LCCC ENGLISH DAILY NEWS BULLETIN
March 11/2020
Compiled & Prepared by: Elias Bejjani
The Bulletin's Link on the lccc Site
http://data.eliasbejjaninews.com/eliasnews19/english.march11.20.htm
News Bulletin Achieves Since 2006
Click Here to enter the LCCC Arabic/English news bulletins Achieves since 2006
Bible Quotations For today
Be sure that Almighty God shows no partiality
Letter to the Galatians 02/01-07/:”Then after fourteen years I went up again to
Jerusalem with Barnabas, taking Titus along with me. I went up in response to a
revelation. Then I laid before them (though only in a private meeting with the
acknowledged leaders) the gospel that I proclaim among the Gentiles, in order to
make sure that I was not running, or had not run, in vain. But even Titus, who
was with me, was not compelled to be circumcised, though he was a Greek. But
because of false believers secretly brought in, who slipped in to spy on the
freedom we have in Christ Jesus, so that they might enslave us we did not submit
to them even for a moment, so that the truth of the gospel might always remain
with you. And from those who were supposed to be acknowledged leaders (what they
actually were makes no difference to me; God shows no partiality) those leaders
contributed nothing to me. On the contrary, when they saw that I had been
entrusted with the gospel for the uncircumcised, just as Peter had been
entrusted with the gospel for the circumcised.”
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese
Related News & Editorials published on March 10-11/2020
Rating Agencies Warn Lebanon over $1.2 Billion Loan Default
Nephew of Parliament Police Chief Held for Firing at Kataeb HQ
Report: Cabinet to Discuss Economic Plan, ‘Capital Control’
Wazni: Lebanon Foreign Reserves More than $20 Billion
Lebanon Records First Coronavirus Death
MoPH accredits new laboratories to test for coronavirus at LBP 150,000
Lebanon reports its first coronavirus-related death
Aoun Says Govt. Must Devise Plans for Debt and Restructuring of Banks
Oueidat Hears Testimonies of Banks Counsels, Owners, Chairmen
Eleven new coronavirus cases and one recorded casualty in Lebanon/Perla
Kantarjian/Annahar/March 10/2020
Lebanon Banks Agree to Ease Some Curbs on Cash-Starved Depositors
Lebanon: Requesting IMF's Help Heralds Political Clash
Lebanese Parliament Shut For A Week Over Coronavirus Fears
Jumblatt Accuses Govt. of Using ‘Tools of Totalitarian Darkness’
Strong Lebanon Bloc meets in periodic session to discuss financial situation
Abdel Samad after cabinet session: Public debt must be restructured, reform plan
pursued
Wazni meets French diplomat over economic situation
Kataeb chief tackles overall situation with Algerian ambassador
Lebanon, the Dilemmas of a Monumental Unraveling
Charles Elias Chartoun/March 10/2020
In Lebanon, Criticism Of New Government: A Puppet Government Controlled By
Hizbullah That Won't Extricate Country From Its Crisis/MEMRI/March 10/2020
Lebanon faces mayhem after defaulting on its debt/Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib/Arab
News/March 10/2020
Titles For The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News published on
March 10-11/2020
UN Security Council endorses US-Taliban peace deal
Afghanistan’s President Ghani signs decree to release Taliban prisoners
Coronavirus in Iran: Senior member of Khamenei’s office reportedly infected
US urges Iran to release American prisoners amid coronavirus outbreak
SOHR: Four Syrian Provinces Hit With Coronavirus Under Regime's Secrecy
Iraqi Woman Accuses Moqtada Al-Sadr of Killing Her Only Son
Palestine Boosts Measures After Recording New Coronavirus Cases in Bethlehem,
Tulkarem
Ramallah – Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Fatah Member Released from Detention after Criticizing Palestinian President
Activists, Lawyers Slam Extended Detention of Journalist, 3 Protesters in
Algeria
Yemenis Accuse UNMHA Chair of Turning Blind Eye to Houthi Violations
LNA Says Sarraj Govt, Militias Preparing to Launch Major Offensive
Tunisian Interior Ministry Proposes Severe Penalties for Glorifying Terrorism
Attempted Assassination Targeting Hamdok Receives Arab, Int'l Condemnation
168 Coronavirus Deaths in Italy in One Day, Toll outside China Passes 1,000
New York Deploys National Guard to Fight Coronavirus
Tunisia Arrests 5 over Attack near U.S. Embassy
Germany to Open Syrian 'Crimes against Humanity' Trial in April
Sudan moves against Omar al-Bashir loyalists after assassination attempt.
Titles For The Latest LCCC English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous
sources published on March 10-11/2020
How Bad Is the Coronavirus? Let’s Run the Numbers/Justin Fox/Asharq Al-Awsat/March
10/2020
Countries Can Still Get Rich From Manufacturing/Noah Feldman/Bloomberg/March
10/2020
Iran: The Mullahs' Coronavirus Lies/Majid Rafizadeh/Gatestone Institute/March
10/2020Can Turkey Defeat Russia's Army in Syria/Michael Peck/The National
Interest/March 10/2020
More red zones like Italy’s are coming/Dr. Theodore Karasik/Arab News/March
10/2020
Children are neglected victims of Syria’s war/Mona Yacoubian/Al Arabiya/March
10/2020
The Latest English LCCC Lebanese & Lebanese Related News &
Editorials published on March 10-11/2020
Rating Agencies Warn Lebanon over $1.2 Billion Loan Default
Associated Press/Naharnet/March 10/2020
Credit ratings agency Moody's warned Tuesday that Lebanon's first-ever default
on paying its sovereign debt will likely lead to significant losses for private
creditors as well as serious implications for the country's banking sector.
Prime Minister Hassan Diab on Saturday said the government will suspend payment
of $1.2 billion in loans that matured Monday. Diab said Lebanon's foreign
currency reserves "have reached a critical stage," leading the government to
suspend its debt payment so it can continue providing basic commodities to the
Lebanese people. Lebanon has been engulfed in a financial and economic crisis
that has worsened since October, when the country was rocked by nationwide
protests over widespread corruption and decades of mismanagement by the ruling
political class. Street demonstrations have been minimal since the outbreak of
the new coronavirus. The default marked a new chapter in Lebanon's economic
crisis and could have severe repercussions on the tiny Mediterranean country,
risking legal action by lenders that could further aggravate and push Lebanon's
economy toward financial collapse. Diab said sovereign debt reached $90 billion
or 170% of GDP, making it one of the highest in the world. He added that the
total debt and interest Lebanon had to pay back in 2020 is at $4.6 billion.
Moody's, which downgraded Lebanon's ratings last month to Ca from Caa2, said the
decision to defer payment of the March 9 international bond maturity "reflects
the country's extreme financial and economic pressures and the move will likely
lead to significant losses for private creditors." "A sovereign default would
have a significant negative impact on banks' financial health, and further
undermine the economy and the sustainability of the peg," said Elisa Parisi-Capone,
a Moody's vice president and the report's author.
She was referring to the local currency, which had been pegged to the dollar
since 1997 but in recent months lost up to 60% of its value on the parallel
market. Local banks, who are a main lender to the Lebanese government, have
imposed crippling capital controls on cash withdrawals and transfers since
November. The statement by Moody's came a day after Fitch Ratings downgraded
Lebanon's Long-Term Foreign-Currency Issuer Default Rating to C from CC. Fitch
said that the $1.2 billion Eurobond payment maturing on Monday has a grace
period for paying the principal of seven days. Failure to make the payment
during the grace period will put the sovereign into Restricted Default, or RD,
and the specific bond into Default, or D. Lebanon's economy has been hammered
over the past years by the war in neighboring Syria, the flow of more than a
million Syrian refugees and a drop in remittances from the Lebanese diaspora.
Nephew of Parliament Police Chief Held for Firing at Kataeb
HQ
Naharnet/March 10/2020
A man who opened fire at dawn Sunday at the headquarters of the Kataeb Party in
Beirut’s Saifi area was arrested on Tuesday, TV networks said. MTV said the man,
Yahia Dimashq, was arrested by the Intelligence Branch of the Internal Security
Forces after it turned out that the car from which the shots were fired belongs
to him. Al-Jadeed TV meanwhile said that Dimashq is a nephew of Parliament
Police chief Youssef Dimashq, aka Abu Khashbeh, a powerful security aide of
Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri. It said he was apprehended in the Beirut
southern suburb of Msharrafiyeh.MTV meanwhile published a video showing Dimashq
being arrested by armed ISF agents. Kataeb’s iconic building in downtown Beirut
was hit by six gunshots according to a statement issued by the party.
Report: Cabinet to Discuss Economic Plan, ‘Capital Control’
Naharnet/March 10/2020
The government is expected to meet on Tuesday in a session dedicated to discuss
the financial and monetary situation and an economic plan to salvage crisis-hit
Lebanon from an unprecedented economic and liquidity crisis. Measures to counter
the spread of coronavirus diseases that left thousands dead worldwide, and
infected 41 so far in Lebanon will also be discussed, according to reports.
According to information obtained by MTV station, "the meeting will not
highlight the issue of appointments." A ministerial source told MTV that the
financial and monetary file will occupy the largest part of the discussion in
the session, which will discuss referring the Capital Control Law proposal to
the Parliament. The Cabinet will convene at Baabda Palace.
Wazni: Lebanon Foreign Reserves More than $20 Billion
Naharnet/March 10/2020
Cash-strapped Lebanon’s foreign reserves stand at more than $20 billion, finance
minister Ghazi Wazni said Monday, amid concerns over the country's liquidity as
it stumbles towards default. The central bank “says it has $29 billion, of which
it has used 7 billion to give to the banking sector” to boost its liquidity,
Wazni told local broadcaster LBCI. Central bank data had put the value of
foreign reserves at $35.8 billion at the end of February. Lebanon, hit by
a severe liquidity crunch and months of anti-establishment protests, was due on
Monday to repay a $1.2-billion Eurobond, while another $700 million matures in
April, and a further $600 million is due for repayment in June. But prime
minister Hassan Diab on Saturday said his government would suspend payment of
the March Eurobond and seek restructuring agreements with creditors on the
country’s debt pile because of plummeting foreign reserves.
Commenting on Saturday's decision, Wazni said the aim was to achieve an “orderly
default” through negotiations with creditors who could pursue legal action
against the state if an agreement is not reached. Lebanon's debt burden, long
among the largest in the world, is now equivalent to nearly 170 percent of its
gross domestic product. Despite its turbulent history, the small Mediterranean
country has never before defaulted, but in recent months it has grappled with
its worst economic turmoil since the 1975-1990 civil war. Foreign currency has
become increasingly scarce, Lebanon's pound has plunged in value and banks have
imposed tough restrictions on dollar withdrawals and transfers. The government
met with a delegation from the International Monetary Fund last month for
technical assistance but it has not requested funds.
Lebanon Records First Coronavirus Death
Naharnet/March 10/2020
Lebanon on Tuesday has recorded its first death from the new coronavirus, a
health ministry source said. The 56-year-old was receiving treatment in a
state-run Beirut hospital, the ministry source told AFP, adding that he had
recently returned from Egypt, where the virus has also spread. Media reports
said he was hospitalized at Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Notre Dame des
Secours hospital, in Jbeil. Lebanon, already hit by economic collapse and
anti-government protests, is now grappling with an outbreak of the deadly
COVID-19 virus -- its latest in a long list of crises. Health Minister Hamad
Hassan said last week that the country has moved beyond the phase of
"containment" and was bracing for a more serious outbreak. Schools,
universities, cafes, pubs and other public places have since been ordered shut
over fears of the virus. Sport tournaments have been postponed and cultural
events cancelled.
According to the health minister, the origins of Lebanon's cases have mostly
been traced to other countries. Lebanon has said it would deny entry to
non-resident foreigners arriving from China, South Korea, Iran and Italy, which
are among the hardest hit by the epidemic. But domestic concern is still high
amid fears that Lebanon is not equipped to face a mass outbreak. With a grinding
liquidity crunch and dwindling foreign reserves, Lebanon has struggled to secure
the dollars needed for medical imports even before coronavirus arrived. Prime
Minister Hassan Diab announced on Saturday that the country would suspend
payment on Eurobonds.
Lebanon Confirms 11 New Coronavirus Cases, Total Reaches 52
Naharnet/March 10/2020
Lebanon on Tuesday confirmed eleven new coronavirus cases, raising the country’s
overall tally to 52. The director of the state-run Rafik Hariri University
Hospital said the 11 cases were confirmed after lab tests for 202 suspected
cases over the past 24 hours. Speaking at a press conference, the director said
a virus patient who died Tuesday – Lebanon’s first fatality – had arrived at the
hospital in a critical condition. “We offered him the internationally endorsed
treatments but he suffered complications such as hypotension and high fever
which resulted in the stoppage of his heart and his death,” the director added.
He also announced that other hospitals should start exerting greater efforts in
the battle against the COVID-19 coronavirus. The patient who died, a 56-year-old
Lebanon man coming from Egypt, had been initially admitted into the Notre Dame
des Secours hospital in Jbeil and Health Minister Hamad Hasan said he was not
transferred in a proper way to the Rafik Hariri hospital. TV networks said he
had diabetes and that his condition worsened after taking antibiotics and after
his diagnosis with the coronavirus was delayed for several days. The Notre Dame
des Secours hospital said the Rafik Hariri hospital had initially refused to
conduct a coronavirus test for the man seeing as he had arrived from Egypt -- a
country not listed as a virus hotbed at the time. The man has reportedly
infected several nurses and patients at the Notre Dame des Secours hospital.
MoPH accredits new laboratories to test for coronavirus at
LBP 150,000
NNA/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
The Ministry of Public Health announced in a statement this Tuesday "The
accreditation of new laboratories – next to the Rafic Hariri University Hospital
lab – to conduct coronavirus tests on suspected patients, since the Hariri
Hospital is approaching its maximum capacity in terms of tests.
The newly accredited laboratories are:
The American University of Beirut.
The Saint George University Hospital.
The Rizk Hospital / Lebanese American University.
The Rodolphe Merieux Laboratory at the Saint Joseph University / Hotel Dieu
Hospital.
The ministry pointed out that any other hospital or private laboratory wishing
to carry out these tests must submit an application to be studied by a
specialized committee, in order to obtain the approval of the ministry before
starting to examine patients. The tariff will amount to a maximum of 150,000 LBP."
Lebanon reports its first coronavirus-related death
The New Arab/March 10/2020
Lebanon recorded its first death from coronavirus on Tuesday, a health ministry
source said, adding that the patient had been in quarantine since returning from
Egypt. A Lebanese man died on Tuesday from the novel coronavirus, a health
ministry source said, marking the country's first recorded death from an
epidemic that has infected 41 people nationwide. The 56-year-old was receiving
treatment in a state-run Beirut hospital, the ministry source told AFP, adding
that he had recently returned from Egypt, where the virus has also spread.
Earlier this week, the government halted flights for non-residents from
epicenters of the virus, shut schools and warned against public gatherings.
Lebanon's health minister said hospitals were ready to deal with any further
spread of the novel coronavirus in the country. Hamad Hassan said the cases had
all either returned from an affected country or were transmitted through "close
contact" with a family member or neighbour - not "local transmission". All
people suffering from the COVID-19 illness are being treated at Beirut's Rafic
Hariri state hospital, where 140 beds have been designated to isolate and
monitor suspected cases, he added.
Hassan said measures had also been taken beyond Beirut, naming eight cities
across the country where hospital wards had been put aside as Lebanon works to
contain the virus nationwide. "We have designated 20 to 40 beds in each facility
to follow any unexpected developments as part of a precautionary plan," he said.
They include a monitoring area for patients suspected of having caught the
coronavirus along with one or two quarantine units, he said. In what he
described as a "positive sign", Hassan said the country's first case, a
45-year-old woman who had tested positive for the virus after visiting Qom in
Iran, had now tested negative. "A second laboratory test will be conducted
tomorrow, and she will be discharged and sent home if the negative result is
confirmed," his ministry said earlier in a statement. That showed that "there's
no need for hysterical panic", Hassan said.
On Friday, Lebanon said it would deny entry to non-resident foreigners arriving
from China, South Korea, Iran and Italy. Schools, universities and other
educational institutions have been closed until 8 March. Globally, more than
100,000 people have been infected and more than 3,800 killed since the virus
first emerged in China's Hubei province late last year. Agencies contributed to
this report.
Aoun Says Govt. Must Devise Plans for Debt and
Restructuring of Banks
Naharnet/March 10/2020
President Michel Aoun on Tuesday said the government must devise a plan to
restructure debt, plans to restructure banks and the central bank and others for
financial and administrative reform as well as economic and social affairs. He
said the plans must be laid out “in parallel with the negotiations with the
Eurobond holders.”Aoun voiced his remarks at the beginning of a Cabinet session
in Baabda. He had earlier met with Prime Minister Hassan Diab to discuss the
latest developments. The session is dedicated to tackling the financial and
monetary situation. A ministerial source had told MTV that the Cabinet will
discuss referring the Capital Control Law proposal to Parliament. Diab announced
Saturday that Lebanon “will seek to restructure its debts in a manner consistent
with the national interest" through negotiations with creditors. Diab said debt
restructuring is part of a wider economic rescue plan that seeks to cut state
spending and save more than $350 million annually. The premier said Lebanon must
now enter into debt restructuring negotiations, which "will take time, effort,
and will require painful measures." The default marks a new chapter in the
country’s financial and economic crisis and could have severe repercussions on
the tiny country, risking legal action by lenders that could further aggravate
and push Lebanon's economy toward financial collapse. The currency has already
lost up to 60% of its value on the dollar on the black market and banks have
imposed crippling capital controls on cash withdrawals and transfers. Lebanon
has been suffering in recent years from a lack of economic growth, high
unemployment and a drop in hard currency inflows from abroad. The financial
crisis erupted amid nationwide protests over widespread corruption and decades
of mismanagement by the ruling political class.
Oueidat Hears Testimonies of Banks Counsels, Owners,
Chairmen
Naharnet/March 10/2020
State Prosecutor Ghassan Oueidat on Tuesday started hearing the testimonies of
the legal counsels, owners and chairmen of Lebanon’s banks over the
controversial capital flight that coincided with the intensification of
Lebanon's financial and monetary crisis. The National News Agency said a
statement will be issued at the end of the hearing sessions. Oueidat had on
Thursday suspended an order freezing the assets of 20 banks and their directors
over concerns about its impact on the country's fragile economy. The order was
postponed to allow for the "study of its impact on the national currency,
banking transactions as well as on the money of savers and economic security,"
Oueidat said. Lebanon has been gripped by mass protests against the political
class and banking sector even as it suffers its worst economic crisis in
decades. Banks have imposed increasingly tight limits on dollar withdrawals and
transfers abroad as part of measures to tackle a severe liquidity crisis. But
bankers stand accused of having sent millions of dollars abroad despite those
limitations. The value of the Lebanese pound has plummeted on the black market,
prices have risen, and many businesses have been forced to slash salaries,
dismiss staff or close. Lebanon is one of the most indebted countries in the
world, with a public debt equivalent to 150 percent of its gross domestic
product (GDP).
Eleven new coronavirus cases and one recorded casualty in
Lebanon
Perla Kantarjian/Annahar/March 10/2020
The very first registered coronavirus patient in Lebanon is said to be on her
road to recovery, as she is no longer showing symptoms of the disease.
BEIRUT: Lebanon recorded its first Coronavirus casualty and 11 new cases on
Tuesday. 202 suspected cases underwent the necessary laboratory examinations on
Tuesday, of which 11 tested positive for the virus, raising the total local
Coronavirus tally to 52, said the General Manager of Rafic Hariri University
Hospital Dr. Firass Abiad, in a press conference at RHUH. As for the first
recorded death from the COVID-19 in Lebanon, the deceased, 56, was a Lebanese
patient who recently came from Egypt.
When symptomatic of the coronavirus, he was transferred from the Notre Dame De
Secours hospital in Jbeil to RHUH. As Abiad explained, the patient came to RHUH
in an already critical condition of acute pulmonary inflammation. “The patient
was subjected to complications, which are hypotension and high temperature,
which led to his heart stopping, and his eventual death,” he added. According to
Abiad, with the increase in Coronavirus cases, the RHUH is working on raising
its capacity by adding a dozen more beds within the coming three days. However,
in terms of conducting tests on suspected patients, RHUH is approaching its
maximum capacity. For that reason, and to cointain the virus outbreak, the
Ministry of Public Health announced in a statement on Tuesday that new
laboratories will be accredited to carry out coronavirus tests on suspected
patients. The newly accredited laboratories are: The American University of
Beirut Medical Center, The Saint George Hospital, The Rizk Hospital (Lebanese
American University Medical Center), and Hotel Dieu Hospital. The ministry
highlighted that any other hospital or private laboratory willing to conduct
these tests must submit an application for a specialized committee to study. If
the laboratory meets the requirements, it will get an approval by the ministry
to start patients’ examinations. The tariff will amount to a maximum of 150,000
LBP. Additionally, with the closure of most educational, industrial, and
recreational facilities in Lebanon for more than a week, the municipality of
Beirut indicated in a Tuesday statement that the city’s public parks will also
temporarily shut down as a preventive measure against the spread of the disease.
Similarly, the Minister of Culture and Agriculture Abbas Mortada, announced that
the national museum and the archeological galleries affiliated to the Ministry
of Culture will also be shut down until further notice. The very first
registered coronavirus patient in Lebanon is said to be on her road to recovery,
as she is no longer showing symptoms.
Lebanon Banks Agree to Ease Some Curbs on Cash-Starved Depositors
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/March 10/2020
Lebanese banks Tuesday agreed to lift certain restrictions imposed last year to
stem a crippling liquidity crisis, the National News Agency said.
Lebanon is grappling with its worst economic crisis in decades, as well as
widespread public discontent with the political class since October.
Since September, banks have increasingly been imposing limits on withdrawals of
both dollars and Lebanese pounds, as well as transfers abroad. At a meeting
between State Prosecutor Ghassan Oueidat and bank representatives Tuesday, both
sides agreed to new rules, NNA said. These include banks allowing depositors to
withdraw up to 25 million Lebanese pounds a month (around $16,500 under the
official exchange rate). Other measures include allowing transfers abroad in
hard currency for education fees, medical bills, tax purposes, "and everything
else necessary," NNA said. Banks would not be allowed to withhold any part of
money freshly transferred into a Lebanese account.
There was, however, no mention of an easing of caps on withdrawals from dollar
accounts, which have been squeezed down to just $100 a week at some banks. A
judicial source said discussions were ongoing with the central bank over
relaxing those limits.
Last week, Financial Prosecutor Ali Ibrahim attempted to impose an asset freeze
on banks in an apparent bid to pressure them, but that order was suspended by
Oueidat within hours. Earlier in the week, Ibrahim separately called in 15 banks
over an alleged more than 2 billion dollars in capital flight late last year. On
Tuesday, Oueidat began hearing the testimonies of banks' legal counsels, owners
and chairmen . Lebanon is facing its worst economic crisis since its 1975-1990
civil war. The value of the Lebanese pound has plummeted by more than a third on
the black market, prices have risen, and many businesses have been forced to
close. The Mediterranean country, one of the most indebted in the world, this
weekend announced its first default on a $1.2 billion Eurobond that matured on
March 9.
Lebanon: Requesting IMF's Help Heralds Political Clash
Beirut - Paula Astih/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
A new clash is expected to erupt between Hezbollah and Lebanese political forces
supporting the request for financial assistance from the International Monetary
Fund (IMF) to save the economic situation in the country. Hezbollah has publicly
declared its refusal to “yield to the IMF to manage the crisis.”In this regard,
member of Hezbollah’s central council, Nabil Qaouk, said that foreign aid should
not be an opportunity to impose tutelage over Lebanon. He stressed the rejection
of “putting our economy, society and the future of our people at the mercy of
external parties." “At the same time, we are keen on reforms that encourage
external parties to provide aid,” Qaouk stated. However, politicians and
economists say Lebanon has no choice but to resort to the Fund. In remarks to
Asharq Al-Awsat, Future Movement MP Dima Jamali said: “Requesting the assistance
of the IMF became necessary and urgent.”“The refusal to resort to the Fund
cannot be justified on the pretext that it will impose difficult measures and
taxes, because addressing an economic crisis in a particular country is carried
out according to the specific situation of that country, and the solutions of
the IMF are not necessarily the same everywhere,” she added.
For his part, Rami al-Rayes, advisor to the head of the Progressive Socialist
Party, Walid Jumblatt, pointed out that all economic, financial and monetary
exits were now closed. “We have no choice but to resort to the IMF after the
systematic destruction of Lebanon’s foreign policy, which led to the
deterioration of relations with donor countries, especially the Gulf States,” he
told Asharq Al-Awsat. Rayes revealed information that none of the decisions of
the CEDRE Conference would be implemented unless they were coupled with the
IMF’s monitoring of the reform process, as the international community has lost
confidence in the Lebanese management. Financial and Economic Expert Walid Abu
Suleiman pointed out that even if the Lebanese government succeeded in curbing
the deficit in the State budget, the country would be forced - in light of the
scarcity of foreign currency reserves - to provide hard currencies from the IMF.
“The IMF was originally created to help countries with balance of payments
problems,” he said, pointing to the possibility of obtaining from the Fund $8.6
billion for a period of 3 years. Writer and political analyst specializing in
Hezbollah affairs, Qassem Kassir, ruled out that the party’s position was final
regarding the request for assistance from the IMF. “The party is emphasizing two
basic points: The first is that no help from the Fund be associated with the
imposition of huge taxes, and the second is that no political conditions be
linked with the assistance,” he explained. According to the Carnegie Middle East
Center, Hezbollah’s refusal to resort to the IMF “may ultimately mean the
collapse of Hassan Diab’s government, and Lebanon itself.”“Resorting to the IMF
is no longer an option, but rather a necessity,” the center said, noting that
without such decision, “Lebanon will not be able to obtain funds to support its
economy, or receive the hard currency necessary to import vital necessities,
such as food and fuel.”
Lebanese Parliament Shut For A Week Over Coronavirus Fears
Beirut - Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
The Lebanese Parliament announced on Monday that its offices in Beirut would be
closed for one week as part of measures to prevent the spread of the coronavirus.
On Monday, Speaker Nabih Berri took a series of instructions in this regard,
including the postponement of the weekly Wednesday meetings usually held at the
Speakership headquarters in Ain el-Tineh. Also, the meetings of the
parliamentary committees were delayed, and the lawmakers’ offices at the
parliament building were shut for one week to conduct sterilization procedures.
Meanwhile, sources said Lebanon witnessed less official meetings and political
activities in the past few days, as part of unannounced measures to contain the
spread of the virus. The Health Ministry said Monday that 41 persons have been
infected with the coronavirus so far, with some recoveries and no fatalities.
And while ministries and municipalities continue with their work as normal,
Lebanese authorities have imposed tight measures to keep those institutions free
from the virus. In this regard, sterilizers and thermometers for measuring the
body temperature were being distributed to employees in some public
administrations. “Public employees are attending work as normal, but they are
being subject to those new measures. However, we cannot deny that fewer people
were showing up at those administrations,” the source said. Lebanon already
closed schools, sports clubs, nightclubs, fairs, and other venues until March
15. Authorities also suspended judicial hearings and shut down academic
institutions across the country. Restaurants were exempted from this decision.
However, owners are not allowed to hold parties. This week, Health Minister
Hamad Hassan announced that the country is no longer in the containment phase
regarding the virus.
Jumblatt Accuses Govt. of Using ‘Tools of Totalitarian
Darkness’
Beirut - Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Lebanon’s Progressive Socialist Party leader Walid Jumblatt on Monday launched
an attack on Prime Minister Hassan Diab’s government, accusing it of adopting a
policy of obscurity. This is the first public criticism by Jumblatt against the
current government. “What is this government hiding? Its president did not
mention a word about reform… [What about] the electricity sector, protecting the
industry, controlling legal and illegal borders, ignoring the coronavirus,
judicial appointments... and others?” he said on Twitter. He went on to accuse
the government of “spreading bankruptcy and seeking revenge against a political
class through the tools of hatred and total darkness.”In contrast, Jumblatt had
last week called for supporting Diab’s cabinet. “In light of these massive
crises of coronavirus, electricity and Eurobonds, the government must be
supported above narrow considerations, because if the void comes again, we will
all fall into the unknown,” he said in a tweet.
Strong Lebanon Bloc meets in periodic session to discuss
financial situation
NNA/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
"Strong Lebanon Bloc" on Tuesday held its periodic meeting, chaired by MP Gebran
Bassil, at the FPM's headquarters in Mirna Chalouhi, to discuss the current
financial situation following the government's decision to suspend Eurobonds'
payment. In a statement issued in the wake of the meeting, the bloc called for
coupling the Eurobonds' suspension decision with a comprehensive
financial-economic plan, which includes the needed reforms to restore confidence
in Lebanon and its financial system and as a basis for negotiations with local
and international donors, with the aim of reaching an orderly debts
restructuring to avoid more negative repercussions on the country's economy and
its public and private sectors. The bloc also affirmed adherence to a free
economic system, including individual initiative and free competition under the
ceiling of the Lebanese laws and social justice, calling for strengthening the
private sector in Lebanon and protecting it as a fundamental pillar of a
productive economy. The Bloc also underlined its keenness on the independence,
fairness and integrity of the judiciary, voicing its rejection of any
interference in its affairs. The Bloc also called on the judiciary to exercise
its powers in accordance with laws in effect.
Abdel Samad after cabinet session: Public debt must be
restructured, reform plan pursued
NNA/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Minister of Information, Manal Abdel Samad, said after the Baabda cabinet
session that was chaired by President Michel Aoun: "Financial conditions must be
strengthened, public debt must be restructured, and a reform program for growth
and dealings must be pursued, along with the restructuring of the banking
system."
She pointed out that "indicators for 2020 are bad," saying: "We will seek a
reasonable initial surplus, and wages will remain under control."
"The Council of Ministers has met with a number of international consultants,
and studied the headlines of the reform plan, from cutting spending to
recovering looted money," Abdel Samad added.
"Prime Minister Hassan Diab confirmed that we will seek to develop the judicial
system, implement anti-corruption laws, address water and electricity problems,
and launch reforms in public institutions," she stressed.
Wazni meets French diplomat over economic situation
NNA/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Minister of Finance, Ghazi Wazni, met Tuesday with Regional Director of the
Department of Economy of the French Embassy in Beirut, Francois de Ricoflis. The
pair reportedly discussed the bilateral economic and financial relations and the
means to improve the financial situation in Lebanon.
Kataeb chief tackles overall situation with Algerian ambassador
NNA/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Kataeb party chief MP Sami Gemayel, on Tuesday welcomed at the Party's Central
House in Saifi the new Ambassador of Algeria to Lebanon, Abdel Karim Rkaibi, who
came on a courtesy visit.
Discussions between the pair reportedly touched on the bilateral relations and
most recent developments on the local and international arena.
شارل الياس شرتوني: كشف معضلات التحلل الكبير في لبنان
Lebanon, the Dilemmas of a Monumental Unraveling
Charles Elias Chartoun/March 10/2020
http://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/84032/%d8%b4%d8%a7%d8%b1%d9%84-%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%8a%d8%a7%d8%b3-%d8%b4%d8%b1%d8%aa%d9%88%d9%86%d9%8a-%d9%83%d8%b4%d9%81-%d9%85%d8%b9%d8%b6%d9%84%d8%a7%d8%aa-%d8%a7%d9%84%d8%aa%d8%ad%d9%84%d9%84-%d8%a7%d9%84/
The latest developments are symptomatic of the structural breakdowns that have
led to the demise of whatever is left in this agonizing Republic: The endemic
crisis of national legitimacy and conflicting loyalties, the recurrent trials of
dysfunctional governance, the pliability to foreign interventions and its
swaying impact on internal dynamics, the brittleness of economic and financial
sectors in an instable environment, and the stultifying effects of destructive
power politics and private interests on public policy making. The endemic
instability which has repeatedly questioned Lebanon’s civil peace,
constitutional governance, liberal political culture and lifestyles have
permeated the Lebanese psyche and created a set of defense mechanisms which
account for the survival instincts of a population used to live through
alternating stages of political and civil instability, socio-economic
volatility, cultural wars and intertwining internal and external conflicts. The
latest episode highlights the compounded nature of the latest financial crises
and their reverberations across the political, economic and social systems,
highly damaging consequences, and metonymic recapitulation of the manifold
existential threats which hover over the country’s future and rickety civil
peace:
A- The destructive fallouts of the financial crisis are expressive of systemic
deadlocks which put at stake the country’s operational sovereignty and ability
to tackle them amidst ramshackle governance, imploding consensuses, and the
incapacity to come up with working compromises on financial policy, in spite of
the exceptional opportunities offered by the civic rebellion and the creative
dynamics it elicited. The Rentier-State status that accounts for the nature of
governance is no hazard, since it reflects the idosyncracies of a deeply
fractured polity made up of a collection of power centers subsumed under the
fiction of a Constitutional State.The nature of the public debt which has been
building up throughout the last three decades, reveals the arcanes of a
plundering mechanism operated by the coalesced Sunnite and Shiite oligarchies,
and their ancillaries among different Christian constituencies. The contracted
odious debt was deliberately initiated to cater to the concurring oligarchic
power strategies, personal self enrichment and in compliance with the agendas of
regional power brokers ( Syria, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Turkey). Rather than being
spent on the assignments of post war reconstruction and integrated development,
the 350 billion dollars dilapidated on staggering institutional rents ( 85/ 90
per cent ), have not yet delivered, and if so they have failed to uphold the
basic standards of professional credibility. The completion of forensic auditing
should help us identify the sources and venues of this monumental robbery,
public mismanagement and outright violation of the rules of elementary civic
boundedness and sense of the common good.
B-The Hezbollah takeover of governance with the due complicity of well crafted
and micro-managed intercommunal and political coalitions, highlighted through
the partnership with General Michel Aoun and his political formation, overlaps
with the radius of Iranian power projections in the larger Middle East, the
expanding dynamics of a self defeating Iranian imperialism undermined by an
eroding national legitimacy and the demise of its foundational narratives,
failed governance and systemic economic and societal breakdowns, and the
hazardous outcomes of its imperial overstretch. The attempt at foreclosing
governance, building stonewalling tactical alliances, and flouting the normative
and operational rules of a working consociational democracy are unlikely to be
managed in the long run, since they have elicited multiple oppositions,
internally and externally, and are swayed by the concurring regional and
international power politics, the bolting weaknesses of the Iranian regime, and
the inability of Hezbollah to curb the Shiite opposition unwilling to endorse
its power drive, and the illusions prompted by the fallacies of a
counter-international order ( along the schemes outlined by H. Chavez and M.
Ahmadinejad in the 2000 ). The intertwining dynamics of a lethal financial
debacle, and the pitfalls of outsized power projections attempted by Hezbollah
have proven to be non dissuasive, so far, and might be at the roots of a new
wave of destructive conflicts. The statements of Hezbollah about the financial
and economic crises betray the inconsistencies of its ideological worldview,
economic illiteracy and the irrelevance of economics on its scale of priorities,
whereas it runs a vast international underground economy, promotes the fortunes
of an illegal and parallel economy, and replicates the ground rules of the
predatory economics of the Iranian regime.
C- The probability of a consistent reform in Lebanon hinges upon an integrated
approach whereby, the reform of political and economic governance, the overhaul
of civic culture, and the delineation of developmental agendas predicated on an
integrated approach based on the complementarity between the economic, social,
educational and environmental variables, evolve symmetrically. The priority of
financial reforms revolves around the following objectives: The recapitalization
of the banking sector, the negotiated solution of the compounded debts, the
recovery of the immense public heist, the reform of the banking sector in
conjunction with the structural reforms of the economy mandated by the
international institutions and the community of potential donor countries, the
implementation of an overall plan of economic reforms congruent with the
epistemological norms of the international community ( IMF, World Bank, ILO,
WTO, European Bank of Development and Reconstruction,.... ), and the inevitable
nexus between consolidated political stability and sustainability. The
stabilization of political life, and the distancing from the disruptive
political and military dynamics of an imploded Middle East, prohibitive
political alliances, imaginary economic shelters, and purported segregated trade
spaces advocated by Hezbollah ( Iran, Russia, Venezuela, North Korea / Syria,
Iraq and Jordan ) are the preliminary conditions of a steady reformist course,
and the creation of its congenial environment. Short of these prerequisites, the
regressive dynamics already in place, are likely to question civil concord and
compromise the chances of cumulative reforms.
The most striking feature of the systemic unraveling we are witnessing, is the
brittleness of social order, its fictitious and fiduciary nature, and the
centrality of social constructivism in any future attempt at recasting the
matrices of statehood, governance and participatory politics. We should avoid
the fallacies of “ misplaced concreteness “ and make sure to keep in sight the
dialectical relationship between political and financial reforms, and the
prevalence of destructive regional power politics, shaky political consensuses
and their stifling role. The civic rebellion sparked last October 2019, is
mandated to build a functional platform of coordination, overcome the traps of
maximal aspirations and the divisiveness of ideological politics, if we were to
oversee a tangible reformist course and preempt their deleterious impact on its
fortunes. The actual oligarchies and ongoing power politics have already erected
their defenses around the demarcation lines of their interests, regional
patronages and determination to use violence and civil war threats to protect
their power turfs and absconded riches. Summarily, at the end of its first
centennial ( 1920-2020 ), Lebanon is experiencing the worst economic
tribulations after the excruciating famine of WWI ordered by the Turkish
authorities ( 1915- 1918 ) which eradicated half of the Maronite population in
Mount Lebanon ( 50/ 100, 400000/ 200000 ), and left its enduring imprints on the
future of the emerging polity, its internal political dynamics and geopolitical
entanglements.
The decision will appease protesters who have clamored for the government to
prioritize domestic concerns. But it does little to solve the nation’s financial
woes.
ميمري: حكومة حزب الله ليست هي المؤهلة لإخراج لبنان من
أزمته..انتقادات للحكومة وتعرية فاضحة لمرجعيتها
In Lebanon, Criticism Of New Government: A Puppet Government Controlled By
Hizbullah That Won't Extricate Country From Its Crisis
MEMRI/March 10/2020
http://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/84035/%d9%85%d9%8a%d9%85%d8%b1%d9%8a-%d8%ad%d9%83%d9%88%d9%85%d8%a9-%d8%ad%d8%b2%d8%a8-%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%84%d9%87-%d9%84%d9%8a%d8%b3%d8%aa-%d9%87%d9%8a-%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%85%d8%a4%d9%87%d9%84%d8%a9-%d9%84%d8%a5/
On February 11, 2020, Lebanon's government, headed by Prime
Minister Hassan Diab, secured a vote of confidence in parliament. The formation
of the new government had followed prime minister Sa'd Al-Hariri's resignation
in response to protests in the country against regime corruption and the
economic crisis, that broke out on October 17, 2019.[1]
Once tasked with forming the government, Diab, who is supported by Hizbullah and
its allies, aimed to mollify the protestors and the general public who were
demanding a government not reliant on existing political elements. Pledging that
it would comprise independent technocrats, the government he presented included
19 ministers, all unfamiliar names. However, most of them are not experts in the
areas for which they are responsible, and nearly all of them were chosen by the
March 8 camp – that is, by Hizbullah and its allies.[2]
Because of this, the newly confirmed government already faces serious opposition
from protestors, who feel cheated. Demonstrations outside the parliament
building immediately following the government's confirmation led to clashes with
security forces.
Also critical of the new government were newspaper op-eds by public figures and
columnists identified with the March 14 camp. They called on the public not to
have confidence in the new government, referring to it, inter alia, as a
disgraceful government and a puppet government – and not a government of
independent technocrats as promised, but one dominated by Hizbullah. Some argued
that it would represent Iran and the resistance axis and make it difficult to
obtain aid from the U.S., Europe, and Arab countries. They also said that it
would be incapable of solving Lebanon's economic problems – which include
restrictions for banks on withdrawals and overseas transfers and a public debt
of some $90 billion. Since this government is neither truly independent nor
reformist, they added, it will not institute real reforms, tackle the security
situation, or deal with the weapons illegally possessed by Hizbullah.
Anti-government protests outside parliament immediately following the
confirmation of the government (Source: Al-Nahar, Lebanon, February 11, 2020)
The following are translated articles and commentary on events surrounding the
confirmation of the new Lebanese government:
Al-Nahar Columnist: "Don't Give [This Government] Your Confidence"
In a column titled "Don't Give [This Government] Your Confidence" in the March
14 camp-affiliated Al-Nahar daily, Akl Awit argued that Prime Minister Diab had
failed to keep his promise of an independent and professional government, and
said that there should be no public confidence in it:
"The new government is no different from the one that preceded it... Those who
brought its leader, its members, and its paymaster [to power] do not want it to
be different, professional, free, sovereign, and independent. They do not want
it to rescue the country and its people from the tragic fate that has befallen
them. Were the prime minister true to himself, his commitments, his promises,
and his declarations, he would have appointed ministers who are independent and
experts [i.e. technocrats]. There is a vast gulf separating half of the members
[of this government] from professionalism. With respect to [the claim] that it
is independent of the elements [that have] controlled [Lebanon in recent years],
you can say this as much as you like, [but it is far from true]. Maybe one or
two ministers, and maybe, just maybe, three, at most, are the exception [to
this, i.e. are independent]. But the government [as a whole] is not...
"In light of [the fact that] this government and its members continue to act
like they have all the time in this world and in the next, that the fundamental
guidelines set by its members are pathetic... that they have broken promises and
[shattered] all hopes pinned on it... I call on the free public, on those who
act peacefully, on those who rise up, on the revolutionaries, on the hungry and
the sick, on the unemployed and the bankrupt, on those who are lost and are
about to emigrate: Do not give this government your confidence, and do not allow
it popular legitimacy."[3]
Lebanese Political Analyst: Through Fraud, The Government Remains In The Same
Hands – And Reform Won't Happen
In a similar vein, Lebanese political commentator Tony 'Issa asserted that the
government remains in the hands of the same political elements, and expressed
skepticism with regard to its ability to institute reforms: "Naturally, the
Europeans and others have reservations about what is happening [in connection
with the makeup of this government]. This is because Diab promised to hand the
government portfolios to independent technocrats, but, through fraud, they
remain in the hands of the same political elements. The previous government's
budget was adopted by [this new so-called] 'reformist government' with no
changes. Likewise, we can expect no changes to the administrative staffs whose
appointments are based on political connections. If this is the case, whence
will reform come?
"The fundamental guidelines of [this] government are from the same mold as the
previous guidelines in all things connected to the political-security aspect.
With regard to the economic aspect, [this government] used numerous slogans
about reform and rescue, to be carried out within undefined periods by means of
no clear mechanism or organized plan. All this gives the impression that the
reason [these issues] were included in the government's fundamental guidelines
was to ward off the [public's] rage and to deceive public opinion with promises
of reform."[4]
Lebanese Journalist: The West And The Arab Countries Will Not Send Aid To
Lebanon – Because It Is Considered Part Of The Iran-Led Resistance Axis
In the London-based Al-Arab daily, Lebanese journalist Khairallah Khairallah
wrote about Lebanon’s foreign relations, arguing that no one in the new
government is capable of communicating with the Americans, the Europeans, or the
Arabs. He wrote:
"The government of Hassan Diab and its founders do not understand that Lebanon's
problem is first and foremost political – and that no one in this government is
capable of talking to the Arabs, the Europeans, or the Americans. This is
because no member has [even] minimally good relations with foreign elements that
have a positive influence on Lebanon's situation…
“The Trump administration no longer wants to deal with Lebanon or to consider
its domestic sentiment. This came about at the same time as the disappearance of
the imaginary, or non-imaginary, line separating Hizbullah and [Lebanon's state]
institutions, first and foremost the presidency and the government...
"With respect to the Arabs, Lebanon cannot request any Arab aid as long as the
Gulf residents are fully convinced that it is a Hizbullah base. The current
government has no way of persuading any Gulf country with financial means that
Lebanon is not part of the Iranian axis. All anyone needs to be certain of this
is to hear any speech by Hizbullah secretary-general Nasrallah –and especially
when the aim of his speech is to attack a country like Saudi Arabia, which does
only good for Lebanon."[5]
In another article, Khairallah wrote: "The new government formed in Lebanon
headed by Hassan Diab absolutely cannot rescue anything, in light of the boiling
[rage] in the street and in light of the fact that official Lebanese elements
are biased towards Iran – which pressured them to form this government led by a
figurehead with no credibility worth mentioning in his community..."[6]
Al-Nahar Columnist: The New Government Is Betraying The Lebanese Protests – And
We Must Oppose It
In his column titled "Struggle Against the Puppet Government" in the Al-Nahar
daily, Ali Hamade criticized the new government's violent suppression of the
protests and urged the public to rebel against it. He wrote: "The government is
a grave stab wound to the 'October 17 Revolution,' that sparked [a demand] for
fundamental change in the country... The rebelling Lebanese people are called
upon to first of all oppose the parliament that has surrendered to... the
foreign occupier [i.e. Iran]; [then] to oppose the puppet government... and the
insolence of [its February 7] meeting of the 'Supreme Defense Council' to
finalize plans for suppressing the rebels, [with the aim of] terrifying
independent national public opinion and letting it know that the government has
extinguished the flames of the revolution that began on October 17...
"There is no alternative but to stand up to the policing mindset that is running
the country, so that these [rulers] will understand that Lebanon is not Iraq and
that the disgraceful government headed by Hassan Diab has no national
legitimacy… Therefore, the free people and the rebels must not allow any rest
for those who have stolen the people's dreams and seek to throw the Lebanese
people into a huge prison.
"We thus call on free public opinion to return to the logic of the resistance…
by taking to the streets, as part of actualizing the democratic and non-violent
right to revolt against the evil reality presented by this government [that sets
out] facts on the ground starting at the tip of the pyramid and radiating to its
base. The Lebanese people's dire circumstances have reached a nadir. We can no
longer remain silent, and we can no longer accept this reality…
"Therefore, we say to the Lebanese people – who are seeing their dreams and
hopes evaporate before their eyes, who line up [at the banks] in shame and
humiliation to salvage what remains of their money, who see their honor trampled
by the few who seize their assets and their rights, who see their crust of bread
being taken from their mouths and the mouths of their children, and whose future
is bleak… – You have no choice but to keep protesting against this illegitimate
political reality and the standard of living that humiliates you and your
dreams…"[7]
Al-Mustaqbal Party Official: This Government Will Find It Hard To Act Against
The Resistance Or Against The Firing Of Missiles From Lebanon
Al-Mustaqbal party senior official Mustafa 'Aloush expressed his doubts
regarding the new government's ability to tackle the country's economic
problems, fight corruption, promote reforms, and take control of the security
situation in the country, and to deal with the issue of Hizbullah's illegal
weapons. He wrote: "How will the government deal with this [economic] situation
in the absence of foreign aid?... If the government [manages] to stabilize [the
dollar exchange rate], what rate and price [will it set]? What will inflation
be, and how much will the citizens' buying power drop… Where will they [get the
money] to return to the public what they stole? Will the members of government
hunt down those outside it?...
"Moving on to the less pressing problems of the day, obviously in comparison to
the current situation – for example the electricity [problem]… For two decades
this issue has been in the hands of the ruling group, and is today [as well],
yet the electricity situation is only getting worse. We have heard no hope of
salvation from the minister – who was advisor to the previous minister. Some say
we must wait to see results. But the minister belongs to the previous staff that
worked on this issue, and [there are still no results]. Regarding corruption,
how can we expect a government to go after its own people in the government, who
are for the most part agents of the rulers who appointed them to their
positions, and as long as corruption is the most important means for the
government and its members to maintain their power?...
"I [also] want to ask about how [the government] is handling the matter of the
illegal weapons, which is the main obstacle facing the economy. The economy has
dwindling investment because of the instability and the death of tourism due to
the ongoing threats and shows of force against tourists in Lebanon by the
weapons of the resistance… Will the resistance's shipments be inspected [at
border crossings]? Will the government know what is in the trucks crossing the
border with resistance passwords? What will the government do if the Lebanese
Revolutionary Guard Corps [i.e. Hizbullah] is ordered to fire missiles? How will
we persuade the Americans to lift the sanctions, in light of the ongoing
struggle with Iran and when the resistance in our country is an integral part of
the enterprise of the resistance [axis]?
"Every reform is likely to fail because of the loss of political and security
control – [all of] which is connected to [Hizbullah's] illegal weapons. Ignoring
this reality ostrich-style will not lead to tackling the centers of the disease
[afflicting the country]."[8]
[1] For more on the protests, see MEMRI Special Dispatch No. 8514, Journalists
In Lebanese 'Al-Nahar' Daily In Pointed Criticism Of Country's Leaders: Your
Corruption Has Turned Lebanon Into Hell And Is Driving Its Citizens To Suicide,
January 22, 2020; MEMRI Inquiry and Analysis No. 1492, Lebanese Protests Place
Hizbullah In A Bind – Part I: Hizbullah's Hostility To The Protests And The
Reasons Behind It, December 3, 2019; MEMRI Inquiry and Analysis No. 1493,
Lebanese Protests Place Hizbullah In A Bind – Part II: Hizbullah's Position On
Protests Evokes Unusually Harsh Criticism Among Its Supporters, Prompts Wave Of
Resignations From Pro-Hizbullah Daily 'Al-Akhbar', December 3, 2019;MEMRI
Special Dispatch No. 8332, Lebanese Politicians, Journalists, Before The
Outbreak Of The Current Protest-Wave: It Is Hizbullah That Caused The Economic
Crisis In The Country, October 25, 2019.
[2] Diab's government is identified with the March 8 camp and its main elements
are Hizbullah and its allies – Amal and the Free Patriotic Movement headed by
Gebran Bassil, son-in-law of President Michel 'Aoun. The Lebanese government
comprises the prime minister and 19 ministers, in this government, four
ministers are from Hizbullah and Amal, six are from the Free Patriotic Movement,
and two represent Druze faction leader Talal Arslan, a rival of longtime Druze
leader Walid Jumblatt who is affiliated with the March 8 camp. Additionally, two
ministers are from the Maronite Marada movement, headed by Suleiman Frangieh,
Hizbullah ally, and one is from Al-Liqaa Al-Tashawuri, which represents the
Sunni opposition to Sa'd Al-Hariri and are also supported by Hizbullah. Another
minister is from the Armenian party Tashnag that joined the March 8 camp. Only
three ministers in the government are politically unaffiliated, but they were
appointed by Diab, who, as noted, is supported by Hizbullah.
[3] Al-Nahar (Lebanon), February 8, 2020.
[4] Al-Gumhouriyya (Lebanon), February 7, 2020.
[5] Al-Arab (London), February 9, 2020.
[6] Al-Arab (London), January 29, 2020.
[7] Al-Nahar (Lebanon), February 8, 2020.
[8] Al-Gumhouriyya (Lebanon), January 28, 2020.
Lebanon faces mayhem after defaulting on its debt
Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib/Arab News/March 10/2020
For the first time in its history, Lebanon will default on its debt. Prime
Minister Hassan Diab made the announcement on Saturday, saying: “How can we pay
foreign creditors when the Lebanese can’t access their deposits?” He added that
reserves had reached a “danger level.” Speculation was rife that it would come
to this. The problem is that Lebanon is defaulting and it is alone — the country
has no backing from the international community or the International Monetary
Fund (IMF). Due to the objections of Hezbollah, which sees the IMF as a tool for
American domination, a possible IMF intervention was rebuffed. Meanwhile, the
international community is standing firm: It will not provide any aid unless
reforms are conducted. The US and its allies do not see a difference between
Hezbollah and the current government.
To start with, no one knows how much the central bank has in reserves, as it
lacks transparency. Officially, the country had, as at the end of last year, $31
billion in reserves while owing $67 billion to banks, meaning the reserves are
negative. Diab has announced reforms, saying they will save $350 millionannually.
However, this number will not really make a difference or save the economy from
collapsing. Drastic reforms are needed. The Ponzi schemethat has kept the system
afloat for the last three decades does not work anymore.
The government is also planning to negotiate with debtors. However, what kind of
negotiations can take place if Lebanon does not have a guarantor. Without an IMF
plan, it is very hard to convince debtors of reforms, especially with a country
like Lebanon, which ranks 137th out of 180in terms of corruption. Now that the
country is bankrupt, opening letters of credit to facilitate imports is becoming
increasingly difficult, especially as Lebanon’s importsare more than five times
its exports. Former Prime Minister Saad Hariri called on friendly countries to
open lines of credit to Lebanon for essential goods, but his call was not
answered as the international community has lost trust and patience with the
corrupt and failing political elite. Last month, a visit by theIMFto offer
technical advice resulted in no developments. The government did not have a plan
and expected the IMF to give it a magic spell that would solve the country’s
problems without formally interfering.
Lebanon’s middle class is becoming poor. The US dollar reached a record high of
2,700Lebanese pounds last week and is expected to increase further, leading to a
huge increase in the price of goods. Hyperinflation will drive people on to the
streets. However, this time it will be violent, as people are hungry and angry.
The government of Diab is on life support, and the important question remains:
What’s next? No one seems to have a plan to take Lebanon out of its crisis.
Unlike Greece, Lebanon does not have anybody ready to bail it out. To add to the
calamity, the current leadership is stubborn and in denial.
Hyperinflation will drive people on to the streets. However, this time it will
be violent, as people are hungry and angry.
One option would be for corrupt politicians to try to buy the people, as they do
at the time of elections. They could use the wealth they have accumulated from
pillaging the country for the past three decades to buy people’s loyalty. This
way, they could regenerate their legitimacy for a while. However, the government
is unable to offer basic services. In the regional context, the stability of
Lebanon is paramount, but the current political configuration cannot offer
stability. A skyrocketing dollar value and an ever-shrinking dollar supply in a
highly dollarized economy is a huge problem. Additionally, inflation will wipe
out people’s safety net in a country where the government does not offer any
real social protection.
It will be important to see what Hezbollah does. Will it act like a militia, as
it has since the beginning of the protests, and seek to intimidate and use force
to strangle the calls for reform, or will the situation be too much and it will
stay on the sidelines? There are many issues with the reforms. The reforms will
mean controlling the porous borders with Syria, the airport and the ports. Even
if Hezbollah is allowed to keep its arms in the south, it will be highly
restricted and this is something the group won’t accept easily.
Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah has previously warned that the protests could
lead to civil war. However, a civil war is not in Hezbollah’s interest, just as
it is not in the interest of any other political faction in the country. Sooner
or later, Hezbollah will have to accept the IMF and its restricting conditions.
Until then, Lebanon is faced with gloomy prospects, and there is no official
plan to be put in place to lift the country from its current plight.
*Dr. Dania Koleilat Khatib is a specialist in US-Arab relations with a focus on
lobbying. She holds a PhD in politics from the University of Exeter and is an
affiliated scholar with the Issam Fares Institute for Public Policy and
International Affairs at the American University of Beirut.
The Latest English LCCC Miscellaneous Reports And News
published on March 10-11/2020
UN Security Council endorses
US-Taliban peace deal
AFP, United Nations/Wednesday, 11 March 2020
The UN Security Council on Tuesday unanimously approved a United States’
resolution on the recent deal between the US and the Afghan Taliban, a rare
endorsement of an agreement with a militant group. The US military has begun
withdrawing troops as part of the pullout agreed in the February 29 pact with
the Taliban. In the resolution, the Security Council “urges the Government of
the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan to advance the peace process, including by
participating in intra-Afghan negotiations through a diverse and inclusive
negotiating team composed of Afghan political and civil society leaders,
including women.”The United States is keen to end its longest-ever conflict, and
under the terms of a deal signed in Doha last month has said all foreign forces
would quit Afghanistan within 14 months - provided the Taliban stick to their
security commitments. Some diplomats expressed unease that the agreement
included two secret appendices on the fight against terrorism that Council
members approved without knowing what they say. The UN resolution came with
Afghanistan in political crisis, following the double swearing-in on Monday of
President Ashraf Ghani and his rival and former chief executive Abdullah
Abdullah, both of whom claimed victory in last year’s presidential election.
Afghanistan’s President Ghani signs decree to release
Taliban prisoners
Reuters, Kabul/Wednesday, 11 March 2020
Afghanistan's President Ashraf Ghani signed a decree to facilitate the release
of some Taliban prisoners in Afghan jails, a spokesman for his office said on
Wednesday. "President Ghani has signed the decree that would facilitate the
release of the Taliban prisoners in accordance with an accepted framework for
the start of negotiation between the Taliban and the Afghan government," Sediq
Sediqqi, Ghani's spokesman said in a tweet. "Details of the decree will be
shared tomorrow," he said. At least 1,000 Taliban prisoners are expected to
released this week, five official sources said earlier, paving the way for
opening direct talks between the Afghan government and the Taliban insurgents.
But the Taliban want the Afghan government to release 5,000 fighters.
Coronavirus in Iran: Senior member of Khamenei’s office
reportedly infected
Yaghoub Fazeli, Al Arabiya English/uesday, 10 March 2020
A senior member of Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei’s office could
be infected with coronavirus, according to local news website Saham News.
Hossein Mohammadi, who is also a member of the Expediency Council, has been
infected with coronavirus and is undergoing treatment in Tehran’s Masih
Daneshvari hospital, Saham News initially reported. Visit our dedicated
coronavirus site here for all the latest updates. Mohammadi is not in good
condition, Saham News said, adding that one of his lungs has been fully
infected. Saham News later reported citing a relative of Mohammadi that he does
not have coronavirus but was hospitalised due to lung problems he had been
suffering from for a while. Saham News reiterated that one of Mohammadi’s lungs
has been fully infected, adding that the test results for his other lung will be
available within the next two days. If confirmed to have coronavirus, Mohammadi
would be the first member of Khamenei’s inner circle to have contracted the
virus. As of Monday, 237 Iranians have died from the virus and there are 7,161
confirmed cases in the country. Several other government officials have been
infected with coronavirus, including two Iranian vice presidents and two other
members of the Expediency Council.
US urges Iran to release American prisoners
amid coronavirus outbreak
AFP, Washingtone/11 March 2020
The United States on Tuesday called for Iran to release American prisoners held
in the country as the coronavirus outbreak reportedly spreads through its
prisons. "The United States will hold the Iranian regime directly responsible
for any American deaths. Our response will be decisive," US Secretary of State
Mike Pompeo said in a statement. "Reports that COVID-19 has spread to Iranian
prisons are deeply troubling and demand nothing less than the full and immediate
release of all American citizens."
SOHR: Four Syrian Provinces Hit With Coronavirus Under Regime's Secrecy
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
The new coronavirus (COVID-19) has spread in the Syrian governorates of
Damascus, Tartus, Latakia and Homs, several medical sources in the regime-run
areas have confirmed to a war monitor. Many coronavirus cases have been
recorded, some of whom have died and some have been quarantined, the Syrian
Observatory for Human Rights (SOHR) said. SOHR contacted doctors at several
hospitals in those provinces who confirmed that they were given strict orders
from the authorities of the Syrian regime to remain silent and refrain from
talking about the outbreak of the coronavirus. Syria hosts a large number of
Iranians coming in and out of it to visit religious sites, as well as other
Iranian forces who have been deployed there and entered Syria with their
families. Iran has recorded thousands of coronavirus cases, with dozens of
people dead. The Syrian regime suspended flights yesterday to and from Iran and
Iraq.
Iraqi Woman Accuses Moqtada Al-Sadr of Killing Her Only Son
Baghdad - Fadhel al-Nashmi
A woman from Iraq's Najaf accused Sadrist Movement Leader Muqtada al-Sadr of
being involved in killing her only son in Sadrayn Square. Armed groups, believed
to be affiliated with the Sadrist movement, attacked the Square early February,
killing nine demonstrators, including Muhannad al-Qaisi, the lady’s son, and
wounding dozens. The woman's statements came on Sunday at the Tahrir Square,
central Baghdad, during demonstrations held in support of the protest movement
on the occasion of “International Women's Day”. She expressed sorrow and grief,
urging international and human rights organizations and the government to take
action in this regard. She also affirmed that her family is independent and
doesn’t support from any political party, stressing that her son stormed Iraq’s
streets in demand for a country that maintains his dignity and that of others
his age. Two weeks ago, the lady recorded a video addressing Sadr and grieving
her son's death, asking what guilt did he commit to be killed. However, back
then she didn’t directly accuse Sadr of her son's murder. The Movement, for its
part, didn’t respond to the accusations. Sources in Najaf told Asharq Al-Awsat
that “the Najafi lady wanted to reach the grave of Mohammed Sadiq al-Sadr to
complain about his son’s actions, but she was not allowed to.” Activists have
launched a criticism campaign against Sadr several weeks ago after his followers
were accused of being involved in the killing and wounding of many demonstrators
in Najaf and Baghdad. Sadr is seen today by many as one of the most prominent
figures defending the regime after he was represented as an opposing figure
against regime corruption and one who seeks to make reforms. Many protesters
believe that his presence in Iran at the beginning of the demonstrations has
affected his stance. The protests Sadr called for late January against the US
presence in Iraq has led to the division between Sadr and the rest of the
anti-Iranian groups in Iraq.
Palestine Boosts Measures After Recording New Coronavirus Cases in Bethlehem,
Tulkarem
Ramallah – Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Palestine on Monday reported six new cases of coronavirus, bringing the total
number of the infected Palestinians to 25. Ibrahim Milhem, the spokesperson of
the Palestinian government, told reporters that five of the new cases were
confirmed in the West Bank city of Bethlehem and one was in the city of Tulkarem.
The five cases in Bethlehem were infected after their meeting with a Greek
tourist group in Bethlehem, while the case in Tulkarem is a Palestinian who
works in Israel, Milhem said. Palestine has declared a state of emergency on
Thursday after the breakout of the deadly virus was discovered in a hotel in
Bethlehem. PA President Mahmoud Abbas issued a presidential decree declaring a
state of emergency in all Palestinian-controlled territory for 30 days beginning
at 8 a.m. Friday, authorizing officials to take “all necessary measures to
confront the risks resulting from the coronavirus and to protect public health.”
The Bethlehem authorities have shut down the entire district and prepared a
specialized quarantine hospital to deal with the coronavirus disease. More than
2,000 Palestinians are currently placed in quarantine in the cities of Bethlehem
and Jericho. Palestinian Health Minister Mai Al-Kaileh said that it was decided
to activate the emergency plan in the governorates of Bethlehem and Jericho.
Accordingly, all educational institutions and training centers in the Bethlehem
Governorate are closed for 14 days. The Palestinian Authority on Sunday also
closed all mosques in the Bethlehem area to prevent the spread of the
coronavirus. The PA Ministry of Wakf and Religious Affairs said the decision was
in accordance with the state of emergency in the Palestinian territories, which
was announced by PA President Mahmoud Abbas after 19 people tested positive for
the virus.
Fatah Member Released from Detention after Criticizing
Palestinian President
Ramallah – Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Palestinian security forces released Hussam Khader, a prominent Fatah member and
former MP, five days after he was detained for criticizing Palestinian President
Mahmoud Abbas. Khader was held after he published a Facebook post critical of
the Palestinian leader and Fatah chief. Abbas ordered the release and judicial
proceedings to take him to court were dropped. Khader’s family said that he was
arrested after he criticized Abbas in wake of a strike by doctors in the West
Bank. Abbas had slammed the announcement of the strike as “inhumane” amid the
outbreak of the new coronavirus. He said doctors should be working, not going on
strike amid the outbreak, Israel’s economic siege and the challenges posed by
the American peace proposal. He revealed that the doctors had pledged to him
that they would halt their strike, but they then “shamefully” went ahead with
it. The strike lifted soon after.
Khader’s family said he was critical of Abbas’ remarks and that he had demanded
that the president apologize.
Activists, Lawyers Slam Extended Detention of Journalist, 3
Protesters in Algeria
Algiers - Boualem Goumrassa/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Human rights activists and lawyers in Algeria protested Monday the “interference
of ‘political police’ in judicial affairs” after authorities extended the
detention of four activists, including journalist Khaled Drareni, a
correspondent for Reporters Without Borders (RSF) and French TV5. Media circles
had expected journalist Samir Belarbi and activists Suleiman Hamtouche and
Toufik Hassani to be released after they appeared in court. They were detained
for two nights at a police station. However, the prosecutor decided to extend
their detention without interrogating them. Abdelghani Badi, one of the most
prominent lawyers defending the detainees, told reporters that the security
services that conducted the initial investigations asked the prosecution for an
extension to continue their inquiry. He wondered: “Why would they need more time
given that they are looking into simple and clear facts?”
Badi confirmed the activists were detained during a protest in Algiers on
Saturday. Drareni was photographing the demonstration, while Belarbi, Hamtouche
and Hassani were among the participants. They were arrested along with 30
others, who were later released.
Badi feared that security services were looking to fabricate charges against the
four activists. He cited the Minister of Justice who had previously boasted that
no journalists were being detained because of their profession. He refuted the
allegation, saying his client was still in custody. Badi criticized the
“political police”, describing it as “a cancer that is hindering the
establishment of the new Algeria promised by President [Abdelmadjid] Tebboune.”
Amnesty International’s office in Algeria strongly condemned the arrest of
Drareni and the activists. It is unacceptable to arrest a journalist while
practicing his profession, just as it is unacceptable to arrest peaceful
demonstrators, it said. The media is the pillar of the new republic if Tebboune
wants to build the state on sound foundations, according to Amnesty official. In
a statement, Reporters Without Borders condemned Drareni’s arrest, affirming its
full support to him and calling for his immediate release. He was summoned for
interrogation two months ago by the security agency, where he was questioned
about the photos and news he published regarding the popular demonstrations. He
wrote on his Twitter that authorities asked him to stop posting, but he defied
their warnings. Belarbi was acquitted a month ago, after five months in prison
over charges of “weakening the morale of the army.”
Yemenis Accuse UNMHA Chair of Turning Blind Eye to Houthi Violations
Aden – Ali Rabea/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
A recent statement made by the Chair of the Redeployment Coordination Committee
(RCC) and Head of the United Nations Mission in support of the Hodeidah
Agreement (UNMHA) Lieutenant General Abhijit Guha of India sparked nationwide
rage and condemnation in Yemen. Coalition airstrikes hinder the peace process
and jeopardize the implementation of the Hodeida deal, Guha said in a statement.
Apart from drawing shock from the internationally recognized government, the
statement also led to leveling accusations against Guha for turning a blind eye
to Houthi aggressions and violations in Hodeidah and all across Yemen. The
airstrikes on Salif, in the Yemeni western governorate of Hodeida, hinder the
peace process and jeopardize the Hodeida pact application, UNMHA said Monday.
UNMHA chair, Guha, expressed deep resentment at the Saturday airstrike in the
Red Sea port of Salif. Despite the decrease in violence during the last months,
the situation in Hodeida is still volatile, the UN official said. On Sunday, the
Saudi-led Arab Coalition said its aircraft had carried out "typical operation
against Houthi military targets in Salif district," to the north of Hodeida
city. "The targeted sites were used for preparing for and carrying out hostile
acts and terrorist operations threatening international navigation and trade
routes in Bab al-Mandeb Strait and the south Red Sea," the Coalition said in a
statement. Information Minister Muammar Al-Eryani expressed his surprise at the
statement of Guha regarding the qualitative operation carried out by the
Coalition against military targets of the Houthi militia in Salif. The attack
destroyed sites used to assemble and launch bomb-rigged boats that constituted a
threat to maritime navigation. As for Guha’s statement on violence decreasing in
Hodeidah, Eryani said it was misleading to the international community as dozens
of Houthi violations continue to take place daily. Eryani reaffirmed that the
internationally-recognized government will not allow for Houthis to exploit the
Hodeidah ceasefire agreement and transform the city’s ports into spots used to
manufacture threats to international maritime navigation.
LNA Says Sarraj Govt, Militias Preparing to Launch Major Offensive
Cairo - Khaled Mahmoud/Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
The Libyan Government of National Accord (GNA) is preparing to attack positions
of the Libyan National Army (LNA) forces, led by Field Marshal Khalifa Haftar,
on various fighting fronts, said LNA Spokesman Major General Ahmed al-Mismari.
In a statement on Sunday evening, Mesmari said “Fayez al-Sarraj’s terrorist and
criminal militias, supported by mercenaries sent by Turkey, have been mobilizing
to launch a massive attack on all LNA forces’ positions.”This has been affirmed
by LNA's reconnaissance units after collecting and analyzing data.
Mesmari didn’t reveal any further details, nor did he clarify the nature of the
countermeasures LNA forces plan to take. The attack would end the fragile truce
that has been concluded under the auspices of the United Nations Support Mission
in Libya between the two parties in January. Meanwhile, Media center of LNA's
Dignity Operations Room has announced the death of commander of Sarraj’s
Salaheddine forces, noting that a number of militia elements have fled the area.
In other news, Volcano of Rage Operation, launched by militias loyal to the GNA,
announced the death of two people and the injury of five others in an attack it
said was launched by LNA forces. It republished photos distributed by the Field
Medicine Center, showing part of what it described as the damage left by the
rockets targeting civilian homes in the Arada region. It also quoted a GNA
spokesman as saying that its forces have dealt carefully with the attacks
launched by LNA forces against populated areas south of Tripoli.
An official from the GNA’s Health Ministry told Xinhua that “two civilians, a
man and a woman, were killed by indiscriminate shelling against the Municipality
of Souk El-Jumaa” in Tripoli. According to the official, five civilians were
injured due to the shelling, which also targeted homes of civilians and a school
in the area.
Tunisian Interior Ministry Proposes Severe Penalties for Glorifying Terrorism
Tunis - Mongi Saidani/Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Tunisian Interior Minister Hichem Mechichi stressed that Tunisian authorities
will not tolerate anyone who praises or glorifies terrorism on social media. In
a presser, he revealed that his ministry will present to parliament a new draft
law, which includes strict penalties for those arrested in connection with
praising terrorism and glorifying perpetrators of terrorist attacks targeting
security forces and the army. The anti-terrorism and money-laundering law, which
was ratified in 2015, included severe penalties for perpetrators of terrorist
acts, amounting to the death penalty against those who caused a single death.
This law holds prison terms that could reach three years against those who
glorify terrorism, but this punishment did not deter supporters of terrorist
organizations from continuing to praise their attacks on social media. Last
week, two assailants on a motorcycle attacked a security forces checkpoint
outside the US Embassy in Tunis, blowing themselves up, killing one police
officer and wounding four others and a civilian. Police launched raids on the
homes of the suspected bombers shortly after the attack. US Ambassador Donald
Blome said “we are outraged by the attack,” and thanked Tunisian security forces
for keeping the embassy secure and their rapid response. “We reaffirm our
commitment to our longstanding friendship with Tunisia and our alliance with
them against the scourge of terrorism,” he said in a statement. The attackers
were previously arrested and imprisoned for glorifying terrorism. The lawyer of
one of the bombers pointed out that his defendant was sentenced to three years
in prison over glorifying terrorism. The court reduced the sentence against him
to one year, after an appeal.
Attempted Assassination Targeting Hamdok Receives Arab, Int'l Condemnation
Asharq Al-Awsat/Tuesday, 10 March, 2020
Saudi Arabia has denounced the attempted assassination that targeted Sudanese
Prime Minister Abdalla Hamdok. The Saudi Ministry of Foreign Affairs expressed
Riyadh’s rejection of this terrorist act and any endeavor to curb Sudan’s
stability and security. For its part, the UAE also denounced the attack in a
statement issued by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International
Cooperation (MoFAIC) that decried what it described as a "criminal act." It also
expressed its rejection of all forms of violence and terrorism, adding that UAE
stands beside Sudan and supports its transitional phase in a way that guarantees
its stability. Further, Egypt denounced Hamdok’s targeting and called for
uniting international and regional efforts to combat terrorism. The Organization
of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) also denounced the attack. OIC Secretary-General
Dr. Yousef al-Othaimeen rejected this terrorist act that jeopardizes the
stability and security of Sudan. Nayef al-Hajraf, Secretary-General of the Gulf
Cooperation Council, denounced the assassination attempt and affirmed that the
GCC shows solidarity with Sudan in committing terrorism and reinforcing
stability and security on its territories. Saudi Arabia's Shoura Council member
Dr. Mishaal bin Fahm al-Salami also decried the attempted assassination and
stressed that this terrorist act will not impact the efforts of the Sudanese
government in proceeding with the peaceful political process. The US Embassy in
Sudan posted on Facebook: “The US Embassy is shocked and saddened at the attack
on Abdalla Hamdok convoy. Our sincere condolences to the victims. We continue to
support Sudan's civilian-led transitional government and stand in solidarity
with the Sudanese people.” The European Union condemned in the strongest terms
the assassination attempt against Hamdok. This shocking incident should not
impair the ongoing efforts to build a stable, peaceful, just and free Sudan, it
added.
168 Coronavirus Deaths in Italy in One Day, Toll outside
China Passes 1,000
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/March 10/2020
Italy recorded 168 deaths Tuesday from the novel coronavirus, its highest
single-day toll to date, pushing the number of fatalities outside China to more
than 1,000. Overall in Italy, 631 people have died from the COVID-19 disease
caused by the virus and 10,149 have been infected in just over two weeks.
Tuesday's toll raised the number of deaths outside China to 1,115, according an
AFP tally.
New York Deploys National Guard to Fight Coronavirus
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/March 10/2020
New York is deploying National Guard troops for the first time in the
coronavirus crisis to help contain the spread of the disease from an
infection-hit suburb of New York City, the state's governor said Tuesday. Andrew
Cuomo said authorities would set up a one-mile radius "containment zone" around
the epicenter of an outbreak in New Rochelle in suburban Westchester county.
Cuomo explained that all facilities in the zone that hold large gatherings, such
as schools and temples, would be closed for two weeks beginning Thursday. "We're
also going to use the National Guard in the containment area to deliver food to
homes, to help with the cleaning of public spaces," Cuomo said. There have been
173 confirmed cases of Covid-19 in New York state, including 108 in Westchester
County, home to New Rochelle where the majority of infections have been
detected. Cuomo told reporters that businesses in the containment zone will
remain open and that people will be free to come and go as they wish, insisting
there is no quarantine. "You're not containing people, it's facilities," he
said. "It is a dramatic action but it is the largest cluster in the country.
This is literally a matter of life and death," Cuomo added. The area is centered
on a synagogue in New Rochelle, a city of 80,000 inhabitants just north of New
York City, which was attended by the state's first case -- a lawyer working in
Manhattan. The United States has more than 800 confirmed cases of the deadly
virus, according to a running tally by Johns Hopkins University.Twenty-eight
people have died, 23 of those in Washington state. No one has died in New York.
Tunisia Arrests 5 over Attack near U.S. Embassy
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/March 10/2020
Five people have been arrested in Tunisia over a double suicide attack that
killed a police officer near the US embassy in Tunis last week, the prosecution
said Tuesday. Two suicide bombers struck outside the embassy on Friday, wounding
six other people and again shaking a city repeatedly hit by jihadist violence.
The five detainees were arrested on Saturday and are being held at a police
station in the capital's El Gorjani district specializing in anti-terrorism
investigations, spokesman Sofiene Sliti told AFP. Tunisian media have reported
that the two suicide bombers were men from Tunis who had served their sentences
after being found guilty on terror charges in 2014. The attack on Friday at
midday rocked the Berges du Lac district hosting the highly fortified embassy,
causing panic among pedestrians and motorists. A video shared later on social
media shows two men in sports clothes and with caps on their heads riding a
scooter up to a police van then pausing for a few seconds before an explosion.
There was no immediate claim of responsibility for the attack and authorities
have not announced any other advances in their investigations. Tunisia has been
hit by multiple jihadist attacks since the 2011 uprising that toppled longtime
dictator Zine El Abidine Ben Ali. A string of deadly attacks in 2015 killed
dozens of foreign tourists and security personnel. An attack that year that
killed 12 presidential guards prompted authorities to announce a state of
emergency that has remained in place ever since.
Germany to Open Syrian 'Crimes against Humanity' Trial in
April
Agence France Presse/Naharnet/March 10/2020
The unprecedented trial of two alleged former Syrian intelligence officers
accused of participating in crimes against humanity will begin in April, a
German court said Tuesday. Legal campaigners at the Berlin-based European Center
for Constitutional and Human Rights (ECCHR) say it will be the first-ever legal
proceedings in the world over state-sponsored torture in Syria. The trial begins
on April 23 in the western German city of Koblenz, and is expected to run at
least until August. Anwar Raslan, 57, is charged with crimes against humanity,
rape and 58 counts of murder, while 43-year-old Eyad Al-Gharib is accused of
having been an accomplice. Raslan allegedly led the investigations division of
"Branch 251" of the Syrian secret services, which operated a prison in the
Damascus area. Prosecutors say he participated in the torture and abuse of
prisoners between April 2011 and September 2012. In a statement Tuesday, the
court cited the charge sheet, which alleged that around 4,000 prisoners were
"beaten, kicked and subjected to electric shocks" under Raslan's leadership at
the Branch 251 prison. There was also allegedly "at least one case of rape and
aggravated sexual assault."Prosecutors believe Raslan "Raslan knew about the
extent of the torture, which means he also knew that prisoners were dying as a
result of extreme violence." Al-Gharib is accused of having rounded up
anti-government demonstrators and driven them to prisons where they were
"brutally and systematically tortured." Both men later fled to Germany, but were
arrested in February 2019 as part of a Franco-German investigation. Although
Syrian nationals, they are to be tried on the principle of universal
jurisdiction, which allows a foreign country to prosecute crimes against
humanity. The German trial follows a series of complaints filed in several
European countries by torture victims and their associates, with the support of
lawyers at the ECCHR. A total of 16 Syrians supported by the ECCHR are expected
to be involved in the trial, nine as joint plaintiffs and seven as witnesses.
"In using the principle of universal jurisdiction, the German judiciary is
sending an important signal to survivors and those affected by Syrian President
Bashar al-Assad’s system of torture and oppression," said the ECCHR in a
statement. "The trial in Koblenz is an important step, if only a beginning on
the long road to justice," said the ECCHR's Patrick Kroker. But, it added, "more
prosecutions must follow."
Sudan moves against Omar al-Bashir loyalists after
assassination attempt.
Reuters, Khartoum/Wednesday, 11 March 2020
Sudan’s ruling council said on Tuesday it would step up its drive to remove
loyalists of former president Omar al-Bashir, a day after the prime minister of
the transitional government escaped an assassination attempt unscathed. A branch
of Sudan’s security services that was closely linked to al-Bashir will be
brought under control of the civilian government and a committee tasked with
dismantling the old regime will be given additional powers, sovereign council
spokesman Mohamed al-Faki said in a statement. Authorities have launched an
investigation into Monday’s assassination attempt, when a blast targeted Prime
Minister Abdalla Hamdok’s convoy as he drove to work. They have not said who was
behind it, but by reasserting that al-Bashir loyalists will be firmly dealt
with, they have suggested possible links with old regime supporters trying to
disrupt a democratic transition. Hamdok heads a government of technocrats
serving under a 39-month power-sharing deal between civilian groups and the
military that was struck after al-Bashir was overthrown last April. As part of
efforts to disempower al-Bashir’s supporters, the “dismantling” committee has
already moved to disband the former ruling party and dismiss senior officials at
banks and embassies. Some officers at the National Intelligence and Security
Service (NISS) have also been dismissed, and the name of the agency has been
changed to the General Intelligence Service (GIS). Al-Faki said on Tuesday that
the part of the GIS that operates inside Sudan would be brought under the
interior ministry. In mid-January, armed security agents linked to Bashir fought
soldiers in Khartoum for several hours, after a dispute linked to severance
packages.
The Latest LCCC English analysis & editorials from miscellaneous sources
published on March 10-11/2020
How Bad Is the Coronavirus? Let’s Run the Numbers
Justin Fox/Asharq Al-Awsat/March 10/2020
The coronavirus outbreak has been turning a lot of us into amateur
epidemiologists. Just listen to Mick Mulvaney, the former real estate developer
and member of Congress from South Carolina who is now acting White House chief
of staff. “The flu kills people,” he said last week. “This is not Ebola. It’s
not SARS, it’s not MERS. It’s not a death sentence, it’s not the same as the
Ebola crisis.”
All those statements are true. The flu does kill people: an estimated 61,099 in
the US in the worst recent flu season, that of 2017-2018. People who get
Covid-19, the World Health Organization’s shorthand for Coronavirus Disease
2019, 1 are much less likely to die than those infected with Ebola, the Severe
Acute Respiratory Syndrome of 2003 and the Middle East Respiratory Syndrome
first reported in 2012. And no, this is not the same as the Ebola crisis.
It’s not the same as the 2014 Ebola crisis in part because it appears to be a
much bigger deal for the US and other countries outside of West Africa. As
Microsoft Corp. co-founder Bill Gates, also technically an amateur
epidemiologist but by this point quite a well-informed one, put it Friday in the
New England Journal of Medicine: “Covid-19 has started behaving a lot like the
once-in-a-century pathogen we’ve been worried about.”
How do we reconcile these differing views of Covid-19? Well, I too am an amateur
as an epidemiologist, but I find that charts and (very simple) equations help me
think through things. On the theory that others might find this helpful, too,
let’s start with the approximate case-fatality rates for the diseases listed by
Mulvaney and a few others you may have heard of.
These fatality rates can change a lot depending on time and place and access to
treatment. The Covid-19 rate is obviously a moving target, so I’ve included both
the 3.4% worldwide mortality rate reported this week by the World Health
Organization and the 1% estimate from a study released Feb. 10 by the MRC Centre
for Global Infectious Disease Analysis at Imperial College London that factored
in probable unreported cases. The authors of that study also said that, given
the information available at the time, they were 95% confident the correct
fatality rate was somewhere between 0.5% and 4%. Gates used the 1% estimate in
his article, and when I ran it by Caroline Buckee, an actual professional
epidemiologist who is a professor at Harvard’s T.H. Chan School of Public
Health, she termed it “reasonable.”
In a context that includes Ebola and MERS, the Covid-19 death rates are much
closer to those of the flu, and it’s understandable why people find the
comparison reassuring. Compare Covid-19 with just the flu, though, and it
becomes clear how different they are.
The 61,099 flu-related deaths in the US during the severe flu season of
2017-2018 amounted to 0.14% of the estimated 44.8 million cases of
influenza-like illness. There were also an estimated flu-related 808,129
hospitalizations, for a rate of 1.8%. Assume a Covid-19 outbreak of similar size
in the US, multiply the death and hospitalization estimates by five or 10, and
you get some really scary numbers: 300,000 to 600,000 deaths, and 4 million to 8
million hospitalizations in a country that has 924,107 staffed hospital beds.
Multiply by 40 and, well, forget about it. Also, death rates would go higher if
the hospital system is overwhelmed, as happened in the Chinese province of Hubei
where Covid-19’s spread began and seems to be happening in Iran now. That’s one
reason that slowing the spread is important even if it turns out the disease
can’t be stopped.
Could Covid-19 really spread as widely as the flu? If allowed to, sure. The
standard metric for infectiousness is what’s called the reproduction number, or
R0. It is usually pronounced “R naught,” and the zero after the R should be
rendered in subscript, but it’s a simple enough concept. An R0 of one means each
person with the disease can be expected to infect one more person. If the number
dips below one, the disease will peter out. If it gets much above one, the
disease can spread rapidly.
Here are R0s for the same list of diseases as above. These are rough
approximations, in most cases the midpoints of quite-large ranges. But they do
give a sense of relative infectiousness.
This helps explain why public health authorities want everybody to get
vaccinated against the measles. It’s not all that deadly a disease, but once it
gets going in an unvaccinated population, everybody gets it.
The numbers also seem to indicate that Covid-19 is a lot more contagious than
the seasonal flu. Average R0 isn’t the whole story, though. Why all the worry
about MERS, for example, which with an R0 below one shouldn’t spread at all?
Well, it’s extremely deadly, its R0 can rise above one in certain environments,
among them hospitals, and ... you can catch it from your camel.
Then there’s SARS, which is both deadlier than Covid-19 and has a similar R0.
Why was it wiped out in about a year, while some experts warn that Covid-19 may
be around forever? Because SARS usually didn’t become contagious until several
days after symptoms appeared. This meant that, as four British infectious
disease experts wrote in 2004, “actions taken during this period to isolate or
quarantine ill patients can effectively interrupt transmission.” They proposed
adding another variable to disease-transmission models: the proportion of
transmission occurring prior to symptoms. For SARS, this was less than 11%,
probably much less. For influenza, it is between 30% and 50%, making it far
harder to control the disease’s spread.
With Covid-19, “it seems that it can transmit quite a bit before symptoms
occur,” Buckee says. How much is still up in the air. World Health Organization
Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has been arguing this week that
pre-symptomatic transmission appears to be low enough that Covid-19 can be
controlled in ways that the flu cannot. “If this was an influenza epidemic, we
would have expected to see widespread community transmission across the globe by
now,” he said Monday, “and efforts to slow it down or contain it would not be
feasible.”
Now, as China begins to go back to work, the big question is whether a
less-draconian approach can keep the disease in check or whether it will just
start spreading again.
That’s the big question in the US, Europe and pretty much everywhere else on
earth too. It can’t be answered entirely by professional epidemiologists,
either. Weighing whether the costs of a particular intervention are worth the
benefits is at heart a political decision. So it’s actually good that
politicians are moonlighting as amateur epidemiologists. Some of them may just
need to study a little harder.
Countries Can Still Get Rich From Manufacturing
Noah Feldman/Bloomberg/March 10/2020
Since the Industrial Revolution began, every country that hasn’t been lucky
enough to have huge oil deposits has gotten rich the same way: by getting good
at manufacturing. Countries like the U.K., Germany, the U.S, Japan, and South
Korea all became world-class manufacturers long before their economies began to
shift toward services. More recently, a new crop of almost-developed countries
including Malaysia, Poland, Turkey, China, Romania, Thailand and Mexico have
also strengthened their manufacturing capacity.
Economists like Ha-Joon Chang and Dani Rodrik and writers like Joe Studwell have
argued that intentional promotion of manufacturing exports is crucial for this
kind of development. In a 2008 paper, Rodrik summarized much of the empirical
and theoretical case in favor of industrial policy. “Development,” he writes,
“is fundamentally about structural change” toward producing high-value
exportable products -- most of which tend to be manufactured goods. Competing in
export markets also forces a country’s producers to increase productivity and
enables them to adopt advanced foreign technologies.
A number of poor countries have been trying to put this idea into practice. Two
prominent examples are Vietnam and Bangladesh, which have experienced
exponential growth in recent years.
Their industrial profiles look just right for countries on the first rung of the
manufacturing ladder. Vietnam’s top exports are electronics and clothing, while
Bangladesh’s are clothing and textiles.
But worryingly, Rodrik has been arguing for several years that the window for
successful manufacturing-driven development has closed. In a 2016 presentation
entitled “Is the Age of Growth Miracles Over?”, he argued that countries like
China and Malaysia would be the last to use manufacturing to make the leap from
poverty to wealth.
Rodrik’s argument was mainly an empirical one. While most countries eventually
shift from manufacturing to services after they get rich, Rodrik observed that
in recent decades, this shift has been happening earlier and earlier -- so that
many countries now actually start shifting away from manufacturing before they
fully industrialize.
Other research seems to have documented a similar phenomenon. For example, a
2015 paper by economists Douglas Gollin, Remi Jedwab and Dietrich Vollrath found
that in many developing countries, urbanization now means poor people moving off
of farms to work in local services rather than in factories.
For countries like Vietnam and Bangladesh, this is bad news. If Rodrik is right,
their current burst of manufacturing prowess may evaporate, and they’ll find
themselves following in the footsteps of countries like Indonesia, Nigeria, and
Brazil, where manufacturing has been declining as a share of GDP.
What’s the reason for this deindustrialization? One obvious explanation is
automation. If robots are replacing the lower end of the supply chain, then the
poor, unskilled workers who traditionally power low-end manufacturing
industries, like garment, toys, and electronics assembly, no longer have a
comparative advantage. Poor countries would presumably then specialize in
natural resource exports and low-value service exports like call centers,
leaving advanced countries with machine tools and robots to build all the
physical stuff.
But there are good reasons to doubt that this is happening. The link between
automation and employment is tenuous; some studies find that industrial robots
replace human workers, but others find that they increase employment, including
among the low-skilled.
More importantly, the timing is wrong for technology to be the story. Much of
the premature deindustrialization Rodrik documented -- including in Nigeria and
Brazil -- happened in the 1980s and 1990s. At the exact same time, China was
ramping up its manufacturing capacity in labor-intensive industries and
beginning its own growth miracle. So it seems likely that something else was
going on in the countries where industrialization reversed.
Many of these countries may have simply had a dysfunctional, premature
industrialization. In Africa, for example, a number of countries used a policy
of import substitution, closing themselves off to trade and trying to
manufacture their own goods, often using inefficient state-owned factories.
Brazil used a similar approach. This is very different than the kind of
export-focused, productivity-boosting industrial policy that Rodrik, Chang or
Studwell would recommend. And then when these industrialization drives left
countries poor, they opened their borders to imports, which decimated
inefficient local industry.
In addition to policy mistakes, China’s own industrialization may have played a
role. That huge country’s incredible manufacturing prowess may have caused
multinational companies to turn away from slower-footed competitors like
Indonesia, stifling their own nascent industries. Notably, Rodrik found that on
average, East Asian countries hadn’t experienced premature deindustrialization
like their counterparts in other regions of the world.
An economic theory created by Paul Krugman, Masahisa Fujita, and Anthony
Venables may hold the key to why this happened. They predicted that as the world
economy develops, regions industrialize in spurts, one after another. If this is
right, then other countries would have had no choice but to wait for China to
finish its own growth miracle before starting their own.
That time may now have come. Thanks to rapidly rising Chinese costs, the
US-China trade war, and multinational companies’ desire to diversify in the face
of threats like coronavirus, it might be time for countries like Vietnam and
Bangladesh to take over much of labor-intensive manufacturing. Even countries
that deindustrialized, like Indonesia, might now get a second chance. Poor
countries shouldn’t give up on the dream of manufacturing-based development just
yet.
مجيد رافزدا: اكاذيب ملالي إيران المتعلقة بفايروس الكورونا
Iran: The Mullahs' Coronavirus Lies
Majid Rafizadeh/Gatestone Institute/March 10/2020
http://eliasbejjaninews.com/archives/84030/%d9%85%d8%ac%d9%8a%d8%af-%d8%b1%d8%a7%d9%81%d8%b2%d8%af%d8%a7-%d8%a7%d9%83%d8%a7%d8%b0%d9%8a%d8%a8-%d9%85%d9%84%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%8a-%d8%a5%d9%8a%d8%b1%d8%a7%d9%86-%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%85%d8%aa%d8%b9%d9%84/
Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, recently called the coronavirus a
"blessing."
The situation has become so perilous that some members of the Iranian parliament
have finally come forward and criticized the theocratic establishment for
failing to address the issue adequately.
The Iranian leaders' cover-up and lies are some the underlying reasons behind
the spread of coronavirus to other nations. By calling the coronavirus a
"blessing", Iran's Supreme Leader seems to suggest that his objective is to
spread the virus to other countries, particularly Israel and the West.
After China, the Islamic Republic of Iran has emerged as the second focal point
of coronavirus, and thanks to the ruling mullahs' lies and cover-ups, Tehran is
spreading it to the rest of the planet.
Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, recently called the coronavirus a
"blessing." After China, the Islamic Republic of Iran, its ally, has emerged as
the second focal point of coronavirus, and thanks to the ruling mullahs' lies
and cover-ups, Tehran is spreading it to the rest of the planet.
The Iranian authorities at first claimed that the country was not experiencing a
crisis regarding the coronavirus: that no one in Iran had contracted the
disease. Soon, however, leaked information disclosed that top Iranian officials
were aware of the coronavirus in Iran but had decided to conceal the truth.
When a few Iranian authorities were pressured to provide information, they
stated that they are not allowed to report the actual number of people who have
been infected or died. The head of the Medical Sciences University in Qom,
Mohammad Reza Ghadir, for instance, said on Iran's state television that the
Ministry of Health had issued a ban on disclosing statistics on the coronavirus
outbreak in the country.
The question is: Are the ruling mullahs attempting purposefully to spread the
coronavirus to other countries as a form of global jihad? Otherwise, why would
Iran's top Ayatollah call coronavirus a "blessing"?
Now, not only is the Iranian regime refusing to give the public or the
international community a full and accurate picture of the coronavirus outbreak;
it is also not taking any necessary steps and precautions to prevent the crisis
from spreading.
While the city of Qom has become the epicenter through which the coronavirus is
being transmitted to other part of the world, Iranian President Hassan Rouhani
pointed out that the government has no plans to quarantine the city or, for that
matter, any other town.
In addition, although Iran's leaders were aware of the high number of its people
infected with the coronavirus, they did not halt their flights to other
countries.
The website Eghtesad Online wrote on February 19 that Iranian officials had
falsely claimed to have suspended flights.
It is important to remind the public that Iran's commercial airlines,
specifically Iran Air and Mahan Air, have been utilized for the illicit
transport of weapons and military staff, including members of the Islamic
Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), its elite Quds Force and the Basij militia.
These airlines usually fly to countries such as Syria unannounced. Several
countries, including Germany and France, have banned flights by Mahan Air.
The Islamic Republic is also failing to provide services across Iran to test
people for the virus. Mohammad Reza Ghadir confirmed that "most of the tests
have to be done in Tehran, and Tehran announces it." The regime is also failing
to conduct full examinations on patients. After some people died in Kamkar
Hospital in Qom, a hospital employee said:
"Precise statistics cannot be said because we had suspected fatalities from
about 10 days ago and, until two days ago, all were buried without careful
examination and there is a high probability that they were infected with the
coronavirus."
The situation has become so perilous that some members of the Iranian parliament
have finally come forward and criticized the theocratic establishment for
failing to address the issue adequately.
Ahmad Amirabadi, a member of Iran's parliament, revealed important information
when he spoke with the state-run Iranian Labour News Agency. It quoted him as
saying:
"Qom is not doing well in terms of the spread of the coronavirus, and I think
the government's performance in controlling the virus has failed.
"Nurses currently lack proper quarantine clothing and are caring for patients
with fear and anxiety. There are many problems for nurses and there are few
facilities, and Qom also lacks laboratory kits.
"It is true that we must keep calm, but we should not observe the scale of the
crisis as if nothing had happened... Unfortunately, the coronavirus outbreak has
been in Qom for three weeks and this has been announced late."
The Iranian leaders' cover-up and lies are some of the underlying reasons behind
the spread of coronavirus to other nations. By calling the coronavirus a
"blessing", Iran's Supreme Leader seems to suggest that his objective is to
spread the virus to other countries, particularly Israel and the West.
*Dr. Majid Rafizadeh is a business strategist and advisor, Harvard-educated
scholar, political scientist, board member of Harvard International Review, and
president of the International American Council on the Middle East. He has
authored several books on Islam and US foreign policy. He can be reached at
Dr.Rafizadeh@Post.Harvard.Edu
© 2020 Gatestone Institute. All rights reserved. The articles printed here do
not necessarily reflect the views of the Editors or of Gatestone Institute. No
part of the Gatestone website or any of its contents may be reproduced, copied
or modified, without the prior written consent of Gatestone Institute.
Can Turkey Defeat Russia's Army in Syria?
Michael Peck/The National Interest/March 10/2020
Turkey and Russia are hardly equal in size or military capability.
But should Turkish and Russian forces actually engage in combat in Syria, Turkey
would have the edge, according to one American analyst.
"The correlation of forces is decidedly against Russia in Syria," says Michael
Kofman, a researcher at the Center for Naval Analyses think tank, and an expert
on the Russian military.
How could this be? Russia is a former superpower that still retains a large
military and the world's biggest arsenal of nuclear warheads. Turkey, though one
of the strongest members of NATO, is a middleweight power that lacks nuclear
weapons.
Russia's overall military edge doesn't translate into superior strength on the
ground in Syria.
But as in real estate, location is everything. Russia's overall military
superiority doesn't translate into superior strength on the ground in
northeastern Syria, where Moscow's Syrian ally has launched an offensive to
recapture Idlib province – on the Syria-Turkish border – from Turkish troops and
Turkish-backed Syrian rebels.
Russia has only one major airbase in Syria – Khmeimim airbase near the port of
Latakia in northwestern Syria – and a naval base at Tartus. This creates a
vulnerability, as does the dependence of Russian forces – estimated to include
several thousand troops and dozens of warplanes – on ships to bring their
supplies Those vessels must transit from the Black Sea – through the Bosporus
straits which are controlled by Turkey – before they can reach Syrian ports in
the eastern Mediterranean. And unlike the U.S., Russia does not have a
substantial airlift capacity to sustain an overseas expeditionary force.
Russia has only one major airbase in Syria.
These infrastructure and logistical constraints mean Russia can't beef up its
present forces in Syria much beyond their present level, Kofman believes. "In a
scenario where Russia has one airbase, a presence that is not scalable, a
presence that requires access to the Bosporus for logistical support, the
Russian forces are actually in a very vulnerable position," he says.
A Russian retaliatory strike on Turkey itself would also be risky. While NATO is
unlikely to support Turkey's campaign in Syria – which is outside the alliance's
zone – it would be obligated to aid a member whose national territory has been
attacked.
To be clear, neither Turkey nor Russia is looking for a military confrontation
with each other. Indeed, in early March 2020, Turkish president Recip Erdogan
flew to Moscow to sign an agreement with Russian president Vladimir Putin that
calls for a cease-fire in Idlib, and a security corridor along the M4 highway
that will feature joint Russian-Turkish patrols.
A Russian guided missile cruiser passes through the Bosporus strait.
The situation resembles the Cold War, where the U.S. and Soviet Union avoided
direct clashes and instead battled through proxy forces. In February 2020, after
Syrian airstrikes killed 33 Turkish soldiers, Turkey retaliated with its own
strikes – including attacks by armed drones – on Syrian troops and shot down
three Syrian warplanes. While a Turkish F-16 did shoot down a Russian Su-24
strike aircraft in 2015, both countries have otherwise managed to avoid coming
to blows.
Yet Turkey has an estimated 7,000 troops in northern Syria, backed by drones and
aircraft. Russian aircraft are supporting Syrian government troops attempting to
wrest back Idlib – the last rebel-controlled territory in Syria. There are also
Russian advisers and military police, and Russian mercenaries, in the area. It's
easy to envision multiple scenarios where Turkish and Russian forces engage in
direct combat. For example, a Turkish attack on Syrian troops might injure
Russian advisers, who call for air support from Russian planes. Or, Turkish
aircraft accidentally shoot down Russian aircraft mistaken for Syrian planes,
and then Russia might retaliate by downing Turkish jets.
While neither Moscow nor Ankara wants a direct fight, neither can afford to back
down from a fight.
While neither Moscow nor Ankara wants a direct fight, neither can afford to back
down from a fight, Kofman says. "While both sides are working to avoid a
conflict, neither side can accept loss of life without taking some kind of
measures."
Turkey and Russia have a troubled history, including a series of wars from the
Seventeenth to the Twentieth Century ("those wars have not gone well for
Turkey," Kofman quips). But ironically, the Syrian flashpoint comes as Moscow
and Ankara have drawn closer over recent years. Once the southern anchor of NATO
against Soviet expansion, Turkey's purchase of Russian S-400 anti-aircraft
missiles angered the U.S. to the point that the Trump administration kicked
Turkey out of the F-35 stealth fighter program.
The question is whether Turkey and Russia have irreconcilable goals, or merely
differing goals that can be mutually satisfied. Turkish troops occupy
northeastern Syria, ostensibly to create a buffer zone between Syrian Kurds who
have formed a breakaway region from the Syrian government, and Turkish Kurds who
have long battled the Turkish government in a bid for independence. Turkey would
also like to see the demise of Syrian president Bashar al-Assad's regime, not
least because the Syrian offensive in Idlib has driven nearly a million refugees
toward the Turkish border.
For its part, Russia is determined to preserve the Syrian regime. Moscow and
Damascus have been allies since the 1960s, and Moscow's only naval base outside
Russia is the Syrian port of Tartus. Determined to stop Syrian rebels who came
close to overthrowing the government, Moscow committed Russian planes that –
along with troops from Iran and Iran's Lebanese proxy Hezbollah – were
instrumental in enabling the battered Syrian army to recapture most of the
country.
"It is understood that the Russian military will intervene on behalf of the
Syrian regime if the regime's stability and survival is in question," Kofman
says. "But it is not going to intervene on behalf of Syrian forces in Idlib.
Russia doesn't need Idlib."
However, experts believe that any cease-fire agreement in Idlib will be
temporary at best. "Ultimately, the Russians will back the Syrian government's
desire to reclaim those territories," predicts Bulent Aliriza, director of the
Turkey Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in
Washington, D.C. "But in the meanwhile, Putin is happy to kick that can down the
road while Syria swallows and digests territory which the opposition had
controlled."
*Michael Peck is a contributing writer for The National Interest and a writing
fellow at the Middle East Forum. He can be found on Twitter, Facebook. or on his
personal web site.
More red zones like Italy’s are coming
Dr. Theodore Karasik/Arab News/March 10/2020
Italian Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte’s decision to quarantine the entire
country will perhaps be the beginning of a series of instances where health care
systems are overwhelmed by coronavirus infection rates. The combustible
situation in Italy, erupting out of Milan and spreading outwards, is radioactive
enough to shut the country down. The increased restrictions will mean all public
gatherings are banned across the country and movement will be limited other than
for work or emergencies.
Conte addressed the young people in Italy who have continued to gather at night
to socialize during the public health emergency. “This nightlife... we can’t
allow this anymore,” he said. “Our habits must change, must change now. We must
all give up something for the good of Italy.” This was a powerful statement
requiring a change in behavior.
The quarantine measures imposed in the north of Italy now apply to the whole
country. That means Italian authorities will allow travel to, from and within
the country only if it is demonstrably necessary for work or health reasons. The
nationwide quarantine also means employees are urged to take vacation and stay
home, while bars and restaurants must close at 6pm and virtually all public
gatherings are banned. In shops, churches and all gathering places, people must
keep 1 meter’s distance apart. Now imagine that in your country — because such
red zones are coming soon to all areas with similar outbreaks. Testimony from an
Italian doctor stated that “an epidemiological disaster is taking place. And
there are no more surgeons, urologists, orthopedists; only doctors who suddenly
become part of a single team to face this tsunami that has overwhelmed us.”
The above testifies just how quickly COVID-19 can “bloom” among a population and
its logistical lines of daily life. Application of the understanding of what
constitutes contact in this particular pathogen environment is a human factors
model that means a significantly altered way of life in order to contain the
spread. Here, an approach using teleworking, or teleschooling, would help to
bring about social distancing and could help buy time so that the pathogen does
not spread so rapidly. This is not meant to instill any form of anxiety, but
illustrates how scientists and practitioners must ask hard questions. These
methods are already being instituted in the Gulf states as a result of the
COVID-19 outbreak, and lessons learned from the ongoing disinfection treatment
will be valuable.
As I notedin this column last month, the following needs to be repeated yet
again: COVID-19 is a pathogen with a two-week incubation period, during which
there are no symptoms. The ability to spread the pathogen by cough, sneeze and
touch is proven. The COVID-19 cases in China appeared to be much more dramatic
in terms of disease spread and issues of confinement and public response,
including Chinese military troops demonstrating the requirements for maintaining
order. Images of fog-spraying throughout Wuhan are raising questions about the
Chinese techniques for treating what appear to be blocks of urban areas. Italy’s
disinfection program is likely to get support from the World Health Organization
as well as from Arabian Gulf states, which are undergoing their own treatment
programs, with daily reminders of sanitation and necessary behavior adjustment.
The Italian program will likely be used across red zone countries or urban areas
and specifically infected “pathways,” or routes through which humans may carry
the pathogen. Seattle comes to mind. So does the disaster in Qom. COVID-19 could
infect 60 percent of the global population if unchecked, according to one
expert. Everybody now seems to be aware of the pandemic, as amply demonstrated
compared to a month ago. Italy will be damaged greatly during next month’s
Easter holiday season.
Japan, South Korea and other countries come to mind when considering COVID-19
forced containment methods aimed at stopping transmission. Islands are good
examples of containment. Japan’s Hokkaido is known for its ski resorts, natural
hot springs and rolling hills, making it a major tourism magnet, but it is in
lockdown after an upsurge in coronavirus infections forced local authorities to
declare a state of emergency. That lockdown began on Feb. 28. Why is Hokkaido
important? The rapid spread of the virus there due to its popularity as a winter
tourism destination illustrated how disease spread can occur. The famed Sapporo
Snow Festival, which saw artists carve giant ice sculptures between Jan. 31 and
Feb. 11, drew millions of visitors from around the world. Any event involving
large crowds increases the transmission rate and illustrates the limits of
preventing spread.
To be clear, any event involving large crowds increases the transmission rate
and illustrates the limits of preventing spread. Festivals and gatherings find
people in close proximity, with funneling through entrances and exits putting
people close to one another.
Italy’s red zone announcement and subsequent handling of the results — prison
riots and people moving rapidly from Lombardy — are likely to set a standard
example of how not being ready for a global pandemic such as COVID-19 impacts
almost everyone, simply due to our interconnected world. Milan’s launch point
illustrates the spread radius and its implications are overwhelming just about
everyone. Local administrators from China to Italy are being found to be
unprepared for such outbreaks.
In Lombardy, the fleeing helped to spread the pathogen. Containment strategies
work when social distancing, in the form of self-isolation, prevents COVID-19
from scattering further. Home education helps to finish studies during the
period of disinfection, and the encouragement of working from home and “staying
put” during this period is important. The risk to Europe is extremely high as
new clusters appear. Applying key isolation rules and adjusting behavior to stem
the distribution of the disease through understanding crowd dynamics is
increasingly important.
*Dr. Theodore Karasik is a senior adviser to Gulf State Analytics in Washington,
DC. Twitter: @tkarasik
Children are neglected victims of Syria’s war
Mona Yacoubian/Al Arabiya/March 10/2020
As the war in Syria enters its tenth year, the conflict’s disproportionate toll
on children underscores the generational challenge that lies ahead. An enduring
political solution to the conflict remains a distant prospect, but humanitarian
interventions to assuage Syrian children’s suffering must be prioritized today.
An end to the fighting would be the most impactful development, but in the
interim, intensifying efforts to address trauma, diminish early marriage and
child labor, and rejuvenate education can help relieve some of the pain and
begin to rescue the generation that holds Syria’s future.
Children have suffered in countless ways over the duration of the war: They have
endured physical harm as well as borne the hidden wounds of psychological
trauma. They have been victims of sexual violence. Children have been recruited
and used in violence by all sides in the conflict, and have been held in
detention, according to a January 2020 UN report. Across Syria, 500,000 children
are chronically malnourished.
Whether inside Syria or outside the country as refugees, children have lost
family members and friends, their homes and schools. In many instances they were
forced to flee their homes, often multiple times, to escape violence. In other
cases, they were compelled to go to Syria with parents answering the siren call
of ISIS’ so-called caliphate. Some children were born into the caliphate,
knowing only ISIS’s chaotic and horror-filled reality when the group occupied
nearly one-third of Syria.
The recent carnage in Syria’s Idlib province underscores the extreme cost borne
by Syrian children in the conflict. The al-Assad regime’s offensive—backed by
Russia and Iran—sparked the single greatest episode of displacement since the
start of the war nearly a decade ago. Children comprise 60 percent of the
961,000 people who have been on the move seeking safety from the regime’s
onslaught since December 1, 2019. At one point the United Nations estimated that
6,500 children were being displaced daily. Displaced in the throes of winter,
children have died from exposure. In late February the Syrian American Medical
Society (SAMS) estimated that the number of children treated in one of its Idlib-based
clinics had tripled.
Children who lived under ISIS occupation have both witnessed and been victims of
unspeakable atrocities. Girls as young as nine were exploited as sex slaves;
young boys have been forced to carry out acts of extreme violence including
executions. Many of these children now live in displacement camps in northeast
Syria under Kurdish control; two-thirds of the al-Hol camp’s population of
66,000 are children, with a large percentage hailing from more than 60 countries
including neighboring Iraq. These children are in dire need of psycho-social
interventions to address the trauma they have suffered.
The Syrian refugee crisis is the largest in the world. Syrian refugee children
are increasingly vulnerable as pressure mounts in host communities, especially
in Turkey and Lebanon, which host the largest numbers of Syrian refugees.
Economic downturns in Lebanon and Turkey have compounded the already difficult
situation faced by Syrian refugees. Many refugee families are thrust further
into poverty and must rely on coping strategies that take children out of school
such as child labor and early marriage.
The international community must do more to address the trauma and suffering of
Syrian children. The moral imperatives embedded in the Geneva Conventions and
laws of war demand the protection of children in armed conflict. Over the long
term, security imperatives may also come into play. A generation of children who
have grown up traumatized and without hope or a sense of dignity could turn to
extremism for answers.
With conflict and instability still raging inside Syria, interventions to
address childhood trauma and suffering are unfortunately limited. Nonetheless,
efforts to create safe spaces—particularly in more stable areas but even in
crowded displacement camps—must be enhanced. Innovative programming that
leverages arts therapy and other creative approaches should be deployed with
greater frequency. Telehealth programming with mental health professionals who
can provide counseling to older children should also be supported wherever
possible.
For those children from foreign countries living in camps for those displaced
from former ISIS areas, the priority must be on repatriation. Some countries,
particularly in Central Asia, have taken the lead in repatriating their
citizens. Meanwhile, European countries have largely adopted a short-sighted
approach, refusing to repatriate women and children from the camps. But, this
must change. Greater effort must be made to facilitate the repatriation at least
of European orphans currently in the camps.
As for Syrian refugee children, protection issues and education gaps will
continue to be critical challenges. At a minimum, the international community
must ensure that the UN humanitarian assistance appeal for Syria is fulfilled,
and priority must be placed on increasing both psycho-social and education
programming for these children.