the Amal Movement are accusing of having fired at their
protesters and starting the clashes that left 7 dead and 32 wounded.
“The biggest threat for the Christian presence in Lebanon is the Lebanese Forces
party and its head,” Hezbollah’s leader stated. According to the Beirut-based
Hezbollah analyst, Kassem Kassir, this speech by Nasrallah was meant as a
deterrent for any possible fighting that could stem from the high tensions since
Thursday’s events. However, political analyst Bashar al-Halabi says that it was
much more than that: Hezbollah is creating a new enemy for the group to
confront. However, he said, the move backfired, strengthening LF leader Samir
Geagea’s political position and weakening that of the Hezbollahs’ Christian
allies, President Michel Aoun and the Free Patriotic Movement. “Of course, this
means that it’s going to fuel sectarian tensions,” al-Halabi told NOW. “Of
course, it means that it’s going to put its main Christian ally in a bind.
Today, Michel Aoun and [Free Patriotic Movement leader] Gebran Bassil are really
stuck between a rock and a hard place.”
An existential crisis
For the most part of its history, Hezbollah has conjured and strengthened
enemies whether within Lebanon or outside of it in order to ensure the cohesion
of its supporter base and to justify keeping its weapons, analysts say. However,
after the group declared victory over Sunni Islamists in the Syrian war, the
Shiite group no longer had an immediate enemy to fight, Halabi explained. “Since
2005 and up until last week, Hezbollah kind of obliterated March 14,” he said.
“It went on and engaged in a war with Israel in 2006 and this was put to rest,
in a way. Then it went to Syria and it helped quell the revolution and, then, it
recreated itself as this militia that is trying to defend Shiites and other
minorities.”The party gained more power in Lebanon and became a super-political
actor, defining Lebanon’s politics. It helped elect Michel Aoun into the
presidential seat. Meanwhile, it continued to say that Israel was a threat that
they would soon destroy. There were several rounds of unrest on the de facto
border in South Lebanon, but all were extinguished within a few days. Hezbollah
no longer had a physical enemy to pose as an imminent threat to its
constituency. The popular uprising began on October 17, 2019 and the beginning
of the economic crisis only put more pressure on the group to change the
narrative, as many accused it of being part of the corrupt Lebanese political
elite. “When Hezbollah came back from Syria, it literally had no enemy and it
reached a point where it saw itself as the main guarantor and the main party
responsible for the meltdown in Lebanon, in one way or the other,” Halabi
stated. “Its talking points around the banks and Riad Salameh did not stick
enough. At the end of the day, Hezbollah and Hassan Nasrallah came out and
publicly announced that the financial meltdown in Lebanon is a result of the
American embargo. And all of the other talking points about Saad Hariri and
meddling from abroad also did not stick.”
This all changed on October 14 when a shootout broke out in Tayouneh, an area
that marks the border between the Christian Ain el-Remaneh and Shiite southern
suburbs, between Hezbollah and Amal, the Lebanese Army and Lebanese Forces
supporters. When Hezbollah came back from Syria, it literally had no enemy and
it reached a point where it saw itself as the main guarantor and the main party
responsible for the meltdown in Lebanon, in one way or the other. Hezbollah and
Amal put out a joint statement after the shooting began, claiming that the
Christian party ambushed them and were the cause of the fighting. The Lebanese
Forces leader Samir Geagea denied that the party had planned any of the events
on Thursday.
But a new opponent for Hezbollah had emerged.
Where the “100,000 strong” came from
In his speech, Nasrallah claimed that while the Lebanese Forces claim to be the
protectors of Lebanese Christians, Hezbollah is the one that actually puts that
into action, citing how there are Christians living in their territories and
that Hezbollah was the one who defended them against threats like the Islamic
State. “Talking about defending Christians was to confirm that the problem with
the [Lebanese] Forces is not with the Christians, but with a Lebanese party,”
Kassir told NOW. Nasrallah also continued the claims that the Lebanese Forces
were the ones who killed Hezbollah members, accusing the Christian faction of
trying to start a new civil war. “The real program of the Lebanese Forces party
is civil war,” Nasrallah said. “They don’t have a problem with causing events
that lead to bloodshed … even if it will lead to a large-scale military
confrontation of civil war.”Nasrallah also said that his party had 100,000
fighters, a number significantly higher than the 85,000 that was previously
thought. “We have prepared [those fighters] with their diverse weapons to defend
our territory, our oil and gas that is being robbed before the eyes of the
Lebanese, to protect the dignity and sovereignty of our country from any
aggression [and] terrorism and not for internal fighting,” Hezbollah’s leader
stated. “Don’t miscalculate. Be wise and behave. Learn a lesson from all your
wars and all our wars,” Nasrallah later said addressing Geagea.
Hezbollah’s leader had reason to use such numbers in his speech. In 2020, the
Hezbollah affiliated newspaper Al-Akhbar published a story claiming that the
Lebanese Forces’ Samir Geagea had said his party had 15,000 soldiers ready to
confront Hezbollah. Geagea denied these claims and threatened to sue Al-Akhbar
for publishing false information. The warning aims to prevent war and send a
message to the inside and the outside that the party is strong.
According to Kassir, these statements by the secretary-general were meant to be
a warning to anyone, including the Lebanese Forces, that they would face a
bloody fight if they tried to confront Hezbollah in an armed conflict.
“The warning aims to prevent war and send a message to the inside and the
outside that the party is strong,” Kassir said. “The goal may be to say that any
action against the party will be met with force.”But instead of deterring a
perceived new enemy, Hasrallah’s attacks against the LF might have done exactly
the opposite: they enhanced the sectarian division lines, increased tensions and
damaged the decades-long work of its Christian Ally, the Free Patriotic
Movement, of painting a different political picture. “[The attacks by Hezbollah
against the Lebanese Forces] is kind of remobilizing or redrawing the fault
lines in the country in a way that we are basically seeing today,” Halabi said.
“Christians versus Muslims – because [former PM Saad]Hariri has not publicly
supported [Tarek] Bitar per se and Walid Joumblatt is going to toe the line with
Hezbollah and Amal on this one, especially that I don’t think Joumblatt really
ever got over his disdain for [Samir] Geagea. I feel that we are at this spot
right now and things are taking this dimension.”
Loss of status
After Lebanon’s bloody civil war ended in 1990, Aoun tried to change the idea of
what a political faction was in Lebanon from that of a former militia to one of
a party that represents the future of Lebanon and its people.
“Part of the legitimacy that Michel Aoun had built and that Gebran Bassil has
been trying to inherit, in a way, is the fact that he represented the Lebanese
state, he represented the military and he wanted to put an end to Christian
militias or these militia actions that were taking place during the civil war,”
Halabi said. The FPM cultivated this image of the party for two decades
following the end of the war, even during Aoun’s exile in France and the Syrian
occupation of Lebanon. However, the party’s line started to change in 2005 when
the FPM allied itself with Hezbollah. “I think at some point they couldn’t see
beyond the power of Hezbollah, thinking that as long as Hezbollah has muscles,
as long as they can still reign supreme in the country, at least they can still
remain supreme in the Christian community,” Halabi explained. The various crises
that have plagued Lebanon for the last two years have also added to the FPM’s
woes. The faction has constantly played on the fears of the Christian community
in an effort to maintain its dominance in Christian politics all the while
presenting the Lebanese Forces as a “militia-like party.” FPM leader Gebran
Bassil has repeated numerous times, especially after the beginning of the Syrian
war in 2011, that the FPM is the one faction to defend the Christians in Lebanon
and many times also turned to Hezbollah as its ally and defender of the
Christians in the face of Sunni Islamism. According to Halabi, Lebanon’s
Christian community has a “minority complex” where they are “always fearing for
their existence” and “always fearing for the loss of privileges within the
Lebanese state.”
I think at some point they couldn’t see beyond the power of Hezbollah, thinking
that as long as Hezbollah has muscles, as long as they can still reign supreme
in the country, at least they can still remain supreme in the Christian
community. Because of the current instability in Lebanon, and especially because
of Hezbollah’s attacks, the Lebanese Forces now come across as the protector of
the Christians rather than the militia that they had been painted as for
decades. And this means all the efforts Hezbollah’s Christian ally, the FPM, and
its leaders have made over decades have been in vain.
“Given the situation and how precarious it is and how fragile it is, people have
moved way past the idea of statesmen versus militiamen and we’ve seen that with
the complete destruction and meltdown of state institutions. They need a
guarantor. They need a protector,” al-Halabi said.
“[Lebanese Christians] see today that Samir Geagea, backed by the Gulf where
many of their interests are present [and] backed by the international community,
is there and is claiming to protect them in a way. Today, Gebran Bassil is the
one that is sanctioned by the US and Geagea is the one that receives the US
ambassador and talks to her.”Since Nasrallah’s speech on Monday, there have been
an increasing number of pro-Lebanese Forces and pro-Geagea posters being erected
not only in areas inhabited by Lebanese Forces supporters, but also in places
like Tripoli, where Sunnis who support the Future Movement make the majority
population. Coupled with the growing fear of Shiite dominance in Lebanon,
Hezbollah’s attacks against Geagea and his party made them look like a better
option for the Christian community than Aoun and his son-in-law Gebran Bassil
who are allied with Hezbollah.
The growing sectarian tensions have also added to the challenges that
pro-revolution groups are facing when they are looking to win seats in the
upcoming 2022 parliamentary election.
A weak secular opposition
Soon after the October 17 uprising started, new political parties started to
form. However, while originally coasting on the momentum brought by the
months-long protests, the new parties soon became divided. “They’ve really let
down everyone,” Halabi said, referring to the opposition only holding an
anniversary protest on Sunday. “Instead of, for example, trying to find a common
ground, a common denominator between all the opposition groups, for example
launching their electoral campaign on October 17 and inviting the international
media and inviting the regional and local media and staging this one massive
conference where they’re all present and launching their electoral campaign.
That would have sent a way-stronger message to the public and it would have sent
a sign of hope to the public rather than what they did last Sunday,” Those
clashes that happened are not a conspiracy between the different leaders to
enhance their positioning in the country. Of course, they use it and capitalize
on it and they try to cash in on it. But tensions have always been there since
the 1940s up until today. The recent sectarian clashes have added another layer
of problems for the opposition groups. “Those clashes that happened are not a
conspiracy between the different leaders to enhance their positioning in the
country. Of course, they use it and capitalize on it and they try to cash in on
it. But tensions have always been there since the 1940s up until today,” Halabi
said.
“There are real grievances among sects in Lebanon. There’s bloodshed. There’s a
heavily armed sectarian party that’s infringing on the other sects in the
country.”
Nicholas Frakes is a multimedia journalist with @NOW_leb. He tweets
@nicfrakesjourno.
The Latest English LCCC
Miscellaneous Reports And News published on
October 20-21/2021
Blast at US outpost in Syria, no American
injuries — US officials
Reuters/October 20, 2021
WASHINGTON: A US outpost in southern Syria was attacked on Wednesday, but there
were no reports of any American casualties from the blast, US officials told
Reuters. The officials, speaking on the condition of anonymity, said it was too
early to say who was responsible for the attack. One of the officials said it
was believed to have been a drone attack. The garrison, known as Tanf, is
located in a strategic area near Syria’s Tanf border crossing with Iraq and
Jordan. The garrison was first set up when Islamic State fighters controlled
eastern Syria bordering Iraq but since the militants were driven out, it is seen
as part of the larger US strategy to contain Iran’s military reach in the
region. Tanf is the only position with a significant US military presence in
Syria outside the Kurdish-controlled north. While it is not common for attacks
on the US troops at the outpost, Iranian-backed forces have frequently attacked
American troops with drones and rockets in eastern Syria and Iraq
Six Loyalist Fighters Killed in Syria Arms Depot Blast
Agence France Presse
Six members of a pro-government militia were killed Wednesday in an arms depot
blast in the central Syrian province of Hama, a war monitor reported. Seven
other members of the National Defense Forces militia were wounded in the blast,
the cause of which remains largely unclear, the Britain-based Syrian Observatory
for Human Rights said.
HRW Says 'Torture' Awaits Syrian Refugees Returning from Lebanon, Jordan
Agence France Presse/October 202021
Syrian refugees returning to their war-battered country have faced alleged
torture, arbitrary arrests and extrajudicial killings, Human Rights Watch (HRW)
said Wednesday. A report titled "'Our Lives Are Like Death': Syrian Refugee
Returns from Lebanon and Jordan" documented "grave abuse" at the hands of
government forces against 65 returnees and their family members between 2017 and
2021. Of the 65, 21 faced arrests and arbitrary detention, 13 said they were
tortured, and five cases of extrajudicial killings were recorded, the report
said. There were also accounts of 17 enforced disappearances, three kidnappings
and one alleged sexual violence case. "The harrowing accounts of torture,
enforced disappearance and abuse that refugees who went back to Syria endured
should make it patently clear that Syria is not safe for returns," said Nadia
Hardman, a researcher on refugee and migrant rights at HRW. Refugees in Lebanon
and Jordan in particular have faced mounting direct and indirect pressure to
return to Syria, in violation of the principle of nonrefoulement, the rights
organization said. In September, the U.N. announced that the toll of identified
individuals killed in the Syrian conflict had risen to 350,209, though it warned
that the real number could be much higher. New York-based HRW accused Lebanon of
pursuing an "aggressive returns agenda" through measures such as the demolition
of concrete shelters, curfews and forced evictions. The situation of Syrian
refugees in Lebanon has been severely exacerbated by the country's economic
crisis, with 90 percent of them left in extreme poverty, the group said.HRW
warned that the heightening pressures and lack of access to information could
result in refugees feeling they have no option but to return. The U.N. refugee
agency estimates that over 6.6 million Syrians have been forced to seek refuge
in neighboring countries. "No country should be forcing refugees to return to
Syria, so long as the Syrian government commits widespread human rights abuses,"
Hardman said. "A decade on, returning refugees are still at risk of persecution
from the same government they fled."
14 Killed in Rare Damascus Army Bus Bombing
Agence France Presse/October 202021
A bomb attack on an army bus in Damascus killed 14 people Wednesday in the
bloodiest such attack to strike the Syrian capital in four years, the SANA state
news agency reported. There was no immediate claim for the bombing but moments
later shelling by government forces killed eight people in the Idlib region
controlled by groups that have claimed such attack in the past. "A terrorist
bombing using two explosive devices targeted a passing bus" at a key bridge in
the capital, the news agency said, reporting that 14 people had been killed and
at least three wounded. Images released by SANA showed first responders
searching the charred carcass of the bus and what the news agency said was a
bomb squad defusing a third device planted in the same area. A military source
quoted by the state agency said the bomb had been planted on the bus itself and
was detonated as it passed near the Hafez al-Assad bridge, close to the national
museum in the heart of the capital. Damascus had been largely spared such
violence in recent years, especially since troops and allied militia retook the
last significant rebel bastion near the capital in 2018. The attack is the
deadliest in the capital since a bombing claimed by the Islamic State jihadist
group targeted the Justice Palace in March 2017, killing at least 30 people.
Around an hour after the Damascus attack, Syrian regime shelling struck the
war-ravaged town of Ariha, in the northwestern region of Idlib.
Idlib carnage
The Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said the rockets struck a busy area at
the time children were heading to school. Three children were among those
killed, the Britain-based war monitoring group said. An AFP reporter saw at
least five dead bodies as first responders treated the wounded and scenes of
chaos filled the streets of Ariha. "At 8 am (0500 GMT) we woke up to the
bombardment. The children were terrified and were screaming," said Bilal Trissi,
a father of two who lives nearby. "We didn't know what to do or where to go and
we didn't see anything because of all the dust around us," he told AFP. "They
bombed us in our neighborhood and in the market. There are children who died and
people who lost their limbs... We don't know why, what are we guilty of?" The
Damascus bombing will challenge the government's assertion that the decade-old
war is over and stability guaranteed for reconstruction efforts and investment
projects to begin in earnest. The government of President Bashar al-Assad has
been striving to claw itself out of international isolation and had been making
inroads in recent months. The conflict that erupted with the brutal repression
of unarmed protests demanding regime change in 2011 has left around half a
million people dead, according to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights.
Conflict on standby
It also led to the largest conflict-induced displacement since World War II,
with half of Syria's pre-war population of 22 million forced to flee their homes
at one point. Assad's position once held by a thread, with his forces and their
allies controlling barely a fifth of Syrian territory, but Russia's military
intervention in 2015 marked the start of a long and bloody fightback. Also
backed by Iran and its proxy militias, government forces have recaptured nearly
all key cities in the country, with US-backed Kurdish forces still running the
northeast. The Islamic State's once-sprawling caliphate, that straddled swathes
of Iraq and Syria, inexorably shrank to its death, which came in eastern Syria
in early 2019. Since then, the Syrian government's main focus has been the
northwestern region of Idlib, where many of the rebels forced to surrender in
other parts of the country have gathered. The area is dominated by the jihadist
group Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), which includes leaders of Al-Qaeda's former
Syria franchise and over which Turkey has some sway. HTS has not claimed attacks
in Damascus in years however. The remnants of IS in eastern Syria have gone
underground but continue to harass government and allied forces, mostly in
desert areas, in hit-and-run attacks. A truce deal brokered by Turkey and
Russia, the two main foreign players in the Syria conflict, has effectively put
fighting in Idlib on standby. Sporadic flareups have kept the egion on edge,
however, and Wednesday's shelling of Ariha was one of the most serious
violations of the truce deal. Assad insists he remains committed to reconquering
all the territory lost to rebels at the beginning of the war, including the
Idlib region.
In historic move, Egypt installs 98 women on main
judicial body
The Arab Weekly/October 20/2021
Some of the judges said they were happy that the dreams of earlier generations
of women had finally come true.
CAIRO--Nearly 100 women Tuesday became the first female judges to join Egypt’s
State Council, one of the country’s main judicial bodies. The 98 women were
sworn in before the council’s chief judge, Mohammed Hossam el-Din, in a
celebratory event in Cairo. The swearing-in came months after President Abdel
Fattah al-Sisi asked for women to join the State Council and the Public
Prosecution, the two judicial bodies that until recently were exclusively male.
Hossam el-Din welcomed the new judges, saying, “They are an important addition
to the State Council.”Some of the judges said they were happy that the dreams of
earlier generations of women had finally come true. “This is a memorable day. It
is a dream for us and for past generations as well,” said Radwa Helmy, one of
the newly sworn-in justices. “Being a woman in one of the chief judiciary
institutions in Egypt and the Arab world was a dream.”Sisi’s decision in March
was applauded by many women’s rights activists. Egypt’s National Council for
Women said at the time that the move represented a political will to further
empower women. Established in 1946, the State Council is an independent judicial
body that mainly handles administrative disputes, disciplinary cases and
appeals. It also reviews draft laws, decisions and contracts to which the
government or a government-run body is a party. The council had repeatedly
rejected women applicants. In recent years, many women challenged council
decisions, arguing that they were discriminated against.
Social unrest threatens ‘fragile’ recoveries in Middle East
The Arab Weekly/October 20/2021
The MENA region saw real GDP growth shrink by 3.2 percent in 2020 due to weak
oil prices and sweeping lockdowns.
DUBAI--The Middle East and North Africa are on track for recovery, but rising
social unrest and increasing inequities threaten the “fragile” progress of
low-income economies, the IMF said on Tuesday. The MENA region, which includes
Arab countries and Iran, saw real GDP growth shrink by 3.2 percent in 2020 due
to weak oil prices and sweeping lockdowns to halt the spread of the coronavirus.
But with rapid vaccination campaigns, especially in oil-rich Gulf nations, the
International Monetary Fund predicted gross domestic product growth would rise
to 4.1 percent this year, up 0.1 of a percentage point from its last projection
in April. “The region is going through recovery in 2021. Since the beginning of
the year, we see progress in the economic performance,” said Jihad Azour,
director for the Middle East and Central Asia at the IMF, adding recovery is not
the same in all countries.
“It is uncertain and uneven because of the divergence in vaccination, recent
developments, increase in prices … but also the uncertainty about the global
financial conditions and the risk of change in interest rate conditions, (and)
geopolitical developments,” he said. In a report, the IMF said that while the
prospects for oil-exporting economies improved with higher oil prices,
low-income and crisis-hit countries were witnessing “fragile” recoveries. It
warned of “a rise in social unrest” in 2021 that “could pick up further due to
repeated infection waves, dire economic conditions, high unemployment and food
prices”. Algeria, Iraq, Lebanon, Sudan and other countries have witnessed
protests by thousands of angry citizens demanding reforms, better jobs and
services. Unemployment increased in MENA last year by 1.4 percent to reach 11.6
percent, a rise exceeding that seen during the 2008-2009 global financial crisis
and 2014-15 oil price shock, the IMF said.
Widening gaps
The IMF warned of the longer-term risk of an uneven recovery, which could lead
to a “permanent widening of existing wealth, income, and social gaps and
ultimately, weaker growth and less inclusive societies”. About seven million
more people in the region are estimated to have entered extreme poverty during
2020-21 compared with pre-crisis projections, according to the IMF. They are
grappling with rising prices as inflation in the region is projected to increase
to 12.9 percent in 2021 from 10.4 last year, pushed by higher food and energy
prices in some countries, before subsiding to 8.8 percent in 2022. “Inequities
are increasing. The low-skilled, the young, women, and migrant workers have been
affected the most by the pandemic, as have smaller firms, particularly those in
contact-sensitive sectors,” said the report. According to the international
lender, the corporate sector has recovered to pre-pandemic levels, but smaller
firms and those in “contact-sensitive sectors” are lagging behind. “Fifteen to
25 percent of firms may need to be restructured or liquidated,” it added. In
Lebanon, the continuing drop in the value of the currency has dashed hopes that
the government formed last month can stem an economic crisis that the World Bank
brands as one of the worst since the mid-19th century. Nearly 80 percent of
Lebanon’s population lives below the poverty line. Azour, a former Lebanese
finance minister, said the Fund has started technical discussions with Lebanese
authorities to develop “the framework within which the fund can help Lebanon”.
Egypt: 19 killed in truck-microbus collision outside
Cairo
AP/October 20, 2021
CAIRO: A head-on vehicle collision Wednesday left at least 19 people dead and
one other injured just outside the Egyptian capital of Cairo, state-run media
said. The Al-Ahram daily reported the crash took place when a passenger microbus
collided with a truck on a highway that links Cairo’s outskirts on the banks of
the Nile River. Another state-run daily, Akhbar el-Yom said the truck crossed to
the wrong side of the highway and collided head-on with the microbus. Footage
circulating online purported to show bodies lying on the roadside as ambulances
rushed to pick up casualties. Traffic accidents kill thousands every year in
Egypt, which has a poor transportation safety record. Crashes are mostly caused
by speeding, bad roads or poor enforcement of traffic laws. Last month, a bus
overturned on a highway linking Cairo with the city of Suez, killing at least 12
people and injuring 30 others. In April, a bus overturned while trying to pass a
truck on a highway in the southern province of Assiut, leaving at least 21
people dead and three others injured. Egypt’s official statistics agency says
around 10,000 road accidents took place in 2019, the most recent year for which
statistics are available, leaving over 3,480 dead. In 2018, there were 8,480 car
accidents, causing over 3,080 deaths.
UN Security Council condemns Houthi violations in Yemen,
Saudi Arabia
Arab News/October 20, 2021
LONDON: The UN Security Council on Wednesday condemned the threat posed by the
Iran-backed Houthi militia to navigation in the Red Sea and its increasing
attacks on commercial ships off the coast of Yemen. The Security Council called
on the Houthis to reduce their military escalation in Marib, lift its blockade
on nearby Abedia, and for an immediate nationwide cease-fire. The Houthi militia
has stepped up its offensive to take control of the strategic city of Marib in
recent weeks, following a lull in September. The UN Security Council also
condemned the Houthis’ recruitment and exploitation of children in the conflict,
some of whom are subjected to sexual abuse. The top UN body also expressed its
concern about the faltering peace efforts in Yemen and called on all parties to
constructively implement the Riyadh Agreement. It said it welcomes and supports
the Saudi initiative to end the war in Yemen and expressed its full support for
the efforts of UN envoy to Yemen Hans Grundberg, calling on all parties to
cooperate with him without preconditions. The Security Council also condemned
the Houthis’ attempts to target Abha International Airport in Saudi Arabia using
explosive-laden drones. Member countries also implicitly warned the Houthi
militia against using Hodeidah port for military purposes, and renewed its
warning of the risk posed by the lack of maintenance of a floating oil tanker
moored in the Red Sea. They reminded the Houthis of their responsibility for the
Safer tanker. The Security Council stressed its full commitment to the unity,
sovereignty and independence of Yemen, and emphasized the need to respect the
arms embargo on Yemen. It also expressed its support for the return of the
Yemeni government to the interim capital, Aden, while also condemning an
assassination attempt on the governor of Aden and the Yemeni minister of
agriculture on Oct. 10. Saudi Arabia’s ambassador to the UN Abdallah Al-Mouallimi
welcomed the Security Council statement and said it constitutes a strong
condemnation of the Houthi militia, Al Arabiya reported. He also welcomed the
statement on Abha airport and said he hoped that the UN envoy to Yemen has
benefited from the council’s statement.
Putin Orders Week-Long Paid Holiday to Curb Covid
Infections
Agence France Presse/October 202021
Russian President Vladimir Putin on Wednesday ordered a nationwide week-long
paid holiday starting on October 30 to curb Covid infections amid record virus
deaths and again urged Russians to vaccinate themselves. At a televised meeting
with officials, Putin said he supported a government proposal to "declare
non-working days between October 30 and November 7 throughout the country" and
asked Russians to "show responsibility" and get Covid jabs.
Second air strike this week hits capital of Ethiopia's Tigray TV
NNA/October 202021
An air strike hit the capital of Tigray region in northern Ethiopia on Wednesday
morning, regionally controlled television said, reporting the second attack on
the city of Mekelle this week. Tigrai Television, controlled by the region's
Tigrayan People's Liberation Front (TPLF), reported the attack targeted the city
centre. It posted photographs of what appeared to be plumes of billowing smoke,
but it was not immediately possible for Reuters to geolocate the photographs.
The TV station said in a statement on Facebook that the strike was at 10:24 a.m.
(0724 GMT). Ethiopia's government spokesman, Legesse Tulu, did not immediately
answer a phone call requesting comment on the reported strike. It was not
immediately possible to reach the spokesperson for the TPLF. The two sides have
been fighting a war for almost a year that has killed thousands of people and
displaced more than 2 million. A humanitarian source in Mekelle told Reuters the
strike was in an area of the city called 05 Kebelle -- an area near the a cement
factory on the city's outskirts. The strike hit around 10:30 a.m., the source
said. The report of a strike comes two days after two air strikes hit the city.
Rebellious Tigrayan forces accused the Ethiopian government of launching the
strikes. Though a government official initially denied any strikes, state-run
media later reported the air force conducted an attack.--
The Latest The Latest LCCC
English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published
on October 20-21/2021
A Sword Of Damocles Over Free Thought In Egypt (And
Elsewhere)
Alberto M. Fernandez/MEMRI/October 202021 |
Imagine living a public life involving writing and speaking on sensitive issues
and constantly having to look over your shoulder, wondering if you have gone too
far, that you have gored too sacred a cow or somehow offended or caught the
attention of those with the power or will to persecute you. This is the reality
for intellectuals and thinkers in much of the Arab and Muslim world (it is also
a growing reality in the West).
The situation varies from place to place. There is more of this open
intellectual space today, more tolerance, in a country like Saudi Arabia, than
in the past. In places known for the broadness of their free spaces, like
Lebanon, tolerance seems to be shrinking. That has certainly happened in Turkey
under Erdoğan.
Some countries have had issues for free thinkers for decades. It was decades ago
that iconic Egyptian writers like Naguib Mahfouz and Taha Hussein felt the lash
of censors. In 1985, Al-Azhar, Egypt's and the Sunni Muslim world's leading
source of religious authority, gave the green light for the execution in Sudan
of liberal Islamic intellectual Mahmud Muhammad Taha, judging him to be an
apostate and the spilling of his blood licit.[1] Article 98(f) of Egypt's penal
code criminalizes "defamation of religions," a subjective category which has
been used mostly against minority Coptic Christians but also against liberal,
heterodox, or secularist Muslims.
One such case reached its endgame with the trial of Ahmed Abdo Muhammad Maher
appearing before the Emergency State Security Misdemeanors Court on Wednesday,
October 20, 2021, under the Emergency Law.[2] He is charged with insulting the
Islamic religion and promoting extremist ideas with the intention of provoking
sedition. He is facing this trial because he authored and published a book,
"Misleading the Ummah with the Fiqh [jurisprudence] of the Imams," which,
ironically, was published by and is still sold by the governmental publishing
house "Dar El-Maaref."[3] The hearing will continue on November 3, 2021. In the
initial hearing, the defense focused on the absence of contempt of religion by
the defendant and that his criticism was solely of religious jurisprudence that
leads to terrorism.
The 77-year-old Maher would seem to have a background that would have given him
some immunity from persecution. He is a supporter of the government of President
Al-Sisi and a military veteran who rose to the rank of brigadier general before
retiring in 1988. Ironically, his work involved combating religious extremism in
the military. He became a lawyer and a mosque preacher for 22 years (both
positions that require a government seal of approval). He authored 13 books,
appeared on hundreds of government or pro-government television programs, with
hundreds of newspaper articles and YouTube videos.
Taken as a whole, Maher comes across as a sincere man of religion concerned
about extremism and zealous in promoting a vision of Islam that he sees as
tolerant enough to appeal to questioning young people.[4] Although no critic of
the regime per se, he was bold enough to strongly criticize Al-Azhar in 2017
after ISIS attacked two Egyptian Coptic churches, warning that Al-Azhar "had
been taken over by Salafism and Wahhabism" and that its "depraved and criminal
jurisprudence" taught hatred against Christians and Jews.[5] In a television
appearance in 2016, he described traditional Islamic jurisprudence as "idiocy
and insanity."[6] Maher's struggle with Al-Azhar and against what he sees as the
violent mis-interpreters of the Qur'an over the centuries has been going on for
years and he has a long track record of ruffling the feathers of the religious
establishment.[7]
In his commentary, Maher has been trotting a well-worn path. Criticism of Al-Azhar
conservatism is not new and there has been and continues to be a school of
Islamic reformers who revere the Qur'an but see the source of Islam's travails
in the supposedly ossified interpretations of divine revelation codified
centuries ago in the schools of fiqh and in spurious sayings of the prophet.
This is the view of the so-called "Qur'anist" reformers[8] and, of course, also
has Shia echoes in the idea that the door of interpretation of the sacred book
and sayings of the prophet need updating and purging.[9]
Maher's latest travails began in May 2020 when gadfly Islamist lawyer Samir
Sabri contacted Egypt's attorney general and supreme state security prosecutor
accusing Maher of "contempt for Islam."[10] Sabri was able to do this because
Egyptian law allows third parties to initiate such processes and indeed Sabri is
a notorious figure, having brought thousands of cases on moral and religious
grounds against all sorts of figures, including actresses, singers, belly
dancers, puppeteers, and writers. He threatened to sue the Egyptian organizers
of a Jennifer Lopez concert because of the skimpy wardrobe choices made by the
American singer-actress. Sabri's peculiar litigious success and area of
specialization even garnered him a 2018 profile in the New York Times.[11]
In his accusation, Sabri described Maher as a figure "who demonstrates hatred
for Sunnis in particular and Muslims in general." Maher "fights Islam and
questions Muslims in their religion," among his misdeeds was a spat with Al-Azhar
where he questioned the number of radicals produced by that institution and
called upon Al-Azhar to apologize for the violence of the early Islamic
conquests. Among Maher's other misdeeds were questioning fasting in Ramadan or
claiming that the Islamic historical and religious record has been "tainted by
superstitions, myths, intrigues and lies that characterize most of the writings
of historians." For his part, Maher has publicly appealed for support to the
Egyptian President, as a fellow army veteran.[12]
Although Egypt under Al-Sisi very much plays the reformist or enlightened card
before the West, the reality on the ground in Egypt is more complicated. While
the regime is strongly against the Muslim Brotherhood organization, it is
perfectly willing and able to allow "approved" types of religious extremism by
certain groups and moral policing by the likes of Sabri to run their course. In
this way, the national security state can curb or unleash religious sentiment as
it best sees fit in order to accomplish its priority – to maintain control and
solidify its hold on power. It also sends the clear message to those (liberals,
Christians, disgruntled moderates) that "we" (the state) are the only thing
standing between you and an avenging Islamist response.
Of course, the Egyptian authorities are not wrong that Islam has power, many or
most Egyptians are devout and that is a reality that must be recognized. It is
easy for Western diplomacy to criticize and demand greater tolerance but that is
perhaps harder to do these days than in the past. Egyptians who know the West
might note that the West, especially the United States, has its own
proliferating sacred cows even if they are not religious ones (traditional
Christianity being one of the safest, most predictable things mocked by elites
in the West).
Authoritarian Egypt and democratic America are not the same but the culture wars
and cancel culture of the West, with their dogmatic positions on a lengthening
list of issues related to gender and race and politics is not unknown in the
East. Our image as paragons of free thought looks much shakier these days.
America has its own freelance inquisitors searching out gender and pronoun
violations, toppling statues and rewriting history, mercilessly enforcing the
latest trendy conformity, punishing heretics, and purging them from public life
with the zeal and purpose that would make a Samir Sabri proud.
*Alberto M. Fernandez is Vice President of MEMRI.
[1] See MEMRI Daily Brief No. 47, Remembering A Radical Reformer: The Legacy Of
Mahmud Muhammad Taha, June 11, 2015.
[2] Anahwa.com/261691, October 19, 2021.
[3] Youtube.com/watch?v=wPJAwP1dIhE, September 7, 2021.
[4] See MEMRI TV clip no. 8473 Egyptian Researcher Ahmad Abdou Maher: Young
People Are Becoming Atheists Because They Are Faced With Religious Texts That
Include Unscientific 'Facts', November 16, 2020.
[5] See MEMRI TV clip no. 5999, Following Church Bombings, Egyptian Researcher
Ahmad Abdou Maher Slams Al-Azhar Teachings: Vile Deformed Jurisprudence, April
12, 2017.
[6] See MEMRI TV clip no. 5669, Egyptian Researcher Ahmad Abdou Maher Criticizes
Ancient Islamic Jurisprudence: "Idiocy and Insanity", August 26, 2016.
[7]
Raseef22.net/article/169485-%D8%B5%D8%AD%D9%8A%D8%AD-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A8%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%8A-%D8%A3%D9%85%D8%
A7%D9%85-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B6%D8%A7%D8%A1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%B5%D8%B1%D9%8A-%D8%A3%D8%AD%D9%85%D8%AF,
October 31, 2018.
[8] Arabicpost.net/opinions/2017/11/12/%d8%b1%d8%ad%d9%84%d8%aa%d9%8a-%d9%85%d8%b9-%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%82%d8%b1%d8%a2%d9%86%d9%8a%d9%8a%d9%86,
December 11, 2017.
[9] Ahmedabdomaher.com/archives/214, accessed October 20, 2021.
[10] Alwafd.news/%D8%A3%D8%AE%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%B1/2962350--, May 9, 2020
[11] Nytimes.com/2018/01/12/world/middleeast/cairo-lawyer-lawsuit.html, January
12, 2018.
[12] Youtube.com/watch?v=CwRQYnQMM-4, October 17, 2021.
Why Turkey should swap military strikes for water
diplomacy
Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib/Arab News/October 20, 2021
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has voiced his anger over the killing of
two Turkish policemen by Kurdish forces in Syria, describing the attack as “the
final straw” and warning that Ankara will take decisive action to eliminate what
it views as a terrorist threat against its citizens.
However, can Turkey be sure another military campaign will serve its purposes,
especially in the lead-up to what appears to be a tightly contested election? A
military strike can have unintended consequences and might not be the best
choice, while any entanglement is unlikely to foster the sense of stability
necessary to attract investors to the country. Since the Turkish leader has been
focusing on attracting investment, a deal might be a better alternative.
What can Turkey offer to turn its adversaries into partners? Water.
Problems with water supply have grown since 1975, when Turkey’s dam construction
program cut the flow of water to Iraq by 80 percent and to Syria by 40 percent.
Studies have shown that the Tigris and Euphrates basin, which covers Turkey,
Syria, Iraq and western Iran, is losing water faster than any other area in the
world, except northern India.
To add to that, Syrian President Bashar Assad’s policies have focused on the
urban sector at the expense of rural areas. This problem has been aggravated by
the conflict. As a result, basic commodities have become more costly and the
price of bread has soared. Water scarcity in Syria’s northeast, a major
agricultural area, has contributed to instability. A RAND Corporation study
found that a secure water supply is essential to prevent the re-emergence of
Daesh.
Water can be a major factor in encouraging people to return to their
communities. During the conflict, water has been used as a weapon by the warring
parties, while lack of access to secure supplies has been cited as a leading
reason behind the rise in refugee numbers as people abandon their communities.
Daesh cut off water supplies to northern Iraq in 2015.
In Iraq, poor governance has led to the targeting of irrigation department
officials and clashes between rural clans. Water supplies in the country are
also under threat because of the growing population. The current water
management infrastructure dates back to the 1970s and is less efficient than
modern systems. More serious still, the city of Mosul faces the threat of a dam
collapse, a disaster that would affect 2 million people and kill hundreds of
thousands. Turkey is an upstream power and, hence, has a valuable asset that can
be used to make people’s lives easy or difficult.
Turkey is an upstream power and, hence, has a valuable asset that can be used to
make people’s lives easy or difficult. The Euphrates and Tigris rivers flow from
the mountains of eastern Turkey into Iraq and Syria. Turkey can use water to
forge better relations with Baghdad and entice the Kurdish factions in the
northeast of Syria into an arrangement that guarantees its security. Ankara
would be better off entering into an arrangement with the Kurds in Syria under
US mediation rather than looking on as Assad agrees to a deal with the Kurds via
Russian efforts.
To build trust, a commission made up of representatives from Turkey, Syria’s
northeast and Iraq, with a rotating presidency, could be created to manage water
across the three countries and explore economically beneficial projects. A
similar commission has been created for the Mekong River to manage water among
Laos, Cambodia and Vietnam. Turkey could also help to upgrade aging
infrastructure in locations such in Mosul. This could be done with US and
European assistance. Public-private partnerships could be created to carry out
such projects, with Turkish companies joining forces with local governments.
These deals would strengthen Erdogan’s efforts to attract investment to Turkey
and bring contracts to Turkish companies.
This approach would also lead to an improvement in Turkey’s relations with the
Iraqi government, which have been soured by Turkish incursions into Iraq to
pursue Kurdish militants hiding in the mountains. Any deal over water could
require the Iraqi government to target the PKK and the pro-Iran militias
protecting it. This will be less costly to Turkey than an incursion in terms of
finances and the lives of Turkish soldiers, as well as diplomatic capital with
Iraq and other Arab countries. The Arab League has condemned Turkey for carrying
out military operations in Iraq.
As Turkey finds itself with far too many enemies in its neighborhood, water
could be an ideal diplomatic tool, improving Ankara’s standing and adding to the
number of friends it has in the region.
• Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib is a specialist in US-Arab relations with a focus on
lobbying. She is co-founder of the Research Center for Cooperation and Peace
Building, a Lebanese NGO focused on Track II. She is also an affiliate scholar
with the Issam Fares Institute for Public Policy and International Affairs at
the American University of Beirut.
Biden’s Syria policy leaves US in no-win situation
Ray Hanania/Arab News/October 20, 2021
Syria is a mess, but it is not a mess for everyone. Russia is building a strong
base through its alliance with President Bashar Assad. Turkey is establishing a
justification for a long-term presence as it battles to prevent the
establishment of a Kurdish state along its border. Iran also has a strong
presence in Syria. And Hezbollah has an armed presence in the country, expanding
its base of militant violence. Even Daesh has been able to use Syria as a base
as the decade-long civil war has gone through various political mutations,
allowing it to strike targets in Syria and in neighboring Iraq. And, in recent
months, China has engaged in the Syrian conflict by joining Russia in demanding
that the US “abide by international laws.”
The only nation not engaged in Syria in a meaningful way is the US, which is
slowly but steadily finding out that the country is being used as an instrument
of international political pressure.
If this were a teenager’s video game, one might conclude that the US was being
squeezed into a corner, with diminished influence in the Levant and the wider
Middle East. But Syria is not a video game, although the number of deaths there
and the refugee surges are more like video game statistics. Certainly, human
life does not seem to have much value in the Syria conflict. Weeks after taking
office, US President Joe Biden in February found himself forced to act
militarily against Syria-based, Iran-backed militias that his administration
blamed for attacks on American troops in neighboring Iraq. He ordered US
military forces to target a small building complex, destroying it with several
500-pound bombs. In June, Pentagon spokesman John Kirby said America would
continue to strike any targets to “protect US personnel.”The US began
withdrawing troops from Syria in the fall of 2019 under a directive from former
President Donald Trump. That withdrawal has been slow and erratic, but now only
about 900, including a number of Green Berets, remain and they will stay in the
country to advise the Syrian Democratic Forces in their fight against Daesh. No
US troops have accompanied rebel forces on military operations for more than a
year. This troop level is the same as was first introduced to Syria and the
agenda, which is to confront Daesh, has not changed since 2014.
Russia sees Syria as a key foundation of its long-term strategy to wedge itself
into the Middle East, a region that had been under US dominance for many decades
— since the Arab world broke its alliances with the old Soviet Union following
the 1973 Arab-Israeli War.
Restricting its presence to a very narrow focus — fighting Daesh — poses many
risks for the US. Several times, Syrian military actions have impacted American
forces. Worse are the pressures on the international community caused by the
refugee crisis and the migration of displaced civilians inside Syria, which has
created a humanitarian crisis.
The bottom line is that all of the other countries involved in Syria are staking
out and re-enforcing their positions, while the American strategy seems to be
one of coasting in neutral, gearing up only for encounters with Daesh. This
makes no real sense, considering that the US in August withdrew from
Afghanistan, surrendering control of the country to its once sworn enemy, the
Taliban. A weak American posture in Syria also invites other countries to take
more military chances.
Biden really only has two choices: He can increase America’s military presence
in an attempt to keep all of the other countries’ interests at bay, or he can
order a complete withdrawal and regroup in Israel, Jordan and in the Gulf. What
he cannot afford to do is maintain a negligible presence that can do little
except exercise punitive actions against Daesh and the Iran-backed militias.
That is a no-win strategy. And it could backfire and result in a situation where
American forces find themselves suffering a terrible loss, which would further
erode its perception as the world’s most powerful nation. Restricting its
presence to a very narrow focus — fighting Daesh — poses many risks for America.
American prestige is at stake and the country cannot afford to allow anything,
either intentional or accidental, to undermine its image as the top predator in
the food chain. All nations around the world are watching how America acts in
Syria, and any signs of weakness could influence them to become more demanding
or less accommodating in their dealings with Washington.If the US loses its
influence in Syria, especially by failing to take decisive, strong action, it
could eventually lose its influence everywhere.
Clearly, the anti-Assad rebels that America backs are losing ground. This makes
the US look weak — an image it cannot afford to portray.
Ray Hanania is an award-winning former Chicago City Hall political reporter and
columnist. He can be reached on his personal website at www.Hanania.com.
Twitter: @RayHanania