English LCCC Newsbulletin For 
Lebanese, Lebanese Related, Global News & Editorials
For December 12/2020
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
#elias_bejjani_news
The Bulletin's Link on the 
lccc Site
http://eliasbejjaninews.com/aaaanewsfor2021/english.december12.21.htm
News 
Bulletin Achieves Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since 2006
Bible Quotations For today
I pray therefore that you 
may not lose heart over my sufferings for you; they are your glory
Letter to the Ephesians 03/01-13/:”This is the reason that I Paul am a prisoner 
for Christ Jesus for the sake of you Gentiles for surely you have already heard 
of the commission of God’s grace that was given to me for you, and how the 
mystery was made known to me by revelation, as I wrote above in a few words, a 
reading of which will enable you to perceive my understanding of the mystery of 
Christ. In former generations this mystery was not made known to humankind, as 
it has now been revealed to his holy apostles and prophets by the Spirit: that 
is, the Gentiles have become fellow-heirs, members of the same body, and sharers 
in the promise in Christ Jesus through the gospel. Of this gospel I have become 
a servant according to the gift of God’s grace that was given to me by the 
working of his power. Although I am the very least of all the saints, this grace 
was given to me to bring to the Gentiles the news of the boundless riches of 
Christ, and to make everyone see what is the plan of the mystery hidden for ages 
in God who created all things; so that through the church the wisdom of God in 
its rich variety might now be made known to the rulers and authorities in the 
heavenly places. This was in accordance with the eternal purpose that he has 
carried out in Christ Jesus our Lord, in whom we have access to God in boldness 
and confidence through faith in him. I pray therefore that you may not lose 
heart over my sufferings for you; they are your glory.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News & Editorials 
published on December 11-12/2021
Miqati Lauds Gulf's 'Confirmation of Support' for Lebanon
Authorities Seize Captagon Shipments in Lebanon, Syria
UNRWA Head Visits Lebanon amid Deteriorating Living Conditions of Palestine 
Refugees
Beirut blast investigator demands arrest of former minister
Blast at south Lebanon Palestinian camp tied to Hamas weapons depot
Lebanon: Hamas Arms Depot Blast at Palestinian Camp Leaves Casualties
Titles For The Latest English LCCC 
Miscellaneous Reports And News published on 
December 11-12/2021
US leads new crunch talks on Iranian nuclear deal
Tehran is serious in nuclear talks: Iran’s President Raisi
Blinken Meets with European Counterparts to Discuss Iran Deal
Raisi Says Iran Serious in Nuclear Talks with World Powers
Iran warns of ‘heavy price’ after report of US-Israeli military drill plans
US, Iran Differ over Tehran’s Frozen Assets
Man wrongly detained over Khashoggi speaks of treatment by French security 
forces
Turkey's Erdogan says social media a ‘threat to democracy’
Turkey Refuses to Take in More Syrian Refugees
ExxonMobil, Qatar sign Cyprus gas deal despite Turkish threats
Palestinians vote in local elections as anger simmers in West Bank
Egypt to Host International Conference on Combating Corruption
Palestinians in West Bank Villages Hold Municipal Polls
Israeli Newspaper Discloses Unknown Massacres Since Palestinian Nakba
EU to Impose Sanctions on Russian Military Contractor Wagner Group, Official 
Says
UK Says West Will Counter 'Aggressors' as G7 Ministers, Allies Meet
China Brands U.S. Democracy 'Weapon of Mass Destruction'
Canada/Minister Joly speaks with EU High Representative/Vice President Josep 
Borrell
Titles For The Latest The Latest LCCC 
English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on 
December 11-12/2021
Erdogan and Hamas: A natural partnership/Jonathan Spyer/The Jerusalem 
Post/December 11/2021
Vienna… Deadlock and Widening Opportunity/Mustafa Fahs/Asharq Al-Awsat/December, 
11/2021 
The Iran Nuclear Deal: Biden Administration's Fatal Mistakes/Majid Rafizadeh/Asharq 
Al-Awsat/December, 11/2021 
Belligerence in Vienna could return to haunt Iran/Hussain Abdul-Hussain/The Arab 
Weekly/December 11/2021
The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & 
Lebanese Related News & Editorials published 
on December 11-12/2021
Miqati Lauds Gulf's 'Confirmation of Support' for 
Lebanon
Naharnet/December 11/2021
Prime Minister Najib Miqati announced Saturday in a tweet that he lauds the 
latest Gulf tour of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman.
"I also laud the continuous efforts to strengthen the ties of cooperation and 
coordination among the Gulf Cooperation Council states, and all Arab states, 
including Lebanon," Miqati added. "I laud the firm confirmation during the tour 
of the support for Lebanon and the Lebanese," the premier went on to say, noting 
that Lebanon will be "a launchpad for the welfare of the Arab countries."
Authorities Seize Captagon Shipments in Lebanon, Syria
Agence France Presse/December 11/2021
Security forces in Lebanon and Syria said Saturday that they had seized two 
separate shipments of the banned stimulant captagon, the latest in a string of 
similar busts. Lebanon's Internal Security Forces said it "thwarted an attempt 
to smuggle four million captagon pills" hidden in a coffee shipment destined for 
Saudi Arabia via Jordan. The pills were confiscated following raids this week on 
a storage facility in Bir Hassan, a neighborhood near Beirut's southern suburbs, 
the ISF said on Twitter. It said it arrested two men behind the operation, 
including one who was trying to flee the country through Beirut's airport. A 
video it posted online showed a man ripping open a bag of coffee stuffed with 
narcotic pills. In a separate operation, Syrian authorities seized "hundreds of 
thousands" of captagon pills in the southern province of Daraa, the official 
SANA news agency said, citing a security source. "The drugs were to be smuggled 
abroad via the Jordan border," SANA said, without specifying the intended 
destination. It said some arrests were made amid ongoing attempts to clamp down 
on remaining members of the smuggling network. Captagon was one of the brand 
names for the amphetamine-type stimulant fenethylline and continues to be 
manufactured, mostly in Lebanon and Syria, for illegal recreational use, mostly 
in Saudi Arabia.According to an EU-funded report by the Center for Operational 
Analysis and Research, "captagon exports from Syria reached a market value of at 
least $3.46 billion" in 2020. In July last year, Italy seized a record 14-ton 
haul of the drug -- or 84 million pills -- that had arrived from Syria.
UNRWA Head Visits Lebanon amid Deteriorating Living Conditions of Palestine 
Refugees
Naharnet/December 11/2021 
The Commissioner-General of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for 
Palestine refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), Phillippe Lazzarini, just ended a 
three-day visit in Lebanon where he met with UNRWA staff and refugees in Bourj 
al-Barajneh camp near Beirut. Lazzarini’s visit comes amid an unprecedented 
economic and financial crisis that is plunging the country deep into poverty. 
"These events have a profound impact on Palestine refugees who are among the 
poorest segment of the society," UNRWA said in a statement. "For decades they 
have faced restrictions on access to the labor market and property ownership," 
it added. “Refugees I met are utterly desperate and struggle to cover their 
basic needs,” said Lazzarini. “I met young graduates whose only hope for a 
better future is to emigrate. They know the prices of each migration route. I 
met parents who have nightmares about how they will afford to buy milk and 
diapers for their children the next day. The social fabric within the community 
is imploding, divorces are on the rise, as is gender-based violence. UNRWA staff 
are also encountering anger and resentment,” he added. "Today, I am raising the 
alarm and calling on the international community to ensure adequate support for 
UNRWA to ensure that those refugees continue receiving much needed assistance 
and have a dignified life,” he continued. At the UNRWA Yarmouk School in the 
camp, Lazzarini met with representatives of the school parliament, the school 
parents’ association and school staff. All talked about the difficult conditions 
and challenges children face to continue their education. Many are dropping out 
of schools as they cannot afford transportation or have to help their families 
make a living. In January, UNRWA will launch an emergency appeal for Lebanon to 
alleviate the humanitarian impact of the situation in Lebanon on Palestine 
refugees. Cash assistance will remain a priority. Lazzarini’s visit also 
included meetings with Prime Minister Najib Miqati, the Minister of Foreign 
Affairs, the Director of General Security, the Chair of the Lebanese Palestinian 
Dialogue Committee, the Palestinian Ambassador and representatives of 
Palestinian factions. He also met with NGOs working in the refugee camps. All 
shared the concern about the deteriorating situation in the camps and committed 
to support the Agency to sustain all services and alleviate the human suffering 
in the camps.
Beirut blast investigator demands arrest of former minister
The Arab Weekly/December 11/2021
The director-general of the interior security forces, Emad Osman, had refused an 
earlier request for Khalil’s arrest.
The Lebanese judge charged with investigating the Beirut port blast demanded 
Friday the immediate arrest of a former minister who has refused to appear 
before court, a judicial source said. The investigation into the massive 
explosion at Beirut port on August 4, 2020, resumed Wednesday after a two-month 
hiatus caused by multiple lawsuits seen as seeking to hamper the work of judge 
Tarek Bitar. The judiciary rejected the lawsuits against the judge — filed 
primarily by senior political figures who have been targeted in his 
investigation — allowing Bitar to resume his work. His first task was to submit 
to the top prosecutor an arrest warrant against former finance minister Ali 
Hassan Khalil, the judicial source said on condition of anonymity. Bitar 
demanded the “immediate” arrest of Khalil, who is considered the right-hand man 
of parliament speaker Nabih Berri who heads the Shia Amal movement. The 
director-general of the interior security forces, Emad Osman, had refused an 
earlier request for the arrest of Khalil citing an article of the constitution. 
“The refusal of a security apparatus to implement an arrest warrant constitutes 
a dangerous precedent that goes against the decisions of the judicial 
authority,” the source said. In a country where political leaders determine 
judicial appointments, including in top courts, there is little room for the 
judiciary to work against Lebanon’s ruling elite. Bitar’s determination to 
question senior officials over the blast has earned him the respect of the 
victims’ families — and the enmity of the political elite, particularly the 
Shiite alliance of Hezbollah and Amal. Deadly clashes broke out in October after 
the two Shiite parties called for his removal as head of the probe. The two 
parties have since prevented the Lebanese cabinet from meeting in a bid to force 
Bitar’s removal. The 2020 blast killed 215 people and injured more than 6,500 
others, destroying much of the Beirut port and devastating entire neighbourhoods 
of the capital. The explosion was caused by a huge stockpile of ammonium nitrate 
that had been improperly stored at the port for years, prompting accusations of 
gross negligence on the part of the authorities.
Blast at south Lebanon Palestinian camp tied to Hamas 
weapons depot
The Arab Weekly/December 11/2021
The NNA reported that the blast emanated from a Hamas weapons depot in the Burj 
al-Shemali camp and a judge had ordered security forces to launch an 
investigation. A large explosion rocked a Palestinian camp in the southern 
Lebanese port city of Tyre on Friday night, injuring about a dozen people, 
according to rescue workers on scene and a Palestinian source inside the camp. 
The state-run National News Agency (NNA) reported an unspecified number of 
deaths, but local media and civil defence workers on the scene said there had 
been no fatalities. A security source also said fatalities had not been 
recorded. The NNA reported that the blast emanated from a Hamas weapons depot in 
the Burj al-Shemali camp and a judge had ordered security forces to launch an 
investigation. A number of armed Palestinian factions, including Hamas and the 
Fatah Movement, hold effective control over roughly a dozen Palestinian camps in 
the country, which Lebanese authorities by custom do not enter. Shehab News 
Agency, seen as close to Hamas, quoted a Palestinian source as saying the 
explosion was caused by the ignition of oxygen canisters stored for use in 
fighting the COVID-19 pandemic. The security source said the fire had since been 
brought under control. Hamas has not officially commented. The area surrounding 
the blast had been evacuated and rescue crews had deployed, the Palestinian 
source said. Videos from the scene shared by local media show a number of small 
bright red flashes above the southern city, followed by a large explosion and 
the sound of glass breaking.
Lebanon: Hamas Arms Depot Blast at Palestinian Camp Leaves 
Casualties
Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
Arms stored for the Palestinian Hamas group exploded in a refugee camp in the 
southern Lebanese port city of Tyre on Friday night, killing and wounding a 
number of people, the state-run National News Agency said. NNA reported an 
unspecified number of deaths at the Burj al-Shemali camp, but local media and 
civil defense workers on scene said there had been no fatalities. A security 
source also said fatalities had not been recorded. The news agency said the 
blast emanated from a Hamas weapons depot and a judge had ordered security 
forces to launch an investigation. Lebanon hosts tens of thousands of 
Palestinian refugees, most of whom live in the country's 12 camps. Unofficially, 
they are said to number as many as half a million. A number of armed Palestinian 
factions, including Hamas and the Fatah Movement, hold effective control over 
the camps, which Lebanese authorities by custom do not enter. Shehab News 
Agency, seen as close to Hamas, quoted a Palestinian source as saying the 
explosion was caused by the ignition of oxygen canisters stored for use in 
fighting the COVID-19 pandemic. The security source said the fire had since been 
brought under control. The area surrounding the blast had been evacuated and 
rescue crews had deployed, the Palestinian source said. Videos from the scene 
shared by local media show a number of small bright red flashes above the 
southern city, followed by a large explosion and the sound of glass breaking.
The Latest English LCCC 
Miscellaneous Reports And News published on 
December 11-12/2021
US leads new crunch talks on Iranian nuclear 
deal
Reuters/December 11/2021
JEDDAH: US Secretary of State Antony Blinken led crunch talks with European 
foreign ministers on Saturday aimed at charting a way forward in negotiations 
with Iran over its nuclear program. The new talks came amid a three-day meeting 
of G7 foreign ministers in the northern English city of Liverpool that is 
expected to result in a joint call for Tehran to curb its nuclear ambitions and 
grasp the opportunity of the continuing negotiations in Vienna.
World powers and Iran resumed those negotiations last week, with the aim of 
reviving the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action — the original 2015 deal to 
restrict Iran’s nuclear program in return for the lifting of economic sanctions. 
That deal collapsed in 2018 when the US pulled out, and Iran began enriching 
uranium beyond the limits imposed by the JCPOA. A European source said 
negotiators were working from texts discussed five months ago, while Iranian 
officials said they were sticking to a tough stance from last week. The indirect 
US-Iranian talks, in which diplomats from France, Britain, Germany, Russia and 
China shuttle between them because Tehran refuses direct contact with 
Washington, aim to get both sides to resume full compliance with the accord. 
“Secretary Blinken had a productive meeting with his counterparts from Germany, 
France and the UK in Liverpool. They discussed the JCPOA talks and our way 
forward,” the State Department said on Saturday. Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi 
insisted on Saturday that Tehran wanted to revive the deal in the negotiations 
in the Austrian capital. “The fact that we presented the text of Iran’s proposal 
to the negotiating parties shows that we are serious in the talks, and if the 
other side is also serious about the removal of sanctions, we will achieve a 
good agreement. We are definitely after a good agreement,” Raisi said. Iran’s 
top negotiator, Ali Bagheri Kani, said Tehran was standing firm on the position 
it laid out last week, when the talks broke off. “Drafts we proposed last week 
are being discussed now in meetings with other parties,” he said. European and 
US officials accused Iran of making new demands and of reneging on compromises 
worked out earlier this year. Iran has also responded to reports that US and 
Israeli defense chiefs were discussing military exercises to prepare for a 
worst-case scenario to destroy Iran’s nuclear facilities if diplomacy fails and 
if their nations’ leaders requested it. “Providing conditions for military 
commanders to test Iranian missiles with real targets will cost the aggressors a 
heavy price,” a senior Iranian military official warned.
Tehran is serious in nuclear talks: Iran’s President 
Raisi
Reuters/11 December ,2021
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi said on Saturday that Tehran was serious in its 
nuclear talks with world powers in Vienna, the official IRNA news agency 
reported. “We are serious in the negotiations and if the other side is also 
serious about the removal of the sanctions, we will achieve a good agreement. We 
are definitely after a good agreement,” IRNA quoted Raisi as saying
Blinken Meets with European Counterparts to Discuss Iran 
Deal
Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Friday held a "productive" meeting with 
counterparts from Britain, Germany and France, including a discussion of the 
Iran nuclear deal, a State Department spokesperson said on Saturday.
"Secretary Blinken had a productive meeting with his E3 counterparts from 
Germany, France, and the UK in Liverpool yesterday. They discussed the JCPOA 
(Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action) talks and our way forward,” the 
spokesperson said. The meeting took place in the northern English city of 
Liverpool on the eve of a G7 foreign ministers' meeting which is expected to 
result in a joint call for Iran to moderate its nuclear program and grasp the 
opportunity of talks in Vienna. Talks between Iran and world powers over 
reviving the 2015 nuclear deal resumed in Vienna on Thursday. Under the original 
deal that then-US President Donald Trump abandoned in 2018, Iran limited its 
nuclear program in return for relief from US, European Union and UN sanctions. A 
year after Trump's reimposition of sanctions on Iran, Tehran began to gradually 
violate nuclear limits of the agreement. Iran wants all sanctions to be lifted. 
A European source, speaking on condition of anonymity, suggested on Friday that 
Iran had agreed to continue the Vienna talks from where they left off in June. 
Iranian officials denied this.
Raisi Says Iran Serious in Nuclear Talks with World Powers
Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi said on Saturday that Tehran was serious in its 
nuclear talks with world powers in Vienna, the official IRNA news agency 
reported. Indirect US-Iranian talks to revive a 2015 Iran nuclear deal resumed 
on Thursday in the Austrian capital. Diplomats from France, Britain, Germany, 
Russia and China shuttle between the two sides because Tehran refuses direct 
contact with Washington. A European source, speaking on condition of anonymity, 
suggested on Friday that Iran had agreed to continue talks from where they left 
off in June. Iranian officials denied this, Reuters reported.
Under the original deal that then-US President Donald Trump abandoned in 2018, 
Iran limited its nuclear program in return for relief from US, European Union 
and UN sanctions. "The fact that we presented the text of Iran's proposal to the 
negotiating parties shows that we are serious in the talks, and if the other 
side is also serious about the removal of sanctions, we will achieve a good 
agreement. We are definitely after a good agreement," IRNA quoted Raisi as 
saying. A year after Trump's reimposition of sanctions on Iran, Tehran began to 
gradually violate nuclear limits of the agreement. Iran wants all sanctions to 
be lifted. Iran's top negotiator, Ali Bagheri Kani, told Reuters on Friday that 
Tehran was standing firm on the position it laid out last week, when the talks 
broke off. European and US officials accused Iran of making new demands and of 
reneging on compromises worked out earlier this year. Asked whether new draft 
proposals that Iran had put forward last week were being discussed, Bagheri Kani 
said: "Yes, the drafts we proposed last week are being discussed now in meetings 
with other parties." A senior European Union official said on Friday the talks 
were moving forward and that various key matters were still open for a deal on a 
final text.
Iran warns of ‘heavy price’ after report of US-Israeli 
military drill plans
Reuters/11 December ,2021
A top Iranian military official warned on Saturday of a “heavy price” for 
aggressors, state media said, after a report of US and Israeli plans for 
possible military drills to prepare for strikes against Iran’s nuclear sites if 
diplomacy fails. “Providing conditions for military commanders to test Iranian 
missiles with real targets will cost the aggressors a heavy price,” Nournews, 
affiliated with Iran’s top security body, said on Twitter, citing an unnamed 
military official. A senior US official told Reuters on Thursday that US and 
Israeli defense chiefs were expected to discuss possible military exercises that 
would prepare for a worst-case scenario to destroy Iran’s nuclear facilities 
should diplomacy fail and if their nations’ leaders request it.
US, Iran Differ over Tehran’s Frozen Assets
London - Adil al-Salmi/Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
Tehran accused the US administration of waging a “psychological war,” a day 
after Washington denied releasing $3.5 billion of Iran’s frozen funds abroad. 
“The United States has not released any money to Iran. Any such report to the 
contrary is incorrect,” State Department spokesman Ned Price affirmed.
“We also understand that our partners have not transferred frozen funds to Iran, 
not even South Korea,” he stressed. “And of course, the US has not authorized or 
approved any such frozen transfers to Iran. All of our current sanctions remain 
in effect. They will remain in effect until and unless we’re able to reach a 
diplomatic agreement,” in Vienna. Price’s remarks, which coincide with a new 
round of talks in the Austrian capital, are part of a “psychological war” 
against Iran, state TV quoted an informed source as saying. These remarks “will 
not affect what has actually happened,” the source added. One of the countries 
will soon release the frozen assets under the sanctions imposed by Donald 
Trump’s administration on Iranian oil sales, deputy Foreign Minister for 
Economic Diplomacy Mehdi Safari said on Thursday. He added that $3.5 billion of 
Iranian assets have been released, noting that the government had requested 
other countries to release larger numbers “Fruitful negotiations were held in 
this regard,” Safari confirmed, while declining to reveal the amount discussed. 
In mid-November, the Central Bank said one billion dollars from the released 
funds would be allotted for the import of “essential goods.”Meanwhile, the 
Iranian rial currency dipped last week but remained above historic lows after 
news that talks with world powers to revive the 2015 Iran nuclear accord may 
have run into difficulties. The US dollar was selling for as much as 302,200 
rials on the unofficial market on Saturday, up from 294,000 on Friday. In 
October 2020, the rial hit a record low of about 320,000 to a dollar as a drop 
in oil prices deepened the economic crisis in the country already reeling under 
US sanctions and the highest COVID-19 death toll in the Middle East.
Man wrongly detained over Khashoggi speaks of treatment 
by French security forces
Al Arabiya English/11 December ,2021
A man wrongly imprisoned in connection to the murder of journalist Jamal 
Khashoggi has described his treatment at the hands of French security forces. 
Saudi citizen Khaled al-Otaibi spoke about the “filthy” conditions he was held 
in after being arrested at Paris’ Charles de Gaulle airport on Tuesday. “They 
detained me in a filthy room of which the walls were stained with blood, where I 
could neither take rest nor sleep,” al-Otaibi told Saudi newspaper Okaz. Soon 
after al-Otaibi’s arrest, the Saudi embassy issued a statement saying that it 
was a case of mistaken identity. Al-Otaibi shares the name of a man listed in a 
UN-commissioned report as having been involved in Khashoggi’s killing. He said 
that after he was detained, he asked authorities to allow him to contact the 
Saudi embassy, but he was not successful. “However,” he said, “I managed to 
contact my friend, who in turn called the embassy, which responded directly, as 
its staff members were looking for me.”Al-Otaibi managed to retrieve his mobile 
phone and eventually received a call from the embassy. Saudi Arabia’s ambassador 
and other embassy officials came to the holding center immediately, but security 
officials did not allow him to meet them, he said.
Speaking about his treatment at the hand of security forces, he said: “They did 
not even give me any opportunity to speak, and all their answers were in French. 
“Later, an Arabic-speaking female lawyer explained to me that I was detained in 
connection with a murder case.”He said that security men laughed at him and 
mocked him when he was detained. “When they had shown me a photograph of a 
person and asked about him, I replied that I did not know anything about him. 
The person in the picture was not me, and that his name was different from that 
of mine,” he told Okaz.Prosecutors said checks had shown that an arrest warrant 
issued by Turkey did not apply to the man. Earlier, a police source said he had 
been detained when a scan of his passport triggered an alert. With Reuters.
Turkey's Erdogan says social media a ‘threat to 
democracy’
The Associated Press/11 December ,2021
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan described social media Saturday as one of 
the main threats to democracy.
Erdogan's government plans to pursue legislation to criminalize spreading fake 
news and disinformation online, but critics say the proposed changes would 
tighten restrictions on free speech. “Social media, which was described as a 
symbol of freedom when it first appeared, has turned into one of the main 
sources of threat to today’s democracy,” Erdogan said in a video message to a 
government-organized communications conference in Istanbul. He added: “We try to 
protect our people, especially the vulnerable sections of our society, against 
lies and disinformation without violating our citizens’ right to receive 
accurate and impartial information.” Turkey passed a law last year requiring 
social media platforms that have more than 1 million users to maintain a legal 
representative and store data in the country. Major social media companies, 
including Facebook, YouTube and Twitter, have since established offices in 
Turkey. The new legislation would make the dissemination of “disinformation” and 
“fake news” criminal offenses punishable by up to five years in prison, 
according to pro-government media reports. It also would establish a social 
media regulator. Most of Turkey’s major media companies are under the control of 
the government, leaving social media as an important outlet for dissenting 
voices. Freedom House’s Freedom on the Net report, published in September, 
characterized Turkey as “not free,” noting the removal of content critical of 
the government and the prosecution of people posting “undesirable” commentary on 
social media.
Turkey Refuses to Take in More Syrian Refugees
Ankara - Saeed Abdulrazek/Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said he refuses for his country to be 
used as a haven for refugees that the West fears to host. He accused the 
international community of failing the humanitarian crisis test in Syria, saying 
western countries have been inhumane and racist in dealing with refugees. 
Moreover, he said the West, under the pretext of combating the ISIS terrorist 
group, offered support to the People's Protection Units (YPG), the largest group 
in the Kurdish Syrian Defense Forces (SDF). The West has not met the pledges 
made to Turkey, alleged Erdogan. It has not taken any steps towards the millions 
of refugees in northern Syria, he added, referring to US support to the SDF that 
is angering Turkey. "Our country already hosts some 5 million refugees, 
including 3.7 million Syrians, it can't handle a new migrant wave", warned 
Erdogan. He denounced western countries, deeming them as partners in crimes that 
have killed one million Syrians and displaced around 16 million others. Turkey 
often uses refugees as bargaining chips with the European Union, with which it 
signed an agreement in 2016 on illegal immigration through which it agreed to 
receive 6 billion euros to support Syrian refugees. Ankara, however, believes 
the amount is not enough and is demanding more and is making more demands 
related to its membership in the EU and exempting its residents from the 
Schengen visa. Meanwhile, Turkish forces shelled the village of Tokhar Saghir 
north of Manbij city in the eastern countryside of Aleppo. The attack is part of 
the ongoing clashes between Turkish forces and its allied factions with Kurdish 
units, the Afrin Liberation Front, and other groups affiliated with the SDF and 
Syrian regime.
ExxonMobil, Qatar sign Cyprus gas deal despite Turkish 
threats
The Arab Weekly/December 11/2021
It is the second gas exploration contract that the consortium has signed for 
Block 5 in the island's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ).
US giant ExxonMobil and Qatar Energy signed a contract Friday for oil and gas 
exploration and production-sharing off the divided island of Cyprus despite 
Turkey's opposition to the deal. Cypriot Energy Minister Natasa Pilides, 
Varnavas Theodosiou, CEO of ExxonMobil Cyprus, and Ali al-Mana, director of 
Qatar Energy's International Upstream and Exploration, signed the contract in 
Nicosia. It is the second gas exploration contract that the consortium has 
signed for Block 5 in the island's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). In February 
2019, the consortium discovered a huge natural gas reserve off Cyprus in Block 
10, the island's largest find to date, holding an estimated five to eight 
trillion cubic feet. The consortium plans to drill an appraisal well on Block 10 
in late December, with results expected by the end of February. Oil and gas 
drilling off Cyprus has been interrupted by the Covid-19 pandemic. 
"Despite the increasingly difficult working environment for the global oil and 
gas industry, today we are taking a decisive step towards enhancing our mutually 
beneficial partnership," Pilides said at Friday's signing ceremony. Asked about 
Turkey's negative reaction to the licensing of Block 5, Pilides said: "We 
proceed based on international law and the Law of the Sea; this has always been 
our principle." "Fieldwork on Block 5 will begin in the second half of 2022," 
she said. Turkey has threatened to prevent ExxonMobil's search for oil and gas 
off Cyprus after Nicosia awarded it the rights to Block 5. Last week, the 
Turkish foreign ministry said a sector of the licensed area violates Turkey's 
continental shelf in the eastern Mediterranean. "Turkey will never allow any 
foreign country, company or ship to engage in hydrocarbon exploration activities 
in its maritime jurisdictions," the ministry said.
"Ankara would "defend" its rights and those of the Turkish Republic of Northern 
Cyprus," it said. The breakaway TRNC, recognised only by Ankara, lays claim to 
energy resources discovered off its coast, insisting the island's natural 
resources belong to both communities. The eastern Mediterranean has become an 
energy hot spot, with significant natural gas finds for Cyprus, Israel and 
Egypt. Ankara was accused of "gunboat diplomacy" in February 2018 when the 
Turkish navy prevented a ship leased by Italy's ENI from reaching its drilling 
target in Cyprus's Block 3. The European Commission has urged Turkey to 
de-escalate and vowed to defend the interests of member states Greece and 
Cyprus. Turkey was widely condemned for sending its own drillships into Cypriot 
waters for energy exploration, with the EU slapping sanctions on Ankara. In the 
first half of 2022, ENI and France's Total are expected to drill in their 
licensed blocks. Cyprus has been divided since Turkey invaded and occupied its 
northern third in 1974 in response to a Greek-engineered coup aiming to annex 
the island. Nicosia has pushed ahead with offshore energy exploration despite 
the collapse in 2017 of UN-brokered talks to end the country's decades-long 
division.
Palestinians vote in local elections as anger simmers in West Bank
The Arab Weekly/December 11/2021
Abbas drew widespread anger in April when he cancelled legislative and 
presidential elections.
Palestinians held municipal elections in the Israeli-occupied West Bank on 
Saturday in a rare democratic exercise and amid rising anger with President 
Mahmoud Abbas after he cancelled planned legislative and presidential votes 
earlier this year.More than 400,000 Palestinians were eligible to cast ballots 
for representatives in 154 village councils in the West Bank, where Abbas’ 
Palestinian Authority has limited self-rule. Municipal votes are typically held 
every four or five years.Municipal elections are not being held in Gaza, whose 
Islamist rulers Hamas are boycotting the vote amid a rift with Abbas’ Fatah 
party. The 86-year-old president postponed municipal votes in major West Bank 
cities, such as Ramallah, that could have been seen as a referendum on Abbas’ 
rule. “These elections cannot be an alternative to legislative elections,” said 
Ahmad Issa, 23, outside a polling station in the West Bank village of Bir Nabala, 
adding that a legislative vote could offer “a horizon for the youth” and lead to 
reforms. In the village of Beit Kahil, women and men lined up outside a polling 
station, some in facemasks to protect against COVID-19. Once inside, they placed 
voting papers in envelopes and dropped them into ballot boxes, dipping their 
fingers in ink as they left in a move to prevent people from voting twice. Abbas, 
whose support has sagged in opinion polls, drew widespread anger in April when 
he cancelled legislative and presidential elections scheduled for the summer, 
citing Israeli curbs on Palestinian voting in East Jerusalem.
Abbas’ rivals, including Hamas, accused him of using the Jerusalem voting 
dispute as an excuse to cancel elections that polls showed he and his party 
would lose to the Islamist group. Abbas, who has ruled by decree for over a 
decade, denies this. A spokesman for Hamas, which boycotted previous municipal 
elections in 2012 and 2017, said the group “refuses to participate in partial 
elections that are tailored to Fatah, and conducted by the Palestinian 
Authority,” calling on Abbas to reschedule the cancelled summer votes.
Hamas has enjoyed a surge in popularity in the West Bank and East Jerusalem 
since fighting an 11-day war with Israel in May. The group won student council 
elections this year at several top West Bank universities, an important 
barometer of support. The Palestinians seek statehood in the West Bank, Gaza and 
East Jerusalem, territory Israel captured in a 1967 war. Israel annexed East 
Jerusalem in a move not recognised internationally, and peace talks between the 
two sides broke down in 2014. Hamas won the Palestinians’ last legislative 
election in 2006. That victory laid the ground for a political rupture. Hamas 
seized Gaza after fighting a short civil war there with Fatah in 2007 and has 
ruled the coastal enclave ever since.
Egypt to Host International Conference on Combating 
Corruption
Cairo - Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
Egypt is scheduled to host the ninth session of the Conference of the States 
Parties to the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC/COSP9) in 
Sharm El Sheikh from 13 December to 17, 2021. The conference is considered one 
of the most important international conferences that brings together member 
states, parliamentarians, international, regional and non-governmental 
organizations, civil society and the private sector, to discuss anti-corruption 
matters. It will review the UN Convention against Corruption, which is the only 
legally binding universal anti-corruption instrument. According to Egypt’s 
state-run Middle East News Agency (MENA), participants will discuss means to 
prevent and reduce corruption, enhance international cooperation to better 
confront all forms of corruption, and discuss the ways to recover from the 
pandemic and to move forward following the first UN General Assembly special 
session against corruption (UNGASS) that was was held in June. The conference 
will touch on various relevant topics, including preventing corruption through 
education, and through women’s role in promoting integrity, the Stolen Asset 
Recovery Initiative, anti-corruption efforts in Africa, the Arab Anti-Corruption 
and Integrity Network, and the challenges and opportunities offered by ICTs and 
digitalization to fight corruption and the urban governance initiatives intended 
to reduce corruption. Cairo had stressed during its participation in the General 
Assembly’s special session in June on the importance of bolstering international 
and regional cooperation in the field of building human, technical and 
technological capacities to pursue corruption crimes. Egypt said its 
participation in the special session’s activities reflect “keenness on 
strengthening efforts to combat corruption being a harmful scourge that 
undermines efforts to achieve development,” the foreign ministry had stated.
Palestinians in West Bank Villages Hold Municipal Polls
Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
Palestinians in villages of the Israeli-occupied West Bank voted in municipal 
polls Saturday, amid a boycott by the main opposition Hamas, the rulers of Gaza, 
in protest at the indefinite postponement of a general election. No legislative 
or presidential election has been held in the Palestinian territories for 15 
years, while the last municipal vote -- also boycotted by Hamas -- took place in 
2017. Of the 367 villages in the West Bank, 60 had no candidates standing and 
another 162 had a single list, leaving only 154 villages actually voting on 
Saturday. The spokesman for the Palestinian Central Elections Commission, Fareed 
Taam Allah, told AFP that polling stations had opened in all villages scheduled 
to hold votes on Saturday. Polling stations are open until 7:00 pm, with some 
405,000 people eligible to vote, according to the elections committee. The 
municipal vote -- the first of two stages, with cities and towns due to vote in 
March 2022 -- is widely considered as inconsequential, with most candidates 
running as independents and Hamas not taking part. They are "politically 
unimportant because they are taking place in villages and not the big cities" 
yet, and are "futile" in the absence of Hamas, according to political analyst 
Jihad Harb. The armed group, which has ruled Gaza since 2007, is boycotting the 
vote in protest at president Mahmud Abbas's indefinite postponement of 
parliamentary and presidential elections that had been scheduled for earlier 
this year. Hamas had been poised to sweep the parliamentary election scheduled 
for May, which was widely seen as the real reason for Abbas's 11th-hour 
postponement of the poll, citing Israel's refusal to allow voting in annexed 
east Jerusalem. Abbas's presidential term was supposed to end in 2009. Hamas and 
Fatah, a secular party led by 86-year-old Abbas, have been at loggerheads since 
2007 when the Movement seized Gaza after a week of deadly clashes.
Israeli Newspaper Discloses Unknown Massacres Since 
Palestinian Nakba
Tel Aviv - Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
An Israeli newspaper has recently published new testimonies and documents about 
unknown massacres committed during the Palestinian Nakba. Nakba refers to the 
expulsion of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians by Zionist gangs from their 
homes in historical Palestine in 1948 to make way for the new state of Israel. 
Haaretz and the Akevot Institute for Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Research have 
revealed the details of three massacres committed by Israeli forces in the 
villages of Reineh, Meron and al-Burj. The report is based on the letters of 
soldiers, unpublished contemporary memoirs, minutes of political party meetings 
and other historical records. According to the newspaper, testimonies continue 
to pile up, documents are revealed and gradually a broader picture emerges of 
the acts of murder committed by Israeli troops during the War of Independence. 
Israel’s leaders knew in real time about the blood-drenched events that 
accompanied the conquest of the Arab villages, it stressed, pointing to Deir 
Yassin massacre, which was carried out in April. The massacre was aimed at 
intimidating the Palestinians and pushing them to leave, it added, noting that 
it was not the only massacre and that other massacres, no less horrific and 
cruel, were carried out in other villages. The report included several examples 
of the recently unveiled massacres, including that carried out in the Galilean 
village of Reineh, near Nazareth, which was occupied in July 1948 and in which 
14 Palestinians were killed. The victims were charged with being smugglers and 
then killed in minutes, the Israeli archive revealed. Testimonies also disclosed 
a massacre carried out in al-Burj, a Palestinian town occupied by Israel in July 
1948 some 15km to the east of Ramle. Today, the Modiin settlement stands in its 
place. According to a document found in the Yad Yaari Archive, four elderly 
remained in the village after its capture. Three of them were detained in a 
house, which Israelis torched, burning their bodies. When the fourth elderly 
returned, he was told that the three others had been sent to the hospital in 
Ramallah. Apparently he didn’t believe the story, and a few hours later he too 
was put to death with four bullets. Further atrocities against Palestinians were 
revealed in a document written by Shmuel Mikunis, a communist member of the 
Provisional State Council, which became the Knesset, asking for clarification 
from Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion about acts committed by Irgun militias. 
These included the killing of 35 Palestinians after they raised a white flag, 
the arrest of Palestinian civilians, including women and children, who were made 
to dig a pit, pushed into it, then shot to death, the rape of a girl by Irgun 
members and the killing of 13 or 14 Palestinian children who were playing with 
grenades. Nearly 120,000 Palestinians, including the elderly, women and children 
decided to stay in the northern area, however, following Israel’s massacres only 
30,000 Palestinians were left.
EU to Impose Sanctions on Russian Military Contractor 
Wagner Group, Official Says
Asharq Al-Awsat/Saturday, 11 December, 2021 
The European Union will impose sanctions on Russian private military contractor 
Wagner Group on Monday, as well as on three entities and seven or eight 
individuals, a senior EU official said, after France pressed for punitive 
measures citing human rights abuses. Over a dozen people with ties to the Wagner 
Group have previously told Reuters it has carried out clandestine combat 
missions on the Kremlin's behalf in Ukraine, Libya and Syria. Russian President 
Vladimir Putin said in December 2018 that Russian private military contractors 
had the right to work and pursue their interests anywhere in the world as long 
as they did not break Russian law. In January 2020, Putin said the Wagner Group, 
whose members are mostly ex-service personnel, neither represented the Russia 
state nor were paid by the Russian state. Moscow has repeatedly told the EU that 
sanctions on its citizens were akin to meddling in Russia's domestic affairs and 
would face retaliation. "Wagner is active in Syria, Libya, in Ukraine and the 
individual (sanctions) are related to gross violations of human rights in 
different countries," the EU senior official said. Two diplomats said the 
sanctions would be approved by EU foreign ministers in Brussels on Monday and 
published in the bloc's official journal. Since the Wagner Group has no direct 
links with the EU, the addition of the three other entities and individuals aims 
to have an impact by hitting companies working with the mercenaries, diplomats 
said. Reuters reported in September that Mali's military junta was in 
discussions about deploying the Wagner Group in Mali, which France says is not 
acceptable because it has its own troops in the region. French officials say the 
junta is turning to Wagner as part of efforts to cling to power beyond a 
transition period due to end after the Feb. 27 presidential and legislative 
elections. Two diplomats said Mali also faces EU sanctions and that a legal 
framework for such measures would be agreed on Monday, although no names would 
be decided by then.
UK Says West Will Counter 'Aggressors' as G7 Ministers, 
Allies Meet
Agence France Presse/Saturday, 11 December, 2021
UK Foreign Secretary Liz Truss on Saturday vowed the West and its allies will 
"take a stand against aggressors who seek to undermine liberty" as she hosts a 
G7 ministerial summit. The two-day gathering in Liverpool, northwest England, of 
foreign and development ministers from the group of wealthy countries -- the 
last in-person meeting of Britain's year-long G7 presidency -- comes amid rising 
global tensions. Russia's build-up of troops on Ukraine's border will top the 
agenda, alongside discussions on confronting China, limiting Iran's nuclear 
ambitions and addressing the crisis in military-ruled Myanmar, according to 
officials. U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken jetted in on Friday, holding 
talks on the sidelines of the summit with Truss and Germany's new foreign 
minister Annalena Baerbock. Blinken will fly out to southeast Asia next week on 
a visit designed to highlight the region's importance in Washington's strategy 
of standing up to China.
Ministers from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) will join the 
summit for the first time ever on Sunday, in a session earmarked for 
wide-ranging talks including on Covid vaccines, finance and gender equality. 
Korea, Australia, South Africa and India will also participate as Britain's 
chosen G7 "guests", with many attendees taking part virtually due to the 
pandemic and emergence of the Omicron variant. "This weekend the world's most 
influential democracies will take a stand against aggressors who seek to 
undermine liberty and send a clear message that we are a united front," Truss 
said ahead of the summit. "I want G7 countries to deepen ties in areas like 
trade, investment, technology and security so we can defend and advance freedom 
and democracy across the world. 
"I will be pushing that point over the next few days."
'Alternative' to adversaries -
Truss, who replaced predecessor Dominic Raab as Britain's top diplomat in 
September, delivered her first major foreign policy address Wednesday as crises 
loom around the world. She warned Moscow it would be "a strategic mistake" to 
invade Ukraine, following growing concerns over a big Russian troop build-up on 
the border. That echoed comments delivered by US President Joe Biden to his 
Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin in a virtual summit the previous day. 
Meanwhile, responding to Beijing's increasing international assertiveness and 
alleged widespread domestic rights abuses has dominated Britain's G7 presidency. 
Biden pushed at a June leaders' summit for a stronger collective stance towards 
both China and Russia, and this week saw Washington, London and Canberra 
announce diplomatic boycotts of the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics. Truss has said 
the West needs to work towards ending the "strategic dependence" of a growing 
number of low- and middle-income countries on its adversaries, in various areas 
from energy to technology. At the summit she will push attendees to provide them 
with more finance for infrastructure and technology projects, according to the 
foreign office.
G7 countries and their allies must offer "an alternative to unsustainable debt 
from non-market economies" like China, it said. Truss will unveil a UK-led 
initiative -- the Africa Resilience Investment Accelerator -- to boost 
collaboration investing in Africa's "most fragile markets" and help develop "a 
pipeline of investable opportunities". "It will help the G7 to meet its 
commitment to invest over $80 billion into the private sector in Africa over the 
next five years to support sustainable economic recovery and growth," the 
foreign office added.
China Brands U.S. Democracy 'Weapon of Mass Destruction'
Agence France Presse/Saturday, 11 December, 2021 
China branded U.S. democracy a "weapon of mass destruction" on Saturday, 
following the U.S.-organized Summit for Democracy which aimed to shore up 
like-minded allies in the face of autocratic regimes. China was left out of the 
two-day virtual summit -- along with countries including Russia and Hungary -- 
and responded by angrily accusing U.S. President Joe Biden of stoking Cold 
War-era ideological divides. "'Democracy' has long become a 'weapon of mass 
destruction' used by the U.S. to interfere in other countries," a foreign 
ministry spokesperson said in an online statement, which also accused the U.S. 
of having "instigated 'color revolutions'" overseas. The ministry also claimed 
the summit was organised by the U.S. to "draw lines of ideological prejudice, 
instrumentalize and weaponize democracy... (and) incite division and 
confrontation." Instead, Beijing vowed to "resolutely resist and oppose all 
kinds of pseudo-democracies". Ahead of the summit, China ramped up a propaganda 
blitz criticising U.S. democracy as corrupt and a failure. Instead, it touted 
its own version of "whole-process people's democracy" in a white paper released 
last week that aimed to shore up legitimacy for the ruling Communist Party, 
which has become increasingly authoritarian under President Xi Jinping. While 
the U.S. has repeatedly denied there will be another Cold War with China, 
tensions between the world's two largest economies have spiralled in recent 
years over issues including trade and technological competition, human rights, 
Xinjiang and Taiwan. The U.S. Treasury on Friday sanctioned two high-level 
Chinese officials for human rights abuses in the Xinjiang region and placed 
Chinese AI surveillance firm SenseTime on a blacklist for its facial recognition 
technology targeting the Uyghur minority. Taiwan, a democratic self-ruling 
island that is claimed by China, was invited to the U.S. summit in a clear snub 
to its larger neighbor. But Beijing got a boost in the middle of Biden's summit 
when Nicaragua dropped its previous diplomatic alliance with Taiwan, saying it 
only recognised China.
Canada/Minister Joly speaks with EU High 
Representative/Vice President Josep Borrell
December 11, 2021 - Liverpool, United Kingdom - Global Affairs Canada
The Honourable Mélanie Joly, Minister of Foreign Affairs, today spoke with Josep 
Borrell, High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and 
Security Policy / Vice-President of the European Commission, on the margins of 
the G7 Summit of Foreign and Development Ministers.
Minister Joly and High Representative Borrell exchanged views on their shared G7 
priorities. They spoke about the economic and humanitarian situation in 
Afghanistan, as well as coordinated responses to Russia’s military buildup in 
and around Ukraine, and situations in Ethiopia, Iran, and Venezuela.
Minister Joly and High Representative Borrell discussed Canada-EU collaboration 
and deepening bilateral engagement.
They agreed that the Canada-EU partnership is invaluable in addressing the 
greatest challenges of the present time, such as authoritarianism and climate 
change.
The Latest The Latest LCCC English 
analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published 
on December 11-12/2021
جوناثان سباير/ جيروزاليم بوست: أردوغان وحماس: شراكة طبيعية
يبدو أن تركيا تسمح ضمنيًا لحماس بتوجيه حملتها العنيفة في الضفة الغربية من 
الأراضي التركية. 
Erdogan and Hamas: A natural partnership
Jonathan Spyer/The Jerusalem Post/December 11/2021
Turkey appears to be tacitly permitting Hamas to direct its campaign of violence 
in the West Bank, from Turkish soil.
http://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/104715/jonathan-spyer-the-jerusalem-post-erdogan-and-hamas-a-natural-partnership-%d8%ac%d9%88%d9%86%d8%a7%d8%ab%d8%a7%d9%86-%d8%b3%d8%a8%d8%a7%d9%8a%d8%b1-%d8%ac%d9%8a%d8%b1%d9%88%d8%b2%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%8a/
At a conference in Istanbul last week, Hamas leader Ismail 
Haniyeh expressed his gratitude for the role that Turkey is playing in the 
advancement of the Palestinian cause. “From the land of the beloved Turkey, 
which is always etched in the conscience of our [Muslim] ummah [nation],” 
Haniyeh told conference participants, according to the Turkish news agency 
Anadolu. “We feel proud to participate in this conference.”
The conference, which took place under the title “The Vanguards of Jerusalem 
hold its Sword,” brought together 400 officials, lawmakers and activists, 
hailing from 40 countries, according to Anadolu.
The Hamas leader went on to outline and analyze what he described as “three 
important changes that surround us at the level of the [Palestinian] cause, the 
region and the ummah.”
The three changes listed by the Hamas leader are of interest because they 
reflect the current view of the region held by the regional alliance, of which 
Hamas is a part, both in terms of its aspirations and in terms of its concerns. 
This is the alliance of states and movements adhering broadly to the 
conservative Sunni political Islamist outlook of the Muslim Brotherhood.
According to Haniyeh, the three significant changes that have taken place are: 
firstly, the outcome of the May clashes with Israel, which the movement depicts 
as a success for itself in that it returned the issue of Jerusalem to regional 
focus. Secondly, the US withdrawal from Afghanistan, which Haniyeh described as 
weakening the US and its allies in the region, and thirdly, the Istanbul 
conference itself, which he depicted as representing part of a reaction to the 
process of normalization with Israel being pursued by some Arab countries.
Haniyeh called for “setting a complete plan to topple the normalization which 
took the shape of military and security alliance with some Arab countries.” He 
concluded that, “We must not allow normalization to spread in the body of our 
ummah.”
The location where the Hamas leader gave his speech is as significant as its 
content. Increasing evidence is emerging that Hamas is seeking to foment a new 
confrontation with Israel. The focus of this effort is the West Bank, not the 
movement’s de facto sovereign fiefdom in the Gaza Strip.
This effort, it appears, is being directed from Turkey. The Istanbul conference 
last week was the visible and declarative element of a broader reality in which 
Ankara is actively promoting the political efforts of Hamas, as the movement 
seeks to emerge as the leading force among the Palestinians. Alongside this 
overt promotion, Turkey appears to be tacitly permitting Hamas to direct its 
campaign of violence in the West Bank, from Turkish soil.
Israeli media reported after the murder of Eliyahu Kay in Jerusalem last month 
that the killer, Fadi Abu Shkhaydam, had traveled to Turkey on a number of 
occasions in the months preceding the attack. Security officials quoted in 
Israeli media said Abu Shkhaydam met with senior Hamas operatives in Turkey in 
the course of these visits. A report on KAN quoted Israeli security officials as 
contending that Abu Shkhaydam received his instructions for his attack from 
these Hamas figures in Turkey.
Similarly, the 50-man Hamas network in the West Bank, which was exposed and 
neutralized by the Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency) in late November was, again 
according to security officials quoted in Israeli media, managed by senior Hamas 
operatives Saleh al-Arouri and Zakaria Najib. Both men are residents of Turkey, 
where Hamas continues to maintain an overt presence.
Foreign Minister Yair Lapid repeated calls after the revealing of the Hamas 
network for the closure of the movement’s offices in Istanbul. The high-profile 
conference held last week in Istanbul, which included the participation of 
senior Turkish officials, was presumably Ankara’s response to this request.
Available evidence suggests that Turkish involvement with Hamas does not consist 
only of allowing the movement to domicile itself and plan actions from Turkish 
soil. Rather, on a number of occasions in recent years, indications of Turkish 
state and quasi-state agencies offering direct assistance to the movement have 
emerged.
The state-run Turkish Cooperation and Development Agency (TIKA), which maintains 
offices in Jerusalem and Gaza, is one organization whose officials have been 
found to have close links to Hamas. In 2017, Muhammad Murtaja, who headed TIKA’s 
Gaza office, was arrested by the Israeli authorities and accused of diverting 
aid money to Hamas’s “military wing.” He was sentenced to nine years in jail in 
2018.
In Gaza, TIKA overtly carries out numerous joint activities with the Hamas 
authorities. The organization is also active in propagation of Muslim 
Brotherhood ideology, and in charity work in Jerusalem.
The footprints of the SADAT International Defense Consultancy company have also 
been detected in the West Bank in recent years. SADAT, the only private military 
company permitted to organize in Turkey, was founded by Brig.-Gen. Adnan 
Tanriverdi, in 2012. Tanriverdi, who had been removed from the army because of 
his Islamist beliefs, served as President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s military 
adviser from 2016-2019. Tanriverdi presided over the purge of Kemalist offices 
from the Turkish military after the “coup” attempt in 2016. SADAT was the agency 
that recruited, trained and financed Syrian Sunni Arab rebels into 
Turkish-supported formations from 2012. While organizationally very different, 
SADAT plays an analogous role to that performed by the IRGC’s Quds Force in the 
Iranian context.
Tanriverdi left his official position in 2019, but remains close to Erdogan and 
his administration.
In January 2018, the Israeli authorities arrested a Turkish citizen, law 
lecturer Cemil Tekeli, on suspicion of assisting in the transfer of money and 
materiel to Hamas. It became clear in his interrogation that Tekeli was linked 
to SADAT and was an associate of Tanriverdi. The Shin Bet investigation found 
that Tekeli and his associate, an Israeli-Arab, had been recruited by one Zaher 
Jabarin, a Hamas member resident in Turkey who reports directly to Saleh al-Arouri.
These glimpses, along with the more visible activities noted above, point to a 
deep and systematic project of support for Hamas by Turkey. The connection is a 
natural one.
Hamas is dependent on Iranian support for the maintenance of its Gaza fiefdom. 
The domestic rocket and missile-making knowhow that the movement utilizes in its 
periodic clashes with Israel is the product of the Iranian link. But this 
alliance is not entirely comfortable for Hamas. It is notable that when for a 
moment the Arab Spring appeared to be heralding the establishment of Sunni 
Islamist regimes in a number of Arab countries, Hamas rapidly quit its domicile 
in Damascus and sought to ally with this emergent trend. This turned out to be a 
mirage, and Hamas was forced to return to its former Iranian allies as a 
supplicant. But meanwhile, alongside this problematic partnership, Hamas appears 
to have built a far more comfortable and apparently no less extensive connection 
to its fellow Sunni Islamists in Ankara. As a result, Turkey is now the 
preferred location for Hamas’s propaganda gatherings. It is also, according to 
the available evidence, the site for the planning of the terror campaign in the 
West Bank, which the movement is currently energetically seeking to activate.
Vienna… Deadlock and Widening Opportunity
Mustafa Fahs/Asharq Al-Awsat/December, 11/2021 
The consensus among the foreign ministers of the European troika taking part in 
the nuclear deal negotiations in Vienna (France, Britain and Germany) is that 
the second phase of the seventh round of negotiations, which resumed Thursday, 
is the last chance for Tehran to return to compliance with the nuclear deal.
Nonetheless, in the negotiating business, especially when such statements are 
made by diplomats, these warnings cannot be labeled as anything but a tactic to 
ramp up the pressure on the other side. In negotiations that are so 
consequential for international security and stability, no round can be 
considered the last chance, even if the statements were issued by the military 
leadership, as these types of negotiations often draw out, with delays and even 
procrastination common. Finding an opening that goes through the wall of 
negotiations may take a lot of time, even if losing this time is no longer in 
the interest of any of the parties. However, despite hinting at a dead end, US 
Foreign Secretary Anthony Blinkin’s latest interview with the Wall Street 
Journal, in which he used more acute rhetoric, asking Tehran to adopt a 
different approach in the negotiations and warning of a stalemate and that “the 
runway is short,” also included criticism of his country’s withdrawal from the 
nuclear deal. He also sent Tehran an important message when he said that US 
officials continue to believe that “the best way, the most effective way, to 
resolve the nuclear challenge posed by Iran is through diplomacy and through a 
return to mutual compliance with the so-called JCPOA, the Iran nuclear deal.”
Despite the United States’ laxity, Tehran has not found its way back to mutual 
compliance. In the previous round, the gap between the main sides (Tehran and 
Washington) was huge. The former wants Washington to immediately lift the 
sanctions that the Trump administration had imposed in 2018. As for the latter, 
it wants Tehran to return to compliance with the 2015 deal. However, both sides 
are clinging to the hindrances preventing these steps from being taken. The way 
Washington sees it, the Biden administration cannot lift all sanctions before 
putting the decision to Congress, and that takes time Tehran cannot tolerate. As 
for Tehran, it is not ready to return to compliance unless it receives legal and 
international assurances that the US administration will not pull out of the 
deal. Thus, it seems that Tehran is in a negotiating position in which it is 
searching for guarantees that maintain the agreement and mechanisms that ensure 
sanctions are lifted all at once. So far, though, it has not found out how to 
ensure that it gets what it wants, and it has not given the other side the 
concessions needed to convince it to grant it those guarantees.
The predicament facing the Iranian delegation returning to Vienna is that it 
left its country as the national currency dropped 6 percent in value following 
the failure of the first phase of the seventh round of negotiations. Also, 
Tehran’s regional or international options are currently closed off. The changed 
regional circumstances begin with the battle in Marib, as the legitimate Yemeni 
government has succeeded in going from defense to attack, leaving Iran without 
the outcomes it had been counting on in Marib, which has left it losing a card 
it could have played to apply pressure and defend its regional influence.
It is also facing the threat of the situation in Iraq slipping totally out of 
its control, with the threat of intra-Shiite conflict ever-present since Iran’s 
Iraqi subordinates lost the latest Iraqi parliamentary elections. As for 
Lebanon, which is usually used to apply pressure in two directions: The first is 
stability in the Mediterranean basin, and the second is Lebanon’s borders with 
the Israeli entity, where domestic Lebanese circumstances have turned Hezbollah 
into a disruptive force that cannot be used to apply pressure on the other 
negotiators.
Regarding Syria, agreements with Moscow have limited its impact on the 
negotiations in Vienna. Though the negotiations are on the nuclear issue, that 
means Tehran cannot swap its regional influence for concessions.
The Iran Nuclear Deal: Biden Administration's Fatal 
Mistakes
Majid Rafizadeh/Asharq Al-Awsat/December, 11/2021 
[T]he Biden administration's objective is not to halt Iran's deeply flawed 
nuclear program permanently -- the biggest flaw being that in a few years Iran 
is permitted in its "sunset period" to have as many nuclear weapons as it likes 
-- but just to limit Iran's program for a period of time while removing the 
sanctions that hurt it economically.
The Biden administration has suggested a new sunset period of 25 years -- 
assuming the Iranian regime does not lower it to 10 or 5 years. This will allow 
the Islamic Republic to resume enriching uranium at any level they desire, spin 
as many advanced centrifuges as they want, make its reactors fully operational, 
build new heavy water reactors, produce as much fuel as they desire for the 
reactors, and maintain higher uranium enrichment capability with no restriction 
after the period of the agreement.
All that is really needed is for Iran to stop enriching uranium. Totally. No 
enriched uranium, no nukes. But the realistic chances of Iran complying with 
anything even resembling that are less than zero.
[T]he Biden administration is also planning to lift the remaining sanctions 
against Iran's regime on the first day of agreement -- before Iran has even 
complied with anything. Washington will then have no actual leverage against the 
regime.
This is the same dangerous mistake that the Obama administration made.... All 
four rounds of UN sanctions that were putting pressure on Iran -- which had 
taken decades and a significant amount of political capital to put in place -- 
were lifted on day one.
Finally, the Biden administration has not so much as mentioned curbing Iran's 
intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) program. A report by Iran's... Afkar 
News... stated: "The same type of ballistic missile technology used to launch 
the satellite could carry nuclear, chemical or even biological weapons to wipe 
Israel off the map, hit US bases and allies in the region and US facilities, and 
target NATO even in the far west of Europe."
Why would the Biden administration want to propose a nuclear deal with the 
Iranian regime that will only empower and embolden the malign actions of the 
ruling mullahs?
The Biden administration, in an attempt to revive the nuclear deal, is 
continuing to forge ahead by negotiating with the government of Ebrahim Raisi 
(pictured), known -- for his crimes against humanity and his involvement in a 
massacre of nearly 30,000 political prisoners -- as the "Butcher of Tehran." 
The Biden administration, in an attempt to revive the nuclear deal, is 
continuing to forge ahead by negotiating with the government of Ebrahim Raisi, 
known -- for his crimes against humanity and his involvement in a massacre of 
nearly 30,000 political prisoners -- as the "Butcher of Tehran."
First of all, the Biden administration's objective is not to halt Iran's deeply 
flawed nuclear program permanently -- the biggest flaw being that in a few 
years, Iran is permitted in its "sunset period" to have as many nuclear weapons 
as it likes -- but just to limit Iran's program for a period of time while 
removing the sanctions that hurt it economically.
The Biden administration has suggested a new sunset period of 25 years -- 
assuming the Iranian regime does not lower it to 10 or 5 years. This will allow 
the Islamic Republic to resume enriching uranium at any level they desire, spin 
as many advanced centrifuges as they want, make its reactors fully operational, 
build new heavy water reactors, produce as much fuel as they desire for the 
reactors, and maintain higher uranium enrichment capability with no restriction 
after the period of the agreement. All that is really needed is for Iran to stop 
enriching uranium. Totally. No enriched uranium, no nukes. But the realistic 
chances of Iran complying with anything even resembling that are less than zero.
In short, the sunset period terms will most likely ensure that after the pause 
detailed in any agreement, Iran will be a nuclear state. It is also pretty safe 
to assume, from Iran's track record, that during any agreement, Iran will 
covertly violate the rules.
Technologically speaking, after Iran becomes a nuclear threshold state, it is 
just a matter of weeks to convert the materials into weapons grade material.
In addition, after having lifted some of the sanctions, the Biden administration 
is also planning to lift the remaining sanctions against Iran's regime on the 
first day of agreement -- before Iran has even complied with anything. 
Washington will then effectively have no actual leverage against the regime. 
Iran will immediately join the international community, increase its oil sales 
and trade, and the ruling clerics will ensure their hold on power, eliminating 
at least the economic danger that accompanies massive domestic unrest and 
threatens even further the mullahs' repressive hold on power.
This is the same dangerous mistake that the Obama administration made. In 2015, 
the Iranian regime received an extremely favorable deal from the "P5+1": China, 
France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States, plus Germany. All four 
rounds of UN sanctions that were putting pressure on Iran -- which had taken 
decades and a significant amount of political capital to put in place -- were 
lifted on day one.
If all sanctions again are lifted immediately upon the revival of the nuclear 
deal, and Iran later decides to breach the terms of the nuclear deal, the West 
will no longer find a consensus in the UN Security Council to reimpose sanctions 
on Iran: China and Russia will vote no. This scenario already took place in 
2020. When the International Atomic Energy Agency announced that Iran was 
violating all restrictions of the nuclear pact, the US could not get the backing 
of Russia and China, or even the consent of the EU3 (France, the UK and 
Germany), to reimpose sanctions on Iran.
Finally, the Biden administration has not so much as mentioned curbing Iran's 
intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) program. Iran's ICBM program is linked 
to the regime's nuclear program. A report by Iran's state-controlled Afkar News, 
with the headline "American soil is now within the range of Iranian bombs," 
stated:
"The same type of ballistic missile technology used to launch the satellite 
could carry nuclear, chemical or even biological weapons to wipe Israel off the 
map, hit US bases and allies in the region and US facilities, and target NATO 
even in the far west of Europe."
The report also boasted about the damage the Iranian regime could inflict on the 
US:
"By sending a military satellite into space, Iran now has shown that it can 
target all American territory; the Iranian parliament had previously warned that 
an electromagnetic nuclear attack on the United States would likely kill 90 
percent of Americans."
The international community also witnessed how the Iranian regime expanded and 
launched more ballistic missiles after the 2015 nuclear deal despite the UN 
Security Council resolution that states:
"Iran shall not undertake any activity related to ballistic missiles capable of 
delivering nuclear weapons, including launches using ballistic missile 
technology, and that States shall take all necessary measures to prevent the 
transfer of technology or technical assistance to Iran related to such 
activities."
Why would the Biden administration want to propose a nuclear deal with the 
Iranian regime that will only empower and embolden the malign actions of the 
ruling mullahs?
*Dr. Majid Rafizadeh is a business strategist and advisor, Harvard-educated 
scholar, political scientist, board member of Harvard International Review, and 
president of the International American Council on the Middle East. He has 
authored several books on Islam and US foreign policy. He can be reached at 
Dr.Rafizadeh@Post.Harvard.Edu
© 2021 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do 
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No 
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied 
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
Belligerence in Vienna could return to haunt Iran
Hussain Abdul-Hussain/The Arab Weekly/December 11/2021
Biden might not be able to hold back the percolating anger in Washington and 
allied capitals against Iran’s arrogance and destabilising behaviour.
To the rest of the world, the most recent round of nuclear talks with Iran in 
Vienna was the seventh since Joe Biden was elected US president last year. To 
the new Iranian government, however, it might as well have been the first as 
Tehran reset whatever agreements the previous delegation had already reached.
Since the last talks six months ago, Iran had installed a new government 
overseen by a hardline president, Ebrahim Raisi. The change was reflected in the 
Iranian approach to the talks. As chief Iranian negotiator Ali Baghiri put it: 
“Changes should be made to the form and content of negotiations.” It appears the 
new Iranian position has shifted from “moderate” to“radical,” and now looks 
closer to the thinking of Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.
The talks are intended to reboot the 2015 agreement with world powers for Iran 
to curb its nuclear programme in exchange for removing sanctions. But the deal 
has been on life support since Donald Trump withdrew from the US in May 2018.
True to form, Tehran choreographed the latest discussions to fit its narrative 
of defiance. The first day of negotiations on Monday was chosen to “celebrate” 
the 11th anniversary of the “martyrdom” of scientist Majid Shahrayar, one of the 
founding fathers of the Iranian nuclear programme who was killed in a car bomb 
in Tehran. On the second day of talks, Iran announced “nuclear advances” at its 
Fordow facility.
Also true to form and as a matter of policy, Iran held talks with P4+1, that is 
representatives of the four permanent members of the Security Council, Britain, 
France, China and Russia, in addition to Germany. America’s Robert Malley, the 
representative of the fifth country in the P5 group, was instructed to sit alone 
in a separate room next to where nuclear talks were being held.
Khamenei has been carefully crafting an image that depicts America, rather than 
Iran, as an isolated country. Khamenei has also been experimenting with what he 
believes to be a plausible foreign policy: peel Europe away from the United 
States.
Next up were the Iranian demands. Whereas the previous government signalled its 
readiness for “mutual compliance,” Iran’s new rulers have parted ways with the 
old policy and gone as far as shooting down all variations of such settlement. 
On the second day in Vienna, Iranian officials made it public that they were 
neither interested in “mutual compliance” nor in “less for less,” the name given 
to the interim agreement, the Joint Plan of Action (JPOA), the predecessor of 
the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) that was signed in 2015 and 
endorsed at the UN Security Council in 2016 under Resolution 2231.
The new Iranian government did not come to Vienna to discuss any past deals, but 
to present its demand: the suspension of unilateral US sanctions on Iran. After 
Trump withdrew from the nuclear deal, sanctions that had been suspended under 
the JCPOA were restored. But Trump went further and added dozens of sanctions of 
his own, mainly targeting Tehran’s money laundering and sponsorship of 
terrorism. Iran wants the suspension of all US sanctions that Trump imposed.
Technically, Trump’s terror-related sanctions did not violate the nuclear deal, 
but Tehran seems to feel powerful enough to force the US to humiliatingly roll 
back everything Trump. Biden has already said that America’s return to the 
nuclear deal does not include the suspension of any non-nuclear sanctions.
The new Iran team went even further. Tehran now says that it will not settle for 
a deal that was approved by the UN Security Council alone. Instead, the Iranian 
regime wants “guarantees” that, should the JCPOA be restored or replaced, 
America will not repeat its 2018 withdrawal.
In the US, cementing an international treaty requires Congressional approval, a 
tall order. Without legislation, no president can guarantee how his successors 
will handle any international promises. This is, after all, a democracy, where 
successive governments endorse different and at times contradictory policies.
Iran has come back to the nuclear talks with bigger demands than ever. Iranian 
pundits reasoned that Biden and his Democratic Party are suffering in the polls 
and that a breakthrough nuclear agreement with Iran would improve his position 
in next year’s midterm elections. But that might prove to be a misreading of the 
US political landscape. Humiliating Biden in nuclear talks further weakens him 
with Americans and proves that his policy of appeasing Tehran failed, 
necessitating a US escalation instead.
Khamenei might not be as maximalist as he now looks in Vienna. The Islamist 
regime has been known for its love of eleventh-hour deals. Iranian delegations 
think that playing on the edge is in their favour, that the closer Biden gets to 
his re-election time in November 2024, the better deal Tehran will get.
Tehran should not be so sure. Biden might not be able to hold back the 
percolating anger in Washington and allied capitals against Iran’s arrogance and 
destabilising behaviour, particularly towards Arab Gulf allies. The longer the 
nuclear talks drag on, the bigger the case for the last resort option: shine the 
B52s and fly them with bunker busters over Iranian nuclear facilities. As the 
famous Arab poem goes: "When you see the lion’s teeth, don’t assume that the 
lion is smiling." Iran should not confuse Washington’s patience with weakness.