LCCC ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
October 26/15
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
http://www.eliasbejjaninews.com/newsbulletins05/english.october26.15.htm
Bible Quotation For Today/The
Parable Of the Sower/Other
seeds fell on good soil and brought forth grain, some a hundredfold, some sixty,
some thirty
"Matthew 13/01-09: "That same day Jesus went out of the house and sat beside the
lake. Such great crowds gathered around him that he got into a boat and sat
there, while the whole crowd stood on the beach. And he told them many things in
parables, saying: ‘Listen! A sower went out to sow. And as he sowed, some seeds
fell on the path, and the birds came and ate them up. Other seeds fell on rocky
ground, where they did not have much soil, and they sprang up quickly, since
they had no depth of soil. But when the sun rose, they were scorched; and since
they had no root, they withered away. Other seeds fell among thorns, and the
thorns grew up and choked them. Other seeds fell on good soil and brought forth
grain, some a hundredfold, some sixty, some thirty. Let anyone with ears
listen".
Bible Quotation For Today/Wrongdoers
will not inherit the kingdom of God?
First Letter to the Corinthians 06/01-11: "When any of you has a grievance
against another, do you dare to take it to court before the unrighteous, instead
of taking it before the saints? Do you not know that the saints will judge the
world? And if the world is to be judged by you, are you incompetent to try
trivial cases? Do you not know that we are to judge angels to say nothing of
ordinary matters? If you have ordinary cases, then, do you appoint as judges
those who have no standing in the church? I say this to your shame. Can it be
that there is no one among you wise enough to decide between one believer and
another, but a believer goes to court against a believer and before unbelievers
at that? In fact, to have lawsuits at all with one another is already a defeat
for you. Why not rather be wronged? Why not rather be defrauded? But you
yourselves wrong and defraud and believers at that. Do you not know that
wrongdoers will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived! Fornicators,
idolaters, adulterers, male prostitutes, sodomites, thieves, the greedy,
drunkards, revilers, robbers none of these will inherit the kingdom of God. And
this is what some of you used to be. But you were washed, you were sanctified,
you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and in the Spirit of our
God."
Titles For Latest LCCC Bulletin analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on
October 25-26/15
What if Russian body bags start turning up in Moscow/Mohamed Chebarro/Al
Arabiya/October 25/15
If the opposition is an illusion, then the Syrian army is a myth/Abdulrahman al-Rashed/Al
Arabiya/October 25/15
What’s the difference between Moscow and Assad/Brooklyn Middleton/Al Arabiya/October
25/15
A call for action on U.S.-Arab relations/Khalaf Ahmad Al Habtoor/Al Arabiya/October
25/15
Gregg Roman on the 'Inextricable Connection' between Islamists and
Hitler/Al-Jazeera English/October 25, 2015
The Shi'ite Leopard: Iran's Religious Persecution/Denis MacEoin/Gastone
Gate/October 25, 2015
The Holocaust is OVER/by Shoshana Bryen/Gatestone Institute/October 25, 2015
Analysis: Iran’s hostage-taking of Americans shows it can’t be
housebroken/Benjamin Weinthal/J.Post/October 25/15
Titles For
Latest LCCC Bulletin for Lebanese Related News published on
October 25-26/15
Report: Salam May Resign if
Garbage Disposal Plan Not Adopted Next Week
Asiri: We are Seriously Dealing with Assassination Threats
Zoaiter Takes Blame for Garbage-Flooded Streets as Rain Exacerbates Trash Crisis
Rain produces rivers of trash in Lebanese capital
Environment Minister Blames 'Political Forces' for Growing Trash Crisis
Abou Faour Says Shehayyeb to 'Expose' Obstructors if Waste Plan Not Implemented
Working Children Given a Path Off Lebanon's Streets
Report: LF-FPM to Continue Efforts to Reach United Stand on Legislative Session
“Cabs turning away guide dogs a rampant problem in Toronto: Advocate,”
Titles For Latest LCCC Bulletin For Miscellaneous Reports And
News published on
October 25-26/15
Palestinian girl shot dead trying to stab Israeli police
Washington ‘to cut aid’ to Palestinian Authority
Kerry lays out steps to ease Israeli-Palestinian strife
Netanyahu: Al-Aqsa surveillance cameras in ‘Israel’s interest’
Saudi Court Confirms Death Sentence against Shiite Cleric
An Israeli Arab flies paraglider into Syria to join ISIS without being
intercepted
Kerry, in Saudi Arabia, meets with King Salman
Lavrov and Kerry discuss Syria, chance of political solution
Saudi, Egypt have ‘similar’ stance on Syria
No election talks, Assad wants to defeat ‘terrorists’
Erdogan: We won't let Kurds ‘seize’ northern Syria
Libya finds 29 bodies of apparent migrants on beach
Assad: 'Eradicating Terror' Will Produce Political Deal
Turkey says won't let Kurds ‘seize’ northern Syria
‘I apologize:’ Tony Blair admits Iraq war mistakes
Europe split on migrant crisis ahead of talks
Death toll in Libya anti-peace deal rally shelling hits 12
5 dead as heavy rains pound Egypt’s Alexandria
Yemeni forces make gains in Taiz
Links From Jihad
Watch Site for
October 25-26/15
Sharia Toronto: Cabbies turning away passengers with seeing-eye dogs
US still wants Pakistan to expand counter-terrorism efforts
UK: Convert to Islam arrested for fundraising for the Islamic State
Denmark: Muslims march for jihad in Copenhagen
Netanyahu Under Fire for Telling Truth About Mufti’s Role in Holocaust
Denmark: Muslim mob attacks police car, shots fired at Shia march
France: Muslim screaming “Allahu akbar” & “Kill the Jews” stabs Jew, punches
rabbi
FBI top dog Comey: It will be “challenging” to identify jihad terrorists among
the refugees
Abbas gives cartoonist who promotes hate and violence the “Palestine Order of
Merit for Culture, Sciences and Arts”
Massachusetts kids build clocks to honor Ahmed the Clock Boy
Report: Salam May Resign if Garbage Disposal Plan Not
Adopted Next Week
Naharnet/October 26/15/Prime Minister Tammam Salam is beginning to “weigh his
options” in light of his realization that solutions to the garbage disposal
crisis may have reached a dead end, reported the pan-Arab daily al-Hayat on
Sunday. A ministerial source told the daily: “Salam will not remain an hour more
in his position on Thursday if the trash disposal plan of Agriculture Akram
Shehayyeb is not adopted.” Speaker Nabih Berri had asked Salam to wait before
taking any step “because he is exerting efforts to overcome obstacles hindering
the plan.”He is also pressuring the premier against resigning in order to avert
vacuum in the “executive authority in Lebanon.”Media reports in recent weeks had
been speculating the Salam would step down from his post following the ongoing
failure to resolve the garbage disposal crisis that erupted with the closure of
the Naameh landfill in July. The government approved in September Shehayyeb's
trash plan that called for waste management to be turned over to municipalities
in 18 months, the temporary expansion of two landfills and the reopening for
seven days of the Naameh dump south of Beirut. However the implementation of the
plan faced wide rejections of residents and municipalities from outside the
capital who refuse to receive the trash other than those of their regions.
Asiri: We are Seriously Dealing with Assassination Threats
Naharnet/October 26/15/Saudi Ambassador to Lebanon Ali Awadh Asiri stressed that
the kingdom's embassy in Lebanon is coordinating with Lebanese security agencies
to “determine the seriousness” of the recent allegations of assassination
threats.He told the Saudi Okaz newspaper Sunday: “Threats against me, any member
of the diplomatic mission, or Saudi expatriates are taken seriously.”He added
that all members of the mission are carrying out their duties in a normal
manner, saying that the Lebanese security authorities have bolstered the
security measures at the Saudi embassy in Beirut.
The members of the mission have been offered additional protection near their
residences, Asiri revealed. British media reports said earlier this week that
the ambassadors of Saudi Arabia and Qatar may be the target of assassinations in
order to create sedition. Interior Minister Nouhad al-Mashnouq stressed Saturday
that the government will provide the necessary security for the ambassadors and
their embassies in light of reports.
Zoaiter Takes Blame for Garbage-Flooded Streets as Rain
Exacerbates Trash Crisis
Naharnet/October 26/15/Minister of Transportation and Public Works Ghazi Zoaiter
took blame on Sunday for the trash that flooded the streets of the country
following the heavy rainfall in the morning, reported Voice of Lebanon radio
(93.3). He told the station: “I assume responsibility in my position as minister
of public works, but I have for months warned of an environmental disaster after
the first rainfall.”The garbage that has been piling up on the sides of the
streets in Lebanon in the past months flooded the streets of the capital and
other areas, exacerbating traffic and floods as trash plugged gutters. Zoaiter
lamented the current situation in Lebanon, saying that he is “willing to
cooperate with all sides in any way possible so that the people do not pay the
price.”He added however that municipalities had resorted to dumping garbage in
the streets, noting that they too should be blamed for the ongoing crisis. He
urged the concerned ministerial committee to take a decision regarding the
garbage disposal crisis soon, “because we are only at the beginning of the
winter season.”In the evening, anti-trash civil society activists staged a
sit-in at the Riad al-Solh Square in downtown Beirut before marching to Prime
Minister Tammam Salam's residence in Msaitbeh. "The government's corruption has
led to the current garbage crisis ... Officials must resign if they can't
address the crisis," protest organizer Ayman Mroueh said in Riad al-Solh. "The
negligent political authorities are the Lebanese people's enemy," he added.
Outside Salam's residence, the activists demanded accountability and measures
from the government, vowing to escalate their protests if the premier does not
move to address the crisis. "We tell the Lebanese to wait for our moves and be
with us on Thursday for a protest whose details will be announce in the right
time. We want to tell the ruling class that enough is enough," a protest
organizer declared. The country has been in the grip of a months-long trash
crisis caused by the government shutting down the country's main landfill in
Naameh without finding an alternative. Political bickering and the refusal of
various municipalities to accept Beirut's trash have prolonged the crisis. The
crisis has ignited mass protests against the government, which has failed to
provide a number of basic services and is widely seen as corrupt and
dysfunctional. Activists from the You Stink movement, which has been leading the
protests, shared videos on their Facebook page of plastic trash bags and other
garbage floating down a narrow street lined with cars. The Beirut River, where
garbage had been piling up on the banks for months, resembled an open sewer.
Activists from You Stink braved rain and volunteered to help clean it on Sunday,
which could revive the anti-government campaign in the country. In September,
the government approved an emergency plan devised by Agriculture Minister Akram
Shehayyeb and a team of experts which calls for waste management to be turned
over to municipalities in 18 months, the setting of two “sanitary landfills” in
Akkar and the Bekaa, and the reopening for seven days of the controversial
Naameh landfill south of Beirut.
Rain produces rivers of trash in Lebanese capital
By AFP, Beirut Sunday, 25 October
2015/Streets in parts of Lebanon turned into rivers of garbage on Sunday as
heavy rains washed through mountains of trash that have piled up during a
months-long waste collection crisis. Residents and activists posted photographs
and video online showing water from torrential showers carrying accumulated
waste down streets in the early morning outside Beirut and beyond. VIEW MORE:
Video shows ‘rivers of rubbish’ in Lebanon On the edge of the capital, activists
from the “You Stink” campaign, which has protested the government’s failure to
solve the crisis, collected and sorted garbage that was washed into the Beirut
river. And elsewhere, residents and municipal workers used bulldozers to push
dispersed trash back into piles after the rains stopped. The scenes come three
months into a crisis precipitated by the closure of Lebanon’s largest landfill
in July, and the government’s failure to find an alternative. The crisis sparked
a protest movement led by the “You Stink” activist group, which brought
thousands of people into the streets for several weeks of demonstrations. The
cabinet in early September approved a plan that involved finding new sites for
landfills and temporarily reopening the closed Naameh site for the immediate
disposal of already-accumulated waste. But the plan has run into a series of
obstacles, including the refusal of residents around Naameh to allow its
reopening and protests by people living near prospective new landfill sites.
Activists and several ministers have long warned that the arrival of winter,
which often brings heavy rains to Lebanon, risked dispersing months worth of
trash that has accumulated in open dumps. “You Stink” activists wearing
protective suits and facemasks sorted trash that had washed into the Beirut
river from piles where it has been dumped along its banks on Sunday.“We are
proud to be ‘waste workers’ in this country, for trash, corruption, and the
corrupt,” the group wrote on its Facebook page. It accused Lebanon’s politicians
of doing nothing “while the country drowns in their trash as a result of
rampant, criminal corruption and inaction.”
Environment
Minister Blames 'Political Forces' for Growing Trash Crisis
Naharnet/October 26/15/Environment Minister Mohammed al-Mashnouq on Sunday
blamed the political forces for the worsening garbage crisis in the country,
after heavy rains turned streets in parts of Lebanon into rivers of trash.
Mashnouq reminded that he had asked the council of ministers two months ago to
“declare an environmental state of emergency in Lebanon, out of fear of the
possible fallout from the garbage crisis, whose solutions are still being
obstructed by the political forces.” “The political forces did not heed my
repeated appeals and today we are facing the situation that we had warned of,”
the minister added. He cautioned that the country will witness “unlimited
threats from the disaster if the political forces do not take an immediate
positive stance.” Noting that “Prime Minister Tammam Salam and Agriculture
Minister Akram Shehayyeb have spared no effort to address the problem,” Mashnouq
warned that “the political forces' obstacles are leading Lebanon into the
unknown.”Mashnouq had on August 31 suspended his participation in a ministerial
panel addressing the crisis amid massive street protests sparked by the trash
collection problem. Civil society activists have voiced repeated calls for the
minister's resignation since the eruption of the unprecedented crisis on July
17. After Mashnouq suspended his role in the waste management file, Salam tasked
Shehayyeb and a team of experts with finding a solution to the garbage
collection problem. An emergency plan devised by Shehayyeb and his team was
approved by the government in September. It calls for waste management to be
turned over to municipalities in 18 months, the setting of two “sanitary
landfills” in Akkar and the Bekaa, and the reopening for seven days of the
controversial Naameh landfill south of Beirut. Shehayyeb's proposals were met by
angry protests by residents and activists in the regions that were cited in his
plan. Fresh protests were organized Sunday in downtown Beirut and outside
Salam's residence in Msaitbeh after heavy rains caused floodwaters to mix with
mounds of uncollected garbage, raising public health concerns. There are fears
the uncollected waste and the rain season could spread diseases such as cholera
among the population.
Abou Faour Says Shehayyeb to 'Expose' Obstructors if Waste
Plan Not Implemented
Naharnet/October 26/15/Health Minister Wael Abou Faour warned Sunday that the
arrival of the rain season will further exacerbate the garbage crisis' health
risks, noting that Agriculture Minister Akram Shehayyeb will “expose”
obstructors if his emergency waste management plan does not get underway soon.
“Minister Shehayyeb will conduct a final round of deliberations and he will
expose facts if the plan does not get implemented soon,” Abou Faour said. “We
have reached the disaster that we had long warned about and the health risks
have increased, especially in the long term, due to the expected precipitation,”
the minister cautioned, stressing that “the priority is for re-collecting the
trash that was scattered” by Sunday's heavy rains. Abou Faour also noted that
his ministry will have to carry out a lot of measures to “avoid the worse,”
warning of the “health and environmental hazards” and “the impact on water and
crops.”Earlier in the day, heavy rains caused floodwaters to mix with mounds of
uncollected garbage, raising public health concerns. There are fears the
uncollected waste and the rain season could spread diseases such as cholera
among the population. The country has been in the grip of a months-long trash
crisis caused by the government shutting down the country's main landfill in
Naameh without finding an alternative. Political bickering and the refusal of
various municipalities to accept Beirut's trash has prolonged the crisis. The
crisis has ignited mass protests against the government, which has failed to
provide a number of basic services and is widely seen as corrupt and
dysfunctional. Activists from the You Stink movement, which has been leading the
protests, shared videos on their Facebook page of plastic trash bags and other
garbage floating down a narrow street lined with cars. The Beirut River, where
garbage had been piling up on the banks for months, resembled an open sewer.
Activists from You Stink braved rain and volunteered to help clean it on Sunday,
which could revive the anti-government campaign in the country. In September,
the government approved an emergency plan devised by Shehayyeb and a team of
experts which calls for waste management to be turned over to municipalities in
18 months, the setting of two “sanitary landfills” in Akkar and the Bekaa, and
the reopening for seven days of the controversial Naameh landfill south of
Beirut.
Working Children Given a Path Off Lebanon's Streets
Naharnet/October 26/15/For two years, Syrian teenager Ibrahim scraped together a
paltry living selling lottery tickets and tissues on the crowded streets of
Beirut, but that seems like a lifetime ago now. The 18-year-old's life turned
around after three months' training at a flower shop as part of an
apprenticeship program for vulnerable Lebanese and Syrian youths organized by an
international humanitarian group. "Among the flowers, I forget what happened to
us. I forget our worries," Ibrahim said, gently arranging a bouquet. He was one
of 24 Syrian and Lebanese youths who took part in a training scheme organized by
the International Rescue Committee (IRC) that took them off the streets and
provided them with a small stipend. IRC requested that the names of youths be
changed for this story. At a flower shop in the Cola district of the Lebanese
capital, Ibrahim has learned how to clean and water flowers, then arrange them
into beautifully designed bouquets. "It really boosted my morale learning the
basics of flower arrangement," he said quietly. "In the streets, I used to hear
really bad things. But here, I've learned mutual respect and a new trade." At
least 1,510 children, three-quarters of them Syrian, live or work in the streets
of Lebanon, according to a report by UN agencies, NGOs and Lebanon's labor
ministry published this year. The report's authors said the real number of
children on the streets could be up to three times higher than that.At least 43
percent of those on the street beg for money, and 37 percent sell small items,
like tissue paper or chewing gum. Others carry grocery bags, shine shoes or
operate small parking lots, with most making between $3 and $12 daily. A number
are exploited in illicit or illegal professions -- including prostitution --
earning between $21 and $36 per day. Whatever their job, working and living on
the street exposes children to danger and exploitation, including street
accidents and sexual assault, according to experts. IRC's Sara Mabger said the
apprenticeship project sought to "give street youth an opportunity to learn a
specific skill that will help them in their life, but also to minimize their
hours of working in the streets".Lebanon hosts more than one million Syrian
refugees, many living in poverty and forced to send their children to work to
make ends meet. Raed, 16, arrived from Syria's second city Aleppo with his
family three years ago. He once shined shoes or sold things along the Beirut
waterfront for cash to help support his father and five younger siblings, who
live in the impoverished Shatila Palestinian refugee camp. But in the program,
he also learned to tend flowers, at a shop in the Jnah area of Beirut, and now
he imagines one day owning his own storefront. "I memorized all the names of the
flowers, and I like chrysanthemums and liliums the best," he said with a smile
as he sprayed rows of greenery sitting on shelves in the shop. "I hope that when
I return to Syria, I can open my own flower shop." Local clothing stores, sweet
shops, and cafes have taken part in the initiative. Fadi Jaber, the 36-year-old
manager of Jaber Flowers, said IRC proposed he take in Raed "to take him off the
street and teach him the basics of the business, and we welcomed the idea." "If
he wants to work in this field, he will return to his own country with a trade,
instead of wasting his future in the street," Jaber added. The program caters to
Lebanese youth too, including 20-year-old Assaad, from a poor district of the
northern city of Tripoli. He has apprenticed at a modest bakery in central
Beirut, helping to prepare bread for a steady stream of customers. "I learned
how to prepare the dough, how much salt you should use, and how to lay the bread
out after baking," he said. "Working here is better than staying at home or
being in the street."The man he is learning from is 30-year-old Syrian Qassem
Mohammad, who owns the bakery and has lived in Lebanon for many years. "I left
Syria when I was young, but I found someone who gave me an opportunity. And in
turn, I wanted to give this opportunity to someone who needs it," Mohammad said.
Although there is no guarantee participants will stay off Lebanon's streets, the
organizers hope to receive enough funding to support those who want to continue
training. And for many, like Raed, the choice is clear. "I swore I would never
go back to the street again," he said.
Report: LF-FPM to Continue Efforts to Reach United Stand on
Legislative Session
Naharnet/October 26/15/The Lebanese Forces and Free Patriotic Movement will
continue their contacts to reach a united stance on the upcoming legislative
session, reported the daily An Nahar on Sunday. LF chief Samir Geagea and Change
and Reform bloc MP Ibrahim Kanaan had held talks to that end on Saturday. The
two sides are exerting efforts to reach an agreement over the “legislation of
necessity,” which is advocated by the FPM, revealed an informed source to An
Nahar. “The legislation of necessity deals with major national issues such as
the parliamentary electoral law and the law on restoring nationality and we are
willing to discuss other issues that fall under this criteria,” Kanaan had
explained on Tuesday after the Change and Reform bloc's weekly meeting. The
source added that the LF and FPM have not changed their position on attending or
not attending the legislative session, saying that it hinges on whether
“legislation of necessity will be adopted.”
“Cabs turning away guide dogs a
rampant problem in Toronto: Advocate,”
Gilbert Ngabo, Toronto Metro News, October 19, 2015/Kaye Leslie can’t count the
number of times she’s hailed a Toronto cab and been turned away. “I once had a
guy drive off quickly as I was getting into the car,” she said. “It’s very
upsetting and quite dangerous.”
Leslie, an advocate with The Seeing Eye who has limited vision, said cabbies
refusing to pick up people with guide dogs are a problem running rampant in the
city. “It’s like saying, ‘Sorry I don’t take blacks or women,’” she said. “If
you can’t accommodate people you shouldn’t be driving a cab.” A leader at one
cab company is promising to hit the streets for a solution. Kristine Hubbard,
operations manager at Beck Taxi, has promised to team up and test the waters
first-hand with a woman who says she was turned away multiple times. The pair
intends to carry out a sting the next time Ann Gallery visits the city. Gallery
complained to Beck — along with Uber and Diamond Taxi — after being turned away
by cabs because she was accompanied by her guide dog in training, Maddie.
Gallery, who’s from B.C., said she’s had no response from Diamond, and Beck has
been able to track down the driver who gave her the snub. Uber, meanwhile, has
fired the person responsible…
Palestinian girl shot dead
trying to stab Israeli police
By AFP, Jerusalem Sunday, 25 October 2015/A Palestinian girl was shot dead by
Israeli border police on Sunday when she attempted to stab officers in the
southern West Bank city of Hebron, police said. “A Palestinian woman acting
suspiciously approached border police forces. She was requested to identify
herself when she suddenly drew a knife and approached the forces yelling. The
forces shot at her and neutralised her,” a police statement said. Police later
pronounced the Palestinian dead and identified her as 17-year-old Dania Irshaid.
Police said none of their forces were harmed in the attack, which took place
near the shrine known to Jews as the Cave of the Patriarchs and to Muslims as
the Ibrahimi Mosque. However several witnesses disputed the official version of
events. One of them, Abdu Khader, said he was only metres (yards) away when he
saw Irshaid approach the checkpoint, wearing a white headscarf. “She presented
her backpack to soldiers who proceeded to search it,” he told AFP. “I heard them
calling her and saying ‘Where is the knife? Where is the knife?’ She took a step
back but there were a dozen soldiers behind her. They shot seven or eight
times,” he said.Raed Abu Rmileh posted a video on YouTube which shows the body
of a woman clad in black lying on the ground surrounded by uniformed officers,
her white headscarf covered in blood. “She was at the checkpoint. A soldier
called her to go through her bag. She put her bag on the ground and then we
heard shooting. The soldiers said she had a knife” but no weapon is visible in
the video, he told AFP. The Palestinian-led International Solidarity Movement
said it had collected eyewitness accounts saying the same thing: that she had
first been shot in the legs, that she tried to walk backwards with her hands in
the air, but that she was killed with seven or eight shots. Police maintained
their version of events, and said they had recovered a knife at the scene. The
flashpoint city of Hebron has been the site of several attacks against Israeli
security forces and settlers in the recent wave of violence. In September the
army was forced to defend itself over questions swirling around the death of an
18-year-old Palestinian woman in Hebron they said had tried to stab a soldier
when she was shot. Activists distributed photos purporting to show the fully
veiled woman with no knife visible at the checkpoint. The pictures however do
not capture the moment of the shooting and no firm conclusion can be drawn from
them. The Israeli military maintained its initial version of events and local
media published a photo distributed by the military of a knife on the ground
that the woman allegedly used.
Washington ‘to cut aid’ to Palestinian Authority
AFP, Amman Sunday, 25 October 2015/The United States is cutting economic aid for
the Palestinian Authority, partly because of "unhelpful actions" by the
Palestinians, a U.S. diplomat said on Saturday. News site al-Monitor earlier
said the U.S. State Department intends to reduce aid for the West Bank and Gaza
in fiscal 2016 from $370 million to $290 million. A U.S. State Department
official, travelling with Secretary of State John Kerry on a trip to Amman,
confirmed there would be a cut. "The decision to reduce assistance to the
Palestinian Authority was made this past spring," he told reporters. "There were
several factors contributing to this decision, including unhelpful actions taken
by the Palestinians and constraints on our global assistance budget."The cut was
not directly linked to the wave of violence that is currently gripping Israel
and the Palestinian territories, the official said.
The source added, however, "we have made clear our concern about inflammatory
rhetoric over these past few weeks".Al-Monitor, which was quoted by the Israeli
newspaper Haaretz, said the cut followed mounting criticism in the U.S. Congress
about Palestinian "incitement". Kerry was in Amman on Saturday where he held
talks with Jordan's King Abdullah II and Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas on how
to brake the latest bloodletting. The visit is part of a diplomatic scramble to
defuse tensions many fear could herald a new intifada, or Palestinian uprising.
Kerry lays out steps to ease Israeli-Palestinian strife
By Reuters Amman/Jerusalem Sunday, 25 October 2015/The United States on Saturday
proposed steps, including 24-hour video surveillance, to end weeks of violence
over a Jerusalem site holy to Muslims and Jews. Speaking in Amman after meeting
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Jordan’s King Abdullah, U.S. Secretary
of State John Kerry said Israel had embraced “an excellent suggestion” by the
king, who is the custodian of the site within Jerusalem’s walled Old City, for
round-the-clock monitoring. Kerry said Israel had also given assurances it had
no intention of changing the status quo at the al-Aqsa mosque compound that is
the third holiest site in Islam. Muslims refer to the site as the Noble
Sanctuary, or Haram al-Sharif, Jews call it Temple Mount. In a detailed
statement, Netanyahu said Israel recognized “the importance of the Temple Mount
to peoples of all three monotheistic faiths... and reaffirms its commitment to
upholding unchanged the status quo of the Temple Mount, in word and in
practice.” He echoed Kerry’s statement that Israel would enforce its
long-standing policy under which Muslims may pray at the site but Jews,
Christians and members of other faiths may only visit but not pray, and that
Israel had no intention of dividing up the compound. Kerry said that Israeli and
Jordanian officials would meet soon to work out the details of the video
monitoring. Authorities from both Israel and the Jordanian waqf, or Islamic
trust, that administers the site, will also meet shortly “to strengthen security
arrangements” at the compound, he said. Netanyahu said Israel welcomed greater
coordination with the waqf. Violence has flared in Israel, Jerusalem, the
occupied West Bank and the Gaza Strip in recent weeks, in part triggered by
Palestinians’ anger over what they see as Jewish encroachment on the compound.
At least 52 Palestinians, half of whom Israel says were assailants, have been
shot dead by Israelis in the West Bank and Gaza since Oct. 1. Nine Israelis have
been stabbed or shot dead by Palestinians. In the latest incident, a Palestinian
was shot dead on Saturday after he tried to stab an Israeli security guard at a
crossing between the West Bank and Israel, Israeli police said. “Today I hope we
can begin to turn the page on this very difficult period,” Kerry said, standing
beside Jordanian Foreign Minister Nasser Judeh, who welcomed his
announcements.Netanyahu said Israel respected the “importance of the special
role” played by Jordan as reflected in the 1994 peace treaty between the two
countries and of the “historical role” of Jordan’s King Abdullah as custodian of
the site.
“PROVOCATIONS”
A U.S. official told reporters it had not yet been decided who exactly would
conduct video monitoring of the site, saying this would be discussed by Israeli
and Jordanian technical officials when they meet. An Israeli official who
declined to be named, said: “Israel has an interest in placing cameras across
the Temple Mount in order to refute the claims that it is changing the status
quo. “We are interested in showing that the provocations are not coming from the
Israeli side,” he added. Standing beside Jordanian Foreign Minister Nasser Judeh
in Amman, Kerry said the cameras “could really be a game-changer in discouraging
anybody from disturbing the sanctity” of the site. In addition to the shooting
of the Palestinian at the West Bank crossing, a 25-year-old Palestinian
protester died of wounds he suffered last week when he was shot by Israeli
troops during a border clash near the Gazan town of Khan Younis, a Gaza health
official said. On Friday, Israeli authorities lifted restrictions that had
banned men aged under 40 from praying at al-Aqsa, a move seen as a bid to ease
Muslim anger. Palestinians are also frustrated by the failure of numerous rounds
of peace talks to secure them an independent state. The last round of
negotiations collapsed in 2014. From Amman, Kerry flew to Riyadh, where he met
King Salman of Saudi Arabia and other senior officials. Those talks were
expected to focus on efforts to end Syria’s four-year civil war and on the
crisis in Yemen, where Saudi Arabia has led an Arab military intervention since
March to try to restore President Abd-Rabbu Mansour Hadi’s government and fend
off what it sees as creeping Iranian influence
Netanyahu: Al-Aqsa
surveillance cameras in ‘Israel’s interest’
By AFP, Jerusalem Sunday, 25 October 2015/Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu said Sunday that an agreement to put 24-hour security cameras around
Jerusalem’s sensitive Al-Aqsa mosque compound was in Israel’s interest. In
remarks relayed by his office Netanyahu said the cameras would serve “firstly,
to refute the claim Israel is violating the status quo (and) secondly, to show
where the provocations are really coming from, and prevent them in advance.”
Israel has been accused of seeking to change longstanding rules that govern the
holy site which is revered in both Islam and Judaism, and which is a key source
of tensions between Israelis and Palestinians. Tensions raised over clashes at
the mosque compound, known as Temple Mount to Jews, have spiralled into a wave
of daily knife attacks and shootings on Israelis as well as deadly protests.
Netanyahu also repeated that Israel did not plan to change the agreement,
referred to as the status quo, that states non-Muslims are allowed to visit, but
not to pray at the site. U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said after talks
with Jordan’s King Abdullah II -- whose country is the custodian of the site --
that the surveillance measure would be a “game changer in discouraging anybody
from disturbing the sanctity of the holy site.” And Jordan’s Foreign Minister
Nasser Judeh said the cameras “will indeed make a difference and a very strong
difference at that.”“I heard the Jordanian foreign minister’s positive
reaction,” said Netanyahu. “I hope it helps calm things, at least regarding the
Temple Mount.”
Saudi Court Confirms Death
Sentence against Shiite Cleric
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/October 26/15/The Supreme Court in Saudi Arabia
has confirmed the death sentence against Shiite cleric Sheikh Nimr al-Nimr, a
leader of anti-government protests, one of his brothers said on Sunday. "After
the confirmation of Sheikh Nimr's death sentence by the Court of Appeal and then
the Supreme Court, his life is in the hands of King Salman who can endorse the
sentence or suspend the execution," said Mohammed al-Nimr. He warned his
brother's execution "could provoke reactions that we do not want," as Sheikh
Nimr had "supporters in the Shiite areas of the Islamic world."Mohammed al-Nimr
said he expected the king to "prove his wisdom" by halting the execution of his
brother and six other Shiites. Among those sentenced to death, "three, including
my son Ali, were minors at the time of arrest" for involvement in
anti-government protests that erupted in the Eastern Province in the wake of the
Arab Spring, he told AFP. The case of Ali al-Nimr, in particular, has aroused
strong reactions around the world, with many asking the Saudi authorities to
grant the young Shiite a stay the execution. Iran, the arch-foe of Saudi Arabia,
on Sunday warned Riyadh not to execute the cleric. "The execution of Sheikh Nimr
would have dire consequences for Saudi Arabia," said Deputy Foreign Minister
Hossein Amir Abdollahian. "The situation in Saudi Arabia is not good and
provocative and tribal attitudes against its own citizens are not in the
government's interests," he said in a statement. Sheikh Nimr had called in 2009
for separating the Eastern Province's Shiite-populated Qatif and al-Ihsaa
governorates from Saudi Arabia and uniting them with Shiite-majority Bahrain.
Last year a special court in Riyadh sentenced him to death for "sedition,"
"disobedience" and "bearing arms." Saudi Arabia's estimated two million Shiites,
who frequently complain of marginalization, live mostly in the east, where the
vast majority of the OPEC kingpin's huge oil reserves lie.
An Israeli Arab flies
paraglider into Syria to join ISIS without being intercepted
DEBKAfile Special Report October 25, 2015
In a major security breach, an Israeli Arab, 23, was able to fly by paraglider
across into Syria from the southwestern village of Mevo Hama Saturday, Oct. 24,
southwestern Golan without being intercepted - although an IDF spotter had
reported the event. The pilot came from the Israeli Arab town of Jaljuliya east
of Kfar Saba near the West Bank. His defection, apparently to the Islamic State,
was clearly organized in advance. His landing in Syria was secured by a party
from the jihadist group who came to pick him up.
The massive air-and-ground search operation the Israeli military scrambled came
too late.
“We believe he planned this move to the other side, and joined a group there,"
Brig.-Gen. Moti Almoz told reporters during a conference call Sunday morning,
after a gag order on the story was lifted. Another IDF statement said that
Israeli forces are still trying to ascertain the person's intentions
debkafile’s military sources count this event as a particularly grave security
lapse for the following reasons:
1. The Shin Bet was clearly taken unawares of a conspiracy for the Israeli
Arab’s flight.
2. No one discovered that a paraglider was being assembled in secret at Mevo
Hama or had it brought there unnoticed. And who helped him launch it?
3. How did he set up communication with ISIS-Syria without being detected by
Israeli security?
4. How did the preparations on the Syrian side to receive the pilot escape the
attention of IDF military intelligence?
5. Why was no one on the spot authorized to shoot the paraglider shot down
before it flew across the border? By the time the report went through channels,
the bird had flown.
ISIS claims it has taken an “Israeli pilot” captive.
Our military sources add that the paraglider operation was set up by a hostile
element to test Israel’s defenses in three areas:
The efficiency of IDF spotter posts across the Golan. The glider was indeed
sighted and reported.
Israeli Air force operations in Golan – which were indeed found with holes that
can be used for penetration.
Israel’s air defense on the Golan. This episode exposed the absence of a
commander with authority to act with dispatch to foil an unforeseen event.
In other words, Israel’s defenses were wide open to attack Saturday.
Kerry, in Saudi Arabia,
meets with King Salman
By Staff writer Al Arabiya News Sunday, 25 October 2015/Saudi
Arabia’s King Salman met with U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry as he arrived
in Riyadh on Saturday for talks on recent developments in the
Palestinian-Israeli conflict and the Syrian war, the Saudi Press Agency
reported. Crown Prince Mohammed bin Nayef and Saudi Foreign Minister Adel Al-Jubeir
had met with Kerry before he made his way to the Dhiraya Farm, the king's
country residence. Washington and Riyadh are part of a U.S.-led coalition that
last year launched an air campaign targeting the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria
(ISIS) militant group which controls swathes of territory in Syria and
neighboring Iraq. The Saudi talks follow a meeting Friday in Vienna between
Kerry and the foreign ministers of Russia, Turkey and Saudi Arabia on ways to
end the Syria conflict. But the Vienna talks failed to make any breakthrough and
Kerry said at the time he hoped to reconvene another "broader" meeting on Syria
as early as October 30.
Lavrov and Kerry discuss Syria, chance of political
solution
Reuters, Moscow Sunday, 25 October 2015/Russia’s Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov
and U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry discussed the Syria crisis during a phone
conversation on Sunday requested by the United States, Russia’s Foreign Ministry
said in a statement. The ministry added that Lavrov and Kerry had continued
their discussions on the prospects for a political resolution of the Syria
crisis with the involvement of the Syrian authorities and "patriotic
opposition", supported by the international community.
Saudi, Egypt have ‘similar’ stance on Syria
Staff writer, Al Arabiya News Sunday, 25 October 2015/Saudi Foreign Minister
Adel Jubair said on Sunday both Cairo and Riyadh have a “similar” stance on
Syria during his visit to Egypt, Al Arabiya News Channel reported. In a joint
press conference with his Egyptian counterpart, Jubair reiterated Saudi stance
that there is “no place” for embattled Syrian President Bashar al-Assad in a
future and post-civil war Syria. Egypt’s Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry said
there were “no differences” between Riyadh and Cairo on Syria and emphasized
that they both have a “similar” position. Jubair's statement comes after his
comments on Thursday saying that Assad's clinging to power is working as a
“magnet” by allowing foreign militants to recruit more fighters, and he must go
to rid Syria of ISIS. Meanwhile, the foreign minister said international talks
to find a solution to the conflict in Syria had yielded some progress but more
consultations were required. “I believe that there has been some progress and
positions have moved closer on finding a solution to the Syrian crisis, but I
cannot say that we have reached an agreement. We still need more consultations
... to reach this point," he told a news conference in Cairo after meeting his
Egyptian counterpart. Moscow says Assad must be part of any political transition
and that the Syrian people will decide who rules them. Washington has said it
could tolerate Assad during a short transition period, but that he would then
have to then exit the political stage. In a flurry of diplomatic activity around
the Syria crisis, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry visited Riyadh on Saturday
and the two countries agreed to boost support for Syria’s moderate opposition
while seeking a political resolution to the four-year-old conflict.(With
Reuters)
No election talks, Assad wants to defeat ‘terrorists’
Staff writer, Al Arabiya News Sunday, 25 October 2015/“The elimination of
terrorist groups would lead to a political solution sought by Syria and Russia,
President Bashar al-Assad said on Sunday during a meeting with a Russian
delegation in the capital Damascus, Syrian state media reported. State news
agency SANA’s initial report on the meeting made no mention of a proposal
floated by Russia for new presidential and parliamentary elections. “Eliminating
the terrorist organizations will lead to the political solution that we strive
for in Syria and Russia,” Assad was quoted as saying. Assad also expressed his
appreciation for Russian air strikes. His comments came during talks with a
Russian parliamentary delegation visiting Damascus just days after Assad went to
Moscow for talks with President Vladimir Putin. Assad said Russia's role was
“writing a new history because this war will determine the future of the region
and the world, and victory against terrorism will protect not only Syria but all
countries.” Earlier the Russian news agency RIA cited a lawmaker who attended
the meeting as saying Assad was ready to take part in presidential elections if
the Syrian people supported the idea. “He [Assad] is ready to conduct elections
with the participation of all political forces who want Syria to prosper,”
Russian lawmaker Alexander Yushchenko said by phone after meeting Assad. A
Russia lawmaker who met Assad on Sunday said the embattled Syrian leader’s
priority was to fight and defeat terrorism and then hold parliamentary and
presidential elections. Asked whether Assad was ready for early elections,
Sergey Gavrilov said his impression from Assad was that “the first aim (is) the
struggle with and victory over ... terrorism, and after that the elections -
parliamentary and president elections.” Gavrilov was speaking in English to
Reuters in Damascus. Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, in an interview
broadcast on Saturday, called for Syria to prepare for both presidential and
parliamentary elections. (With Reuters and AFP)
Erdogan: We won't let Kurds ‘seize’ northern Syria
By Humeyra Pamuk, Reuters Sunday, 25 October 2015/Turkish President Tayyip
Erdogan accused Kurdish groups on Saturday of trying to grab control of northern
Syria, saying Ankara would not allow this to happen. In a speech in southeast
Turkey, Erdogan also blasted Russia's President Vladimir Putin for hosting
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad earlier this week, in comments that were his
most critical yet towards his Russian counterpart. On northern Syria, Erdogan
denounced the merging of the Syrian town of Tel Abyad last week into an
autonomous political structure created by the Kurds. "All they want is to seize
northern Syria entirely," Erdogan said. "We will under no circumstances allow
northern Syria to become a victim of their scheming. Because this constitutes a
threat for us, and it is not possible for us as Turkey to say 'yes' to this
threat."Tel Abyad, on the border with Turkey, was captured in June from ISIS by
Kurdish YPG militia with help from U.S.-led air strikes. Last week, a local
leadership council declared it part of the system of autonomous self government
established by the Kurds. Syrian Kurds have established three autonomous zones,
or "cantons", across northern Syria since the civil war broke out in 2011. They
deny aiming to establish their own state. Turkey is alarmed by territorial gains
for the Kurds in Syria's civil war, which it fears could stir separatism among
its own Kurdish minority. For the past three decades Ankara has been trying to
end an insurgency by fighters of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), which is
classified as a terrorist organization by the United States and European Union.
The PKK has been staging almost daily attacks in the southeast since July, when
a ceasefire fell apart. Turkey accuses the Syrian Kurds' political arm, the PYD,
of deep links to the PKK. It has been incensed by the role the Kurds have carved
out for themselves, with U.S. support, in the fight against ISIS in northern
Syria. Erdogan also slammed countries who provided assistance to the PYD,
although he did not name them, and said it harbored 1,400 PKK members. Earlier
this month, the YPG Kurdish militia announced a new alliance with small groups
of Arab fighters, and the group was air-dropped small arms and ammunition by
U.S. forces in northeast Syria. Washington has indicated it could direct funding
and weapons to Arab commanders on the ground who cooperate with the YPG. Erdogan
also criticized Putin for hosting Assad in Moscow earlier this week, questioning
how he could "welcome on a red carpet someone who has spilled the blood of
370,000 people".Assad flew to Moscow on Tuesday evening to thank Putin for his
military support, his first foreign visit since the start of the Syrian crisis
in 2011.The surprise trip came three weeks after Russia launched a campaign of
air strikes against Islamist militants and rebels in Syria that has bolstered
Assad's forces.
Libya finds 29 bodies of
apparent migrants on beach
By AFP, Tripoli Sunday, 25 October 2015/The bodies of 29 people
thought to be migrants have been discovered on beaches around a city 160
kilometres (100 miles) east of Tripoli, the Red Crescent said. “Local residents
told us about bodies on the beaches around Zliten,” spokesman Mohamed al-Misrati
said. “We discovered 25 bodies, then another four.” Misrati did not give any
further details about the nationality of the deceased, but the Tripoli
authorities’ official news agency reported that they were from Africa. The Red
Crescent was expecting to recover several more bodies this Sunday, the press
agency quoted Misrati as saying. The North African country, with its 1,770
kilometres of poorly patrolled coastline, is a popular jumping off point for
migrants seeking to reach Europe. The most popular destination is the Italian
island of Lampedusa, barely 300 kilometres away.
Assad: 'Eradicating
Terror' Will Produce Political Deal
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/October 26/15/Syrian President Bashar Assad said
Sunday his country must "eradicate terrorism" to find a political solution to
its civil war, as he reportedly expressed a willingness to hold new elections.
Meeting with a Russian parliamentary delegation as Moscow steps up efforts for a
political deal, Assad emphasized the need for greater security. "The eradication
of terrorist organizations will lead to the political solution that Syria and
Russia seek and that will satisfy the Syrian people and preserve Syria's
sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity," state news agency SANA
quoted Assad as saying. The visit by Russian lawmakers came just days after
Assad's own surprise trip to Moscow for talks with President Vladimir Putin.
That trip -- and ramped-up Russian diplomacy following it -- have led to
speculation that Moscow is pushing for a new political agreement to end the
conflict that began with protests against Assad's rule in March 2011. But the
shape of any such deal remains unclear, with Syria's opposition firmly against
Moscow leading peace efforts while pursuing an air campaign it launched in
support of Assad on September 30. A member of the Russian delegation said Sunday
that Assad had expressed a willingness to hold new parliamentary and
presidential elections, and would run again as president. "He is ready to
conduct elections with the participation of all political forces who want Syria
to prosper," Russian lawmaker Alexander Yushchenko told AFP by phone from
Damascus.Assad said he was ready to take part in the polls "if the people are
not against it," Yushchenko added.
Opposition dismisses new vote
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said on Saturday that Syria needed to
begin preparing for new elections. Syria last held parliamentary elections in
May 2012, and is due to hold its next legislative vote in 2016.But a
presidential vote was held just in June last year, with Assad re-elected for a
seven-year term with 88.7 percent of the vote. That election was dismissed as a
"farce" by the opposition and its supporters, with voting held only in
government-controlled areas and millions of the displaced and refugees unable to
vote. It is unclear whether new elections could be held under different
circumstances, and Syria's opposition has already said holding a vote now would
be absurd. "The Russians are ignoring the real facts on the ground, with
millions who have been displaced inside and outside Syria, where cities are
destroyed every day," said Samir Nashar of the Syrian National Coalition
opposition group. "What elections are they talking about holding under such
circumstances?"Rebel forces were equally dismissive of Lavrov's offer Saturday
of Russian support for "patriotic" opposition forces fighting against the
Islamic State group. While Russia says its aerial campaign launched last month
is targeting IS and other "terrorists," moderate and Islamist rebels say they
have been the real focus, not the jihadists. "Russia is bombing the Free Syrian
Army and now it wants to cooperate with us?" said Lieutenant Colonel Ahmad Saoud,
a spokesman for Division 13, a Western-backed rebel group.
HRW urges Russia investigate raid
Russia's strikes have allowed Syrian regime forces to launch ground operations
in several provinces, including Aleppo, where clashes continued on Sunday. The
Syrian Observatory for Human Rights monitor said some 43 regime forces and 28 IS
fighters had been killed in the last 48 hours in the province, fighting for
control of a key government supply route cut by the jihadists on Friday.
Elsewhere, the Observatory said Russian war planes had carried out strikes in
Hama province, where Syrian regime forces are trying to secure part of the
Aleppo-Damascus highway. Human Rights Watch meanwhile urged Russia on Sunday to
investigate two air strikes in Homs province that killed 59 civilians earlier
this month. The group said the two strikes on October 15 were believed to be
Russian and had killed at least 32 children. And in Israel, the army said an
Arab Israeli had crossed into Syria using a paraglider, apparently intending to
join opposition forces. The army said the man had taken off from the southern
section of the Israeli-occupied Golan Heights, adjacent to southern Syria. Some
45 Arab Israelis have joined jihadist forces in Syria, according to Israel's
Shin Bet internal security agency.
Turkey says won't let
Kurds ‘seize’ northern Syria
By Humeyra Pamuk Reuters, Istanbul Saturday, 25 October
2015/Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan accused Kurdish groups on Saturday of
trying to grab control of northern Syria, and said Ankara would not allow this
to happen. In a speech in southeast Turkey, Erdogan denounced the merging of the
Syrian town of Tel Abyad last week into an autonomous political structure
created by the Kurds. "All they want is to seize northern Syria entirely,"
Erdogan said. "We will under no circumstances allow northern Syria to become a
victim of their scheming. Because this constitutes a threat for us, and it is
not possible for us as Turkey to say 'yes' to this threat."Turkey is alarmed by
territorial gains for the Kurds in Syria's civil war, which it fears could stir
separatism among its own Kurdish minority. Tel Abyad, on the border with Turkey,
was captured in June from Islamic State of Iraq and Syria group militants by
Kurdish YPG militia with help from U.S.-led air strikes. Last week, a local
leadership council declared it part of the system of autonomous self-government
established by the Kurds. Syrian Kurds have established three autonomous zones,
or "cantons', across northern Syria since the civil war broke out in 2011. They
deny aiming to establish their own state. The YPG's capture of Tel Abyad linked
up the Kurdish-controlled canton of Kobane, which was besieged by Islamic State
last year, with the bigger canton of Jazeera, which is further east and borders
Iraq. Turkey has for the past three decades been trying to end an insurgency by
fighters of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK), which is classified as a
terrorist organization by the United States and European Union. The PKK has been
staging almost daily attacks in the southeast since July, when a ceasefire fell
apart. Ankara accuses the Syrian Kurds' political arm, the PYD, of deep links to
the PKK. It has been incensed by the role the Kurds have carved out for
themselves, with U.S. support, in the fight against Islamic State in northern
Syria. Erdogan also slammed countries who provided assistance to the PYD,
although he did not name them. "Right now there are 1,400 PKK members in PYD.
There is no point ignoring this, this is a fact," said Erdogan. "But all these
countries who seem friendly towards us are trying to make this look the opposite
way. Whatever arms assistance they (PYD) receive, it is coming from these
countries. We know very well whose arms." Earlier this month, the YPG Kurdish
militia announced a new alliance with small groups of Arab fighters, and the
group was air-dropped small arms and ammunition by U.S. forces in northeast
Syria. Washington has indicated it could direct funding and weapons to Arab
commanders on the ground who cooperate with the YPG.
‘I apologize:’ Tony Blair admits Iraq war mistakes
By Staff writer, Al Arabiya News Sunday, 25 October 2015/Former
British Prime Minister Tony Blair has apologized for aspects of the Iraq war in
an upcoming television interview, British media reported Sunday. His comments,
in a yet-to-be-aired interview CNN that has been reported by the Mail on Sunday,
have prompted allegations of an attempted "spin" ahead of the release of
Britain’s Iraq war probe – the Chilcot Inquiry. In the interview, Blair
allegedly expressed regret over the failure to adequately plan for the aftermath
of the war in 2003, which saw the toppling of Saddam Hussein.He also reportedly
conceded that the Iraq war was partly to blame for the rise of the Islamic State
of Iraq and Syria (ISIS). Blair also discussed the false intelligence suggesting
the country had weapons of mass destruction, which was used to justify the
invasion. “I apologize for the fact that the intelligence we received was wrong
… I also apologize for some of the mistakes in planning and, certainly, our
mistake in our understanding of what would happen once you removed the regime,”
Blair was quoted by the Mail on Sunday as saying. Blair was asked by CNN host
Fareed Zakaria if the war was "the principal cause" of the rise of ISIS, he was
reported to have said: 'I think there are elements of truth in that.""Of course
you can't say those of us who removed Saddam in 2003 bear no responsibility for
the situation in 2015," he added.
'He's said this before'
Following the report on Blair's apology, a spokeswoman for the former PM was
quoted by The Guardian as saying: “Tony Blair has always apologized for the
intelligence being wrong and for mistakes in planning. He has always also said,
and says again here, that he does not however think it was wrong to remove
Saddam. “He did not say the decision to remove Saddam in 2003 ‘caused ISIS’ and
pointed out that Isis was barely heard of at the end of 2008, when al-Qaeda was
basically beaten. “He went on to say in 2009, Iraq was relatively more stable.
What then happened was a combination of two things: there was a sectarian policy
pursued by the government of Iraq, which were mistaken policies. “But also when
the Arab Spring began, ISIS moved from Iraq into Syria, built themselves from
Syria and then came back into Iraq. “All of this he has said before,” the
spokeswomen added. According to the UK’s ITV News. Nicola Sturgeon, the First
Minister for Scotland has accused Blair of participating in a "spin operation"
to prepare the ground for criticisms that may surface from the Chilcot Inquiry.
Leaked email
Last week, a leaked White House memo allegedly proved that Blair backed military
action a year before seeking a vote in parliament. The revelations focused on a
memo allegedly written by former U.S. secretary of state Colin Powell on March
28, 2002 to then president George Bush a week before the U.S. leader’s meeting
with Blair at his ranch in Crawford, Texas. “On Iraq, Blair will be with us
should military operations be necessary,” wrote Powell, in a document the Mail
on Sunday published on its website. “He is convinced on two points: the threat
is real; and success against Saddam will yield more regional success,” Powell
said, referring to former Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein, who was eventually ousted
in the 2003 US-led invasion. The Mail on Sunday said the memo and other
sensitive documents were part of a batch of secret emails held on the private
server of Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton which U.S. courts
have forced her to reveal. A separate quote from Powell assured Bush “the UK
will follow our lead in the Middle East”, while other statements suggest Blair’s
willingness to present “strategic, tactical and public affairs lines” to
strengthen public support for the Iraq war. Blair, who served as prime minister
between 1997 and 2007, has repeatedly denied rushing to war. Under his
leadership, Britain made the second biggest troop contribution to the Iraq
invasion, and British forces were stationed in the country until 2011. (With
AFP)
Europe split on migrant
crisis ahead of talks
By Reuters Sunday, 25 October 2015/European leaders traded
threats and reprimands on Saturday as thousands more migrants and refugees
streamed into the Balkans on the eve of European Union talks aimed at agreeing
on urgent action to tackle the crisis. Concern is growing about hundreds of
thousands of migrants arriving in Europe, many from war zones in the Middle
East, and camping in western Balkan countries in ever colder conditions as
winter approaches. More than 680,000 migrants and refugees have crossed to
Europe by sea so far this year, fleeing war and poverty in the Middle East,
Africa and Asia, according to the International Organisation for Migration.
Bulgaria, Serbia and Romania said they would close their borders if Germany or
other countries shut the door on refugees, warning they would not let the Balkan
region become a “buffer zone” for stranded migrants. “The three countries, we
are standing ready, if Germany and Austria close their borders, not to allow our
countries to become buffer zones. We will be ready to close borders,” Bulgarian
Prime Minister Boiko Borisov told reporters. European Commission president
Jean-Claude Juncker has invited the leaders of Austria, Bulgaria, Croatia,
Macedonia, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Romania, Serbia and Slovenia to Sunday’s
mini-summit. The aim of the meeting is to agree “common operational conclusions
which could be immediately implemented.”German media have reported that Juncker
will present a 16-point plan, including an undertaking not to send migrants from
one country to another without prior agreement. Slovenia, which said on Friday
it would consider putting up a fence on its border with Croatia unless a
solution is found on Sunday, said the EU “must ease the burden on the most
exposed countries.” It called for “EU action that would stop the uncontrolled
migration flows on the outer borders of the EU.”Almost all the migrants are
entering the EU via its poorer members in south-eastern Europe and heading north
to seek asylum in countries including Germany, Sweden and the Netherlands.
Leaders of the richer Western states worry that large-scale immigration will
boost support for the xenophobic far-right. Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte said
Eastern European countries owe it to their partners to do more to stem the
inflow, and demanded a fairer distribution of asylum seekers among member
states. “Eastern Europe has done too little to resist the refugee stream,” told
public television on Saturday. “We have invested a huge amount in them, and now
they are doing too little.”The EU’s eastern members have resisted calls for
refugees to be divided between the bloc’s 28 members. Hungary’s Prime Minister
Viktor Orban has erected a fence along his country’s southern frontier,
effectively handing the problem on to neighbouring Croatia and Slovenia.
Chancellor Angela Merkel has said Germany must prepare to receive as many as
800,000 refugees this year, despite opposition from some of her governmental
allies. Juncker praised Merkel for ignoring public opinion in her efforts to
tackle the refugee crisis, which she describes as a bigger challenge for Europe
than Greece’s debt woes. “This isn’t about short-term popularity but about
substance,” he told German media group Funke. For exhausted refugees and
migrants making their way across the continent, falling temperatures and
worsening weather are adding to their difficulties. “We want to go to the
Netherlands. I just want this ordeal to stop,” said Hamrein, 20, from Syria, as
she held her feverish six-month-old son near the Slovenian village of Rigonce.
She was among about 2,000 migrants and refugees waiting in a muddy field waiting
to cross to a nearby camp. Many lit fires and wrapped themselves in blankets as
early morning temperatures sank close to zero.
Death toll in Libya anti-peace deal rally shelling hits 12
By AFP Tripoli Sunday, 25 October 2015/The death toll for the shelling of a
rally in Libya’s second city Benghazi protesting against a U.N.-proposed peace
deal has jumped to 12, medics said. At least 12 people died and 39 were wounded
after a volley of shells hit the rally attended by hundreds of people, the LANA
news agency close to the internationally recognised Libyan government reported
Saturday. Those present were demonstrating against a proposed power-sharing deal
put forward by Libya’s U.N. envoy, Bernardino Leon. On their Facebook pages, the
Benghazi Medical Centre announced eight dead, while the city’s Al-Jalaa hospital
announced four had died. Medics initially said five people were killed. There
was no immediate word on who was behind the shelling. Libya descended into chaos
after the October 2011 ouster and killing of longtime dictator Moamer Kadhafi,
with two governments vying for power and armed groups battling for control of
its vast energy resources. A militia alliance including Islamists overran
Tripoli in August 2014, establishing a rival government and a parliament that
forced the internationally recognised administration to flee to the country’s
remote east. On October 8, after almost a year of arduous negotiations, Leon put
forward a list of names to head a power-sharing government, but both sides
rejected the proposed appointments. Friday’s shelling came two days after Leon
insisted he would press on with efforts to clinch a political deal.The U.N.
Support Mission in Libya (UNSMIL) condemned the attack. “UNSMIL calls on Libyans
to reject violence as a means to settle political differences and stresses that
peaceful expression of political views is one of the basic rights in a free
society,” it said. A unity government in Libya is seen as the best chance to
tackle the rise there of the Islamic State of Iraq And Syria (ISIS) group and
migrant-smuggling from Libya across the Mediterranean to Europe. “Only through
unity can terrorism be confronted and violence brought to an end,” UNSMIL added.
Fayez el-Serraj, a member of the internationally recognised parliament who has
been put forward as prime minister in the latest proposal for a unity
government, agreed. “We need to work to overcome our political differences to
stand up, hand in hand... against terrorism,” he said. The Tripoli authorities
also condemned the attack, calling it a “criminal and terrorist act carried out
by those who have been cracking down on Benghazi for a year and a half.” The UN
last month accused the army of Libya’s internationally recognised government of
deliberately trying to sabotage the peace talks with a new offensive in
Benghazi.
5 dead as heavy rains pound Egypt’s Alexandria
By AFP, Cairo Sunday, 25 October 2015/Torrential rains lashed Egypt’s
Mediterranean city of Alexandria Sunday, killing five people, including two
children and the captain of a ship who was trapped in his car by floodwaters,
officials said.A man and two children were electrocuted to death when a cable
from a tramway fell into a street flooded with water, the health ministry said
in a statement. And the captain of a ship drowned as he was unable to get out of
his car which filled with floodwaters. A 25-year-old man was also electrocuted
after he fell into a pit full of electric cables. An AFP photographer said the
downpour began in the early morning and quickly flooded several streets in
Egypt’s second city as well as the corniche. Temperatures dropped sharply on
Sunday across several governorates in Egypt, including Cairo, bringing also
heavy rains and strong winds.
Yemeni forces make gains
in Taiz
Reuters, Dubai Sunday, 25 October 2015/Yemeni forces loyal to the internally
recognized President Abd-Rabbu Mansour Hadi made gains on Sunday in the
southwestern city of Taiz after days of intense battles with Houthi militants, a
local official and residents said. The Iran-backed Haddi supporters, who have
been backed by air strikes from a Saudi-led coalition since March, made
particular progress around the presidential palace, they added, a complex that
has changed hands several times and been largely destroyed by fighting. Medical
sources said 13 Houthi militants had been killed in the fighting in Yemen’s
third largest city as well as eight fighters loyal to Hadi. Reuters could not
independently verify these accounts. The Arab coalition is trying to restore
Hadi’s government and fend off what it sees as creeping Iranian influence. The
Houthis are allied to Iran and also have support from forces loyal to former
president Ali Abdullah Saleh. Several residents said that Hadi loyalists had
managed to wrest control of a number of mountain peaks on the southern approach
to Taiz, long regarded as Yemen’s cultural capital. At least 5,400 people have
been killed in the poorest country on the Arabian Peninsula and the United
Nations says the humanitarian situation, exacerbated by the Saudi-led Arab
blockade of Yemen’s ports, grows worse every day. The United Nations envoy to
Yemen said on Friday he was arranging face-to-face negotiations between the
Yemeni government and Houthi rebels but warned that a disastrous humanitarian
conflict had left most of the country in dire need. The Saudi-led coalition has
gained ground in southern Yemen, but Houthi forces remain in control of much of
the country despite the almost daily air strikes. Hadi’s government has
officially returned to Aden after southern fighters and Arab coalition forces
drove the Houthis out in July. But a suicide attack earlier this month forced
the government to relocate back to Saudi Arabia, while efforts were being made
to restore security to the southern port city. Sudanese forces that arrived in
Aden last week to reinforce Arab coalition troops in the city, have deployed
around the airport and at the city’s four ports, while Hadi supporters have
begun to enforce moves aimed at preventing gunmen from moving around with
weapons. A security official in Aden told Reuters on Sunday that armed tribesmen
raided the central prison in Aden, killing a guard and wounding another, in
order to free a prisoner held for an earlier attack in the city.
What if Russian body bags
start turning up in Moscow?
Mohamed Chebarro/Al Arabiya/October 25/15
Russia’s intervention in Syria has changed the stalemate preferred by all
parties to the crisis.
Yet it is unlikely that this intervention, seen by many as a smart coup by
Moscow against Western and Arab countries opposed to the Syrian regime, will
produce anything conducive to a political settlement. Syrian President Bashar
al-Assad’s words after meeting his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin in Moscow
also indicate that nothing has changed or will change. Anti-Assad strategists
may see no harm in seeing a few downed Russian warplanes to send a message to
Moscow that a settlement means compromise, and that everyone is likely to lose a
bit in order to save what is left of Syria and its people.
Russia’s efforts seem to be focused on propping up Assad for the short term,
though this is disguised as a push to saving the Syrian state. Moscow must
factor in that for its intervention to be fruitful, it must one day be seen as a
potential neutral broker capable of bringing together a mosaic of interests to
the negotiating table. The air campaign so far demonstrates that Russia is
singling out opposition-held areas, not strongholds of the Islamic State of Iraq
and Syria (ISIS). Moscow’s hasty deployment has blocked various plans to
establish no-fly zones in northern and southern Syria. It has also done away
with establishing safe havens to protect Syrians mainly from regime barrel bombs
and ISIS, and to stem the flow of refugees. The clear imbalance created by
Moscow’s deployment is unlikely to be contained unless weapons capable of
clipping Russian wings are given to the opposition.
Military assistance
Countries such as Turkey, Qatar and Saudi Arabia are likely to find themselves
increasingly pressured if Moscow manages to bolster pro-Assad forces to the
extent that its starts to turn the tide in opposition-held areas. So far,
however, nearly a month of continued Russian airstrikes and air cover for
pro-Assad forces have failed to present a clear winning momentum in the fight
against ISIS or the many armed opposition groups. Through the downing of a few
Russian warplanes with surface-to-air missiles, the Kremlin would be sent a
clear message that the Middle East is not Georgia or Ukraine. The first waves of
attacks were halted after heavy casualties suffered by pro-regime forces,
seemingly due to anti-tank guided missiles. The second in command of Iran’s
Revolutionary Guards was killed, as were leaders of the Lebanese Hezbollah
militia. These successes indicate that Syrian rebel groups received detailed
intelligence and maybe coordinates that allowed them to inflict heavy
casualties. Until Putin is persuaded that a genuine political settlement should
take precedence over bombing, anti-aircraft weapons should be provided to
opposition groups in Syria. They must be deployed in a controlled manner, and
used to alert Assad that his civilian-killing air force is redundant, and to
show Russia that its propping up of the regime against all odds is untenable and
cannot ensure Moscow’s long-term interests in the Middle East.
Duplicity
The duplicity of supporting Assad and singing from the hymn books of Iran and
Israel to promote the establishment of religious entities will backfire, even if
it is camouflaged as an anti-terror campaign. Moscow must not fool anyone that
it is working hard to negotiate a settlement that includes forces it has always
labelled as terrorists, as their bases are prime targets for Russian airstrikes.
Moscow cannot assume one day the role of executioner, and the second that of
peacemaker. Through the downing of a few Russian warplanes with surface-to-air
missiles, the Kremlin would be sent a clear message that the Middle East is not
Georgia or Ukraine, as the stakes in Syria are higher for religious, ethnic and
demographic reasons. I am not an advocate of war, but leaving Syria and its
people to their fate to face Russian, Iranian, Hezbollah, Iraqi, and now
reportedly Cuban troops will only give Assad and his cronies, and their tactical
allies ISIS, a new lease of life, and the region and beyond more destruction and
refugees. The conflict is at a crossroad, and Russia’s intervention is a
disaster that could spin out of control regionally and beyond. U.S. President
Barack Obama seems to have chosen the wrong conflict to hang up his gloves.
If the opposition is an illusion, then the Syrian army is a
myth
Abdulrahman al-Rashed/Al Arabiya/October 25/15
Statements on the Syrian Arab Army have resurfaced, and there have been recent
Russian and Syrian reports on the army's battles against the opposition in
Syria. In reality, the armed group these reports refer to is made up of a
mixture of foreign powers who are carrying out most of the fighting in Syria on
behalf of the Syrian regime. These foreign parties mainly include members of the
Lebanese party Hezbollah, of the Iraqi League of the Righteous and of the
Iranian Quds Brigade. They also include Afghani Shiite Fatimid militias and
others who have been recruited and trained to serve the Iranian regime’s aims of
fighting in Syria and in other conflict zones in the Middle East. These are the
parties comprising the Syrian Arab Army. This is the army the Syrian official
statements have recently referred to and which the Russians claim they are
intervening in Syria to support.
Where is the Syrian Arab Army?
The Russian foreign minister once taunted the Free Syrian Army, asking for its
address to write to it. He did so to voice doubt it actually exists and to imply
that those fighting Bashar al-Assad are terrorists and that everyone who belongs
to the opposition is actually affiliated with the Islamic State of Iraq and
Syria (ISIS) and al-Qaeda. Two days ago, the Russian envoy to Saudi Arabia
described the Syrian opposition as fragile. The Saudis confidently responded to
that by asking Moscow to point to the Syrian Arab Army which they claim to be
supporting on ground. There are now a few thousand soldiers and a few hundred
officers and generals left in the Syrian army, which was once made up of around
250,000 soldiers
For more than a year and a half now, military experts have confirmed that
there’s no trace of this army as many have either defected from its ranks since
the revolution erupted or have been killed during the war. This is in addition
to the fact that many of those who have continued to serve in the army have been
marginalized because most of them are Sunnis whose loyalty to the regime is
doubted, and are hence supplied with little amounts of fuel and ammunition as
the regime fears they may defect and escape to the opposing camp.
Who is now in the Syrian Arab Army?
The Syrian regime has thus filled the vacuum by resorting to popular forces for
defense – as per the Iraqi way. However this did not yield any fruitful results
as most of these forces are not trained and are mainly formed of youths who
belong to minorities, such as the Alawite sect to which Assad belongs. Most of
these forces’ members have preferred to escape military service, and many of
them have thus fled Syria.
Today, the Syrian Arab Army, or Assad’s army, is mostly formed of forces which
are gathered and managed by Iranian military leader Qassem Soleimani who spoke
of the presence of 100,000 fighters that were brought to Syria to defend the
Assad regime. The opposition Free Syrian Army includes different parties and
factions, and most of them are moderate and patriotic, and although it also
includes religious extremist parties, none of these opposition parties include
foreign fighters like ISIS and al-Nusra Front do. The FSA was mainly born as
part of the Syrian opposition project, which comes under the umbrella of the
political coalition council that includes all of Syria’s religious and racial
components. Sunnis, Kurds and Christians have served as its chiefs and its
leaders include Alawites, Druze, Trukmen and others. However, Assad whom the
Russians and the Iranians defend, no longer represents anyone, not even his
small Alawite sect upon which he inflicted the biggest massacre against its sons
as he forced them to engage in battles during the past four horrific years.
There are in fact Syrian traffic police in Damascus; however there’s nothing
called “the Syrian army” in the sense which the Russians keep mentioning. Even
their Iranian allies avoid using the term “Syrian army” as they consider
themselves Syria’s armed forces. When the different parties, i.e. the Gulf,
Turkish, Russian, American and European governments, who are involved in the
struggle in Syria talk about the future role of the Syrian army and security
forces, they mean symbolic concepts of the state’s official institutions. There
are now a few thousand soldiers and a few hundred officers and generals left in
the Syrian army, which was once made up of around 250,000 soldiers.
Syrian security infrastructure has been destroyed
It’s not only the Syrian army which has evaporated. During the past four years
of the war, the structure of the security forces’ institutions and intelligence
apparatuses, which were once described as among the strongest in the world, have
been destroyed. Therefore, the Russians and Iranians must not try and paint a
false picture regarding what’s happening in Syria. The truth is no longer a
secret due to the several parties fighting there. There is currently no state,
no system, no legitimate president, no security forces and no army in Syria.
Above all, we are aware that the Iranians, and not the Russians, are the biggest
winners from a Russian involvement in Syria which is mainly targeting Syrian
opposition forces and not terrorists like ISIS. The Russians are trying to
create a balance by eliminating the armed Syrian national opposition so the
world, including Turkey and Gulf countries, is forced to support the so-called
regime in Damascus in order to fight foreign fighters in ISIS and other
terrorist groups. This is the result which will finally serve the interest of
Iran who, by then, will have seized Iraq, Syria and Lebanon and also have
dangerous influence over the Gulf region.
What’s the difference between Moscow and Assad?
Brooklyn Middleton/Al Arabiya/October 25/15
Russian airstrikes reportedly struck a Syrian-American Medical Society-run field
hospital, killing at least 13 people, including two medical staff members, in
Sarmin, Idlib province on October 20th. Russia’s Foreign Ministry spokeswoman
Maria Zakharova predictably dismissed the claims as “fake,” and launched a petty
diatribe against the Syrian Observatory of Human Rights Director Rami Abdel
Rahman, one of the people who initially reported the strikes. But the SOHR was
not the only party that reported the carnage and the attack was not the first
incident of Russia striking a medical facility in war-torn Syria.
Russia has reportedly targeted multiple medical facilities and hospitals – sites
that should be sacred and untouchable to all warring parties despite Bashar
al-Assad’s own history of destroying them.
Russia will not help end this bloody conflict
The outright denial by Moscow is only the latest claim in continued attempts to
spread propaganda that utterly contradicts the apparent reality on the ground.
In a new Reuters analysis, their team’s assessments concluded that a stunning 80
percent of Russian strikes have failed to target ISIS-held areas.
Moscow’s apparent inability or unwillingness to accurately report on the targets
of its own attacks underscores the risk and foolishness of believing Russia will
help end this bloody conflict. According to Physicians for Human Rights (PHR),
Russia has targeted at least seven medical facilities or hospitals since
beginning its aerial offensive on 30 September in Syria. On 2-3 October alone,
PHR reported that Russian jets bombarded three hospitals in Hama governorate,
Idlib, and Latakia. According to a press release published by the same group,
the airstrike that hit al-Burnas Hospital in Latakia destroyed the site’s
capability to provide obstetrics and gynecology care and was since, “only able
to provide some emergency services.”The basic plea to acknowledge that the
remaining medical facilities in Syria must be deemed totally off limits is one
that Russia cannot disregard. The Assad regime attacks on health care workers
and the sites at which they operate are well-documented; since the conflict has
begun hundreds of medical personnel have been killed while the country’s health
care system has unraveled. Such barbaric, criminal attacks cannot be conducted
by yet another party involved in the conflict.
U.S. attack on Kunduz hospital
As documentation regarding Russian attacks on medical facilities comes to light,
the United States must face its own deadly attack on an MSF hospital in Kunduz,
Afghanistan. The U.S. airstrikes that unjustifiably bombarded the hospital,
killing at least 23 people, should be subjected to a thorough inquiry. But the
important inquiry and the shame of such an attack should not prevent the U.S.
from publicly pressuring Russia to halt its attacks. The U.S. should step up
efforts to document and confirm the Russian strikes on Syrian medical facilities
and demand that an independent investigation be conducted with UN oversight.
Moscow’s apparent inability or unwillingness to accurately report on the targets
of its own attacks underscores the risk and foolishness of believing Russia will
help end this bloody conflict. With an overwhelming number of reports detailing
macabre scenes consistently emanating from Syria since 2011, the risk of
collective empathy fatigue is real; but the potential horror of the remaining
health care centers being obliterated or rendered useless should not be ignored.
A call for action on U.S.-Arab relations
Khalaf Ahmad Al Habtoor/Al Arabiya/October 25/15
The following is a speech by Khalaf Ahmad Al Habtoor at the 24th Annual Arab-U.S.
Policymakers’ Conference organized by the National Council on U.S.-Arab
Relations at the Reagan Building and International Trade Center in Washington DC
on Oct. 15, 2015. I would like to start by thanking the National Council on
U.S.-Arab Relations, led by Dr. John Duke Anthony – Founding President and CEO,
for inviting me to speak at the 24th Annual Arab-U.S. Policymakers’ Conference.
I thank you for having me. In face of what is happening in our world, there
could not have been a more relevant topic to discuss than the topic selected for
this year’s conference: ‘the future of U.S.-Arab relations.’The relationship
between the United States of America and the Arab countries is at a turning
point. For decades, the alliance between the U.S. and the Arab countries, mainly
the GCC States, has proven to be paramount for regional and global stability,
prosperity and peace. We recognize with gratitude, and cannot deny that we have
greatly benefited from your knowledge for decades. As per the Office of the
United States Trade Representative, the volume of trade between the U.S. and the
GCC countries is worth hundreds of billions of U.S. dollars every year.
Americans in the United Arab Emirates form one of the largest Western
communities in the UAE; around 50,000 U.S. nationals reside in my
country.However, what the previous administrations have done to the Arab world
in the last decade, particularly to the Sunni populations, leaves a dark stain
on this great nation’s history.
America has nurtured the Ayatollah Khomeini to replace its former best friend
the Shah of Iran.
Under false pretenses, the George W. Bush administration invaded Iraq. When
American troops pulled out, they handed Iraq to Iran on a silver platter, and
this former great Arab nation, the Cradle of Civilization, was turned into a
cradle for terrorism. I cannot understand why the Obama administration is
championing our common enemies and their expansionist agenda in our region.
Washington turns a blind eye to the Palestinian tragedy. Right now, we are
witnessing the U.S.’s lack of decisive action against one of the most ruthless
criminals of our century – Syrian President Bashar al-Assad – and the
empowerment of Iran, the patron of terrorism in our world, and most importantly,
turning a blind eye to the continuous Palestinian tragedy. The daily suffering
of our Palestinian brothers and sisters is marginalized – it rarely makes the
daily news. But the U.S. State Department was fast to make a statement on Monday
“condemning in strong terms the terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians
which resulted in the murder of three Israelis”. I never take the death of a
human being lightly – any human being, whether Palestinian or Israeli. But the
fact of the matter is that Israeli forces are murdering Palestinian families in
bulk on a daily basis, even burning them in their homes, and the American
authorities have not once condemned those criminal acts. I will not comment
further on the Palestinian issue today. I leave this issue to you, ladies and
gentleman, to consider what differentiates one man from another man? It is the
decision making! It is the ability to make difficult choices when no one else
can. That is what leadership is! And that is what is lacking right now!
Syrian refugee crisis must be dealt with at the source
We are currently facing one of the biggest challenges of our time, and that is
the issue of refugees around the world.
According to the United Nations High Commission for Refugees, the number of
refugees and the internally displaced has reached its highest point since World
War II. The annual cost of this displacement, according to the Internal
Displacement Monitoring Centre, has reached almost U.S. $100 billion.
It is no surprise that many of these people are concentrated in the Middle East
and in particular in Iraq and Syria. A third of the world’s refugees come from
those two nations alone. Twenty-one percent of the world’s refugees are Syrians.
More than 9.5 million have been displaced. That amounts to nearly half of the
Syrian population – men, women and children. This is a human tragedy! Hundreds
of thousands of desperate Syrians have flooded to Europe, risking their lives
for a chance of a better life. This tsunami of desperate people is unlikely to
ease anytime soon. Do you think they want to leave their country? Their homes?
Their family members? No! These people have no choice. This is a last resort,
and they have given up hope completely.
Unfortunately, the reception the refugees are met with, in some parts of Europe,
is not much better than the conditions they are running away from. And some of
the European leaders are refusing to host Syrian refugees for fear of
jeopardising Christian history. It is a real disappointment to hear such
statements from leaders in Europe in the 21st century. The fact that Syrians are
being turned away based on their religious belief is totally unacceptable! The
discrimination is blatant and unforgiving! I am not here to point fingers, but
rather to tell those who are fostering the hate feelings against those
unfortunate refugees in camps that they are attacking the wrong enemy. Their
enemy is not the women and children seeking refuge from a bloodthirsty leader. I
should take this opportunity to salute Pope Francis for his call for mercy for
the Syrian refugees in Europe.
Instead of dealing with this escalating crisis, this human tragedy, why are we
not dealing with the source of the problem? We are looking at solutions to deal
with its ramifications, rather than eliminating it at its root.
If Bashar al-Assad was dealt with in 2011, or when he used chemical weapons in
2013 against the Syrian people, then we would not be dealing with a world
epidemic. Didn’t President Obama draw a red line to the Assad regime, and all
the players on the ground, when sarin gas and other chemical weapons were being
utilised? What the previous administrations have done to the Arab world in the
last decade, particularly to the Sunni populations, leaves a dark stain on this
great nation’s history. I quote what President Obama said in 2013, “It’s about
humanity’s red line. And it’s a red line that anyone with a conscience ought to
draw.”
With all that is happening to Syrians so far, has this not crossed yet any
“humanitarian red lines” for the U.S. and The World? Two years later, and after
continuous use of chemicals weapons in Syria, the world still fails to take any
action and materialize on its promise. Are five years not enough for the
international community to intervene? While world leaders are making plans to
host refugees in their countries, all they offer is a temporary solution. But
you must know that Syrians do not want to be refugees in Europe even more than
Europe’s reluctance to host them! What they need is to go back home to Syria. A
‘safe zone’ should be created within Syrian land, where Syrians can have a safe
shelter from the butcher Assad while a solution is being found. A safe zone
protected by the NATO. And the criminal Bashar al-Assad should be led to the
International Criminal Court. Assad cannot be negotiated with. He should not be
allowed an easy exit! He should be tried for all the crimes he committed against
his own people. Assad must pay for more than 350,000 innocent lives he has
taken! This is what the Syrian people need from you! If justice is not carried
out against Assad, you will never be forgiven.
What will happen after sanctions on Iran are lifted?
Let us not forget Syria is not the only troubled country in the Middle East.
Iraq, Lebanon, Yemen are not any better. And the common denominator in all these
problems is the Islamic Republic of Iran. Iran’s malicious fingerprints are left
all over the region by supporting terrorist groups, such as Hezbollah in
Lebanon, militant groups and destabilizing forces in Iraq, and most recently the
Houthis in Yemen. If Iran has managed to create all this turbulence and damage
despite sanctions, what guarantees can ensure that it does not do more harm once
sanctions are lifted? Iran officially supports terrorism. It does not only back
Shiite terrorist groups but Sunni ones, such as Al-Qaeda itself. This is not an
assumption, but a fact stated in official reports prepared by the U.S.
Department of State. Most importantly, the Iranian regime, which regards the
United States as the “Great Satan”, has for decades been involved in
state-funded terrorism against America and its allies in the region. All that
has happened despite the crippling economic sanctions over Iran. Imagine what
will happen if the sanctions are lifted!
If an Arab country were perceived to be hostile to the U.S. or the international
community, it would be attacked without hesitation. On the other hand, this
administration is treating its ‘favorite enemy’ with a velvet glove instead of
the iron fist it deserves. Both the U.S. and Iran have displayed exceptional
commitment to the nuclear deal, and now a nuclear framework has been agreed. It
is easy to understand Iran’s willingness to compromise when sanctions have bit
hard. But why the Obama administration has made supreme efforts to shake hands
with America’s long-time enemy is perplexing. The P5+1 – Iranian nuclear deal is
set to enrich and empower Tehran once economic sanctions are lifted. President
Obama says Iran’s new wealth will be used to improve lives in Iran, rather than
to fund Hezbollah, the Shiite Yemeni Houthis, or other troublemakers under the
Iranian wing. One needs to be naïve at best to believe that. According to a
Daily Telegraph report, Ali Khamenei – Iran’s Supreme leader, controls “a
financial empire” estimated to be worth $95 billion. That alone should tell you
that Iran has no intention of prioritizing the needs of its people over its
regional troublemakers.
Iran’s ayatollahs have been oppressing religious and ethnic minorities ever
since they took power in 1979. Look at how they have treated Ahwazi Arabs in the
occupied province of Arabistan, that they now call Khuzestan. Although Arabistan
provides Iran with 80 percent of its oil requirements and half of its gas,
Ahwazi Arabs are persecuted and oppressed on daily basis. They are not entitled
to their basic human rights. Their identity is being destroyed. They are forced
to study in Farsi if they are lucky enough to go to school – a meagre 50 percent
chance for boys, and 20 percent for girls. Over 30 percent of Ahwazis under the
age of 30 are unemployed. They have no access to drinking water. Their streets
are open sewers, and they are deprived of electricity and gas. And more often
than not, Arab farmers are stripped of their agricultural land. There is no
country on earth, which oppresses its population underfoot, both politically and
socially, while keeping over almost 11 million illiterate and 15 million
struggling below the poverty line. Meanwhile, Iran spends $15-30 billion every
year to support terrorists across the region, according to a recent report. Its
proxy Hezbollah has hijacked Lebanon and turned it into a hub for terrorism in
the Middle East. Whether it is the military or the political wing, there is no
difference, Hezbollah is a terrorist organization created and nurtured by Iran
to destabilize the Arab world. It goes without saying that the United States is
far better off on the side of its long-term and stability-seeking allies, the
GCC countries. Contrary to Iran, our countries track down and punish terrorists
and financers of such groups. I would love to know why this entity, which has
been hostile to Western powers and their allies since its inception in 1979, is
being rewarded for its terrorist associations and its regional will to power! Or
is this hostility between Iran and the West just a farce to fool us?
Unfortunately, America no longer inspires the world. I say that with deep
regret. When President Obama signed up to the Iran nuclear deal, he placed the
Middle East and the Gulf in danger from an enriched, empowered, and legitimized
Tehran.
Upcoming U.S. election
As the American people prepare to elect a new president, a man or a woman who
will influence the future of the world, it is important that voters begin
scrutinizing the presidential candidates through a new lens – one that is
serious, positive, and objective. Americans should stop judging a man by his
cover and dig deep to see who possesses the necessary tools as well as life
experiences. Voters should not care about their candidates’ personal lives, or
what candidates do in their homes, behind closed doors. That is nobody’s
business. Instead voters should look for a shrewd businessman, with economic
know-how, a candidate who will create jobs for them. Money is power, and money
comes from smart and healthy economies. Americans need employment. Americans
need opportunities. They need investments in infrastructure. Most of all, they
want to enjoy a healthy economy. They have tried the speakers who made empty
promises or announced unrealistic policies – who have failed to return America
to its former glory.
The U.S. is a powerhouse of leaders, but this time instead of selecting a
politician for president, it is best to vote for a successful businessman with a
positive approach to run the country. Some might say that the presidential
election is an American matter, and as an Arab, I should not interfere. Allow me
to correct them! The choice of President, and his policies, will affect the
whole world. The world needs leadership. The American president needs to gain
the admiration of your own people as well as ours. America’s light of truth and
justice should shine bright again! To conclude, I invite you to please join me
for a moment of silence to honor the UAE military men and women who sacrificed
their lives in the line of duty in Yemen recently. May God bless their souls. A
large number of our finest UAE soldiers were killed while defending their Yemeni
brothers and sisters from Iranian-sponsored Houthi rebels. We Emiratis are a
population tied together by tribal roots and family connections. Every single
Emirati life is precious to us, and we will not forget the sacrifice of our
heroes. Our shared grief has joined us together as never before. We are very
proud of the martyrs, there are defenders of the oppressed. I am very proud of
my country. The United Arab Emirates never skirts its duty and has proved its
courage time and time again. My country is committed to the region’s security
and fighting terrorism. Our hands are always open to help our friends and
neighbors, be it with financial support or assistance in preserving their
freedom.
We are determined to prevail over the threat of the Iranian thugs. Our resolve
to fight on the side of right will never falter. We will never permit terrorist
plotters to be victorious when the future of our nations is at stake.We extend
our hands to our allies, and it is my deepest hope that the United States of
America, our long-time friend and ally, stands with us again in our common fight
against terrorism to make our world safe again. God bless America. And God bless
our troubled Arab World. Thank you very much.
Gregg Roman on the 'Inextricable Connection' between
Islamists and Hitler
Al-Jazeera English/October 25, 2015
Middle East Forum director Gregg Roman appeared alongside Mouin Rabbani, a
senior fellow at the Institute for Palestine Studies, and Sakarya University
professor Norman Finkelstein on Al-Jazeera English on October 22 to discuss
Benjamin Netanyahu's controversial statement that Palestinian Grand Mufti Haj
Amin al-Husseini contributed to Nazi planning of the Holocaust. See video below
right.
Excerpt
moderator: Gregg, do you think Netanyahu expected such a backlash? Gregg Roman:
No, but I also think there were several points in Netanyahu's speech that were
not factually accurate, like Mr. Finkelstein said. For instance, he said the
mufti died in Cairo in 1974 from cancer. He actually died in Beirut. But I think
the real element of what we have to look at here regarding the mufti's
involvement, not just with the Holocaust but [with] Palestinian and Arab
incitement against Jews, is the history of the mufti's meetings with Hitler. In
February 1941, an invitation was extended from Hitler to the mufti in Jerusalem
[to come to] Berlin. The meeting didn't take place until November 28, 1941. This
is all available in the German foreign record ... The mufti and Hitler met in
Berlin. There were four agreements that came to be. And of those agreements, one
would be the use of the mufti's propaganda trying to rally Arabs in coming for a
Middle Eastern Holocaust that was going to be planned. And this is also part of
the historical record. I would even ...
moderator: All right, but hang on a second Gregg. Let me ask you, why would the
prime minister of a country, why would the prime minister of Israel, be standing
in front of the world and making factually incorrect statements?
Roman: Sometimes politicians make factually incorrect statements. However, I
don't think he was trying to point to the historical record as his general
point. I think what he was trying to point to was the linkage between the mufti,
his ideological heir Yasser Arafat, and subsequently Palestinian incitement
that's going on today, as being of the same lineage as the mufti's hatred toward
Jews. That's the wider issue of what he was trying to bring up. The context in
how he did it may have been incorrect. However, I have to say, the element,
pathos of what he was talking about was correct.
Middle East Forum director Gregg Roman (left) and Mouin Rabbani on Al-Jazeera
English
Mouin Rabbani: ... Trying to trivialize this by saying that politicians make
factually inaccurate mistakes. Well, suppose that, for example, Mahmoud Abbas
were to get up today and say, "actually, the Holocaust was not Hitler's idea, it
was proposed to him by David Ben Gurion and Chaim Weizmann in order to justify
the creation of the state of Israel." Imagine the outrage. We wouldn't have
someone like John Kerry saying both side need to tone down the rhetoric. Imagine
the outrage if a Palestinian leader had said something similar. So, to seek to
trivialize this is, I think, quite obscene.
I also do think, however, it raises an opportunity for another important
discussion we need to have. And that is the role of the Zionist movement in the
30s and the 40s. Now, Netanyahu is the heir to that faction of the pre-state
Zionist movement eventually known as revisionism, which was in fact inspired by
fascism, albeit an Italian variant led by Mussolini. Um, and during World War
II, in 1941, one faction of that movement, which was eventually led by Yitzhak
Shamir, made an approach to Nazi Germany, during the Holocaust I should add,
proposing an alliance with Berlin against the British, who then ruled Palestine.
So, there's a long history here. Netanyahu today is the heir and the leader of
that wing of the Zionist movement.
Roman: ... So let me address the incitement narrative that I was asked about by
the interviewer.
moderator: Yes, please.
Hitler and Husseini in Berlin, November 1941
Roman: The roots of Palestinian incitement come from Haj Amin al-Husseini, the
former grand mufti of Jerusalem. In his ... [Damascus memoirs], written only in
Arabic and not translated into English until 2014, when a book came out called
Nazis, Islamists, and the Making of the Modern Middle East, we see that the
grand mufti himself describes the protocols of his meetings with Hitler
[inaudible] ... trying to claim responsibility for incitement that took place in
North Africa and in the Middle East, even taking responsibility for the Farhud,
which was the June 1941 pogrom against Jews in Baghdad.
There is an inescapable and inextricable connection between Islamists in the
1940s and the Nazi movement. And to make the claim that there was any kind of
effort to have an 'unholy alliance' between Zionism and Nazism is absurd. The
conversation that took place between Shamir and ...
Rabbani (interrupting): It's documented. It is in the public record. Roman: ...
that conversation that we're talking about was not an alliance against the
British, it was an effort to try to extract Jews from Europe so they wouldn't
die in the gas chambers.
http://www.meforum.org/5578/roman-al-jazeera
The Shi'ite Leopard: Iran's Religious Persecution
Denis MacEoin/Gastone Gate/October 25, 2015
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/6671/iran-religious-persecution
Despite promises of amelioration from Iran's current President, Hassan Rouhani,
the situation for Christians has not improved at all.
Rouhani, came to power as a proponent of human rights and reform, and has been
considered a reformer and moderate in the West ever since. He made countless
declarations of his intention to pursue a human rights agenda and guarantee
equal rights for all Iranians: Every one of those promises has been broken, yet
the U.S. continues to put faith in Rouhani as an honest broker.
"Christians continue to be arbitrarily arrested... [They] disappear for weeks at
a time... Detainees are sometimes told they must to convert to Islam or their
families will be killed." -- Ruth Gledhill, journalist
Even though many Sufi Muslims are fervently pious in their devotion to the faith
of the Shi'a, clerics in Qom declared Sufis to be apostates and attempted to
expel them from the town and to take over their religious centre.
The document organized the methods of oppression used to persecute the Baha'is,
and contained specific recommendations. When Iranian judges offer the Bahai's
life in exchange for abandonment of faith it is a clear admission of a purely
religious motive.
Why do so many Western states and the UN condemn Israel while bending over
backwards to accommodate every demand Iran makes in its bid to build nuclear
weapons, expand its terrorist influence, and threaten the West?
In the wake of the infamous nuclear deal with the hard-line Iranian regime,
countries around the world, led by U.S. President Barack Obama, are busy trying
to bring the Islamic Republic, so long sanctioned and held at arm's length by
decent people, in from the cold. Business deals beckon, great claims are made of
coming dialogue and a slackening of the tensions of the Middle East. We are told
that war has been avoided.
But has the Shi'ite leopard, overnight, truly changed its spots? It still
executes more people per capita than China, it still supports and conducts
terrorist activities in several countries, its leaders still preach hatred for
America, Israel, and the West. In reality, nothing has changed, yet the
theocratic, human-rights-denying regime is now to be everybody's best buddy.
An important indicator of Iran's unfitness to be counted among the nations as a
legitimate actor must be its treatment of its many minorities, above all its
religious minorities. As with Saudi Arabia, the theocratic character of the
state is most clearly exposed when it comes to its treatment of religions and
sects that are not held by the majority. A strict interpretation and application
of Islamic law unfailingly leads to disrespect for and harshness towards
non-Muslims.
Iran's current president, Hassan Rouhani, came to power as a proponent of human
rights and reform, and has been considered a reformer and moderate in the West
ever since. During his election campaign, he made countless declarations of his
intention to pursue a human rights agenda. On April 11, 2013, he said: "All
Iranian people should feel there is justice. Justice means equal opportunity.
All ethnicities, all religions, even religious minorities, must feel justice."
In a Press TV interview that August, he repeated that his administration would
guarantee equal rights for all Iranians: "no authority should differentiate
between various ethnicities, religions, minorities and followers of different
faiths." Every one of those promises has been broken, yet the U.S administration
continues to put faith in Rouhani as an honest broker.
Twelver Shi'ism, which has been the official faith of Iran since the 16th
century, has itself been a persecuted religion wherever its adherents have lived
under Sunni rule. It was imposed on the population of Iran by the Safavid
dynasty (1502-1736), and during the nineteenth century, its clerical hierarchy
grew steadily more powerful. Despite setbacks in the twentieth century, the
clerical elite came to supreme power during the 1979 Islamic Revolution. Since
the Shi'a are a minority in the Islamic world overall, they are deeply conscious
of a need to clamp down on any other religious movements that might threaten to
destabilize their rule.
Ironically, Iran is also home to a variety of religious communities, the most
notable being the Jews, Christians, Zoroastrians, Sufis, and the indigenous
Baha'i religion. Jews, who had lived in Iran for some 2,500 years, numbered
between 60,000 and 80,000 in 1978; after the revolution the following year,
two-thirds of the community went abroad. The 2011 census showed less than 9000
Jews left in Iran. It has just been reported that the last synagogue in Borujerd,
once home for a significant Jewish community, had to close because there was not
a minyan, a minimum prayer quorum of ten men.
Iran's regime has tried to portray itself as tolerant towards Jews, but its
fanatical hatred for Israel and Zionism has often exposed the community to
accusations of espionage, arrests, and executions. Outwardly, Iranian Jews are
not particularly molested, and are represented by a single Member of Parliament.
They operate synagogues and ritual baths, celebrate festivals, and are granted
the status of dhimmi people: protected by an Islamic government in return for
discriminatory debasing requirements. The tolerance, however, is apparently skin
deep, with anti-Zionism lying near the surface.[1]
The second of Iran's dhimmi faiths, Christianity, has not fared as well. The
total number of Christians in Iran (of all denominations) has been estimated at
between 200,000 and 250,000. Ninety percent of these belong to long-standing
indigenous churches, for Armenians, Assyrians, and Chaldeans. They do not seek
converts and are relatively unmolested. But churches that have links to foreign
countries are treated harshly. According to Minority Rights International:
"The Protestants, and particularly evangelical groups, face the most
difficulties from amongst the Christian communities in Iran. Human Rights Watch
estimated their numbers at around 10,000-15,000 in 2002. Churches have been
closed down, the use of Persian in sermons banned, the publishing of Bibles
restricted and Muslims strictly prohibited from attending sermons, with previous
converts from Islam being put under particular surveillance. A number of
Christian leaders have been killed or found murdered since the early 1990s:
Assemblies of God Minister Bishop Haik Hovsepian Mehr was found stabbed to death
in 1994; Reverend Mehdi Dibaj, pastor of the Church of the Assemblies of God, a
convert from Islam 41 years previously, was released from prison in January 1994
but found dead by the authorities on July 2 that year; Reverend Tateos
Michaelian, found murdered in July 1994; pastor Mohammad Bagher Yusefi,
disappeared and was found dead in 1996, and pastor Ghorban Dordi Tourani was
found dead in 2005.
Respected religious affairs journalist Ruth Gledhill has argued that, despite
promises of amelioration from the current President, Hasan Rouhani, the
situation for Christians has not improved at all. By the end of 2014, over 90
Christians were behind bars. Gledhill writes:
"Christians continue to be arbitrarily arrested and interrogated because of
their faith. Some face 'severe physical and psychological torture' during
detention, and simple prayer or Bible study meetings are regarded as political
activities that threaten the national security of Iran.
"Christians disappear for weeks at a time while they are interrogated. They are
held in solitary and questioned nightly, for hours at a time, beginning just
after midnight. A key goal of the security services is to find and remove any
New Testaments from the homes of Christians. Detainees are sometimes told they
must to convert to Islam or their families will be killed."[2]
Despite such threats, it has been claimed by some missionary organizations that
thousands of Iranian Muslims are converting to Christianity, resulting in a
growth rate of 20% per annum. Mohammed Zamir, a church leader in the UK for
expatriate Iranians, has stated that hundreds of thousands of Iranians are
converting to Christianity, out of control of the authorities. These claims need
to be taken with a pinch of salt. The longest-lasting and most indigenous faith
in the country is, of course, the ancient Zoroastrian religion, founded by the
Iranian prophet Zardosht (Zarathustra, Zoroaster) somewhere between 1700 and 500
BCE, but traditionally dated to around 600 BCE. Until modern times, the religion
has remained largely confined to Iran and India (where Zoroastrians are known as
Parsis, having moved to the sub-continent from Iran from the 8th to 10th
centuries to avoid persecution by the Muslim newcomers).[3] Although the Qur'an
mainly speaks of Jews and Christians when it refers to "the people of the book"
(Ahl al-kitab), one verse (22:17) speaks of the Magis (al-Majus): "As for the
believers [the Muslims], those who follow the Jewish religion, the Sabaeans, the
Christians, the Magians, and the idol worshippers, God will decide between them
on the Last Day."
After the Arab Muslim conquest of Iran between 633 and 651 CE, it became a
matter of urgency to define the status of the Zoroastrian population. Exegetes
and jurists agreed that they should be treated as scriptuaries and not pagans,
which led to a degree of toleration for them and their religious practices.
Under the Islamic regime, however, this toleration has been severely strained.
In November 2005, Ayatollah Ahmed Jannati, chairman of the Council of Guardians
of the Constitution, disparaged Zoroastrians and other religious minorities as
"sinful animals who roam the earth and engage in corruption." When the
Zoroastrians' solitary parliamentary representative protested, he was hauled
before a revolutionary tribunal. There, mullahs threatened execution before
sparing his life with a warning never to challenge their declarations again. A
frightened community subsequently declined to re-elect him. Writing in 2011,
Sanskrity Sinha commented that "Zoroastrianism in Iran is on the verge of dying
an ignominious death, with only a few thousand living in a country where their
rights are suppressed."
Sufism is another indigenous community that has suffered greatly at the hands of
the Islamic regime. Sufism is the mystical trend in Islam, and in the Sunni
world, across North Africa, the Middle East, and far beyond. In some periods,
the many Sufi brotherhoods (tariqat) were followed by as much as 90% of the
population. Sufism has been attacked in modern times, especially by the Saudi
Wahhabis, and its numbers have greatly fallen. In Iran (and in regions such as
Tajikistan, Afghanistan and northern India, saturated with Persian influences),
although there were few orders, the culture was deeply embedded with Sufi
mysticism. Persian poetry, for example, is considered one of the greatest canons
of verse in the world. [4]
The Islamic regime will never dare ban the works of these poets, considered the
highest achievement of Persian culture. But in a bizarre move, it has clamped
down hard on Iran's best-known Sufi order, the Ne'matollahis.[5]
Today, even though members of it are fervently pious in their devotion to the
faith of the Shi'a and their twelve holy imams, the Sufis, especially the
Gonabadi branch, have been persecuted. In 2006, for instance, clerics in Qom
(where the important Khomeinist seminary is situated) declared Sufis to be
apostates and attempted to expel them from the town and to take over their Shi'i-style
religious centre. Dervishes from across Iran travelled to Qom, held several days
of protests around the centre, and declared their desire for peace, their
commitment to the Shi'i faith, and their loyalty to the revolution.
In spite of this display of devotion, police suppressed the protest. Over 1,000
Sufis were arrested and the religious centre was burned to the ground. The
anti-Sufi campaign then moved to other cities such as Bojnurd and Isfahan, where
more centres were destroyed. In 2009, the shrine of Sufi poet and philosopher
Dervish Naser 'Ali, situated in a local cemetery in Isfahan, was looted and then
destroyed. Protesters who gathered outside the Majlis (Iran's parliament) were
disrupted when police arrested sixty of them.
That same year, the Green Movement for democracy in Iran was violently
suppressed. It had been supported by the Gonabadi Sufis. Since then, lawyers,
website managers, and others have been imprisoned, tortured and killed. On
September 10, four Gonabadi activists were arraigned in Shiraz for trying to
appeal their earlier convictions. Their website describes this: "At the court
hearing in the case of four dervishes, Mr. Saleheddin Moradi, Mr. Farzad Darviah,
Mr. Behzad Nouri and Mrs. Farzaneh Nouri that was held in Branch 16 of the
appeals court of Shiraz, the representative of the prosecution contemptuously
emphasized the necessity of their penitence, to discontinue... website
activities... and also the maximum punishment for the mentioned dervishes."
The attack on the Sufis of Iran reveals something particularly dark about the
Islamic regime. Sufi mysticism, with its close ties to the most central aspects
of Persian culture -- poetry, calligraphy, music, miniature painting, the rose,
the nightingale, the garden -- is vital to the healthy working of Iranian
society, yet the regime that asserts its right to protect the people under its
rule has turned on it.
Not far from that denial of Persian values stands the greatest persecution of
all: the ongoing attack made on Iran's largest indigenous religious minority,
the Baha'is. "The Baha'is of Iran," according to Payam Akhavan, Professor of
International Law at McGill University, have long been the canary in the
mineshaft as far as human rights are concerned. Their treatment is the litmus
test of the direction the leadership intends to take the country."
This is a subject that has resulted in a vast outpouring of articles, reports,
government debates, websites, legal appeals, protests, speeches and
encyclopaedia articles. Although there have been many executions, this is not a
story like that of Islamists killing Christians in the Middle East. It is
something more chilling than that. It's best parallel is the persecution of Jews
in Germany in the 1930s, before the move to a "Final Solution" -- a slow,
steady, calculated, often bureaucratic campaign of attrition.
Baha'ism (the Baha'i Faith) is a monotheistic religion that emerged in the
mid-nineteenth century out of a Shi'ite sect known as Babism.[6]
Today, it is estimated that there are about five million Baha'is across the
globe, with their largest numbers among Hindu converts in India and Western
converts in Europe, North and South America. The Baha'i temple in New Delhi,
with over 100 million visitors, is considered by UNESCO to be one of the most
visited buildings in the world. Although small in numbers, the Baha'is are
racially, nationally, and religiously diverse, well organized and well
integrated.
Where Babism was militant and grew embroiled in clashes with state troops in
several places, Baha' Allah abrogated jihad, advocated world peace, equality of
the sexes, world brotherhood and other teachings ultimately derived from Western
sources. His religion, built on a mixture of Shi'i and Sufi beliefs, was
nonetheless progressive in nature, at ease with modernity, and divorced from
political intrigue. This combination of religious heresy and Western social
themes brought it directly in conflict with the clergy of the day and through
the twentieth century. Baha'is were martyred, imprisoned, and faced with daily
suspicion and animosity. For all that, their stress on education and their
openness to science and professional pursuits meant that they prospered as
doctors, lawyers, teachers, academics, and technicians. Some even held positions
at the Shah's court. More complicated is that many Iranian Jews converted to
Baha'ism, despite this exposing them to harsher treatment.[7]
After the 1979 Islamic Revolution, things changed greatly for the worse. After
the fall of the Shah, Dr. James Cockcroft interviewed Ayatollah Khomeini and
asked specifically about the Baha'is:
Cockroft: Will there be either religious or political freedom for the Baha'is
under the Islamic government?
Khomeini: They are a political faction; they are harmful. They will not be
accepted.
Cockroft: How about their freedom of religion– religious practice?
Khomeini: No.[8]
So began the first major persecution in the Middle East in modern times.[9]
In the first ten years after the Revolution, over 200 Baha'is were murdered or
executed, while hundreds more were tortured and imprisoned. Tens of thousands
lost jobs, access to education, pensions, and other civil rights for no other
reason than that they belonged to a religion that claimed there had been two new
prophets after Muhammad. It was thought by many that the regime would finally
carry out a genocide of the community, then numbering around 300,000.[10]
Among thousands of incidents, two stand out as indicative of the violent tactics
underlying the Revolution, its institutions, and its laws. The single greatest
example of violence towards Baha'is occurred in 1983 in the southern city of
Shiraz. A few years earlier, in February 1979, the suburb of Sa'diyeh had been
rocked by an anti-Baha'i pogrom that left over two hundred homes and businesses
looted and burned. In 1981, five Baha'i leaders, and in 1982 another three, were
executed. In October and November 1982, mass arrests were carried out by local
members of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. The stage was set for further
violence.[11]
After a prolonged persecution, at the beginning of June 1983, in accordance with
Islamic tradition, the 22 remaining Baha'i detainees in prison were offered four
last opportunities to convert to Islam and save their lives. They all declined.
Ten women who were hanged had been charged with the crime of teaching children's
classes. The classes, known as Dars-e Akhlaq, "Morality lessons," are similar in
nature to Christian Sunday schools or Jewish religious classes for children.
They teach moral behaviour that could come straight from any Judaeo-Christian
ethics curriculum. All ten had been tortured and interrogated for months before
their execution. The youngest, Mona Mahmudnizhad, seventeen at the time of her
death, has become a symbol of Baha'i martyrdom.
It is reported that while in prison Mona was bastinadoed on the soles of her
feet with a cable and forced to walk while bleeding. One account states that she
kissed the hand of her executioner and then the rope itself, before putting it
around her own neck. Her father was arrested and executed at about the same
time. During the trial of another young victim, 23-year-old Roya Eshraqi, a
veterinary student, the judge said "You put yourselves through this agony only
for one word: Just say you are not a Baha'i and I'll see that... you are
released..." Ms. Eshraqi is said to have responded, "I will not exchange my
faith for the whole world."
U.S. President Ronald Reagan asked the Iranian government to show clemency. He
was ignored.
What is clear again is the purely religious character of the persecution.
Khomeini's claim that the Baha'is "are a political faction" and the frequent
claims that they are spies could not be farther from the truth. Baha'is are
forbidden by their own doctrines to take part in any form of politics and are
even dissuaded from voting in elections. They do have teachings about a future
world government and international economics, but have no interest in party
politics and are commanded to be loyal to whatever country they may live in.
Baha'is can be sanctioned by their own institutions for breaking these rules.
The Iranian government knows this perfectly well, and when judges offer life in
exchange for abandonment of faith it is a clear admission of a purely religious
motive.
Although clerics have called for genocide, it has became official policy to
suppress the Baha'is in a more careful fashion.[12] It is highly likely that the
international protests about the fate of the Baha'is may have convinced the
regime that a total liquidation of the community would produce a storm of
condemnation that they might find hard to weather.
In February 1991, a confidential circular[13] was issued by the Supreme Council
of the Cultural Revolution, a body set up by Khomeini in Qom, whose members were
at that time all appointees of Supreme Leader 'Ali Khamene'i. The Council has
extraordinary powers. Its rulings must be treated as laws and may not be
overruled. Stamped "confidential," the circular was signed by Hujjatu'l Islam
Seyyed Mohammad Golpaygani, Secretary of the Council, and approved by Ayatollah
Khamene'i, who added his signature. The circular addressed "the Baha'i question"
and signalled an increase in efforts to suffocate the Iranian Baha'i community
in a more "silent" fashion. The document organized the methods of oppression
used to persecute the Baha'is, and contained specific recommendations on how to
block the progress of the Baha'i communities both inside and outside Iran. The
document stated that the most excessive types of persecutions should be avoided
and instead, among other things recommended, that Baha'is be expelled from
universities, "once it becomes known that they are Baha'is," to "deny them
employment if they identify themselves as Baha'is" and to "deny them any
position of influence."
The systematic exclusion of Baha'i professors and students from the universities
started soon after the Revolution, but became clear by 1983. In response, the
Baha'is themselves tried to remedy the situation by establishing in 1987 the
Baha'i Institute for Higher Education, a clandestine university that operated
underground and continues nowadays mainly through the internet. Its curriculum
is broad; many graduates have been credited by American and European
universities for higher studies. The teachers are generally made up of Baha'i
lecturers and professors who have been dismissed from their posts in the regular
Iranian universities. Over the years, the university has been closed down on
several occasions, many teachers have been arrested, and many remain in Iran's
prisons, serving long sentences.[14] The Bahai Institute of Higher Education in
Iran has, however, received considerable support from universities, academic
institutes, governments, and other bodies (such as Amnesty International) around
the world, which have repeatedly petitioned the Iranian government to legalize
it and permit Baha'is to attend national universities.
The Baha'is, like the Jews, have always considered education to be a primary
function of a healthy society. In 1973, when the national literacy rate for
women under 40 in Iran stood at 15%, the figure for Baha'i women was 100%.[15]
The first Girls school in Iran was opened by Baha'is in 1899, closed down, then
re-opened in 1911 as the Tarbiyyat-e Banat in Tehran, with a secular curriculum
and American Baha'i women teachers. It was immensely popular, and by the 1930s
there were dozens of Baha'i schools for both girls and boys. They were the best
schools in the country, the academies to which many of the middle and upper
classes sent their children. But in 1934, the government under Reza Shah shut
them down permanently.[16] Today, Baha'i children in regular schools, the
dabestans and dabirestans, suffer ill treatment. According to the Baha'i
International Community, "Baha'i school children at all levels continue to be
monitored and slandered by administrators and teachers in schools. Secondary
school students often face pressure and harassment, and some have been
threatened with expulsion. Religious studies teachers are known to insult and
ridicule Baha'i beliefs. In a few reported cases, when Baha'i students attempt
to clarify matters at the request of their peers, they are summoned to the
school authorities and threatened with expulsion if they continue to 'teach'
their Faith."
In one of the cruellest phases of this persecution, the Islamic government has
behaved in an identical fashion to the Islamic State terrorist organization.
Across Iraq and Syria, IS has destroyed churches, shrines, ancient monuments,
and cultural artefacts of deep significance in human history. The Iranian regime
has demolished all the holy places of the Baha'i faith in Iran, shrines and
buildings associated with their prophets, martyrs, and early followers. In
Shiraz, a charming early 19th-century dwelling known as the House of the Bab,
where the first of the two Baha'i prophets revealed his mission to his first
followers, was summarily bulldozed shortly after the Revolution, and a mosque
built on the site. This little house, which the author visited several times
while living in Shiraz in the 1970s, was of historical and religious
significance, with its exquisite Persian carpets, stained glass windows, and
genial atmosphere.
The regime has not stopped at shrines. Over the years, many Baha'i cemeteries
have been dug up and the corpses in them disinterred and scattered. As recently
as April 2014, Shiraz's Revolutionary Guards commenced the destruction of a
historic Baha'i cemetery. International pressure halted this destruction for a
while, but a few months later, in August, the work of demolition began again,
and a concrete foundation was laid for a complex of recreational buildings.
Among the 950 Baha'is who had been buried there were the ten women hanged in
1983. Incidentally, Baha'i law prohibits burial more than an hour's distance
from the place of death. (This is in conscious contradiction of the Shi'i
practice of keeping corpses for months or years before sending them to be buried
at one of the shrine centres in Iraq.)
The destruction of a historic Baha'i cemetery in Shiraz, Iran, by the Islamic
Revolutionary Guards Corp. (Image source: Baha'i World News Service)
This insidious process of attrition operates across the board. Baha'is face the
monitoring of their movements, activities and bank accounts; the denial of their
pensions and inheritances; exclusion from employment in most sectors; the
closure of their shops and businesses; the prohibition of their access to
publishing or copying facilities for the printing of Baha'i sacred and general
literature; and the confiscation of property. Muslims who associate with Baha'is
are intimidated. Anti-Baha'i writings and broadcasts are common. From January
2014 through May 2015, the Baha'i International Community documented more than
6,300 items of anti-Baha'i propaganda in Iran's official or semi-official media.
A report on the media campaign to demonize Baha'is is available here.
A particular injustice that has received considerable comment around the world
is the current imprisonment of seven Baha'i leaders. They were arrested in 2008
and given to a twenty-year prison sentence in 2010. Their sentence was passed by
Mohammad Moghiseh, head of Branch 28 of Tehran's Revolutionary Court. Moghiseh
is one of six regime judges accused of being behind recent crackdowns on
dissidents, journalists and others. According to Mahmood Amiry-Moghaddam, an
Iranian human rights activist in Norway, "This group is among the most notorious
judges in Iran. They are known for their politicised verdicts, unfair trials
[and] sentencing prisoners based on confessions made under duress." Gissou Nia,
of the US-based Iran Human Rights Documentation Centre (IHRDC), said: "It seems
that in the courtrooms of Salavati, Moghiseh and Pirabbasi, there is [something]
counter-intuitive at play -- that is, the shorter the hearing, the longer the
sentence." She added: "Those cases that have made their way before this trio of
revolutionary court judges, and have resulted in long terms of imprisonment or,
even worse, death, read like a who's who of the most high-profile miscarriages
of justice in the Iranian legal system."
The condemned, five men and two women, were elected members of the National
Spiritual Assembly of the Baha'is of Iran. The Baha'i religion has no priesthood
and a very limited clerical class. All the main Baha'i institutions at local,
national and international level are created through open elections (without
electioneering), and individuals take on their responsibilities as a religious
duty. In other words, these seven Baha'is are volunteers who took on
administrative functions in a time of very great danger for their faith and
themselves. Known as the Yaran (Friends), they embody the injustice,
irrationality, and cruelty of the Iranian regime.
Writing on the day of their final trial in Canada's Globe and Mail, Howard
Adelman (professor emeritus of philosophy at York University and founder of the
Centre for Refugee Studies) lists the seven and provides short but pertinent
information on who they are:
Fariba Kamalabadi, 46, whose physician father was arrested in the 1980s,
tortured and imprisoned, was an honours student denied entry to university but
who became a developmental psychologist while raising three children. On the
first anniversary of Ms. Kamalabadi's arrest, her youngest, Alhan, wrote an open
letter expressing the "mountain load of pain and sorrow" she carried during "a
year of being far from a mother."
Jamaloddin Khanjani is a 75-year old industrialist, a father of four and a
grandfather of six.
Afif Naeimi, 47, is a brilliant student who was denied entry to medical school
but who became a successful industrialist. He is a father of two.
Saeid Rezaie, 51, is a Baha'i scholar and an agricultural engineer with a
farming equipment business. He has three children.
Mahvash Sabet, 55, is a teacher and principal who was dismissed from public
education for being a Baha'i. She served as director of the Baha'i Institute for
Higher Education for 15 years. She has two children.
Behrouz Tavakkoli, 57, is a former lieutenant in the Iranian army and social
worker who specialized in the care of people with disabilities. He lost his
government job after the Islamic Revolution because he was a Baha'i. He has
spent previous time under arrest in solitary confinement. He has two sons, one a
student and the other an engineer living in Canada.
Vahid Tizfahm, 35, is an optometrist and a former member of the Baha'i National
Youth Committee. He has one son.
The head of their legal team, Nobel Laureate Shirin Ebadi, has stated that her
clients have been convicted of "spying for America and Israel, acting against
national security and [engaging in] propaganda against the [Islamic Republic's]
system", adding: "I read the dossier and fortunately or unfortunately, found in
it no cause or evidence to sustain the criminal charges upheld by the
prosecutor." In an interview with Washington TV, she described the difficulties
she and her fellow lawyers faced:
"When I and my colleagues accepted to act as their defense lawyers, they had not
been allowed to see their families for over a year. And for some time too, they
were not allowed to meet with us. After a year and a half when the investigation
ended, I and the rest of the lawyers were permitted to read the dossier and we
met them on one occasion in prison."
The seven leaders are confined in Section 209 in Evin, Iran's most notorious
prison. The campaign for their release continues. A detailed summary of the
injustices meted out to them has been penned by American jurist Dr. Christopher
Buck J.D., and is available here. In it, Buck argues with detailed use of
quotations that the trial and sentencing were in contradiction of Iran's
constitution, but argues that the protections offered in that document are
always suspended if anything is deemed contrary to "Islamic criteria".
All of the above could be expanded on over a dozen articles or more. But I would
like to end on a positive note. Iran, a country whose clerical leadership has
for decades instructed the population to chant "Death to Israel" in its mosques
and on its streets, terrorizes its religious minorities and threatens its Baha'i
population with slow extinction. Israel, on the other hand, the one country in
the world that almost every other country condemns as an evil Zionist entity, is
the only country in the Middle East that offers full-time protection to its own
religious minorities, be they Christians, Muslims, or Baha'is. Israel hosts the
two holiest Baha'i shrines, the seat of the supreme Baha'i legislative body, the
Universal House of Justice, gardens, a cemetery, their international archives,
and other foundations. One day, a Baha'i temple as original in design as the
other temples on five continents will be built atop Mount Carmel. Every year,
thousands of Baha'i pilgrims from around the world come to perform visitation at
the shrines. The Baha'i World Center has been designated by UNESCO as a World
Heritage Site and is today one of the most popular destinations for tourists to
Israel.
This single fact alone is the clearest evidence of how wholly different Iran is
from Israel: Iran is a murderous theocracy while Israel is a thoroughly tolerant
democracy. Why, then, do so many Western states and the UN, condemn Israel while
bending over backwards to accommodate every demand Iran makes in its bid to
build nuclear weapons, expand its terrorist influence, and threaten the West?
The Iranian leadership must now feel invulnerable; it seems that no matter what
they do, the Western powers will let them get away with it. This sense of
invulnerability, if not checked, will mean even harsher treatment of religious
minorities and quite possibility a fast-track impetus towards a genocide of the
Baha'i population, as well as the accelerated murder of others.
Denis MacEoin has a PhD in Persian Studies from King's College, Cambrdge. He has
written many books, journal articles, and encyclopedia entries about the Baha'is
and their predecessors.
[1] Dr. Esther Webman, director of the Stephen Roth Institute for the Study of
Contemporary Antisemitism and Racism, has said the tolerance is a mere façade.
[2] Citing a 2015 report, The Persecution of Christians in Iran, from the UK
all-party Christians in Parliament group.
[3] Regarding Iran, in a 2009 report, the U.S. State Department declared that
"the [Iranian] Government estimates there are 30,000 to 35,000 Zoroastrians, a
primarily ethnic Persian minority; however, Zoroastrian groups claim to have
60,000 adherents."
[4] The majority of these great poets – whose work has been translated into many
languages – were Sufi mystics: Rumi (1207-1273, today known as America's
favourite poet), Hafez (1325-1389), Sa'di (1210-1291), Omar Khayyam (1048-1131),
Attar (1110-1221), Sana'i (d. 1131/41), and dozens more. Every Iranian home has
a copy of Hafez's Divan alongside a copy of the Qur'an. Iranians, even peasants,
will quote at length from this mystical poetry. Traditional singers use poetry
for their lyrics. That most exquisite of all Persian arts, calligraphy, is seen
everywhere in renditions of famous poems. In the famous city of Shiraz, the
tombs of Hafez and Sa'di are daily visited by pilgrims from around the country.
A series of radio programmes without parallel in the West, Barnama-ye Golha (The
Flowers Programme), was broadcast in Iran for twenty-three years, from 1956 to
1979 (when the regime imposed a general ban on music), discussing the links
between Persian poetry and musical traditions.
[5] The Ne'matollahis, and specifically on its chief branch, the
Gonabadi-Ne'matollahis. The Ne'matollahi order was founded by Shah Ne'matollah
Vali (1330-1431), an Iranian Sufi shaykh and poet. Soon after the establishment
of the Shi'ite Safavid dynasty in 1501, the order declared itself Shi'i. Today,
the Gonabadi branch, which emerged in 1861 following the death of the last
overall Ne'matollahi shaykh, is fervently pious in its devotion to the faith of
the Shi'a and their twelve holy imams.
[6] The fullest account of this movement is to be found in Denis MacEoin, The
Messiah of Shiraz: Studies in Early and Middle Babism, 738 pp., Brill, Leyden,
2009. Readers should also consult, Abbas Amanat, Resurrection and Renewal: The
Making of the Babi Movement in Iran, 1844-1850, 477 pp., Cornell U.P., Ithaca,
N.Y., 1989. Its two prophet-founders, Sayyid 'Ali Muhammad Shirazi, the Bab [the
Gate] (1819-1850) and Mirza Husayn-'Ali Nuri, Baha' Allah (Baha'u'llah)
(1817-1892) were born Shi'i Iranians. The Bab, shot by a firing squad in Tabriz
in 1850, is buried in the famous golden-domed shrine on the slopes of Mount
Carmel in Haifa, Israel. Baha' Allah, exiled to Ottoman Syria, is buried in a
shrine outside the city of Acco.
[7] See Mehrdad Amanat, Jewish Identities in Iran: Resistance and Conversion to
Islam and the Baha'i Faith, I. B. Tauris, London, 2011.
[8] James Cockcroft, "Iran's Khomeini," an exclusive interview by Jim Cockcroft,
SEVEN DAYS, February 23, 1979, Volume III, Number 1, pp. 17-24.
[9] The most comprehensive accounts of this phenomenon are three major reports
by the Iran Human Rights Documentation Center, a non-profit organization based
in New Haven, funded by the US State Department as well as the Canadian
government, private foundations and other donors. The reports are available
online: "A Faith Denied", "Crimes Against Humanity", and "Community Under
Siege". Their work has been reinforced by Dr. Nabila Ghanea's 2003 book, Human
Rights, the U.N. and the Baha'is in Iran, a 640-page report by an experienced
human rights expert.
[10] In a 1982 study of the persecution, Iran's Secret Pogrom, British author
Geoffrey Nash predicted such an outcome.
[11] In its Executive Report at the heads of its lengthy report on these
incidents, the Iran Human Rights Documentation Center provides this summary: In
February 1983, the Revolutionary Court in Shiraz accidentally sent an internal
circular intended for distribution within the Revolutionary Guard Corps to the
offices of a local newspaper, Khabar-i Junub. The circular stated that the Court
had issued an order for the execution of twenty-two members of the local Baha'i
community. The victims were not named. The newspaper published this information
following it up with an interview with the Head of the Revolutionary Court,
Hojjatolislam Qaza'i, ominously headlined: "I Warn the Baha'is to come to the
Bosom of Islam." At the time one detainee had already been executed in January.
Three more prominent Baha'i detainees were executed in March 1983.
The Khabar-i Junub article provoked an international outcry. The Islamic
Republic regime responded by exploiting the foreign pressure as evidence to
support its narrative that the Baha'i Faith was the artificial creation of the
superpowers with the aim of undermining Iranian society. In a widely reported
speech in May 1983, Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khomeini, dismissed
international protests with the comment: "Were these people not spies, you would
not be raising your voices."
Six male detainees were executed on June 16. Ten female detainees were hanged in
Shiraz's Chawgun Square on June 18. Of the two remaining male detainees who died
in 1983, one was executed at the end of June and the other died while in prison
custody.
Although the Iranian authorities have never explicitly named the Shiraz
twenty-two, the IHRDC has identified twenty-two Baha'i detainees who died in
1983 in the custody of the Shiraz authorities. Twenty-one were executed and one
victim died in prison after months of abuse. We believe that it is reasonable to
conclude from the existing evidence that it was the original intention of the
Shiraz Revolutionary Court that all twenty-two be executed for their refusal to
recant their faith.
[12] Moojan Momen, "The Babi and Baha'i community of Iran: a case of 'suspended
genocide'?", Journal of Genocide Studies, volume 7, number 2, June 2005, pp.
221-241, available at:
[13] UN Doc. E/CN.4/1993/41, Commission on Human Rights, 49th session, 28
January 1993, Final report on the situation of human rights in the Islamic
Republic of Iran by the Special Representative of the Commission on Human
Rights, Mr. Reynaldo Galindo Pohl, paragraph 310. See also "Iran's secret
blueprint for the destruction of the Baha'i community."
[14] Friedrich W. Affolter, "Resisting Educational Exclusion: The Bahai
Institute of Higher Education in Iran", International Journal of Diaspora,
Indigenous and Minority Education 1 (1) 2007: 65–77.
[15] See Tahirih Tahririha-Danesh, "The Right to Education: The Case of the
Bahá'ís in Iran", in Tahririha-Danesh, Bahá'í-Inspired Perspectives on Human
Rights, Juxta Publishing Co., 2001, pp. 216–230.
[16] See Soli Shahvar (Haifa University), The Forgotten Schools: The Baha'is and
Modern Education in Iran 1899-1934, I. B. Tauris, London and New York, 2009.
© 2015 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. No part of this website or any
of its contents may be reproduced, copied or modified, without the prior written
consent of Gatestone Institute.
The Holocaust is OVER
by Shoshana Bryen/Gatestone Institute.
October 25, 2015
This minute, the UN is labeling one of the oldest existing symbols of Jewish
patrimony in the Land of Israel -- the Tomb of Rachel, wife of the biblical
patriarch Jacob -- as a Muslim holy site.
The UN had not a word, however, about the Muslims who burned the Jewish holy
site at Joseph's Tomb last week. This omission raises a different question: the
same Joseph is also a prophet in Islam; why are they firebombing his tomb?
Abbas has been lying about threats to the status quo on the Temple Mount, and
proposing his own change: The Jews, he said, have no right to "desecrate" the
mosque with their "filthy feet."
Watch a beautiful little girl with a large knife tell her approving father, "I
want to stab a Jew."
In 2000, the New York Times wrote about Arafat's summer "war-game camps" in
Gaza, teaching Palestinian children how to prepare for battle. That is fifteen
years of learning to kill Jews and creating child soldiers: a violation of the
UN Convention on Child Soldiers, and one reason so many young Palestinians are
primed for violence.
In the summer of 2015, tens of thousands of teenagers in Gaza participated in
these "summer camps" to learn from their Hamas teachers to kill Jews.
If what happened in the 1930s and 1940s, however, is allowed to turn our
attention from the current threats to the Jewish State, we will have granted
Hitler and the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem a belated victory they do not deserve.
Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, set off a firestorm on October 21
by saying that the Mufti of Jerusalem had actually planted the idea of
exterminating the Jews in Hitler's mind; that Hitler would have simply ousted
them from Europe.
Scholars, academicians, politicians, friends and enemies of Jews, Israel, and
Netanyahu leapt to the barricades. The Washington Post had the story on the
front page. Twitter and blogs have overflowed with it. The Chancellor of Germany
found it oddly necessary to say, "Germany is responsible for the Holocaust."
But enough about who, between two long-dead anti-Semites, was the worst. It is a
distraction and provides cover for today's racists and those who would destroy
Israel.
Palestinian agitator Saeb Erekat used the tumult to weigh in. In the latest
Palestinian effort to rewrite history, he said, "Palestine's efforts against
Nazis, are deep-rooted part of our history."
Palestinian Authority (PA) strongman Mahmoud Abbas, a Holocaust denier at least
since his PhD days (and now in the 10th year of his four-year term, so he cannot
be called "President") did not say anything on that subject. He does, however
continue to incite Palestinians to kill Jews. Right now, today, this minute.
Abbas has been lying about threats to the status quo on the Temple Mount, and
proposing his own change: The Jews, he said, have no right to "desecrate" the
mosque with their "filthy feet." He then assures those Palestinians who go out
to kill Jews -- because they understood the recommendation to be officially
sanctioned -- that, "Every drop of blood spilled in Jerusalem is pure, every
shahid [martyr] will reach paradise, and every injured person will be rewarded
by God."
Also, right now, today, this minute, the United Nations is labeling one of the
oldest existing symbols of Jewish patrimony in the Land of Israel -- the Tomb of
Rachel, wife of the biblical patriarch Jacob -- as a Muslim holy site. The U.S.,
U.K., Germany, Netherlands, Czech Republic, and Estonia voted against this
surreal piracy. But 26 other countries voted in favor of a resolution, totally
fraudulent, that condemned Israel for aggression and illegal measures taken
against the "freedom of worship and access" of Muslims to Al-Aqsa mosque and
Israel's "attempts to break the status quo since 1967."
The UN had not a word, however, about the Muslims who burned the Jewish holy
site at Joseph's Tomb last week. This omission raises a different question: the
same Joseph is also a prophet in Islam; what are they doing firebombing his
tomb?
In addition, right now, today, this minute, the State of Israel is under
physical and political attack, and its best ally, the United States, is largely
absent. Secretary of State John Kerry admonished, "We continue to urge everybody
to exercise restraint and restrain [sic] from any kind of self-help in terms of
the violence, and Israel has every right in the world to protect its citizens,
as it has been, from random acts of violence."
No self-help? Kerry specifically said it; he meant that if the government shows
up and kills the terrorist before he kills, fine, but he does not want Israelis
to take their defense into their own hands. That is not the way defense is done
in America, and it is not the way it is done in Israel. The United States is
abandoning a core American value in pursuit of the chimera of
Israeli-Palestinian "peace."
Right now, this minute, young Palestinian children are being marinated in
Jew-hatred by their parents and by their society. Watch a beautiful little girl
with a large knife tell her approving father, "I want to stab a Jew." Watch a
Palestinian children's TV program in which a girl of about 10, her hair covered,
draped in a Palestinian shawl, tell other children that the "martyrs" are "grown
up kids." She compares their number to the number of dead Israelis. "It's almost
like a game," she says.
In 2000, before the so-called "second intifada," the New York Times wrote about
Yasser Arafat's summer "war-game camps" in Gaza, teaching young Palestinian
children how to prepare for the battle they would fight. That is fifteen years
of learning to kill Jews -- and fifteen years of creating child soldiers: a
violation of the UN Convention on Child Soldiers, and one reason so many young
Palestinians are primed for violence. Any Palestinian now under the age of, say,
23 could have had that "training." In the summer of 2015, tens of thousands of
teenagers in Gaza participated in these "summer camps" to learn from their Hamas
teachers to kill Jews.
Even before that -- since the Palestinians created their own school curriculum
21 years ago, in 1994, under the Oslo Accords -- Palestinian children have been
exposed to lies, incitement to violence and raw anti-Semitism, in the schools of
the Palestinian Authority and UNRWA. Palestinians under the age of 30 spend most
of their formative years in schools that deny the legitimacy of the State of
Israel and that deny any connection of the Jews to the land.
We are currently seeing the results of the long-term abuse of Palestinian
children by their parents and teachers -- abetted by the United Nations.
There have been many calls for the U.S. to defund the Palestinian Authority,
either completely or in part. This week Congress, in rare bipartisan agreement,
took up part of the challenge, stripping $80 million from $370 million of U.S.
economic aid to the Palestinian Authority.
History provides a framework for understanding today's politics. The Mufti of
Jerusalem was not only a kindred spirit of Hitler; he spent much of the war in
Berlin as the guest of like-minded practitioners of Jew-hatred. If what happened
in the 1930s and 1940s, however, is allowed to turn our attention from the
current threats to the Jewish State, we will have granted them a belated victory
they do not deserve.
© 2015 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. No part of this website or any
of its contents may be reproduced, copied or modified, without the prior written
consent of Gatestone Institute.
Analysis: Iran’s hostage-taking of Americans shows it can’t be housebroken
Benjamin Weinthal/J.Post/October 25/15
Obama has showed himself to be prickly and hyper-sensitive about his
administration’s failure to secure the release of the US hostages.
Iran’s refusal to release American hostages gets at the heart of some of the
skepticism voiced by critics that the July nuclear deal will help the Islamic
Republic reenter the international community. US President Barack Obama
envisioned in a post-nuclear deal that Iran would “take some decisive steps to
move toward a more constructive relationship with the world community.”Iran’s
blunt response was to convict the American-Iranian Washington Post reporter
Jason Rezaian in a Star Chamber setting earlier this month. Rezaian is widely
believed to have been framed based on trumped-up espionage charges by Iran’s
regime. His only “crime” was journalistic news gathering. As a result, the
expectation that Iran could be housebroken because of the over $100 billion in
sanctions relief it will receive due to the nuclear deal is already limping on
both legs at this nascent phase of the deal. The shaky formula behind the deal
between the US and its world partners (France, UK, Germany, China and Russia)
with Iran consisted of a quid pro quo: lucrative economic incentives – the
lifting of sanctions on Iran – in exchange for the mullah regime’s curtailment
of its illicit nuclear program.
In a Friday Washington Post opinion article, Naghmeh Abedini, whose husband,
Pastor Saeed, is imprisoned in Iran, captured the defects of the Iran deal.
“Finally, when the United States agreed to a nuclear deal with Iran in the
summer, there was much hope and anticipation that Iran would do the right thing
and release my husband and the other Americans it was holding hostage. The
reality: The deal did not produce freedom for our loved ones... The truth is
Iran cannot be trusted.” “Mr. President, it’s past time to bring the Iranian
hostages – including my husband – home,” wrote Abedini. Her husband was jailed
in 2012 for practicing his Christian faith.
He, along with three other Americans – Rezaian, Bob Levinson and Amir Hekmati –
have been incarcerated longer than the first wave of US hostages during the 1979
Embassy crisis in Tehran. Obama has showed himself to be prickly and
hyper-sensitive about his administration’s failure to secure the release of the
US hostages. In response to CBS News reporter Major Garrett’s question as to why
Obama was “content, with all of the fanfare around this [nuclear] deal, to leave
the conscience of this nation, the strength of this nation, unaccounted for, in
relation to [the] Americans” imprisoned in Iran, Obama responded, “That’s
nonsense, and you should know better.”
The Obama administration uses a peculiar terminology when describing the US
prisoners. “We continue to call on Iran to immediately release the detained US
citizens,” Secretary of State John Kerry said. “Detained” suggests that they are
being held temporarily, rather than the combined 15 years of incarceration
served by the four Americans. Kerry has doubled-down on his decision to not link
the release of US hostages to the Iran nuclear deal. “I think it was the right
strategy to pursue,” Kerry said, after the conviction of Rezaian. For critics of
the Iran deal, Kerry’s position is perplexing. After all, the US agreed to allow
Iran to procure conventional weapons. While the deal was supposed to be narrowly
focused on Iran’s nuclear program, Obama agreed to remove the UN embargo on
conventional weapons sales within five years. After eight years, the UN sanction
on missile sales will be lifted.
All of this helps to explain the headline of a Christian Science Monitor article
on Friday: “Why the nuclear deal has empowered Iran, for now.” A European
diplomat told the publication, “What you have to expect is a stiffening of the
Iranian position, a hardening really.”
Iran’s recalcitrance is not merely limited to hostage-taking, but to its refusal
to stop arming Syrian dictator Bashar Assad’s war machine, as well as to its
support for the Lebanese terrorist entity Hezbollah. Thus far, more carrots have
not domesticated Iran. It appears to be a case of “Everything old is new again.”
Benjamin Weinthal is a fellow for the Foundation for Defense of Democracies.
http://www.jpost.com/Middle-East/Analysis-Irans-hostage-taking-of-Americans-shows-it-cant-be-housebroken-429982