Lebanon’s political paralysis exacerbated by Saudi-Iran spat
Joseph A. Kechichian/Gulf News/January 12/16
Beirut: Can Lebanon elect a head-of-state in the middle of the Saudi-Iranian spat and is Sa’ad Hariri, perhaps with Saudi assistance, seeking to break the Aoun-Geagea monopoly on the country’s Christian representation? Beirut’s rumors mill, which are rich in quantity though seldom accurate in content, have raised these key questions allegedly because the former prime minister was anxious to pave the way for Christian figures other than Lebanese Forces Leader and presidential hopeful Samir Geagea to receive Saudi Arabia’s blessing. Unnamed sources told Naharnet that Hariri encouraged former President Michel Sulaiman to visit the Kingdom on Sunday, ostensibly to send a signal to Geagea that if the latter contemplated an alliance with the Free Patriotic Movement’s Michel Aoun, also a presidential candidate, that he, Hariri, could cajole Riyadh to open its doors to other Christian figures.
The rumor was far-fetched for at least three reasons: first, because Saudi officials have repeatedly said that they would accept any leader chosen by the Maronite leadership; second, that whoever emerged must inevitably be backed by Geagea given his popularity and that they, the Saudis, backed him; and third, because Sulaiman was not anyone’s lackey. What is clear, however, was that both Geagea and Aoun were working to end Franjieh’s candidacy. Their consultations over the weekend also seemed aimed at keeping the March 14 coalition, which includes the Lebanese Forces as well as the Future Movement, intact. They also seem to want to end Druze leader, Walid Junblatt’s, king-maker role in selecting a president. Few predicted the political vacuum that descended on Lebanon after May 24, 2014 when Sulaiman ended his 6-year term of office. Since then, an overwhelming 35 parliamentary sessions failed to elect a leader as the decision relied heavily on regional politics, specifically the war in Syria. The anti-Syrian March 14 alliance has nominated Geagea for the vacancy while the pro-Syrian March 8 alliance, which Hezbollah is a part of, wants Aoun for the position. Several weeks into his “Hail Mary” initiative to end the political impasse, Hariri is suggesting an alternative candidate: Marada Movement Chief Sulaiman Franjieh, a close friend of Syrian President Bashar Al Assad. Lebanon’s Christians overwhelmingly opposed his nomination, effectively ending the initiative. The election of a president in Lebanon was difficult even before recent tensions between Saudi Arabia and Iran, and observers believe it will only be more difficult now.
Why so many Lebanese are looking abroad
Mona Alami/Al-Monitor/January 12/16
A worsening economic situation with increasing poverty and unemployment are pushing many Lebanese toward immigration, looking for better prospects either in the West or in Gulf countries. “There is no more hope in Lebanon,” said Charbel Lahoud, an agricultural engineer with an MBA who is preparing his papers to emigrate to Europe. Statistics support Lahoud’s grim outlook. According to Information International, about 34% of Lebanese were looking to leave Lebanon in 2015.
“The statistics are actually much higher,” Mohammad Chamsedine, researcher at Information International, told Al-Monitor. “If we take in account the fact that about 25% of the population is already outside the country, this means that over 50% of the population is either looking to leave the country or is already living abroad,” Chamsedine added. A growing number of nationals are trying to reach Europe or Australia in boats. In October 2015, seven people from the Safwan family drowned when their boat capsized on the way to Europe from nearby Turkey. In another incident in September 2013, some 60 Lebanese drowned while trying to reach Australia from Indonesia.
According to Chamsedine, the meteoric rise in immigration began in 2010.
Lebanon has historically seen high immigration. According to figures provided by Information International, in 2014, about 1.3 million Lebanese out of a 5.2 million population were already living abroad. These figures only include holders of Lebanese nationality while excluding people of Lebanese descent and who do not hold Lebanese citizenship. This population mostly resides in South America.
Immigration levels, which steadily grew during Lebanon’s civil war (1975-1989), slowed between 1993 and 2010, a time marked by relative economic stability. “From the year 1992 until 2014, the number of Lebanese who left Lebanon was about 508,407 people,” Chamsedine said. Immigration levels picked up again in 2011-2013. The number of Lebanese who left during this period was at 174,704, with an average annual rate of 58,234, compared to 14,500 for the 1993 to 2010 period, the researcher explained.
The Lebanese government has done little to end the brain drain. An official source in the Ministry of Social Affairs told Al-Monitor that the issue is becoming “a priority and that the ministry has put in place developmental projects that could help put an end to it.” Others interviewed by Al-Monitor were nonetheless skeptical.
“We are in a state of a political cold war. Things are not moving; everyone is in a wait-and-see approach,” Lahoud said, referring to the impact of regional sectarian tensions, which have paralyzed both the government and the presidency. Lebanon has been without a president for one year and eight months, since the end of the mandate of President Michel Suleiman in May 2014. Prime Minister Tammam Salam even stated on Dec. 15, 2015, that the paralyzed government was “worthless,” as political deadlock has prevented the Cabinet from meeting regularly.
Institutional and economic decay has pushed Lebanese from all walks of life to seek better opportunities in faraway lands. Interestingly, Chamsedine noted, in 2014, the proportion of Muslims who wished to immigrate became higher than that of their Christian counterparts. In effect, about 24% of Maronite respondents said they were considering im, in comparison to 43% of Sunnis and 50% of Alawites. In addition, the large majority of people who wanted to emigrate were highly educated, representing 46% of the total of respondents.
Several reasons can explain the Lebanese nationals’ eagerness to leave their home country. Marwan Nuwayhid, a journalist who was living in Dubai and is now temporarily in Lebanon, explained that there are limited career opportunities for Lebanese in their home country. He told Al-Monitor, “Career progression has become very difficult in Lebanon. One can grow more in Dubai because of the number of multinationals operating there and the economic stability.”This opinion is shared by Lahoud, who underlined that in Lebanon, “It takes a very long time to go up the corporate ladder and it is extremely difficult without the right connections.”
Other reasons mentioned by those interviewed by Al-Monitor were a general dearth of motivation and the lack of respect many employers have for employees. Maria, a young banker who wished to remain anonymous, said large Lebanese companies rarely show appreciation for their employees, who are often treated with little respect. “At least in France or America, employees have rights and they are treated equally whatever their background is,” Lahoud added.
Greater financial reward is another important motivator for Lebanese seeking employment abroad. Nuwayhid explained that local jobs barely cover people’s basic needs. Tarek Baz, who earned a business degree but works as a salesperson for a distribution company, said that he was offered a salary four times his current one if he immigrated. “It makes a big difference when you have a family,” he told Al-Monitor.
Nuwayhid believes that those residing in Lebanon can rarely afford to buy a house and have to live with their parents. Lahoud agrees, adding, “I have not achieved as much as my friends in the same age group who left Lebanon, whether from an employment or a social perspective. My friends have made enough money to afford to buy a house and get married, which is not the case for most people in Lebanon.”
However, some in Lebanon say that family responsibilities or social ties keep them here. Baz said that in spite of the interesting offers and political instability, he is still hesitant to leave, as he feels he will miss the social and family relations he still enjoys here. Others, like banker Maya Chehayeb, say they cannot leave for family reasons. She pointed out to Al-Monitor, “Besides the fact that I do not want to start from zero, I also have family responsibilities, namely toward my parents, whom I do not want to leave behind.”
Worsening living conditions are making things more difficult for Lebanese who want to remain. Lebanon has been facing a waste crisis since August 2015, one Health Minister Wael Abou Faour labeled a potential “health catastrophe.” The government finally agreed in September 2015 to ship its waste to a location that has not been revealed, but the plan has yet to be implemented. “Deciding to stay in Lebanon means giving up on your standard of living, and [fewer and fewer] people are willing to do that, especially if they have experienced another lifestyle elsewhere,” Nuwayhid said.
