LCCC ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
November 08/15
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
http://www.eliasbejjaninews.com/newsbulletins05/english.november08.15.htm
Bible Quotation For Today/My
sheep hear my voice. I know them, and they follow me. I give them eternal life,
and they will never perish
John 10/22-42: "At that time the festival of the Dedication took place in
Jerusalem. It was winter, and Jesus was walking in the temple, in the portico of
Solomon. So the Jews gathered around him and said to him, ‘How long will you
keep us in suspense? If you are the Messiah, tell us plainly.’ Jesus answered,
‘I have told you, and you do not believe. The works that I do in my Father’s
name testify to me; but you do not believe, because you do not belong to my
sheep. My sheep hear my voice. I know them, and they follow me. I give them
eternal life, and they will never perish. No one will snatch them out of my
hand.
What my Father has given me is greater than all else, and no one can snatch it
out of the Father’s hand.The Father and I are one.’ The Jews took up stones
again to stone him. Jesus replied, ‘I have shown you many good works from the
Father. For which of these are you going to stone me?’
The Jews answered, ‘It is not for a good work that we are going to stone you,
but for blasphemy, because you, though only a human being, are making yourself
God.’Jesus answered, ‘Is it not written in your law, "I said, you are gods"?If
those to whom the word of God came were called "gods" and the scripture cannot
be annulled. can you say that the one whom the Father has sanctified and sent
into the world is blaspheming because I said, "I am God’s Son"? If I am not
doing the works of my Father, then do not believe me. But if I do them, even
though you do not believe me, believe the works, so that you may know and
understand that the Father is in me and I am in the Father.’ Then they tried to
arrest him again, but he escaped from their hands. He went away again across the
Jordan to the place where John had been baptizing earlier, and he remained
there. Many came to him, and they were saying, ‘John performed no sign, but
everything that John said about this man was true.’And many believed in him
there."
Bible Quotation For Today/Christ,
who through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish to God, purify
our conscience from dead works to worship the living God!
Letter to the Hebrews 09/11-15: "When Christ came as a high priest of the good
things that have come, then through the greater and perfect tent (not made with
hands, that is, not of this creation), he entered once for all into the Holy
Place, not with the blood of goats and calves, but with his own blood, thus
obtaining eternal redemption. For if the blood of goats and bulls, with the
sprinkling of the ashes of a heifer, sanctifies those who have been defiled so
that their flesh is purified, how much more will the blood of Christ, who
through the eternal Spirit offered himself without blemish to God, purify our
conscience from dead works to worship the living God! For this reason he is the
mediator of a new covenant, so that those who are called may receive the
promised eternal inheritance, because a death has occurred that redeems them
from the transgressions under the first covenant."
Titles For Latest LCCC Bulletin analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources published on
November 07-08/15
Question: "Is God / the Bible sexist?GotQuestions.org/November
07/15
Lebanon’s Salafist,
Sheikh Ahmad al-Assir Trials: An Explainer/Ana Maria Luca/Now Lebanon/November 07/15
Analysis: Why the West should worry about Turkey/PETER MARINO, REUTERS/J.Post/November
07/15
No one falls on his sword anymore: The ghosts of Iraq, again/Hisham Melhem/Al
Arabiya/November 07/15
Reviving interfaith and intercultural dialogue/Samar Fatany/Al Arabiya/November
07/15
Rampant sexual harassment on Egypt’s public transport/Yara al-Wazir/Al Arabiya/November
07/15
Titles For
Latest LCCC Bulletin for Lebanese Related News published on
November 07-08/15
“Patriarch of Antioch: Muslims want to conquer Europe with
‘faith and the birthrate'”
Minor Earthquake Jolts Northern Bekaa
Army Apprehends Fugitive for Smuggling Weapons
Jumblat: Boycotting Legislative Session is 'Suicide'
Report: Sweden to Deport Tens of Lebanese Families
U.S. Chargé d’Affaires Urges Lebanon Leaders to Find 'Innovative Compromises'
Lebanon’s Salafist, Sheikh Ahmad al-Assir Trials: An Explainer.
Titles For Latest LCCC Bulletin For Miscellaneous Reports And
News published on
November 07-08/15
ISIS frees 37 kidnapped Syrian Christians: NGO.
Intercepted ISIS chatter ‘boasted about Egypt crash’.
UK plane entering Sharm ‘missed rocket by 300m’ in August.
Putin halts flights to Egypt until “true causes” known for Metrojet crash.
Report: Israel worried Egypt's Sisi might fall to jihadist insurgents.
Egypt Says no Findings Yet from Russian Plane Crash Probe.
Egypt: West ignored calls to fight terrorism.
Russia faces evacuating 80,000 nationals from Egypt.
The ISIS affiliate in Sinai that is eluding Egypt's security dragnet.
Despite Russian strikes, Syrian rebels hold ground
U.S.-led strikes on ISIS to ‘increase in coming weeks’
U.S. to launch Syrian refugee screening centers.
‘Children massacred’ in South Sudan battles.
Sierra Leone celebrates end of Ebola epidemic.
Israeli troops in Hebron crackdown after shootings.
Links From Jihad
Watch Site for
November 07-08/15
Maronite Patriarch of Antioch: Muslims want to conquer Europe with ‘faith and
the birthrate’.
Islamic State frees 37 kidnapped Syrian Christians.
Michigan: Majority Muslim city council elected, “Today we show the Polish and
everybody else”.
Newsmax video: Raymond Ibrahim on downed Russian flight and Sisi’s Egypt.
Palestinian” Muslims shoot Israelis worshiping at Hebron shrine
Pakistan’s spy service engages jihadis to vandalize Hindu sites in India.
Report: UC Merced stabber was on terror watch list, had Islamic State flag
India’s VP: Western countries wrong to link Islam with terrorism.
California school district bans drawing Muhammad.
New Jamie Glazov Moment: The Leftist Heart of Darkness.
Question: "Is God / the Bible sexist?"
Answer: Sexism is one gender, usually male, having dominance over the other
gender, usually female. The Bible contains many references to women that, to our
modern mindset, sound discriminatory towards women. But we have to remember that
when the Bible describes an action, it does not necessarily mean that the Bible
endorses that action. The Bible describes men treating women as little more than
property, but that does not mean God approves of that action. The Bible is far
more focused on reforming our souls than our societies. God knows that a changed
heart will result in a changed behavior.
During Old Testament times, virtually every culture in the entire world was
patriarchal in structure. That status of history is very clear—not only in
Scripture but also in the rules that governed most societies. By modern value
systems and worldly human viewpoint, that is called “sexist.” God ordained the
order in society, not man, and He is the author of the establishment principles
of authority. However, like everything else, fallen man has corrupted this
order. That has resulted in the inequality of the standing of men and women
throughout history. The exclusion and the discrimination that we find in our
world is nothing new. It is the result of the fall of man and the introduction
of sin. Therefore, we can rightly say that the term and the practice of “sexism”
is a result of sin. The progressive revelation of the Bible leads us to the cure
for sexism and indeed all the sinful practices of the human race.
To find and maintain a spiritual balance between the God-ordained positions of
authority, we must look to Scripture. The New Testament is the fulfillment of
the Old, and in it we find principles that tell us the correct line of authority
and the cure for sin, the ill of all humanity, and that includes discrimination
based upon gender.
The cross of Christ is the great equalizer. John 3:16 says, “Whoever believes,”
and that is an all-inclusive statement that leaves no one out on the basis of
position in society, mental capacity, or gender. We also find a passage in
Galatians that speaks of our equal opportunity for salvation. “You are all sons
of God through faith in Christ Jesus, for all of you who were baptized into
Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. There is neither Jew nor Greek,
slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus” (Galatians
3:26-28). There is no sexism at the cross.
The Bible is not sexist in its accurate portrayal of the results of sin in both
men and women. The Bible records all kinds of sin: slavery and bondage and the
failures of its greatest heroes. Yet it also gives us the answer and the cure
for those sins against God and His established order—a right relationship with
God. The Old Testament was looking forward to the supreme sacrifice, and each
time a sacrifice for sin was made, it was teaching the need for reconciliation
to God. In the New Testament, the “Lamb that takes away the sin of the world”
(see John 1:29) was born, died, was buried and rose again, and then ascended to
His place in heaven, and there He intercedes for us. It is through belief in Him
that the cure for sin is found, and that includes the sin of sexism.
The charge of sexism in the Bible is based upon a lack of knowledge of
Scripture. When men and women of all ages have taken their God-ordained places
and lived according to “thus says the LORD,” then there is a wonderful balance
between the genders. That balance is what God began with, and it is what He will
end with. There is an inordinate amount of attention paid to the various
products of sin and not to the root of it. It is only when there is personal
reconciliation with God through the Lord Jesus Christ that we find true
equality. “Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free” (John
8:32).
It is also very important to understand that the Bible’s ascribing different
roles to men and women does not constitute sexism. The Bible makes it abundantly
clear that God expects men to take the leadership role in the church and the
home. Does this make women inferior? Absolutely not. Does this mean women are
less intelligent, less capable, or viewed as less in God’s eyes? Absolutely not!
What it means is that in our sin-stained world, there has to be structure and
authority. God has instituted the roles of authority for our good. Sexism is the
abuse of these roles, not the existence of these roles.
Recommended Resources: What's the Difference? Manhood and Womanhood Defined
According to the Bible by John Piper and Logos Bible Software.
What's new on GotQuestions.org?
“Patriarch of Antioch:
Muslims want to conquer Europe with ‘faith and the birthrate'”
Thomas D. Williams, PhD, Breitbart News, November 6, 2015
In a stunning interview, the Maronite patriarch of Antioch, Cardinal Bechara
Boutros al-Rahi, has contended that Islam has a clear, two-pronged strategy to
take over Europe: religion and procreation. The cardinal said that Muslims look
on Christians as weak and believe that since they have no children and barely
practice their faith, Islam will easily conquer them. Sadly, he said, Muslims
take their faith more seriously than most Christians, and they are gaining
ground because of it. “I have often heard from Muslims that their goal is to
conquer Europe with two weapons: their faith and their birthrate,” al-Rahi said
in a recent interview with Famiglia Cristiana, an Italian Catholic weekly
magazine. For the Muslims, the Cardinal said, “the practice of the faith is
essential and fundamental. In Saudi Arabia they go to Friday prayers even if
they need a walking stick. They know the Koran by heart, and when they talk they
often cite it. The same is not true for Christians who do not refer either to
the Bible or the teachings of the Church.” The Muslims “believe that God’s will
is to procreate and that marriage is aimed at this,” he said. “They think that
numbers will give them the upper hand.” Christians, however, “hardly get married
anymore, and have few children,” he said. The Cardinal also said that Muslims
“identify anything that comes from the West as Christian per se. All Western
politics is Christian politics, it is a new crusade. They say that Christians
are the remains of the Crusades and of Western imperialism,” he said.
At the same time, al-Rahi sharply criticized the EU’s ineffective solutions to
Europe’s migration crisis, arguing that the only way to end the chaos is by
stopping the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. The 75-year-old cardinal is the
Maronite Patriarch of the ancient city of Antioch, where Christianity has deep
and millennial roots. He said that the ongoing conflict provoked by the Islamic
State is forcing both Christians and moderate Muslims to emigrate from the Holy
Land, so before all else, attention must be given to putting an end to the
siege. It is useless for Europe to quarrel over the reception of refugees
without addressing the root cause of emigration from the Middle East, which is
armed conflict, he said. “The first thing to do to protect Christians in the
Middle East is to end the war in Syria, Iraq, Yemen and Palestine,” the Cardinal
said. “European states quarrel with each other about the number of refugees to
be admitted but do nothing to end the conflict.” “The Middle East is emptying
and leaving the field open to fundamentalist and terrorist organizations,” al-Rahi
said. For some reason, he said, “States do not talk about it, the only one
making appeals is Pope Francis.”“Europe is talking about the reception of
refugees, those who would like ten thousand and another who will take three
thousand people, but this does not help us,” he said. “Europe should focus on
the cause of migration, namely the war. You have to turn off the tap and ensure
that Muslims and Christians will return to their lands.”“A Middle East without
Christians,” the Cardinal continued, “has no identity.”“This is the place of all
divine revelation. It is where Jesus took flesh, died and rose again. It is
where the Church was born and began to proclaim the Gospel to the world,” he
said. Al-Rahi also noted that Christians resent being called a “minority” in the
Middle East. We have been here for two thousand years, he said, “six hundred
years before the arrival of Islam.” “Just as Europe discusses how to preserve
its identity, it is urgent that we do the same,” he said.
Minor Earthquake Jolts
Northern Bekaa
Naharnet/November 07/15/A minor earthquake rocked several regions in northern
Bekaa on Friday evening, causing no casualties or damage. The state-run National
Center for Geophysical Research said the epicenter of the 3.9-magnitude tremor
was an area between the city of Baalbek and the town of al-Fakiha. It said the
earthquake hit at 7:50 pm. The National News Agency said the tremor was felt by
residents in Baalbek, northern Bekaa, Hermel and the northern district of
Bsharri. According to NCGR, over 600 earthquakes with magnitudes below 3 degrees
hit Lebanon each year. In 1956, a 6 degrees on the Richter scale earthquake
struck Lebanon, killing 136 people and destroying 6,000 houses.
Army Apprehends Fugitive for Smuggling Weapons
Naharnet/November 07/15/The army arrested a Lebanese national in the northern
region of Akkar on charges of smuggling weapons to a terrorist group, an army
statement said on Saturday.“An army patrol arrested Youssef Mahmoud al-Khodr on
Friday, in the northern Lebanese border town of Mashta Hassan,” the statement
said. “Khodr is wanted on charges of transporting weapons and ammunition in 2014
in the town of al-Douseh, and attempting to smuggle them through the northern
border to one of the terrorist groups,” it added. The man was handed to the
related authorities for interrogations.
Jumblat: Boycotting Legislative Session is 'Suicide'
Naharnet/November 07/15/Progressive Socialist Party leader MP Walid Jumblat
described the stances of Christian blocs that are rejecting to take part in a
legislative session as a "suicide," An Nahar daily reported on Saturday. “The
stances of the Christian blocs is only a bidding and a message towards
additional self suicide,” Jumblat told the daily in a phone conversation from
Paris. “It is a pity that some of them (political factions) have not learned
from the lessons of the past, but we will not join them in this suicide,” he
added. Speaker Nabih Berri has called for a legislative session on the 12 and 13
of November to pass urgent laws and to prevent Lebanon from losing millions of
dollars in grants and loans amid threats that the major Christian parties could
boycott the session. The Free Patriotic Movement and the Lebanese Forces are set
to boycott the legislative sessions over the exclusion of the electoral law
proposal and a citizenship draft law from the agenda. The Kataeb Party also
refuses to attend the legislative session amid the presidential vacuum,
reiterating the need to hold the session primarily to elect a head of state.
Parliamentary sources supporting a parliament convention said on the expectation
of a quorum that more than 85 lawmakers are expected to take part in the
session, reflecting the concern to pass inevitable financial entitlements. Later
on Saturday, LF leader Samir Geagea addressed Jumblat via Twitter saying: “My
friend Walid Jumblat, you are very kind but sometimes love can kill.”
Report: Sweden to Deport Tens of Lebanese Families
Naharnet/November 07/15/Swedish authorities decided to deport tens of Lebanese
families that have already resorted to Sweden many years ago after it refused to
give them the necessary accommodation to settle on its territory, media reports
said on Saturday. Despite the fact that these families have settled in Sweden
for more than ten years and have founded private businesses and paid the taxes,
they did not get the accommodation required, the reports stated. With the
aggravation of the Syrian migrants crisis to Europe, the Lebanese expats were
surprised with the decision to expel them. Some of the Lebanese families who are
listed for deportation from Sweden face several humanitarian and economic
problems, most notably the children who were born there and got adapted with the
Swedish educational curricula and the families who have started their own
business, it added. A delegations from the listed families are expected to meet
with Lebanon's Ambassador to Sweden and Scandinavia Ali Ajami to ask for help.
The step will take place in parallel with moves that include peaceful marches
and sit-ins in front of the Swedish official quarters with the participation of
Swedish citizens supporting the case.
U.S. Chargé d’Affaires Urges Lebanon Leaders to Find
'Innovative Compromises'
Naharnet/November 07/15/U.S. Chargé d’Affaires ad interim Richard Jones on
Friday urged Lebanon's political leaders to find “innovative compromises” and
“Lebanese solutions” in order to overcome the country's growing political
crisis. “Domestic political stability cannot be bought or furnished from the
outside. Lebanese political leaders need to come together now to find innovative
compromises and Lebanese solutions to the challenges facing the country, so as
to end the current political paralysis,” said Jones after his first meeting with
Prime Minister Tammam Salam at the Grand Serail. The chargé d’affaires, who
arrived in Beirut overnight, will help fill a transition period until the
nomination and confirmation of a new ambassador, the U.S. embassy said in a
statement. “The Cabinet, Parliament, and a new President need to get back to
work for the benefit of the people they were or will be elected to serve,” Jones
said after his talks with Salam. “While these challenges require Lebanese
solutions, please rest assured that America will stand by your side as you
grapple with them,” he added. The envoy said talks tackled “the many
interlocking political, economic, security, and humanitarian challenges
confronting Lebanon today.”“I told Prime Minister Salam that America will remain
a steadfast partner as Lebanon responds to the threats presented by the
spillover from the crisis in Syria,” he said. Jones also vowed to “work
tirelessly to ensure American assistance in the military, economic, and
humanitarian spheres continues to help build a secure, prosperous, and stable
Lebanon.”“Our assistance will continue to equip and modernize the Lebanese Armed
Forces in order to bolster their ability to counter the extremist threat and to
fulfill the LAF’s responsibilities as the sole entity with the legitimacy and
capacity to defend Lebanon’s territory and its people,” he said. Jones has “deep
experience” serving in the region, including as ambassador to Lebanon from 1996
to 1998, the embassy said in its statement. “His return to Beirut and continued
service underscores the priority that the United States places on its strong and
enduring partnership with Lebanon at this critical time,” it underlined.
Lebanon’s Salafist,
Sheikh Ahmad al-Assir Trials: An Explainer
Ana Maria Luca/Now Lebanon/November 07/15
When Salafist Sheikh Ahmad al-Assir, clean shaven and disguised, was arrested at
the Beirut airport on his way to Cairo this August, there was little doubt he
would face serious charges. He reportedly admitted immediately to funding a
group led by another Salafist cleric, Sheikh Khaled Hoblos, whose sermons often
openly supported Jabhat al-Nusra and whose mosque displayed the group’s flag.
The charges, which were already serious before Assir’s arrest, accumulated over
a few weeks while he was interrogated. He’s accused of murder and attempted
murder of military personnel, including officers, as well as civilians;
incitement to murder army officers; forming sleeper cells in order to carry out
“terror acts” and assassinations of religious, political, and military figures;
forming an armed group with intent to undermine state authority; funding a
separate armed group led by the militant Khaled Hoblos; “incitement of sectarian
strife;” and damage to public and private property. The trial has already been
postponed twice. The next hearing was set for January 2016 at the request of the
defense lawyer. The excuse was that Assir needs the approval of Dar al-Fatwa,
the only Sunni religious authority recognized by the Lebanese state, in order to
appear in court. However, being a Salafist cleric, Assir is not officially
recognized by Dar al-Fatwa as a Sunni cleric in Lebanon. Both lawyers and
members of the Salafi community expect the trial to be postponed for much
longer. Salafist detainees investigated by the Lebanese security forces usually
face long legal procedures. Nabil Halabi, human rights lawyer and executive
director of the Lebanese Institute for Democracy and Human Rights (LIFE), says
this is so not only because of the political implications of Salafist trials,
but also because of the lack of due process in a complicated legal system based
on the military court, which is the only court in Lebanon that handles terrorism
and security cases.
The average Salafist trial
Lawyers are used to waiting for months, sometimes years, before a case is even
sent to the military court. Halabi told NOW that Islamist detainees are detained
without charges and kept in detention by the security forces without being given
a reason. When they are sent to the military court things get even more
complicated. “If any of the detainees said things in the court contrary to what
they’d said in the primary investigations in the Defense Ministry, or accuses
the investigators of torture, they get sent back to military intelligence where
they are investigated once again, sometimes by the same people,” Halabi said.
This raises questions over how real the evidence is. It also leads to situations
in which people who have served years in prison are eventually released for lack
of evidence. In many cases, Salafists are detained for being part of militant
groups, Halabi says. Investigations last much longer because the members are not
tried individually but rather as a group. The security forces rarely arrest all
the group members at the same time, and those arrested first have to wait until
the rest of the group are detained before they are sent to court as a group.
These practices also delay the trials. Other legal sources familiar with the
process say that many times the confessions of the detainees are obtained under
alleged torture. Allegations of torture have been documented by several
international human rights organizations, including Human Rights Watch. In these
cases, lawyers usually contest the primary investigation in court. The detainees
appear at a hearing and most say that they were forced to sign a confession.
That also takes time, and erstwhile the detainees remain in prison.
Political pressure
The same sources also explain that Salafists’ trials are also sensitive because
there is always political pressure. It all goes back to the Syrian crisis and
how the political factions in Lebanon position themselves in relation to the
war. Most activist Salafist leaders support the Syrian rebel factions and are
outspoken against Hezbollah’s intervention in Syria. They also gained a lot of
political support towards the beginning of the Syrian crisis. Many militants
fought in Syria and also were involved in attacks against Hezbollah that also
killed civilians. The political battle over which political faction controls
Lebanese security is also visible in how the cases of Salafists are treated: the
pro-Syrian March 8 movement controls security institution hunts for Salafists
and arrests them indiscriminately, which creates more unrest among the Salafist
community against the Lebanese Army.
A Salafist sheikh based in Tripoli told NOW on condition of anonymity that,
indeed, most young men who attend Salafist mosques fear they might be arrested.
“People just stay in their neighborhood; they don’t go out anymore,” he said.
“The authorities issued around 1,000 or more warrants for the people who
participated in the clashes that took place between Jabal Mohsen and Bab al-Tabanneh.
But in 2014 the Ministry of Justice decided to withdraw the warrants. However,
it seems that some security institutions, such as General Security and Military
Intelligence, continue to arrest people.” The sheikh also said that many young
men are afraid not so much of getting caught but that it will take a long time
for the state security apparatus to admit that there is no evidence to
incriminate them.
The precedents
Such arbitrary detention has happened before. Tripoli-based Salafists were
arrested in connection with the Nahr al-Bared war against jihadist Fatah
al-Islam. According to Halabi, many young men were detained for years without
being charged. In some cases, he says, the trials were resumed in 2014 after
Ashraf Rifi was named Minister of Justice. “When the cases were reopened, they
found that some of the detainees were innocent. In other cases, the prisoners
were released after the ends of their sentences. Also, could you imagine that
some were accused and sentenced for terrorism and received the death penalty
because they did not appear on time before the court. They claim it was because
of the absence of a private courtroom. When the retrial began, they turned out
to be innocent. Can you imagine that they were detained for seven-and-a-half
years?” Another spin to many of their stories is that after being charges of
belonging to Fatah al-Islam or militant Salafist groups, they were charged with
possession of assault rifles. “In this country almost every family owns one!”
Halabi adding that this approach angers the Sunni community and leads to
resentment and even to terrorism. “Most of the time, terrorism comes from
injustice and not just from deviant ideologies.”Ahmad al-Assir was the main
figure in the Abra clashes that took place in June 2013 between his supporters,
the Lebanese Army and, reportedly, members of the Resistance Brigades. He was
indicted for these incidents, which carry the risk of a death penaly, in
February 2014, and many others were arrested for supporting him. “Many were
arrested incommunicado [without a warrant issued by a judicial authority]
despite the fact that the government cancelled that type of warrant, which was
used heavily during the Syrian occupation of Lebanon,” Halabi said. “The thing
is that as long as you’re accused of terrorism on any type of evidence, the
Lebanese Criminal Code allows the judge to detain you indefinitely. And that is
a long time.”
Ana Maria Luca tweets @aml1609.
Amin Nasr contributed with translation.
https://now.mmedia.me/lb/en/reportsfeatures/566188-lebanons-salafist-trials-an-explainer
ISIS frees 37 kidnapped
Syrian Christians: NGO
AFP, Beirut Saturday, 7 November 2015/The Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS)
group on Saturday released 37 Syrian Christians, most of them women, who were
among more than 200 people kidnapped more than eight months ago, an NGO said.
The Assyrian Monitor for Human Rights said the group of freed Assyrian
Christians included 27 women and 10 men, most of them elderly. They arrived on
Saturday morning in the town of Tal Tamr in the Khabur region of Hasakeh
province in northeastern Syria, the group said. The releases were confirmed by
the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights monitor, which said most of those freed
were from other towns elsewhere in the Khabur region. The former hostages were
among a group of 220 Assyrians captured by ISIS when they overran parts of the
Khabur region in February. Since then, a trickle of the prisoners have been
released, with between 140 and 150 believed to still be held by ISIS. The
Assyrian Monitor said the releases were the result of negotiations carried out
by the church, but other reports suggest ISIS has been paid to free the
hostages. Assyrians numbered about 30,000 among Syria’s 1.2 million Christians
before the country’s conflict began. They lived mostly in 35 villages in Hasakeh.
In February, ISIS overran many of the villages, but Kurdish forces later
expelled them. ISIS has captured hundreds of hostages, including Christians from
different sects, in territory it controls in Syria and Iraq. Elsewhere, the
Britain-based Observatory said the toll in Thursday’s air strikes on the town on
Albu Kamal on the Syrian border with Iraq had risen to 49 people, at least 31 of
them civilians. The monitoring group had previously said at least 22 people were
killed in the strikes, but it was not able to confirm who was behind the
attacks. Russia, Syria’s government and a US-led coalition are all carrying out
air strikes on Syrian territory, sometimes operating in the same areas. The
Observatory said at least four of those killed in the raids on the ISIS-held
town were children.
Intercepted ISIS chatter
‘boasted about Egypt crash’
Staff writer, Al Arabiya News Saturday, 7 November 2015/Communications between
ISIS leaders in Raqqa, Syria, and persons in the Sinai Peninsula included boasts
about the downing of a Russian passenger jet over the area, NBC reported on
Friday, citing unidentified U.S. officials. “They were clearly celebrating,” NBC
Nightly News quoted a U.S. official as saying. The “chatter” included a boast of
taking down the plane on Saturday and how it was done.The U.S. intelligence
community intercepted a message from a Sinai group affiliated with ISIS that
warned of “something big in the area” before the jet crash.
U.S. steps up screening of flights. The U.S. said Friday it was stepping up
security screenings of U.S.-bound flights from some Middle East airports as a
precaution after the crash of the Russian airliner in Egypt. In this photo made
available Monday, Nov. 2, 2015, and provided by Russian Emergency Situations
Ministry, Egyptian Military on cars approach a plane's tail at the wreckage.
(Reuters) Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson said the U.S. also would
review its assessments of certain foreign airports and offer them help with
security, as well as take other measures, “both seen and unseen.”There is
growing evidence that the plane that crashed Saturday in the Sinai, killing all
224 people, was brought down by an explosion. Sources close to the investigation
told AFP that information from the airliner’s flight data and voice recorders
“strongly favors” the theory that a bomb exploded on board the Airbus A321.
Russia suspends Egypt flights. Moscow suspended passenger flights to Egypt, but
has said it is premature to reach conclusions that the flight was attacked.
However President Vladimir Putin agreed with Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi
to bolster coordination to secure Russian flights and resume them as soon as
possible. Sisi called Putin and they agreed “to bolster cooperation between the
two countries’ relevant agencies to ensure the safety of Russian tourists and
strengthen security measures for Russian planes,” a statement said.
International security warnings. Following international security warnings in
the wake of the crash, Denmark urged its citizens on Friday to avoid Egypt’s
southern Sinai Peninsula, including the Sharm el-Sheikh resort. The foreign
ministry said the advice was based on an assessment of aviation safety made
after fresh information was received on Friday, without going into further
details. The Danish ministry said on its website it now advised “against
non-essential journeys to the southern part of the Sinai Peninsula, including
Sharm el-Sheikh”. [With agencies]
UK plane entering Sharm ‘missed rocket by 300m’ in August
AFP, London Saturday, 7 November 2015/A British tourist plane heading in to land
at the Egyptian resort of Sharm el-Sheikh came within 1,000 feet (300 metres) of
a missile in August, newspapers reported Saturday. The near-miss involved a
Thomson Airways plane carrying 189 passengers from London on August 23. British
authorities concluded it was not a “targeted attack.”The incident happened
around two months before a Russian tourist plane leaving the Red Sea resort
plummeted from the sky into the Sinai Peninsula last Saturday, killing all 224
people onboard. A spokesman for Britain’s Department for Transport (DfT) said of
the August near-miss: “We investigated the reported incident at the time and
concluded that it was not a targeted attack and was likely to be connected to
routine exercises being conducted by the Egyptian military in the area at the
time.”The Daily Mail newspaper said the Thomson Airways pilot took evasive
action and landed safely. Holidaymakers were not told about the incident. “The
pilot was in the cockpit and saw the rocket coming towards the plane. He ordered
the flight turn to the left to avoid the rocket, which was about 1,000 feet
away,” the tabloid quoted a source as saying.
“Another Thomson plane was also flying into (Sharm el-Sheikh) at the same time
and saw the rocket. “The crew were told the rocket was from an Egyptian military
exercise, but with what has happened there is a lot of fear. The incident left
staff petrified.” A Thomson spokesman said: “Thomson Airways can confirm that an
event was reported by the crew of flight TOM 476 on August 23. “Upon landing
into Sharm el-Sheikh, an initial assessment was conducted and the event was
immediately reported to the UK DfT in line with established protocol. “The DfT
conducted a full investigation in conjunction with other UK government experts.
“After reviewing the details of the case, the investigation concluded that there
was no cause for concern and it was safe to continue our flying programme to
Sharm-el Sheikh.” Britain suspended flights to Sharm el-Sheikh on Wednesday
after saying it feared a bomb may have brought down the Russian jet, with Moscow
following suit on Friday. The resort is a popular destination with British and
Russian holidaymakers, usually hosting some 20,000 Britons. Moscow said Saturday
that it still has nearly 80,000 nationals in Egypt but there will be no
emergency evacuation, with tourists able to return at their own pace. Thomson
Airways has been repatriating Britons trying to return home following last
weekend’s crash. The first such flights back to Britain landed on Friday.
Putin halts flights to Egypt until “true causes” known for
Metrojet crash
DEBKAfile Special Report November 6, 2015: President Vladimir Putin halted all
Russian flights to Egypt Friday, Nov. 6, “until we know the true causes of the
incident” .i.e. the cause of the Russian Metrojet flight crash over Sinai
Saturday which killed all 224 people aboard. Several European and Gulf Arab
governments suspended flights to Sharm el-Sheikh, but Russia was the first to
halt all outbound flights to Egypt. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that
Putin acted on the recommendation of the Russian security service chief
Alexander Bortnikov.
The language of the statement – “true causes of the incident” - indicates that
the Russians have lost patience with President Abdel-Fatteh El-Sisi and don’t
trust the Egyptian investigation into the causes of the disaster. For most of
the week, the Russians played along with Egypt’s obstinate resistance to any
suggestion of terrorism and insisted on waiting for the official investigations
before making any determinations. Thursday, Moscow sharply criticized British
prime minister for presuming on the strength of intelligence that the plane was
most likely downed by a bomb.
Putin abruptly changed course Friday following four developments:
1. Russian investigators collecting samples at the crash scene in Sinai found
residue and other evidence of an explosion emanating from inside the plane or
externally from a missile. They discovered holes made by iron balls planted
inside a bomb and scattered through all parts of the plane (see attached
photos), as well as large tears in the outer walls that were caused by a
powerful explosion. Samples from the airplane’s wreckage were collected and
presented to a meeting of the National Anti-Terrorist Committee Thursday.
2. Forensic examination of victims’ remains left no doubt that they died as a
result of an explosive blast.
These findings spread like wildfire in Moscow and in St. Petersburg among the
grieving families. The Russian leader saw he could no longer afford to line up
with Cairo’s playdown of the terrorist factor.
3. Moscow received intelligence that the Islamic State plans to follow up on its
first “success” with further terrorist attacks on Russian and European passenger
jets.
By downing the Russian airliner over Sinai, the Islamist terror group delivered
a huge blow to Egypt’s tourism industry. Russia tops Egypt’s tourist market.
Last year, 3.1 million Russians visited Egypt, yielding $2.5bn out of the total
national tourism income of $7.3bn in 2014.
Sharm el-Sheikh was the scene of havoc Friday, as Russian and British tourists
mobbed the airport in an attempt to fly home after the Egyptian authorities
limited the number of outbound flights.
Report: Israel worried Egypt's Sisi might fall to jihadist
insurgents
J.Post/November 07/15/Israeli officials are reportedly growing concerned over
the long-term viability of the current Egyptian regime in light of gains made by
Islamists in their insurgency. Bloomberg News quoted a former Republican
lawmaker on Friday as saying that Israeli government figures are beginning to
wonder whether Egypt's president, Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, can successfully
overcome the threats posed to his rule by Islamic State-inspired Salafist
gunmen. Egypt's tourism industry - a key source of revenue for the cash-strapped
Arab giant - is expected to take an even bigger hit in the wake of Saturday's
crash of a Russian airline in the Sinai Peninsula. All 224 passengers on board
were killed in what Western intelligence agencies say may have been a terrorist
bomb. "We encountered a lot of people in Israel and elsewhere that don't think
that he is going to survive his term," Vin Weber, a former Republican member of
Congress, told Bloomberg. Weber is currently the co-chairman of the Egypt policy
task force of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
The think tank released a report co-authored by Weber in which he states that
his team met with a number of Israeli defense and security analysts in recent
weeks. According to the report, Weber's interlocutors paint a bleak picture of
Sisi's current standing in Cairo. "[Sisi] is under constant death threats,"
Weber told Bloomberg. "Many people said we're not sure where he sleeps every
night. And I think there is that question mark in the minds of the Israelis
about whether or not the government can succeed."An insurgency based in Sinai
and mounted by Islamic State's Egyptian affiliate has killed hundreds of
soldiers and police. In recent months, it has expanded to Western targets in
Egypt. The Islamist insurgency gained pace after Egypt's military, under Sisi's
command, overthrew President Mohamed Morsi of the Muslim Brotherhood Islamist
movement in mid-2013 in the wake of mass protests against his rule.
Islamic State controls large parts of Iraq and Syria, has a presence in Libya
and the support of militants in Egypt seeking to topple the Cairo government.
Sisi has described Islamist militancy as an existential threat to Egypt, the
most populous Arab state and a close US ally. Weber's co-chair in heading the
task force, Greg Craig, told Bloomberg that while Egyptian-Israeli security
cooperation in the Sinai has never been better - particularly since the 2014
Israeli military offensive against Hamas in the Gaza Strip - Jerusalem gives the
former general low marks in the manner in which he has tried to crush the
Islamist uprising. "We did spend some time with Israeli national security
folks," said Craig, a former Obama administration official. "One of the smartest
persons I've ever met in terms of analytical capacity was talking about the
Egyptian proclivity to do all the wrong things when it comes to
counter-insurgency." "If you had a list of boxes you checked of things not to
do, the Egyptian military has checked every one of those boxes," Craig said.Sisi
has reportedly acknowledged that Islamists have tried to assassinate him on at
least two occasions. Remarkably, though, there is now concern that the Egyptian
president has enemies within the ranks of the military.This past August, 26
Egyptian officers were sentenced to jail by a military court for allegedly
plotting to overthrow Sisi.
Egypt Says no Findings
Yet from Russian Plane Crash Probe
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/November 07/15/Egypt pushed back on Saturday
against international suspicions a bomb downed a Russian plane in the Sinai, as
intensifying restrictions on air travel threatened to cripple its vital tourism
industry. In the Red Sea resort of Sharm el-Sheikh, from where the doomed
airliner took off on October 31, thousands of Russian and British tourists
waited anxiously for word of when they might be able to fly home. Moscow on
Friday halted all Russian flights to Egypt and London has stopped British
flights to Sharm. Empty aircraft are to be sent out to bring home stranded
holidaymakers but the process will be slow. Sources in France close to the crash
probe told AFP that black box data pointed to a bomb having gone off and a
sudden, violent demise of the Airbus less than half an hour after takeoff.
British Prime Minister David Cameron has said that a bomb "had more likely than
not" been the cause of the explosion in which all 224 people on board lost their
lives. But Egyptian Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry said on Saturday the
Egyptian-led inquiry into disaster had yet to establish any theory about the
cause. "We have not dismissed any possibility but there is no hypothesis yet,
before the investigations are over and a full report is ready," Shoukry said. He
said that foreign intelligence that had triggered the international travel
restrictions had not been shared with Egypt. "We expected that any technical
information should have been shared with us, at a technical level, before
publicising it in the media," he said. Already battered by years of unrest,
Egypt is heavily reliant on tourism revenues and fears the impact any firm
determination that a bomb caused the crash would have on the key industry.
Fortnight for Russian repatriations
Russians make up the bulk of tourists who visit Red Sea resorts such as Sharm
el-Sheikh each year, and nearly 80,000 are currently holidaying in the country,
a Russian official told AFP. Empty aircraft will be sent to Egypt to bring them
home after President Vladimir Putin's decision to halt Russian flights but the
repatriations will be spread over the coming fortnight. "Tourists will be
returning from Egypt to Russia when they planned to," said Deputy Prime Minister
Arkady Dvorkovich, who heads a task force established to oversee their return.
"Most people left for two weeks -- our usual holiday tour lasts two weeks --
therefore they will return in about two weeks," he said. Russia followed in
Britain's footsteps, saying that holidaymakers would be returning home without
their hold luggage, which will be brought back to the country separately.
That restriction has prompted Egypt to limit the number of daily repatriation
flights because it says there is only so much left behind baggage its airports
can accommodate. At Sharm airport, one bemused Russian tourism stared at the
departures board trying to figure out when she might be able to fly home. "An
hour ago my flight was there but now it disappeared," Yulia Suvorova said.
British airlines said they expected to operate seven repatriation flights on
Saturday, only enough to make a small dent in the 19,000 Britons still in Sharm.
There were tears of relief as the first returning passengers landed in London's
Gatwick Airport on Friday after days of delays. "I'm so grateful to be home with
my family. I didn't think we would come back," said Emma Turner, 34, from Kent
in southeast England. - 'Suddenly there was nothing' -Kremlin spokesman Dmitry
Peskov told news agencies the decision to restrict flights did not mean Moscow
believed the crash -- the worst aviation disaster in Russia's history -- was due
to an attack, and the investigation continued. The head of Russia's emergencies
ministry said Russian experts had taken samples from the crashed jet and were
testing it for any traces of explosives. A source in Paris close to the
investigation told AFP the black box data "strongly favours" the theory a bomb
on board brought down the plane. Another person close to the case said the plane
had suffered "a violent, sudden" end, saying: "Everything was normal during the
flight, absolutely normal, and suddenly there was nothing." The Islamic State
group said it downed the plane in retaliation for Russian air strikes in Syria,
but has provided no details as to how. If it was behind the attack, it would be
the first time the jihadists, who control large areas of Syria and Iraq, have
hit a passenger plane. U.S. President Barack Obama has said that Washington is
"seriously" considering the possibility of a bomb aboard the plane. Homeland
Security Secretary Jeh Johnson said security screenings of U.S.-bound flights
from some Middle East airports would be stepped up as a precaution. Once a
remote beach on the edge of the Red Sea, Sharm el-Sheikh has grown into the
jewel of Egypt's tourism industry, with dozens of luxury hotels and night life
attracting tourists from around the world. The town attracted on average three
to four million tourists a year before the 2011 popular uprising that ousted
longtime president Hosni Mubarak.
Egypt: West ignored calls
to fight terrorism
By Asma Alsharif and Omar Fahmy Reuters, Cairo Saturday, 7 November 2015/Egypt
criticized its foreign partners on Saturday for ignoring calls to work harder to
combat terrorism, after Western intelligence sources said there were signs
Islamist militants may have bombed the Russian plane which crashed in Sinai. An
Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) affiliate has claimed responsibility for
the crash of the Airbus A321 operated by a Russian carrier that was bringing
holidaymakers home from the Sinai Peninsula resort of Sharm al-Sheikh one week
ago. All 224 people on board were killed in what the militants described as
revenge for Russian air strikes against Islamist fighters in Syria. Russia,
Turkey and several European countries have suspended flights to Sharm al-Sheikh
and the United States has imposed new air travel security requirements in the
wake of the crash. Egypt's Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukry, speaking hours before
authorities were due to make an announcement about their investigations so far,
said it would be wrong to speculate on the cause until findings were delivered.
But he said Cairo was not ruling out any possibility, and suggested countries
now flagging the likelihood that militants were behind the crash should have
heeded Egypt's repeated calls for coordination to combat militants. "The spread
of terrorism, which we have for a long time called on our partners to tackle
more seriously, did not get through to many of the parties which are now exposed
and which are currently working for the interests of their citizens to face this
danger," Shoukry told a news conference. He also expressed frustration that
foreign intelligence about the cause of the crash had not been passed on to
Cairo. "The information we have heard about has not been shared with Egyptian
security agencies in detail," he said. "We were expecting that the technical
information would be provided to us."
Explosion
An Egyptian source close to the investigation of the Russian plane's black boxes
said on Wednesday the cause of the crash was believed to be an explosion, but it
was not clear whether that was the result of a bomb. Western intelligence
sources have said British and U.S. spies intercepted "chatter" from suspected
militants suggesting that a bomb, possibly hidden in luggage in the hold, downed
the plane. U.S. television network NBC said some communications between Islamic
State leaders in Syria and the Sinai Peninsula included boasts about bringing
down the jet. "They were clearly celebrating," it quoted U.S. officials as
saying.On Friday, Moscow suspended flights to Egypt, leaving nearly 80,000
Russians stranded, mainly in the Red Sea resorts of Hurghada and Sharm
al-Sheikh, and adding to the growing chaos facing many tourists. British
attempts to fly home thousands of holidaymakers on Friday were mired in
confusion when Egypt restricted the number of flights, citing capacity limits at
Sharm al-Sheikh airport and British airliners' refusal to take passenger luggage
in the hold. British media reported on Saturday that a British passenger jet
came close to being hit by a rocket as it came in to land at Sharm al-Sheikh in
August, although the British government said it concluded the incident was part
of routine Egyptian military exercises, not a deliberate attack. The pilot of
the Thomson flight from London to Egypt took evasive action after spotting the
missile coming towards the plane as it flew to the Red Sea resort, the Daily
Mail reported. Egypt's Tourism Minister Hesham Zaazou said Cairo regretted the
suspension of flights and was doing all it could to secure its airports and
tourist sites, adding that he would fly to Sharm al-Sheikh to oversee measures
to support tourists there.
Russia faces evacuating 80,000 nationals from Egypt
Reuters, Moscow Saturday, 7 November 2015/Around 80,000 Russians are stranded in
Egypt after the Kremlin grounded all flights to the country following the crash
of a Russian airliner in the Sinai Peninsula, Deputy Prime Minister Arkady
Dvorkovich said on Saturday. President Vladimir Putin ordered the flight
suspension on Friday, a possible sign that Russia is attaching more credence to
the theory that a bomb brought down the Russian passenger jet in Egypt a week
ago, killing all 224 people on board. “Today the number of tourists in Egypt was
clarified, it is around 80,000,” RIA news agency quoted Dvorkovich as saying.
“The Egyptian military has taken control of the operation to put passengers on
flights,” he added. Russia will be wanting to avoid the chaotic scenes endured
by thousands of British holidaymakers stuck in Red Sea resorts after Egypt
slashed the number of flights it would allow to take them home. Oleg Safonov,
head of Russian state tourism agency Rostourism, said 1,200 Russian tourists had
returned home and future flights would be leaving without hold luggage. “A
planned process to evacuate tourists will be executed,” Russian news agencies
quoted Safonov as saying. “Planes will arrive empty and be boarded by those
tourists who should return home on that date.”The Russian Travel Industry Union
said nearly all Russian tourists due to visit Egypt in the coming days had
agreed to fly to Turkey instead. “In the near future, flights which should have
flown to Egypt are being redirected to Antalya,” the Interfax news agency quoted
union spokeswoman Irina Turina as saying. “Practically all tourists have agreed
with this.”
The ISIS affiliate in Sinai that is eluding Egypt's
security dragnet
Reuters/J.Post/November 07/15
The Islamic State branch suspected of bringing down a Russian airliner in Egypt
had eluded a security dragnet by operating in secretive cells inspired by a
leader who used to import clothes for a living, Egyptian intelligence officials
say. Western officials are increasingly pointing the finger of blame at Sinai
Province, which has focused on killing Egyptian soldiers and police since the
military toppled President Mohamed Morsi of the Muslim Brotherhood in 2013 after
mass protests. If solid evidence emerges it attacked the aircraft, that would
instantly propel the group to the top of the jihadi ladder, with one of the
deadliest attacks since al-Qaida flew planes into the World Trade Center in New
York in 2001.If a bomb knocked Airbus A321 out of the sky, that would challenge
Egypt's assertions that it had brought under control militants who have carried
out high-profile attacks on senior government officials and Western targets.
Security experts and investigators have said the plane is unlikely to have been
struck from the outside and Sinai militants are not believed to have any
missiles capable of striking a jet at 30,000 feet.Sinai Province is partly the
product of Egypt's efforts to eliminate militancy, which has threatened the most
populous Arab country for decades, according to the intelligence sources. The
three officials, who closely follow the Sinai-based insurgency, say many of its
fighters fled to Syria after Morsi was removed and then army chief Abdel Fattah
al-Sisi unleashed security forces on Islamists, both moderate and radical. Sinai
Province's leader - a 42-year-old former clothes importer known by his nom de
guerre Abu Osama al-Masri - studied at Al-Azhar, a 1,000-year old Egyptian
center for Islamic learning that supports the government, said the officials.
But like others who learned in a center known for its moderation, he was
radicalized and took up arms in Sinai before heading to Syria with about 20
followers when security forces clamped down on Islamists after Morsi's
departure, the sources said.
'THEY BECAME EXPERTS'
There, he and the other fighters gained experience that would prove useful upon
their eventual return to the Sinai, when they were approached by Islamic State
and embraced its goal of creating a caliphate across the Muslim world. It seems
they were mesmerized by Islamic State's mysterious Iraqi leader, Abu Bakr
al-Baghdadi, said the officials. Islamic State sent arms and cash by boat from
Iraq to neighboring Libya, where militants have thrived in the chaos that
followed the fall of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011, said another intelligence
official. A porous border then enabled Baghdadi's supporters to travel to Sinai,
on the other side of Egypt, to deliver the goods to Islamist militant comrades,
the officials added. "Other militants taught them how to evade capture and they
learned how to shoot accurately and assemble bombs," said one of the
intelligence officials, speaking on condition of anonymity. "They became
experts."Will McCants, director of the Center for Middle East Policy at the
Washington-based Brookings Institution, said that not a lot is known about the
working relationship between the Islamic State's Sinai affiliate and the
movement's central leadership. But the Egyptian group - like other affiliates -
appears to enjoy considerable autonomy. The state security crackdown launched
against the Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamists has gained the Islamic
State's Sinai branch significant local support, allowing its fighters to hide
and operate among ordinary people, he said.
SECRETIVE
During Morsi's time, security officials allege, militants from al-Qaida,
including some who had traveled from as far away as Afghanistan, had a free hand
in Sinai. They included about 4,000 fighters who would form the core of Sinai
Province, which was called Ansar Beyt al-Maqdis before declaring its support for
Islamic State last year, said the officials. The crackdown on Islamists by Sisi
- now president - led to many militants being killed, jailed or fleeing for
countries like Syria and Libya. Sinai Province now consists of only hundreds of
militants scattered into groups of 5-7 men, which have few links to reduce the
chances of capture, said the officials. "They are very secretive," one of the
intelligence officials said. "Each cell doesn't know about other cells." Another
said: "It's a small number of militants but it takes just one person to carry
out a suicide bombing." Last year, security officials said Masri and a few other
leaders had been killed. He later appeared in a video purported to prove he is
alive and reaffirmed his loyalty to Baghdadi. Masri could be seen kneeling
beside weapons he said were seized from 30 Egyptian soldiers killed in an
attack. A military armored personnel carrier burned in the background. A tribal
leader in the Sinai told Reuters he had recently noticed pro-Islamic State
militants driving around in new Toyota Land Cruisers. Some had Apple computers.
"It seems they are getting more and more ambitious," he said.
Despite Russian strikes,
Syrian rebels hold ground
By Bassem Mroue, The Associated Press Saturday, 7 November 2015/Despite a month
of heavy battering by Russian airstrikes, Syria's rebels have so far been able
to fend off offensives by government forces trying to retake territory from the
rebel's heartland. The fierce fighting shows how even greater backing from
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad's international allies is not swiftly tipping
the conflict in his favor. aAssad's military has launched assaults on severl
fronts in the north and northwest the past weeks, supported by Russian
airstrikes pummeling rebel positions that government forces are trying to
retake. Assad's troops have also been backed by the tougher fighters of
Lebanon's Hezbollah guerrilla army and combat advisers from Iran's elite
Revolutionary Guard — and top commanders from both Hezbollah and the Iranians
have been killed, a sign of the intensity of the battles. The rebels say they
have been able to hold out because of support from their own allies: An
increasing flow of American anti-tank TOW missiles that have allowed their
fighters to blunt attempted advances by Assad's forces. Despite more than 1,000
combat sorties by Russian aircraft hitting more than 2,000 targets, government
forces' gains have been minimal. "We don't deny that the airstrikes are
effective, but they (troops) will not advance on the ground," Lt. Col. Fares al-Bayoush,
commander of the 1,300-strong Fursan al-Haq Brigade, told The Associated Press,
speaking in the Turkish border city of Reyhanli.
The TOW rockets have been instrumental, he and other commanders said. The United
States has been supplying the missiles to select rebel factions for months, part
of its program alongside Saudi Arabia, Turkey and Qatar to boost the insurgency.
Al-Bayoush, a defector from Assad's army, said his fighters have a constantly
replenished supply and use them not only against tanks but also against troop
formations and other positions. "We fire 15 TOWs and we get 15 TOWs in return,"
he said. The combination of Russian strikes and Assad's ground offensives have
also rallied the multiple rebel factions to defend northwest Idlib province,
which they wrested completely from government control over the spring. The
territory is now the heartland for the rebels, a mix of moderate nationalist
factions and others with hard-line Islamic ideologies. "There is a sort of
competition now among the factions to excel in defending the areas so none of
them can get accused of being a traitor for losing a strip of land," said Hadi
Abdullah, an opposition activist who travels with the rebels to the front lines
to report on fighting. "They come to the rescue of each other on their different
turf."
The fighting suggests the Russians may run into the same reality as the
13-month-old American-led air campaign against ISIS in Syria: Air power doesn't
automatically translate into victories on the ground. It also points to how
international patrons have ensured each side can keep fighting in a war grinding
toward the 5-year mark with more than 250,000 killed and millions displaced.
Nikolay Kozhanov, a fellow with the Russia and Eurasia Programme at the
international affairs think tank Chatham House, said Russia's intervention is
"not enough to completely change the situation in the favor of the regime. ...
When it comes to urban fighting the Syrian army is still quite limited in its
capacities to advance." Soon after the Russian air campaign began on Sept. 30,
Assad's forces launched several ground offensives. One campaign is aimed at
taking back territory in Idlib to carve out a belt separating the province from
neighboring Hama province and connect government-held areas in Hama with Assad's
stronghold on the Mediterranean coast. Moscow says its air campaign is intended
to crush ISIS and other Islamic militants, not to help Assad in the war. But
while some strikes have targeted ISIS forces, more often they have battered
rebels factions that are rivals of ISIS and seem directly intended to help the
Syrian military's offensives.
For example, Russian strikes have hit the rebel-held town of Kfar Naboudeh
almost daily, according to Rami Abdurrahman, head of the Britain-based Syrian
Observatory for Human Rights, which monitors the Syrian war. The town, in Idlib,
is near the border with Hama province, and Assad's troops and Hezbollah fighters
have been battling to try to seize it as part of a campaign aimed at increasing
protection to a string of Alawite-majority, pro-government towns in Hama. Backed
by the strikes, Assad's forces briefly captured the town, but days later rebel
forces retook it. During the fighting, Hezbollah commander Hassan Hussein al-Haj
was killed, believed to be the highest-ranking figure lost by the group since it
joined Syria's civil war in 2012. The Russian airstrikes have been punishing for
the rebels, several commanders said. The more advanced Russian warplanes pack a
far more powerful and accurate punch and have better observation capabilities
than Assad's air force. Al-Bayoush said he sent home 130 fighters who had been
undergoing training because if a missile hit their training camp, "there would
be a massacre."Another local commander, Murhaf Anjeer from the small Al-Arbaeen
Battalion, said the Russian strikes were "wearing out" his fighters, leaving
them constantly on edge that they are about to be hit from the air. But the
rebels have adapted by avoiding fixed positions and hiding their movements
better. Factions rely more on small groups of fighters that fire TOWs and
retreat to avoid drawing attention of warplanes. The battles have continued in
the farmland and villages all along the Idlib-Hama border. A video released by
Fursan al-Haq last month showed one of its fighters using a TOW to destroy a
government tank at Tell Skeik, a hill that has gone back and forth between the
two sides. In parts of Hama, jihadi fighters from Uzbekistan and other parts of
Central Asia with the hard-line Syrian rebel group Army of Conquest have played
a big role in repelling government attacks, Abdurrahman said.
Another government campaign that has stalled aimed to open the highway linking
Hama with the city of Homs, further south. In weeks of fighting, troops have
been unable to advance despite Russian strikes on the rebel-held towns of
Talbiseh and Rastan. The Russian campaign has also been hitting ISIS, which
controls a large stretch from the outskirts of the northern city of Aleppo east
across the country to Iraq. Russian warplanes have been striking almost daily
around Kweiras, a base of Assad's military in Aleppo province that ISIS fighters
have been besieging for months. Backed by the strikes, Syrian troops have been
trying to reach Kweiras and break the siege. They have so far reached about 5
miles away in heavy fighting that killed a senior Iranian Revolutionary Guard
commander, Gen. Hossein Hamedani. ISIS fighters have lashed back. They captured
several towns north of Aleppo from rebels. They also launched a surprise attack
south of Aleppo, capturing part of a main highway used by the military to supply
government-held parts of the city. Assad's forces battled for two weeks and
finally took back the road Wednesday. Several rebel commanders said Russia's
entry in to the battle only encourages them by showing how reliant Assad is on
his allies. In July, Assad acknowledged in a speech that his troops had lost
territory and were running short on manpower. "The regime is collapsing and only
the Russians are propping them up," said Ahmed Saoud, a commander in the 13th
Division, another American-based FSA faction that has gotten new infusions of
TOWS and ammunition. "Even though we are the weakest link in the Syrian
conflict, we will win with our weapons."
U.S.-led strikes on ISIS
to ‘increase in coming weeks’
Reuters, Dubai Saturday, 7 November 2015/U.S. and coalition forces are likely to
increase air strikes against ISIS targets in Iraq and Syria in coming weeks
after a lull in September and October, the head of U.S. Air Forces Central
Command said Saturday. Lieutenant General Charles Brown told reporters at the
Dubai International Air Chiefs Conference that the reduction in air strikes was
due to weather and to a slowdown in activity on the ground and not due to the
start of Russian air strikes in the region. He said both government forces and
insurgents were increasing their ground movements, which could create more
opportunities for the United States and its allies to carry out more air strikes
against ISIS targets. "If they're not out and about, it's harder to strike,
particularly for an adversary that may wrap themselves in the civilian
population," he said. Brown also rejected criticism that the United States was
not using air strikes as much or effectively as possible, saying coalition
forces were striving to avoid civilian casualties that could help recruitment
for ISIS. He also noted that the sheer number of air strikes was less of an
indicator than the targets hit and the number of weapons used. The United States
and its allies targeted ISIS in Iraq with 14 air strikes on Thursday, and also
hit the militant group with nine air strikes in Syria, the U.S. military said on
Friday. Brown told reporters that an agreement signed with Russia to avoid
possible mid-air collisions was working well, and no incidents had been
reported. "They don't want a mid-air and neither do we," he said. He said the
agreement did not hinder U.S. forces from carrying out strikes where needed.
"We've said we're going to fly where we need to get the job done," he said.
U.S. to launch Syrian refugee screening centers
Julia Edwards, Reuters Washington Saturday, 7 November 2015/The Obama
administration is moving to increase and accelerate the number of Syrian
refugees who might be admitted into the United States by opening new screening
outposts in Iraq and Lebanon, administration officials told Reuters on Friday.
The move comes after President Barack Obama pledged in September to admit an
additional 10,000 refugees in 2016 from Syria, torn by four years of civil war
and disorder. The U.S. State Department confirmed the plans to open a refugee
settlement processing center in Erbil, Iraq, before the end of 2015, and to
resume refugee processing in Lebanon in early 2016, said spokeswoman Danna Van
Brandt. The White House would not say how many additional refugees it may take
in beyond the 10,000, but two senior administration officials said they are
seeking ways to increase the number. "We want to be in a place where we can push
out really ambitious goals," said one of the officials, who spoke to Reuters on
the condition of anonymity. The State Department runs nine screening centers
worldwide that serve as meeting points for refugees and U.S. Department of
Homeland Security employees who have to decide who is suitable for resettlement
in the United States. The additional centers will double the number available to
refugees in the Middle East. Most Syrians are now screened for potential U.S.
resettlement at centers in Istanbul and Amman, Jordan. The new centers are
designed to "increase the channels" the United States has for reaching Syrian
refugees, the official said. Homeland Security workers stopped traveling to
Lebanon to meet with refugees when the facility there closed over a year ago due
to security concerns. That closure sparked outrage among refugee advocates who
say Lebanon holds the largest number of Syrian refugees, most of whom live in
poverty because it is illegal for them to work. Lebanon announced last month,
however, that it would no longer accept Syrian refugees except in special cases.
Amid a tide of refugees in Europe, some congressional Democrats and refugee
advocates say the United States should do more for Syrians who often make
dangerous journeys to lands where they have no home or means of employment. Some
Republicans have raised concerns that allowing more Syrians into the United
States jeopardizes national security. "We have little or no information about
who these people are ... no ability to determine whether they are radicalized,"
Republican Senator Jeff Sessions said at a hearing on Oct. 2. Another senior
administration official told Reuters that the United States is also encouraging
other countries to contribute more money to the United Nations' effort to help
refugees. The administration is also looking to increase aid to Syria's border
countries of Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey as they take in millions fleeing the
war, the official said.
‘Children massacred’ in South Sudan battles
AFP, Juba Saturday, 7 November 2015/Dozens of children have been killed in
fighting in South Sudan, where battles rage despite political deals to end
almost two years of civil war, the United Nations has said. The U.N. said that
fighting in the northern battleground state of Unity has "intensified with grave
consequences for civilians" in recent weeks, adding that 40,000 people are also
starving to death. The report by the U.N. Office for the Coordination of
Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) released late Friday detailed killings in just one
area of Unity state during a two-week period.It said that in the Leer district
of southern Unity, which has swapped hands multiple times between government and
rebel forces, at least 80 civilians were killed between October 4 to 22. Almost
three-quarters of those killed were children -- at least 57 killed in Leer --
while there were more than 50 cases of rape being used as "a weapon of war", the
report said. Both sides are accused of having perpetrated ethnic massacres,
recruited and killed children and carried out widespread rape, torture and
forced displacement of populations to "cleanse" areas of their opponents. Hunger
experts from the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) have warned
of a "concrete risk of famine" before the end of the year if fighting continues
and aid does not reach the hardest-hit areas. While some aid has reached two
districts in Unity -- Buaw and Koch -- other areas are cut off. Some 3.9 million
people are in critical need of aid -- a third of the country's population and a
massive 80 percent rise compared to the same period last year, the U.N. said.
Civil war began in December 2013 when President Salva Kiir accused his former
deputy Riek Machar of planning a coup, setting off a cycle of retaliatory
killings that have split the poverty-stricken, landlocked country along ethnic
lines. The army and rebels have repeatedly accused each other of breaking an
internationally-brokered August 26 ceasefire, the eighth such agreement aimed at
ending the nearly two-year long war.
Sierra Leone celebrates end of Ebola epidemic
Saturday, 7 November 2015/Following 42 days with no new cases, the West African
nation’s epidemic was declared over on Saturday at a ceremony attended by
President Ernest Bai Koroma and U.N. World Health Organization (WHO)
representative Anders Nordstrom. Thousands of people gathered overnight around
the Cotton Tree, a massive tree in the center of Freetown, for a candlelit vigil
organized by women’s groups to pay tribute to health workers who lost their
lives. “They died so we could live,” university student Fatmata said with tears
in her eyes. Many of the health workers who died were infected due to inadequate
protective equipment and training. The country’s first confirmed Ebola survivor,
Victoria Yillia, told the crowd she was “happy that this disease which almost
killed me has finally ended.” She appealed to authorities not to forget
survivors, many of whom have faced social stigma and persistent health problems.
Elsewhere in the city, residents celebrated the end of the epidemic, which
forced schools to close, overwhelmed healthcare systems and hurt the local
economy. “We’re happy. I feel free again after a period of bondage in the hands
of Ebola,” said trader Joseph Katta as he clutched a pint of beer at a pub in
the suburb of Lumley. Ebola has killed more than 11,300 people in Sierra Leone,
Liberia and Guinea since the epidemic was announced in March 2014 and about
28,500 were infected, according to WHO data. Sierra Leone’s death toll was 3,955
people. Liberia was declared free of Ebola on Sept. 3, while a handful of cases
remain in Guinea. The 42-day countdown to be declared Ebola-free starts when the
last patient tests negative a second time, normally after a 48-hour gap
following their first negative test. The country now enters a 90-day period of
surveillance with support from the WHO, which said the monitoring phase was
critical to ensure early detection of any possible new cases. “We now have
a unique opportunity to support Sierra Leone to build a strong and resilient
public health system ready to detect and respond to the next outbreak of disease
or any other public health threat,” Nordstrom said at the ceremony. Fear of the
virus transformed the three countries and hampered efforts in Sierra Leone and
Liberia to recover from civil wars. At the height of the epidemic, authorities
in Sierra Leone and Liberia ordered people to stay indoors for days at a time in
an attempt to identify new cases and slow the disease’s spread.''
Israeli troops in Hebron crackdown after shootings
AFP -Hebron, Occupied West Bank Saturday, 7 November 2015/Israeli forces blocked
on Saturday exits from the southern West Bank city of Hebron as they launched a
manhunt for assailants after shooting incidents targeting Jewish worshippers and
a soldier. Two Israeli teens were shot and wounded on Friday at the flashpoint
site known to Jews as the Tomb of the Patriarchs and Muslims as the Ibrahimi
Mosque, the army said. Around 4,000 Jewish worshippers were visiting Hebron on
Friday and Saturday as part of a religious pilgrimage centered around the
biblical matriarch Sarah, who according to tradition was buried in a field which
eventually became part of the city Hebron. A soldier was also shot and wounded
on Friday near the Palestinian village of Beit Anon north of Hebron. Army
spokesman Lieutenant Colonel Peter Lerner told AFP there was “ongoing activity
to locate the perpetrators of yesterday’s attacks.”Israeli forces were searching
Palestinian homes in and around Hebron as well as setting up new checkpoints for
vehicles and people, an AFP reporter said. In addition the army blocked off the
northern entrance of Hebron with mounds of dirt. The eastern entrance has been
sealed off for days. Israeli rights group B’Tselem on Friday criticized the army
for carrying out “immoral and unlawful” measures which it said hinder
Palestinian freedom of movement in Hebron, including closing off the Tel Rumeida
neighborhood. “These steps constitute collective punishment of residents of
Hebron who are suspected of nothing and are forced to suffer serious disruptions
in their daily lives,” the group said. Hebron has 200,000 Palestinian residents
with approximately 500 Israeli settlers living in the centre, protected by an
army-patrolled buffer zone. The situation is a constant source of tensions. Also
on Friday a 72-year-old Palestinian woman was shot dead by soldiers after
allegedly attempting to ram them with her car nearby Hebron. Friday’s unrest
broke a brief lull in the wave of deadly attacks and violent protests throughout
October that raised fears of a new Palestinian intifada, or uprising, against
Israeli occupation. Most of it had occurred in and around Hebron and mainly
involved Palestinian stabbing attacks. There were no clashes or attacks in the
city on Saturday as troops searched for the assailants. But an army spokeswoman
said a soldier was slightly wounded by “an accidental discharge of a bullet near
a military position in Hebron.”
Analysis: Why the West should worry about Turkey
By PETER MARINO, REUTERS/J.Post/11/06/2015
Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan appears to have beaten down his opponents and
returned his Islamist-rooted Justice and Development Party (AK Party) to a
fourth term of single-party rule over the country. In doing so, he has cemented
his own already-firm control over the country, and is a large step closer to
becoming the most influential figure in Turkish politics since Ataturk himself.
The consequences of the AK Party’s victory are likely to be enormous, for
Turkey, the region, and possibly for Europe, Russia and the United States as
well.
After Sunday’s parliamentary election, it is now possible that the secular
Turkish republic - as it has been established since 1923 - will eventually
become something unrecognizable to its founders. In his early years in power,
Erdogan and his AK Party were hailed by Western governments as pragmatic
reformers, and proof that political Islam could be democratic and pluralistic.
Turkey was moving closer to serious consideration for EU membership, opening up
to foreign investment and growing economically.
But since the 2008 financial crisis, and especially since the 2013 Gezi Park
protests in Istanbul, during which Erdogan cracked down on perceived opponents
in full view of the world, he has become increasingly autocratic. Indeed,
Erdogan called for Sunday’s elections after the AK Party failed to gain the
majority of votes in June elections and Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu was
unable to form a coalition with the three opposition parties in parliament. Many
Turkey analysts believe that Erdogan had no intention of letting the talks
succeed in the first place, and may have pressured Davutoglu to allow them to
fail.
Erdogan’s unwillingness to accept a legitimate, democratic election result, and
his desire to politicize an office that is nominally non-partisan - the
presidency - are just two of many signs that he is tightening his grip on power.
Sunday’s results will likely make Erdogan more autocratic, as the former prime
minister has been vocal about his desire to convert the parliamentary republic
into one headed by a president, which, conveniently for him, is the office he
already holds. And while the results don’t give the AK Party sufficient power to
amend the constitution on its own, Erdogan’s party has a history of following
his orders regardless of what the constitution says.
Erdogan’s relationship with the liberal and secular Turkish Kurds, damaged by
his divisive rhetoric and political tactics, is likely to deteriorate further
under the new AKP government. Indeed, it was because of the Kurds’ success in
the June elections that Erdogan’s AK Party was denied a majority, compelling him
to call for Sunday’s election.
On Sunday the Kurds were successful enough that they denied Erdogan his
longed-for supermajority. And Erdogan is unlikely to forget. The possibility
that the Kurds and the Turkish government will resume conflict in the Kurdish
regions is no longer that farfetched.
All of this, of course, comes amid a rapidly worsening security situation in
Turkey’s backyard, much of which involves Kurds in Iraq and Syria. Additional
instability in this already very unstable region worries Europe and the United
States, as well as other Middle Eastern countries.
But the same instability that troubles these countries also prevents them from
being able to do much about Turkey’s commitment to democracy in the near-term.
Turkey’s location, combined with its NATO membership, makes it an indispensable
partner in dealing with Russian activity in the region, Islamic State, the
Syrian civil war and the unfolding migrant crisis. Dealing with Erdogan is now,
for his Western partners, much like holding a wolf by the ears: risky, but the
alternative seems much worse.
Sunday’s results don’t end the political and social divides that threaten
Turkey. They merely reset the stage for continued struggle: the AK Party against
the secular cosmopolitan elite; Erdogan against the Kurds; Islamic State against
Turkey and the region; and Europe, the United States and even Russia standing by
nervously, assessing the potential impact on their regional interests. Erdogan
has the means, motive and opportunity to exploit this moment of authority, and
his recent political behavior suggests he will.
**Peter Marino is an international politics analyst, specializing in Northeast
Asian affairs and international political economy. He holds an MSc from the
London School of Economics and currently produces and hosts the global politics
web series Globalogues.
No one falls on his sword
anymore: The ghosts of Iraq, again
Hisham Melhem/Al Arabiya/November 07/15
‘Finally, he [Brutus] spoke to Volumnius himself in Greek, reminding him of
their student life, and begged him to grasp his sword with him and help him
drive home the blow. And when Volumnius refused, and the rest likewise ...
grasping with both hands the hilt of his naked sword, he fell upon it and died.’
Plutarch
The ghosts of Iraq are haunting us again. In fact these ghosts have been
hovering over us ever since that fateful violent encounter on March 19, 2003
when the American invasion of Iraq began. Millions of Iraqis are still
experiencing the painful and chaotic reverberations of that transformative day,
and hundreds of thousands of Americans have been scarred by a war that refuses
to end. In the span of few days some of the participants in that in that
invasion forced us to reflect once again on the folly of a war that was supposed
to end all the wars that Iraq went through ever since Saddam Hussein blundered
into the invasion of Iran in September 1980.
These ghosts have been hovering over us ever since that fateful violent
encounter on March 19, 2003 when the American invasion of Iraq began
Former British Prime Minister Tony Blair offered a pre-emptive and very
qualified apology for ‘mistakes in planning’ the war, and former American
President George Herbert Walker Bush lashed out at his son’s senior aides such
as former Vice President Dick Cheney and former Secretary of Defense Donald
Rumsfeld, accusing the former of pushing for a ‘very hard line’ and of being too
eager to ‘use force to get our way’ in the Middle East and the latter of being
an ‘arrogant fellow’ and full of ‘swagger’. In the interim came the news of the
passing of Ahmad Chalabi, the Iraqi opposition leader in exile, who exaggerated
Iraq’s supposed arsenal of weapons of mass destruction and was close to many
U.S. lawmakers and the darling of the neo-conservatives in Washington who wanted
him to lead a liberated, pro-American Iraq.
Insincere and very late ‘apology’
Blair’s apology was a pre-emptive spin designed to address in part the so-called
Chilcot inquiry (named after Sir John Chilcot) into the British role in the Iraq
war, and particularly Blair’s actions before the expected damning findings are
published. The apology was hedged with qualifications; ‘I apologize for the fact
that the intelligence we received was wrong’ implying that the fault is that of
U.S. Intelligence agencies only. But, according to U.S. officials then, Blair
was a very enthusiastic warmonger. Blair also apologized for ‘our mistake in our
understanding of what would happen once you removed Saddam Hussein’. But, the
smarmy unreconstructed Blair said ‘I find it hard to apologize for removing
Saddam’. Blair dismissed calls that he should stand trial as a war criminal,
implying that the judgement of history on ‘my crime’ will not be very harsh.
But Blair came closer to the truth when he admitted that ‘there are elements of
truth’ that the invasion of Iraq had been the ‘principal cause’ of the rise of
the Islamic State (ISIS). Blair’s insincere apology was many years late, and
instead of addressing a sincere apology to the people of Iraq, who bore the
brunt of it, and to the British people in whose name he participated in the
invasion, he made his pro-forma gesture in an interview with CNN. Blair’s
apology is a way of avoiding moral and legal responsibility for the invasion,
and certainly not an attempt at atonement. Blair is not the kind of a man who
would fall on his sword.
The rage of the Patriarch
In the twilight of a long life, the Patriarch of the Bush family former
President George H. W. Bush raised implicitly the uncomfortable question as to
who is responsible for the invasion of Iraq. The first President Bush, after
directing his rage against his son’s lieutenants, also threw some gentle jabs at
his son because of his ‘hot rhetoric’ like his infamous ‘axes of evil’ speech,
and he pointedly said that final responsibility for the faulty views of Cheney
and Rumsfeld rests with Bush the second. But the Patriarch Bush, who stated
these assessments in a new biography, did not fault his son for the invasion
which is still rattling the Bush dynasty, particularly the presidential campaign
of the third Bush who would be President, Jeb Bush who is still dogged by a war
he cannot denounce nor embrace.
Me saying Mea Culpa?
People are reluctant to apologize and own their mistakes. Harder still is for
people to be held morally and legally accountable. For leaders to apologize
publicly, to seek atonement or resign from their positions because they failed
the institutions they represent is infinitely more difficult in part because of
the legal and political ramifications of their apologies.
For a leader saying mea culpa is very hard to do. No American President ever
apologized for the war in Vietnam or for the invasions of Panama, Afghanistan
and Iraq. Moreover, no president or senior official was held legally accountable
for using force overseas and very few resigned over principles. Former U.S.
secretary of defense Robert McNamara, who was the architect of escalating the
war in Vietnam, spent the last years of his life beating his chest and
apologizing repeatedly for his errors of judgement during the war. The once
powerful man was haunted by his bloody blunders ‘We were wrong, terribly wrong.
We owe it to future generations to explain why’. But, McNamara also opted not to
fall on his sword when he had the chance.
There were two significant resignations in protest of the war in Vietnam during
the presidency of Lyndon B. Johnson. Johnson’s first secretary of health,
education and welfare, John Gardner resigned because of his moral opposition to
the war; he even told Johnson that he could not support his re-election. The
second official to resign was deputy secretary of defense Cyrus Vance, who
initially supported the war, before he realized that it could not be won. But
Vance is known more for his second resignation over a principle. Vance served as
President Jimmy Carter’s first secretary of State. When the principled statesman
who strongly believed in diplomacy realized that President Carter decided to
accept the recommendation of his rival the National security advisor Zbigniew
Brzezinski to use force to rescue the American diplomats held hostage in Iran in
1980, he quietly submitted his resignation. Several days after the rescue
mission failed tragically the resignation was made public. Vance was the second
secretary of state to resign his position over a principled opposition to force
in the twentieth century after William Jennings Bryan who opposed America’s
entry into the First World War in 1915.
Vance was the last senior American official to resign over a principled
opposition to the use of military force. In the run up to the invasion of Iraq,
it was believed that former deputy secretary of state Richard Armitage had
suggested to his friend and boss former secretary of state Colin Powell that
they should resign, given Powell’s initial skepticism about the claims of WMD in
Iraq, but that Powell, after mulling the idea for few days decided against it.
His argument was that if they had resigned, things could have degenerated
further. Powell also chose not to fall on his sword when it became clear that
his testimony at the United Nations about Iraq’s WMD program was bogus.
Apologies have become meaningless
In recent years a strange culture of qualified apologies appeared. American
officials, public figures and chairmen of powerful corporations, when they give
up their initial resistance to issue apologies for mistakes of judgements, turn
and issue apologies that are laced with many qualifications that they lose their
meanings. Most of them use the preferred form of neutral apology; ‘mistakes were
made’. Rarely these apologies carry legal ramification. There is also the
redemptive and cathartic aspect of apologies. When the financial or sexual
transgressions of a prominent politician, a major CEO, or a head of a church are
exposed, they perform an impressive amount of breast-beating asking for
redemption and forgiveness, hoping to reach the next stage of ‘moving on’.
Americans like public catharsis, and are willing to give the sinners a second
chance. In most cases these public rituals of seeking redemption work.
In recent years some American presidents were forced to issue public apologies
for their failings, and the return of these apologies were impressive. In 1961,
President John F. Kennedy took responsibility for the ill-fated of the Bay of
Pigs invasion of Cuba. He famously said ‘there is an old saying that victory has
a hundred fathers and defeat is an orphan.’ He assured the American people that
he will not conceal his responsibility ‘because I am the responsible officer of
the government’. Kennedy’s popularity after his mea culpa in fact soared. After
the Iran-Contra scandal rocked his administration, President Ronald Reagan took
responsibility for his government’s illegal schemes. He said: ‘now, what should
happen when you make a mistake is this: you take your knocks, you learn your
lessons, and then move on. That’s the healthiest way to deal with a problem...’
Reagan fully succeeded in ‘moving on’ beyond the scandal. President Bill
Clinton’s apology over his sexual tryst with the intern Monica Lewinsky allowed
him to dampen the frenzy of those seeking his head, and like Kennedy and Reagan,
his popularity remained high until the end of his tenure.
No one falls on his sword anymore
The George W. Bush administration which launched the two longest wars in
American history is infamous for living in denial of the human and material
wreckage it left behind in Afghanistan and Iraq. No official had the moral
courage to fall on his or her sword and resign or to seriously apologize to
those Iraqis and Americans who suffered mightily because of the war, and no one
showed genuine remorse, for the deceptions and the horrors visited on many
including those tortured in detention camps. The pro-forma apologies over the
abomination of Abu Ghraib torture, do not count, because those who were held
legally accountable were not high on the totem pole. Almost every senior
official, from President Bush on down published his or her memoirs, made money,
and toured the country peddling their accounts of what happened in Afghanistan
and Iraq; they claimed the high moral ground, while passing the buck implicitly
or explicitly to other officials. It is still murky as to the decision making
process that led Paul Bremer, America’s civilian ‘Viceroy’ in charge of Iraq
after the fall of the Baathist regime to issue his infamous and destructive
Provisional Authority Order Number 1 to ban the Baath party, and the more
self-defeating Order Number 2 which disbanded the Iraqi army.
In his memoir as well as in interviews and speeches Bush would acknowledge that
he continues to have that ‘sickening feeling’ about the failure to find weapons
of mass destruction in Iraq, but that does not negate the fact that toppling the
Iraqi regime was the right thing the former President would insists. President
Bush would only admit that Abu Ghraib was a mistake in addition to other minor
ones like his strong rhetoric and braggadocio in phrases like ’bring them on’ or
‘dead or alive’. In his biography of his father, which was published last year,
President Bush wrote: ’ one thing is certain: the Iraqi people, the United
States and the world are better off without Saddam Hussein in power’. Bush added
‘I believe the decision that Dad made in 1991 was correct - -and I believe the
same is true of the decision I made a dozen years later.’
Saddam Hussein was a war criminal; he victimized and brutalized his own people
before he terrorized the Iranians and Kuwaitis. But Iraq today is a broken
country as a result of the invasion and the early decisions of the Bush
administration, as well as the depredations of Iraq’s sectarian and corrupt
rulers.
Twelve years after the invasion and the horrendous number of Iraqi and American
casualties, Baghdad is firmly in the grip of Iran, while large swath of Iraqi (
and Syrian) territories are under the barbaric rule of ISIS, which emerged from
the ashes of the invasion. And yet the man who ordered the invasion still
insists that Iraq, the U.S. and the world are better off because of his historic
blunder. No one falls on his sword anymore.
Reviving interfaith and intercultural dialogue
Samar Fatany/Al Arabiya/November 07/15
The Saudi Council of Ministers recently directed its National Committee to
follow up on King Abdullah’s initiatives for dialogue among followers of various
religions and cultures. It is heartening to finally hear about a positive
contribution to this cause. The King Abdullah Bin Abdulaziz International Center
of Interreligious and Intercultural Dialogue which was established in Vienna in
2010 needs more support to carry out its ambitious mission. The interfaith
initiative needs to be renewed and given more serious political, financial,
academic and media support to dispel misconceptions about the Muslim faith and
to end the cycle of suspicion based on distorted information which attempts to
demonize Muslims and to create a divide between Islam and the West. The
management of interfaith dialogue is not an easy task. It needs international
experts to efficiently engage faith-based organizations, social activists,
prominent religious leaders and advocates of peace who can actively address
universal challenges and concerns with a more scientific, civil and humane
approach. It is important to establish cooperation with global organizations
that acknowledge Muslim contributions and exhibit genuine goodwill toward Islam
and Muslims. International Muslim organizations do not have enough backing to
carry out their mission effectively. As a result, many religious scholars and
specialists in the field have lost their enthusiasm to contribute. Extremism is
still prevalent in many parts of the Muslim world. It is important to promote
moderate and reputable Muslim scholars to influence change and to expose those
who instigate wars in the name of religion. Moderate scholars should be more
vocal and should be given international exposure and support. Religious leaders
in the Muslim world need to effectively integrate the perspectives of
traditional Islam with the realities of the 21st century. Human rights values
should be integrated into our Islamic teachings. The debate among Muslim
scholars and the lack of a consensus on Islamic teachings continue to undermine
the image of all Muslims and to reflect badly abroad on Islamic culture and
heritage.
We need to provide more opportunities for Arab and Muslim scientists and
professionals to cooperate in global scientific and humanitarian projects and
events. Muslim contributions in global initiatives can project the true image of
Muslims who are peaceful and caring.
Religious leaders in the Muslim world need to effectively integrate the
perspectives of traditional Islam with the realities of the 21st century
A coalition of academic institutions can also play an important role. Muslim and
international educators, writers and book publishers if given enough support can
be effective in confronting the teachings of hatred and the contempt and
damaging stereotypes that are found in various religious school classrooms in
many parts of the world today. Interactive workshops involving religious school
educators and administrators can stimulate inter-religious thinking and promote
moderate teaching models and literature. What we also lack is a strong media
campaign to counter the vicious attack on Islamic values and heritage. Media
analysts urge the need to train Muslim journalists and seek expert advice from
media professionals in the West who advocate peace. We need to establish strong
cooperation with international Islamic organizations, like the Council on
American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) or the U.S. Council of Muslim Organizations
that provide the mechanisms to enable the American Muslim community to overcome
their challenges. They offer advice and direction and institutionalize policies
to protect the interests of Muslim communities. They support their mission by
monitoring publications, films, cartoons and other damaging stereotypes that
propagate hatred and contempt against Islam in Europe and the U.S. We need to
learn from their experience and build our own media professionals and
organizations to provide direction for our youth and expose the evil designs of
our enemies who continue to threaten our security and social stability. Cultural
exchange can play a very important role in building bridges of understanding.
Engaging Muslim women in interfaith and intercultural dialogue can also greatly
contribute to erasing negative stereotypes about women in Islam. A revival of
King Abdullah’s noble initiative of interfaith dialogue needs a well-structured
strategy on a global scale to confront the rise of Islamophobia and expose the
extremist elements with vested interests who attempt to defame Islam and
Muslims.
Rampant sexual harassment on Egypt’s public transport
Yara al-Wazir/Al Arabiya/November 07/15
According to the United Nations, 99.3percent of women in Egypt have experienced
some form of sexual harassment, with 81 percent reporting frequent harassment
while using public transport. To tackle this, Cairo’s metro service now features
billboards of cartoons that advocate against sexual harassment.
They feature a woman in various scenarios: on the street, the metro or a bus.
The emotional toll of harassment on the woman is depicted through thought
bubbles as men verbally abuse her. The cartoons remind commuters of the
important roles that women play in Egyptian society, for example as doctors,
engineers and teachers. They also remind commuters that sexual harassment
affects everyone. Yet the cartoons merely touch on the impact of the harassment,
and focus more on the impact on the harasser than on the victim. In a block of
images, the cartoons tell the story of how a newlywed wife is “on edge” with her
husband, how a teacher now educates with a “cane” after she once taught with
conviction, and how a female engineer was so upset because of the harassment
that she faced, that the drawings of a bridge she designed had a mistake that
jeopardise the integrity of the structure of the bridge. The impact of sexual
harassment goes far beyond anxiety, as depicted by the cartoons. Victims live in
a constant state of fear. It can lead to depression, insomnia, eating disorders,
elevated blood pressure and even suicidal thoughts, according to Shepherd
University.
The prevalent mentality that blames the victim for her looks, behavior or
clothing must be addressed. In one cartoon, a woman tries on several outfits,
but imagines what negative comments male commuters will make for wearing each
one. Yet no link has been found between sexual harassment and clothing in Egypt,
as 72 percent of veiled women reported harassment, according a study by the U.N.
Population Fund.
Blaming the victim
Sexual harassment was outlawed in Egypt last year, yet women continue to suffer.
One of the main factors that contribute to its continuation is the shaming and
blaming of women. The audacity of TV presenter Reham Saeed to publically shame a
woman for alleged ‘indecency’ after she was slapped in a Cairo mall is a prime
example of how society reacts to a woman being harassed. Saeed scrutinized the
way the victim was dressed during the incident, and in private pictures obtained
from her mobile phone. Regardless of the backlash against the TV show, the
producers would not have agreed to broadcast Saeed’s statements if they did not
believe the public agreed with what she said. Research shows that 98 percent of
attacks occur when a woman wears conservative clothing, compared with 2.1
percent of attacks that occur when a woman wears revealing clothing and
full-face makeup. There is no correlation between what a woman wears and the
probability of her being harassed. The absence of a safe environment and support
system is the biggest hurdle to tackling sexual harassment in Egypt. The
prevalent mentality that blames the victim for her looks, behavior or clothing
must be addressed. Women must be able to commute to work in safety. They must
know their rights and understand that sexual harassment is illegal - 23 percent
of victims are not aware of this. Female-only commuter carriages on the metro,
introduced in Egypt in 2007, are the equivalent of a plaster on a gushing wound.
The government must work diligently to prosecute attackers.