LCCC ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
September 24/15
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
http://www.eliasbejjaninews.com/newsbulletins05/english.september24.15.htm
Bible Quotation For Today/It
is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is
rich to enter the kingdom of God.
Mark 10/17-27: "As Jesus was setting out on a journey, a man ran up and knelt
before him, and asked him, ‘Good Teacher, what must I do to inherit eternal
life?’ Jesus said to him, ‘Why do you call me good? No one is good but God
alone. You know the commandments: "You shall not murder; You shall not commit
adultery; You shall not steal; You shall not bear false witness; You shall not
defraud; Honour your father and mother." ’He said to him, ‘Teacher, I have kept
all these since my youth.’Jesus, looking at him, loved him and said, ‘You lack
one thing; go, sell what you own, and give the money to the poor, and you will
have treasure in heaven; then come, follow me.’When he heard this, he was
shocked and went away grieving, for he had many possessions. Then Jesus looked
around and said to his disciples, ‘How hard it will be for those who have wealth
to enter the kingdom of God!’ And the disciples were perplexed at these words.
But Jesus said to them again, ‘Children, how hard it is to enter the kingdom of
God! It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone
who is rich to enter the kingdom of God.’ They were greatly astounded and said
to one another, ‘Then who can be saved?’Jesus looked at them and said, ‘For
mortals it is impossible, but not for God; for God all things are possible.’"
Bible Quotation For Today/Be
faithful until death, and I will give you the crown of life
Book of Revelation 02/08-11: "‘To the angel of the church in Smyrna write: These
are the words of the first and the last, who was dead and came to life: ‘I know
your affliction and your poverty, even though you are rich. I know the slander
on the part of those who say that they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue
of Satan. Do not fear what you are about to suffer. Beware, the devil is about
to throw some of you into prison so that you may be tested, and for ten days you
will have affliction. Be faithful until death, and I will give you the crown of
life. Let anyone who has an ear listen to what the Spirit is saying to the
churches. Whoever conquers will not be harmed by the second death."
Titles For Latest LCCC Bulletin analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on September
23-24/15
The tongue-tied “friends”/Ahmad El Assaad/ September 23, 2015
How the U.S. rebel program and policy on Syria failed/Brooklyn Middleton/Al
Arabiya/September 23/15
Can Assad establish an Alawite state in Syria/Abdulrahman al-Rashed/Al Arabiya/September
23/15
Egypt's War on Terrorism Bears Fruit/Khaled Abu Toameh/Gatestone
Institute/September 23/15
Diplomatic Immunity: License for Crime? Saudi Arabia at It Again/Mohshin Habib/Gatestone
Institute/September 23/15
Israel and Palestine: Is it the economy, stupid/Yossi Mekelberg/Al Arabiya/September
23/15
How peace with Turkey emboldened the PKK/Mahir Zeynalov/Al Arabiya/September
23/15
Why Russia wants to echo the Cuban Missile Crisis in Syria/Raed Omari/Al Arabiya/September
23/15
Canada Should Welcome Syrian Refugees, Carefully/Tarek Fatah/The Toronto
Sun/September 23, 2015
Palestinians in Lebanon think of “emigration”/Ana Maria Luca/Now
Lebanon/September 23/15
Arrested for reporting rape in Lebanese detention center/Myra Abdallah/Now
Lebanon/September 23/15
Policemen shot dead in Tartous militia's "de-facto state"/Now Lebanon/September
23/15
Titles For
Latest LCCC Bulletin for Lebanese Related News published on
September 23-24/15
Report: Hezbollah to cease offensive action in Syria
The tongue-tied “friends”
Hale Meets Salam: U.S. to Dedicate $59 Million for Border Security Equipment for
Lebanese Army
Hale Meets Salam: U.S. to Dedicate $59 Million for Border Security Equipment for
Lebanese Army
Friend of the Court' to Appeal Lettieri's Decision, Khayat Carries on with
Confrontation
Report: Berri has Proposed to Host Inter-Palestinian National Dialogue
Jumblat: Seychelles Proposal Result of Immature Conditions for Presidential
Polls
EU Leaders Expected to Give more Funding to Lebanon
Dutch FM Advises EU Talks with Lebanon over Refugee Crisis
Czech Court Allows Extradition of Lebanese Terror Suspect to U.S.
Mustaqbal Says Presidential Vote is 'Obligatory Gateway' to Resolve Political
Crisis
Lebanese Army Arrests Prostitution Ring Linked to Kidnap Gang
Canada: Two Muslims get life sentences for jihad plot to derail passenger train
“2 Via Rail terror plotters sentenced to life in prison,”
Titles For Latest LCCC Bulletin For Miscellaneous Reports And
News published on
September 23-24/15
ISIS mobilizing for large Deir
Ezzor battle
Obama Offers Pope Warm White House Welcome
Al-Jazeera Journalists Walk Free in Egypt after Sisi Pardon
Canada welcomes Mohamed Fahmy’s pardon
Rouhani suggests Iran's military is best defense against ISIS
Israel wary as Russia, Iran expand Syrian presence
Clashes after Funeral of Palestinian Shot by Israeli Forces
Father of Saudi Youth on Death Row Asks King for Clemency
IS Frees Kurdish Journalist in Exchange
France to Sell Warships to Egypt, after Russia Deal Scrapped
Egypt Military Winds Down Campaign against IS in Sinai
Links From
Jihad Watch Web site For Today
Canada: Two Muslims get life sentences for jihad plot to derail passenger train
Hungarian bishop: Pope wrong in appealing for aid to sea of refugees; this is
actually a Muslim invasion of Europe
Pressure on Obama grows to declare war against Christians a genocide
Pakistan: Christian arrested after Muslim mob sets his house on fire
Bangladesh: Islamic jihad group issues international hit list of bloggers,
activists and writers
New Jersey Muslim teen facing charges for threats to Obama, claims of Islamic
State jihad plots against New York City
Relax: Muslim writer Khaled Diab heaps scorn on idea that Muslims might want to
conquer Europe
Clockmaker Ahmed Mohamed’s sister was once suspended from school for threatening
to blow it up
Ahmadi Muslim leader claims Ben Carson’s words “intolerant and wrong,”
dissembles about political aspects of Sharia
UK Defence Secretary: “Harder by the day” to stop jihad terror attacks
US-trained rebels gave their weapons to al-Qaeda immediately on entering Syria
Islamic State appeals to refugees to come to caliphate rather than Europe
Report: Hezbollah to cease offensive action in
Syria
Ynetnews/Roi Kais/September 23/15
Lebanese media outlet quotes diplomats claiming Hezbollah will only act
defensively in Syria after fight for Al-Zabadani ends. While Syria, Russia and
Iran solidify their military relationships, embattled President Bashar Assad may
be about to lose another key ally in his fight against rebel groups including
the Islamic State, according to Lebanese reports on Monday. Hezbollah has been
actively involved in Syria's civil war with troops on the ground fighting for
the Assad regime, but the organization has informed the Syrian government that
it will no longer take part in offensive military action, according to
diplomatic sources who spoke to the Daily Star. According to the report,
Hezbollah is now expected to participate only in defensive actions after a
battle currently being fought for the city of Al-Zabadani, some 45 kilometers
from Damascus, is completed. Even with the direct support of Iran and Russia,
losing Hezbollah's offensive capabilities would be a serious blow to the Assad
regime, which has suffered a string of losses for the past several months as
government forces have found themselves on the back foot against the Islamic
State and other rebels. Current assessments suggest that Hezbollah is less than
likely to entirely abandon the Syrian government, but perhaps Russia's increased
involvement was, in part, meant to coincide with Hezbollah's decreased activity.
Russia has established a forward air base near the northern city of Latakia
where the US claims 28 Sukhoi fighter jets have been deployed. A ceasefire
was declared in Al-Zabadani and three other cities in the area between rebels
and government forces. A similar agreement was reached in the area last month,
but didn't hold. Meanwhile, Hezbollah appears to be dealing with internal
struggles. Kuwaiti news source Al Rai reported Tuesday morning that the
organization arrested one of its members accused of spying for a Western nation.
According to the report, the individual worked at a Hezbollah-run hospital in
Beirut.Hezbollah was said to be investigating the amount of damage done by the
infiltration. No official sources confirmed the report, but the arrested
individual was said to be privy to sensitive information including the details
of wounded and dead fighters in the organization.
The tongue-tied “friends”
Ahmad El Assaad/ September 22, 2015
LOP General Chancellor
“Thugs” supporting the leader of the Movement did it again with activists!They
did not settle for the first attack against demonstrators, but repeated their
brutal intimidation to those who dared criticize their chief and include him to
the list of corrupt politicians in the country. They did so because escaping
impunity and accountability is the norm in Lebanon and because their earlier
practices did not cause an actual fuss the first time but had rather gone
unnoticed, as if nothing had happened. Following the first attack, “the thugs of
the Parliament” thought that no one would hold them accountable for their
actions, and that the streets were open for them to do as they please. Their
leader also realized that nothing could prevent him from sending his thugs to
the streets, and that no one would raise the voice in condemnation. He thought
he could be absolutely at ease in playing the role he excels at: the Middle Ages
man who is ready to do anything for people to feel intimidated by him and by the
mere thought of criticizing him or objecting to his demeanors. It may be normal
for the March 8 forces to disregard what happened. For them, this behavior is
the work of an ally, and one must not upset his entourage. Of course, this
position is morally impermissible, but morality in Lebanese politics has become
a value of the remotest of times, especially among the March 8 parties. Yet what
is stranger and even more unfortunate is the fact that the March 14 camp also
made no reaction to what happened. Not only that none of the ministries assumed
by March14-affiliated ministers (i.e. Justice, Interior and others) failed to
take appropriate action after the first and second rounds of bullying against
demonstrators, but the worst part is that no statement condemning the attacks
has been issued, neither the first, nor the second time. None of the leaders of
the March 14 camp voiced a word of denouncement over what happened. If dialogue
at the House of Representatives was the "dialogue of the deaf," then everyone
has dealt with what happened in the street as tongue-tied as could be. There is
no hope that any of the March 14 leaders would utter condemnation, because they
describe the holder of the Parliament’s Hammer as a "friend", a “very dear
friend” even. No one should be friends with a person capable of such behavior.
March 14 forces, which claim that they want to build a state of law and
institutions, must not go on with a friendship with a person who works against
the principle of Statesmanship.Failure to make any statement to condemn these
attacks and continuing to brag about the friendship with the actor of such
practices is sheer complicity with the logic of bullying, intimidation and
repression. It is also a proof that narrow calculations are the priority of the
leaders of the March 14 forces.
Hale Meets Salam: U.S. to
Dedicate $59 Million for Border Security Equipment for Lebanese Army
Naharnet/September 23/15/U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon David Hale expressed on
Wednesday his country's ongoing support for the Lebanese army, announcing
additional funds for the military. He said after meeting Prime Minister Tammam
Salam at the Grand Serail: “I am very pleased to announce today that my
government is allotting an additional $59 million for border security equipment
for the army.”“In addition, this week America received the latest, substantial
transfer of funds from Saudi Arabia to purchase more U.S. equipment to help the
Lebanese army,” he continued. “These funds, combined with U.S. funding, will
assist the Lebanese army to develop further a precision air force strike
capability; we will announce the exact details as soon as they have been
arranged,” he revealed ahead of Salam's upcoming trip to New York where he will
attend the U.N. General Assembly opening and the ministerial meeting of the
International Support Group for Lebanon. “This latest transfer and project are
yet another demonstration of the strong and effective partnership among Lebanon,
America, and Saudi Arabia to improve the Lebanese army’s capability to defend
Lebanon’s borders and people,” Hale stated.
“Whether through political support, military aid, or humanitarian assistance,
America will stand by Lebanon,” declared the ambassador. “Only our actions are
the standard by which to judge America’s commitment to Lebanese stability. Those
actions include an American investment of more than $1.3 billion in security
assistance for Lebanon in the past 10 years,” he added. “This year, Lebanon is
the fifth largest recipient of U.S. foreign military financing and Lebanon is
also the fifth largest annual recipient of U.S. bilateral training for your
military personnel. “The U.S. has provided nearly $1 billion in humanitarian
assistance to host communities and Syrian refugees in Lebanon since the tragic
conflict in Syria began and our bilateral development assistance for the last
decade will also exceed one billion dollars, to help income generating
opportunities, education, and provision of services such as water,” Hale
remarked.“But when it comes to stability, there is no amount of foreign
assistance or goodwill that can substitute for the stability that comes from
good governance. That can only come from within. I know Lebanon’s leaders are
working to reactivate a functioning cabinet and to resume dialogue on the deeper
issues,” said the ambassador. “We welcome any such effort, and earlier this
month we joined other members of the U.N. Security Council in reiterating that
now is the time for parliament to meet and elect a president as soon as possible
and to schedule parliamentary elections,” he stressed.
“As I said several weeks ago, citizens everywhere look to the state to protect
their right to free speech and assembly; and citizens everywhere have a
responsibility to exercise their right peacefully and responsibly and
accountability is expected when either side transgresses rights or
responsibilities,” he continued. “We support these universal rights, and urge
adherence to these responsibilities across the world. America supports these
values here in Lebanon and the principle of civil society’s right to voice its
views and frustrations, as does the Prime Minister. But the United States is in
no way involved, directly or indirectly, in the civil society demonstrations,
nor do we condone violence or the destruction of property,” Hale emphasized. “We
very much look forward to the Prime Minister’s trip to New York and the
opportunity to discuss with him ways the international community can be of
further support for Lebanon and our shared goals of stability, security, and
good governance,” he concluded.
Friend of the Court' to Appeal Lettieri's Decision, Khayat
Carries on with Confrontation
Naharnet/September 23/15/Leidschendam, Naharnet Exclusive: The “Friend of the
Court,” who is similar to a prosecutor in contempt cases related to the Special
Tribunal for Lebanon, is on the verge of making a decision to appeal three out
of four verdicts issued by Contempt Judge Nicola Lettieri against television
station al-Jadeed S.A.L. and the station's deputy chief editor Karma Khayat.
According to informed sources, the “Friend of the Court's” appeal of the fourth
verdict considering Khayat guilty in one of two charges of contempt still awaits
next Monday, which has been set as the deadline to issue the sentence against
the journalist. If the verdict came "light," then the “Friend of the Court” will
appeal the four verdicts in an attempt to get the Appeals Chamber to condemn the
three cases that Lettieri cleared al-Jadeed and Khayat from, and to give a
stronger sentence in the fourth case in which the judge found Khayat guilty with
the obstruction of justice. On the other hand, both parties continue with making
media and legal campaigns in an attempt to prove slander on the court's part and
a violation of freedom of speech in Lebanon. Therefore, those closely informed
about the contempt case against Khayat believe that she will appeal the verdict
which will be issued next Monday.
Report: Berri has Proposed to Host Inter-Palestinian
National Dialogue
Naharnet/September 23/15/Speaker Nabih Berri has proposed to host talks between
the Fatah and Hamas movements who remain deeply divided over a meeting of the
Palestine National Council (PNC), al-Akhbar daily reported on Thursday. PNC, a
congress representing those in the Palestinian territories and the diaspora, was
to take place on September 14-15. But it was postponed to an undetermined date.
The PNC serves as the parliament of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Hamas
belongs to neither the PLO nor the 740-member PNC, which has not met since 1996.
Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri has called on Palestinian factions to boycott the
congress, labeling it a "farce,” and causing growing differences with Fatah.
“The parliament's doors are open in case Egypt refuses to host a meeting”
between Fatah and Hamas representatives to resolve their differences, Berri has
reportedly told several Palestinian officials he met recently. Hamas officials
told al-Akhbar that Berri's invitation is “serious.” “If we succeed in our
dialogue, then that would reflect positively on the security situation in
Lebanon's camps, mainly Ain el-Hilweh,” they said. The impoverished Ain el-Hilweh
camp has gained notoriety as a refuge for extremists and fugitives and for the
settling of scores between factions. By long-standing convention, the Lebanese
army does not enter the Palestinian refugee camps, leaving the factions
themselves to handle security. More than 450,000 Palestinians are registered in
Lebanon with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian
refugees. Most live in squalid conditions in the country's 12 official refugee
camps.
Jumblat: Seychelles Proposal Result of Immature Conditions
for Presidential Polls
Naharnet/September 23/15/Progressive Socialist Party chief MP Walid Jumblat has
mocked the failure to elect a new president by proposing to move the national
dialogue from Beirut to the islands of Seychelles. In remarks to As Safir daily
published on Wednesday, Jumblat said he made the proposal to insist that “the
conditions are not yet ripe for the election of a president.”
“We should wait,” he said.
Baabda Palace has been vacant since the term of President Michel Suleiman ended
in May last year. Jumblat's remarks came a day after he attended a meeting on
the sidelines of the national dialogue at parliament that brought together
Speaker Nabih Berri, Premier Tammam Salam, Change and Reform bloc chief MP
Michel Aoun, al-Mustaqbal bloc leader lawmaker Fouad Saniora and the head of
Hizbullah's bloc MP Mohammed Raad. The meeting sought to revive the work of the
government which has been paralyzed over its working mechanism and military
promotions. However, the top officials failed to reach a deal on the promotions,
a key demand of Aoun, who wants to keep Commando Regiment chief Chamel Roukoz in
the military and make him eligible to become army commander.
Roukoz is Aoun's son-in-law.
High-ranking sources said that Saniora rejected the promotions from Brig. Gen.
to Maj. Gen., saying they would harm the military institution’s structure. But
in remarks to As Safir, the MP denied his responsibility for the obstruction of
the deal. Progress has been made in the talks but have not yet reached the
expected results, said Saniora.
EU Leaders Expected to Give more Funding to Lebanon
Associated Press/Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/European Union
leaders, who will gather for an emergency summit on the migration crisis on
Wednesday, are expected to give extra funding to Turkey, Jordan, Lebanon and
U.N. agencies. The leaders are hoping that the funding would help stop the flow
of refugees to Europe. A high-ranking U.N. official has said there are 4 million
Syrian refugees in Lebanon, Jordan and Turkey. Growing numbers have left these
countries for Europe. The summit comes a day after ministers forced through a
controversial deal to relocate 120,000 refugees in a major blow to unity within
the bloc.The deeply divided ministers agreed to relocate the asylum-seekers to
ease the strain on Greece and Italy, which are on the front line of the migrant
flood. But a senior European leader conceded the move was only a small step
toward resolving one of the worst crises ever faced by the 28-nation bloc. Four
eastern European countries — the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Romania and Hungary —
voted against the plan, and it's unclear if they will even implement it. Those
nations have resisted accepting the forced resettlement of refugees on their
territory.
Dutch FM Advises EU Talks with Lebanon over Refugee Crisis
Associated Press/Naharnet/September 23/15/ Dutch Foreign Minister Bert Koenders
has said the only way to halt the flow of migrants pouring into Europe is to end
the war in Syria, advising the European Union to hold talks with Lebanese
officials. Koenders, who visited a refugee camp in the eastern Bekaa Valley on
Tuesday, said: "It is not only a question of border controls and quotas. If the
war in Syria does not end, people will keep coming."Koenders said the EU, whose
leaders are meeting Wednesday in Brussels to try to hammer out a united front in
tackling the migrant crisis, should talk to the Lebanese authorities, "because
that country knows not only the problems but also the region."He said the EU
should discuss possible solutions to the Syrian conflict with Lebanon and other
countries from the Middle East. The Dutch government has pledged 25 million
euros ($28 million) to help Syrian refugees in Lebanon. Koenders met with
Foreign Minister Jebran Bassil on Monday. "It's important to note that this
amount of money... is something meant for refugees but also Lebanese
communities," the Dutch diplomat said.
Czech Court Allows Extradition of Lebanese Terror Suspect
to U.S.
Associated Press/September 23/15/A Prague court has ruled a Lebanese national
and two Ivory Coast citizens can be extradited to the United States to face
terror charges.The three men were arrested in Prague in April 2014 while trying
to sell weapons to undercover U.S. law enforcement officials who pretended to be
from a Colombian terrorist group. Spokeswoman Marketa Puci says Prague's
Municipal Court approved their extradition Tuesday. The three have appealed. If
the verdict is upheld, Justice Minister Robert Pelikan will have the final say.
In July, a Czech lawyer for the Lebanese suspect Ali Taan Fayad, also known as
Ali Amin, went missing in Lebanon together with four other Czechs and their
Lebanese driver, who was identified by Lebanese media as Taan's relative. Czech
officials have not commented on that.
Mustaqbal Says Presidential Vote is 'Obligatory Gateway' to Resolve Political Crisis
Naharnet/September 23/15/Al-Mustaqbal parliamentary bloc reiterated Tuesday that
the country's political deadlock can only be resolved through holding the
long-stalled presidential election, hours after MP Michel Aoun called for
staging parliamentary polls under a proportional representation law. “The
continued presidential vacuum that is being imposed on the Lebanese by Hizbullah
and the Free Patriotic Movement is an incomplete coup against the Constitution,”
said the bloc in a statement issued after its weekly meeting. It called on
lawmakers “to reach an agreement on electing a new president in order to pull
Lebanon out of the major quandary that is going through.”The bloc noted that the
election of a president would reactivate the work of the paralyzed cabinet and
parliament. “Some are making a lot of suggestions, but what we need remains
unchanged: the election of a president as an obligatory gateway to reach a
solution,” Mustaqbal underlined. It also criticized the civil society protest
movement for demanding parliamentary elections that would precede the
presidential vote, saying such a suggestion reflects “bias in favor of a certain
political camp.”“The election of a president is the key to rebuilding the
constitutional institutions,” the bloc insisted. Earlier on Tuesday, Aoun
suggested devising a law for parliamentary elections that would be based on
proportional representation and 15 electoral districts, noting that most parties
who took part in Tuesday's dialogue session supported his proposal. He also
emphasized that “there is no law that stipulates electing a president before
electing a parliament.” The last legislative elections were held in 2009, and
parliament has twice extended its own mandate, citing internal political
divisions and regional instability as justification. The country has been
without a president for more than a year, as a divided parliament has been
unable to fill the post despite meeting more than 20 times. The parliamentary
blocs of Aoun and Hizbullah have been boycotting the electoral sessions and
stripping them of the needed quorum.
Lebanese Army
Arrests Prostitution Ring Linked to Kidnap Gang
Naharnet/September 23/15/The army announced Wednesday that it has arrested a
“prostitution ring linked to a kidnap gang” in the northern city of Tripoli. “An
Intelligence Directorate patrol arrested yesterday in the city of Tripoli the
Palestinian-Syrian woman Kinda Oueis and Lebanese national Walid Sobh, who
together with fugitive Syrian Tarek Wifaqi constitute a prostitution ring linked
to a kidnap gang,” the Army Command said in a statement. It said the gang had
two days ago tried to abduct the son of a soldier after chasing him on the al-Bohsas
highway.“The two detainees have been referred to the relevant authorities for
further investigations,” the military added.
Canada: Two Muslims get
life sentences for jihad plot to derail passenger train
September 23, 2015 7:10 pm By Robert Spencer Leave a Comment
“‘I am satisfied that life imprisonment is the appropriate sentence,’ the judge
added, noting that the men would receive credit for time already spent in
custody. He said both men have not renounced their violent, jihadist ideology
and have shown no remorse.”But remember: if you start to inquire about what
exactly that violent, jihadist ideology consists of, and call for it to be
combated by the Muslim communities that ostensibly reject it, you’re a racist,
bigoted Islamophobe.
“2 Via Rail terror plotters sentenced to life in prison,”
CBC News, September 23, 2015
Raed Jaser and Chiheb Esseghaier, the men convicted earlier this year on
terrorism charges for plotting to derail a Via passenger train, were both
sentenced to life in prison today in a Toronto courtroom. In passing sentence,
Superior Court of Justice Judge Michael Code said the unusual gravity of
terrorism offences means he had to send a strong enough message to deter others
considering carrying out similar crimes. He said there was little evidence
presented that mitigates the presumptive sentence of life in prison.“These are
the most serious of terrorism offences, designed to result in indiscriminate
killings of innocent human beings,” he said. “I am satisfied that life
imprisonment is the appropriate sentence,” the judge added, noting that the men
would receive credit for time already spent in custody. He said both men have
not renounced their violent, jihadist ideology and have shown no remorse.
Crown sought life sentences In March, both men were found guilty of conspiring
to commit murder for the benefit of, at the direction of or in association with
a terrorist group. Esseghaier, of Montreal, was found guilty of all charges
against him, while Jaser, of Toronto, was convicted of all but one charge. The
jury also found the men guilty of six other terror-related charges between them.
The Crown was seeking life sentences for both men. Jaser’s lawyer argued for a
sentence of 5½ years in jail which would include three years for time already
served. Esseghaier made no sentencing submission.
After the sentences were delivered, Jaser shook his head, closed his eyes at one
point and held his face in one hand. Esseghaier crossed his arms and leaned back
in the prisoner’s box as Code read out his 53-page sentencing decision. “The
life sentence doesn’t have any meaning for me,” Esseghaier told the judge after
his sentence was delivered, adding God was his “master.”A copy of the ruling was
offered to Esseghaier after it was read by the judge, but he threw it back.
Mental health questions
Regarding Esseghaier, the judge addressed in detail questions about his mental
health, including Esseghaier’s assertion that it is currently the year 2014 and
that he and his soul, will be released from jail on Dec. 25 of that year. The
judge called them “realizations” not “delusions” and said he’s skeptical
Esseghaier is schizophrenic. In short, he said, Esseghaier’s mental health was
not a mitigating factor in the sentence. “The evidence is overwhelming that he
was not delusional or psychotic at the time of the offence,” Code said. “It is
unprecedented to adjourn a sentencing hearing indefinitely to await treatment.”
Code said it was “unnecessary to arrive at any firm conclusions regarding
Esseghaier’s alleged mental illness.”
FBI recordings prove critical
The most important evidence in the case was 25 hours of secretly recorded
conversations between the two men and an undercover FBI agent. The agent posed
as a wealthy Egyptian-American real estate developer whose views had supposedly
become more hard line in recent years and who was a willing accomplice in the
conspiracy….In passing sentence Wednesday, Code rejected Jaser’s argument that
he was entrapped by the undercover FBI agent, saying both he and Esseghaier were
predisposed to carry out violent acts before the agent was introduced to the
group….
ISIS mobilizing for large
Deir Ezzor battle
Now Lebanon/September 23/15/BEIRUT – ISIS has been mobilizing equipment and
fighters on a large scale for an upcoming operation to seize the last-two large
regime controlled areas in the urban center of Deir Ezzor, according to
All4Syria. The anti-regime outlet reported Wednesday that since the beginning of
the week ISIS has been undertaking preparations to attack the Jawra and Qusour
neighborhoods of the city located on the western banks of the Euphrates. The
report added that ISIS has dubbed the upcoming operation the “Battle of Arafah”
in reference to the Muslim Holy Day that marks the second day of the Hajj
pilgrimage to Mecca, which in 2015 falls on September 23. “Columns of ISIS
vehicles headed to Syria from Iraq via the border town of Qaim have been sighted
entering Syria from the desert despite intensive over-flights by coalition
warplanes,” All4Syria cited activists as saying. The group has mobilized many of
its members and readied its heavy machinery to begin the battle,” the report
added. “There is news that the group intends to enforce mandatory recruitment on
the sons of Deir Ezzor province, in a bid to mobilize as many fighters as [possible].”The
Syrian regime has managed to maintain its presence in the city of Deir Ezzor
despite the rebel takeover of the rest of the surrounding province in 2013. One
year later, the eastern Syrian region was seized by ISIS. The regime holds most
of the city’s neighborhoods along the western banks of the Euphrates—including
the Jawra and Qusuor neighborhoods—while ISIS has established a bridgehead in
the center of the city as well as outside of the airbase to the southeast. In
early May, ISIS launched a new offensive against regime troops holding out in
the city, the latest in a series of campaigns against the Syrian army that began
in mid-2014. Last fall, the extremist group had failed in a bid to seize the
military airport and the city’s industrial area, as well as Huweijat Sakr, an
Island on the Euphrates River, which runs through the middle of Deir Ezzor.
Fierce back-and-forth fighting has since raged in the city, with the regime and
ISIS launching a series of attacks and counterattacks against each other. Much
of the fighting has focused on the military airbase to the southeast of the
city, where ISIS launched a renewed attack in mid-September that reportedly
brought them to the gates of the installation.
Obama Offers Pope Warm White House Welcome
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/Barack Obama
welcomed Pope Francis to the White House on Wednesday -- the first black U.S.
president hailing the first pontiff from the Americas as a unique moral
authority. The South Lawn of the White House echoed to the strains of the
Pontifical Anthem, the Star-Spangled Banner and a thundering 21-gun salute, as
Washingtonians thronged the streets for the historic visit. An inspiration to
many of America's 70 million Catholics, Francis is also a potential political
ally for Obama, sharing many of his progressive goals. Both men called for
action on climate change and hailed the approchement between the United States
and Cuba -- causes dear to the White House but opposed by U.S. conservatives."I
believe the excitement around your visit must be attributed not only to your
role as pope, but to your unique qualities as a person," Obama told his
guest."In your humility, your embrace of simplicity, the gentleness of your
words and the generosity of your spirit, we see a living example of Jesus'
teachings, a leader whose moral authority comes not just through words but
through deeds."Speaking in fluent but accented English, the 78-year-old
Argentine pontiff returned the warm blessings of his host. "I am deeply grateful
for your welcome in the name of all Americans," he said, to applause."As the son
of an immigrant family, I am happy to be a guest in this country, which was
largely built by such families."In a nod to Washington's bitter debate about
immigration reform, Francis said he would address Congress "to offer words of
encouragement to those called to guide the nation's political future in fidelity
to its founding principles." Many U.S. conservatives call into question the very
existence of man-made climate change, but Francis and Obama made a de facto
joint appeal for action on the issue."Holy Father, you remind us that we have a
sacred obligation to protect our planet, God's magnificent gift to us," Obama
said.
Francis took up the call.
"Accepting the urgency, it seems clear to me also that climate change is a
problem which can no longer be left to a future generation," Francis said.
"When it comes to the care of our 'common home,' we are living at a critical
moment of history."The pope was afforded a full ceremonial welcome on his
historic first visit to the United States, and to Washington -- a political city
that ordinarily shrugs its shoulders when presidents, queens and sheikhs roll
through.Well-wishers lined the Pope's route and Obama himself made an
exceedingly rare ceremonial trip to the airport to meet the Argentine's plane
Tuesday, bringing his wife, daughters, Vice President Joe Biden to underscore
the special welcome.The visit is a political mirror of pope Benedict's 2008
visit to George W. Bush's White House. Those two leaders were as conservative as
their current successors are progressive.Still, the White House insists it is
not co-opting a holy man in order to batter Republican foes in Congress."The
goal of this meeting is to give the two men the opportunity to talk about their
shared values," said White House spokesman Josh Earnest. "There'll be time for
politics, frankly, the other 364 days of the year," he said.Francis has signaled
he is also unlikely to wade directly into America's bitterly fought politics.
The Vatican played a crucial role in brokering talks between Havana and
Washington that led to the recent restoration of diplomatic ties after more than
half a century.But the pope also told reporters that he would not specifically
bring up Washington's embargo of Cuba in his speech Thursday before American
lawmakers, who largely favor taking a tough line with Havana. "The Holy See is
against this embargo, but it is against all embargoes," he said. Yet there is no
mistaking the value of enlisting a popular pope's moral authority and offering
him America's largest political platform. Even the half of Americans who hold an
unfavorable view of the Catholic Church like Pope Francis, according to a recent
Washington Post-ABC poll. Francis will make two key speeches during his U.S.
visit, the address to Congress and another to the United Nations on Friday.
Topics will include critiques of the dominance of finance and technology; a
condemnation of world powers over the conflicts gripping the planet; appeals to
protect and welcome immigrants; and climate change, according to Vatican
sources. The pope's agenda tracks so closely with Obama's efforts to introduce
immigration reform, as well as domestic and international limits on carbon
emissions, that Republicans are already crying foul. Congressman Paul Gosar, who
is Catholic, declared he would boycott the pontiff's historic address to
Congress to protest his "leftist" views. During the historic six-day trip to New
York, symbolic home of capitalism, Francis will preside over an inter-faith
ceremony at Ground Zero, visit a Harlem Catholic school and greet crowds on a
procession through Central Park. He will wrap up his trip Saturday and Sunday in
Philadelphia at an international festival of Catholic families.
Al-Jazeera Journalists Walk Free in Egypt after Sisi Pardon
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/Canadian Al-Jazeera journalist
Mohamed Fahmy and colleague Baher Mohamed walked free after being pardoned along
with scores of others Wednesday by Egypt's president, following criticism of his
government for jailing opponents.
The 100 prisoners pardoned by President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi included women
activists Sana Seif and Yara Sallam, the president's office said, in a goodwill
gesture on the eve of a major Muslim holiday.Within hours of the announcement,
Fahmy and Mohamed were dropped off by authorities in the upmarket Cairo suburb
of Maadi in their blue prison uniforms and were waiting there for family
members. They told an AFP correspondent on the spot that they were looking
forward to being reunited with their families, but were unsure of their
long-term plans. "I'm feeling ecstatic knowing that I don't have to worry about
lawyers, police officers following me all over the place and knowing that I'm
going to share my apartment tonight with my beloved wife," said Fahmy. Mohamed
said: "We're very, very happy. But we're a bit surprised about how it was
done".The pair had been sentenced in a retrial in August to three years for
fabricating "false" news in support of the Muslim Brotherhood movement, which
the army removed from power in 2013 and outlawed. The retrial was ordered early
this year after an appeals court overturned an initial sentence of seven years,
saying the prosecution had presented scant evidence.
Greste 'overjoyed' Australian reporter and Al-Jazeera colleague Peter Greste was
also convicted, but was deported by presidential decree in February after 400
days in jail. An award-winning former BBC reporter, Greste said in an interview
with Al-Jazeera that he was "overjoyed" by their release.
"President Sisi has taken a very important step in restoring confidence in the
system but it is only a partial step," said Greste. "More than anything else,
we've been concerned for their safety, concerned for their welfare."
It was not immediately clear if Greste was included in the pardon, and the
pan-Arab network continued to demand that all charges and sentences against its
journalists be dropped. The detention and trial sparked global criticism of Sisi,
who has said he wished the journalists had been deported from the outset rather
than put on trial. After their sentencing last month, Egypt summoned the British
ambassador to Cairo for criticizing the ruling.The United States and the United
Nations had led calls for the journalists' release. Their arrest in December
2013 came at a time of heightened unrest and a deadly crackdown on the Muslim
Brotherhood following Islamist president Mohamed Morsi's overthrow by the
military.At the time, Qatar, which owns Al-Jazeera, had been supportive of the
Islamists.Fahmy had dropped his Egyptian citizenship to qualify for deportation
like Greste.
Fahmy wants 'nationality back'
His euphoric fiancee, Marwa Omran said that, after his release, "he wants to
pursue getting his nationality back."The pardons came on the eve of the Muslim
holiday of Eid al-Adha, when prisoner releases often take place in Muslim
countries. They also came a day before Sisi is due to head to New York, where he
will deliver a speech at the U.N. General Assembly. The pardons appeared to be
mainly of activists, with the presidency saying the cases involved violations of
a protest law and "assaulting police officers," in addition to some releases on
health grounds. Sisi has faced mounting calls to release activists such as Seif
and Sallam, a human rights worker detained after a small protest outside the
presidential palace in 2014.The two women were charged with holding an illegal
protest, under a law that bans all but police-sanctioned demonstrations, and
sentenced to three years in jail. No official list was immediately issued of
those pardoned, leaving it unclear whether other secular activists such as Alaa
Abdel Fattah and Ahmed Maher were included. It was also not known if the pardon
covered Mahmoud Abu Zeid, a photographer arrested in August 2013 as hundreds of
Islamist protesters were killed in clashes with police clearing two Cairo
sit-ins. Thousands of Islamists, including Morsi, have been arrested since his
overthrow, and scores sentenced to death. But the crackdown on the Islamists has
also extended to secular leaning activists who had supported Morsi's overthrow
after his divisive year in power.
Sisi, the former army chief who was elected president in 2014, remains popular
with many Egyptians as he seeks to put an end to unrest in the wake of the
country's 2011 revolution that toppled longtime strongman Hosni Mubarak. He has
vowed to steer clear of court cases out of respect for the judiciary's
independence.
Canada welcomes Mohamed
Fahmy’s pardon
September 23, 2015 - Ottawa, Ontario - Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development
Canada The Honourable Lynne Yelich, Minister of State (Foreign Affairs and
Consular), today issued the following statement: “Canada is pleased that Egypt’s
President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi has granted Mohamed Fahmy a pardon. “Canada has
consistently called at the highest level for Mr. Fahmy’s release and return to
Canada. “The Government of Canada will continue to provide Mr. Fahmy with
consular assistance and will assist in facilitating his departure from Egypt.
“We look forward to Mr. Fahmy reuniting with his family and loved ones, and his
return to Canada.”
Rouhani suggests Iran's
military is best defense against ISIS
JPOST.COM STAFF/09/22/2015/Iranian President Hassan Rouhani claimed on Tuesday
that the Islamic Republic's military is the biggest force combating terrorism in
the Middle East. The Iranian president stated that Tehran was prepared to assist
others in the region as it has aided Syria and Iraq, in reference to the battle
against the Sunni Islamic State terror group. Iran has provided military support
to Syria and to Shi'ite militias in Iraq, but has not sent military units to
Damascus. In Syria's years-long conflict, Iran has backed President Bashar Assad
and has called for him stay in power at least until Islamic State militants are
defeated. In a speech on Tuesday at a defense ceremony marking the onset of the
Iran-Iraq War in 1980, Rouhani said, “we tell the world today that the biggest
anti-terrorism force in the region is the Armed Forces of the Islamic Republic
of Iran.”“Just as we have helped the governments of Syria and Iraq against
terrorism, upon requests from their governments, if, heavens forbid, terrorism
emerged in other countries, the governments of those countries will pin their
hopes to the Armed Forces of the Islamic Republic of Iran,” Iran's semi-official
news agency Mehr quoted Rouhani as saying.While Iran is considered to be one of
the world's leading state sponsors of terror for groups such as Hezbollah and
Hamas, Rouhani claimed that the Islamic Republic "has never had the intention to
invade another country."Islamic State, which emerged last year in the anarchic
Sunni heartlands straddling Syria and Iraq, routinely executes prisoners,
enslaves captives and destroys historic sites. Iranian officials frequently cite
such actions as a justification for their support of Syrian President Bashar
Assad, whose forces have also carried out mass killings since the beginning of
an initially peaceful popular uprising in 2011.
Reuters contributed to this report.
Israel wary as Russia,
Iran expand Syrian presence
Ynetnews/September 23/15/Russia rapidly expanding base in Syria; Israeli,
Russian chiefs of staff agree to create coordinating committee after Netanyahu,
Putin discuss need to avoid military "misunderstandings". Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu met Russian President Vladimir Putin on Monday in order to
set up a system to prevent any clashes between the Russian and Israeli armies in
the region, as Moscow continues to send troops to its growing base on Latakiya,
and as American sources report that Russia has placed 28 fighter jets and a
bomber at another base. Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot later met his Russian
counterpart and the two agreed to create a committee to plan coordination.
According to an American source, the number of Russian fighter planes in Syria
has gone up this last weekend from four to 28. It was also reported on Monday
that Russian drones had begun being used in Syria. The growing Russian air
presence and use of drones led to the need to quickly reach agreements aimed at
avoiding confrontations in the sky, added American sources. The Wall Street
Journal also reported that Russia and Iran have increased their coordination in
Syria in hopes of protecting Bashar Assad's hold on Syria's coastal region.
According to sources in the US and the Middle East, Iranian and Russian
diplomats and generals have held a number of meetings in Moscow in recent
months. One of these alleged secret meetings involved Quds Force commander Qasem
Soleiman, who reportedly met Putin this month. An American defense source said
the Pentagon believes Soleimani's purported visit was "very important". The
Kremlin denied the visit, and Washington claimed it occurred and was a breach of
a UN travel ban. Besides Russians, posts in Latakiya also house Iranian advisers
and soldiers, as well as Hezbollah fighters. Putin, said European and American
sources, is exploiting the Syrian conflict to increase his country's influence
in the Middle East. Tehran, meanwhile, wants to maintain Syrian control over
areas close to the Lebanese border in order to secure arms supplies to
Hezbollah. Syrian rebels have recently made important territorial advances, and
Russia and Iran have increased their involvement accordingly. One option for the
Russo-Iranian-Syrian alliance is action around Palmyra, which was conquered by
ISIS. Putin described the Russian presence in Syria as a counterattack, and an
attempt to retake Palmyra would help justify his intervention. Another option is
an attack against the Nusra Front in Idlib province."Their first major attack
will show us what they intend," said a Lebanese military expert.Ron Ben-Yishai
contributed to this report
Cameron and Hollande:
Syrian Political Process Must be Revived
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/British Prime Minister David
Cameron and French President Francois Hollande agreed that a political process
in Syria must be revived, a source close to the French president said on
Tuesday.At a meeting at Cameron's country residence, Chequers, the two leaders
"expressed agreement on the need to revitalize the political process" in Syria,
according to a source in Hollande's entourage.In addition, the two leaders
"discussed how a big part of the answer to the refugee crisis must be a solution
to the situation in Syria", a spokesman for Cameron's office said. The two
agreed that a European Council meeting on Wednesday should focus on "increasing
assistance for the countries neighboring Syria to enable more refugees to stay
there" the spokesman added. The regime of Bashar al-Assad in Syria -- where a
brutal conflict has killed more than 240,000 and caused four million to flee --
received its first new fighter planes and weapons from ally Russia to fight the
Islamic State group on Tuesday. The French source described as "an important
step" Cameron and Hollande's exchange of views on Syria and Libya, where
instability is blamed for exacerbating the worst refugee crisis since World War
II. On Tuesday, European Union countries agreed to accept 120,000 refugees
between them despite fierce opposition from central and eastern European
countries. The two had agreed "that EU countries should do more to return
migrants who don't have a genuine claim to asylum to their countries of origin",
according the Cameron spokesman. The prime minister also "underlined the UK
support for French efforts to secure a global climate deal" at upcoming United
Nations talks in Paris at the end of this year. The Conservative leader showed
Hollande around Chequers, including a portrait gallery of 16 former prime
ministers and the "Long Gallery", where former leader Winston Churchill watched
films during World War II. The two shared a working dinner where they discussed
British demands for reforms to the European Union ahead of a referendum on its
membership due by 2017. Cameron is seeking changes to areas including
competitiveness in Europe, powers for national parliaments, relations in the
euro zone and the ability of citizens from one member state to claim social
security benefits in another, the French source said. "They agreed that many
things could be settled without having to revise the treaties," the source
added. The talks also touched on Russia and Ukraine, where separatist rebels are
battling Kiev's forces in the east. Both leaders agreed on the importance of
implementing a peace plan signed in February in Belarussian capital Minsk,
according to the French source.
Clashes after Funeral of Palestinian Shot by Israeli Forces
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/Clashes broke out Wednesday
between Palestinian youths and Israeli forces in the West Bank city of Hebron
following the funeral of a young woman shot dead after allegedly trying to stab
a soldier. Around 50 youths threw stones at soldiers, who responded with stun
grenades and tear gas in the flashpoint city, where some 500 Israeli settlers
live under heavy guard among Palestinians. The clashes followed the funeral of
18-year-old student Hadeel al-Hashlamon, who died after being shot by Israeli
soldiers at a checkpoint on Tuesday. Several thousand people joined the funeral
procession, carrying photos of her with her face completely veiled, as well as
Palestinian flags. The military said she was shot while attempting to stab a
soldier, but her father, Salaheddin al-Hashlamon, said she was innocent and had
been killed "in cold blood" by multiple shots. Her death followed that of
another Palestinian who was killed in a village outside Hebron by an explosive
device he intended to toss at a military vehicle, the army said. Residents
provided a similar account. But Palestinian security officials said the man,
whom they identified as Dia al-Talahmeh, 21, was shot dead by Israeli troops.
Their deaths came amid high tensions in the West Bank and Jerusalem following
clashes last week at the Al-Aqsa mosque compound and with the convergence of the
Jewish Yom Kippur and Muslim Eid al-Adha holidays. Jerusalem has been placed
under tight security, with thousands of Israeli police deployed and checkpoints
between the city and the West Bank closed, as is usual for Yom Kippur. Yom
Kippur began at sundown Tuesday and ends at sundown Wednesday. Eid al-Adha
begins on Wednesday evening and continues until Sunday. Next week, Jews
celebrate Sukkot, a holiday that usually leads to an increase in visits to the
Al-Aqsa compound, known to Jews as Temple Mount. It is the third-holiest site
for Muslims and the most sacred site in Judaism. Palestinian president Mahmud
Abbas warned Tuesday of the risk of a new intifada, or uprising, if the
volatility at the Al-Aqsa compound worsens. A U.N. this week said "the absence
of a political process and the rise of violent extremism and terrorism in the
region present a danger as much to the legitimate aspirations of Palestinians
for statehood, as to the security of Israel."Peace negotiations between Israel
and the Palestinians have been at a standstill for more than a year.
Father of Saudi Youth on Death Row Asks King for Clemency
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/The father of a Saudi youth facing
execution for taking part in pro-reform protests appealed to King Salman on
Wednesday to spare his life. The sentence against Ali al-Nimr, only 17 when he
was arrested in February 2012, has drawn international condemnation over his
young age at the time and allegations that he was tortured into making a
confession.It is the latest case to highlight the death penalty and human rights
in the Islamic kingdom, which Amnesty International says is one of the world's
most prolific executioners. In an interview with AFP, Mohammed al-Nimr said he
hoped the king would save his son. "We hope that the king will not sign" the
execution order, Nimr said, after Saudi Arabia's highest court confirmed the
death sentence, leaving his son's fate in the hands of the king. Nimr warned
that if his son is put to death the minority Shiite community could react
violently, something he does not want to happen. "We don't need that; we don't
need even one drop of blood," he said. The youth is a nephew of Nimr al-Nimr, a
Shiite religious leader who is also on death row. Mohammed al-Nimr, a Dammam
businessman, was in Riyadh to visit his jailed brother for the Muslim feast of
sacrifice, Eid al-Adha, which falls on Thursday. Nimr al-Nimr was a driving
force behind demonstrations that began four years ago in Eastern Province. Most
of Sunni-dominated Saudi Arabia's Shiites live in the east, and have complained
of marginalization. Ali al-Nimr's father admitted that his son, then a high
school student, had joined thousands of other people in protest. But he said he
is innocent of numerous other charges including burglary, attacking police and
using a Molotov cocktail. The court sentenced Ali al-Nimr to death but gave no
further details.Execution in the kingdom is usually carried out with a sword,
sometimes in public.
'High morale'
France's foreign ministry appealed on Wednesday for a stay of execution and
expressed concern about the case of the youth, "condemned to death even though
he was a minor at the time of the incident," a spokesman said. France opposes
the death penalty in all circumstances, the spokesman added. On Tuesday, U.N.
rights experts also called for Ali al-Nimr's life to be spared. A statement said
the youth was reportedly tortured, coerced into a confession and denied adequate
access to a lawyer before and during a trial that did not meet international
standards. "Any judgment imposing the death penalty upon persons who were
children at the time of the offense, and their execution, are incompatible with
Saudi Arabia’s international obligations," the experts said. Mohammed al-Nimr
said his last monthly visit with his son in the Dammam jail came three weeks
ago, and he expects to see him again in a couple of days."I am sure that his
morale is very high, and he is strong," the father said, adding that the family
is buoyed by the outpouring of global support on social media. Ali al-Nimr is
one of six sons and daughters in his family. Mohammed al-Nimr said his son and
Nimr al-Nimr, are among eight Shiites who have exhausted all court appeals in
connection with death sentences imposed after the protests.Ali al-Nimr is the
youngest of those eight, he said. Saudi Arabia has executed 133 locals and
foreigners this year, according to an AFP tally, compared with 87 last year.
"Saudi Arabia has been on an execution spree in 2015, but beheading a child
offender whose trial was unfair would be an appalling new low," Joe Stork, the
deputy Middle East director of Human Rights Watch, said in a statement last
week. Local activists are also worried about the threat to Ali al-Nimr's life.
"It's a very painful story," said one Eastern Province activist, asking for
anonymity.
IS Frees Kurdish Journalist in Exchange
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/The Islamic State group has
released in a prisoner exchange one of two Kurdish journalists captured late
last year, an official with Iraq's Kurdish television Rudaw said Wednesday.
Freelance reporters Massoud Aqeel and Farhad Hamo were on assignment for Rudaw
in northeastern Syria when they were seized on December 15. Aqeel "was freed
yesterday as part of a prisoner exchange between Kurdish forces and Daesh," the
Rudaw official said, using another acronym for IS. "He spent the night in Tell
Kocher under the protection of Kurdish fighters and he is now back in Qamishli,"
a large town in Syria's Kurdish area, near the border with Turkey. "Farhad
Hamo's fate remains unknown," said the official, who refused to provide further
details on the exchange. Reporters Without Borders ranked Syria 177th out of 180
in its 2015 press freedom index. According to the Paris-based watchdog, at least
30 journalists and online information providers are detained by the regime and
at least 28 others are either missing or held hostage by armed groups, including
IS.
France to Sell Warships to Egypt, after Russia Deal
Scrapped
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/French President Francois Hollande
said Wednesday Egypt had agreed to buy two Mistral warships which France built
for Russia before scrapping the sale over the Ukraine crisis. The deal is the
second big military contract this year between France and Egypt, which Hollande
said he increasingly views as a strategic partner. "It was my preferred buyer
because we already have military cooperation with Egypt," Hollande said of the
deal he struck with President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi. "Egypt plays an important
role in the Middle East and wants to move towards a democratic transition, which
is not easy, and we should support their efforts." French government sources
said Egypt would pay 950 million euros ($1 billion) for the warships, with
"significant" financing from Saudi Arabia. The two warships, which can each
carry 16 helicopters, four landing craft and 13 tanks, were ordered by Russia in
2011 in a 1.2-billion-euro deal. France found itself in an awkward situation as
the delivery date neared in 2014, with ties between Russia and the West plunging
to Cold War lows over Moscow's annexation of Crimea and support for separatists
in eastern Ukraine. Paris faced the wrath of its allies around the world if it
were to deliver the technology to Russia, and decided to cancel the delivery. It
was an expensive decision for France, which has had to foot the bill of over one
billion euros for the upkeep of the ships and the cost of training 400 Russian
sailors to crew them. After months of intense negotiations, France and Russia
agreed on the reimbursement of the deal in August. Paris returned 949.7 million
euros which had already been paid and also committed not to sell the two
warships to a country that could "contravene Russia's interests", such as Poland
or the Baltic states, a diplomatic source told AFP. Several other countries were
said to be interested in the warships, including Canada, India and Singapore.
The defense ministry source who revealed the cost of the ships said they were
due to be delivered to Egypt in March.
Ships after jets
The deal comes after Egypt became the first foreign buyers of France's Rafale
fighter jet, agreeing to purchase 24 in February, in what Paris hailed as an
"historic" accord. The 5.2-billion-euro ($5.9 billion) sale of the planes and a
frigate was a rare triumph for France which had failed to export its flagship
multi-role combat jet. However rights group Amnesty International slammed the
decision to sell the planes to a nation it has accused of "alarming" human
rights abuses. Analysts said that deal required overlooking some serious abuses
by a regime which Paris sees as a bulwark against several threats in the region.
With Libya to the west wracked by instability, and the threat from Islamic
State-linked jihadists on its eastern flank, Egypt has become a strategic
partner to France despite a rights record sullied by Sisi's brutal crackdown on
opponents. Sisi was elected president in May 2014 with almost 97 percent of the
vote a year after toppling the country's first freely elected leader, Islamist
Mohamed Morsi. A subsequent crackdown on Morsi's supporters left at least 1,400
dead and thousands more in jail. Hollande said during a visit to Egypt in August
that the ever-closer ties between Paris and Cairo stemmed from the "fight
against terrorism." "Unfortunately it is the Egyptian people who pay the price,"
Didier Billion of the Paris-based Institute of Strategic and International
Relations said at the time of the Rafale sale. "We can shut our eyes over the
rights situation in Egypt but we can't shut our eyes over Russia, because Russia
is at the center of an international power struggle," said Billion. Sisi was
also the subject of scathing global criticism over the detention and trial of
Al-Jazeera journalists, two of whom he pardoned on Tuesday on the eve of a major
Muslim holiday.
Egypt Military Winds Down Campaign against IS in Sinai
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/September 23/15/Egypt's military announced
Wednesday it was winding down its largest campaign in the Sinai against
Islamists, following a 16-day operation in which it said scores of Islamic State
group jihadists were killed. The army said the campaign in the Sinai Peninsula
had "achieved its goals" in destroying militant hideouts and equipment, in joint
operations by special forces, armoured divisions and the air force. The next
phase would see the military and police assert full control over the North Sinai
towns of El-Arish, Sheikh Zuweid and Rafah, it said in a statement. In previous
statements on the campaign, the military had announced having killed scores of
militants and captured dozens. The operation to quell a two-year-old insurgency
came less than three months after Islamic State launched its most ambitious
attack in Sinai, briefly seizing parts of the town of Sheikh Zuweid before F-16
air strikes forced its retreat. The military said the attack on July 1 killed 17
soldiers. A health ministry spokesman had been quoted by the state-owned Ahram
news site as giving a toll of 21 soldiers, but he has since clarified to Agence
France Presse that the tally included four civilians.
Islamist militants have killed hundreds of soldiers and policemen in attacks
since the army overthrew Islamist president Mohamed Morsi in 2013, ushering in a
crackdown on his supporters. Most of the attacks have been in the sparsely
populated north of the Sinai Peninsula, which borders the Gaza Strip and Israel.
Militants in Sinai last year pledged allegiance to the Islamic State group that
controls parts of Iraq and Syria.
How the U.S. rebel
program and policy on Syria failed
Brooklyn Middleton/Al Arabiya/September 23/15
The Russian military continued escalating its involvement in Syria this week
while the United States essentially admitted that its official $500-million
dollar rebel training program has so far utterly failed. The U.S. commander
General Lloyd Austin, who is responsible for heading the war against ISIS,
publicly admitted that only “four or five” U.S.-trained Syrian rebels were
actually currently fighting against the militant group. If DC is attempting to
overhaul the rebel-training program – and they clearly should – making the
mistake of ignoring Assad, the number-one enemy, will only result in further
failure.
Brooklyn Middleton
In a follow-up statement, that potentially secured the understatement of the
year award, Austin noted that the rebel-training program had, in fact, “gotten
off to a slow start.”Meanwhile, whether the CIA’s rebel training program –
launched in 2013 – has been successful remains unclear. Yet the Washington Post
reported in recent months that The House Intelligence Committee “voted
unanimously to cut as much as 20 percent of the classified funds” allocated for
the nearly billion dollar program that has seen approximately 10,000 fighters
trained since its inception.
Divisions over Division 30
Worse yet, Colonel Mohammed Daher, chief of staff for the U.S.-trained and
backed Division 30 Syrian rebel group, publicly announced his resignation from
the program this week, citing at least six reasons for his decision. In an
English translation from the Arabic provided by Business Insider, Daher notes
the following issues:
“1. Slowness in the implementation of the training program of the 30th brigade
and the lack of sufficient numbers of trainees
2. Failure of the 30th brigade to secure basic needs such as the ability to work
3. The lack of seriousness in the implementation of the project to establish the
30th brigade
4. The lack of census numbers of the 30th brigade members who are on the ground
5. The lack of accuracy and methodology in the selection of teams of the 30th
brigade
6. The heterogeneity in the ideas of the trainees to achieve the objective on
which the 30th brigade was created.”
Ignoring enemy No. 1
The reasons are unsurprising and highlight the deep failures of a program in
desperate need of total overhaul. At the same time, several of the complaints,
specifically numbers 2, 4 and 6, underscore the difficulty of facilitating unity
among the Syrian fighters. This aspect of the program has no doubt been
complicated, and often obliterated, by the fact that the United States has
continuously failed to acknowledge that Syrian President Bashar al-Assad remains
the primary enemy of opposition fighters – not ISIS. If DC is attempting to
overhaul the rebel-training program – as they clearly should – making the
mistake of ignoring the number-one enemy will only result in further failure.
The latest damning evidence of the rebel-training program – that, notably, has
already reportedly seen approximately $42 million squandered – occurred amid
what appears to be the buildup to Russian airstrikes in Syria. The most recent
reports via the New York Times indicated Moscow has now deployed over two dozen
fighter jets in addition to a number of SAMs and aircraft equipped with
air-to-air fighting capability. The latter two, John Kerry said, “raise serious
questions.” Despite that Kerry said DC “welcomed” Russia’s fight against
ISIS, he reiterated that Assad still has to go. But his remarks on the matter
appeared softer than in the past, noting that “it doesn’t have to be on Day 1 or
Month 1.”Such rhetoric, which seems to indicate that after more than 320,000
people have been killed and millions displaced there is plenty of time for Assad
to depart, is a mistake. Russia’s involvement is far more likely to secure the
Assad regime’s future in power, thus prolonging the bloody conflict. DC’s
failure to acknowledge that could deal the final blow to U.S. policy on Syria.
Can Assad establish an
Alawite state in Syria?
Abdulrahman al-Rashed/Al Arabiya/September 23/15
Can Syrian President Bashar al-Assad establish an Alawite state? The reason we
ask this question is the unprecedented Russian military intervention in Syria,
the biggest in the Middle East since the late Egyptian President Anwar Sadat
expelled Soviet military advisers in 1972.
Russian military activity in Syria is mostly in Latakia and the coastal area
extending to Tartus in the south. This area is viewed as a possible project for
an Alawite state in case the regime collapses or the Syrian state disintegrates.
Civil war will follow Assad wherever he goes in Syria.Russian forces, fighter
jets and the construction of airports, residential compounds and warehouses in
Syria can be clearly seen in the photos snapped by American satellites. These
photos have pushed Washington to officially inquire about the Russians’ aims.
Russia sparks suspicion
My article last week – on whether Assad is seeking the help of the Russians to
reduce the domination of its Iranian ally – was within the context of this
scenario, and the dangerous development of the Russians’ intervention in
Syria.We must however doubt the narrative of Assad’s dispute with the Iranians
being the reason that he resorted to the Russians. We must doubt this for
several reasons, such as the fact that the Iranians are stronger than the
Russians in Syria, and that they also militarily surround Syria given their
involvements in Iraq and Lebanon. Despite that, the intentions of Russian
activity remains suspicious and its truth will not be revealed for a long time.
Dividing Syria a difficult aim
If we take the possibility of dividing Syria, and assume that Assad plans to
resort to the coast of the Mediterranean to establish an Alawite state due to
the increased attacks on the capital, then building such a state there and
protecting it will be more difficult than maintaining governance in Syria.
There has been much talk of dividing Syria since the uprising of the Syrian
people in 2011. It’s now in the spotlight again due to the Russians’ heavy
presence around Latakia, the largest port city, and Tartus. The concept of
dividing Syria is not as easy as some think, as most governments oppose it given
the dangerous repercussions for regional countries. And previous divisions have
proven that they increase the region’s problems, rather than put an end to them.
The events since the divisions in Iraq in 1991 are an example of that. The
international community, to this day, opposes the idea of the Iraqis’ act of
solving their disputes via divisions – because such solutions merely divide Iraq
into several states fighting together. There’s also the case of Somalia, which
has been through a bitter experience ever since the regime collapsed following
the death of President Siad Barre. Somalia has been in chaos for more than 20
years now, and it’s divided into at least three statelets, including Somaliland,
which declared its independence two decades ago and it has its own government,
police and currency; however, no one recognizes it.
Perpetual civil war
Therefore, if Assad escapes Damascus to Latakia or to Qardaha and decides to
build his republic there, it will not guarantee international recognition. And
there are two more dangerous factors about a potential Alawite state. The first
is civil war, which will follow Assad wherever he goes in Syria. Assad will be
the target of all angry Syrians and he will not be capable of providing
permanent international protection for his new state. The second factor is that
Alawites themselves will consider Assad a burden and will blame him for their
disaster. We must not forget that most of the Alawite elites left the country to
Europe and Gulf countries after the crisis erupted, as they were aware of the
size of the threat Assad had subjected them to. There’s no reason that obliges
the sons of the Alawite sect, which represents 10 percent of the population, to
accept that the Assad family governs them. Former President Hafez al-Assad at
least used patriotic and nationalistic slogans to unite the Syrians under his
rule – but his son Bashar has entered a war against the majority of citizens,
and he enabled some of his relatives to manage the country’s resources and
assume high-ranking posts of authority. Assad is aware that there’s no place to
go to if he leaves his castle in Damascus. This is why he rejects all the
suggestions calling on him to step down and give up governance. To stay in
power, he scarified 250,000 people and displaced more than 12 million. In
addition, the barrel bombs his forces used have destroyed most cities. By the
Iranians’ continuous presence in Syria and the emergence of Russian troops, the
two allies – Russia and Iran – are playing a lost game in holding on to Assad.
They are now trying to suggest ideas and send more troops so Assad remains in
power. The question is: For how long will they bear the losses?
Egypt's War on Terrorism Bears Fruit
Khaled Abu Toameh/Gatestone Institute/September 23/15
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/6559/egypt-war-on-terrorism
Egyptian President Sisi's war against the smuggling tunnels will undoubtedly
weaken Hamas and other radical groups in the Gaza Strip. Sisi should be
commended, rather than criticized, for his courageous actions against Islamist
terrorists, both in the Gaza Strip and in Sinai.
Sisi's actions will benefit not only Egyptians, but also many Palestinians who
are opposed to Hamas and radical Islamist groups.
When the Egyptians destroy a Hamas tunnel, that is called "war on terrorism."
But when Israel destroys a tunnel, that is condemned as an "act of aggression."
This moral slithering is why it is important for the international community to
stand behind Sisi's relentless war on radical Islam.
Without such backing, Islamists will continue to pose a major threat not only to
Israel, but to many Arabs and Muslims who oppose Hamas, Islamic State and
Islamic Jihad.
The environment of the Gaza Strip is the last thing that Hamas cares about.
Hamas did not think about damage to the environment or to agricultural fields
when it used those fields, as well as populated areas, as launching pads for
attacking Israel.
Egypt began this week flooding smuggling tunnels along their border with the
Gaza Strip with water from the Mediterranean Sea -- a move being condemned by
Hamas and other Palestinian factions as a "disturbing nightmare."
The Egyptian army's move is another sign of President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi's
determination to destroy the tunnels that were used to smuggle weapons, people
and merchandise from Sinai to the Gaza Strip and the other way around.
This act is also a sign of Sisi's resolve to pursue his military campaign
against Islamist terror groups that are waging war against the Egyptian
authorities in Sinai. The Egyptians are convinced that Hamas and other
Palestinian groups have been providing aid to the terror groups in Sinai.
Since the beginning of the year, dozens of Egyptian soldiers and police officers
have been killed in a spate of terror attacks launched by Islamist groups in
Sinai.
Earlier this week, Egypt's Interior Ministry announced that terrorists shot dead
an Egyptian general in Sinai. In another similar shooting a few days earlier, a
terror group killed General Khaled Kamel Osman.
The decision to pump water into the smuggling tunnels is seen as a severe blow
not only to the terror groups in Sinai, but also to Hamas, Islamic Jihad and
other Palestinian factions inside the Gaza Strip.
Seawater covers parts of the ground where Egypt has been pumping water into
smuggling tunnels along the border with Gaza. (Image source: Al Jazeera video
screenshot)
Judging from the reaction of the Palestinian groups, it is clear that they are
in a state of hysteria as they see their tunnels collapsing one after the other.
In a statement published in the Gaza Strip, Palestinian groups, including Hamas,
denounced the flooding of the tunnels as a "disturbing nightmare" for the
Palestinians. The factions appealed to the Egyptian authorities to "stop this
despicable crime against the Palestinian people and their environment."
"The Palestinian people are surprised by the Egyptian move, which will tighten
the blockade on the Gaza Strip, destroy vast areas of agricultural land and harm
those living near the border (with Egypt)," the statement said.
Initially, Hamas leaders did not take the reports about flooding the tunnels
seriously. Some Hamas leaders, in fact, first thought that these were rumors
designed to scare them and other Palestinian groups in the Gaza Strip.
But when Hamas leaders woke up on September 13 to discover that the Egyptians
had begun pumping water into the smuggling tunnels, they could not believe what
they were seeing.
Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri announced that his movement asked the Egyptians
to stop flooding the tunnels with seawater. "We hope that the Egyptians will
comply with our demand," Abu Zuhri said. "This measure is completely
unacceptable and poses a threat to many families living alongside the border."
Sources in the Gaza Strip noted this week that the Egyptian move has thus far
proven to be effective and successful. They said that since being flooded with
water, several tunnels have collapsed.
It is worth noting that despite its outrage, Hamas has stopped short of issuing
threats against Egypt in response to the flooding of the tunnels.
Hamas's response would have been different had it been Israel that was flooding
the tunnels with water. But Hamas knows very well that it would not be a good
idea to mess with the Egyptian authorities and President Sisi.
During the past two years, the Egyptians have destroyed hundreds of smuggling
tunnels along their border with the Gaza Strip. Nevertheless, Hamas did not dare
launch one terror attack against Egypt.
Hamas is now pretending that it is concerned about the damage to the environment
that is caused by the flooding of the smuggling tunnels. But the truth is that
the environment of the Gaza Strip is the last thing that Hamas cares about.
Hamas did not think about damage to the environment or to agricultural fields
when its men fired thousands of rockets at Israel in the past few years. In
fact, Hamas used these fields, as well as populated areas, as launching pads for
attacking Israel.
Hamas is interested only in one thing: preserving its rule in the Gaza Strip.
The tunnels that are now being destroyed by the Egyptians were used by Hamas to
smuggle all types of weapons into the Gaza Strip. Hamas warlords are also
believed to have earned millions of dollars from the smuggling industry during
the past few years. Sisi's war against the smuggling tunnels will undoubtedly
weaken Hamas and other radical groups in the Gaza Strip. The Egyptian president
should be commended, rather than criticized, for his courageous actions against
Islamist terrorists, both in the Gaza Strip and in Sinai.
Sisi's actions will benefit not only Egyptians, but also many Palestinians who
are opposed to Hamas and radical Islamist groups. Israel also stands to benefit
from Sisi's war against Hamas. The destruction of the tunnels means fewer
weapons used by Hamas to attack Israel.
However, Israel still has good reason to be worried about Hamas's plans and
intentions.
While Sisi is busy flooding the tunnels on the border with Egypt, Hamas
continues to dig new ones on the border between the Gaza Strip and Israel. It is
no secret that Hamas has also managed to rebuild many of the terror tunnels that
were used to infiltrate gunmen into Israel during last year's military
confrontation between the two sides. Hamas is planning to use these tunnels in
the future, to dispatch its men to kill as many Israelis as possible. The
Israelis have thus far been monitoring the situation very closely and have
refrained from attacking the tunnels. That is because Israel is keen on
maintaining the unofficial truce with Hamas that was reached in the aftermath of
last year's war, known as Operation Protective Edge. There is not much that
Israel can do at this stage other than hope that Sisi will continue with his
measures to undermine Hamas. Any attempt by Israel to flood a Hamas tunnel will
most likely spark an international outcry and bring condemnations from the
United Nations. In addition, such a move on the part of Israel is likely to
trigger a violent response from Hamas -- one that could lead to another war.
When the Egyptians destroy a Hamas tunnel, that is called "war on terrorism."
But when Israel destroys a tunnel, that is condemned as an "act of aggression."
This moral slithering is why it is important for the international community to
stand behind Sisi's relentless war on radical Islam. Without such backing, the
Islamists will continue to pose a major threat not only to Israel, but to many
Arabs and Muslims who oppose Hamas, Islamic State and Islamic Jihad.
Diplomatic Immunity: License for Crime? Saudi Arabia at It
Again
Mohshin Habib/Gatestone Institute/September 23/15
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/6500/diplomatic-immunity-saudi-arabia
"Saudi Arabia has always protected its diplomats, despite what one official
termed a 'disproportionately high' number of cases involving Saudi officials in
heinous crimes." – The Hindu newspaper.
The Indian government is as embarrassed as its citizens are outraged by a crime
committed by Saudi a diplomat, who will enjoy not only diplomatic immunity, but
also blind support from his superiors.
Majed Hassan Ashoor, First Secretary at the Saudi Arabian embassy in New Delhi,
has been accused of raping two Nepalese maids, a woman of 50 and her 25-year-old
daughter. The women were rescued by the Indian police from diplomat's apartment
in Gurgaon, on the outskirts of India's capital.
"There were days when seven to eight men—all from Saudi Arabia—would take turns
in raping us," the victims said.
"If we resisted, the diplomat and his family would threaten to kill us and
dispose of our bodies in the sewer. We were made to do all the household chores
from morning until late in the night, and then subjected to sexual assault at
the end of the day. We were not given food. Sometimes we only survived on
biscuits, bread and watery tea. We were never allowed to step out of the house."
The victims, in a written complaint stated, "After we returned in May, he asked
us to message him... he then raped us and forced us to have unnatural sex and
oral sex. After that he offered us to his friends regularly."
The women were in captivity for more than three months. Eventually they were
rescued with the help of an NGO, Maiti Nepal India, which was informed about the
crimes by another woman who had been employed as a domestic help at the
diplomat's residence, but who managed to run away after three days. The NGO then
informed the Nepalese Embassy, which wrote to India's Ministry of External
Affairs and Gurgaon police. On September 7, a police team raided Ashoor's
residence and rescued the women.
The diplomat's wife and others have also been accused of various offenses, but
so far, no arrests have been made.
The victims underwent medical examinations at the Gurgaon General Hospital.
Hospital sources reported that the younger of the two victims had developed an
infection in her anus and pelvic area. Her vagina was found to be severely
bruised and damaged. The results of the examinations, sources said, corroborated
most of the claims made by the victims.
Indian authorities have asked the Saudi Ambassador in Delhi to cooperate in the
ongoing police investigation. However, instead of cooperating, the Saudi Embassy
has dismissed the charges by saying that they are "completely false."
Riyadh has so far denied any wrongdoing by its diplomats. Reuters reports that
the Saudi Embassy has accused Gurgaon Police of breaking international
conventions by raiding a diplomatic property, and is pressing India to drop the
case. According to a New York Times report of September 17, Ashoor has already
left India.
Indian women protest near the Saudi Arabian embassy in New Delhi on September
10, 2015, following the rescue of two Nepalese women raped by a Saudi diplomat
stationed in the city.
Human Rights Watch said, "We have seen similar crimes occurring in Saudi Arabia
and the Saudis have not shown any great enthusiasm for prosecuting them."
One of India's most popular English newspapers, The Hindu, wrote in an
editorial, "Saudi Arabia has always protected its diplomats, despite what one
official termed a 'disproportionately high' number of cases involving Saudi
officials in heinous crimes."
It should be noted here that the Article 29 of the Vienna Convention states that
"the person of a diplomatic agent shall be inviolable. He shall not be liable to
any form of arrest or detention. The receiving state shall treat him with due
respect and shall take all appropriate steps to prevent attack on his person,
freedom or dignity."
Article 30(1) states, "The private residence of a diplomatic agent shall enjoy
the same inviolability and protection as the premises of the mission."
Article 31(1) states, "A diplomatic agent shall enjoy immunity from the criminal
jurisdiction of the receiving State. He shall also enjoy immunity from its civil
and administrative jurisdiction, except in the case of: a) A real action
relating to private immovable property situated in the territory of the
receiving State, unless he holds it on behalf of the sending State for the
purposes of the mission, b) An action relating to succession in which the
diplomatic agent is involved as executor, administrator, heir or legatee as a
private person and not on behalf of the sending State, c) An action relating to
any professional and commercial activity exercised by the diplomatic agent in
the receiving State outside his official functions."
India is now in an awkward situation. Saudi Arabia is India's largest crude oil
supplier. About three million Indians work in Saudi Arabia. In addition, Prime
Minister Narendra Modi's government is looking for much needed investment from
Saudi Arabia, and Modi plans to visit Saudi Arabia later this year. On the other
hand, a large number of Indians and neighboring Nepalese want to see the accused
brought to justice, either by the Indian government or by Riyadh.
The Times of India wrote on September 13
"If the Saudis send the diplomat home, it would amount to an admission of guilt,
and weaken the line they have taken that the first secretary is innocent and is
being framed. India, for its part, could provide the Saudis with a face-saving
device by expelling the diplomat. That would allow the Saudis to stick to their
line that their man was innocent, but that might open up the possibility of a
retaliatory expulsion of an Indian diplomat from Riyadh.
India does not want relations between the two countries to suffer, especially
with the millions of Indian laborers in Saudi Arabia, now seemingly as effective
hostages.
In 2011, a case in the U.K. involving two women held in conditions like
'slavery' by a Saudi diplomat in London caused an international uproar after
details emerged of their severe ill-treatment.
Yet another case in 2013 involved two women held as 'domestic slaves' for months
by the Saudi defense attaché and his wife in the United States. In both the
cases, the diplomats were not prosecuted, thanks to diplomatic immunity.
Perhaps it is time to revoke the concept of diplomatic immunity; at every level
internationally, it is all too often a license for crime.
© 2015 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. No part of this website or any
of its contents may be reproduced, copied or modified, without the prior written
consent of Gatestone Institute.
Israel and Palestine: Is it the economy, stupid?
Yossi Mekelberg/Al Arabiya/September 23/15
In the endless debates revolving around the merits of a peace agreement between
the Israelis and the Palestinians, economic costs and benefits often seem to be
ignored or even neglected. Moreover, fact-based debate about the nature and
possible solutions to the conflict is sorely missing from many of the
discussions and writings about this protracted conflict.
It is therefore refreshing to see new in-depth research published by the
American RAND policy think tank, addressing the economic costs of the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict. A group of researchers led by C. Ross Anthony and
Charles Ries, employing quite sophisticated research methods, demonstrate
scientifically and convincingly, what one might argue should have been basic
common sense for everyone involved in the conflict.
Though Israel’s economy would appear to gain more in absolute terms from a
two-state solution, and lose more in absolute should violence resume, in
relative terms the gains and losses are way greater for the Palestinians.
In short, the idea is that peace between the Israelis and the Palestinians would
bring enormous economic benefits to both. Yet, after twenty-two years to this
month, since the Oslo Accords were signed, economic incentives proved not to be
the deciding force in pushing both sides to reach a peace agreement.
Five alternative trajectories
RAND’s research looks at five alternative trajectories for the Israeli
Palestinian conflict and how they would impact Israel and Palestine’s GDP by
2024. A two-state solution would increase Israeli GDP by $123 billion vs $50
billion increase of Palestinian GDP over ten years.
On the other extreme scale of scenarios, the one of returning to full-blown
violence, both economies would suffer immensely, with a decrease of 46 percent
in GDP per-capita in the West Bank and Gaza, and 10 percent in Israel by 2024.
Other alternative options, such as coordinated or uncoordinated unilateral
withdrawal, and nonviolent resistance, have a less profound impact on both
economies. Though Israel would appear to gain more in absolute terms from a
two-state solution, and lose more in absolute should violence resume, in
relative terms the gains and losses are way greater for the Palestinians.
Power asymmetry
This is not surprising, considering the power asymmetry between the two
protagonists. Consequently it skews the role economics can play in bringing
peace. The Palestinians recognise it as a source of vulnerability and would not
like to be blackmailed over this; in the Israeli mind it is a bonus and not of
vital interest. This explains to an extent why the economic factor is not a
deciding, or even highly prioritised, aspect for the decision makers on both
sides.
The Israeli economy, with all its difficulties and inequalities, is doing quite
well. For Israel’s current decision makers the potential economic gain, even on
the scale suggested by this research, does not justify the territorial
concessions required for a two-state solution and definitely not the security
implications of an independent Palestinian state. The leader of one of the main
partners in the current Israeli coalition government, Naftali Bennett, said in
the past that a Palestinian state will destroy the Israeli economy. His lopsided
logic argues that a Palestinian state will become a safe haven for anti-Israeli
militancy, which will interrupt normal life in Israel. He ignores the fact that
in the period before the outbreak of the Second Intifada both economies enjoyed
economic growth, especially the Palestinian one which experienced unprecedented
economic prosperity. It was in fact a lack of political solution, which led to
violence and the Second Intifada. For the Palestinians the lure of improving
economic conditions is very tempting. Yet, it would be naïve to suggest that the
Palestinians would abandon a just and fair resolution to issues such as borders,
territory, refugees or Jerusalem in return for economic benefits.
Economics of two-state solution
The economic rational for a two-state solution is evident both in the experience
of the 1990s, and from research such as that presented by the Costs of the
Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. Nevertheless, to make it count as a major aspect
of a peace process there is a need for leadership, which sees economic
development not only as an added value for a peace process, but as one of its
major pillars. It could be utilised as a tool to mobilise the popular support
for difficult concessions on both sides, as well as an essential source for
sustaining peaceful relations between both peoples in the long-run. In addition,
donor countries and international investors can positively contribute by sending
a unified and coherent message, that a genuine peace between the Israelis and
Palestinians will bring economic benefits for everyone – not only for corrupt
elites. This could encourage grassroot, bottom-up pressure to resume the peace
negotiations.
Politics of fear
Tragically, the opportunity to improve the standard of living and human
development is sacrificed for those intangible aspects of the conflict beyond
the remit of RAND’s research. For instance, the politics of fear and distrust
have increased throughout the peace process. Violence, bloodshed and destruction
make both sides disillusioned with each other and the merits of the peace
process. It deepened rifts within both societies and between them.
As long as the conflict is hijacked by those distrusting religious-nationalists,
who see security through the narrowest of prisms, it is hard to see how a more
fact-based rational discourse can emerge.
Religious-nationalism mixed with security perceptions has provided the
justification for embarking on the Jewish settlements project in the
Palestinians occupied territories – one of the major and most visible obstacles
to peace. The consequences of these activities are reflected on the Palestinian
side with the emergence of the Hamas and their original demand for an Islamic
Caliphate in the entire territory of mandatory Palestine. As long as the
conflict is hijacked by those distrusting religious-nationalists, who see
security through the narrowest of prisms, it is hard to see how a more
fact-based rational discourse can emerge. The sort of discourse that is required
is one which attributes greater significance to the economy as a major component
to reaching peace and maintaining it.
How peace with Turkey emboldened the PKK
Mahir Zeynalov/Al Arabiya/September 23/15
People in Turkey jubilantly celebrated the Kurdish peace process for nearly
three years, predicting that the negotiations could spawn an era of calm
following three decades of conflict. They were unaware, however, that the
outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) had exploited the lull in the conflict
to replenish its forces, stock up on arms and increase its military posture.
For years, critics and opposition parties asked the government to be more
transparent in peace negotiations, and warned against the PKK’s increasingly
visible posture in towns and cities in the southeast, where the rebel group is
more active and dominant. It seems the government was aware of the situation all
along. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan acknowledged in a live TV
interview this month that the Kurdish rebel group had exploited the peace
process to stock up on arms.
Both sides must return to peace talks, with conditions that they must be held
transparently with no strings attached.
Only last year, the Turkish army asked governors in three provinces for a
permission to conduct military operations against PKK militants. Out of 110
demands in Sirnak, 100 in Hakkari and 80 in Tunceli, governors only allowed
eight operations, revealing how the authorities tolerated the PKK activities in
restive areas in southeast Turkey.
Presidential gambit
Erdogan’s primary goal to commit himself to a peace process was to have a chance
to secure Kurdish support for his presidential ambitions. That tentative
agreement with Kurds fell apart when Kurdish leader Selahattin Demirtas built
his electoral campaign in early summer on a promise that his party would thwart
Erdogan’s presidential bid. Erdogan’s former chief aide and current deputy prime
minister Yalcin Akdogan acknowledged that the peace process was halted because
Demirtas railed against Erdogan’s presidential gambit.
Shortly after the Kurdish party surged in the polls to cost the AKP its 13-year
single-party rule, the fighting between the PKK and the Turkish army resumed in
one of the deadliest confrontations in the recent past. More than 130 members of
Turkish security services were killed. There is no credible report of the death
toll on the PKK side, but Erdogan claims the number of PKK militants killed is
nearly 2,000. Hundreds were killed in massive air campaign against PKK targets
in northern Iraq. Washington reluctantly extended its support to Turkey’s
operations against the PKK at a time when U.S. diplomats worked assiduously to
get Ankara on board in the fight against the ISIS.The PKK’s approval rate in Turkey is very low, hovering around 6 percent. More
than half of Turkey’s Kurds even loathe the PKK for its continued armed
campaign. The Kurdish HDP party’s surge in the June elections was possible
because the party – and its charismatic leader Demirtas – distanced itself from
the PKK.
To garner nationalist votes and defame Demirtas as “PKK’s pawn,” the government
has significantly escalated the war following the elections and the
pro-government newspapers decorated their front pages with Demirtas-bashing. It
was a well-calculated strategy to strip the HDP from necessary votes in upcoming
elections slated for Nov. 1. If the Kurdish party fails to pass the threshold
necessary to gain parliamentary seats, the AKP could regain its parliamentary
majority.
PKK’s new military tactic
In the past, the PKK usually ganged up in huge numbers to attack gendarmerie
posts in the rural southeast, with armed skirmishes continuing for hours. They
retreated to nurse their wounds and to avoid upcoming air support for Turkish
troops. With U.S. support in drone intelligence-gathering, it was hard for the
PKK to attack the troops in big numbers.
The new method of assault is roadside bombs, which have been nightmare in Iraq
for years. With explosives buried underground, PKK militants could now blow up
Turkish armored vehicles carrying soldiers, avoiding armed shootouts and
escaping with minimal casualties, if any.
On Sept. 6, the PKK detonated three roadside bombs in Daglica, killing 16
Turkish soldiers, the biggest attack on Turkish security forces since 2011, when
at least 26 Turkish soldiers were killed in a night-long clash. A day later, a
truck loaded with explosives was detonated in Igdir, killing at least 13 police
officers. In the past two months, dozens of Turkish soldiers were killed in 27
separate bombing attacks.
The Turkish army is unable to retaliate against these attacks within Turkey. The
government declared bounty for informants tipping off PKK militants and usually
responded by heavily bombing PKK camps in northern Iraq.
Is peace possible?
In any negotiations to solve a military conflict, the different sides seek to
gain an upper hand so that they have more say in peace talks. In this regard,
the PKK’s intention to embolden its ranks could be considered rational. It is
also obvious that the Turkish authorities sought to maintain the peace process
by avoiding going after the PKK; but allowing the militant group to increase its
presence in southeastern Turkey is a cause for concern. The majority of the
Turkish people supported the peace process, because the government promised that
the PKK would bury arms as a result. Quite the opposite took place.
Because the PKK’s strength comes from constant recruitment, there is no military
solution to the conflict. The youth wing of the PKK is fighting the security
forces in highly dense urban areas, making it very difficult for the Turkish
army to retaliate without civilian casualties.
Peace talks failed because both sides had different motivations to maintain
them. The government wanted to increase Erdogan’s chance for expanded presidency
while the PKK sought to bolster its military presence at a time of ceasefire.
Both sides must return to peace talks, with conditions that they must be held
transparently with no strings attached. Support for the PKK will erode slowly if
Kurds are granted necessary rights and freedoms. No rebel group could fight the
establishment without a legitimate cause. The content of peace talks must be
simple: PKK will commit to cease its military existence as Kurds are given their
rights and freedoms.
Why Russia wants to echo the Cuban Missile Crisis in Syria
Raed Omari/Al Arabiya/September 23/15
Russia’s recent escalation in Syria is about a lot more than an attempt to
secure a foothold in the Middle East. I don’t think it would be an exaggeration
to say that Moscow's goal behind its deployment of weapons and military
equipment in Syria was not simply to assist its ally President Bashar al-Assad,
but to seize a historic moment brought about by the withdrawal of the United
States from the region.
For that strategic objective, Russia has partially succeeded in resurrecting
some of the spirit of the Cold War. Moscow has ‘directed’ its escalation in
Syria in a way to echo the 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis – during which the world
held its breath for 13 agonizing days, as nuclear war between the U.S. and USSR
seemed to lurch closer and closer.
Russia’s Putin has sought to deliver a message to America that its stubborn
stance on Syria will remain irreversible.
Soviet Union no more
Are we witnessing a new Cuban Missile Crisis between Moscow and Washington? The
answer is definitely ‘no’ – simply because Russia is no longer the Soviet Union,
nor can it be, just as Erdogan’s Turkey cannot be the Ottoman Empire. Things
have changed. And, presumably, there are no nuclear-tipped missiles among the
weapons the Russians have reportedly deployed in Syria – a country that, unlike
Cuba, is far away from North America.
Russia’s recent move in Syria also comes at a time when President Obama is
particularly hands-off in the Middle East – and when America is busy with
preparations for the next presidential election. Obama was unenthusiastic for
any military action in Syria, or elsewhere, in the beginning of his second term
– let alone in his last year in office. Obama, the reluctant war leader, is also
tied up with many “peace commitments” he pledged to the American people.
A message to America
Despite the apparent triviality in comparing Moscow’s military buildup in Syria
to the Cuban Missile Crisis, both involve sending a strong message to America.
And Putin’s message is that his stubborn stance on Syria will remain
irreversible even if that means sending troops on the ground to fight alongside
Assad.
Russia has been seeking to become the “manager” of the Syrian crisis, and not
just one of the key players, especially given that the consequences of Syria’s
four-and-a half-year conflict have reached Europe.
To achieve this endeavor, the Russians will continue advocating the war on
terror in Syria, fully aware that the “nobility” and “allure” of the cause means
no one will object.
It is the Russians’ wish to depict the war in Syria solely in terms of the war
on terror, so that they can achieve supremacy there. The war in Syria should be
only on ISIS and radicalism; this is the notion the Russians have been trying to
put across. Remarkably enough, the Syrian army jets have begun bombarding ISIS
in Palmyra, with the story of the Russian weapons no longer, it seems, a secret.Moscow is trying to reach out boldly in the Middle East, partly to counter
Washington’s attempts to cut off Moscow’s economic and political ties to the
outside world. Washington’s policy of withdrawing from the Middle East allows
Moscow to step forward as a stubborn adversary. Decisiveness, as opposed to
prudence, has given the Kremlin – not the White House – a leading position in
handling the world’s affairs.
Canada Should Welcome Syrian Refugees, Carefully
Tarek Fatah/The Toronto Sun/September 22, 2015
Originally published under the title, "Let's Welcome Syria's Refugees,
Carefully."The Syrian migrant famously tripped by a Hungarian TV camerawoman on
September 8 has been identified by Syrian Kurdish rebels as a member of
Al-Qaeda's Syrian franchise. The video showing a Hungarian camerawoman tripping
a Syrian refugee as he ran across an open field on the Hungary-Serbia border
sent a wave of revulsion across the world. Her television network fired her. On
the other hand, her victim was offered a job by the football club Real Madrid in
Spain. This was poetic justice unfolding in real life.
However, what appeared to be a happy ending has now taken a new twist. No sooner
did his name and picture flash across social media then a Kurdish-based
political party in Syria identified him as a member of the jihadi Nusra Front.
The Syrian Democratic Union Party (PYD) is one of Syria's major opposition
parties and is banned by the government of dictator Basher al-Assad. It said on
its website the refugee had fought alongside the Nusra Front before leaving
Syria with his family, earlier this year. I reached out to him for comment
through his new employer, Real Madrid, but the club's public relations office
told me: "We receive all kind of opinions concerning these matters, and we
acknowledge them, but we cannot nor should (we) take a stance on any of them." I
was not able to reach him directly for comment. To be clear, no country has laid
any charges against him in relation to allegations he belonged to a terrorist
group, and I have no knowledge if they are true. That said, this does illustrate
the concerns of those advocating for thorough background security checks of all
future Syrian refugees coming to Canada. 40% of British Muslims support
introducing sharia in parts of the UK. Many in Canada have invoked the 1956
Hungarian refugee crisis, the 1968 Czech refugee crisis, and the 1978 Vietnamese
Boat People crisis as shining examples of how Canada reached out to those
fleeing dictatorial regimes. But this is different. In those crises we knew the
people we welcomed to Canada hated our enemies and were committed to the West's
values of democracy, freedom, and individual liberty. They embraced our values
while retaining their own faith and cultures. This may also be true of the
Kurds, Iranians, Yazidis, Darfuris, and Baloch who wish to flee the tyranny of
Islamism and embrace Canada and the West, and of the vast majority of Muslim
refugees. But it cannot be said of any radical Islamists who seek refuge in the
West.We must not allow Syrian refugees to be manipulated by Islamists already in
our midst. Take Britain. Despite the fact many were born in the UK, 40% of
British Muslims surveyed by the Telegraph newspaper said they backed introducing
sharia in parts of Britain, while 20% felt sympathy with the motives of the
London July 7 bombers.We will now rightfully open our doors to 10,000 Syrian
refugees.
But let us not repeat the mistakes made by other countries and allow our
refugees to be manipulated by Islamists already in our midst.Let us make sure
that before Islamist organizations and mosques poison their minds, they are
introduced to Sir Wilfrid Laurier, Sir John A. Macdonald, Pierre Trudeau, Tommy
Douglas, and to Voltaire and Rousseau.Let us help them understand the futility
of armed jihad and sharia as public law. Let us heed the warning by Hans-Georg
Maassen, president of Germany's domestic intelligence services, who said
Tuesday: "There is a big worry that Islamists in Germany, on the pretext of
offering humanitarian help, could try to take advantage of the migrants'
situation to convert and recruit those seeking asylum."
**Tarek Fatah, a founder of the Muslim Canadian Congress and columnist at the
Toronto Sun, is a Robert J. and Abby B. Levine Fellow at the Middle East Forum.
Palestinians in Lebanon think of “emigration”
Ana Maria Luca/Now Lebanon/September 23/15
In the Palestinian refugee camp of Baddawi, in Tripoli, North Lebanon, only the
lucky and the desperate think of leaving the country. The lucky have enough
money to put aside and bribe their way to Turkey; while the desperate, many of
whom come from Syria’s besieged Yarmouk camp, have only their luck to try on the
Mediterranean Sea. There have been many Palestinian refugees that left Lebanon
with fishing boats fromTripoli’s shores, the deputy head of the Popular
Committee in Baddawi camp, Abou Riad Shakli, told NOW. He said that Baddawi
received approximately 1100 families from Syria. “Almost 200 of them traveled.
Some of them managed to reach Turkey before they went on to Germany or somewhere
else in Europe. Some of them are still in Greece. Some died on the way. They
drowned,” he explains. “They went using an inflatable boat through Tripoli; the
boat was overloaded. When it reached the Turkish borders, it capsized, it was
too heavy,” he adds. Nine Palestinians from Yarmouk drowned in Turkish waters in
mid-August after leaving Tripoli’s shore with a fishing boat that carried 40
people. In the beginning of September, two Palestinians were arrested in Tripoli
by the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF) for trying to smuggle 21 refugees to Turkey
with a fishing boat. Getting caught is worse than living in a crowded refugee
camp in Lebanon: they are deported. The 21 Palestinians from Syria who were
caught by the LAF trying to leave Tripoli fishermen’s harbor in early September
were not from Baddawi, but the Popular Committee tried its best to save them.
“The Lebanese system is clear. Every person without a residency permit is to be
deported. We only interfered to tell them that people from Yarmouk are not able
to go back there; that Yarmouk is besieged and these people can’t enter it. This
is when they gave him a period of 1 week to 10 days before they deported them,”
he explained.
The struggle to leave
The men gathered in the tiny living room that barely fits two couches and a
small coffee table say there is hardly a man in the whole Baddawi Palestinian
refugee camp who doesn’t think of leaving. Some borrow money to pay greedy
middlemen and corrupt embassy personnel to get visas to more welcoming
countries. It is not just the Palestinians who fled Syria’s war that think of
“emigration,” but also the Palestinian refugees who were born in Lebanon and who
see that there is a chance for a better life somewhere else. “People are paying
huge amounts of money to obtain a visa,” Hisham, a thin tall man wearing a blue
t-shirt with a UNICEF logo, tells NOW. “The only way you can obtain a visa is
through a broker. The lists are long, the wait is longer. These brokers are
blackmailing the people who want to travel to Turkey, they’re exploiting the
desperation of the people. They increased the price. At first it was $200, then
$500, then $700, $1000; and then, lately, they ask for $2000. A visa to Turkey
costs only $60. It’s just that they don’t give visas to Palestinians so easily,”
Hisham explains.
The struggle to live
Abou Khalid, the head of the Popular Committee of the Baddawi camp, is in his
80s and has lived through many tragedies in Lebanon: the Israeli bombing of the
refugee camp in Nabatieh in 1974, the Tel al-Zaatar battle in 1976 between the
Lebanese Front and the Palestine Liberation Organization, he’s seen the war
between the Lebanese army and jihadists from Fatah al-Islam that destroyed Nahr
al-Bared camp in Tripoli in 2007. But he says he has never seen the Palestinians
suffering helplessly like they’re suffering in the besieged Yarmouk camp in
Syria: starvation, bombings, extremists, war. “Despite the fact that the
Palestinians have nothing to do with anything that happened in Syria, they have
suffered the most. We have many families from Yarmouk here and most of them are
thinking of leaving,” Abou Khalid says slowly, taking his time to breathe.
“There is nothing for them here: we don’t have the right to work, the living
conditions are catastrophic. No one likes to risk their lives on the sea, but
sometimes circumstances force them to take that risk. They want to live in a
place where they actually have rights and can live a normal life,” he explains.
He then takes a deep breath and rests for a few seconds. Hisham, who says he
works for United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the
Near East (UNRWA) as a laborer, explains that the agency and a few
non-governmental organizations that deliver aid to the camp are the only sources
of survival for the Palestinians. He explains that the refugees have been
feeling the harsh lack of funding for UNRWA for years, but with the Syrian war
next door things have become unbearable. Palestinians also don’t have the right
to work in Lebanon, unless they find a sponsor. “Doctors, lawyers, engineers…
These are professions that we, the Palestinians, are not allowed to work in.
Palestinian engineers opened minimarkets in order to live; doctors are working
for $500 a month. It happened at the UNRWA office once: a young man who studied
engineering applied to work as a scavenger! Can you imagine?” Hisham explains.
“Of course everyone is thinking of leaving! Why would we stay here?”
The struggle to stay
According to UNRWA’s spokesperson Christopher Gunness, the international
organization’s appeal for 2015 only raised 35 percent of the funds, while 95
percent of the Palestinian refugees rely on UNRWA to meet their daily needs of
food, water and healthcare. “At a time when refugees are heading for Europe in
ever increasing numbers, it has never been so clear that a fully functioning
UNRWA, delivering a full range of humanitarian and development services to some
of the most marginalized people in the Middle East is one very cost effective
option for European governments. For donor states now grappling with rising
extremism and refugee flows, the humanitarian work of UNRWA is an important part
of the global response,” Gunness said. In the meantime, the attempts to leave
with a boat from Lebanon’s shore are still timid. “From our camp there were not
many who left. Only 10-15 people ventured on the sea, compared to the larger
number of people from other places in Lebanon. Only 2 people from our camp
drowned,” Shakli says. Some boats leave from Syria’s Tartous and stop to pick up
people from Tripoli on their way to Cyprus, sources in the refugee camps in
Lebanon say. Many refugees have made the trip and are now in Europe, trying to
get to Germany or the Scandinavian countries where they believe human rights are
valued and they might have a better chance than in any country of the Middle
East. But back in Baddawi, there are also many people who feel discouraged by
the news of capsized boats and drowned children. “It’s not that we don’t want to
leave. But the only thing that keeps us here is the sea. It’s dangerous,”
Fatima, a resident of the camp, says while serving tea. “I just saw this morning
on Facebook that a small boat carrying 40 people capsized in the middle of the
sea. I read on Facebook that among the dead were small children; they used boats
to leave from Al-Mina in Tripoli. This is the only thing that keeps us here: the
danger of the sea,” she points out. Ana Maria Luca tweets @aml1609
Arrested for reporting rape in Lebanese detention center
Myra Abdallah/Now Lebanon/September 23/15
Layal al-Kayaje, an employee at a veterinary clinic in Saida, was first summoned
for investigation by the Lebanese army in 2013 as Sheikh Ahmad al-Assir—who was
recently arrested in Beirut attempting to flee the country—rose to prominence.
She was accused of supporting the extremist Sunni sheikh against the Lebanese
Armed Forces because she had posted messages of support for the cleric on
Facebook and because many of her shop’s customers were also his followers. She
was arrested for five days.
In August, Layal told NOW her story—using “Amar” as a fake name—that was
published on September 4, 2015. During her detention in the Lebanese army’s
intelligence branch in Rihaniyyeh she said she was tortured, raped and sodomized
(for Layal’s full story click here).
NOW chose not to reveal Layal’s identity at the time in order to protect her in
case her allegations were true. Regardless, Lebanese authorities were able to
uncover who she was and on September 21 she was summoned for investigation to
the same institution she had been held two years before. She was re-arrested and
her lawyer and family have not been allowed to see her.
On September 22, the Lebanese army issued a statement claiming that Layal
confessed to having lied about her rape in order to raise sympathy for herself
and find a job opportunity. Layal was arrested alongside Insaf al-Yaman, a
Lebanese woman who also reported being raped in one of the country’s detention
centers.
NOW as well as several human rights organizations in Lebanon have concerns over
the conditions of Layal’s detention, including the fact that she was not
permitted to contact her lawyer and was summoned to the same institution whose
employees she had accused of abuse.
Below is the statement issued by the group of organizations that is following up
on her case:
The signatory organizations call upon the Lebanese judiciary to act on the case
of Layal al-Kayaje, a veterinary clinic employee from Saida, who was summoned
for investigation on September 21, 2015 by Lebanese army intelligence in Saida,
Lebanon, following her statements on alleged torture and rape during detention.
Layal was summoned for investigation two weeks after NOW News published a report
on her alleged rape and torture during detention. According to the article,
Layal stated that she was arrested for five days in 2013 at the Ministry of
Justice and Rihaniyyeh, where she was not allowed access to a lawyer or contact
with her family. Layal also affirmed being raped by her investigators.
Layal notified NGOs on September 21 that she had been summoned to the Lebanese
army intelligence branch in Saida. Both her family and the human rights
organizations were unable to receive any answers about her whereabouts. Such
acts fall under incommunicado detention since authorities have actively
concealed information regarding Layal’s detention, and in so doing effectively
deprived her of her right of access to a lawyer to challenge the arrest or
detention before an independent judicial authority. Layal was also forbidden to
contact her family.
Coercively denying a detainee communication with the outside world is not only a
violation of Lebanese laws but would also amount to a violation of international
human rights law guarantees protecting the liberty and dignity of a suspect. On
the evening of September 22, a statement by the military command reported that
her summon on September 21 is justified under charges of defamation and libel
against the Lebanese army.
The signatory organizations call on the judicial authorities to open impartial
and independent investigations with regard to the detention of Layal and
previous allegations of torture and hold those responsible criminally
accountable. The signatory organizations stress that investigations and
proceedings have to be conducted by an independent and impartial judicial
authority. All charges brought against Layal must be conducted respecting the
guarantees of fair trial promulgated by national and international legal
obligations.
The signatory organizations
ALEF – Act for Human Rights
ALK- Alkarama Foundation
Badael Alternatives
Lebanese Institute for Democracy and Human Rights – LIFE
Policemen shot dead in Tartous militia's "de-facto state"
Now Lebanon/September 23/15
BEIRUT – Security forces in an Alawite town near Tartous have been attacked by a
National Defense Force unit amid residents’ complaints over the rogue actions of
the militia force, the latest instance of the growing lawlessness in the
regime’s coastal heartland. Two police officers in the town of Dreikish were
killed Monday during clashes with members of local NDF chief Ahmad al-Houry’s
militia, who one local pro-Bashar al-Assad outlet called a “criminal.” A number
of pro-regime Facebook pages based in the area blamed Houry’s militia for the
deaths of security officers Firas Dakhil and Ali Hamid, who were mourned Tuesday
in large funeral processions in the town which is famous for its mineral
springs. “A gang of armed outlaws led by Shaaban Khamm opened fire on a police
patrol today in the Dreikish area causing the martyrdom of two security forces
members and the injury of a third,” pro-regime Facebook page Tartous Patriotic
News Network reported on Monday. “Meanwhile while the gang escaped unpunished,”
the outlet added. “The gang answers to Ahmad Houry, a mandatory military service
deserter who claims to impose the law.” Another local Facebook page implied that
the two police officers’ killer had been arrested but rebuked the authorities
for not taking action against the militia as a whole. “Does the handover of
Shaaban Khamm absolve that gang of its responsibility?” a post from Tuesday on
Al-Dreikish asked. “Does it please our good state to sell us one by one on
behalf of those [criminals]?”
Residents of Dreikish have blasted the local NDF militia and called for the
regime to strike it with an “iron fist.”“There is a large group of murderous
criminals who have banded together in a militia under the leadership of the
criminal Ahmad Houry,” read a post late Monday on Al-Dreikish.
“They gathered all the degenerates and together, and because the state did not
do its duty and bury them they ran rampant and set themselves up as a de-facto
state,” the bitter post added. “Matters are still deteriorating and we are
waiting for the state to strike with an iron fist - otherwise we are headed for
oblivion.” A subsequent post on the page accused Houry’s militia of operating
“in cooperation with the governor of Tartous, and those above him too.”Meanwhile,
a source told pro-opposition outlet All4Syria that the militia’s leader relies
on the sale of “stolen goods from areas raided by regime forces, kidnapping,
blackmail and carjacking in areas where [his militias] are deployed.”“Houry has
imposed himself as a de-facto authority in the Dreikish area, one of the NDF’s
largest reservoirs.”The source added that the town “sees the death of at least
one of its sons every day after they are killed fighting alongside the regime.”
“The transgressions of Houry and his companions… have created a state of popular
anger and discontent over the regime government’s policy towards such people.”
“The chaos of weapons has [allowed them to] impose themselves as overlords and
[turned] civilians [into] their slaves.”
The Dreikish incident comes on the heels of a long series of incidents of local
pro-regime militias taking the law into their own hands amid lawlessness in the
Tartous region.
On June 22, members of a local National Defense Force militia opened fire on
residents of the Tartous town of Safita, which is populated by a nearly equal
mix of Greek Orthodox and Alawites approximately 20 kilometers southeast of
Tartous.A pro-regime Facebook page covering news in the town roundly condemned
the incident and called for a government crackdown. “We call on the competent
authorities to put an end to this chaos which is increasing day after day,” a
post on the pro-regime Safita News Network read. The outlet demanded that the
government “restrict [weapons] to the army and the armed forces alone.”Armed militiamen in Syria’s coastal region have acted with growing impunity,
with car thefts and kidnappings being blamed on them.Only a week before the
Saifta shooting, four Christian men were kidnapped from the nearby town Khreibat
by unknown gunmen, sparking tension among the town’s residents.